betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Exact operator bounds on Leggett-Garg violations

Abstract

Leggett-Garg (LG) inequalities test whether correlations measured at different times admit a positive joint probability distribution over histories. A violation requires negative values in any joint quasiprobability distribution reproducing those correlations, but such distributions can have negative values even without a violation. Spacetime density kernels extend the density-matrix description to multiple times and are used to study timelike entanglement. We establish a universal bound that relates LG violations to their negative eigenvalue weight. For LG tests involving any number of measurements, we determine the least compatible kernel negativity through an exact relation valid for any system dimension, initial state, dynamics, or measurement rule. This minimum is nonzero if and only if at least one LG inequality is violated. Three-time Lüders LG tests certify at most one eighth of negativity, whereas measurements resolving individual spin levels can approach one half. Including additional incompatible qubit observables gives a further exact minimum that can exceed the LG-only ceiling without increasing the LG violation.

Introduction

For spatially separated quantum degrees of freedom, Bell inequalities test whether their correlations admit a local classical description [1]. Correlations between different time slices, on the other hand, require a related but conceptually distinct notion of Leggett–Garg inequalities (LGIs) [2, 3, 4]. A classical description assigns a single positive probability distribution to histories, each specifying the values of an observable at the measurement times. If measurements reveal these values without changing later ones, the measured pair correlations must follow from that probability distribution. Quantum systems can violate the LGIs. Any joint probability description that reproduces the pair correlations must then contain negative weights. Thus, the precise quantitative relation between this negativity and LGI violation is a natural and important question.

Spacetime density kernels put this question in an operator setting [5, 6, 7]. They assign a copy of the system’s state space to each time and collect multitime correlations in one operator, much as a density matrix describes correlations between different parts of a system [7, 8, 9, 10]. This approach also connects to studies of timelike entanglement [5, 6, 11]. Unlike an ordinary density matrix, a Hermitian spacetime kernel can have negative eigenvalues. Their total magnitude defines its negativity [6].

Negativity alone does not establish an LG violation. Temporal quasiprobabilities can be negative when all LG inequalities hold [12, 13]. The minimum negativity of a joint quasiprobability distribution has previously been related to LG violations. [14, 15, 16]. Here, we provide a precise spacetime density kernel description of these violations and distinguish between two questions. We ask how much negativity is required by the LG correlations in every compatible kernel, and how much additional negativity is necessary when additional temporal averages are retained. The distinction is important because a standard LG test fixes only pair correlations, not the single-time averages, higher correlations or other observables.

We derive bounds on LG violations that every Hermitian, unit-trace density kernel reproducing the measured pair correlations must obey. For measurements at three times, we construct a kernel that attains the least negativity and obtain an exact necessary-and-sufficient relation for LG violation. For these tests, Lüders measurements, which preserve coherence between states giving the same outcome, certify at most one eighth of negativity. Measurements that resolve these states individually, corresponding to a von Neumann-type update, can exceed this ceiling already for spin one and approach one half in a higher-spin family. We extend the exact minimum and its necessary-and-sufficient condition for LG cycles involving any number of measurement times, for arbitrary system dimension, state, dynamics and measurement rule. Finally, we show that measuring a qubit along two perpendicular directions yields an additional exact minimum without increasing the LG violation.

Exact bounds on LG violations

We measure an observable QQ with outcomes q=±1q=\pm1 at three ordered times. To determine pair correlations, we repeat the same preparation and measure only at the two times in that pair. The measured pair probabilities, pijp_{ij} give

Cij=∑qi,qj=±1qiqj pij(qi,qj),∣Cij∣≤1.(1)C_{ij}=\sum_{q_i,q_j=\pm1}q_iq_j\,p_{ij}(q_i,q_j),\qquad|C_{ij}|\leq1. \tag*{(1)}

There are four LG combinations [3, 17]

K1=C12+C23−C13,K2=C12−C23+C13,K3=−C12+C23+C13,K4=−C12−C23−C13.(2)\begin{aligned} K_1 &= C_{12}+C_{23}-C_{13}, \qquad K_2 = C_{12}-C_{23}+C_{13},\\ K_3 &= -C_{12}+C_{23}+C_{13}, \qquad K_4 = -C_{12}-C_{23}-C_{13}. \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

Each has a classical upper bound of one. For a definite history, each combination equals either one or minus three. For K1K_1, minus three occurs only for the two histories (+,−,+)(+,-,+) and (−,+,−)(-,+,-). A violation therefore requires their combined weight to be negative [12]. Supplementary Sections S1 and S3 give the operational definitions and the history-weight calculation.

A three-time spacetime kernel acts on three copies of a state space, one for each measurement time. It returns multitime correlations through

⟨O1(t1)O2(t2)O3(t3)⟩=Tr⁡[H(O1⊗O2⊗O3)].(3)\langle O_1(t_1)O_2(t_2)O_3(t_3)\rangle= \operatorname{Tr}[H(O_1\otimes O_2\otimes O_3)]. \tag*{(3)}

The correlation on the left is specified by the chosen measurement prescription. An identity on a leg means no measurement at that time. For our bounds, we require only that HH be Hermitian, have unit trace and satisfy Tr⁡(HQiQj)=Cij\operatorname{Tr}(HQ_iQ_j)=C_{ij}. Here QiQ_i is QQ on leg ii and the identity on the others. We call such a kernel compatible. Its negativity is

N(H)=∑λ<0∣λ∣=∥H∥1−12.(4)\mathcal{N}(H)=\sum_{\lambda<0}|\lambda|=\frac{\lVert H\rVert_1-1}{2}. \tag*{(4)}

A positive compatible kernel yields ordinary history probabilities when QQ is measured on its legs and hence satisfies every LG inequality. The negativity also equals its trace distance to the nearest positive, unit-trace operator [6, 18].

To bound a violation, associate each LG combination with a witness operator. For the first combination,

W1=Q1Q2+Q2Q3−Q1Q3,K1=Tr⁡(HW1).(5)W_1=Q_1Q_2+Q_2Q_3-Q_1Q_3,\qquad K_1=\operatorname{Tr}(HW_1). \tag*{(5)}

The leg observables commute, so W1W_1 has the two history values one and minus three as eigenvalues. Reversing outcome labels on one leg gives the other witnesses with the same spectrum. Write H=H+−H−H=H_+-H_- for its positive and negative parts. Since Tr⁡H−=N(H)\operatorname{Tr}H_-=\mathcal{N}(H) and Tr⁡H+=1+N(H)\operatorname{Tr}H_+=1+\mathcal{N}(H),

Kα=Tr⁡(H+Wα)−Tr⁡(H−Wα)≤Tr⁡H++3Tr⁡H−=1+4N(H).(6)\begin{aligned} K_\alpha&= \operatorname{Tr}(H_+W_\alpha)-\operatorname{Tr}(H_-W_\alpha)\\ &\le\operatorname{Tr}H_+ + 3\operatorname{Tr}H_-=1+4\mathcal{N}(H). \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

The bound holds for arbitrary leg dimensions, regardless of the dynamics or the measurement rule.

For any three measured pair correlations, we construct a compatible kernel with the least possible negativity. We introduce a two-dimensional space at each time to record the outcomes, with Q∣q⟩=q∣q⟩Q|q\rangle=q|q\rangle. These spaces need not coincide with the physical state space. We define

Hpair=18[I⊗3+C12(Q⊗Q⊗I)+C23(I⊗Q⊗Q)+C13(Q⊗I⊗Q)].(7)H_{\mathrm{pair}}=\frac{1}{8}\left[\mathbb{I}^{\otimes3}+C_{12}(Q\otimes Q\otimes\mathbb{I})+C_{23}(\mathbb{I}\otimes Q\otimes Q)+C_{13}(Q\otimes\mathbb{I}\otimes Q)\right]. \tag*{(7)}

This kernel reproduces the measured correlation pairs and sets the unspecified single-time averages and three-time correlation to zero. This choice makes no assumption about the physical initial state.

The product basis states ∣q1,q2,q3⟩=∣q1⟩⊗∣q2⟩⊗∣q3⟩|q_1,q_2,q_3\rangle=|q_1\rangle\otimes|q_2\rangle\otimes|q_3\rangle, with qi=±1q_i=\pm1, label the eight possible outcome sequences and are eigenstates of HpairH_{\mathrm{pair}}. Reversing all three outcomes leaves their pair products unchanged, so the corresponding eigenvalues are equal. The eight eigenvalues therefore form four pairs,

λα=1−Kα8,α=1,…,4,each twice.(8)\lambda_\alpha=\frac{1-K_\alpha}{8},\qquad\alpha=1,\ldots,4,\qquad\text{each twice}. \tag*{(8)}

The four LG inequalities are exactly its positivity conditions. At most one is violated, since the sum of two distinct combinations is at most two. Thus

Nmin⁡≡min⁡H compatibleN(H)=N(Hpair)=14[max⁡αKα−1]+,(9)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{N}_{\min}\equiv\min_{H\ \mathrm{compatible}}\mathcal{N}(H) \\ &=\mathcal{N}(H_{\mathrm{pair}})=\frac{1}{4}\left[\max_\alpha K_\alpha-1\right]_+, \tag*{(9)} \end{aligned}

where [x]+=max⁡(x,0)[x]_+=\max(x,0). The least compatible negativity is nonzero if and only if an LG inequality is violated. The pair kernel attains it for any system, initial state, dynamics or measurement rule. Those choices can change the correlations and hence the numerical minimum, but not the exact relation. The construction also works on the physical time legs of arbitrary dimension and outcome degeneracy; see Supplementary Section S3.

The three correlations define a point in a cube. The correlations that can be reproduced by a nonnegative joint probability distribution over the outcomes at all three times form a tetrahedron bounded by the four LG inequalities [3]. Outside it, one inequality is violated and the minimum negativity grows in proportion to the violation. Its largest possible value is one half. Figure 1 shows a two-dimensional view and several measurement protocols; the projection is explained in Supplemental Section S4.

The minimum negativity concerns only the measured pair correlations. A kernel reproducing more temporal correlations can require additional negativity. To make this distinction precise, we now consider sequential Lüders measurements.

The full Lüders kernel HLH^{\mathrm{L}} describes measurements of different observables on the physical system. For an initial state ρ0\rho_0, it is defined by

Tr⁡[HL(O1⊗O2⊗O3)]=14Tr⁡[ρ0({{O3(t3),O2(t2)},O1(t1)})].(10)\operatorname{Tr}\left[H^{\mathrm{L}}(O_1\otimes O_2\otimes O_3)\right] =\frac{1}{4}\operatorname{Tr}\left[\rho_0\left(\{\{O_3(t_3),O_2(t_2)\},O_1(t_1)\}\right)\right]. \tag*{(10)}

where the braces denote anticommutators and Oi(ti)O_i(t_i) are Heisenberg operators [7]. The relation for every choice of the three observables fixes HLH^{\mathrm{L}} uniquely. Inserting identities gives the single-time and pair correlations. For a qubit with Pauli observables, this is the pseudo-density matrix [8]. Supplementary Section S2 shows the construction.

If we retain only measurements of QQ, the resulting kernel is

HQ=Hpair+18[m1(Q⊗I⊗I)+m2(I⊗Q⊗I)+m3(I⊗I⊗Q)+T(Q⊗Q⊗Q)],(11)H_Q=H_{\rm pair}+\frac{1}{8}\left[m_1(Q\otimes\mathbb{I}\otimes\mathbb{I})+m_2(\mathbb{I}\otimes Q\otimes\mathbb{I})+m_3(\mathbb{I}\otimes\mathbb{I}\otimes Q)+T(Q\otimes Q\otimes Q)\right], \tag*{(11)}

where

mi=Tr⁡(HLQi),T=Tr⁡(HLQ1Q2Q3).(12)m_i=\operatorname{Tr}(H^{\rm L}Q_i),\qquad T=\operatorname{Tr}(H^{\rm L}Q_1Q_2Q_3). \tag*{(12)}

Each single-time average is measured without measurements at the other times, whereas TT is the average product of the outcomes when all three measurements are performed. The pair correlations are still obtained from their separate two-time runs.

As in HpairH_{\rm pair}, the tensor products in Eq. (11) act on two-dimensional spaces recording the outcomes. The traces in Eq. (12) instead use the physical time legs of HLH^{\rm L}. The relation between the two kernels can also be written directly. On each physical leg, let Πq\Pi_q project onto the eigenspace of the measured observable QQ with eigenvalue qq. With Πq=Πq1⊗Πq2⊗Πq3\Pi_{\mathbf q}=\Pi_{q_1}\otimes\Pi_{q_2}\otimes\Pi_{q_3}, we have

HQ=∑qTr⁡(HLΠq)∣q⟩⟨q∣.(13)H_Q=\sum_{\mathbf q}\operatorname{Tr}(H^{\rm L}\Pi_{\mathbf q})\lvert\mathbf q\rangle\langle\mathbf q\rvert. \tag*{(13)}

Thus HQH_Q keeps all the moments of QQ, but discards information about other observables. This restriction cannot increase the trace norm or the negativity. Since HQH_Q reproduces the pair correlations, it cannot have less negativity than the optimal pair kernel.

More generally, suppose additional operators are measured for the same preparation and Lüders protocol. Let AA contain these operators and the three pair products, and let Nmin⁡(A)\mathcal{N}_{\min}(A) be the least negativity among Hermitian, unit-trace kernels reproducing all their averages. Then for A⊆BA\subseteq B,

N(HL)≥N(HQ)≥N(Hpair)=Nmin⁡,\mathcal{N}(H^{\rm L})\geq\mathcal{N}(H_Q)\geq\mathcal{N}(H_{\rm pair})=\mathcal{N}_{\min},
Nmin⁡(A)≤Nmin⁡(B)≤N(HL).(14)\mathcal{N}_{\min}(A)\leq\mathcal{N}_{\min}(B)\leq\mathcal{N}(H^{\rm L}). \tag*{(14)}

The first line compares three descriptions of the same Lüders process. The second follows because adding measured averages cannot lower the minimum, while HLH^{\rm L} itself reproduces every included average. If the measurements determine the full kernel, the upper value is attained. Supplementary Sections S3 and S8 give the proofs.

For sequential Lüders measurements, every three-time LG combination obeys the known upper bound of three halves, independently of the system dimension and Hamiltonian [19, 20]. Combining this bound with Eq. (9) gives

References

  1. [1]J. S. Bell, Physics Physique Fizika 1, 195 (1964).
  2. [2]A. J. Leggett and A. Garg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 54, 857 (1985).
  3. [3]C. Emary, N. Lambert, and F. Nori, Rept. Prog. Phys. 77, 016001 (2013), arXiv:1304.5133 [quant-ph].DOI
  4. [4]G. Vitagliano and C. Budroni, Phys. Rev. A 107, 040101 (2023), arXiv:2212.11616 [quant-ph].DOI
  5. [5]A. M. Milekhin, Z. Adamska, and J. Preskill, Observable and computable entanglement in time (2025), arXiv:2502.12240 [quant-ph].
  6. [6]R. N. Das, A. Kundu, and N. C. Sarkar, Timelike Entanglement Signatures of Ergodicity and Spectral Chaos (2026), arXiv:2601.19981 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2601.19981
  7. [7]R. N. Das, A. Kundu, M. H. Martins Costa, and N. C. Sarkar, JHEP 04, 141, arXiv:2512.06078 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2512.06078
  8. [8]J. F. Fitzsimons, J. A. Jones, and V. Vedral, Sci. Rep. 5, 18281 (2015), arXiv:1302.2731 [quant-ph].
  9. [9]D. Horsman, C. Heunen, M. F. Pusey, J. Barrett, and R. W. Spekkens, Proc. Nat. Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 473, 20170395 (2017).
  10. [10]J. Fullwood and A. J. Parzygnat, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 478, 20220104 (2022), arXiv:2202.03607 [quant-ph].DOI
  11. [11]W.-z. Guo, JHEP 01, 128, arXiv:2508.20397 [hep-th].
  12. [12]J. J. Halliwell, Physical Review A 93, 10.1103/physreva.93.022123 (2016).
  13. [13]P. Solinas and S. Gherardini, Phys. Rev. A 111, 052217 (2025), arXiv:2408.00088 [quant-ph].DOI
  14. [14]J. A. de Barros, E. N. Dzhafarov, J. V. Kujala, and G. Oas, in Quantum Interaction, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 9535, edited by H. Atmanspacher, T. Filk, and E. Pothos (Springer, 2016) pp. 36–47, arXiv:1406.3088 [quant-ph].
  15. [15]H. Meng, H. Cao, W. Wang, L. Chen, and Y. Fan, Science China Physics, Mechanics & Astronomy 59, 100311 (2016).
  16. [16]H. Meng, H. Cao, W. Wang, L. Chen, and Y. Fan, Science China Physics, Mechanics & Astronomy 60, 010351 (2017).
  17. [17]C. Mawby and J. Halliwell, Phys. Rev. A 105, 022221 (2022), arXiv:2109.03118 [quant-ph].DOI
  18. [18]See Supplementary Material at URL will be inserted by publisher for the construction of the Lüders kernel, full proofs of the three-time and n-time minima, the Lüders ceiling, the qubit and spin-j calculations, and the time independence of the full-kernel spectrum.
  19. [19]C. Budroni, T. Moroder, M. Kleinmann, and O. Gü hne, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 020403 (2013), arXiv:1302.6223 [quant-ph].DOI
  20. [20]C. Budroni and C. Emary, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 050401 (2014).
  21. [21]X. Liu, H. Verma, Y. Xiao, O. Dahlsten, and M. Gu, Spatial Incompatibility Witnesses for Quantum Temporal Correlations (2025), arXiv:2511.01179 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2511.01179
  22. [22]J. von Neumann, Mathematische Grundlagen der Quantenmechanik (Springer, Berlin, 1932).
  23. [23]H. Pashayan, J. J. Wallman, and S. D. Bartlett, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 070501 (2015).
  24. [24]A. Fine, Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 291 (1982).
  25. [25]M. M. Deza and M. Laurent, Geometry of Cuts and Metrics (Springer, Berlin, 1997).DOI
  26. [26]J. J. Halliwell and C. Mawby, Phys. Rev. A 87 (2013), arXiv:1906.04865 [quant-ph].
  27. [27]J. Kofler and Č. Brukner, Phys. Rev. A 87 (2013).
  28. [28]L. Clemente and J. Kofler, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 150401 (2016), arXiv:1509.00348 [quant-ph].DOI
  29. [29]F. Barahona and A. R. Mahjoub, Math. Program. 36, 157 (1986).

Paper details

vlnc:W_375kgykd
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents