betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Multiplet structure of chromium(III) dopants in wide band gap materials

Abstract

Transition metal doping is commonly used for altering the properties of solid-state materials to suit applications in science and technology. Partially filled dd-shells of transition metal atoms lead to electronic states with diverse spatial and spin symmetries. Chromium(III) cations have shown great potential for designing laser materials and, more recently, for developing spin qubits in quantum applications. They also represent an intriguing class of chemical systems with strongly correlated multi-reference excited states, due to the d3d^3 electron configuration. These states are difficult to describe accurately using single-reference quantum chemical methods such as density functional theory (DFT), the most commonly used method to study the electronic structures of solid-state systems. Recently, the periodic effective Hamiltonian of crystal field (pEHCF) method has been shown to overcome some limitations arising in the calculations of excited dd-states. In this work, we assess the suitability of DFT and pEHCF to calculate the electronic structure and dd-dd excitations of chromium(III) dopants in wide band gap host materials. The results will aid computational development of novel transition metal-doped materials and provide a deeper understanding of the complex nature of transition metal dopants in solids.

Introduction

Solid-state materials containing transition metal dopants are widely used in many areas of science and engineering, including optoelectronics [1, 2], optics [3, 4], laser technologies [5, 6, 7], photovoltaics and photoelectrochemistry [8, 9], spintronics [10], semiconductors [10, 11, 12], and quantum computing [13, 14]. The distinct properties of transition metal atoms primarily stem from the partially filled dd-shells, which lead to a rich multiplet structure of the electronic spectrum, including states with different spatial and spin symmetries and respective degrees of degeneracy. The structure of dd-multiplets can be fine-tuned by targeting doping sites with particular symmetries and modifying the host material to affect dopant–host interactions. Chromium(III) (Cr3+\mathrm{Cr}^{3+}) is an attractive dopant choice as its d3d^3 electronic configuration and corresponding multiplet structure make it a useful candidate for laser materials [15, 16] and spin qubits [13]. For example, Sewani et al. [13] demonstrated optical initialization and read-out, along with long relaxation times, for the S=3/2S = 3/2 spin population associated with Cr3+\mathrm{Cr}^{3+} dopants in Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_2\mathrm{O}_3, where SS is the spin quantum number. Continued investigations of Cr3+\mathrm{Cr}^{3+} and other transition metal dopants in different host materials will prove fruitful for quantum technologies by providing a rich set of systems for extended applications.

Dopants with open dd-shells exhibit electronic correlation effects [17] of both static and dynamical nature, which occur due to the strong electron–electron interactions characteristic of dd-electrons. Static correlations appear when the ground state (or an excited state of interest) exhibits a multi-reference character, i.e. it cannot be represented quantitatively by a single Slater determinant (see Benavides-Riveros et al. [18] and references therein for further details). Such correlation effects are present in systems with electron (quasi-)degeneracy, which are typical for the dd-states of transition metals in highly symmetrical crystal fields [19], either ideal or slightly distorted. These strongly-correlated materials pose a significant challenge to computational research [20, 21] as the electronic structure of dd-multiplets cannot be adequately captured by standard density functional theory [22, 23] (DFT) methods, which are commonly employed to investigate the electronic structures of solid-state systems. Limitations of DFT are most pronounced when calculating the dd-dd excitations and band gaps of strongly-correlated systems. Advanced methods based on hybrid density functional approximations can yield better results than standard semi-local functionals [24], however these solutions are not universal and have limitations on the types of excitations that can be accurately predicted [25].

This highlights the pressing requirement to search beyond DFT for more reliable methods for electronic structure calculations. One of the most direct ways for addressing strong correlations involves the use of post-Hartree-Fock approaches, such as complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) [26], second-order Møller–Plesset perturbation theory [27] and coupled cluster methods [28]. While examples of applying post-Hartree-Fock treatment to solid-state materials exist in the literature [29, 30, 31], the range of applications is limited due to a strong scaling with system size. CASSCF has occasionally been used to calculate the energies of local dd-dd excitations in small (finite) clusters that represent the first coordination sphere of a transition metal atom in a crystalline system [14]. This approach is, however, associated with significant underestimation of the delocalization effects taking place in extended systems. An alternative to post-Hartree-Fock approaches is to combine multiple electronic structure methods within a hybrid embedding approach, whereby the electronic structure of localized dd-shells is treated using a correlated method and the host is described within a weakly correlated (e.g. one-electron self-consistent field) treatment. Such hybrid approach allows one to reduce computational costs while providing a multi-reference description of strongly correlated dd-electrons. One of the examples of hybrid electronic structure methods used in solid state theory is dynamical mean-field theory [32].

In our previous work [33] we extended a hybrid embedding method, called the effective Hamiltonian of crystal field (EHCF), [34, 35] to periodic systems (pEHCF). pEHCF has been shown to be successful in describing the dd-multiplet structure of various solid materials including oxides [33], carbodiimides and metal-organic frameworks [36, 37]. In this work, we evaluate and compare the suitability of DFT and pEHCF to investigate the electronic structure and dd–dd excitations of Cr3+^{3+} dopants in three wide band gap host materials: corundum (α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3), aluminium oxonitridoborate (AlB4_4O6_6N) [38] and chrysoberyl (BeAl2_2O4_4).

α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3 with Cr3+^{3+} dopants is a well-known laser material [15, 39] with excellent optical properties and distinctive fluorescence which has been also explored for quantum applications [13]. AlB4_4O6_6N recently synthesized by Widmann et al. [38] possesses interesting fluorescence and luminescence properties as well as high thermal stability. Finally, BeAl2_2O4_4 has been widely utilized in solid-state laser technologies due to its exceptional emission properties in the 700–800 nm range [40]. All three host materials show characteristics that are promising for quantum technologies which will benefit from deeper understanding of the complex electronic structure of transition metal dopants in solids provided in this study.

Methodology

Periodic Effective Hamiltonian of Crystal Field

The periodic effective Hamiltonian of crystal field (pEHCF) method splits the electronic system into two subsystems, where one contains only the local dd-shell(s) of transition metal atoms and the other includes the crystalline environment embedding these shells [33]. The idea of such division of the electronic system into subsystems was first proposed by Harrison [41], who considered the electronic structure of transition metal oxides as delocalized s,ps,p-bands augmented with local dd-multiplets. Mathematically, this splitting is performed by separating a space of one-electron states into dd- and ll-subspaces spanned by local atomic dd- and s,ps,p-orbitals, respectively. Transition metal s,ps,p-orbitals are included in the ll-subsystems along with the orbitals of light elements. The many-electron wavefunction of the system is expressed using (1):

Ψ=Ψd(nd)∧Ψl(N−nd)(1)\Psi= \Psi_d(n_d) \wedge\Psi_l(N-n_d) \tag*{(1)}

where Ψd\Psi_d and Ψl\Psi_l are the many-electron wavefunctions built in the dd- and ll- subspaces, respectively, ndn_d is the number of electrons in the dd-subspace, NN is the total number of electrons in the system, and ∧\wedge stands for the antisymmetric product. The wavefunctions Ψd\Psi_d and Ψl\Psi_l are treated differently. In the case of an impurity ion, its strongly correlated dd-shell is described by a full configuration interaction wavefunction:

Ψd(nd)=∑iciΨi(nd)(2)\Psi_d(n_d) = \sum_i c_i\Psi_i(n_d) \tag*{(2)}

where the summation goes over all configurations, Ψi\Psi_i, with coefficients cic_i, built on dd-orbitals of the impurity ion. This accounts for correlations in the dd-shell and accurately reproduces both the energy and spin multiplicity of the excited dd-multiplets. The non-correlated ll-subsystem is treated using the Hartree-Fock method with the single-determinant wavefunction in the basis of the Bloch states constructed from the s,ps,p-atomic orbitals of the system [33].

The wavefunction in (1) assumes the number of electrons in both dd- and ll-subsystems to be fixed and therefore excludes charge transfer states. The presence of such states is taken into account in pEHCF by the Löwdin partitioning technique [42], which provides effective corrections to the Hamiltonian operators of the subsystems arising due to the electron hopping between them [33, 34]. This results in the effective Hamiltonian for the dd-subsystem, Hdeff\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{eff}}_d, having the following form:

Hdeff=∑μν∑σ(Hμνd+Hμνcoul+Hμνres)dμσ†dνσ+12∑μνλη∑στ⟨μν∣λη⟩dμσ†dλτ†dητdνσ+h.c.(3)\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{eff}}_d = \sum_{\mu\nu}\sum_\sigma\left(\mathcal{H}^{d}_{\mu\nu}+\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{coul}}_{\mu\nu}+\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{res}}_{\mu\nu}\right)d^\dagger_{\mu\sigma}d_{\nu\sigma} + \frac{1}{2}\sum_{\mu\nu\lambda\eta}\sum_{\sigma\tau}\langle\mu\nu|\lambda\eta\rangle d^\dagger_{\mu\sigma}d^\dagger_{\lambda\tau}d_{\eta\tau}d_{\nu\sigma}+\mathrm{h.c.} \tag*{(3)}

where dμσ†d^\dagger_{\mu\sigma} and dμσd_{\mu\sigma} are the electron creation and annihilation operators, respectively, for the μ\mu-th dd-orbital, σ\sigma and τ\tau correspond to the spin projection, and h.c. is the Hermitian conjugate. The second term includes two-electron one-center integrals ⟨μν∣λη⟩\langle\mu\nu|\lambda\eta\rangle over atomic dd-orbitals and describes the two-electron Coulomb interactions within the dd-shell. The one-electron part of Hdeff\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{eff}}_d includes the bare Hamiltonian of the dd-subsystem (Hd\mathcal{H}^d), and both Coulomb (Hcoul\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{coul}}) and resonance (Hres\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{res}}) interactions of dd-electrons with electrons and nuclei in the ll-subsystem. Contributions from Hcoul\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{coul}} and Hres\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{res}} determine the “splitting parameter” of the dd-orbitals, as referred to within the crystal field theory. In pEHCF, unlike in the crystal field theory, the main contribution to the splitting of dd-orbitals is the resonance interactions [33, 34] corresponding to the one-electron transfers between the dd- and ll-subsystems. Therefore, Hres\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{res}} is the most important factor when analyzing variations in the splitting parameters during spin-crossover processes. The matrix elements of Hres\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{res}} have the following form [33, 43]:

Hμνres=∑a,bβμaβνb(RGab+(−Id)+RGab−(−Ad))(4)\mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{res}}_{\mu\nu} = \sum_{a,b}\beta_{\mu a}\beta_{\nu b}\left(\mathcal{R}\mathcal{G}^{+}_{ab}(-I_d)+\mathcal{R}\mathcal{G}^{-}_{ab}(-A_d)\right) \tag*{(4)}

where the summation is over atomic orbitals (AOs) a and b of the ll-subsystem, βμa\beta_{\mu a} are resonance (hopping) integrals between the μ\mu-th dd-orbital and ll-AO a, and IdI_d and AdA_d are the ionization potential and electron affinity, respectively, of the dd-subsystem. The orbital-projected Green’s functions, Gab±G_{ab}^{\pm}, of the ll-subsystem are expressed as:

Gab+(ε)=lim⁡δ→0+∑n,k(1−fnk)⟨a∣nk⟩⟨nk∣b⟩ε−εnk+iδ(5)G_{ab}^{+}(\varepsilon)=\lim_{\delta\to0^{+}}\sum_{n,\mathbf{k}}(1-f_{nk})\frac{\langle a|nk\rangle\langle nk|b\rangle}{\varepsilon-\varepsilon_{nk}+i\delta} \tag*{(5)}
Gab−(ε)=lim⁡δ→0+∑n,kfnk⟨a∣nk⟩⟨nk∣b⟩ε−εnk+iδ(6)G_{ab}^{-}(\varepsilon)=\lim_{\delta\to0^{+}}\sum_{n,\mathbf{k}}f_{nk}\frac{\langle a|nk\rangle\langle nk|b\rangle}{\varepsilon-\varepsilon_{nk}+i\delta} \tag*{(6)}

In Equations (5) and (6), k\mathbf{k} is a vector in the first Brillouin zone, nn enumerates bands of the ll-subsystem, and εnk\varepsilon_{nk} and fnkf_{nk} are energies and occupation numbers, respectively, of the ll-bands. Spin variables are omitted for clarity. As can be seen, the resonance term (and therefore the splitting of the dd-orbitals) depends on three main factors: the geometry of the first coordination sphere through the resonance integrals between local atomic orbitals (βμa\beta_{\mu a}), the occupations of local atomic orbitals forming the first coordination sphere, and the energy difference between dd-states and the valence/conduction bands of the ll-subsystem.

Solving the linear Schrödinger equation for the wavefunction of the dd-system, as shown in Equation (2), with the effective Hamiltonian in Equation (3) produces the whole spectrum of energies for the dd-multiplets with all allowed spins and symmetries, among them the ground state. pEHCF electronic structure calculations were performed for geometries obtained by DFT with use of the r2^{2}SCAN [44] meta-generalized gradient approximation as described below.

Density Functional Theory Calculations

Kohn-Sham DFT [22, 23] calculations were performed using version 6.4.1 of the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP) [45, 46, 47] software within the spin-polarized framework, with the Be (s1.99p0.01s^{1.99}p^{0.01}), B (2s22p12s^{2}2p^{1}), and O (2s22p42s^{2}2p^{4}), Al (3s23p13s^{2}3p^{1}), and Cr_sv (3s23p63d54s13s^{2}3p^{6}3d^{5}4s^{1}) projector-augmented wave pseudopotentials [46, 48]. The r2^{2}SCAN [44] meta-generalized gradient approximation (meta-GGA) and the HSE06 [49, 50] range-separated hybrid generalized gradient approximation were used to perform geometry optimization of the structures and their corresponding density of states. Converged plane-wave cut-off energies of 700 eV, 700 eV, and 750 eV were used for the Al2_2O3_3, BeAl2_2O4_4, and AlB4_4O6_6N hosts, respectively. Furthermore, a reciprocal space grid (kk-grid) of size 4×4×24 \times4 \times2 was used for the primitive unit cells. Convergence tests for the plane-wave cut-off energy and kk-point mesh were performed until the total energies from single-point calculations were converged to within 1 meV atom−1^{-1}. All undoped structures were optimized until the residual forces on all ions were less than 0.001 eV Å−1^{-1} while for the defect supercells the convergence criterion of forces on all ions was set to 0.01 eV Å−1^{-1}. The energy convergence criterion for geometry optimizations was set to 10−610^{-6} eV. For the defect structures, 2×2×12 \times2 \times1 expanded supercells of 120, 168, and 192 atoms were used for α-Al2_2O3_3, BeAl2_2O4_4, and AlB4_4O6_6N, respectively, to reduce interactions between periodic images of the defects. Delta Self-Consistent Field (Δ\DeltaSCF) calculations were performed to determine the electronic excited states and the corresponding absorption energies [51, 52]. This method is known to be highly effective for calculating excitation energies in quantum defects [53]. The Δ\DeltaSCF occupation for the spin-up and spin-down components at each kk-point was manually set to fix the electron configuration of the system. This provides the total energy of the excited structure without relaxing the geometry. We use this method to simulate the vertical excitations of the first and second excited states of crystal hosts.

Results and Discussion

The crystal lattices of α-Al2_2O3_3, AlB4_4O6_6N, and BeAl2_2O4_4 correspond to trigonal, hexagonal and orthorhombic systems with space groups R3ˉ\bar{3}c [54], P63_3mc [38] and Pbnm [55], respectively. Their experimental crystal parameters along with the values calculated by r2^{2}SCAN and HSE06 are collected in Table I. The calculated values are within 1% of the reported experimental data for all three structures. In all materials, the Cr3+^{3+} dopant substitutes an aluminium cation (Al3+^{3+}), leading to the formation of six-coordinate dopant sites of various symmetries, as shown in Figure 1. The geometries of the Cr3+^{3+} dopant in each host, obtained with use of r2^{2}SCAN and HSE06, are illustrated in Figure 2 (all structures are given in Supplementary Information †). The dopant site in AlB4_4O6_6N is of high OhO_h symmetry with minimal distortion from the perfect octahedral coordination characterized by bond length deviation not exceeding 0.01 Å and bond angles deviating from the perfect 90° by 0.8°. α-Al2_2O3_3 also has a single dopant site that exhibits C3C_3 symmetry and BeAl2_2O4_4 has two dopant sites characterized by CsC_s (Wyckoff position 4cc) and CiC_i (Wyckoff position 4aa) local symmetry point groups. In all cases, the geometries of the coordination spheres are close to that of a regular octahedron, with fairly small distortions resulting in symmetry lowering. In CrAl3+^{3+}_{\mathrm{Al}}:α-Al2_2O3_3, the distortion is characterized by a maximum deviation of 0.05 Å in Cr–O bond lengths and a deviation of 10° in bond angles, whereas in the case of CrAl3+^{3+}_{\mathrm{Al}}:BeAl2_2O4_4 these values are 0.09 Å and 10°, respectively. Due to this, we use the notations of irreducible representations of the OhO_h point group to label electronic states in all three systems and separately discuss splittings of the high-symmetry multiplets caused by the imperfections of dopant sites. As follows from the Tanabe-Sugano diagram of the d3d^3 configuration in an octahedral field, Cr3+^{3+} cations must always have a high-spin quartet (S=3/2S=3/2) ground state (4A2{}^{4}A_2), and a set of low-spin quartet and doublet (S=1/2S=1/2) excited states, the order and energies of which depend on the interactions of the Cr3+^{3+} dopant with its host. Transitions between these states correspond to the class of crystal field dd-dd excitations and can be experimentally probed via ultraviolet–visible and photoluminescence spectroscopy. We further test the capabilities of DFT and pEHCF in reproducing the energies and spin-symmetries of excited dd-multiplets of Cr3+\mathrm{Cr}^{3+} dopants.

Figure 1. Crystalline structures of Cr3+^{3+}-doped (a) α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3, (b) AlB4_4O6_6N, and BeAl2_2O4_4 at (c) CsC_s- and (d) CiC_i-symmetrized sites. Cell boundaries are shown with black dotted lines. All shown crystalline structures are available in Supplementary Information for both r2^2SCAN and HSE06 functionals.†^\dagger

Ground-state geometries of the Cr coordination sphere and the splitting diagrams of the one-electron d-states

Figure 2. Ground-state geometries of the Cr coordination sphere and the splitting diagrams of the one-electron dd-states for (a) α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3, (b) AlB4_4O6_6N, and BeAl2_2O4_4 at (c) CsC_s- and (d) CiC_i-sites. The corresponding splitting parameters of the one-electron dd-states calculated with r2^2SCAN, HSE06, and pEHCF are presented in Table II.

First, we analyse the one-electron states of the three systems, as calculated using DFT and pEHCF methods. The atomic orbital-projected density of states (DOS) for the ground states of Cr3+\mathrm{Cr}^{3+}-doped α\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3}, AlB4O6N\mathrm{AlB}_{4}\mathrm{O}_{6}\mathrm{N}, and BeAl2O4\mathrm{BeAl}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{4} are shown in Figure 3. For all systems, as can be seen from the r2^{2}SCAN-calculated DOS, the narrow dd-bands of Cr3+\mathrm{Cr}^{3+} lie within the gap between the wide spsp valence and conduction bands of the host. The small width of the dd-bands indicates a small degree of coupling between the dd-shell and spsp-states, supporting the assumption regarding the locality of dd-shells that is employed within pEHCF. In the case of DFT, there is a minor contribution from the oxygen 2p2p states in the gap states reflecting a small degree of hybridization with the chromium 3d3d states. The pEHCF-calculated DOS plots qualitatively agree with DFT regarding the position of the one-electron dd-states and the structure of the frontier spsp-bands. The valence band of the spsp-subsystem mostly comprises oxygen 2p2p orbitals for each host material, whereas the conduction band has significant contributions from aluminium 3p3p orbitals. If the concentration of Cr3+\mathrm{Cr}^{3+} dopants is sufficiently low, the gap between the valence and conduction spsp-bands should be close to the band gap of the host material.

Atomic orbital-projected density of states for Cr3+-doped α-Al2O3, AlB4O6N and BeAl2O4(Cs)

Figure 3. The atomic orbital-projected density of states (DOS) for Cr3+^{3+}-doped (a) α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3, (b) AlB4_4O6_6N and (c) BeAl2_2O4_4 (CsC_s), as calculated using the r2^2SCAN, HSE06 and pEHCF. The total density of states, chromium 3dd, oxygen 2pp and aluminium 3pp states are shown in gray, red, green and blue, respectively. Other atomic orbitals are not shown for clarity. For the purpose of comparison across all three methods, the position of the reference point on the energy axis is chosen such that the top of the spsp-valence band corresponds to 0 eV. In pEHCF, the peaks corresponding to the dd-states indicate the position of the one-electron dd-orbitals. This representation does not fully reflect the complexity of the electronic structure of the dd-system containing multi-reference many-electron multiplets described by pEHCF.

Our calculations show that for the given unit cells, the spsp-band gaps of the doped materials are smaller than the band gaps of the pure hosts by 0.1–0.2 eV, which can be compared against corresponding experimental values. Experimental values of the band gap of α\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} have been reported to range from 8.15–9.40 eV depending on conditions [57], while the reported experimental value for BeAl2O4\mathrm{BeAl}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{4} is 9.00 eV [58]. The calculated values of the band gap are compared to the available experimental data in Table II. It shows that pEHCF systematically overestimates the gap by 0.50–1.50 eV for CrAl3+:α\mathrm{Cr}_{\mathrm{Al}}^{3+}:\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} and by 2.00 eV for CrAl3+:BeAl2O4\mathrm{Cr}_{\mathrm{Al}}^{3+}:\mathrm{BeAl}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{4} as the Hartree-Fock method is used to calculate the electronic structure of the spsp-subsystem. In contrast, r2^{2}SCAN underestimates the band gap by about 1.5 eV for both materials whilst HSE06 gives the improved values of 8.15 eV for α\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} and 8.38 eV for BeAl2O4\mathrm{BeAl}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{4}. No experimental band gap value has been reported for AlB4O6N\mathrm{AlB}_{4}\mathrm{O}_{6}\mathrm{N}, but we calculate a band gap of 9.78 eV using HSE06. Other reported theoretical band gap values range from 7.32–9.31 eV, depending on the computational method [38].

Splitting diagrams for the one-electron dd-states and the ground state, as calculated with pEHCF, r2^{2}SCAN and HSE06, are shown in Figure 2. All methods qualitatively follow the same symmetry considerations, exhibiting a significant t2gt_{2g}–ege_g splitting characteristic of an octahedral crystal field. An additional minor splitting within the three-fold degenerate t2gt_{2g} manifold is present in CrAl3+:α\mathrm{Cr}_{\mathrm{Al}}^{3+}:\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} (C3C_{3} symmetry), while full degeneracy lifting occurs for CrAl3+:BeAl2O4\mathrm{Cr}_{\mathrm{Al}}^{3+}:\mathrm{BeAl}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{4}, which possesses lower-symmetry (CsC_{s} and CiC_{i}) dopant sites. Quantitatively, the absolute magnitudes of crystal-field splittings differ significantly between pEHCF and the DFT methods (Table II). For instance, the r2^{2}SCAN splitting of t2gt_{2g}–ege_g has values of around 4.00–4.40 eV; HSE06 provides splittings of 6.10–6.60 eV, while pEHCF shows splittings of 2.08–3.47 eV. This disparity is to be expected due to the nature of the one-electron energies in both methods. pEHCF splitting diagrams correspond to the eigenvalues of the one-electron part of the effective Hamiltonian, whereas energy levels produced by DFT already include an effect of dd-dd electron interactions. From this point of view, pEHCF produces splitting parameters that are usually discussed in the literature related to spectroscopy of transition metal ions, such as 10Dq10Dq in the OhO_{h} crystal field.

Many-electron multiplet energies calculated using r2^{2}SCAN, HSE06, and pEHCF are detailed in Tables III, Table IV, and Table V for the three materials, where they are compared against experimental values. Theoretically, the simplest transition is 4A2→4T2{}^{4}A_{2}\rightarrow{}^{4}T_{2}, which corresponds to the promotion of one electron from the t2gt_{2g}-orbital to the ege_g-orbital. Both multiplets can be accurately described using a single determinant wavefunction [19]; the effect of static correlations should therefore be minor. r2^{2}SCAN and HSE06 accurately reproduce the energy of this transition for all materials with absolute errors compared to experiment ranging between 0.10–0.15 eV, and pEHCF also provides the same level of accuracy. As shown in Table III, CASSCF calculations previously performed [14] for a finite [CrO6]9−[\mathrm{CrO}_{6}]^{9-} cluster cut out from Cr3+:Al2O3\mathrm{Cr}^{3+}:\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} give slightly larger errors for the 4A2→4T2{}^{4}A_{2}\rightarrow{}^{4}T_{2} transition as compared to DFT and pEHCF.

TransitionExperimentpEHCFr2^{2}SCANHSE06
4A2→2E^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{2}E1.811.911.251.12
4A2→2T1^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{2}T_{1}1.891.99; 2.01--
4A2→4T2^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{4}T_{2}2.432.40; 2.42; 2.442.462.49
4A2→2T2^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{2}T_{2}2.702.89; 2.92--
4A2→4T1^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{4}T_{1}3.263.30; 3.323.493.46

Table IV. Calculated energies (in eV) of excited dd-multiplets of Cr3+^{3+}:AlB4_4O6_6N using different quantum mechanical methods compared to photoluminescence excitation and emission spectroscopy data for the 4A2→2E^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{2}E transition from Widmann et al. [38].

TransitionExperiment\multicolumn{3}{c}{Cs_{s} site}\multicolumn{3}{c}{Ci_{i} site}
pEHCFr2^{2}SCANHSE06pEHCFr2^{2}SCANHSE06
4A2→2E^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{2}E1.821.89; 1.901.271.171.80; 1.891.221.15
4A2→2T1^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{2}T_{1}1.911.95; 1.99; 2.00--1.91; 2.01; 2.04--
4A2→4T2^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{4}T_{2}2.102.34; 2.41; 2.522.182.162.72; 2.91; 2.952.472.49
4A2→2T2^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{2}T_{2}-2.91; 2.95; 2.96--3.00; 3.04; 3.09--
4A2→4T1^{4}A_{2} \rightarrow^{4}T_{1}3.023.23; 3.372.982.723.643.163.02

Table V. Calculated energies (in eV) of excited dd-multiplets of Cr3+^{3+}:BeAl2_2O4_4 using different quantum mechanical methods compared to ultraviolet–visible spectroscopy data from Demirbas et al. [63].

Other excited states, such as 2E{}^{2}E, have significant multireference character, and correct description of their electronic structure is therefore much more challenging for DFT. As has been previously shown with Δ\DeltaSCF, the low-spin excited states may not be achievable or could be significantly underestimated with respect to experimental values [59]. This is clearly illustrated by the results for the 2E{}^{2}E multiplet that presents an interest for Cr3+\mathrm{Cr}^{3+}-based spin qubits as it plays an important role in the inter-system crossing pathway [59]. Both r2^{2}SCAN and HSE06 consistently underestimate the energy of the 2E{}^{2}E state as compared to experiments, with absolute errors ranging between 0.50–0.60 eV. At the same time, pEHCF provides good accuracy for the 4A2→2E{}^{4}A_{2}\rightarrow{}^{2}E lines for all materials, with absolute errors ranging between 0.07–0.11 eV. The 2T1{}^{2}T_{1} and 2T2{}^{2}T_{2} states are even more complicated, as their energies cannot be calculated using Δ\DeltaSCF at all due to their multireference nature. This is because their many-determinant wavefunctions cannot be approximated by the one-electron population matrix that is used to set up a trial Kohn-Sham wavefunction in Δ\DeltaSCF. Full configuration interaction treatment of the dd-shell, as implemented in pEHCF, permits the 2T1{}^{2}T_{1} and 2T2{}^{2}T_{2} wavefunctions to be determined and results in energies that are in good agreement with experimental data for all systems.

Regarding the second excited quartet state, 4T1{}^{4}T_{1}, all methods agree well with experimental data. For CrAl3+:α\mathrm{Cr}_{\mathrm{Al}}^{3+}:\alpha-Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3}, pEHCF successfully captures the reported experimental values ranging from 3.01–3.12 eV [60, 61, 62]. r2^{2}SCAN and HSE06 give excitation energies of 3.31 eV and 3.05 eV, respectively. For CrAl3+^{3+}_{\mathrm{Al}}:AlB4_4O6_6N, the second excited quartet is calculated to be 3.30 eV in pEHCF and 3.46–3.49 eV by DFT methods, which can be compared to the experimental value of 3.26 eV [38]. Finally, for CrAl3+^{3+}_{\mathrm{Al}}:BeAl2_2O4_4 the experimentally reported value of 3.02 eV [63] agrees well with our r2^2SCAN-calculated energy of 2.98 eV for the CsC_s-symmetrized site and our HSE06-calculated energy of 3.02 eV for the CiC_i-symmetrized site. In contrast, pEHCF overestimates the energy of 4A2→4T1^4A_2 \rightarrow^4T_1 transition by 0.20 eV and 0.10 eV for the CsC_s- and CiC_i-symmetrized sites, respectively.

α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3AlB4_4O6_6NBeAl2_2O4_4
Exp. [56]r2^2SCANHSE06Exp. [38]r2^2SCANHSE06Exp. [55]r2^2SCANHSE06
aa4.764.764.755.035.035.029.429.409.39
bb––––––5.485.475.47
cc12.9812.9812.968.238.238.224.434.424.41

Table 1. Experimental (Exp.) lattice parameters (in Å) of α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3, AlB4_4O6_6N, and BeAl2_2O4_4 compared to the DFT calculations performed in this work.

We also note an interesting discrepancy with experimental data for CrAl3+^{3+}_{\mathrm{Al}}:BeAl2_2O4_4 at the CiC_i dopant site. As shown in Table V, the pEHCF-, r2^2SCAN-, and HSE06-calculated energies for the 4A2→4T2^4A_2 \rightarrow^4T_2 transition are in good agreement with the experimentally observed line for the CsC_s dopant site. However, for the CiC_i dopant site, the 4A2→4T2^4A_2 \rightarrow^4T_2 transition is significantly overestimated by all computational methods: by around 0.6–0.9 eV with pEHCF and 0.4 eV with DFT. This indicates that the CsC_s dopant site might be largely responsible for the experimental emission, whereas the CiC_i dopant site plays a minor role. This conclusion is further supported by our DFT calculations showing that Cr3+^{3+} in the CsC_s-symmetrized site lies lower in energy than the CiC_i-symmetrized site by 0.17 eV and 0.19 eV for r2^2SCAN and HSE06, respectively. A wide range of experimental studies confirm the preference of the CsC_s site. For instance, electron paramagnetic resonance and optical absorption spectroscopic analyses of BeAl2_2O4_4 indicate that 75% of Cr3+^{3+} ions substitute the CsC_s-symmetrized site [64]. Using X-ray absorption spectroscopy, Bordage et al. [65] also confirmed Cr3+^{3+} substitution at the CsC_s-symmetrized site to be 70%. These experimental findings are consistent with our computational results suggesting that the optical features observed experimentally predominantly correspond to Cr3+^{3+} substitution at the energetically and structurally favoured CsC_s-symmetrized site.

Our results show that, for the excited multiplets of Cr3+^{3+}, r2^2SCAN and HSE06 functionals consistently give close energy values and perform particularly well for the high-spin states. Previous work on NV-like defects has shown that both hybrid density-functional approximation and meta-GGA can yield reliable predictions for the formation energy and charge transition levels [66]. However, as shown in Ref. [67], HSE06 may fail for transition metal containing systems due to the Coulombic interactions between localised dd-electrons not being sufficiently screened. This results in an incomplete removal of self-interaction error and violation of the generalised Koopmans’ condition. This makes r2^2SCAN a competitive, lower-cost alternative to hybrid density-functional approximations for systems containing transition metal atoms, particularly when combined with the pEHCF multi-reference treatment of the dd-shell.

Conclusions

In this work, we have used the r2^2SCAN meta-generalized gradient approximation and the range-separated HSE06 hybrid density-functional approximation, alongside the wavefunction-based pEHCF method, to investigate the electronic structure of the low-lying dd-dd excited states of chromium(III) dopants in three wide band gap materials. Our results demonstrate that the energy of the 4A2→4T2^4A_2 \to^4T_2 and 4A2→4T1^4A_2 \to^4T_1 transitions between single-reference quartet states can be accurately described by all three methods with a similar level of accuracy. r2^2SCAN and HSE06 yield similar results for the high-spin excited states, making r2^2SCAN an accurate and relatively low-cost density-functional approximation compared to HSE06. At the same time, high-spin to low-spin transitions are much more difficult to capture with DFT methods. However, as the pEHCF method treats open dd-shells at the configuration interaction level, the energies of all the transitions can be calculated at a high level of accuracy. A combination of DFT and pEHCF, therefore, provides a reliable tool for the quantitative study of transition metal-doped materials. While DFT is effective in predicting ground-state geometry and properties and certain high-spin excited states, its underestimation of the energies of low-spin configurations due to their multi-reference nature is a considerable limitation. In contrast, pEHCF, with its full configuration interaction treatment of the dd-shell, excels at capturing these multiplets, as well as the energies of spin-forbidden transitions. Our proposed computational framework can guide future materials design for optical, magnetic and quantum technologies.

host →\toα\alpha-Al2_2O3_3AlB4_4O6_6NBeAl2_2O4_4 (CsC_s)BeAl2_2O4_4 (CiC_i)
pEHCFr2^2SCANHSE06pEHCFr2^2SCANHSE06pEHCFr2^2SCANHSE06pEHCFr2^2SCANHSE06
t2gt_{2g} [eV]0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00
0.000.000.000.060.050.110.190.050.050.140.090.08
0.030.100.100.100.050.110.300.070.090.370.190.15
ege_g [eV]2.084.046.212.404.156.322.503.926.112.954.296.47
2.154.046.212.554.156.322.694.066.263.174.406.59
EgapspE_{\mathrm{gap}}^{sp} [eV]9.867.228.2113.457.999.7211.717.458.4511.777.458.42
Exp. EgapspE_{\mathrm{gap}}^{sp} [eV]8.15–9.40 [57]-9.00 [58]9.00 [58]

Table 2. Energies of the one-electron dd-states of Cr3+^{3+} dopants and spsp-band gaps calculated using different quantum mechanical methods. The calculated values of the band gap are compared to available experimental data for α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3 and BeAl2_2O4_4.

TransitionExperimentpEHCFr2^2SCANHSE06CASSCF
4A2→2E^4A_2 \to^2E1.78 [60]; 1.80 [61]1.901.211.141.78 [14]
4A2→2T1^4A_2 \to^2T_1not resolved1.97; 2.00---
4A2→4T2^4A_2 \to^4T_22.22 [60, 61]; 2.25 [62]; 2.28 [60]2.08; 2.142.372.362.49 [14]
4A2→2T2^4A_2 \to^2T_2not resolved2.82; 2.83; 2.90---
4A2→4T1^4A_2 \to^4T_13.01-3.03 [60, 61, 62]; 3.12 [60]2.94; 2.97; 3.113.313.05-

Table 3. Calculated energies (in eV) of excited dd-multiplets of CrAl3+^{3+}_{\mathrm{Al}}: α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3 using different quantum mechanical methods compared to optical absorption spectroscopy data and CASSCF calculations for a [CrO6_6]9−^{9-} cluster (cut from CrAl3+^{3+}_{\mathrm{Al}}: α\alpha-Al2_2O3_3) from Shang et al. [14]. The 4A2→2E^4A_2 \to^2E transition is extracted from the RR-line in the experimental references.

Author contributions

I.P. – conceptualization, investigation (pEHCF calculations), data curation, visualization, writing - original draft & editing.

P.P.F. – investigation (DFT calculations), data curation, visualization, writing - original draft & editing. S.C. – investigation (DFT calculations), writing - review & editing. A.L.T. – conceptualization, writing - review & editing. K.I. – conceptualization, supervision, writing - review & editing. E.B. – conceptualization, supervision, writing - review & editing, project administration.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.

Data availability

The structural data supporting this article have been included as part of the Supplementary Information.†

Acknowledgements

E.B. acknowledges a Royal Society Wolfson Fellowship and the EPSRC Program Grant "Enabling Net Zero and the AI Revolution with ultra-low energy 2D Materials and Devices (NEE2D2)" [UKRI-1249] for funding. E.B. and I.P. are funded by the EPSRC Program Grant "Metal Atoms on Surfaces and Interfaces (MASI) for Sustainable Future" [EP/V000055/1]. K.I. and P.P.F. are funded by the EPSRC Fellowship Programme [EP/W028131/1] and S.C. is funded by Wellcome Leap as part of the Quantum for Bio

Program. The work of A.L.T. is supported by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation. Computing resources were provided by the University of Nottingham, the EPSRC-funded HPC Midlands+ consortium [EP/T022108/1] for access to Sulis, and the EPSRC-funded High-End Computing Materials Chemistry Consortium [EP/X035859/1] for access to the ARCHER2 UK National Supercomputing Service (https://www.archer2.ac.uk). P.-P.F. acknowledges Prof. Ádám Gali and Dr. Gergo Thiering (Wigner Research Centre for Physics, Hungarian Academy of Sciences) for useful discussions. The authors also thank the reviewers for their valuable assessment of this work.

References

References

  1. [1]Z. Suo, J. Dai, S. Gao and H. Gao, Results in Physics, 2020, 17, 103058.
  2. [2]K. O. Egbo, A. E. Adesina, C. V. Ezeh, C. P. Liu and K. M. Yu, Physical Review Materials, 2021, 5, 094603.
  3. [3]K. Greeshma, A. K. Adiyodi, S. Ancy, S. P. Dhale, N. S. Ugemuge and K. Nissamudeen, Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, 2025, 337, 126086.
  4. [4]S. Dhale, A. Nande, N. Ugemuge, V. S. Singh and S.V.Moharil, Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, 2025, 337, 126088.
  5. [5]I. T. McKinnie, L. A. W. Gloster, Z. X. Jiang and T. A. King, Applied Optics, 1996, 35, 4159.
  6. [6]T. Carrig, A. Zakel, G. Wagner and W. Alford, 2005 IEEE LEOS Annual Meeting Conference Proceedings, 2005, p. 260–261.
  7. [7]N. Z. Alpaslan Yayli, A. C. Talmac, S. Keskin Tunc, D. Akbal, D. Altindal and A. S. Ertugrul, Lasers in Medical Science, 2021, 37, 665–674.
  8. [8]S. Wieghold, Y. Luo, A. S. Bieber, J. Lackner, N. Shirato, Z. A. VanOrman, D. Rosenmann, K. Nienhaus, B. Lai, G. U. Nienhaus, V. Rose and L. Nienhaus, Chemistry of Materials, 2021, 33, 6099–6107.
  9. [9]H. Maruska and A. K. Ghosh, Solar Energy Materials, 1979, 1, 237–247.
  10. [10]V. Dierolf, I. Ferguson and J. Zavada, Rare Earth and Transition Metal Doping of Semiconductor Materials. Synthesis, Magnetic Properties and Room Temperature Spintronics, Woodhead Publishing, 2016.
  11. [11]Y. Murai, S. Zhang, T. Hotta, Z. Liu, T. Endo, H. Shimizu, Y. Miyata, T. Irisawa, Y. Gao, M. Maruyama, S. Okada, H. Mogi, T. Sato, S. Yoshida, H. Shigekawa, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, R. Canton-Vitoria and R. Kitaura, ACS Nano, 2021, 15, 19225–19232.
  12. [12]E. C. R. Lopez, Next Materials, 2025, 8, 100550.
  13. [13]V. K. Sewani, R. J. Stöhr, R. Kolesov, H. H. Vallabhapurapu, T. Simmet, A. Morello and A. Laucht, Physical Review B, 2020, 102, 104114.
  14. [14]L. Shang, Q. Chen, W. Jing, C.-G. Ma, C.-K. Duan and J. Du, Physical Review Materials, 2022, 6, 086201.
  15. [15]T. H. Maiman, Nature, 1960, 187, 493–494.
  16. [16]A. Sennaroglu and Y. Morova, Applied Physics B, 2021, 128, 9.
  17. [17]P.-O. Löwdin, Physical Review, 1955, 97, 1509–1520.
  18. [18]C. L. Benavides-Riveros, N. N. Lathiotakis and M. A. L. Marques, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 2017, 19, 12655–12664.
  19. [19]Y. Tanabe and S. Sugano, Journal of the Physical Society of Japan, 1954, 9, 753–766.
  20. [20]J. Lischner, J. Deslippe, M. Jain and S. G. Louie, Physical Review Letters, 2012, 109, 036406.
  21. [21]E. Pavarini, La Rivista del Nuovo Cimento, 2021, 44, 597–640.
  22. [22]P. Hohenberg and W. Kohn, Physical Review, 1964, 136, B864–B871.
  23. [23]W. Kohn and L. Sham, Physical Review, 1965, 140, A1133–A1138.
  24. [24]K. Czelej, M. Rey Lambert, M. E. Turiansky, A. Koshevarnikov, S. Mu and C. G. Van de Walle, ACS Nano, 2024, 18, 28724–28734.
  25. [25]J. Yang, S. Falletta and A. Pasquarello, npj Computational Materials, 2023, 9, 108.
  26. [26]J. Olsen, International Journal of Quantum Chemistry, 2011, 111, 3267–3272.
  27. [27]M. Head-Gordon, J. A. Pople and M. J. Frisch, Chemical Physics Letters, 1988, 153, 503–506.
  28. [28]B. Jeziorski and H. J. Monkhorst, Physical Review A, 1981, 24, 1668–1681.
  29. [29]G. H. Booth, A. Grü­neis, G. Kresse and A. Alavi, Nature, 2012, 493, 365–370.
  30. [30]T. Gruber, K. Liao, T. Tsatsoulis, F. Hummel and A. Grü­neis, Physical Review X, 2018, 8, 021043.
  31. [31]V. A. Neufeld, H.-Z. Ye and T. C. Berkelbach, Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters, 2022, 13, 7497–7503.
  32. [32]A. Georges, G. Kotliar, W. Krauth and M. J. Rozenberg, Reviews of Modern Physics, 1996, 68, 13–125.
  33. [33]I. Popov, E. Plekhanov, A. Tchougréeff and E. Besley, Molecular Physics, 2023, 121, e2106905.
  34. [34]A. V. Soudackov, A. L. Tchougréeff and I. A. Misurkin, Theoretica Chimica Acta, 1992, 83, 389–416.
  35. [35]A. L. Tchougréeff, A. V. Soudackov, J. van Leusen, P. Kögerler, K. Becker and R. Dronkowsk, International Journal of Quantum Chemistry, 2015, 116, 282–294.
  36. [36]I. Popov, D. Raenko, A. Tchougréeff and E. Besley, Journal of Physical Chemistry C, 2023, 127, 21749–21757.
  37. [37]I. Popov, A. Tchougréeff and E. Besley, The Journal of Chemical Physics, 2025, 163, 054117.
  38. [38]I. Widmann, G. Kinik, M. Jähnig, R. Glaum, M. Schwarz, C. Wüstefeld, D. Johrendt, M. Tribus, C. Hejny, L. Bayarjargal, L. Dubro­vinsky, G. Heymann, M. Suta and H. Huppertz, Advanced Functional Materials, 2024, 34, 2400054.
  39. [39]B. Ratzker, A. Wagner, B. Favelukis, S. Goldring, S. Kalabukhkov and N. Frage, Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 2021, 41, 3520–3526.
  40. [40]R. M. F. Scalvi, M. S. Li and L. V. Scalvi, Physics and Chemistry of Minerals, 2005, 31, 733–737.
  41. [41]W. Harrison, Electronic Structures and the Properties of Solids: The Physics of the Chemical Bond, Freeman Co, San Francisco, 1980.
  42. [42]P. Löwdin, International Journal of Quantum Chemistry, 1982, 21, 69–92.
  43. [43]A. Tokmachev and A. Tchougréeff, Journal of Solid State Chemistry, 2003, 176, 633–645.
  44. [44]J. W. Furness, A. D. Kaplan, J. Ning, J. P. Perdew and J. Sun, Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters, 2020, 11, 8208–8215.
  45. [45]G. Kresse and J. Furthmüller, Physical Review B, 1996, 54, 11169.
  46. [46]G. Kresse and D. Joubert, Physical Review B, 1999, 59, 1758.
  47. [47]G. Kresse and J. Furthmüller, Computational Materials Science, 1996, 6, 15–50.
  48. [48]P. E. Blöchl, Physical Review B, 1994, 50, 17953.
  49. [49]J. Heyd, G. E. Scuseria and M. Ernzerhof, Journal of Chemical Physics, 2003, 118, 8207–8215.
  50. [50]J. Paier, M. Marsman, K. Hummer, G. Kresse, I. C. Gerber and J. G. Ángyán, Journal of Chemical Physics, 2006, 124, 154709.
  51. [51]A. Gali, E. Janzén, P. Deák, G. Kresse and E. Kaxiras, Phys. Rev. Lett., 2009, 103, 186404.
  52. [52]C. Freysoldt, B. Grabowski, T. Hickel, J. Neugebauer, G. Kresse, A. Janotti and G. G. Van de Walle, Rev. Mod. Phys., 2014, 86, 253–305.
  53. [53]D. Wang, L. Liu and H. L. Zhuang, Journal of Applied Physics, 2021, 130, 225702.
  54. [54]B. Ramogayana, D. Santos-Carballal, K. P. Maenetja, N. H. De Leeuw and P. E. Ngoepe, ACS Omega, 2021, 6, 29577–29587.
  55. [55]R. M. Hazen, Physics and Chemistry of Minerals, 1987, 14, 13–20.
  56. [56]M. Lucht, M. Lerche, H.-C. Wille, Y. V. Shvyd’ko, H. D. Rüter, E. Gerdau and P. Becker, Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2003, 36, 1075–1081.
  57. [57]R. H. French, Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 1990, 73, 477–489.
  58. [58]V. Y. Ivanov, V. Pustovarov, E. Shlygin, A. Korotaev and A. Kruzhalov, Physics of the Solid State, 2005, 47, 466–473.
  59. [59]G. Thiering and A. Gali, Physical Review B, 2017, 96, 081115.
  60. [60]D. C. Cronemeyer, Journal of the Optical Society of America, 1966, 56, 1703.
  61. [61]H. H. Kusuma, B. Astuti and Z. Ibrahim, Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2019, 1170, 012054.
  62. [62]C. Song, Y. Hang, C. Xia, J. Xu and G. Zhou, Optical Materials, 2005, 27, 699–703.
  63. [63]U. Demirbas, A. Sennaroglu and F. X. Kä́rtner, Optical Materials Express, 2019, 9, 3352.
  64. [64]N. M. Trindade, A. Tabata, R. M. F. Scalvi and L. V. de Andrade Scalvi, Materials Sciences and Applications, 2011, 2, 284.
  65. [65]A. Bordage, S. Rossano, A. H. Horn and Y. Fuchs, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 2012, 24, 225401.
  66. [66]G. Abbas, O. Bulancea-Lindvall, J. Davidsson, R. Armiento and I. A. Abrikosov, Applied Physics Letters, 2025, 126, 154001.
  67. [67]V. Ivády, I. A. Abrikosov, E. Janzén and A. Gali, Physical Review B, 2013, 87, 205201.

Paper details

vlnc:W_2eaqs4ke
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents