betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Saddle Codazzi tensor on spheres and hemisphere rigidity

Abstract

Let (Mn,g)(M^n,g), n≥3n\geq 3, be a compact connected Riemannian manifold with smooth boundary. We ask whether MM must be isometric to the standard hemisphere if sec⁡g≥1\sec_g\geq 1, ∂M\partial M is isometric to the standard unit sphere, and its second fundamental form is Codazzi. Our approach centers on saddle Codazzi tensors on round spheres, where the saddle condition requires the restriction to every tangent two-plane to have nonpositive determinant. By analyzing the associated support maps, we prove that every smooth saddle Codazzi tensor on Sm\mathbb S^m vanishes identically for m≥3m\geq 3. Together with Panina's examples on S2\mathbb S^2, this shows that, among unit spheres of dimension at least two, nontrivial smooth saddle Codazzi tensors exist precisely in dimension two. The vanishing theorem yields an affirmative answer to the hemisphere rigidity question for n≥4n\geq 4. In dimension three, we realize the nontrivial saddle Codazzi tensors provided by Panina's construction, after scaling, as the second fundamental forms of smooth perturbations of the standard hemisphere, preserving the round boundary metric and the sectional curvature lower bound. This produces counterexamples to rigidity in dimension three. Nevertheless, under the same curvature and boundary assumptions, we prove the sharp inradius estimate rin(M)≤π/2r_{\mathrm{in}}(M)\leq π/2, with equality if and only if MM is isometric to the standard hemisphere.

Introduction

Rigidity phenomena for compact Riemannian manifolds with boundary have been studied extensively from both geometric and analytic points of view. A fundamental result in this direction is a theorem by Hang and Wang, [1]. In one of its standard forms, their theorems asserts that if (Mn,g)(M^n,g) is a compact Riemannian manifold with smooth boundary such that

Ric⁡g≥(n−1)g,(∂M,g∣T∂M)≅Sn−1,h≥0,\operatorname{Ric}_g \ge(n-1)g,\qquad(\partial M,g|_{T\partial M}) \cong S^{n-1},\qquad h \ge0,

where hh denotes the second fundamental form of ∂M\partial M with respect to the outward unit normal and the convention h(X,Y)=g(∇XMν,Y)h(X,Y)=g(\nabla^{M}_{X}\nu,Y), then (M,g)(M,g) is isometric to the standard hemisphere S+n\mathbb{S}^{n}_{+}. Generalizations to spherical domains bounded by Clifford tori appear in [3].

The prescribed boundary metric and second fundamental form can also be viewed as geometric analogues of Dirichlet and Neumann data. This viewpoint connects hemisphere rigidity with overdetermined boundary problems, such as Serrin’s symmetry theorem [Ser71], and with rigidity results for the Obata equation ∇2f+fg=0\nabla^{2}f+fg=0; see [5 Esc90, Xia91, CLW21]. We ask whether the stronger interior condition sec⁡g≥1\sec_{g}\geq1 allows one to replace boundary convexity by a condition that does not prescribe the signs of the principal curvatures.

Grove and Petersen [GP22] studied the related problem for Alexandrov spaces of curvature at least 1. They prove that maximal boundary volume, vol⁡(∂M)=vol⁡(Sn−1)\operatorname{vol}(\partial M)=\operatorname{vol}(\mathbb{S}^{n-1}), forces the space to be a spherical lens LαnL_{\alpha}^{n}, bounded by two hemispheres meeting at an angle α∈(0,π]\alpha\in(0,\pi]. This does not directly resolve the smooth Riemannian problem: without local convexity of the boundary, a lower sectional curvature bound need not make the intrinsic distance space an Alexandrov space with the same lower curvature bound.

Our additional boundary assumption is the Codazzi equation. After identifying the boundary with the unit sphere, it reads

(∇Xh)(Y,Z)=(∇Yh)(X,Z)(X,Y,Z∈TSn−1).(\nabla_{X}h)(Y,Z)=(\nabla_{Y}h)(X,Z)\qquad(X,Y,Z\in T\mathbb{S}^{n-1}).

Together with the Gauss equation, this condition gives a boundary problem on the round sphere that can be studied independently of the interior metric. The resulting rigidity holds in dimensions at least four.

Theorem A. Let (Mn,g)(M^{n},g), n≥4n\geq4, be a compact connected Riemannian manifold with smooth boundary. Assume that

  1. sec⁡g≥1\sec_{g}\geq1;

  2. (∂M,g∣T∂M)(\partial M,g|_{T\partial M}) is isometric to the standard unit sphere Sn−1\mathbb{S}^{n-1};

  3. the second fundamental form hh of ∂M\partial M is a Codazzi tensor.

Then (M,g)(M,g) is isometric to the standard hemisphere S+n\mathbb{S}^{n}_{+}.

Remark 1.1. The boundary argument uses only sec⁡M(Π)≥1\sec_{M}(\Pi)\geq1 for planes Π⊂T∂M\Pi\subset T\partial M. Once h=0h=0, the theorem of Hang and Wang uses Ric⁡g≥(n−1)g\operatorname{Ric}_{g}\geq(n-1)g in the interior. These two assumptions may therefore replace condition (1) in Theorem A.

Remark 1.2. The corresponding statement is false in dimension two. A smooth simple closed curve of length 2π2\pi in S2\mathbb{S}^{2} need not be a great circle. Either region bounded by such a curve has Gaussian curvature 1 and boundary intrinsically isometric to S1\mathbb{S}^{1}, but is not a hemisphere. The Codazzi condition imposes no restriction on a one-dimensional boundary.

Dimension three admits a different behavior. Panina’s construction [Pan05] provides nonzero Codazzi tensors on S2S^2 satisfying the sign condition required by the Gauss equation. We show that these boundary data can be realized by metrics whose sectional curvatures remain at least 1 throughout the interior.

Theorem B. There exists a compact Riemannian manifold (M3,g)(M^3,g), diffeomorphic to the closed three-dimensional ball, such that

sec⁡g≥1,(∂M,g∣T∂M)≅S2,\operatorname{sec}_g \ge1,\qquad(\partial M,g|_{T\partial M}) \cong S^2,

and the second fundamental form of ∂M\partial M is a nonzero Codazzi tensor. In particular, (M,g)(M,g) is not isometric to the standard hemisphere.

Theorem B is related to the study of saddle spheres in the standard S3S^3. Gálvez, Mira, and Tassi [GMT24] prove that every real analytic immersed saddle two-sphere in S3S^3 is equatorial, and show that this rigidity fails in the smooth category. In their setting, the ambient metric is round, while the induced metric on the sphere is allowed to vary. Our construction fixes the induced boundary metric to be the standard metric on S2S^2 and realizes nontrivial saddle Codazzi tensors, after scaling, as its second fundamental form by deforming the ambient metric while maintaining sec⁡g≥1\operatorname{sec}_g \ge1.

Although these boundary conditions do not imply rigidity in dimension three, they give a sharp bound for the distance from an interior point to the boundary. Equality restores rigidity.

Theorem C. Let (M3,g)(M^3,g) be a compact connected Riemannian manifold with smooth boundary. Assume that

  1. sec⁡g≥1\operatorname{sec}_g \ge1;

  2. (∂M,g∣T∂M)(\partial M,g|_{T\partial M}) is isometric to the standard unit sphere S2S^2;

  3. the second fundamental form hh of ∂M\partial M is a Codazzi tensor.

Then

rin(M):=max⁡p∈Mdg(p,∂M)≤π2,r_{\mathrm{in}}(M) := \max_{p\in M} d_g(p,\partial M) \le\frac{\pi}{2},

with equality if and only if (M,g)(M,g) is isometric to the standard hemisphere S+3S^3_+.

The common geometric mechanism behind our proofs is the study of saddle Codazzi tensors on round spheres. These are symmetric Codazzi tensors whose restrictions to all tangent two-planes have nonpositive determinant. Put m=n−1m=n-1 and identify a symmetric boundary tensor with its self-adjoint endomorphism using the round metric. Every Codazzi tensor on SmS^m, m≥2m\ge2, is of the form Af=∇2f+fgSmA_f=\nabla^2f+fg_{S^m}. When the boundary is round and sec⁡g≥1\operatorname{sec}_g\ge1, the Gauss equation shows that its second fundamental form satisfies precisely the saddle condition. The boundary geometry thus leads naturally to the question of whether nontrivial saddle Codazzi tensors can exist on SmS^m. Pointwise, the saddle condition allows at most one positive and one negative eigenvalue, so rank Af≤2A_f \le2. This rank restriction is the starting point of our analysis of the associated support map.

The potential ff determines a map into Euclidean space,

Ff:Sm⟶Rm+1,Ff(x)=∇f(x)+f(x)x,dFf=Af.F_f:S^m\longrightarrow\mathbb{R}^{m+1},\qquad F_f(x)=\nabla f(x)+f(x)x,\qquad dF_f=A_f.

It parametrizes the envelope of the planes ⟨y,x⟩=f(x)\langle y,x\rangle=f(x), with singularities allowed. On a sufficiently small constant-rank neighborhood its image is a submanifold, and xx is a unit normal to that image. If r=max⁡rank⁡Af>0r=\max\operatorname{rank} A_f>0 and m≥3m\ge3, then r≤2<mr\le2<m. A suitable linear projection of FfF_f has a compact regular fiber component that is a full unit normal sphere of a local image. This sphere has dimension m−r≥1m-r\ge1, so it contains a complete great circle on which FfF_f is constant.

Such a circle gives a global obstruction. Restrict ff to any great 2-sphere containing the circle and subtract the linear function determined by the constant value of FfF_f. The resulting function uu and its first derivatives vanish along the circle. Vanishing of uu alone makes the orthogonal projection of FuF_u onto the plane of the circle zero there. Stokes’ theorem gives zero projected signed area on each hemisphere, so the saddle condition forces det⁡Au=0\det A_u=0. An energy identity then realizes equality in the first Dirichlet eigenvalue inequality on each hemisphere and shows that uu is linear. Its vanishing first derivatives along the circle now give u=0u=0. Varying the great 2-sphere gives Af=0A_f=0 on SmS^m. Thus h=0h=0 in every dimension n≥4n\ge4, and Hang–Wang rigidity applies.

The same map also explains the boundary data in dimension three. Its signed area vector gives the balance identity needed to construct the counterexamples. We first realize the data on an exact boundary collar. A correction supported in the interior then gives the global curvature bound while preserving the collar.

For the inradius equality case, we separate distance comparison from a rigidity statement for contact sets on S2S^2 (Proposition 4.5). Distance comparison produces a nonnegative boundary function uu satisfying ∇2u+bh≤0\nabla^2u+bh\le0, with b>0b>0, near its compact zero set CC. At contact points, h≤0h\le0 and rank h≤1h\le1. The two distinct support-map values supplied by Gálvez–Mira [GM26], together with a convex barrier argument, force a scalar projection of FfF_f to have an interval of values on CC. A regular level curve meeting CC stays in CC and becomes a complete great circle on which FfF_f is constant. Lemma 2.4 then gives h=0h=0. Thus the two rigidity arguments end with the same circle obstruction; in dimension three, the contact inequality and the Gálvez–Mira theorem supply the circle.

§ 2 develops support maps and the geometry of their normal fibers, which yields non-existence of nontrivial saddle Codazzi tensors on SmS^m for m≥3m\ge3. Using this, we complete the proof of Theorem A. § 3 realizes the nonzero saddle data on S2S^2 by metrics with sec⁡≥1\operatorname{sec} \ge1. § 5 proves the inradius estimate and its equality case.

Classification of Saddle Codazzi tensors on SmS^m (m≥3m \ge3)

On the unit round sphere (Sm,gSm)(S^m,g_{S^m}), m≥2m \ge2, we identify a symmetric bilinear form hh with its self-adjoint endomorphism AA by h(X,Y)=⟨AX,Y⟩h(X,Y)=\langle AX,Y\rangle. We say that AA is saddle if

det⁡(h∣Π)≤0for every two-plane Π⊂TxSm and every x∈Sm,\det(h|_{\Pi}) \le0 \qquad\text{for every two-plane } \Pi\subset T_xS^m \text{ and every } x \in S^m,

where the determinant is computed in an orthonormal basis of Π\Pi. For a function ff, we write AfA_f for the endomorphism determined by

⟨AfX,Y⟩=∇2f(X,Y)+f⟨X,Y⟩.\langle A_fX,Y\rangle=\nabla^2f(X,Y)+f\langle X,Y\rangle.

Thus AfA_f represents the spherical Hessian of ff under this identification. Pointwise evaluation is denoted by A(x)A(x) or Af(x)A_f(x); the subscript in AfA_f records the potential function. For the boundary in Theorem A, the Gauss equation gives

det⁡(h∣Π)=1−sec⁡M(Π)≤0.(1)\det(h|_{\Pi})=1-\operatorname{sec}_M(\Pi)\le0. \tag*{(1)}

The essential rigidity statement is therefore intrinsic to the sphere. We will prove that this boundary tensor vanishes in every dimension m≥3m \ge3. We first describe the support map and the geometry of its compact fibers.

Lemma 2.1. A self-adjoint endomorphism is saddle if and only if it has at most one positive and at most one negative eigenvalue. In particular, its rank is at most two.

Proof. Applying the saddle condition to the plane spanned by any two orthonormal eigenvectors gives λiλj≤0\lambda_i\lambda_j \le0 for i≠ji \ne j. Conversely, if there is at most one eigenvalue of each sign, the restriction to any two-plane is neither positive nor negative definite, and hence has nonpositive determinant. □\square

Lemma 2.2. Let AA be a smooth self-adjoint Codazzi tensor on SmS^m, m≥2m \ge2. Then A=AfA=A_f for a smooth function ff, and the map

F:Sm⟶Rm+1,F(x)=∇f(x)+f(x)x,F:S^m\longrightarrow\mathbb{R}^{m+1},\qquad F(x)=\nabla f(x)+f(x)x,

satisfies dFx(X)=A(x)XdF_x(X)=A(x)X, viewed as an identity in Rm+1\mathbb{R}^{m+1}. Conversely, AfA_f is Codazzi for every smooth ff. The potential ff is unique modulo functions x↦⟨a,x⟩x\mapsto\langle a,x\rangle.

Proof. Regard ω(X)=AX\omega(X)=AX as an Rm+1\mathbb{R}^{m+1}-valued one-form. The Euclidean Gauss formula gives

dω(X,Y)=(∇XA)Y−(∇YA)X−(⟨X,AY⟩−⟨Y,AX⟩)x=0.d\omega(X,Y)=(\nabla_XA)Y-(\nabla_YA)X-\bigl(\langle X,AY\rangle-\langle Y,AX\rangle\bigr)x=0.

References

  1. [1]Fengbo Hang and Xiaodong Wang. “Rigidity theorems for compact manifolds with boundary and positive Ricci curvature”. In: J. Geom. Anal. 19.3 (2009), pp. 628–642. ISSN: 1050-6926,1559-002X. DOI: 10.1007/s12220-009-9074-y.DOI
  2. [2]Jürgen Jost, Yuanlong Xin, and Ling Yang. “The regularity of harmonic maps into spheres and applications to Bernstein problems”. In: J. Differential Geom. 90.1 (2012), pp. 131–176. DOI: 10.4310/jdg/1335209491.DOI
  3. [3]Mijia Lai. “A note on Hang-Wang’s hemisphere rigidity theorem”. In: Math. Z. 296.3-4 (2020), pp. 901–909. ISSN: 0025-5874,1432-1823. DOI: 10.1007/s00209-020-02469-w.DOI
  4. [5]Robert C. Reilly. “Applications of the Hessian operator in a Riemannian manifold”. In: Indiana Univ. Math. J. 26.3 (1977), pp. 459–472. ISSN: 0022-2518,1943-5258. DOI: 10.1512/iumj.1977.26.26036.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_2skuszbw
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 11

downloads · 2

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents