betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Gravo-thermal catastrophe in gravitational collapse and energy progenitor of Gamma-Ray Bursts

Abstract

We study the homologous collapse of stellar nuclear core, the virial theorem for hadron collisional relaxations, and photon productions from hadron collisions. We thus show the gravo-thermal dynamical process that transforms gravitational energy to photon energy. The process is energetically and entropically favourable. The total baryon number conservation, Euler equation for energy-momentum conservation and Poisson's equation for gravitational potential are adopted to describe homologous core collapses. The virial theorem determines the hadron collision energy gain from gravitational potential. The hadronic photon production rate determines the photon energy density. The time scales of macroscopic and microscopic processes are studied to verify approximations. As a result, we show the formation of opaque photon-pair spheres, whose total energy, size, temperature and number density, accounting for the main energetic features of Gamma-Ray Burst progenitors. We obtain the intrinsic correlations of these quantities. They depend only on the averaged thermal index of the stellar core. We discuss the possibility to confront them with observational data.

Introduction

Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) are the most energetic and complex events in the Universe. One of the peculiar features is that the progenitors of these events release hard photons of tremendous energy 1049∼105410^{49}\sim10^{54} ergs in a few seconds. Since the last decades, great progress has been made for understanding the GRB natures [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9]. However it still remains an open question what is the dominate dynamics of GRB progenitors, and many efforts have been made to find answers [7, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34]. It is no doubt that massive stellar gravitational potentials are great energy reservoirs, stellar collapse and coalescence must gain gravitational energies. How huge and invisible potential energies are converted to visible hard photon energies in just a few seconds, accounting for GRBs. Slowly hydrodynamical and kinematic processes are probably unlikely to make such rapid energy conversions. The most probable candidatures are electromagnetic and/or strong interacting processes. On the latter candidature, we mostly focus on this article.

In a self-gravitating system, Lynden-Bell and Wood [35, 36] pioneered the study of gravo-thermal catastrophe by using violent particle collisionless relaxation and virial theorem. The relevant dynamics and time scales in galactic and stellar systems have been discussed in the references, see for example [37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44]. We are inspired by the Lynden-Bell and Wood study, which shows the relaxation process that particles gain their mean kinetic heat energy from gravitational potential. On the other hand, we learn the hadron and quark-gluon photon productions by heavy-ion collisions. In the last decades, such photon productions have been intensively studied theoretically and experimentally in nuclear and particle physics [45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50]. This microscopic photon production process may have important applications in the arena of astrophysics and cosmology.

Suppose that hadrons inside compact stellar core gain gravitation energy by collisional relaxation, and hadron collisions produce photons. We study the gravo-thermal dynamics: how the gravitational core-collapse process converts the gravitational energy to photon energy and create a photon-pair sphere. To qualitatively show how the dynamics work, we adopt homologous core collapses [51] and discuss different time and length scales of macroscopic and microscopic processes. Using both analytical and numerical approaches for calculations, we show the formation of opaque and energetic photon-pair spheres, possibly explaining GRB progenitors.

We organise this article as follow. In Secs. 22 and 33, we present the discussions of gravo-thermal catastrophe, virial theorem, and photon productions from hadron collisions. We discuss the gravo-thermal dynamics by using homologously collapsing core in Secs. 44 and 55. In Secs. 66 and 77, we analyse photon-pair sphere properties and intrinsic correlations in connection with GRB progenitor features. Finally, we show that photon-pair sphere formation is energetically and entropically favourable in Sec. 88, and give conclusion and remarks in Sec. 99. The stellar core density is characterised by the nuclear saturation density n0≈0.16 fm−3=1.6×1038/cm3n_0 \approx0.16\,\mathrm{fm}^{-3}=1.6\times10^{38}/\mathrm{cm}^{3} or ρ0=mn0≈2.4×1035 ergs/cm3\rho_0=mn_0\approx2.4\times10^{35}\,\mathrm{ergs}/\mathrm{cm}^{3}, and m≈1 GeVm\approx1\,\mathrm{GeV} is the typical baryon (neutron) mass. The light speed c=1c=1, Planck constant ℏ=1\hbar=1 and Boltzmann constant k=1k=1 are used, unless otherwise specified.

Gravo-thermal catastrophe and virial theorem

A stellar core is composed of nuclear matter, whose total mass MM and baryon number N=M/mN=M/m of baryons of mass mm1. This is a self-gravitating system. Its negative gravitational energy UU and potential ϕ\phi,

U=12∫dx3 ρ(x)ϕ<0,ϕ(x)=−G∫d3x′ ρ(x′)∣x−x′∣,(1)U=\frac{1}{2}\int d x^{3}\,\rho(x)\phi<0,\qquad\phi(x)=-G\int d^{3}x'\,\frac{\rho(x')}{\lvert x-x'\rvert}, \tag*{(1)}

where GG is the Newton constant. In the time-varying gravitational potential, via collisionless relaxation, baryons gain their mean kinetic energy from the gravitational energy. The baryon mean kinetic energy contributes to the core internal energy FF, that in turn balances the self-gravitating potential energy. Such gravo-thermal catastrophe phenomenon of stellar cores is studied by considering violent relaxation [35] and equipartition theorem [36]. In these studies, they obtained the collisionless relaxation timescale (3/4)(2πGρˉ)−1/2(3/4)(2\pi G\bar{\rho})^{-1/2} of baryons in time-varying gravitational potential, in terms of the core mean density ρˉ\bar{\rho}. The stellar core is assumed to be an isothermal core of temperature T≪mT\ll m and internal “heat” energy F=32TN≪mNF=\frac{3}{2}TN\ll mN. Moreover, they considered the isothermal core as an equilibrium or equipartition system. Therefore, the virial theorem of Clausius can be applied

2F+U=3PV,(2)2F+U=3PV, \tag*{(2)}

where VV is the core volume and PP is the external pressure, acting on the core surface. These studies show that the baryon collisionless relaxation process in gravitational potential and external pressure leads to two consequences. (i) The gravitational energy is converted to the internal heat energy of baryon gas. (ii) The balance between gravitational dynamics and thermodynamics is established, and the virial theorem (2) is applicable. The second point is correct, provided the time scales of relaxation processes is much smaller than that of macroscopic gravitational and hydrodynamical processes.

For the reasons given in the next paragraph, we generalise these discussions from an entire stellar core to a small fluid element of volume dVdV inside the stellar core. The virial theorem (2) can be given by

2dF+dU=3p dV,dF=(3/2)T(ρ/m)dV,dU=(1/2)ρϕ dV,(3)2dF+dU=3p\,dV,\qquad dF=(3/2)T(\rho/m)dV,\qquad dU=(1/2)\rho\phi\,dV, \tag*{(3)}

and dF≪ρdVdF\ll\rho dV, i.e., T≪mT\ll m. Associating to each fluid element ρdV\rho dV, the baryon temperature TT characterises the mean kinetic energy of baryon motions and collisions. We approximately describe the internal pressure pp by the equation of state (EoS)

p=κργ,(4)p=\kappa\rho^\gamma, \tag*{(4)}

with two parameters: mean thermal index γ\gamma and coefficient κ\kappa. The latter relates to the maximal value of core centre density ρc\rho_c. Here we have to mention that the EoS (4) is adopted for this simple model and preliminary study. Because of large core density and possible phase transition, more complex types of EoS are expected, for example, γ\gamma and κ\kappa are not constants in space and time.

We will consider compact stellar cores of nuclear density so that equipartition or equilibrium should be achieved by the relaxation processes of baryon-baryon collisions. Unlike the virial theorem (2) based on collisionless relaxation, the virial theorem (3) mainly bases on collisional relaxation. The collisional relaxation timescale can be estimated as

τrelax=(σnvn)−1≈5.21×10−3(n0/n)(T/m)1/2T−1<T−1,(5)\tau_{\mathrm{relax}}=(\sigma_n v n)^{-1}\approx5.21\times10^{-3}(n_0/n)(T/m)^{1/2}T^{-1}<T^{-1}, \tag*{(5)}

where n=ρ/mn=\rho/m (v)(v) is the baryon number density (mean velocity), σn≈1/mπ2\sigma_n\approx1/m_\pi^2 is the typical cross-section of baryon-baryon collisions, and averaged collision energy (baryon temperature) T=(1/2)mv2≪mc2T=(1/2)mv^2\ll mc^2. The baryon collisional relaxation time scale τrelax\tau_{\mathrm{relax}} (5) is smaller than the time scales (T−1)(T^{-1}) of baryon kinetic motion and collisionless relaxation2. Therefore, a local equilibrium or equipartition state can be established. Thus, the local virial theorem (3) is applicable. As a consequence, the baryon temperature TT is determined by

3T/m≈3vs2(1/γ)−(1/2)ϕ,(6)3T/m\approx3v_s^2(1/\gamma)-(1/2)\phi, \tag*{(6)}
vs2=∂p/∂ρ=γp/ρv_s^2=\partial p/\partial\rho=\gamma p/\rho

where vsv_s is the sound velocity. For an isothermal core, integrating Eq. (3) over the core volume ∫dV\int dV, one obtains the virial theorem (2), using ∫p dV=PV\int p\,dV=PV.

Photon production from hadron collisions

Through baryon-baryon collisions, baryons gain their mean kinetic (heat) energy from the gravitational potential of self-gravitating cores. The mean baryon collision energy is characterised by the baryon temperature TT (6). Besides, the baryon-baryon collisions produce photons and pairs of light charged leptons and quarks, As a result, baryons’ mean kinetic heat energy is converted to the energy of photons, and pairs of other light charged leptons and quarks.

From the studies of heavy-ion collisions, see for example references [45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50], we learn the hadron productions of photons in the heavy-ion collision. References [46, 47] show high-energy photons produced from quark-gluon plasma versus hot hadronic gas. The photon production rates of the quark-gluon plasma and the hadron gas are approximately the same in the energy range of a few hundred MeV. The transition from hadron matter to quark-gluon plasma (QGP) occurs at a temperature of about 200 MeV. In this energy range, quarks and gluons are deconfined in colourless particles, and become the pertinent degrees of freedom of the system. Given the temperature TT of hadron gas (or quark gluon plasma) collisions, the photon production rate Rγ=dNγ/dtdVR_\gamma= dN_\gamma/dtdV per volume is [45]

dRγd3q⃗=q0−12ααs3 2π2T2e−q0/Tln⁡(1+2.94παsq0T)(7)\frac{dR_\gamma}{d^3\vec{q}} = q_0^{-1}\frac{2\alpha\alpha_s}{3\,2\pi^2}T^2e^{-q_0/T}\ln\left(1+\frac{2.9}{4\pi\alpha_s}\frac{q_0}{T}\right) \tag*{(7)}

where QED and QCD fine structure constants α=1/137\alpha= 1/137 and αs≈0.5\alpha_s \approx0.5. Based on the hadronic photon production (7) in heavy-ion collisions, the production rates of the photon number and energy densities can be calculated as,

dnγdt=∫d3q⃗dRγd3q⃗,anddργdt=∫d3q⃗ q0dRγd3q⃗.(8)\frac{dn_\gamma}{dt} = \int d^3\vec{q}\frac{dR_\gamma}{d^3\vec{q}}, \qquad\text{and} \qquad\frac{d\rho_\gamma}{dt} = \int d^3\vec{q}\,q_0\frac{dR_\gamma}{d^3\vec{q}}. \tag*{(8)}

In addition to photons, we consider pairs of relativistic charged leptons or quarks are approximately massless, i.e., q2=q02−q⃗ 2=0q^2 = q_0^2-\vec{q}^{\,2}=0 at energy scale TT of a few hundred MeV. Their chemical potentials are zero, due to lepton- or baryon-number conservation. Integrating over the phase space d3q⃗=4πq2dqd^3\vec{q}=4\pi q^2dq in Eq. (7), we obtain,

Rγ≈4ααs3πT4ln⁡(1+2.94παs).(9)R_\gamma\approx\frac{4\alpha\alpha_s}{3\pi}T^4\ln\left(1+\frac{2.9}{4\pi\alpha_s}\right). \tag*{(9)}

Here we use the saddle point approximation q0≈Tq_0 \approx T to arrive at a simple formula for astrophysical applications. The exponential suppression factor e−q0/Te^{-q_0/T} (7) shows the dominant photon production at energy q0∼Tq_0 \sim T. On the other hand, the Heisenberg uncertainty relation in thermal particle productions yields q0τ∼1q_0\tau\sim1. This implies that the thermal photon production time scale τprod∼q0−1∼T−1\tau_{\rm prod} \sim q_0^{-1} \sim T^{-1}. Therefore, the photon number and energy densities (8) can be approximately estimated as,

nγ≈4ααs3πT3ln⁡(1+2.94παs),(10)n_\gamma\approx\frac{4\alpha\alpha_s}{3\pi}T^3\ln\left(1+\frac{2.9}{4\pi\alpha_s}\right), \tag*{(10)}
ργ≈8ααs3πT4ln⁡(1+2.94παs).(11)\rho_\gamma\approx\frac{8\alpha\alpha_s}{3\pi}T^4\ln\left(1+\frac{2.9}{4\pi\alpha_s}\right). \tag*{(11)}

We thus consistently define the production time scale

τprod≡nγ/Rγ≈T−1>τrelax.(12)\tau_{\rm prod} \equiv n_\gamma/R_\gamma\approx T^{-1} > \tau_{\rm relax}. \tag*{(12)}

These are qualitative properties of photons produced by heavy-ion collisions at baryon temperature TT.

The photon productions by baryon-baryon collisions in an isothermal baryon core of temperature TT (6) are inevitable. The necessary condition is that photons are massless, and no energy gap needs to overcome in their thermal production. Other relativistic charged lepton or quark pairs are approximately massless for temperature being much larger than their masses (T≫mℓ,qT \gg m_{\ell,q}). The sufficient condition on the other hand is that the photon production time scale τprod\tau_{\rm prod} (12) should be larger than the relaxation time scale τrelax\tau_{\mathrm{relax}} (5). This is indeed the case τprod>τrelax\tau_{\mathrm{prod}} > \tau_{\mathrm{relax}}. The gravothermal catastrophe produces not only massive baryons’ heat energy (3/2)T(ρ/m)dV(3/2)T(\rho/m)\mathrm{d}V (3), but also relativistic particles’ energy ργdV\rho_\gamma\mathrm{d}V (11).

For the baryon temperature T∼O(102)T \sim\mathcal{O}(10^{2}) MeV, the photon density nγn_\gamma (11) is so large that relativistic particles are opaqued and thermalized by collisions among themselves. The photon thermalization time scale, which is the mean-free path divided by the speed of light cc, can be estimated by

τtherm=(σγcnγ)−1≈3.23×106[ln⁡(2Tγ/me)](meTγT2)1T≫τprod.(13)\tau_{\mathrm{therm}} = (\sigma_\gamma c n_\gamma)^{-1} \approx\frac{3.23 \times10^{6}}{[\ln(2T_\gamma/m_e)]}\left(\frac{m_e T_\gamma}{T^2}\right)\frac{1}{T} \gg\tau_{\mathrm{prod}}. \tag*{(13)}

Here we use the Thomson cross section σγ≈σT(3/8)(me/Tγ)ln⁡(2Tγ/me)\sigma_\gamma\approx\sigma_T(3/8)(m_e/T_\gamma)\ln(2T_\gamma/m_e) and σT=(8π/3)α2/m2\sigma_T = (8\pi/3)\alpha^2/m^2. The photon temperature TγT_\gamma represents the mean energy of photon collisions. The mean temperature TγT_\gamma of thermalized photons can be estimated by equating photon thermal energy density to Eq. (11)

π215Tγ4≈ργ,⇒Tγ≈0.21T.(14)\frac{\pi^2}{15}T_\gamma^4 \approx\rho_\gamma,\quad\Rightarrow\quad T_\gamma\approx0.21T. \tag*{(14)}

It shows that the photon temperature TγT_\gamma is the same order of the baryon temperature TT. Inequality τtherm≫τprod\tau_{\mathrm{therm}} \gg\tau_{\mathrm{prod}} (13) implies that many photons are produced by baryon collisions before they are thermalised through their electromagnetic interactions. We further note that the viscous hydrodynamical evolutions of photons start at thermalisation time τtherm\tau_{\mathrm{therm}} [45, 52].

Moreover photons produced from baryon-baryon collisions electromagnetically are coupled to pairs of charged leptons (quarks) and anti-leptons (-quarks). Among these charged particle pairs, we particularly consider pairs of electrons and positrons, since their mass (MeV) is smaller than the photon characteristic energy ∼T>\sim T > MeV (6). Therefore the forth and back processes γ+γ↔e++e−\gamma+\gamma\leftrightarrow e^{+}+e^{-} of electron and positron pair production and annihilation are kinematically possible. The cross section σγγ↔e+e−\sigma_{\gamma\gamma\leftrightarrow e^{+}e^{-}} is of the order of the Thomson cross section σγ\sigma_\gamma in Eq. (14), and the corresponding mean-free length ∼(σγγ↔e+e−nγ)−1\sim(\sigma_{\gamma\gamma\leftrightarrow e^{+}e^{-}}n_\gamma)^{-1} is very small. This indicates that via processes γ+γ↔e++e−\gamma+\gamma\leftrightarrow e^{+}+e^{-}, photons and electron-positron pairs participate thermalisation or thermal equipartition in particle energy and number. In addition, electron-positron pairs can be produced by photons interacting with viral photons γ∗\gamma^{*} of classical external magnetic fields [53, 54]. Since the electron and positron pairs are relativistic at the energy scale under consideration, the degree freedoms of photon polarisation and electron-positron pair are the same, their thermal equipartition results in the particle energy densities ρe+e−≈ργ\rho_{e^{+}e^{-}}\approx\rho_\gamma and number densities ne+e−≈nγn_{e^{+}e^{-}}\approx n_\gamma, conserving the total lepton number. Thus, a half of photons produced from baryon-baryon collisions converts to electron-positron pairs. Equation (14) becomes (π2/15)(Tγ4+Te+e−4)≈ργ(\pi^2/15)(T_\gamma^4+T_{e^{+}e^{-}}^4)\approx\rho_\gamma, where Tγ≈Te+e−T_\gamma\approx T_{e^{+}e^{-}}. The same discussions can be applied to the inclusion of the lightest uu and dd quarks if the mean photon energy can excite them to participate in the thermalisation. As a result, these processes lead to an electrically neutral, deeply opaque and thermalised plasma (fluid) of photons and electron-positron pairs.

To end this section, it is worthwhile to have a brief discussion on other possibilities of photon productions from baryon-baryon collisions. We point out that the hadronic photon production (7) or (8) is proportional to ααs\alpha\alpha_s. The strong QCD coupling constant αs\alpha_s comes from the kinematic motion of charged quark-gluon matter (fluid) inside hadrons, which is predominately governed by the shorted ranged QCD dynamics. Whereas, the QED coupling constant α\alpha come from the charged quark-gluon matter coupling to photons, and producing photons via its QCD govern kinematic motion. It is conceivable that the kinematic motions of charged baryonic matter are partially governed by the long-ranged QED dynamics, and the photon production proceeds via QED processes like thermal bremsstrahlung, double Compton scattering, and Comptonized cyclotron/synchrotron in the presence of fluctuating electromagnetic fields in microscopic length scales and/or classical magnetic fields in macroscopic length scales. In this case, the photon production rates should be proportional to at least αα\alpha\alpha, which is smaller than ααs\alpha\alpha_s. The reason for αα\alpha\alpha is that both charged baryonic particle motions and radiations are attributed to the QED dynamics. These preliminary and qualitative discussions imply that the QCD hadronic photon-production rate (7) or (8) should be the leading order contribution, while the contributions from the QED photon-production processes should be the next leading order. Detailed and quantitative calculations should be possibly performed by simulations in heavy-ion collision physics. Nevertheless, the contributions from QED photon-production processes further increase the photon-production efficiency in baryon-baryon collisions. As a consequence, the total number density of produced photons should be larger than the one (10) from the QCD process. These QED processes are in favour of increasing the energy and number densities of thermalised plasma (fluid) of photons and electron-positron pairs, which we discussed above.

Adiabatic process of gravitational collapse

We now turn to study the gravo-thermal dynamics. How gravitational collapses convert the gravitational potential energy to the photon sphere energy via baryon collisional relaxation in gravitational potential, and baryon-baryon collisions for photon productions. The problems are that gravitational collapse is a dynamical avalanche process instead of a stationary process for which we discuss the virial theorem for particle collisionless relaxation in § 2. Besides, baryon collisional relaxation and photon production are dynamical back reaction processes, as aforementioned. In practice, dealing with such a complex system, it is rather difficult for both analytical and numerical approaches to analyse all dynamics without any approximation. To make appropriate approximations, we need to understand what is dominant physical process and variation in given relevant length and time scales.

Fundamental equations for gravitational collapse

Following the approach to homologously gravitational collapsing [51], we adopt in Newtonian approximation the continuity equation for total baryon number conservation, Euler equation for energy-momentum conservation and Poisson’s equation for gravitational potential ϕ\phi,

∂ρ∂t+∇⋅(ρu)=0,(15)\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot(\rho\mathbf{u})=0, \tag*{(15)}
(∂ρ∂t)+∇(12∣u∣2)+(∇×u)×u+∇h+∇ϕ=0,(16)\left(\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t}\right)+\nabla\left(\frac{1}{2}|\mathbf{u}|^2\right)+(\nabla\times\mathbf{u})\times\mathbf{u}+\nabla h+\nabla\phi=0, \tag*{(16)}
∇2ϕ−4πGρ=0.(17)\nabla^2\phi-4\pi G\rho=0. \tag*{(17)}

Here, u\mathbf{u} is the baryon fluid velocity. Equation of State (4) yields the baryon heat function h=H/ρh=H/\rho (HH for Enthalpy)

∇h=∇p/ρ;h=∫∇p/ρ=κγγ−1ργ−1.(18)\nabla h=\nabla p/\rho;\quad h=\int\nabla p/\rho=\frac{\kappa\gamma}{\gamma-1}\rho^{\gamma-1}. \tag*{(18)}

The gradient of heat function gives a thermal force against gravity. If the baryon fluid flow is vorticity free, the velocity can be obtained from a stream function u=∇v\mathbf{u}=\nabla v up to a constant. The Euler equation (16) becomes

∂v∂t+12∣∇v∣2+h+ϕ=0.(19)\frac{\partial v}{\partial t}+\frac{1}{2}|\nabla v|^2+h+\phi=0. \tag*{(19)}

In the following, we present the solution for arbitrary γ\gamma value, generalising the γ=4/3\gamma=4/3 solution [51]. Note that for γ<4/3\gamma<4/3, self-gravitating cores become dynamically unstable, and undergo gravitationally homologous collapses, see for example Refs. [55, 56, 57].

Macroscopic and microscopic time scale hierarchy

Self-gravitating core collapse processes have the time scale τgrav=∣R∣/∣R˙∣\tau_{\mathrm{grav}}=|\mathbf{R}|/|\dot{\mathbf{R}}|, and ∣R∣|\mathbf{R}| is the core radius. The notation τgrav\tau_{\mathrm{grav}} represents also the time scale ∼∣R∣/vs\sim|\mathbf{R}|/v_s of other hydrodynamical processes, where vsv_s is the sound velocity. As will be shown in next selection 5, the τgrav\tau_{\mathrm{grav}} is a macroscopic time scale. It is much larger than the microscopic process time scales of baryon collisional relaxation τrelax\tau_{\mathrm{relax}} (5), photon production τprod\tau_{\mathrm{prod}} (12) and thermalization τtherm\tau_{\mathrm{therm}} (13),

τgrav≫τtherm>τprod>τrelax.(20)\tau_{\mathrm{grav}}\gg\tau_{\mathrm{therm}}>\tau_{\mathrm{prod}}>\tau_{\mathrm{relax}}. \tag*{(20)}

This time scale hierarchy means that (i) these microscopic processes occur not only “instantaneously”, but also “locally” (ℓmicro≈cτmicro≪∣R∣\ell_{\mathrm{micro}}\approx c\tau_{\mathrm{micro}}\ll|\mathbf{R}|), comparing with gravitational collapsing and hydrodynamical process; (ii) there is no causal correlation among the concurrence of these microscopic processes at different space-time points in macroscopic scales. In other words, the vast difference in microscopic and macroscopic time scales implies that gravitational collapse can be considered as a very slowly adiabatic process, comparing with these rapid and local microscopic processes. Therefore, we regard that these microscopic processes can be approximately analysed, as if self-gravitating cores were static. Namely, in a gravitational collapse process, we can approximately adopt the results of baryon temperature TT (6) and photon temperature TγT_{\gamma} (14), as well as photon production number and energy densities (3.4, 3.5), obtained in previously sections. It is what we call the adiabatic approximation.

Moreover, the shorter time scale process proceeds several times and has been well established in the smooth varying period of longer time scale processes. But the inverse is not correct. The time scale hierarchy (20) shows that the most rapidly established microscopic process is the baryon collisional relaxation (6). The photon production process (12) is less rapid. The photon thermalisation process (13) is the slowest one. These microscopic processes are well established within the smooth varying periods of gravitational collapse and hydrodynamical processes. This time sequence (20) provides a necessary condition for the gravo-thermal dynamics. Namely, from gravitational potential, baryons gain heat energy via their collisional relaxations (3). Via hadronic photon productions, baryons convert their heat energy to photon energy (9), which are then thermalised (13).

A priori, we give the reasons why such an adiabatic approximation can be adopted to study microscopic dynamics in gravitational collapsing and hydrodynamic processes. However, its self-consistency has to be verified a posterior. It follows the same reasons, discussed in the pioneer works [58, 59]. There it is stated that the gravitational evolution time scale due to stellar evaporation and consumption is longer than the core relaxation time scale, the core will maintain an approximate isothermal core profile (2) and will evolve homologously.

Homologously collapsing stellar core

Basic gravitational length scale and sound velocity

We consider only the case of spherically symmetric stellar cores. The core radial coordinate is rescaled from (dimensioned) R\mathbf{R} to (dimensionless) r=R/a(t)\mathbf{r} = \mathbf{R}/a(t). The time dependent length scale function a(t)a(t) is defined as

a(t)=(γpcρc)1/2(γπGρc)−1/2=ρcγ2−1(κπG)1/2,(21)a(t) = \left(\frac{\gamma p_c}{\rho_c}\right)^{1/2}\left(\gamma\pi G\rho_c\right)^{-1/2} = \rho_c^{\frac{\gamma}{2}-1}\left(\frac{\kappa}{\pi G}\right)^{1/2}, \tag*{(21)}

where the subscript or superscript cc indicates the values at core center R=0\mathbf{R} = 0 or r=0\mathbf{r} = 0. The baryon density is rewritten as

ρ=ρcf3,ρc=(κπG)12−γa2γ2−γ,(22)\rho= \rho_c f^3,\qquad\rho_c = \left(\frac{\kappa}{\pi G}\right)^{\frac{1}{2-\gamma}}a^{\frac{2\gamma}{2-\gamma}}, \tag*{(22)}

where the core centre density ρc=ρc(t)\rho_c = \rho_c(t) is a function of time, and homologous profile f=f(r)f = f(r) is a function of dimensionless radius rr only. The scale function a(t)a(t) decreases and centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t) increases as gravitational collapse goes on. The gravitational potential ϕ\phi is re-expressed

ϕ=(γpcρc)ψ=(vsc)2ψ=γκρcγ−1ψ,(23)\phi= \left(\frac{\gamma p_c}{\rho_c}\right)\psi= (v_s^c)^2\psi= \gamma\kappa\rho_c^{\gamma-1}\psi, \tag*{(23)}

in terms of another homologous function ψ\psi and the sound velocity

vs2=γp/ρ=(vsc)2f3(γ−1);(vsc)2≡γpc/ρc=γκρcγ−1.(24)v_s^2=\gamma p/\rho=(v_s^c)^2f^{3(\gamma-1)};\qquad(v_s^c)^2\equiv\gamma p_c/\rho_c=\gamma\kappa\rho_c^{\gamma-1}. \tag*{(24)}

The sound velocity at core center (vsc)2=γpc/ρc(v_s^c)^2=\gamma p_c/\rho_c increases as the centre density ρc\rho_c increases and scale function a(t)a(t) decreases. The maximal sound velocity (vsc)2=γκρcγ−1≤1/3(v_s^c)^2=\gamma\kappa\rho_c^{\gamma-1}\leq1/3 [60] leads to the minimal scale length amin⁡a_{\min} and maximal center density ρcmax⁡\rho_c^{\max}

amin⁡=(3γ)2−γ2(γ−1)(κ1γ−1πG)1/2,ρcmax⁡=(3γκ)−1γ−1.(25)a_{\min}=(3\gamma)^{\frac{2-\gamma}{2(\gamma-1)}}\left(\frac{\kappa^{\frac{1}{\gamma-1}}}{\pi G}\right)^{1/2},\qquad\rho_c^{\max}=(3\gamma\kappa)^{-\frac{1}{\gamma-1}}. \tag*{(25)}

The sound velocity and baryon density can be expressed as

ρc=ρcmax⁡(aamin⁡)−22−γ;(vsc)2=13(aamin⁡)−2γ−22−γ=13(ρcρcmax⁡)γ−1.(26)\rho_c=\rho_c^{\max}\left(\frac{a}{a_{\min}}\right)^{-\frac{2}{2-\gamma}};\qquad(v_s^c)^2=\frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{a}{a_{\min}}\right)^{-\frac{2\gamma-2}{2-\gamma}}=\frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{\rho_c}{\rho_c^{\max}}\right)^{\gamma-1}. \tag*{(26)}

These relates three functions a(t)a(t), (vsc)2(v_s^c)^2 and ρc\rho_c at the core centre. We will use the centre density ρc\rho_c as the primal variable. The maximal core centre density ρcmax⁡\rho_c^{\max} (25) is about 5 ∼\sim 8 times the nuclear saturation energy density ρ0\rho_0. To illustrate numerical results in this article we will adopt ρcmax⁡=10ρ0\rho_c^{\max}=10\rho_0. Thus, the coefficient κ\kappa of EoS (4) is constrained. The only one parameter left is the averaged thermal index γ\gamma in EoS (4).

To present physical results and their relevance, we define the basic gravitational length in homologous collapse:

amin⁡=3.06×105(3γ)−1/2(ρcmax⁡ρ0)−1/2 (cm).(27)a_{\min}=3.06\times10^5(3\gamma)^{-1/2}\left(\frac{\rho_c^{\max}}{\rho_0}\right)^{-1/2}\,(\mathrm{cm}). \tag*{(27)}

The minimal scale length amin⁡a_{\min}, “sound horizon”, comes from Eq. (25). The scale amin⁡a_{\min} gives the macroscopic length scale that we discussed in the time scale hierarchy (20).

Eigenvalue problem for homologous collapse configurations

Setting u=a˙r\mathbf{u}=\dot{a}r or v=(1/2)aa˙r2v=(1/2)a\dot{a}r^2 [51], we reduce the continuity equation (15) to the trivial relation f˙=0\dot{f}=0 which states that the homologous profile ff and density profile f3f^3 (22) do not evolve in time. Euler’s equation (19) is separable in spatial rr and temporal tt variables,

ψ=1γ−1(λ6r2−f3(γ−1)),(28)\psi=\frac{1}{\gamma-1}\left(\frac{\lambda}{6}r^2-f^{3(\gamma-1)}\right), \tag*{(28)}
aγ2−γa¨=−λ62γγ−1(κ1γ−1πG)γ−12−γ,(29)a^{\frac{\gamma}{2-\gamma}}\ddot{a}=-\frac{\lambda}{6}\frac{2\gamma}{\gamma-1}\left(\frac{\kappa^{\frac{1}{\gamma-1}}}{\pi G}\right)^{\frac{\gamma-1}{2-\gamma}}, \tag*{(29)}

and λ\lambda is the eigenvalue. Via Eqs. (23) and (28), Poisson’s equation (17) yields the nonlinear eigenvalue equation for the homologous profile f(r)f(r),

1r2ddr(r2df3(γ−1)dr)+4(γ−1)γf3=λ,(30)\frac{1}{r^2}\frac{d}{dr}\left(r^2\frac{df^{3(\gamma-1)}}{dr}\right)+\frac{4(\gamma-1)}{\gamma}f^3=\lambda, \tag*{(30)}

and the boundary conditions are f′(0)=0f'(0)=0 and f(0)=1f(0)=1.

The theoretical scheme turns out to be an eigenvalue problem. All physical solutions of eigenvalues (γ,λm)(\gamma,\lambda_m) and 1<γ<4/31<\gamma<4/3 have to be numerically found, consistently with physical conditions and observations. Using numerical approach (mathematics), we first reproduce the γ=4/3\gamma=4/3 solution [51], as a check of numerical algorithm. Furthermore, as shown in the left of Figure 1, we find three physical solutions of homologous density profile f3f^3 corresponding to the selected eigenvalues (γ,λm)(\gamma,\lambda_m):

Figure 1. Colours on line for three eigenvalues (5.11). We show solutions to the eigenvalue problem (5.9) and (30). The homologous density profile f3f^{3} is plotted (left) as a function of dimensionless radius r=R/ar = R/a (21). The density profile f3f^{3} does not change in time, and it vanishes at the core outer radius r=rsr = r_s (5.12). The scale function a(t)/amin⁡a(t)/a_{\min} is plotted as in terms of t/τmin⁡t/\tau_{\min}, using units amin⁡a_{\min} (27) and τmin⁡\tau_{\min} (34). Note that t∼107τmin⁡∼O(10)t \sim10^{7}\tau_{\min} \sim O(10) sec., depending on ρcmax⁡\rho_c^{\max} value.

Orange (1.24,1.0×10−4)(1.24,1.0\times10^{-4}); Blue (1.23,8×10−5)(1.23,8\times10^{-5}); Green (1.225,8×10−6)(1.225,8\times10^{-6}), (5.11)

for which the homologous profile f(r)f(r) becomes tangent to f=0f=0 at the outer radius rsr_s, namely f′(rs)≈0f'(r_s)\approx0. The corresponding outer radius rsr_s are:

Orange (rs≈23)(r_s\approx23); Blue (rs≈36)(r_s\approx36); Green (rs≈34)(r_s\approx34), (5.12)

corresponding to three cases of eigenvalues (γ,λm)(\gamma,\lambda_m) (5.11). In this article, we illustrate physical results by using three colour lines (orange, blue, green), representing typically selected eigenvalues (5.11). The shadow in between these colour lines indicates other possible physical solutions.

These limiting eigenvalues λm\lambda_m (5.11) for f′(rs)≈0f'(r_s)\approx0 are reached when the core surface at rsr_s (5.12) is in free fall, see discussions in Ref. [51]. Using Eq. (30) and outer boundary condition f′(rs)≈0f'(r_s)\approx0, the mean core density ρˉ\bar{\rho} is obtained in terms of the core centre density

ρˉ≡M(4πrs3/3)=∫0rs4πr2dr ρ(4πrs3/3)=γ4(γ−1)λmρc.(31)\bar{\rho}\equiv\frac{M}{(4\pi r_s^3/3)}=\frac{\int_0^{r_s}4\pi r^2dr\,\rho}{(4\pi r_s^3/3)}=\frac{\gamma}{4(\gamma-1)}\lambda_m\rho_c. \tag*{(31)}

The MM is the total mass of the homologously collapsing core. Both the core mean density ρˉ\bar{\rho} and the core centre density ρc\rho_c are functions of the time tt.

Given the eigenvalue λ\lambda, the first and second time integrations of the temporal equation (29) give

12a˙2=λγ(2−γ)6(γ−1)2(κ1/(γ−1)πG)(γ−1)/(2−γ)a2(1−γ)/(2−γ)+C,(32)\frac{1}{2}\dot{a}^{2}=\frac{\lambda\gamma(2-\gamma)}{6(\gamma-1)^2}\left(\frac{\kappa^{1/(\gamma-1)}}{\pi G}\right)^{(\gamma-1)/(2-\gamma)}a^{2(1-\gamma)/(2-\gamma)}+C, \tag*{(32)}
a(t)amin⁡={1+[λγ3(2−γ)(γ−1)2]1/2(tτmin⁡)}1/(2−γ).(33)\frac{a(t)}{a_{\min}}=\left\{1+\left[\frac{\lambda\gamma}{3(2-\gamma)(\gamma-1)^2}\right]^{1/2}\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\min}}\right)\right\}^{1/(2-\gamma)}. \tag*{(33)}

The basic gravitational time scale in homologous collapse is:

τmin⁡≡(1πGρcmax⁡)1/2=1.02×10−5(ρcmax⁡ρ0)−1/2(sec),(34)\tau_{\min}\equiv\left(\frac{1}{\pi G\rho_c^{\max}}\right)^{1/2}=1.02\times10^{-5}\left(\frac{\rho_c^{\max}}{\rho_0}\right)^{-1/2}(\mathrm{sec}), \tag*{(34)}

and τmin⁡=(3γ)1/2amin⁡\tau_{\min}=(3\gamma)^{1/2}a_{\min}. When the time approaches to the ending of homologous collapse, t→τmin⁡t\to\tau_{\min}, the scale function a(t)a(t) approaches to the “sound horizon”, a(t)→amin⁡a(t)\to a_{\min}, and core centre density approaches to its maximal value, ρ(t)→ρcmax⁡\rho(t)\to\rho_c^{\max} (25). As a comparison, the time scale τmin⁡\tau_{\min} is larger than the free-fall time scale τff=[3π/(32Gρˉ)]1/2\tau_{ff}=[3\pi/(32G\bar{\rho})]^{1/2}. for ρc>ρˉ\rho_c > \bar{\rho} (31). In fact the time scale τmin⁡\tau_{\min} characterises the macroscopic time scale τgrav\tau_{\mathrm{grav}} that we discussed in the time scale hierarchy (20).

The constant of integration CC in Eq. (32) determines the initial velocity of collapse. Its value has no great effect on the solution a(t)a(t), when the scale function a(t)a(t) approaches to the “sound horizon” amin⁡a_{\min} (25). We put C=0C = 0 and λ>0\lambda> 0 to obtain the second integration (33). The gravitational collapse process goes in the inverse time direction from the starting time t>τmin⁡t > \tau_{\min} when a=a(t)a = a(t) and ρc=ρc(t)\rho_c = \rho_c(t), to the ending time τmin⁡\tau_{\min} when a→amin⁡a \to a_{\min} and ρc(τmin⁡)→ρcmax⁡\rho_c(\tau_{\min}) \to\rho_c^{\max}. Namely, when the core starts homologous collapse at time tt, its centre density is ρc=ρc(t)\rho_c = \rho_c(t) and centre sound velocity vsc=vsc(t)v_s^c = v_s^c(t), given the core mass MM and radius rsr_s (31).

As results, the scale function a(t)a(t) (33) is shown in the right of Figure 1. The density ρc\rho_c and sound velocity vscv_s^c at the core centre are shown in Figure 2. These figures show the variations of scale function a(t)a(t), centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t) and sound velocity vsc(t)v_s^c(t) in homologous collapsing process from t∼10t \sim10 seconds to t∼10−5t \sim10^{-5} seconds. The centre scale function a(t)a(t) (21) and sound velocity (vsc)2(t)(v_s^c)^2(t) (24) are in terms of the centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t). All physical quantities are then functions of ρc(t)\rho_c(t). While, at the time tt when the core starts homologous collapse, the initial value ρc(t)\rho_c(t) depends on the baryon core total mass MM and its homologously collapsing radius rsr_s (31).

Figure 2. Colours on line for three eigenvalues (5.11). The core centre density ρc\rho_c (left) and sound velocity (vsc)2(v_s^c)^2 (right) are plotted as functions of time in an homologous collapsing process. Their final values end up to t=τmin⁡t=\tau_{\min} when ρc=ρcmax⁡=10ρ0\rho_c=\rho_c^{\max}=10\rho_0 and (vsc)2=1/3(v_s^c)^2=1/3. Their initial values ρc(t)\rho_c(t) and (vsc)2(t)(v_s^c)^2(t) depend on the initial time tt, given the core mass MM and radius rsr_s (31) and the validity of homologous collapse description. For instance, t=107τmin⁡∼O(10)t=10^7\tau_{\min}\sim O(10) second, when ρc=10−(11∼10)ρcmax⁡=10−(10∼9)ρ0\rho_c=10^{-(11\sim10)}\rho_c^{\max}=10^{-(10\sim9)}\rho_0 and (vsc)2=(0.001∼0.003)(v_s^c)^2=(0.001\sim0.003).

To illustrate the gravitational and thermal dynamics of homologous collapse, we also plot in Figure 3 the positive heat function (18) and negative gravitational potential (23)

Heat function and gravitational potential profiles

Figure 3. Colours on line for three eigenvalues (5.11). Using solutions (35) for maximal sound velocity (vsc)2=1/3(v_s^c)^2=1/3, the positive heat function hh, negative gravitational potential ϕ\phi (left) and their sum (right) are plotted as a function of dimensionless radius rr. These homologous function (h,ϕ)(h,\phi) profiles do not depend on the time tt. However their amplitudes depend on the sound velocity (vsc)2(t)(v_s^c)^2(t). The time variations of these homologous profile amplitudes can be obtained by multiplying the sound velocity given by the right of Figure 2.

h=(vsc)2γ−1f3(γ−1);ϕ=(vsc)2γ−1(λ6r2−f3(γ−1))(35)h = \frac{(v_s^c)^2}{\gamma- 1} f^{3(\gamma- 1)}; \qquad\phi= \frac{(v_s^c)^2}{\gamma- 1}\left(\frac{\lambda}{6}r^2 - f^{3(\gamma- 1)}\right) \tag*{(35)}

and their sum h+ϕ=(vsc)2γ−1λ6r2h + \phi= \frac{(v_s^c)^2}{\gamma- 1}\frac{\lambda}{6}r^2 in the Euler equation (19). The results depend on the thermal index γ\gamma in the equation of state (4) and the eigenvalue λ>0\lambda> 0. The latter relates to the material binding energy of baryon fluid per energy density ρ\rho [51]. Indeed, our solutions (5.11) and (5.12) show that the binding energy λm\lambda_m value decreases, the outer boundary rsr_s becomes larger, i.e., the core is less bound, and the thermal index γ\gamma becomes smaller, i.e., the EoS (4) becomes soften.

Photon-pair sphere formation and properties

Photon-pair sphere temperature and energy density

On the basis of adiabatic approximation discussed below the time scale hierarchy (20), we use the “local” virial theorem (3) or (6) to obtain the baryon temperature TT (2.6), then the photon-pair sphere temperature TγT_\gamma (3.8)

Tγm≈0.21(vsc)2T(r),T(r)≡16γ(γ−1)[(7γ−6)f3(γ−1)−λ6γr2].(36)\frac{T_\gamma}{m} \approx0.21(v_s^c)^2\mathcal{T}(r), \qquad\mathcal{T}(r) \equiv\frac{1}{6\gamma(\gamma-1)}\left[(7\gamma-6)f^{3(\gamma-1)}-\frac{\lambda}{6}\gamma r^2\right]. \tag*{(36)}

The time-dependent centre sound velocity (vsc)2(v_s^c)^2 comes from Eq. (24). The photon-pair sphere temperature TγT_\gamma reaches its maximum

Tγmax⁡m≈0.21(vsc)2(7γ−6)6γ(γ−1),(37)\frac{T_\gamma^{\max}}{m} \approx0.21(v_s^c)^2\frac{(7\gamma-6)}{6\gamma(\gamma-1)}, \tag*{(37)}

at photon-pair sphere centre r=0r = 0. The photon-pair sphere temperature has no any lower limit, and it vanishes at the outer boundary r=rγ<rsr = r_\gamma< r_s, determined by T(rγ)=0\mathcal{T}(r_\gamma) = 0.

Furthermore, we use photon productions (10) and (11) by baryon collisions to approximately obtain the photon-pair sphere energy and number densities

ργρ0≈1.29×4ααs3π(Tγm)4ln⁡(1+2.94παs),(38)\frac{\rho_\gamma}{\rho_0} \approx1.29 \times\frac{4\alpha\alpha_s}{3\pi}\left(\frac{T_\gamma}{m}\right)^4 \ln\left(1+\frac{2.9}{4\pi\alpha_s}\right), \tag*{(38)}
nγn0≈6.16×4ααs3π(Tγm)3ln⁡(1+2.94παs).(39)\frac{n_\gamma}{n_0} \approx6.16 \times\frac{4\alpha\alpha_s}{3\pi}\left(\frac{T_\gamma}{m}\right)^3 \ln\left(1+\frac{2.9}{4\pi\alpha_s}\right). \tag*{(39)}

In Figure 4, we plot the photon-pair sphere temperature Tγ/mT_\gamma/m and energy density ργ/ρ0\rho_\gamma/\rho_0 for (vsc)2=1/3(v_s^c)^2 = 1/3. As a self-consistency check, we find that the baryon temperature TT and photon temperature TγT_\gamma are much smaller than baryon mass (Tγ≈0.21T≪m)(T_\gamma\approx0.21T \ll m). The condition is fully filled for applying the virial theorem (3).

Homologous profiles of temperature and energy density as functions of dimensionless radius

Figure 4. Colours on line for three eigenvalues (5.11). Using results (36) and (38) for maximal sound velocity (vsc)2=1/3(v_s^c)^2 = 1/3, we plot the homologous profiles of temperature Tγ/mT_\gamma/m (left) and energy density ργ/ρ0\rho_\gamma/\rho_0 (right) as a function of dimensionless radius rr. Both profiles vanish at the photon-pair sphere radius rγr_\gamma (40), which is smaller than the core outer radius rsr_s (5.12), namely rγ<rsr_\gamma< r_s, see left of Figure 1. Note that the typical hadron mass m≈1 GeVm \approx1\ \mathrm{GeV} and nuclear saturation density ρ0≈2.4×1035ergs/cm3\rho_0 \approx2.4 \times10^{35}\mathrm{ergs}/\mathrm{cm}^3. These homologous profiles do not depend on the time tt. But their absolute values depend on time-dependent sound velocity (vsc)2(t)(v_s^c)^2(t), see Eqs. (36) and (38). The time evolutions of photon-pair sphere temperature Tγ(r,t)/mT_\gamma(r,t)/m (36) and energy density ργ(r,t)/ρ0\rho_\gamma(r,t)/\rho_0 (38) are given in Figure 7 in Appendix § 11.

In addition, the photon energy density ργ\rho_\gamma (11) is much smaller than not only baryon mass-energy density ρ\rho, but also baryon heat energy density (3/2)Tρ/m(3/2)T\rho/m (3). This justifies a posteriori that the photon-pair sphere energy density ργ\rho_\gamma and heat function (thermal potential) hγ=ργ+pγh_\gamma=\rho_\gamma+p_\gamma can be neglected in homologous collapse dynamics, studied in previous § 5. Further discussions on the effective photon heat function will be presented in § 8.

The “instant” and “locality” of microscopic processes discussed below the time hierarchy (20) are necessary conditions that, and reasons why photons produced can form an optic thick sphere or jet at macroscopic scales. Such trapped photons are in collective motions through density perturbations and/or other hydrodynamical processes of time scale ∼∣R∣/vs\sim|\mathbf{R}|/v_s.

Photon-pair sphere size and opacity

As shown in Figure 4, the photon-pair sphere temperature and energy density profiles vanish at dimensionless radius rγ<rsr_\gamma<r_s:

Orange (rγ=21.59);Blue (rγ=30.00);Green (rγ=33.56),(40)\textit{Orange}\ (r_\gamma=21.59);\quad\textit{Blue}\ (r_\gamma=30.00);\quad\textit{Green}\ (r_\gamma=33.56), \tag*{(40)}

corresponding to three cases of eigenvalues (γ,λm)(\gamma,\lambda_m) (5.11) and rsr_s (5.12). This determines the photon-pair sphere radial size Rγ=a(t)rγR_\gamma=a(t)r_\gamma (21). Using Eqs. (26), (27) and (33), we obtain

Rγ=3.06×105(3γ)−1/2rγ(ρ0ρcmax⁡)γ−12(ρ0ρc)2−γ2 (cm),(41)R_\gamma=3.06\times10^5(3\gamma)^{-1/2}r_\gamma\left(\frac{\rho_0}{\rho_c^{\max}}\right)^{\frac{\gamma-1}{2}}\left(\frac{\rho_0}{\rho_c}\right)^{\frac{2-\gamma}{2}}\ (\mathrm{cm}), \tag*{(41)}

which is plotted in Figure 5 as a function of initial core centre density ρc=ρc(t)\rho_c=\rho_c(t), when a homologous collapse initiates. This result shows that the photon-pair sphere radius RγR_\gamma depends weakly on the eigenvalue rγ(γ,λm)r_\gamma(\gamma,\lambda_m), which is independent of the time tt. This behaviour is shown in some details by the homologous profiles given in Figure 7 in Appendix § 11. The photon-pair sphere radius RγR_\gamma decreases, as the initial core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t) increases. The reason will be given below when we discuss the total photon-pair sphere energy and number.

Figure 5. Colours on line for three eigenvalues (5.11). For maximal sound velocity (vsc)2=1/3(v_s^c)^2=1/3, we plot (left) the photon number density nγ/n0n_\gamma/n_0 (39) vanishes at outer boundary rγr_\gamma (40). The photon-pair sphere size Rγ=arγR_\gamma=ar_\gamma (43) (right) is plotted as a function of the initial core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t) at the time tt when core homologous collapse starts. The nuclear saturation density is n0≈1.6×1038/cm3n_0\approx1.6\times10^{38}/\mathrm{cm}^3 or ρ0≈2.4×1035ergs/cm3\rho_0\approx2.4\times10^{35}\mathrm{ergs}/\mathrm{cm}^3. The time evolution of photon-pair sphere number density nγ(r,t)/n0n_\gamma(r,t)/n_0 (39) profile is given in Figure 7 in Appendix § 11.

Time evolutions of homologous profiles

Figure 7. Colours on line. The green (below) line for time t1/τmin⁡≈106t_1/\tau_{\min} \approx10^6, orange (middle) line for time t2/τmin⁡≈104t_2/\tau_{\min} \approx10^4 and blue (above) line for time t3/τmin⁡≈102t_3/\tau_{\min} \approx10^2, see Figure 2. As described in text, the time sequence t1>t2>t3t_1 > t_2 > t_3 for ongoing gravitational collapses is in the inverse direction of the time arrow, from t≫τmin⁡t \gg\tau_{\min} to t=τmin⁡t = \tau_{\min}. These figures show the time evolutions of homologous profiles of baryon core density, photon-pair sphere temperature, energy and number densities for the eigenvalue (γ,λm)=(1.23,8×10−5)(\gamma, \lambda_m) = (1.23, 8 \times10^{-5}). Top panel: the baryon core density ρ(r,t)/ρ0\rho(r,t)/\rho_0 (5.2) (left), and photon energy density ργ(r,t)/ρ0\rho_\gamma(r,t)/\rho_0 (6.3) (right). Bottom panel: the photon temperature ⟨Tγ(r,t)⟩/m\langle T_\gamma(r,t)\rangle/m (6.1) (left) and number density ⟨nγ⟩/n0\langle n_\gamma\rangle/n_0 (6.4) (right). Note that typic baryon mass m≈1m \approx1 GeV, the nuclear saturation density ρ0≈2.4×1035ergs/cm3\rho_0 \approx2.4 \times10^{35}\mathrm{ergs}/\mathrm{cm}^3 and n0≈1.6×1038/cm3n_0 \approx1.6 \times10^{38}/\mathrm{cm}^3.

Moreover, we show in Figure 5 the photon-pair sphere number density nγn_\gamma (39) and photon-pair sphere size Rγ=arγR_\gamma= ar_\gamma (41). The results show that the photon number density nγn_\gamma is in the range of (1037∼1030)/cm3(10^{37} \sim10^{30})/\mathrm{cm}^3, and photon-pair sphere size RγR_\gamma is in the range of (107∼1010)(10^7 \sim10^{10}) cm. The photon-pair sphere is deeply opaque, since the photon mean-free path λγ=(σγnγ)−1\lambda_\gamma= (\sigma_\gamma n_\gamma)^{-1} is much smaller than the photon-pair sphere size RγR_\gamma, namely σγnγRγ≫1\sigma_\gamma n_\gamma R_\gamma\gg1.

On the other hand, we find in Figure 4 that the photon-pair sphere temperature TγT_\gamma can be well above the critical energy threshold 2me=1.022m_e = 1.02 MeV of electron-positron (e+e−e^+e^-) pair production. The photon-pair sphere energy density ργ\rho_\gamma can be well above the critical energy density ρe=me4=5.93×10−11ρ0\rho_e = m_e^4 = 5.93 \times10^{-11}\rho_0 of electron-positron pairs. This means that the photons are quickly thermalised to form an electro-position-photon plasma characterised by the thermalisation time scale τtherm\tau_{\mathrm{therm}} (13) [14, 17, 61], as briefly discussed in § 2.

Total photon-pair sphere energy and number

The total relativistic particle energy EγE_\gamma and number NγN_\gamma of photon-pair sphere can be obtained by numerically integrating the energy density (38) and number density (39) over the photon-pair sphere volume ∫d3R=a3∫4πr2dr\int d^3R = a^3 \int4\pi r^2dr. For comparison, we also compute the total baryon core mass M=∫ρd3R=ρca3F0M = \int\rho d^3R = \rho_c a^3 F_0 and number N=M/mN = M/m, where F0≡∫0rs4πr2drf3F_0 \equiv\int_0^{r_s}4\pi r^2dr f^3. Defining coefficients Yn≡∫0rγ4πr2dr[T(r)]nY_n \equiv\int_0^{r_\gamma}4\pi r^2dr[T(r)]^n, we obtain

EγM≈1.29×(13)44ααs3πln⁡(1+2.94παs)Y4F0(ρcmax⁡ρ0)4(1−γ)(ρ0ρc)5−4γ.(42)\frac{E_\gamma}{M} \approx1.29 \times\left(\frac{1}{3}\right)^4 \frac{4\alpha\alpha_s}{3\pi}\ln\left(1+\frac{2.9}{4\pi\alpha_s}\right)\frac{Y_4}{F_0}\left(\frac{\rho_c^{\max}}{\rho_0}\right)^{4(1-\gamma)}\left(\frac{\rho_0}{\rho_c}\right)^{5-4\gamma}. \tag*{(42)}
NγN≈6.16×(13)34ααs3πln⁡(1+2.94παs)Y3F0(ρcmax⁡ρ0)3(1−γ)(ρ0ρc)4−3γ.(43)\frac{N_\gamma}{N} \approx6.16 \times\left(\frac{1}{3}\right)^3 \frac{4\alpha\alpha_s}{3\pi}\ln\left(1+\frac{2.9}{4\pi\alpha_s}\right)\frac{Y_3}{F_0}\left(\frac{\rho_c^{\max}}{\rho_0}\right)^{3(1-\gamma)}\left(\frac{\rho_0}{\rho_c}\right)^{4-3\gamma}. \tag*{(43)}

We expressed them in terms of the core centre density ρc=ρc(t)\rho_c = \rho_c(t) at the time tt when the core starts to homologous collapse. Whereas, the time evolution of core centre density ρc\rho_c can be found in Figure 2 or Eq. (26).

Results (42), (42) and (43) show the photon-pair sphere size RγR_\gamma, energy EγE_\gamma and number NγN_\gamma depend on the initial core centre density ρc\rho_c and the averaged thermal index γ\gamma. When the massive core starts to homologous collapse, the smaller initial value of the core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t) is, the more extend core mass density profile ρ(r,t)\rho(r,t) is, provided total core mass MM and baryon number NN fixed and conserved. As a consequence, the more gravitational energy can be gained in collapse and converted to the photon-pair sphere energy EγE_\gamma so that the photon-pair sphere size RγR_\gamma and number NγN_\gamma are larger as well. However, in contrast, these quantities are also power functions of the averaged thermal index γ\gamma, that represents the core repulsive reaction against gravitational collapse and energy gain. As shown in Figure 6, we notice that for a large variation of the core centre density ρc/ρ0\rho_c/\rho_0, the total photon-pair sphere energy Eγ/ME_\gamma/M slowly varies within a order of magnitude. As an illustration, in Figure 6, we make plots starting from the core centre density ρc(t)∼10−9ρ0\rho_c(t) \sim10^{-9}\rho_0 corresponds to the core collapsing time t≈107τmin⁡∼10t \approx10^7\tau_{\min} \sim10 sec., see Figure 2. From these figures 1, 2, 5, and 6, people can find baryon core and photon-pair sphere properties, given an initial collapsing core density ρc(t)/ρ0\rho_c(t)/\rho_0 and time t/τmin⁡t/\tau_{\min}, e.g., ρc(t)/ρ0∼10−3\rho_c(t)/\rho_0 \sim10^{-3} and time t/τmin⁡∼103t/\tau_{\min} \sim10^3.

Figure 6. Colours on line for three eigenvalues (5.11). Top panel: the total photon sphere energy Eγ/ME_\gamma/M (42) (left) and number Nγ/NN_\gamma/N (43) (right); bottom panel: the mean photon-pair sphere temperature ⟨Tγ⟩/m\langle T_\gamma\rangle/m (44) (left) and energy density ⟨ργ⟩/ρ0\langle\rho_\gamma\rangle/\rho_0 (45) (right), are plotted as a function of the initial core centre density ρc\rho_c, when homologous collapse starts. The nuclear saturation density ρ0≈2.4×1035 ergs/cm3\rho_0 \approx2.4 \times10^{35}\,\mathrm{ergs}/\mathrm{cm}^3 and typical hadron mass m≈1m \approx1 GeV. MM and NN are total mass and baryon number of the homologous collapsing core, M⊙≈1.8×1054M_\odot\approx1.8 \times10^{54} ergs and N⊙≈1.2×1057N_\odot\approx1.2 \times10^{57}. The ratio ρc(t)/ρ0\rho_c(t)/\rho_0 relates to the time t/τmin⁡t/\tau_{\min} when the collapse start, see Figure 2.

In addition, we define the mean photon-pair sphere temperature and energy density as averaged values of TγT_\gamma (36) and ργ\rho_\gamma (38) over photon-pair sphere volume (4π/3)rγ3(4\pi/3)r_\gamma^3,

⟨Tγ⟩m≡0.21(vsc)2Y1(4π/3)rγ3=0.21(13)Y1(4π/3)rγ3(ρ0ρ0max⁡)γ−1(ρcρ0)γ−1,(44)\frac{\langle T_\gamma\rangle}{m} \equiv0.21(v_s^c)^2\frac{Y_1}{(4\pi/3)r_\gamma^3}=0.21\left(\frac{1}{3}\right)\frac{Y_1}{(4\pi/3)r_\gamma^3}\left(\frac{\rho_0}{\rho_0^{\max}}\right)^{\gamma-1}\left(\frac{\rho_c}{\rho_0}\right)^{\gamma-1}, \tag*{(44)}
⟨ργ⟩ρ0=Eγ(4π/3)a3rγ3ρ0=(EγρˉMρ0)(rsrγ)3=γλm4(γ−1)(EγM)(rsrγ)3(ρcρ0).(45)\frac{\langle\rho_\gamma\rangle}{\rho_0}=\frac{E_\gamma}{(4\pi/3)a^3r_\gamma^3\rho_0}=\left(\frac{E_\gamma\bar{\rho}}{M\rho_0}\right)\left(\frac{r_s}{r_\gamma}\right)^3=\frac{\gamma\lambda_m}{4(\gamma-1)}\left(\frac{E_\gamma}{M}\right)\left(\frac{r_s}{r_\gamma}\right)^3\left(\frac{\rho_c}{\rho_0}\right). \tag*{(45)}

These represent the characteristic temperature and energy density of the photon-pair sphere. They are plotted in the bottom panel of Figure 6 as functions of the initial core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t), when homologous collapse starts. Beside, the photon dimensionless energy ν/⟨Tγ⟩\nu/\langle T_\gamma\rangle and distribution function Fν(ν/⟨Tγ⟩)F_\nu(\nu/\langle T_\gamma\rangle) in phase space are relativistic and cosmological redshift invariants resulting from the Liouville theorem (see e.g. [62]). The photon energy ν\nu has a maximum (or peak energy) at νγmax⁡∝⟨Tγ⟩\nu_\gamma^{\max} \propto\langle T_\gamma\rangle.

We close this section with the following emphases. Instead of photon-pair spheres, photon-pair jets are formed for angular momentum conservation in the cases of rotating stellar core collapse, two stellar cores merger, and the presence of strong magnetic fields. Such a photon-pair jet is in the direction along with the system axial symmetric axis. One can study a photon-pair jet by considering the centrifugal or magnetic potentials with gravitational potential ϕ\phi in the local virial theorem (3). The physical quantities should be functions of radius rr and azimuth angle θ\theta, characterised by not only the initial core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t), but also photon-pair jet collimation angle θcoll\theta_{\mathrm{coll}} determined by system angular momenta and magnetic fields.

Intrinsic correlations and connections with GRB sources

We have just shown the possible mechanism of how the vast gravitational energy converts to the huge energy of an opaqued photon-pair sphere energy in homologous core collapses. In the case that photon-pair sphere heat energy is much larger than its baryon loading, such an energetic photon-pair sphere/jet undergoes ultrarelativistically hydrodynamic outward expansion, and its temperature and radius thickness remains approximately TγT_\gamma and RγR_\gamma due to relativistic effects. At the transparency point, the photon-pair sphere becomes a photosphere. These were studied in the literature, and some details of using hydrodynamic equations and rate equation of back and forth process γ+γ↔e++e−\gamma+\gamma\leftrightarrow e^{+}+e^{-} in general relativity framework can be found in Refs. [63, 64, 65]. During relativistic expansion, photon-pair sphere/jet proceeds “internal” energy dissipation processes, it sweeps and interacts with the circumburst media executing the “external” energy dissipation processes, accounting for GRB phenomena. Thus, the photon-pair sphere/jet kinematic motions (baryon loading and collimation), dynamical interactions (collisions, shocks and fluid dynamics) and energy dissipation mechanism (particle accelerations and radiation mechanisms) are important and have been modelled to account for the complex phenomena of GRB sources observed, see for example Refs. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8]. The opaqued photon-sphere formation is only the initial phase of GRB engines (progenitors). Therefore our present study is not in the position of directly explaining complex phenomena of GRB sources observed. Nevertheless, we examine photon-pair sphere properties and possible connections with GRB observations in this section.

Photon-pair sphere characteristics

The total core mass MM, initial core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t), and eigenvalue (γ,λm)(\gamma,\lambda_m) uniquely represent different configurations of homologously collapsing core,

{M,ρc(t),(γ,λm)}.(46)\{M,\rho_c(t),(\gamma,\lambda_m)\}. \tag*{(46)}

The configuration determines the homologous core density profile f3(r)f^{3}(r), outer boundary radius rsr_s (5.12) and the photon sphere radius RγR_\gamma (40), see Eq. (31), as well as all other baryon core and photon-pair sphere quantities we have obtained. The various configurations (46) in fact correspond to different photon-pair spheres.

From the results presented in Figure 6, we find the ranges of the total photon-pair sphere energy Eγ∼(10−2∼10−4)ME_\gamma\sim(10^{-2} \sim10^{-4})M and number Nγ∼(1∼10−3)NN_\gamma\sim(1 \sim10^{-3})N, taking into account the centre sound velocity (vs)2(v_s)^2 variation, see right of Figure 2. These results are consistent with the total energy and entropy budgets. They are necessarily required to explain the cosmological origin of GRB phenomena observed. On the other hand, recall that the variation of gravitational energy GM2/(2R)GM^2/(2R) is M/4M/4 for a core-collapse from infinity R=∞R = \infty to R=2GMR = 2GM. It implies that the total photon-pair sphere energy EγE_\gamma is only a few per cent of maximally available gravitational energy M/4M/4. The rest could be for core hydrodynamical and kinematic motion, as well as gravitational wave (non-spherical collapse) and other particles emissions. Such conversion from the available gravitational energy to the photon-pair sphere energy occurs in a couple of seconds. It means that the gravo-thermal dynamics is very efficient via hadron collisional relaxation and photon production in gravitational collapses.

Depending only on the averaged core thermal index 1≲γ≲4/31 \lesssim\gamma\lesssim4/3, Figure 4, Figure 5 and Figure 6 represent the qualitative results and characteristic properties of the photon-pair sphere, namely the photon temperature TγT_\gamma, energy density ργ\rho_\gamma and number density nγn_\gamma, as well as the photon-pair sphere size RγR_\gamma and opacity. These results show that the photon-pair sphere is deeply opaque, highly energetic and rather sizeable. Its temperature, size, energy and number densities are in the correct ranges, necessarily for the initial configurations of the opaque photon-pair sphere, i.e., fireball or fireshell, that subsequently undergoes various hydrodynamical and electromagnetic evolutions to explain GRB phenomena observed.

Notwithstanding, we show that the gravo-thermal dynamics can necessarily account for main energetic natures of GRB progenitor dynamics. In general, the realistic situations of gravitational collapse, baryon collisional relaxation and photon production are much more complicated. It is expected that the photon-pair sphere energy and number densities are reduced, the energy spectrum is softened, and the collapsing time is prolonged. Among others, the main reasons are that internal perturbation and/or shock waves are formed due to the baryon matter EoS (4) variations, phase transition and hydrodynamics, as well as the presence of macroscopic electromagnetic fields and thermal photon-pair sphere dynamics, even general relativistic effects. These are beyond the scopes of this article and subjects for future studies.

Universal scaling laws with only one index parameter

All physical quantities of photon-pair sphere are described in the rest frame anchored to the origin of homologously collapsing core. The photon-pair sphere size RγR_\gamma (41), total energy EγE_\gamma (42), mean temperature ⟨Tγ⟩\langle T_\gamma\rangle (44) and energy density ⟨ργ⟩\langle\rho_\gamma\rangle (45) depend on the core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t) (46) when homologous core collapse starts. Therefore they are intrinsically related each others via ρc(t)\rho_c(t). Equation (44) gives ⟨Tγ⟩∝(ρc)γ−1\langle T_\gamma\rangle\propto(\rho_c)^{\gamma-1}, and Eq. (42) gives Eγ∝(ργ/ρc)∝⟨Tγ⟩4/ρc∝ρc(4γ−5)E_\gamma\propto(\rho_\gamma/\rho_c) \propto\langle T_\gamma\rangle^4/\rho_c \propto\rho_c^{(4\gamma-5)}. Recall that the initial core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t) values (46) represent different GRB sources. As a result, eliminating the dependence on ρc(t)\rho_c(t), we qualitatively obtain the intrinsic correlation or universal scaling law between the photon-pair sphere total energy EγE_\gamma and characteristic energy scale (temperature) ⟨Tγ⟩\langle T_\gamma\rangle

Eγ∝⟨Tγ⟩χ,χ=4γ−5γ−1>0.(47)E_\gamma\propto\langle T_\gamma\rangle^\chi,\quad\chi=\frac{4\gamma-5}{\gamma-1}>0. \tag*{(47)}

This correlation (47) and those below are universal for all photon-pair spheres in the scenes that they are independent of the homologously collapsing core mass MM and initial core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t) in Eq. (46). Here the theoretical index χ\chi depends on the averaged value of effective thermal index γ\gamma. The present theoretical model and EoS (4) are too simple and preliminary to quantitatively determine the averaged value of effective thermal index γ\gamma. Nevertheless, we find that γ∼O(1)\gamma\sim O(1) values are on the right spot to give χ∼O(1)\chi\sim O(1) in Eq. (47). We will treat χ∼O(1)\chi\sim O(1) as a unique parameter for all correlations discussed here.

From the viewpoint of total photon-pair sphere energy conservation, we can define the total photon-pair sphere luminosity

Lγ≡4πcRγ2⟨ργ⟩∝⟨ργ⟩ρc−(2−γ)∝ρc5γ−6∝⟨Tγ⟩(χ+1).(48)L_\gamma\equiv4\pi cR_\gamma^2\langle\rho_\gamma\rangle\propto\langle\rho_\gamma\rangle\rho_c^{-(2-\gamma)}\propto\rho_c^{5\gamma-6}\propto\langle T_\gamma\rangle^{(\chi+1)}. \tag*{(48)}

This givs rise to the correlation of photon-pair sphere luminosity and temperature. The correlating index is not a new parameter, but (χ+1)(\chi+1) relating to the index χ\chi in the correlation (47). The Eγ−TγE_\gamma-T_\gamma (47) and Lγ−TγL_\gamma-T_\gamma (48) correlations lead to Eγ−LγE_\gamma-L_\gamma correlation,

Eγ∝Lγχχ+1.(49)E_\gamma\propto L_\gamma^{\frac{\chi}{\chi+1}}. \tag*{(49)}

With only one free parameter χ∼O(1)\chi\sim O(1), three correlations Eγ−TγE_\gamma-T_\gamma (47), Lγ−TγL_\gamma-T_\gamma (48) and Eγ−LγE_\gamma-L_\gamma (49) coherently reflect the energetic natures of gravo-thermal dynamics, which possibly explains GRB energetics.

Moreover, the photon-pair sphere size RγR_\gamma (41) represents the characteristic time scale τγ=Rγ/c\tau_\gamma=R_\gamma/c of the photon-pair sphere. It should relates the temporal duration of GRBs. Equation (41) gives Rγ∝ρc−(2−γ)/2R_\gamma\propto\rho_c^{-(2-\gamma)/2} dependence on the core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t). Using the EγE_\gamma, TγT_\gamma and LγL_\gamma relations to the core center density ρc(t)\rho_c(t), we obtain three anti-correlations Tγ−τγT_\gamma-\tau_\gamma, Eγ−τγE_\gamma-\tau_\gamma and Lγ−τγL_\gamma-\tau_\gamma:

⟨Tγ⟩∝τγ−δ=τγ−23−χ,(50)\langle T_\gamma\rangle\propto\tau_\gamma^{-\delta}=\tau_\gamma^{-\frac{2}{3-\chi}}, \tag*{(50)}
Eγ∝τγ−χδ=τγ−2χ3−χ,(51)E_\gamma\propto\tau_\gamma^{-\chi\delta}=\tau_\gamma^{-\frac{2\chi}{3-\chi}}, \tag*{(51)}
Lγ∝τγ−δ(χ+1)=τγ−2(χ+1)3−χ,(52)L_\gamma\propto\tau_\gamma^{-\delta(\chi+1)}=\tau_\gamma^{-\frac{2(\chi+1)}{3-\chi}}, \tag*{(52)}

where

δ≡2γ−12−γ=23−χ>0.(53)\delta\equiv2\frac{\gamma-1}{2-\gamma}=\frac{2}{3-\chi}>0. \tag*{(53)}

These are consistent with correlations (47), (48) and (49), and indeed Eγ∝LγτγE_{\gamma} \propto L_{\gamma}\tau_{\gamma} as it should be. Three anti-correlations Tγ−τγT_{\gamma}-\tau_{\gamma}, Eγ−τγE_{\gamma}-\tau_{\gamma} and Lγ−τγL_{\gamma}-\tau_{\gamma} coherently reflect the time-scale natures of gravo-thermal dynamics for GRB energetics.

Via the sound velocity (vsc)2(v_{\mathrm{s}}^{c})^{2} (26) at the core center, the maximal photon-pair sphere temperature Tγmax⁡∝(ρc)γ−1T_{\gamma}^{\max} \propto(\rho_{\mathrm{c}})^{\gamma-1} (37). Its dependence on the core center density ρc\rho_{\mathrm{c}} is in the same way as the mean temperature ⟨Tγ⟩∝(ρc)γ−1\langle T_{\gamma}\rangle\propto(\rho_{\mathrm{c}})^{\gamma-1} (44), and Tγmax⁡≈6.87⟨Tγ⟩T_{\gamma}^{\max} \approx6.87\langle T_{\gamma}\rangle. Therefore the correlations between Tγmax⁡T_{\gamma}^{\max} and other physical quantities can be obtained by substituting Tγmax⁡T_{\gamma}^{\max} for ⟨Tγ⟩\langle T_{\gamma}\rangle in Eqs. (47), (48) and (50). These could be of some interests. Because the maximal photon-pair sphere temperature Tγmax⁡T_{\gamma}^{\max} might be related to the high-energy threshold of GRB photons.

The theoretical correlations (47), (48) and (49), anti-correlations (50), (51) and (52) are not completely independent each other. However they base on only one free parameter χ∼O(1)\chi\sim O(1). They should receive corrections from the cosmological redshift zz, Eγ→Eγ/(1+z)E_{\gamma} \to E_{\gamma}/(1+z), ⟨Tγ⟩→⟨Tγ⟩/(1+z)\langle T_{\gamma}\rangle\to\langle T_{\gamma}\rangle/(1+z), τγ→τγ(1+z)\tau_{\gamma} \to\tau_{\gamma}(1+z) and Lγ→LγL_{\gamma} \to L_{\gamma}.

Possible connections to GRB observations

The theoretical correlation (47) seems to be the empirical Amati/Yonetoku relation Eiso∝Ep2E_{\mathrm{iso}} \propto E_{\mathrm{p}}^{2} in GRBs [66, 67], if we identify the photon-pair sphere energy EγE_{\gamma} and mean energy ⟨Tγ⟩\langle T_{\gamma}\rangle to the observed total isotropic energy EisoE_{\mathrm{iso}} and peak energy EpE_{\mathrm{p}}, or νγmax⁡\nu_{\gamma}^{\max} at which the maximum of photon energy spectrum νFν\nu F_{\nu} locates. However, we cannot simply make such identification for the reasons that the photon-pair sphere undergoes complex processes up to the transparency at which it becomes an observably relevant photosphere. One of reasons is that the peak energy EpE_{\mathrm{p}} value sensitively depends on the photon-pair sphere baryon loading, see for example, Refs. [63, 64, 68, 69]. We attempt to give a general discussion on the possible connections between theoretical correlations (7.2-7.8) of different photon-pair spheres and observational correlations of different GRB sources.

The photon-pair spheres provide the necessary energy budgets for GRB events. Suppose that each photon-pair sphere created by a gravitational collapse process corresponds to a GRB event/source observed. As aforementioned at the beginning of the section, a photon-pair sphere (initial state) undergoes complex (intermediate processes) to a (final state) of GRB phenomena observed. The photon-pair sphere quantities TγT_{\gamma}, EγE_{\gamma}, LγL_{\gamma} and RγR_{\gamma} are not exactly the same as observed GRB event’s mean energy, total energy, total luminosity, and time duration. Therefore, the correlations (7.2-7.8) cannot be directly examined by observed GRB events. However, photon-pair spheres’ overall quantities (Tγ,Eγ,Lγ,Rγ)(T_{\gamma}, E_{\gamma}, L_{\gamma}, R_{\gamma}) and basic relations (7.2-7.8) must imprint themselves in GRB data measured. Though the intermediate processes from a photon-pair sphere to an observed GRB source are complex, they are randomly different from one GRB source to other. Such randomness implies that the data of GRB events relevant to overall photon-pair sphere quantities should scatter around the basic relations (7.2-7.8) if these scaling relations truly reflect the universal natures of centre engines for GRB energetics. The more GRB events are taken into account, the more statistically confident level will be achieved on the validity of the basic relations (7.2-7.8) of photon-pair spheres. However, these are very general discussions. The relevant GRB phase identification, spectrum and event selection, elaborate data analysis are required to give conclusions. These are subject to future studies. If these theoretical correlations and scaling laws are correct and verified, GRB sources can be considered as standard candles for determining cosmological distance.

Thermodynamic of photon-pair sphere formation

It is necessary to study the thermodynamic of photon-pair sphere formation in gravitation collapses. It gives further insight into the dynamics of baryon relaxation (virial theorem) and photon-pair sphere formation in the gravo-thermal dynamics during gravitational collapses. It is very different from the hydrodynamical evolution of the photon-pair sphere.

Negative pressure and gravitational energy gain

The first thermodynamics law for the adiabatic transformation of the system, in which the particle number changes in time, is given by [70, 71],

dQ=d(ϱV)+PdV−ϱ+Pn~d(n~V),dQ=0.(54)dQ = d(\varrho V) + \mathcal{P}dV - \frac{\varrho+ \mathcal{P}}{\tilde{n}}d(\tilde{n}V), \qquad dQ = 0. \tag*{(54)}

The system is of the volume VV, the particle number density n~\tilde{n}, usual internal energy density ϱ\varrho and pressure P\mathcal{P}. In Eq. (54), the third term of the negative sign represents the system gains energy. It is due to the change in the particle number n~V\tilde{n}V. The thermal pressure P\mathcal{P} is determined by the energy production dϱd\varrho and particle production dn~d\tilde{n}. Equation (54) is equivalent to dϱ=(ϱ+P)dn~/n~d\varrho= (\varrho+ \mathcal{P})d\tilde{n}/\tilde{n} or P=(n~dϱ−ϱdn~)/dn~\mathcal{P} = (\tilde{n}d\varrho- \varrho d\tilde{n})/d\tilde{n}.

As the time-scale hierarchy (20) discussed in § 4, the macroscopic gravitational collapse and hydrodynamic processes are approximately adiabatic, w.r.t. the microscopic processes for creation and thermalization of particle energy and the number distributions. We apply the thermodynamics law (8.1) to the system that undergoes gravitational collapse and photon-pair sphere formation. The self-gravitating system contains (i) the baryon core of density nn and conserved baryon number NN; (ii) the photon-pair sphere of density nγn_{\gamma} and increasing photon number NγN_{\gamma}. The photon production is caused by hadron collisions, consuming the hadron “heat” energy dFdF (3). The total internal energy density ϱ=F/V+ργ\varrho= F/V + \rho_{\gamma} and pressure P=p+pγ\mathcal{P} = p + p_{\gamma}. The photon-pair sphere is opaque, and no heat energy is transferred outside the system dQ=0dQ = 0. Considering the first thermodynamics law in the presence of gravitational potential energy, see for example [72], we generalise the law (8.1) to

dQ=d(ϱV)+PdV−ργ+pγnγd(nγV)+dU,dQ=0.(55)dQ = d(\varrho V) + \mathcal{P}dV - \frac{\rho_{\gamma} + p_{\gamma}}{n_{\gamma}}d(n_{\gamma}V) + dU, \qquad dQ = 0. \tag*{(55)}

This is the total energy conservation of the system. The baryon core and photon-pair sphere exchange heat energy. This can be seen by rewriting Eq. (55) as

−d(ϱV)−p dV−dU=d(ργV)+pγdV−ργ+pγnγd(nγV).(56)-d(\varrho V) - p\,dV - dU = d(\rho_{\gamma}V) + p_{\gamma}dV - \frac{\rho_{\gamma} + p_{\gamma}}{n_{\gamma}}d(n_{\gamma}V). \tag*{(56)}

The left-handed side indicates the hadron collision energy pumped into the photon-pair sphere. The right-handed side can be effectively rewritten as d(ργV)+(pγ+pn)dVd(\rho_\gamma V) + (p_\gamma+ p_n)dV with a negative pressure pnp_n defined as

pn≡−ργ+pγnγd(nγV)dV<−(ργ+pγ)=−4pγ,(57)p_n \equiv-\frac{\rho_\gamma+ p_\gamma}{n_\gamma}\frac{d(n_\gamma V)}{dV} < -(\rho_\gamma+ p_\gamma) = -4p_\gamma, \tag*{(57)}

where photon production leads to d(nγV)>0d(n_\gamma V) > 0 and dnγ>0dn_\gamma> 0.

In contrast with the normal positive photon pressure pγp_\gamma, negative pressure pnp_n is in energetic favor of gravitational collapse. The total effective photon pressure (pγ+pn)<−3pγ(p_\gamma+ p_n) < -3p_\gamma is negative. Therefore, the photon-pair sphere creation of increasing photon number density dnγ>0dn_\gamma> 0 is energetically favourable in gravitational collapse. It gains energy from the hadron collisional energy, which comes from the gravitational potential energy. This result indicates that the total effective heat function of the photon-pair sphere hγeff≡hγ+pn=ργ+pγ+pnh^{\rm eff}_\gamma\equiv h_\gamma+ p_n = \rho_\gamma+ p_\gamma+ p_n can be negative, favouring gravitational collapse rather than positively repelling as usually expected. However, when the total photon number stops increasing d(nγV)=0d(n_\gamma V) = 0, the photon-pair sphere becomes a normal relativistic fluid of positive pressure pγ=ργ/3p_\gamma= \rho_\gamma/3, pushing outwardly against gravitational attraction. In this article, we do not consider these photon-pair sphere effects on homologous collapse dynamics since the photon-pair sphere energy density ργ\rho_\gamma is much smaller than the baryon core energy density.

Entropy increases in particle relaxation and production

We turn now to the second law of thermodynamics. To evaluate the entropy flow and the entropy production, one starts from the total differential of the entropy SS [70, 71],

TdS=d(ρV)+PdV−μd(n~V),(58)T dS = d(\rho V) + P dV - \mu d(\tilde{n}V), \tag*{(58)}

where TT and n~μ=ρ+P−TS/V\tilde{n}\mu= \rho+ P - TS/V are the temperature and chemical potential respectively. Applying the total differential of entropy (58) to the self-gravitating system of the baryon core and photon-pair sphere, we have,

TdS+TγdSγ=d(ρV)+pdV+d(ργV)+pγdV−μγd(nγV),(59)T dS + T_\gamma dS_\gamma= d(\rho V) + p dV + d(\rho_\gamma V) + p_\gamma dV - \mu_\gamma d(n_\gamma V), \tag*{(59)}

where TT and SS are baryon core temperature and entropy, TγT_\gamma and SγS_\gamma are photon-pair sphere temperature and entropy. The photon-pair sphere chemical potential μγ\mu_\gamma is

μγ=nγ−1(ργ+pγ−TγSγ/V).(60)\mu_\gamma= n_\gamma^{-1}\left(\rho_\gamma+ p_\gamma- T_\gamma S_\gamma/V\right). \tag*{(60)}

Substituting the first law (56) to the total differential of entropy (59), we obtain the total entropy increase

TdS+TγdSγ=−dU+TγSγnγVd(nγV)>0,(61)T dS + T_\gamma dS_\gamma= -dU + \frac{T_\gamma S_\gamma}{n_\gamma V}d(n_\gamma V) > 0, \tag*{(61)}

since −dU>0-dU > 0 and d(nγV)>0d(n_\gamma V) > 0. Assuming the baryon entropy TdS=−dUT dS = -dU purely comes from gravitation energy conversion, we have dSγ=Sγd(nγV)/nγVdS_\gamma= S_\gamma d(n_\gamma V)/n_\gamma V. This leads Sγ∝nγVS_{\gamma} \propto n_{\gamma} V, namely photon entropy produced is proportional to photon number produced.

We thus conclude that in gravitational collapses, the processes of baryon relaxation and photon-pair sphere formation are energetically and entropically favourable.

Conclusion and remarks

Using a simplified model describing homologous gravitational collapses of massive and dense stellar baryon cores, we present a preliminary understanding of how and why gravo-thermal catastrophe occurs in gravitational collapses, converting gravitational potential energy to observable photon energy. Such gravo-thermal dynamics attributes to two aspects. (i) From self-gravitating core potential energy, baryons gain their heat energy via collisional relaxation. We adopt the virial theorem to approximately describes this process. (ii) Via baryon collisions, photons are produced and gain their energy from baryons’ heat energy. We approximately calculate this process by using the photon production by heavy-ion collisions. The vast difference between macroscopic and microscopic time scales, i.e., the time scale hierarchy (20), is a priori the prerequisite for using semi-analytical analyses at the qualitative level. The obtained physical results need verifications for theoretical self-consistencies a posteriori and compared with observational data. As a result, we show that a photon-pair sphere formation process is energetically and entropically favourable. Such created photon-pair spheres possess fundamental physical quantities, i.e., size, total energy, energy and number densities that possibly qualitatively account for the main energetic features of GRB progenitors. All these quantities uniquely depend on the baryon core centre density ρc(t)\rho_c(t) (46), which is determined by homologous core mass MM and radius rsr_s, as well as the eigenvalue (γ,λm)(\gamma,\lambda_m) of homologous configurations. These configurations represent different GRB sources (events). There are two basic parameters in the baryon core EoS (4): the averaged thermal index 1<γ<4/31 < \gamma< 4/3 and maximal core central density ρcmax⁡(γ,κ)≳ρ0\rho_c^{\max}(\gamma,\kappa) \gtrsim\rho_0 (25). Eliminating the ρc(t)\rho_c(t)-dependence in these physical quantities, we obtain intrinsic correlations (universal scaling laws) among them, in terms of only one parameter χ=χ(γ)∼O(1)\chi=\chi(\gamma)\sim O(1). These theoretical correlations (scaling laws) and their scaling indices must confront observational data.

In reality, the gravo-thermal dynamics for stellar core collapse and photon-pair sphere formation must be very complex. There are not only violent hadron collisions and photon productions, but also violently strong electromagnetic field fluctuations, plasma oscillations, and hadron-quark phase transition in microscopic scales. As a consequence, the thermal index γ\gamma in the effective EoS (4) should be a function of space and time. Such γ\gamma-inhomogeneity should cause sound velocity (24) variation and shock wave occurrence, impacting on homologous collapse and photon-pair sphere formation. Indeed, the macroscopic hydrodynamics of baryon core and photon-pair sphere, on the other hand, play important roles in the gravo-thermal dynamics. Due to the vast time scale hierarchy (20), it is very inviting to adopt analytical approaches to microscopic processes and numerical simulation algorithms for macroscopic processes, to give a quantitative study of the gravo-thermal dynamics in connection with GRB observations.

We end this article by making some remarks on possible relevant issues of neutrino bursts, high-energy photons, cosmic rays and high-frequency gravitation wave emissions. In the photon-pair sphere, the electron-positron pair annihilation e++e−→ν+νˉe^{+}+e^{-}\rightarrow\nu+\bar{\nu} is the dominant neutrino production, and the neutrino opacity is mainly due to the scattering ν+e±→ν+e±\nu+e^{\pm}\rightarrow\nu+e^{\pm}. If neutrinos are trapped inside the photon-pair sphere, the neutrino mean energy ⟨Eν⟩\langle E_{\nu}\rangle is about Te+e−≈TγT_{e^{+}e^{-}}\approx T_{\gamma}. At decoupling bursts, neutrino sphere total energy Etotν=3.1×1051 erg[Eγ52Rγ6.5]11/16E_{\mathrm{tot}}^{\nu}=3.1\times10^{51}\,\mathrm{erg}[E_{\gamma52}R_{\gamma6.5}]^{11/16} and mean energy ⟨Eν⟩=56 MeV×[Eγ52]1/4[Rγ6.5]−3/4\langle E_{\nu}\rangle=56\,\mathrm{MeV}\times[E_{\gamma52}]^{1/4}[R_{\gamma6.5}]^{-3/4} [73], where Eγ52=Eγ/1052 ergE_{\gamma52}=E_{\gamma}/10^{52}\,\mathrm{erg} and Rγ6.5=Rγ/106.5 cmR_{\gamma6.5}=R_{\gamma}/10^{6.5}\,\mathrm{cm}. They are relevant for observations and should follow the same scaling laws discussed in § 7.2. If neutrinos are not trapped, neutrino continuous emission and cooling processes occur, which may prevent the photon-pair sphere from forming. This does not seem to be the case. The reasons are that (i) electron-positron (e+e−e^{+}e^{-}) plasma density and size are large enough, see Figure 5, to trap neutrinos; (ii) the hadronic photon production rate (9) is fast enough, namely, its time scale (12) is shorter than the time scale (13) of e+e−e^{+}e^{-} pair production. Moreover, due to its weak interaction nature, the νˉν\bar{\nu}\nu production time scale is longer than e+e−e^{+}e^{-} pair production. However, these reasons require a quantitative analysis based on the time scale hierarchy (20) and the time scale of photon-pair sphere hydrodynamical expansion. It is worthwhile to mention that in the photon-pair sphere, hot and dense photon-electron-positron plasma modes emit high-frequency (ω∼Tγ\omega\sim T_{\gamma}) gravitational wave [74, 75].

Last, but certainly not least, we discuss the possibilities for the continuous emissions of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays (protons), ultra-high-energy photons and neutrinos from the photon-pair sphere. Due to the gravitational attraction and hydrodynamical expulsion, the photon-pair sphere is split into two parts. The inner part of the energy Eγin≲Eγ/2E_{\gamma}^{\mathrm{in}}\lesssim E_{\gamma}/2 falls inward, while its outer part expands outward, and the separatrix radius locates at Rsep≈4GMR_{\mathrm{sep}}\approx4GM [65]. As mentioned, the expanding outer part leads to complex GRB phenomena. While the falling inner part takes a long time to trap onto the horizon R+=2GMR_{+}=2GM because of the general relativity effect. The inner part energy density ργ∼Tγ4>me4\rho_{\gamma}\sim T_{\gamma}^{4}>m_{e}^{4} indicates violent fluctuating electromagnetic fields E~m>Ec=Bc=me2/e\widetilde{E}_{m}>E_{c}=B_{c}=m_{e}^{2}/e. The fields possibly accelerate protons to ultra high energies E≈eE~mℓ\mathcal{E}\approx e\widetilde{E}_{m}\ell, up to GeV, TeV, PeV, EeV and 1021 eV10^{21}\,\mathrm{eV}, in small lengths ℓ<(E/me)λe\ell<(\mathcal{E}/m_{e})\lambda_{e} and times τ<(E/me)τe\tau<(\mathcal{E}/m_{e})\tau_{e}, where the Compton length λe∼10−11 cm\lambda_{e}\sim10^{-11}\,\mathrm{cm} and time τe∼10−21 sec\tau_{e}\sim10^{-21}\,\mathrm{sec}. These high-energy protons can be candidates of high-energy cosmic rays. They produce high-energy photons via possible QED processes by interacting with charge particles and external classical magnetic fields. They produce high-energy neutrinos via proton-proton collisions. The inner part size and optical depth are much smaller than the outer part. The inner part activities of releasing particles and energy are continuous, in contrast to the outer part decoupling bursts. It may account for the high-energy cutoff power-law spectrum of GRBs. The inner part activities can be observed after the outer part becomes transparent. All these speculations need further studies.

Acknowledgment

The author thanks Professor Ruffini and ICRANet members for many discussions on GRB physics and phenomena.

Appendix: the time evolutions of homologous profiles

For readers’ convenience, we show in Figure 7 the time evolutions of homologous profiles of baryon core density, photon-pair sphere temperature, energy and number densities. These homologous profiles do not change their shapes in time. However, their amplitudes change greatly in time as the gravitational collapse process proceeds. Note that the homologous core radius rsr_s and photon-pair sphere radius rγr_\gamma are independent of the collapsing time tt. They depend on the eigenvalue (γ,λm)(\gamma, \lambda_m), core centre mass ρc\rho_c and homologous core mass MM, see Eq. (31). Moreover, Figure 7 gives us some intuitive ideas about how these homologous profiles smoothly evolving and varying in macroscopic time and length scale. Whereas the microscopic processes of baryon collisional relaxation, photon production and thermalisation violently take place in tiny spacetime shells of width τmicro\tau_{\mathrm{micro}} and ℓmicro≈cτmicro\ell_{\mathrm{micro}} \approx c\tau_{\mathrm{micro}}.

References

  1. [1]T. Piran, The physics of gamma-ray bursts, Reviews of Modern Physics 76 (2004) 1143 [astro-ph/0405503].DOI
  2. [2]P. Mészáros, Gamma-ray bursts, Reports on Progress in Physics 69 (2006) 2259 [astro-ph/0605208].
  3. [3]E. Berger, Short-Duration Gamma-Ray Bursts, Annual Review of Astron and Astrophys 52 (2014) 43 [1311.2603].DOI
  4. [4]P. D’Avanzo, Short gamma-ray bursts: A review, Journal of High Energy Astrophysics 7 (2015) 73.DOI
  5. [5]P. Kumar and B. Zhang, The physics of gamma-ray bursts & relativistic jets, Physics Reports 561 (2015) 1 [1410.0679].DOI
  6. [6]B. Zhang, The Physics of Gamma-Ray Bursts. Cambridge University Press, 2018, 10.1017/9781139226530.
  7. [7]R. Ruffini, R. Moradi, J. A. Rueda, L. Becerra, C. L. Bianco, C. Cherubini et al., On the gev emission of the type i bdhn grb 130427a, The Astrophysical Journal 886 (2019) 82 [1812.00354].DOI
  8. [8]J. A. Rueda, R. Ruffini and Y. Wang, Induced Gravitational Collapse, Binary-Driven Hypernovae, Long Gamma-ray Bursts and Their Connection with Short Gamma-ray Bursts, Universe 5 (2019) 110 [1905.06050].DOI
  9. [9]R. Ruffini, R. Moradi, J. A. Rueda, L. Li, N. Sahakyan, Y. C. Chen et al., The morphology of the X-ray afterglows and of the jetted GeV emission in long GRBs, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 504 (2021) 5301 [2103.09142].DOI
  10. [10]S. E. Woosley, Gamma-Ray Bursts from Stellar Mass Accretion Disks around Black Holes, The Astrophysical Journal 405 (1993) 273.DOI
  11. [11]C. L. Fryer and S. E. Woosley, Helium Star/Black Hole Mergers: A New Gamma-Ray Burst Model, The Astrophysical Journal Letters 502 (1998) L9 [astro-ph/9804167].DOI
  12. [12]S. R. Kulkarni, D. A. Frail, M. H. Wieringa, R. D. Ekers, E. M. Sadler, R. M. Wark et al., Radio emission from the unusual supernova 1998bw and its association with the γ-ray burst of 25 April 1998, Nature 395 (1998) 663.DOI
  13. [13]A. I. MacFadyen and S. E. Woosley, Collapsars: Gamma-Ray Bursts and Explosions in “Failed Supernovae”, The Astrophysical Journal 524 (1999) 262 [astro-ph/9810274].DOI
  14. [14]G. Preparata, R. Ruffini and S-S. Xue, The dyadosphere of black holes and gamma-ray bursts, Astron. Astrophys. 338 (1998) L87 [astro-ph/9810182].arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9810182
  15. [15]G. Preparata, R. Ruffini and S-S. Xue, On the dyadosphere of black holes, J. Korean Phys. Soc. 42 (2003) S99 [astro-ph/0204080].arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0204080
  16. [16]R. Ruffini and S-S. Xue, Dyadosphere formed in gravitational collapse, AIP Conf. Proc. 1059 (2008) 72 [0810.1438].DOI
  17. [17]R. Ruffini, G. Vereshchagin and S-S. Xue, Electron-positron pairs in physics and astrophysics: from heavy nuclei to black holes, Phys. Rept. 487 (2010) 1 [0910.0974].DOI
  18. [18]W.-B. Han, R. Ruffini and S-S. Xue, Electron and positron pair production of compact stars, Phys. Rev. D 86 (2012) 084004 [1110.0700].DOI
  19. [19]R. Ruffini and S-S. Xue, Gravitational and electric energies in the collapse of a spherical thin-shell capacitor, Phys. Lett. A 377 (2013) 2450 [1302.5356].DOI
  20. [20]J. S. Bloom, S. R. Kulkarni and S. G. Djorgovski, The Observed Offset Distribution of Gamma-Ray Bursts from Their Host Galaxies: A Robust Clue to the Nature of the Progenitors, The Astronomical Journal 123 (2002) 1111 [astro-ph/0010176].DOI
  21. [21]P. A. Crowther, Physical Properties of Wolf-Rayet Stars, Annual Review of Astron and Astrophys 45 (2007) 177 [astro-ph/0610356].DOI
  22. [22]S. E. Woosley and A. Heger, The Progenitor Stars of Gamma-Ray Bursts, The Astrophysical Journal 637 (2006) 914 [astro-ph/0508175].DOI
  23. [23]J. P. U. Fynbo, D. Watson, C. C. Thöne, J. Sollerman, J. S. Bloom, T. M. Davis et al., No supernova associated with two long-duration γ-ray bursts, Nature 444 (2006) 1047 [astro-ph/0608313].
  24. [24]R. Perna, D. Lazzati and B. Giacomazzo, Short Gamma-Ray Bursts from the Merger of Two Black Holes, The Astrophysical Journal Letters 821 (2016) L18 [1602.05140].DOI
  25. [25]Z.-P. Jin, X. Li, H. Wang, Y.-Z. Wang, H.-N. He, Q. Yuan et al., Short GRBs: Opening Angles, Local Neutron Star Merger Rate, and Off-axis Events for GRB/GW Association, The Astrophysical Journal 857 (2018) 128 [1708.07008].DOI
  26. [26]R. Ruffini, J. D. Salmonson, J. R. Wilson and S. S. Xue, On the pair-electromagnetic pulse from an electromagnetic black hole surrounded by a baryonic remnant, Astronomy and Astrophysics 359 (2000) 855 [astro-ph/0004257].DOI
  27. [27]P. Mészáros and M. J. Rees, Collapsar Jets, Bubbles, and Fe Lines, The Astrophysical Journal Letters 556 (2001) L37 [astro-ph/0104402].DOI
  28. [28]A. de Rújula, GRBs in the cannonball model: an overview, in New Views on Microquasars, P. Durouchoux, Y. Fuchs and J. Rodriguez, eds., p. 185, Jan., 2003, astro-ph/0207033.
  29. [29]Y. Wang, Y.-Z. Fan and D.-M. Wei, Are GRB 090423 and Similar Bursts due to Superconducting Cosmic Strings?, Physical Review Letters 106 (2011) 259001 [1105.5147].DOI
  30. [30]D. Nakauchi, K. Kashiyama, Y. Suwa and T. Nakamura, Blue Supergiant Model for Ultra-long Gamma-Ray Burst with Superluminous-supernova-like Bump, The Astrophysical Journal 778 (2013) 67 [1307.5061].DOI
  31. [31]C. L. Fryer, J. A. Rueda and R. Ruffini, Hypercritical Accretion, Induced Gravitational Collapse, and Binary-Driven Hypernovae, The Astrophysical Journal Letters 793 (2014) L36 [1409.1473].DOI
  32. [32]R. Ruffini, J. A. Rueda, M. Muccino, Y. Aimuratov, L. M. Becerra, C. L. Bianco et al., On the Classification of GRBs and Their Occurrence Rates, The Astrophysical Journal 832 (2016) 136 [1602.02732].DOI
  33. [33]T. Hayakawa and K. Maeda, A Collapsar Model with Disk Wind: Implications for Supernovae Associated with Gamma-Ray Bursts, The Astrophysical Journal 854 (2018) 43 [1801.09681].DOI
  34. [34]L. Li, X.-F. Wu, W.-H. Lei, Z.-G. Dai, E.-W. Liang and F. Ryde, Constraining the type of central engine of grbs with swift data, Astrophys. J. Suppl. 236 (2018) 26 [1712.09390].DOI
  35. [35]D. Lynden-Bell, Statistical mechanics of violent relaxation in stellar systems, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 136 (1967) 101.
  36. [36]D. Lynden-Bell and R. Wood, The gravo-thermal catastrophe in isothermal spheres and the onset of red-giant structure for stellar systems, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 138 (1968) 495.DOI
  37. [37]T. Padmanabhan, Antonov instability and gravothermal catastrophe—revisited, The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 71 (1989) 651.DOI
  38. [38]P. H. Chavanis, Gravitational instability of finite isothermal spheres in general relativity: analogy with neutron stars, Astronomy and Astrophysics 381 (2002) 709 [astro-ph/0108230].DOI
  39. [39]P. H. Chavanis, Gravitational instability of isothermal and polytropic spheres, Astronomy and Astrophysics 401 (2003) 15 [astro-ph/0207080].DOI
  40. [40]M. C. Sormani and G. Bertin, Gravothermal catastrophe: The dynamical stability of a fluid model, Astronomy and Astrophysics 552 (2013) A37 [1301.6038].DOI
  41. [41]Z. Roupas, Relativistic gravothermal instabilities, Class. Quant. Grav. 32 (2015) 135023 [1411.4267].DOI
  42. [42]Z. Roupas, B. Kocsis and S. Tremaine, Isotropic-nematic phase transitions in gravitational systems, The Astrophysical Journal 842 (2017) 90 [1701.03271].DOI
  43. [43]Á. Takács and B. Kocsis, Isotropic-nematic phase transitions in gravitational systems: ii. higher order multipoles, The Astrophysical Journal 856 (2018) 113 [1712.04449].DOI
  44. [44]P. Dutta and P. K. Karmakar, Dynamics of gravoviscothermal instability in complex astrofluids amid cosmic radiative moderation effects, Astrophysics and Space Science 364 (2019) 217.DOI
  45. [45]S. Turbide, R. Rapp and C. Gale, Hadronic production of thermal photons, Phys. Rev. C 69 (2004) 014903 [hep-ph/0308085].DOI
  46. [46]J. I. Kapusta, P. Lichard and D. Seibert, High-energy photons from quark - gluon plasma versus hot hadronic gas, Phys. Rev. D 44 (1991) 2774.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10014167
  47. [47]J. I. Kapusta, P. Lichard and D. Seibert, High-energy photons from quark - gluon plasma versus hot hadronic gas, Nucl. Phys. A 544 (1992) 485C.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10014167
  48. [48]P. B. Arnold, G. D. Moore and L. G. Yaffe, Photon emission from quark gluon plasma: Complete leading order results, JHEP 12 (2001) 009 [hep-ph/0111107].DOI
  49. [49]C. Gale, Y. Hidaka, S. Jeon, S. Lin, J.-F. Paquet, R. D. Pisarski et al., Production and elliptic flow of dileptons and photons in a matrix model of the quark-gluon plasma, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114 (2015) 072301 [1409.4778].pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25763954
  50. [50]Y. Hidaka, S. Lin, R. D. Pisarski and D. Satow, Dilepton and photon production in the presence of a nontrivial polyakov loop, JHEP 10 (2015) 005 [1504.01770].DOI
  51. [51]P. Goldreich and S. V. Weber, Homologously collapsing stellar cores, Astrophysical Journal 238 (1980) 991.DOI
  52. [52]G. Vujanovic, C. Young, B. Schenke, R. Rapp, S. Jeon and C. Gale, Dilepton emission in high-energy heavy-ion collisions with viscous hydrodynamics, Phys. Rev. C 89 (2014) 034904 [1312.0676].DOI
  53. [53]J. K. Daugherty and I. Lerche, On pair production in intense electromagnetic fields occurring in astrophysical situations, Astrophys. and Space Sci. 38 (1975) 437.DOI
  54. [54]J. K. Daugherty and A. K. Harding, Pair production in superstrong magnetic fields., Astrophysical Journal 273 (1983) 761.DOI
  55. [55]K. A. van Riper and J. M. Lattimer, Stellar core collapse. i - infall epoch, Astrophys. J. 249 (1981) 270.DOI
  56. [56]Y. Cao and Y.-Q. Lou, Perturbation analysis of a general polytropic homologously collapsing stellar core, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 400 (2009) 2032 [0908.3225].DOI
  57. [57]Y.-Q. Lou and B. Lian, Three-dimensional hydrodynamic instabilities in stellar core collapses, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (2012) [1111.2935].DOI
  58. [58]D. Lynden-Bell, Homology in the evolution of cluster cores, cores, in dynamics of stellar systems, Proceedings from IAU Symposium no. 69, A. Hayli ed., Besançon, France, 9–13 September 1974. 69 (1974) 27.
  59. [59]S. L. Shapiro, The dissolution of globular clusters containing massive black holes., Astrophysical Journal 217 (1977) 281.DOI
  60. [60]P. Bedaque and A. W. Steiner, Sound velocity bound and neutron stars, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114 (2015) 031103 [1408.5116].DOI
  61. [61]R. Ruffini, L. Vitagliano and S. S. Xue, On plasma oscillations in strong electric fields, Phys.Lett. B559 (2003) 12-19 (2003) [astro-ph/0302549].DOI
  62. [62]J. Ehlers, General relativity and kinetic theory in general relativity and cosmology, Proceedings of cours 47 of the International School of Physics: Enrico Fermi, ed. Sachs, R.K. , Academic Press, New York. (1971) .
  63. [63]R. Ruffini, J. D. Salmonson, J. R. Wilson and S.-S. Xue, On the pair electromagnetic pulse of a black hole with electromagnetic structure, Astron. Astrophys. 350 (1999) 334 [astro-ph/9907030].arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9907030
  64. [64]R. Ruffini, J. D. Salmonson, J. R. Wilson and S.-S. Xue, On the pair-electromagnetic pulse from an electromagnetic black hole surrounded by a baryonic remnant, Astron. Astrophys. 359 (2000) 855 [astro-ph/0004257].DOI
  65. [65]R. Ruffini, L. Vitagliano and S.-S. Xue, On a separatrix in the gravitational collapse to an overcritical electromagnetic black hole, Phys. Lett. B 573 (2003) 33 [astro-ph/0309022].DOI
  66. [66]L. Amati, F. Frontera, M. Tavani, J. J. M. in’t Zand, A. Antonelli, E. Costa et al., Intrinsic spectra and energetics of bepposax gamma-ray bursts with known redshifts, Astronomy & Astrophysics 390 (2002) 81 [astro-ph/0205230].DOI
  67. [67]D. Yonetoku, T. Murakami, T. Nakamura, R. Yamazaki, A. K. Inoue and K. Ioka, Gamma-ray burst formation rates inferred from the spectral peak energy-peak luminosity relation, Astrophys. J. 609 (2004) 935 [astro-ph/0309217].
  68. [68]P. Mészáros and M. J. Rees, Steep slopes and preferred breaks in gamma-ray burst spectra: The role of photospheres and comptonization, The Astrophysical Journal 530 (2000) 292 [astro-ph/9908126].DOI
  69. [69]B. Zhang, Y. Wang and L. Li, Dissecting the energy budget of a gamma-ray burst fireball, Astrophys. J. Lett. 909 (2021) L3 [2102.04968].DOI
  70. [70]I. Prigogine, J. Geheniau, E. Gunzig and P. Nardone, Thermodynamics of cosmological matter creation, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 85 (1988) 7428.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16593986
  71. [71]I. Prigogine, J. Geheniau, E. Gunzig and P. Nardone, Thermodynamics and cosmology, General Relativity and Gravitation 21 (1989) 767.
  72. [72]F. O. Koenig, Note on thermodynamic equilibrium in the gravitational field, J. Phys. Chem. 40 (1936) 373.DOI
  73. [73]H. B. J. Koers and R. A. M. J. Wijers, The effect of neutrinos on the initial fireballs in gamma-ray bursts, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 364 (2005) 934 [astro-ph/0505533].DOI
  74. [74]S. Weinberg, Gravitation and Cosmology: Principles and Applications of the General Theory of Relativity. 1972.
  75. [75]W.-B. Han and S.-S. Xue, Electromagnetic and gravitational radiation from the coherent oscillation of electron-positron pairs and fields, Phys. Rev. D 89 (2014) 024008 [1307.6148].DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_2vxk976v
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents