WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Coupling Evaporation, Chemical Reactions, and Crystallization: A Population-Balance Framework Applied to Two-Step Perovskite Crystallization
Abstract
A limited understanding of how evaporation couples to crystallization pathways hampers control over the formation of solution-processed perovskite photoactive layers. Identifying these mechanisms-and learning how to select and tune them-is essential for achieving the desired crystal morphology and, ultimately, improving solar-cell performance and stability. To investigate crystallization pathways in evaporating thin films, we develop a simple and general zero-dimensional population-balance model that couples evaporation, chemical reactions, and crystallization. We use the model to explore a range of parameters for a solvent-solute system that follows a two-step crystallization pathway: solvent evaporation first induces formation of a crystalline precursor, which subsequently recrystallizes into the final phase. The model predicts the evolution of the film composition during drying and provides quantitative LaMer curves. Based on these results, we introduce a vocabulary of "supply limitations" and "rate limitations" that enables the interpretation of crystallization kinetics in terms of the governing process conditions.
Introduction
Solar cells are a primary energy-harvesting technology, with steadily decreasing energy costs per kilowatt-hour and, in many regions, a lower levelized cost of electricity than fossil-based generation. They contribute significantly to the renewable energy transition [1]. Solar cells with the potential for solution processing that avoid costly traditional high-vacuum, high-temperature fabrication conditions are progressing toward pilot-scale and early-stage industrial production [2]. Among the solution-processable photoactive layer materials, for which roll-to-roll production-compatible techniques, such as slot-die coating, have been demonstrated, metal halide perovskites are a promising class. This owes to their compositionally tunable optoelectronic properties and the high power conversion efficiencies of the resulting solar cells [3]. However, solution processing of thin films poses fundamental challenges for controlling their formation. For perovskites, the films’ optoelectronic properties are closely linked to film roughness, grain size, density, and grain-boundary density. Thus, achieving reproducible, durable, high-performing devices requires precise control of crystallization [4, 5]. This control, however, is challenging; in many deposition protocols, solvent evaporation dynamically controls crystallization, triggering nucleation after a critical solution concentration is reached, and determines the time evolution of the concentration-dependent nucleation and crystal growth rates. The chemical activity of the precursor solutions further amplifies this complexity.
To elucidate film formation mechanisms, a range of in situ characterization techniques has been used. Early studies relied primarily on ex situ X-ray diffraction (XRD) to analyze the final crystalline phases and infer crystallization pathways retrospectively [6]. More recently, time-resolved in situ techniques—including grazing-incidence wide-angle X-ray scattering (GI-WAXS) [7], optical laser or white light reflectometry (LR/WLR) [8, 9], and combined multimodal approaches [10]—have enabled direct observation of intermediate phases and phase transitions during drying and annealing [11]. These studies have significantly advanced the mechanistic understanding of perovskite crystallization [12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19]. Strong solvent-precursor interactions can lead to the formation of colloidal pre-clusters [20] and solvent-coordinated crystalline intermediate phases prior to the final perovskite. Intermediates alter supersaturation dynamics and provide alternative nucleation pathways: The perovskite may form directly, in parallel to, or from intermediate phases [21]. Consequently, the final film morphology—including grain size distribution, grain boundary density, and defect density—is highly sensitive to the specific crystallization pathway followed during deposition [22, 23]. Despite these advances in in situ monitoring, many investigations remain incomplete and qualitative [24]. In particular, evaporation kinetics, which control crystallization, are not consistently measured. Moreover, suggested film-formation pathways are rarely quantitatively tested against the data. In parallel, modeling frameworks that integrate chemical reactions, solvent evaporation, and crystallization are lacking in photovoltaic research. Quantitative modeling is rare and typically relies on decoupled, substantially simplified process descriptions. Evaporation of two solvents from a perovskite precursor solution has been successfully modeled under realistic coating conditions in [12, 19, 25] but without accounting for the solidification of the film. Furthermore, a single secondary perovskite crystallization could be modeled as a single process in [26] and [27], but the role of evaporation and prior solid-state precursor crystallization has not been likewise considered. In other fields, for instance, chemical engineering, more holistic approaches are employed. For chemical reactions, for example, automated model discrimination provides systematic strategies for assessing reaction pathways using experimental data [28]. For particulate systems, population balance modeling (PBM) can serve as a framework to describe how multiple distinct processes, such as chemical reactions, evaporation, and crystallization, jointly affect particle populations (e.g., crystals) [29]. For instance, it has been used for direct crystallization control of a polymer [30], to understand salt crystallization in droplets [31], or to rationalize the growth of single perovskite crystals at constant supersaturation [32]. However, such integrated approaches have not yet been widely applied to the formation of perovskite thin films. Applied modeling is rare and typically relies on decoupled or overly simplified process descriptions [26, 27, 33]. A general population balance model framework to clarify the role of evaporation in crystallization and perovskite crystallization pathways is still lacking.
Therefore, given the experimental findings on hypothetical mechanisms and the modeling state outlined above, we conclude that it is useful to propose a model that can simultaneously handle multiple chemical reactions, the evaporation of multiple solvents, and multiple successive or competitive crystallization processes.
In this paper, we propose a general zero-dimensional kinetic model for the evolution of the material composition in reactive, evaporating, and crystallizing thin films. The model, in principle, allows us to quantitatively compare a variety of process systems encompassing multiple coupled evaporation, crystallization, and chemical processes. Subsequently, in a simulation study, we investigate evaporation-induced successive crystallization for perovskite formation.
Model description
In this section, we detail our general modeling framework. It allows us to describe a set of processes (chemical reactions, evaporation, crystallization, sublimation, condensation, light-, or stress-induced evolution, demixing,...), over a set of states defined, for instance, by phase (e.g., gaseous (), liquid (), or solid ()) and molecular species (e.g. HO).
Population balance model
First, we outline the theory’s general idea. Then, for each process type, we go through the basic building blocks and the rate expressions in turn.
Consider a process converting reagents into distinct products with all :
Here, are the reactant and product stoichiometric coefficients. In the following, we consider only chemical reactions, crystallization, and evaporation processes, but these can, in principle, be replaced by any other process (sublimation, condensation, light- or stress-induced evolution, demixing, ...). Thereby, in this work, the reagents and products are defined by their chemical nature and phase state (e.g., chemical species in the liquid phase, a gaseous solvent, atoms or molecules in the crystalline state, etc.). However, more generally, they can also be defined by additional properties, such as mass or size (e.g., a polymer chain of given molar mass, a particle of given volume, ...). Then, the population balance for the number of moles of all reagents and products is given by the process advancement rate of process :
This allows us to obtain the contribution of process to the population evolution of any reagent or product as
whereby the sign is negative or positive depending on whether appears as a reactant or product. Finally, if there are active processes in the system, the global population evolution of each species is determined by the evolution of all processes. More specifically, if a species is involved as either reactant or product in of the processes with stoichiometry , its population changes as
The equation above expresses the population balance for all species subject to the set of active processes and enables evaluation of the time-dependent evolution of species populations.
In the following, we detail the process-specific rates for chemical reactions, evaporation, and crystallization. Thereby, the starting point for a process will typically be an empirical volumetric process advancement rate . This rate is measured with reference to the volume within which the process takes place, which we refer to as the ”mother phase volume” hereafter. The definition of the mother phase depends on the process and will be detailed below.
Chemical reactions
As a kinetic model for chemical reactions, we use a generalization of the of mass-action rate equations [34] formulated through chemical potentials rather than concentrations [35]. For a chemical reaction involving reactants , with stoichiometry with , whose chemical potentials in the liquid phase depend on the volume fractions , the chemical reaction rate is
For our target application, we consider reactions in a common liquid phase . Here, is an Arrhenius-type rate prefactor, assumed independent of composition, and the reaction orders are taken to equal the stoichiometric coefficients .
To characterize the mixture thermodynamics, we assume an incompressible liquid that can be described by the Flory-Huggins-Gibbs free energy density
where the , denote pairwise material volume interaction parameters and relative molar volumes with molar volumes and reference . From the free energy density, we deduce the material-resolved chemical potentials for the liquid part of the blend:
Thus in ideally mixing solutions with equal molar volumes , the chemical rate reduces to the standard mass action product of the concentrations where we used that the volume fractions are proportional to the concentrations by the molar volumes .
In general, each reaction thus introduces two free kinetic parameters, the pre-exponential factor and the activation energy of , which reduce to a single value under isothermal conditions.
Evaporation
Consider a thin film, consisting of a mixture containing, among non-evaporating materials (solutes and potentially some crystals), evaporating solvents . We describe the evaporation process as a phase transformation taking place at the surface separating the condensed film from the gas phase,
whereby the -th liquid solvent becomes gaseous and leaves the film.
For the rates, we use one of the semi-empirical expressions derived from the Hertz–Knudsen (HK) model [36], [37]. For each solvent , we have
which yields the expected average particle effusion rate through the surface. We approximately account for the slowdown of evaporation due to a reduction in initial surface area as the film becomes crystalline through the relative liquid-to-total film volume . The molecular escape probability depends only on the flow conditions and surface geometry. It can be considered constant given stationary drying conditions at constant temperature [38, 39]. For instance, can be used to account for the drying conditions encountered during spin coating [40, 41, 42] and gas quenching [19]. The basic assumption of HK, that the liquid-vapor interface is in equilibrium, i.e., , yields the solvent pressure at the film surface. Thereby, is the -th solvent vapor pressure and are its chemical potential in the liquid and gas phases, and is the gas constant. The driving force for evaporation is the pressure difference between the film surface and the environment . For gas molecules of mass , with the Boltzmann constant, multiplying the pressure by yields the rate at which particles cross a unit area of a plane from one side.
All in all, for evaporation, we consider one drying-condition-dependent adjustable parameter, , and pairwise interaction parameters .
Crystallization
For the derivation of a crystallization rate, we take inspiration from classical nucleation theory (CNT) [43] and the visualizations from spatial simulation approaches, such as [44], but mostly we lean on the commonly employed kinetic approach due to Kolmogorov-Johnson-Mehl-Avrami (KJMA) [45, 46].
A single crystallization process
We conceptualize crystallization as a particular phase transition (first order) where an liquid or solid material transitions to a different solid phase state through the sub-processes of nucleation and growth. Consider, for instance, the phase transition of a single material :
During nucleation, according to CNT, clusters of crystalline material called nuclei form within the mother phase volume due to thermal fluctuations. These nuclei either shrink or, when they exceed a critical size [], become stable nuclei that grow into macroscopic crystals. Thus, crystals begin to form at a characteristic nucleation rate density [#/ms] - that is, the number # of supercritical nuclei per unit time and per d-dimensional mother-phase volume. Note that with a composition-dependent nucleation rate density , the expected first crystal arrival or induction time is already implicitly determined.
During crystal growth, the sizes of the existing crystals increase. With each crystal, we associate a radius
whereby [] is the time of birth of the crystal, and [] is the velocity at which the crystal’s interface propagates, i.e., the ”growth rate”. The ”impingement function” accounts for the geometrical confinement of crystals by boundaries due to other crystals that hinder further growth into the directions where crystal interfaces touch. It decreases monotonically from 1, corresponding to freely growing crystals at the beginning of the process, to 0 when the volume is fully crystalline and all crystals impinge.
The crystallization rate can be expressed as the sum of the volume increases due to nucleation and growth:
Here, denotes the volume of a unit sphere, with gamma function and the number of linearly independent directions into which crystals grow, termed ”growth dimension”. The expression can be interpreted as follows: The first part of the right-hand side of Eq. (3) corresponds to nucleation: During a time step , a number of nuclei of volume form in the mother phase volume . The second part corresponds to growth: already-present nuclei contribute volume changes according to their time of appearance. The
volume change at time for each of the crystals born at is equal to . The volume increase due to all crystals born at all times between 0 and is therefore equal to , whereby is given by Eq. (2).
Eq. (3) constitutes our general crystallization model. However, to calculate for a concrete system, we need to specify further the nucleation rate density and growth rate as well as the impingement function for each crystallization process. Let us now discuss these quantities in detail for a system relevant to perovskites involving multiple crystallization processes.
Example including multiple crystallization processes
Consider three materials , , and , where and part of are liquid , and and part of are crystalline . The process system
includes a direct crystallization (P3) competing with a two-step crystallization (P0-P2). Once combines with into (P0), crystallizes (process P1) and eventually transforms to crystalline , releasing (P2). Thus, if we interpret as the solvent and as the dissolved precursor, P3 represents a direct crystallization, and P0-P2 a secondary crystallization of perovskite via solid-state intermediate phase formation of from solution.
Nucleation rate density and growth rate
To specify nucleation rate densities and growth rates, we draw inspiration from the commonly referred to as LaMer theory [47, 48]. LaMer theory, in essence, introduces two distinct thresholds for nucleation and growth that determine when each phase begins and ends, which we refer to as the criticality threshold and solubility limit.
For each crystallization, we use a reaction volume fraction , where the reactant volume is the amount of material available to the process in the mother phase. For Eq. (4) for instance, for P1 and for P2 is one if the mother phase is available and zero if not. Thus if for example P0 is balanced on the time scale of P1, one effectively has where , are the forward and backward rates for P0.
With and , one can then generally define composition-dependent nucleation and growth rates. In the following, we will, for instance, use
where are constant scalings. Eq. (4) constitutes a simple choice where both growth and nucleation accelerate as the available volume fraction of the crystallizing material increases beyond the thresholds . Generally, through refined expressions, additional effects, such as changes in the mixture's diffusion properties, curvature-driven growth, etc., can be accommodated.
Mother phases and impingement functions
To handle the process system Eq. (4), we introduce the following simplifying assumptions:
A1: Solid products of a crystallization cannot extend beyond the boundaries of their mother phase.
A2: Every crystalline phase can impinge against any other crystalline phase growing in the same phase.
A3: Liquid crystallization products end up in a common liquid phase.
In Figure 1, the situation is schematically visualized, assuming that , generated by P2, reenters the liquid phase. On the one hand, both C crystals and X crystals, due to the direct crystallizations P1 and P3, are produced from the liquid phase. Therefore, they share the liquid phase as their mother phase and thus can impinge on each other. On the other hand, X crystals due to P2 are produced in the phase, and therefore their mother phase

Figure 1. Sketch of material domains for competitive successive crystallization in a dilute liquid phase (). On the one hand, and directly crystallize from the liquid phase, and as solids, they occupy separate domains. On the other hand, resulting from re-crystallization of appears inside 's domain and thereby released reenters the common liquid phase. Because the conditions regarding material supply and crystal impingement differ for the crystallization processes between the liquid phase on the one hand () and the phase on the other hand, material supply and crystal impingement need to be distinguished between the processes.
is the phase, i.e., a separate solid phase. Thus, if we assume that the growing X crystals due to P2 remain within the phase domains, they can only impinge on each other but not on X crystals from process P3.
Therefore, considering Figure 1, we define the impingement volume as the volume of subdomains included in the mother-phase where crystallization is prohibited. Based on this definition, we make the following ansatz:
Here, represents the impingement volume fraction, and is a positive empirical exponent. Typically, the mother phase volume is consumed by crystallization, whereas the impingement volume corresponds to the volume of crystalline species.
Returning to our previous discussion of Eq. (4), for the liquid to solid transitions P1 and P3, the mother phase and impingement volumes are and . For the solid to solid transition P2, the mother phase and impingement volume are and , where and denote the solid products produced from processes P2 and P3, respectively.
For processes P1 and P3, the impingement volume fractions are equal and equal to the total liquid volume fraction: . In contrast, the impingement volume fraction for P2 is given by .
Here, decreases from one to zero - similar to a single process - but with a time-dependent denominator. , however, decreases monotonically from one and reaches zero only if the final state is fully crystalline, which depends on the initial amounts of and .
To determine , we turn to a single crystallization of a pure material from its liquid phase . In this case, one can compare the crystalline volume fraction evolutions predicted by our model, Eq. (2) and Eq. (3), with those predicted by KJMA. Assuming for this constant rates (), () and , our model is expected to recover . Adjusting to fit our model curves to the KJMA curves, we thus choose the value , which we use in the following. Figure 11 shows such a fit for some choice of parameters.

Figure 11. Transformed crystalline volume fraction per time for a single crystallization in a -blend, calculated from our crystallization cell-model and the common literature model KJMA0: . For a critical radius , nucleation rate density , and growth rate . The curves generated with our model using an impingement function closely match the curves from the common KJMA0 model.
Per crystallization, we thus have six parameters that are: The growth dimension , the critical radius , a growth rate and nucleation rate density scaling , and two thresholds, one saturation limit per growth rate and one criticality threshold per nucleation rate density. The latter are, however, obsolete for solid-state transitions ().
Model System for Perovskite film formation
To illustrate the typically expected - but not validated-behavior of our general model, for a particular system, we consider coating of the common perovskite reference Methylammonium lead halide (MAPI) from standard solvents such as Dimethylformamide (DMF), Dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), and N-Methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP). For these materials in-situ data on process mechanisms are available [14, 15, 16, 18, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53].
As reported by these studies, perovskite crystallization from a solvent-precursor solution involves several processes: solvent () evaporation [19], solvent and precursor (, ) coordination into complexes () eventually forming colloidal clusters [16], and a crystalline solid state precursor (), as well as crystallization of perovskite (), either directly or from the solid state precursor [15].
Based on this, we propose the following reference process system template for perovskite formation from solution:
Although the representation is schematic, we use effective species by summarizing the complete solution chemistry in terms of two chemical reactions. We mostly ignore stoichiometry. This makes the process system generic, enabling it to serve as a starting point for analyzing a wide range of material systems.
Figure 2 shows the corresponding time-resolved composition of a film for an illustrative set of parameters: Dissolved precursor (yellow) reacts with the solvent (blue), building up complexes (purple). Solvent evaporation reduces the total film height (black) and increases the complex concentration. As the complex concentration rises, perovskite (dark red) or solid-state precursor (orange) starts crystallizing. Once an intermediate phase is present, it recrystallizes into perovskite, thereby releasing the solvent. Finally, when the solvent has evaporated and all intermediate phase has recrystallized, a pure perovskite film remains.
Figure 2. Composition of a drying perovskite ink depending on processing time: denotes the volumes of the species and the total initial volume. Liquid solvent (blue) evaporates reducing the total film volume (black). Solvent coordinates with liquid precursor (yellow) building up complexes (purple). The increasingly concentrated complexes accumulate and reorganize into crystalline perovskite (dark red) or solid-state precursor (orange) clusters. Subsequently, the intermediate phase recrystallizes into the perovskite phase, releasing a structurally integrated solvent.
In our modeling framework, the system Eq. (5), with two chemical reactions, one evaporation, and three crystallizations, involves at least free parameters, making parameter studies challenging. Therefore, to understand the basic system behavior, we
will focus on the successive crystallization subsystem:
Here, we adapted the stoichiometry to the DMF/MAPI material system Table I. corresponds to DMF, to PbI + MAI, to MAPI-2(DMF), and to MAPI. Eq. (6) can be viewed as the crystallization sector of our template Eq. (4), without direct perovskite crystallization, provided that the chemical equilibrium is balanced on the timescale of evaporation and crystallization.
Model Behaviour
We turn to studying Eq. (6). Our strategy is to build understanding from interpretable subsystems, using simulated curves to explore which subsystems — and which curve features — are informative about the process system. The extracted physical interpretations do not depend strongly on the precise parameter values but only on the parameter regimes. For instance, to vary crystallization speeds, we vary the growth rates rather than the nucleation rate density . This choice does not affect the interpretations, since increasing either rate leads to more crystal volume appearing at earlier times. The simulation results presented are, for concreteness, based on material parameters for Dimethylformamid (DMF) as the solvent and Methylammonium lead halide (MAPI) as the perovskite. For more detailed information on the parameters, see Appendix § 1.4 B.
Preliminary study: direct crystallization of a pure material
As we use a non-standard crystallization model, we first consider a single crystallization of a material :
Furthermore, we assume that initially all material is in the liquid state .
Consider Figure 3. In panels a) and b), the contributions from nucleated crystalline volume (the first part of the LHS of Eq. (3)) are negligible (). The standard sigmoidal shape of the crystallization curves shifts to later times as the growth-rate scaling decreases. Panel b) demonstrates that the parameter space is degenerate: For each of the three growth dimensions (green, orange black) two distinct combinations of growth and nucleation rate density scalings , yield identical curves. That the factor controls the crystallization timescale rather aligns with expectations based on KJMA theory. In contrast, panels c) and d) explore cases where a non-negligible fraction of the crystalline volume has nucleated. In panel c), for and finite we adjust the relative importance of and while keeping constant. For very large nucleation rates, the volume change due to nucleation becomes dominant, and the crystallization curve is no longer controlled by . While the curves overlap at higher growth rates for a constant (as seen in black and red), as nucleation increasingly dominates (from orange to blue), the curves change shape drastically. This transition between nucleation- and growth-dominated regimes is also reflected in the Avrami plot in panel d), where the slope is often associated with the growth dimension. The slope, however, cannot be interpreted as the growth dimension in general; rather, it ranges from 1 to 3, corresponding to the exponents of the nucleation- and growth-dominated regimes, respectively. For the ensuing investigations, we are primarily interested in the features of the curves related to the process system. Therefore, without loss of generality, we restrict variations in crystallization speeds to the standard growth-dominated regime and vary either or .

Figure 3. Crystallization of a pure material: Relative time-resolved mole numbers of for a) different growth rates and b) at constant scaling with growth rate raised to the growth dimension , and nucleation rate density . c) and d) Variation of relative importance of nucleation against growth for c), relative time-resolved mole numbers of , d) a monotonic transformed version of c) and the volume fraction called Avrami plot. The crystallization curves in a) shift to later times, from black to blue, as the growth rate increases. Their sigmoid shape is typically expected. b) Several combinations of distinct nucleation rate density and growth rate scalings raised by the growth dimension yield equivalent crystallization curves. This depends on the balance between nucleation and crystallization, as illustrated in panels c) and d). As the importance of relative to for increases (black to blue), the Avrami Exponent d) decreases. The degeneracy of the parameter space demonstrated in b) is reflected in the concentration of curves in c) when the growth-rate scaling is dominant.
Solvent-integrating crystallization
Now consider the primary crystallization step as in Eq. (6):
Here, when a sufficient amount of precursor is dissolved in the solvent , the precursor crystallizes into
a distinct solid material that structurally incorporates solvent. In contrast to the previously considered direct crystallization (Section IV A), the transformation now occurs in a precursor-solvent environment. Furthermore, it depends on the relative amounts of the two reactant species and . To appreciate the qualitative behavior difference, we consider variations of the initial precursor volume fraction .
In Figure 4 panel a), the transformed precursor mole numbers are plotted against time. The LaMer graph in panel b) characterizes the instantaneous state of the solution by the time-dependent precursor volume fraction in the liquid phase. The horizontal lines therein correspond to the implied material-specific solubility and criticality limits given by the condition . The two resulting limits correspond to the liquid precursor in the solvent and the solvent in the liquid precursor . At the equimolar volume fraction , the same number of reactant molecules are available relative to the process: . If the initial precursor liquid volume fraction lies outside the range set by the criticality limit and the equimolar volume fraction — either below it (black, ), or above it (blue, ) crystallization does not occur. This happens since in both cases one of the two reactants, and , becomes too sparse to trigger nucleation. Otherwise, if the initial precursor volume fraction lies within the critical region (between the dotted lines) - (orange and red) or (yellow and green) - crystallization occurs. It then proceeds in the direction of the limiting reactant until either the saturation limit above or below the equimolar volume fraction is reached. For instance, if there is less liquid precursor than solvent (), the crystallization is limited by the available precursor. The precursor liquid volume fraction approaches the solubility limit of the precursor in the solvent, . For a series of initializations approaching the equimolar reactant initialization (within the critical region) form either below (red, orange) or above (green, yellow), therefore the final amount of crystalline material increases. The process kinetics, in contrast, depends on the likelihood of finding the three-molecule combination , hence the process speed therefore is not necessarily maximal at the equimolar reactant initialization .

Figure 4. Solvent integrating crystallization for different initial precursor volume fractions . a) Relative mole number of intermediate phase () molecules against time. b) Precursor volume fraction per time (LaMer Curve) with solubility and criticality thresholds for precursor () and solvent (), and equimolar reactant volume fraction . The process starts only if the initial precursor concentration lies in the critical region between and (between the dotted lines). If the process starts, it proceeds until its supply is exhausted, which occurs when a saturation limit is reached. For instance, if precursor is sparse compared to solvent the precursor will be exhausted first and therefore the lower solubility limit is approached. The final amount of intermediate phase formed therefore is higher for initial precursor volume fractions that are closer to the equimolar volume fraction (comparing only volume fractions on the same side, e.g., either below or above ).
Successive Crystallization of a pure material
As a first combination of two crystallizations, consider the two successive steps:
{#eq:P\gamma}
Here, initially, liquid crystallizes into solid , which recrystallizes into solid . Thereby, the progress of the first process referred to as Pγ depends on the supply of solid provided by the process Pβ. Therefore, we will investigate the system’s behavior with respect to the relative speeds of the two processes. Without loss of generality, we will vary the speed of Pγ relative to the speed of Pβ, varying Pγ’s growth rate. Initially, there is an unlimited consumption of by Pγ, where it proceeds independently of Pβ. However, as Pγ becomes process-limited by Pβ, the production of converges to the up-slope of the rise.
In Figure 5, the curve in a) remains unchanged upon variations of Pγ’s speed. If Pγ is so slow that the production of completes before the production of begins (black to orange), the kinetics of are independent of the kinetics of . The curves reflect both the crystallization kinetics of (the build-up phase) and the crystallization kinetics of . As the speed of Pγ increases (from yellow to green), the kinetics of Pγ become partly limited by Pβ.

Figure 5. Successive crystallization for different growth rates of the secondary crystallization step. Mole numbers per material relative to the total initial number of moles over time. a) The single collapsed curve (blue) corresponds to the up-flank of the curves in b). c) As the speed of the crystallization increases with higher growth rates (black to blue), the maximal cumulative amount of decreases. This, in the extreme, leads to a process-limited secondary crystallization step (yellow to blue).
In extreme cases, for the green curve, this can lead to an extended tail after the peak: until Pγ becomes limited by Pβ, the consumption of by Pγ outpaces the production of by Pβ. Once Pγ becomes limited by Pβ, its consumption matches Pβ’s production, resulting in a plateau that eventually ends when Pγ stops.
Finally, if Pγ is significantly faster than Pβ (as shown by the blue curves), the global transformation process is completely limited by Pβ. In this scenario, the production of is entirely controlled by the production of . The production of becomes nearly unobservable, and the observed production of ultimately reflects the kinetics of formation.
More importantly, if the kinetics of production are entirely dictated by the crystallization of , the absolute height of the peak will be very low. Therefore, in the case of perovskite formation, the absence of a signal (for example, from in-situ GIWAXS) corresponding to an intermediate phase does not provide sufficient evidence to conclude that formation occurs through direct crystallization.
Successive solvent-coupled crystallization
As compared to the successive crystallization Section IV C, the successive subsystem appearing in Eq. (6) and given by
additionally involves the solvent . The release of by P3 therefore always couples the processes, and this feedback from P3 to P2 can alter P2. Therefore, as previously, we will analyze the role of the release by P3 by varying the initial precursor volume fraction.
Figure 6 shows the LaMer curve for various initial precursor volume fractions (black to blue). The effect of the solvent coupling on the crystallization P2 can be assessed by comparison with Figure 4. If there is an oversupply of either or , such that is fully miscible in or is fully miscible in , the process cannot proceed. In contrast to Figure 4, however, when is abundant, and is sparse, the process always proceeds to fully exhaust . This is possible since P3 resupplies . The effect of the solvent coupling, therefore, is that P3 can effectively lift any solvent supply limitation on P2.
P2, as compared to the solvent, integrating crystallization Section IV B, therefore depends only weakly on the amount of solvent. Because of this, we expect the material amount curves based on P2 and P3 to show few qualitative differences from those based on the successive system without the solvent coupling Figure 5. To test this, we also vary the speed of the secondary crystallization, P3, relative to that of the first, P2. In particular we consider a fixed initial volume ratio of to within the region where is the limiting reactant .
Compare Figure 7 with Figure 5 based on the successive system Figure 5. Here, in the solvent-coupled successive crystallizations (P2 and P3), even if the secondary step (P3) is slower than the first (P2), the steps do not decouple. This occurs because, initially, there is less solvent reactant than there is of the precursor reactant . Consequently, P2 eventually requires P3 to resupply the solvent to proceed (yellow process).
In the extreme, when P3 is much slower than P2 (black curve), P2 can become fully P3-limited, yielding a flat peak. Two other differences are evident when comparing the amounts of the final product . First, the conversion is incomplete as the curve does not reach zero. This is the expected influence of the finite solubility threshold of the precursor in the solvent, which dictates that the precursor can only be consumed above . Second, while the amounts of final product are constant for the successive system (Figure 5), they can vary for the solvent-coupled successive system (Figure 7). One might again suspect the influence of P2’s solubility threshold. However, according to Figure 4, for a single crystallization from solution that starts at constant initial volume fraction, the amount of final product should not change with the speed of the process. Instead, the differences in the amount of final product arise not from varying initial amounts of solvent, but from differences in the final amount of solvent. If P3 is sufficiently slow (black to orange and curves), P3 will continue after P2 has stopped because P2’s precursor supply is exhausted. As P3 continues to resupply solvent , the final solution will therefore contain less precursor than dictated by the solubility limit. Conversely, if P3 is sufficiently fast (yellow to purple), the time lag between the stopping of P2 and P3 becomes small. Consequently, both processes effectively come to a halt when the solubility limit of the precursor in the solvent is reached. The final amount of the perovskite , therefore, again depends only on the initial amounts of the precursor and solvent.

Figure 7. Successive crystallization with solvent coupling. Variation of the growth rates of the crystallization with fixed solvent-limited crystallization. Relative material-resolved mole numbers over time. a,b,c) Precursor and solvent are consumed to build up intermediate phase crystals, which then recrystallize into the perovskite . d) For larger growth rate scalings , crystallization becomes faster than crystallization and is limited by it (yellow to purple). For smaller growth rate scalings (orange to black), crystallization from is slower than crystallization. As initially there are fewer than molecules available for integration into , the crystallization of is limited in its final stages by the release of solvent from due to the crystallization of . For the black curve, this leads to an extended plateau at its maximum height.
Evaporation-induced, solvent-integrating crystallization
In real-life processing of perovskite films for photovoltaics, crystallization is induced by solvent evaporation. Within our modeling framework, the description of the intermediate phase crystallization thus requires an evaporation process coupled to a single concentration-dependent crystallization:
X^{(\ell)} + 2S^{(\ell)} \to C^{(s)}
In contrast to the concentration-dependent crystallization discussed in the absence of evaporation (Section IV B), here the precursor concentration also changes due to the solvent evaporation P1. Evaporation increases the precursor concentration over time. Hence we expect the crystallization P2 to occur eventually—even starting from sub-critical initial concentrations . Once crystallization begins, its progress depends on the relative rates of evaporation and crystallization. We therefore fix the evaporation-rate parameters while varying the growth rate of the crystallization process, P2.

Figure 6. Successive crystallization with solvent coupling for different initial precursor volume fractions . Liquid precursor volume fraction per time. Crystallization happens only if lies in the critical region between the dotted curves defined by the criticality limits for the liquid precursor in the solvent and solvent in the liquid precursor, respectively (for green to red but not for black and blue). Crystallization ends only when the precursor saturation limit is reached (lower dotted line) and proceeds towards this limit even starting from initial precursor volume fractions close to the solvent in precursor solubility limit (green).
Consider the LaMer graphs in Figure 8 panel b). There are two asymptotes corresponding to two final states that we identify from the and curves: As evaporates, first, the precursor concentration becomes larger than and triggers nucleation. Afterward, if the crystallization is fast (blue to yellow), buildup proceeds (see curve) until the precursor volume fraction in the liquid reaches the saturation limit . Subsequently, since the crystallization P2 lowers supersaturation faster than evaporation builds it up, P2 is limited by the rate at which evaporation builds supersaturation. This results in a single maximum in the LaMer curve, followed by a constant regime at the solubility limit. Otherwise, if crystallization is slow (orange to black), the solvent fully evaporates before the precursor is exhausted, leaving liquid residues of the precursor.
Figure 8. Evaporation-induced crystallization for various crystal growth rates . a,b,c) Relative material-resolved molecule numbers over time. d) Precursor volume fraction in liquid phase per time. Black horizontal lines indicate characteristic thresholds for solubility , criticality and equimolar reactants . a,b,c) evaporation builds supersaturation, inducing crystallization that exhausts the precursor. c) For large growth-rate scalings (yellow to blue), crystallization occurs much faster than evaporation. The crystallization exhausts the supersaturation and then becomes kinetically limited by the evaporation. Otherwise, for small growth rates (orange to black), is completely removed before all is integrated into the , leaving precursor residues (2). b) The LaMer curve correspondingly shows two distinct behaviors (blue to yellow) and (orange to black).
Both regimes are also visible in the precursor and the intermediate phase curves. Consider, for instance, : If the crystallization P2 is fast (blue to yellow) after a steep rise corresponding to the free P2 kinetics, a sudden slowdown becomes visible towards the end. This secondary slope in the curve is entirely determined by evaporation; we therefore say that P2 becomes evaporation-limited. Despite P2’s evaporation-limited kinetics, however, in this regime, crystallization proceeds until all precursor available to the process (up to the solubility limit) is finally consumed. In contrast, when crystallization (P2) is significantly slower than evaporation (P1) (orange to black), the solvent can evaporate before the precursor is fully converted to the intermediate phase; therefore, crystallization stops as the solvent is exhausted.
In summary, slow evaporation relative to crystallization leads to the complete conversion of into through two subsequent kinetic regimes. In contrast, fast evaporation leads to partial conversion through a single kinetic regime.
Evaporation-induced successive solvent-coupled crystallization
Finally, we add the secondary intermediate phase-to-perovskite crystallization step to the evaporation-induced intermediate phase crystallization system:
As before, we restrict the volume fraction to below the criticality limit, which ensures that crystallization of (P2) is evaporation-induced. From our analysis of evaporation-induced -integrating crystallization Section IV E, we expect P2 kinetics to fall into two distinct regimes, depending on its speed relative to the evaporation (P1). If the evaporation is slow compared with the crystallization of (“P1 < P2”), P2 kinetics become evaporation-limited. If evaporation is fast (“P1 > P2”), P2 kinetics become solvent-limited. In addition, the relative speed of the secondary crystallization of (P3) compared with P1 and P2 may also matter. In principle, each of the six possible speed orderings of P1, P2, and P3 (e.g., “P1 < P2 < P3”, “P2 < P1 < P3”, ...) could yield distinct behavior. To scan these, we first fix both the evaporation P1 and the crystallization P2, and then consider the effects of accelerating P3 by increasing its growth rate.
P2 evaporation-limited
The curves in panel a) of Figure 9 show the kinked rise characteristic of evaporation-limited kinetics. This occurs when crystallization is faster than evaporation, as in the yellow-to-blue curves of Figure 8 panel (a). Likewise, and for the same reason, the conversion of to is complete in all cases here. The collapsed LaMer curves in panel b) (blue to black) essentially correspond to the single LaMer curve for evaporation-induced-limited crystallization in Figure 8 panel b) (blue and green). Therefore, the influence of recycling on the global kinetics is negligible regardless of the relative speed of P3: whether P3 is slower than P2 (black to red), of the same order as P2 (orange), or faster than P2 (yellow to blue). This might also be expected since is always present in excess. Still, the global evolution and formation depend on the kinetic balance between P2 and P3. This manifests as a transition between ”kinetics only weakly coupled by recycling” and ”P3 fully P2-limited”.

Figure 9. Evaporation-induced successive solvent coupled crystallization for various growth rates of the secondary crystallization, starting from an evaporation-induced primary crystallization that is faster than the evaporation. a,b,c) Relative material resolved time-dependent molecule numbers. b) Precursor volume fractions in the liquid phase. a,b,c) Solvent evaporation induces the crystallization, which exhausts the precursor . c) The crystallization is limited by the evaporation, as it drains supersaturation faster than it is built up by the evaporation (blue to black). d) Simultaneously, crystallizes from , and this process can either be limited by the production of (yellow to blue) or proceed independently (black to orange). In all cases, within the significant crystallization region, the LaMer curves in panel b) collapse to a single curve. Initially, the supersaturation threshold for the liquid precursor in the solvent is reached. Subsequently, it is consumed by the crystallization, which continues at the saturation limit .
P2 solvent-limited
Now, we fix the evaporation kinetics and keep the primary crystallization P2 slower than the evaporation, as for orange and red in Figure 8. Subsequently, we vary the speed of the secondary crystallization, P3, via the growth-rate scaling. The curves in Figure 10 show three regimes.

Figure 10. Evaporation-induced successive solvent-coupled crystallization for various growth rates of the secondary crystallization and starting from an initially evaporation-induced primary crystallization that is slower than the evaporation. a,b,c) Relative material-resolved molecule numbers over time. e) Precursor volume fractions in the liquid phase per time. a,b,c) Evaporation of the solvent induces crystallization, which drains but may not completely consume it (red to black in b). d) forms from releasing solvent. If the crystallization is sufficiently fast (orange to purple), it lifts the solvent limitation from the crystallization. If it is slow (red to black), however, it can only partially counterbalance solvent evaporation. The crystallization therefore remains solvent-limited, which results in residues. The LaMer curves in panel e) show two basic behaviors in the significant crystallization regions. For the faster crystallizations (purple to orange), the concentration of the supersaturated precursor decreases to the saturation limit of the precursor in the solvent, , at which the crystallization subsequently continues. Conversely, for slower crystallizations (red to black), the solvent is exhausted before the precursor . Consequently, the liquid precursor volume-fraction curves approach 1.
If P3 is very slow (black), the recycled evaporates before it can be consumed by P2. P2’s kinetics therefore remain solvent-limited: crystallization stops early, and residues may remain. As a result, to conversion is incomplete.
If P3 is slightly faster (red), the solvent limitation on P2 can be partly lifted, resulting in distinct crystallization phases. The LaMer curve in panel b) crosses three times: crystal growth pauses after the first crossing, then resumes between the second and third crossings. Finally, if P3 is sufficiently fast (orange to purple), solvent recycling due to P3 lifts the solvent limitation on P2. Consequently, is fully converted to and the -to- conversion is complete. Within this regime, for P3 even faster (purple), P3 is P2-limited, and the curve follows the production—as also visible in the corresponding curve.
Conclusions
In summary, we developed a general zero-dimensional population balance framework coupling crystallization, evaporation, and chemical reactions. For perovskite films formed from solution, we proposed an effective reaction template informed by multichannel in situ studies of MAPI in common solvents, intended as a reasonable mechanistic prior for these systems. Within that framework, we used parameter sweeps to investigate the evaporation-driven two-step (successive) crystallization subsystem, building up from subsystems with fewer coupled processes.
The resulting quantitative evaporation, phase-resolved crystallization, and LaMer curves yield several findings and their consequences:
Allowing finite-size nuclei, crystallization admits a nucleation-dominated regime alongside the classical growth-dominated one, lowering the Avrami exponent without changing the growth dimension. The Avrami exponent is therefore ambiguous as a growth dimension.
When a secondary step is kinetically limited by the primary one, the intermediate phase can be practically invisible, although the mechanism is indirect. The absence of an intermediate signal is insufficient evidence for direct formation.
With limited solvent, the primary and secondary solvent-coupled steps are mutually coupled regardless of their relative rates. In the evaporation-driven case, intermediate crystallization is therefore either incomplete, from solvent depletion when evaporation is fast, or rate-limited by evaporation itself rather than by its own kinetics when it is slow; perovskite can also form at the evaporation rate with no intermediate detectable at all. Evaporation therefore shapes both phase-specific crystallization curves — directly the intermediate’s, and, through it, the perovskite’s — so neither curve identifies the mechanism on its own, and evaporation must be measured with them.
These findings concern the subsystem studied; because they depend mainly on relative timescales, they should hold irrespective of the rate parameters, and hence of material system and processing conditions. Varying evaporation rates rather than crystallization rates, for instance, should give equivalent results [54].
Where diffusion limitations or preferential crystallization at the substrate or film surface dominate, spatially resolved modeling will be required. Because the template retains the direct and successive channels in parallel, their competition can be examined without further model construction, and because mechanistic specificity enters only through the rate parameters, the same framework applies to other materials and to the effects of temperature and precursor composition. Ultimately, these mechanistic signatures offer a route to distinguishing crystallization pathways from the features of measurable drying and phase-resolved composition curves.
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge the financial support from the Helmholtz Association through the Solar Technology Acceleration Platform for emerging Photovoltaics (Solar-TAP) and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) via the Collaborative Research Center (‘ChemPrint’, Project No. 538767711, CRC 1719).
Appendix
Model Description
Model Behaviour
a. Simulation Setup Each run is specified by the material properties Table I, its initial and boundary conditions, the temperature , Flory parameter and evaporation prefactor (Table II), and the parameters of each crystallization, and, where present,
| DMF | PbI | MAI | MAPI | |
| chemical formula | CHNO | PbI | CHNHI | [CHNH]PbI |
| density [] | 944 | 6160 | 2280 | 4118 |
| molar mass [] | 0.0731 | 0.4610 | 0.1590 | 0.6200 |
| vapor pressure [] | 490.9 |
caption: TABLE I. Material characteristics at [], [].
:::
| Fig. | Processes | [] | |||
| 3 | |||||
| 4 | |||||
| 5 | |||||
| 6 | |||||
| 7 | |||||
| 8 | 351 | 0 | |||
| 9 | 352 | 0 | |||
| 10 | 352 | 0 |
Table 2. TABLE II. Initial and boundary conditions. is the initial composition with solute, solvent, solid-state intermediate, perovskite components; are the pairwise Flory–Huggins interaction parameters and is the prefactor appearing in the rate expression Eq. (1) for the evaporation , absent where no evaporation is active.
| Fig. | Cryst. | [#/m] | [m/s] | [m] | ||||
| One crystallisation | ||||||||
| 3 a) | 3 | 0 | 0 | |||||
| 3 b) | 0 | 0 | ||||||
| 3 c,d) | 3 | 0 | 0 | |||||
| 4 | 3 | 0.1 | 0.25 | |||||
| Two crystallisations | ||||||||
| 5 | 1 | 0 | 0 | |||||
| 5 | 3 | 0 | 0 | |||||
| 6 | 1 | 0.05 | 0.15 | |||||
| 6 | 3 | 0.1 | 0.25 | |||||
| 7 | 1 | 0.1 | 0.25 | |||||
| 7 | 3 | 0.1 | 0.25 | |||||
| Evaporation active (, Table II) | ||||||||
| 8 | 3 | 0.05 | 0.15 | |||||
| 9 | 3 | 0.05 | 0.15 | |||||
| 9 | 3 | 0.05 | 0.15 | |||||
| 10 | 3 | 0.05 | 0.15 | |||||
| 10 | 3 | 0.05 | 0.15 |
Table 3. TABLE III. Crystallisation parameters , are the rescaled nucleation rate density and growth rate scalings, is growth dimension, the critical radius and the growth and nucleation thresholds. is the reactant volume fraction given in the third column.
(Table Table III) according to the rate laws:
For and , and using and , these are identical to Eq. (4). In the main text, the factors and have been absorbed into the scalings and , respectively, for ease of presentation. The reaction volume fraction entering Eq. (4) is supplied by one of three closures: for the pure-material runs, where crystallisation is solvent-coupled, and for . A cell marked indicates a parameter that is varied across the curves of the figure/panel if specified, with the per-curve values given in the figure legend. Quantities are dimensionless if no unit is noted.
Parameters were generally chosen so that the effects discussed in the main text are visible within a single observation window.
b. Numeric All evolution equations were solved using a first-order Euler discretization with rate-clipping safeguards to ensure positivity while preserving population number conservation. Domain constraints for physical quantities have generally been enforced explicitly. Simulation results have been cross-checked for several time resolutions. Physical consistency against the expectations based on the reaction systems has been assessed in all cases. Where possible, implementations have been validated against analytical results, e.g., Figure 11.
References
References
- [1]International Renewable Energy Agency, Renewable Power Generation Costs in 2021, Tech. Rep. (International Renewable Energy Agency, Abu Dhabi, 2022).
- [2]O. Almora, G. C. Bazan, C. I. Cabrera, et al., Device Performance of Emerging Photovoltaic Materials (Version 5), Advanced Energy Materials 15, 2404386 (2025).
- [3]S. Lee, N.-G. Park, and H. S. Jung, Cutting-Edge Advances in Scalable Perovskite Photovoltaic Devices, MRS Bulletin 49, 1265 (2024).DOI
- [4]F. Yang, D. Jang, L. Dong, et al., Upscaling Solution-Processed Perovskite Photovoltaics, Advanced Energy Materials 11, 2101973 (2021).DOI
- [5]S. Qiu, M. Majewski, L. Dong, et al., Over one-micron-thick void-free perovskite layers enable highly efficient and fully printed solar cells, Energy & Environmental Science 18, 5926 (2025).
- [6]J. Wang, W. Wang, Y. Chen, et al., Growth and Degradation Kinetics of Organic–Inorganic Hybrid Perovskite Films Determined by In Situ Grazing-Incidence X-Ray Scattering Techniques, Small Methods 5, 2100829 (2021).DOI
- [7]J. A. Steele, E. Solano, D. Hardy, et al., How to GI-WAXS: Grazing Incidence Wide Angle X-Ray Scattering Applied to Metal Halide Perovskite Thin Films, Advanced Energy Materials 13, 2300760 (2023).
- [8]B. Schmidt-Hansberg, M. Baunach, J. Krenn, et al., Spatially Resolved Drying Kinetics of Multi-Component Solution Cast Films for Organic Electronics, Chemical Engineering and Processing: Process Intensification 50, 509 (2011).
- [9]J. Rappich, C. Kaspari, C. Camus, and N. H. Nickel, Fast Optical Reflectance Measurements during Spin Coating and Annealing of Organic–Inorganic Perovskite Precursor Solutions, physica status solidi (b) 258, 2000479 (2021).
- [10]V. Da Silva, J. Just, Áureo. Freitas, et al., Multimodal Data Acquisition System at MAX IV, in Proceedings of the 20th International Conference on Accelerator and Large Experimental Physics Control Systems (ICALEPCS 2025) (2025) pp. 1279–1284.DOI
- [11]R. Sztosak, A. de Souza Gonçalves, J. N. de Freitas, et al., In Situ and Operando Characterizations of Metal Halide Perovskite and Solar Cells: Insights from Lab-Sized Devices to Upscaling Processes, Chemical Reviews 123, 3160 (2023).
- [12]S. Ternes, T. Börnhorst, J. A. Schwenzer, et al., Drying Dynamics of Solution-Processed Perovskite Thin-Film Photovoltaics: In Situ Characterization, Modeling, and Process Control, Advanced Energy Materials 9, 1901581 (2019).DOI
- [13]A. Merdasa, C. Rehermann, K. Hirselandt, et al., Eye in the Process: Formation of “Triple Cation” Perovskite Thin Films Rationalized by in Situ Optical Monitoring (2020), preprint.DOI
- [14]N. Alhazmi, E. Pineda, J. Rawle, et al., Perovskite Crystallization Dynamics during Spin-Casting: An In Situ Wide-Angle X-ray Scattering Study, ACS Applied Energy Materials 3, 6155 (2020).DOI
- [15]O. Shargaeva, H. Nässt rö m, J. Li, et al., Temperature-Dependent Crystallization Mechanisms of Methylammonium Lead Iodide Perovskite From Different Solvents, Frontiers in Energy Research 9 (2021).
- [16]S. Pratap, F. Babbe, N. S. Barchi, et al., Out-of-Equilibrium Processes in Crystallization of Organic-Inorganic Perovskites during Spin Coating, Nature Communications 12, 5624 (2021).DOI
- [17]C. Rehermann, V. Schröder, M. Flatken, et al., Role of Solution Concentration in Formation Kinetics of Bromide Perovskite Thin Films during Spin-Coating Monitored by Optical in Situ Metrology, RSC Advances 12, 32765 (2022).DOI
- [18]M. A. Reus, L. K. Reb, A. F. Weinzierl, et al., Time-Resolved Orientation and Phase Analysis of Lead Halide Perovskite Film Annealing Probed by In Situ GIWAXS, Advanced Optical Materials 10, 2102722 (2022).DOI
- [19]S. Ternes, J. Mohacsi, N. Lüdtke, et al., Drying and Coating of Perovskite Thin Films: How to Control the Thin Film Morphology in Scalable Dynamic Coating Systems, ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 14, 11300 (2022).DOI
- [20]S. Pratap, Hybrid Perovskites : Colloidal Precursors to Thin Films, Ph.D. thesis, Technische Universität München (2021).
- [21]L. Schmidt-Mende, V. Dyakonov, S. Olthof, et al., Roadmap on Organic–Inorganic Hybrid Perovskite Semiconductors and Devices, APL Materials 9, 109202 (2021).
- [22]I. Hwang, Challenges in Controlling the Crystallization Pathways and Kinetics for Highly Reproducible Solution-Processing of Metal Halide Perovskites, The Journal of Physical Chemistry C 127, 24011 (2023).DOI
- [23]A. G. Ortoll-Bloch, H. C. Herbol, B. A. Sorenson, et al., Bypassing Solid-State Intermediates by Solvent Engineering the Crystallization Pathway in Hybrid Organic-Inorganic Perovskites, Crystal Growth & Design 20, 1162 (2020).
- [24]S. Ternes, C. J. Brabec, L. A. Castriotta, et al., Process Parameter Specification and Control in Solution Processing of Hybrid Perovskite Photovoltaics: From Domain-Specific Jargon to Evidence-Based, Unambiguous Description of Experimental Workflows, Advanced Energy Materials 15, e03187 (2025).
- [25]S. Ternes, In Situ Characterization and Modelling of Drying Dynamics for Scalable Printing of Hybrid Perovskite Photovoltaics, Ph.D. thesis, KIT (2022).DOI
- [26]K. Suchan, J. Just, P. Becker, et al., Optical in Situ Monitoring during the Synthesis of Halide Perovskite Solar Cells Reveals Formation Kinetics and Evolution of Optoelectronic Properties, Journal of Materials Chemistry A 8, 10439 (2020).DOI
- [27]N. Mrkyvkova, V. Held, P. Nádasdy, et al., Combined in Situ Photoluminescence and X-ray Scattering Reveals Defect Formation in Lead-Halide Perovskite Films, The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 12, 10156 (2021).DOI
- [28]C. J. Taylor, M. Booth, J. A. Manson, et al., Rapid, automated determination of reaction models and kinetic parameters, Chemical Engineering Journal 413, 127017 (2021).DOI
- [29]J. B. Rawlings, S. M. Miller, and W. R. Witkowski, Model Identification and Control of Solution Crystallization Processes: A Review, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 32, 1275 (1993).DOI
- [30]M. T. Verki, R. H. Haldadj, S. Habibzehadeh, and F. M. Shalmani, Crystallization and Particle Size Distribution of Hydrothermally Synthesized SAPO-34: An Experimen tal and Population Balance Study, Scientific Reports 15, 6301 (2025).
- [31]tal and Population Balance Study, Scientific Reports 15, 6301 (2025). [31] D. A. Hardy, J. F. Robinson, T. G. Hilditch, et al., Accurate Measurements and Simulations of the Evaporation and Trajectories of Individual Solution Droplets, The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 127, 3416 (2023).DOI
- [32]L. Gao, X. Luo, J.-L. Sun, et al., Room-Temperature Solvent Evaporation Induced Crystallization: A General Strategy for Growth of Halide Perovskite Single Crystals by Applying the Le Chatelier’s Principle, Small 19, 2303687 (2023).DOI
- [33]V. L. Pool, B. Dou, D. G. Sun Campen, et al., Thermal Engineering of FAPbI3 Perovskite Material via Radiative Thermal Annealing and in Situ XRD, Nature Communications 8, 1407 (2017).DOI
- [34]M. Z. Bazant, Theory of Chemical Kinetics and Charge Transfer based on Nonequilibrium Thermodynamics, Accounts of Chemical Research 46, 1144 (2013).
- [35]C. Vallance, An Introduction to Chemical Kinetics (Morgan & Claypool Publishers, 2017).DOI
- [36]A. H. Persad and C. A. Ward, Expressions for the Evaporation and Condensation Coefficients in the Hertz-Knudsen Relation, Chemical Reviews 116, 7727 (2016).DOI
- [37]O. J. J. Ronsin, D. Jang, H.-J. Egelhaaf, et al., Phase-Field Simulation of Liquid–Vapor Equilibrium and Evaporation of Fluid Mixtures, ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 13, 55988 (2021).arxiv.org/abs/2106.14460
- [38]M. Bond and H. Struchtrup, Mean Evaporation and Condensation Coefficients Based on Energy Dependent Condensation Probability, Physical Review E 70, 061605 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15697379
- [39]H. Schlichting and K. Gersten, Boundary-Layer Theory (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2017).
- [40]D. E. Bornside, R. A. Brown, P. W. Ackmann, et al., The Effects of Gas Phase Convection on Mass Transfer in Spin Coating, Journal of Applied Physics 73, 585 (1993).DOI
- [41]D. Meyerhofer, Characteristics of Resist Films Produced by Spinning, Journal of Applied Physics 49, 3993 (2008).
- [42]J. J. van Franeker, D. Westhoff, M. Turbiez, et al., Controlling the Dominant Length Scale of Liquid–Liquid Phase Separation in Spin-Coated Organic Semiconductor Films, Advanced Functional Materials 25, 855 (2015).DOI
- [43]V. I. Kalikmanov, Nucleation Theory, Lecture Notes in Physics, Vol. 860 (Springer, Heidelberg, 2013).
- [44]O. J. J. Ronsin, D. Jang, H.-J. Egelhaaf, et al., A Phase-Field Model for the Evaporation of Thin Film Mixtures, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 22, 6638 (2020).DOI
- [45]C. D. Van Siclen, Random Nucleation and Growth Kinetics, Physical Review B 54, 11845 (1996).
- [46]J. S. Blázquez, F. J. Romero, C. F. Conde, and A. Conde, A Review of Different Models Derived from Classical Kolmogorov, Johnson and Mehl, and Avrami (KJMA) Theory to Recover Physical Meaning in Solid-State Transformations, physica status solidi (b) 259, 2100524 (2022).DOI
- [47]C. B. Whitehead, S. Özkar, and R. G. Finke, Lamer’s 1950 Model of Particle Formation: A Review and Critical Analysis of Its Classical Nucleation and Fluctuation Theory Basis, of Competing Models and Mechanisms for Phase-Changes and Particle Formation, and Then of Its Application to Silver Halide, Semiconductor, Metal, and Metal-Oxide Nanoparticles, Materials Advances 2, 186 (2021).DOI
- [48]N. T. K. Thanh, N. Maclean, and S. Mahiddine, Mechanisms of Nucleation and Growth of Nanoparticles in Solution, Chemical Reviews 114, 7610 (2014).DOI
- [49]K. H. Stone, A. Gold-Parker, V. L. Pool, et al., Transformation from Crystalline Precursor to Perovskite in PbCl2-Derived MAPbI3, Nature Communications 9, 3458 (2018).DOI
- [50]R. Szostak, S. Sanchez, P. E. Marchezi, et al., Revealing the Perovskite Film Formation Using the Gas Quenching Method by In Situ GIWAXS: Morphology, Properties, and Device Performance, Advanced Functional Materials 30, 2007473 (2020).DOI
- [51]T.-B. Song, Z. Yuan, M. Mori, et al., Revealing the Dynamics of Hybrid Metal Halide Perovskite Formation via Multimodal In Situ Probes, Advanced Functional Materials 30, 1908337 (2020).DOI
- [52]E. Kneschaurek, A. Hinderhofer, B. Hofferberth, et al., Compact Sample Environment for In Situ X-ray Scattering during Spin-Coating, Review of Scientific Instruments 94, 063901 (2023).DOI
- [53]L. Merten, T. Eberle, E. Kneschaurek, et al., Halide Segregated Crystallization of Mixed-Halide Perovskites Revealed by In Situ GIWAXS, ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 16, 8913 (2024).DOI
- [54]M. Majewski, S. Qiu, O. Ronsin, et al., Simulation of Perovskite Thin Layer Crystallization with Varying Evaporation Rates, Materials Horizons 10.1039/D4MH00957F (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2404.09739

