In this paper
AbstractIntroductionEnergy exchange between the vacuum and dark matterCoupling and conservation equationsBackground evolutionLinear perturbations and the growth of structureCombination with early-time solutionsDark radiation: CDMEarly dark energy: EDEData and methodologyDataModels and priorsSampling and model comparisonResultsThe – planeConstraints on the couplingModel comparisonDependence on alpha and on the direction of the energy flowGrowth rate Confronting cosmic shearEffective lensing amplitudeKiDS-Legacy shear correlation functionsMethodResultsRobustness and limitationsDiscussionThe exchange with different early-time solutionsPhysical interpretation of the preferred couplingCaveatsConclusionsImplementation in CLASS and numerical validationCosmic shear pipeline validationConvergence diagnosticsAcknowledgmentsReferencesWorksPhysics and Astronomy
Vacuum energy interacting with dark matter and dark radiation: alleviating the - seesaw
Abstract
Extensions of CDM that raise with additional energy before recombination, such as dark radiation and early dark energy (EDE), also raise . We study whether a late-time energy exchange between the vacuum and the dark sector can offset this increase. The coupling rate scales as and is negligible before recombination for ; the energy is transferred along the four-velocity of geodesic cold dark matter, so the dark matter produced by the vacuum carries no density perturbation and slows the growth of structure. We add the exchange to dark radiation (CDM) and to a one-parameter EDE model (EDE), and constrain the models with Planck 2018, DESI DR2 BAO and Pantheon+ data (CBS), and with the SH0ES calibration added (CBSH) to test the exchange when is held at a high value. For CBS the posteriors favour an energy flow from the vacuum into dark matter at 1.8-2.7, and the exchange lowers by 0.02-0.08 but does not raise : CDM gives km s Mpc, 3.1 below SH0ES. For CBSH the exchange removes the increase of caused by dark radiation, giving at km s Mpc, and about a third of that caused by EDE for , with the coupling at 1.1-2.0. The reduction of is concentrated at : at the redshifts probed by KiDS-Legacy the lensing amplitude decreases by only 1-2%, the shear of the dark-radiation models changes by less than 3, and the exchange reduces but does not remove the excess shear of EDE. A late-time exchange can therefore offset part of the increase of early-time solutions, but it does not ease the Hubble tension, and current data do not require it.
Prepared for submission to JCAP
Introduction
The cold dark matter (CDM) model fits a wide range of cosmological observations, including the anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) [1], baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) [2] and type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) [3, 4]. As the precision of these probes has improved, however, several discrepancies have emerged between parameters inferred from the early and the late Universe [5, 6, 7, 8]. The most significant is the Hubble tension: within CDM, Planck 2018 CMB data give [1], whereas the SH0ES distance ladder gives [9], a difference of . Observations with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) have confirmed the Cepheid calibration [10, 11], although other primary distance indicators give [12]. A second, weaker discrepancy concerns the amplitude of matter clustering, . The cosmic-shear analyses of KiDS-1000 and DES Y3 find [13] and [14, 15], below the Planck CDM value [1] by and as quoted in these analyses, whereas the final KiDS-Legacy analysis finds , consistent with the CMB [16]. In either case, low-redshift structure probes do not favour an amplitude higher than that of Planck CDM.
Many extensions of CDM have been proposed to raise [6, 17, 18, 19]. Some of them act before recombination: a higher expansion rate reduces the sound horizon , and a larger is then needed to keep the angular acoustic scale of the CMB fixed. Two examples are additional dark radiation (DR), which raises the effective number of relativistic species [19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24], and early dark energy (EDE), a scalar field that contributes briefly to the energy density shortly before recombination [25, 26, 27]. In both cases the CMB requires a larger physical dark matter density (and, for EDE, a larger ) to compensate for the extra early expansion, so a higher comes with a higher [28, 29]. Easing the Hubble tension in this way therefore worsens the agreement with low-redshift structure probes, a problem referred to as the – seesaw [30]. Late-time modifications, such as dynamical or interacting dark energy [31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40], leave unchanged, but BAO and SNe Ia data tightly constrain the low-redshift expansion history and limit how much these models can raise [18, 20, 41]. An energy exchange between dark energy and dark matter can lower [42, 43], and a coupling between EDE and dark matter has been proposed to offset the increase of in EDE [44]. Reference [30] eased the seesaw with a dark sector of two components: a decaying dark-energy fluid that raises and an ultralight axion that suppresses the matter power spectrum.
In this work we study whether an energy exchange between the vacuum and cold dark matter (CDM) can play the role of the second component, on top of an early-time solution that raises . In our previous works we studied the CDM model, which is motivated by asymptotic safety [45] and particle production [46] in gravitational field theory and describes a vacuum energy interacting with matter and radiation [47, 48], and constrained it with scaling solutions of its rate equations [49, 50, 51]. Here we solve the rate equations directly, together with the linear perturbations, and restrict the exchange to the dark sector, while baryons and photons evolve as in CDM. The coupling rate is set by a mass parameter and scales as a power of the Hubble rate with , so the exchange is negligible before recombination and becomes active only at low redshift. The exchange therefore leaves the sound horizon and the early-time effect of the extra component unchanged. The energy is transferred along the CDM four-velocity, so that the vacuum stays homogeneous in the CDM rest frame and CDM follows geodesics, as in the interacting vacuum–geodesic CDM scenario [52, 53, 54, 55]. When the vacuum decays into CDM, the newly created dark matter carries no density perturbation and dilutes the existing density contrast, so increases while decreases, and the net effect is a lower (see ref. [56] for the growth of structure with geodesic CDM). We add this exchange to the two early-time solutions discussed above. With dark radiation, the vacuum exchanges energy with both CDM and the dark-radiation fluid, and we call the model ; with EDE, the vacuum exchanges energy with CDM only, and we call the model .
We constrain the models with the Planck 2018 TT,TE,EE+lowE+lensing CMB data [1, 57, 58], the DESI DR2 BAO measurements [2, 59] together with 6dFGS [60] and SDSS MGS [61], and the Pantheon+ SNe Ia sample [3, 4]. We refer to this combination as CBS, and to CBS plus the SH0ES Cepheid calibration [9] as CBSH. To isolate the effect of the exchange, we compare with plus the same dark-radiation fluid without exchange (), and with EDE. We leave the sign of the coupling free, so that the data determine the direction of the energy flow, and vary the power-law index , which controls how late the exchange becomes active. Fitting each model with and without the SH0ES calibration shows whether a preference for the exchange comes from the calibration or from the other data. We find that in both models the data mildly favour an energy flow from the vacuum into CDM, more strongly without the SH0ES calibration, and that the exchange lowers but does not raise .
A lower does not necessarily imply a weaker cosmic-shear signal. Since the exchange changes the matter density at low redshift, no longer scales as , and , defined with the present-day and , cannot be compared directly with cosmic-shear values inferred within . Cosmic shear is sensitive to the matter clustering over a range of redshifts set by the distances of the source galaxies, so what matters is how the exchange changes the clustering at those redshifts rather than today. We therefore compute the effective lensing amplitude and the shear two-point correlation functions with the matter density of each model, and compare them with the KiDS-Legacy measurements [16]. This comparison shows how much of the reduction in translates into a weaker shear signal.
This paper is organised as follows. § 2 describes the energy exchange, its effect on the background and on the growth of structure, and the two models built on it, and . § 3 presents the data, the models and their priors, and the sampling method. In § 4 we give the parameter constraints in the – plane and their dependence on the power-law index . § 5 computes the effective lensing amplitude and compares the predicted shear with KiDS-Legacy. We discuss other approaches to the seesaw and the limitations of this work in § 6, and conclude in § 7. The appendices describe the numerical implementation, the validation of the cosmic-shear calculation and the convergence diagnostics.
Energy exchange between the vacuum and dark matter
In this section we write the exchange for a dark sector made of CDM and, optionally, a dark-radiation fluid, and then add it to the two early-time solutions considered in this work. We assume a spatially flat Friedmann–Lemaître–Robertson–Walker universe, use cosmic time with for the background, and conformal time with and for the perturbations.
Coupling and conservation equations
The vacuum energy, with energy density and energy–momentum tensor , where is the inverse metric, exchanges energy with CDM and, in CDM, with the dark radiation. We denote by and the energy densities of CDM and dark radiation, and by and their energy–momentum tensors; in EDE there is no dark radiation and . Baryons, photons and neutrinos do not take part in the exchange and are separately conserved. The conservation equations read
where is the covariant derivative and is the energy–momentum transfer four-vector, so that the total energy–momentum tensor is conserved. We take the transfer to be parallel to the CDM four-velocity , normalised as ,
where is the energy transferred per unit volume and unit time, measured in the CDM rest frame, and is the coupling rate, given in eq. (6) below. The dependence of on the densities follows the rate equations of the CDM model [48], which describe the exchange between the vacuum and matter by analogy with a back-and-forth reaction such as . In these equations the energy that matter and radiation exchange with the vacuum is times their energy density, as for a decay or an annihilation process, so that the exchange per unit volume scales with the amount of matter present. We distribute the transfer between CDM and dark radiation in proportion to their energy densities. The background equations are then
so that CDM and dark radiation lose (or gain) the same fraction of their energy per unit time.
The coupling rate is
where and include all components, and the vacuum contributes to but not to , since ; is a mass parameter that sets the strength and the direction of the exchange, is a power-law index, and is the value obtained from the production of massive particle and antiparticle pairs [62, 63]. In the CDM model the time variation of the vacuum energy follows from the scaling of the cosmological term in asymptotically safe gravity [45, 47], and the energy released by the vacuum is converted into massive particle–antiparticle pairs [62, 63]; eq. (6) parametrises this conversion, with fixed by the pair-production rate, treated as a free parameter, and the factor introduced phenomenologically to control when the exchange becomes active. For energy flows from the dark sector into the vacuum, and for from the vacuum into the dark sector. We quote in units of . The rate per Hubble time,
measures the fraction of the CDM energy transferred per -fold. Today , so gives . At recombination , and for the factor suppresses to . For the exchange has no effect on the sound horizon, on recombination, or on the early-time effect of dark radiation or EDE. For , is also small at early times, but in the radiation era , and the energy exchanged with the dark radiation changes by an amount that grows as towards the past; we therefore switch the exchange on only at . At low redshift the index sets how fast the exchange switches on, as shown in panel (a) of Figure 1. At , is about 1.5, 0.9 and 0.1 times its present value for , and , respectively, and at about 1.5, 0.5 and 0.006 times.
Figure 1. Time dependence of the exchange and its effect on the background and on the growth of structure. (a) Coupling rate per Hubble time, eq. (2.7), normalised to its present value, for , and ; in the limit of weak coupling its shape does not depend on . (b) and (c) vary for , with , the early-time CDM density , the early-time , , , and held fixed. (b) Physical matter density , eq. (2.9). (c) rms of the linear density field in spheres of fixed comoving radius Mpc ( Mpc for ), divided by its value for ; the fixed radius in Mpc removes the change of with [64]. Negative (blue) corresponds to energy flowing from the vacuum into CDM.
Background evolution
Equations (4) and (5) integrate to
where the subscript 0 denotes present-day values. We use the present-day densities and as input parameters and integrate the background backwards from today (appendix A). For the vacuum transfers energy to the dark sector, in the past, and grows towards the present. Since the CMB fixes the CDM density at early times, , the present-day and are larger than in a model without exchange. For the same reason the contribution of dark radiation to the effective number of relativistic species before recombination is , smaller than . The vacuum energy decreases with time, and the extra CDM changes the low-redshift expansion history, which is constrained by BAO and SNe Ia. At fixed angular acoustic scale the larger late-time matter density lowers : for and , with the early-time parameters fixed as in Figure 1, decreases by }.
The exchange also changes the redshift dependence of the matter density. We define
where includes baryons, CDM and massive neutrinos. In CDM is constant for apart from the small contribution of massive neutrinos, whereas for it decreases with redshift. The present-day therefore overestimates the matter density at the redshifts probed by cosmic shear, which we take into account in § 5.
Linear perturbations and the growth of structure
Because is parallel to , there is no momentum transfer in the CDM rest frame, and the CDM velocity obeys the same equation as in CDM. In the synchronous gauge comoving with CDM, remains a solution, and CDM follows geodesics. We further take the energy transfer to be unperturbed in this frame, , so that the vacuum stays homogeneous in the CDM rest frame and does not cluster. This is the geodesic model of an interacting vacuum [52, 53, 54, 55]. Since the vacuum has no perturbations, the model avoids the large-scale instability that affects some interacting dark energy models and is otherwise treated with the parametrised post-Friedmann approach [65]. The perturbed continuity equation for CDM becomes
where is the trace of the metric perturbation in the notation of ref. [66]. The last term follows from being unchanged by the exchange while changes at the rate . For the vacuum adds CDM uniformly in the CDM rest frame: the new dark matter carries no density perturbation and dilutes the existing density contrast [56]. The metric perturbations are sourced by , which is not changed directly, so the growth of and of the baryon perturbations that follow it is slowed down. With the primordial amplitude fixed by the CMB, is lower and higher than without exchange.
Panels (b) and (c) of Figure 1 illustrate these effects for , varying with the early-time parameters held fixed. The exchange is active at , where the physical matter density departs from its value without exchange and the amplitude of the density fluctuations at fixed comoving scale decreases. For , decreases from 0.809 to 0.747 and increases from 0.292 to 0.330. The two changes act in opposite directions on , and the decrease of dominates: decreases from 0.797 to 0.784. The same behaviour appears in the posteriors of § 4.
Combination with early-time solutions
Dark radiation: CDM
In CDM the vacuum exchanges energy with CDM and with a dark-radiation fluid, following Eqs. (3)–(5). We parametrise the present-day dark-radiation density as , so that counts the dark radiation in units of one massless neutrino species. The dark radiation raises the expansion rate before recombination and reduces the sound horizon. We treat it as a perfect fluid with sound speed and no anisotropic stress. Since it does not free-stream, it does not produce the phase shift of the acoustic peaks caused by free-streaming neutrinos, and its effect on the CMB differs from that of extra neutrino species [23, 67, 68]. For the model reduces to CDM+DR, which we use to isolate the effect of the exchange.
Early dark energy: EDE
In EDE the dark sector contains no dark radiation, and the vacuum exchanges energy with CDM only, i.e. eqs. (3) and (4) with . The EDE scalar field does not take part in the exchange. It contributes to the energy density mainly around the critical redshift , which we fix together with the initial field displacement (§ 3.2), so that is negligible when EDE is dynamically relevant and the two components act at separate epochs. For the model reduces to EDE.
Data and methodology
Data
For the CMB, we use the Planck 2018 likelihoods, Planck TT,TE,EE+lowE+lensing [1, 57]. At high multipoles (), we use the full Plik likelihood for the TT, TE and EE power spectra, sampling all of its foreground and calibration nuisance parameters. At low multipoles (), we use the Commander likelihood for TT and the SimAll likelihood for EE. For the lensing reconstruction, we use the baseline conservative multipole range [58].
For BAO, we use the DESI DR2 measurements with their covariance matrix [2, 59], which comprise 13 data points at seven effective redshifts, , 0.51, 0.706, 0.934, 1.321, 1.484 and 2.33: one point at and two points at each of the other redshifts. We also include one measurement each from 6dFGS at [60] and from SDSS MGS at [61]. The MGS sample partly overlaps in redshift and sky area with the DESI BGS sample; we neglect the correlation between the two measurements, which has little effect because the MGS distance has an uncertainty of about 4%, compared with about 1% for BGS. In total, the BAO data consist of 15 data points.
For SNe Ia, we use the Pantheon+ sample [3, 4], which contains 1701 light curves. Without SH0ES, we use the 1580 light curves at and treat the absolute magnitude as a free parameter, so that the SNe Ia constrain the shape of the expansion history but not . With SH0ES, we use the joint Pantheon+ and SH0ES likelihood [4, 9], which includes the 1371 Hubble-flow SNe Ia at and 77 light curves of SNe Ia in Cepheid host galaxies, 1448 light curves in total; the Cepheid distances calibrate and thus constrain . Since the two SN samples differ, we do not compare values between CBS and CBSH, but only differences between models within each data combination. We do not impose a Gaussian prior on , because the SH0ES value of is derived assuming a CDM-like expansion history at low redshift, which does not hold for models that modify the late-time expansion [69, 70], such as the models with energy exchange considered here.
Models and priors
We compare CDM with two models without energy exchange. The first is CDM. The second, CDM+DR, adds to CDM the same dark-radiation fluid as in CDM, with abundance , but no exchange; the difference between CDM+DR and CDM isolates the effect of the coupling. In CDM the coupling and are free and the power-law index is fixed; we take as the baseline, for which the exchange is confined to (Figure 1a), where it affects the growth of structure, and also consider and , for which it extends to higher redshift. For we switch the exchange on only at , for the reason given in § 2.1. At the posterior values of give , so the exchange is already weak where it is switched on. Both signs of are allowed, so the data determine the direction of the energy flow.
| Parameter | CDM | CDM+DR | CDM |
| , , , , | unbounded | unbounded | unbounded |
| – | |||
| – | – | ||
| (fixed) | – | – |
Table 1. Flat priors of the models with dark radiation. “Unbounded” means no prior boundary, and a dash means that the parameter is not varied. and refer to present-day densities (section 2.2). The Planck nuisance parameters and the SN Ia absolute magnitude are varied in all models.
For EDE we take the axion-like potential [25, 26, 71]. We vary only the maximum fractional contribution of EDE to the total energy density, , and fix the critical scale factor and the initial field displacement to and , the best-fit values of the three-parameter model to the Planck power spectra, as in the one-parameter EDE of refs. [72, 73]. For EDE (section 2.4.2) we consider and . Since more negative confines the exchange to lower redshift, a larger is needed for the same effect on , and we widen the prior on accordingly for .
| Parameter | EDE | EDE () | EDE () |
| [km s Mpc] | |||
| – |
Table 2. Flat priors of the EDE models. Following the AxiCLASS setup, these models are sampled in and instead of and , with bounded priors on the base parameters. The EDE parameters and are fixed. Other conventions as in table 1.
We compute CDM, CDM+DR and CDM with the Boltzmann code CLASS1 [74, 75], in which we implement the energy exchange (appendix § 8), and EDE and EDE with AxiCLASS2 [26, 76], to which we add the same exchange. In all models we include one massive neutrino with eV, and compute the non-linear matter power spectrum with HMcode [77], which enters the Planck lensing likelihood and the shear predictions of § 5. The free parameters of all models and their priors are listed in tables 1 and 2.
Sampling and model comparison
We sample the posterior distributions with MontePython [78, 79], using its Metropolis–Hastings algorithm. For each model and data combination we run four chains, starting from proposal covariance matrices obtained in preliminary runs. We stop the chains when the Gelman–Rubin statistic [80], computed after removing the first 30% of each chain, satisfies for the cosmological parameters in two consecutive checks, and discard the same 30% as burn-in in the analysis. With the burn-in removal and the estimator of MontePython, all runs have , and twelve of the fifteen have (appendix C).
We compare the models through the minimum found in the chains. For each data combination we quote relative to CDM and, for the models with energy exchange, relative to the corresponding model without exchange, CDM+DR for CDM and EDE for EDE. To account for the extra parameters we also quote the Akaike information criterion [81], , where is the number of free parameters added to CDM: one for CDM+DR and EDE, and two for CDM and EDE. Since the minimum is estimated from the chains rather than with a dedicated minimiser, we do not interpret differences of order unity.
We quantify the agreement with external measurements of and in two ways. For a single parameter we use , where and are the posterior mean and standard deviation and, for asymmetric external errors, is the error on the side of . For and jointly we use the parameter-shift statistic of ref. [82]. With , the distribution of the shift is
where is our posterior and is the product of the two external likelihoods, treated as independent, each a Gaussian with the upper and lower errors on the two sides of the central value. The probability that the shift lies in the region where exceeds its value at zero shift,
is converted into an equivalent number of Gaussian standard deviations, . We evaluate eq. (11) on a grid, from the weighted histogram of the chain samples. As external values we take from SH0ES [9] and from KiDS-Legacy [16]. For CBSH, which includes the SH0ES calibration, these numbers measure the consistency of the combined posterior with the external values rather than the tension between independent data sets. For the models with energy exchange the comparison in is only indicative, since is defined with present-day quantities (§ 2.2); we compare with cosmic shear directly in § 5.
Results
The – plane
Figure 2 shows the marginalised posteriors in the – plane, and Figure 3 summarises the constraints on , , and . Table 3 and Table 4 list the constraints on all cosmological parameters. In CDM we find and , and and , for CBS and CBSH, respectively.
| Parameter | CDM | CDM+DR | CDM | EDE | EDE | EDE |
Table 3. Posterior means and 68% intervals of the parameters for CBS; upper limits are at the 95% confidence level. is in units of km s Mpc; and are present-day values, and is relative to CDM.
| Parameter | CDM | CDM+DR | CDM | EDE | EDE | EDE |
| – | – | – | – | |||
| – | – | – | ||||
| – | – | – | ||||
Table 4. Posterior means and 68% intervals of the parameters for CBSH; upper limits are at the 95% confidence level. is in units of km s Mpc; and are present-day values, and is relative to CDM. The columns CDM, EDE with , and EDE with are labelled accordingly.
Figure 2. Marginalised 68% and 95% contours in the – plane for CBS (left) and CBSH (right). Top: CDM, CDM+DR and CDM (); bottom: CDM, EDE and EDE ( and ). The points mark the posterior means, and the arrows connect each model without exchange to the corresponding model with exchange. The vertical and horizontal bands show the and ranges of SH0ES [9] and KiDS-Legacy [16].

Figure 3. Posterior means and 68% intervals of , , and for CBS (open circles) and CBSH (filled squares). The dotted lines mark CDM for CBSH, and the bands show the and ranges of SH0ES and KiDS-Legacy.
Both early-time solutions raise and together. For CBS the dark radiation is not detected, at 95% confidence level, and increases to km s Mpc with almost no change in . For CBSH we find and km s Mpc; increases from 0.1171 to 0.1274, and from 0.804 to 0.815. EDE raises further, to km s Mpc and km s Mpc for CBS and CBSH, respectively, with and . For CBS and CBSH, respectively, the CDM density increases to and 0.134, the spectral index to and 0.992, and to 0.830 and 0.840, i.e. by 0.018 and 0.036 relative to CDM.
The exchange moves the posteriors to lower at almost fixed , as indicated by the arrows in Figure 2. For CBSH, CDM gives , below both CDM+DR and CDM, while km s Mpc decreases by only 0.3 km s Mpc. In EDE with and , decreases from 0.840 to 0.8270.015 and 0.7800.032, respectively, and by 0.2 and 0.4 km s Mpc. For CBS the shifts in are larger: for CDM, and 0.8120.015 and 0.7500.032 for EDE with and , respectively. Without the SH0ES calibration is less tightly constrained and follows the coupling (§ 4.2), and it decreases by 0.6, 0.4 and 1.0 km s Mpc, respectively. In all models with exchange the posterior of becomes broader, since is correlated with the coupling, which the data constrain only weakly.
The lower results from a lower and a higher (Figure 3). For CBSH, CDM has and , compared with and in CDM+DR, and the decrease of dominates, as in the single-parameter scan of § 2.3. For EDE with the changes are larger, and . These are present-day quantities, and we compare the models with cosmic shear directly in § 5.
Constraints on the coupling
Figure 4 shows the posterior of and its correlations with , and the parameter of the early-time solution. In all six cases the posterior peaks at , i.e. at an energy flow from the vacuum into the dark sector. We quote the significance of a non-zero coupling as the posterior mean divided by the standard deviation, together with the posterior probability of . For the skewed posteriors of the ratio is only indicative and is the more direct measure; both depend on the prior range of (§ 6.3). For CBS we find for CDM, from zero with , and (, ) and (, ) for EDE with and , respectively. Adding SH0ES weakens the preference: for CBSH we find (, ), (, ) and (, ) for CDM and EDE with and , respectively. For the preferred values correspond to a present rate to (Figure 7), so that the vacuum adds about 10–15% of the CDM energy per e-fold today. For the present rate is larger, (CBS) and (CBSH), but it falls below in absolute value at , and the exchange is confined to .

Figure 4. Posterior of (first column) and its correlations with , and or , for CDM (top) and EDE with (middle) and (bottom), for CBS (dashed) and CBSH (solid lines and filled contours). The vertical dotted lines mark , and the bands show the and ranges of SH0ES and KiDS-Legacy.
Figure 7. Late-time evolution for CBS (top) and CBSH (bottom). Left: coupling rate per Hubble time for the models with exchange, on a symmetric logarithmic scale. Middle: relative to the median of CDM. Right: , with of eq. (13) for the models with exchange, compared with the RSD measurements from 6dFGS, SDSS MGS, BOSS DR12 and eBOSS DR16 [83, 84, 85]. Lines and bands show the median and the 68% range of 80 posterior samples; for CDM and the models without exchange only the median is shown.
The coupling is strongly correlated with and anti-correlated with : the correlation coefficients are 0.94–0.99 and to in all six cases. The correlation with is weaker, 0.64–0.95, because the changes in and partly compensate, and the correlation with is only 0.2–0.4. In the – plane (Figure 5) the posteriors of the models with exchange extend from the region of the models without exchange towards lower and higher , and cross the lines of constant towards lower values. For CDM the coupling is anti-correlated with , and for CBSH the posterior mean of increases from 0.52 to 0.64. Since is defined today and the vacuum also transfers energy to the dark radiation, part of this increase is produced at low redshift and does not contribute to the early expansion (§ 2.2). In EDE changes little, from 0.138 to 0.154 and 0.150 for CBSH.
Figure 5. Marginalised 68% and 95% contours in the – plane, with the same layout as Figure 2. The grey lines are lines of constant .
Model comparison
Table 5 lists and AIC and the agreement with the external measurements of and . For CBS, all extensions improve the fit only moderately. The exchange lowers relative to the corresponding model without exchange by 3.7 for CDM and by 1.9 and 7.2 for EDE with and . EDE with gives the largest improvement over CDM, and AIC=-9.2$, followed by EDE and EDE with , ; for CDM+DR and CDM is close to zero. For CBSH the extensions that raise improve the fit substantially, by for CDM+DR and for EDE, and the exchange adds , and for CDM and EDE with and , respectively. The lowest is obtained for EDE with , and , but its difference from EDE in , before rounding, is within the uncertainty of the minimum estimated from the chains.
| Model | Joint | ||||||
| CBS | |||||||
| 0 | 0 | – | – | ||||
| – | – | ||||||
| EDE | – | – | |||||
| CBSH | |||||||
| 0 | 0 | – | – | ||||
| – | – | ||||||
| EDE | – | – | |||||
Table 5. Table 5. Model comparison. and are relative to for the same data, and is relative to the corresponding model without exchange ( for , EDE for ). The significance of the coupling is the posterior mean of divided by its standard deviation. The last three columns give the agreement with SH0ES in , with KiDS-Legacy in (positive when the model is higher), and the joint tension in (§ 3.3). For CBSH, the and joint columns measure the consistency of a posterior that includes SH0ES.
For CBS, CDM is in tension with SH0ES and in joint tension with SH0ES and KiDS-Legacy. EDE reduces the joint tension to , and EDE with to , the lowest value for CBS. In the dark-radiation models the joint tension remains at –, since stays below . For CBSH, the joint tension decreases from in CDM to below in all extensions, and is lowest for EDE: for and for , compared with for EDE. The improvement comes from : EDE is above KiDS-Legacy, and the exchange reduces this to for , while the agreement in changes little. Since the KiDS-Legacy value of is close to that of CDM, a lower
does not always improve the agreement: for with and CBS, lies below KiDS-Legacy. Compared with the lower KiDS-1000 value, [13], the exchange reduces the difference in all models, for example for CBSH from to and in the EDE models with and .
Dependence on alpha and on the direction of the energy flow
Figure 6 shows for CBSH with , and , and with and the prior restricted to . The constraint on tightens as increases: for , for , and for . For larger the exchange is active over a wider range of redshift (Figure 1a), where BAO and SNe Ia constrain the expansion history, and a smaller coupling is allowed. The reduction of relative to CDM+DR therefore increases with decreasing , from for to and for and , respectively, and the improvement in from to and . The same trend holds for : with the exchange is confined to , and both the reduction of and the improvement in are larger than for (§ 4.1).
If the energy is allowed to flow only from the dark sector into the vacuum, , the posterior peaks close to zero, . The vacuum then removes CDM at late times, so that decreases to and increases to , above CDM+DR. The fit is not improved relative to CDM+DR, . An energy flow from the vacuum into the dark sector lowers and improves the fit, whereas the opposite flow raises and does not.
Growth rate
Figure 7 shows the redshift dependence of the coupling rate, of relative to CDM, and of , computed for 80 samples of each posterior. The reduction of is concentrated at low redshift. For CBSH, in is 4% below CDM at , 1.5% below at and equal to it at . In with , is 12% below CDM at , but at it is 4% above, close to EDE without exchange. Probes of the clustering amplitude at are much less affected by the exchange than the present-day .
Redshift-space distortions measure the peculiar velocities, which are related to the growth of the density contrast through the continuity equation. With the exchange, the matter density contrast obeys on sub-horizon scales, from eq. (10), and the velocity growth rate differs from the density growth rate :
We compare with the measurements from 6dFGS [83], SDSS MGS [84], BOSS DR12 and eBOSS DR16 [85], which are not included in the likelihood. For the second term in eq. (13) is positive and partly compensates the lower at . Using the diagonal errors, the seven measurements give – for all models and both data combinations, and the models differ by at most 1.1. Current growth-rate measurements do not discriminate between the models.
Confronting cosmic shear
The parameter combines the present-day values of and . Cosmic shear, however, measures the matter distribution integrated along the line of sight, and the values of quoted by shear surveys are inferred assuming that . With the exchange this scaling no longer holds at low redshift (§ 2.2), and the lower found in § 4 need not imply a weaker shear signal. In this section we first compare the models through an effective lensing amplitude as a function of redshift, and then compute the shear correlation functions of each model directly and compare them with the KiDS-Legacy measurements.
Effective lensing amplitude
The lensing kernel is proportional to the matter density, and the shear power spectrum to the square of the amplitude of the matter fluctuations. We therefore define the effective lensing amplitude
where is the linear rms fluctuation in spheres of radius at redshift and is defined in eq. (9). Today , and in CDM the ratio is constant. We compute for 60 samples drawn from each posterior, independently of the samples
Figure 6. CDM for CBSH with different power-law indices and directions of the energy flow. (a) 68% (dark) and 95% (light) contours in the – plane for , , , and with , compared with CDM+DR (dashed). (b)–(e) The corresponding posteriors of . The bands show the 1 and 2 ranges of SH0ES and KiDS-Legacy.
used for the shear predictions of § 5.2. For reference, the lensing kernels of the six KiDS-Legacy source bins peak between and .
Figure 8 shows and relative to CDM. For the models without exchange the ratios are almost independent of redshift: CDM+DR is 0.4% (CBS) and 1.3% (CBSH) above CDM, and EDE 2.2% and 4.5% above. With the exchange the reduction is largest today and decreases with redshift. For relative to CDM+DR, is lower by 2.7% (CBS) and 1.4% (CBSH) at , by 1.8% and 1.0% at , and by 0.7% and 0.5% at . For with the reduction relative to EDE is 2% at , 1.5% at and 0.4% at for both data combinations. For , is lower than in EDE by 10% (CBS) and 8% (CBSH), but the difference falls to 1.2–1.5% at , and at the two models agree within 0.5%. The matter added by the vacuum is present only at late times, so approaches the value without exchange at higher redshift, and the growth of structure is suppressed only after the exchange becomes active. The reduction of therefore overstates the change of the lensing amplitude at the redshifts that dominate the shear signal, in particular for .
Figure 8. Effective lensing amplitude , eq. (14) (top), and (bottom), relative to the median of CDM for the same data, for CBS (left) and CBSH (right). Points and error bars show the median and the 68% range of 60 posterior samples; the points are slightly offset in redshift for clarity. The models without exchange are shown with dashed lines. The grey band marks the range in which the lensing kernels of the KiDS-Legacy source bins peak.
KiDS-Legacy shear correlation functions
Method
We use the shear two-point correlation functions of KiDS-Legacy in six tomographic bins [16], with the covariance matrix of ref. [86]. We apply the scale cuts of the KiDS-Legacy analysis, for and for , which leave 357 of the 378 data points. In the Limber approximation [87] the shear power spectrum of the bins and is
where is the comoving distance and the non-linear matter power spectrum. We compute the lensing kernel with the matter density of each model,
where is the normalised redshift distribution of bin ; in CDM and eq. (16) reduces to the standard kernel. We compute with HMcode-2020 [77] without baryonic feedback, applied to the linear power spectrum of each model. Intrinsic alignments are described by the non-linear alignment model [88, 89], with the intrinsic-alignment kernel proportional to , where and is the linear growth factor normalised to unity today; we use for consistency with eq. (16), and in CDM the kernel reduces to the standard form. The correlation functions follow from , evaluated at the effective angular separations of the data.
For each model and data combination we draw 60 samples from the posterior and compute the of the KiDS-Legacy data for each of them. The amplitude is the only nuisance parameter; we minimise over for each sample, and keep the redshift distributions and the shear calibration fixed. We quote the mean over the samples, which measures how well the predictions of a posterior agree with the shear data; since it includes the scatter of the predictions, it penalises the models with exchange, whose posteriors are broader, and compare models through relative to CDM and to the corresponding model without exchange. The shear data are not included in the sampling: the cosmic-shear likelihoods available to us compute the lensing kernel with , which does not hold for the models with exchange. We check the calculation for CDM in appendix B.
Results
Table 6 lists the results, and Figure 9 compares the predicted with the data for the auto-correlations of the six bins. In the dark-radiation models the of the shear data changes by less than 3 relative to CDM, and the exchange lowers it by 2.0 (CBS) and 0.8 (CBSH) relative to CDM+DR. EDE raises the by 12.2 for CBS and 22.7 for CBSH. For CBSH the predicted of EDE lie about 10–15% above CDM on scales in bins 2 to 6, which reflects the higher lensing amplitude and the larger . The fit also prefers a larger intrinsic-alignment amplitude, – compared with – in CDM, which partly compensates the higher amplitude. For CBS and CBSH, respectively, the exchange reduces this excess by 3.6 and 3.0 for and by 10.8 and 5.6 for , but does not remove it: relative to CDM the remains higher by 8.6 and 19.7 for , and by 1.4 and 17.1 for . The exchange lowers mainly at , where the kernels of the lower source bins peak, whereas at the amplitude of with equals that of EDE (§ 5.1), so the excess in the higher source bins remains. For CBS, where EDE has a smaller and a smaller excess in , the of with is only 1.4 above CDM.
| Model | CBS | CBS | CBS | CBSH | CBSH | CBSH |
| CDM | 0 | – | 0.30 | 0 | – | 0.23 |
| CDM+DR | +1.2 | – | 0.31 | +2.7 | – | 0.31 |
| CDM | −0.8 | −2.0 | 0.26 | +1.9 | −0.8 | 0.29 |
| EDE | +12.2 | – | 0.44 | +22.7 | – | 0.50 |
| EDE () | +8.6 | −3.6 | 0.41 | +19.7 | −3.0 | 0.48 |
| EDE () | +1.4 | −10.8 | 0.32 | +17.1 | −5.6 | 0.48 |
Table 6. Comparison with the KiDS-Legacy correlation functions (357 data points). is the mean over 60 posterior samples relative to CDM, is relative to the corresponding model without exchange, and is the mean of the best-fitting intrinsic-alignment amplitude.
Figure 9. KiDS-Legacy correlation functions (upper two rows) and (lower two rows) for the auto-correlations of the six tomographic bins, relative to the median prediction of CDM for CBSH. Lines and bands show the median and the 68% range of the predictions of 60 posterior samples for CBSH; the models without exchange are shown with dashed lines. The points show the data with the square root of the diagonal of the covariance matrix; points outside the scale cuts are not shown. The corresponding figure for CBS is shown in appendix § 9.
The varies between posterior samples with a standard deviation of 1–3 for the CDM and dark-radiation models and 6–12 for the EDE models, so the statistical uncertainty of the mean from 60 samples is between 0.1 and 1.5. The differences between EDE and are larger than this uncertainty, while those of order unity among the dark-radiation models are not significant.
Robustness and limitations
Our comparison is simpler than the KiDS-Legacy analysis in several respects. First, we keep the redshift distributions, the shear calibration and the baryonic feedback fixed, and the only nuisance parameter is . Marginalising over these parameters would reduce the absolute differences in , in particular for the EDE models, whose excess is concentrated on small scales where baryonic feedback suppresses the power. Since the dark-radiation models and the models with and without exchange differ mainly in the overall amplitude, we expect the ordering of the models to be less sensitive to these choices than the size of the differences. Second, the fiducial KiDS-Legacy constraints are based on COSEBIs and band powers [16]; the correlation functions are provided for comparison, and we evaluate the predictions at the effective angular separations without averaging over the angular bins. Third, HMcode is calibrated on -body simulations without energy exchange [77]. We apply it to the linear power spectrum of each model, which captures the change in the amplitude of the linear fluctuations, but not the changes in the abundance and internal structure of haloes caused by the inflow of homogeneous dark matter, which modifies spherical collapse and the virial overdensity [33]. The size of this effect depends on how much dark matter is transferred while haloes form: about 5–7% of the present CDM density at for , and 20–25% for . For we expect the error to be small compared with the differences between the models, whereas for the predictions on small scales, which dominate , should be regarded as indicative; simulations of an interacting vacuum with geodesic CDM would be needed to model these scales reliably. Finally, the comparison is a test of the posterior predictions of each model rather than a joint fit, and we do not include other shear surveys such as DES Y3. A joint analysis would require a shear likelihood with the lensing kernel of eq. (16) and the full set of nuisance parameters, which we leave to future work.
Discussion
The exchange with different early-time solutions
The exchange acts in the same way on both early-time solutions. For CBSH and it lowers by 0.014 in the dark-radiation model and by 0.013 in the EDE model, and changes by at most 0.3 km s Mpc in both. The early-time solutions, however, raise by different amounts. Dark radiation raises by 0.011 relative to CDM, and the exchange removes this increase. EDE raises by 0.036, through a larger and a larger , and the exchange with removes only about a third of it. For the decrease of exceeds the increase due to EDE, but the decrease of the lensing amplitude is concentrated at , and at the redshifts probed by the higher source bins of KiDS-Legacy the lensing amplitude remains that of EDE (section 5). The exchange changes the amplitude of the matter fluctuations at late times, whereas the larger of EDE also changes the shape of the power spectrum, which a late-time exchange cannot compensate. The exchange is therefore most effective when the early-time solution raises mainly through , as dark radiation does.
The idea of combining a component that raises with a component that suppresses the growth of structure was explored in ref. [30], where an ultralight axion suppresses matter power spectrum on scales below its Jeans length. In our case the suppression comes from the late-time inflow of dark matter without density perturbations, eq. (10). Since the extra term in eq. (10) does not depend on , the suppression is nearly scale-independent on sub-horizon scales and is confined to low redshift, and it is accompanied by an increase of the matter density, , that is absent in the axion case. The two mechanisms leave different imprints on the scale and redshift dependence of the clustering amplitude, which tomographic shear and galaxy clustering data could distinguish.
Physical interpretation of the preferred coupling
In all cases the posteriors favour , i.e. an energy flow from the vacuum into the dark sector. This is the direction expected from particle production by the vacuum in an expanding universe [46], which motivates the CDM model [47, 48]. The flow in the opposite direction is not favoured: with the posterior peaks at zero and the fit is slightly worse than without exchange (section 4.4). The preference is stronger for CBS than for CBSH, and the coupling is correlated mainly with and and only weakly with (§ 4.2), so it is not driven by the SH0ES calibration. The same direction of the energy flow is found in late-time analyses of interacting dark energy with and , where the preference weakens when is left free and moves to [90]; since the exchange itself gives the vacuum an effective equation of state above (see below), the two descriptions are partly degenerate.
The preferred coupling corresponds to a present rate to for , so the vacuum transfers about 10–15% of the CDM energy per e-fold today. Since the vacuum loses this energy, its density decreases slowly, and its effective equation of state obtained from eqs. (3)–(5) is
which for lies above . Since stays above at all times, the exchange does not produce the crossing of preferred by the DESI DR2 analysis of the parametrisation [2]. With today, – for . For the present rate is to , and – today, but the exchange switches on only at . In this case relative to CDM increases by about 20–30% between and today (Figure 8), most of it at . For the exchange is active over a wider range of redshift, and the data restrict the coupling to values for which the effect on is small (section 4.4). An exchange that switches on late, with , therefore allows a larger reduction of , although the differences in between the values of are small.
Caveats
Our analysis has several limitations. We use the one-parameter EDE model with and fixed [72, 73]. Varying these parameters broadens the EDE posterior, but the late-time exchange acts in the same way for any early-time solution, and we expect the shift in caused by the exchange to be similar. We treat as a limiting case that confines the exchange to , in order to show how the effect on depends on when the exchange is active, rather than as a model preferred on physical grounds. In this case the present rate is large, –, and about 20–25% of the present CDM density is transferred from the vacuum at , compared with 7–10% over the whole history for . The linear equations remain valid for any value of , since the energy is transferred along the CDM four-velocity and the vacuum, with , does not cluster, so that the early-time instability of interacting dark-energy fluids does not arise [52, 53]; the large change of at low redshift, however, makes the non-linear modelling discussed below less reliable for this case. The significance of the coupling depends on the prior on in the usual way for a parameter that is consistent with zero at the – level, and the improvement in is estimated from the chains rather than with a minimiser, so differences of order unity in and should not be over-interpreted. We use the Planck 2018 CMB data; ground-based CMB measurements constrain EDE more tightly [91], which would likely reduce the increase of and of in the EDE models. The non-linear power spectrum is computed with HMcode, which is calibrated on simulations without energy exchange; this affects the Planck lensing likelihood only weakly, but limits the accuracy of the cosmic-shear predictions on small scales, in particular for (§ 5.2.3). Finally, our comparison with cosmic shear fixes the redshift distributions, the shear calibration and the baryonic feedback (§ 5.2.3); a joint analysis of CMB, BAO, SNe Ia and shear data with a consistent treatment of the lensing kernel would test whether the preference for survives when the shear data enter the likelihood.
Conclusions
Extensions of CDM that raise through additional energy before recombination also raise , because the CMB then requires a larger dark matter density. We have studied whether an energy exchange between the vacuum and the dark sector, active only at late times, can offset this increase. The coupling rate scales as , so that for the exchange is negligible before recombination and leaves the sound horizon unchanged. The energy is transferred along the CDM four-velocity and is unperturbed in the CDM rest frame, so that CDM follows geodesics and the vacuum does not cluster. When the vacuum decays into CDM, the new dark matter carries no density perturbation: increases, decreases, and decreases. We added this exchange to two early-time solutions, dark radiation (CDM) and a one-parameter EDE model (EDE), and constrained the models with Planck 2018, DESI DR2 BAO and Pantheon+ data (CBS), and with the SH0ES calibration added (CBSH). Our main results are the following.
Without the SH0ES calibration the posteriors favour an energy flow from the vacuum into the dark sector, , at for CDM and at and for EDE with and , respectively, with , and relative to the models without exchange. The exchange lowers from to in the dark-radiation model and from to and in the EDE model. It does not raise , which decreases by – km s Mpc; CDM gives km s Mpc, below SH0ES, and EDE lies – below.
With the SH0ES calibration, which holds at a high value, the exchange lowers at almost fixed . CDM gives km s Mpc and ; the corresponding values are km s Mpc and for CDM+DR, and km s Mpc and for CDM. In the EDE model the exchange lowers from to and for and , respectively, with decreasing by at most km s Mpc. The coupling differs from zero by –. Since these posteriors include SH0ES, the high values of reflect the calibration and test the exchange conditionally on it, rather than showing that the Hubble tension is eased.
The direction and the timing of the exchange matter. Restricting the flow to the opposite direction raises and does not improve the fit. For and the exchange is active over a wider range of redshift, the coupling is more tightly constrained, and the reduction of is smaller; is a limiting case in which the exchange is confined to .
The reduction of overstates the effect on cosmic shear. Since the exchange changes the matter density at low redshift, the reduction of the lensing amplitude is largest today and amounts to only 1–2% at –0.6, where the KiDS-Legacy lensing kernels peak. In the dark-radiation models the of the KiDS-Legacy correlation functions changes by less than 3. EDE raises it by 12 (CBS) and 23 (CBSH) relative to CDM, and the exchange reduces this excess by 3–4 for and by 6–11 for , without removing it.
A late-time exchange between the vacuum and dark matter can thus offset the increase of caused by dark radiation and part of that caused by EDE, without undoing the increase of provided by the early-time solution. It does not ease the Hubble tension itself, its effect is concentrated at the lowest redshifts, where current shear data have little weight, and it leaves the larger of EDE unchanged. The coupling differs from zero by at most , so current data do not require the exchange. A joint analysis with a cosmic-shear likelihood that uses the matter density of each model in the lensing kernel would test the preference for directly. Tomographic shear and clustering measurements from Euclid [92] and LSST [93] will measure the lensing amplitude as a function of redshift, and can distinguish a late-time exchange, whose effect grows towards , from mechanisms that suppress the growth of structure at all redshifts. Observations of the redshifted 21-cm line provide a complementary probe. Intensity mapping of neutral hydrogen with the SKA [94] and other radio telescopes will measure the expansion rate and the growth of structure over [95, 96] and can constrain energy exchange in the dark sector [97]; since the exchange changes both and the growth rate at , such data combined with cosmic shear would separate its effects on the background and on the clustering amplitude.
Implementation in CLASS and numerical validation
We implement the exchange in version 3.3 of CLASS. The background equations (2.3)–(2.5) are integrated together with the other background quantities. The input parameters are the present-day densities and , and the present vacuum density follows from the flatness condition. Since the exchange changes the CDM and dark-radiation densities between the initial time and today, the initial values are not known in advance. We obtain them by integrating eqs. (2.3)–(2.5) backwards from today to the initial scale factor of CLASS with a fourth-order Runge–Kutta scheme in , and then integrate forwards with the standard background integrator. At the best-fitting point of CDM for CBSH, , the forward integration recovers the input values of and to relative precision and , and agrees with to . For the exchange is switched off at (§ 2.1). The dark radiation is implemented as the interacting dark radiation species of CLASS with fluid perturbations, so that its background density can exchange energy with the vacuum.
In the perturbation module we add the term to the CDM continuity equation, eq. (10), and keep in the synchronous gauge. The perturbations of the dark-radiation fluid follow the standard fluid equations. Adding the corresponding exchange terms, and , to the dark-radiation equations changes the CMB spectra at the best-fitting points for and by less than in TT, in EE and in the lensing potential, and by , so these terms have no effect on our results.
We have checked the implementation in several ways. For the modified code reproduces the unmodified CLASS: the of the CDM best-fitting point is recovered exactly, and CDM+DR agrees with the interacting dark radiation fluid of CLASS to . For the EDE models we add the same equations to AxiCLASS. With the modified AxiCLASS reproduces the of the original code at the EDE best-fitting point to all printed digits. Without EDE and with , the two implementations give the same change in , , the same factor at , and the same ratio , to five significant digits. Finally, the values of and recomputed for the posterior samples used in sections 4.5 and § 5 agree with those stored in the chains to .
Cosmic shear pipeline validation
The predictions of § 5.2 use a simplified pipeline with as the only nuisance parameter. To assess it, we have also implemented the full KiDS-Legacy correlation-function likelihood following the official pipeline [16]: the theory is averaged over the angular bins with the measured pair counts, the redshift distributions are shifted with the correlated priors of the redshift calibration, the intrinsic alignment follows the mass-dependent model of the KiDS-Legacy analysis, and the non-linear power spectrum includes baryonic feedback through HMcode-2020. For 30 samples drawn at random from the official KiDS-Legacy chain, this likelihood reproduces to within 0.3% and the of the official analysis with a mean difference of and a scatter of 1.9, for . In this comparison the AGN heating temperature of HMcode was fixed to rather than taken from the official chain, which accounts for most of the remaining scatter.
With the nuisance parameters fixed, the simplified pipeline gives larger values of : for the CDM posteriors the mean is 430 (CBS) and 428 (CBSH) for 357 data points. We therefore interpret only the differences in between models, which are computed with the same fixed nuisance parameters. Rescaling the predicted of CDM by a free amplitude gives a best-fitting factor of for CBS and for CBSH, consistent with the agreement between the value of found by KiDS-Legacy [16] and that inferred from the CMB in CDM at the level of a few per cent. In CDM the lensing kernel of eq. (16) reduces to the standard one, so the differences between models come only from the background and the power spectrum of each model. Figure 10 shows the predictions for CBS.
Figure 10. As Figure 9, for CBS.
Convergence diagnostics
During sampling we monitored the Gelman-Rubin statistic [80] of the cosmological parameters, computed after removing the first 30% of each chain, and stopped the chains when in two consecutive checks. Table 7 lists the final values computed with MontePython, which removes the initial part of each chain before the sampler reaches the region of high likelihood. Twelve of the fifteen runs have , and all have . These values are below the thresholds commonly used in analyses of EDE models [72, 73].
| Data | Model | Parameter | Steps | |
| CBS | CDM | 0.0110 | 343,454 | |
| CBS | CDM+DR | 0.0087 | 224,474 | |
| CBS | CDM () | 0.0190 | 251,385 | |
| CBS | EDE | 0.0184 | 364,136 | |
| CBS | EDE () | 0.0131 | 215,223 | |
| CBS | EDE () | 0.0190 | 1,211,029 | |
| CBSH | CDM | 0.0060 | 348,754 | |
| CBSH | CDM+DR | 0.0150 | 347,455 | |
| CBSH | CDM () | 0.0131 | 241,291 | |
| CBSH | EDE | 0.0074 | 317,321 | |
| CBSH | EDE () | 0.0180 | 1,130,608 | |
| CBSH | EDE () | 0.0237 | 445,857 | |
| CBSH | CDM () | 0.0222 | 224,905 | |
| CBSH | CDM () | 0.0200 | 292,759 | |
| CBSH | CDM (, ) | 0.0091 | 305,780 |
Table 7. Convergence of the chains: the largest Gelman–Rubin among the cosmological parameters, computed by MontePython, the parameter for which it is reached, and the number of steps after burn-in (including repeated points), summed over the four chains.
Data availability. The modified versions of CLASS and AxiCLASS and the chains are available from the first author upon reasonable request.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the Early-Career Young Scientists and Technologists Project of Jiangxi Province under Grant No. 20262BEJ730225, the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant Nos. 12533001, 12473001 and 12575049, the National SKA Program of China under Grant Nos. 2022SKA0110200 and 2022SKA0110203, the China Manned Space Program under Grant No. CMSCSST2025A02, and the 111 Project under Grant No. B16009. This work is based on observations obtained with Planck (http://www.esa.int/Planck), an ESA science mission with instruments and contributions directly funded by ESA Member States, NASA, and Canada. We thank the DESI collaboration for making the DR2 BAO measurements publicly available, and the Pantheon+ and SH0ES teams for releasing their data. The cosmic-shear data are based on observations made with ESO Telescopes at the La Silla Paranal Observatory under programme IDs 179.A-2004, 177.A-3016, 177.A-3017, 177.A3018 and 298.A-5015. We used Claude (Anthropic) for language editing of the manuscript; the authors take full responsibility for the content.
References
- [1]Planck collaboration, Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters, Astron. Astrophys. 641 (2020) A6 [1807.06209].
- [2]DESI collaboration, DESI DR2 results. II. Measurements of baryon acoustic oscillations and cosmological constraints, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 083515 [2503.14738].
- [3]D. Scolnic et al., The Pantheon+ Analysis: The Full Data Set and Light-curve Release, Astrophys. J. 938 (2022) 113 [2112.03863].DOI
- [4]D. Brout et al., The Pantheon+ Analysis: Cosmological Constraints, Astrophys. J. 938 (2022) 110 [2202.04077].
- [5]L. Verde, T. Treu and A.G. Riess, Tensions between the Early and the Late Universe, Nature Astron. 3 (2019) 891 [1907.10625].DOI
- [6]E. Di Valentino, O. Mena, S. Pan, L. Visinelli, W. Yang, A. Melchiorri et al., In the realm of the Hubble tension—a review of solutions, Class. Quant. Grav. 38 (2021) 153001 [2103.01183].DOI
- [7]E. Abdalla et al., Cosmology intertwined: A review of the particle physics, astrophysics, and cosmology associated with the cosmological tensions and anomalies, JHEAp 34 (2022) 49 [2203.06142].DOI
- [8]T.-N. Li, G.-H. Du, H. Wang, Y.-H. Li, J.-F. Zhang and X. Zhang, Dark Energy in the DESI Era: A Brief Review of Evidence, Beyond-ΛCDM Interpretations, and Tensions, Res. Astron. Astrophys. 26 (2026) 084002 [2606.21826].DOI
- [9]A.G. Riess et al., A Comprehensive Measurement of the Local Value of the Hubble Constant with 1 km s−1 Mpc−1 Uncertainty from the Hubble Space Telescope and the SH0ES Team, Astrophys. J. Lett. 934 (2022) L7 [2112.04510].DOI
- [10]A.G. Riess, G.S. Anand, W. Yuan, S. Casertano, A. Dolphin, L.M. Macri et al., JWST Observations Reject Unreconciled Crowding of Cepheid Photometry as an Explanation for the Hubble Tension at 8σ Confidence, Astrophys. J. Lett. 962 (2024) L17 [2401.04773].DOI
- [11]A.G. Riess et al., JWST Validates HST Distance Measurements: Selection of Supernova Subsample Explains Differences in JWST Estimates of Local H0, Astrophys. J. 977 (2024) 120 [2408.11770].arxiv.org/abs/2408.11770
- [12]W.L. Freedman, B.F. Madore, T.J. Hoyt, I.S. Jang, A.J. Lee and K.A. Owens, Status Report on the Chicago-Carnegie Hubble Program (CCHP): Measurement of the Hubble Constant Using the Hubble and James Webb Space Telescopes, Astrophys. J. 985 (2025) 203 [2408.06153].arxiv.org/abs/2408.06153
- [13]KiDS collaboration, KiDS-1000 Cosmology: Cosmic shear constraints and comparison between two point statistics, Astron. Astrophys. 645 (2021) A104 [2007.15633].
- [14]DES collaboration, Dark Energy Survey Year 3 results: Cosmology from cosmic shear and robustness to data calibration, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 023514 [2105.13543].
- [15]DES collaboration, Dark Energy Survey Year 3 results: Cosmology from cosmic shear and robustness to modeling uncertainty, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 023515 [2105.13544].
- [16]A.H. Wright et al., KiDS-Legacy: Cosmological constraints from cosmic shear with the complete Kilo-Degree Survey, Astron. Astrophys. 703 (2025) A158 [2503.19441].
- [17]L. Knox and M. Millea, Hubble constant hunter’s guide, Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 043533 [1908.03663].DOI
- [18]N. Schöneberg, G. Franco Abellán, A. Pérez Sánchez, S.J. Witte, V. Poulin and J. Lesgourgues, The H0 Olympics: A fair ranking of proposed models, Phys. Rept. 984 (2022) 1 [2107.10291].
- [19]R.-Y. Guo, J.-F. Zhang and X. Zhang, Can the H0 tension be resolved in extensions to ΛCDM cosmology?, JCAP 02 (2019) 054 [1809.02340].DOI
- [20]J.L. Bernal, L. Verde and A.G. Riess, The trouble with H0, JCAP 10 (2016) 019 [1607.05617].
- [21]M.-M. Zhao, D.-Z. He, J.-F. Zhang and X. Zhang, Search for sterile neutrinos in holographic dark energy cosmology: Reconciling Planck observation with the local measurement of the Hubble constant, Phys. Rev. D 96 (2017) 043520 [1703.08456].DOI
- [22]L. Feng, J.-F. Zhang and X. Zhang, Search for sterile neutrinos in a universe of vacuum energy interacting with cold dark matter, Phys. Dark Univ. 23 (2019) 100261 [1712.03148].DOI
- [23]N. Blinov and G. Marques-Tavares, Interacting radiation after Planck and its implications for the Hubble Tension, JCAP 09 (2020) 029 [2003.08387].DOI
- [24]D. Aloni, A. Berlin, M. Joseph, M. Schmaltz and N. Weiner, A Step in understanding the Hubble tension, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 123516 [2111.00014].DOI
- [25]V. Poulin, T.L. Smith, T. Karwal and M. Kamionkowski, Early Dark Energy Can Resolve The Hubble Tension, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122 (2019) 221301 [1811.04083].DOI
- [26]T.L. Smith, V. Poulin and M.A. Amin, Oscillating scalar fields and the Hubble tension: a resolution with novel signatures, Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 063523 [1908.06995].DOI
- [27]V. Poulin, T.L. Smith and T. Karwal, The Ups and Downs of Early Dark Energy solutions to the Hubble tension: A review of models, hints and constraints circa 2023, Phys. Dark Univ. 42 (2023) 101348 [2302.09032].arxiv.org/abs/2302.09032
- [28]J.C. Hill, E. McDonough, M.W. Toomey and S. Alexander, Early dark energy does not restore cosmological concordance, Phys. Rev. D 102 (2020) 043507 [2003.07355].DOI
- [29]M.M. Ivanov, E. McDonough, J.C. Hill, M. Simonović, M.W. Toomey, S. Alexander et al., Constraining Early Dark Energy with Large-Scale Structure, Phys. Rev. D 102 (2020) 103502 [2006.11235].DOI
- [30]I.J. Allali, M.P. Hertzberg and F. Rompineve, Dark sector to restore cosmological concordance, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) L081303 [2104.12798].DOI
- [31]M. Chevallier and D. Polarski, Accelerating universes with scaling dark matter, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 10 (2001) 213 [gr-qc/0009008].DOI
- [32]E.V. Linder, Exploring the expansion history of the universe, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90 (2003) 091301 [astro-ph/0208512].pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12689209
- [33]B. Wang, E. Abdalla, F. Atrio-Barandela and D. Pavon, Dark Matter and Dark Energy Interactions: Theoretical Challenges, Cosmological Implications and Observational Signatures, Rept. Prog. Phys. 79 (2016) 096901 [1603.08299].DOI
- [34]E. Di Valentino, A. Melchiorri, O. Mena and S. Vagnozzi, Interacting dark energy in the early 2020s: A promising solution to the H_0 and cosmic shear tensions, Phys. Dark Univ. 30 (2020) 100666 [1908.04281].
- [35]T.-N. Li, P.-J. Wu, G.-H. Du, S.-J. Jin, H.-L. Li, J.-F. Zhang et al., Constraints on Interacting Dark Energy Models from the DESI Baryon Acoustic Oscillation and DES Supernovae Data, Astrophys. J. 976 (2024) 1 [2407.14934].DOI
- [36]T.-N. Li, G.-H. Du, Y.-H. Li, P.-J. Wu, S.-J. Jin, J.-F. Zhang et al., Probing the sign-changeable interaction between dark energy and dark matter with DESI baryon acoustic oscillations and DES supernovae data, Sci. China Phys. Mech. Astron. 69 (2026) 210413 [2501.07361].DOI
- [37]T.-N. Li, W. Giarè, G.-H. Du, Y.-H. Li, E. Di Valentino, J.-F. Zhang et al., Robust Preference for Dark Sector Interactions, 2601.07361.arxiv.org/abs/2601.07361
- [38]T.-N. Li, G.-H. Du, Y.-H. Li, Y. Li, J.-L. Ling, J.-F. Zhang et al., Updated constraints on interacting dark energy: A comprehensive analysis using multiple CMB probes, DESI DR2, and supernovae observations, 2510.11363.arxiv.org/abs/2510.11363
- [39]T.-N. Li, G.-H. Du, S.-H. Zhou, Y.-H. Li, J.-F. Zhang and X. Zhang, Robust evidence for dynamical dark energy in light of DESI DR2 and joint ACT, SPT, and Planck data, Phys. Dark Univ. 52 (2026) 102254 [2511.22512].
- [40]X. Zhang, Diagnosing dark energy in the post-DESI era: From effective dynamics to multi-probe consistency tests, Sci. China Phys. Mech. Astron. 69 (2026) 120401.DOI
- [41]K. Aylor, M. Joy, L. Knox, M. Millea, S. Raghunathan and W.L.K. Wu, Sounds Discordant: Classical Distance Ladder & ΛCDM -based Determinations of the Cosmological Sound Horizon, Astrophys. J. 874 (2019) 4 [1811.00537].
- [42]A. Pourtsidou and T. Tram, Reconciling CMB and structure growth measurements with dark energy interactions, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 043518 [1604.04222].DOI
- [43]M. Lucca, Dark energy–dark matter interactions as a solution to the S8 tension, Phys. Dark Univ. 34 (2021) 100899 [2105.09249].DOI
- [44]E. McDonough, M.-X. Lin, J.C. Hill, W. Hu and S. Zhou, Early dark sector, the Hubble tension, and the swampland, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 043525 [2112.09128].
- [45]S. Weinberg, Asymptotically Safe Inflation, Phys. Rev. D 81 (2010) 083535 [0911.3165].DOI
- [46]L. Parker and S.A. Fulling, Quantized matter fields and the avoidance of singularities in general relativity, Phys. Rev. D 7 (1973) 2357.DOI
- [47]S.-S. Xue, How universe evolves with cosmological and gravitational constants, Nucl. Phys. B 897 (2015) 326 [1410.6152].DOI
- [48]S.-S. Xue, Holographic massive plasma state in Friedman universe: cosmological fine-tuning and coincidence problems, JCAP 05 (2024) 113 [2309.15488].arxiv.org/abs/2309.15488
- [49]L.-Y. Gao, Z.-W. Zhao, S.-S. Xue and X. Zhang, Relieving the H 0 tension with a new interacting dark energy model, JCAP 07 (2021) 005 [2101.10714].DOI
- [50]L.-Y. Gao, S.-S. Xue and X. Zhang, Dark energy and matter interacting scenario to relieve H 0 and S 8 tensions*, Chin. Phys. C 48 (2024) 051001 [2212.13146].DOI
- [51]Y.-M. Zhang, T.-N. Li, G.-H. Du, S.-H. Zhou, L.-Y. Gao, J.-F. Zhang et al., Alleviating the H 0 tension through the interacting dark energy model from quantum gravitational field theory in light of DESI DR2, 2510.12627.arxiv.org/abs/2510.12627
- [52]D. Wands, J. De-Santiago and Y. Wang, Inhomogeneous vacuum energy, Class. Quant. Grav. 29 (2012) 145017 [1203.6776].DOI
- [53]Y. Wang, D. Wands, G.-B. Zhao and L. Xu, Post-Planck constraints on interacting vacuum energy, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 023505 [1404.5706].DOI
- [54]M. Martinelli, N.B. Hogg, S. Peirone, M. Bruni and D. Wands, Constraints on the interacting vacuum–geodesic CDM scenario, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 488 (2019) 3423 [1902.10694].DOI
- [55]N.B. Hogg, M. Bruni, R. Crittenden, M. Martinelli and S. Peirone, Latest evidence for a late time vacuum–geodesic CDM interaction, Phys. Dark Univ. 29 (2020) 100583 [2002.10449].
- [56]H.A. Borges and D. Wands, Growth of structure in interacting vacuum cosmologies, Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 103519 [1709.08933].DOI
- [57]Planck collaboration, Planck 2018 results. V. CMB power spectra and likelihoods, Astron. Astrophys. 641 (2020) A5 [1907.12875].
- [58]Planck collaboration, Planck 2018 results. VIII. Gravitational lensing, Astron. Astrophys. 641 (2020) A8 [1807.06210].
- [59]DESI collaboration, DESI DR2 results. I. Baryon acoustic oscillations from the Lyman alpha forest, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 083514 [2503.14739].
- [60]F. Beutler, C. Blake, M. Colless, D.H. Jones, L. Staveley-Smith, L. Campbell et al., The 6dF Galaxy Survey: Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and the Local Hubble Constant, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 416 (2011) 3017 [1106.3366].DOI
- [61]A.J. Ross, L. Samushia, C. Howlett, W.J. Percival, A. Burden and M. Manera, The clustering of the SDSS DR7 main Galaxy sample – I. A 4 per cent distance measure at z = 0.15, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 449 (2015) 835 [1409.3242].DOI
- [62]S.-S. Xue, Massive particle pair production and oscillation in Friedman Universe: its effect on inflation, Eur. Phys. J. C 83 (2023) 36 [2112.09661].arxiv.org/abs/2112.09661
- [63]S.-S. Xue, Massive particle pair production and oscillation in Friedman Universe: reheating energy and entropy, and cold dark matter, Eur. Phys. J. C 83 (2023) 355 [2006.15622].arxiv.org/abs/2006.15622
- [64]A.G. Sanchez, Arguments against using h−1Mpc units in observational cosmology, Phys. Rev. D 102 (2020) 123511 [2002.07829].
- [65]Y.-H. Li, J.-F. Zhang and X. Zhang, Parametrized Post-Friedmann Framework for Interacting Dark Energy, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 063005 [1404.5220].DOI
- [66]C.-P. Ma and E. Bertschinger, Cosmological perturbation theory in the synchronous and conformal Newtonian gauges, Astrophys. J. 455 (1995) 7 [astro-ph/9506072].DOI
- [67]S. Bashinsky and U. Seljak, Neutrino perturbations in CMB anisotropy and matter clustering, Phys. Rev. D 69 (2004) 083002 [astro-ph/0310198].
- [68]D. Baumann, D. Green, J. Meyers and B. Wallisch, Phases of New Physics in the CMB, JCAP 01 (2016) 007 [1508.06342].DOI
- [69]D. Camarena and V. Marra, On the use of the local prior on the absolute magnitude of Type Ia supernovae in cosmological inference, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 504 (2021) 5164 [2101.08641].DOI
- [70]G. Efstathiou, To H0 or not to H0?, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 505 (2021) 3866 [2103.08723].DOI
- [71]M. Kamionkowski, J. Pradler and D.G.E. Walker, Dark energy from the string axiverse, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 (2014) 251302 [1409.0549].DOI
- [72]R. Murgia, G.F. Abellán and V. Poulin, Early dark energy resolution to the Hubble tension in light of weak lensing surveys and lensing anomalies, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 063502 [2009.10733].DOI
- [73]T.L. Smith, V. Poulin, J.L. Bernal, K.K. Boddy, M. Kamionkowski and R. Murgia, Early dark energy is not excluded by current large-scale structure data, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 123542 [2009.10740].DOI
- [74]J. Lesgourgues, The Cosmic Linear Anisotropy Solving System (CLASS) I: Overview, 1104.2932.arxiv.org/abs/1104.2932
- [75]D. Blas, J. Lesgourgues and T. Tram, The Cosmic Linear Anisotropy Solving System (CLASS) II: Approximation schemes, JCAP 07 (2011) 034 [1104.2933].
- [76]V. Poulin, T.L. Smith, D. Grin, T. Karwal and M. Kamionkowski, Cosmological implications of ultralight axionlike fields, Phys. Rev. D 98 (2018) 083525 [1806.10608].DOI
- [77]A. Mead, S. Brieden, T. Tröster and C. Heymans, hmcode-2020: improved modelling of non-linear cosmological power spectra with baryonic feedback, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 502 (2021) 1401 [2009.01858].DOI
- [78]B. Audren, J. Lesgourgues, K. Benabed and S. Prunet, Conservative Constraints on Early Cosmology: an illustration of the Monte Python cosmological parameter inference code, JCAP 02 (2013) 001 [1210.7183].DOI
- [79]T. Brinckmann and J. Lesgourgues, MontePython 3: boosted MCMC sampler and other features, Phys. Dark Univ. 24 (2019) 100260 [1804.07261].arxiv.org/abs/1804.07261
- [80]A. Gelman and D.B. Rubin, Inference from Iterative Simulation Using Multiple Sequences, Statist. Sci. 7 (1992) 457.DOI
- [81]H. Akaike, A new look at the statistical model identification, IEEE Trans. Automatic Control 19 (1974) 716.DOI
- [82]M. Raveri and C. Doux, Non-Gaussian estimates of tensions in cosmological parameters, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) 043504 [2105.03324].DOI
- [83]F. Beutler, C. Blake, M. Colless, D.H. Jones, L. Staveley-Smith, G.B. Poole et al., The 6dF Galaxy Survey: z ≈ 0 measurement of the growth rate and σ8, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 423 (2012) 3430 [1204.4725].
- [84]C. Howlett, A. Ross, L. Samushia, W. Percival and M. Manera, The clustering of the SDSS main galaxy sample – II. Mock galaxy catalogues and a measurement of the growth of structure from redshift space distortions at z = 0.15, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 449 (2015) 848 [1409.3238].
- [85]EBOSS collaboration, Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Cosmological implications from two decades of spectroscopic surveys at the Apache Point Observatory, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 083533 [2007.08991].
- [86]R. Reischke et al., KiDS-Legacy: Covariance validation and the unified OneCovariance framework for projected large-scale structure observables, Astron. Astrophys. 699 (2025) A124 [2410.06962].
- [87]M. LoVerde and N. Afshordi, Extended Limber Approximation, Phys. Rev. D 78 (2008) 123506 [0809.5112].DOI
- [88]C.M. Hirata and U. Seljak, Intrinsic alignment-lensing interference as a contaminant of cosmic shear, Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004) 063526 [astro-ph/0406275].arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0406275
- [89]S. Bridle and L. King, Dark energy constraints from cosmic shear power spectra: impact of intrinsic alignments on photometric redshift requirements, New J. Phys. 9 (2007) 444 [0705.0166].
- [90]P.-J. Wu, M. Zhang and S.-J. Jin, How dark sector equations of state govern interaction signatures, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026) L081302 [2512.05548].DOI
- [91]ATACAMA COSMOLOGY TELESCOPE collaboration, The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: DR6 constraints on extended cosmological models, JCAP 11 (2025) 063 [2503.14454].
- [92]EUCLID collaboration, Euclid - I. Overview of the Euclid mission, Astron. Astrophys. 697 (2025) A1 [2405.13491].
- [93]LSST collaboration, LSST: from Science Drivers to Reference Design and Anticipated Data Products, Astrophys. J. 873 (2019) 111 [0805.2366].
- [94]SKA collaboration, Cosmology with Phase 1 of the Square Kilometre Array: Red Book 2018: Technical specifications and performance forecasts, Publ. Astron. Soc. Austral. 37 (2020) e007 [1811.02743].
- [95]P. Bull, P.G. Ferreira, P. Patel and M.G. Santos, Late-time cosmology with 21cm intensity mapping experiments, Astrophys. J. 803 (2015) 21 [1405.1452].DOI
- [96]P.-J. Wu and X. Zhang, Prospects for measuring dark energy with 21 cm intensity mapping experiments, JCAP 01 (2022) 060 [2108.03552].
- [97]M. Zhang, B. Wang, P.-J. Wu, J.-Z. Qi, Y. Xu, J.-F. Zhang et al., Prospects for Constraining Interacting Dark Energy Models with 21 cm Intensity Mapping Experiments, Astrophys. J. 918 (2021) 56 [2102.03979].DOI







