WorksMathematics
Commutators in selfless C-algebras
Abstract
We show that if is a selfless C-probability space with being a faithful trace, then commutators are dense in .
Introduction
The question of when an operator on a Hilbert space can be written as a commutator first receieved serious interest because of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle in physics. The Wielandt-Wintner theorem, see [8, 9], states that the identity operator on a Hilbert space cannot be expressed as the commutator of two bounded operators. Wielandt already pointed out in his paper that his proof is valid in any normed unital ring, thus opening the door to an abstract analysis of the problem. A popular variation of the problem is to write elements vanishing on every trace in a -algebra as a sum of a bounded number of commutators. Recently, Ciu and Ma deviced a method to reduce sums of commutators to single commutators using matrix algebra. We refer the reader to their paper [2] and the references therein for an overview of the area. Their result, building on the results of [4], show that for a broad class of simple -algebras, including UHF-algebras, irrational rotation algebras and Cuntz algebras, the set of elements vanishing on all traces coincides with the set of single commutators. This points to a common theme in the literature on the topic: Most avaliable results require some form of abundance of projections, since this allows the reduction of the problem to (approximately) solving matrix equations with respect to a partition of the unit by projections. The projectionless case has been left largely unexplored.
Alain Valette posed on MathOverflow [7] the question if every element deleted by the unique trace on the reduced group -algebra of a free group is close to a sum of commutators. In fact, much more is true: Any element in a -algebra vanishing on all bounded traces is close to a sum of commutators; this follows from a Hahn-Banach argument akin to one in [5]. Nevertheless, Jesse Peterson provided an elegant answer for the specific situation using Powers’ averaging technique. Prompted by the author with the question of whether the representative of a group generator is close to a single commutator in , Claude Opus 5.5 generated a variation of Peterson’s argument using Abel’s summation trick to show that this is indeed the case. Inspired by this trick, we show in this note that if is a -probability space with being a faithful trace, then commutators are dense in . This constitutes a generalization of a result by Robert in his seminal paper [6], where he also requires that have real rank zero. In particular, it applies to the stably projectionless -algebras for , which were shown to be selfless in the landmark paper [1], and the Jiang-Su algebra, see [6 Theorem 5.2]. It remains open if the set of commutators is closed in both cases.
I wish to thank Leonel Robert and Mikael Rørdam for reading drafts of this note.
Approximation by commutators
A -probability space is a pair consisting of a unital -algebra and a state on . A -probability space is selfless if for some -probability space such that and has faithful GNS-representation, there is an ultrafilter such that the diagonal embedding factors through the first factor embedding , i.e., there is embedding such that . In fact, the pair may be assumed to be any one of a series of well-known -probability spaces, see [6 Theorem 2.6]. Selflessness is a strong regularity property for -probability spaces bundling together many well-studied regularity properties for simple -algebras. Importantly, Robert showed in [6 Theorem 3.1] that if is a selfless -probability space, then is simple and satisfies the following dichotomy: If is not a trace, then is purely infinite, and if is a trace, then has stable rank one and strict comparison of positive elements, and is the unique -quasitrace on . We are interested in the tracial case since if is purely infinite, then any non-central element is a single commutator by [5] and [2].
We will use the following trick.
Lemma 2.1. Let be a unital -algebra and fix a unitary element . Let and and set
Then
where .
Proof. By using Abel summation on the scalar and non-scalar part of the terms in the first sum, we have
The second equality is trivial.
Theorem 2.2. Let be a selfless -probability space such that is a faithful trace. Then commutators are dense in . In fact, any element in may be arbitrarily well approximated by a commutator of one element with a unitary.
Proof. Fix an element and . Let denote the state on corresponding to the normalized Lebesgue measure on . Since is selfless, there is an embedding into an ultrapower of such that , following the same notation as above. We have . Let denote the image of the identity function on in . Then, cf. [3 Proposition 3.2], there is an such that
By Lemma 2.1,
where
Hence, in , which means that there is a unitary and element such that .
References
Department of Mathematical Sciences
University of Copenhagen
Universitetsparken 5
2100 Copenhagen
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]Tattwamasi Amrutam, David Gao, Srivatsav Kunnawalkam Elayavalli, and Gregory Patchell. “Strict comparison in reduced group C*-algebras”. In: Inventiones mathematicae 242 (2025), pp. 639–657.arxiv.org/abs/2412.06031
- [2]Lu Cui and Minghui Ma. Single commutators in C*-algebras. 2026. arXiv: 2609.14585.arxiv.org/abs/2609.14585
- [3]Kenneth J. Dykema. “Simplicity and the stable rank of some free product C*-algebras”. In: Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 351 (1999), pp. 1–40.arxiv.org/abs/funct-an/9702015
- [4]Laurent W. Marcoux. “Sums of small number of commutators”. In: Journal of Operator Theory 56 (2006), pp. 111–142.
- [5]Ciprian Pop. “Finite sums of commutators”. In: Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society 130 (2002), pp. 3039–3041.DOI
- [6]Leonel Robert. “Selfless C*-algebras”. In: Advances in Mathematics 478 (2025), p. 110409.arxiv.org/abs/2309.14188
- [7]Alain Valette, Jesse Peterson, and Leonel Robert. Commutators in the reduced C*-algebra of the free group. https://mathoverflow.net/questions/66343/commutators-in-the-reduced-c-algebra-of-the-free-group. Accessed: 09.10.2026.
- [8]Helmut Wielandt. “Über die Unbeschränktheit der Operatoren der Quantenmechanik”. In: Mathematische Annalen 121 (1949), pp. 21–21.DOI
- [9]Aurel Wintner. “The unboundedness of quantum-mechanical matrices”. In: Physical Review 71 (1947), p. 738.DOI