WorksMathematics
Essential dimension of geometric local systems
Abstract
Let f : X → B be a smooth projective family over a smooth complex variety, and let H = (Rmf∗Z)/tors. We prove that there is an integer N such that, whenever pn ≥N, the essential dimension at p of H/pn is at least the dimension of its period image. This proves the Brosnan–Fakhruddin conjecture for these local systems. The proof compares the geometric Sen operator with the Higgs field. Integral Hodge–Tate theory gives a bound uniform in large primes. For each remaining prime, a bounded rational comparison at one geometric point suffices when n is large.
Introduction
Let be a smooth irreducible complex algebraic variety, and let be an integral variation of Hodge structure on . For a positive integer , the finite local system determines a finite étale cover of . Its essential dimension at a prime is the least dimension of a variety from which this cover can be obtained by rational pullback, after a generically finite base change of degree prime to . We recall the field-theoretic definition in § 4.
Motivated by the results for Shimura varieties in [6], Brosnan and Fakhruddin conjectured that, for a polarized integral variation with period map , there is an integer such that
[3 §1.5, Conjecture 1]. We prove this assertion when is the full cohomology of a smooth projective family, modulo torsion.
Theorem A. Let be a smooth projective morphism, with a smooth irreducible complex variety, and fix . Put , and let be the dimension of its period image. There is an integer such that, for every prime and every integer with ,
We first prove the inequality for at sufficiently large primes. We then treat the finitely many remaining primes, allowing the required exponent to depend on . We do not know how to extend the result to an arbitrary variation of Hodge structure and this remains an interesting question.
A sketch of the proof
For simplicity we sketch only the argument for sufficiently large. The argument for the remaining primes is given in § 4.3. It is in fact somewhat easier, since the result is only required to hold with sufficiently large. A standard argument reduces us to a statement for a proper smooth family over a finite extension of , however it will be useful to give a precise formulation. Let be a finite extension of , with ring of integers and residue field . Set . Let be smooth projective, where is smooth over and its generic and special fibres are geometrically integral. Assume that the Hodge cohomology sheaves are locally free and commute with base change. Assume also that the relative de Rham cohomology and its Hodge filtration are locally free and commute with base change, and that is finite free.
Write
for the Hodge bundles and their Higgs field, induced by the Gauss–Manin connection. We set outside . The rank of the Higgs field means the rank of the contraction map
Let be its generic rank on the special fibre.
Theorem B. Under these hypotheses,
To prove Theorem B, let . We again write for the generic fiber of , and we denote by the -adic completion of . Suppose that is a rational map over such that , and descends to . (We ignore here the auxiliary prime to covering, which is straightforward to deal with.) The idea is to construct a map of formal schemes such that is well defined and constant. Then is constant, and the theory of the geometric Sen operator gives a contradiction, provided the pullback of the Kodaira–Spencer map is non-zero modulo at the origin, where satisfies
We normalize and fix a scalar of valuation . To construct we choose a suitable point and a derivation of (defined on an open containing ) such that , and is non-zero modulo the maximal ideal of , and define by
Crucially, the existence of satisfying these properties does not depend on the integral properties of the map . Such a dependence would be fatal, as depends on .
Let us explain the use of the geometric Sen operator in more detail. Write for the generic fiber of . For a finite free -local system on , put and , where is the completed integral structure sheaf on the pro-étale site of . Its geometric Sen operator is a map , where denotes the Tate twist. If is constant and , Proposition 2.1.6 gives
Apply this to so is constant. Under the hypotheses of Theorem B, we use Scholze’s results [14] to control the comparison between the étale and Hodge lattices in , and Howe’s theorem [9] identifies the graded Sen operator with . These comparisons turn (1.1.2) into
(Proposition 2.4.1). This is a contradiction as .
In fact, in the proof, it is more convenient to take to be the geometric point associated with the valuation at the generic point of the special fibre of . So is defined over a complete algebraically closed extension . The disc is then defined over , but the argument above remains unchanged.
We remark that it should be possible to adapt the above proof, at least for sufficiently large , to other versions of integral -adic Hodge theory, for example Faltings’ integral crystalline theory [5], or the prismatic theory of Bhatt–Scholze [2]. As remarked above, the key observation is that the map above can be chosen without any assumptions on the integral behaviour of the map . We leave this as an exercise for the reader.
Relation to earlier work
In the paper [6] with Farb and Wolfson, we used deformation theory at ordinary points to prove incompressibility of congruence covers. Fakhruddin and Saini extended the finite group scheme method to certain nonordinary cases in [4]. At the time of writing [6], it was already clear to us that, morally speaking, there should be an argument with the Kodaira–Spencer map, but we were unable to make this work without assuming good reduction properties of the map .
The paper [10] proves -incompressibility of principal congruence covers of Shimura varieties at all sufficiently large good primes. For exceptional groups the results of the present paper do not contain those of [10], as the corresponding variations of Hodge structures are not known to be motivic.
In [7], Farb, Kisin, and Wolfson use prismatic cohomology to obtain lower bounds for essential dimension from differential forms. Here we compare the Hodge bundles with the lattices induced by the local system on its Hodge–Tate graded pieces. Proposition 2.3.1 gives the required bound by retaining the integral Kummer complexes in Scholze’s relative Hodge–Tate comparison [14]. We use the local integral calculation and décalage estimates of Bhatt, Morrow, and Scholze [1], in the relative form of Gaisin and Koshikawa [8]. Geometric Sen theory [13] and Howe’s theorem [9] then relate this comparison to the Higgs field. We apply these results directly to the family over the formal disc.
The argument at a fixed prime uses only the rational comparison and geometric Sen theory. It is given in § 4.3; § 4.4 combines the two arguments to prove Theorem A.
AI use
Extensive use of GPT Astra was made both to arrive at the proofs of the results presented here, and to write a first draft of the manuscript. Significant human effort was needed to check and refine the arguments, and make the paper more readable. Part of this work was done at The Overhang, held in San Francisco on 9–10 September 2026. We thank the organizers and other participants for a very pleasant experience.
-adic Hodge theory
Constancy and the geometric Sen operator
We first prove an integral estimate on a disc.
Let be any complete algebraically closed extension of . Write for its valuation ring and for the maximal ideal, and normalize . Fix compatible -power roots of unity and set
For a rational number , the notation denotes the multiple of an -module by a scalar of valuation ; it is independent of the scalar chosen. If is finite free, and , we write for the minimum of over linear maps (which is well defined).
An almost zero module is a module killed by . The almost category is the quotient by these modules; a superscript denotes passage to this category. When working there we suppress this superscript. If is finite free and satisfies , then .
For a smooth rigid space , write for its pro-étale site and for the completed integral structure sheaf. Put . For a finite free -local system on , put
The geometric Sen operator is the -linear Higgs field
of [13]. Here is the usual Tate twist.
Let be an indeterminate and set
The second ring is the -adic completion of the union of the finite-level rings. The map is an affinoid perfectoid pro-étale cover with group . Let be the generator satisfying for all .
We also write for the Gauss valuation on and for the minimum valuation of the entries of a matrix over .
Lemma 2.1.2. Let be a finite free -local system on . Suppose is constant. For every rational , the module has an -basis in which the matrix of is congruent to modulo .
Reference. Put . A choice of basis of the constant local system gives an isomorphism of sheaves
By [16 Lemma 5.9], applied with , the module is finite free of rank and, for , the trivialization of induces a -equivariant isomorphism
and the matrix of on is mod in this basis. The proof in loc. cit. uses only almost acyclicity on affinoid perfectoid objects and almost algebra, so applies over the present field . □
Lemma 2.1.3. Let be a finite free -module of rank with continuous semilinear -action. If its matrix for satisfies , an integral change of basis makes a matrix .
Proof. Projection onto the monomials with integral exponents gives a bounded -linear decomposition
The projection to has norm one. On a monomial with and , the operator acts by multiplication by . The operator on the -linear span of these monomials is bounded, so extends to its completion . Consequently
Write using (2.1.4), with and in and respectively. Suppose . Put
By (2.1.5), ; both and its inverse are integral. Using , we first compute
Subtracting gives
Both terms on the right have valuation at least . Multiplying by the integral matrix gives the same bound for . Now replace by and repeat the above. Each iteration increases by at least . The products of the changes of basis converge in , and taking the limit of the matrices gives the required . □
Proposition 2.1.6. Let be a finite free -local system on the generic fibre of . If is constant and , then
as an inclusion of sheaves on .
Proof. The formal opens where , respectively , is invertible cover . Each is isomorphic to , with , respectively . On these opens is a unit multiple of , so it suffices to prove the estimate on .
Fix a rational with . Lemmas 2.1.2 and 2.1.3 give an integral basis of whose -span is -stable and satisfies . Thus is a decompletion of on the Kummer tower. The action of on is -linear, with matrix , where . Let be dual to . By [13], Proposition 3.1.2 and proof of Proposition 3.2.3, the geometric Sen operator is obtained by extending
-linearly. The th term of the logarithm has valuation at least , since . This proves that
The proposition now follows by intersecting the right hand side of this inclusion over all , and noting that .
Lemma 2.1.7. For a finite free -local system on , the geometric Sen operator commutes with extension of complete algebraically closed constant fields, and with pullback along a morphism of smooth rigid spaces over a field.
Proof. Pullback over a fixed field is [13], Theorem 1.0.3(5). For an extension , work locally on a toric chart of . The construction in [13], Proposition 3.2.3 computes the operator by differentiating the action of an open subgroup of the Kummer Galois group on a finite projective module at a finite level of the tower. Scalar extension to the infinite tower recovers from this module. Completed scalar extension from to preserves this description: the action matrices, their convergent logarithms, Kummer differentials, and Tate twists all commute with it. This proves the assertion.
The Hodge–Tate filtration
We compare the lattices supplied by the local system and the Hodge bundles. The comparison will be applied to the family on the formal disc constructed in §3.
Let be finite, and let be the analytification of a smooth projective morphism of smooth -varieties. Fix , and put
The relative de Rham comparison [14], Theorem 8.8 and Remark 8.9 identifies the filtered bundle with connection associated to with . Write for its Higgs field.
Fix an embedding of into , and let be a morphism of smooth rigid spaces over . Write for its composite with , and put
We also write for the pullback Higgs field on , with values in .
Let be the pullback of to along , with coefficients in . Taking the degree-zero graded part of the relative de Rham comparison and pulling back gives
Define to be the inverse image of the sum over under . This is the Hodge–Tate filtration
Thus in decreasing notation. By [9], proof of Lemma 3.2.1, the graded maps of are the scalar extensions to of isomorphisms
Lemma 2.2.3 (Howe). The geometric Sen operator satisfies
Under and , its induced graded map is $\theta_i.
Proof. Over this is [9], Lemma 3.2.1. For the assertion follows by pulling back along , using Lemma 2.1.7.
The integral bound
Put , and suppose that is the rigid generic fibre of a smooth proper morphism of smooth -adic formal schemes locally of finite type over . Assume that all are locally free and commute with base change, and that is torsion-free. It then identifies with . Put
Here differentials on formal schemes are continuous, and denotes pullback along the specialization map . The generic fibre of is . We regard as a submodule of via .
Proposition 2.3.1. In the almost category there is an -submodule such that
Here , and the equality of graded pieces is taken inside .
Proof. We work in the almost category. To take relative pro-étale cohomology before proper push-forward, use the relative topos of [8 §2.1 and Proposition 5.7], with its maps
Here and is the other projection. We equip with the sheaf of rings , and take pullbacks to with coefficients in this ring. Put
The décalage functor is represented, on a nonnegative complex of -torsion-free modules, by
Since is -torsion-free, there is a natural map [1 Lemma 6.10]. Put , and let be the image of in . The relative primitive comparison isomorphism [14 Theorem 1.3 and proof of Theorem 8.8(i)] identifies with . Thus induces , which is an isomorphism after inverting . We will identify the graded pieces of and bound its image under above and below.
The relative integral Hodge–Tate comparison [8 Theorem 5.19] gives
Now take a formally étale -morphism , where is an open of , and let be the pullback of one of the toric coordinates. Let be the image in of the Kummer class of on the generic fibre of . Using (2.3.3), one has
[1 Definition 8.2], [8 (5.34)]. Taking exterior products then determines the map on cohomology induced by in every degree. By (2.3.3) and coherent base change [8 Corollary 5.27], canonical truncation of gives the spectral sequence
We next compare the filtration on with . Let be the pullback of along , with coefficients in . The graded relative Poincaré resolution [14 Proposition 8.5] gives a quasi-isomorphism
Here is the -linear Higgs field induced from the connection on by taking the associated graded. The pullback on the left has coefficients in . The proof of [14 Lemma 8.7(iv)] shows that each term is -acyclic, with direct image . The complex obtained from (2.3.5) by applying has zero differentials: the coefficients in and the pulled-back algebra are killed by . Applying to the resolution therefore gives
where tensors are over . The algebra is locally polynomial over , hence faithfully flat. Thus canonical truncation through degree on the left of (2.3.6) corresponds to the sum with on the right.
Applying to (2.3.6) and taking gives (2.2.1). Indeed, coherent base change identifies the summands on the right, and the relative de Rham comparison is constructed from the same Poincaré resolution [14 proof of Theorem 8.8(ii)]. The definition of and faithful flatness of now give .
The cohomology maps in (2.3.6) are compatible with (2.3.3) via the map . Indeed, after twisting by (1), the inverse degree-one map sends to , up to sign [14 Lemma 6.17]. This agrees with on after scalar extension to . Exterior products give agreement in every degree. In particular induces the maps , up to signs, on associated gradeds. Now (2.3.6) implies rational degeneration of (2.3.4) which then implies integral degeneration, since the terms are -torsion-free. Thus and are -torsion-free. As is an isomorphism, embeds in ; the equality then gives . Under this identification, the preceding comparison gives
Finally, by [1 Lemma 6.9], multiplication by on factors through . Apply and take ; truncation above does not affect this cohomology. It follows that .
The estimate on a disc
Keep the hypotheses of Theorem B, and let be a complete algebraically closed extension. Put , and write for its rigid generic fibre. For an -morphism , let be its generic fibre. The pullback family has Hodge bundles and local system . Write
for its Higgs field, and put .
Proposition 2.4.1. If is constant on and , then
Proof. Put . By Proposition 2.1.6, the contraction sends into . Let denote the lattice of Proposition 2.3.1, applied to the pullback family over . Then
By Lemma 2.2.3, this operator lowers the filtration on . The factors and in the source and target graded pieces give, after cancelling the Tate twists, an almost integral map
Evaluation at gives the asserted bound, since . Almost inclusions suffice for this valuation inequality, as observed in § 3.1.
Compressions and bounded derivations
We recall the field-theoretic definition of essential dimension at . For a finite étale -scheme , where is a finitely generated field, define to be the least for which there exist a finite extension of degree prime to , a finitely generated subfield , and a finite étale -scheme such that . For a finite local system on an integral variety, we apply this definition to its étale space at the generic point.
Valuations and bounded derivations
Let be a complete algebraically closed extension of , and let be a finitely generated extension of transcendence degree . Equip with a valuation extending that of , normalized by , with . Write for its completion. Choose a basis of such that
These derivations extend continuously to and preserve . Put
For a finite extension , write for its completion at a chosen extension of the valuation.
Lemma 3.1.1. If is finite of degree prime to , then is finite étale. Each extends uniquely to a derivation of preserving .
Proof. The value group of is divisible, so the ramification index is one. By Ostrowski’s lemma [11 Chapter 11, Lemma 11.17], the defect is a power of , as is the inseparable residue degree. Since is prime to , the residue extension is separable of degree .
By [15 Tag 04GK], the residue extension lifts to a finite étale -algebra . Henselian lifting embeds in , and equality of degrees gives . Since is normal, . The assertion about derivations follows from formal étaleness; see [15 Tag 00UP].
For a finite free -module , let denote the minimum of the coordinate valuations in any -basis. We use this notation on and after any valued extension of . Let be an -linear map whose reduction has rank . Fix and an extension of the valuation for which is prime to .
Lemma 3.1.2. Let be a finitely generated field with . There is such that and .
Proof. Extend scalars to , retaining the notation , , , and . Choose a transcendence basis of . The equations impose at most linear conditions on . In characteristic zero they also imply . Their solution space has dimension at least .
The quotient is finite and torsion-free over the valuation ring , hence free by [15 Tags 0539 and 00NZ]. Thus is a direct summand of of rank .
The reduction of has dimension at least . It cannot be contained in the kernel of the reduction of , which has dimension . Choose a vector in this reduction outside the kernel, and lift it to . This derivation has the required properties.
The exponential disc
Lemma 3.2.1. Let be a -linear derivation of preserving , and let satisfy . For an indeterminate , the map
is a -algebra embedding . It maps into , and it fixes every element annihilated by .
Proof. Since , dividing by a constant of the same valuation shows that . This also holds for . Hence
using . The series converges in , and the Leibniz rule shows that is a -algebra homomorphism. Evaluation at is a left inverse to , so is injective. By (3.2.2), maps into . If , all positive-degree terms in the defining series vanish, so .
Proof of Theorem B. After replacing by an affine open meeting the generic point of its special fibre, write and choose étale coordinates over , where . We may also trivialize the Hodge bundles and arrange that the reduction of (1.1.1) has rank throughout this open.
Take with the Gauss valuation defined by the generic point of . It extends the valuation of , has value group , and has residue field . The coordinate derivations preserve and its localization at . For , normalizing its numerator and denominator by constants of and applying the quotient rule gives . The reductions of the form a basis of . Put
The Higgs contraction induces whose reduction has rank .
Suppose that admits a compression of dimension . Thus there is an extension of degree prime to and a subfield , of transcendence degree , over which the finite étale space of descends to a finite étale -scheme . The algebra is a product of finite extensions of . Since the sum of their degrees is prime to , at least one factor has degree prime to . Choose the corresponding valuation on ; its completion is this factor.
Choose the bounded derivation of Lemma 3.1.2. Since , we may choose with
Let be a completed algebraic closure of and put . The restriction takes values in , and hence gives a formal map
Here is the -adic completion of , and . Write for the generic fibre, where .
By the definition of the compression, the étale space of is identified with . Since , the map factors through the algebraically closed field , so this étale space is constant. Its module operations are constant as well, since is connected.
Proposition 2.4.1 now gives
But this matrix is and has a unit entry. Its valuation is , a contradiction.
The estimate for an arbitrary prime
We now remove the restriction on and the hypothesis of good reduction by passing to sufficiently high -power levels. The rational Hodge–Tate comparison at a fixed analytic point gives a valuation estimate with a constant independent of the level and the compression; increasing the exponent absorbs this constant.
Let be finite, put , and let be smooth projective, with smooth and geometrically integral. Put
The Gauss–Manin connection on induces a Higgs contraction
Let be its generic rank.
Theorem 3.3.1. There is an integer such that
Proof. We may assume . After a finite extension of , choose a closed analytic polydisc in the rank- locus of , with coordinates obtained by rescaling algebraic étale coordinates, where . Put and . Specialize § 4.1 to with the Gauss valuation induced by and . Since the subfield is dense in , the inclusion defines the Gauss point .
Fix a completed algebraic closure of , and write for the extension of to . Put . The Higgs contraction at is
The image is a finitely generated torsion-free module over the valuation ring , hence free of rank by [15 Tags 0539 and 00NZ]. To preserve this rank on reduction, extend an -basis of to an -basis of , and let be its -span. Then is a direct summand of ; in particular, the reduction of has rank .
We now replace Proposition 2.4.1 by an estimate with a constant depending on and . Put
Pulling (2.2.2) back to gives a filtration on . The comparison maps of § 3.2 identify with . Let consist of the maps with for every . Using these identifications, taking associated graded and cancelling the Tate twists defines
Since extends to a -linear map on , there is an integer such that
Put . For a map with , write . Lemmas 2.2.3 and 2.1.7 give
Proposition 2.1.6 therefore gives
whenever is constant and . The constant is independent of and of the compression.
Now a compression of dimension gives a finite extension of degree prime to and a subfield with . As in the proof of Theorem B, choose a completion with prime to , and embed in the fixed . Lemma 3.1.2, with , gives such that and . For , choose with . By Lemma 3.2.1, the restriction of to defines with and . Since , the argument in the proof of Theorem B shows that is constant. But (3.3.2) would give
This contradiction proves the assertion for any integer .
Spreading out
Proof of Theorem A. The Higgs contraction (1.1.1) has generic rank . After spreading out in characteristic zero, choose a specialization over a number field whose Higgs contraction still has generic rank . By [12 Theorem 10.2], applied to the frame torsors of , and [6 Lemma 2.2.4], essential dimension at cannot increase under this specialization. We may therefore replace by , retaining the notation and .
For each prime , choose a place of and put , , , and . By the étale–Betti comparison isomorphism and invariance of essential dimension under extension of algebraically closed base fields [6 Lemma 2.2.5 and §2.2.6],
After shrinking and inverting an integer , spread out to a smooth projective morphism , where is smooth over with geometrically integral fibres. We may arrange that the Hodge and de Rham cohomology sheaves of and the Hodge filtration are locally free and commute with base change [15 Tags of FM10 and OB8W], and that the Higgs contraction has rank on every fibre. Enlarge to exclude the primes dividing the torsion in . For , the base change to then satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem B, with special-fibre Higgs rank . Together with (3.4.1), this gives
for some . By [6 Lemma 2.1.6], , so the same lower bound holds for every when .
For each prime , Theorem 3.3.1 and (3.4.1) give the same bound for , for some integer . This proves the theorem.
References
- [1]B. Bhatt, M. Morrow, and P. Scholze, Integral p-adic Hodge theory, Publ. Math. Inst. Hautes Études Sci. 128 (2018), 219–397. arXiv:1602.03148.arxiv.org/abs/1602.03148
- [2]B. Bhatt and P. Scholze, Prisms and prismatic cohomology, Ann. of Math. (2) 196 (2022), no. 3, 1135–1275. doi:10.4007/annals.2022.196.3.5.
- [3]P. Brosnan and N. Fakhruddin, Fixed points, local monodromy, and incompressibility of congruence covers, arXiv:2007.01752v2 (2020).arxiv.org/abs/2007.01752
- [4]N. Fakhruddin and R. Saini, Finite group scheme actions and incompressibility of Galois covers: beyond the ordinary case, Doc. Math. 27 (2022), 151–182. doi:10.4171/DM/868.DOI
- [5]G. Faltings, Integral crystalline cohomology over very ramified valuation rings, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 12 (1999), no. 1, 117–144. doi:10.1090/S0894-0347-99-00273-8.DOI
- [6]B. Farb, M. Kisin, and J. Wolfson, The essential dimension of congruence covers, Compos. Math. 157 (2021), 2407–2432. arXiv:1901.09013v2.DOI
- [7]B. Farb, M. Kisin, and J. Wolfson, Essential dimension via prismatic cohomology, Duke Math. J. 173 (2024), 3059–3106. arXiv:2110.05534.DOI
- [8]I. Gaisin and T. Koshikawa, Relative Ainf-cohomology, arXiv:2206.07983v1 (2022).
- [9]S. Howe, The geometric Sen morphism is the unique lift of the Kodaira–Spencer morphism, arXiv:2512.09669v1 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2512.09669
- [10]M. Kisin, Essential dimension of principal congruence covers of Shimura varieties, manuscript, 2026.
- [11]F.-V. Kuhlmann, Valuation theory, book manuscript, Chapter 11, Defect. https://www.fvk" + "uhlmann.de/bookch11.pdf.
- [12]Z. Reichstein and F. Scavia, The behavior of essential dimension under specialization, II, Algebra Number Theory 17 (2023), no. 11, 1925–1958. doi:10.2140/ant.2023.17.1925.DOI
- [13]J. E. Rodríguez Camargo, Geometric Sen theory over rigid analytic spaces, arXiv:2205.02016v4.arxiv.org/abs/2205.02016
- [14]P. Scholze, p-adic Hodge theory for rigid-analytic varieties, Forum Math. Pi 1 (2013), e1. arXiv:1205.3463v2.arxiv.org/abs/1205.3463
- [15]The Stacks Project Authors, The Stacks Project. https://stacks.math.columbia.edu.
- [16]Y. Wang, A p-adic Simpson correspondence for rigid analytic varieties, Algebra Number Theory 17 (2023), 1453–1499. arXiv:2101.00263v4.DOI