betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The Conditional CMB Visibility of High-Redshift X-Ray Cavities in Galaxy clusters

Abstract

At high redshift, the cosmic microwave background (CMB) both cools relativistic leptons and provides seed photons for inverse-Compton (IC) X-ray emission. These two effects link the particle content of a bubble directly to the soft X-ray depression used to identify a cavity. We derive a physical criterion connecting lepton cooling, bubble volume, enthalpy evolution, and 0.5–2 keV X-ray visibility, while separating intrinsic filling of the X-ray depression from detector-dependent cavity recovery. For uncooled electron populations described by a power law with spectral index s=2.5s=2.5, minimum Lorentz factor 100≤γmin⁡≤1000100\leqγ_{\min}\leq1000, and maximum Lorentz factor γmax⁡=105γ_{\max}=10^5, the measured atmosphere of the testbed high-redshift cluster SPT-CL J2215−-3537 requires 0.6–1.2% of the pressure in radiating leptons to fill the soft-band deficit. Across the full tested ranges of ss, γmin⁡γ_{\min}, and atmospheric properties, the required fraction is 0.2–3.7%. Complete loss of this component reduces the enthalpy by less than 3% relative to an otherwise identical adiabatic bubble at the same pressure. A low-cutoff control with γmin⁡=10γ_{\min}=10 and s=3s=3 instead requires 18.9%, identifying the poorly constrained low-energy spectrum as the main physical uncertainty. For a fixed atmosphere and spectrum, the required fraction scales as (1+z)−4(1+z)^{-4}. The declining-pressure tracks show that the X-ray deficit can cross the adopted detection threshold while the enthalpy deficit remains below 0.4%; the time of this transition depends on the assumed pressure history. Thus, high-redshift cavity visibility depends on both the surrounding atmosphere and the pressure-carrying particle spectrum. This criterion provides the physical basis for an instrument-specific recovery analysis.

Introduction

Mechanical feedback from accreting supermassive black holes is widely regarded as a key process regulating the thermal evolution of massive galaxies and the hot intracluster medium (ICM) in galaxy clusters ([24, 12]). The most direct observational tracers of this feedback are X-ray cavities, where the work done in displacing the surrounding gas provides an estimate of the mechanical energy injected by the central black hole (see J. Hlavacek-Larrondo et al. [18], for a review). For a relativistic cavity, this enthalpy is commonly written as H=4pVH = 4pV, where pp is the bubble pressure, assumed to equal the surrounding ICM pressure, and VV is the cavity volume. Combined with a buoyancy, sound-crossing, or refill timescale, this yields an estimate of the time-averaged jet power ([7, 26]). As cavity searches are extended to progressively higher redshifts ([17, 19]), the completeness of the detected cavity population becomes increasingly important for reconstructing the cosmic history of radio-mode feedback.

The recent extension of cavity searches toward z∼1z \sim1 makes the question of completeness increasingly timely. Cavity demographics remain one of the few direct observational routes to the cosmic evolution of radio-mode mechanical power, yet the assumptions inherited from low-redshift studies are least tested in this regime. Radio-faint ghost cavities show that relativistic plasma can outlive its bright radio phase ([6, 11]), while aged lobes and remnants may remain visible through inverse-Compton (IC) X-ray emission ([10, 25, 20]). At high redshift, the stronger IC loss channel also alters radio-lobe energetics ([14]). These studies establish the relevant physical ingredients, but they do not determine how those ingredients modify the X-ray criterion used to identify a cavity.

At high redshift, a basic assumption inherited from low-redshift cavity studies begins to fail: the bubble contents and the X-ray depression used to identify the bubble are no longer independent. Because the CMB energy density, UCMBU_{\mathrm{CMB}}, scales as (1+z)4(1+z)^4, the same photon field both increases the IC cooling rate and provides the seed photons for IC X-ray emission. Radiating leptons can therefore lose pressure while replacing part, or even all, of the soft-band thermal signal displaced by the bubble. A cavity may remain energetically important even as its X-ray shadow weakens. For a fixed atmosphere and lepton spectrum, the radiating-lepton fraction required for full soft-X-ray fill-in scales as (1+z)−4(1+z)^{-4}, so the redshift dependence is explicit. The possibility that IC emission could fill a high-redshift cavity was raised by M. Markevitch et al. [23], while M. J. Hardcastle [15] followed radiative losses in radio-galaxy dynamics. What has remained missing is a direct calculation connecting the lepton pressure, the evolving bubble volume and enthalpy, and the soft X-ray contrast in a measured atmosphere.

In this paper, we develop an analytical model which follows these quantities with a single accumulated cooling variable, separates physical filling of the soft-band deficit from the observational threshold used to recover a cavity, and determines the required lepton pressure for an observed cluster atmosphere. The reported SPT-CL J2215−3537 (hereafter, J2215) feature (V. S. Bessa et al. [5]) is used only to supply the measured temperature, density, and X-ray emissivity at its projected radius as a testbed; none of the calculations requires the feature itself to be a cavity. § 2 develops the cooling and contrast model, § 3 gives the lepton pressure required to fill the X-ray deficit and illustrates the resulting contrast evolution, and § 4 discusses the physical limits and observational implications. We adopt the same flat Λ\LambdaCDM cosmology as V. S. Bessa et al. [5], with H0=70H_0 = 70 km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1}, Ωm=0.3\Omega_m = 0.3, and ΩΛ=0.7\Omega_\Lambda= 0.7.

Physical Model

Model assumptions and cooling evolution

We follow the bubble from detachment, defined as the time at which the jet stops inflating it. The bubble contains two components: radiating leptons (electrons and positrons, hereafter “electrons”), described by a single homogeneous power-law spectrum, and a non-radiating component whose radiative losses are negligible (for example, relativistic protons). Both are assigned an adiabatic index Γ=4/3\Gamma= 4/3. Appendix § 7 separately tests a thermal, non-relativistic non-radiating component with Γnr=5/3\Gamma_{\mathrm{nr}} = 5/3. The bubble is assumed to remain in pressure balance with its surroundings, and the external pressure along its trajectory is prescribed rather than solved. We neglect particle escape and re-acceleration, and do not model the buoyant trajectory, bubble disruption, or the surrounding pressure profile. Pressure balance requires the bubble to adjust to external pressure changes faster than its contents cool. At the J2215 feature (z=1.16z = 1.16, kT=7.77kT = 7.77 keV; § 3.1), the ambient sound-crossing time across one bubble radius, Rb≃33R_b \simeq33 kpc, is about 23 Myr. This is 0.16 tIC0.16\,t_{\mathrm{IC}}, where tICt_{\mathrm{IC}} is the inverse-Compton cooling time (Equation (22)) of electrons with γ∗≃753\gamma_\ast\simeq753, the Lorentz factor near the peak of the 0.5–2 keV IC response (§ 2.2). This comparison supports approximate pressure balance for the shorter illustrative trajectories, although the approximation becomes less secure for the longest tracks.

Let pdetp_{\mathrm{det}} and VdetV_{\mathrm{det}} be the bubble pressure and volume at detachment, and define P(t)≡p(t)/pdetP(t) \equiv p(t)/p_{\mathrm{det}} and V(t)≡V(t)/VdetV(t) \equiv V(t)/V_{\mathrm{det}}, so that P(0)=V(0)=1P(0) = V(0) = 1. The adiabatic and radiative aging equation (e.g., T. A. Enßlin & M. Brüggen [11]; P. Mocz et al. [25]) is

γ˙=−V˙3Vγ−a(t)γ2,a(t)=4σT3mec(UCMB+UB),γ(t)=A(t)γ01+Ψ(t)γ0,A=V−1/3,Ψ(t)=∫0ta(t′)V(t′)−1/3 dt′.(1)\begin{aligned} \dot{\gamma} &= -\frac{\dot{V}}{3V}\gamma- a(t)\gamma^2,\qquad a(t) = \frac{4\sigma_{\mathrm{T}}}{3m_e c}\left(U_{\mathrm{CMB}} + U_B\right),\\ \gamma(t) &= \frac{A(t)\gamma_0}{1+\Psi(t)\gamma_0},\qquad A = V^{-1/3},\\ \Psi(t) &= \int_0^t a(t')V(t')^{-1/3}\,\mathrm{d}t'. \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

Here σT\sigma_{\mathrm{T}} is the Thomson cross section, mem_e is the electron mass, and cc is the speed of light. The quantity γ(t)\gamma(t) is the electron Lorentz factor at time tt, γ0\gamma_0 is its value at detachment, and a(t)a(t) is the radiative-loss coefficient. The first term in γ˙\dot{\gamma} describes the adiabatic change in electron energy as the bubble expands or contracts, and the second describes inverse-Compton losses against the CMB and synchrotron losses in the magnetic field, whose energy densities are UCMBU_{\mathrm{CMB}} and UBU_B, respectively. The factor A(t)A(t) describes the adiabatic energy change, whereas Ψ(t)\Psi(t) measures the accumulated radiative cooling. Equation (1) therefore maps each initial Lorentz factor γ0\gamma_0 to its value at time tt, which we use below to evolve the electron distribution.

At detachment, we assume a power-law electron spectrum,

dN0dγ0=Kγ0−s,γmin⁡≤γ0≤γmax⁡.\frac{\mathrm{d}N_0}{\mathrm{d}\gamma_0} = K\gamma_0^{-s},\qquad\gamma_{\min} \le\gamma_0 \le\gamma_{\max}.

Here N0N_0 denotes the electron number distribution at detachment. The constant KK is the normalization, ss is the spectral index, and γmin⁡\gamma_{\min} and γmax⁡\gamma_{\max} are the low- and high-energy cutoffs. We define

I1=∫γmin⁡γmax⁡γ01−s dγ0,I_1 = \int_{\gamma_{\min}}^{\gamma_{\max}} \gamma_0^{1-s}\,\mathrm{d}\gamma_0,
R1(Ψ)=1I1∫γmin⁡γmax⁡γ01−s1+Ψγ0 dγ0.(2)R_1(\Psi) = \frac{1}{I_1}\int_{\gamma_{\min}}^{\gamma_{\max}} \frac{\gamma_0^{1-s}}{1+\Psi\gamma_0}\,\mathrm{d}\gamma_0. \tag*{(2)}

The quantity I1I_1 normalises the initial electron energy distribution. With this normalization, R1=1R_1 = 1 at detachment, before radiative cooling has acted, and decreases as the electrons lose energy. Thus, R1R_1 measures the fraction of the radiating-electron pressure that remains after radiative cooling, apart from the common adiabatic change associated with the changing bubble volume. We define

fe,0=pe,detpdet,f_{\mathrm{e},0} = \frac{p_{\mathrm{e,det}}}{p_{\mathrm{det}}},

where pe,detp_{\mathrm{e,det}} is the radiating-electron pressure at detachment, so that fe,0f_{\mathrm{e},0} is the fraction of the total bubble pressure carried by these electrons. The remaining fraction, 1−fe,01-f_{\mathrm{e},0}, is supplied by the non-radiating component. Because each electron’s energy scales as γ\gamma, Equation (1) gives the radiating-electron pressure pe=pe,detV−4/3R1(Ψ)p_{\mathrm{e}} = p_{\mathrm{e,det}}\mathcal{V}^{-4/3}R_1(\Psi), while the non-radiating pressure is pnr=(1−fe,0)pdetV−4/3p_{\mathrm{nr}} = (1-f_{\mathrm{e},0})p_{\mathrm{det}}\mathcal{V}^{-4/3}. Pressure balance, pe+pnr=pp_{\mathrm{e}} + p_{\mathrm{nr}} = p, then gives

P=V−4/3D,D=1−fe,0+fe,0R1,P = \mathcal{V}^{-4/3}D,\qquad D = 1-f_{\mathrm{e},0}+f_{\mathrm{e},0}R_1,
V=(DP)3/4,Ψ˙=a(t)(PD)1/4.(3)\mathcal{V} = \left(\frac{D}{P}\right)^{3/4},\qquad\dot{\Psi}=a(t)\left(\frac{P}{D}\right)^{1/4}. \tag*{(3)}

Here DD accounts for the reduction in pressure caused by radiative losses from the electron population. Without radiative cooling, R1=1R_1 = 1 and therefore D=1D = 1, recovering the usual relativistic adiabatic relation P=V−4/3P = \mathcal{V}^{-4/3}. As the electrons cool, R1<1R_1 < 1 and hence D<1D < 1, so the bubble volume must adjust to maintain pressure balance. The final equation follows by substituting this volume relation into the definition of the cooling coordinate Ψ\Psi in Equation (1).

For any prescribed pressure history P(t)P(t), the electron spectrum, bubble volume, and enthalpy thus follow from the single cooling variable Ψ\Psi. Since H=4pVH = 4pV for contents with Γ=4/3\Gamma= 4/3, the enthalpy relative to its value at detachment, and relative to an otherwise identical adiabatic bubble at the same pressure, is

HHdet=P1/4D3/4,Crad≡Had(P)H=D−3/4.(4)\frac{H}{H_{\mathrm{det}}}=P^{1/4}D^{3/4},\qquad C_{\mathrm{rad}}\equiv\frac{H_{\mathrm{ad}}(P)}{H}=D^{-3/4}. \tag*{(4)}

Here HH is the bubble enthalpy, HdetH_{\mathrm{det}} is its value at detachment, and Had(P)H_{\mathrm{ad}}(P) is the enthalpy of an otherwise identical bubble evolved adiabatically to the same external pressure PP.

The corresponding fractional enthalpy deficit is

ΔH≡1−HHad=1−Crad−1.(5)\Delta_H \equiv1-\frac{H}{H_{\mathrm{ad}}}=1-C_{\mathrm{rad}}^{-1}. \tag*{(5)}

At the same ambient pressure, V/Vad=Crad−1V/V_{\mathrm{ad}}=C_{\mathrm{rad}}^{-1}. A spherical bubble rising at its terminal speed, where buoyancy balances drag, has vb∝(gRb)1/2v_b\propto(gR_b)^{1/2}, where gg is the local gravitational acceleration. Since Rb∝V1/3R_b\propto V^{1/3}, this gives vb/vb,ad=Crad−1/6v_b/v_{b,\mathrm{ad}}=C_{\mathrm{rad}}^{-1/6} (e.g., [e.g. 22]), where vbv_b and vb,adv_{b,\mathrm{ad}} are the terminal rise speeds of the radiatively affected and the corresponding adiabatic bubble. A large change in X-ray surface brightness need not imply a large change in the bubble enthalpy, because the radiating leptons carry only a small fraction of the total pressure. For example, complete loss of a radiating component with fe,0=0.01f_{\mathrm{e},0}=0.01 gives Crad=(1−0.01)−3/4=1.008C_{\mathrm{rad}}=(1-0.01)^{-3/4}=1.008, or ΔH=0.75%\Delta_H=0.75\%, whereas § 3.1 shows that a component of this size can fill the soft-X-ray deficit.

We use Crad=3C_{\mathrm{rad}}=3 as a model-validity limit for the illustrative trajectories and exclude crossings occurring beyond this value from the quoted results, because the model does not solve the dynamical response of the bubble to its own radiative losses self-consistently. At Crad=3C_{\mathrm{rad}}=3, the terminal rise speed is already 1−3−1/6≃17%1-3^{-1/6}\simeq17\% below its adiabatic value, so the neglected dynamical feedback may no longer be small. Magnetic losses are parameterized by b0=UB,0/UCMBb_0=U_{B,0}/U_{\mathrm{CMB}}, where UB,0U_{B,0} and UCMBU_{\mathrm{CMB}} are the magnetic and CMB energy densities at detachment. Assuming isotropic flux freezing, B=B0V−2/3B=B_0\mathcal{V}^{-2/3}, where B0B_0 and BB are the magnetic-field strengths at detachment and at time tt, respectively, giving UB/UCMB=b0P/DU_B/U_{\mathrm{CMB}}=b_0P/D. Magnetic pressure is not included in Equation (3). All main-text evolutionary results adopt b0=0b_0=0, i.e., IC cooling only.

Observed X-ray response

The cooling solution above determines the evolving lepton spectrum. To connect it to the observed X-ray emission, we calculate the response in a fixed observed band [E1,E2][E_1,E_2], where E1E_1 and E2E_2 are the lower and upper observed-frame photon energies. The full isotropic Thomson response ([8]) is

WX(γ)=135π4∫y1∞x3 dxex−1{G[min⁡(1,y2x)]−G(y1x)}.(6)W_X(\gamma)=\frac{135}{\pi^4}\int_{y_1}^{\infty}\frac{x^3\,\mathrm{d}x}{e^x-1}\left\{G\left[\min\left(1,\frac{y_2}{x}\right)\right]-G\left(\frac{y_1}{x}\right)\right\}. \tag*{(6)}

where x=ϵ/kTCMBx=\epsilon/kT_{\mathrm{CMB}} is the CMB photon energy ϵ\epsilon in units of kTCMBkT_{\mathrm{CMB}}, the bracket vanishes for y1/x≥1y_1/x\geq1 and

yi=Ei4γ2kTCMB,0,G(ξ)=ξ22+ξ39+2ξ33ln⁡ξ−ξ42.(7)y_i=\frac{E_i}{4\gamma^2 kT_{\mathrm{CMB},0}},\qquad G(\xi)=\frac{\xi^2}{2}+\frac{\xi^3}{9}+\frac{2\xi^3}{3}\ln\xi-\frac{\xi^4}{2}. \tag*{(7)}

Here kk is Boltzmann’s constant, TCMB,0T_{\mathrm{CMB},0} is the present-day CMB temperature, yiy_i is the dimensionless band edge corresponding to EiE_i, and ξ\xi is the dimensionless scattering variable. The prefactor normalises the all-band response to unity. Since the emitted band edges and TCMBT_{\mathrm{CMB}} share the same (1+z)(1+z) factor, the dimensionless response WX(γ)W_X(\gamma) is redshift invariant in a fixed observed band. The IC-to-thermal X-ray ratio (RXR_X, Equation (13)) is not redshift invariant, because it retains UCMBU_{\mathrm{CMB}} and the evolving thermal denominator. The 0.5–2 keV response peaks at γ≃749\gamma\simeq749, or at γ≃762\gamma\simeq762 after Galactic absorption. We evaluate the characteristic IC cooling time at γ∗≃753\gamma_* \simeq753, the unabsorbed peak on our numerical grid; the difference is below 2%. Even for γmax⁡=105\gamma_{\max}=10^5 at z=1.5z=1.5, 4γmax⁡kTCMB/mec2=4.60×10−44\gamma_{\max}kT_{\mathrm{CMB}}/m_{\mathrm e}c^2=4.60\times10^{-4}, so the calculation remains safely in the Thomson regime.

We describe the contribution of each Lorentz factor to the electron pressure through

q(γ,t)=1pdpedln⁡γ,QX(t)=∫WX(γ)γq(γ,t) dln⁡γ.(8)q(\gamma,t)=\frac{1}{p}\frac{\mathrm{d}p_{\mathrm e}}{\mathrm{d}\ln\gamma},\qquad Q_X(t)=\int W_X(\gamma)\gamma q(\gamma,t)\,\mathrm{d}\ln\gamma. \tag*{(8)}

Here pep_{\mathrm e} is the radiating-electron pressure, q(γ,t)q(\gamma,t) is its contribution per logarithmic Lorentz-factor interval normalised by the total bubble pressure pp, and QXQ_X is the corresponding X-ray-response-weighted moment. Thus, ∫qdln⁡γ=pe/p\int q\mathrm{d}\ln\gamma=p_{\mathrm e}/p rather than unity. At detachment,

QX(0)=fe,0MX,MX=∫γ2−sWX(γ) dγI1.(9)Q_X(0)=f_{\mathrm e,0}\mathcal{M}_X,\qquad\mathcal{M}_X=\frac{\int\gamma^{2-s}W_X(\gamma)\,\mathrm{d}\gamma}{I_1}. \tag*{(9)}

Here MX\mathcal{M}_X gives the X-ray spectral response per unit radiating-electron pressure at detachment. All numerical moments and figures use the Galactic-screened response. At γmin⁡=100\gamma_{\min}=100, MX=101.9\mathcal{M}_X=101.9, 104.0104.0, and 67.267.2 for s=2.1s=2.1, 2.52.5, and 3.03.0, respectively. For s=2.5s=2.5, MX=184.2\mathcal{M}_X=184.2 and 149.0149.0 at γmin⁡=300\gamma_{\min}=300 and 10001000. The spectral response MX\mathcal{M}_X depends non-monotonically on γmin⁡\gamma_{\min}: raising the cutoff first removes electrons that carry pressure but contribute little soft-band IC emission, so MX\mathcal{M}_X increases, and MX\mathcal{M}_X decreases again once the cutoff reaches the energies that dominate the response. We also define the response-weighted Lorentz factor at detachment

γeff≡∫γ3−sWX(γ) dγ∫γ2−sWX(γ) dγ.(10)\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}\equiv\frac{\int\gamma^{3-s}W_X(\gamma)\,\mathrm{d}\gamma}{\int\gamma^{2-s}W_X(\gamma)\,\mathrm{d}\gamma}. \tag*{(10)}

which gives the characteristic Lorentz factor of the electrons contributing to the observed X-ray band and generally differs from the kernel maximum γ∗\gamma_*. Using the cooling relation in Equation (1), the X-ray-weighted moment evolves as

QX(t)=fe,0AI1D∫γmin⁡γmax⁡γ02−s(1+Ψγ0)2WX(Aγ01+Ψγ0) dγ0.(11)Q_X(t)=\frac{f_{\mathrm e,0}A}{I_1D}\int_{\gamma_{\min}}^{\gamma_{\max}}\frac{\gamma_0^{2-s}}{(1+\Psi\gamma_0)^2}W_X\left(\frac{A\gamma_0}{1+\Psi\gamma_0}\right)\,\mathrm{d}\gamma_0. \tag*{(11)}

Because WX(γ)W_X(\gamma) is broad, electrons can cool into the range that contributes strongly to the observed band before later cooling below it.

We next relate this spectral moment to the observed X-ray deficit. Let δ0>0\delta_0>0 be the 0.5–2 keV deficit of an empty cavity relative to the undisturbed atmosphere. If IdispI_{\mathrm{disp}} is the X-ray intensity displaced by the cavity and IICI_{\mathrm{IC}} is the IC intensity produced inside the cavity,

δX=δ0(1−RX),RX≡IIC/Idisp,(12)\delta_X=\delta_0(1-\mathcal{R}_X),\qquad\mathcal{R}_X\equiv I_{\mathrm{IC}}/I_{\mathrm{disp}}, \tag*{(12)}
RX=FIC4σTUCMBpmecnenHΛXQX.(13)\mathcal{R}_X=\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}}\frac{4\sigma_{\mathrm T}U_{\mathrm{CMB}}p}{m_{\mathrm e}c n_{\mathrm e}n_{\mathrm H}\Lambda_X}Q_X. \tag*{(13)}

Here δX\delta_X is the remaining X-ray deficit, FIC\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}} is the geometric correction for the IC-emitting path length, nen_{\mathrm e} and nHn_{\mathrm H} are the electron and hydrogen number densities of the surrounding gas, and ΛX\Lambda_X is its 0.5–2 keV emissivity coefficient. When the IC and displaced thermal emission arise from the same projected region, the common (1+z)−4(1+z)^{-4} surface-brightness dimming cancels in their ratio. The remaining redshift dependence enters through UCMBU_{\mathrm{CMB}} and the atmosphere. The condition RX=1\mathcal{R}_X=1 means that the IC emission exactly replaces the displaced thermal emission in the 0.5–2 keV energy flux. It need not give equal detector counts, because the instrument response weights the IC and thermal spectra differently.

The foreground-absorbed 0.5–2 keV emissivity per nenHn_{\mathrm e}n_{\mathrm H} is

ΛX=∫(1+z)E1(1+z)E2λEAPEC(T,Z)e−NHσ[E/(1+z)] dE.(14)\Lambda_X=\int_{(1+z)E_1}^{(1+z)E_2}\lambda_{\mathrm E}^{\mathrm{APEC}}(T,Z)e^{-N_{\mathrm H}\sigma[E/(1+z)]}\,\mathrm{d}E. \tag*{(14)}

where λEAPEC(T,Z)\lambda_{\mathrm E}^{\mathrm{APEC}}(T,Z) is the APEC spectral emissivity at gas temperature TT and metallicity ZZ, NHN_{\mathrm H} is the Galactic hydrogen column density, and σ(E)\sigma(E) is the photoelectric absorption cross section per hydrogen atom. We use AtomDB/APEC 3.1.3, Z=0.3Z⊙Z=0.3Z_\odot on the abundance scale of EE. E. Anders & N. Grevesse [1], and nH=0.83nen_{\mathrm H}=0.83n_{\mathrm e} [28, 13]. The adopted absorbed emissivities, computed with pyatomdb 1.2.0/CIESession for z=1.16z=1.16 and NH=1.01×1020 cm−2N_{\mathrm H}=1.01\times10^{20}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-2}, are ΛX=(7.83,8.02,8.15)×10−24 erg cm3 s−1\Lambda_X=(7.83,8.02,8.15)\times10^{-24}\ \mathrm{erg\ cm^3\ s^{-1}} at kT=(6.33,7.77,10.29)kT=(6.33,7.77,10.29) keV. For consistency, all quoted moments, thresholds, and figures include the same Galactic absorption in the IC emission. Relative to the unabsorbed response, a neutral-gas transmission matched to the adopted NHN_{\mathrm H} and E. Anders & N. Grevesse [1] abundance scale lowers MX\mathcal{M}_X by 2.2–3.0% over the displayed γmin⁡\gamma_{\min} range without changing the qualitative behaviour. Because the absorption depends on observed energy, the screened fixed-band response remains redshift invariant. We retain the abundance scale used in the source analysis.

The factor FIC\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}} corrects the IC-to-thermal ratio for the thermal emission displaced along the cavity line of sight. For a uniformly emitting projected fraction ϕ\phi of a spherical cavity of radius RbR_b, centered at projected radius bb and line-of-sight coordinate ℓ0\ell_0, in an isothermal β\beta-model, the factor can be written as:

FIC=ϕ[12Rb∫ℓ0−Rbℓ0+Rb(1+(b2+ℓ2)/rc21+(b2+ℓ02)/rc2)−3βdℓ]−1(15)\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}}=\phi\left[\frac{1}{2R_b}\int_{\ell_0-R_b}^{\ell_0+R_b}\left(\frac{1+(b^2+\ell^2)/r_c^2}{1+(b^2+\ell_0^2)/r_c^2}\right)^{-3\beta}\mathrm{d}\ell\right]^{-1} \tag*{(15)}

Here ϕ\phi is the projected IC-emitting fraction of the cavity, rcr_c is the β\beta-model core radius, and β\beta is its slope parameter. The term in brackets is the mean thermal emissivity along the cavity chord relative to its value at the cavity centre. Direct integration for our testbed cluster SPT-CL J2215−3537, using Rb≃33R_b \simeq33 kpc, b≃230b \simeq230 kpc, and its published double-β\beta density profile, gives 0.9817≤FIC/ϕ≤1.01460.9817 \leq\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}}/\phi\leq1.0146 over ∣ℓ0∣≤b|\ell_0| \leq b. Thus, for this system the geometric correction is only at the percent level.

The radiating-lepton pressure fraction used here is local: it refers to the plasma that produces the IC emission, and we do not infer a volume-averaged value. In the time-dependent examples, we assume the emitting plasma fills the whole cavity, so ϕ=1\phi=1; a smaller covering fraction is used only in the instantaneous fill-in calculation. We exclude any compressed rim from IdispI_{\mathrm{disp}}, since its emission is instead accounted for separately, in the two-dimensional surface-brightness model used to detect the cavity.

The soft-band thermal deficit is exactly filled when RX=1\mathcal{R}_{X}=1. This condition is evaluated at a single instant and does not require the evolutionary model of § 2.1 or a prescribed pressure history. For an idealised detection threshold Smin⁡≡δdet/δ0S_{\min}\equiv\delta_{\mathrm{det}}/\delta_0, where δdet\delta_{\mathrm{det}} is the minimum deficit required for detection, the cavity satisfies the detection criterion when

RX<Rcrit≡1−Smin⁡,(16)\mathcal{R}_{X}<R_{\mathrm{crit}}\equiv1-S_{\min}, \tag*{(16)}

and fails it when RX>Rcrit\mathcal{R}_{X}>R_{\mathrm{crit}}. We refer to a crossing from RX>Rcrit\mathcal{R}_{X}>R_{\mathrm{crit}} to RX<Rcrit\mathcal{R}_{X}<R_{\mathrm{crit}} as a downward, or recovery, crossing. The condition RX=1\mathcal{R}_{X}=1 describes complete filling of the energy deficit in the chosen band, whereas Equation (16) is only a simplified detection threshold, not a calibrated survey completeness function. For reference, Appendix Figure 3(b) also shows RX,b=3\mathcal{R}_{X,b}=3 as an illustrative IC-bright state, not as a boundary.

Results

For the instantaneous fill-in calculation, the benchmark state is a local region containing an uncooled power-law electron spectrum. In the time-dependent examples, the same state defines the start of the trajectory, so

fe,b=fe,0f_{e,b}=f_{e,0} and P(0)=1P(0)=1. Here fe,bf_{e,b} is the local radiating-lepton pressure fraction at the benchmark state, whereas fe,0f_{e,0} denotes the same fraction at the start of an evolutionary trajectory. The IC-to-thermal X-ray ratio at the benchmark state is

RX,b=FICfe,bMXKatm,Katm≡4σTUCMBpmecnenHΛX.(17)\mathcal{R}_{X,b}=\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}}f_{e,b}\mathcal{M}_{X}\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}},\qquad\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}}\equiv\frac{4\sigma_{\mathrm{T}}U_{\mathrm{CMB}}p}{m_{\mathrm{e}}c n_{\mathrm{e}}n_{\mathrm{H}}\Lambda_X}. \tag*{(17)}

Here Katm\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}} contains the dependence on the local gas properties and the CMB energy density; the other three factors are the geometric factor FIC\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}}, the radiating-lepton pressure fraction fe,bf_{e,b}, and the spectral response MX\mathcal{M}_{X} (Equation (9)). The main instantaneous fill-in results are summarized in Table 1.

CaseRequired FICfe,b\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}}f_{e,b}CradC_{\mathrm{rad}}
Central atmosphere, s=2.5s=2.50.57–1.22%1.004–1.009
Atmospheric TT–pp range, s=2.5s=2.50.27–2.39%1.002–1.018
Full spectral and TT–pp range0.20–3.70%1.001–1.029
Low-cutoff control18.9%1.170

Table 1. Soft-X-ray fill-in thresholds. The second column gives the required product FICfe,b\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}}f_{e,b} for RX=1\mathcal{R}_{X}=1. The final column gives CradC_{\mathrm{rad}} after complete loss of the corresponding co-spatial lepton component, assuming FIC=1\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}}=1.

Pressure required for X-ray fill-in

We first evaluate the fill-in condition using the measured atmosphere of SPT-CL J2215−3537 at z=1.16z=1.16, which we use as the testbed for the model. At the projected radius of the feature, the azimuthally averaged radial bin gives kT=7.77−1.44+2.52kT=7.77^{+2.52}_{-1.44} keV and p=0.06−0.01+0.02 keV cm−3p=0.06^{+0.02}_{-0.01}\,\mathrm{keV\,cm^{-3}} ([5]). The pressure is derived from the deprojected density profile using p=1.92nekTp=1.92n_{\mathrm{e}}kT, giving ne=4.02×10−3 cm−3n_{\mathrm{e}}=4.02\times10^{-3}\,\mathrm{cm^{-3}} at the central values and nH=0.83nen_{\mathrm{H}}=0.83n_{\mathrm{e}}. Using the central temperature, pressure, and X-ray emissivity, we obtain Katm=0.790\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}}=0.790, which scales as

Katm0.790=(T7.77 keV)2(0.06 keV cm−3p)(8.02×10−24 erg cm3 s−1ΛX).(18)\frac{\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}}}{0.790}=\left(\frac{T}{7.77\ \mathrm{keV}}\right)^2\left(\frac{0.06\ \mathrm{keV\,cm^{-3}}}{p}\right)\left(\frac{8.02\times10^{-24}\,\mathrm{erg\,cm^3\,s^{-1}}}{\Lambda_X}\right). \tag*{(18)}

Combining the quoted upper and lower limits on temperature and pressure with the corresponding emissivities gives the conservative range

Katm=0.403–1.635.(19)\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}}=0.403\text{--}1.635. \tag*{(19)}

Because the covariance between temperature and spectral normalization is unavailable, this range is not a statistical confidence interval.

For s=2.5s = 2.5, 100≤γmin⁡≤1000100 \le\gamma_{\min} \le1000, and γmax⁡=105\gamma_{\max} = 10^{5}, the central atmosphere requires

FICfe,b=(0.57–1.22)×10−2(Katm=0.790)(20)\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}} f_{\mathrm{e,b}} = (0.57\text{–}1.22) \times10^{-2} \qquad(\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}} = 0.790) \tag*{(20)}

to fill the thermal deficit in the soft X-ray band. Figure 1(a) shows how this threshold depends on the electron spectrum. For fixed ss, the required pressure fraction first decreases as γmin⁡\gamma_{\min} is increased, reaches a minimum at intermediate γmin⁡\gamma_{\min}, and then rises again. This behaviour produces a broad minimum in the required pressure fraction rather than a monotonic dependence on γmin⁡\gamma_{\min}. Across 2.1≤s≤3.02.1 \le s \le3.0, the central-atmosphere threshold spans 0.410.41–1.88%1.88\% over the adopted spectral range. The threshold also depends on the surrounding atmosphere, as shown in Figure 1(b). Increasing Katm\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}} increases the IC emission relative to the displaced thermal emission and therefore lowers the required lepton-pressure fraction. The blue band shows the s=2.5s = 2.5 cases, while the wider grey band includes the full range 2.1≤s≤3.02.1 \le s \le3.0; the vertical dotted line marks the central value Katm=0.790\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}} = 0.790. Thus, both the electron spectrum and the local ICM properties change the numerical threshold, but the required radiating pressure remains at the percent level around the measured J2215 atmosphere. Including the atmospheric limits broadens the s=2.5s = 2.5 result to 0.270.27–2.39%2.39\%. Over the full adopted spectral domain, 2.1≤s≤3.02.1 \le s \le3.0 and 100≤γmin⁡≤1000100 \le\gamma_{\min} \le1000, the threshold becomes 0.200.20–3.70%3.70\% across the conservative temperature–pressure range (Figure 1, right). Even at the upper end, complete loss of this co-spatial lepton component reduces the enthalpy by only 2.8%2.8\% relative to a same-pressure adiabatic bubble. At fixed TT, pp, nXn_{\mathrm{X}}, spectrum, and overlap, the redshift dependence follows directly from UCMBU_{\mathrm{CMB}}. Writing fe,fillf_{\mathrm{e,fill}} for the radiating-lepton pressure fraction required for full soft-X-ray fill-in, we have:

Figure 1. Dependence of the soft-X-ray fill-in threshold on the electron spectrum and the cluster atmosphere. Left: The radiating-lepton pressure fraction required for RX,b=1R_{\mathrm{X,b}} = 1 in the central J2215 atmosphere, with Katm=0.790\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}} = 0.790 and FIC=1\mathcal{F}_{\mathrm{IC}} = 1. The contours give the required fraction in per cent as a function of the spectral index ss and low-energy cutoff γmin⁡\gamma_{\min}. Right: The required pressure fraction as the atmospheric factor Katm\mathcal{K}_{\mathrm{atm}} varies over the conservative range 0.4030.403–1.6351.635. The blue band shows s=2.5s = 2.5, while the grey band includes 2.1≤s≤3.02.1 \le s \le3.0; both use 100≤γmin⁡≤1000100 \le\gamma_{\min} \le1000 and γmax⁡=105\gamma_{\max} = 10^{5}. The vertical line marks the central J2215 value.

fe,fill(z)=fe,fill(1.16)(2.161+z)4.(21)f_{\mathrm{e,fill}}(z) = f_{\mathrm{e,fill}}(1.16)\left(\frac{2.16}{1+z}\right)^{4}. \tag*{(21)}

For the central s=2.5s = 2.5 range, a 1%1\% component reaches full soft-X-ray fill-in at z≃0.87z \simeq0.87–1.271.27. Across the full adopted spectral and atmospheric range, the corresponding interval is z≃0.44z \simeq0.44–2.002.00. These values show only the CMB redshift scaling at fixed atmospheric properties; they are not an evolutionary model for the cluster atmosphere.

The low-energy spectrum is the main remaining spectral uncertainty. A control spectrum with γmin⁡=10\gamma_{\min} = 10 and s=3s = 3 requires 18.9%18.9\% in the central atmosphere because most of its pressure lies below the soft-X-ray response. Such populations are also more sensitive to Coulomb losses and to departures from an ultrarelativistic equation of state during cooling. We therefore adopt γmin⁡≥100\gamma_{\min} \ge100 as the primary analysis range, while retaining γmin⁡=10\gamma_{\min} = 10 as a low-energy control case. Partial projected coverage raises the required local fraction approximately as ϕ−1\phi^{-1}; a global pressure fraction cannot be inferred without a multiphase volume model.

Evolution of the X-ray surface brightness

The instantaneous fill-in threshold above does not require a bubble trajectory. To illustrate how the X-ray emission may evolve after detachment, we use

tIC(γ∗,z)≡3mec4σTUCMBγ∗=194 Myr(γ∗753)−1(1+z2)−4,(22)t_{\rm IC}(\gamma_\ast,z) \equiv\frac{3m_{\rm e}c}{4\sigma_{\rm T}U_{\rm CMB}\gamma_\ast} =194\ {\rm Myr}\left(\frac{\gamma_\ast}{753}\right)^{-1}\left(\frac{1+z}{2}\right)^{-4}, \tag*{(22)}
P(u)=(1+uΘp)−η,u=t/tIC,(23)P(u)=\left(1+\frac{u}{\Theta_{\rm p}}\right)^{-\eta},\qquad u=t/t_{\rm IC}, \tag*{(23)}
T2/ΛXT02/ΛX,0=PβX.(24)\frac{T^2/\Lambda_X}{T_0^2/\Lambda_{X,0}}=P^{\beta_X}. \tag*{(24)}

Here u=t/tICu=t/t_{\rm IC} is the dimensionless time, while T0T_0 and ΛX,0\Lambda_{X,0} are the temperature and X-ray emissivity at detachment. The parameter Θp=τp/tIC\Theta_{\rm p}=\tau_{\rm p}/t_{\rm IC}, where τp\tau_{\rm p} is the pressure-evolution timescale, sets the timescale over which the pressure changes; η\eta controls the decline rate, and βX=dln⁡(T2/ΛX)/dln⁡P\beta_X={\rm d}\ln(T^2/\Lambda_X)/{\rm d}\ln P describes the thermal response. The ranges Θp=0.5\Theta_{\rm p}=0.5–2, η=0.5\eta=0.5–1.5, and βX=−0.3\beta_X=-0.3 to 0.3 sample declining pressure histories; they are not fitted to J2215. For fixed projected overlap,

RX(u)=RX,0QX(u)fe,0MXP(u)βX−1.(25)R_X(u)=R_{X,0}\frac{Q_X(u)}{f_{\rm e,0}M_X}P(u)^{\beta_X-1}. \tag*{(25)}

Here RX,0R_{X,0} is the IC-to-thermal X-ray ratio at detachment. If the overlap changes, the right-hand side is multiplied by FIC(u)/FIC(0)F_{\rm IC}(u)/F_{\rm IC}(0).

The broad Thomson response reveals leptons over a wider energy range than the delta-function estimate (Figure 2, left). As the population cools, electrons initially above the energies that contribute most strongly to the 0.5–2 keV band can move into this range before later cooling below it. Consequently, the soft-X-ray IC emission can increase during the early stages of cooling even though the electron population is continuously losing energy. At later times, the electrons that contribute most strongly to the observed band cool to lower energies and the IC emission decreases. This allows a non-monotonic X-ray evolution without requiring a comparable change in the total bubble enthalpy.

Figure 2. Soft-X-ray response and evolution of the cavity signal. Left: Galactic-absorbed Thomson response WX(γ)W_X(\gamma) for IC/CMB emission in the observed 0.5–2 keV band. The response peaks near γ≃762\gamma\simeq762, while γeff=1114\gamma_{\rm eff}=1114 for (s,γmin⁡)=(2.5,100)(s,\gamma_{\min})=(2.5,100). The shaded interval shows the electron energies selected by the delta-function approximation. Middle: The spectral response per unit radiating-lepton pressure, MXM_X, as a function of γmin⁡\gamma_{\min} for s=2.1s=2.1, 2.5, and 3.0. Removing low-energy electrons initially increases the X-ray emission per unit pressure, but the response falls once the cutoff reaches the electrons that contribute strongly to the observed band. Right: Two example trajectories in the central J2215 atmosphere. One crosses the adopted detection threshold twice, whereas the other crosses it once as the electrons cool. The right axis gives the fractional enthalpy deficit, which remains below 0.4% at the downward crossings. Both trajectories use s=2.5s=2.5, γmax⁡=105\gamma_{\max}=10^5, P=(1+u)−1P=(1+u)^{-1}, b0=βX=0b_0=\beta_X=0, FIC=1F_{\rm IC}=1, and Smin⁡=0.2S_{\min}=0.2.

The two example trajectories show how this spectral evolution produces different X-ray histories in the measured central atmosphere of J2215 (Figure 2, right). Both adopt s=2.5s=2.5, γmax⁡=105\gamma_{\max}=10^5, P=(1+u)−1P=(1+u)^{-1}, b0=βX=0b_0=\beta_X=0, and FIC=1F_{\rm IC}=1. With fe,0=0.006f_{\rm e,0}=0.006 and γmin⁡=1000\gamma_{\min}=1000, the IC-to-thermal ratio begins at RX,0=0.706R_{X,0}=0.706, rises as electrons cool into the soft-X-ray-producing energy range, and then decreases again as they cool below it. It therefore crosses the adopted threshold twice, with the downward crossing at ure=0.626u_{\rm re}=0.626, where ureu_{\rm re} denotes the dimensionless time of the downward recovery crossing. With fe,0=0.010f_{\rm e,0}=0.010 and γmin⁡=300\gamma_{\min}=300, the ratio begins at RX,0=1.455R_{X,0}=1.455 and decreases after detachment, crossing the same threshold only once at ure=0.648u_{\rm re}=0.648. In this case, a larger fraction of the initial electron population already contributes efficiently to the observed band, so there is no comparable initial rise. We refer to the first case as a two-crossing history and to the second as a one-way history. The enthalpy ratios at these downward crossings are 1.0033 and 1.0039, corresponding to deficits below 0.4%. Thus, the X-ray visibility can change substantially while the mechanical energy of the bubble remains nearly unchanged.

The wider parameter grid also includes Smin⁡=0S_{\min}=0 and 0.5. The following interval refers specifically to the selected grid subset, rather than to the two illustrative trajectories quoted above. Restricting this grid subset to b0=0b_0=0, γmin⁡≥100\gamma_{\min}\ge100, cases with a finite downward crossing, and Crad≤3C_{\rm rad}\le3 gives ure=0.70u_{\rm re}=0.70–1.82, corresponding to roughly 0.06–0.35 Gyr over z=1z=1–1.5. These are crossing times within the model and depend partly on the prescribed pressure history; they are not measured cavity ages. A two-crossing history additionally requires the cavity to remain coherent until the downward recovery crossing. Defining tre≡uretICt_{\rm re}\equiv u_{\rm re}t_{\rm IC}, this requires

tre<tdis,(26)t_{\rm re}<t_{\rm dis}, \tag*{(26)}

where tdist_{\rm dis} is the disruption or loss-of-coherence time. We impose this condition but do not calculate tdist_{\rm dis}. We evaluate UCMBU_{\rm CMB} at the observed redshift throughout; allowing it to evolve would change the numerical crossing times but not their ordering. Backward evolution over 0.35 Gyr at z=1.16z=1.16 raises UCMBU_{\rm CMB} by 22% in the adopted cosmology, so the longest times should not be read as precise ages. The full parameter grid and its numerical controls are described in Appendix A.

Discussion and Conclusions

The result separates two quantities that cavity analyses often treat together. A percent-level radiating-lepton component can fill the X-ray deficit in the soft X-ray band even though it contributes only a small fraction of the total bubble pressure. The bubble may therefore remain mechanically important even when its X-ray depression becomes weak or disappears. If the X-ray surface-brightness depression is not identified, the cavity cannot enter a standard X-ray cavity analysis, and the corresponding 4pV4pV estimate is never made.

The atmospheric factor KatmK_{\rm atm} and spectral moment MXM_X determine how much radiating-lepton pressure is required for X-ray fill-in. KatmK_{\rm atm} increases with UCMBU_{\rm CMB} and, at fixed observed-band emissivity, approximately as kT/nekT/n_e, so the required lepton fraction decreases rapidly with redshift and also decreases in hotter or lower-density gas. MXM_X measures how efficiently the electron population produces IC emission in the observed band per unit lepton pressure. The quoted percent-level range therefore applies to the tested uncool­ed power laws with 100≤γmin⁡≤1000100\le\gamma_{\min}\le1000 and γmax⁡=105\gamma_{\max}=10^5. Spectral curvature, spatial gradients, and mixed plasma ages will broaden this behaviour, whereas a low-cutoff spectrum can carry substantial pressure while remaining inefficient in soft-band IC emission.

The time-dependent examples show that the X-ray visibility can change while the bubble enthalpy remains nearly unchanged. A two-crossing history additionally requires tre<tdist_{\rm re}<t_{\rm dis} and little reacceleration over the same interval. Whether such a history occurs in a physical bubble will therefore depend on disruption, entrainment, mixing, magnetic draping, and turbulence [22, 9]. The prescribed pressure paths are not source fits, and tracks reaching u≳3u\gtrsim3 are less reliable because pressure balance and the neglect of dynamical feedback (§ 2.1) become less accurate at late times. Excluding these late stages changes neither the instantaneous fill-in threshold nor the early one-way behaviour.

Coulomb and magnetic losses set additional limits on the time-dependent examples. At the lowest Lorentz factor reached in the selected tests, γ≃60\gamma\simeq60, Coulomb and IC losses are equal for an internal thermal-plasma number density nint=7.7×10−4 cm−3n_{\rm int}=7.7\times10^{-4}\ {\rm cm}^{-3}, and the Coulomb-loss time satisfies tCoul≥3tICt_{\rm Coul}\ge3t_{\rm IC} for nint≲2.5×10−4 cm−3n_{\rm int}\lesssim2.5\times10^{-4}\ {\rm cm}^{-3} [27]. The evolutionary tracks are therefore most applicable to cavities with low internal gas density. At z=1.16z=1.16, the equivalent CMB magnetic field is BCMB=15.1 μGB_{\rm CMB}=15.1\ \mu{\rm G}. Fields of 1–5 μG\mu{\rm G} give UB/UCMB=0.004U_B/U_{\rm CMB}=0.004–0.11, so IC losses remain dominant and these fields can be treated as tests of additional synchrotron cooling. At 10 μG\mu{\rm G}, UB/UCMB=0.44U_B/U_{\rm CMB}=0.44, so synchrotron losses are no longer negligible, although UB/p≃0.04U_B/p\simeq0.04 at the benchmark pressure. A fully self-consistent calculation at such field strengths would also need to include magnetic pressure in Equation (3). For γ∼103\gamma\sim10^3, the corresponding observed synchrotron frequency is about 1.7–8.6 MHz for B=1B=1–5 μG\mu{\rm G}, below the terrestrial ionospheric cutoff. Thus, the absence of radio emission would not by itself rule out the electron population considered here.

The calculation establishes when IC/CMB emission can fill the 0.5–2 keV X-ray deficit before applying the detector response. Translating that threshold into a prediction for observed high-redshift cavity samples requires a source model together with the instrument response, orientation, partial filling, spatially varying spectra, point spread function (PSF), background, and exposure effects. Establishing a population bias further requires the distribution of bubble properties. The present result provides the physical input for those analyses: at fixed atmosphere, geometry, and redshift, stronger IC/CMB emission should be associated with a weaker X-ray cavity deficit. Failure to find such a relation would constrain the prevalence of this channel under the assumed spectra. More broadly, the result connects radio-faint ghost plasma [11] (L. Bırzan et al. 2008) and IC/CMB-bright aged lobes [10, 25, 20] to the observable used in X-ray cavity calorimetry. High-redshift cavity visibility therefore depends not only on geometry, but also on the surrounding atmosphere and the particle content of the bubble.

Acknowledgments

We thank the anonymous referee for their constructive comments that have improved the overall clarity and presentation of the paper. R.S. and S.M. acknowledge support from the Department of Atomic Energy, Government of India, under project no. RTI4019. Generative-AI tools were used for language editing and code debugging; the authors verified the scientific content, calculations, references, and final text.

Software: astropy [2, 3, 4], NumPy [16], SciPy [29], Matplotlib [21], pyatomdb 1.2.0, xraydb 4.5.8

Appendix

Model Tests and Numerical Checks

Crossing behaviour and projected filling

The instantaneous fill-in thresholds do not depend on a prescribed bubble trajectory. The pressure-history grid is used only to test how the X-ray evolution changes when the model parameters are varied. Figure 3(a) classifies each point of this grid by the resulting crossing behaviour. One-way crossings, in which the X-ray deficit becomes detectable once and stays detectable, occupy a broad part of the parameter space. Two-crossing histories, in which the deficit is first filled and then reappears, are confined to the narrow strip shown in the inset, and therefore require a more specific combination of spectrum and pressure history. A third class of tracks shows no recovery crossing by umax⁡=6u_{\max}=6, where umax⁡u_{\max} is the maximum dimensionless integration time. The black curve marks the instantaneous fill-in condition RX,b=1\mathcal{R}_{X,b}=1 from § 3, so the map shows where the time-dependent behaviour sits relative to that threshold. Figure 3(b) shows the separate effect of partial projected coverage, which increases the required local lepton-pressure fraction approximately as ϕ−1\phi^{-1}.

Tests of the X-ray evolution and projected filling

Figure 3. Tests of the X-ray evolution and projected filling. Left: The crossing behaviour as a function of the low-energy cutoff γmin⁡\gamma_{\min} and the local radiating-lepton pressure fraction for s=2.5s = 2.5, Smin⁡=0.2S_{\min} = 0.2, γmax⁡=105\gamma_{\max} = 10^{5}, and (Θp,η,b0,βX)=(1,1,0,0)(\Theta_{\mathrm{p}}, \eta, b_{0}, \beta_{\mathrm{X}}) = (1, 1, 0, 0). The orange region contains histories that cross the detection threshold twice, while the blue region contains cases with one downward crossing. The black curve marks full soft-X-ray fill-in, RX,b=1R_{\mathrm{X},b} = 1, and the grey band shows the measured atmospheric range. Cases for which Crad>3C_{\mathrm{rad}} > 3 at the downward recovery crossing lie beyond the adopted model-validity limit and are excluded from the quoted grid-based crossing-time interval. Right: Required local radiating-lepton pressure fraction at γmin⁡=100\gamma_{\min} = 100 as the projected emitting fraction ϕ\phi is varied. The blue band gives the full-fill-in condition. The RX,b=3R_{\mathrm{X},b} = 3 band is shown only as an illustrative IC-bright case.

Equation of state and age mixing

For radiating leptons with adiabatic index Γe=4/3\Gamma_{\mathrm{e}}=4/3 and non-radiating support with adiabatic index Γnr\Gamma_{\mathrm{nr}},

P=(1−fe,0)V−Γnr+fe,0R1(Ψ)V−4/3.(27)P=(1-f_{\mathrm{e},0})\mathcal{V}^{-\Gamma_{\mathrm{nr}}}+f_{\mathrm{e},0}R_1(\Psi)\mathcal{V}^{-4/3}. \tag*{(27)}

For each PP and Ψ\Psi, this equation gives the bubble volume V\mathcal{V}. The total enthalpy is

H=(4pe+ΓnrΓnr−1pnr)V.(28)H=\left(4p_{\mathrm{e}}+\frac{\Gamma_{\mathrm{nr}}}{\Gamma_{\mathrm{nr}}-1}p_{\mathrm{nr}}\right)\mathcal{V}. \tag*{(28)}

Here pep_{\mathrm{e}} and pnrp_{\mathrm{nr}} are the radiating-lepton and non-radiating pressures, respectively. Taking Γnr=5/3\Gamma_{\mathrm{nr}}=5/3 represents thermal, non-relativistic support. The two-crossing behaviour is still present in this case and extends to somewhat lower fe,0f_{\mathrm{e},0}. The electron-dominated limit is unchanged because the non-radiating pressure vanishes as fe,0→1f_{\mathrm{e},0}\to1.

We also test whether a spread in plasma ages changes the X-ray evolution. We average the response as

QX‾(u)=∫QX(ru)w(r) dr∫w(r) dr.(29)\overline{Q_X}(u)=\frac{\int Q_X(ru)w(r)\,\mathrm{d}r}{\int w(r)\,\mathrm{d}r}. \tag*{(29)}

Here rr rescales the effective plasma age and w(r)w(r) is the corresponding weight. For a top-hat distribution, let Δr\Delta_r denote the fractional half-width, so that r∈[1−Δr,1+Δr]r\in[1-\Delta_r,1+\Delta_r] with uniform weight; for a lognormal distribution, Δr\Delta_r denotes the coefficient of variation at unit mean. For Δr=0.5\Delta_r=0.5, both choices preserve the reference crossings. This test includes only the effect of mixing different plasma ages on the X-ray response; it does not model their dynamics separately.

Parameter range and numerical checks

The parameter grid varies s=2.1,2.5,3.0s = 2.1, 2.5, 3.0; γmin⁡=10,100,300,1000\gamma_{\min} = 10, 100, 300, 1000; Θp=0.5,2\Theta_{\mathrm{p}} = 0.5, 2; η=0.5,1.5\eta= 0.5, 1.5; b0=0,1b_{0} = 0, 1; and βX=−0.3,0.3\beta_{\mathrm{X}} = -0.3, 0.3, together with the reference pressure path. The quoted grid-based crossing interval uses only b0=0b_{0} = 0, γmin⁡≥100\gamma_{\min} \ge100, cases with a finite downward crossing, and Crad≤3C_{\mathrm{rad}} \le3. The two illustrative trajectories in Figure 2 are reported separately and do not define this interval. The main parameter map fixes s=2.5s = 2.5, FIC=1F_{\mathrm{IC}} = 1, Smin⁡=0.2S_{\min} = 0.2, and umax⁡=6u_{\max} = 6. We also repeat the calculation with Smin⁡=0S_{\min} = 0 and 0.50.5, different pressure paths, umax⁡=10u_{\max} = 10, and half the integration step. These runs test whether the results depend strongly on the chosen numerical setup. Cases with b0=1b_{0} = 1 are not included in the quoted crossing-time range because Equation (3) does not include magnetic pressure. For b0=1b_{0} = 1, UB/p≃0.094U_{\mathrm{B}}/p \simeq0.094 initially and reaches 0.410.41 by Crad=3C_{\mathrm{rad}} = 3. The adopted γmax⁡=105\gamma_{\max} = 10^{5} has the largest effect when ss is close to 2. Varying γmax⁡\gamma_{\max} from 10410^{4} to 10610^{6} changes the central fill-in threshold by at most 44% over the tested grid, with the largest change at s=2.1s = 2.1 and γmin⁡=1000\gamma_{\min} = 1000; the largest changes are 24% for s=2.5s = 2.5 and 9% for s=3s = 3. The main-text range therefore applies to the adopted value γmax⁡=105\gamma_{\max} = 10^{5} and does not include uncertainty from this upper cutoff.

Several numerical checks were also carried out. The kernel satisfies the analytic all-band normalization to 4×10−164 \times10^{-16} and agrees with direct quadrature to a maximum relative interpolation error 2.23×10−32.23 \times10^{-3}. Two independent methods for evolving Ψ\Psi agree to 3.7×10−73.7 \times10^{-7}. Extending umax⁡u_{\max} from 6 to 10 does not change the type of crossing history, and halving the step shifts the reference ureu_{\mathrm{re}} by less than 10−310^{-3}. Direct integration of Equation (15) gives 0.9817≤FIC/ϕ≤1.01460.9817 \le F_{\mathrm{IC}}/\phi\le1.0146 across the two J2215J_{2215} components. The screened-kernel calculation agrees with the direct moment calculation, and including Galactic absorption does not change the crossing behaviour.

References

  1. [1]Anders, E., & Grevesse, N. 1989, GeoCoA, 53, 197, doi: 10.1016/0016-7037(89)90286-XDOI
  2. [2]Astropy Collaboration, Robitaille, T. P., Tollerud, E. J., et al. 2013, A&A, 558, A33, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201322068
  3. [3]Astropy Collaboration, Price-Whelan, A. M., Sipőcz, B. M., et al. 2018, AJ, 156, 123, doi: 10.3847/1538-3881/aabс4f
  4. [4]Astropy Collaboration, Price-Whelan, A. M., Lim, P. L., et al. 2022, ApJ, 935, 167, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ac7c74DOI
  5. [5]Bessa, V. S., Dupke, R. A., & Jiménez-Teja, Y. 2026, ApJ, 998, 35, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ae2d20DOI
  6. [6]Bîrzan, L., McNamara, B. R., Nulsen, P. E. J., Carilli, C. L., & Wise, M. W. 2008, ApJ, 686, 859, doi: 10.1086/591416
  7. [7]Bîrzan, L., Rafferty, D. A., McNamara, B. R., Wise, M. W., & Nulsen, P. E. J. 2004, ApJ, 607, 800, doi: 10.1086/383519DOI
  8. [8]Blumenthal, G. R., & Gould, R. J. 1970, Reviews of Modern Physics, 42, 237, doi: 10.1103/RevModPhys.42.237DOI
  9. [9]Bourne, M. A., & Yang, H.-Y. K. 2023, Galaxies, 11, 73, doi: 10.3390/galaxies11030073DOI
  10. [10]Celotti, A., & Fabian, A. C. 2004, MNRAS, 353, 523, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2004.08085.xDOI
  11. [11]Enßlin, T. A., & Brüggen, M. 2002, MNRAS, 331, 1011, doi: 10.1046/j.1365-8711.2002.05261.x
  12. [12]Fabian, A. C. 2012, ARA&A, 50, 455, doi: 10.1146/annurev-astro-081811-125521DOI
  13. [13]Foster, A. R., Ji, L., Smith, R. K., & Brickhouse, N. S. 2012, ApJ, 756, 128, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/756/2/128DOI
  14. [14]Ghisellini, G., Haardt, F., Ciardi, B., et al. 2015, MNRAS, 452, 3457, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stv1541DOI
  15. [15]Hardcastle, M. J. 2026, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 550, stag1253, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stag1253DOI
  16. [16]Harris, C. R., Millman, K. J., van der Walt, S. J., et al. 2020, Nature, 585, 357, doi: 10.1038/s41586-020-2649-2DOI
  17. [17]Hlavacek-Larrondo, J., Fabian, A. C., Edge, A. C., et al. 2012, MNRAS, 421, 1360, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.20405.x
  18. [18]Hlavacek-Larrondo, J., Li, Y., & Churazov, E. 2022, in Handbook of X-ray and Gamma-ray Astrophysics, ed. C. Bambi & A. S. D. Sangalangelo, 5, doi: 10.1007/978-981-16-4544-0_122-1
  19. [19]Hlavacek-Larrondo, J., McDonald, M., Benson, B. A., et al. 2015, ApJ, 805, 35, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/805/1/35
  20. [20]Hodges-Kluck, E., Gallo, E., Ghisellini, G., et al. 2021, MNRAS, 505, 1543, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stab1314
  21. [21]Hunter, J. D. 2007, Computing in Science and Engineering, 9, 90, doi: 10.1109/MCSE.2007.55
  22. [22]Kaiser, C. R., Pavlovski, G., Pope, E. C. D., & Fanghor, H. 2005, MNRAS, 359, 493, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2005.08902.xDOI
  23. [23]Markevitch, M., Nicastro, F., Nulsen, P., et al. 2009, in astro2010: The Astronomy and Astrophysics Decadal Survey, Vol. 2010, 192, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.0902.3709
  24. [24]McNamara, B. R., & Nulsen, P. E. J. 2007, ARA&A, 45, 117, doi: 10.1146/annurev.astro.45.051806.110625DOI
  25. [25]Mocz, P., Fabian, A. C., & Blundell, K. M. 2011, MNRAS, 413, 1107, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.18198.xDOI
  26. [26]Rafferty, D. A., McNamara, B. R., Nulsen, P. E. J., & Wise, M. W. 2006, ApJ, 652, 216, doi: 10.1086/507672DOI
  27. [27]Sarazin, C. L. 1999, ApJ, 520, 529, doi: 10.1086/307501DOI
  28. [28]Smith, R. K., Brickhouse, N. S., Liedahl, D. A., & Raymond, J. C. 2001, ApJL, 556, L91, doi: 10.1086/322992DOI
  29. [29]Virtanen, P., Gommers, R., Oliphant, T. E., et al. 2020, Nature Methods, 17, 261, doi: 10.1038/s41592-019-0686-2DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_22g229da
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 8

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Generative-AI tools

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents