betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Relativistic precession around rotating neutron stars. I. Slow rotation: Hartle–Thorne spacetimes, particle orbits and the QPOs of atoll and Z sources

Abstract

We study the relativistic precession model (RPM) of quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) in the spacetimes of slowly rotating neutron stars computed from the equation of state (EOS). For four EOSs (WFF1, G3, FSUGarnet and IOPB-I) we solve the Hartle–Thorne equations to second order in the angular velocity and compute the orbital and epicyclic frequencies of the exterior metric without expanding in the spin or the quadrupole. At 1.9 M⊙1.9\,\mathrm{M}_\odot the spin-induced quadrupole is 2–4 times that of a black hole with the same spin; it lowers the nodal precession frequency by up to 25 per cent near the innermost stable circular orbit and limits the nodal frequency that any spin can produce. An eccentric, tilted geodesic around a 1.92 M⊙1.92\,\mathrm{M}_\odot star spinning at 363~Hz precesses at the epicyclic rates, and the power spectrum of a hot spot on it peaks at the orbital, periastron and nodal precession frequencies. Applied to the atoll sources 4U 1636−-53 and 4U 1728−-34, the RPM gives masses of 2.02–2.15 M⊙2.15\,\mathrm{M}_\odot and 1.88–1.92 M⊙1.92\,\mathrm{M}_\odot. For 4U 1728−-34 the low-frequency QPO favours stars with large moments of inertia, I≃2.5×1045I\simeq2.5\times10^{45}~g,cm2^{2}. Without an EOS the QPOs give M=1.920−0.012+0.014 M⊙M=1.920^{+0.014}_{-0.012}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot, j=0.162−0.011+0.023j=0.162^{+0.023}_{-0.011} and Qˉ=2.2−0.8+1.1\bar Q=2.2^{+1.1}_{-0.8}; a Kerr spacetime with the same nodal frequency would underestimate the moment of inertia by 22 per cent. For the Z sources GX 5−-1 and GX 340+0 the horizontal-branch oscillations cannot be twice the nodal precession frequency for any of the four EOSs: the fits are driven to spins of 730–745~Hz and to the maximum mass.

Introduction

Low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) that contain a weakly magnetized neutron star are divided into atoll and Z sources according to the tracks they trace in X-ray colour–colour diagrams and the variability that goes with each part of the track ((Hasinger & van der Klis 1989)). Their power spectra show quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) over a wide range of frequencies. In 1996 the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer (RXTE) found QPOs near 1 kHz in the Z source Sco X-1 ([59]) and in the atoll sources 4U 1728−34 ((Strohmayer et al. 1996)) and 4U 1608−52 ((Berger et al. 1996)). These kHz QPOs usually appear in pairs, the lower and upper kHz QPO, with frequencies between a few hundred hertz and about 1.3 kHz, and both move together as the source moves along its track ([57, 58]). During thermonuclear bursts several of the same sources show nearly coherent burst oscillations, which give the spin frequency of the star, for example 363 Hz in 4U 1728−34 ((Strohmayer et al. 1996)) and 581 Hz in 4U 1636−53 ((Strohmayer & Markwardt 2002)). At lower frequencies, Z sources show the horizontal-branch oscillation (HBO) at 15–60 Hz, and atoll sources show QPOs and noise components with similar properties ([58]). The frequencies of the low-frequency features are correlated with those of the kHz QPOs over a wide range, and similar correlations are found in black-hole binaries ((Psaltis et al. 1999)). Since RXTE, kHz QPOs have also been observed with the Large Area X-ray Proportional Counter (LAXPC) on AstroSat ((Chauhan et al. 2017; Anand et al. 2026)). For 4U 1728−34, Anand et al. (2024) detected 13 simultaneous triplets of a low-frequency QPO and twin kHz QPOs in a single observation, with the frequency of the lower kHz QPO measured to about 1 Hz. The kHz QPO frequencies are close to orbital frequencies a few gravitational radii from a neutron star, and most models connect them with the motion of gas in the inner accretion flow. In beat-frequency models the upper kHz QPO is an orbital frequency near the inner edge of the disc and the lower one is its beat with the stellar spin; such models were first proposed for the HBO ((Alpar & Shaham 1985; Lamb et al. 1985)) and later developed for the kHz QPOs as the sonic-point model ((Miller et al. 1998)). The separation of the two kHz QPOs, however, changes with their frequencies and is not simply related to the spin ((van der Klis 2006). Resonance models relate the two peaks to a nonlinear coupling of epicyclic oscillations of the flow (Abramowicz & Kluźniak 2001), and other models use oscillation modes of thick tori (Matuszková et al. 2024). The relativistic precession model (RPM) of Stella & Vietri (1998, 1999) identifies the upper kHz QPO with the orbital frequency, the lower kHz QPO with the periastron precession frequency, and the low-frequency QPO with the nodal precession frequency of a slightly eccentric and tilted orbit, all at the same radius. To match the observed low frequencies, the last identification was later made with twice the nodal frequency (Stella et al. 1999). The RPM uses only test-particle frequencies and has few free parameters. It has been used to estimate neutron-star masses (Török et al. 2010, 2012; du Buisson et al. 2019; Anand et al. 2024) and, for black holes, masses and spins (Motta et al. 2014, 2022). For the low-frequency QPOs of black-hole binaries, Lense–Thirring precession of a hot inner flow is a widely discussed interpretation (Ingram et al. 2009; Ingram & Motta 2019). The model also has known difficulties. The RPM masses inferred for several sources are high, about 2 M⊙_\odot or more, and depend strongly on the assumed spin (Török et al. 2010, 2012). In a study of 13 sources with known spin, van Doesburgh & van der Klis [56] found that the low-frequency QPO frequency rises more steeply with the upper kHz QPO frequency than the RPM predicts, and that it shows no clear dependence on the spin.

Of the three RPM frequencies, the nodal precession frequency is the most sensitive to the spacetime of the star. It contains the Lense–Thirring term, proportional to the dimensionless spin j=cJ/GM2j = cJ/GM^2, and a retrograde term caused by the oblateness of the star, proportional to the quadrupole q=c4Q/G2M3q = c^4Q/G^2M^3. Morsink & Stella (1999) computed these frequencies for numerical models of rapidly rotating neutron stars and showed that near the star the two terms are comparable. For a Kerr black hole q=−j2q = -j^2. For a neutron star the reduced quadrupole Qˉ=−q/j2\bar{Q} = -q/j^2 is several times larger, and its value depends on the equation of state (EOS) and the mass (Laarakkers & Poisson 1999; Pappas & Apostolatos 2012; Yagi & Yunes 2013). The orbital frequencies around neutron stars have therefore been computed in spacetimes with independent multipoles. Pappas (2012) showed how the multipole moments could be read from QPO frequencies in the RPM, Pachón et al. (2012) compared the precession frequencies of axisymmetric exterior solutions with those of numerical stars, and Maselli et al. (2020) fitted kHz QPOs of three atoll sources, including 4U 1728–34, with an accurate analytic metric of rotating neutron stars.

The Hartle–Thorne (HT) metric (Hartle 1967; Hartle & Thorne 1968) is the simplest such spacetime. It describes a rigidly rotating star to second order in its angular velocity, its exterior depends only on (M,J,Q)(M, J, Q), and it agrees well with numerical models for the spin frequencies of most known pulsars (Berti et al. 2005; Urbancová et al. 2019). Boshkayev et al. (2014, 2015) derived the epicyclic frequencies of the HT metric and used the kHz QPOs of atoll and Z sources to infer MM, JJ and QQ as free parameters. More recently they applied the RPM in HT and other spacetimes to eight neutron-star LMXBs (Boshkayev et al. 2024, 2026). Urbancová et al. (2019) gave a systematic study of the orbital and epicyclic frequencies of the HT metric for realistic EOSs, using the universal relations between II, QQ and the stellar parameters (Yagi & Yunes 2013). The same group has studied the oscillations and precession of fluid tori in this metric (Matuszková et al. 2024) and has shown that, because of the competition between the Lense–Thirring and the quadrupole terms, the nodal frequency at a given radius has a maximum as a function of jj, so that slowly and rapidly rotating stars can show the same precession frequency (Török et al. 2025). On the observational side, Anand et al. (2024) used the RPM in the Kerr metric to obtain M=1.92±0.01 M⊙M = 1.92 \pm0.01\,M_\odot for 4U 1728–34 and a moment of inertia of about 2×1045 g cm22 \times10^{45}\,\mathrm{g\,cm^2}, and estimated that a self-consistent neutron-star metric would change these values by about 1 per cent and 5 per cent.

In most of these studies the spacetime is Kerr, or jj and qq are fitted as independent parameters, or the low-frequency QPO is left out. Studies with EOS-consistent stars, such as Urbančová et al. (2019), have mainly addressed the twin kHz QPOs. Yet the EOS fixes jj and qq for a star of given mass and spin frequency, and for the atoll sources the spin frequency is known from burst oscillations. Independent EOS constraints now come from the masses of the heaviest pulsars (Fonseca et al. 2021) and from NICER pulse-profile modelling (Riley et al. 2021; Miller et al. 2021). In this paper we compute the spacetime and the orbital frequencies together from the EOS. For four EOSs we solve the HT equations, including the spin-induced change of mass and the deformed surface, and obtain (j,q,Req)(j, q, R_{\rm eq}) for any mass and spin. We compute the orbital and epicyclic frequencies from the full exterior metric without expanding in jj or qq. We then integrate eccentric, tilted geodesics around one of these stars and compute the power spectrum of a hot spot moving on them, to see how the three RPM frequencies appear in the flux. Finally, we use the RPM to infer the masses and spins of the atoll sources 4U 1636–53 and 4U 1728–34 and of the Z sources GX 5–1 and GX 340+0. We address three questions. (i) How does the quadrupole of the star change the precession frequencies compared with a black hole of the same spin? (ii) Do the precession frequencies of real orbits appear in the flux of matter moving on them? (iii) What masses and spins do the observed QPOs imply, and can the HBOs of the Z sources be nodal precession?

This is the first paper of a series. Here we treat the stars in the slow-rotation approximation, which gives the multipoles and the frequencies in closed form and makes their dependence on jj and Qˉ\bar{Q} transparent. Rapidly rotating stars, computed with numerical spacetimes, will be treated in a companion paper (Paper II), which will also test the accuracy of the approximation used here. § 2 summarises the HT stars and § 3 the orbital frequencies and the RPM. § 4 presents the stellar and orbital properties for the four EOSs, and § 5 the particle orbits and their power spectra. § 6 confronts the model with the observed QPOs, and § 7 discusses the results. The appendices give the HT equations and the derivation of the epicyclic frequencies. We use G=c=1G = c = 1 except where frequencies are quoted in Hz.

Slowly rotating stars in the Hartle–Thorne approximation

Consider a star of central energy density ϵc\epsilon_c that rotates rigidly with angular velocity Ω=2πν\Omega= 2\pi\nu. Hartle (1967) expanded the metric to second order in Ω\Omega about the nonrotating Tolman–Oppenheimer–Volkoff (TOV) solution,

ds2=−eν[1+2(h0+h2P2)]dt2+eλ[1+2(m0+m2P2)r−2m]dr2+r2[1+2k2P2][dθ2+sin⁡2θ(dϕ−ω dt)2],(1)\begin{aligned} ds^2={}&-e^\nu\left[1+2(h_0+h_2P_2)\right]dt^2\\ &+e^\lambda\left[1+\frac{2(m_0+m_2P_2)}{r-2m}\right]dr^2\\ &+r^2\left[1+2k_2P_2\right]\left[d\theta^2+\sin^2\theta(d\phi-\omega\,dt)^2\right], \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

where P2=P2(cos⁡θ)P_2=P_2(\cos\theta) is the Legendre polynomial, eλ=(1−2m/r)−1e^\lambda=(1-2m/r)^{-1}, and ν(r)\nu(r), m(r)m(r) are the TOV potential and mass function. The function ω(r)\omega(r) is of order Ω\Omega, and h0h_0, m0m_0, h2h_2, m2m_2, k2k_2 are of order Ω2\Omega^2. We first solve the TOV equations and then three perturbation problems in turn. The equations are collected in Appendix § 12; here we summarise what each one gives.

The first problem (ℓ=1\ell=1) describes frame dragging. The angular velocity of the fluid relative to the local inertial frames, ϖ=Ω−ω\varpi=\Omega-\omega, obeys a second-order equation that is regular at the centre. Matching to the exterior solution ω=2J/r3\omega=2J/r^3 gives the angular momentum JJ and the moment of inertia I=J/ΩI=J/\Omega.

The second problem (ℓ=0\ell=0) describes the spherical deformation. The functions m0m_0 and p0∗p_0^* give the change of the gravitational mass at fixed central density, δM=m0(R)+J2/R3\delta M=m_0(R)+J^2/R^3, where RR is the TOV radius. The mass that enters the exterior metric and all orbital frequencies is the total mass M=MTOV+δMM=M_{\mathrm{TOV}}+\delta M. All masses quoted in this paper are total masses of rotating stars.

The third problem (ℓ=2\ell=2) describes the quadrupolar deformation. The functions h2h_2 and v2=h2+k2v_2=h_2+k_2 obey two coupled first-order equations. Matching them to the exterior solution fixes a constant KK and the quadrupole moment

Q=−(J2M+85KM3).(2)Q=-\left(\frac{J^2}{M}+\frac{8}{5}KM^3\right). \tag*{(2)}

We use the Geroch–Hansen sign convention, in which an oblate star has Q<0Q<0 and the Kerr metric has Q=−J2/MQ=-J^2/M. The dimensionless spin and quadrupole are j=J/M2j=J/M^2 and q=Q/M3q=Q/M^3. We also use the reduced quadrupole

Qˉ=−qj2=−QMJ2,(3)\bar{Q}=-\frac{q}{j^2}=-\frac{QM}{J^2}, \tag*{(3)}

which equals unity for a Kerr black hole and lies between about 1.5 and 12 for the neutron stars considered here (Figure 1). In the Hartle–Thorne (HT) approximation J∝ΩJ\propto\Omega and Q,δM∝Ω2Q,\delta M\propto\Omega^2 at fixed central density, so to leading order Qˉ\bar{Q} depends on the EOS and the mass but not on the spin.

Figure 1. Stellar properties for the four EOSs. (a) Mass–radius relations of nonrotating stars. (b) Dimensionless spin j=cJ/GM2j=cJ/GM^2 at νs=363\nu_s=363 Hz (thick) and 581 Hz (thin). (c) Reduced quadrupole Qˉ=−q/j2\bar{Q}=-q/j^2 at 363 Hz; the dotted line is the Kerr value. (d) ISCO radius (thick) and equatorial radius (thin) in units of MM at 581 Hz. The disc ends at the larger of the two.

The surface of the rotating star is r(θ)=R+ξ0+ξ2P2(cos⁡θ)r(\theta)=R+\xi_0+\xi_2P_2(\cos\theta), with ξ0\xi_0 and ξ2\xi_2 from the ℓ=0\ell=0 and ℓ=2\ell=2 pressure perturbations (Appendix § 12). The equatorial coordinate radius Req=R+ξ0−ξ2/2R_{\mathrm{eq}}=R+\xi_0-\xi_2/2 is the radius at which an accretion disc would touch the star, in the same coordinate as the exterior metric. The circumferential equatorial radius is Req,circ=Req(1−k2/2)R_{\mathrm{eq,circ}}=R_{\mathrm{eq}}(1-k_2/2), which is the quantity measured by pulse-profile modelling.

Outside the star the metric functions are known in closed form (Hartle & Thorne 1968). With ξ=r/M−1\xi=r/M-1 and the associated Legendre functions of the second kind Q21Q_2^1, Q22Q_2^2 (Appendix B),

ω=2Jr3,h0=J2r3(r−2M),m0=−J2r3,\omega=\frac{2J}{r^3},\qquad h_0=\frac{J^2}{r^3(r-2M)},\qquad m_0=-\frac{J^2}{r^3},
h2=J2Mr3(1+Mr)+KQ22(ξ),h_2=\frac{J^2}{Mr^3}\left(1+\frac{M}{r}\right)+KQ_2^2(\xi),
v2=−J2r4+K2Mr(r−2M)Q21(ξ).(4)v_2=-\frac{J^2}{r^4}+K\frac{2M}{\sqrt{r(r-2M)}}Q_2^1(\xi). \tag*{(4)}

with m2=(r−2M)(−h2+6J2/r4)m_2=(r-2M)(-h_2+6J^2/r^4) and k2=v2−h2k_2=v_2-h_2. The metric depends on (M,J,Q)(M,J,Q) only, so for given (M,j,q)(M,j,q) the exterior and all orbital frequencies are fixed, whatever the interior. The EOS enters through the map (M,νs)↦(j,q,Req)(M,\nu_s)\mapsto(j,q,R_{\mathrm{eq}}). Because the metric is correct to O(Ω2)\mathcal{O}(\Omega^2), setting q=−j2q=-j^2 reproduces the Kerr metric to O(j2)\mathcal{O}(j^2), which is a useful check of the frequencies (Appendix C).

Orbital frequencies and the relativistic precession model

Circular orbits and epicyclic frequencies

Consider a test particle on a prograde circular orbit of radius rr in the equatorial plane of a stationary, axisymmetric, reflection-symmetric metric with components gttg_{tt}, gtϕg_{t\phi}, gϕϕg_{\phi\phi}, grrg_{rr}, gθθg_{\theta\theta}. The coordinate angular velocity Ωϕ=dϕ/dt\Omega_\phi=d\phi/dt follows from the radial geodesic equation,

Ωϕ=−gtϕ,r+gtϕ,r2−gtt,rgϕϕ,rgϕϕ,r,(5)\Omega_\phi=\frac{-g_{t\phi,r}+\sqrt{g_{t\phi,r}^2-g_{tt,r}g_{\phi\phi,r}}}{g_{\phi\phi,r}}, \tag*{(5)}

References

  1. [56]van Doesburgh M., van der Klis M., 2017, MNRAS, 465, 3581
  2. [57]van der Klis M., 2000, ARA&A, 38, 717
  3. [58]van der Klis M., 2006, in Lewin W. H. G., van der Klis M., eds, Cambridge Astrophysics Series, Vol. 39, Compact Stellar X-ray Sources. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p. 39 (arXiv:astro-ph/0410551)
  4. [59]van der Klis M., Swank J. H., Zhang W., Jahoda K., Morgan E. H., Lewin W. H. G., Vaughan B., van Paradijs J., 1996, ApJ, 469, L1

Paper details

vlnc:W_2c3z22f2
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents