betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Bounds for inertialess dynamo

Abstract

We derive necessary conditions for instantaneous dynamo action for rotating convection. A magnetohydrodynamic model is considered in two settings: the rapidly rotating plane layer where inertia and viscosity are absent, and at an arbitrary rotation rate where viscosity is finite. In contrast to kinematic dynamo bounds, the evolution of the magnetic field is coupled via an inertialess force balance. The buoyancy-driven part of the flow uA\mathbf{u}^{\mathrm{A}} in the event of dynamo action must in fact satisfy, for 3≤p≤∞3\leq p \leq \infty Rm Ap∥uA∥Lp≥1 Rm\, A_p\| \mathbf{u}^{\mathrm{A}}\|_{L^p} \geq 1 where ApA_p is an explicit constant, and RmRm is the magnetic Reynolds number. In the inviscid model, uA\mathbf{u}^{\mathrm{A}} depends only on the horizontal gradients of the vertical primitive of temperature. A refinement via the poloidal-toroidal decomposition allows us to replace LpL^p in our constraint with an anisotropic norm for Lz∞H˙x,y1L^{\infty}_z \dot{H}^1_{x,y}. For the viscous model, we also derive necessary conditions for the growth of magnetic enstrophy and a combined thermo-magnetic energy. One branch of our constraints implies that the scaling Raν≳Ek−3/2Ra_ν\gtrsim Ek^{-3/2} is necessary for dynamo action, where RaνRa_ν is the classical Rayleigh number and EkEk is the Ekman number.

In memory of Dr. John Bryan Taylor

Introduction

The Earth, several other planets, and the Sun all possess large scale magnetic fields driven by the motion of an electrically conducting fluid under convection. The Earth’s magnetic field is aperiodic, undergoing secular variation and reversals, and the other planetary magnetic fields across the Solar System exhibit considerable temporal and morphological diversity; see [10, 6, 1, 7] and [?, 10, 11, 13].

Understanding which balance of forces and parameter regimes are necessary for dynamo action remains a central problem in dynamo theory [8, 15]. A basic model for the force balance is the magnetohydrodynamic equations under the Boussinesq approximation [?, ?]. Planetary magnetic fields are expected to be generated by a rapidly rotating dynamo, where inertial and viscous forces are relatively small [8]. This force hierarchy can be investigated by direct numerical simulations, but the parameters relevant to planets are beyond the current capabilities of computational methods [?]. In this paper, we address mathematically the basic question: what conditions are necessary for dynamo action in an inertialess dynamo?

Contribution

We first consider the Taylor limit, in which inertia and viscosity are absent from the force balance, in a horizontally periodic plane layer with either boundary or internal heating; see [12] and [?, ?, ?, ?, ?]. We show that critical to dynamo action is the contribution of the buoyancy-driven part of the flow, i.e., the Archimedean part of the fluid velocity

uA(x,y,z)=Ra∇x,y⊥∫0zT(x,y,z′) dz′\boldsymbol{u}^{A}(x,y,z) = Ra \nabla_{x,y}^{\perp} \int_{0}^{z} T(x,y,z') \,\mathrm{d}z'

where RaRa is the modified Rayleigh number. More precisely, we prove that for 3≤p≤∞3 \le p \le\infty instantaneous growth of the magnetic energy requires

RmAp∥uA∥Lp=Rm Ra Ap∥∇x,yT‾∥Lp≥1Rm A_p \lVert\boldsymbol{u}^{A} \rVert_{L^p} = Rm\,Ra\,A_p \lVert\nabla_{x,y}\overline{T} \rVert_{L^p} \ge1

where T‾\overline{T} is the vertical primitive of the temperature, ApA_p is a constant, and RmRm is the magnetic Reynolds number. We refine the above bound via the poloidal-toroidal decomposition of the magnetic field to replace LpL^p with the anisotropic Lz∞H˙x,y1L_z^\infty\dot{H}_{x,y}^{1}. Further, we prove absorbing ball estimates for the temperature equation wherein we determine explicit regions of parameter space in which magnetic energy growth is prohibited in long-time convection.

We then extend the analysis to the viscous inertialess problem with finite the Ekman number Ek>0Ek > 0 and stress-free velocity boundary conditions. The condition for dynamo action is robust and holds with finite viscosity corrections, showing that the restriction on the Archimedean response is not reliant on singular properties of Taylor’s constraint. The constraint naturally yields the scaling Raν≳Ek−3/2Ra_{\nu} \gtrsim Ek^{-3/2}, where RaνRa_{\nu} is the classical Rayleigh number in the study of convection. In addition to magnetic energy, we prove a constraint for the growth of magnetic enstrophy and a combined thermo-magnetic energy. The growth condition for the combined energy in a rapidly rotating solution branch again has the scaling Raν≳Ek−3/2Ra_{\nu} \gtrsim Ek^{-3/2}.

Magneto-geostrophic models

The inviscid model considered in this paper was studied by J. B. Taylor in his seminal work on the geodynamo [12]. Taylor observed that when inertia and viscosity are absent, for a fluid in a self gravitating sphere, the total magnetic torque on every geostrophic cylinder centred on the rotation axis must vanish. This condition is now known as Taylor’s constraint [?]. Equivalently, the Lorentz force must lie in the range of the Coriolis operator after projection onto solenoidal vector fields [?]. The constraint is one of the main reasons why the Taylor dynamo is mathematically delicate. At each instant, the magnetostrophic and buoyancy driven components of the velocity are constrained, whereas the geostrophic component is not determined by the instantaneous force balance alone [?, ?, ?]. Taylor proposed that the requirement of remaining on the constraint manifold determines this geostrophic flow, but the original prescription was later shown to be insufficient in general three-dimensional Taylor states due to an incorrect evaluation of the boundary data in spherical domains [?].

At finite viscosity, Ek>0E_k > 0, viscous forces regularise the degeneracy of the Taylor limit. This viscous inertialess problem has formed the basis of several plane layer studies, including computations observing weak- and strong-field dynamo states [?, ?, ?, ?]. Realistic Ek≪1E_k \ll1 remain computationally inaccessible by direct numerical simulations. Instead, a ‘Taylorisation coefficient’ has been used to measure the degree to which Taylor’s constraint is satisfied as EkE_k decreases [6, 9]. We consider both the singular Taylor limit and its finite viscosity extension.

The solution theory of the Taylor model is incomplete. Well-posedness is subtle even for perturbative variants [?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?]. However, the instantaneous force balance still imposes useful constraints. In particular, identities associated with the Coriolis operator allow magnetic energy production to be related to the horizontal Archimedean flow generated by buoyancy, without determining the subsequent evolution of the geostrophic flow. We can therefore ask: for smooth solutions of Taylor’s model, what quantitative conditions are necessary for magnetic energy or magnetic enstrophy to grow?

Kinematic dynamo theory

Previous rigorous studies of dynamo action are restricted to kinematic dynamos. Kinematic dynamos are simplifications in which magnetic feedback on the flow is neglected [1]. In this setting, the velocity field, u\mathbf{u}, is determined independently of the magnetic field. The induction equation then becomes a linear evolution equation for the magnetic field, and dynamo action is formulated as the existence of magnetic fields with a positive asymptotic growth rate under the action of the induction operator. The study of kinematic dynamos is diverse [?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, 5], here we review the results relevant to our subsequent nonlinear study.

The first major antidynamo result is due to Cowling [?] and states that an axisymmetric magnetic field vanishing at infinity cannot be maintained by dynamo action. A Cartesian analogue of Cowling’s theorem states that a magnetic field invariant in one Cartesian direction and decaying appropriately at infinity cannot be maintained. This restriction on magnetic field geometry is distinct from Zel’dovich’s theorem, which prohibits dynamo action driven by a planar two dimensional velocity field in an unbounded domain [16]. A related result is that a purely toroidal flow cannot generate a dynamo; however, if a small poloidal flow exists, a kinematic dynamo requires a sufficiently large toroidal flow [2]. Nuances to the axisymmetric theorems have also been shown to exist [?], [?], [?].

Antidynamo theorems exclude exact geometries. A complementary approach excludes flows that are too weak, by deriving necessary lower bounds on RmRm. The first result due to Childress [?] applies to velocity fields normalised by their maximum, in which case, Rm≥πRm \ge\pi, whereas if the maximum strain, ∇u\nabla\mathbf{u}, of the flow is chosen as the velocity scale, Rm≥π2Rm \ge\pi^2 [?]. Both results can be improved for insulating boundary conditions requiring continuity of the wall normal magnetic field to a potential field in the exterior, thereby increasing the minimal necessary RmRm to 3.51 and 12.29 [4]. In spherical domains, with a radially weighted maximum norm, Kaiser & Tilgner demonstrate that for a selection of velocity fields, the lower bounds are improved by a factor of up to 2.6 [?].

By contrast, if the velocity is normalised by an L2L^2 norm, there is no positive universal lower bound on RmRm. A result demonstrated by constructing a class of flows with decreasing minimum RmRm under a fixed energy norm [3]. However, when the velocity is normalised in an LpL^p norm with 3≤p≤∞3 \le p \le\infty, then Luo et al. [?] proved that Rm≥π6−n2n(3−1/2(2π−1)2/3)6−3n2nRm \ge\pi^{\frac{6-n}{2n}}(3^{-1/2}(2\pi-1)^{2/3})^{\frac{6-3n}{2n}} where 2≤n≤62 \le n \le6 and 1/n+1/p=1/21/n + 1/p = 1/2. Their result for n=2n = 2 and p=∞p = \infty is equivalent to the original result of Childress, while for n=6n = 6 and p=3p = 3 it gives 2.34. The authors also find that, under an L2L^2 enstrophy normalisation, Rm≥3.1Rm \ge3.1 [?].

Kinematic dynamo theory has limited application to the magneto-geostrophic models discussed in §1.2 because the geostrophic component of the flow is typically difficult to compute. Crucially, our constraints for dynamo action do not require information from geostrophic component.

Outline

The paper is organised as follows. In §2 we introduce the dynamo model and Taylor’s constraint. §3 states the main results, first for the Taylor limit and then for the viscous inertialess model. In §4 we present bounds for the temperature equation and use them to simplify the results of the previous section in terms of "classical" Rayleigh numbers. §5, 6 and 7 contain the proofs of the inviscid, viscous and temperature equation results. §8 provides concluding remarks. The appendices collect constants and identities of the poloidal-toroidal decomposition.

Governing Equations

We consider an electrically conducting fluid confined by two horizontal parallel plates in a rotating frame of reference. The frame rotates at a rate Ω\Omega and gravity acts antiparallel to the vertical direction with strength gg.

The fluid is considered incompressible and has density ρ\rho. The fluid has kinematic viscosity ν\nu. For thermal properties, the fluid has thermal diffusivity κ\kappa, specific heat capacity cpc_p and thermal expansion coefficient α\alpha. As a conductor, the fluid has electrical conductivity σ\sigma and permeability μ\mu. The plates are separated by a distance dd, and are periodic in the horizontal directions with periods LxdL_xd and LydL_yd. The fluid is subject to internal or boundary heating.

Figure 1. Schematic diagram of our dynamo configuration. The fluid is bounded between two horizontal plates and the domain is periodic in the xx and yy directions. The frame rotates about the zz axis at a constant rate Ω\Omega and gg is the acceleration due to gravity. The magnetic field BB generated by the fluid is illustrated with blue lines.

Inertialess Magnetohydrodynamics

To nondimensionalise the problem, we fix dd as the characteristic length scale, UU as the velocity scale, B0B_0 as the magnetic field scale, and T0T_0 as the temperature scale. In nondimensional terms, the electrically conducting fluid fills a domain V=[0,Lx]×[0,Ly]×[0,1]V = [0,L_x] \times[0,L_y] \times[0,1] and is described by the magnetohydrodynamic equations

ez×u+∇P−Ek⁡∇2u=Λ(∇×B)×B+RaTez(1)\mathbf{e}_z \times\mathbf{u} + \nabla P - \operatorname{Ek}\nabla^2\mathbf{u} = \Lambda(\nabla\times\mathbf{B}) \times\mathbf{B} + RaT\mathbf{e}_z \tag*{(1)}
∇⋅u=0(2)\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u} = 0 \tag*{(2)}
∂tB−∇×(u×B)=1Rm∇2B(3)\partial_t\mathbf{B} - \nabla\times(\mathbf{u} \times\mathbf{B}) = \frac{1}{Rm}\nabla^2\mathbf{B} \tag*{(3)}
∇⋅B=0(4)\nabla\cdot\mathbf{B} = 0 \tag*{(4)}
∂tT+∇⋅(uT)=1Pe∇2T+QPe(5)\partial_t T + \nabla\cdot(\mathbf{u}T) = \frac{1}{Pe}\nabla^2T + \frac{Q}{Pe} \tag*{(5)}

The equations are inertialess having taken the limit Ro→0Ro \to0, where RoRo is the Rossby number. The nondimensional parameters, and their role in the model, are detailed below.

The unknowns are the fluid velocity, the magnetic field, and the temperature:

u=∑i∈{x,y,z}ui(x,t)ei,B=∑i∈{x,y,z}Bi(x,t)ei,T=T(x,t).(6)\mathbf{u} = \sum_{i \in\{x,y,z\}} u_i(\mathbf{x},t)\mathbf{e}_i,\quad\mathbf{B} = \sum_{i \in\{x,y,z\}} B_i(\mathbf{x},t)\mathbf{e}_i,\quad T = T(\mathbf{x},t). \tag*{(6)}

The internal heating

Q=Q(x),(7)Q = Q(\mathbf{x}), \tag*{(7)}

is nondimensionalized by T0T_0.

Imposed on these functions are periodicity in xx and yy, and boundary conditions on ∂V={z=0}∪{z=1}\partial V = \{z = 0\} \cup\{z = 1\}. On the boundaries S±={z=1/2±1/2}S_{\pm} = \{z = 1/2 \pm1/2\} the outward unit normal is n±=±ez\mathbf{n}_{\pm} = \pm\mathbf{e}_z. The boundaries are impenetrable, ferromagnetic and isothermal. In the inviscid limit Ek→0Ek \to0, the boundary conditions are

u⋅n±∣S±=0,(8)\mathbf{u} \cdot\mathbf{n}_{\pm} \big|_{S_{\pm}} = 0, \tag*{(8)}
B×n±∣S±=0,(9)\mathbf{B} \times\mathbf{n}_{\pm} \big|_{S_{\pm}} = 0, \tag*{(9)}
T∣S±=T±.(10)T \big|_{S_{\pm}} = T_{\pm}. \tag*{(10)}

In the viscous case Ek>0Ek > 0, the fluid satisfies the stress-free condition

(∇×u)×n±∣S±=0.(11)(\nabla\times\mathbf{u}) \times\mathbf{n}_{\pm} \big|_{S_{\pm}} = 0. \tag*{(11)}

The ferromagnetic boundary condition for the magnetic field (9) implies

(∇×B)⋅n±∣S±=0,(12)(\nabla\times\mathbf{B}) \cdot\mathbf{n}_{\pm} \big|_{S_{\pm}} = 0, \tag*{(12)}
∂zB⋅n±∣S±=0.(13)\partial_z \mathbf{B} \cdot\mathbf{n}_{\pm} \big|_{S_{\pm}} = 0. \tag*{(13)}

The boundary values T+T_{+} and T−T_{-} are constant temperatures.

The model is completed with initial conditions for B\mathbf{B} and TT. As our analysis is independent of this data, given it is compatible, we do not detail this point.

Nondimensional parameters

From the dimensional parameters defined in the previous section the magnetic diffusivity can be defined as η=1/(σμ)\eta= 1/(\sigma\mu). The nondimensional numbers are

References

  1. [1]Henry K Moffatt. Field generation in electrically conducting fluids. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, London, New York, Melbourne 2 (1978) 5–1.
  2. [2]Michael RE Proctor. An extension of the toroidal theorem. Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 98 (2004) 235–240.DOI
  3. [3]Michael RE Proctor. Energy requirement for a working dynamo. Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 109 (2015) 611–614.
  4. [4]Michael RE Proctor. On Backus’ necessary condition for dynamo action in a conducting sphere. Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 9 (1977) 89–93.DOI
  5. [5]François Rincon. Dynamo theories. Journal of Plasma Physics 85 (2019) 205850401.
  6. [6]Jon Rotvig, Chris A Jones. Rotating convection-driven dynamos at low Ekman number. Physical Review E 66 (2002) 056308.
  7. [7]Paul H Roberts, Eric M King. On the genesis of the Earth’s magnetism. Reports on Progress in Physics 76 (2013) 096801.DOI
  8. [8]Tobias Schwaiger, Thomas Gastine, Julien Aubert. Force balance in numerical geodynamo simulations: a systematic study. Geophysical Journal International 219 (2019) S101–S114.DOI
  9. [9]Stephan Stellmach, Ulrich Hansen. Cartesian convection driven dynamos at low Ekman number. Physical Review E–Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics 70 (2004) 056312.
  10. [10]Krista M Soderlund, Sabine Stanley, Hao Cao, Michael A Calkins, Matthew K Browning. Puzzles in planetary dynamos: Implications for planetary interiors. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences 53 (2025).DOI
  11. [11]Gerald Schubert, Krista M Soderlund. Planetary magnetic fields: Observations and models. Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors 187 (2011) 92–108.
  12. [12]John B Taylor. The magneto-hydrodynamics of a rotating fluid and the Earth’s dynamo problem. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences 274 (1963) 274–283.DOI
  13. [13]Sonia M Tikoo, Alexander J Evans. Dynamos in the inner solar system. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences 50 (2022) 99–122.
  14. [15]Rakesh K Yadav, Thomas Gastine, Ulrich R Christensen, Scott J Wolk, Katja Poppenhaeger. Approaching a realistic force balance in geodynamo simulations. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113 (2016) 12065–12070.
  15. [16]Yakov B Zel’dovich. The magnetic field in the two-dimensional motion of a conducting turbulent liquid. J Exp Theor Phys 31 (1957) 460–462.

Paper details

vlnc:W_2ruszaf2
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents