WorksPhysics and Astronomy
A No-Go Theorem of Analytical Mechanics for the Second Law Violation
Abstract
We follow the Boltzmann-Clausius-Maxwell (BCM) proposal to solve a long-standing problem of identifying the underlying cause of the second law (SL) of spontaneous irreversibility, a stochastic universal principle, as the mechanical equilibrium (stable or unstable) principle (Mec-EQ-P) of analytical mechanics of an isolated nonequilibrium system of any size. The principle leads to nonnegative system intrinsic (SI) microwork and SI-average macrowork dW during any spontaneous process. In conjuction with the first law, Mec-EQ-P leads to a generalized second law (GSL) dQ=dW>0, where dQ=TdS is the purely stochastic SI-macroheat that corresponds to dS>0 for T>0 and dS<0 for T<0, where T is the temperature. The GSL supercedes the conventional SL formulation that is valid only for a macroscopic system for positive temperatures temperatures, but reformulates it to dS<0 for negative temperatures. It is quite surprising that GSL is not only a direct consequence of intertwined mechanical and stochastic macroquantities through the first law but also remains valid for any arbitrary irreversible process in a system of any size as an identity for positive and negative temperatures. It also becomes a no-go theorem for GSL-violation unless we abandon Mec-EQ-P of analytical mechanics used in the BCM proposal, which will be catastrophic for theoretical physics. In addition, Mec-EQ-P also provides new insights into the roles of spontaneity, nonspontaneity, negative temperatures, instability, and the significance of dS<0 due to nonspontaneity and inserting internal constraints.
Even though Einstein [1] was convinced that classical thermodynamics (Cl-Th) as ” ... the only physical theory of universal content ... will never be overthrown,” and Eddington [2] considered the fundamental axiom of the second law (SL) in terms of entropy for an isolated system as its cornerstone holds ” ... the supreme position among the laws of Nature,” the recent trend has been to search for SL-violation [3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15] [16] in , whose size ranges from mesoscopic to cosmological scales, to cast doubt on Cl-Th of a nonequilibrium (NEQ) macrostate , following Maxwell [17]; here, is formed by microstates of the Hamiltonian with microenergies appearing with probabilities , . These attempts span widely different fields from information to biological thermodynamics. Do positive and negative temperatures both satisfy SL as is commonly believed [18, for example]?
There are indirect but strong arguments for a deep connection of SL with thermodynamic stability [19–30], in which a (stable) NEQ macrostate with a lower bound in energy, the continuous blue curve in Figure 1, asymptotically converges to a unique and stable equilibrium (SEQ) macrostate [30] along blue arrows. Thus, a SL-violation strongly suggests, but not yet verified, thermodynamic instability for its cause so we also consider rarely studied unstable macrostate , the continuous red curve, emerging out of its unstable equilibrium (UEQ) macrostate along red arrows; however, see [18] as exception. All arrows point towards increasing time , during which (or ) becomes less (or more) nonuniform with the entropy increasing (decreasing), with its evolution controlled by its sink (or source ) as succinctly explained in Supplementary Material [31]. We use compact notation Q for , and for . Thus, we say that controls -evolution along continuous curves, while controls -evolution along dashed-dot trajectories. We also let Q denote , , and , the last two defined later.
Figure 1. Schematic forms of microenergy (dashed-dot curves) and macrowork function (solid curves) as functions of the internal variable , with denoting EQ in . Alternatively, these curves can be considered as a function of time in , which increases along the directions of the blue and red arrows. We only consider the case when each curve has a single extremum. The discussion is easily extended to more complex forms. The blue color curves and solid blue arrows represent the evolution controlled by the stable (s) case. The red color curves and solid red arrows represent the evolution controlled by the unstable (u) case. In both cases, the arrows lower the energy. The extrema of all curves occur at and represent a uniform body. For the extremum to denote equilibrium, we must also have there. The green double-arrow is discussed in the text.
All processes in are system-intrinsic (SI) and generated internally to change . They are commonly called spontaneous [32] and are governed by SL, which is only satisfied by a macroscopic system [20, 24–26]. Any SL-violation, being uncommon and controversial, will most probably result in puzzling outcomes, not all of which are recognized or discussed so far in the current literature. Also, there is no serious inquiry into violation thermodynamics (Viol-Th) supporting it because the root cause of SL and any special stochasticity [33] for its validity are not understood; however, see [18]. A nonspontaneous process is not internally generated and requires external agent so cannot occur in .
We prove a generalized SL (GSL), not to be confused with the one proposed by Bekenstein [34, 35] for black holes, by considering in an isolated NEQ discrete system [36, 37] of any size, not necessarily . It unravels the mystery of and provides deeper insight into the root cause of SL and its violation [38]. The equality occurs in the equilibrium (EQ) macrostate having maximum entropy [39], and is always given by Gibbs’ formulation [19, 40] . There is another system of intermediate size determined by the interaction range to ensure -additivity in , which is uniform in the state space , while is uniform as expressed by [31]; here, is the fixed observable set containing energy and work parameter that uniquely specifies and . There are two distinct ways to specify . The most common approach is to use to nonuniquely specify so that its various quantities such as or have explicit dependence. In , we can focus on a of any size [31]. The alternative is to uniquely specify and in an extended state space spanned by , the extended work parameter including the internal variable [41–46] that is determined by internal structures generated by nonuniformity in and . It contains components, with increasing and decreasing with nonuniformity of . There is no explicit time dependence in and in that provides some benefit. We define so that in [31, (B)] for which . We also assume that is the same for all 's; extension to different is easily done. As explicit time dependence in in is equivalent to the implicit time dependence in and in , we can adopt either approach. We mostly use and the first approach for its simplicity. We use for any system when the state space is not specified.
The four steps below form the core of our analysis:
(S1) Describe mechanically by its deterministic by specifying and SI-microwork .
(S2) Introduce stochasticity by appending a probability to as was first proposed by Clausius, Maxwell, and Boltzmann (the BCM proposal) [17, 19, 20, 25, 30, 47, 48] to capture dissipation in , and to identify various ensemble averages such as its energy
and above. In general, is a state function only for in , but not for and . Different choices for result in different macrostates and averages for the same . A constant , , describes a pure mechanical system [33] with constant and .
(S3) Introduce the first law [31, (D)] during any infinitesimal change of to determine the allowed change and to identify the physics behind
a stochastic quantity [33], and
a mechanical quantity. The law immediately leads to the irreversibility principle (Irr-P) [44, 45] expressed by the identity
that intertwines these seemingly unrelated macroquantities similar to intertwining of electric and magnetic fields in the Maxwell theory. While they have the same sign, their sign is fixed yet. We use (S1), (S2), the first law involving and , and to formulate a generic version of NEQ statistical thermodynamics to be called General Thermodynamics (Gen-Th) for any possible by taking arbitrary for ; see Eq. (3).
(S4) Invoke the mostly overlooked fundamental principle Mec-EQ-P [49, 50] introduced below that controls (spontaneous) evolution of , , in [32] to formulate the BCM proposal for (MicroBCM) that fixes the nonnegative signature of in Lemma 1, and to directly establish the generalized second law (GSL) that controls dissipation [33] in in Theorem 2:
It requires to take a special form that not only determines but also ensures ; any form different from such as does not satisfy GSL and must be rejected under MicroBCM proposal. The nonnegative signature of after including (S4) in Gen-Th determines the (spontaneous) evolution of , and the resulting thermodynamics is denoted by Gen-GSL-Th. We combine Eqs. (1) and (2) as
in terms of the SI-temperature for any , which for [31, (E)] becomes the standard definition .
The traditional approach in CI-Th is to supplement (S1), (S2), (S3) by the SL axiom for [24] instead of (S4) and then prove its thermodynamic stability [25]. However, by reversing this approach, we succeed not only to prove GSL for any spontaneous process in and for any as a direct consequence of -evolution in (S4), but also proclaim a No-Go Theorem of theoretical physics for its violation; see Theorem 2. Our proof should be contrasted with the current situation of proving without ever mentioning ; one usually recourses to ad-hoc assumptions like molecular chaos or master equations [57, 58]. The real significance of our reverse approach becomes very transparent and unravels many mysteries of SL by recognizing fluctuating as the primitive mechanical concept that completely captures the stochasticity in and the importance of for SL. Their intertwining provides the basis for the famous fluctuation-dissipation theorem [51–53]; see also [54–56]. To our knowledge, our reverse approach with MicroBCM proposal has never been used before to directly prove SL () for and its extension requiring a reformulation of for ; the latter contradicts the conventional wisdom [18]. In addition, GSL also disproves that instability causes SL violation.
Setup: We describe the salient aspects [31] to prove Theorem 2 for in Gen-GSL-Th before justifying them. We assume [59] for simplicity that has only a single extremum at as shown by the dashed-dotted curves in Figure 1 for and , each spontaneously evolving to lower microenergies as increases along the blue and red arrows, respectively. From the Uniformity Theorem of in [31, (C)], the extremum represents a uniform microstate so the rest of the dashed-dotted curves denote nonuniform microstates ( or ). Then, is the (asymptotically) stable equilibrium of , where is minimum. Any perturbation away from always restores back to so the latter acts as a sink for which spontaneously as shown by the blue arrow; we say that controls -evolution [52] during which becomes more uniform with . At a mechanically unstable equilibrium of , is maximum; any perturbation from it to spontaneously repels it further away from . As never returns to with running away from , becomes a source controlling -evolution along the red arrow during which becomes more nonuniform with . Both are deterministic spontaneous -evolutions, whose directions are controlled by the principle of mechanical equilibrium (Mec-EQ-P) [31, (C)].
In Gen-GSL-Th for , the directional -evolution performs (Lemma 1), whose average is due to spontaneous irreversible processes [60] and from Irr-P is dissipated or wasted [33] as macroheat to ensure unchanging . Without (S4), Gen-Th also describes GSL-violation () and SL-violation (), resulting in violation thermodynamics, Viol-GSL-Th of GSL and Viol-Th of SL, for ; see [31, (C)] for various possible thermodynamics.
To make a state function for in requires an important restriction on , but not on . The resulting form of Gen-Th is called restriction thermodynamics (Rest-Th) for [31, (E)}, which still allows of either sign so in Rest-Th, unless supplemented by (S4); see Eq. (3).
JUSTIFICATION: We justify the above claims for in within Gen-GSL-Th without any restriction on possible . The claims also apply to and in without any change. A simple calculation at the end clarifies the claims for a one-particle system in .
The extremum and the form of determine the extremum and the form of () after averaging [31, (D)] for as shown by continuous curves in Figure 1. The averaging also generalizes microstate Mec-EQ-P to the thermodynamical principle of (stability and instability) equilibrium (Th-EQ-P) for in Gen-GSL-Th, according to which the extremum of controls -evolution. We must not confuse this evolution with that produced by intervention required to prepare nonuniform out of uniform by internal constraints as discusses below and in [31]; see also [24, 61]. As is, in effect, physically equivalent to a “nonexistent” microstate because of its instability, is also physically nonexistent [22, 62, 63]. Because of this, CI-Th only deals with having the sink to which it asymptotically converges. Accordingly any converges to . Despite this, we also consider to obtain additional and surprising information at the microstate level that is not available in CI-Th, and allows for a reformulation of SL for negative .
We first prove the following lemma for an equilibrium point of a mechanical and a thermodynamic .
Lemma 1 During -controlled spontaneous evolution of of in Gen-GSL-Th, performs nonnegative microwork as . Performing ensemble average with arbitrary then determines thermodynamic stability (instability) of the resulting macrostate in , which spontaneously performs nonnegative macrowork in Gen-GSL-Th as .
Proof. (a) Microstate Evolution: The extremum of at represents that is uniform in ; see Uniformity Theorem in [31, (C)]. We now consider a nonuniform away from as it spontaneously evolves towards , see red and blue arrows in Figure 1, during which spontaneously decreases to so that . Thus, performs spontaneous nonnegative microwork during its evolution towards given by
(b) Macrostate Evolution: We now average over and using arbitrary to obtain macroquantities of and , respectively, in Gen-GSL-Th. The mechanical equilibrium microstate determines the thermodynamic EQ macrostate . The macrowork function gives for thermodynamic EQ and uniform macrostate in [31, (C)]. The spontaneous process results in the nonnegative spontaneous macrowork
This completes the proof. ■
We recall that there is no sign restriction on and in Gen-Th of . We now prove the main Theorem.
Theorem 2 We consider in . The spontaneous -evolution of any in Gen-GSL-Th during which it either converges to the sink for or runs away from the source for directly leads to GSL in Eq. (2), making it internally consistent with analytical mechanics. A violation of GSL requires that cannot occur in so the theorem is a No-Go Theorem for GSL violation. The due to instability in the spontaneous evolution in is not a violation of SL because of its negative . This makes Viol-GSL-Th and Viol-Th inconsistent with analytical mechanics and the BCM proposal.
Proof. In Gen-GSL-Th, the isolated in either spontaneously relaxes as increases to during which or runs off from during which . As , we have from Lemma 1. It then follows from Eq. (2) that the corresponding spontaneous macroheat is nonnegative, which proves GSL in Eq. (3) for any in , and establishes its consistency with Mech-EQ-P of analytical mechanics. A GSL-violation can only happen if such as along the double green arrow in Figure 1 near . As this evolution violates Lemma 1, it is nonspontaneous and cannot occur in . This makes any GSL violation impossible and turns the theorem into a No-Go theorem for GSL-violation. The requirement is consistent with and for , and and for . The instability in and during its spontaneous evolution does not imply violating SL, contrary to the comment at the start [18, for example]. It is also clear that Viol-GSL-Th and Viol-Th can only hold for nonspontaneous processes. As they cannot occur in , they are inconsistent with analytical mechanics and the BCM proposal. This completes the proof. ■
It is instructive to consider, as an example, a two-level particle as our system . The entropy is , where and are the probabilities of the two levels. Then, . The maximum of occurs at , which represents the EQ point. For any other value of , the behavior is different for and . In the former case, brings and closer to the EQ point making it a sink, while in the latter case, and move away from the EQ point making it a source. This is consistent with our discussion above and brings out the difference of to vividly. To make the example more interesting, we need to associate energies to the two level. We capture nonuniformity of the system by adding small contributions and to the equilibrium energies and , respectively, so that and . We also take and , with a small quantity. We keep only leading order terms. For and , we are considering ; see the blue solid curve. Along the blue arrow, we have , and . From Irr-P, we have , which is the condition for , as is easily seen from equating , and , and , , making the system more uniform and . For and , we are considering ; see the red solid curve. Along the red arrow, we again have but as system becomes more nonuniform. In both cases, so GSL remains intact, but the behavior of shows that as expected.
DISCUSSION: We are ready to highlight our findings and discuss their tantalizing consequences. Gen-Th for always satisfies the first law [31, (D)] (from which follows Irr-P in (S2)) for any that determines . Irr-P intertwines and , but without imposing restrictions on [33] so has either sign but always determined by . It is here the relevance of microscopic Mec-EQ-P for , which has not been properly recognized so far, becomes central in our reverse approach to finally identify Mec-EQ-P as the root cause of the stochastic principle of GSL/SL that is surprisingly and completely determined by mechanical works and alone in Gen-GSL-Th for . Thus, GSL is a consequence of analytical mechanics, the foundation of the BCM proposal, with directly related to depending on , respectively. This provides a direct proof of SL for for and , and extends it to for and , a very tantalizing extension, which corrects a common misconception of SL about negative [18]. As negative temperatures are not physically impossible [18, 25, 64, 65], it is quite surprising to realize that is not a violation of SL, if . This has been recognized before; however, see [66]. Thus, Gen-GSL-Th supersedes Cl-Th for . In addition, Viol-Th and Viol-GSL-Th cannot be taken as a viable possibility within the BCM proposal.
It is clear from the above theorem that alone without any reference to cannot be used to describe SL or its violation, a point that has not been appreciated so far and highlights the role of for SL.
For a genuine GSL/SL violation in , we need nonspontaneous evolution requiring and for , and and for . During this evolution, becomes less and less uniform () and becomes more and more uniform (). Thus, runs off from the uniform sink catastrophically to asymptotically approach an extremely nonuniform macrostates so that as if is unstable. Similarly, runs towards and terminates in the uniform source along the direction opposite to red arrows with increasing to as if is stable. Both possibilities require some external agent that, for example, inserts an internal partition for () to obtain by manipulating () to drive () run away from (towards) the sink () in a nonspontaneous manner; see [31, (E)], where various possibilities are discussed. If is now detached from , the result will be an internal constraint discussed by Callen [24], removal of which will initiate spontaneous processes to increase the entropy in accordance with GSL/SL as it must. A similar situation occurs in the demon paradox [17, 67–69], in which the demon starts manipulating in a nonspontaneous manner as discussed recently [61, 69].
Th-EQ-P for becomes a consequence of SL in Cl-Th for . Instead, we prove not only Th-EQ-P for and but also GSL for by using (S4), i.e., Mec-EQ-P, of analytic mechanics (instead of SL) in Gen-GSL-Th. This shows the strength of our reverse approach. As and asymptotically converge to and , respectively, by removing nonuniformity gradually, continuously increases and reaches its maximum. As and runs away from and , respectively, by increasing nonuniformity gradually, continuously decreases and reaches some minimum , even though GSL remains valid so this case corresponds to . With (S4) in Gen-GSL-Th, BCM proposal imposes a very strong constraint of nonnegativity on for . The nonnegative average through Irr-P determines , which imposes a restriction on to have a particular form to ensure . Another important finding is that Theorem 2 also becomes the No-Go theorem so that that GSL-violation requires rejecting (S4), i.e., Mec-EQ-P and, therefore, the BCM proposal, a prospect that has not been recognized so far. Indeed, the violation cannot be taken as a viable possibility as it defies analytic mechanics. The conclusion provides not only a tantalizing insight into SL-violation in for the first time by recognizing that Viol-Th requires rejecting analytical mechanics, but is also a testament to the robustness of the BCM proposal. This elevates Mec-EQ-P to be of primary relevance for thermodynamic foundation of GSL/SL in Gen-GSL-Th, and clarifies the significance of ”asymptotic approach to stable equilibrium” for a thermodynamic system in in time after being momentarily disturbed [22, 24, 62, 70] from , which forms the cornerstone of Cl-Th. We also extend GSL/SL now to cover , where negative plays an important role. Thus, SL must always be stated along with , a fact that has not been appreciated.
Thermodynamic behavior of in Figure 1 can also be used to obtain GSL/SL [31, (D)], but we have used to emphasize their mechanical nature.
References
it will always refer to nonvanishing and nonvanishing as discussed in the text. We use dissipation to always mean converting to , but use irreversibility to imply any signature of .
Supplementary Material
We consider an isolated mechanical system containing particles, which is then treated thermodynamically following the BCM proposal introduced in the main text. Its deterministic Hamiltonian with no explicit time dependence is a function of , denoting the set of positions and momenta of particles and specified by the fixed set of extensive observable work parameters (including , volume , etc. but not energy ) of . Its microstates of energies are also time-independent and depend only on of the entire and not of its various parts. We express this fact of stationarity by saying that , and are uniform in , which is in the spirit of and consistent with the well-known result of equilibrium (EQ) thermodynamics [1] that an EQ macrostate is uniform in the set of its state variables that defines the EQ state space . As a consequence of uniformity, and can neither perform any mechanical work nor generate any mechanical power. Various system-intrinsic (SI) EQ functions including entropy of remain time independent. (From now on, we will mostly suppress for unless necessary as it is fixed.) In a nonequilibrium (NEQ) macrostate of that we are interested in, all SI-quantities such as , , and in must change in time so they acquire an explicit time dependence; see, for example, Eq. (9) that captures this observation for microwork and micropower by microstate [2]. This time-dependence is a result of nonuniformity among various disjoined but mutually interacting uniform subsystems with Hamiltonians in terms of work variables , ; nonuniformity results in internal flows among that affect so a NEQ and are individually nonuniform in and , respectively. For the isolated system, all SI-changes in it such as and are generated internally and are commonly identified as spontaneous. They are governed by the second law (SL) in classical thermodynamics (Cl-Th) [3]. A nonspontaneous process, which is never under the purview of SL, cannot occur in . For it to occur, intervention from an outside agent that may also include Maxwell’s demon [4] is required to disturb . The intervention only creates an internal constraint as discussed by Callen [3], whose removal, however, is controlled by SL.
In (B) below, we show that nonuniformity in can be described precisely in terms of a set of internal variables [5, 6, 7, 8] if we restrict the size of subsystems to satisfy quasi-additivity of their energies. This requires imposing size restriction on , which is denoted by . We introduce as the work variable and as the state variable that determines a NEQ state space for . The explicit time dependence of in is fully equivalent to the implicit dependence only through in ; see Eq. (13).
For NEQ statistical mechanics, we follow the BCM proposal and consider an ensemble in which appears with probability , see (D) below; they together define various macrostates for the same set but different sets , which define the entropy by its Gibbs-Shannon formulation [9] for as the ensemble average of microentropy ,
which is easy to verify, see for example [10], for any arbitrary collection . The validity of the above is based on the use of Stirling’s approximation. We will not be concerned about the error in the approximation and accept the formula to be the definition of . To make the subsystems entropies additive, we require to be a state function in , which requires a further restriction on the size as macroscopic (M) to capture quasi-independence of subsystems. We denote this macroscopic system by to be uniquely specified in ; in contrast, and are not uniquely specified in and , respectively. We use to denote any of the three systems and any possible subsystems when we are not interested in specifying the state space.
| Table of Various Forms of Thermodynamics in the text | |
| Gen-Th | (S1), (S2), (S3) for , |
| Cl-Th | Gen-Th and SL axiom for |
| Rest-Th | Gen-Th for with state function |
| Viol-Th | Gen-Th for with |
| Gen-GSL-Th | Gen-Th and (S4) for with |
| Viol-GSL-Th | Gen-Th and (S4) for with |
Table 1.
In NEQ thermodynamics, is the most convenient state space as it requires no knowledge of any internal nonuniformity that is hidden from the observer and may not always be known, but requires an explicit time dependence such as in ; see Figure 1 in main text. Despite this, the choice of helps to explain not only the origin of explicit time dependence resulting from nonuniformity but also to justify the nonstandard definition of in Eq. (7). The first law and macroheat , see (D), for play a central role in proving the generalized second law (GSL); both can be directly introduced without identifying . But we need to relate GSL to to also directly prove the second law (SL) , and to shed light on the possible significance of in its violation, which is one of our goals. In most cases of interest shown by the solid blue curve [1], attempts to thermodynamically minimize nonuniformity in by reducing internal flows and become uniform as continue to increase as explained below. As is fixed, we introduce a NEQ temperature as the ratio , which we also simply write as
in any infinitesimal internal process within . While this definition is unconventional, it is indeed the conventional definition for as seen later from Eqs. (28) and (37). Thus, we take above to represent the temperature for any number of particles in .
(A), (B) and (C) below are based on step (S1), see main text, only and deal with microstates of the nonuniform deterministic Hamiltonian . (A) deals with it in to show the explicit time dependence in , which is related to the implicit time-dependence of in introduced in (B). (C) introduces the Mechanical Equilibrium Principle (Mec-EQ-P) of Energy [11], which forms step (S4). This step is required to complete the BCM proposal by connecting it to analytical mechanics. and their thermodynamics in and are considered next. (D) requires step (S2) with any arbitrary to identify a general NEQ macrostates , and develop its first law for any . This results in (S3) and the General thermodynamics (Gen-Th) but without invoking Mec-EQ-P for any possible . (E) puts macroscopic size restriction and considers to ensure is additive and a state function in .
Various forms of thermodynamics that we consider are listed in the table and in the main text.
Mechanical Systems
(A) MECHANICAL SYSTEMS : We first consider the mechanical system in that is specified by given in terms of and with explicit time dependence. Let denote one of its microstates with microenergy so that
as the first term vanishes due to Hamilton’s equations of motion. As this term includes the effect of interparticle potentials, we are not interested in those potentials so we will no longer exhibit , which is explicitly identified by the suffix . Instead, we are interested in that is determined solely by varying the parameter [12]. We write as or simply ; similarly, we simply write for unless clarity is needed. The SI-microwork can be expressed in terms of instantaneous power in as
Similarly, the mechanical system in a microstate in is specified by , which now depends on the set of work parameters of , see (B) below, that determines the microwork as we now explain. We remark that is assumed to be the same for all microstates so it does not carry the suffix , while the microforce in Eq. (11) and do so the latter are fluctuating (over ). We will not consider here the case when is fluctuating (over ), to which the present method is easily extended [13, 14]. The significance of becomes clear when we consider the microenergy of , for which
by using the same argument as used in Eq. (8). As above, we simply denote by , and by unless clarity is needed. The SI-microforce, also known as the generalized microforce, in is given by
and the SI-microwork done by it is given by
which clarifies the significance of as the work parameter for . In NEQ thermodynamics, the macroscopic analog (ensemble average , see (D) below) of determines the affinity [5, 6] associated with . For us, describes nonuniformity and changes spontaneously with time in accordance with the principle of mechanical equilibrium, called Mec-EQ-P; see (C) below, the main text and [11 p. 99]. Thus, continues to change with and results in the above microwork. The corresponding instantaneous microstate power in is
which can be used in Eq. (9) to obtain . We thus see that implicit time-dependence in for in is equivalent to the explicit time dependence in without any for . The variation of for an isolated system in as shown in Figure 1 in the main text with can also be treated as time variation of in . This is also consistent with the way a time-dependent Hamiltonian is treated in mechanics [12] by considering as a parameter in the Hamiltonian so we can use instead of , in which case Eq. (12) reduces to Eq. (9) obtained in , where has no restriction on its size. We will not be concerned with the actual time dependence of in in this investigation; all we need to remember that it can be accounted for by an explicit time dependence in and other quantities for in .
According to the discussion above, we can consider either explicitly (to be specified in (B) below) and use the state space , or consider instead in the state space without any specification of . In the former case, microstates are specified in , which restricts to . NEQ temperature in Eq. (7) is always defined.
Internal Variables for Mechanical Microstates
(B) INTERNAL VARIABLES FOR MECHANICAL MICROSTATES OF : We now turn to the definition of internal variable [5, 6, 7, 8] for a deterministic nonuniform mechanical system , but denote it by to simplify notation unless clarity is needed. For simplicity, we consider it to be formed by two different and disjoined but mutually interacting subsystems and that are each uniform in . The internal variables are required to uniquely specify in ; they are not specified uniquely in . We use suffixes for and no suffix for . We consider , and in microstate , and of energy , and , respectively. We also introduce and . If we neglect the energy due to the interface between and , the Hamiltonians of the three bodies (we do not show them their arguments , and , respectively, but use microstate suffixes) are related by
which ensures microenergy quasi-additivity
which can be justified only if we restrict the minimum sizes of and to be some that itself is determined by the range of inter-particle interactions. Under this conditions, we denote , , and by , , and , and we have . However, for the sake of notational simplicity, we suppress E in the suffix for various quantities except for bodies.
The discussion in (A) applies to any and . In general, is much smaller in size than . The additivity of extensive (which is not) work parameters and in (16) is not affected by the presence or absence of so that we can introduce the extensive work parameter set
We introduce a new extensive internal variable set , where
and the extensive work parameter
are independent variables for in that and form pairs of independent variables. The introduction of is to ensure that the number of variables on both sides in (14) are equal as they must be for an equality. We also have
We can easily extend the above discussion to any numbers of subsystems , forming , each specified by its own observable set to allow for a complex form of nonuniformity in terms of uniform subsystems; Eq. (15) remains valid for any . It is easy to verify that all internal variables in , whose number we denote by , can be expressed as a linear combinations of [8, 13], with and increasing with the degree of nonuniformity of . Even though the definition of is not unique, we choose it for convenience so that it vanishes when is uniform i.e., in EQ as defined in Eq. (14). The set forms the complete set of variables to uniquely specify of in . It is easily verified that
a consequence of independent and so the variation of does not generate any SI-microwork for any . This explains why it is not included in , in which remains constant as evolves in time; however, continues to change due to internal flows.
Here, we focus on two () subsystems and of , for simplicity, each of which is uniform (no internal variables for them) but is not. We let specify uniform microstates , in . We now focus on the nonuniform microstate of , which require internal variables along with and to be specified in . We keep observables and of fixed along with and of and . Following (17), we have
to identify for .
Densities in and are equal in a uniform microstate of so and need not be considered. This is consistent with the fact that uniform is uniquely specified in . In this case, we have a trivial additivity of the Hamiltonians in (14) given by
with no internal flows between subsystems. In a nonuniform microstate, . We recall that is fixed for but and can change due to possible transfers (internal flows) between and with . It follows from (19) that
for .
As , i.e., in (18) for is the work variable in (we suppress as it is constant), corresponding to is only a function of due to (20). This is shown in Figure 1 in main text. As continuously changes due to transfers between and , this causes variations in . The variation is similar to the variation in for a in as discussed in (A).
In summary, as long as an internal variable is used, the system is restricted to be at least in size and requires for unique specification. There is no explicit time dependence in this state space. If considerations of subsystems are not important in any discussion then quasi-additivity is not an issues as is the case for the discussion of (9). In that case, can be considered as a whole in ; there is no need to consider separately, which is included in . Thus, the mechanical situation here is that of (A).
(C) MECHANICAL EQUILIBRIUM PRINCIPLE OF ENERGY (MEC-EQ-P) FOR : Time-independent microstates of a Hamiltonian system, being uniform as demonstrated by the Uniformity Theorem below, play an important role in our approach as we explain now. Any nonuniformity in endows with explicit time dependence as for or implicit time dependence through as for or as shown by and ; see dashed-dotted blue and red curves, respectively; the directions of blue and red arrows on them denote increasing during their temporal SI-evolution controlled by internally generated processes that are mechanically spontaneous and generate micropower . In analytical mechanics, there is no dissipation in evolution but is special in that its evolution will normally undergo oscillations about that will persist forever as manifested by the dashed-dot blue curve in Figure 1 in main text; in contrast, the evolution of has no oscillation, see the dashed-dot red curve there, as runs away from but terminates is a catastrophe in which becomes extremely nonuniform, which for or corresponds to an extremely large ; see (E) below. Thus, is the source for the SI-evolution of .
As we are eventually interested in and in a thermodynamic setting, there will be macroheat to be be simultaneously considered that we discuss in (D) below. As is well known, its presence gives rise to dissipation so all stable thermodynamic processes in terminate asymptotically at as shown by the solid blue curve in the figure. Keeping this in hindsight, we intentionally overlook oscillations in as they do not affect the change in during its SI-evolution to only, making the latter as the sink for the SI-evolution of . This is a useful strategy, since oscillations become thermodynamically irrelevant as asymptotically approaches ; see below. This also clarifies the importance of the uniform microstate ; see the UniformityTheorem below.
We first treat , whose results pave the way for a clear understanding of what to expect for . In analytical mechanics, the temporal evolution of and in is controlled by , and is governed by the emergent SI-microforce in Eq. (10) by controlling internal flows within . The emergent processes in resulting in the SI-microwork in Eq. (11) are commonly identified as spontaneous since they are internally controlled by SI-microforce and not from the outside by any nonsystem microforce. The mechanical equilibrium (Mec-EQ) point at is the equilibrium point [11] in the SI-evolution under the SI-microforce , where not only the SI-internal velocity but also the SI-microforce vanish:
It follows from Eq. (21b) that this point represents an extremum in ; see Figure 1 in main text. Its minimum at representing a mechanically stable EQ point enunciates the mechanical asymptotic stability principle of minimum energy. In thermodynamics, stability refers to asymptotic stability in that the system must eventually approach stable equilibrium so that as [3]. In this sense, we see that the absolute value behaves similar to in the figure. The asymptotic approach is a stronger requirement than just imposing stability in which the system never strays far away from stable EQ point. In contrast, the maximum of at representing a mechanically unstable EQ point enunciates the mechanical instability principle of maximum energy. In this case, behaves similar to in the figure. Both kinds of points are determined by the curvature of at . The two principles are collectively called Mec-EQ-P in this investigation.
We now prove the following important theorem emphasizing the physical significance of the uniformity of the Mec-EQ point for thermodynamic stability, which must exist only in at , where exists.
Theorem 3 Uniformity Theorem of : The Mec-EQ point of is stationary and uniform microstate with no internal flows between the microstates of its uniform subsystems.
Proof. We begin by considering a microstate for in to establish that is stationary. The asymptotic convergence of to as means that must be stationary so it must be a uniform microstate of the time-independent Hamiltonian . The instability of is due to the instability of the in this case so it is also uniform.
As contains no information about its internal structure, it cannot be used to understand internal flows for which we need to at least consider to justify the remainder part of the theorem. From (24), we obtain and . Using first in (23), we conclude that , which follows directly from (22). Using then in (23) along with , we conclude that . Together, they show that all flows cease at , which makes stationary and, therefore, uniform as above. Any nonzero is due to nonuniformity, and affects as shown in Figure 1 in main text. This completes the proof of the theorem. ▪
It should be clear from the above mechanical proof of the theorem that any time-dependent must be uniform and stationary only at the equilibrium point for . Away from it, must be nonuniform.
The First Law and General Thermodynamics (Gen-Th) for
So far, we have only considered the step (S1), see main text. We now take the step (S2) and introduce stochasticity by considering an ensemble of in which appears with probability , but without invoking Mec-EQ-P discussed in (C). It should be stressed that the deterministic Hamiltonian is oblivious to so is also oblivious to in that all its microquantities such as do not change with . Despite this, they together define various macrostates for the same set but different sets . We put no restrictions on possible sets so the resulting macrostates may have nothing to do with what we encounter in classical thermodynamics (Cl-Th), see the table above, and their thermodynamics, to be called general thermodynamics (Gen-Th), may not always satisfy the second law () that is a fundamental axiom (or assumption) in Cl-Th [3] as we will see below. By taking arbitrary will allow us to determine the root cause of the second law of Cl-Th and what will cause its violation in the violation thermodynamics (Viol-Th), both of them are contained in Gen-Th.
The macroenergy of in Gen-Th is given by the ensemble average
which is valid for any . It follows from this that
From Eq. (11) in (A), we observe that the second sum gives the negative of the SI-macrowork
as the ensemble average of SI-microwork . We identify the first sum, which is , with SI-macroheat as the ensemble average of SI-microheat
where is the Gibbs probability index [9]. It should be stressed that the above identification of does not require any size restriction on and any notion of temperature or entropy; see below. We thus obtain the statement of the first law
for in terms of and , both defined for any . This completes the step (S3). It should be clear that and are the primary concepts in the first law and Gen-Th, making them equivalent as both are independent of SL ().
We observe that in so that
where is the probability of , and is the macroenergy of . We use this fact in the first law in Eq. (28) to obtain a simple but very remarkable and extremely profound result
which provides the mechanical formulation by of the stochasticity inherent in the thermodynamic process through . We conclude that the stochasticity, i.e., the change in is strongly constrained by the mechanical work and its signature for any . Because of this constraint, we call Eq. (29) the irreversibility principle (Irr-P) under steps (S1-S3), which is valid for an isolated of any size, and is a direct consequence of the first law.
We show in Lemma 1 in the main text that the inequality is satisfied in any spontaneous infinitesimal process controlled by Mec-EQ-P. As a consequence, must only happen in any nonspontaneous infinitesimal process that violates Mec-EQ-P.
This completes the discussion of Gen-Th and the first law in it.
As remains constant in , it represents an isentropic macroquantity to justify it as a mechanical quantity, the average of the change ; see Eq. (22a). On the other hand, does not remain constant in so it justifies as a stochastic quantity undergoing entropy change but the two are not simply related in all cases as discussed below.
We are interested in the microwork done during the -controlled evolution of along a trajectory in a thermodynamic process in . The accumulated microwork along in step (S1) follows from Eq. (9), and is given by
by the microenergy change along ; recall Eq. (20). In step (S2), its ensemble average over yields the SI-macrowork
in Gen-Th; it remains valid even if remains constant over . In the cumulative form of Eq. (29), we have the identity
where is given by
and exists if and only if does not remain constant during . This is consistent with the conventional wisdom that the concept of heat does not apply to mechanical bodies for which . While is determined by the instantaneous value of along , it does not determine how it changes along it. The latter is determined by and determines .
The macroworks and play an important role in understanding the function shown in Figure 1. We first introduce the cumulative macrowork
along a process starting from EQ point to some point on solid curves in Figure 1. We immediately see that is in the direction opposite to the blue arrow for but in the direction of the red arrow for . We use it to introduce a macrowork function
of or . It is this average that is shown in Figure 1, and differs from by the cumulative macrowork . We see that
a result that provides an equivalent justification of GSL, which is thermodynamically more intuitive regarding the role of the extremum of in the evolution of . We have focused on microstates to emphasize the role of mechanics for deriving GSL.
Different components of take different times when they vanish. They are called relaxation times so the components can be ordered according to them [10] as fast and slow. As or evolves in time, they appear or disappear at different times, making more or less uniform, a point that is discussed in (C). For a single in the figure in the main text, () becomes more and more (less and less) uniform as increases so that during any infinitesimal change .
Restriction Thermodynamics (Rest-Th)
We now put a particular form of restriction on for in of that ensures that its becomes a state function of its and , which in turn means that is a state function of and in , whereas it is not a state function for . Using as a state function , and fixed, we obtain the Gibbs fundamental relation
where is the thermodynamic temperature of , , are SI-macroforces, and . It is the first law now in terms of and and yields the restriction thermodynamics (Rest-Th), which is nothing but Gen-Th for . The first term is nothing but in Eq. (28), which immediately establishes
It should be noted that the relationship [8] is simply a the mathematical consequence of the state function . However, the functional dependence still does not enforce SL () as was also the case for Gen-Th, so Rest-Th allows us to make direct connection with Cl-Th and Viol-Th. the justification for keeping in the new formulation will be justified in the main text within the context of generalized SL (GSL). We thus note that and have the same signature for positive , but opposite signature for negative .
From Eq. (37) follows a simple but very remarkable and extremely profound relation
for in Gen-Th (we add an extra suffix as a reminder that is fixed, and should not be confused the suffix in ) so it remains valid both in Cl-Th and Viol-Th for :
But what is most remarkable about Eq. (38) is that it provides a purely mechanical definition of stochastic entropy change by using the first law that holds in all kinds of thermodynamics discussed here. In addition, we also see from this equation that for here is no different than in Eq. (7) for of any size so we use the latter as the definition of for any system of any size.
This completes the introduction of the Rest-Th (we remove the extra suffix in Eq. (39) for simplicity), which is applied below to a macrostate of used for Eq. (21), in which must be replaced by its ensemble average . A simple calculation using the state function and yields
where , , and , are the inverse temperature and pressure of and , respectively, and is the inverse temperature of . The two terms on the right side in Eq. (40) represent entropic contributions due to the two internal variables and in Rest-Th; each must be nonnegative for SL or negative for its violation. In terms of as the macroenergy change and as the volume change of , we have
Using introduced by Ramsey [15], whose numerical values define the ”hotness” of as it increases from to covering positive and negative temperatures, Eq. (40) becomes
for in Rest-Th, where , and ; means that is hotter than , and vice-versa. For GSL to hold, we require in to be for () and for (). For GSL violation, we require for and for . Both situations are considered in the main text. Let us consider just the first term above to be specific by setting . We consider various scenarios; (a) and (b) refer to having , and (c) and (d) refer to having . The analysis here is more extensive compared to an earlier preliminary and incomplete investigation [13], where the issue of catastrophic evaluation was first discussed.
(a) For and , we must have for so that macroheat flows from hot to cold as expected in which it converges to due to an attractive SI-macroforce pointing towards . The SI-evolution of is spontaneous due to pointing towards its sink . Therefore, as expected in this case, so Cl-Th and Gen-GSL-Th remain valid. This is the most common situation.
(b) For and , so that macroheat flows from cold to hot, and $\mathcal{M}^s
runs away from due to some repulsive macroforce , distinct from the SI-macroforce , to eventually converge to by becoming more and more nonuniform. The evolution of is not spontaneous as is in (a) and is no longer the sink. In this case, (Viol-Th), but we also violate GSL (Gen–GSL-Th).
(c) For but for , so that macroheat flows from cold to hot and becomes more and more nonuniform because of the instability in it as discussed in the main text. The spontaneous evolution of from its source under the repulsive SI-macroforce is catastrophic in that it converges to a catastrophic macrostate . In this case, so SL is violated (Viol-Th) but GSL (Gen–GSL-Th) remains valid.
(d) For and , we must have so that macroheat flows from hot to cold in . In this case, nonspontaneously converges to due to an attractive macroforce, which is distinct from the repulsive SI-macroforce , with so CI-Th remains valid but not Gen–GSL-Th. Thus, is no longer the source for -evolution.
We analyze nonspontaneous processes further. We first consider (b). As runs away from its sink to a new macrostate , the latter further runs away from by its deviating further from their values in . Thus, we get successive macrostates , which run away from the sink farther and farther, during which remains non-positive as increases. Therefore, the evolution to is catastrophic in that it makes highly nonuniform due to unexplained nonsystem repelling macroforce that mutilates .
It follows from the stability of considered here that and are also stable so their specific heats at constant volume are nonnegative. As , the disparity continues to increase with getting more hot and getting more cold, until takes its maximum value in .
We now consider (d), where a similar discussion can also be carried out for but different conclusions. Here, gets more uniform but the uniformity is not due to SI-macroforce so the evolution is not governed by SL. On the other hand, the catastrophe in (c) occurs spontaneously at negative so should be treated as being governed by SL. Thus, GSL seems to capture spontaneous processes at both positive and negative temperatures. In this sense, GSL subsumes SL.
The discussion is easily extended to include the second term in Eq. (41) with same conclusions, which is consistent with Lemma in the main text.
We clearly see from (a) and (d) that is not always a consequence of spontaneous processes. In (d), it is a consequence not only of negative but also of negative performed by nonsystem forces that result in a nonspontaneous process. This process is not controlled by SL so has no significance. Similarly, in (b) and (c) shows that it is not always a consequence of nonspontaneous processes. In (b), it is a consequence only of negative performed by nonsystem forces that result in a nonspontaneous process such as during the creation of internal constraints as explained by Callen [3]. Again, this process is not controlled by SL, while SI-macrowork or the removal of the internal constraint is controlled by SL so in (d) has no significance for SL-violation. From (a) and (c), we observe that GSL is always a consequence of spontaneous processes, but fails for nonspontaneous processes in (b) and (c).
References
- [1]L.D. Landau and E.M. Lifshitz, Statistical Physics, Third Ed., Pergamon Press, Oxford (1980).
- [2]The prefix micro- is used for quantities pertaining to microstates, while macro- is used for quantities pertaining to macrostates.
- [3]H.B. Callen, Thermodynamics and an introduction to thermostatis, Second Ed, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1985).
- [4]J.C. Maxwell, Theory of Heat, Longmans, Green, and Co., London (1902).
- [5]S.R. de Groot and P. Mazur, Nonequilibrium Thermodynamics, First Edition, Dover, New York (1984).
- [6]D. Kondepudi and I. Prigogine, Modern Thermodynamics, John Wiley and Sons, West Sussex (1998).
- [7]G.A. Maugin, The Thermodynamics of Nonlinear Irreversible Behaviors: An Introduction, World Scientific, Singapore (1999).
- [8]P.D. Gujrati, Entropy, 23, 1584 (2021).
- [9]J.W. Gibbs, Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics, Scribner’s Sons, N.Y. (1902).
- [10]P.D. Gujrati, Entropy 20, 149 (2018).
- [11]A.I. Arnold, Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, Second Ed, Springer-Verlag, New York (1989).
- [12]L.D. Landau and E.M. Lifshitz, Mechanics, Third Ed., Pergamon Press, Oxford (1976).
- [13]P.D. Gujrati, Foundations, 1, 1 (2023).
- [14]P.D. Gujrati, Phys. Rev. E 102, 012140 (2020).
- [15]N.F. Ramsey, Phys. Rev. 103, 20 (1956).
