WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Synchronization-based lossless non-reciprocal scattering
Abstract
Breaking the reciprocity of wave propagation is a problem of fundamental interest, and a mucht-sought functionality in practical applications, both in photonics and phononics. Although it has been achieved using resonant linear scattering from cavities with broken time-reversal symmetry, such realizations have remained inescapably plagued by inherent passivity constraints, which make absorption losses unavoidable, leading to stringent limitations in transmitted power. In this work, we solve this problem by converting the cavity resonance into a limit cycle, exploiting the uncharted interplay between non-linearity, gain, and non-reciprocity. Remarkably, strong enough incident waves can synchronize with these self-sustained oscillations and use their energy for amplification. We theoretically and experimentally demonstrate that this mechanism can simultaneously enhance non-reciprocity and compensate absorption. Real-world acoustic scattering experiments allow us to observe perfect non-reciprocal transmission of audible sound in a synchronisation-based 3-port circulator with full immunity against losses.
Introduction
Wave propagation is said to be reciprocal if it is symmetric with respect to exchanging the locations of any sender-receiver pair. Due to its close links to time-reversal symmetry, reciprocity is ubiquitous in physics [1, 2, 3]. Breaking reciprocity is necessary in applications which aim to guide waves in one direction while isolating another, for example to protect a source from unwanted reflections, or to induce strong topological protection against obstacles or imperfections [4, 5]. Such non-reciprocal transmission is of high practical interest and has recently been reviewed for electromagnetic [6, 7] and mechanical [8, 9] waves.
Analogous to how light can be non-reciprocally routed using biased magneto-optical media [10], unidirectional acoustic waves can be induced in a resonant cavity with a biased air flow [11]. Both aforementioned effects are based on scattering waves at a pair of isolated, degenerate cavity modes whose symmetry is broken by a frequency splitting similar to the electronic Zeeman effect [12], where an external magnetic field lifts the degeneracy of the atom’s eigenstates. The exploitation of this effect to construct a circulator is well-known, and illustrated in Figure 1a and Figure 1b, which represents the state of the art in linear, resonance-based non-reciprocal scattering. Of course, any macroscopic realizations, albeit inspired from atomic-scale quantum phenomena, will suffer from dissipative effects [13, 14]. The present study proposes a solution to remedy this fundamental problem by unveiling a synchronization-based mechanism for achieving lossless non-reciprocal transmission. Our method requires no internal active elements to control the field [15, 16].

Figure 1. Concept of synchronization-based lossless non-reciprocal scattering in a circulator. a, b State of the art. Inducing a Zeeman-type bias in a resonator cavity (a) leads to non-reciprocal transmission of incident waves (b). Due to the passivity of the resonance, non-reciprocal transmission will be lossy, even if the isolation of the blocked direction is perfect. c A limit cycle in a round cavity with multiple ports continuously radiates a signal through the ports. d A harmonic wave incident on the cavity can synchronize with and gain energy from the limit cycle’s emissions. In the presence of a bias, this enables lossless non-reciprocal transmission. e In absence of external forcing, the acoustic field is either spinning right or left. f Under external forcing, the spinning acoustic field becomes a standing wave.
Instead, we show here that a lossless circulator can be designed based on the non-linear interference between a wave and a cavity limit cycle, which emits self-sustained radiation in the absence of an external source (Figure 1c). The concept proposed in this work is sketched in Figure 1d. Not only can a wave impinging on a cavity limit cycle extract energy from its radiated signal by synchronization, but the non-linear interference simultaneously enhances non-reciprocal isolation between the ports. In a three-port circulator with a properly tuned bias, the above scenario can enable lossless non-reciprocal transmission, overcoming the dissipation induced by low factors in resonant cavities. After extending classical coupled-mode theory [17, 18] to the non-linear case, we can explain and predict the synchronization-based transmission using only a few parameters. To validate our theory of synchronization-based lossless non-reciprocity, we finally present an experimental realization of a loss-immune acoustic circulator, which exploits flow-induced whistling [19, 20, 21] to create spinning acoustic limit cycles [22, 23].
Non-linear wave-mode coupling
In this section, we describe the non-linear interference between the cavity modes and the incident wave in a circulator with three ports, highlighting the key ingredients required to achieve lossless non-reciprocal transmission. The concept and the theoretical foundations are not limited to acoustic circulators. As in [10], cross-coupling between the modes is neglected under the assumption that the dominant mechanisms are the coupling between the incident and the outgoing wave (W→W), coupling from the incident wave to the cavity modes (W→M) and coupling from the cavity modes to the outgoing wave (M→W). As discussed in the next section, only one mode () is undergoing a limit cycle. The non-linear coupling between the cavity modes and the incident wave is governed by the following system:
where are the eigenfrequencies, is the decay rate, are the linear gain coefficients, is the non-linearity constant, is the background scattering matrix, is the outgoing wave, is the coupling matrix. A dot denotes the time derivative and is the Hermitian transpose. Explicit expressions of and are given in the Supplementary Notes [24]. Note that Eq. (1) corresponds to two decoupled equations, one for and one for . The eigenfrequencies are generally assumed to be quasi-degenerate () and well-isolated in the cavity spectrum, meaning that there are no nearby resonances. Analogously, the linear gain coefficients are assumed to be similar: . Due to symmetry, the decay rate and the non-linearity coefficient are assumed to be the same for both modes. To compute the steady-state forced response of , we assume that the modes are perfectly synchronized with the incident wave. The functional form of the amplification term in Eq. (1) is motivated by experimental results [21] and this type of saturable gain was also used in [25]. For a wave incident from the first port, , where is the incident wave amplitude, is the angular forcing frequency and is a unit vector. We define the nondimensionalized amplitude as , where is the arithmetic mean of the linear gain coefficients. Using the definition of the scattering matrix given by , a general expression for can be found using the Moore-Penrose pseudoinverse [25]:
In general, is a non-linear function of because the outgoing wave is a linear function of the cavity modes , which, in turn, depend non-linearly on .
In the following, we provide analytical results which numerically illustrate the mechanism visualized in Figure 1. We recall that, in order to synchronize with the limit cycle so as to profit from the energy of its self oscillations, the incident amplitude must be sufficiently large. In the limit of infinitely large amplitudes , the modal equations (1) reduce to the classical temporal coupled mode theory which describes linear scattering at a resonant cavity [10, 17, 18]. This limit plays an important role in the non-linear transmission scenario we propose. One can imagine the limit of infinitely large amplitude as a dissipative ground state which we seek to overcome by synchronizing with the cavity limit cycle. In practice, the goal is to increase the incident wave amplitude to a large enough value such that the resulting scattering matrix is a weakly perturbed version of its infinite amplitude limit, and then to tune the amplitude and the modal parameters until the desired scattering state is reached. By expanding the modal dynamics (1) in a perturbation series in , one can compute the leading-order correction to the scattering matrix in the limit of large incident wave amplitudes. The derivation of the non-linear scattering matrix and its large amplitude approximation is provided in the Supplementary Notes [24]. To model dissipation in our model, we introduce the unitarity factor , which is equal to 1 for a perfectly reversible process and takes values between 0 and 1 if the scattering is lossy. Thus, is a measure of the dissipation present in a real-world system that must be overcome to achieve lossless scattering. Next, we assume that the Zeeman splitting and incident wave frequency satisfy , which corresponds to perfect matching (see the Supplementary Notes [24]). Computing the synchronized forced response of the modal amplitudes for an incident wave from port “1”, , yields the amplitude transmission coefficients for large normalized amplitudes [24]:
For mildly dissipative systems with , and large enough , Eq. (4) shows that the non-linear interference of the incident wave with the cavity limit cycle decreases transmission to the blocked port “2”, eventually reaching an identically zero value. Under these conditions, Eq. (5) indicates that transmission to port “3” is enhanced and reaches values close to or even exceeding unity, depending on level of dissipation . The above results show that qualitatively, this synchronization-based mechanism enables an increase in the non-reciprocal behavior of the system, while at the same time compensating transmission losses. Quantitative comparisons between theory and experiments will be provided in § 4.
Experimental validation
For our scattering experiments, we built and characterized a circulator which consists of a deep annular cavity subject to a swirling flow [23] and is equipped with three equispaced ports along its circumference. The bulk flow speed, the swirl number of the flow and the amplitude of the incident wave through one of the ports can be set individually to tune the non-linear scattering matrix. Three waveguides are connected to the cavity ports, thus forming an acoustic circulator. The experimental setup is shown in Figure 2a. Technical information is given in Appendix § 8.1. Let us first consider Figure 2a in the absence of acoustic forcing. A swirling flow is imposed in the blue pipe, and passes through the center of the axisymmetric cavity. At suitable conditions, the swirling jet in the cavity exhibits self-sustained oscillations thanks to the intrinsic coupling between one of its hydrodynamic modes and a spinning acoustic mode of the cavity. The trapped aeroacoustic mode producing this cavity whistling is shown in Figure 2b, where one can see the acoustic pressure field that interacts with the coherent vorticity fluctuations. The latter fluctuations develop along the shear layer in the cavity aperture region, and were measured with particle image velocimetry (see Figure 2c). A bifurcation diagram of the acoustic pressure inside the cavity, depicting the transition between the quiet and the whistling phase, is presented in Appendix § 8.4.

Figure 2. Acoustic circulator based on a spinning cavity limit cycle. a Experimental setup. A swirling flow with fixed axial and azimuthal components is imposed in the blue pipe which passes through a cylindrical cavity, leading to a limit cycle (whistling) at around 800 Hz. In contrast with classic wind instruments whose sound radiation originates from self-oscillating standing modes, our special whistle involves spinning modes. For the scattering experiments, three 70 cm long square waveguides are connected to the upstream wall of the round cavity at equispaced angular positions ( apart). These waveguides are equipped with sound absorbing foam at their left termination in order to provide quasi-anechoic conditions. For the scattering experiments, incident waves are sent to the cavity using a compression driver (source) mounted on one of the waveguides. Microphones in the waveguides are used to reconstruct the incident and outgoing waves. b Acoustic mode of the circulator cavity, also showing isosurfaces of the azimuthal component of the coherent vorticity fluctuations (see Appendix § 8.2 and Appendix § 8.3). c Zoomed-in view of this instantaneous snapshot of the vorticity fluctuations, which was obtained from stereoscopic particle image velocimetry.
Once an aeroacoustic limit cycle has been established and the cavity is whistling, acoustic forcing with a specified amplitude is imposed from a compression driver mounted on one of the ports. The incident and outgoing signals are reconstructed using microphones mounted on the ports to obtain the transmission coefficients. For sufficiently strong and in-tune forcing, the cavity limit cycle can synchronize with the forcing, as demonstrated in Appendix § 8.5. Therefore, this experimental set-up is a realistic representation of the model assumptions made in § 2.
Results
In order to facilitate the comparison of theoretical and experimental results, we define the incident wave amplitude relative to the maximum range of amplitudes , imposed in the scattering process: , and analogously for . We show in Figure 3 that our theoretical model reproduces the non-linear scattering experiments with remarkable accuracy using only few parameters. The ranges of excitation amplitudes used in the model and in the experiments were and Pa, respectively. No fit was performed to adjust the model parameters, but they were manually defined to match the experiments. The parameter values used in the model were , , Hz, Hz, , , (in units of ). For these values, perfect matching in the model is achieved at 802.5 Hz, similar to what is observed in the experiments (see also Appendix § 8.6).

Figure 3. Experimental validation of a perfect lossless circulator. Amplitude transmission coefficients for increasing incident wave amplitudes and (expressed relative the intervals and Pa, respectively; see § 4). Top row: Theoretical results obtained from the non-linear coupled-mode theory described in § 2. Bottom row: experimental measurements performed on the setup described in § 3. In both cases, a harmonic incident wave is imposed in port “1”. The blue and black curves refer to the transmitted wave amplitudes at ports “2” and “3”, respectively, relative to the incident wave amplitude and frequency.
For small incident wave amplitudes, sharp peaks are visible because the self-sustained radiation of the limit cycle dominates transmission through the ports. As the incident wave amplitude is increased, a non-reciprocal, lossless scattering state emerges. To verify the robustness of the experimental results shown in Figure 3, we investigated the sensitivity of the lossless, non-reciprocal state (see Appendix § 8.7). For this, we repeated the scattering experiments for a fixed value of while varying the axial and azimuthal components of the swirling flow. The results show that there exists a continuum of low-loss, non-reciprocal scattering states in the vicinity of the operating point treated in this study. Therefore, our measurements evidence the relevance of loss-compensated non-reciprocity as a robust synchronisation phenomenon which persists under small variations of the operating conditions. As limit cycles are ubiquitous in dynamical systems with saturable gain, we surmise that synchronization-based lossless non-reciprocity may be transposed to other physical platforms, from electronics to non-Hermitian photonics. Semiconductor-based electronic amplifiers and continuous optical gain media may allow for a direct implementation of our concept in high-frequency circuits or silicon nanophotonics. More fundamentally, our loss-compensation mechanism may open new experimental opportunities in topological physics, where time-reversal symmetry plays a pivotal role in the robustness of chiral edge states, which can be induced in circulator networks [4, 5]. The complex interplay between non-linearity and gain to produce limit cycles capable of breaking reciprocity remains a promising avenue, and we envision that extensions to periodic lattices, or systems coupled to a radiation continuum may lead to a wealth of unforeseen progress in a field that used to be thought as fundamentally hindered by absorption losses.
Data availability
The data that support the findings of this study are available at https://polybox.ethz.ch/index.php/s/CLxLxoDsWkSuIgq.
Code availability
The codes that support the findings of this study are available at https://polybox.ethz.ch/index.php/s/CLxLxoDsWkSuIgq.
Contributions
N.N. conceptualized and supervised the research. T.P. and A.F. conducted the acoustic and flow measurements. T.P. and N.N. developed the theory. T.P. performed data analysis and validated the model. T.P., A.F., R.F., and N.N. discussed the results. T.P. wrote the first draft of the article. N.N. and R.F. reviewed and edited it. All authors approved the final version of the article.
Appendix
Scattering experiments
To test our theoretical predictions, we designed an aeroacoustic circulator, shown in Figure 2a, which uses a low-Mach air flow to generate acoustic limit cycles. For this, a swirling flow with bulk speed , whose axial () and azimuthal () components can be separately tuned (see Figure 4), is imposed in the pipe to which the cavity is connected. The axial velocity is deduced from the mass flow and the temperature in the channel, which are measured with a mass flow meter and a thermocouple. The azimuthal flow is induced using a swirler based on tangential injection of air in the upstream part of the pipe, and also monitored using a mass flow meter. Note that the velocity corresponds to the contribution of the mass flow through the swirler to the bulk flow in the pipe, and not to the local velocity in the swirler: , where is the ambient density and is the pipe diameter. The ambient speed of sound in the experiments is equal to . Three semi-anechoic waveguides (arms) with square cross-sections are connected to the cavity through compact circular holes. The ends of the arms are filled with acoustic foam and have been measured to reflect less than 13% of the acoustic energy for all considered operating conditions. Three G.R.A.S. 46BD 1/4” CCP microphones are flush mounted in each of the arms , and , where is measured from the upstream inner cavity wall. The multi-microphone method was used to reconstruct the traveling waves in the arms at the incident wave frequency from the acoustic measurements [26]. Two microphones of the same type as in the waveguides were flush mounted on the downstream wall of the cavity at the same radial positions , separated by degrees, to measure the acoustic limit cycle oscillations in the absence of forcing from any of the waveguides. The incident waves were imposed by a Beyma CP-850Nd compression driver mounted on one of the arms. The voltage of the signal to the drivers can be calibrated at each frequency to achieve a specified acoustic amplitude .

Figure 4. Sketch of the experimental setup used in this work (not for scale). A blower and shop air from the laboratory supply wind the channel of the experimental setup. The respective air flows are monitored using mass flow meters. At the swirler, air is injected tangentially to the wall of the circular cross-section wind channel, and it mixes with the main air from the blower. This configuration enables full control of the swirl intensity of the jet flowing through the cavity. This deep axisymmetric cavity is the central element of the 3-port circulator, which is equipped with three waveguides. Their angular positions are apart at the same radius. One of the waveguides is equipped with a compression driver to acoustically force one of the three circulator’s ports. Microphones are placed along the waveguides and on the cavity for acoustic measurements. The wind channel has anechoic, catenoidal terminations which are filled with acoustic foam. Similarly, the ends of the waveguides attached to the cavity are also filled with anechoic foam to achieve low acoustic reflection.
Acoustic field
The acoustic mode shown in Figure 2b corresponds to the analytical solution of the Helmholtz equation for a circular cavity, , where is the Bessel function of the first kind of order 1, is the radial coordinate and is the first zero of the first derivative of with respect to [23].
Fluid-dynamical data
Shown in Figure 2c are isosurfaces of the azimuthal component of the vorticity fluctuations at the acoustic frequency, which were extracted using stereoscopic particle image velocimetry (PIV) in an earlier study of a limit cycle at m/s and , and which are included here for illustration purposes. The isosurfaces were produced from postprocessed data originally presented in [22 Fig. 6a]. The type of aeroacoustic instability used here is based on a low Mach flow [19, 20, 21], and as in the case of human whistling, the subtle interplay between the acoustic field and the rotational fluid motion results in finite-amplitude acoustic pressure oscillations in the cavity. To engineer our circulator, we designed a special whistle in the sense that its eigenmodes are spinning inside the cavity [22], in contrast to the classic police whistle or wind instruments like flutes, in which standing acoustic oscillations are found. Furthermore, by imposing a swirl on the cavity flow, we can provide self-sustained aeroacoustic waves that spin against the swirl, be it in the clockwise or in the counterclockwise direction, as explained in [23].
Bifurcation diagram
The whistling phenomenon observed in the experiments can be described in low-order models, such as the “” branch in Eq. (1), which, for and , describes a limit cycle arising from a supercritical Hopf bifurcation. Idealized theory predicts that the square of the modal amplitude varies linearly with the bifurcation parameter in the vicinity of the bifurcation point. The bifurcation is governed by the system nonlinearity shown in Figure 5. In the experiments, we have two free parameters ( and ), which results in a two-parameter Hopf bifurcation, as shown in Figure 6. To generate this inset, we recorded the acoustic pressure oscillations in the absence of waves incident to the cavity ports with two microphones on the downstream wall of the cavity. These 10 s timetraces were recorded over an equally spaced grid of values of the bulk velocity and the swirl number . For each measurement, we then computed the RMS amplitude of each of the two microphones and took the arithmetic mean of these two values, which we denote by . We used the average of the RMS amplitudes from two non-diametrically opposed microphones instead of the RMS of a single microphone to avoid the situation that the nodal line of the aeroacoustic mode (compare Figure 2b) lies on the microphone during the measurement. The operating point ( hPa) for the scattering experiments, marked by the red dot, clearly lies in the limit cycle regime. The smaller cyan and green insets show the variation of the whistling intensity (gray curves) along the cyan ( m/s) and green () lines in Figure 3c, respectively, and the black lines within the smaller insets are linear regressions to extrapolate the bifurcation points. In the cyan inset, the regression itself is trivial because the black line connects exactly two measuring points, but the estimation of the bifurcation point is nevertheless informative.

Figure 5. Some features of the theoretical model presented in the main text. Left inset: Typical damping non-linearity of the cavity modes considered in this work. In the absence of an incident wave, if the linear gain of the “−” mode, , exceeds the linear damping , and if the non-linear component of the cavity gain decreases for increasing amplitude , a stable limit cycle with amplitude occurs, which corresponds to an equilibrium between gain and loss mechanisms. In this example, the mode is linearly stable because . Right inset: Sketch of the effective resistance associated with the non-linear cavity modes considered in this work. At large amplitudes , the system exhibits a finite resistive term tending to , i.e., its response is essentially equivalent to that of a linearly stable resonance.

Figure 6. Bifurcation diagram of the circulator cavity. Shown is the whistling intensity, defined as the squared acoustic RMS amplitude , measured inside the cavity for different values of the bulk flow speed and the swirl number (see Figure 4 for a definition of and ). The operating point at m/s and is marked by a red dot. The smaller insets show the variation of (gray curves) along the cyan and green curves, respectively. The black lines in the smaller insets are linear regression lines to extrapolate the bifurcation points.
Synchronization dynamics
As described in the last section, we now consider a scenario where a limit cycle is reached at the conditions described above. Then, in addition to these self-sustained oscillations, using the compression driver mounted on the top arm, harmonic sound waves are sent through the channel towards the cavity. As we measure the acoustic pressure inside the cavity, at the same azimuthal position as the forcing waveguide, we can observe synchronization phenomena similar to those described in the book of Balanov et al. [27] To analyze these dynamics, we performed repeated forced experiments at different incident wave amplitudes for fixed amplitude of the limit cycle. The results are presented in Figure 7. Figure 7a illustrates the Arnold tongue [28] representing the region in which synchronization of the incident waves takes place. As we can see, for the smallest incident wave amplitude, the synchronized region is almost a double its size at the largest forcing amplitude. This is consistent with the classic paradigm that synchronization requires large amplitudes and small detuning. For a stronger forcing, hence, larger detuning is acceptable to satisfy this double constraint, leading to a wider region in which synchronization can take place. We now take closer look at two specific points, marked by the purple and green dots in Figure 7a at a forcing amplitude of Pa, we can visually compare the synchronized and asynchronous modes. For the latter, as we can see from Figure 7b, there are two dominant peaks in the PSD while for the synchronized we observe just one. The non-synchronized mode has a peak at the self-sustained limit cycle around 800 Hz, another at the forcing frequency and a significantly less dominant harmonic peak at around 820 Hz. For the synchronized state, a peak is only observed at the forcing frequency. Figure 7c shows the pressure dynamics for a synchronized mode, which can be compared to those of an asynchronous mode as shown in Figure 7d. While the synchronized mode shows roughly constant amplitude, significant beating oscillations accompany the asynchronous state, stemming from the interplay between the coexisting, detuned peaks of the forced and the self-sustained oscillations.

Figure 7. a Experimental Arnold tongue. Incident waves at fixed amplitudes and frequencies were sent to the obstacle. By analyzing the relative peak height of the power spectrum density (PSD) of the forced mode, synchronized states can be identified. b A synchronized mode has an isolated peak at the forcing frequency. A non-synchronized mode has one peak at the self-sustained limit cycle frequency and another at the forcing frequency, as well as less dominant harmonics. c Pressure dynamics of a synchronized mode: quasi-sinusoidal oscillation at quasi-constant amplitude. d Non-synchronized states show beating oscillations due to interference of the self-sustained mode and the external forcing. The small insets in c and d show a couple of cycles of the same time traces.
Zeeman bias modeling
As in [11], the broken symmetry of the theoretical model, expressed here by and , corresponds in the experiments to the bias introduced by an azimuthal flow. Under the simplifying assumption that and depend linearly on and that for , the system is perfectly symmetric, we obtain the variations of these parameters over the swirl number (see Figure 8). In this case, corresponds to the mode spinning with the swirling flow and to the mode spinning against it. Note that and split in opposite direction in our model, which is consistent with experiments and numerical simulations performed on the same cavity and presented in [23, Figure 5]. The bifurcation points extrapolated from the experiments and from the theoretical model both lie at with less than 1% relative deviation from each other, showing that the model and the experiments are consistent in their representation of the limit cycle’s stability boundary.

Figure 8. Modeled variation of the eigenfrequencies , the linear gains and the decay rate with respect to the swirl number . The bias introduced by the swirl governs the Zeeman splitting of the eigenfrequencies that are degenerate at . The values at the operating point are marked by red dots. The “+” and “−” branches correspond to the modes spinning with and against the swirling flow, respectively.
Transmission without and with flow
If no flow is imposed on the cavity, then it behaves like a reciprocal, lossy and linear 3-port scatterer, as shown in Figure 9. This shows that, besides the whistling tone induced by the air flow, there are no non-linear effects present in the system. If a flow is imposed on the cavity, a non-reciprocal lossless transmission can be achieved, as shown in Figure 10.

Figure 9. Measured transmission coefficients in the no-flow case for different values of the incident wave amplitude (see § 4). The black dotted curves correspond to , the solid blue curves correspond to and the red lines correspond to 100% transmission.

Figure 10. Sensitivity of the measured amplitude transmission coefficients at over different values of the axial () and azimuthal () flow components. The black dotted curves correspond to , the solid blue curves correspond to and the red lines correspond to 100% transmission. The operating point is marked with a thick red box around the respective inset.
Supplementary notes to “Synchronization-based lossless non-reciprocal scattering”
Tiemo Pedergnana; Abel Faure-Beaulieu; Romain Fleury; Nicolas Noiray
*Corresponding authors. E-mails: [email protected]; [email protected];
Theory
Scattering matrix derivation
To model the non-linear scattering process, we propose a coupled-mode theory for the cavity modes , which are forced by the incoming wave , leading to an outgoing wave . The following equations form the theory presented in this work:1
where a dot denotes the time derivative, are the eigenfrequencies, are the decay rates corresponding to dissipative processes in the cavity and radiation losses, are the linear gain coefficients, are the non-linearity constants, is the background scattering matrix and the matrix with column vectors describes the wave-mode coupling. When the system is harmonically excited from the port, we have , where is the incident wave amplitude and is the unit vector in -direction. The vector in Eq. (7), where is the transpose, comprises both cavity modes.
For simplicity, to compute the forced response, we write and we assume that the modes are perfectly synchronized with the excitation: , where is the absolute value and and are the amplitudes and phases of the forced response, respectively. With this assumption, the modal dynamics (S1) become
Separating real and imaginary parts yields
where the terms represent the detuning between the forcing and the respective oscillators. The unforced () limit cycles , are given by
and can only exist when the respective linear gain is greater than the dissipation: . Assuming this is the case, the linearized unforced modal dynamics around the limit cycles ,
are asymptotically stable. If , the limit cycles given by Eq. (11) do not exist and the only stationary solution is the trivial one: . In that case, the linearized dynamics around the trivial solution,
are also asymptotically stable. If there does exist a limit cycle, then we see from Eq. (13) that the trivial solution is linearly unstable. Since the unforced modal equations (S1) are decoupled, depending on the sign of , each of the modes has exactly one linearly stable stationary solution, which can be either a limit cycle or the trivial solution.
Having discussed the modes’ unforced dynamics, we now compute their forced response by setting , leading to the following expression:
which can be written as two cubic equations for :
where
The linearly stable branches of of the forced response are given by
At infinitely large amplitudes , the term dominates the -modulated term in the equations for . In this limit, therefore, the dynamics (S1) converge to
which are exactly equivalent to the classic temporal coupled-mode theory2. To model this limiting case in a manner which is consistent with non-reciprocal scattering, following the method from Pedergnana and Noiray3, we superimpose a non-reciprocal optimal scattering matrix on a purely reflectional background :
The matrix , where is the unitarity factor, has the following eigenvalues and corresponding eigenvectors , :
where is the complex conjugate. Formally approximating the linear part of the scattering matrix by yields a low-rank approximation problem for by the coupling matrix :
where
In the recent work from Pedergnana and Noiray[4], consistency conditions are given to determine and perfect matching condition for a scatterer with one mode and two ports. The latter condition describes an optimal parameter configuration at which the dominant eigenspace of is best approximated by . The goal of the consistency conditions is to ensure that the linear scattering matrix derived in this section successfully approximates the dominant sub-spectrum of . Because is the only unknown in our formulation of the wave-mode coupling, we consider the problem (S18) instead of directly approximating by . We formulate the following requirements for a scatterer with two modes and three ports:
(I) The singular (rank 2) matrix spans the subspace corresponding to the eigenvalues of with the largest absolute values , . In general, does not share any eigenvalues with .
(II) At perfect matching for a non-unitary process , the two out of three eigenvalues with largest absolute values and the corresponding eigenvectors of coincide with the two of with largest absolute value.
We show that (R1) and (R2) imply that at perfect matching, and also share the sub-spectrum corresponding to the two eigenvalues with largest absolute value. To understand how is determined by (R1) and (R2), we write out the right-hand-side of the approximation (S18) explicitly:
where we have defined . In comparison, the left-hand-side of the approximation (S18) can be expressed as
To approximate the dominant part of the spectrum of , noting that , we make the Ansatz
where . In the unitary case (), and the perfect matching condition is .5 By analogy, we assume the perfect matching condition for has the form
where . Substituting the assumed relations (S23) and (S24) into Eq. (26) yields, at perfect matching,
Comparing Eq. (30) to Eq. (27), we require that
Since , and , Eq. (31) has the following unique solutions for and :
which, for , reduce to the well-known values and found in literature on unitary scattering. Using the above results, the coupling matrix becomes
By computing the linear scattering matrix , it is straightforward to verify that for a perfectly matched sub-unitary scatterer (), its two eigenvalues with largest absolute value coincide with those of . Indeed, at perfect matching,
which has the eigenvalues , and corresponding eigenvectors , . The optimal scattering matrix also shares the same eigenvectors, with eigenvalues and . Therefore, for a perfectly matched unitary scatterer with , the optimal state is reached exactly: . This shows that the linear scattering matrix derived in this section successfully approximates the dominant sub-spectrum of .
Using the above intermediate result and the Moore-Penrose Pseudoinverse6, the non-linear scattering matrix is found to be
where and , , are obtained by solving the forced response equations (S10) and (S11) for .
At large amplitudes , the non-reciprocal amplitude transmission coefficients converge to
Perfect matching is achieved for , leading to and .
Large amplitude limit
Equations (38) and (S34) describe the asymptotically linear scattering process which occurs in the limit of infinitely large incident wave amplitudes. To understand how the non-linear terms in the modal dynamics (S1) affect the transmission coefficients in the large (but not infinite) amplitude limit, we use a perturbation series approach. For this, we introduce the small, auxiliary parameter . In the following, we assume forcing from port “1”: , where the incident wave amplitude is assumed to be of order , i.e., large. For , the coupled-mode equations (S1) and (S2) reduce to Eqs. (S12) and (S13). These limiting cases predict that both and depend linearly on in the large amplitude limit. Therefore, we assume that the leading order terms in and scale also with , or , in the large amplitude limit. We later set equal to 1 and verify analytically that the assumed scaling () is indeed reproduced by our perturbation approach, applied to the non-linear coupled-mode theory described the previous section. To compute the perturbation series, we define the rescaled quantities
which, by the above assumptions, are all of order . Substituting Eqs. (S35)–(S37) into the non-linear coupled-mode theory (S1) and (S2) yields, after cancelling out ,
Since was assumed to be small, the rational function in Eq. (S38) can be expanded as a geometric series:
Next, we expand and the outgoing wave in terms of the perturbation parameter:
Using the general expression (S31), the expansion (S42) also implies that the scattering matrix can be expanded analogously:
Because the modal dynamics (S1) contain a quadratic non-linearity, only even powers of appear in the geometric series (S40). Accordingly, only even orders of contribute to the expansions (S41) and (S42).
By substituting Eqs. (S40)–(S42) into the rescaled system (S38) and (S39), we obtain the contributions of different orders in to the scattering matrix. To zeroth order , as expected, this procedure yields the modal equations in the limit of infinitely large amplitudes:
As standard in the TCMT literature, we assume synchronized conditions in the steady state, , which leads to
Therefore, the leading-order contribution to the scattering matrix at large amplitudes is the TCMT scattering matrix
where the matrix is defined in Eq. (24). Following the above steps and using the expansion (S40) we obtain, to order ,
Substituting Eq. (51) into Eq. (54) and solving for yields
Using Eq. (54) and setting , then, the next-to-leading order term in the scattering matrix expansion (S43) is found to be
where is the incident wave amplitude and
As assumed above in the expansion (S43), is of order . For infinitely large incident wave amplitudes , and all higher expansion terms vanish. One could continue the perturbation series to show that the next-to-next-to-leading order term is of order etc. Therefore, for large , the term (S51) will dominate the higher-order terms in the expansion (S43), justifying our perturbative approach. Accordingly, all higher-order contributions to the scattering matrix in the large amplitude limit are neglected in the following.
Collecting the above results, we obtain the first-order correction to the scattering matrix due to the non-linearity in the modal dynamics (S1):
To obtain a simple analytical expression for the scattering matrix at optimally tuned conditions, we assume perfectly matched frequencies: . As in the numerical examples shown in the main text, we set . These simplifications lead to
We can now rewrite the approximate amplitude transmission coefficients as follows:
In the following, we assume that the second brackets under the square roots in Eqs. (S57) and (S58), respectively, is small, which is generally true for small asymmetry . This leads to
We also assume that
, so that the term in Eq. (64) is positive.
That the -modulated term in Eq. (64) is less than or equal to , such that the respective expression inside the vertical lines is non-negative.
The first of these assumptions is a minor restriction, since values of represent a broad range of dissipative conditions (see also the next section for a quantitative discussion of this point). The second of the above assumptions is generally true for large enough . We note that, in the parameter range considered, is decreased and is increased by the non-linear effects described in the modal dynamics (S1) for . For dissipative conditions (), the non-linear interference with the limit cycle compensates–at least partially–for the dissipation incurred at port “3”, while simultaneously decreasing transmission to port “2”. To summarize, the above results demonstrate analytically that the non-linear wave-mode coupling envisioned in this work enhances the non-reciprocity of the 3-port scatterer at large incident wave amplitudes, while simultaneously decreasing transmission losses.
Unitarity and reversibility
We model dissipation, or irreversible losses, in the infinite amplitude limit (S12 and S13) using the intrinsic decay rates . Specifically, we assume that the decay rates can be decomposed into a part related to (reversible) decay through the ports (radiation losses) and another part representing irreversible losses:
The decay through the ports is reversible because the wave energy transmitted through the ports is available to the environment, while the irreversible losses are irrecoverable. In our theory, the presence of intrinsic losses is marked by a broken time-symmetry: while in forward time, the perturbations decay like , their time-reversed counterparts grow like in backward time, i.e., only the reversible part of the decay rate contributes to the growth of time-reversed perturbations. Following the work of Zhao, Guo and Fan7, the balance of reversible energy is expressed as
To confirm the broken time symmetry, we apply a time-reversal transformation to the exponential decay of the perturbations in an initially energized cavity, which is governed by Eq. (17), in the absence of forcing . This transformation interchanges and in Eq. (17). In the time-reversed scenario, time-reversed perturbations grow exponentially in backward time with a priori undetermined growth rates . The time-reversed dynamics are therefore given by
where is the transpose. At the complex frequencies , we have
Comparing Eqs. (71) and (S62) yields
demonstrating that time-symmetry is broken () for . Using Eqs. (34) and (S62), a relation between the intrinsic decay rates and the unitarity factor is established:
The non-unitarity and the irreversible losses of the scattering process are intrinsically connected. In particular, unitary scattering () corresponds to perfect reversibility (). It was mentioned in the previous section that describes a broad range of dissipative conditions. We see from Eq. (73) that, at , the irreversible decay rates make up more than a third of the total decay rates in the limit of infinitely large amplitudes.
References
- [1]Onsager, L. Reciprocal relations in irreversible processes. I. Phys. Rev. 37 (4), 405 – 426 (1931). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.37.405.
- [2]Onsager, L. Reciprocal relations in irreversible processes. II. Physical Review 38 (12), 2265 – 2279 (1931). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.38.2265.
- [3]Casimir, H. On Onsager’s principle of microscopic reversibility. Rev. Mod. Phys. 17 (2-3), 343 – 350 (1945). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.17.343 .
- [4]Zhang, Z., Delplace, P. & Fleury, R. Superior robustness of anomalous non-reciprocal topological edge states. Nature 598 (7880), 293 – 297 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03868-7 .
- [5]Zhang, Z., Delplace, P. & Fleury, R. Anomalous topological waves in strongly amorphous scattering networks. Sci. Adv. 9 (12) (2023). https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adg3186 .
- [6]Verhagen, E. & Alù, A. Optomechanical nonreciprocity. Nat. Phys. 13 (10), 922 – 924 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys4283 .
- [7]Caloz, C. et al. Electromagnetic nonreciprocity. Phys. Rev. Appl. 10 (4) (2018). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevApplied.10.047001 .
- [8]Nassar, H. et al. Nonreciprocity in acoustic and elastic materials. Nat. Rev. Mater. 5 (9), 667 – 685 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41578-020-0206-0 .
- [9]Rasmussen, C., Quan, L. & Alù, A. Acoustic nonreciprocity. J. Appl. Phys. 129 (21) (2021). https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0050775 .
- [10]Wang, Z. & Fan, S. Magneto-optical defects in two-dimensional photonic crystals. Appl. Phys. B 81, 369–375 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00340-005-1846-x .
- [11]Fleury, R., Sounas, D., Sieck, C., Haberman, M. & Alù, A. Sound isolation and giant linear nonreciprocity in a compact acoustic circulator. Science 343 (6170), 516–519 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1246957 .
- [12]Cohen-Tannoudji, C., Diu, B. & Laloë, F. Quantum mechanics. Vol. 1 (Hermann, Wiley, NY, 1991, 2009).
- [13]Callen, H. B. & Welton, T. A. Irreversibility and generalized noise. Phys. Rev. 83 (1), 34 – 40 (1951). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.83.34 .
- [14]Kubo, R. The fluctuation-dissipation theorem. Rep. Prog. Phys. 29 (1), 255 – 284 (1966). https://doi.org/10.1088/0034-4885/29/1/306 .
- [15]Dinc, T. et al. Synchronized conductivity modulation to realize broadband lossless magnetic-free non-reciprocity. Nat. Commun. 8 (1) (2017). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-017-00798-9 .
- [16]Zhang, H., Li, R., Bao, Y., Liu, X. & Zhang, Y. Total acoustic transmission in a honeycomb network empowered by compact acoustic isolator. Sci. Rep. 13 (1) (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-28097-y .
- [17]Fan, S., Suh, W. & Joannopoulos, J. Temporal coupled-mode theory for the fano resonance in optical resonators. J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 20 (3), 569–572 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1364/JOSAA.20.000569 .
- [18]Suh, W., Wang, Z. & Fan, S. Temporal coupled-mode theory and the presence of non-orthogonal modes in lossless multimode cavities. IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 40 (10), 1511–1518 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1109/JQE.2004.834773 .
- [19]Howe, M. The dissipation of sound at an edge. J. Sound Vib. 70 (3), 407–411 (1980). https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-460X(80)90308-9 .
- [20]Elder, S., Farabee, T. & DeMetz, F. Mechanisms of flow-excited cavity tones at low mach number. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 72 (2), 532–549 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1121/1.388034 .
- [21]Bourquard, C., Faure-Beaulieu, A. & Noiray, N. Whistling of deep cavities subject to turbulent grazing flow: Intermittently unstable aeroacoustic feedback. J. Fluid Mech. 909 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2020.984 .
- [22]Faure-Beaulieu, A., Xiong, Y., Pedergnana, T. & Noiray, N. Self-sustained azimuthal aeroacoustic modes. Part 1. Symmetry breaking of the mean flow by spinning waves. J. Fluid Mech. 971, A21 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2023.352 .
- [23]Faure-Beaulieu, A., Pedergnana, T. & Noiray, N. Self-sustained azimuthal aeroacoustic modes. Part 2. Effect of a swirling mean flow on the modal dynamics. J. Fluid Mech. 971, A22 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2023.348 .
- [24]Supplementary notes to “Synchronization-based lossless non-reciprocal scattering” (2023) .DOI
- [25]Pedergnana, T. & Noiray, N. Superradiant scattering by a limit cycle. Phys. Rev. Appl. 20, 034068 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevApplied.20.034068 .
- [26]Jang, S.-H. & Ih, J.-G. On the multiple microphone method for measuring in-duct acoustic properties in the presence of mean flow. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 103 (3), 1520–1526 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1121/1.421289 .
- [27]Balanov, A., Janson, N., Postnov, D. & Sosnovtseva, O. Synchronization: From Simple to Complex (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2009).DOI
- [28]Coombes, S. & Bressloff, P. Mode locking and arnold tongues in integrate-and-fire neural oscillators. Phys. Rev. E 60 (2), 2086 – 2096 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.60.2086 .