betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Disorder-mediated linear and nonlinear magnetotransport in the charge-density-wave material Ta2NiSe7{\rm Ta_2NiSe_7 }

Abstract

We report disorder-mediated first-order linear and higher-order nonlinear (magneto-)transport of Ta2_2NiSe7_7 (TNS) in the charge-density-wave (CDW) regime. CDW transition temperature (TCDWT_{CDW}) and carrier density are proportional and inversely proportional to residual resistance ratio of samples, respectively. Such relation helps to understand the unique CDW order therein. High-TCDWT_{CDW} TNS exhibits negative first-harmonic magnetoresistance (MR1ω^{1ω}) under a magnetic field (BB) parallel to the direction of alternating current (IωI^ω), which may arise from the anomalous velocity induced by the Berry curvature of three-dimensional topological bands near the Fermi level. As TCDWT_{CDW} drops, a positive-to-negative MR1ω^{1ω} transition is observed with decreasing perpendicular BB, which is likely due to the contribution of Zeeman effect on current pathways in the disordered system. Moreover, interestingly, the second-harmonic nonlinear signals are suppressed, while the third-harmonic signals are significant and sensitive to both BB and TCDWT_{CDW}. Such observations, together with scaling analysis, suggest the quantum geometry quadrupole at play and the modulation of disorder on third-order nonlinearity. Our results pave an avenue for tailoring distinct-order magnetoresistive phases in disordered topological materials.

  • Email:

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

It is straightforward to detect a quadratic positive magnetoresistance (pMR) in most metals and semiconductors due to magnetic field (BB)-induced localization of electrons in cyclotron orbits [1, 2]. However, the magnitude of such pMR is always weak and hampers practical applications such as magnetic field sensing [3]. By contrast, diverse topological materials showcase exotic MR phenomena thanks to unique topological orders [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11], which helps to unveil fundamental physics and implements various functions for applications. Apart from nontrivial band topology, disorder induced by defects/impurities acts as a tuning knob for modulating the MR behaviors in such materials [13, 14] [12]. Control over the disorder is of great importance for elucidating and tailoring distinct magnetoresistive phases. Most recently, research interests have shifted to higher-order nonlinear transport in various materials [15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23], which is intimately linked to quantum geometry effects [24, 25, 26, 27]. However, it remains largely unexplored how disorder affects such nonlinear magnetotransport, especially the third-order nonlinearity.

Here, we present systematic magnetotransport study of ternary chalcogenides Ta2_2NiSe7_7 (TNS) featuring a variable CDW transition temperature (TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}). We unveil the relations among TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}, carrier density (nsn_{\mathrm{s}}), and residual resistance ratio (RRR) of samples, which help to understand the unique CDW order. Bulk TNS exhibits TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}-specific anisotropic first-harmonic MR (MR1ω^{1\omega}) behaviors, where the negative MR1ω^{1\omega} (nMR1ω^{1\omega}) is governed by different mechanisms. Moreover, the second-harmonic nonlinear signals are suppressed while the third-harmonic signals are prominent and of significant BB dependence, suggesting the quantum geometry quadrupole at play under inversion symmetry accompanied with other extrinsic contributions. Strikingly, the MR3ω^{3\omega} exhibits non-monotonic BB dependence and its amplitude varies one to three order(s) of magnitude with decreasing TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}, indicating the modulation of disorder on higher-order moments of quantum geometry and resultant nonlinear transport.

Transition metal ternary chalcogenides, Ta2_2NiSe7_7 (TNS), have long garnered much attention due to complex crystalline structure, controversial topological character, and peculiar CDW phase [28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40]. Overall, it is a layered material in a centered monoclinic space group (No. 12, C2/mC2/m), despite a staggered van der Waals gap normal to the bb-cc plane, as shown in Figure 1(a). Looking over each layer, it can be viewed as a quasi-1D system consisting of three types of atomic chains: one comes from the Ni atoms (marked by blue balls) in distorted octahedra (d-OCT) form and the others are double chains formed by Ta1 (red balls) and Ta2 (purple balls) atoms in bicapped trigonal prismatic (BTP) and octahedral (OCT) coordination, respectively. In such “2+1D” crystal, the predicted band topology is currently under dispute in either the CDW (T<TCDWT < T_{\mathrm{CDW}}) or the normal-state (T>TCDWT > T_{\mathrm{CDW}}) regime [35, 36, 37, 57, 58], and also incompatible with recent angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) results [38]. More prominently, bulk TNS hosts two distinct CDW wavevectors, q=(0,0.483,0)\mathbf{q} = (0,0.483,0) and 2q2\mathbf{q}, at which lattice distortion is manifested as transverse and longitudinal displacement of Ni/Se and Ta2 atoms, respectively [30, 31, 32, 33, 38]. However, the understanding of such unique CDW order and its origin remains elusive [33, 38, 39].

Image not extracted

Figure 1. First-harmonic transport properties of Ta2NiSe7\mathrm{Ta}_2\mathrm{NiSe}_7. (a) Crystal structure and device configuration of Ta2NiSe7\mathrm{Ta}_2\mathrm{NiSe}_7 (TNS) where a quasi-one-dimensional chain-like structure is along the bb axis, α=δ=90∘\alpha= \delta= 90^\circ and β=108.8∘\beta= 108.8^\circ. The alternating current (IωI^\omega) is applied along the bb axis, and the first-, second- and third-harmonic longitudinal (Vxx1,2,3ωV_{xx}^{1,2,3\omega}) and transverse (Vyx1,2,3ωV_{yx}^{1,2,3\omega}) voltages signals are simultaneously detected. (b) TT dependence of normalized longitudinal resistance Rxx∗R_{xx}^{*} and its derivative dRxx∗/dTdR_{xx}^{*}/dT of the sample S9. (c) dRxx∗/dTdR_{xx}^{*}/dT of seven samples versus TT. Gray arrows mark the CDW transition temperature TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}. (d) TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} and carrier density nsn_s (taken at 2 K) versus RRR. Filled circles and empty squares denote the data of TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} and nsn_s obtained from this work (S8, S11, S13, and S18) and former studies. The red and blue solid lines are linear fits to experimental data, respectively.

In our experiments, tens of TNS flakes are exfoliated from different batches of single crystals for transport measurements (Supplemental Material, Methods, Table S1, and Figs. S1-S4 [41]). The distinct-harmonic longitudinal (Rxx1,2,3ωR_{xx}^{1,2,3\omega}) and transverse (Ryx1,2,3ωR_{yx}^{1,2,3\omega}) resistance are obtained by measuring the corresponding voltages Vxx1,2,3ωV_{xx}^{1,2,3\omega} and Vyx1,2,3ωV_{yx}^{1,2,3\omega} driven by an alternating current (IωI^{\omega}) with the same frequency ω\omega. Figure 1(b) shows TT dependence of normalized first-harmonic resistance Rxx∗=Rxx1ω(T)/Rxx1ω(300 K)R_{xx}^{*}=R_{xx}^{1\omega}(T)/R_{xx}^{1\omega}(300\ \mathrm{K}) in a representative sample (S9). Upon cooling, the monotonically decreasing trend confirms its metallic nature, in agreement with the results reported in previous works [34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39]. Notably, a kink near 60.8 K signals the onset of CDW transition. We take the derivative of normalized resistance (dRxx∗/dTdR_{xx}^{*}/dT) and define TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} from the temperature point at which dRxx∗/dTdR_{xx}^{*}/dT reaches its dip. Figure 1(c) shows dRxx∗/dTdR_{xx}^{*}/dT of seven samples as a function of TT, where the dip moves towards the lower TT. We summarize the extracted TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} and nsn_s (Fig. S5 in Supplemental Material [41]) versus RRR=Rxx1ω(300 K)/Rxx1ω(2 K)\mathrm{RRR}=R_{xx}^{1\omega}(300\ \mathrm{K})/R_{xx}^{1\omega}(2\ \mathrm{K}), as plotted in Figure 1(d).

Notably, TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} and nsn_s are proportional and inversely proportional to RRR, respectively, indicating that the disorder boosts pp-type carrier doping and modulates the CDW transition in TNS. Such doping effect is unlikely associated with the CDW gap that typically varies with TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}, since the gap cannot be detected via ARPES measurement [38] and previous transport results show that the carrier density keeps constant around TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}[34]. Such doping effect is likely due to the presence of metal-atom vacancy defects, which always act as hole donors [59]. The modulation of TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} is similar to that observed in Nb-doped TNS, (Ta1−xNbx)2NiSe7(\mathrm{Ta}_{1-x}\mathrm{Nb}_{x})_{2}\mathrm{NiSe}_{7} [33], where the tuning mechanism is tied to the 2q2\mathbf{q} ordering at the Ta2 atoms instead of the primary q\mathbf{q} ordering at the Ni/Se sites. Given these facts, we infer that such linear relations originate from the presence of Ta2 (vacancy) defects. As RRR drops, the Ta2 vacancies accumulate and give rise to increasing pp-type carrier density. Meanwhile, they pose a marked impact on the 2q2\mathbf{q} ordering, resulting in the decrease of TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}. This speculation is supported by our X-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) results where the Ta-atom concentration in low- (high-) TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} samples is statistically less (more) than 20% (Fig. S3 in Supplemental Material [41]). All results highlight the crucial role of the 2q2\mathbf{q} ordering in the formation of CDW in TNS.

First-harmonic magnetotransport is investigated in high-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} samples. Figure 2(a,Figure 2b) shows the first-harmonic MR, MR1ω=[Rxx1ω(B)−Rxx1ω(0)]/Rxx1ω(0)×100%\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega} = [R_{xx}^{1\omega}(B) - R_{xx}^{1\omega}(0)]/R_{xx}^{1\omega}(0) \times100\%, of S1 (TCDW=67T_{\mathrm{CDW}} = 67 K, RRR = 5.3) as a function of BB applied with an out-of-plane polar angle θ=90∘\theta= 90^\circ and θ=0∘\theta= 0^\circ from the direction of alternating current (IωI^\omega) along the bb axis of the crystal at various TT, respectively. Clearly, the quadratic positive MR1ω\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega} (pMR1ω\mathrm{pMR}^{1\omega}) is observed under either B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} (i.e., B⊥bB \perp b) or B∥B_{\parallel} (i.e., B∥bB \parallel b) at T≥8T \ge8 K. However, the nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} occurs in a wide range of B∥B_{\parallel} at low TT. Among various mechanisms for such MR1ω\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega} behaviors, the anisotropic behavior first rules out the Zeeman effect on percolating current pathways in the disordered system [13], the Kondo effect [49, 50] or the 3D weak localization (WL) [51] as the possible origin, since the first two produce isotropic nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} while the last gives rise to the dominance (suppression) of nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} under B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} (B∥B_{\parallel}), all in stark contrast to our observations (Note 1 and Table S2 in Supplemental Material [41]). Moreover, possible external artifacts such as current jetting are carefully excluded [52] (Fig. S7 in Supplemental Material [41]). Indeed, such MR1ω\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega} behaviors are strongly reminiscent of those observed in topological semimetals and insulators due to chiral anomaly [6- 8] and Berry curvature effect [53, 60], respectively.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. First-harmonic magnetotransport properties in the high-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} TNS flakes. First-harmonic MR (MR1ω^{1\omega}) of S1 versus BB applied (a) perpendicular to the bb-cc plane (i.e., B⊥opB^{\mathrm{op}}_{\perp}) and (b) parallel to the bb axis (i.e., B∥B_{\parallel}) at a set of TT. First-harmonic longitudinal MR of S1 (c) and S4 (d) versus BB applied with the rotated angle θ\theta and φ\varphi from the direction of IωI^{\omega} (or the bb axis) out of and in the bb-cc plane, respectively. Clearly, the nMR1ω^{1\omega} relies on the BB components parallel to IωI^{\omega}.

To gain more insight into the band topology in the CDW regime, we perform full electronic simulations based on first-principles density functional theory (DFT) (Methods, Note 2 and Figs. S9, S10 in Supplemental Material [41]). Our theoretical calculations explicitly demonstrate that bulk TNS is a 3D topological insulator (TI) with Z4=3Z_{4}=3 while considering spin-orbit coupling (SOC) [55], consistent with that proposed in the normal state [58]. Interestingly, we find that the magnitude and tendency of nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} in S1 exactly coincide with that in the strong TI Bi2Se3\mathrm{Bi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{3} [60] (Fig. S8 in Supplemental Material [41]). The overlapped data are in quantitative agreement with the theoretical calculation taking into account the correction to magnetoconductivity from the Berry curvature [53]. Therefore, we attribute such nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} to the Berry-curvature-induced anomalous velocity and resulting enhancement of conductivity under B∥B_{\parallel}. To further elaborate on this point, angular dependence of MR1ω\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega} of S1 and S4 (TCDW=64T_{\mathrm{CDW}}=64 K, RRR = 4.38) is further investigated by rotating the sample out of [Figure 2(c)] and in [Figure 2(d)] the bb-cc plane with respect to applied BB, respectively. Notably, the total MR1ω\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega} at any angle can be quantitatively treated as a superposition of nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} and pMR1ω\mathrm{pMR}^{1\omega} components that depends exclusively on the parallel and perpendicular field components, respectively (Note 1 and Fig. S6 in Supplemental Material [41]). This excellent agreement with no free parameters provides robust, quantitative evidence that the nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} is indeed a function only of B∥B_{\parallel}. We remark that, despite the presence of nontrivial topology, the topological bands traverse the Fermi level, thus resulting in a metallic behavior.

We then turn to the first-harmonic magnetotransport in low-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} samples. Figure 3(a,Figure 3b) shows B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} and B∥B_{\parallel} dependence of MRxx1ω\mathrm{MR}_{xx}^{1\omega} in S17 (TCDW=50T_{\mathrm{CDW}}=50 K, RRR = 2.92), respectively. Similar nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} behavior is observed under B∥B_{\parallel} [Figure 3(b)], suggesting the Berry curvature contribution still at play. Whereas, an unexpected nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} occurs in a small range of B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} (<5<5 T) at T<8T<8 K [Figure 3(a)]. Such nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} behavior under B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} is more likely due to the Zeeman effect on percolating current pathways in such disordered bulk (referred to as disorder contribution to nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} below) [13], rather than 3D weak localization (WL) effect [51] (Fig. S11 in Supplemental Material [41]). To elucidate the MR1ωMR^{1\omega} behaviors in bulk TNS with different TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}, a circuit model is employed for phenomenological simulation, as illustrated in Figure 3(c). The equivalent circuit mimicking realistic system is comprised of two resistors (RpR_p and RnR_n) in series, where the total resistance is described as [61]:

Image not extracted

Figure 3. First-harmonic magnetotransport properties of the low-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} TNS flakes and phenomenological simulation using a reduced two-resistor model. (a,b) First-harmonic MR (MR1ω^{1\omega}) of S17 versus B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} and B∥B_{\parallel} at a set of TT, respectively. (c) Schematic of the two-resistor-in-series model. The normal regions in high- or low-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} samples behave as a resistor (RpR_p) contributing to the pMR under B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} (painted in pink) while acting as RnR_n leading to the nMR under B∥B_{\parallel} (light blue) thanks to Berry curvature effect. The disordered regions (dark blue) in low-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} samples always act as RnR_n contributing to the nMR. The pMR and nMR are illustrated using MR(B)=1+αB2\mathrm{MR}(B)=1+\alpha B^2 and MR(B)=1/(1+βB2)\mathrm{MR}(B)=1/(1+\beta B^2), respectively. For simulation, α=β=0.01\alpha=\beta=0.01. (d,e) TT dependence of the derived ratio for pMR (γ\gamma) and the nMR (1−γ1-\gamma) from the reduced model under B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} and B∥B_{\parallel} in S3 and S17, respectively. (f) θ\theta dependence of the derived ratio for pMR (γ\gamma) and the nMR (1−γ1-\gamma) in S1 and S10.

R(B)=Rp(B)+Rn(B)=R0[γ(1+αB2)+(1−γ)/(1+βB2)],(1)R(B) = R_p(B) + R_n(B) = R_0[\gamma(1 + \alpha B^2) + (1 - \gamma)/(1 + \beta B^2)], \tag*{(1)}

where R0R_0 is the measured resistance at zero field, α\alpha, β\beta and γ\gamma are fitting parameters. The first and second terms denote the positive and negative contributions to the total MR with a ratio of γ\gamma and 1−γ1-\gamma, respectively.

The MR1ωMR^{1\omega} behaviors in both high- and low-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} samples are well captured by using the phenomenological model, as shown in Figure 3(d-Figure 3f) (Figs. S12-S17 in Supplemental Material [41]). Figure 3(d,Figure 3e) plots TT dependence of the derived fitting parameters for the high-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} sample S3 (TCDW=65T_{\mathrm{CDW}} = 65 K, RRR = 4.29) and the low-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} one S17 under B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} and B∥B_{\parallel}, respectively. At low TT (<10< 10 K), the nMR1ωMR^{1\omega} component in S3 accounts for more than 80% under B∥B_{\parallel}, while it is negligible under B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} [Figure 3(d)], which is an indication of the nMR1ωMR^{1\omega} caused by the Berry curvature effect. As TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} (or RRR) drops, disorder-driven nMR1ωMR^{1\omega} component contributes to the first-order magnetotransport under B⊥opB_{\perp}^{\mathrm{op}} and reinforces the dominance of nMR1ωMR^{1\omega} under B∥B_{\parallel} [Figure 3(e)]. We further determine angle (θ\theta) dependence of the ratio of pMR to nMR at low TT. In the high-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} sample S1, the Berry-curvature-induced nMR1ωMR^{1\omega} significantly relies on the BB component parallel to IωI^\omega such that its ratio plummets and rapidly vanishes with increasing θ\theta [Figure 3(f), upper]. When the disorder contribution is involved, the nMR1ωMR^{1\omega} in the low-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} sample S10 (TCDW=55T_{\mathrm{CDW}} = 55 K, RRR = 2.44) survives at much larger θ\theta since the disorder contribution behaves in an isotropic fashion [Figure 3(f), lower].

Apart from the tunable first-order magnetotransport, bulk TNS exhibits distinct higher-order nonlinear (magneto-)transport behaviors in the CDW regime. After carefully excluding possible current heating effect (Fig. S18 in Supplemental Material [41]), we systematically investigate transport behaviors in distinct harmonics by injecting moderate IωI^\omega into different samples. Figure 4(a) plots distinct-harmonic longitudinal voltages Vxx1,2,3ωV_{xx}^{1,2,3\omega} in S8 (TCDW=62T_{\mathrm{CDW}} = 62 K, RRR = 5.25) as a function of IωI^\omega at T=2T = 2 K and B=0B = 0 T. Obviously, the trace of Vxx1ωV_{xx}^{1\omega} shows an excellent linearity, conforming to Ohm’s law under Iω≤1000I^\omega\le1000 μA. By contrast, Vxx2ωV_{xx}^{2\omega} and Vxx3ωV_{xx}^{3\omega} scale quadratically and cubically with IωI^\omega, which is a direct indication that the second- and third-order quantum nonlinearity occurs in bulk TNS. Note that the second-harmonic nonlinear signals are around twice lower than the third-harmonic ones. We further investigate B⊥opB_{\perp}^{op} dependence of Vxx1,2,3ωV_{xx}^{1,2,3\omega} in distinct-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} samples, as shown in Figure 4(b,Figure 4c). Remarkably, Vxx2ωV_{xx}^{2\omega} has a relatively small magnitude and varies slightly with B⊥opB_{\perp}^{op}, while Vxx3ωV_{xx}^{3\omega} is prominent and displays drastically different magnetic field dependence.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Higher-harmonic magnetotransport properties in TNS flakes. (a) Distinct-harmonic II-VV curves of S8 in the longitudinal direction under zero field at T=2T = 2 K. The solid curves indicate the linear, quadratic and cubic fits to experimental data, respectively. (b,c) BB dependence of Vxx1,2,3ωV_{xx}^{1,2,3\omega} (marked by blue, gray, purple curves, respectively) in S8 and S15 with Iω=500I^{\omega} = 500 μA and 70 μA at T=2T = 2 K, respectively. (d,e) Vxx3ω/(Vxx1ω)3V_{xx}^{3\omega}/(V_{xx}^{1\omega})^3 versus σ2\sigma^2 in S2 and S19, respectively. The circles represent experimental data. The solid lines are linear fits to the data from 4 K to (d) 6.6 K and (e) 11 K, respectively. The fitting parameters are: (d) p=−5.21×10−9p = -5.21 \times10^{-9} V−2^{-2}Ω2^2m2^2, q=4672q = 4672 V−2^{-2}; (e) p=−3.40×10−10p = -3.40 \times10^{-10} V−2^{-2}Ω2^2m2^2, q=688q = 688 V−2^{-2}. (f) BB dependence of MR1,2,3ω^{1,2,3\omega} (marked by blue, gray, purple curves, respectively) in S8 and S15 at T=2T = 2 K. (g) The maximum of MR1ω^{1\omega} (marked by purple circles) and MR3ω^{3\omega} (blue circles) data under various IωI^{\omega} within ±10 T at T=2T = 2 K versus TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}. The purple and blue lines indicate the exponential (MR3ω∝e−TCDW/T0^{3\omega} \propto e^{-T_{\mathrm{CDW}}/T_0}, with T0∼3.6T_0 \sim3.6 K) and the linear fits, respectively.

We here discuss the origin of such higher-order magnetotransport. The third-(second-) harmonic nonlinear signals are prominent (suppressed), indicating the dominance of third-order nonlinearity over second-order harmonics in bulk TNS where inversion symmetry is substantially retained. The scaling relation of third-order nonlinearity under time-reversal symmetry can be described as [21, 22] (Note 3 in Supplemental Material [41]):

Vxx3ω(Vxx1ω)3=pσxx2+q,(2)\frac{V_{xx}^{3\omega}}{\left(V_{xx}^{1\omega}\right)^3} = p\sigma_{xx}^{2} + q, \tag*{(2)}

where σxx\sigma_{xx} is first-harmonic longitudinal conductivity, the first and second terms on the right-hand side denote the Drude-like tensor and quantum metric quadrupole (QMQ) contributions, respectively. The fitting of Eq. (2) to the experimental data in the high- and low-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} samples, S2 (TCDW=66T_{\mathrm{CDW}} = 66 K, RRR = 3.7) and S19 (with no CDW transition), is plotted in Figure 4(d,Figure 4e), respectively. Clearly, the low-TT data (corresponding to the higher σxx\sigma_{xx}) agree well with such scaling law, revealing that both Drude-like tensor and QMQ contribute to the third-order nonlinearity with comparable magnitude. Interestingly, both the contributions decrease with TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}. Notably, the obtained QMQ contribution (qq) in S2 at low TT reaches around 4700 V−2^{-2}, which is two orders of magnitude larger than that in antiferromagnetic TI bulk MnBi2_2Te4_4 [21] and few-layer WTe2_2 [22]. We remark that the data deviate from the linear fit at higher TT [or lower σ\sigma, see Figure 4(d,Figure 4e)], which indicates that other τ\tau-dependent conductivity mechanisms than the Drude-like and QMQ contributions play a role in the third-order nonlinear transport. Such deviation is likely due to the enhancement of phonon skew scattering process and suppression of the τ\tau term (here is QMQ) with increasing TT. Similar behavior has been observed in few-layer WTe2_2 [22].

Moreover, the measured Vxx3ωV_{xx}^{3\omega} (or MR3ω\mathrm{MR}^{3\omega}) is an even function of B⊥opB_{\perp}^{op} [Figure 4(b,Figure 4c)] while the Vyx3ωV_{yx}^{3\omega} is odd in B⊥opB_{\perp}^{op} (Fig. S19 in Supplemental Material [41]). In the third-order nonlinearity, the quantum metric (Berry curvature) quadrupole contributes exclusively to the Vxx3ωV_{xx}^{3\omega} (Vyx3ωV_{yx}^{3\omega}) with even- (odd-)symmetry with respect to the directions of applied B⊥opB_{\perp}^{op}. Whereas, the contribution from Drude-like tensor (skew scattering) is insensitive to B⊥opB_{\perp}^{op} [21]. Therefore, the BB dependence of third-order nonlinearity is mainly governed by intrinsic QMQ with a constant background formed by extrinsic contributions. Nevertheless, the origin of non-monotonic BB-dependent Vxx3ωV_{xx}^{3\omega} (or MR3ω\mathrm{MR}^{3\omega}) remains unknown and warrants further theoretical and experimental investigations.

To better compare the higher-order magnetotransport behaviors with the first-order ones, we define the higher-harmonic MR as MR2,3ω=[Vxx2,3ω(B)−Vxx2,3ω(0)]/Vxx2,3ω(0)×100%\mathrm{MR}^{2,3\omega} = [V_{xx}^{2,3\omega}(B) - V_{xx}^{2,3\omega}(0)]/V_{xx}^{2,3\omega}(0) \times100\%. Figure 4(f) plots BB dependence of MR1,2,3ω\mathrm{MR}^{1,2,3\omega} in S8 and S15 at T=2T = 2 K. Obviously, the amplitude of MR3ω\mathrm{MR}^{3\omega} is much larger than that of MR1ω\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega} or MR2ω\mathrm{MR}^{2\omega}, and its polarity is tuned by both BB and TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}. Furthermore, we summarize the maximum of MR1ω\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega} and MR3ω\mathrm{MR}^{3\omega} under various IωI^\omega within 10 T in multiple samples as a function of TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}, as plotted in Figure 4(g). Despite a slight fluctuation of MR1ω\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega}, the MR3ω\mathrm{MR}^{3\omega} expands exponentially with decreasing TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}, indicating a significant effect of disorder on third-order nonlinear magnetotransport.

In summary, we carry out first-order linear and higher-order nonlinear (magneto-)transport study in bulk TNS. The RRR dependence of TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} and nsn_s suggests a crucial role of the 2q\mathbf{2q} ordering located at Ta2 sites in the formation of CDW. The nMR1ω\mathrm{nMR}^{1\omega} in high-TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} samples relies exclusively on B//IωB // I^\omega, whose origin is tied to the Berry curvature effect. As TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} drops, a growing degree of disorder brings into play an additional contribution from the Zeeman effect on percolating current pathways. The whole MR1ω\mathrm{MR}^{1\omega} behaviors can be well captured by a phenomenological two-resistor model. Moreover, the suppressed second-order nonlinear signals enable the third-order ones—mainly contributed by both intrinsic QMQ and extrinsic Drude-like tensor—standing out as the leading nonlinear longitudinal response under inversion symmetry. The MR3ω\mathrm{MR}^{3\omega} is giant and its magnitude is sensitive to TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}}. Our work not only advances the understanding of disorder-mediated linear and nonlinear (magneto-)transport as well as associated quantum geometric properties, but also opens a feasible route for achieving field-sensitive device applications based on higher-order MR engineering.

Figures

Acknowledgements

This work is financially supported by the National Key R&D Program of China (Grants Nos. 2023YFA1406002, 2020YFA0308800, 2022YFA1403400, 2022YFA1602802, 2022YFA1602800, 2021YFA1401800), the National Natural Science Foundation (NNSF) of China (Grants Nos. 12321004, 12204045, 12204037, 12134018, 11921004), the Beijing Natural Science Foundation (Grant No. Z210006), and the Beijing National Laboratory for Condensed Matter Physics (Grant No. 2023BNLCMPKF007). J.Q. acknowledges the support by the Beijing Institute of Technology Research Fund Program for Young Scholars. M.J. acknowledges the support by Beijing Institute of Technology Laboratory Research Project (Grant No. 2023BITSYB07).

Data availability

The data that support the findings of this article are openly available [62]. calculations and transport data of TNS, which includes Refs. [43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56] [42].

References

  1. [1]J.L. Olsen, Electron Transport in Metals (Interscience, New York, 1962).
  2. [2]A. B. Pippard, Magnetoresistance in Metals (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 1989).
  3. [3]J. Heremans, Solid-state magnetic field sensors and applications, J. Phys. D 26, 1149-1168 (1993).DOI
  4. [4]X.L. Wang, Y. Du, S.X. Dou & C. Zhang, Room temperature giant and linear magnetoresistance in topological insulator Bi₂Te₃ nanosheets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 266806 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23005006
  5. [5]M.N. Ali, J. Xiong, S. Flynn, J. Tao, Q.D. Gibson, L.M. Schoop, T. Liang, N. Haldolaarachchige, M. Hirschberger, N.-P. Ong, & R.J. Cava, Large, non-saturating magnetoresistance in WTe₂, Nature 514, 205-208 (2014).DOI
  6. [6]J. Xiong, S.K. Kushwaha, T. Liang, J.W. Krizan, M. Hirschberger, W. Wang, R.J. Cava & N.P. Ong, Evidence for the chiral anomaly in the Dirac semimetal Na₃Bi, Science 350, 6259 (2015).DOI
  7. [7]T. Liang, Q. Gibson, M.N. Ali, M.H. Liu, R.J. Cava & N.P. Ong, Ultrahigh mobility and giant magnetoresistance in the Dirac semimetal Cd₃As₂, Nat. Mater. 14, 280-284 (2015).DOI
  8. [8]X.C. Huang, L.X. Zhao, Y.J. Long, P.P. Wang, D. Chen, Z.H. Yang, H. Liang, M.Q. Xue, H.M. Weng, Z. Fang, X. Dai & G. Chen, Observation of the chiral-anomaly-induced negative magnetoresistance in 3D Weyl Semimetal TaAs, Phys. Rev. X 5.031023 (2015).DOI
  9. [9]L.R. Thoutam, Y.L. Wang, Z.L. Xiao, S. Das, A. Luican-Mayer, R. Divan, G.W. Crabtree & W.K. Kwok, Temperature-dependent three-dimensional anisotropy of the magnetoresistance in WTe₂, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 046602 (2015).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26252701
  10. [10]C. Shekhar, A.K. Nayak, Y. Sun, M. Schmidt, M. Nicklas, I. Leermakers, U. Zeitler, Y. Skourski, J. Wosnitza, Z. Liu, Y. Chen, W. Schnelle, H. Borrmann, Y. Grin, C. Felser & B. Yan, Extremely large magnetoresistance and ultrahigh mobility in the topological Weyl semimetal candidate NbP, Nat. Phys. 11, 645-649 (2015).DOI
  11. [11]N. Kumar, Y. Sun, N. Xu, K. Manna, M.Y. Yao, V. Süß, I. Leermakers, O. Young, T. Förster, M. Schmidt, H. Borrmann, B.H. Yan, U. Zeitler, M. Shi, C. Felser & C. Shekhar, Extremely high magnetoresistance and conductivity in the type-II Weyl semimetals A. Narayanan, M.D. Watson, S.F. Blake, Y.L. Chen, D. Prabhakaran, B. Yan, N. Bruyant, L. Drigo, C. Felser, T. Kong, P. C. Canfield & A.I. Coldea, Linear magnetoresistance caused by mobility fluctuations in n-doped Cd₃As₂, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 117201 (2015).
  12. [13]O. Breunig, Z.W. Wang, A.A. Taskin, J. Lux, A. Rosch & Y. Ando, Gigantic negative magnetoresistance in the bulk of a disordered topological insulator, Nat. Commun. 8, 15545 (2017).DOI
  13. [14]D. Zhang, W. Jiang, H. Yun, O.J. Benally, T. Peterson, Z. Cresswell, Y. Fan, Y. Lv, G. Yu, J.G. Barriocanal, P.W. Swatek, K.A. Mkhoyan, T. Low & J.-P. Wang, Robust negative longitudinal magnetoresistance and spin-orbit torque in sputtered Pt₃Sn and Pt₃SnₓFe₁₋ₓ topological semimetal, Nat. Commun. 14, 4151 (2023).DOI
  14. [15]S. Lai, H.Y. Liu, Z.W. Zhang, J.Z. Zhao, X.L. Feng, N.Z. Wang, C.L. Tang, Y.D. Liu, K.S. Novoselov, S.Y. A. Yang & W.B. Gao, Third-order nonlinear Hall effect induced by the Berry-connection polarizability tensor, Nat. Nanotechnol. 16, 869-873 (2021).DOI
  15. [16]C. Wang, R.-C. Xiao, H. Liu, Z. Zhang, S. Lai, C. Zhu, H. Cai, N. Wang, S. Chen, Y. Deng, Z. Liu, S. A. Yang & W.-B. Gao, Room-temperature third-order nonlinear Hall effect in Weyl semimetal TaIrTe₄, Natl. Sci. Rev. 9, nwac020 (2022).DOI
  16. [17]A.Y. Gao, Y.F. Liu, J.X. Qiu, B. Ghosh, T.V. Trevisan, Y. Onishi, C.W. Hu, T.M. Qian, H.-J. Tien, S.W. Chen, M.G. Huang, D. Bérubé, H.C. Li, C. Tzschaschel, T.Dinh, Z. Sun, S.C. Ho, S.W. Lien, B. Singh, K. Watanabe, T. Taniguchi, D.C. Bell, H. Lin, T.R. Chang, C.-H.R. Du, A. Bansil, L. Fu, N. Ni, P.P. Orth, Q. Ma & S.Y. Xu, Quantum metric nonlinear Hall effect in a topological antiferromagnetic heterostructure, Science 381, 181-186 (2023).
  17. [18]N.Z. Wang, D. Kaplan, Z.W. Zhang, T. Holder, N. Cao, A.-F Wang, X.Y. Zhou, F.F. Zhou, Z.Z. Jiang, C.S. Zhang, S.H Ru, H.B. Cai, K. Watanabe, T. Taniguchi, B.H. Yan & W.-B. Gao, Quantum metric-induced nonlinear transport in a topological antiferromagnet, Nature 621, 487-492 (2023).DOI
  18. [19]T.-Y. Zhao, A.-Q. Wang, X.-G. Ye, X.-Y. Liu, X. Liao & Z.-M. Liao, Gate-tunable Berry curvature dipole polarizability in Dirac semimetal Cd₃As₂, Phys. Rev. Lett. 131, 186302 (2023).DOI
  19. [20]P. He, H. Isobe, G. K. W. Koon, J. Y. Tan, J. Hu, J. Li, N. Nagaosa, J. Shen, Third-order nonlinear Hall effect in a quantum Hall system, Nat. Nanotechnol. 19, 1460-1465 (2024).
  20. [21]H. Li, C.P Zhang, C.J Zhou, C. Ma, X. Lei, Z.J Jin, H.T He, B.K Li, K.T. Law, & J.N. Wang, Quantum geometry quadrupole-induced third-order nonlinear transport in antiferromagnetic topological insulator MnBi₂Te₄, Nat. Commun. 15, 7779 (2024).DOI
  21. [22]X.-Y. Liu, A.-Q. Wang, D. Li, T.-Y. Zhao, X. Liao & Z.-M. Liao, Giant third-order nonlinearity induced by the quantum metric quadrupole in few-layer WTe₂, Phys. Rev. Lett. 134, 026305 (2025).DOI
  22. [23]H. Yu, X. Li, Y.-Q. Bie, L. Yan, L. Zhou, P. Yu & G. Yang, Quantum metric third-order nonlinear Hall effect in a non-centrosymmetric ferromagnet, Nat. Commun. 16, 7698 (2025).DOI
  23. [24]Z.Z. Du, C.M. Wang, S. Li, H.-Z. Lu & X.C. Xie, Disorder-induced nonlinear Hall effect with time-reversal symmetry, Nat. Commun. 10, 3047 (2019).
  24. [25]H. Liu, J. Zhao, Y.-X. Huang, X. Feng, C. Xiao, W. Wu, S. Lai, W.-B. Gao & S. A. Yang, Berry connection polarizability tensor and third-order Hall effect, Phys. Rev. B 105, 045118 (2022).DOI
  25. [26]C.-P. Zhang, X.-J. Gao, Y.-M. Xie, H.C. Po & K. T. Law, Higher-order nonlinear anomalous Hall effects induced by Berry curvature multipoles, Phys. Rev. B 107, 115142 (2023).DOI
  26. [27]D. Mandal, S. Sarkar, K. Das & A. Agarwal, Quantum geometry induced third-order nonlinear transport responses, Phys. Rev. B 110, 195131 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2310.19092
  27. [28]S.A. Sunshine & J.A. Ibers, Synthesis, structure, and transport properties of tantalum nickel selenide (Ta₂NiSe₇) and tantalum platinum selenide (Ta₂PtSe₇), Inorg. Chem. 25, 4355-4358 (1986).DOI
  28. [29]R.M. Fleming, S.A. Sunshine, C.H. Chen, L.F. Schneemeyer & J.V. Wasc zczak, Defect-inhibited incommensurate distortion in Ta₂NiSe₇, Phys. Rev. B 42, 4954–4959 (1990).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9996055
  29. [30]Z.X. Dai, C.G. Slough, W.W. McNairy & R.V. Coleman, Charge-density-wave formation in Ta₂NiSe₇ studied by scanning tunneling microscopy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 1769 (1992).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10046309
  30. [31]A. Spijkerman, A. Meetsma, J. L. de Boer, Y. Gao & S. van Smaalen, Modulated structure of NiTa₂Se₇ in its incommensurate charge-density-wave state at 16 K, Phys. Rev. B 52, 3892 (1995).
  31. [32]J.Lüdecke, M.Schneider, S.van Smaalen, Independent q→ and 2q→ distortions in the incommensurately modulated low-temperature structure of NiTa₂Se₇, J. Solid State Chem. 153, 152 (2000).DOI
  32. [33]J. Lüdecke, E. Riedl, M. Dierl, K. Hosseini & S.V. Smaalen, Influence of niobium on the charge-density-wave transition of Ni(Ta₁−ₓNbₓ)₂Se₇, Phys. Rev. B 62, 7057-7062 (2000).DOI
  33. [34]J.M. He, Y.R Zhang, L.B. Wen, Y.S. Yang, J.Y Liu, Y.S. Wu, H.L. Lian, H. Xing, S. Wang, Z.Q Mao & Y. Liu, Band dependence of charge density wave in quasi-one-dimensional Ta₂NiSe₇ probed by orbital magnetoresistance, Appl. Phys. Lett. 111, 052405 (2017).DOI
  34. [35]J.M. He, L.B. Wen, Y.S. Wu, J.Y. Liu, G.X. Tang, Y.S Yang, H. Xing, Z.Q. Mao, H. Sun & Y. Liu, Angle-dependent magnetoresistance as a sensitive probe of the charge density wave in quasi-one-dimensional semimetal Ta₂NiSe₇, Appl. Phys. Lett. 113, 192401 (2018).DOI
  35. [36]H.P. Chen & Z.T. Sun, Phonon dispersion and electronic structure in quasi-one-dimensional layered Ta₂NiSe₇ single crystal, J. Mater. Chem. C 9, 5162 (2021).DOI
  36. [37]L.X. Liu, X. Luo, X.C. Yang, Y. Li, W.Q. Tu, M. Cheng, T.Y Wang, N. Zhou, R.R. Zhang, X.G. Zhu, W.H. Song, W.J. Lu, J.S. Chen & Y.P Su, Origin of the anomalous electrical transports in quasi-one-dimensional Ta₂NiSe₇, J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 14, 10736-10747 (2023).DOI
  37. [38]M.D. Watson, A. Louat, C. Cacho, S. Choi, Y.H. Lee, M. Neumann & G. Kim, Spectral signatures of a unique charge density wave in Ta₂NiSe₇, Nat. Commun. 14, 3388 (2023).DOI
  38. [39]C. Yao, L.B. Wen, Y. Zhao, Y.L. Zhu, Y. Wang, G.X. Tang, X.X. Yan, J.M Zhang, Y.X. Huang, H. Sun, Z.Q. Mao, Y.P Qi, Y. Zheng & H. Xing, Electric field effect on the charge density wave in the quasi-one-dimensional semimetal Ta₂NiSe₇, Phys. Rev. B 110, 165136 (2024).
  39. [40]P. Xiao, X. Sun, Y. Chen, Y. Han, Z.-M. Yu, W.J. Liu, X. Li, W.D. Xiao & Y.G Yao, Robust edge states of quasi-1D material Ta₂NiSe₇ and applications in saturable absorbers, Nano Lett. 24, 10402-10407 (2024).DOI
  40. [41]See Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.1103/1zzi-lcf1 for more theoretical G. Kresse and J. Furthmüller, Efficiency of ab-initio total energy calculations for metals and semiconductors using a plane-wave basis set, Comput. Mater. Sci. 6, 15 (1996).
  41. [43]G. Kresse and J. Hafner, Ab initio molecular-dynamics simulation of the liquid-metal–amorphous-semiconductor transition in germanium, Phys. Rev. B 49, 14251 (1994).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10010505
  42. [44]P.E. Blöchl, Projector augmented-wave method, Phys. Rev. B 50, 17953 (1994).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9976227
  43. [45]J.P. Perdew, J.A. Chevary, S.H. Vosko, K.A. Jackson, M.R. Pederson, D.J. Singh, and C. Fiolhais, Atoms, molecules, solids, and surfaces: Applications of the generalized gradient approximation for exchange and correlation, Phys. Rev. B 46, 6671 (1992).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10002368
  44. [46]J.C. Gao, Q.S. Wu, C. Persson, and Z.J Wang, Irvsp: To obtain irreducible representations of electronic states in the VASP, Comput. Phys. Commun. 261, 107760 (2021).DOI
  45. [47]I. Souza, N. Marzari, and D. Vanderbilt, Maximally localized Wannier functions for entangled energy bands, Phys. Rev. B 65, 035109 (2001).DOI
  46. [48]N. Marzari and D. Vanderbilt, Maximally localized generalized Wannier functions for composite energy bands, Phys. Rev. B 56, 12847 (1997).DOI
  47. [49]J. Kondo, Resistance minimum in dilute magnetic alloys, Prog. Theor. Phys. 32, 37-49 (1964).DOI
  48. [50]J. Ge, T. Luo, Z. Lin, J. Shi, Y. Liu, P. Wang, Y. Zhang, W. Duan, & J. Wang, Magnetic moments induced by atomic vacancies in transition metal dichalcogenide flakes. Adv. Mater. 33, 2005465 (2021).DOI
  49. [51]Q. Cheng, G. Xian, Y. Huang, H. Guo, L. Pan, H. Zhou, J. Wang, S. Lv, C. Shen, X. Lin, H. Chen, Y. Li, H. Yang & H.-J. Gao, Three-dimensional weak localization and negative magnetoresistance in high-quality PtP₂ crystals, Sci. China Mater. 66, 2393-2399 (2023).DOI
  50. [52]F. Arnold, C. Shekhar, S.C. Wu, Y. Sun, R.D. dos Reis, N. Kumar, M. Naumann, M.O. Ajeesh, M. Schmidt, A.G. Grushin, J.H. Bardarson, M. Baenitz, D. Sokolov, H. Borrmann, M. Nicklas, C. Felser, E. Hassinger & B. Yan, Negative magnetoresistance without well-defined chirality in the Weyl semimetal TaP, Nat. Commun. 7, 11615 (2016).DOI
  51. [53]X. Dai, Z.Z. Du & H.Z. Lu, Negative magnetoresistance without chiral anomaly in topological insulators, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 166601 (2017).DOI
  52. [54]B. Bradlyn, L. Elcoro, J. Cano, M.G. Vergniory, Z.J. Wang, C. Felser, M. I. Aroyo & B.A. Bernevig, Topological quantum chemistry, Nature 547, 7663 (2017).
  53. [55]L. Fu, C. L. Kane & E. J. Mele, Topological Insulators in Three Dimensions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 106803 (2007).
  54. [56]H.-Z. Lu & S.-Q. Shen, Quantum transport in topological semimetals under magnetic fields, Front. Phys. 12, 127201 (2017).DOI
  55. [57]T. Zhang, Y. Jiang, Z. Song, H. Huang, Y. He, Z. Fang, H. Weng & C. Fang, Catalogue of topological electronic materials, Nature 566, 475–479 (2019).DOI
  56. [58]M.G. Vergniory, B.J. Wieder, L. Elcoro, S.S. P. Parkin, C. Felser, B.A. Bernevig & N. Regnault, All topological bands of all nonmagnetic stoichiometric materials, Science 376, eabg9094 (2022).DOI
  57. [59]X.K. Zhang, L. Gao, H.H. Yu, Q.L. Liao, Z. Kang, Z. Zhang & Y. Zhang, Single-atom vacancy doping in two-dimensional transition metal dichalcogenides, Acc. Mater. Res. 2, 655-668 (2021).DOI
  58. [60]J. Wang, H. Li, C. Chang, K. He, J. S. Lee, H. Lu, Y. Sun, X. Ma, N. Samarth, S. Shen, Q. Xue, M. Xie & M. H. W. Chan, Anomalous anisotropic magnetoresistance in topological insulator films, Nano Res. 5, 739 (2012).DOI
  59. [61]J. Xu, M.K. Ma, M. Sultanov, Z.L. Xiao, Y.-L. Wang, D.F. Jin, Y.Y. Lyu, W. Zhang, L.N. Pfeiffer, K.W. West, K.W. Baldwin, M. Shayegan & W.K. Kwok, Negative longitudinal magnetoresistance in gallium arsenide quantum wells, Nat. Commun. 10, 287 (2019).DOI
  60. [62]X. Sun, et al., Dataset for "Disorder-mediated linear and nonlinear magnetotransport in charge-density-wave Ta₂NiSe₇", Figshare (2025). https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.29586974.v1

Paper details

vlnc:W_2x8cyuqy
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents