betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

A Counterexample to Voiculescu's Normal Dilation Conjecture

Abstract

We construct a compact operator TT with trace class self-commutator and vanishing Helton-Howe measure such that T⊕S−M∉S2T\oplus S-M\notin \mathcal{S}_2 for every bounded operator SS and every bounded normal operator MM. This gives counterexamples to Voiculescu's normal dilation and stable classification conjectures. The construction uses magnetic shifts on finite square tori. Their real parts have commutators of uniformly bounded trace norm, while their frame errors admit logarithmic lower bounds in the lattice size. A summability criterion for frame error turns these finite-dimensional estimates into a compact counterexample. The same operator inequalities yield a rank profile invariant under Hilbert-Schmidt perturbations and normal stabilization, which distinguishes the example from zero.

Introduction

In the 70s, Brown, Douglas, and Fillmore [2, 3] beautifully classified essentially normal operators by developing the operator theoretic realization of KK-homology theory. This development inspired a fundamental interaction between functional analysis and topology, e.g. [5].

Let TT be an essentially normal operator. The image [T][T] of TT in the Calkin algebra is normal. The Brown-Douglas-Fillmore theory shows that the essential spectrum of TT defined by [T][T] and the Fredholm index of T−zIT-zI on the complement of the essential spectrum determine its unitary equivalence class modulo the compact operators. Since then, researchers have been exploring an analogous problem for almost-normal operators and Hilbert–Schmidt perturbations.

Let S1S_1 and S2S_2 denote the trace class and Hilbert–Schmidt class, equipped with the norms

∥K∥1=Tr⁡∣K∣,∥K∥22=Tr⁡(K∗K).\lVert K\rVert_1 = \operatorname{Tr}|K|,\qquad\lVert K\rVert_2^2 = \operatorname{Tr}(K^*K).

An operator TT is called almost normal if

[T∗,T]∈S1[T^*,T] \in S_1

Write T=A+iBT=A+iB, where AA and BB are bounded and self-adjoint. Observe that [T∗,T]=2i[A,B][T^*,T]=2i[A,B]. So TT is almost normal if and only if [A,B]∈S1[A,B]\in S_1.

Helton and Howe [9, 10] associated to a pair of bounded self-adjoint operators AA, BB with [A,B]∈S1[A,B]\in S_1 a compactly supported finite signed Borel measure PTP_T on R2\mathbb{R}^2, where T=A+iBT=A+iB, that records traces of polynomial commutators. With the normalization of [26 §2.3], PTP_T satisfies

Tr⁡[P(A,B),Q(A,B)]=12πi∫R2(∂xP ∂yQ−∂yP ∂xQ) dPT(1)\operatorname{Tr}[P(A,B),Q(A,B)] = \frac{1}{2\pi i}\int_{\mathbb{R}^2}(\partial_xP\,\partial_yQ-\partial_yP\,\partial_xQ)\,dP_T \tag*{(1)}

2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 47B20. Secondary 47A20, 47B10.

Key words and phrases. Almost normal operators, normal dilation, Hilbert–Schmidt perturbations, magnetic holonomy, Helton–Howe measure.

for P,Q∈C[x,y]P,Q \in\mathbb{C}[x,y]. The measure PTP_T is absolutely continuous, and its density is called the Pincus principal function. Carey and Pincus [4] related the principal function to the Fredholm index. The trace formula (1.1) gives invariance of PTP_T under trace-class perturbations, which change each polynomial evaluation by a trace-class operator.

In 1981, Voiculescu [23] proved that two almost-normal operators differing by a Hilbert–Schmidt operator have the same Helton–Howe measure when one has finite multicyclicity. He asked for analogues of the Brown–Douglas–Fillmore theory for almost normal operators with Hilbert–Schmidt perturbations.

Voiculescu [23 p. 317], [25], and [26 §2.5] proposed the following conjectures about the classification of almost normal operators up to Hilbert–Schmidt perturbations on a separable infinite-dimensional Hilbert space H\mathcal{H}.

Conjecture 1.1. ([26 Conjecture 3]) If T1T_1 and T2T_2 are almost normal on a Hilbert space H\mathcal{H} and PT1=PT2P_{T_1}=P_{T_2}, then there are a bounded normal operator NN on H\mathcal{H} and a unitary WW on H⊕H\mathcal{H}\oplus\mathcal{H} such that

T1⊕N−W(T2⊕N)W∗∈S2.(2)T_1\oplus N-W(T_2\oplus N)W^* \in\mathcal{S}_2. \tag*{(2)}

Conjecture 1.2. ([26 Conjecture 4]) For every almost normal TT on H\mathcal{H}, there are an almost-normal SS on H\mathcal{H} and a bounded normal MM on H⊕H\mathcal{H}\oplus\mathcal{H} such that

T⊕S−M∈S2.(3)T\oplus S-M\in\mathcal{S}_2. \tag*{(3)}

Several classes of operators are known to satisfy the normal dilation conclusion. In 1983, Pasnicu proved [19] that a unilateral weighted shift with nonnegative weights an↑aa_n \uparrow a satisfies Conjecture 1.2 if ∑n(a−an)p<∞\sum_n(a-a_n)^p<\infty for some p>0p>0. Lauric [14, 15, 16] identified further affirmative cases, including subnormal operators with trace-class self-commutator, hyponormal contractions TT with I−TT∗∈S1I-TT^*\in\mathcal{S}_1, and almost-normal operators whose square is normal.

In this note, we prove the following theorem.

Theorem 1.3. There is a compact operator TT on a separable infinite-dimensional Hilbert space H\mathcal{H} with [T∗,T]∈S1[T^*,T]\in\mathcal{S}_1 and PT=0P_T=0 such that

T⊕S−M∉S2T\oplus S-M\notin\mathcal{S}_2

for every bounded operator SS on a separable Hilbert space K\mathcal{K} and every bounded normal operator MM on H⊕K\mathcal{H}\oplus\mathcal{K}.

The proof of Theorem 1.3 uses a finite-dimensional measure of normal comparison. For a self-adjoint pair (A,B)(A,B), its frame error, Definition 2.1, is the least total squared residual over finite labelled Parseval frames. This quantity is bounded above by the squared Hilbert–Schmidt cost of intertwining (A,B)(A,B) with a commuting self-adjoint pair on a larger space. For a bounded direct sum of finite-dimensional blocks, we show in Proposition 2.5 that normal dilation modulo S2\mathcal{S}_2 is equivalent to summability of the block frame errors.

We therefore seek finite-dimensional pairs with uniformly bounded commutator trace norms and unbounded frame errors. We introduce in § 3 such pairs from signed shifts on finite square tori. We consider signs that are supported on a finite string with endpoints giving two flux defects, and compute that disjoint loops surrounding one defect yield a positive operator with logarithmically growing trace.

The key estimate in our study is Proposition 4.1 which shows that for the pair (AL,BL)(A_L,B_L) constructed in § 3, their frame error satisfies

∂(AL,BL)≥clog⁡L−C0,\partial(A_L,B_L)\ge c\log L-C_0,

where dd is defined by (4) and c,C0c,C_0 are independent of LL. In § 5, we form

T=⨁jλj(ALj+iBLj),λj=2−j.T=\bigoplus_j \lambda_j(A_{L_j}+iB_{L_j}),\qquad\lambda_j=2^{-j}.

The uniform bound on the block commutator trace norms, together with ∑jλj2<∞\sum_j\lambda_j^2<\infty, ensures that TT is almost normal. We choose LjL_j so that λj2log⁡Lj→∞\lambda_j^2\log L_j\to\infty. Proposition 4.1 and the criterion in Proposition 2.5 then exclude every bounded companion SS and bounded normal comparator MM. This study of frame error connects Hilbert–Schmidt intertwining methods [22, 6] with quadratic frame approximation [8, 1] and spectral variance in joint diagonalization [18 §7].

Theorem 1.3 shows that Conjectures 1.1 and 1.2 do not hold in their current forms. New invariants are needed to completely classify almost normal operators up to stable unitary equivalence modulo the Hilbert–Schmidt class. In Definition 6.4, we introduce a quantitative invariant R(T)\mathcal{R}(T), the rank profile, for an almost normal operator TT. In Proposition 6.5, we show that the rank profile invariant must agree for two almost normal operators that are stably unitarily equivalent modulo the Hilbert–Schmidt class. In particular, the rank profile distinguishes the operator TT constructed in Theorem 1.3 from zero. In a forthcoming paper, we will investigate refinements of this invariant and possible connections with quantitative KK-theory, with the aim of developing a complete invariant for stable unitary equivalence of almost normal operators modulo Hilbert–Schmidt perturbations.

The magnetic shifts used in our construction define discrete magnetic connections on square tori with two localized flux defects. Their normalized Hilbert–Schmidt defect tends to zero as the lattice size grows. The construction also suggests analogous models on surfaces of higher genus, which we plan to investigate in future work.

Acknowledgements: We would like to thank Professor Ronald G. Douglas for introducing the problem of classification of almost normal operators and the inspiring discussion. Our research was supported in part by DMS-2350181 and Simons Foundation Collaboration Grant MPS-TSM-00007714.

Frame errors and normal comparisons

Frame error measures the least squared cost of comparing a finite-dimensional self-adjoint pair with a commuting pair on a larger Hilbert space. We first define the quantity in terms of Parseval frames.

Let A,BA,B be self-adjoint operators on a finite-dimensional Hilbert space H\mathcal{H}. Recall that a finite Parseval frame is a family (ψν)ν(\psi_\nu)_\nu in H\mathcal{H} satisfying ∑νψνψν∗=IH\sum_\nu\psi_\nu\psi_\nu^*=I_{\mathcal{H}}, with ψνψν∗\psi_\nu\psi_\nu^* the rank-one operator associated to ψν\psi_\nu. For such a frame, assign a real label xνx_\nu to the first coordinate and yνy_\nu to the second.

Definition 2.1. Define the frame error of the pair (A,B)(A,B) by

∂(A,B)=inf⁡∑ν(∥(A−xνI)ψν∥2+∥(B−yνI)ψν∥2).(4)\partial(A,B)=\inf\sum_\nu\left(\lVert(A-x_\nu I)\psi_\nu\rVert^2+\lVert(B-y_\nu I)\psi_\nu\rVert^2\right). \tag*{(4)}

where the infimum ranges over all finite Parseval frames and all real labels.

We remark that a similar definition has appeared in [21 Eq. (114)]. In particular, for n=dim⁡Hn=\dim\mathcal{H}, ∂(A,B)\partial(A,B) can be identified with nI({A,B},IH/n)nI(\{A,B\},I_{\mathcal{H}}/n) for the convex-roof functional II in [21].

We omit any zero vectors for a fixed Parseval frame. Given ψν\psi_\nu, we notice that the functions x↦∥(A−xI)ψν∥2x \mapsto\lVert(A-xI)\psi_\nu\rVert^2 and y↦∥(B−yI)ψν∥2y \mapsto\lVert(B-yI)\psi_\nu\rVert^2 reach their minimum at

xν=⟨Aψν,ψν⟩∥ψν∥2,yν=⟨Bψν,ψν⟩∥ψν∥2.x_\nu=\frac{\langle A\psi_\nu,\psi_\nu\rangle}{\lVert\psi_\nu\rVert^2},\qquad y_\nu=\frac{\langle B\psi_\nu,\psi_\nu\rangle}{\lVert\psi_\nu\rVert^2}.

These labels satisfy

∣xν∣≤∥A∥,∣yν∣≤∥B∥.(5)\lvert x_\nu\rvert\leq\lVert A\rVert,\qquad\lvert y_\nu\rvert\leq\lVert B\rVert. \tag*{(5)}

Thus the infimum defining ∂(A,B)\partial(A,B) is unchanged if we restrict to {xν,yν}\{x_\nu,y_\nu\} satisfying these bounds, i.e.

∂(A,B)=inf⁡∣xν∣≤∥A∥,∣yν∣≤∥B∥,(ψν)ν∑ν(∥(A−xνI)ψν∥2+∥(B−yνI)ψν∥2).(6)\partial(A,B)=\inf_{\lvert x_\nu\rvert\leq\lVert A\rVert,\lvert y_\nu\rvert\leq\lVert B\rVert,(\psi_\nu)_\nu}\sum_\nu\left(\lVert(A-x_\nu I)\psi_\nu\rVert^2+\lVert(B-y_\nu I)\psi_\nu\rVert^2\right). \tag*{(6)}

Furthermore, using (4), we observe that for λ∈R\lambda\in\mathbb{R} rescaling A,BA,B to λA,λB\lambda A,\lambda B gives λ2\lambda^2 multiple of ∂(A,B)\partial(A,B),

∂(λA,λB)=λ2∂(A,B),∀λ∈R.(7)\partial(\lambda A,\lambda B)=\lambda^2\partial(A,B),\qquad\forall\lambda\in\mathbb{R}. \tag*{(7)}

References

  1. [1]P. Balázs, Hilbert–Schmidt operators and frames–classification, best approximation by multipliers and algorithms, Int. J. Wavelets Multiresolut. Inf. Process. 6 (2008), 315–330.
  2. [2]L. G. Brown, R. G. Douglas, and P. A. Fillmore, Unitary equivalence modulo the compact operators and extensions of C*-algebras, in Proceedings of a Conference on Operator Theory (Halifax, 1973), Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 345, Springer, Berlin, 1973, pp. 58–128. doi:10.1007/BFb0058917.DOI
  3. [3]L. G. Brown, R. G. Douglas, and P. A. Fillmore, Extensions of C*-algebras and K-homology, Ann. of Math. (2) 105 (1977), no. 2, 265–324. doi:10.2307/1970999.DOI
  4. [4]R. W. Carey and J. D. Pincus, An invariant for certain operator algebras, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 71 (1974), no. 5, 1952–1956. doi:10.1073/pnas.71.5.1952.DOI
  5. [5]A. Connes, Noncommutative Geometry, Academic Press, San Diego, CA, (1994).
  6. [6]K. R. Davidson, Normal operators are diagonal plus Hilbert-Schmidt, J. Operator Theory 20 (1988), 241–249.
  7. [7]G. De Nittis and H. Schulz-Baldes, Spectral flows associated to flux tubes, Ann. Henri Poincaré 17 (2016), no. 1, 1–35. doi:10.1007/s00023-014-0394-5.
  8. [8]M. Frank, V. I. Paulsen, and T. R. Tiballi, Symmetric approximation of frames and bases in Hilbert spaces, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 354 (2002), 777–793.DOI
  9. [9]J. W. Helton and R. E. Howe, Integral operators: commutators, traces, index and homology, in Proceedings of a Conference on Operator Theory (Halifax, 1973), Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 345, Springer, Berlin, 1973, pp. 141–209.DOI
  10. [10]J. W. Helton and R. E. Howe, Traces of commutators of integral operators, Acta Math. 135 (1975), 271–305. doi:10.1007/BF02392022.DOI
  11. [11]R. Kenyon, Spanning forests and the vector bundle Laplacian, Ann. Probab. 39 (2011), no. 5, 1983–2017. doi:10.1214/10-AOP596.DOI
  12. [12]A. Kitaev, Anyons in an exactly solved model and beyond, Ann. Physics 321 (2006), no. 1, 2–111. doi:10.1016/j.aop.2005.10.005.DOI
  13. [14]V. Lauric, Commutators of almost normal operators that have trace zero, Int. J. Math. Anal. 9 (2015), no. 55, 2721–2723. doi:10.12988/ijma.2015.58216.DOI
  14. [15]V. Lauric, Remarks on almost normal operators and almost normal operators, Mathematiche (Catania) 72 (2017), no. 1, 3–8. doi:10.4418/2017/72.1.1.
  15. [16]V. Lauric, A remark concerning Putinar’s model of hyponormal weighted shifts, Czechoslovak Math. J. 68 (2018), no. 4, 1125–1130. doi:10.21136/CMJ.2017.0129-17.DOI
  16. [18]T. A. Loring and A. P. W. Sørensen, Almost commuting unitary matrices related to time reversal, Comm. Math. Phys. 323 (2013), 859–887DOI
  17. [19]C. Pasnicu, Weighted shifts as direct summands mod C₂ of normal operators, in Dilation Theory, Toeplitz Operators, and Other Topics (Timişoara, 1982), Oper. Theory Adv. Appl., vol. 11, Birkhäuser, Basel, 1983, pp. 275–281.
  18. [21]G. Tóth and F. Fröwis, Uncertainty relations with the variance and the quantum Fisher information based on convex decompositions of density matrices, Physical Review Research 4, 013075 (2022).DOI
  19. [22]D. Voiculescu, Some results on norm-ideal perturbations of Hilbert space operators, J. Operator Theory 2 (1979), 3–37.
  20. [23]D.-V. Voiculescu, Remarks on Hilbert–Schmidt perturbations of almost normal operators, in Topics in Modern Operator Theory, Oper. Theory Adv. Appl., vol. 2, Birkhäuser, Basel, 1981, pp. 311–318. doi:10.1007/978-3-0348-5456-6_20.
  21. [25]D.-V. Voiculescu, Almost-normal operators modulo κ, in Linear and Complex Analysis Problem Book, V. P. Havin, S. V. Hruščëv, and N. K. Nikol′skiĭ, eds., Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 1043, Springer, Berlin, 1984, pp. 227–230.
  22. [26]D.-V. Voiculescu, Almost normal operators mod Hilbert–Schmidt and the K-theory of the algebras EΛ(Ω), J. Noncommut. Geom. 8 (2014), no. 4, 1123–1145. doi:10.4171/JNCG/181.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_38kue5kn
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents