betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Direct simulation Monte Carlo for dark matter production and phase-space evolution

Abstract

To study the early-universe production of dark matter particles beyond thermal equilibrium often requires solving several coupled Boltzmann equations at the phase-space level. We present a new method to address this challenge using Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) based on stochastic interactions of an ensemble of particles. We implement and validate efficient algorithms to describe freeze-out, decays, elastic scattering and number-changing processes within the dark sector. These algorithms do not require a discretisation of momentum space on a pre-defined grid and do not rely on approximations such as thermally averaged cross sections. As illustrative example, we consider a scenario with two-step dark matter production, leading to a bimodal phase-space distribution, and consider the subsequent evolution under elastic and number-changing processes. We show that DSMC is a flexible approach to explore out-of-equilibrium processes and solve Boltzmann equations at the phase-space level in order to predict the abundance of dark matter particles and their effect on structure formation.

Introduction

The Boltzmann equation is used in many areas of physics to build the bridge from micro-physics to macroscopic thermodynamic behaviour. It describes the time evolution of the phase-space distribution function, with the effects of particle motion and interactions encoded in the Liouville and collision operators, respectively. Since the Boltzmann equation is generally difficult to solve, different areas of physics have developed different strategies tailored to the specific context and available approximations.

In cosmology, for example, one can often assume that distributions are spatially homogeneous and that particle species are in kinetic equilibrium, in which case the collision operator can be integrated to give ordinary differential equations for number and energy densities. This approach is commonly used for example to calculate the relic abundance of dark matter (DM) following departure from chemical equilibrium, the so-called freeze-out mechanism [1, 2]. However, as the DM particles depart from thermal equilibrium, the approximations underlying the integrated Boltzmann equations become less accurate [3, 4, 5]. It has been shown that the simple freeze-out calculation can give significantly biased results in scenarios with early kinetic decoupling [4].

If DM particles maintain kinetic equilibrium among themselves through self-scatterings, a possible strategy is to include higher moments of the Boltzmann equation [4] leading to a system of coupled differential equations. If self-scattering is inefficient, the most common approach is to return to the unintegrated form of the Boltzmann equation and solve it by discretising phase space, an approach first developed in the context of neutrino decoupling [6] and then adopted also to the case of DM [7, 8, 9, 10]. This approach however quickly becomes numerically very expensive in spite of various strategies that have been proposed recently to improve its efficiency [11, 12, 13]. A particularly challenging situation arises if DM particles never achieve thermal equilibrium, as in the case of freeze-in production [14]. In such a scenario the phase-space distribution function may differ significantly from the thermal form and can even be multimodal [15, 16, 17, 18], making an efficient discretisation of momentum space particularly difficult.

A promising way forward is to consider strategies developed in other branches of physics, which commonly study systems that are spatially inhomogeneous and/or far from thermal equilibrium. In the study of rarefied gas dynamics, for example, a widely used strategy to solve the Boltzmann equation is the so-called Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) method, introduced in the 1960s [19, 20, 21]. This method considers a random sample of particles drawn from the phase-space distribution function and simulates their time evolution by alternating free-streaming and stochastic scattering processes. It has been applied in a wide range of areas, ranging from space engineering [22] to heavy ion collisions [23, 24].

DSMC methods turn out to be particularly advantageous for dilute systems far away from thermal equilibrium, which contain particles with a wide range of different momenta, because they do not require a parametrised functional form for the phase-space distribution and naturally accommodate even broad ranges of momenta. Moreover, DSMC methods avoid explicit evaluation of the full collision integral and therefore perform well in models with complicated collision processes involving more than two particles in the initial and/or final state. Finally, DSMC methods provide control over statistical uncertainties, which can be assessed by repeating simulations and reduced proportional to 1/N1/\sqrt{N} by increasing the number NN of simulation particles. Indeed, several recent studies have shown that DSMC methods can be very useful for cosmology to study neutrino decoupling and derive constraints on physics beyond the Standard Model from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis [25, 26, 27]. These studies find that DSMC methods often outperform alternative approaches based on discretised momentum space or parametrised distribution functions.

In the present work we investigate possible applications of DSMC in the context of the production of DM particles and their subsequent phase-space evolution. These considerations are particularly important in models where interactions between DM particles and Standard Model (SM) states are very feeble, as for freeze-in production. Since such DM particles are extremely difficult to detect in laboratory experiment, astrophysical and cosmological probes of the matter power spectrum – using for example the Lyman-alpha forest, the abundance and dynamics of dwarf galaxies or gravitational lensing of galaxies and clusters – provide the most promising strategy to study the properties of DM (see ref. [28] for a recent review). At the same time it becomes very challenging to accurately predict these observables, because thermal equilibrium cannot be assumed at any point in cosmological history and phase-space distributions can differ substantially from the equilibrium form [29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37].

To illustrate different applications of DSMC, we consider a toy model in which DM particles are produced through the decays of a heavy scalar particle that freezes out of thermal equilibrium. We use DSMC to describe the freeze-out beyond kinetic equilibrium, the decays of the decoupled scalars as well as the subsequent interactions between DM particles. We consider both elastic 2↔22 \leftrightarrow2 scattering, which can redistribute energy between relativistic and non-relativistic particles and thereby change the evolution of the energy density in an expanding universe, as well as 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 number-changing processes, which convert kinetic energy into rest mass and thereby change both the abundance of DM particles and their average momentum [38, 39, 40]. Wherever possible, we validate our solutions against alternative ways to solve the Boltzmann equation analytically or numerically. In some cases, however, we obtain new results that cannot be easily obtained using other methods.

We show that the Monte Carlo error decreases as expected when increasing the number of simulation particles and that already a particle number of order 10510^5 is sufficient to predict the relevant observables at the level of precision required by observations. While the present work considers constant matrix elements for simplicity, the algorithms that we consider can be easily adapted to include more complicated cases. In fact, our set-up is well suited for models that require Monte Carlo integration and importance sampling from the final-state phase space. The present study therefore constitutes a first step towards the precision analysis of realistic DM models beyond thermal equilibrium.

The remainder of this work is structured as follows. In § 2 we introduce the Boltzmann equation and the most common strategies for solving it. We furthermore define the toy model considered in the following. § 3 discusses in detail the DSMC approach, the implemented algorithm and various validation tests. Our main results are presented in § 4 followed by our conclusions in § 5.

General set-up

Phase-space evolution

The evolution of the phase-space distribution fx(p,t)f_x(p,t) of a particle species xx with internal degrees of freedom gxg_x in a homogeneous and isotropic universe is governed by the Boltzmann equation

∂fx(p,t)∂t−Hp∂fx(p,t)∂p=C^[fx]E(1)\frac{\partial f_x(p,t)}{\partial t}-Hp\frac{\partial f_x(p,t)}{\partial p}=\frac{\widehat{C}[f_x]}{E} \tag*{(1)}

where HH denotes the Hubble rate,1 pp and EE are momentum and energy of the particle xx and C^[fx]\widehat{C}[f_x] denotes the collision operator, which incorporates all interactions the particle xx takes part in. Since the collision operator depends on fxf_x as well as on the phase-space distributions of all other involved particles, one obtains a system of coupled partial differential equations that is generally hard to solve.

Moments approach. A widely used approach to simplifying the Boltzmann equation is to consider only its lower moments. To take the zeroth moment, one performs the integration gx∫d3p/(2π)3g_x \int\mathrm{d}^3p/(2\pi)^3, which results in a differential equation for the number density nx=gx∫d3p/(2π)3fxn_x = g_x \int\mathrm{d}^3p/(2\pi)^3 f_x:

n˙x+3Hnx=gx∫d3p(2π)3C^[fx]E.(2)\dot{n}_x + 3Hn_x = g_x \int\frac{\mathrm{d}^3p}{(2\pi)^3} \frac{\hat{C}[f_x]}{E}. \tag*{(2)}

In order to solve this differential equation, one needs to close the Boltzmann hierarchy by making assumptions regarding the phase-space distributions of the involved particles. In case of kinetic equilibrium of species xx with the Standard Model thermal bath, a reasonable assumption is that fx∝exp⁡(−E/T)f_x \propto\exp(-E/T) where TT is the thermal bath temperature.2 This assumption is enough in order to solve eq. (2). We refer to this approach as the number density Boltzmann equation (nBE).

If the interactions of xx with the thermal bath are not strong enough to maintain kinetic equilibrium with it, one needs to weaken the assumption on fxf_x. In case of kinetic equilibrium of xx with itself, the species xx can be characterised by a separate temperature TxT_x, so that fx∝exp⁡(−E/Tx)f_x \propto\exp(-E/T_x). The temperature is given by

Tx=⟨p23E⟩x=gxnx∫d3p(2π)3p23Efx,(3)T_x = \left\langle\frac{p^2}{3E} \right\rangle_x = \frac{g_x}{n_x} \int\frac{\mathrm{d}^3p}{(2\pi)^3} \frac{p^2}{3E} f_x, \tag*{(3)}

where the brackets ⟨⟩x\langle\rangle_x denote the expectation value with respect to the normalised momentum distribution fx(p)/nxf_x(p)/n_x. An equation for the evolution of TxT_x can then be obtained by performing the corresponding integration over eq. (1), which results in

3n˙xTx+3nxT˙x+15HnxTx−gxH∫d3p(2π)3p4E3fx=gx∫d3p(2π)3p2EC^[fx]E.(4)3\dot{n}_xT_x + 3n_x\dot{T}_x + 15Hn_xT_x - g_xH \int\frac{\mathrm{d}^3p}{(2\pi)^3} \frac{p^4}{E^3} f_x = g_x \int\frac{\mathrm{d}^3p}{(2\pi)^3} \frac{p^2}{E} \frac{\hat{C}[f_x]}{E}. \tag*{(4)}

Eqs. (2) and (4) form a system of coupled differential equations, which we refer to as the coupled Boltzmann equations (cBE).

Full Boltzmann equation. As soon as the shape of the phase-space distribution differs from the kinetic equilibrium form, the cBE approach is no longer sufficient and one needs to solve the full Boltzmann equation (fBE) in eq. (1) at the phase-space level. Prominent examples in which a non-trivial phase-space distribution can arise include for example very momentum-selective interactions (e.g. resonances), which deplete or populate only parts of the phase space [7, 41] or scenarios where the production of the species xx happens in consecutive steps populating different phase-space regions at different times [17, 42, 43, 44, 45]. In the following, we will consider the latter scenario and introduce a novel approach for solving the fBE.

Toy model

In our set-up, we consider three different particle species: ψ\psi, ϕ\phi and ρ\rho. For simplicity, we assume that these particles are real scalars and that all their interactions conserve CP symmetry. The particle ψ\psi is assumed to be fully thermalised with the SM thermal bath of temperature TT at all relevant times and sufficiently light that its mass is irrelevant for our calculations. It can be thought of as a simplified representation of any of the light SM fermions. The main simplification achieved by assuming ψ\psi to be a real scalar is that we can take the matrix element for the process ψψ→ϕϕ\psi\psi\to\phi\phi as a constant independent of momentum and scattering angle, which speeds up the Monte Carlo simulations introduced below.

The second particle, ϕ\phi, on the other hand, has a mass mϕm_{\phi} that is non-negligible compared to the temperature. It interacts with ψ\psi exclusively through the annihilation process ψψ↔ϕϕ\psi\psi\leftrightarrow\phi\phi, which we assume to be initially strong enough so that ϕ\phi is in thermal equilibrium with ψ\psi and then undergoes Boltzmann suppression and thermal freeze-out. We neglect all other interactions between ψ\psi and ϕ\phi, such as scattering processes ψϕ↔ψϕ\psi\phi\leftrightarrow\psi\phi or (inverse) decays ϕ↔ψψ\phi\leftrightarrow\psi\psi.

A coupling between ϕ\phi and ρ\rho allows for the decay ϕ→ρρ\phi\to\rho\rho. Here we assume that mρ≪mϕm_{\rho} \ll m_{\phi} and that the decays are slow enough that the ρ\rho particles never thermalise with the ψ\psi particles. The decays of ϕ\phi then happen in two stages: The first stage (in-equilibrium decays) occurs while the ϕ\phi particles are still abundant and in thermal equilibrium with the bath, but the decay width is small compared to the Hubble rate. The second stage occurs after the ϕ\phi particles have frozen out, once the Hubble rate has decreased enough to become comparable with the decay width. We show a schematic sketch of the abundance evolution in Figure 1. This scenario has been intensely studied for example in [18] and is known to produce bimodal phase-space distributions for the ρ\rho particles. This is because in-equilibrium decays produce ρ\rho particles with momentum comparable to the thermal bath, while the out-of-equilibrium decays produce particles with momentum p≈mϕ/2≫Tp \approx m_{\phi}/2 \gg T as illustrated in the left panel of Figure 2.

Figure 1. Evolution of the yield including only ψψ↔ϕϕ\psi\psi\leftrightarrow\phi\phi (left), ϕ→ρρ\phi\to\rho\rho (middle) and ρρ↔ρρρ\rho\rho\leftrightarrow\rho\rho\rho (right).

Figure 2. Phase-space distribution of ρ\rho particles after all interactions cease without (left) and with (right) ρ\rho self-interactions.

While the initial phase-space distribution of ρ\rho particles arising from ϕ\phi decays has been studied in great detail in the literature, the focus of our study is on the subsequent evolution of this distribution under self-interactions of ρ\rho particles. We consider not only elastic 2ρ↔2ρ2\rho\leftrightarrow2\rho collisions, but include also number-changing interactions of the form 2ρ↔3ρ2\rho\leftrightarrow3\rho. As we will see below, the latter type of process can lead to large effects because it can convert the large kinetic energy of ρ\rho particles produced in out-of-equilibrium decays into additional particles with less kinetic energy, as shown in the right panel of Figure 2.

Dark Matter Direct Simulation Monte Carlo

The standard approach for solving the unintegrated Boltzmann equation in DM phenomenology goes via discretizing the phase space. This approach has been shown to work reliably, but it has some disadvantages. For example, knowledge of the relevant phase-space areas is needed beforehand to decide on the discretised momentum bins. Furthermore, a large separation of relevant momentum scales necessitates a large momentum lattice which becomes computationally unfeasible. Instead of discretizing the phase space, we present a novel approach based on performing a Monte-Carlo simulation of the involved particles and interactions. We will use the DSMC method and extend it to 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 collisions.

Overview of DSMC

DSMC solves the full Boltzmann equation by simulating NN particles and their interactions in a volume VV. Since we consider a homogeneous and isotropic universe, we only need to know the energies of the particles in the simulation volume. During each time step Δt\Delta t, a collision step is performed, followed by a transport step, see Figure 3. During the collision step, particles are randomly selected and assigned with random isotropic momentum directions, and collisions between selected particles are sampled as described below in more detail. During the transport step, the momenta of the particles and the temperature of the thermal bath are redshifted and the simulation volume is expanded. The size of the time step Δt\Delta t is chosen such that Δt≪Γ−1\Delta t \ll\Gamma^{-1}, where Γ\Gamma denotes all relevant rates, ranging from the Hubble rate to collision and decay rates.

Figure 3. Flowchart of the DSMC scheme for n→mn \to m scattering. For simplicity, we illustrate here the case of just one type of interaction per timestep. The implementation with multiple interactions is described below.

The collision step is performed using the so-called No-time-counter (NTC) algorithm [21, 46, 47]. While the literature describes the NTC algorithm only for 2→22 \to2 collisions, we extend it here to n→mn \to m collisions. Consider nn particles i1,…,ini_1,\ldots,i_n randomly selected from the simulation volume. Their probability to perform an n→mn \to m collision is denoted as Pi1,…,inP_{i_1,\ldots,i_n}. The brute-force way of performing the collision step would be to go through all (Nn)\binom{N}{n} nn-plets,3 generate a random number ui1,…,in∈Uniform⁡(0,1)u_{i_1,\ldots,i_n} \in\operatorname{Uniform}(0,1) for each nn-plet and accept the collision if ui1,…,in<Pi1,…,inu_{i_1,\ldots,i_n} < P_{i_1,\ldots,i_n}. In general, however, the collision probability may be very small, making this approach highly inefficient. Instead, in the NTC approach, at the beginning of each time step, the maximal possible interaction probability Pnmax⁡P_n^{\max} among all nn-plets is determined. Then, Nn-plets=(Nn)⋅Pnmax⁡N_{n\text{-plets}} = \binom{N}{n} \cdot P_n^{\max} nn-plets are selected. In practice, since Nn-pletsN_{n\text{-plets}} is not an integer number, we choose the number of nn-plets from a Poisson distribution with mean Nn-pletsN_{n\text{-plets}}. For each nn-plet a collision is accepted if the random number satisfies

ui1,…,in<Pi1,…,inPnmax⁡.(5)u_{i_1,\ldots,i_n} < \frac{P_{i_1,\ldots,i_n}}{P_n^{\max}} . \tag*{(5)}

The interaction probability can be determined using the stochastic collision criterion [23, 48, 49, 50], which we review following the discussion in ref. [23]. We first only consider 2→22 \to2 scattering, the generalisation to n→mn \to m scattering follows along similar lines. The collision operator for 2→22 \to2 scattering is given by

C^[f1]E1=12E1∫dπ2 κ∫dπ1′dπ2′ f1′f2′∣M1′2′→12∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1′+p2′−p1−p2)−12E1∫dπ2 κ∫dπ1′dπ2′ f1f2∣M12→1′2′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′),(6)\frac{\hat{C}[f_1]}{E_1} = \frac{1}{2E_1}\int\mathrm{d}\pi_2\,\kappa\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\,f'_1f'_2\left|\mathcal{M}_{1'2'\to12}\right|^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p'_1+p'_2-p_1-p_2) -\frac{1}{2E_1}\int\mathrm{d}\pi_2\,\kappa\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\,f_1f_2\left|\mathcal{M}_{12\to1'2'}\right|^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2-p'_1-p'_2), \tag*{(6)}

where κ\kappa is a symmetry factor accounting for identical particles in the final state (κ=1/2\kappa= 1/2 for identical final state particles) and dπi=d3pi(2π)32Ei\mathrm{d}\pi_i = \frac{\mathrm{d}^3p_i}{(2\pi)^3 2E_i} is the Lorentz-invariant differential phase-space. The collision probability for 12→1′2′12 \to1'2' when selecting two particles from an ensemble of particles in a volume VV can be easily obtained by reinterpreting the Boltzmann equation in eq. (1) for vanishing Hubble expansion: The remaining parts of the Boltzmann equation describe how the phase-space distribution of particle 1 changes solely due to scattering. The phase-space distribution is related to the number of particles NiN_i in a given unit phase-space box Δx3Δp3\Delta x^3 \Delta p^3 around phase-space coordinate (x,p)(x,p) through

fi(x,p)=Ni1(2π)3Δx3Δp3(7)f_i(x,p) = \frac{N_i}{\frac{1}{(2\pi)^3}\Delta x^3\Delta p^3} \tag*{(7)}

assuming no internal degrees of freedom. The change in the number of particles 1 corresponds to the number of collisions: ΔN1=Ncoll\Delta N_1 = N_{\mathrm{coll}}. The number of collisions of N1N_1 particles of type 1 in momentum range (p1,p1+Δp1)(\mathbf{p}_1,\mathbf{p}_1+\Delta\mathbf{p}_1) and N2N_2 particles of type 2 in the momentum range (p2,p2+Δp2)(\mathbf{p}_2,\mathbf{p}_2+\Delta\mathbf{p}_2) in a volume Δ3x\Delta^3x and time interval Δt\Delta t is given by

∂f(p1,t)∂t→NcollΔt1(2π)3Δx3Δp13=12E1Δp23(2π)32E2κf1f2∫dπ1′dπ2′∣M12→1′2′∣2×(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′).(8)\frac{\partial f(p_1,t)}{\partial t} \to\frac{N_{\mathrm{coll}}}{\Delta t\frac{1}{(2\pi)^3}\Delta x^3\Delta p_1^3} = \frac{1}{2E_1}\frac{\Delta p_2^3}{(2\pi)^3 2E_2}\kappa f_1f_2\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\left|\mathcal{M}_{12\to1'2'}\right|^2 \times(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2-p'_1-p'_2). \tag*{(8)}

The collision probability for a randomly drawn pair of particles in the momentum ranges (p1,p1+Δp1)(\mathbf{p}_1,\mathbf{p}_1+\Delta\mathbf{p}_1) and (p2,p2+Δp2)(\mathbf{p}_2,\mathbf{p}_2+\Delta\mathbf{p}_2) is therefore given by

P2→2=NcollN1N2=12E112E2ΔtΔx3κ∫dπ1′dπ2′∣M12→1′2′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′)=σ2→2vΔtΔx3,(9)\begin{aligned} P_{2\to2} = \frac{N_{\mathrm{coll}}}{N_1N_2} \\ &= \frac{1}{2E_1}\frac{1}{2E_2}\frac{\Delta t}{\Delta x^3}\kappa\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\left|\mathcal{M}_{12\to1'2'}\right|^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2-p'_1-p'_2) \\ &= \sigma_{2\to2}v\frac{\Delta t}{\Delta x^3}, \tag*{(9)} \end{aligned}

where we used the definition of the cross section

σ2→2v=12E112E2κ∫dπ1′dπ2′∣M12→1′2′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′)(10)\sigma_{2\to2}v = \frac{1}{2E_1}\frac{1}{2E_2}\kappa\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\left|\mathcal{M}_{12\to1'2'}\right|^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2-p'_1-p'_2) \tag*{(10)}

with the relative velocity vv of the two incoming particles in the cosmic frame. The expression for P2→2P_{2\to2} corresponds to the standard geometric interpretation of the cross section, where σ2→2vΔt\sigma_{2\to2}v\Delta t is the ”collision area” swept by the two incoming particles during a time step Δt\Delta t. The advantage of this derivation of the collision probability is that it can easily be generalised to n→mn \to m scattering by using the corresponding collision integrals. In the present work we restrict ourselves to 2↔22 \leftrightarrow2 and 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 scatterings. The collision probabilities for 2ρ→3ρ2\rho\to3\rho and 3ρ→2ρ3\rho\to2\rho scatterings are derived in appendix A and are given by

P2→3=σ2→3vΔtΔx3(11)P_{2\to3} = \sigma_{2\to3}v \frac{\Delta t}{\Delta x^3} \tag*{(11)}

with

σ2→3v=12E112E213!∫dπ1′dπ2′dπ3′∣M12→1′2′3′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′−p3′)(12)\sigma_{2\to3}v = \frac{1}{2E_1}\frac{1}{2E_2}\frac{1}{3!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\mathrm{d}\pi'_3 \left\lvert\mathcal{M}_{12\to1'2'3'}\right\rvert^2 (2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}\left(p_1+p_2-p'_1-p'_2-p'_3\right) \tag*{(12)}

and

P3→2=18E1E2E3Δt(Δx3)2I32(13)P_{3\to2} = \frac{1}{8E_1E_2E_3}\frac{\Delta t}{(\Delta x^3)^2}I_{32} \tag*{(13)}

where we defined the Lorentz-invariant integral expression

I32=12!∫dπ1′dπ2′∣M123→1′2′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2+p3−p1′−p2′).(14)I_{32} = \frac{1}{2!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2 \left\lvert\mathcal{M}_{123\to1'2'}\right\rvert^2 (2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}\left(p_1+p_2+p_3-p'_1-p'_2\right). \tag*{(14)}

Implemented algorithm

Determining the maximum possible interaction probability for the particles in the simulation volume is a crucial step in the NTC scheme. The stricter the upper bound, the higher the acceptance rate of collisions, which heavily influences the runtime. To optimise the runtime, methods adapted to the specific particles and interactions are needed. For the model we consider as an example, we will describe these methods in the following.

ψψ→ϕϕ\psi\psi\to\phi\phi production: Since we assume that ψ\psi is in thermal equilibrium with the SM bath, we can sample collision pairs from the thermal probability density function

geq(p)=p22T3exp⁡(−p/T)(15)g_{\mathrm{eq}}(p) = \frac{p^2}{2T^3}\exp(-p/T) \tag*{(15)}

for temperature TT and negligible mass mψm_\psi. To be consistent with the implemented collision scheme where we do not include Bose enhancement or Pauli blocking, we neglect here quantum statistics factors in the momentum distribution. Due to the assumed hierarchy mϕ≫mψm_\phi\gg m_\psi, only high-energy ψ\psi particles can annihilate into ϕ\phi particles simply due to kinematics. Sampling random pairs from the ψ\psi bath and testing them for collisions according to the NTC algorithm thus results in a huge overhead of rejected collisions.

Instead of sampling pairs directly from the thermal distribution, one can introduce sequential sampling, which takes into account the energy threshold for successful annihilation: An annihilation is only possible if the maximal possible center-of-mass (CM) energy of the selected pair smax⁡=4p1p2s_{\max}=4p_1p_2 is larger than 4mϕ24m_\phi^2. Sampling the momenta of the two incoming ψ\psi particles, p1p_1 and p2p_2, independently of the thermal distribution and accepting a pair only if p1p2>mϕ2p_1p_2>m_\phi^2 corresponds to sampling from the joint distribution g(p1,p2)=geq(p1)geq(p2)θ(p1p2−mϕ2)/Ng(p_1,p_2)=g_{\mathrm{eq}}(p_1)g_{\mathrm{eq}}(p_2)\theta(p_1p_2-m_\phi^2)/\mathcal{N}, where N\mathcal{N} is given by the fraction of pairs that satisfy the threshold condition

N=∫dp1dp2 geq(p1)geq(p2)θ(p1p2−mϕ2)=12(mϕT)3(2+mϕ2T2)K3(2mϕT).(16)\mathcal{N}=\int\mathrm{d}p_1\mathrm{d}p_2\,g_{\mathrm{eq}}(p_1)g_{\mathrm{eq}}(p_2)\theta(p_1p_2-m_\phi^2)=\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{m_\phi}{T}\right)^3\left(2+\frac{m_\phi^2}{T^2}\right)K_3\left(\frac{2m_\phi}{T}\right). \tag*{(16)}

where KiK_i denotes the modified Bessel function of the second kind of order ii. This is equivalent to sampling p1p_1 from the marginal distribution

g(p1)=∫dp2 g(p1,p2)=1Ngeq(p1)∫mϕ2/p1∞dp2 geq(p2)g(p_1)=\int\mathrm{d}p_2\,g(p_1,p_2)=\frac{1}{\mathcal{N}}g_{\mathrm{eq}}(p_1)\int_{m_\phi^2/p_1}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}p_2\,g_{\mathrm{eq}}(p_2)
∝(mϕ4+2mϕ2Tp1+2T2p12)exp⁡(−mϕ2Tp1−p1T)(17)\propto(m_\phi^4+2m_\phi^2Tp_1+2T^2p_1^2)\exp\left(-\frac{m_\phi^2}{Tp_1}-\frac{p_1}{T}\right) \tag*{(17)}

and then sampling p2p_2 from the conditional distribution

g(p2∣p1)=g(p1,p2)g(p1)=geq(p2)θ(p1p2−mϕ2)∫mϕ2/p1∞dp2 geq(p2)g(p_2|p_1)=\frac{g(p_1,p_2)}{g(p_1)}=\frac{g_{\mathrm{eq}}(p_2)\theta(p_1p_2-m_\phi^2)}{\int_{m_\phi^2/p_1}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}p_2\,g_{\mathrm{eq}}(p_2)}
∝p22exp⁡(−p2T)θ(p1p2−mϕ2).(18)\propto p_2^2\exp\left(-\frac{p_2}{T}\right)\theta(p_1p_2-m_\phi^2). \tag*{(18)}

The sampling from the marginal and conditional distributions is realised using inverse transform sampling with pre-tabulated inverse cumulative distribution functions. With this sampling procedure, the number of tested ψ\psi pairs has to be reduced by a factor N\mathcal{N} to account for the increased acceptance rate. Instead of testing N2-plets=(N2)Pψψ→ϕϕmax⁡N_{2\text{-plets}}=\binom{N}{2}P^{\max}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi} random pairs, we thus consider N2-plets=N(N2)Pψψ→ϕϕmax⁡N_{2\text{-plets}}=\mathcal{N}\binom{N}{2}P^{\max}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi} pre-selected pairs.

Finally, to obtain Pψψ→ϕϕmax⁡P^{\max}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi}, we need an upper bound on the interaction cross section for ψψ→ϕϕ\psi\psi\to\phi\phi, which is given by

(σv)ψψ→ϕϕ=14E1E212!∫dπ1′dπ2′ ∣Mψψ→ϕϕ∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′)=∣Mψψ→ϕϕ∣264πE1E21−4mϕ2s≤∣Mψψ→ϕϕ∣264πE1E21−mϕ2E1E2≤∣Mψψ→ϕϕ∣2963πmϕ2(19)\begin{aligned} (\sigma v)_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi}=\frac{1}{4E_1E_2}\frac{1}{2!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\,|\mathcal{M}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi}|^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2-p'_1-p'_2) \\ &=\frac{|\mathcal{M}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi}|^2}{64\pi E_1E_2}\sqrt{1-\frac{4m_\phi^2}{s}}\leq\frac{|\mathcal{M}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi}|^2}{64\pi E_1E_2}\sqrt{1-\frac{m_\phi^2}{E_1E_2}}\leq\frac{|\mathcal{M}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi}|^2}{96\sqrt{3}\pi m_\phi^2} \tag*{(19)} \end{aligned}

where ss is the CM energy of the ψ\psi particles. In the first inequality we have used that s≤4E1E2s\leq4E_1E_2 and in the second inequality that x1−x≤2/(33)x\sqrt{1-x}\leq2/(3\sqrt{3}). In our toy model, the matrix element is taken to be constant.

ϕϕ→ψψ\phi\phi\to\psi\psi annihilation: In this case there is no kinematic threshold and the annihilation process is allowed for all pairs of ϕ\phi particles. The cross-section is given by

(σv)ϕϕ→ψψ=∣Mψψ→ϕϕ∣264πE1E2.(20)(\sigma v)_{\phi\phi\to\psi\psi}=\frac{|\mathcal{M}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi}|^2}{64\pi E_1E_2}. \tag*{(20)}

An upper bound on the cross section for the particles in the simulation is given by

(σv)ϕϕ→ψψmax⁡=∣Mψψ→ϕϕ∣264πE1min⁡E2min⁡(21)(\sigma v)^{\max}_{\phi\phi\to\psi\psi}=\frac{|\mathcal{M}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi}|^2}{64\pi E_1^{\min}E_2^{\min}} \tag*{(21)}

where E1min⁡E_1^{\min} and E2min⁡E_2^{\min} are the lowest and second-lowest energies of the ϕ\phi particles in the cell.

ϕ→ρρ\phi\to\rho\rho decays: For a rest-frame decay rate Γdec\Gamma_{\mathrm{dec}}, the decay probability of a particle with energy EϕE_{\phi} in a time interval Δt≪Γdec−1\Delta t \ll\Gamma_{\mathrm{dec}}^{-1} is given by

Pdec=mϕEϕΓdecΔt.(22)P_{\mathrm{dec}} = \frac{m_{\phi}}{E_{\phi}}\Gamma_{\mathrm{dec}}\Delta t . \tag*{(22)}

In principle, these decays could be implemented along similar lines as in the NTC scheme described above, by testing only a fraction of all particles for decays. However, since decays only involve one particle in the initial state, the computational cost only grows as O(N)O(N) with the number of particles in the cell. Hence, it is fast enough to iterate over all ϕ\phi particles in the cell, compute PdecP_{\mathrm{dec}}, generate a random number uu and accept a decay if u<Pdecu < P_{\mathrm{dec}}. We do this at the beginning of each time step. If a decay happens, the energies of the decay products are given by Eρ∗=mϕ2E_{\rho}^{*} = \frac{m_{\phi}}{2} in the rest frame of the decaying particle and are then boosted into the cosmic frame. We can assume without loss of generality that this boost happens along the zz-axis, such that the resulting energy of the first ρ\rho-particle is given by Eρ,1=EϕmϕEρ∗−pϕmϕpρ∗cos⁡θ∗E_{\rho,1} = \frac{E_{\phi}}{m_{\phi}}E_{\rho}^{*} - \frac{p_{\phi}}{m_{\phi}}p_{\rho}^{*}\cos\theta^{*} where pρ∗=(Eρ∗)2−mρ2p_{\rho}^{*} = \sqrt{(E_{\rho}^{*})^{2} - m_{\rho}^{2}} and cos⁡θ∗\cos\theta^{*} is uniformly distributed in [−1,1][-1,1] for an isotropic decay. The energy of the first decay product is therefore uniformly distributed between Emin⁡=EϕmϕEρ∗−pϕmϕpρ∗E_{\min} = \frac{E_{\phi}}{m_{\phi}}E_{\rho}^{*} - \frac{p_{\phi}}{m_{\phi}}p_{\rho}^{*} and Emax⁡=EϕmϕEρ∗+pϕmϕpρ∗E_{\max} = \frac{E_{\phi}}{m_{\phi}}E_{\rho}^{*} + \frac{p_{\phi}}{m_{\phi}}p_{\rho}^{*}, while the energy of the second decay product is simply given by Eρ,2=Eϕ−Eρ,1E_{\rho,2} = E_{\phi} - E_{\rho,1}.

2ρ→2ρ2\rho\to2\rho elastic scattering: The 2→22 \to2 scattering cross section is given by

(σv)2ρ→2ρ=14E1E212!∫dπ1′dπ2′∣M2ρ→2ρ∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′)=∣M2ρ→2ρ∣24E1E2116π1−4mρ2s=14E1E2U22(s),(23)\begin{aligned} (\sigma v)_{2\rho\to2\rho} &= \frac{1}{4E_{1}E_{2}}\frac{1}{2!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi_{1}^{\prime}\mathrm{d}\pi_{2}^{\prime}\lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\to2\rho}\rvert^{2}(2\pi)^{4}\delta^{(4)}(p_{1}+p_{2}-p_{1}^{\prime}-p_{2}^{\prime}) \\ &= \frac{\lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\to2\rho}\rvert^{2}}{4E_{1}E_{2}}\frac{1}{16\pi}\sqrt{1-\frac{4m_{\rho}^{2}}{s}} = \frac{1}{4E_{1}E_{2}}U_{22}(\sqrt{s}) , \tag*{(23)} \end{aligned}

where we defined

U22(s)=∣M2ρ→2ρ∣216π1−4mρ2s≤∣M2ρ→2ρ∣216π1−4mρ2smax⁡=U22max⁡(24)U_{22}(\sqrt{s}) = \frac{\lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\to2\rho}\rvert^{2}}{16\pi}\sqrt{1-\frac{4m_{\rho}^{2}}{s}} \leq\frac{\lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\to2\rho}\rvert^{2}}{16\pi}\sqrt{1-\frac{4m_{\rho}^{2}}{s_{\max}}} = U_{22}^{\max} \tag*{(24)}

with smax⁡=4Emax⁡2s_{\max} = 4E_{\max}^{2} being the maximal possible CM energy in the simulation volume. The flux factor 1/(E1E2)1/(E_{1}E_{2}) suppresses scattering of highly-relativistic particles whereas the phase-space factor (1−4mρ2/s)1/2(1-4m_{\rho}^{2}/s)^{1/2} suppresses scattering of non-relativistic particles. Hence, scattering preferentially happens for low-energetic but still relativistic particles. Due to the energy dependence of the upper bound on the cross section, selecting the collision pairs uniformly from the simulation particles creates a large overhead of rejected high-energy pairs. To increase the acceptance rate of collisions, one can preferably select low-energy particles: Instead of the standard NTC algorithm, which requires

Npairs=(N2)P2→2max⁡=12∑k≠k′P2→2max⁡(25)N_{\mathrm{pairs}} = \binom{N}{2}P_{2\to2}^{\max} = \frac{1}{2}\sum_{k\ne k^{\prime}}P_{2\to2}^{\max} \tag*{(25)}

randomly selected pairs, we follow ref. [26] and select

Npairs=12∑k≠k′Pk,k′maj=18ΔtΔx3U22max⁡[S12−S2](26)N_{\mathrm{pairs}} = \frac{1}{2}\sum_{k\ne k^{\prime}}P_{k,k^{\prime}}^{\mathrm{maj}} = \frac{1}{8}\frac{\Delta t}{\Delta x^{3}}U_{22}^{\max}\left[S_{1}^{2}-S_{2}\right] \tag*{(26)}

pairs with

Pk,k′maj=14EkEk′ΔtΔx3U22max⁡(27)P^{\mathrm{maj}}_{k,k'}=\frac{1}{4E_kE_{k'}}\frac{\Delta t}{\Delta x^3}U_{22}^{\max} \tag*{(27)}

being the energy-dependent majorant on the interaction probability and Sn=∑k(Ek)−nS_n=\sum_k(E_k)^{-n}. Instead of selecting particles randomly with equal weight, these pairs are constructed by selecting the first particle with probability P=(1/E1)/S1P=(1/E_1)/S_1 and the second with probability P=(1/E2)/(S1−1/E1)P=(1/E_2)/(S_1-1/E_1). For each pair, a collision is then accepted with probability P=U22/U22max⁡P=U_{22}/U_{22}^{\max}. For scattering with constant matrix element, this procedure leads to a very high acceptance rate, but it can also be adopted for scattering processes with more general energy dependence.

2ρ→3ρ2\rho\rightarrow3\rho number-changing process: The cross section is given by

(σv)2ρ→3ρ=14E1E213!∫dπ1′dπ2′dπ3′ ∣M2ρ→3ρ∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′−p3′)=∣M2ρ→3ρ∣24E1E213!Φ3(s)≤∣M2ρ→3ρ∣24E1E213!Φ3(2mρ2+2(E1E2+p1p2))(28)\begin{aligned} (\sigma v)_{2\rho\rightarrow3\rho}=\frac{1}{4E_1E_2}\frac{1}{3!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\mathrm{d}\pi'_3\,\lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\rightarrow3\rho}\rvert^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2-p'_1-p'_2-p'_3) \\ &=\frac{\lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\rightarrow3\rho}\rvert^2}{4E_1E_2}\frac{1}{3!}\Phi_3(\sqrt{s})\leq\frac{\lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\rightarrow3\rho}\rvert^2}{4E_1E_2}\frac{1}{3!}\Phi_3\left(\sqrt{2m_\rho^2+2(E_1E_2+p_1p_2)}\right) \tag*{(28)} \end{aligned}

with the 3-particle phase space Φ3(s)\Phi_3(\sqrt{s}). For the inequality, we use the monotonicity of Φ3(s)\Phi_3(\sqrt{s}) to substitute the largest possible CM energy for given energies E1E_1 and E2E_2 of the ρ\rho particles in the cosmic frame. In the relativistic limit, the 3-particle phase space is given by Φ3(s)=s/(256π3)≤4E1E2/(256π3)\Phi_3(s)=s/(256\pi^3)\leq4E_1E_2/(256\pi^3), so that

(σv)2ρ→3ρmax⁡=13!∣M2ρ→3ρ∣2256π3(29)(\sigma v)_{2\rho\rightarrow3\rho}^{\max}=\frac{1}{3!}\frac{\lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\rightarrow3\rho}\rvert^2}{256\pi^3} \tag*{(29)}

We emphasise that our assumption of a constant matrix element implicitly corresponds to an effective interaction of the form 1Λ5ρ5\frac{1}{\Lambda^5}\rho^5 where Λ\Lambda has dimension of energy. The squared matrix element is then proportional to Λ−2\Lambda^{-2}, which has the unit of a cross section, such that no additional factors of energy are needed. Compared to the case of 2→22\rightarrow2 scattering (where the squared matrix element is dimensionless), this leads to an enhancement of the scattering probability for highly-energetic particles, as expected for a non-renormalisable interaction.

3ρ→2ρ3\rho\rightarrow2\rho number-changing scattering: The scattering probability given in eq. (13) depends on the factor I32/(E1E2E3)I_{32}/(E_1E_2E_3). For a constant matrix element, I32I_{32} reduces to

I32=∣M3ρ→2ρ∣216π1−4mρ2s(30)I_{32}=\frac{\lvert\mathcal{M}_{3\rho\rightarrow2\rho}\rvert^2}{16\pi}\sqrt{1-\frac{4m_\rho^2}{s}} \tag*{(30)}

The CM energy satisfies 9mρ2≤s<∞9m_\rho^2\leq s<\infty, such that 1−4mρ2/s∈(0.74,1)\sqrt{1-4m_\rho^2/s}\in(0.74,1) and the values of I32I_{32} have almost no dependence on the scattering kinematics. Most importantly, we have

I32≤∣M3ρ→2ρ∣216π=I32max⁡.(31)I_{32}\leq\frac{\lvert\mathcal{M}_{3\rho\rightarrow2\rho}\rvert^2}{16\pi}=I_{32}^{\max}. \tag*{(31)}

The interaction probability is therefore mostly determined by the energy-dependent factor 1/(E1E2E3)1/(E_1 E_2 E_3), leading to enhanced scattering probability for low-energy particles. We adopt a similar approach as for the case of 2→22 \to2 scattering and select

N3-plets=16∑k≠k′≠k′′Pk,k′,k′′maj=148Δt(Δx3)2I32max⁡[S13−3S1S2+2S3](32)N_{3\text{-plets}} = \frac{1}{6} \sum_{k \ne k' \ne k''} P^{\mathrm{maj}}_{k,k',k''} = \frac{1}{48} \frac{\Delta t}{(\Delta x^3)^2} I_{32}^{\max} \left[S_1^3 - 3S_1S_2 + 2S_3\right] \tag*{(32)}

pairs with Pk,k′,k′′maj=18EkEk′Ek′′Δt(Δx3)2I32max⁡P^{\mathrm{maj}}_{k,k',k''} = \frac{1}{8E_k E_{k'} E_{k''}} \frac{\Delta t}{(\Delta x^3)^2} I_{32}^{\max} and SnS_n as defined above. We select the first particle of the triplet with probability P=(1/E1)/S1P = (1/E_1)/S_1, the second with probability P=(1/E2)/(S1−1/E1)P = (1/E_2)/(S_1 - 1/E_1) and the third with probability P=(1/E3)/(S1−1/E1−1/E2)P = (1/E_3)/(S_1 - 1/E_1 - 1/E_2). A triplet collision is then accepted with probability P=I32/I32max⁡P = I_{32}/I_{32}^{\max}.

Sampling of final states: In case a collision is accepted, a random final state must be sampled. The differential collision probability for n→mn \to m scattering is dPn→m∝dΦm∣Mn→m∣\mathrm{d}P_{n \to m} \propto\mathrm{d}\Phi_m |\mathcal{M}_{n \to m}|, where dΦm\mathrm{d}\Phi_m is the differential mm-body phase space. Since we assume for simplicity constant matrix elements for all processes, the final state of a collision is sampled by first going to the CM frame of the incoming particles, computing the CM-energy, then uniformly sampling one mm-particle final state from the mm-particle phase space for the given CM-energy and then boosting this final state back into the cosmic frame. For a 2-particle final state, the uniform phase-space sampling is done by calculating the final state energies in the CM-frame and then sampling the polar and azimuthal scattering angles cos⁡(θ)\cos(\theta) and φ\varphi uniformly from [−1,1][-1,1] and [0,2π)[0,2\pi). For the 3-particle final state, we use the RAMBO algorithm as implemented in the HAZMA package [51, 52, 53].

Multiple interactions: During each time step, the different types of interaction can happen simultaneously. We therefore compute the number of tested pairs for all the different interaction types and sum them to NtotalN_{\mathrm{total}}. Then, we draw a number from a Poisson distribution with mean NtotalN_{\mathrm{total}} and iterate up to this number. At each iteration we choose one of the scattering processes with the weight given by its contribution to NtotalN_{\mathrm{total}} and then perform the stochastic collision test.

Evaluation of results

From our DSMC simulations, we want to extract various quantities that can have an observable impact on the evolution of the universe. The simplest such quantity is the particle yield Y=n/sY = n/s, where ss is the entropy density of the Standard Model thermal bath with the entropy effective degrees of freedom assumed to be constant at g∗,S=3.91g_{*,S} = 3.91. For cosmologically stable particles, the yield is expected to approach a constant value Y0Y_0 for T→0T \to0, which can be compared to the measured abundance of DM in the present universe. The yield is obtained by simply counting the number of particles in the simulation volume and dividing by the entropy density: Y=N/(V(t)⋅s(t))Y = N/(V(t) \cdot s(t)).

Another quantity of interest is the temperature TxT_x of the particle species xx, which gives a first indication of whether the particles will cluster like cold or warm DM during structure formation. Determining the temperature requires the calculation of an expectation value, see eq. (3). Here we once again benefit from the Monte Carlo approach, because we can replace the integral ∫d3p(2π)3f(p)\int\frac{\mathrm{d}^{3}p}{(2\pi)^{3}} f(p) simply by an ensemble average (1/V)∑i(1/V) \sum_i. The temperature is therefore calculated as

Tx=⟨p23E⟩x=1N∑ipi23Ei.(33)T_x = \left\langle\frac{p^2}{3E} \right\rangle_x = \frac{1}{N} \sum_i \frac{p_i^2}{3E_i}. \tag*{(33)}

Validation tests

In order to confirm the implementation of the algorithm presented above, we have performed multiple tests, which we briefly present in the following.

ψψ↔ϕϕ\psi\psi\leftrightarrow\phi\phi annihilation: We perform a simulation for the ψψ↔ϕϕ\psi\psi\leftrightarrow\phi\phi scattering with ∣Mψψ↔ϕϕ∣2=3.4×10−11|\mathcal{M}_{\psi\psi\leftrightarrow\phi\phi}|^2 = 3.4 \times10^{-11} and show the evolution of the ϕ\phi yield and temperature in Figure 4. We compare our simulation to the standard freeze-out computation with the nBE approach (see § 2). However, since we do not include elastic scattering, ψϕ→ψϕ\psi\phi\to\psi\phi, the usual assumption that ϕ\phi is in kinetic equilibrium with the thermal bath throughout the freeze-out procedure is not valid and hence we expect the standard nBE approach for freeze-out to deviate from our simulation. We therefore also compare to the cBE-approach for freeze-out, which is suitable for the case of early kinetic decoupling because it allows for a separate temperature of the ϕ\phi particles.

Figure 4. Left: Evolution of the ϕ\phi yield during freeze-out. Shown are results of the nBE, cBE and DSMC approaches. The star indicates where the nBE solution deviates by 10% from the equilibrium yield indicated by the dashed line. Right: Evolution of the ϕ\phi temperature compared to the SM bath-temperature for cBE and DSMC approaches.

The left panel of Figure 4 shows the well-known freeze-out behaviour as the ϕ\phi particles decouple from chemical equilibrium. While there is a clear difference between the DSMC result and the nBE approach, the DSMC and the cBE approach agree very well. The right panel of Figure 4 shows how the temperature TϕT_\phi starts to deviate from the temperature TT of the thermal bath. This deviation arises because the production of highly energetic ϕ\phi particles from the thermal bath is suppressed, such that TϕT_\phi decreases more quickly. The small difference between the temperature determined from the DSMC and from the cBE approach arises because the ϕ\phi particles are not in kinetic equilibrium with themselves after the decoupling, i.e. the assumption of a thermal phase-space distribution made in the cBE approach is not perfectly valid in the absence of ϕϕ→ϕϕ\phi\phi\to\phi\phi scattering processes.

For the matrix element chosen in Figure 4, the ϕ\phi particle yield is suppressed by less than two orders of magnitude before freeze-out occurs. Larger ψψ↔ϕϕ\psi\psi\leftrightarrow\phi\phi annihilation rates would correspond to a later freeze-out and hence a stronger suppression. If the yield drops over many orders of magnitude, it becomes difficult to perform the DSMC, because one would need to start with a huge number of particles during the initial stages in order to end up with a statistically significant number of ϕ\phi particles after decoupling. Simulating such a large number of particles with larger cross sections becomes computationally infeasible. To circumvent this difficulty for our simulations in § 4, we make use of the fact that in the initial stages of freeze-out, the ϕ\phi momentum distribution still pretty accurately tracks the thermal equilibrium distribution and Tϕ≈TT_\phi\approx T. Instead of performing a simulation that captures the full ψψ↔ϕϕ\psi\psi\leftrightarrow\phi\phi decoupling with the initial equilibrium stage, we will start the simulations presented in § 4 when the nBE solution deviates from the equilibrium yield YeqY_{\rm eq} by 10%. This point is marked by an orange star in Figure 4 for the given freeze-out process. Until this point we simply sample the ϕ\phi particles from a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution with SM-bath temperature.

ϕ→ρρ\phi\to\rho\rho decay: For a decaying particle ϕ\phi, which follows a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution, fϕ(p)∼exp⁡(−E/Tϕ)f_\phi(p) \sim\exp(-E/T_\phi), the Boltzmann equation for decay can be solved analytically [14]. The resulting yield of ρ\rho particles is given by

Y(Tϕ)=135π552MplΓdecmϕ2g∗sg∗∫0mϕ/Tϕdx x3K1(x)(34)Y(T_\phi) = \frac{135}{\pi^5}\sqrt{\frac{5}{2}}\frac{M_{\rm pl}\Gamma_{\rm dec}}{m_\phi^2 g_*^s \sqrt{g_*}}\int_0^{m_\phi/T_\phi}\mathrm{d}x\,x^3K_1(x) \tag*{(34)}

with K1K_1 being the first modified Bessel function of the second kind. Furthermore, the distribution function of ρ\rho momenta after the completion of in-equilibrium freeze-in for mρ≪mϕm_\rho\ll m_\phi is given by

fρ(p)=1210TϕΔg∗πpMplΓdecmϕ2Δ3exp⁡(−pTϕΔ)(35)f_\rho(p) = 12\sqrt{\frac{10T_\phi\Delta}{g_*\pi p}}\frac{M_{\rm pl}\Gamma_{\rm dec}}{m_\phi^2\Delta^3}\exp\left(-\frac{p}{T_\phi\Delta}\right) \tag*{(35)}

with Δ=1−mρ2/mϕ2\Delta= 1 - m_\rho^2/m_\phi^2. In Figure 5, we show the evolution of the ρ\rho yield and the late-time momentum distribution for the DSMC together with the analytical solution for a benchmark where Γdec=10−14 GeV\Gamma_{\rm dec} = 10^{-14}\,\mathrm{GeV}, mϕ=103 GeVm_\phi= 10^3\,\mathrm{GeV}, mρ=10 keVm_\rho= 10\,\mathrm{keV}. The DSMC agrees very well with the analytic solution.

Figure 5. Left: Evolution of the ρ\rho yield from in-equilibrium decay of ϕ\phi particles. Right: Distribution of ρ\rho momenta normalised to temperature.

2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 number-changing scattering: For 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 scattering, we can check that in a static universe, number-changing processes lead to thermal equilibrium. Since we assume a constant matrix element, all momenta above the kinematic threshold are involved in these processes, and hence we expect that both kinetic and chemical equilibrium are eventually reached. Given the initial energies of the particles in the simulations, we can then determine the number density and temperature in the equilibrium state using energy conservation in a non-expanding universe. Neglecting effects from quantum statistics, kinetic equilibrium leads to a phase-space distribution of the shape f(p)=exp⁡(−(E−μ)/T)f(p) = \exp(-(E-\mu)/T) with the chemical potential μ\mu. In chemical equilibrium, we furthermore have μ=0\mu= 0, such that the number and energy densities are solely a function of the equilibrium temperature:

n(T)=m2T2π2K2(mT),(36)n(T) = \frac{m^2 T}{2\pi^2} K_2\left(\frac{m}{T}\right), \tag*{(36)}
ρ(T)=m2T22π2(3K2(mT)+mTK1(mT)).(37)\rho(T) = \frac{m^2 T^2}{2\pi^2}\left(3K_2\left(\frac{m}{T}\right) + \frac{m}{T}K_1\left(\frac{m}{T}\right)\right). \tag*{(37)}

From the known initial energy density, we can thus compute the equilibrium temperature using eq. (37) and then the equilibrium number density using eq. (36).

As initial distribution, we choose a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution with temperature Tinitial=5.4T_{\mathrm{initial}} = 5.4.4 We start with N=8⋅104N = 8 \cdot10^4 particles in a volume V=800V = 800. The mass of the ρ\rho particles is chosen to be mρ=1m_\rho= 1 and the matrix element is ∣M2ρ→3ρ∣2=1|\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\to3\rho}|^2 = 1. For these initial conditions, the initial value of nn is larger than its value in chemical equilibrium. In other words, we expect 3→23 \to2 processes to dominate over 2→32 \to3 processes, leading to a decrease in particle number and an increase in temperature as the system approaches chemical equilibrium.5

In Figure 6 we show the evolution of number density and effective temperature under 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 processes. The purple line represents the scenario where only 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 collisions are present whereas the blue line includes efficient 2↔22 \leftrightarrow2 collisions to keep the distribution in kinetic equilibrium throughout the simulation. We see that in both cases, number density and effective temperature approach their equilibrium values. The dashed orange line in Figure 6 shows the solution to the cBE-approach described in § 2.1, which matches the DSMC simulation in case of efficient 2→22 \to2 collisions. This result agrees with expectation, since the cBE approach assumes kinetic equilibrium, which is ensured by the elastic scattering processes.

Figure 6. Evolution of number density (left) and temperature (right) towards equilibrium. The results with efficient 2→22 \to2 scattering are shown in blue, without 2→22 \to2 scattering in purple. The black dashed line shows the equilibrium quantities, the dashed orange line the cBE-solution.

When only 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 collisions are included, the DSMC solution deviates from the cBE solution. This is because the 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 collisions are not fast enough to maintain kinetic equilibrium for changing nn. This result is visualised in Figure 7, where we show the distribution of momenta at an intermediate time together with the kinetic equilibrium shape given the effective temperature and chemical potential of the particle ensemble. For the case of only 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 collisions, we see departures from the Maxwell-Boltzmann shape at intermediate times, whereas with efficient 2↔22 \leftrightarrow2 collisions, the distribution of ensemble momenta closely tracks the Maxwell-Boltzmann shape at all times.

Figure 7. Momentum histogram at intermediate temperatures with and without efficient 2→22 \to2 scattering together with the kinetic equilibrium distribution (yellow) for the corresponding temperature and chemical potential of the ensemble.

Results

Having validated our implementation, we now present the results from our simulations of the toy model described in § 2.2. Our benchmark parameters are mϕ=1m_\phi= 1 TeV, mρ=10m_\rho= 10 keV, Γdec=10−17\Gamma_{\mathrm{dec}} = 10^{-17} GeV, ∣Mψψ→ϕϕ∣2=2.3×10−8|\mathcal{M}_{\psi\psi\to\phi\phi}|^2 = 2.3 \times10^{-8}. These parameters are chosen such that the different processes happen at different periods in the early universe: The freeze-out of ϕ\phi happens when the particles become Boltzmann-suppressed at T∼100 GeVT \sim100\ \mathrm{GeV}, while out-of-equilibrium decays happen when Γdec≳H\Gamma_{\mathrm{dec}} \gtrsim H at T≲10 GeVT \lesssim10\ \mathrm{GeV}. The ρ\rho particles are still highly relativistic at this point and the precise value of their mass plays no role in the following discussion. The value mρ=10 keVm_{\rho} = 10\ \mathrm{keV} is chosen such that the observed DM relic abundance Ωh2=0.12\Omega h^2 = 0.12 is reproduced in the absence of number-changing processes. This value also lies in the mass range where warm DM constraints become relevant. We start the simulation at a bath temperature of T0=10mϕT_0 = 10m_{\phi}. The simulation volume ViV_i at the initial temperature is Vi=10−4 GeV−3V_i = 10^{-4}\ \mathrm{GeV}^{-3}. This corresponds to a volume of roughly 60 L today and O(7000)\mathcal{O}(7000) ρ\rho particles after the freeze-in is finished in the case of no number-changing processes. We chose the time step size as Δt=0.01×min⁡(H−1,Γmax⁡−1)\Delta t = 0.01 \times\min(H^{-1}, \Gamma_{\max}^{-1}), with Γmax⁡\Gamma_{\max} denoting the maximal interaction rate of all possible interactions.

Before including number-changing processes, we first present the pure freeze-in simulation results as a baseline. We show the evolution of the yields for ϕ\phi and ρ\rho as well as the evolution of the phase-space distribution of ρ\rho in Figure 8. We plot the phase-space distribution in terms of pρ/Tp_{\rho}/T, which is invariant under the expansion of the universe as long as g⋆g_{\star} for the SM thermal bath is approximately constant such that T∝a−1T \propto a^{-1}. Around mϕ/T∼3−5m_{\phi}/T \sim3 - 5, in-equilibrium decays of the ϕ\phi particles start to populate the ρ\rho sector. This creates the low-momentum peak at pρ/T∼2.5p_{\rho}/T \sim2.5 [17] in the right part of Figure 8. When the ϕ\phi particles freeze out and decay, they create the high-momentum peak at pρ/T∼mϕ/(2Tdec)p_{\rho}/T \sim m_{\phi}/(2T_{\mathrm{dec}}), where TdecT_{\mathrm{dec}} is defined by H(Tdec)=ΓdecH(T_{\mathrm{dec}}) = \Gamma_{\mathrm{dec}}.

Figure 8. Left: Evolution of the ρ\rho yield from decays of ϕ\phi particles. Right: Distribution of ρ\rho-momenta at different times normalised to temperature.

2ρ→2ρ\rho\to2\rho scattering

We now include the 2ρ→2ρ2\rho\to2\rho scattering with a matrix element ∣M2ρ→2ρ∣2=2×10−14\lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\to2\rho}\rvert^2 = 2 \times10^{-14}, corresponding to a self-scattering cross section of σ/mρ=∣M2ρ→2ρ∣2/(128πmρ3)∼10−5 cm2/g\sigma/m_{\rho} = \lvert\mathcal{M}_{2\rho\to2\rho}\rvert^2/(128\pi m_{\rho}^3) \sim10^{-5}\ \mathrm{cm}^2/\mathrm{g} in the non-relativistic limit, and an initial volume V=10ViV = 10V_i. Including 2ρ→2ρ2\rho\to2\rho scattering leads to reshuffling of momenta in the ρ\rho phase-space distribution but not to changes in the number density. Hence the yield evolution remains the same as in the left side of Figure 8. We show the simulation results for the evolution of the phase-space distribution including 2ρ→2ρ2\rho\to2\rho scattering in Figure 9. In Figure 10, we show on the left the evolution of the 2→22 \to2 scattering rate per particle,

Figure 9. Evolution of the phase-space distribution under 2→22 \to2 scattering. The vertical dashed lines indicate the average momenta of the low and high energy scattering partners in the collision.

Figure 10. Left: Evolution of the 2→22 \to2 scattering rate in the simulation together with the analytical approximation assuming kinetic equilibrium, and the Hubble rate. Right: Evolution of the effective ρ\rho particle temperature TρT_\rho in the simulation.

Γ2→2=2×number of 2→2 collisionsNρΔt(38)\Gamma_{2\to2} = 2 \times\frac{\text{number of } 2 \to2\text{ collisions}}{N_\rho\Delta t} \tag*{(38)}

along with the analytical expectation in case of kinetic equilibrium. The analytical prediction is given by Γ2→2eq=nρ⟨σv⟩2→2eq(Tρ)\Gamma^{\mathrm{eq}}_{2\to2} = n_\rho\langle\sigma v \rangle^{\mathrm{eq}}_{2\to2}(T_\rho) with the thermally averaged cross section for general nρ→mρn\rho\to m\rho scattering

⟨σvn−1⟩nρ→mρeq=1neq(Tρ)1n!m!∫∏i∈n∏j∈mdπidπj′∣Mnρ→mρ∣2fieq(Tρ)(2π)4δ(4)(∑i∈npi−∑j∈mpj′)(39)\left\langle\sigma v^{n-1}\right\rangle^{\mathrm{eq}}_{n\rho\to m\rho} = \frac{1}{n_{\mathrm{eq}}(T_\rho)}\frac{1}{n!m!} \int\prod_{i\in n}\prod_{j\in m} \mathrm{d}\pi_i\mathrm{d}\pi'_j \left|\mathcal{M}_{n\rho\to m\rho}\right|^2 f_i^{\mathrm{eq}}(T_\rho)(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)} \left(\sum_{i\in n}p_i-\sum_{j\in m}p'_j\right) \tag*{(39)}

where feq(p,T)=exp⁡(−E/T)f^{\mathrm{eq}}(p,T)=\exp(-E/T) and neq(T)=∫d3p/(2π)3feq(p,T)n_{\mathrm{eq}}(T)=\int\mathrm{d}^3p/(2\pi)^3 f^{\mathrm{eq}}(p,T). We use the effective ρ\rho particle temperature obtained from our simulation (c.f. eq. (3), shown on the right side of Figure 10) as input for the analytical scattering rate.

The evolution of the phase-space distribution can be understood by looking at the actual collision rate obtained from the simulation compared with the analytical prediction assuming kinetic equilibrium. The following picture emerges:

  1. Up to x=mϕ/T∼40x=m_\phi/T\sim40, the ρ\rho-population consists only of the low energy peak created through the in-equilibrium decay. Since the particles are all highly relativistic and the cross section scales as σ(s)∝s−1\sigma(\sqrt{s})\propto s^{-1}, 2→22\to2 scattering is suppressed. In fact, the scattering rate is so small that it cannot be reliably estimated from our simulations and is therefore not shown in Figure 10.

  1. Between mϕ/T=40m_\phi/T=40 and 600600, the out-of-equilibrium decays of the ϕ\phi particles happen, producing the higher-momentum peak in the distribution. This leads to the visible increase in the effective temperature TρT_\rho seen in the right panel of Figure 10. The increase of the effective temperature leads to a decrease in the would-be equilibrium scattering rate as higher energy particles are less likely to scatter. All momenta of the particles are still too large to lead to effective scattering.

  1. As the universe expands, the momenta redshift and the lower momentum peak reaches the momentum range where scattering is no longer negligible. The fact that the scattering rate in the simulation is larger than the equilibrium estimate reflects the highly non-thermal shape of the true distribution. Since the true distribution is broader than the equilibrium one, and since σ\sigma is a convex function of s\sqrt{s}, it follows that ⟨σv⟩>⟨σv⟩eq\langle\sigma v\rangle>\langle\sigma v\rangle^{\mathrm{eq}}. Below mϕ/T∼106m_\phi/T\sim10^6, the scattering rate is still smaller than the Hubble rate and therefore does not efficiently alter the phase-space distribution. However, the interaction rate for relativistic particles decreases as Γ∝T\Gamma\propto T, so slower than the Hubble rate.

  1. As soon as the scattering rate becomes comparable to the Hubble rate, kinetic equilibration at the lower end of the momentum spectrum becomes efficient. The scattering processes slowly alter the momentum distribution towards the equilibrium one and thereby lower the scattering rate towards the equilibrium value. During this approach to equilibrium, the scattering rate approximately tracks the Hubble rate. The fact that the two rates coincide almost exactly for an extended period of time is to some degree a coincidence for the chosen separation and heights of the momentum peaks. For different parameter values, the scattering rate does not exactly follow the Hubble rate, but the qualitative behaviour of the two rates scaling in a similar way remains.

⑤ As the momenta redshift further, also the high momentum peak becomes relevant for scattering. Eventually, also the equilibrium scattering rate becomes larger than the Hubble rate, at which point the distribution reaches full kinetic equilibrium, such that the actual scattering rate tracks the analytical estimate perfectly.

⑥ At around mϕ/T=1010m_{\phi}/T = 10^{10}, the effective temperature drops below the mass. As a result, the momentum distribution changes from the relativistic form, f(p)∝p2e−p/Tf(p) \propto p^{2}e^{-p/T}, to the non-relativistic one, f(p)∝p2e−p2/(2mρT)f(p) \propto p^{2}e^{-p^{2}/(2m_{\rho}T)}. The scattering cross section approaches a constant in the non-relativistic limit but number density and the relative velocities continue to decrease. Soon after the particles have become non-relativistic, the scattering therefore becomes inefficient and the interaction freezes out.

For the chosen parameter values, the DM particles become non-relativistic only for very small temperatures of the SM thermal bath, T≲0.1T \lesssim0.1 keV. This value results from the small assumed DM mass mρ=10m_{\rho} = 10 keV and the large momenta injected by out-of-equilibrium decays (pρ/T∼100p_{\rho}/T \sim100). As a result, the model considered here clearly does not satisfy the typical warm DM bounds and would not give successful structure formation [34]. This finding motivates a detailed investigation of the effect of number-changing processes which lead to a cooling of the dark sector [54].

number-changing scattering

Let us now turn to the case with number-changing processes. In Figure 11, we show the evolution of the ρ\rho yield and effective ρ\rho temperature of the simulated particle ensemble for various 2ρ↔3ρ2\rho\leftrightarrow3\rho matrix elements. The grey-shaded area corresponds to all possible values between no number-changing interactions at all (as considered above) and full chemical equilibrium. The latter case can be readily calculated for relativistic particles, since the energy density redshifts as ρ∝a−4\rho\propto a^{-4}, so we can calculate the equilibrium quantities using energy conservation as discussed in § 3.4. Crucially, we find that the set-up that we consider corresponds to an under-occupied dark sector at the end of the freeze-in stage, such that 2→32 \to3 processes dominate over 3→23 \to2 processes, leading to an increase in the number density of ρ\rho particles.

Figure 11. Evolution yield (left) and effective temperature (right) for different 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 matrix elements.

As expected, when increasing the matrix elements for number-changing processes, the ρ\rho particle yield is driven more and more towards its chemical equilibrium value. The increase in number density leads to a cooling of the dark sector (see the right panel of Figure 11) as kinetic energy is converted into the rest mass of additional particles. We further observe that thermalisation during the period of in-equilibrium decays (mϕ/T∼10m_{\phi}/T \sim10) requires smaller matrix elements than thermalisation during the period of out-of-equilibrium decays (mϕ/T∼100m_{\phi}/T \sim100–10001000).

In Figure 12 we show the phase-space distribution at several points in the evolution for the different matrix elements. The shown stages correspond to the following behaviour:

Figure 12. Evolution of the momentum distribution under 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 scattering for the matrix elements of the simulations shown in Figure 11. The grey contour shows the momentum distribution in absence of self-scattering.

① For large matrix elements, the in-equilibrium decay abundance thermalises directly, whereas the smallest matrix element does not lead to complete thermalisation. Compared to the phase-space distribution without number-changing processes (shown in grey), the 2→32 \to3 processes increase the total number of particles and distribute the particle momenta towards smaller values.

  1. During the out-of-equilibrium decays, the second peak is produced. For the larger matrix elements, the number-changing processes drive the distribution towards equilibrium. For the smallest matrix element, the interaction is no longer efficient and the high-energy peak does not thermalise at all.

  1. The out-of-equilibrium decay has finished and the ρ\rho particle yield has become constant. For the largest matrix element, complete thermal equilibrium was achieved. The intermediate matrix element was not large enough to achieve complete thermal equilibration for the second peak, and for the smallest matrix element, the second peak is unchanged from the decays.

To understand these findings, we can look at the per-particle interaction rates for

2ρ↔3ρ2\rho\leftrightarrow3\rho scatterings:

Γ2→3=2×number of 2→3 collisionsNρΔt(40)\Gamma_{2\to3}=2\times\frac{\text{number of }2\to3\text{ collisions}}{N_\rho\Delta t} \tag*{(40)}
Γ3→2=3×number of 3→2 collisionsNρΔt(41)\Gamma_{3\to2}=3\times\frac{\text{number of }3\to2\text{ collisions}}{N_\rho\Delta t} \tag*{(41)}

We show them in Figure 13 along with the analytic expectations for kinetic (but not chemical) equilibrium Γ2→3eq=nρ⟨σv⟩2→3eq\Gamma^{\mathrm{eq}}_{2\to3}=n_\rho\langle\sigma v\rangle^{\mathrm{eq}}_{2\to3} and Γ3→2eq=nρ22⟨σv2⟩3→2eq\Gamma^{\mathrm{eq}}_{3\to2}=\frac{n_\rho^2}{2}\langle\sigma v^2\rangle^{\mathrm{eq}}_{3\to2} with the thermally averaged cross sections as defined in equation (39). To calculate these thermal averages we use the would-be chemical equilibrium temperature, i.e. the lower end of the grey band on the right side of Figure 11.

Figure 13. Figure 13. 2→32 \to3 (left) and 3→23 \to2 (right) scattering rates for the two largest matrix elements of the simulations shown in Figure 11. We do not include the rate for the lowest matrix element here as scattering processes happen too rarely to calculate the corresponding rate. The dotted line shows the analytic expectations in case of thermal equilibrium.

For constant matrix elements the cross section (σv)2→3(\sigma v)_{2\to3} is constant for relativistic particles. The time dependence of the interaction rate is therefore set only by the number density. In case of a constant comoving number density, one finds Γ2→3∼T3\Gamma_{2\to3}\sim T^3, so the rate decreases faster than the Hubble rate. This shows that 2ρ→3ρ2\rho\to3\rho processes are active only if the combination of initial abundance produced through decays and matrix element is large enough to have Γ2→3≳H\Gamma_{2\to3}\gtrsim H immediately at production. In this case, the comoving number density increases further making number-changing processes even more important. This self-amplifying process only stops once the chemical equilibrium abundance is reached and the production of particles is balanced by the inverse 3→23\to2 process.

In the absence of further external particle injection, the number density is then once again covariantly conserved (for relativistic particles), such that the number-changing rate drops faster than the Hubble rate and ultimately becomes inefficient. The out-of-equilibrium decay enhances the number density once more, potentially pushing the interaction rate again above the Hubble rate, such that also the high-energy peak thermalises.

For 3→23\to2 scattering, we know from eq. (13) that the scattering rate scales as Γ3→2∼∣M3ρ→2ρ∣2nρ2/E3\Gamma_{3\to2}\sim|\mathcal{M}_{3\rho\to2\rho}|^2 n_\rho^2/E^3, where EE is the energy of the involved particles. For relativistic particles, we then find that Γ3→2∼T3\Gamma_{3\to2}\sim T^3 in case of constant comoving number density. Since the equilibrium number density lies above the number density produced through the decays, the 3→23 \to2 rate is initially small. As soon as the 2→32 \to3 scatterings increase the number density sufficiently, also 3→23 \to2 scatterings become important and start to balance the 2→32 \to3 scatterings. In case the matrix element is large enough, thermalisation is achieved and the interaction rate decreases again. The out-of-equilibrium decays and subsequent increase of 2ρ→3ρ2\rho\to3\rho scatterings also again increases the 3ρ→2ρ3\rho\to2\rho scattering rate for large enough matrix elements, which can lead to thermalisation also of the second peak. Deviations between the analytical and simulated rates reflect the fact that the phase-space distribution is non-thermal immediately after the production of the high-momentum peak because the considered rates are too small to instantly thermalise the injected particles.

To conclude this discussion, we point out that the final ρ\rho particle yield, corresponding to the predicted DM abundance, depends sensitively on the rate of number-changing processes. For example, the orange and purple lines correspond to matrix elements that differ only by a factor of 2, while the resulting abundances differ by an order of magnitude. Moreover, in the most decisive stage, when high-momentum particles are injected through out-of-equilibrium decays, there are visible differences between the actual interaction rates in the simulations and their analytical estimates assuming thermal distributions. This highlights the need for more sophisticated methods such as DSMC.

Convergence

As the DSMC stochastically solves the Boltzmann equation, each simulation inherently comes with a statistical error from the finite particle number. For example, the DM abundance predicted from our simulation is directly proportional to the total number NendN_{\mathrm{end}} of simulation particles at the end of the simulation, such that one can expect a relative error of the order of 1/Nend1/\sqrt{N_{\mathrm{end}}}. For quantities obtained from the normalised phase-space distribution, such as the temperature TρT_\rho, the error can be estimated from the sample variance using the standard formula for Monte Carlo integration, which again predicts that the error decreases as 1/Nend1/\sqrt{N_{\mathrm{end}}}. These error estimates can be directly confirmed by re-running the DSMC several times to obtain independent samples of the final distribution.

To check for convergence of our results with increasing particle number, we exemplarily performed three sets of simulations for ∣M3ρ→2ρ∣2=2×10−11 GeV\left|\mathcal{M}_{3\rho\to2\rho}\right|^2 = 2 \times10^{-11}\,\mathrm{GeV} for three different initial simulation volumes ViV_i, 4Vi4V_i and 9Vi9V_i, corresponding to a final number of ρ\rho particles of Nend=O(450000)N_{\mathrm{end}} = \mathcal{O}(450000), O(180000)\mathcal{O}(180000), and O(405000)\mathcal{O}(405000), respectively. For each case we ran ten independent simulations and computed the mean and standard deviation for the final ρ\rho abundance of the simulation ensembles.

In Figure 14, we show on the left side the evolution of the ±1σ\pm1\sigma uncertainty band for YρY_\rho obtained from the simulation ensembles and on the right side the ensemble average and standard deviation for Ωρh2\Omega_\rho h^2. We see that the results for the different volumes agree with each other and that the precision increases with simulation size. For the largest simulations, percent-level precision in the final abundance is achieved. We observe that the standard deviation roughly decreases as 1/N1/\sqrt{N} with the number of simulation particles, as expected for a stochastic simulation. The actual uncertainty is larger than the naive expectation of a Poisson distribution with uncertainty N\sqrt{N}, because all the number-changing processes (i.e. decays and 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 scatterings) introduce correlations in the ensemble. In Figure 15, we show the phase-space distribution after finished freeze-in for the different volumes for three different simulation runs. Convergence towards a unique phase-space distribution with increasing simulation volume is visible. We have also confirmed that quantities calculated from the phase-space distribution, such as the temperature, exhibit the expected convergence with increasing particle number.

Figure 14. Left: Evolution of YρY_{\rho} as a function of temperature for three different simulation sizes. The band shows the ±1σ\pm1\sigma uncertainty obtained from ten independent simulation runs. Right: Mean value and standard deviation of YρY_{\rho} for the different simulation sizes. The simulation volume of initial size ViV_i corresponds to O(45000) ρO(45000)\ \rho particles at the end of the simulation.

Figure 15. Phase-space distribution after finished freeze-in for three different runs with a simulation volume of ViV_i (left), 4Vi4V_i (middle) and 9Vi9V_i (right).

Conclusions and outlook

The phase-space distribution of dark matter (DM) carries important information for cosmology but is challenging to calculate whenever thermal equilibrium cannot be assumed. Solving Boltzmann equations for DM production at the phase-space level hence becomes increasingly important in the era of precision cosmology. In this work, we showed that Monte Carlo simulations provide a highly useful tool in the context of non-equilibrium evolution. A particular advantage is that the relevant phase-space regions do not need to be known ahead of time, because the simulations can be used as an explorative tool to identify physically relevant momentum ranges. Within the framework of Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC), we studied freeze-out, decay, elastic as well as number-changing interactions for constant matrix elements, demonstrating that a wide range of DM production scenarios can be explored at the phase-space level. We confirmed the correct implementation of the various reaction processes by cross-checking against analytical expectations.

To illustrate the relevant effects, we considered a toy model based on a well-known scenario with two-step production of DM through in-equilibrium and out-of-equilibrium decays of a parent particle. The resulting bimodal phase-space distribution is highly non-thermal, necessitating an unintegrated Boltzmann equation to study the effect of subsequent 2→22 \to2 and 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 scatterings. As expected, for large enough matrix elements, 2→22 \to2 scattering leads to kinetic equilibrium, while 2→32 \to3 scattering also establishes chemical equilibrium. The DSMC approach is able to describe both the approach towards thermal equilibrium for large matrix elements as well as scenarios with smaller matrix elements, both of which cannot be modelled using approximations that assume thermal distributions.

A DSMC run predicts not only the final number of particles in the simulation volume corresponding to the DM relic abundance, but it also provides a random sample from the DM phase-space distribution. This sample can be used for efficient Monte Carlo integration of integrals involving the phase-space distribution function. These include simple expectation values such as the DM temperature, but also more complicated quantities such as the perturbations needed to calculate the suppression of small-scale structure in Boltzmann codes [55]. For all these quantities, the statistical Monte Carlo error can be determined by running the simulation several times and reduced by increasing the simulation volume.

The present work did not aim to describe a realistic DM scenario. The toy model under consideration instead served as a proof of concept to show the flexibility and limitations of DSMC in context of DM production. So far, we have only considered constant matrix elements, but it is in principle straightforward to include more complicated matrix elements. In fact, in this context the DSMC approach can benefit strongly from established methods for Monte Carlo event generation, such as importance sampling or adaptive integration. However, in order to make the simulations efficient, tight upper bounds on the interaction cross section are needed for the matrix elements under consideration. Furthermore, we have not included quantum statistics effects, but these can be handled within DSMC as demonstrated in e.g. Ref. [27].

An important challenge for the DSMC approach arises when considering scenarios where the particle number changes by orders of magnitude or when several processes of interest occur at vastly different rates. In such cases new strategies are needed to guarantee computational feasibility, based for example on splitting and merging algorithms that have been developed in the context of DSMC. In this context it will also be interesting to systematically benchmark the DSMC approach against alternative ways to solve unintegrated Boltzmann equations in order to identify which approach works best in which scenario. The present work demonstrates that it is worthwhile to explore these directions in the future in order to provide the community with new tools and techniques to understand the evolution of DM in the early universe and pin down its role in structure formation.

Acknowledgments

We thank Torsten Bringmann, Oleksii Ihnatenko and Thomas Schwetz for helpful discussions, Tim-Leon Klocke for valuable comments on the manuscript and Maksym Ovchynnikov for sharing the code from Ref. [25].

Derivation of 2 ↔\leftrightarrow 3 scattering probability

In this appendix we provide additional details on the calculation of the scattering rates of number-changing processes. These have been derived in ref. [23].

2 →\to 3 scattering. The collision operator for 2↔32 \leftrightarrow3 scattering is given by

C^23E1=12E112!∫dπ2dπ312!∫dπ1′dπ2′f1′f2′∣M1′2′→123∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1′+p2′−p1−p2−p3)+12E1∫dπ213!∫dπ1′dπ2′dπ3′f1′f2′f3′∣M1′2′3′→12∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1′+p2′+p3′−p1−p2)−12E112!∫dπ2dπ312!∫dπ1′dπ2′f1f2f3∣M123→1′2′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2+p3−p1′−p2′)−12E1∫dπ213!∫dπ1′dπ2′dπ3′f1f2∣M12→1′2′3′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′−p3′).(42)\begin{aligned} \frac{\widehat{C}_{23}}{E_1}={}&\frac{1}{2E_1}\frac{1}{2!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi_2\mathrm{d}\pi_3\frac{1}{2!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2 f'_1f'_2\lvert\mathcal{M}_{1'2'\to123}\rvert^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p'_1+p'_2-p_1-p_2-p_3)\\ &+\frac{1}{2E_1}\int\mathrm{d}\pi_2\frac{1}{3!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\mathrm{d}\pi'_3 f'_1f'_2f'_3\lvert\mathcal{M}_{1'2'3'\to12}\rvert^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p'_1+p'_2+p'_3-p_1-p_2)\\ &-\frac{1}{2E_1}\frac{1}{2!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi_2\mathrm{d}\pi_3\frac{1}{2!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2 f_1f_2f_3\lvert\mathcal{M}_{123\to1'2'}\rvert^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2+p_3-p'_1-p'_2)\\ &-\frac{1}{2E_1}\int\mathrm{d}\pi_2\frac{1}{3!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\mathrm{d}\pi'_3 f_1f_2\lvert\mathcal{M}_{12\to1'2'3'}\rvert^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2-p'_1-p'_2-p'_3). \tag*{(42)} \end{aligned}

To obtain the probability of scattering in a time interval Δt\Delta t when choosing two initial particles in the momentum range (p1,p1+Δp1)(\mathbf{p}_1,\mathbf{p}_1+\Delta\mathbf{p}_1) and (p2,p2+Δp2)(\mathbf{p}_2,\mathbf{p}_2+\Delta\mathbf{p}_2) in a volume Δx3\Delta x^3, we proceed in the same way as for the 2→22\to2 scattering (by selecting the last term in eq. (A.1) responsible for 2→32\to3 scattering). The scattering probability is then given by

P2→3=NcollN1N2=σ2→3vΔtΔx3(43)P_{2\to3}=\frac{N_{\mathrm{coll}}}{N_1N_2}=\sigma_{2\to3}v\frac{\Delta t}{\Delta x^3} \tag*{(43)}

with

σ2→3v=12E112E213!∫dπ1′dπ2′dπ3′∣M12→1′2′3′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p1′−p2′−p3′).(44)\sigma_{2\to3}v=\frac{1}{2E_1}\frac{1}{2E_2}\frac{1}{3!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\mathrm{d}\pi'_3\lvert\mathcal{M}_{12\to1'2'3'}\rvert^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2-p'_1-p'_2-p'_3). \tag*{(44)}

3 →\to 2 scattering. To obtain the scattering probability, we again use the Boltzmann equation, now selecting the third term in eq. (A.1). The number of 3→23\to2 collisions during a time interval Δt\Delta t in a volume Δx3\Delta x^3 with NiN_i particles in the momentum range (pi,pi+Δpi)(\mathbf{p}_i,\mathbf{p}_i+\Delta\mathbf{p}_i) is given by

NcollΔt1(2π)3Δx3Δ3p1=12E1Δ3p2(2π)32E2Δ3p3(2π)32E312!f1f2f3∫dπ1′dπ2′∣M123→1′2′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2+p3−p1′−p2′).(45)\frac{N_{\mathrm{coll}}}{\Delta t\frac{1}{(2\pi)^3}\Delta x^3\Delta^3p_1} =\frac{1}{2E_1}\frac{\Delta^3p_2}{(2\pi)^3 2E_2}\frac{\Delta^3p_3}{(2\pi)^3 2E_3}\frac{1}{2!}f_1f_2f_3 \int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\lvert\mathcal{M}_{123\to1'2'}\rvert^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2+p_3-p'_1-p'_2). \tag*{(45)}

The collision probability after selecting three particles with momenta in the range (pi,pi+Δpi\mathbf{p}_i,\mathbf{p}_i+\Delta\mathbf{p}_i) is then given by

P3→2=NcollN1N2N3=18E1E2E3Δt(Δx3)2I32(46)P_{3\to2}=\frac{N_{\mathrm{coll}}}{N_1N_2N_3}=\frac{1}{8E_1E_2E_3}\frac{\Delta t}{(\Delta x^3)^2}I_{32} \tag*{(46)}

where we defined the Lorentz-invariant integral expression

I32=12!∫dπ1′dπ2′∣M123→1′2′∣2(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2+p3−p1′−p2′).(47)I_{32}=\frac{1}{2!}\int\mathrm{d}\pi'_1\mathrm{d}\pi'_2\left|\mathcal{M}_{123\to1'2'}\right|^2(2\pi)^4\delta^{(4)}\left(p_1+p_2+p_3-p'_1-p'_2\right). \tag*{(47)}

Note that the additional factor of 1/2!1/2! in the collision operator appears due to initial state identical particles and is not included in the collision probability because we account for it by considering unordered triplets N3-plets=(N3)N_{3\text{-plets}}=\binom{N}{3} in § 3.

References

  1. [1]P. Gondolo and G. Gelmini, Cosmic abundances of stable particles: Improved analysis, Nucl. Phys. B 360 (1991) 145.
  2. [2]K. Griest and D. Seckel, Three exceptions in the calculation of relic abundances, Phys. Rev. D 43 (1991) 3191.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10013275
  3. [3]T. Bringmann and S. Hofmann, Thermal decoupling of WIMPs from first principles, JCAP 04 (2007) 016 [hep-ph/0612238].arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0612238
  4. [4]T. Binder, T. Bringmann, M. Gustafsson and A. Hryczuk, Early kinetic decoupling of dark matter: when the standard way of calculating the thermal relic density fails, Phys. Rev. D 96 (2017) 115010 [1706.07433].arxiv.org/abs/1706.07433
  5. [5]S. Profumo, Chemical and kinetic equilibrium in cosmology: Facts and myths, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 103509 [2508.20988].arxiv.org/abs/2508.20988
  6. [6]S. Hannestad and J. Madsen, Neutrino decoupling in the early universe, Phys. Rev. D 52 (1995) 1764 [astro-ph/9506015].DOI
  7. [7]T. Binder, T. Bringmann, M. Gustafsson and A. Hryczuk, Dark matter relic abundance beyond kinetic equilibrium, Eur. Phys. J. C 81 (2021) 577 [2103.01944].DOI
  8. [8]A. Hryczuk and M. Laletin, Impact of dark matter self-scattering on its relic abundance, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 023007 [2204.07078].DOI
  9. [9]S. Chatterjee and A. Hryczuk, Conversions in two-component dark sectors: a phase space level analysis, JHEP 07 (2025) 279 [2502.08725].arxiv.org/abs/2502.08725
  10. [10]F. D’Er​amo, A. Lenoci and T. Sassi, Seasons of dark matter freeze-in shaped by the weather of the early Universe, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026) 083502 [2511.07511].
  11. [11]J.-H. Yoon, Boltzmann equation solver for thermalization, Comput. Phys. Commun. 327 (2026) 110295 [2603.28848].DOI
  12. [12]J. Spinner and J.D. Shergold, Neural Boltzmann Equations, 2608.23022.arxiv.org/abs/2608.23022
  13. [13]E. Cervantes, Kinetic XGPU: A Tensorized Collision Operator for Dark-Sector Self-Scattering, 2607.00755.DOI
  14. [14]L.J. Hall, K. Jedamzik, J. March-Russell and S.M. West, Freeze-In Production of FIMP Dark Matter, JHEP 03 (2010) 080 [0911.1120].
  15. [15]J. McDonald, Warm Dark Matter via Ultra-Violet Freeze-In: Reheating Temperature and Non-Thermal Distribution for Fermionic Higgs Portal Dark Matter, JCAP 08 (2016) 035 [1512.06422].DOI
  16. [16]S.B. Roland and B. Shakya, Cosmological Imprints of Frozen-In Light Sterile Neutrinos, JCAP 05 (2017) 027 [1609.06739].DOI
  17. [17]J. Heeck and D. Teresi, Cold keV dark matter from decays and scatterings, Phys. Rev. D 96 (2017) 035018 [1706.09909].DOI
  18. [18]Y. Du, F. Huang, H.-L. Li, Y.-Z. Li and J.-H. Yu, Revisiting dark matter freeze-in and freeze-out through phase-space distributions, JCAP 04 (2022) 012 [2111.01267].DOI
  19. [19]G.A. Bird, Approach to Translational Equilibrium in a Rigid Sphere Gas, The Physics of Fluids 6 (1963) 1518.DOI
  20. [20]G.A. Bird, Direct Simulation and the Boltzmann Equation, The Physics of Fluids 13 (1970) 2676.DOI
  21. [21]G.A. Bird, Molecular Gas Dynamics And The Direct Simulation Of Gas Flows, Oxford University Press (05, 1994), 10.1093/oso/9780198561958.001.0001.
  22. [22]M. Pfeiffer, P. Nizenkov, A. Mirza and S. Fasoulas, Direct simulation Monte Carlo modeling of relaxation processes in polyatomic gases, Physics of Fluids 28 (2016) 027103.DOI
  23. [23]Z. Xu and C. Greiner, Thermalization of gluons in ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions by including three-body interactions in a parton cascade, Phys. Rev. C 71 (2005) 064901 [hep-ph/0406278].DOI
  24. [24]SMASH collaboration, Particle production and equilibrium properties within a new hadron transport approach for heavy-ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C 94 (2016) 054905 [1606.06642].
  25. [25]M. Ovchynnikov and V. Syvolap, How new physics affects primordial neutrinos decoupling: Direct simulation Monte Carlo approach, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) 063527 [2409.07378].DOI
  26. [26]O. Inhatenko and M. Ovchynnikov, Precision calculation of Neff with neutrino direct simulation Monte Carlo, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 103543 [2508.08379].
  27. [27]K. Akita, M. Escudero, O. Inhatenko and M. Ovchynnikov, Neutrino Direct Simulation Monte Carlo: Accurate modeling of out-of-equilibrium decaying cosmological relics, 2609.31833.arxiv.org/abs/2609.31833
  28. [28]E.O. Nadler, K.K. Rogers and A. Drlica-Wagner, Dark Matter Constraints from Small-Scale Cosmic Structure, 2607.28564.arxiv.org/abs/2607.28564
  29. [29]K.J. Bae, A. Kamada, S.P. Liew and K. Yanagi, Light axions from freeze-in: production processes, phase space distributions, and Ly-α forest constraints, JCAP 01 (2018) 054 [1707.06418].DOI
  30. [30]A. Kamada and K. Yanagi, Constraining FIMP from the structure formation of the Universe: analytic mapping from mWDM, JCAP 11 (2019) 029 [1907.04558].DOI
  31. [31]C. Dvorkin, T. Lin and K. Schutz, Cosmology of Sub-MeV Dark Matter Freeze-In, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 (2021) 111301 [2011.08186].DOI
  32. [32]G. Ballesteros, M.A.G. Garcia and M. Pierre, How warm are non-thermal relics? Lyman-α bounds on out-of-equilibrium dark matter, JCAP 03 (2021) 101 [2011.13458].DOI
  33. [33]F. D’Eramo and A. Lenoci, Lower mass bounds on FIMP dark matter produced via freeze-in, JCAP 10 (2021) 045 [2012.01446].
  34. [34]D. Egana-Ugrinovic, R. Essig, D. Gift and M. Loverde, The Cosmological Evolution of Self-interacting Dark Matter, JCAP 05 (2021) 013 [2102.06215].
  35. [35]Q. Decant, J. Heisig, D.C. Hooper and L. Lopez-Honorez, Lyman-α constraints on freeze-in and superWIMPs, JCAP 03 (2022) 041 [2111.09321].DOI
  36. [36]K.R. Dienes, F. Huang, J. Kost, B. Thomas and H.-B. Yu, Evaluating Lyman-α constraints for general dark-matter velocity distributions: Multiple scales and cautionary tales, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 123521 [2112.09105].DOI
  37. [37]Z. Xu, Q. Zhou and S. Zheng, Constraints on freeze-in dark matter from Lyman-α forest and 21-cm signal: Single-field models, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 115003 [2407.08225].DOI
  38. [38]E.D. Carlson, M.E. Machacek and L.J. Hall, Self-interacting dark matter, Astrophys. J. 398 (1992) 43.DOI
  39. [39]D. Pappadopulo, J.T. Ruderman and G. Trevisan, Dark matter freeze-out in a nonrelativistic sector, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 035005 [1602.04219].DOI
  40. [40]E. Cervantes and A. Hryczuk, Freezing-in cannibal dark sectors, JHEP 11 (2024) 050 [2407.12104].DOI
  41. [41]R.T. D’Agnolo, D. Pappadopulo and J.T. Ruderman, Fourth Exception in the Calculation of Relic Abundances, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119 (2017) 061102 [1705.08450].DOI
  42. [42]A. Merle and M. Totzauer, keV Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter from Singlet Scalar Decays: Basic Concepts and Subtle Features, JCAP 06 (2015) 011 [1502.01011].
  43. [43]J. König, A. Merle and M. Totzauer, keV Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter from Singlet Scalar Decays: The Most General Case, JCAP 11 (2016) 038 [1609.01289].DOI
  44. [44]K.R. Dienes, F. Huang, J. Kost, S. Su and B. Thomas, Deciphering the archaeological record: Cosmological imprints of nonminimal dark sectors, Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 123511 [2001.02193].DOI
  45. [45]C. Benso, F. Kahlhoefer and H. Mansour, Dark matter phase-in: producing feebly-interacting particles after a first-order phase transition, JHEP 07 (2025) 195 [2504.10593].
  46. [46]E. Roohi and S. Stefanov, Collision partner selection schemes in DSMC: From micro/nano flows to hypersonic flows, Physics Reports 656 (2016) 1.DOI
  47. [47]S. Stefanov, On the basic concepts of the direct simulation Monte Carlo method, Physics of Fluids 31 (2019) 067104.DOI
  48. [48]P. Danielewicz and G.F. Bertsch, Production of deuterons and pions in a transport model of energetic heavy-ion reactions, Nuclear Physics A 533 (1991) 712.DOI
  49. [49]W. Cassing, Anti-baryon production in hot and dense nuclear matter, Nucl. Phys. A 700 (2002) 618 [nucl-th/0105069].
  50. [50]SMASH collaboration, Deuteron production in relativistic heavy ion collisions via stochastic multiparticle reactions, Phys. Rev. C 104 (2021) 034908 [2106.14287].
  51. [51]R. Kleiss, W.J. Stirling and S.D. Ellis, A New Monte Carlo Treatment of Multiparticle Phase Space at High-energies, Comput. Phys. Commun. 40 (1986) 359.DOI
  52. [52]A. Coogan, L. Morrison and S. Profumo, Hazma: A Python Toolkit for Studying Indirect Detection of Sub-GeV Dark Matter, JCAP 01 (2020) 056 [1907.11846].DOI
  53. [53]A. Coogan, L. Morrison, T. Plehn, S. Profumo and P. Reimitz, Hazma meets HERWIG4DM: precision gamma-ray, neutrino, and positron spectra for light dark matter, JCAP 11 (2022) 033 [2207.06734].DOI
  54. [54]E. Cervantes, A. Hryczuk and S. Lederer, Light Dark Matter from Self-cooling Dark Sectors, 2608.22307.arxiv.org/abs/2608.22307
  55. [55]J. Lesgourgues and T. Tram, The Cosmic Linear Anisotropy Solving System (CLASS) IV: efficient implementation of non-cold relics, JCAP 09 (2011) 032 [1104.2935].DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_27u4txqx
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 8

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents