WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Integrable singularities obstruct Cauchy horizons and mass inflation
Abstract
Black-hole interiors with an inner (Cauchy) horizon are unstable through the Poisson-Israel-Ori mass-inflation mechanism, governed by the Dray-'t Hooft-Redmount relation and widely regarded as a dynamical realization of strong cosmic censorship. We show that static, spherically symmetric anisotropic interiors supported by a marginally divergent but integrable density , with and mild screening at finite radius, are incompatible with this mechanism. The compactness decreases monotonically from a super-critical central value to at the unique event horizon, producing a strictly positive compactness gap throughout the trapped region and excluding any second zero of the lapse. This gap enters the dynamics quantitatively. (i) Under the null energy condition and a dynamical screening condition, is non-decreasing along both future null directions of a trapped domain, so the gap propagates under nonlinear spherically symmetric evolution. (ii) For ingoing radiation (generalized Vaidya), the gap bounds the blueshift: the advanced time spent in the gapped region is finite, whereas it diverges at a Cauchy horizon. (iii) For counter-streaming null dust, the radiative part of the Misner-Sharp mass obeys exactly , of which the DTR relation is the thin-shell form; the in-out coupling is uniformly bounded on the interior precisely when the gap is positive. This yields an a priori mass bound and, in the Ori thin-shell model, an e-folding rate bounded by the influx luminosity instead of tending to the inner-horizon surface gravity. Integrable-singularity interiors thus realize a class of sources for which the Poisson-Israel-Ori amplification channel is structurally inoperative in the models in which mass inflation was originally established.
Introduction.— Black-hole interiors in general relativity are expected to be dynamically unstable due to the phenomenon of mass inflation [1, 2, 3]. In spacetimes admitting a Cauchy horizon, ingoing perturbations undergo an unbounded blueshift governed by the Dray–’t Hooft–Redmount (DTR) relation [4, 5], leading to exponential growth of the Misner–Sharp mass and to the breakdown of the classical interior geometry. This mechanism is widely regarded as a dynamical realization of strong cosmic censorship [6, 7, 8, 9].
Most analyses of this instability assume the existence of an inner horizon and study its nonlinear fate under perturbations. A complementary, less explored question is whether the formation of such a horizon can be obstructed at a structural level by the matter content itself. Several works have instead modified the black-hole interior through effective or semiclassical considerations, including regular black-hole models that can retain mass inflation even in the absence of a Cauchy horizon [10, 11].
Here we follow a different, more modest route: rather than demanding full regularity, we consider interiors that admit an integrable singularity at the center – curvature invariants diverge, yet suitable volume-weighted integrals remain finite, in the sense of [12] and as realized in explicit static models by [13]. Whether this integrability property itself survives under generic, non-spherical perturbations is a separate and still-debated question, recently challenged on the grounds of test-field backreaction [14]; this is distinct from the obstruction to mass inflation studied below, which depends only on the existence of a compactness gap in the trapped region away from the center, not on the exact preservation of integrability at under generic perturbations. We do not construct these interiors as candidate descriptions of realistic collapse; instead, we ask a narrower structural question: once such a matter content is assumed, under what conditions is the standard Poisson–Israel–Ori channel for mass inflation kinematically inoperative? Density profiles of marginal form and the associated linear behavior of the Misner–Sharp mass have been discussed before in a different context, in connection with anomalies of quasilocal mass constructions [15, 16]. Our contribution is not the existence of such profiles, but the identification of the single quantity through which they act on the mass-inflation mechanism. The lapse is simultaneously (a) the blueshift factor relating the advanced time of the exterior to affine time along outgoing rays, , and (b) the denominator of the nonlinear coupling between ingoing and outgoing fluxes, of which the DTR relation is the thin-shell form. A uniform lower bound on therefore controls both ingredients of the Poisson–Israel–Ori mechanism, and we show that such a bound is preserved by the dynamics (Theorems 1 and 2 below).
The logical structure of the result is the following chain, which we state here so that the role of each hyhypothesis is clear before the derivation:
The first arrow is Proposition 1 (static) and Theorem 1 (dynamical). The second arrow is where the gap is actually used, and constitutes Theorem 2: the gap bounds the blueshift and the in–out coupling, and both bounds fail precisely when . The last arrow is made quantitative in the models in which mass inflation was originally established [2, 3]: ingoing radiation (generalized Vaidya), continuous counter-streaming null dust, and an outgoing thin shell crossed by an influx (the Ori model). All dynamical statements are made in spherical symmetry and for matter obeying the null energy condition (NEC).
Static set-up and integrable singularities.— We consider static, spherically symmetric interiors in Schwarzschild gauge,
where is the unit-sphere line element, supported by an anisotropic fluid
In this gauge, Einstein equations imply
so that identically – a direct consequence of staticity plus spherical symmetry in this gauge, not an additional assumption. Introducing the Misner–Sharp mass via
Eq. (4) becomes
The quantity controlling the interior causal structure is the compactness
whose derivative, using (8) and the averaged density , is
The sign of is thus fixed by the comparison between the local and the averaged density – the physical content of everything that follows.
We adapt the notion of an integrable singularity by requiring curvature invariants to diverge at the origin while the volume-weighted integral of the Ricci scalar stays finite,
for some , i.e. the Ricci scalar is locally integrable with respect to the volume measure, in the spirit of the classical theory of distributions [17] and its use in the analysis of wave equations on curved backgrounds [18]. For the stress tensor (3), with , and the conservation law gives , hence
Consider a marginal profile
where we write with , and as , i.e. the correction is differentiably subleading; this is what makes the profile “marginal” rather than merely asymptotic. Then , so diverges, but is bounded near the origin and
converges, so the singularity is integrable in the sense of (11); the precise statement is given in Appendix A. At the same time Eq. (8) gives , so the central compactness
is finite. If , the center already lies in the trapped region, . The exact power law , for which and is constant, is Letelier’s cloud of strings [19]; the interiors considered here are screened versions of it.
Non-local criterion and compactness gap.— An inner (Cauchy) horizon would correspond to a radius with , in addition to the event horizon at ; equivalently, a second zero of . We show that a broad class of marginally screened profiles forbids this. Assume:
(i) near the origin, with , so ;
(ii) for all , ; (iii) there exists with , where denotes the outermost zero of (the event horizon of the, static asymptotically flat geometry), and this horizon is non-degenerate: , i.e. its surface gravity is positive.
It is worth clarifying the status of hypothesis (ii), since unlike (i) and (iii) it is not an asymptotic or boundary statement but a condition imposed throughout the trapped region. A mere monotonic decrease of would only guaranty : when comparing with the mean of over weighted by , a decreasing integrand always satisfies this weaker bound. Hypothesis (ii) demands the sharper inequality , i.e., that the density not only decrease but decrease fast enough that its local value stays below one third of the enclosed average, a genuinely stronger requirement than monotonicity alone, and the one that turns into a strict, self-sustaining property rather than a generic feature of centrally condensed matter. We do not derive (ii) from a standard energy condition or a known equation of state, and we do not claim it is generic; we regard it as a geometric sufficient hypothesis, to be checked directly on the density profile in each case, as we do below for two structurally different choices of . That said, it is not an arbitrary threshold: for the marginal profile (13) itself, and as , so exactly at the center. Hypothesis (ii) is therefore saturated asymptotically by the very profile the construction is built on, rather than imposed as an unrelated external constraint on top of it. Its dynamical meaning is made explicit by Theorem 1: (ii) is the static restriction of the condition under which the compactness cannot decrease towards the future inside a trapped region.
Proposition 1 (static compactness gap). Under (i)–(iii), on , is the unique zero of , and for every
with as .
Proof. By (10) and (ii), on , so for , and the infimum in (16) is attained at . If , monotonicity would force on and hence , contradicting (iii). Thus on ; since is the outermost zero of , it is the only one. The expansion follows from . □
Hence
and no Cauchy horizon is present: the future boundary of the trapped region is the spacelike locus . Two remarks on the role of the hypotheses are in order. First, without (ii) the first zero of met from the center need not be the event horizon: for an asymptotically flat profile with the zeros of come in odd number, and three zeros would make an inner horizon of the trapped shell ; (ii) is what excludes this. Second, the gap (16) is defined, by construction, on the interval , which stays a finite distance away from the event horizon itself; the bound (17) therefore never applies at , where genuinely vanishes. Note also that is bounded but not closed at the origin, so we refer to it as a bounded interior region rather than a compact one throughout. The trapped region thus stays uniformly separated from away from the event horizon.
Figure 1 illustrates this for the exponentially screened example of the next paragraph: descends monotonically and uniformly stays above until it reaches the event horizon, never approaching it again.
Figure 1. Compactness for the exponentially screened marginal profile (18), with . The curve decreases monotonically from the super-critical central value to at the unique event horizon . The shaded region shows the compactness gap on , where : never returns to away from , so no second (Cauchy) horizon forms.
Example: exponentially screened marginal profile.—Consider , . Then , and, with ,
Since for ,
so decreases strictly from at the center to zero at infinity. defines a unique, non-degenerate event horizon, there is no inner horizon, and for every . Similar conclusions hold for other screened marginal profiles (e.g. rational screeners; see Appendix B), indicating that the compactness gap is a robust feature of this class of interiors rather than a fine-tuned property of (18).
The standard mass-inflation mechanism.—The standard scenario is most transparent in double-null coordinates ,
with the Misner–Sharp mass defined by
In Reissner–Nordström interiors, the inner horizon is a second zero of the lapse, with the inner-horizon surface gravity. Three facts, all traceable to this zero, make up the mechanism [2, 3]; we state them quantitatively because the obstruction below acts on each of them.
(1) Infinite advanced time. Let be the Eddington advanced time of the stationary exterior, in which the interior metric reads . Outgoing radial null rays obey , and is an affine parameter along them. Near this integrates to : the whole exterior history is received within a finite affine interval.
(2) Bounded influx, unbounded blueshift. In this gauge the late-time influx is governed by radiative tails, [20, 21]; it is bounded, and in fact decays. Boundedness of in the exterior advanced time is therefore the standard physical input of the mass-inflation analyses, not a restriction that removes the instability. The divergence appears only in affinely normalized frames: for the tangent of an outgoing ray with , , which grows like .
(3) Nonlinear coupling to the outflux. An influx alone produces no mass inflation; the growth of requires an outgoing component [1, 2]. For an ingoing and an outgoing thin null shell crossing at radius , the DTR relation [4, 5, 22] reads at , where () is the sector to the past (future) of both shells and () the sector crossed by the ingoing (outgoing) shell only. In terms of the shell masses and it is equivalent to
Inside the trapped region and the last term is a positive amplification. When the crossing takes place at , fact (1) gives and the amplification grows like —the hallmark of mass inflation, .
It is essential that this degeneracy of occurs inside the trapped region, at a locus distinct from the event horizon, where also vanishes but for an unrelated reason (the outer boundary of trapping, not a Cauchy horizon). The compactness-gap bound (16) is stated precisely on for this reason: it excludes lapse degeneracy in the interior of the trapped region while saying nothing about, and not needing to say anything about, the lapse at itself.
Recently, [10, 11] showed that mass inflation can persist even without a Cauchy horizon, through slowly evolving trapping horizons: the absence of an inner horizon at one instant is not by itself sufficient to prevent unbounded mass growth. Complementing this, [23] recently showed, for several specific regular-black-hole models (Hayward, Bardeen, Dymnikova, and an asymptotically-safe collapse model), that the growth of the Misner–Sharp mass at the inner horizon is generically tamed—power-law or even logarithmic rather than exponential—via a dynamical basin-of-attraction analysis performed model by model; see also [24] for a broader perspective on the quasi-local, rather than strictly teleological, status of the horizons involved. Our result is complementary to both: rather than solving the nonlinear dynamics for each model individually, we identify a static sufficient condition—the compactness gap—under which exponential growth is excluded for an entire class of interiors at once. The point raised by [10, 11] is nevertheless decisive for what must be proven: a static gap is not enough, one must show that the lapse cannot approach zero dynamically. This is the content of Theorem 1.
Dynamical obstruction to mass inflation.—We work in the double-null gauge (20) with and future directed, so that a sphere is trapped when and ; therefore by (21). Einstein’s equations give (Appendix C)
In the dynamical spacetime the density is defined invariantly as . For the sources of this paper, in the block, this is the energy density of (3) itself, and null dust does not contribute to it (for a general anisotropic fluid it is half the difference between the energy density and the radial pressure). We also define as before, now with the dynamical mass. Equations (23)–(24) are equivalent to the identities
On the static solutions, where , they reduce to (10).
Theorem 1 (propagation of the compactness gap). Let be a double-null rectangle of trapped spheres in a spherically symmetric solution of Einstein’s equations, and assume that on : (a) and (null energy condition along the radial null directions); (b) (dynamical screening). Then is non-decreasing in both and on . In particular, if on the past boundary of , then on all of : the lapse cannot approach zero towards the future within , and no inner horizon forms there.
Proof. In a trapped region and , so under (a) and (b) every term on the right-hand sides of (25)–(26) is non-negative. Any point of is reached from the past boundary along a segment of constant or constant , along which does not decrease.
Theorem 1 is nonlinear in the sense that it is formulated for the full spherically symmetric Einstein equations, without linearizing the metric or the Misner–Sharp mass around the static background, and uses no property of the matter beyond (a) and (b). Hypothesis (b) is the same inequality as the static hypothesis (ii), now required of the evolving density and mass, and (a) is where the outgoing component first enters: positive outflux can only widen the gap. Reissner–Nordström illustrates the sharpness of (b): it is a source of the same type, with and , for which holds only for . The inner horizon lies in the region where the screening condition is violated; there decreases towards the future and the gap closes.
To quantify the mechanism we now specify the perturbation as in [2, 3]: the static fluid of Proposition 1 plus non-interacting ingoing and outgoing null dust, and , i.e. with each of the three components separately conserved. Equations (23)–(26) are identities valid for any spherically symmetric matter and Theorem 1 requires only its two hypotheses, whereas the equations below are specific to this model. For a fluid with in the block, conservation forces : the density remains the same function of the areal radius in the dynamical spacetime. We may therefore split
with the static profile (8) and the radiative part of the mass; is the integrable member of the family, and adds a Schwarzschild-like term to it. With ingoing flux only, the exact solution is the generalized Vaidya metric [25, 26]
with , , and the advanced time of fact (1).
Theorem 2 (the gap bounds the blueshift and the in–out coupling). Consider the static fluid of Proposition 1 perturbed by null dust obeying the NEC, , , with non-negative radiative mass on the past characteristic boundary of the trapped domain considered. Fix . Then:
(a) The gap persists, on . For ingoing flux only (28), every future-directed causal curve in this region satisfies
with equality in the first relation for outgoing radial null rays. The advanced time spent in the annulus is at most , and the advanced time elapsed between and is at most . On the static background, the outgoing radial null tangent of fact (2), normalized by , obeys .
(b) Within this model, the radiative mass obeys the exact equation
with , . On every double-null rectangle of trapped spheres contained in the annulus , the coupling coefficient satisfies , and
Denoting by the right-hand side, the radiative mass is bounded by the data injected through the past boundary,
which holds in particular when and both and are smaller than .
(c) For two thin shells crossing at , the DTR amplification in (22) is . For a continuous influx crossing one outgoing thin shell of mass at in the geometry (28) (the Ori model [3]), along the portion of its trajectory with ,
so that, if ,
Proof. (a) Since in a trapped region by (23)–(24) and the NEC, persists, and by (17); this is Theorem 1 in the present model, where (b) of that theorem holds because the density is still the static profile and , so that with . For (28), a future-directed causal displacement has and , i.e. , which is (29); integrating over the annulus, or from to using that on all of , gives the bounds on the elapsed advanced time. On the static background () is affine along outgoing radial null geodesics and , whence the flux bound. (b) (30) is derived in Appendix C from (23)–(24), the Raychaudhuri equations and the conservation of each dust stream. With and part (a), the coefficient is at most , so . Hence , and integrating in gives (31), which is equivalent to (32) when ; for and boundary masses below each exponential exceeds , so . (c) The first statement is (22), derived in Appendix D, with . (33) is the continuum limit of (22) for infinitesimal (also in Appendix D); (34) follows by integration along the portion of the trajectory in the annulus, using and the bound on the advanced time spent there.
Theorem 2 makes the role of the gap explicit: by (30) and (22) the coupling between the two fluxes is exactly , so on the annulus , where is bounded above and below, it is uniformly bounded if and only if there. The gap is therefore not an auxiliary hypothesis but precisely the condition that controls the in–out coupling. By contrast, the ingoing equation alone carries no such information: in the Eddington gauge and (23) gives , so a bounded influx changes the mass at most linearly in with or without an inner horizon. What distinguishes the two cases is the range of [part (a)] and the coupling to [parts (b) and (c)], and both are controlled by .
The comparison with an inner horizon is instructive, and is shown in Figure 2 for the same influx on both geometries. At an inner horizon , and the lapse on the shell, , obeys near , with attractor (Appendix D). Inserting this in (33) gives independently of the amplitude of the influx: the rate is set by the geometry, the range of is infinite, and [3]. With a compactness gap there is no such attractor: is proportional to , vanishes with it, and acts for a finite advanced time.
Figure 2. Ori model (33) integrated numerically for the same Price-law influx profile , with the same normalization in units of , on a Reissner–Nordström interior and on the exponentially screened integrable interior (18) (parameters in Appendix D; denotes the event-horizon radius of each geometry). Top: logarithmic amplification of the outgoing-shell mass. Bottom: instantaneous e-folding rate . With an inner horizon (dashed curves) (dotted line; the approach is ) and the growth is exponential for all . With a compactness gap (solid curves) decays with the influx, the amplification accumulated in the annulus obeys (34), and the integration continued to (dot) shows that the total amplification remains of order unity after a finite advanced time.
, and on , with the same as in (16); has no zero in and the apparent horizon lies at . (2) Hypotheses (a) and (b) of Theorem 1 hold. (3) Consequently parts (a) and (c) of Theorem 2 apply with the static gap : the advanced time spent in the gapped region is bounded by (29), and an outgoing thin shell crossing the influx is amplified at most according to (33)–(34) while it lies in , so that no exponential mass inflation occurs there. When a continuous outgoing null flux is present as well, the decomposition (27) and the gap inequality of Theorem 2(b) continue to hold, and the radiative mass is controlled by Theorem 2(b).
Proof. (1) For plus ingoing null dust the field equations reduce to and [26], whose solution with is (28). Since , and ,
Corollary 1. Let satisfy (i)–(iii), and let the corresponding static interior be irradiated, from on, by ingoing null dust of luminosity . Then, for all : (1) the exact solution is (28) with
which is on by Proposition 1 and on ; hence the outermost zero of is at . (2) and ; null dust does not contribute to , so the density is still the static profile, , the last step because . (3) The hypotheses of Theorem 2(a),(c) are (1) and (2); with an additional outflux , Theorem 2(a),(b) apply directly, since their proof uses only (27) and the NEC. In particular the growth exponent in (34) is finite and proportional to the accreted mass, whereas exponential inflation requires to grow linearly in over an unbounded range of , which (29) excludes.
The static observation that no second zero of exists is thus only the starting point. Theorem 1 shows that, in contrast with the slowly-evolving-horizon scenarios of [10, 11], the lapse cannot approach zero dynamically as long as the NEC and the screening condition hold, and Theorem 2 converts the surviving gap into explicit bounds on the quantities that grow without bound at a Cauchy horizon.
Discussion.— The result of this Letter is summarized by the chain (1). A screened marginal profile has a compactness gap (Proposition 1); the gap is propagated by the NEC and the screening condition (Theorem 1); and the gap is the quantity that bounds, on the one hand, the blueshift factor and the advanced time available to the interior, and on the other hand the coupling between ingoing and outgoing fluxes through which the Misner–Sharp mass inflates (Theorem 2). An inner horizon is the limiting case , in which these bounds are lost; there the growth rate is instead fixed by the surface gravity , as derived in Appendix D.
Scope and outlook. The analysis is formulated in spherical symmetry and for matter obeying the NEC. Theorem 1 is nonlinear and requires only its two hypotheses on the evolved domain, which hold for the fluid-plus-null-dust model; the explicit mass bounds of Theorem 2 are obtained for counter-streaming null dust and thin shells, the models in which mass inflation was established, with (32) explicit for boundary data below the threshold . The uniform estimates are formulated on the annulus , where the static gap alone controls the coefficient , since vanishes at the center. This is a property of the uniform estimate rather than of the dynamics: for one has as , so the coupling remains finite at the center, where the accreted mass produces a Schwarzschild-like singularity [14]; no infinite range of is involved. The NEC plays an essential role: for , as in an evaporating interior, changes sign near the center at , with surface gravity , so that the semiclassical evolution of these interiors is a natural next problem. In this sense the present analysis complements the rigorous nonlinear analyses of [6, 7, 8, 27]: it isolates the specific geometric condition — a lapse-degeneracy locus inside the trapped region — that the Poisson–Israel–Ori mechanism requires, and shows that a compactness gap removes exactly that condition.
An arguably more ambitious goal would be to identify non-pathological classes of inner horizons rather than excluding them outright, and it is worth being precise about why this is harder than the present construction. Our mechanism sidesteps the instability by removing its geometric prerequisite — a second zero of — entirely; a non-pathological-horizon program would instead have to allow while controlling the DTR blueshift itself, for instance by forcing the inner-horizon surface gravity (an extremal-type degeneration, which trades exponential growth for a slower, possibly polynomial one) or by finding matter content for which the flux term in Eq. (30) is dynamically suppressed near rather than merely bounded on a region away from it. Both routes require dynamical, not just static, control at the horizon itself — precisely the point our compactness-gap argument avoids by construction, since is only claimed on . To our knowledge no explicit example of this second, more demanding, type is currently established, and we regard it as a natural but substantially harder open problem rather than one this Letter resolves. Extending the present gap condition beyond spherical symmetry, to rotating interiors, and connecting it to fully nonlinear Einstein–matter evolutions, remain open directions as well. In this sense, marginally screened densities furnish a concrete, if narrow, class of interiors for which the standard mass-inflation channel is structurally, not just instantaneously, inoperative — a statement compatible with, but weaker than, strong cosmic censorship itself; indeed, the regularity class in which such a statement is made matters, since the weaker formulation of strong cosmic censorship has recently been shown to fail for vacuum perturbations of Kerr, which admit a continuous extension across the Cauchy horizon [8] — our obstruction, like the mass-inflation mechanism itself, concerns the stronger, lapse-regularity sense, not extendibility in the weakest, merely continuous, one.
Appendix A: Uniform convergence of the marginal profile
Here we make precise the sense in which guarantees the integrability condition (11), addressing the convergence concern directly. Write
with continuous on for some . Fix ; by definition of the limit there exists such that for all . On this interval, by (12),
where, from (35), , so that . Assuming, as is standard for a marginal profile, that is with as (i.e. the correction is differentiably subleading, not merely bounded), and there exists , independent of , such that
Since is continuous and bounded on , it is integrable there, and (37) gives
which is (11). This is the precise sense in which the marginal profile (13) produces an integrable singularity: it is not merely that has a limit, but that this limit is approached uniformly, which is what allows the bound in (37) to be taken independent of and hence what justifies passing the limit through the integral in (14) of the main text.
Appendix B: Rational screener
As a second, algebraically independent example of a marginally screened profile, consider
Near the origin , so (39) is marginal in the same sense as (13). Using (8),
so that, with ,
This is manifestly monotonically decreasing in for all , with and as ; in fact holds identically, without need of an inequality analogous to (19). Choosing places the center in the trapped region as before, defines a unique event horizon at , non-degenerate with , and
for every , exactly as in the exponential case. The Ricci scalar again behaves as near the origin by the same argument as in Appendix A, so the singularity is integrable. This second, algebraically simpler example confirms that the existence of a compactness gap is not a special feature of the exponential screening (18), but persists across at least two structurally different marginal profiles.
Appendix C: Double-null identities and the equation for the radiative mass
For the metric (20) with , the and equations are the Raychaudhuri equations
and the equation is . Differentiating and using these three equations gives (23)–(24). The identity (25) follows from upon inserting (23) and ; (26) is obtained by exchanging and . Equations (23)–(26) are covariant under , .
Static solutions. For let , , . Then (2) takes the form (20) with and ; in the block gives and , so (25) reduces to , i.e. to (10). In this (Eddington) gauge at a zero of : this is the lapse degeneracy on which the standard mechanism relies.
Conservation. For , with and the projections on the quotient and on the spheres, gives , hence and wherever . For non-interacting null dust, and , so and .
Equation (30). With , Eq. (23) reads , with
where and in a trapped region. By (43), , and by (21), . Therefore
which is (30). Reissner–Nordström belongs to the same class of sources, with and , and for it (30) is the wave equation for the mass function, with a source quadratic in the fluxes, that underlies the analysis of [2]. We have verified (23)–(26), (43) and (30) by direct symbolic computation of the Einstein tensor. Note that in the Eddington gauge of the static background , so : this is the statement that a bounded influx changes the mass linearly in , used in the main text.
Appendix D: DTR relation, Ori limit and numerical illustration
DTR relation. Let an ingoing shell at and an outgoing shell at cross at a sphere of radius , in continuous double-null coordinates. The derivative is tangential to the outgoing shell and is therefore continuous across , while is continuous across . Denoting by the values of for and , and by those of for and , Eq. (21) gives at the crossing , , , with the same factor , hence [4, 5, 22]. The relation involves only the Misner–Sharp masses at and holds for any spherically symmetric sectors. Writing , and ,
which is (22). In a trapped region under the NEC by (23)–(24).
Ori limit. Let the outgoing shell, of mass , sit at in the geometry (28), so that , and let the influx between and act as an ingoing shell with . The mass of the outgoing shell after the crossing is by (22), i.e.
which is (33); applied to a Reissner–Nordström background it reproduces the growth law of [3] (see below). The static profile is the same on both sides of the shell and drops out of .
Inner-horizon attractor. Along the shell, obeys . If has an inner horizon, and , so , whose solutions relax at the rate to for slowly varying . Then , and including the first correction for , , i.e. . With a compactness gap and no such attractor exists.
Numerical illustration. Figure 2 is obtained by integrating , the equation for above and (33), in units of the event-horizon radius of each background, for with , and total accreted mass , the shell being launched at . The backgrounds are Reissner–Nordström with and the exponentially screened profile (18) with . In the first case the rate approaches the surface gravity of the final inner horizon, , as ; in the second the shell reaches after with , in agreement with (29) and, on the annulus, with (34). The system is integrated from with and arbitrary, over for Reissner–Nordström and until for the integrable interior, with an implicit Radau IIA scheme and, as a check, an explicit eighth-order Runge–Kutta scheme (DOP853), at relative tolerances between and ; all quantities quoted are stable to the digits given, and coincides with the quadrature . For Reissner–Nordström, at , against , and at . For the integrable interior with and , one has , the lapse on the shell satisfies throughout the annulus, there, the advanced time spent in the annulus is against the bound , and the amplification is accumulated almost entirely inside the annulus.
References
References
- [1]E. Poisson and W. Israel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 1663 (1989).
- [2]E. Poisson and W. Israel, Phys. Rev. D 41, 1796 (1990).
- [3]A. Ori, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 789 (1991).
- [4]T. Dray and G. ’t Hooft, Commun. Math. Phys. 99, 613 (1985).
- [5]I. H. Redmount, Prog. Theor. Phys. 73, 1401 (1985).
- [6]M. Dafermos, Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 58, 445 (2005).
- [7]J. Luk and S.-J. Oh, Ann. of Math. 190, 1 (2019).
- [8]M. Dafermos and J. Luk, Ann. of Math. (2) 202, 309 (2025).
- [9]O. J. C. Dias, F. C. Eperon, H. S. Reall, and J. E. Santos, Phys. Rev. D 97, 104060 (2018).
- [10]R. Carballo-Rubio, F. Di Filippo, S. Liberati, C. Pacilio, and M. Visser, J. High Energy Phys. 2022, 118 (2022).
- [11]R. Carballo-Rubio, F. Di Filippo, S. Liberati, and M. Visser, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 181402 (2024).
- [12]V. N. Lukash and V. N. Strokov, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 28, 1350007 (2013).
- [13]J. Ovalle, Phys. Rev. D 107, 104005 (2023).
- [14]J. Arrechea, S. Liberati, H. Neshat, and V. Vellucci, Phys. Rev. D 112, 044024 (2025).
- [15]H. Faraoni, A. Giusti, and T. F. Bean, Phys. Rev. D 103, 044026 (2021), arXiv:2010.00069.DOI
- [16]S. A. Hayward, Phys. Rev. D 53, 1938 (1996), arXiv:gr-qc/9408002.DOI
- [17]L. Hörmander, The Analysis of Linear Partial Differential Operators II: Differential Operators with Constant Coefficients (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2005).
- [18]F. G. Friedlander, The Wave Equation on a Curved Space-Time, Cambridge Monographs on Mathematical Physics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1975).
- [19]P. S. Letelier, Phys. Rev. D 20, 1294 (1979).
- [20]R. H. Price, Phys. Rev. D 5, 2419 (1972).
- [21]C. Gundlach, R. H. Price, and J. Pullin, Phys. Rev. D 49, 883 (1994), arXiv:gr-qc/9307009.DOI
- [22]C. Barrabès and W. Israel, Phys. Rev. D 43, 1129 (1991).
- [23]A. Bonanno, A. Panassiti, and F. Sauressig, arXiv e-prints (2025), arXiv:2507.03581 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2507.03581
- [24]M. Visser, Gen. Relativ. Gravit. 56, 146 (2024).
- [25]V. Husain, Phys. Rev. D 53, R1759 (1996), arXiv:gr-qc/9511011.DOI
- [26]A. Wang and Y. Wu, Gen. Relativ. Gravit. 31, 107 (1999), arXiv:gr-qc/9803038.DOI
- [27]J. L. Costa, P. M. Girão, J. Natário, and J. Silva, Commun. Math. Phys. 339, 903 (2015).

