betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Controls on the deformation and reorientation of mafic enclaves during magma mingling: A computational study

Abstract

Mafic microgranular enclaves in granitic plutons record magma mingling, and their shapes are often interpreted as a record of the flow that deformed them. We investigate how a dense, low-viscosity droplet deforms in a lighter, much more viscous host under shear and gravity, using 96 two-dimensional Level-Set simulations. The viscosity ratio (μrμ_r) spans 10−610^{-6} - 10−310^{-3}, the capillary number (Ca\mathrm{Ca}) ranges from 10610^{6} to 8×1098\times10^{9}, the Bond number (Bo\mathrm{Bo}) takes values of 3.5×1063.5\times10^{6} and 9.8×1069.8\times10^{6}, and the Reynolds number (Re\mathrm{Re}) remains below 10−210^{-2}, with a fixed density contrast (ΔρΔρ) of 400 kg m−3400~\mathrm{kg\,m^{-3}}. Two broad regimes identified- sinking and non-sinking which spread over six outcomes like sinking, edge, mid and multiple break-up, rotation, and retraction. The ratio Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca/Bo} separates sinking from shear-dominated behaviour near unity, although the transition spans a range of Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca/Bo} values that shifts with confinement. In the shear-dominated regime, a lower viscosity ratio promotes stretching. Multiple pinch-off occurs mainly at viscosity ratios of 10−610^{-6} - 10−510^{-5}, rotation occurs only at the higher vertical confinement, and retraction occurs only at the lower vertical confinement. The strain at maximum stretch averages 1.1 - 1.4 and increases with Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca/Bo}, with a stronger increase at higher confinement. The orientation of the major axis decreases by approximately 10∘10^\circ per unit strain and is lowest for rotating droplets. Because the capillary number exceeds conventional critical values for breakup for droplets, breakup is interpreted in terms of accumulated deformation rather than capillary stability alone. Enclave shape therefore reflects the flow regime and is not a direct measure of finite strain.

Introduction

Granitic plutons are one of the most common intrusive features on Earth and their widespread occurrences record the evolution of the continental crust. Mafic microgranular enclaves in granitic plutons are commonly interpreted as fragments of injected mafic magma that became dispersed within a felsic host during magma mingling [1, 2]. Depending on the physical conditions prevailing during emplacement, enclaves may remain nearly spherical, become progressively elongated, fragment into smaller bodies, or develop highly irregular morphologies. A review of microgranitoid enclave shapes and orientations concluded that these features need careful interpretation and cannot simply be treated as strain markers [3], and multi-pronged enclaves in particular have been used to argue that several fabrics can be recorded in the same pluton [4]. The deformed enclave shapes, in field, range from rounded and ellipsoidal bodies to strongly elongated, folded or fragmented forms, including chains of small fragments and multi-pronged bodies. A systematic study of which flow conditions produce which enclave shapes is still pending. A mafic enclave in a felsic host is a drop of one viscous fluid in another, so the classical theory of drop deformation applies [5, 6, 7, 8, 9].

For Newtonian fluids in simple shear, the response is controlled by a small set of dimensionless groups: the capillary number Ca\mathrm{Ca}, which compares viscous and interfacial stresses, the viscosity ratio μr\mu_r between drop and host, the Reynolds number Re\mathrm{Re}, and, when walls are close, the confinement ratio 2a/H2a/H of drop diameter to wall separation. At small Ca\mathrm{Ca} a circular drop deforms into an ellipse inclined at roughly 45∘45^\circ to the flow [6]. With increasing Ca\mathrm{Ca} it elongates and turns towards the flow direction until it either reaches a steady shape or breaks up. Confinement modifies this picture. Lattice-Boltzmann simulations of confined shear flow find that stronger confinement increases deformation and turns the drop further towards the flow direction, and the same trend has been reported in experiments and in other simulations [10, 11]. Volume-of-Fluid, phase-field, lattice-Boltzmann and Level-Set methods can resolve strongly deformed complex interfaces [12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17]. [15] used a Level-Set method to map steady and break-up regions across Ca\mathrm{Ca}, μr\mu_r, Re\mathrm{Re} and confinement ratio, and [16] used a multiphase SPH method to show that deformation grows with both Ca\mathrm{Ca} and Re\mathrm{Re} and that the critical Ca\mathrm{Ca} for break-up depends on confinement.

Most of these works concern viscosity ratios of order one and capillary numbers close to the critical value for break-up. The viscosity ratio nevertheless matters a great deal. When the host is no more viscous than the drop, deformation is sluggish and a higher Ca is needed to reach a given shape. When the drop is much less viscous than the host, vigorous internal circulation allows deformation at modest Ca and leads to pinch-off at the tips [9, 18]. In highly viscous magmatic system with negligible inertia and surface tension, extreme values of Ca and Re are expected. Break-ups and other deformation of viscous drop, at such high parameter range, have hardly been explored. Similarly, negetive buoyancy effect on droplets has also received very little attention. In the engineering and biological flows that motivate most droplet studies, settling is too slow to compete with shear, and the body-force term is usually omitted from the governing equations. Bond-number effects have been examined for sheared drops attached to a wall [19], but we are not aware of a systematic study of how settling and shear compete for a free drop over a controlled parameter space. In magmatic systems both processes act over long times, and their balance is measured by Ca/Bo=μhU/(Δρga2)\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} = \mu_h U/(\Delta\rho g a^2), where μh\mu_h is the host viscosity, UU the characteristic shear velocity, Δρ\Delta\rho the density contrast and aa the drop radius. Up to a factor of order unity, Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} is the ratio of the imposed shear to the gravity induced settling of the drop, and because interfacial tension cancels, it does not depend on σ\sigma. Natural magmas lie in exactly this regime. Felsic granitic melts have viscosities of 10510^5 - 10910^9 Pa s [20], and the mafic magmas injected into them are several orders of magnitude less viscous, of order 10 - 10310^3 Pa s [21, 22]. The drop-to-host viscosity ratio can therefore reach 10−310^{-3} - 10−610^{-6}. Interfacial tension between silicate melts is also recorded to be very low [23, 24]. Together with enclave sizes of centimetres to metres and these viscosities, this gives Ca≫1\mathrm{Ca} \gg1, so interfacial tension offers essentially no resistance to deformation once flow is imposed, and the Reynolds number is far below unity, so inertia is negligible and the flow is Stokes-like [25]. Mafic microgranular enclaves record the mingling of mafic and felsic magmas in plutons, as in the Nimchak pluton, India (Figure 1). The two magmas differ in density as well as viscosity, and the interaction lasts long enough for buoyancy to act alongside shear resulting different deformed enclave shape. Several lines of work have addressed enclave deformation. [26] applied drop-deformation theory to deformation of microgranitic enclaves under the assumption of simple shear, [27] used the shapes and orientations of bubbles in obsidian to infer shear rate and flow type through the capillary number, and [28] performed shear-rig experiments to get insight into different shape evolution of viscous inclusion. Analogue experiments on injected mafic dykes show that their break-up depends strongly on the rheological contrast between the magmas [29, 30], and [31] simulated enclave deformation numerically and fitted a first-order relationship between shear and deformation. To our knowledge, none of these studies resolves how buoyancy and shear compete across a controlled parameter space at very high capillary number. Our earlier multiphase models using Volume-of-Fluid simulations of a less viscous fluid injected into a more viscous host showed that increasing the viscosity ratio changes the ascent from continuous to pulsating [12]. Here we extend such parametric study to the deformation of a dense droplet under shear and buoyancy.

Different shapes of deformed enclaves found in Nimchak Pluton

Figure 1. Different shapes of deformed enclaves found in Nimchak Pluton: a) elliptical; b) & e) curved; c) multi-pronged; d) flattened; f) folded.

We develop a two-dimensional Level-Set model of a dense, low-viscosity droplet embedded in a lighter, more viscous host between walls that move in opposite directions, and we run 96 simulations. The simulations span viscosity ratios μr=10−6\mu_{\mathrm{r}} = 10^{-6} - 10−310^{-3}, capillary numbers Ca=106\mathrm{Ca} = 10^{6} - 8×1098 \times10^{9}, Bond numbers Bo=3.53×106\mathrm{Bo} = 3.53 \times10^{6} and 9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6} and Reynolds numbers Re=10−6\mathrm{Re} = 10^{-6} - 10−210^{-2}, with a fixed density contrast Δρ=400 kg m−3\Delta\rho= 400\ \mathrm{kg}\,\mathrm{m}^{-3}, vertical confinement ratios 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 and 0.200.20 and domain aspect ratios L∗=1.6L^{*} = 1.6, 2 and 3. We separate a sinking regime, in which buoyancy dominates—the drop descends and gets flattened near the base, from a non-sinking regime, in which the drop stretches and then breaks up, rotates, or retracts. We show that the sinking transition is organised by Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} and that confinement shifts it, and we relate the remaining outcomes to the viscosity ratio and confinement. We also quantify the orientation of the droplet and the strain at maximum stretch, which bear directly on whether enclave shape can serve as a strain marker.

Section 2 describes the model and the mesh convergence. Section 3 presents the deformation regimes, the regime map and the sinking transition, and the orientation and strain at maximum stretch. Section 4 discusses the mechanisms and the implications for natural enclaves, and Section 5 gives the conclusions.

Numerical Method

Model description

We consider a two-dimensional rectangular box of length LL and height HH, with Cartesian coordinates x∈[0,L]x \in[0,L] and y∈[0,H]y \in[0,H] (Figure 2). A dense, low-viscosity circular drop (representing the mafic enclave) of radius aa, density ρd\rho_d and viscosity μd\mu_d, is embedded in a lighter and much more viscous host (representing the felsic magma) of density ρh\rho_h and viscosity μh\mu_h. Gravity acts in the negative yy-direction, g=−gy^\mathbf{g}=-g\hat{\mathbf{y}}, with g=9.81 m s−2g=9.81\ \mathrm{m\ s^{-2}}. The top (y=Hy=H) and bottom (y=0y=0) walls move in opposite directions with speeds ±U\pm U, which imposes a nominal shear rate γ˙=2UH\dot{\gamma}=\frac{2U}{H} on the host. No-slip conditions are applied at the moving walls, u(x,H)=(+U,0)\mathbf{u}(x,H)=(+U,0) and u(x,0)=(−U,0)\mathbf{u}(x,0)=(-U,0), whereas the left and right boundaries are free slip walls. All the walls thus have zero normal flux. The drop is initially at rest at the centre of the box, (x0,y0)=(L/2,H/2)(x_0,y_0)=(L/2,H/2). It is then subjected to the imposed shear flow and to downward gravitational motion arising from the density contrast Δρ=ρd−ρh>0\Delta\rho=\rho_d-\rho_h>0. The drop viscosity is held fixed at μd=103 Pa s\mu_d=10^3\ \mathrm{Pa\ s} while the host viscosity is varied between 10610^6 and 109 Pa s10^9\ \mathrm{Pa\ s}. (Table 1).

Schematic of the model setup

Figure 2. Schematic of the model setup (not to scale). A circular drop of radius aa, density ρd\rho_d and viscosity μd\mu_d is placed at the centre of a host of density ρh\rho_h and viscosity μh\mu_h in a domain of length LL and height HH. The level-set variable ϕ\phi is 1 in the drop and 0 in the host, and the interface is the ϕ=0.5\phi= 0.5 contour. The top and bottom walls move in opposite directions with speeds ±U\pm U, imposing a shear of rate γ˙=2U/H\dot{\gamma} = 2U/H. Gravity acts in the negative yy-direction.

ParameterDescriptionRangeReference
ρd\rho_dDensity of the magma drop2700 kg m−32700\ \mathrm{kg\ m^{-3}}[20]
ρh\rho_hDensity of the host2300 kg m−32300\ \mathrm{kg\ m^{-3}}[20]
Δρ\Delta\rhoDensity difference between the magma drop and the host400 kg m−3400\ \mathrm{kg\ m^{-3}}
μd\mu_dViscosity of the magma drop1000 Pa⋅s1000\ \mathrm{Pa\cdot s}[20]
μh\mu_hViscosity of the host106−109 Pa⋅s10^{6} - 10^{9}\ \mathrm{Pa\cdot s}[20]
μr\mu_rViscosity ratio of the host and the magma drop10−3−10−610^{-3} - 10^{-6}
σ\sigmaInterfacial tension of the silicic magma1.00×10−21.00 \times10^{-2}[32]

Table 1. Parameters, their physical ranges, and references used in the numerical model.

Governing equations

The two magmas are treated as immiscible, incompressible Newtonian fluids with constant properties, and the flow is assumed to be isothermal. Following the one-fluid approach, a single set of equations is solved over the whole domain, with the fluid properties varying smoothly across a thin interfacial layer through the level-set (phase) variable ϕ(x,t)\phi(\mathbf{x},t), defined as ϕ=1\phi= 1 in the drop and ϕ=0\phi= 0 in the host. The flow is governed by the continuity and Navier-Stokes equations as follows:

∇⋅u=0,(1)\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u} = 0, \tag*{(1)}
ρ[∂u∂t+(u⋅∇)u]=−∇p+∇⋅[μ(∇u+∇uT)]+ρg+Fst,(2)\rho\left[\frac{\partial\mathbf{u}}{\partial t} + (\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla)\mathbf{u}\right] = -\nabla p + \nabla\cdot\left[\mu\left(\nabla\mathbf{u}+\nabla\mathbf{u}^{\mathrm{T}}\right)\right] + \rho\mathbf{g} + \mathbf{F}_{\mathrm{st}}, \tag*{(2)}

where u=(u,v)\mathbf{u}=(u,v) is the velocity, pp the pressure, g\mathbf{g} the gravitational acceleration and Fst\mathbf{F}_{\mathrm{st}} the interfacial-tension force per unit volume.

Following Brackbill et al. [33], the interfacial tension enters as a body force acting in the interface region and expressed as: Fst=σκδn\mathbf{F}_{\mathrm{st}}=\sigma\kappa\delta\mathbf{n}, where σ\sigma is the surface tension coefficient, κ\kappa is the local curvature of the interface, δ\delta is a regularised Dirac delta function that localises the surface tension force near the interface, and n\mathbf{n} is the unit normal vector to the interface. Surface tension is expected to have a limited influence in the present parameter range (capillary number Ca≫1\mathrm{Ca}\gg1), but its contribution is retained in the governing equations. The density and viscosity are interpolated across the interface as

ρ=ρh+(ρd−ρh)ϕ,μ=μh+(μd−μh)ϕ.(3)\rho= \rho_h + (\rho_d-\rho_h)\phi,\qquad\mu= \mu_h + (\mu_d-\mu_h)\phi. \tag*{(3)}

The interface is tracked using the conservative level-set method developed by Olsson et al. [34, 35]. It is represented by the (ϕ=0.5\phi= 0.5) contour, with the level-set variable varying smoothly from 0 in one fluid to 1 in the other. The initial profile is defined as

ϕ=12[1+tanh⁡(d2ε)],(4)\phi= \frac{1}{2}\left[1+\tanh\left(\frac{d}{2\varepsilon}\right)\right], \tag*{(4)}

where dd is the signed distance from the interface (positive inside the drop) and ε\varepsilon controls the interface thickness. For the initial circular drop (t=0t = 0), d=a−(x−x0)2+(y−y0)2d = a-\sqrt{(x-x_0)^2+(y-y_0)^2}. As the flow evolves, the level-set variable ϕ\phi is advected by the velocity field. A reinitialisation term is included to maintain the interface profile and limit numerical spreading:

∂ϕ∂t+u⋅(∇ϕ)=βls∇⋅[ε∇ϕ−ϕ(1−ϕ)∇ϕ∣∇ϕ∣].(5)\frac{\partial\phi}{\partial t}+\mathbf{u}\cdot(\nabla\phi)=\beta_{\mathrm{ls}}\nabla\cdot\left[\varepsilon\nabla\phi-\phi(1-\phi)\frac{\nabla\phi}{\lvert\nabla\phi\rvert}\right]. \tag*{(5)}

where u\mathbf{u} is the velocity field, ε\varepsilon controls the interface thickness, and βls\beta_{\mathrm{ls}} (m/s) determines the rate at which the interface profile is restored. The right hand side term counteracts numerical spreading and helps maintain a smooth transition between the two fluids as the drop deforms.

The unit normal pointing into the drop, the interface curvature and a smoothed interface delta function are obtained directly from ϕ\phi:

n=∇ϕ∣∇ϕ∣,κ=−∇⋅n,δ=6ϕ(1−ϕ)∣∇ϕ∣.(6)\mathbf{n}=\frac{\nabla\phi}{\lvert\nabla\phi\rvert},\quad\kappa=-\nabla\cdot\mathbf{n},\quad\delta=6\phi(1-\phi)\lvert\nabla\phi\rvert. \tag*{(6)}

The factor 6 normalises δ\delta such that ∫δ dn=∫016ϕ(1−ϕ) dϕ=1\int\delta\,\mathrm{d}n=\int_0^1 6\phi(1-\phi)\,\mathrm{d}\phi=1 across the interface.

Dimensionless parameters

The simulations solve the dimensional governing equations (1), (2) and (5) using the material properties listed in Table 1. The dimensionless parameters used to organise and report the results are defined below, and their ranges are listed in Table 2.

Non-dimensional ParameterValue range
Capillary Number (Ca)1×1061 \times10^{6} - 8×1098 \times10^{9}
Bond Number (Bo)3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6} and 9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}
Model Dimension (L∗L^*)1.61.6, 22 and 33
Viscosity Ratio (μr\mu_r)1×10−31 \times10^{-3} - 1×10−61 \times10^{-6}
Vertical Confinement Ratio (2a/H2a/H)0.120.12 and 0.20.2
Lateral Confinement Ratio (2a/L2a/L)4.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2} - 1.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}
Reynolds number, Re1.15×10−61.15 \times10^{-6} - 9.20×10−39.20 \times10^{-3}

Table 2. Value range for non-dimensional parameters used to numerically simulate the models.

Capillary number Ca (ratio of the viscous stress to the interfacial stress), Bond number Bo (ratio of gravitational forces arising from the density contrast between the drop and the host magma to interfacial tension), Reynolds number Re (ratio of inertial and viscous stresses in the host magma) are defined as

Ca=μhUσ;Bo=Δρ g a2σ;Re=ρhUHμh.(7)\mathrm{Ca}=\frac{\mu_h U}{\sigma};\quad\mathrm{Bo}=\frac{\Delta\rho\,g\,a^2}{\sigma};\quad\mathrm{Re}=\frac{\rho_h U H}{\mu_h}. \tag*{(7)}

The model dimension L∗L^* (the aspect ratio of the domain), vertical confinement ratio CvC_v (ratio of the drop diameter to the height of the chamber), lateral confinement ratio ClC_l (ratio of the drop diameter to the length of the chamber), Viscosity ratio μr\mu_r (ratio of the drop to the host viscosity) are expressed as

L∗=LH;Cv=2aH;Cl=2aL;μr=μdμh.(8)L^* = \frac{L}{H}; \quad C_v = \frac{2a}{H}; \quad C_l = \frac{2a}{L}; \quad\mu_r = \frac{\mu_d}{\mu_h}. \tag*{(8)}

The dimensionless shear flow timescale t∗t^* is defined as t∗=γ˙tt^* = \dot{\gamma}t where shear rate

γ˙=2UH.\dot{\gamma} = \frac{2U}{H}.

The accumulated shear strain (γ\gamma) at time tt is γ=γ˙t\gamma= \dot{\gamma}t. The strain at the instant at which a drop reaches its maximum stretch, γmax⁡=γ˙tmax⁡\gamma_{\max} = \dot{\gamma}t_{\max}.

The drop deformation is characterised by two parameters. The Taylor deformation parameter is defined as:

D=l−bl+b,(9)D = \frac{l-b}{l+b}, \tag*{(9)}

where ll and bb are the semi-major and semi-minor axes of the deformed drop, respectively. The parameter DD is zero for a circular drop and approaches unity as the drop becomes increasingly elongated. When the shape of the drop is no longer ellipsoidal, the Taylor deformation parameter may not adequately represent the overall elongation. In such cases, the elongation parameter δ=l/a\delta= l/a is used, where ll is half the end-to-end length of the drop and aa is its initial radius. The second parameter is the orientation angle, θ\theta, defined as the angle between the drop’s major axis and the shear-flow direction.

The following parameters are kept fixed in all simulations: chamber height H=50H = 50 m, drop density ρd=2700\rho_d = 2700 kg m−3^{-3}, host density ρh=2300\rho_h = 2300 kg m−3^{-3} (Δρ=400\Delta\rho= 400 kg m−3^{-3}), drop viscosity μd=103\mu_d = 10^3 Pa s, interfacial tension σ=10−2\sigma= 10^{-2} N m−1^{-1} and gravitational acceleration g=9.81g = 9.81 m s−2^{-2}. The varied parameters are listed in Table 2. The host viscosity is varied between μh=106\mu_h = 10^6 - 10910^9 Pa s corresponding to 10−6≤μr≤10−310^{-6} \le\mu_r \le10^{-3}. For each μh\mu_h, four wall speeds U=0.01U = 0.01, 0.030.03, 0.050.05 and 0.080.08 m s−1^{-1} are imposed so that Ca=μhU/σ\mathrm{Ca} = \mu_h U/\sigma ranges from 1×1061 \times10^{6} to 8×1098 \times10^{9}. The drop radius (a=3a = 3 or 55 m) sets 2a/H2a/H and Bo\mathrm{Bo}, and the chamber length (L=80L = 80, 100100 or 150150 m) sets L∗L^* and 2a/L2a/L as mentioned in Table 2. The 96 simulations cover all combinations of the four μh\mu_h, four UU, two aa and three LL values, and are listed in the Appendix § 7 (Table 5 and 6).

Simulationμr\mu_r2a/H2a/H2a/L2a/LCaBoRe
SIM 11.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}1.00×1061.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−31.15 \times10^{-3}
SIM 21.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}3.00×1063.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−33.45 \times10^{-3}
SIM 31.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}5.00×1065.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−35.75 \times10^{-3}
SIM 41.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}8.00×1068.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−39.20 \times10^{-3}
SIM 51.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}1.00×1061.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−31.15 \times10^{-3}
SIM 61.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}3.00×1063.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−33.45 \times10^{-3}
SIM 71.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}5.00×1065.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−35.75 \times10^{-3}
SIM 81.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}8.00×1068.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−39.20 \times10^{-3}
SIM 91.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}1.00×1061.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−31.15 \times10^{-3}
SIM 101.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}3.00×1063.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−33.45 \times10^{-3}
SIM 111.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}5.00×1065.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−35.75 \times10^{-3}
SIM 121.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}8.00×1068.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−39.20 \times10^{-3}
SIM 131.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}1.00×1061.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−31.15 \times10^{-3}
SIM 141.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}3.00×1063.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−33.45 \times10^{-3}
SIM 151.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}5.00×1065.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−35.75 \times10^{-3}
SIM 161.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}8.00×1068.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−39.20 \times10^{-3}
SIM 171.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}1.00×1061.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−31.15 \times10^{-3}
SIM 181.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}3.00×1063.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−33.45 \times10^{-3}
SIM 191.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}5.00×1065.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−35.75 \times10^{-3}
SIM 201.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.120.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}8.00×1068.00 \times10^{6}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−39.20 \times10^{-3}
SIM 211.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}1.00×1061.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−31.15 \times10^{-3}
SIM 221.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}3.00×1063.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−33.45 \times10^{-3}
SIM 231.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}5.00×1065.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−35.75 \times10^{-3}
SIM 241.00×10−31.00 \times10^{-3}0.20.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}8.00×1068.00 \times10^{6}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−39.20 \times10^{-3}
SIM 251.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}1.00×1071.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−41.15 \times10^{-4}
SIM 261.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}3.00×1073.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−43.45 \times10^{-4}
SIM 271.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}5.00×1075.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−45.75 \times10^{-4}
SIM 281.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}8.00×1078.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−49.20 \times10^{-4}
SIM 291.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}1.00×1071.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−41.15 \times10^{-4}
SIM 301.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}3.00×1073.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−43.45 \times10^{-4}
SIM 311.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}5.00×1075.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−45.75 \times10^{-4}
SIM 321.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}8.00×1078.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−49.20 \times10^{-4}
SIM 331.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}1.00×1071.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−41.15 \times10^{-4}
SIM 341.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}3.00×1073.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−43.45 \times10^{-4}
SIM 351.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}5.00×1075.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−45.75 \times10^{-4}
SIM 361.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}8.00×1078.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−49.20 \times10^{-4}
SIM 371.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}1.00×1071.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−41.15 \times10^{-4}
SIM 381.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}3.00×1073.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−43.45 \times10^{-4}
SIM 391.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}5.00×1075.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−45.75 \times10^{-4}
SIM 401.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}8.00×1078.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−49.20 \times10^{-4}
SIM 411.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}1.00×1071.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−41.15 \times10^{-4}
SIM 421.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}3.00×1073.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−43.45 \times10^{-4}
SIM 431.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}5.00×1075.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−45.75 \times10^{-4}
SIM 441.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.120.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}8.00×1078.00 \times10^{7}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−49.20 \times10^{-4}
SIM 451.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}1.00×1071.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−41.15 \times10^{-4}
SIM 461.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}3.00×1073.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−43.45 \times10^{-4}
SIM 471.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}5.00×1075.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−45.75 \times10^{-4}
SIM 481.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}0.20.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}8.00×1078.00 \times10^{7}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−49.20 \times10^{-4}
SIM 491.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.120.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}1.00×1081.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−51.15 \times10^{-5}
Simulationμr\mu_r2a/H2a/H2a/L2a/LCaBoRe
SIM 501.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}3.00×1083.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−53.45 \times10^{-5}
SIM 511.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}5.00×1085.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−55.75 \times10^{-5}
SIM 521.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}8.00×1088.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−59.20 \times10^{-5}
SIM 531.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}1.00×1081.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−51.15 \times10^{-5}
SIM 541.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}3.00×1083.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−53.45 \times10^{-5}
SIM 551.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}5.00×1085.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−55.75 \times10^{-5}
SIM 561.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}8.00×1088.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−59.20 \times10^{-5}
SIM 571.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}1.00×1081.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−51.15 \times10^{-5}
SIM 581.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}3.00×1083.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−53.45 \times10^{-5}
SIM 591.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}5.00×1085.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−55.75 \times10^{-5}
SIM 601.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}8.00×1088.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−59.20 \times10^{-5}
SIM 611.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}1.00×1081.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−51.15 \times10^{-5}
SIM 621.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}3.00×1083.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−53.45 \times10^{-5}
SIM 631.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}5.00×1085.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−55.75 \times10^{-5}
SIM 641.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}8.00×1088.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−59.20 \times10^{-5}
SIM 651.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}1.00×1081.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−51.15 \times10^{-5}
SIM 661.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}3.00×1083.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−53.45 \times10^{-5}
SIM 671.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}5.00×1085.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−55.75 \times10^{-5}
SIM 681.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}8.00×1088.00 \times10^{8}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−59.20 \times10^{-5}
SIM 691.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}1.00×1081.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−51.15 \times10^{-5}
SIM 701.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}3.00×1083.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−53.45 \times10^{-5}
SIM 711.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}5.00×1085.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−55.75 \times10^{-5}
SIM 721.00×10−51.00 \times10^{-5}0.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}8.00×1088.00 \times10^{8}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−59.20 \times10^{-5}
SIM 731.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}1.00×1091.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−61.15 \times10^{-6}
SIM 741.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}3.00×1093.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−63.45 \times10^{-6}
SIM 751.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}5.00×1095.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−65.75 \times10^{-6}
SIM 761.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.127.50×10−27.50 \times10^{-2}8.00×1098.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−69.20 \times10^{-6}
SIM 771.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}1.00×1091.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−61.15 \times10^{-6}
SIM 781.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}3.00×1093.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−63.45 \times10^{-6}
SIM 791.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}5.00×1095.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−65.75 \times10^{-6}
SIM 801.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.21.25×10−11.25 \times10^{-1}8.00×1098.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−69.20 \times10^{-6}
SIM 811.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}1.00×1091.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−61.15 \times10^{-6}
SIM 821.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}3.00×1093.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−63.45 \times10^{-6}
SIM 831.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}5.00×1095.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−65.75 \times10^{-6}
SIM 841.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.126.00×10−26.00 \times10^{-2}8.00×1098.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−69.20 \times10^{-6}
SIM 851.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}1.00×1091.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−61.15 \times10^{-6}
SIM 861.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}3.00×1093.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−63.45 \times10^{-6}
SIM 871.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}5.00×1095.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−65.75 \times10^{-6}
SIM 881.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.21.00×10−11.00 \times10^{-1}8.00×1098.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−69.20 \times10^{-6}
SIM 891.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}1.00×1091.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}1.15×10−61.15 \times10^{-6}
SIM 901.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}3.00×1093.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}3.45×10−63.45 \times10^{-6}
SIM 911.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}5.00×1095.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}5.75×10−65.75 \times10^{-6}
SIM 921.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.124.00×10−24.00 \times10^{-2}8.00×1098.00 \times10^{9}3.53×1063.53 \times10^{6}9.20×10−69.20 \times10^{-6}
SIM 931.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}1.00×1091.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}1.15×10−61.15 \times10^{-6}
SIM 941.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}3.00×1093.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}3.45×10−63.45 \times10^{-6}
SIM 951.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}5.00×1095.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}5.75×10−65.75 \times10^{-6}
SIM 961.00×10−61.00 \times10^{-6}0.26.67×10−26.67 \times10^{-2}8.00×1098.00 \times10^{9}9.81×1069.81 \times10^{6}9.20×10−69.20 \times10^{-6}
SimulationDDδ\deltaθ\thetaγ\gamma
SIM 10.391.399.235.89×10−15.89 \times10^{-1}
SIM 20.451.4426.831.89×1001.89 \times10^{0}
SIM 30.521.5032.718.42×10−18.42 \times10^{-1}
SIM 40.631.6827.878.83×10−18.83 \times10^{-1}
SIM 50.631.633.541.18×1001.18 \times10^{0}
SIM 60.701.7118.488.84×10−18.84 \times10^{-1}
SIM 70.711.7229.079.47×10−19.47 \times10^{-1}
SIM 80.751.7833.891.10×1001.10 \times10^{0}
SIM 90.501.517.676.62×10−16.62 \times10^{-1}
SIM 100.541.5631.527.45×10−17.45 \times10^{-1}
SIM 110.571.6234.329.66×10−19.66 \times10^{-1}
SIM 120.581.7634.959.93×10−19.93 \times10^{-1}
SIM 130.742.162.544.97×10−14.97 \times10^{-1}
SIM 140.762.2128.221.24×1001.24 \times10^{0}
SIM 150.792.3427.261.24×1001.24 \times10^{0}
SIM 160.581.6333.526.62×10−16.62 \times10^{-1}
SIM 170.511.516.347.17×10−17.17 \times10^{-1}
SIM 180.641.7114.802.07×1002.07 \times10^{0}
SIM 190.651.8133.209.66×10−19.66 \times10^{-1}
SIM 200.671.8935.578.83×10−18.83 \times10^{-1}
SIM 210.772.281.845.52×10−15.52 \times10^{-1}
SIM 220.671.9313.539.10×10−19.10 \times10^{-1}
SIM 230.661.7824.588.28×10−18.28 \times10^{-1}
SIM 240.671.9132.468.83×10−18.83 \times10^{-1}
SIM 250.271.2737.851.18×1001.18 \times10^{0}
SIM 260.511.5831.171.42×1001.42 \times10^{0}
SIM 270.571.7031.131.26×1001.26 \times10^{0}
SIM 280.591.8026.241.52×1001.52 \times10^{0}
SIM 290.740.8634.076.74×10−16.74 \times10^{-1}
SIM 300.840.9530.879.47×10−19.47 \times10^{-1}
SIM 310.872.3012.341.58×1001.58 \times10^{0}
SIM 320.882.47−0.39-0.391.66×1001.66 \times10^{0}
SIM 330.341.3434.661.43×1001.43 \times10^{0}
SIM 340.411.4539.774.14×10−14.14 \times10^{-1}
SIM 350.421.4937.546.21×10−16.21 \times10^{-1}
SIM 360.451.5537.456.62×10−16.62 \times10^{-1}
SIM 370.761.4838.755.79×10−15.79 \times10^{-1}
SIM 380.842.0029.421.12×1001.12 \times10^{0}
SIM 390.852.1428.841.24×1001.24 \times10^{0}
SIM 400.912.2628.001.32×1001.32 \times10^{0}
SIM 410.421.4535.891.24×1001.24 \times10^{0}
SIM 420.611.7634.031.24×1001.24 \times10^{0}
SIM 430.621.8332.321.03×1001.03 \times10^{0}
SIM 440.711.9633.411.10×1001.10 \times10^{0}
SIM 450.421.5336.876.21×10−16.21 \times10^{-1}
SIM 460.621.9432.079.47×10−19.47 \times10^{-1}
SIM 470.642.0532.241.03×1001.03 \times10^{0}
SIM 480.802.7126.391.66×1001.66 \times10^{0}
SIM 490.132.3440.081.01×1001.01 \times10^{0}
SIM 500.571.6023.331.61×1001.61 \times10^{0}
SIM 510.601.7226.121.42×1001.42 \times10^{0}
SIM 520.691.9122.391.54×1001.54 \times10^{0}
SimulationDDδ\deltaθ\thetaγ\gamma
SIM 530.571.8025.601.47×1001.47 \times10^{0}
SIM 540.621.910.441.45×1001.45 \times10^{0}
SIM 550.641.993.601.58×1001.58 \times10^{0}
SIM 560.662.062.361.66×1001.66 \times10^{0}
SIM 570.381.3340.361.82×1001.82 \times10^{0}
SIM 580.651.4638.616.21×10−16.21 \times10^{-1}
SIM 590.671.5337.256.90×10−16.90 \times10^{-1}
SIM 600.701.8732.725.52×10−15.52 \times10^{-1}
SIM 610.631.9629.051.24×1001.24 \times10^{0}
SIM 620.672.0929.431.24×1001.24 \times10^{0}
SIM 630.712.2427.181.38×1001.38 \times10^{0}
SIM 640.772.5323.701.66×1001.66 \times10^{0}
SIM 650.531.5141.877.59×10−17.59 \times10^{-1}
SIM 660.651.8332.851.24×1001.24 \times10^{0}
SIM 670.631.7930.291.03×1001.03 \times10^{0}
SIM 680.711.9633.751.10×1001.10 \times10^{0}
SIM 690.832.4027.271.72×1001.72 \times10^{0}
SIM 700.872.7524.771.86×1001.86 \times10^{0}
SIM 710.852.7025.701.72×1001.72 \times10^{0}
SIM 720.863.1123.142.02×1002.02 \times10^{0}
SIM 730.251.2232.392.59×1002.59 \times10^{0}
SIM 740.441.5234.671.01×1001.01 \times10^{0}
SIM 750.551.6730.291.26×1001.26 \times10^{0}
SIM 760.611.7924.561.54×1001.54 \times10^{0}
SIM 770.631.8322.711.68×1001.68 \times10^{0}
SIM 780.722.121.112.02×1002.02 \times10^{0}
SIM 790.762.301.552.53×1002.53 \times10^{0}
SIM 800.772.402.691.99×1001.99 \times10^{0}
SIM 810.411.3340.401.60×1001.60 \times10^{0}
SIM 820.581.6133.339.93×10−19.93 \times10^{-1}
SIM 830.611.7133.109.66×10−19.66 \times10^{-1}
SIM 840.631.7934.029.93×10−19.93 \times10^{-1}
SIM 850.752.3126.051.77×1001.77 \times10^{0}
SIM 860.772.3725.511.61×1001.61 \times10^{0}
SIM 870.782.4624.591.66×1001.66 \times10^{0}
SIM 880.812.5323.681.66×1001.66 \times10^{0}
SIM 890.431.4842.541.77×1001.77 \times10^{0}
SIM 900.611.7531.421.66×1001.66 \times10^{0}
SIM 910.651.9135.931.10×1001.10 \times10^{0}
SIM 920.681.9334.041.10×1001.10 \times10^{0}
SIM 930.742.3026.571.66×1001.66 \times10^{0}
SIM 940.802.5824.981.66×1001.66 \times10^{0}
SIM 950.822.8225.581.79×1001.79 \times10^{0}
SIM 960.832.8225.951.77×1001.77 \times10^{0}

Table 5. Complete simulation input parameters for runs 1 to 96.

Numerical implementation and convergence study

The governing equations (2.1), (2.2) and (2.5) are solved using the finite element method coupled with the level-set method to track the interface between the drop and the host magma. The computational domain is discretised using a mesh of triangular and quadrilateral elements, with local refinement around the drop to resolve the interface and its deformation. The level-set variable distinguishes the drop from the surrounding fluid, and the interface is identified by the contour ϕ=0.5\phi= 0.5. Its evolution is governed by Eq. (5), which describes interface advection and maintains a finite interface thickness. The time-dependent equations are integrated using an implicit backward differentiation formula and an adaptive time step controlled by a relative tolerance of 0.005.

A grid-convergence test is performed for Sim 2 (see Table 5) with input parameters μr=10−3\mu_r = 10^{-3}, 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12, 2a/L=0.0752a/L = 0.075, Ca=3×106\mathrm{Ca} = 3 \times10^{6}, Ca/Bo=0.85\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} = 0.85 on four progressively refined meshes (Normal, Fine, Finer and Extra fine). The fall time, defined as the time required for the drop to descend a vertical distance of 17.5 m, is used to assess the effect of mesh resolution. As shown in Table 3, the fall time decreases from 1965.5 s for the Normal mesh to 1655.2 s for the Fine mesh and 1344.8 s for the Finer mesh. The Extra fine mesh yields identical results to the Finer mesh to the reported precision. Relative to the Extra fine mesh result, the fall time is approximately 46.2% higher on the Normal mesh and 23.1% higher on the Fine mesh. Although the Extra fine mesh contains 95 678 elements and requires 412 s of computational time, the Finer mesh contains 26 108 elements and requires only 113 s. The Finer mesh is therefore adopted for the subsequent simulations reported in § 3.

ParameterNormal meshFine meshFiner meshExtra fine mesh
Mesh vertices243935831365549007
Triangles412662342530894122
Quads3003728001556
Edge elements174214432834
Vertex elements8888
Number of elements442666062610895678
Minimum element quality0.31790.32390.33330.3179
Average element quality0.82370.84520.90340.9350
Element area ratio0.052480.057980.15280.1611
Mesh area (m2^2)4000400040004000
Fall time to 17.5 m depth (s)1965.51655.21344.81344.8
Total computational time (s)5756113412

Table 3. Mesh statistics and convergence metrics for the four refinement levels tested.

Results and Discussion

Enclave Deformation Regimes: The enclaves undergo deformation due to magma mingling inside dynamic magma chamber. Different shapes and sizes found in nature manifest interplay among various forces applicable to magma chamber settings. Our study recognises different deformation regimes depending on dominant force. We broadly categorised deformed enclaves as Sinking and Non-sinking. Due to the initial boundary condition, a global flow is induced in the chamber which has huge effect on the deformed shape of enclaves. In general they get stretched, some get fragmented, some rotate and some resist the deformation. This section will investigate the relative importance of all the dimensionless parameters like Ca\mathrm{Ca}, Bo\mathrm{Bo}, Re\mathrm{Re}, μr\mu_r, 2a/H2a/H, 2a/L2a/L and describe how they guide the ultimate deformation regimes (their interpretation is given in § 4).

Deformation measures. The shape of each droplet is characterised by the deformation parameter DD, the second shape measure δ\delta, and the orientation angle θ\theta of its major axis measured from the flow direction. The strain is γ=γ˙t\gamma= \dot{\gamma}t, where γ˙\dot{\gamma} is the imposed shear rate, and the normalised depth (H∗=2d/HH^* = 2d/H) is the depth (dd) of the deformed droplet’s centre relative to original centre depth (H/2H/2). Break-up is registered when particular areas on droplet body gets thinned and ultimately pinched off.

Sinking

We investigate deformation of the dense magma drop in a viscous host with the fixed density contrast (Δρ=400 kg/m3\Delta\rho= 400\ \mathrm{kg}/\mathrm{m}^{3}) and higher viscosity ratio (μr=10−3\mu_r = 10^{-3}). Figure 3 presents the progressive change of the drop shape under two different lateral confinement ratios. Left column corresponds to 2a/L=0.1252a/L = 0.125 (Sim 5), where Figure 3a starts with deformed droplet at t∗=0.168t^* = 0.168 where it sinks as well as stretches with respect to original undeformed position and shape. The deformation can be measured by the values of DD, δ\delta and θ\theta which are 0.12, 1.11 and 40.90 respectively. Figure 3b and c show that the drop continue to sink while getting more deformed with narrower upper right edge when time progressed from t∗=0.505t^*=0.505 to t∗=1.011t^*=1.011. Corresponding DD, δ\delta and θ\theta values are 0.31, 1.32 and 38.00 for t∗=0.505t^*=0.505 and 0.48, 1.57 and 31.18 for t∗=1.011t^*=1.011. Ca/Bo for this simulation has been recorded as 0.1. Figure 3d-Figure 3f shows the pattern of deformation at lower confinement (2a/L=0.12a/L=0.1, Sim 13). At t∗=0.055t^*=0.055 the droplet starts to sink and deform (Figure 3d), with D=0.05D=0.05 and δ=1.04\delta=1.04. At t∗=0.166t^*=0.166, the droplet deforms further to form an kidney bean shape (Fig. 3e}) as DD increased to 0.31 and δ=1.28\delta=1.28. With increasing time (t∗=0.276t^*=0.276) the drop keeps descending towards the base and its shape get laterally flattened with DD valued at 0.50 and δ=1.57\delta=1.57. However, unlike Sim 5, Sim 13 doesn’t get inclined and θ\theta is maintained at ∼0∘\sim0^\circ. Deformed drop in both cases doesn’t sink vertically, rather they shift leftward as they go down. It can also be noticed that the drop reaches the base much faster in Sim 13 than Sim 5. We assess the relative effect of Capillary number (Ca) and Bond number (Bo) and it is found that both have Ca/Bo = 0.1. This low ratios indicate gravitational forces dominate over viscous forces causing heavy magma drop to sink. Further simulations with μr=10−3\mu_r=10^{-3} yield that their range of Ca/Bo varies from 0.1 to 2.27. The simulations with Ca/Bo <1<1 can be grouped as

Descent and progressive deformation of the magma drop through time for lateral confinement ratios 0.125 and 0.1, with panels a–c showing $t^*=0.168$, $t^*=0.505$, and $t^*=1.011$, and panels d–f showing $t^*=0.055$, $t^*=0.166$, and $t^*=0.276$

Figure 3. Descent and progressive deformation of the magma drop through time for lateral confinement ratios 0.125 and 0.1 (left and right panels respectively).

purely Sinking enclaves. The normalized depths (H∗H^{*}) for these sinking enclave drops are 0.7 and 0.23 respectively.

Non-sinking

We differentiate Non-sinking enclaves from Sinking based on the values of Ca/BoCa/Bo. The cases where Ca/Bo>1Ca/Bo > 1, can be categorised as Non-sinking as gravitational forces are relatively weaker for those simulations. The Non-sinking deformation can again be broadly classified among three deformation processes - a) stretching-and-breakup, b) stretching-and-rotation and, c) stretching-and-retraction. All these enclaves essentially undergo initial tilt and elongation. However eventually the deformation pattern diversify depending on selected non-dimensional parameter settings and their combinations.

Stretching with Breakup

We simulated models using large range of viscosity ratio (μr=10−6−10−3\mu_{r} = 10^{-6} - 10^{-3}) where in all cases host is more viscous than the droplet. It is found that decreasing viscosity ratio has a positive impact on droplet stretching. Intense stretching causes steady increase in long axis and decrease in short axis dimension, ultimately causing formation of neck along which the drop get fragmented. We also use the Capillary number (Ca), lateral confinement ratio (2a/L2a/L) and vertical confinement ratio (2a/H2a/H) to understand their effect on droplet breakup. Among the 96 simulations we performed for this study, this mode of deformation is the most widely observed outcome.

Breakup occurs with the stretching of the magma droplets to their maximum limit, and a pinch-off point is formed at which the magmatic droplet breaks apart. Depending on the preferred sites for pinch-off, we can identify three kinds of droplet break-up which finally controls the daughter droplet numbers and sizes - i) Edge break-up, ii) Mid break-up, iii) Multi break-up. The types are identified by the first break-up of a particular droplet. If there is only one preferential site for pinch off, there will be a single break-up at first. We find single pinch off locations generally forms either near top-right edge or near the middle of stretched droplet. Whereas, multiple pinch off locations are caused by thinning at more than one location along the long axis of the elongated and deformed droplet. Eventually these secondary droplets may undergo further break-ups, which are not considered during break-up nomenclature. We will discuss the individual deformation patterns of these three as well as their transitions driven by change in parameter settings.

At viscosity ratio between drop and host decreases further (μr=10−4\mu_{r} = 10^{-4}) from Sinking regime (μr=10−3\mu_{r} = 10^{-3}), we encounter Stretching with Break-up. Figure 4 shows the transient deformation history for Sims 34 (left panel) and 38 (right panel) where first can be identified as Mid break-up and second as Edge break-up. We present the results upto the time of pinch-off locations are fixed.

Pinching and breakup mechanism at mid-point and at edge

Figure 4. Pinching and breakup mechanism at mid-point (left panel) and at edge (right panel) for lateral dimension ratio 0.1, vertical confinement ratios of 0.12 and 0.2, viscosity ratio 1.00×10−41.00 \times10^{-4}, Ca=3.00×107\mathrm{Ca} = 3.00 \times10^{7}.

Sim 34 has been performed at Ca=3.00×107\mathrm{Ca} = 3.00 \times10^{7} and Re=3.45×10−4\mathrm{Re} = 3.45 \times10^{-4}. In Figure 4a, we see the initial deformation of the magma droplet at t∗=0.069t^{*} = 0.069. The droplet deforms into an ellipse having δ=1.16\delta= 1.16 and D=0.20D = 0.20. θ\theta value at this stage is 43.52 which is changed to 38.72 as time progresses to t∗=0.207t^{*} = 0.207 (Figure 4b). Corresponding δ\delta and DD are increased to 1.45 and 0.43 respectively which indicates higher deformation due to stretching. At t∗=0.345t^{*} = 0.345, the magma droplet stretches further (Figure 4c) causing higher DD (0.57) and δ\delta (1.59), whereas θ\theta shows 33.94. Finally pinch off is observed at t∗=0.483t^{*} = 0.483 (Figure 4d) when the droplet attains its maximum stretch as a continuous body (δ=1.78\delta= 1.78). Thickness is minimum at this stage with D=0.96D = 0.96. The site of the pinch off is located near the middle of the long axis, making this case a representative of mid break-up. The Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} in this case is 8.49, vertical and lateral confinement ratios are 0.12 and 0.06 respectively.

A transition occurs when Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} reduces to 3.06 and vertical & lateral confinement ratios are changed to 0.2 and 0.1 respectively. This corresponds new trend of deformation (Figure 4e-Figure 4h) in Sim 38 even though the Ca\mathrm{Ca} and the Re\mathrm{Re} values are the same as Sim 34. Figure 4e displays early deformation at t∗=0.041t^{*} = 0.041 where an ellipse is formed. The value of the deformation parameter is relatively low (D=0.12D = 0.12) and corresponding δ\delta is calculated to be 1.11. At t∗=0.207t^{*} = 0.207, the droplet stretches into a deformed ellipsoid (Figure 4f) of dimensions with increased values DD and δ\delta of 0.49 and 1.60. At the same time the deformed magma drop has a tilt (θ\theta) of 36.68. At t∗=0.414t^{*} = 0.414, the deformation looks asymmetric where top-right corner is narrower than the rest of the body (Figure 4g). Corresponding DD, δ\delta and θ\theta values are 0.73, 2.11 and 29.95 respectively. This asymmetry increases with time (t∗=0.579t^{*} = 0.579) and prominent pinch off is formed near right edge (Figure 4h). At this stage DD increases further to D=0.92D = 0.92 and δ\delta to 2.51, whereas θ\theta reduces to 24.66. Though the locations of break-up are different in these two cases, both of them belong to Non-sinking regime as Ca/Bo>1\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} > 1. Time taken to get stretched and pinched is relatively more in Sim 38 than Sim 34. Interestingly, we still can see effect of body force in Sim 38 as the centre of the deformed drop lies beneath the centreline of the chamber (H∗=0.88H^{*} = 0.88).

Within Non-sinking regime, single pinch off leading to either edge or mid break-up spans almost all over the total viscosity range of current study i.e. μr=10−6−10−3\mu_{r} = 10^{-6} - 10^{-3}. However, occurrence of multiple pinch off causing multi break-up is generally found at lower viscosity range (μr=10−6−10−5\mu_{r} = 10^{-6} - 10^{-5}). In Figure 5 we will present a mid-break-up case (Sim 61) at μr=10−5\mu_{r} = 10^{-5} and its transition to multi break-up (Sim 85) at μr=10−6\mu_{r} = 10^{-6}. Corresponding Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} increase from 10.2 to 102 from Sim 61 to Sim 85.

Mid-point breakup and multiple breakup mechanism of the magma droplet under shear

Figure 5. Mid-point breakup (left panel) and multiple breakup (right panel) mechanism of the magma droplet under shear for lateral confinement ratio 0.1; vertical confinement ratio 0.2, viscosity ratio 1.0×10−51.0 \times10^{-5} and 1.0×10−61.0 \times10^{-6}, shear rate 4.00×10−44.00 \times10^{-4}, Ca=1.0×108\mathrm{Ca} = 1.0 \times10^{8} and 1.0×1091.0 \times10^{9}.

In both simulations, the vertical confinement ratio and the lateral confinement ratio were maintained at 0.2 and 0.1.

In Figure 5a, we see that the magma droplet undergoes mild deformation at t∗=0.083t^{\ast} = 0.083 for Sim 61. Deformation related parameters are measured to be D=0.11D = 0.11, δ=1.07\delta= 1.07. Figure 5e represents equivalent initial deformation for Sim 85 at t∗=0.110t^{\ast} = 0.110. The deformed shapes at this preliminary stage are almost similar for both cases with later having slightly higher DD (= 0.13) and δ\delta (1.10). The droplet continues to deform with an increase in time, and at the timestep t∗=0.579t^{\ast} = 0.579, it deforms to take the shape of a distorted ellipse (Figure 5b) with DD (= 0.52) and δ\delta (= 1.55). Though the equivalent stage for Sim 85 at t∗=0.772t^{\ast} = 0.772 shows same pattern of deformation (Figure 5f), it shows higher stretching. The corresponding values of DD and δ\delta are 0.54 and 1.67. If we compare the δ\delta and θ\theta values, we find that δ\delta increases from 1.96 in Sim 61 to 2.23 in Sim 85, whereas θ\theta is 28.91 in Sim 61 and 27.71 in Sim 85. Drop in Sim 85 continue to stretch more than that in Sim 61 as time progresses (Figure 5c & Figure 5g). Finally, single pinch off occurs in Sim 61 at t∗=1.986t^{*} = 1.986 with D=0.95D = 0.95, δ=2.37\delta= 2.37 and θ=24.55\theta= 24.55. Similarly, in Sim 85, at t∗=2.207t^{*} = 2.207, with further stretching and deformation (D=0.93D = 0.93), necking of droplet occurs at two different positions (Figure 5h). This resultant multi break-up enclave shape looks like a tilted “candy” having θ=23.72\theta= 23.72.

Stretching with Rotation

Another deformation pattern of magma droplet is observed in our simulation where the droplet undergoes high strain and rotates toward the applied shear direction. In some cases, the rotation continues beyond this alignment and the stretched droplet enters the zone of compression crossing the zone of extension. The resultant deformed droplet resists further stretching and break-up and is folded instead. We notice that this type of deformation occurs when the confinement ratios are relatively higher (2a/H=0.22a/H = 0.2 and 2a/L=0.1252a/L = 0.125) among the simulations. However, this parameter alone can’t guide the deformation as there are many break-up cases in current study also have same parameter ratios. We choose Sim 77 and Sim 80 and observe what change can cause the transition from stretching with break-up to stretching with rotation.

In Figure 6a, we see the initial deformation of the magma droplet at t∗=0.211t^* = 0.211 for Sim 77. The droplet deformation was measured and the corresponding values of DD, δ\delta and θ\theta were 0.17, 1.14 and 43.40 respectively. Figure 6e depicts initial deformation for Sim 80 at t∗=0.055t^* = 0.055 with DD value of 0.31 which is higher than the former simulation. The δ\delta and θ\theta values are 1.31 and 37.46. At t∗=1.053t^* = 1.053, the droplet deforms to take the shape of an asymmetric ellipse with D=0.53D = 0.53, δ=1.66\delta= 1.66 and θ\theta valued at 30.03 as shown in Figure 6b. Figure 6f depicts the next stage deformation for sim 80, wherein the ellipse is stretched to form an oblate disc at t∗=0.221t^* = 0.221. The deformation parameters DD, δ\delta and θ\theta for this stage are valued at 0.68, 2.13 and 20.78 respectively. Figure 6c shows the deformation for sim 77 where the ellipse is stretched and the corresponding values of DD, δ\delta and θ\theta are 0.65, 2.01 and 18.90 at t∗=2.316t^* = 2.316. Figure 6g shows the equivalent stage of deformation for sim 80 at t∗=0.386t^* = 0.386. The oblate droplet is further stretched and the DD and δ\delta values measure 0.78 and 2.45. The inclination of the droplet reduces to 5.01 and appears horizontal. Figure 6d shows the final pinch off stage for Sim 77 at t∗=3.368t^* = 3.368. The stretched magma droplet further stretches to form a narrow pinch off point from which it breaks off with DD, δ\delta and θ\theta measuring 0.93, 2.17 and 11.39. Figure 6h shows that the magma droplet resists further deformation (D=0.64D = 0.64), and folds to form a faint “z” shape at t∗=0.662t^* = 0.662.

Mid-point breakup and stretching with rotation mechanisms

Figure 6. Mid-point breakup (left panel) and Stretching with Rotation (right panel) mechanism at lateral confinement ratio 0.125; vertical confinement ratio 0.2, viscosity ratio 1.0 × 10−610^{-6}, shear rates 4.00 × 10−410^{-4} and 3.20 × 10−310^{-3}, Ca = 1.0 × 10910^{9} and 8.0 × 10910^{9}.

Stretching with Retraction

We observe another deformation pattern of the magma droplet in our simulations, where the droplet under the effect of low strain undergoes little stretching as compared to other cases and then compress or retracts. We notice this type of deformation at lower vertical confinement ratio (2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12) and over a range of vertical confinement ratios (2a/L=0.075−0.042a/L = 0.075 - 0.04). We choose Sim 73 and 74 for the study of the deformational pattern for the transition of stretching with breakup and stretching with retraction and what changes in parameters act as the driving force behind this transition.

The transition from stretching with retraction to stretching with breakup is observed at lower viscosity ratio (10−610^{-6}). Increase in velocity contributes to the increase in the capillary number (1.0×1091.0 \times10^{9} - 3.0×1093.0 \times10^{9}) which in turn promotes the transition. In Figure 7 we present a stretching and retraction case (Sim 73) having Ca=1.00×109\mathrm{Ca} = 1.00 \times10^{9} and a mid breakup case (Sim 74) with Ca=3.00×109\mathrm{Ca} = 3.00 \times10^{9}. The corresponding Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} value increases from 283 to 849.

Stretching with retraction and Mid-point breakup mechanisms

Figure 7. Stretching with retraction (left panel) and Mid-point breakup (right panel) mechanism at lateral confinement ratio 0.075; vertical confinement ratio 0.12, viscosity ratio 1.0×10−61.0 \times10^{-6}, shear rates 4.00×10−44.00 \times10^{-4} and 1.20×10−31.20 \times10^{-3}, Ca=1.0×109\mathrm{Ca} = 1.0 \times10^{9} and 3.0×1093.0 \times10^{9}.

In Figure 7a, the magma droplet initially deforms at t∗=0.211t^{*} = 0.211 for Sim 73. The deformation parameters DD, δ\delta and θ\theta were measured to be 0.16, 1.12 and 42.94 respectively. Figure 7e represents the initial deformation of magma droplet for Sim 74 at t∗=0.084t^* = 0.084 where the DD, δ\delta and θ\theta have the corresponding value of 0.19, 1.16 and 42.81. Figure 7b shows the deformation at t∗=0.632t^* = 0.632 for Sim 73, where the magma droplet is stretched with DD valued at 0.35, which is higher than the earlier timestep. The corresponding values of δ\delta and θ\theta are 1.31 and 41.03. The equivalent step for Sim 74 is shown by Figure 7f, in which the magma droplet undergoes more stretching, depicted by D=0.41D = 0.41 at t∗=0.253t^* = 0.253. The corresponding values of δ\delta and θ\theta are 1.42 and 36.44, respectively. Figure 7c shows the deformation at t∗=1.053t^* = 1.053 where the magma droplet, instead of experiencing more deformation, resists it and starts to retract. The value of DD and δ\delta does not change for this step while the value of θ\theta is decreased to 40.74. Figure 7g shows the further deformation of the magma droplet at t∗=0.421t^* = 0.421. The droplet is stretched and forms an ellipse with uneven boundary and the value of DD, δ\delta and θ\theta are 0.53, 1.60 and 31.07, respectively. Figure 7d shows the retracted magma droplet at t∗=1.474t^* = 1.474 with a reduction in the values of DD, δ\delta and θ\theta to 0.28, 1.25 and 40.06. Figure 7h shows the mid-point pinching of the magma droplet due to further deformation for Sim 74. The corresponding values of DD, δ\delta and θ\theta are 0.77, 1.67 and 24.16.

Quantitative synthesis of deformation and regime selection

This section quantifies the deformation patterns described in § 3.1 across the full set of 96 simulations. § 3.2 presents the regime map, the outcome statistics and the sinking transition (Figure 8–Figure 10), and § 3.3 presents the orientation and strain at maximum stretch of the non-sinking enclaves (Figure 11 and Figure 12).

Deformation-regime map in the $\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo}$-$\mu_r$ parameter space

Figure 8. Deformation-regime map in the Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo}-μr\mu_r parameter space for 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 and 0.200.20. Symbols identify sinking, edge break-up, mid break-up, multi break-up, rotation, and retraction.

Ca/Bo as a function of normalized sinking depth, H*, for the two vertical confinement ratios

Figure 10. Ca/Bo as a function of normalized sinking depth, H∗H^*, for the two vertical confinement ratios. The dashed curve marks the empirical transition between the gravity-dominated and shear-dominated regions represented by the simulations.

Orientation angle versus strain at maximum stretch for two confinement ratios

Figure 11. Orientation angle, θ\theta, versus strain at maximum stretch, γ\gamma, for 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 and 0.200.20. The dash-dotted lines are major-axis linear fits.

Strain at maximum stretch as a function of Ca/Bo for two vertical confinement ratios

Figure 12. Strain at maximum stretch, γ=γ˙tmax⁡\gamma= \dot{\gamma}t_{\max}, as a function of Ca/Bo for vertical confinement ratios 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 and 0.200.20. The dashed line and shaded band denote the panel mean and ±1\pm1 s.d.; the dash-dotted line is the least-squares trend.

Quantitative analysis is very necessary to understand and relate the deformation patterns and the force balances behind them. Here we will try to synthesize the transient history of deformation discussed in section 3.2.

Figure 8 maps the Ca/Bo values of all simulations against the viscosity ratio μr\mu_r and summarises the deformation regimes in the Ca/Bo −- μr\mu_r parameter space. The sinking and non-sinking regimes separate near Ca/Bo = 1: sinking occurs predominantly below this value and non-sinking above it. Within the non-sinking field the simulations span a broad range of Ca/Bo and μr\mu_r, and three sub-regimes are identified: stretching with break-up, stretching with rotation and stretching with retraction. All of them are stretched initially, as they lie at high Ca/Bo. Figure 8a shows the results for 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 and Figure 8b those for 2a/H=0.22a/H = 0.2. Lower μr\mu_r is associated with more intense deformation. Stretching with rotation and stretching with retraction are mutually exclusive: retraction is found at low confinement and rotation at high confinement.

Figure 9 complements Figure 8 by quantifying the regime distribution as fractions of outcomes. At 2a/H=0.22a/H = 0.2, the high-μr\mu_r range is 100% sinking, whereas at 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 the outcomes are shared equally between sinking and edge break-up. Mid break-up is the main outcome over the mid-to-low μr\mu_r range at 2a/H=0.22a/H = 0.2, with retraction and multi break-up next in importance. At 2a/H=0.22a/H = 0.2, multi break-up is prominent

Approximate outcome fractions as a function of viscosity ratio

Figure 9. Approximate outcome fractions as a function of viscosity ratio, μr\mu_r, for the two vertical confinement ratios. Increasing μr\mu_r shifts the outcome distribution toward sinking, while lower μr\mu_r favours break-up and, at higher confinement, rotation.

at μr=10−6\mu_r = 10^{-6}–10−510^{-5}, where rotation is also observed, and edge break-up becomes significant around μr=10−4\mu_r = 10^{-4}. These fractions reflect how the 96 simulations were distributed across the parameter space and should not be read as probabilities of occurrence.

Because Ca/Bo represents the relative forcing of shear and gravitational buoyancy, it provides a measure of the sinking transition that does not rely on the regime classification. Figure 10 shows the normalized depth H∗H^* as a function of Ca/Bo at high viscosity ratio (μr=10−3\mu_r = 10^{-3}). Simulations with low Ca/Bo sink as deep as H∗=0.2H^* = 0.2, whereas relatively large Ca/Bo values are associated with shallower displacement. The lower-confinement simulations (2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12) cluster at low Ca/Bo (<1< 1), in contrast to those at higher confinement (2a/H=0.22a/H = 0.2). The transition therefore occurs over a range of Ca/Bo that depends on confinement, and not at a single threshold.

Orientation and strain at maximum stretch

For the non-sinking enclaves we examine the relation between the orientation angle θ\theta and the strain at the stage of maximum stretching (γmax⁡\gamma_{\max}). In our simulations, just after this stage the droplet pinches off and breaks up. θ\theta decreases linearly with γ\gamma for both confinements (Figure 11a and Figure 11b), indicating progressive reorientation of the major axis as deformation accumulates. The fitted relations are θ=44.2−10.5γmax⁡\theta= 44.2 - 10.5\gamma_{\max} for 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 (R2=0.54R^2 = 0.54) and θ=41.3−9.5γmax⁡\theta= 41.3 - 9.5\gamma_{\max} for 2a/H=0.202a/H = 0.20 (R2=0.88R^2 = 0.88). The slopes are comparable, suggesting that the rate of reorientation is broadly similar for the two confinement ratios, although the difference in R2R^2 indicates that the linear relationship is more consistent for 2a/H=0.202a/H = 0.20. For the lower confinement ratio, the data show greater scatter, particularly at intermediate and higher strains. Overall, high confinement simulations accumulate high strain. Rotation regime γmax⁡\gamma_{\max} lies at higher end but orientation angle is characterically low Figure 11b which distinguish it from the other deformation modes.

Among the non-sinking simulations, break-up cases dominate, ranging from edge to mid to multi break-up. Figure 12 shows the strain accumulated before maximum stretch, γmax⁡=γ˙tmax⁡\gamma_{\max} = \dot{\gamma}t_{\max}, as a function of Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo}. γmax⁡\gamma_{\max} increases with Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} for both confinements. For 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 the fitted trend is γmax⁡=0.95+0.07log⁡10(Ca/Bo)\gamma_{\max} = 0.95 + 0.07\log_{10}(\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo}), and for 2a/H=0.202a/H = 0.20 it is γmax⁡=0.91+0.35log⁡10(Ca/Bo)\gamma_{\max} = 0.91 + 0.35\log_{10}(\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo}). The panel means are 1.07±0.311.07 \pm0.31 and 1.42±0.401.42 \pm0.40, respectively, so the dependence of γmax⁡\gamma_{\max} on Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} is stronger at the higher vertical confinement. The slope for 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 is small compared with the scatter about the mean, so the contrast between the two confinements should be treated as indicative.

Discussion

The simulations show how a dense, low-viscosity droplet in a viscous host responds to the competition between shear and buoyancy. Figure 3–Figure 12 together form an ensemble which consistently provides a fluid-dynamic basis for interpreting the diversity of natural enclave shapes. We discuss the controls on regime selection, the regime-forming mechanisms, the implementation of droplet dynamics for natural enclaves as the novelty of the study and the limitations of our model.

Controls and Mechanisms behind the regimes

Ca/Bo is the first-order control on whether an enclave sinks or is deformed by the host flow. At higher Ca/Bo the shear-induced flow overpowers gravity-driven motion and suppresses sinking (Figure 8 and Figure 10). Because the boundary occurs over a range of Ca/Bo that depends on confinement (Figure 10), it is better viewed as a transition zone than as a sharp boundary at Ca/Bo = 1. Within the non-sinking field, lower viscosity ratio promotes stretching, because a highly viscous host stretches and aligns the low-viscosity enclave more readily, and multiple pinch-off appears only at the lowest ratios (μr=10−6−10−5\mu_r = 10^{-6} - 10^{-5}). However, the viscosity ratio alone does not fix the final morphology within this field. Confinement (2a/H2a/H) and shear intensity (Ca/Bo) determine how the available strain is accommodated, whether by pinch-off, rotation or retraction (Figure 9), and together they distribute the accumulated strain to reshape and reorient the droplet after stretching instead of causing immediate pinch-off. At the Capillary numbers explored here (Ca ≫1\gg1), interfacial tension has negligible contribution, so the deformation histories described in § 3 are set by the competition between the host flow, which stretches and rotates the droplet, and buoyancy, which displaces it. In the sinking regime (Ca/Bo <1< 1) the droplet descends through the host while the imposed global flow advects it sideways (Figure 3).

For Ca/Bo>1\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} > 1 the droplet is rotated by the host flow almost similarly in both confinements, while the viscosity ratio determines how freely it stretches. The location of the first pinch-off appears to reflect how strongly buoyancy perturbs the otherwise symmetric stretching. In Sim 34 (Ca/Bo=8.49\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} = 8.49) the droplet thins near the middle of its long axis, whereas in Sim 38 (Ca/Bo=3.06\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} = 3.06), at the same Ca\mathrm{Ca} and Re\mathrm{Re}, it develops a narrower upper-right end and pinches near the right edge, with its centre displaced below the chamber centreline (H∗=0.88H^{*} = 0.88). This is consistent with buoyancy-induced asymmetry favouring edge break-up at lower Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo}. At the lowest viscosity ratios (μr=10−6−10−5\mu_r = 10^{-6} - 10^{-5}), where the droplet offers the least resistance to the host flow, thinning can occur at more than one position along the stretched droplet, producing multiple break-up (Sims 61 and 85). Rotation and retraction occur when the stretched droplet does not pinch off. The lowest orientation angles belong to the rotation regime (Figure 11): after maximum elongation at this orientation the droplet keeps rotating, enters the compressional field and folds instead of pinching off. On the other hand, interfacial tension is negligible at these Ca\mathrm{Ca}, retraction cannot be a capillary relaxation and must be driven by the host flow. Confinement ratio must act as trigger as retraction is only associated with lower confinement and rotation with higher confinement. Confinement also changes the strain history and the kinematic path leading to break-up, in addition to the deformed shape. γmax⁡\gamma_{\max} increases with Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} as shear overpowers buoyancy, and this dependence is stronger at the higher vertical confinement (Figure 12), although the weak trend at 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 is comparable to its scatter, so the difference between the two confinements is indicative.

Novelty and Implications for natural enclaves

Earlier works on droplets have used moderate Ca\mathrm{Ca} and identified a critical capillary number above which a droplet in shear breaks up, and show that this critical value depends on the viscosity ratio and on confinement [15, 16]. At these values, surface tension has significant effect on the break up dynamics. However, interfacial tension is very low in magmatic system [23, 24]. The simulations here lie far above any such threshold (Ca\mathrm{Ca} from 10610^{6} to 8×1098 \times10^{9}), so break-up is not controlled by capillary stability but by how much strain the droplet accumulates. This is why the strain at maximum stretch (on average about 1.1 to 1.4, Figure 12). We have chosen Re\mathrm{Re} applicable to very low inertia condition of plutonic system [25] which is not common in droplet studies. The present results add buoyancy as a competing control and discusses deformation dependence on Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} and confinement. As a result, simulations produce a sinking regime that neutrally buoyant studies cannot capture, and they show that rotation and retraction occur under controls that differ from the capillary relaxation familiar from low-Ca\mathrm{Ca} studies. The dependence of the break-up mode on viscosity ratio is consistent with the analogue experiments of [29, 30], who found that the break-up of injected mafic dykes depends strongly on the rheological contrast between the magmas, and with the general expectation that a less viscous droplet in a more viscous host deforms readily and ends in pinch-off at its tips [8, 9]. Our results extends the existing droplet studies to quantify the relationship between orientation, Ca/BoCa/Bo and strain at maximum stretching for the two confinement ratios considered here. The lowest orientation angles are associated with the rotation regime, particularly for 2a/H=0.202a/H = 0.20, where this regime is clearly separated from the other deformation modes. Together the regimes give a way to read enclave shape in terms of the flow that produced it (Table 4). Buoyancy-dominated descent (Ca/Bo<1Ca/Bo < 1) to the floor of the chamber causes the sagging or flattening of the enclaves along shear direction (Figure 1b,Figure 1d,Figure 1e). They do not by themselves indicate weak flow or low strain but a local low viscosity host. Strongly fragmented swarms with chains of small fragments point to shear-dominated flow by high viscosity host, whereas two comparable fragments, or a main body with a small satellite, indicate mid or edge break-up at lower Ca/BoCa/Bo. Moderately elongated and aligned enclaves (Figure 1a) may have experienced large accumulated strain, because in the rotation and retraction regimes the droplet does not break up and retracts (Figure 1c) or folds (Figure 1f) after maximum stretch. Retracted enclaves may have multi-pronged structure (Figure 1c) and the aspect ratio of such enclaves can underestimate finite strain. Our results also analyse the claim by [3] that mafic enclaves can’t be used as strain markers. Their argument is based on that enclaves, with varied initial shapes and times of formation, undergo large temperature-dependent changes in viscosity contrast. Our simulations considers the hot and fluid stage of enclaves with μr=10−6−10−3\mu_r = 10^{-6} - 10^{-3}, that lie within the “enclave strain” field of [36]. Because all drops start as identical circles, the variety of outcomes in Figure 3 - Figure 8 arises from flow regime alone, so shape is non-unique even without differences in initial shape or history. Folded and multi-lobed forms, including “double-pronged” enclaves linked to two successive foliations as described by [3], can also arise from a single flow in our retraction and folding regimes, so natural examples should be evaluated against both possibilities.

RegimeConditions in the simulationsDroplet responseExpected enclave appearance
SinkingCa/Bo<1\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} < 1; all μr=10−3\mu_r = 10^{-3} runs with low Ca/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo}Buoyancy dominates; descends toward the base like sagging, sometimes drifting sidewaysRounded to peanut shaped to long flattened enclaves
Non-SinkingEdge break-upMostly Ca/Bo<5\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} < 5, limited to μr=10−4\mu_r = 10^{-4} to 10−310^{-3}Asymmetric thinning; pinch-off near one endLarge main body with a small satellite
Non-SinkingMid break-upCa/Bo\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} spans from low to high; main outcome at mid to low μr=10−6\mu_r = 10^{-6} to 10−410^{-4}Symmetric thinning; pinch-off near the middle of the long axisTwo comparable fragments
Non-SinkingMulti break-upMostly Ca/Bo≫1\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} \gg1; μr=10−6\mu_r = 10^{-6} to 10−510^{-5}Necking at several positions along the stretched dropletChain of fragments
Non-SinkingRotationCa/Bo>1\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} > 1 but spans over large range; higher confinement (2a/H=0.22a/H = 0.2); μr=10−6\mu_r = 10^{-6} to 10−410^{-4}Stretches, then rotates and folds instead of pinching offStrongly aligned enclaves, sometimes appear folded
Non-SinkingRetractionCa/Bo>1\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo} > 1; mainly lower confinement (2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12); μr=10−6\mu_r = 10^{-6} to 10−510^{-5}Stretches, then shortens toward a compact shapeCompact enclave despite high accumulated strain

Table 4. Deformation regimes, the conditions under which they occur in the simulations, and the enclave appearance they would produce.

Limitations

The results should be interpreted in the context of the following simplifying assumptions and limitations. The model is two-dimensional, so the out-of-plane stretching and capillary instabilities are absent. The fluids are Newtonian and isothermal with a single density contrast (400 kg m−3400\ \mathrm{kg\ m^{-3}}), and crystallisation and thermal equilibration, which change the enclave viscosity in natural chambers, are not included. The lateral confinement 2a/L2a/L was varied through the chamber length, whereas the vertical confinement 2a/H2a/H changed through the droplet radius, so the vertical confinement is partly combined with droplet size and Bo. The regimes are identified using Ca/BoCa/Bo, with H∗H^{*} (Figure 10) providing an independent measure of the sinking transition. Finally, natural magma chambers may contain multiple interacting mafic enclaves, whereas the present study considers a single enclave to isolate its deformation and kinematics under the combined effects of buoyancy, confinement, and viscosity contrast. Extending the present framework to multiple interacting enclaves would be a valuable direction for future work, allowing the influence of inter-enclave interactions on deformation, motion, and breakup to be investigated.

Conclusions

We have presented a systematic numerical study of how a dense, low-viscosity magma droplet deforms in a lighter, more viscous host under shear and buoyancy, in the regime of mafic enclaves in granitic plutons (μr=10−6−10−3\mu_r = 10^{-6} - 10^{-3}, Ca\mathrm{Ca} up to 8×1098 \times10^{9}, low Re, Δρ=400\Delta\rho= 400 kg m−3^{-3}. The 96 two-dimensional Level-Set simulations resolve six distinct outcomes (sinking, edge, mid and multiple break-up, rotation and retraction) and organise them in terms of Ca/Bo, the viscosity ratio and the confinement. The main results are as follows:

  1. Ca/Bo separates gravity-dominated from shear-dominated behaviour. Enclaves with Ca/Bo <1< 1 sink while retaining much of their shape, reaching depths as low as H∗≈0.2H^* \approx0.2, whereas those with Ca/Bo >1> 1 are stretched and reoriented by the host flow. The normalised sinking depth shows that the transition is a range in Ca/Bo, shifted by vertical confinement, and not a single threshold.

  1. The viscosity ratio sets the mode of failure in the shear-dominated regime. Lower μr\mu_r promotes stretching, break-up is the most common outcome, single pinch-off (edge or mid) occurs across the full μr\mu_r range, and multiple pinch-off appears only at μr=10−6−10−5\mu_r = 10^{-6} - 10^{-5}, producing chains of fragments.

  1. Confinement decides how the accumulated strain is released. Retraction occurs at lower confinement and rotation at higher confinement, so the two are mutually exclusive. The strain at maximum stretch grows with log⁡10(Ca/Bo)\log_{10}(\mathrm{Ca}/\mathrm{Bo}), and this dependence is stronger at 2a/H=0.202a/H = 0.20 (slope 0.31) than at 2a/H=0.122a/H = 0.12 (slope 0.07). The orientation of the major axis falls linearly with strain at similar rates for both confinements (−10.5-10.5 to −9.5∘-9.5^\circ per unit strain).

  1. Together these results turn the diversity of enclave shapes in granitic plutons into a classification that can be read in terms of flow. Rounded, nearly undeformed enclaves can record buoyancy-dominated descent, chains of fragments point to shear-dominated flow at very low viscosity ratio, and moderately elongated enclaves can reflect large accumulated strain, so enclave shape alone is not a direct proxy for finite strain.

The framework rests on a model that is two-dimensional, Newtonian and isothermal. Extending it to three dimensions, to temperature-dependent and crystal-bearing rheology and to a variable density contrast, and testing the regimes against morphometric data from natural enclaves, are natural next steps.

Acknowledgement

UD acknowledges CSIR-India for ASPIRE research grant no. 25WS(0009)/2023-24/EMR-II/ASPIRE. PS acknowledges for the financial support through ASPIRE research grant no. 25WS(0009)/2023-24/EMR-II/ASPIRE.

Complete List of input and output parameters

Bibliography

References

  1. [1]B. Barbarin and J. Didier, Genesis and evolution of mafic microgranular enclaves through various types of interaction between coexisting felsic and mafic magmas, Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 83 (1992) 145–153.
  2. [2]B. Barbarin, Mafic magmatic enclaves and mafic rocks associated with some granitoids of the central sierra nevada batholith, california: nature, origin, and relations with the hosts, Lithos 80 (2005) 155–177.DOI
  3. [3]S. R. Paterson, G. S. Pignotta and R. H. Vernon, The significance of microgranitoid enclave shapes and orientations, Journal of Structural Geology 26 (2004) 1465–1481.DOI
  4. [4]S. R. Paterson, J. Onezime, L. Teruya and J. Žák, Quadruple-pronged enclaves: their significance for the interpretation of multiple magmatic fabrics in plutons, Journal of the Virtual Explorer 10 (2003) 15–30.DOI
  5. [5]G. I. Taylor, The viscosity of a fluid containing small drops of another fluid, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Containing papers of a mathematical and physical character 138 (1932) 41–48.DOI
  6. [6]G. I. Taylor, The formation of emulsions in definable fields of flow, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, containing papers of a mathematical and physical character 146 (1934) 501–523.DOI
  7. [7]J. Rallison, The deformation of small viscous drops and bubbles in shear flows, Annual review of fluid mechanics 16 (1984) 45–66.DOI
  8. [8]H. A. Stone, Dynamics of drop deformation and breakup in viscous fluids, Annual review of fluid mechanics 26 (1994) 65–102.
  9. [9]S. Guido, Shear-induced droplet deformation: Effects of confined geometry and viscoelasticity, Current opinion in colloid & interface science 16 (2011) 61–70.DOI
  10. [10]A. Vananroye, P. Van Puyvelde and P. Moldenaers, Effect of confinement on the steady-state behavior of single droplets during shear flow, Journal of rheology 51 (2007) 139–153.DOI
  11. [11]H. Hua, Y. Li, J. Shin, H.-k. Song and J. Kim, Effect of confinement on droplet deformation in shear flow, International Journal of Computational Fluid Dynamics 27 (2013) 317–331.DOI
  12. [12]U. Dutta, S. Sarkar, A. Baruah and N. Mandal, Ascent modes of jets and plumes in a stationary fluid of contrasting viscosity, International Journal of Multiphase Flow 63 (2014) 1–10.DOI
  13. [13]A. Komrakova, O. Shardt, D. Eskin and J. Derksen, Lattice boltzmann simulations of drop deformation and breakup in shear flow, International Journal of Multiphase Flow 59 (2014) 24–43.DOI
  14. [14]U. Dutta, A. Baruah and N. Mandal, Role of source-layer tilts in the axi-asymmetric growth of diapirs triggered by a rayleigh–taylor instability, Geophysical Journal International 206 (2016) 1814–1830.DOI
  15. [15]A. Amani, N. Balcazar, E. Gutierrez and A. Oliva, Dns of unequal size droplets collision using a moving-mesh/level-set method, in ERCOTFAC workshop direct and large eddy simulation, pp. 103–109, Springer, 2019.
  16. [16]K. Wang, H. Liang, C. Zhao and X. Bian, Dynamics of a droplet in shear flow by smoothed particle hydrodynamics, Frontiers in Physics 11 (2023) 1286217.arxiv.org/abs/2307.02807
  17. [17]U. Dutta and N. Mandal, Solitary waves forming pulsating thermal plumes and their implications for multiple eruption events in large igneous provinces, Episodes Journal of International Geoscience 47 (2024) 227–239.DOI
  18. [18]H. A. Stone and L. G. Leal, Relaxation and breakup of an initially extended drop in an otherwise quiescent fluid, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 198 (1989) 399–427.DOI
  19. [19]P. Dimitrakopoulos, Gravitational effects on the deformation of a droplet adhering to a horizontal solid surface in shear flow, Physics of Fluids 19 (2007) .DOI
  20. [20]N. Petford, Rheology of granitic magmas during ascent and emplacement, Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences 31 (2003) 399–427.DOI
  21. [21]D. B. Dingwell, Volcanic dilemma: flow or blow?, Science 273 (1996) 1054–1056.DOI
  22. [22]D. Giordano, J. K. Russell and D. B. Dingwell, Viscosity of magmatic liquids: a model, Earth and Planetary Science Letters 271 (2008) 123–134.
  23. [23]M. J. Edwards, L. Pioli, A. J. Harris, L. Gurioli and S. Thivet, Magma fragmentation and particle size distributions in low intensity mafic explosions: the july/august 2015 piton de la fournaise eruption, Scientific reports 10 (2020) 13953.DOI
  24. [24]A. Toramaru and T. Kichise, A new model of crystallization in magmas: Impact of pre-exponential factor of crystal nucleation rate on cooling rate exponent and log-linear crystal size distribution, Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth 128 (2023) e2023JB026481.DOI
  25. [25]A. F. Glazner, Magmatic life at low reynolds number, Geology 42 (2014) 935–938.
  26. [26]Q. Williams and O. Tobisch, Microgranitic enclave shapes and magmatic strain histories: constraints from drop deformation theory, Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth 99 (1994) 24359–24368.DOI
  27. [27]A. Rust, M. Manga and K. V. Cashman, Determining flow type, shear rate and shear stress in magmas from bubble shapes and orientations, Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 122 (2003) 111–132.
  28. [28]S. Piazolo and C. W. Passchier, Experimental modeling of viscous inclusions in a circular high-strain shear rig: Implications for the interpretation of shape fabrics and deformed enclaves, Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth 107 (2002) ETG–11.DOI
  29. [29]K. F. Hodge, G. Carazzo and A. M. Jellinek, Experimental constraints on the deformation and breakup of injected magma, Earth and Planetary Science Letters 325 (2012) 52–62.
  30. [30]K. F. Hodge, G. Carazzo, X. Montague and A. M. Jellinek, Magmatic structures in the tuolumne intrusive suite, california: a new model for the formation and deformation of ladder dikes, Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology 164 (2012) 587–600.DOI
  31. [31]A. Burgisser, A. Carrara and C. Annen, Numerical simulations of magmatic enclave deformation, Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 392 (2020) 106790.DOI
  32. [32]I. V. Veksler, J. Kahn, G. Franz and D. B. Dingwell, Interfacial tension between immiscible liquids in the system k2o-feo-fe2o3-al2o3-sio2 and implications for the kinetics of silicate melt unmixing, American Mineralogist 95 (2010) 1679–1685.DOI
  33. [33]J. Brackbill, D. Kothe and C. Zemach, A continuum method for modeling surface tension, Journal of Computational Physics 100 (1992) 335–354.DOI
  34. [34]E. Olsson and G. Kreiss, A conservative level set method for two phase flow, Journal of Computational Physics 210 (2005) 225–246.DOI
  35. [35]E. Olsson, G. Kreiss and S. Zahedi, A conservative level set method for two phase flow ii, Journal of Computational Physics 225 (2007) 785–807.DOI
  36. [36]B. Scaillet, A. Whittington, C. Martel, M. Pichavant and F. Holtz, Phase equilibrium constraints on the viscosity of silicic magmas ii: implications for mafic–silicic mixing processes, Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 91 (2000) 61–72.

Paper details

vlnc:W_25vnvm9a
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents