WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Revealing Rotational Symmetry Breaking Charge-density Wave Order in Kagome Superconductor (Rb, K)VSb by Ultrafast Pump-probe Experiments
Abstract
The recently discovered Kagome superconductor AVSb (where A refers to K, Rb, Cs) has stimulated widespread research interest due to its interplay of non-trivial topology and unconventional correlated physics including charge-density waves (CDW) and superconductivity. The essential prerequisite to understanding the microscopic mechanisms of this complex electronic landscape is to unveil the configuration and symmetry of the charge-density wave order. As to now, little consensus has been made on what symmetry is broken. Herein, we clarify the microscopic structure and symmetry breaking of the CDW phase in RbVSb and KVSb by ultrafast time-resolved reflectivity. Our approach is based on extracting coherent phonon spectra induced by three-dimensional CDW and comparing them to calculated phonon frequencies via density-functional theory. The combination of these experimental results and calculations provides compelling evidence that the CDW structure of both compounds prevailing up to T is the 2 2 2 staggered inverse Star-of-David pattern with interlayer phase shift, in which the six-fold rotational symmetry is broken. These observations thus corroborate six-fold rotational symmetry breaking throughout the CDW phase of RbVSb and KVSb.
When the energy scale of interaction between electrons is on the same order of the electron kinetic energy, a wealth of unconventional strongly correlated phases emerge. In this regard, the newly discovered Kagome materials AV₃Sb₅ (A = K, Rb, Cs) have been at the forefront of this field, providing a new platform to study the interaction between a plethora of exotic correlated phases. This group of materials host a unique phase transition into charge-density wave (CDW) order with TCDW = 78-102 K followed by superconductivity at low temperatures with Tc = 0.9-2.5 K[1, 2, 3, 4]. The CDW order sets the stage for a cascade of intertwined symmetry breaking orders developing concomitantly or subsequently with the CDW transition, including a possible orbital flux phase[5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17], electronic nematicity[18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24], and superconductivity. Therefore, determining the exact microscopic configuration and symmetry of the CDW order is of top significance to establish the foundation of understanding these unconventional many-body effects.
AV₃Sb₅ host a Kagome lattice of vanadium atoms with space group P6/mmm in the normal phase above TCDW. The pristine phases exhibit structural instability, with unstable phonon modes at the M and L points of the Brillouin zone in all 3 compounds[25]. Note there are three symmetry equivalent M points and three symmetry equivalent L points, thus there are three M modes and three L modes in total. We show the distortion patterns of the unstable M phonon and the unstable L phonon respectively in Fig. 1c, [26, 27, 28]. Other symmetry equivalent M and L modes have similar distortion patterns. The soft phonons at the M point can be characterized by breathing modes of V atoms forming either a Star-of-David (SD) or inverse Star-of-David (ISD) structure[10, 25, 26], both of which exhibit an in-plane 2 × 2 supercell with preserved six-fold rotational symmetry. Then, combining three Q wavevectors of unstable M and L phonons, one can construct various 2 × 2 × 2 3D CDW orders[25, 26, 27]. For example, by condensing one M and two L unstable phonons on three Q directions (MLL), one realizes the ISD + ISD with interlayer π phase shift order (Fig. 1e). Thus the ISD + ISD with interlayer π phase shift order is denoted as MLL. Via condensing three L unstable phonons on three Q directions (LLL), one realizes the alternative SD + ISD without interlayer π phase shift order (Fig. 1f). Thus the alternative SD + ISD without interlayer π phase shift order is denoted as LLL. Despite elaborate research, consensus on the precise real-space structure of the CDW state among AV₃Sb₅ has not been reached. Due to the complex energetic landscape, there are various competing CDW real-space structures with similar energy scale[25, 26, 28]. In RbV₃Sb₅ and KV₃Sb₅, which are our focus in this study, several proposed CDW phases are: (i) 2 × 2 × 1 ISD[29, 30], in which C₆ is preserved (Fig. 1b), (ii) ISD + ISD with interlayer π phase shift[27, 31, 32](MLL). Also called staggered inverse Star-of-David state) in which C₆ is broken down to C₂ (Fig. 1e), and (iii) alternative SD + ISD without interlayer π phase shift[33, 34, 35] (LLL) in which C₆ is preserved (Fig. 1f). Here C₆ and C₂ refer to six-fold and two-fold rotational symmetry. Evidently, there is still intense dispute on the exact rotational symmetry of the CDW structure in AV₃Sb₅.
Figure 1. Unstable phonon modes and CDW distortions in RbV₃Sb₅ and KV₃Sb₅. (a) SD. (b) ISD. (c) Distortion corresponding to the unstable M phonon. (d) Distortion corresponding to the unstable L phonon. (e) ISD + ISD with interlayer -phase shift via combination of one M and two L unstable phonons (MLL). (f) SD + ISD without interlayer phase shift via combination of three L unstable phonons (LLL). From (a) to (f) The V atoms are shown in gray. In (a) and (b) the alkali metal atoms (Rb or K) are shown in orange, and from (c) to (f) only the vanadium atoms are shown for simplicity. The lines connecting V atoms indicate shorter bonds. Note that the structure in (a), (b) and (f) keeps the symmetry while the structure in (e) breaks the six-fold rotational symmetry down to two-fold (point group ).
In this study, we investigate ultrafast phonon dynamics in RbV₃Sb₅ and KV₃Sb₅ using optical pump-probe technique to evaluate the proposed CDW structures in these two compounds. By extracting coherent phonon spectra from the measurement of time-resolved reflectivity and comparing to density-functional theory (DFT) calculations, we determine the CDW structure to be most aligned with the staggered inverse Star-of-David pattern with interlayer phase shift. Our work thus confirms C6 rotational symmetry breaking onset at TCDW, bringing forth new understandings of CDW order in the AV₃Sb₅ family.
Single crystals of RbV₃Sb₅ and KV₃Sb₅ were synthesized using the self-flux method[1, 3]. We perform time-resolved reflectivity measurements on freshly cleaved (001) surfaces of RbV₃Sb₅ and KV₃Sb₅ single crystals. We use an ultrafast fiber laser system for all the measurements, with a repetition rate of 80 MHz and pulse duration of 100 fs. The pump wavelength is 1560 nm and probe wavelength is 780 nm, with both having a fluence less than 10 J/cm². The pump pulse intensity is modulated at a frequency of 84 kHz using a photo-elastic modulator (PEM) and a pair of linear polarizers. We use a balanced detection method to improve the signal to noise ratio. Both pump and probe beams are at normal incidence and are focused by an objective lens to achieve a spot size of ≈10 m in diameter[36].
Figure 2a shows the time-resolved reflectivity data measured on RbV₃Sb₅ and its evolution with temperature. Above the CDW transition temperature , a single phonon oscillation can be observed. In contrast, multiple phonon oscillations can be observed below as seen from the complex oscillation pattern (Appendix Fig. 1a). The sign of the initial reflectivity change also flips across , similar to CsV₃Sb₅[37], which is likely due to band renormalization and partial bandgap opening at the CDW transition[38, 39]. To better understand the evolution of coherent phonon modes as a function of temperature, we perform a Fourier transformation on the oscillation parts of traces after subtracting a decaying background to reveal the phonon spectra and plot it in Figure 2b. There is only one mode centered at 4.0 THz above . This mode agrees well with the DFT-calculated mode frequency in the pristine phase of RbV₃Sb₅ (Table I) and persists in the CDW phase. In contrast, multiple phonon modes emerge in the CDW phase. At T = 5 K, there exists another two conspicuous modes centered at 1.53 and 3.12 THz, along with a 3.75 THz mode and a much weaker mode at 1.75 THz. Inset Figure 2c highlights the peak at 1.75 THz. No more modes are detected up to 15 THz. The 1.53 THz mode persists during warming but abruptly vanishes at T ≈ 100 K, matching with the reported TCDW = 102 K in RbV₃Sb₅[4, 40]. We note modest local laser heating may cause a slight decrease of the measured TCDW in the current optical method. No obvious frequency softening is observed for the 1.53 THz mode when elevating the temperature, more consistent with a zone-folded phonon mode arising from the CDW order which explains the disappearance of this mode in the coherent phonon spectrum above TCDW. Contrary to the single peak feature of the 1.53 THz mode, the 3.12 THz mode is accompanied by a weaker peak at 2.92 THz. This close phonon pair weakens in amplitude as temper-
Figure 2. Evolution of the coherent phonon spectrum in vs. temperature. (a) Time-resolved reflectivity curves in the temperature range of 5 K – 110 K across the CDW transition temperature. (b) Amplitudes of Fourier transforms of coherent phonon oscillations in time traces after subtracting the decay background. Inset (c) shows the weak 1.75 THz mode. Curves in (a) and (b) are offset for clarity.
ature increases and disappears at K. This is reminiscent of a mode in CsVSb at a similar frequency of 3.1 THz which vanishes in pump-probe phonon spectrum at K, 30 K below [37, 41].
The observations are qualitatively similar in KVSb (Figure 3). The sign of the curves also becomes opposite across , which may likewise arise from the CDW-induced band renormalization and partial CDW gap opening observed by ARPES[42, 43]. A zoomed-in curve also highlights multiple phonons in the CDW phase (Appendix Fig. 1b). Regarding the coherent phonon spectrum, we observe three main peaks at 1.94, 3.04 and 4.00 THz along with weaker peaks at 1.68, 3.45 and 3.64 THz. Inset Figure 3c highlights the peak at 1.68 THz. The 1.94 THz mode shows minimal frequency softening and is present up to K in accordance with K[3], agreeing with a CDW zone-folded mode. Analogous to RbVSb, the 3.04 THz mode is also accompanied by a weaker peak at 2.71 THz which vanishes at K. Above , only the 4.00 THz mode exists, which matches with the mode in the pristine KVSb phase (Table II).
Figure 3. Temperature-dependent coherent phonon spectroscopy in . (a) Time-resolved reflectivity curves at different temperatures across the CDW transition temperature. Each curve is normalized to its peak value. (b) Amplitudes of Fourier transforms of coherent phonon oscillations in (a) after subtracting the decaying background. Inset (c) shows the weak 1.68 THz mode. Curves in (a) and (b) are offset for clarity.
To explain the observed phonon spectrum and determine the CDW structure of both compounds, we perform DFT calculations of phonon frequencies and compare with the phonon spectra detected by TR-reflectivity. In time-resolved reflectivity measurements, the femtosecond pump pulse selectively excites Raman-active phonons coherently[44, 45]. The generated coherent phonons by the pump pulse then modulates the refractive index by the ion motion[46, 47, 48] which causes the observed transient reflectivity changes.
Our observation is consistent with the displacive excitation of coherent phonons (DECP) mechanism where absorption at the pump frequency is required and only fully symmetric phonon modes are observed[49, 50]. Fully symmetric phonon modes host symmetry, such as modes in point group and modes in point group. In DECP, the instantaneous electronic excitation caused by absorption of the pump pulse leads to a sudden change in the free energy of the system, which causes the displacement of quasi-equilibrium nuclear coordinates within a unit cell. Such an ultrafast change of quasi-equilibrium position generates a restoring force for the coherent atomic motion of the phonons[49, 51]. Our pump light wavelength is much larger than the partial
CDW gap opening in both compounds[38, 39, 42, 43, 52], indicating strong absorption. Meanwhile, above , Raman spectroscopy detected one mode at 4.1 THz and one mode at 3.6 THz with comparable amplitude[53] in both (Rb, K)VSb. This 3.6 THz mode is active in pristine phase. This Raman measurement also showed this dominant mode at 3.6 THz persists below and has the maximum amplitude among all non-fully-symmetric modes. However, in our time-resolved reflectivity measurements, we only observe the mode near 4.0 THz at temperatures above (Table I, II). Below , we do not observe this dominant 3.6 THz mode either. Since we do not observe a mode that shows similar frequency to the 3.6 THz mode and is present at all temperatures, we can rule out the detection of non-fully-symmetric modes in our time-resolved reflectivity measurements. These observations serve as the evidence of DECP, and we assume all the detected phonon modes in our time-resolved reflectivity measurements are fully symmetric modes. This also matches with a previous pump-probe study on CsVSb[37] where DECP was also used to interpret the coherent phonon spectroscopy data.
We first analyze the possible CDW structure in RbVSb. Figure 4a shows the calculated modes in the two -symmetric CDW phases, Star-of-David (SD) and inverse star-of-David (ISD), in the relevant frequency range. Both phases cannot explain the observed phonon spectra due to the lack of the two lower frequency modes and two close modes near 3.12 THz. Thus, interlayer modulation of the CDW order along axis must be included. Regarding the CDW phases, we consider the two reported structures: ISD + ISD with interlayer phase shift (MLL) with broken , and SD + ISD without interlayer phase shift (LLL) with preserved . The calculated fully-symmetric phonon frequencies for both structures have been listed in Table I and Figure 4b. According to Figure 4b, both host two fully symmetric modes between 1 and 2 THz, while the frequency difference of these two modes in MLL state are better matched with the detected 1.53 and 1.75 THz mode. Further supportive evidence of MLL arises from the DFT-calculated phonon oscillation patterns (Figure 4c, Figure 4d). As shown by DFT, for the two modes near the observed phonon frequencies in MLL, the 1.42 THz mode is Rb-related while the 1.60 THz mode involves V and Sb atoms. If MLL is the actual CDW structure in RbVSb, our observed 1.53 THz mode should correspond to the calculated 1.42 THz mode that is related with Rb atoms, and our observed 1.75 THz mode should correspond to the calculated 1.60 THz mode that is related with V and Sb atoms (Figure 4c). When moving from Rb to Cs, the frequency of the 1.53 THz mode will decrease and the frequency of the 1.75 THz mode will remain similar. This matches with the phonon spectrum of CsVSbSn with = 0.03-0.04 which also has an MLL-type CDW[27, 54] (Figure 6). Our measurement on CsVSbSn with = 0.03-0.04 shows a 1.34 THz mode that corresponds to a Cs related mode, and a 1.80 THz mode that corresponds to a V and Sb related mode[54]. When switching Rb to Cs, the 1.53 THz Rb-related mode in RbVSb decreases in frequency and evolves to the 1.34 THz Cs-related mode in this Sn-doped CsVSb. Meanwhile, the frequency of the 1.75 THz V and Sb-related mode in RbVSb should remain similar and evolves to the 1.80 THz V and Sb-related mode in this Sn-doped CsVSb. We can also rule out the LLL phase since both phonons below 2 THz in LLL are Rb-related only (Appendix § 3). We thus conclude the ISD + ISD with interlayer phase shift (MLL) is the actual CDW structure in RbVSb, in which six-fold rotational symmetry is broken.
Figure 4. Comparison of the phonon spectrum of RbVSb calculated by DFT and measured by time-resolved reflectivity at K. (a) DFT-calculated phonon frequencies in the SD and ISD CDW phases in RbVSb. (b) The calculated () Raman mode frequencies in the SD+ISD without interlayer phase shift (ISD+ISD with interlayer phase shift) state and comparison with the time-resolved reflectivity results. The vertical lines in both figures denote the frequency of the measured phonon peak or the fully-symmetric () modes in DFT calculation. (c) The DFT-calculated oscillation pattern of the fully-symmetric Raman active modes in ISD + ISD with interlayer phase shift (MLL) in RbVSb that are near our detected 1.53 and 1.75 THz modes via time-resolved reflectivity, respectively. The 1.42 and 1.60 THz modes are the lowest and second-lowest frequency mode in the phonon spectrum of MLL phase in (b). (d) The DFT-calculated oscillation pattern of the fully-symmetric Raman active modes in SD + ISD without interlayer phase shift (LLL) CDW state in RbVSb that are near our detected 1.53 and 1.75 THz modes via time-resolved reflectivity, respectively. The 1.27 and 1.78 THz modes are the lowest and second-lowest frequency mode in the phonon spectrum of LLL phase in (b). In (c) and (d), the Rb atoms are shown in cyan, the V atoms are shown in blue, and the Sb atoms are shown in yellow.
Figure 6. The measured coherent phonon spectrum by time-resolved reflectivity in KVSb, RbVSb, CsVSb, and Sn-doped CsVSb. The spectrum for Sn-doped CsVSb is taken at T = 3.5 K, while the spectra for other 3 compounds are taken at T = 5 K. The data from CsVSb and Sn-doped CsVSb will be published elsewhere[54]. The orange arrow marks the evolution of the frequency of the alkali metal atom mode. The blue arrow marks the evolution of the frequency of the V and Sb atom related mode near 1.7 - 1.8 THz.
| Pristine RbVSb | 4.07 | 3.86 | ||||||
| SD in RbVSb | 2.53 | 3.70 | 4.06 | 0.88 | 1.59 | 3.54 | 3.86 | |
| ISD in RbVSb | 2.87 | 3.70 | 4.11 | 1.66 | 2.62 | 3.69 | 3.87 | |
| ISD + ISD with inter-layer phase shift of RbVSb | 1.42 | 1.60 | 2.69 | 3.11 | 3.65 | 3.76 | 3.87 | 4.02 |
| SD + ISD without inter-layer phase shift of RbVSb | 1.27 | 1.78 | 2.77 | 3.12 | 3.72 | 3.83 | 3.98 | 4.10 |
Table 1. Frequency (unit: THz) of the selected Raman-active modes in the pristine and CDW phases of RbVSb calculated by DFT. Only relevant , and modes with frequencies below 4.5 THz are included.
| Pristine KVSb | 4.05 | 3.85 | ||||||
| SD in KVSb | 1.73 | 3.61 | 4.08 | 0.75 | 1.56 | 3.53 | 3.87 | |
| ISD in KVSb | 2.78 | 3.62 | 4.06 | 1.61 | 2.57 | 3.64 | 3.86 | |
| ISD + ISD with inter-layer phase shift of KVSb | 1.71 | 1.82 | 2.22 | 2.69 | 3.63 | 3.72 | 3.88 | 4.06 |
| SD + ISD without inter-layer phase shift of KVSb | 1.70 | 2.09 | 2.62 | 2.89 | 3.72 | 3.73 | 4.04 | 4.10 |
Table 2. Frequency (unit: THz) of the selected Raman-active modes in the pristine and CDW phases of KVSb calculated by DFT. Only relevant , and modes with frequencies below 4.5 THz are included.
Also, in our previous study[9], we observed three birefringence domains on both compounds and their principal axes are 120° relative to each other, showing strong evidence of breaking as well. Since the reported birefringence domain size is ≈100 μm and the laser spot size in our time-resolved reflectivity experiments is ≈10 μm, we can measure in a single birefringence domain. This allows us to pinpoint -breaking MLL as the exact CDW structure. We note that while there are more fully-symmetric modes in calculation than observed, some modes could be missing in our observation due to their weak modulations on refractive index and reflectivity.
We then perform similar phonon frequency calculations on KVSb. Figure 5a compares the calculated phonons of SD and ISD with the time-resolved reflectivity results. Clearly, these two CDW structures fail to explain the two close modes near 3.04 THz and the multiple observed phonons near 3.5 THz. We again compare our measured phonon spectrum with MLL and LLL. The calculated fully-symmetric phonon frequencies for both structures have been listed in Table II and Fig.
Figure 5. Comparison of the phonon spectrum of KVSb calculated by DFT and measured by time-resolved reflectivity at K. (a) DFT-calculated phonon frequencies in the SD and ISD CDW phases in KVSb. (b) The calculated () Raman mode frequencies in the SD + ISD without interlayer phase shift (ISD+ISD with interlayer phase shift) state and comparison with the time-resolved reflectivity results. The vertical lines in both figures denote the frequency of the measured phonon peak or the fully-symmetric () modes in DFT calculation. (c) The DFT-calculated oscillation pattern of the fully-symmetric Raman active modes in ISD + ISD with interlayer phase shift (MLL) CDW state in KVSb that are near our detected 1.68 and 1.94 THz modes via time-resolved reflectivity, respectively. The 1.71 and 1.82 THz modes are the lowest and second-lowest frequency mode in the phonon spectrum of MLL phase in (b). (d) The DFT-calculated oscillation pattern of the fully-symmetric Raman active modes in SD + ISD without interlayer phase shift (LLL) CDW state in KVSb that are near our detected 1.68 and 1.94 THz modes via time-resolved reflectivity, respectively. The 1.70 and 2.09 THz modes are the lowest and second-lowest frequency mode in the phonon spectrum of LLL phase in (b). In (c) and (d), the K atoms are shown in cyan, the V atoms are shown in blue, and the Sb atoms are shown in yellow.
5b. For the phonon spectrum of LLL phase of KVSb, it shows four phonons at 3.72, 3.73, 4.04 and 4.10 THz. The frequency differences of some adjacent phonons (0.01 THz, 0.06 THz) are too small to match well with our measured values. Comparatively, the frequency values and frequency difference of the observed multiple modes near 3.5 THz (i.e. the observed 3.45 and 3.64 THz modes) match better with the MLL phase. For the modes below 2 THz, we note that a previous Raman study[53] observed a 51 cm = 1.53 THz fully-symmetric mode in RbVSb and a 64 cm = 1.92 THz fully symmetric mode in KVSb, matching with our observed 1.53 THz mode in RbVSb and 1.94 THz mode in KVSb respectively. This Raman study also established the frequency evolution from 1.53 THz to 1.94 THz when changing Rb to K. If MLL is the actual CDW structure in KVSb, our observed 1.68 THz mode should correspond to the calculated 1.71 THz mode that is related with V and Sb atoms, and our observed 1.94 THz mode should correspond to the calculated 1.82 THz mode that is related with K atoms (Figure 5c). Considering the CDW structure of RbVSb is determined to be MLL, by switching from Rb to K, one expects the frequency of the Rb-related 1.53 THz mode in RbVSb to increase and the frequency of the V- and Sb-related 1.75 THz mode in RbVSb to be similar. This exactly agrees with our observed 1.94 and 1.68 THz mode in KVSb respectively: the 1.53 THz mode in RbVSb evolves to 1.94 THz mode in KVSb, and the 1.75 THz mode in RbVSb evolves to 1.68 THz mode in KVSb, indicating the CDW structure in KVSb is MLL as well. Analogous argument as for RbVSb can rule out LLL (Appendix § 3). We thus conclude the CDW structure in KVSb is also ISD + ISD with interlayer phase shift. We note a previous Raman spectroscopy study on AVSb family also revealed the two close modes near 3 THz for both RbVSb and KVSb and matched well with our measured frequencies[53]. Therein, a CDW order has been shown to give rise to doublets and was utilized to explain these detected pairs.
However, XRD measurements on either RbVSb or KVSb did not find any evidence of orders[31, 55]. Thus, we suggest CDW orders may not be the reason for our observed two close modes near 3 THz in (Rb, K)VSb. Instead, the -breaking MLL order can explain the observed two close modes near 3 THz.
Our measurements of the coherent phonon dynamics in Rb- and KVSb via time-resolved reflectivity provide a new perspective to resolve the dispute of the CDW structure in these compounds. Although in-plane CDW orders were proposed by some ARPES[30] and NMR[29] measurements, the observation of the two close modes near 3 THz and the alkali-metal modes below 2 THz in Rb- and KVSb unambiguously rules out the two CDW structures for both compounds. The observation of the 1.53 and 1.75 THz modes in RbVSb along with 1.94 and 1.68 THz modes in KVSb also supports the -breaking MLL phase against LLL phase in both materials, in agreement with previous theoretical predictions that MLL is energetically more favorable than LLL[25, 37] and sharing the result of recent ARPES[27, 56] and NMR[32, 57] measurements. In addition to previous STM studies[7, 58] visualizing breaking at low temperatures from different CDW peak height along three in-plane directions, the persistence of the observed 1.53 and 1.94 THz modes up to in our time-resolved reflectivity results confirms the existence of MLL phase and six-fold rotational symmetry breaking up to in both Rb- and KVSb.
The collation of the measured phonon spectrum in all AVSb members from Cs to K by time-resolved reflectivity allows us to track the evolution of the phonon frequencies (Figure 6). We observe prominent long-lived phonon modes at 1.33 THz in CsVSb[54], 1.53 THz in RbVSb and 1.94 THz in KVSb, all of which vanish at . These modes match with alkali metal atom related phonon modes seen by DFT. As the atomic mass decreases from Cs, Rb to K, we expect the phonon vibration frequency to increase. This explains the detected phonon frequency evolution from 1.33 THz in CsVSb to 1.53 THz in RbVSb to 1.94 THz in KVSb (orange arrow in Figure 6). Our time-resolved reflectivity measurements also observe a weaker fully-symmetric mode near 1.7 - 1.8 THz in all AVSb members in Figure 6 that is not observed in previous pump-probe measurements. This mode is related to V and Sb atoms, and whose frequency only shows slight decreases when the alkali metal atom mass decreases from Cs, Rb to K, i.e. from 1.8 THz in CsVSb to 1.75 THz in RbVSb to 1.68 THz in KVSb (blue arrow in Figure 6). This mode comes from symmetry breaking as it can be explained by splitting of an mode () when is reduced to (Table III & Table IV)[54]. These parent modes have been detected by Raman[53] and shown to evolve from 1.83 THz in CsVSb to 1.77 THz in RbVSb to 1.68 THz in KVSb, matching with our measured frequency values and evolution. In addition, in all compounds, we observe a close pair of fully-symmetric phonons near 3 THz. Previous pump-probe studies on CsVSb[37, 41] suggested the 3 THz mode to be linked to the 1Q uniaxial order observed by STM below 60 K[21, 59], much lower than . We note the 1Q uniaxial order is not seen in KVSb[6], thus indicating the 1Q uniaxial order might not be the reason for the observed 3 THz modes. In contrast, we point out the 3Q MLL phase with interlayer phase shift can already explain the two close modes near 3 THz. This close phonon pair near 3 THz is also a direct consequence of symmetry breaking, as the lower frequency branch mode comes from splitting of an mode () induced by broken (Table III & Table IV). Moreover, our measurements push the onset temperature of rotational symmetry breaking up to in Rb- and KVSb rather than below . Previous Raman studies on CsVSb[60, 61] showed this 3 THz mode exhibits significant weakening and broadening upon warming toward , becoming overdamped between 60 and 90 K with the linewidth as large as 50 cm right below . This might explain why the 3 THz modes vanish in our experiment at 20–30 K below in RbVSb and KVSb.
| ISD of RbVSb () | ISD+ISD with inter-layer phase shift of RbVSb () | |
| : 1.66 THz | : 1.60 THz | |
| : 1.66 THz | ||
| ISD of RbVSb () | ISD+ISD with inter-layer phase shift of RbVSb () | |
| : 2.87 THz | : 3.11 THz | |
| : 2.62 THz | : 2.69 THz | |
| : 2.82 THz |
Table III. DFT-calculated phonon split due to six-fold rotational symmetry breaking in RbVSb. The pair of modes near 3.1 THz shown in the second table correspond to the observed two close modes near 3.1 THz.
| ISD of KVSb () | ISD+ISD with inter-layer phase shift of KVSb () | |
| : 1.61 THz | : 1.71 THz | |
| : 1.65 THz | ||
| ISD of KVSb () | ISD+ISD with inter-layer phase shift of KVSb () | |
| : 2.78 THz | : 2.69 THz | |
| : 2.57 THz | : 2.22 THz | |
| : 2.45 THz |
Table IV. DFT-calculated phonon split due to six-fold rotational symmetry breaking in KVSb. The pair of modes near 3 THz shown in the second table correspond to the observed two close modes near 3.0 THz.
In conclusion, our coherent phonon excitation studies determine the precise structure and symmetry in the CDW phase of RbVSb and KVSb. We resolve the fully-symmetric phonon spectrum via ultrafast time-resolved reflectivity, from which we pinpoint the microscopic 3D CDW pattern to be ISD + ISD with interlayer phase shift (MLL) by comparing with DFT calculations, indicating rotational symmetry breaking up to . Our results thus provide fresh insights into the current understanding of CDW state in AVSb and essential guidance on the development of microscopic theory of emergent electronic orders stabilized within the CDW phase, such as chiral loop current states and superconductivity. Looking forward, we envision our technique will help deciphering of the evolution of CDW order across the extremely rich phase diagram of AVSb, extending new vision for fundamental studies at the intersection of frustration, topology, and strong correlations.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The construction of the pump-probe setup was supported by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research under award no. FA9550-22-1-0410. Q.D. was mainly supported by the Vagelos Institute of Energy Science and Technology graduate fellowship and also partly supported by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research under award no. FA9550-22-1-0410 and the NSF EPM program under grant no. DMR-2213891. S.D.W. and B.R.O. gratefully acknowledge support via the UC Santa Barbara NSF Quantum Foundry funded via the Q-AMASE-i program under award DMR-1906325. B.R.O. thanks support from the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), Office of Science, Basic Energy Sciences (BES), Materials Sciences and Engineering Division. B.Y. acknowledges the financial support by the Israel Science Foundation (ISF: 2932/21, 2974/23), German Research Foundation (DFG, CRC-183, A02), and by a research grant from the Estate of Gerald Alexander.
Correspondence: Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to L.W. ([email protected]).
References
Ruling out LLL CDW Structure in RbVSb and KVSb
The DFT-calculated fully-symmetric phonon modes of different CDW structures in RbVSb and KVSb are shown in Table I and Table II.
In RbVSb
For the DFT-calculated two modes below 2 THz in MLL that are near the observed 1.53 and 1.75 THz modes, the lower frequency mode (1.42 THz) only involves Rb atoms, while the higher frequency mode (1.60 THz) involves V and Sb atoms. For the DFT-calculated two modes below 2 THz in LLL (at 1.27 THz and 1.78 THz) that are near the observed 1.53 and 1.75 THz modes, both only involve Rb atom oscillations. See Figure 4c, Figure 4d.
If LLL was the correct CDW structure, both the experimentally detected 1.53 and 1.75 THz modes would correspond to Rb-related modes. When Rb is switched to Cs, their frequencies should decrease. Thus, in CsVSb with the coexistence of SD and ISD which contains the whole LLL phonon set[54], one would expect two modes with frequency below 1.53 THz and 1.75 THz respectively, with the higher frequency mode much weaker than the lower frequency mode, as observed in CsVSb[54]. Although the observed 1.26 and 1.33 THz mode in CsVSb satisfy this frequency evolution[54], the higher frequency 1.33 THz mode always show stronger amplitude instead of being much weaker than the lower frequency 1.26 THz mode. This rules out the LLL as the CDW structure in RbVSb.
In KVSb
For MLL, DFT calculation shows two modes at 1.71 THz and 1.82 THz that are near the observed 1.68 and 1.94 THz modes. The 1.71 THz mode involves the oscillations of Sb and V atoms, while the 1.82 THz mode only involves the oscillation of K atoms. For LLL, DFT calculation shows two modes at 1.70 THz and 2.09 THz that are near the observed 1.68 and 1.94 THz modes. Both modes only involve the oscillations of K atoms. See Figure 5c, Figure 5d.
If LLL was the correct CDW structure, both the experimentally detected 1.94 and 1.68 THz modes would correspond to K-related modes. When K is switched to Cs, their frequencies should decrease. Thus, in CsVSb with the coexistence of SD and ISD which contains the whole LLL phonon set[54], one would expect two modes with frequency below 1.68 THz and 1.94 THz respectively, with the higher frequency mode much stronger than the lower frequency mode. Although the observed 1.26 and 1.33 THz mode in CsVSb satisfy this frequency evolution[54], the amplitude of these two modes are comparable, in contrast to KVSb where the amplitude of the higher frequency 1.94 THz mode is more than one order of magnitude stronger than the lower frequency 1.68 THz mode. This rules out the LLL as the CDW structure in KVSb.
Figure 1 (PDF p. 12). The zoomed-in plots highlighting the oscillation patterns of time-resolved reflectivity curves at 5 K for (a) RbVSb and (b) KVSb. (c) The oscillatory part of the measured time-resolved reflectivity curve on RbVSb at 5 K in the first 12 ps. (d) The oscillatory part of the measured time-resolved reflectivity curve on KVSb at 5 K in the first 12 ps.
References
- [1]Ortiz, B. R. et al. New kagome prototype materials: discovery of kv 3 sb 5, rbv 3 sb 5, and csv 3 sb 5. Physical Review Materials 3, 094407 (2019).DOI
- [2]Ortiz, B. R. et al. Cs v 3 sb 5: A z 2 topological kagome metal with a superconducting ground state. Physical Review Letters 125, 247002 (2020).DOI
- [3]Ortiz, B. R. et al. Superconductivity in the z 2 kagome metal kv 3 sb 5. Physical Review Materials 5, 034801 (2021).DOI
- [4]Yin, Q. et al. Superconductivity and normal-state properties of kagome metal rbv3sb5 single crystals. Chinese Physics Letters 38, 037403 (2021).DOI
- [5]Mielke III, C. et al. Time-reversal symmetry-breaking charge order in a kagome superconductor. Nature 602, 245–250 (2022).DOI
- [6]Jiang, Y.-X. et al. Unconventional chiral charge order in kagome superconductor kv3sb5. Nature materials 20, 1353–1357 (2021).DOI
- [7]Xing, Y. et al. Optical manipulation of the charge-density-wave state in rbv3sb5. Nature 1–7 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2308.04128
- [8]Guo, C. et al. Switchable chiral transport in charge-ordered kagome metal csv3sb5. Nature 611, 461–466 (2022).DOI
- [9]Xu, Y. et al. Three-state nematicity and magneto-optical Kerr effect in the charge density waves in kagome superconductors. Nature physics 18, 1470–1475 (2022).DOI
- [10]Park, T., Ye, M. & Balents, L. Electronic instabilities of kagome metals: saddle points and landau theory. Physical Review B 104, 035142 (2021).DOI
- [11]Feng, X., Jiang, K., Wang, Z. & Hu, J. Chiral flux phase in the kagome superconductor av3sb5. Science bulletin 66, 1384–1388 (2021).DOI
- [12]Denner, M. M., Thomale, R. & Neuper t, T. Analysis of charge order in the kagome metal a v 3 sb 5 (a= k, rb, cs). Physical Review Letters 127, 217601 (2021).DOI
- [13]Guo, C. et al. Correlated order at the tipping point in the kagome metal csv3sb5. Nature Physics 1–6 (2024).DOI
- [14]Christensen, M. H., Birol, T., Andersen, B. M. & Fernandes, R. M. Loop currents in a v 3 sb 5 kagome metals: Multipolar and toroidal magnetic orders. Physical Review B 106, 144504 (2022).DOI
- [15]Tazai, R., Yamakawa, Y. & Kontani, H. Drastic magnetic-field-induced chiral current order and emergent current-bond-field interplay in kagome metals. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 121, e2303476121 (2024).DOI
- [16]Saykin, D. R. et al. High resolution polar kerr effect studies of csv 3 sb 5: Tests for time-reversal symmetry breaking below the charge-order transition. Physical Review Letters 131, 016901 (2023).DOI
- [17]Farhang, C., Wang, J., Ortiz, B. R., Wilson, S. D. & Xia, J. Unconventional specular optical rotation in the charge ordered state of kagome metal csv3sb5. Nature Communications 14, 5326 (2023).DOI
- [18]Nie, L. et al. Charge-density-wave-driven electronic nematicity in a kagome superconductor. Nature 604, 59–64 (2022).DOI
- [19]Li, H. et al. Unidirectional coherent quasiparticles in the high-temperature rotational symmetry broken phase of a v3sb5 kagome superconductors. Nature Physics 19, 637–643 (2023).DOI
- [20]Xiang, Y. et al. Twofold symmetry of c-axis resistivity in topological kagome superconductor csv3sb5 with in-plane rotating magnetic field. Nature communications 12, 6727 (2021).DOI
- [21]Chen, H. et al. Roton pair density wave in a strong-coupling kagome superconductor. Nature 599, 222–228 (2021).DOI
- [22]Wulferding, D. et al. Emergent nematicity and intrinsic versus extrinsic electronic scattering processes in the kagome metal csv 3 sb 5. Physical Review Research 4, 023215 (2022).DOI
- [23]Asaba, T. et al. Evidence for an odd-parity nematic phase above the charge-density-wave transition in a kagome metal. Nature Physics 20, 40–46 (2024).DOI
- [24]Liu, Z. et al. Absence of e 2 g nematic instability and dominant a 1 g response in the kagome metal csv 3 sb 5. Physical Review X 14, 031015 (2024).DOI
- [25]Tan, H., Liu, Y., Wang, Z. & Yan, B. Charge density waves and electronic properties of superconducting kagome metals. Physical review letters 127, 046401 (2021).DOI
- [26]Christensen, M. H., Birol, T., Andersen, B. M. & Fernandes, R. M. Theory of the charge density wave in a v 3 sb 5 kagome metals. Physical Review B 104, 214513 (2021).DOI
- [27]Kang, M. et al. Charge order landscape and competition with superconductivity in kagome metals. Nature Materials 22, 186–193 (2022).DOI
- [28]Ning, H. et al. Dynamical decoding of the competition between charge density waves in a kagome superconductor. Nature Communications 15, 1–8 (2024).DOI
- [29]Zhang, X. et al. Nmr study of charge density wave phase in the kagome metal rbv3sb5. Applied Physics Letters 124 (2024).DOI
- [30]Kato, T. et al. Three-dimensional energy gap and origin of charge-density wave in kagome superconductor kv3sb5. Communications Materials 3, 30 (2022).DOI
- [31]Kautzsch, L. et al. Structural evolution of the kagome superconductors av 3 sb 5 (a= k, rb, and cs) through charge density wave order. Physical Review Materials 7, 024806 (2023).DOI
- [32]Frassinetti, J. et al. Microscopic nature of the charge-density wave in the kagome superconductor rbv 3 sb 5. Physical Review Research 5, L012017 (2023).
- [33]Subires, D. et al. Order-disorder charge density wave instability in the kagome metal (cs, rb) v3sb5. Nature Communications 14, 1015 (2023).DOI
- [34]Hu, Y. et al. Coexistence of hexagonal and star-of-david pattern in the charge density wave of the kagome superconductor av 3 sb 5. Physical Review B 106, L241106 (2022).DOI
- [35]Kato, T. et al. Surface-termination-dependent electronic states in kagome superconductors av 3 sb 5 (a= k, rb, cs) studied by micro-arpes. Physical Review B 107, 245143 (2023).
- [36]Gray, I. et al. Time-resolved magneto-optical effects in the altermagnet candidate mnTe. Applied Physics Letters 125 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2404.05020
- [37]Ratcliff, N., Hallett, L., Ortiz, B. R., Wilson, S. D. & Harter, J. W. Coherent phonon spectroscopy and interlayer modulation of charge density wave order in the kagome metal csv 3 sb 5. Physical Review Materials 5, L111801 (2021).
- [38]Liu, Z. et al. Charge-density-wave-induced bands renormalization and energy gaps in a kagome superconductor rbv 3 sb 5. Physical Review X 11, 041010 (2021).DOI
- [39]Wenzel, M. et al. Optical study of rbv 3 sb 5: Multiple density-wave gaps and phonon anomalies. Physical Review B 105, 245123 (2022).DOI
- [40]Li, H. et al. Observation of unconventional charge density wave without acoustic phonon anomaly in kagome superconductors av 3 sb 5 (a= rb, cs). Physical Review X 11, 031050 (2021).DOI
- [41]Wang, Z. et al. Unconventional charge density wave and photoinduced lattice symmetry change in the kagome metal csv 3 sb 5 probed by time-resolved spectroscopy. Physical Review B 104, 165110 (2021).DOI
- [42]Luo, H. et al. Electronic nature of charge density wave and electron-phonon coupling in kagome superconductor kv3sb5. Nature communications 13, 273 (2022).DOI
- [43]Uykur, E., Ortiz, B. R., Wilson, S. D., Dressel, M. & Tsirlin, A. A. Optical detection of the density-wave instability in the kagome metal kv3sb5. npj Quantum Materials 7, 16 (2022).DOI
- [44]Merlin, R. Generating coherent thz phonons with light pulses. Solid state communications 102, 207–220 (1997).DOI
- [45]Stevens, T., Kuhl, J. & Merlin, R. Coherent phonon generation and the two stimulated raman tensors. Physical Review B 65, 144304 (2002).DOI
- [46]Shen, Y.-R. Principles of nonlinear optics (1984).
- [47]Shen, Y. R. & Bloembergen, N. Theory of stimulated brillouin and raman scattering. Physical Review 137, A1787 (1965).DOI
- [48]Giordmaine, J. A. & Kaiser, W. Light scattering by coherently driven lattice vibrations. Physical Review 144, 676 (1966).DOI
- [49]Zeiger, H. et al. Theory for displacive excitation of coherent phonons. Physical Review B 45, 768 (1992).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10001117
- [50]Cheng, T. et al. Mechanism for displacive excitation of coherent phonons in sb, bi, te, and ti2o3. Applied Physics Letters 59, 1923–1925 (1991).DOI
- [51]Lobad, A. I. & Taylor, A. J. Coherent phonon generation mechanism in solids. Physical Review B 64, 180301 (2001).DOI
- [52]Zhou, X. et al. Electronic correlations and evolution of the charge density wave in the kagome metals av 3 sb 5 (a= k, rb, cs). Physical Review B 107, 165123 (2023).DOI
- [53]Wu, S. et al. Charge density wave order in the kagome metal av 3 sb 5 (a= cs, rb, k). Physical Review B 105, 155106 (2022).DOI
- [54]Deng, Q. et al. to be published .
- [55]Scagnoli, V. et al. Resonant x-ray diffraction measurements in charge ordered kagome superconductors kv3sb5 and rbv3sb5. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 36, 185604 (2024).DOI
- [56]Jiang, Z. et al. Observation of electronic nematicity driven by the three-dimensional charge density wave in kagome lattice kv3sb5. Nano Letters 23, 5625–5633 (2023).DOI
- [57]Wang, Y., Wu, T., Li, Z., Jiang, K. & Hu, J. Structure of the kagome superconductor csv 3 sb 5 in the charge density wave state. Physical Review B 107, 184106 (2023).DOI
- [58]Li, H. et al. Rotation symmetry breaking in the normal state of a kagome superconductor kv3sb5. Nature Physics 18, 265–270 (2022).DOI
- [59]Zhao, H. et al. Cascade of correlated electron states in the kagome superconductor csv3sb5. Nature 599, 216–221 (2021).DOI
- [60]Liu, G. et al. Observation of anomalous amplitude modes in the kagome metal csv3sb5. Nature communications 13, 3461 (2022).DOI
- [61]He, G. et al. Anharmonic strong-coupling effects at the origin of the charge density wave in csv3sb5. Nature Communications 15, 1895 (2024).DOI






