betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Classification problems for diassociative and dendriform algebras: a survey

Abstract

Diassociative algebras (associative dialgebras) and dendriform algebras are vector spaces with two binary operations, introduced by J.-L. Loday in the study of Leibniz algebras; their operads are Koszul dual to each other. We survey the classification problem for these two classes, including the Zinbiel algebras, the commutative dendriform algebras, which are Koszul dual to Leibniz algebras. We recall the definitions, the main examples and the Loday diagram with its extension by left-symmetric algebras and dialgebras, and describe the methods used to classify algebras of small dimension: direct computation from lists of associative algebras, annihilator (central) extensions and geometric classification by degenerations. We then collect, by dimension, the known algebraic classifications of diassociative algebras, dendriform algebras and their commutative case, the Zinbiel algebras, point out lists that later work corrected, and summarise the cohomological results that the methods rely on. We close with a list of open problems.

Introduction

The structure theory of associative algebras goes back to the second half of the nineteenth century. Peirce’s Linear associative algebra [66] already contained lists of algebras of small dimension, and the classification of associative algebras of a given dimension remains a source of problems today [67, 73, 27]. In the last decades of the twentieth century non-associative structures moved to the centre of algebra, largely because of their role in geometry and physics. Lie algebras are the main example: over a field of characteristic zero every finite-dimensional Lie algebra is the semidirect sum of a semisimple subalgebra and its solvable radical, the semisimple part is a direct sum of simple algebras classified by Cartan and Killing, and the problem reduces to solvable and finally to nilpotent algebras [46, 43, 20].

In the early 1990s J.-L. Loday introduced a family of algebraic structures, now often called Loday algebras, while studying the periodicity of algebraic KK-theory and Leibniz homology [55, 56]. The four main members are Leibniz algebras, diassociative algebras, dendriform algebras and Zinbiel algebras. A Leibniz algebra is a non-antisymmetric analogue of a Lie algebra. A diassociative algebra (associative dialgebra) has two associative products ⊣\dashv and ⊢\vdash and plays for Leibniz algebras the role that associative algebras play for Lie algebras: the bracket [x,y]=x⊣y−y⊢x[x,y]=x\dashv y-y\vdash x is a Leibniz bracket. A dendriform algebra has two products ≺\prec and ≻\succ whose

2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 17-02; Secondary 17A30, 17A32, 16W99. sum is associative, so it “splits” an associative product; Zinbiel algebras are the commutative dendriform algebras. In the language of operads, Dias and Dend are Koszul dual, as are Leib and Zinb [41, 56]. These structures have since appeared in homological algebra [37, 38, 39], deformation theory [61, 62, 87, 35], combinatorics of planar trees and polytopes [57], Rota–Baxter algebras [5, 29, 30], polynomial identities [51, 21, 52] and low-dimensional topology [53].

This paper surveys one problem for the two classes with two binary operations, diassociative and dendriform algebras: their classification. As for associative and Lie algebras, a complete classification in all dimensions is out of reach, and the literature consists of lists of algebras of small dimension, often restricted to nilpotent algebras, together with methods to obtain them. These results are scattered over journals and conference proceedings, several lists were later corrected, and the methods developed for other varieties (central extensions, degenerations) have been applied to dialgebras only partly. Our aim is to collect the known classifications by dimension, explain the methods behind them, record the corrections and list the problems that remain open. Earlier surveys covering related ground are Bremner’s survey of dialgebras and polynomial identities [21], Rakhimov’s survey of the classification problem for Loday algebras [70], and the surveys of Kaygorodov and coauthors on the algebraic and geometric classification of non-associative algebras [47, 48].

Section 2 recalls the definitions, the main examples and the Loday diagram with its extension by left-symmetric algebras and dialgebras. Section 3 describes the classification problem and its methods. Sections 4 and 5 collect the results for diassociative and dendriform algebras, Section 6 summarises the cohomological results used by the methods, and Section 7 lists open problems.

Algebras with two binary operations

Throughout, an algebra is a vector space over a field K\mathbb{K} with one or more bilinear products; the dimension of the algebra is the dimension of the space. Unless stated otherwise, K=C\mathbb{K} = \mathbb{C}.

Leibniz algebras

A (right) Leibniz algebra is a vector space LL with a bilinear bracket satisfying

[[x,y],z]=[[x,z],y]+[x,[y,z]](x,y,z∈L).(1)[[x,y],z] = [[x,z],y] + [x,[y,z]] \qquad(x,y,z \in L). \tag*{(1)}

An antisymmetric Leibniz algebra is a Lie algebra. Leibniz algebras were introduced by Bloh [18] and, independently, by Loday [55]. Their structure theory is well developed (Levi decomposition, Cartan subalgebras, solvable and nilpotent algebras), and their low-dimensional classification is a large subject in its own right; see [10, 11, 12, 7] and the survey [47]. In this paper Leibniz algebras appear mainly as the target of the functor from diassociative algebras.

Diassociative algebras

Definition 2.1 ([56]). A diassociative algebra (or associative dialgebra) is a vector space DD with two bilinear products ⊣\dashv and ⊢\vdash such that, for all x,y,z∈Dx,y,z \in D,

(x⊣y)⊣z=x⊣(y⊣z),(x⊣y)⊣z=x⊣(y⊢z),(x⊢y)⊣z=x⊢(y⊣z),(x⊣y)⊢z=x⊢(y⊢z),(x⊢y)⊢z=x⊢(y⊢z).(2)\begin{aligned} (x \dashv y) \dashv z &= x \dashv(y \dashv z), \\ (x \dashv y) \dashv z &= x \dashv(y \vdash z), \\ (x \vdash y) \dashv z &= x \vdash(y \dashv z), \\ (x \dashv y) \vdash z &= x \vdash(y \vdash z), \\ (x \vdash y) \vdash z &= x \vdash(y \vdash z). \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

The first and the last identity say that ⊣\dashv and ⊢\vdash are associative, and the three middle identities link the two products. Many authors therefore define a diassociative algebra as a vector space with two associative products satisfying the three identities

(x⊣y)⊣z=x⊣(y⊢z),(x⊢y)⊣z=x⊢(y⊣z),(x⊣y)⊢z=(x⊢y)⊢z,\begin{aligned} (x \dashv y) \dashv z &= x \dashv(y \vdash z), \qquad(x \vdash y) \dashv z = x \vdash(y \dashv z),\\ (x \dashv y) \vdash z &= (x \vdash y) \vdash z, \end{aligned}

the last one being the combination of the fourth and fifth identities in (2); the two definitions are equivalent. An associative algebra is a diassociative algebra with x⊣y=x⊢yx \dashv y=x \vdash y. The following examples are due to Loday [56] and Lin–Zhang [54].

Example 2.2. Let (A,d)(A,d) be a differential associative algebra with d2=0d^{2}=0. Then

x⊣y=xd(y),x⊢y=d(x)yx \dashv y=xd(y), \qquad x \vdash y=d(x)y

define a diassociative algebra on AA.

Example 2.3. Let AA be an associative algebra, MM an AA-bimodule and f:M→Af:M\to A a bimodule map. Then

m⊣m′=mf(m′),m⊢m′=f(m)m′m \dashv m^{\prime}=mf(m^{\prime}), \qquad m \vdash m^{\prime}=f(m)m^{\prime}

define a diassociative algebra on MM.

Example 2.4. Let AA be an associative algebra and D=AnD=A^{n}. Then

(x⊣y)i=xi(∑jyj)and(x⊢y)i=(∑jxj)yi(x \dashv y)_{i}=x_{i}\left(\sum_{j}y_{j}\right) \qquad\text{and}\qquad(x \vdash y)_{i}=\left(\sum_{j}x_{j}\right)y_{i}

define a diassociative algebra.

Example 2.5 [54]. On the polynomial algebra K[x,y]\mathbb{K}[x,y] the products

f(x,y)⊣g(x,y)=f(x,y)g(y,y),f(x,y)⊢g(x,y)=f(x,x)g(x,y)f(x,y)\dashv g(x,y)=f(x,y)g(y,y), \qquad f(x,y)\vdash g(x,y)=f(x,x)g(x,y)

define a diassociative algebra.

Proposition 2.6 [56]. If DD is diassociative, then [x,y]=x⊣y−y⊢x[x,y]=x\dashv y-y\vdash x satisfies (1). This gives a functor Dias→Leib\mathbf{Dias}\to\mathbf{Leib} extending the commutator functor As→Lie\mathbf{As}\to\mathbf{Lie}.

Loday showed that the universal enveloping algebra of a Leibniz algebra is naturally a diassociative algebra, and Aymon and Grivel proved a Poincaré–Birkhoff–Witt theorem in this setting [13]. The free diassociative algebra has a basis described by planar binary trees [56].

Dendriform and Zinbiel algebras

Definition 2.7 [56]. A dendriform algebra is a vector space EE with two bilinear products ≺\prec and ≻\succ such that, for all x,y,z∈Ex,y,z\in E,

(x≺y)≺z=x≺(y≺z+y≻z),(x≻y)≺z=x≻(y≺z),(x≺y+x≻y)≻z=x≻(y≻z).(3)\begin{aligned} (x\prec y)\prec z &= x\prec(y\prec z+y\succ z), \qquad(x\succ y)\prec z=x\succ(y\prec z),\\ (x\prec y+x\succ y)\succ z &= x\succ(y\succ z). \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

Adding the three identities shows that x∗y=x≺y+x≻yx*y=x\prec y+x\succ y is associative, which gives a functor Dend→As\mathbf{Dend}\to\mathbf{As}. Moreover x∘y=x≻y−y≺xx\circ y=x\succ y-y\prec x is a left-symmetric (pre-Lie) product, which gives a functor Dend→LSA\mathbf{Dend}\to\mathbf{LSA} [5, 56].

Example 2.8 [5, 29]. Let AA be an associative algebra with a Rota–Baxter operator RR of weight 00, that is,

R(x)R(y)=R(R(x)y+xR(y)).R(x)R(y)=R(R(x)y+xR(y)).

Then x≺y=xR(y)x\prec y=xR(y) and x≻y=R(x)yx\succ y=R(x)y define a dendriform algebra. Operators of non-zero weight give dendriform trialgebras in the same way [29], and every dendriform algebra embeds into a Rota–Baxter algebra [30, 25, 44].

Definition 2.9. A Zinbiel algebra is a vector space ZZ with a product satisfying

(x⋅y)⋅z=x⋅(y⋅z)+x⋅(z⋅y).(x\cdot y)\cdot z=x\cdot(y\cdot z)+x\cdot(z\cdot y).

A Zinbiel algebra is exactly a dendriform algebra with x≻y=y≺xx \succ y = y \prec x, through x⋅y=x≺yx \cdot y = x \prec y; its symmetrisation x⋅y+y⋅xx \cdot y + y \cdot x is commutative and associative. A standard example is the space of integrable functions with (f⋅g)(x)=f(x)∫0xg(t) dt(f \cdot g)(x) = f(x)\int_{0}^{x}g(t)\,\mathrm{d}t. The name is Leibniz read backwards, and Loday also wrote under the pseudonym G. W. Zinbiel [91].

The Loday diagram

The operads Dias and Dend are binary, quadratic and Koszul, and Dias!=Dend\mathrm{Dias}^{!}=\mathrm{Dend}; likewise Leib!=Zinb\mathrm{Leib}^{!}=\mathrm{Zinb}, while As!=As\mathrm{As}^{!}=\mathrm{As} and Com!=Lie\mathrm{Com}^{!}=\mathrm{Lie} [41, 56]. Chapoton [24] showed that these operads are anticyclic and computed their characters. The corresponding categories of algebras form the commutative diagram of functors in Figure 1, in which the Koszul dual categories occupy symmetric positions [56].

The extended Loday diagram

Left-symmetric algebras (LSA) satisfy (x,y,z)=(y,x,z)(x,y,z)=(y,x,z) for the associator (x,y,z)=(xy)z−x(yz)(x,y,z)=(xy)z-x(yz); see the survey [22]. Felipe [33] introduced their dialgebra analogue, the left-symmetric dialgebras (LSDA): vector spaces with products ⊣,⊢\dashv,\vdash satisfying

x⊣(y⊣z)=x⊣(y⊢z),(x⊢y)⊢z=(x⊣y)⊢z,x \dashv(y \dashv z)=x \dashv(y \vdash z), \qquad(x \vdash y)\vdash z=(x \dashv y)\vdash z,
x⊣(y⊣z)−(x⊣y)⊣z=y⊢(x⊣z)−(y⊢x)⊣z,x \dashv(y \dashv z)-(x \dashv y)\dashv z=y \vdash(x \dashv z)-(y \vdash x)\dashv z,
x⊢(y⊢z)−(x⊢y)⊢z=y⊢(x⊣z)−(y⊢x)⊢z.x \vdash(y \vdash z)-(x \vdash y)\vdash z=y \vdash(x \dashv z)-(y \vdash x)\vdash z.

Every diassociative algebra is an LSDA, an LSDA with ⊣=⊢\dashv=\vdash is an LSA, and x⊣y−y⊢xx \dashv y-y \vdash x is again a Leibniz bracket [33, 76]. Adding these classes gives the extended diagram of Figure 2 [76]. The two ways from Dend to Lie agree, since (x≻y−y≺x)−(y≻x−x≺y)=x∗y−y∗x(x \succ y-y \prec x)-(y \succ x-x \prec y)=x*y-y*x.

The classification problem and its methods

Structure constants and orbits

Fix a basis e1,…,ene_1,\ldots,e_n. An algebra with two products is given by structure constants ei⊣ej=∑kγijkeke_i\dashv e_j=\sum_k\gamma_{ij}^{k}e_k and ei⊢ej=∑kδijkeke_i\vdash e_j=\sum_k\delta_{ij}^{k}e_k, a point of C2n3\mathbb{C}^{2n^3}. The identities (2) (or (3)) are polynomial equations of degree two in these constants, so the nn-dimensional diassociative algebras form an affine variety Diasn\mathrm{Dias}_n, and similarly Dendn\mathrm{Dend}_n. The group GLn(C)\mathrm{GL}_n(\mathbb{C}) acts on the variety by change of basis, and isomorphism classes are the orbits. To classify nn-dimensional algebras means to give one representative of each orbit together with a criterion deciding when two representatives are isomorphic. Because the number of orbits is infinite already in small dimension, the answer usually contains parametric families. The methods and their difficulty depend on the base field and on the class of algebras considered (all, nilpotent, solvable, with given properties).

Nilpotency

Nilpotency. For a diassociative algebra DD put D1=DD^1=D and

Dk=∑i+j=k(Di⊣Dj+Di⊢Dj)(k≥2).D^k=\sum_{i+j=k}\left(D^i\dashv D^j+D^i\vdash D^j\right)\quad(k\geq2).

The algebra is nilpotent if Ds=0D^s=0 for some ss [75]. An analogue of Engel’s theorem holds, and if the associative algebras (D,⊣)(D,\dashv) and (D,⊢)(D,\vdash) are nilpotent (solvable), then so is DD [75]. The same definition applies to dendriform and other algebras with two products. Every finite-dimensional Zinbiel algebra is nilpotent: Dzhumadildaev and Tulenbaev proved this in characteristic zero [28], and Towers extended it to all fields [85].

Direct method from associative lists

Direct method from associative lists. Since both products of a diassociative algebra are associative, one may start from a list of nn-dimensional associative algebras [73], fix ⊣\dashv to be one of them, treat the structure constants of ⊢\vdash as unknowns, and solve the system (2); the solutions are then sorted into isomorphism classes. This is the approach of the first classifications of diassociative algebras in dimensions two and three [16, 78, 75], carried out with computer algebra. The same idea, with the associative algebra (E,≺+≻)(E,\prec+\succ) fixed first, was used for dendriform algebras [79], and in the compatible version for anti-dendriform algebras [1]. The method is elementary, but the systems grow quickly with the dimension, and sorting the solutions into orbits without omissions is the delicate step.

Annihilator extensions

Annihilator extensions. Every non-zero nilpotent algebra SS has a non-zero annihilator Ann⁡(S)\operatorname{Ann}(S), the set of elements whose products with SS vanish on both sides for both operations, and SS is an annihilator (central) extension of the smaller algebra S/Ann⁡(S)S/\operatorname{Ann}(S). This reduces the classification of nilpotent algebras of dimension nn to two steps: compute the second cohomology H2(A,C)H^2(A,\mathbb{C}) of each nilpotent algebra AA of dimension n−sn-s, and find the orbits of Aut⁡(A)\operatorname{Aut}(A) on the ss-dimensional subspaces of H2(A,C)H^2(A,\mathbb{C}) satisfying a non-degeneracy condition. method is due to Skjelbred and Sund for Lie algebras [83]; it was developed for many varieties by Hegazi, Abdelwahab and Calderón Martín [45] and by Kaygorodov and his coauthors [47], and for nilpotent associative algebras by de Graaf [27]. For associative dialgebras Rakhimov established the basic properties of central extensions and applied the method to low-dimensional nilpotent algebras [69]. Mainellis studied the related multipliers and cover algebras of nilpotent diassociative algebras [59, 60]. The method has been adapted to left-symmetric dialgebras, which contain the diassociative algebras, in [77].

Characteristic sequences and gradings

For Lie, Leibniz and Zinbiel algebras of larger dimension one classifies subclasses defined by invariants, such as the characteristic sequence (the Jordan type of generic right multiplication operators) or the natural grading. This gives the filiform and quasi-filiform classes in arbitrary dimension [43, 4, 3, 2]. For diassociative and dendriform algebras this approach has hardly been used.

Geometric classification

The orbit closures in Diasn\mathrm{Dias}_n or Dendn\mathrm{Dend}_n define degenerations: AA degenerates to BB if BB lies in the closure of the orbit of AA. The geometric classification describes the irreducible components of the variety and the rigid algebras, whose orbits are open. It is surveyed in [48]. For the Loday algebras considered here it is complete for Zinbiel algebras up to dimension five [49, 8]; for diassociative and general dendriform algebras we are not aware of any geometric classification.

Diassociative algebras

Table 1 lists the known classifications of diassociative algebras and closely related algebras.

ClassDimensionResultReference
Diassociative, C\mathbb{C}2complete list (four classes)[16]
Diassociative, any field2complete list; corrects and completes [16][71]
Diassociative, C\mathbb{C}3complete list[78]
Nilpotent diass., C\mathbb{C}≤3\le3complete list; Engel-type theorem[75]
Nilpotent diass., C\mathbb{C}4complete list[17]
Nilpotent diass., C\mathbb{C}smallcentral extension method[69]
Hom-associative dialgebras, C\mathbb{C}≤4\le4classification, α\alpha-derivations, centroids[88]
Triassociative, C\mathbb{C}1, 2complete list[58]

Table 1. Classification results for diassociative and related algebras.

Dimensions two and three

Basri and Rikhsiboev [16] obtained the first list of two-dimensional complex diassociative algebras by the direct method. Rakhimov later classified two-dimensional associative and diassociative algebras over an arbitrary field [71]. In characteristic different from 2 and 3 his list contains eight entries, three of them with a parameter. The four algebras of [16] correspond to four of these entries, and the other four do not appear in [16], so the list of [16] has to be completed accordingly [71]. Three-dimensional complex diassociative algebras were classified in [78] from the list of three-dimensional associative algebras [73]. In view of the correction in dimension two, an independent check of the three-dimensional list, for example by computer algebra or by the central-extension method, would be valuable.

Nilpotent algebras

The nilpotent diassociative algebras of dimension at most three were classified in [75], and those of dimension four in [17], both by the direct method. Rakhimov [69] set up central extensions of associative dialgebras and applied the Skjelbred–Sund method to low-dimensional nilpotent algebras; this method gives an independent route to these lists. In dimension three the nilpotent diassociative algebras also appear inside the classification of nilpotent left-symmetric dialgebras [77], since every diassociative algebra is an LSDA. The two lists can be compared directly. Mainellis [59, 60] studied multipliers, covers and unicentral nilpotent diassociative algebras, extending results for Lie and Leibniz algebras; these invariants are useful for organising central extensions.

Structure theory

The quotient of a diassociative algebra by the ideal generated by the elements x⊣y−x⊢yx \dashv y - x \vdash y is an associative algebra, which links the structure of dialgebras to classical associative theory. González [42] studied associative dialgebras from this structural viewpoint. Split dialgebras, annihilator ideals and regular elements were studied by Velásquez and Felipe [86], and dialgebras with a bar-unit, which are the closest analogues of unital algebras, appear in [32, 34, 68]. Crossed modules of diassociative algebras were studied in [23], Gröbner–Shirshov bases in [19], and the Gelfand–Kirillov dimension in [90]. A general construction of dialgebras from bimodules over algebras, equivalent to the Kolesnikov–Pozhidaev construction, is given in [82].

Derivations

Derivations, which control the solvable algebras with a given nilradical and are used as invariants, have been computed for low-dimensional diassociative algebras in [80]; generalised (α,β,γ)(\alpha,\beta,\gamma)-derivations in [36]; outer derivations in [63]; and derivations and bi-derivations in [74]. For the polynomial dialgebra K[x,y]\mathbb{K}[x,y] Lin and Zhang determined the derivations and automorphisms [54].

Variants

Hom-associative dialgebras of dimension at most four were classified by Zahari [88], and BiHom-associative dialgebras were introduced in [89]. Loday and Ronco’s triassociative algebras [57] were classified in dimensions one and two by Mainellis [58]. Splittings of the operations of diassociative and triassociative algebras are studied in [84], and Poisson dialgebras in [26].

Dendriform algebras

Dimension two

Two-dimensional complex dendriform algebras were described in [79] by the direct method: the associative algebra (E,∗)(E,*) with x∗y=x⊣y+x⊢yx*y=x\dashv y+x\vdash y is fixed first, and the structure constants of ⊣\dashv are then found. Algebras in which one of the operations vanishes are excluded there, since the other operation is then simply associative. The list of [79] contains twelve classes, one of which depends on a parameter, and it has been used to classify derivations and Rota-type operators (Rota–Baxter, Reynolds, Nijenhuis and averaging operators) on two-dimensional dendriform algebras [15]. Rakhimov and Bekbaev [72] classified two-dimensional dendriform algebras over an arbitrary base field, fixing instead the operation ⊣\dashv from the classification of all two-dimensional algebras. Over fields of characteristic different from 2 and 3 they obtain fourteen labelled classes, and over fields of characteristic 2 and 3 fifteen; they also revise the complex list of [79]. Comparing the two lists, and checking the dendriform identities and the isomorphisms by computer, gives the following final list over C\mathbb{C}.

ClassDimensionResultReference
Dendriform, C\mathbb{C}212 classes, one with a parameter; incomplete[79]
Dendriform, any field2classification for all characteristics; revises the complex list[72]
Dendriform, C\mathbb{C}2final list: one family and 13 algebras (Theorem 5.1)[79, 72]
Zinbiel, C\mathbb{C}2complete list[65]
Zinbiel, C\mathbb{C}3complete list; nilpotency[28]
Zinbiel, C\mathbb{C}4complete list (central extensions)[9]
Zinbiel, C\mathbb{C}4degenerations, irreducible components[49]
Zinbiel, C\mathbb{C}5algebraic and geometric classification[8]
Zinbiel, C\mathbb{C}anynaturally graded, filiform, quasi-filiform[4, 3, 2]
Tridendriform, C\mathbb{C}lowclassification[64]
Anti-dendriform, C\mathbb{C}3complete list[1]

Table 2. Classification results for dendriform and related algebras.

Theorem 5.1 ([79, 72]). Every two-dimensional complex dendriform algebra in which both operations are non-zero is isomorphic to exactly one of the following algebras (only non-zero products are listed):

Dend21(α)\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{1}(\alpha), α≠0\alpha\ne0: e1≺e1=e2e_{1} \prec e_{1} = e_{2}, e1≻e1=αe2e_{1} \succ e_{1} = \alpha e_{2};

Dend22\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{2}: e1≺e1=e1e_{1} \prec e_{1} = e_{1}, e1≻e2=e2e_{1} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend23\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{3}: e1≺e1=e1e_{1} \prec e_{1} = e_{1}, e2≺e1=e2e_{2} \prec e_{1} = e_{2}, e1≻e2=e2e_{1} \succ e_{2} = e_{2}, e2≻e1=−e2e_{2} \succ e_{1} = -e_{2};

Dend24\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{4}: e2≺e1=e2e_{2} \prec e_{1} = e_{2}, e1≻e1=e1e_{1} \succ e_{1} = e_{1};

Dend25\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{5}: e1≺e2=−e2e_{1} \prec e_{2} = -e_{2}, e2≺e1=e2e_{2} \prec e_{1} = e_{2}, e1≻e1=e1e_{1} \succ e_{1} = e_{1}, e1≻e2=e2e_{1} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend26\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{6}: e1≺e1=e1e_{1} \prec e_{1} = e_{1}, e2≻e2=e2e_{2} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend27\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{7}: e1≺e2=−e2e_{1} \prec e_{2} = -e_{2}, e2≺e2=e2e_{2} \prec e_{2} = e_{2}, e1≻e1=e1e_{1} \succ e_{1} = e_{1}, e1≻e2=e2e_{1} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend28\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{8}: e1≺e1=e1+e2e_{1} \prec e_{1} = e_{1} + e_{2}, e1≺e2=−e2e_{1} \prec e_{2} = -e_{2}, e2≺e2=e2e_{2} \prec e_{2} = e_{2}, e1≻e1=−e2e_{1} \succ e_{1} = -e_{2}, e1≻e2=e2e_{1} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend29\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{9}: e1≺e1=e1e_{1} \prec e_{1} = e_{1}, e2≺e1=e2e_{2} \prec e_{1} = e_{2}, e2≻e1=−e2e_{2} \succ e_{1} = -e_{2}, e2≻e2=e2e_{2} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend210\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{10}: e1≺e1=−e2e_{1} \prec e_{1} = -e_{2}, e2≺e1=e2e_{2} \prec e_{1} = e_{2}, e1≻e1=e1+e2e_{1} \succ e_{1} = e_{1} + e_{2}, e2≻e1=−e2e_{2} \succ e_{1} = -e_{2}, e2≻e2=e2e_{2} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend211\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{11}: e2≺e1=e2e_{2} \prec e_{1} = e_{2}, e1≻e1=e1e_{1} \succ e_{1} = e_{1}, e1≻e2=e2e_{1} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend212\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{12}: e1≺e1=e1e_{1} \prec e_{1} = e_{1}, e2≺e1=e2e_{2} \prec e_{1} = e_{2}, e1≻e2=e2e_{1} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend213\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{13}: e1≺e2=−e2e_{1} \prec e_{2} = -e_{2}, e1≻e1=e1e_{1} \succ e_{1} = e_{1}, e1≻e2=e2e_{1} \succ e_{2} = e_{2};

Dend214:e1≺e1=e1, e2≺e1=e2, e2≻e1=−e2.\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{14}: \qquad e_{1} \prec e_{1}=e_{1},\ e_{2} \prec e_{1}=e_{2},\ e_{2} \succ e_{1}=-e_{2}.

Here Dend21(α)≅Dend21(α′)\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{1}(\alpha) \cong\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{1}(\alpha') if and only if α=α′\alpha=\alpha'. In total there are fourteen classes, one of them a one-parameter family.

The algebras Dend21,…,Dend212\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{1},\ldots,\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{12} are those of [79], and Dend213,Dend214\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{13},\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{14} are the two algebras found in [72]. Table 3 gives the associated associative algebra and the corresponding algebras of [72 Theorem 3.1], written D\mathbb{D} there.

Theorem 5.1(E,∗)(E,\ast)[72 Theorem 3.1]
Dend21(α)\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{1}(\alpha)e1e1=(1+α)e2e_{1}e_{1}=(1+\alpha)e_{2}D131(δ1), δ1=α\mathbb{D}_{13}^{1}(\delta_{1}),\ \delta_{1}=\alpha
Dend22, Dend23\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{2},\ \mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{3}e1e1=e1, e1e2=e2e_{1}e_{1}=e_{1},\ e_{1}e_{2}=e_{2}D38, D310(0)\mathbb{D}_{3}^{8},\ \mathbb{D}_{3}^{10}(0)
Dend24, Dend25\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{4},\ \mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{5}e1e1=e1, e2e1=e2e_{1}e_{1}=e_{1},\ e_{2}e_{1}=e_{2}D34, D36\mathbb{D}_{3}^{4},\ \mathbb{D}_{3}^{6}
Dend26,…,Dend210\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{6},\ldots,\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{10}C⊕C\mathbb{C}\oplus\mathbb{C}D37, D313, D314, D39(1)≅D311(1), D35(1)\mathbb{D}_{3}^{7},\ \mathbb{D}_{3}^{13},\ \mathbb{D}_{3}^{14},\ \mathbb{D}_{3}^{9}(1)\cong\mathbb{D}_{3}^{11}(1),\ \mathbb{D}_{3}^{5}(1)
Dend211, Dend212\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{11},\ \mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{12}e1e1=e1, e1e2=e2e1=e2e_{1}e_{1}=e_{1},\ e_{1}e_{2}=e_{2}e_{1}=e_{2}D35(0), D39(0)\mathbb{D}_{3}^{5}(0),\ \mathbb{D}_{3}^{9}(0)
Dend213, Dend214\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{13},\ \mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{14}e1e1=e1e_{1}e_{1}=e_{1}D27≅D36, D311(0)\mathbb{D}_{2}^{7}\cong\mathbb{D}_{3}^{6},\ \mathbb{D}_{3}^{11}(0)

Table 3. Two-dimensional complex dendriform algebras with both operations non-zero.

Remark 5.2. The comparison shows the following.

  1. Dend213\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{13} and Dend214\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{14} are missing from [79] because the list of two-dimensional associative algebras used there omits C⊕0\mathbb{C}\oplus0 (e1e1=e1e_{1}e_{1}=e_{1}), which is the associative algebra of both. Moreover, Dend21(0)\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{1}(0) of [79] has ≻=0\succ=0 and should be excluded under the convention of that paper.

  1. Dend24\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{4} is a dendriform algebra and coincides with D34\mathbb{D}_{3}^{4} of [72]. In [72 Remark 3.1] it is reproduced with e1≺e2=e2e_{1}\prec e_{2}=e_{2} in place of e2≺e1=e2e_{2}\prec e_{1}=e_{2}; the resulting structure is not dendriform, which explains the statement there that Dend24\mathrm{Dend}_{2}^{4} is not a dendriform algebra.

  1. In [72 Theorem 3.1] as printed, D27≅D36\mathbb{D}_{2}^{7}\cong\mathbb{D}_{3}^{6} via e1↦e1−e2e_{1}\mapsto e_{1}-e_{2}, e2↦−2e2e_{2}\mapsto-2e_{2}, and D311(1)≅D39(1)\mathbb{D}_{3}^{11}(1)\cong\mathbb{D}_{3}^{9}(1) via e1↦e1−e2e_{1}\mapsto e_{1}-e_{2}, e2↦e2e_{2}\mapsto e_{2}. The structures D310(1)\mathbb{D}_{3}^{10}(1) and D33\mathbb{D}_{3}^{3} do not satisfy the dendriform identities, since x≺y+x≻yx\prec y+x\succ y is not associative for them; presumably these are misprints.

  1. If one operation vanishes, the algebra is A≺=(A,⋅,0)A^{\prec}=(A,\cdot,0) or A≻=(A,0,⋅)A^{\succ}=(A,0,\cdot) for a two-dimensional associative algebra (A,⋅)(A,\cdot). This gives twelve further non-zero algebras, two for each of the six non-zero two-dimensional associative algebras [71].

Zinbiel algebras

For Zinbiel algebras the classification is much further advanced. Two reasons are their Koszul duality with Leibniz algebras, whose well-developed classification techniques carry over, and the simplicity of their structure: a single product satisfying a single identity. Omirov classified the two-dimensional complex Zinbiel algebras [65], and Dzhumadildaev and Tulenbaev proved that finite-dimensional Zinbiel algebras over a field of characteristic zero are nilpotent and classified those of dimension three [28]; nilpotency over arbitrary fields is due to Towers [85]. Using central extensions, Alvarez, de Mello and Kaygorodov classified the four-dimensional Zinbiel algebras and the five-dimensional ones with two-dimensional annihilator [9]. Alvarez, Fehlberg Júnior and Kaygorodov completed the algebraic and geometric classification in dimension five: the variety of five-dimensional Zinbiel algebras has dimension 24, with 16 irreducible components and 11 rigid algebras [8]. The degenerations of four-dimensional Zinbiel algebras are described in [49]. In arbitrary dimension, naturally graded, filiform and quasi-filiform Zinbiel algebras are classified through the characteristic sequence [4, 3, 2].

Related algebras

Tridendriform algebras of small dimension are classified in [64], and three-dimensional anti-dendriform algebras in [1]. The connection with Rota–Baxter operators [5, 29, 30] and OO-operators [14] gives a second way to produce dendriform structures: every dendriform algebra arises from an OO-operator on its associated associative algebra [14], so classifications of OO-operators on small associative algebras yield dendriform algebras. New identities in dendriform algebras are studied in [31], quadri-algebras in [6], and dendriform algebras attached to an arbitrary variety in [44].

Cohomology and deformations

The classification methods of Section 3 rely on cohomology: central extensions are classified by H2H^2, and degenerations are the geometric counterpart of deformations. We summarise the relevant results in chronological order.

Loday introduced the bar homology HYHY of diassociative algebras [56]. Frabetti showed that for a unital associative algebra the dialgebra homology is isomorphic to Hochschild homology up to a shift of degree [37], computed the Leibniz homology of matrix dialgebras in terms of a shuffle-type dialgebra homology [38], and developed dialgebra (co)homology with coefficients, proving that HY2HY^2 classifies abelian extensions and that Morita invariance holds for bar-unital dialgebras [39, 40]. Majumdar and Mukherjee showed that the dialgebra cohomology HY∗(D,D)HY^*(D,D) carries a GG-algebra structure, as Hochschild cohomology does [61], and developed the deformation theory of dialgebras controlled by this cohomology [62]. Yau studied deformations of morphisms of dialgebras and their rigidity [87], and Fialowski and Majumdar constructed miniversal deformations [35]. Later work treats equivariant [81] and oriented [50] dialgebras, and the varieties of dialgebras in the sense of Kolesnikov [51]; Bremner’s survey [21] covers their polynomial identities.

For the classification problem the most useful facts are these: H2(A,C)H^2(A,\mathbb{C}) is computable by linear algebra from the structure constants of AA; its dimension bounds the number of parameters of the central extensions; and a vanishing second cohomology with coefficients in the algebra itself implies rigidity, so the rigid algebras that appear in a geometric classification can often be predicted from cohomology.

Open problems

We end with problems that, as far as we know, are open.

Problem 7.1. Verify the classification of three-dimensional complex diassociative algebras [78] independently, by computer algebra or by central extensions, in view of the correction of the two-dimensional list [71], and extend it to arbitrary fields as in [71].

Problem 7.2. Classify the four-dimensional (not necessarily nilpotent) complex diassociative algebras, and the five-dimensional nilpotent ones by the central-extension method [69, 59].

Problem 7.3. Check the classifications of two-dimensional dendriform algebras over fields of characteristic 2 and 3 [72] in the light of Remark 5.2, for example by computer algebra.

Problem 7.4. Give a complete and independently verified classification of the three-dimensional complex dendriform algebras, and classify the nilpotent dendriform algebras of dimension four, for instance by central extensions.

Problem 7.5. Give the geometric classification of the varieties Diasn\mathrm{Dias}_{n} and Dendn\mathrm{Dend}_{n} for small nn: describe the degenerations, the irreducible components and the rigid algebras, as done for Zinbiel algebras in [49, 8].

Problem 7.6. Develop a structure theory of diassociative algebras (radical, semisimple part, Wedderburn-type decomposition) sufficient to reduce the classification to the nilpotent case, as for associative and Lie algebras; see [42] for first steps.

Problem 7.7. Study the classification of algebras in the extended Loday diagram simultaneously, using the functors of Figure 1 and Figure 2: for example, compare the Leibniz algebras obtained from the classified diassociative and left-symmetric dialgebras [77] with the known lists of Leibniz algebras.

Figure 1. The Loday diagram. Hooked arrows are inclusions of subcategories; the other arrows are the functors described in Section 2.

Figure 2. The extended Loday diagram with left-symmetric algebras and dialgebras.

Acknowledgments

The author used an AI assistant (Claude, Anthropic) for literature searches, drafting and language editing. All statements and references were checked by the author, who takes full responsibility for the content of this paper. This research received no external funding.

References

  1. [1]K. Abdurasulov, J. Adashev, Z. Normatov, Sh. Solijonova, Classification of three-dimensional anti-dendriform algebras, arXiv:2404.00981 (2024). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2404.00981.arxiv.org/abs/2404.00981
  2. [2]J. Q. Adashev, L. M. Camacho, S. Gómez-Vidal, I. A. Karimdjanov, Naturally graded Zinbiel algebras with nilindex n − 3, Linear Algebra Appl. 443 (2014), 86–104.
  3. [3]J. Q. Adashev, A. Kh. Khudoyberdiyev, B. A. Omirоv, Classification of complex naturally graded quasi-filiform Zinbiel algebras, in: Algebras, Representations and Applications, Contemp. Math. 483, Amer. Math. Soc., 2009.arxiv.org/abs/0805.3072
  4. [4]J. Q. Adashev, B. A. Omіrov, A. Kh. Khoudberdiyev, Classification of some classes of Zinbiel algebras, J. Gen. Lie Theory Appl. 4 (2010).arxiv.org/abs/math/0702809
  5. [5]M. Aguiar, Pre-Poisson algebras, Lett. Math. Phys. 54 (2000), no. 4, 263–277.DOI
  6. [6]M. Aguiar, J.-L. Loday, Quadri-algebras, J. Pure Appl. Algebra 191 (2004), no. 3, 205–221.
  7. [7]S. Albeverio, B. A. Omіrov, I. S. Rakhimov, Classification of 4-dimensional nilpotent complex Leibniz algebras, Extracta Math. 21 (2006), no. 3, 197–210.DOI
  8. [8]M. A. Alvarez, R. Fehlberg Junior, I. Kaygorodov, The algebraic and geometric classification of Zinbiel algebras, J. Pure Appl. Algebra 226 (2022), 107106. doi:10.1016/j.jpaa.2022.107106.DOI
  9. [9]M. A. Alvarez, T. C. de Mello, I. Kaygorodov, Central extensions of 3-dimensional Zinbiel algebras, Ric. Mat. 72 (2023), 921–947. doi:10.1007/s11587-021-00604-1.
  10. [10]Sh. A. Ayupov, B. A. Omіrov, On Leibniz algebras, in: Algebra and Operator Theory (Tashkent, 1997), Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1998, 1–13.DOI
  11. [11]Sh. A. Ayupov, B. A. Omіrov, On 3-dimensional Leibniz algebras, Uzbek Math. J. (1999), no. 1, 9–14.
  12. [12]Sh. A. Ayupov, B. A. Omіrov, On some classes of nilpotent Leibniz algebras, Siberian Math. J. 42 (2001), no. 1, 15–24.DOI
  13. [13]M. Aymon, P.-P. Grivel, Un théorème de Poincaré–Birkhoff–Witt pour les algèbres de Leibniz, Comm. Algebra 31 (2003), no. 2, 527–544.
  14. [14]C. Bai, L. Guo, X. Ni, О-operators on associative algebras and dendriform algebras, arXiv:1003.2432 (2010). doi:10.48550/arXiv.1003.2432.DOI
  15. [15]I. Basdouri, B. Mosbahi, Rota-type operators on 2-dimensional dendriform algebras, arXiv:2411.15358 (2024). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2411.15358.DOI
  16. [16]W. Basri, I. M. Rikhsiobev, On low dimensional dissociative algebras, in: Proceedings of the Third Conference on Research and Education in Mathematics (ICREM-3), UPM, Malaysia, 2007, 164–170.
  17. [17]W. Basri, I. S. Rakhimov, I. M. Rikhsiobev, Four-dimensional nilpotent dissociative algebras, J. Gen. Lie Theory Appl. 9 (2015), no. 1, 7 pp. doi:10.4172/1736-4337.1000218.DOI
  18. [18]A. Bloh, On a generalization of the concept of Lie algebra, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 165 (1965), 471–473 (in Russian).
  19. [19]L. A. Bokut, Y. Chen, C. L. Gröbner–Shirshov bases for dialgebras, arXiv:0804.0638 (2008). doi:10.48550/arXiv.0804.0638.DOI
  20. [20]L. Boza, E. M. Fedriani, J. Núñez, Á. F. Tenorio, A historical review of the classifications of Lie algebras, Rev. Un. Mat. Argentina 54 (2013), no. 2, 75–99.
  21. [21]M. R. Bremner, Algebras, dialgebras, and polynomial identities, Serdica Math. J. 38 (2012), 91–136.arxiv.org/abs/1201.3379
  22. [22]D. Burde, Left-symmetric algebras, or pre-Lie algebras in geometry and physics, Cent. Eur. J. Math. 4 (2006), no. 3, 323–357.
  23. [23]J. M. Casas, R. F. Casado, E. Khmaladze, M. Ladra, More on crossed modules in Lie, Leibniz, associative and dissociative algebras, J. Algebra Appl. 16 (2017), 1750107. doi:10.1142/S0219498817501079.
  24. [24]F. Chapoton, On some anticyclic operads, Algebr. Geom. Topol. 5 (2005), 53–69.DOI
  25. [25]Y. Chen, Q. Mo, Embedding dendriform algebra into its universal enveloping Rota–Baxter algebra, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. (2011).arxiv.org/abs/1005.2717
  26. [26]A. Das, S. K. Mishra, G. Mukherjee, Poisson dialgebras, arXiv:2311.13826 (2023). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2311.13826.
  27. [27]W. A. de Graaf, Classification of nilpotent associative algebras of small dimension, Internat. J. Algebra Comput. 28 (2018), no. 1, 133–161. doi:10.1142/S0218196718500078.DOI
  28. [28]A. S. Dzhumadildaev, K. M. Tulenbaev, Nilpotency of Zinbiel algebras, J. Dyn. Control Syst. 11 (2005), no. 2, 195–213.DOI
  29. [29]K. Ebrahimi-Fard, Loday-type algebras and the Rota–Baxter relation, Lett. Math. Phys. 61 (2002), no. 2, 139–147.DOI
  30. [30]K. Ebrahimi-Fard, L. Guo, Rota–Baxter algebras and dendriform algebras, J. Pure Appl. Algebra 212 (2008), 320–339.DOI
  31. [31]K. Ebrahimi-Fard, D. Manchon, F. Patras, New identities in dendriform algebras, J. Algebra 320 (2008), no. 2, 708–727. doi:10.1016/j.jalgebra.2007.12.013.
  32. [32]R. Felipe, An analogue to functional analysis in dialgebras, Comunicación Técnica No. I-03-16, CIMAT, 2003.
  33. [33]R. Felipe, A brief foundation of the left-symmetric dialgebras, Comunicaciones del CIMAT, No. I-11-02, 2011.
  34. [34]R. Felipe, N. López-Reyes, F. Ongay, R. Velásquez, Yang–Baxter equations on matrix dialgebras with a bar unit, Linear Algebra Appl. 403 (2005), 31–44. doi:10.1016/j.laa.2005.01.014.DOI
  35. [35]A. Fialowski, A. Majumdar, Miniversal deformations of dialgebras, arXiv:0807.3180 (2008). doi:10.48550/arXiv.0807.3180.arxiv.org/abs/0807.3180
  36. [36]M. A. Fiidow, I. S. Rakhimov, Sh. K. Said Husain, W. Basri, (α, β, γ)-derivations of dissociative algebras, Malays. J. Math. Sci. 10(S) (2016), 101–126.
  37. [37]A. Frabetti, Dialgebra homology of associative algebras, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 325 (1997), 135–140.DOI
  38. [38]A. Frabetti, Leibniz homology of dialgebras of matrices, J. Pure Appl. Algebra 129 (1998), 123–141.DOI
  39. [39]A. Frabetti, Dialgebra (co)homology with coefficients, in: Dialgebras and Related Operads, Lecture Notes in Math. 1763, Springer, Berlin, 2001, 67–103.
  40. [40]A. Frabetti, Simplicial properties of the set of planar binary trees, J. Algebraic Combin. 13 (2001), 41–65.DOI
  41. [41]V. Ginzburg, M. Kapranov, Koszul duality for operads, Duke Math. J. 76 (1994), no. 1, 203–272.
  42. [42]C. M. González, Associative dialgebras from a structural viewpoint, Comm. Algebra 41 (2013), no. 5, 1903–1912. doi:10.1080/00927872.2011.653066.DOI
  43. [43]M. Goze, Yu. Khakimdjanov, Nilpotent Lie Algebras, Mathematics and its Applications 361, Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1996.
  44. [44]V. Yu. Gubarev, P. S. Kolesnikov, Embedding of dendriform algebras into Rota–Baxter algebras, Cent. Eur. J. Math. 11 (2013), 226. doi:10.2478/s11533-012-0138-z.
  45. [45]A. S. Hegazi, H. Abdelwahab, A. J. Calderón Martín, The classification of n-dimensional non-Lie Malcev algebras with (n − 4)-dimensional annihilator, Linear Algebra Appl. 505 (2016), 32–56.DOI
  46. [46]N. Jacobson, Lie Algebras, Interscience Tracts in Pure and Applied Mathematics 10, New York, 1962.
  47. [47]I. Kaygorodov, Non-associative algebraic structures: classification and structure, Commun. Math. 32 (2024), no. 3, 1–62.DOI
  48. [48]I. Kaygorodov, M. Khrypchenko, P. Páez-Guillán, The geometric classification of non-associative algebras: a survey, Commun. Math. 32 (2024), no. 2, 185–284.DOI
  49. [49]I. Kaygorodov, Yu. Popov, A. Pozhidaev, Yu. Volkov, Degenerations of Zinbiel and nilpotent Leibniz algebras, Linear Multilinear Algebra 66 (2018), no. 4, 704–716.DOI
  50. [50]A. N. A. Koam, R. Saha, Cohomology and deformations of oriented dialgebras, arXiv:2001.02386 (2020). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2001.02386.DOI
  51. [51]P. S. Kolesnikov, Varieties of dialgebras and conformal algebras, Siberian Math. J. 49 (2008), no. 2, 257–272.arxiv.org/abs/math/0611501
  52. [52]P. S. Kolesnikov, V. Yu. Voronin, On special identities for dialgebras, Linear Multilinear Algebra 61 (2013), no. 3, 377–391. doi:10.1080/03081087.2012.686108.DOI
  53. [53]O. Kravchenko, M. Polyak, Dissociative algebras and Milnor’s invariants for tangles, Lett. Math. Phys. 95 (2011), no. 3, 297–316. doi:10.1007/s11005-010-0459-4.DOI
  54. [54]L. Lin, Y. Zhang, F[x, y] as a dialgebra and a Leibniz algebra, Comm. Algebra 38 (2010), no. 9, 3417–3447. doi:10.1080/00927870903164677.
  55. [55]J.-L. Loday, Une version non commutative des algèbres de Lie: les algèbres de Leibniz, Enseign. Math. (2) 39 (1993), no. 3–4, 269–293.DOI
  56. [56]J.-L. Loday, A. Frabetti, F. Chapoton, F. Goichot, Dialgebras and Related Operads, Lecture Notes in Math. 1763, Springer, Berlin, 2001.DOI
  57. [57]J.-L. Loday, M. Ronco, Trialgebras and families of polytopes, in: Homotopy Theory: Relations with Algebraic Geometry, Group Cohomology, and Algebraic K-theory, Contemp. Math. 346, Amer. Math. Soc., 2004, 369–398.arxiv.org/abs/math/0205043
  58. [58]E. Mainellis, Classification of low-dimensional complex triassociative algebras, arXiv:2209.04351 (2022). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2209.04351.DOI
  59. [59]E. Mainellis, Multipliers of nilpotent diassociative algebras, Results Math. 77 (2022), 191. doi:10.1007/s00025-022-01730-4.DOI
  60. [60]E. Mainellis, Multipliers and unicentral diassociative algebras, J. Algebra Appl. 22 (2023), no. 5, 2350107. doi:10.1142/S0219498823501074.DOI
  61. [61]A. Majumdar, G. Mukherjee, Dialgebra cohomology as a G-algebra, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 356 (2004), no. 6, 2443–2457.DOI
  62. [62]A. Majumdar, G. Mukherjee, Deformation theory of dialgebras, K-Theory 35 (2005), no. 3–4, 395–397. doi:10.1007/s10977-005-5542-8.DOI
  63. [63]N. F. Mohammed, H. F. Qasim, Z. H. Maibed, Outer derivations of low-dimensional diassociative algebras, J. Discrete Math. Sci. Cryptogr. 28 (2025), no. 4-B.DOI
  64. [64]B. Mosbahi, A. Asif, A. Zahir, Classification of tridendriform algebra and related structures, arXiv:2305.08513 (2023). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2305.08513.DOI
  65. [65]B. A. Omirov, Classification of two-dimensional complex Zinbiel algebras, Uzbek Math. J. (2002), no. 2, 55–59 (in Russian).
  66. [66]B. Peirce, Linear associative algebra, Amer. J. Math. 4 (1881), 97–229.
  67. [67]R. S. Pierce, Associative Algebras, Graduate Texts in Mathematics 88, Springer, New York, 1982.
  68. [68]A. P. Pozhidaev, 0-dialgebras with bar-unity, Rota–Baxter and 3-Leibniz algebras, Contemp. Math. 499, Amer. Math. Soc., 2009. doi:10.1090/conm/499/09807.DOI
  69. [69]I. S. Rakhimov, On central extensions of associative dialgebras, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 697 (2016), 012009. doi:10.1088/1742-6596/697/1/012009.DOI
  70. [70]I. S. Rakhimov, On classification of Poisson algebras, Contemp. Math. 672, Amer. Math. Soc., 2016. doi:10.1090/conm/672/13471.
  71. [71]I. S. Rakhimov, Complete classification of two-dimensional associative and diassociative algebras over any basic field, arXiv:2307.09927 (2023). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2307.09927.DOI
  72. [72]I. S. Rakhimov, U. Bekbaev, Two-dimensional dendriform algebra structures over any base field, Malays. J. Math. Sci. 19 (2025), no. 3, 891–920. doi:10.47836/mjms.19.3.07.DOI
  73. [73]I. S. Rakhimov, I. M. Rikhsioboev, W. Basri, Complete lists of low dimensional complex associative algebras, arXiv:0910.0932 (2009). doi:10.48550/arXiv.0910.0932.DOI
  74. [74]G. G. Restrepo-Sánchez et al., Derivations and bi-derivations in dialgebras, arXiv:2511.17522 (2025). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2511.17522.
  75. [75]I. M. Rikhsioboev, Classification of low dimensional complex nilpotent diassociative algebras, Uzbek Math. J. (2007), no. 2, 112–118 (in Russian).
  76. [76]I. M. Rikhsioboev, On the classification of left-symmetric dialgebras, Contemp. Math. 672, Amer. Math. Soc., 2016. doi:10.1090/comm/672/13464.DOI
  77. [77]I. M. Rikhsioboev, The algebraic classification of three-dimensional nilpotent left-symmetric dialgebras, submitted.
  78. [78]I. M. Rikhsioboev, I. S. Rakhimov, W. Basri, Classification of 3-dimensional complex diassociative algebras, Malays. J. Math. Sci. 4 (2010), no. 2, 241–254.
  79. [79]I. M. Rikhsioboev, I. S. Rakhimov, W. Basri, The description of dendriform algebra structures on two-dimensional complex space, J. Algebra Number Theory Adv. Appl. 4 (2010), no. 1, 1–18.
  80. [80]I. M. Rikhsioboev, I. S. Rakhimov, W. Basri, Diassociative algebras and their derivations, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 553 (2014), 012006. doi:10.1088/1742-6596/553/1/012006.
  81. [81]R. Saha, Equivariant associative dialgebras and its one-parameter formal deformations, J. Geom. Phys. 146 (2019), 103491. doi:10.1016/j.geomphys.2019.103491.DOI
  82. [82]O. P. Salazar-Díaz, R. Velásquez, L. A. Wills-Toro, Construction of dialgebras through bimodules over algebras, Linear Multilinear Algebra 64 (2016), no. 10, 1980–2001. doi:10.1080/03081087.2015.1134428.
  83. [83]T. Skjelbred, T. Sund, Sur la classification des algèbres de Lie nilpotentes, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris Sér. A-B 286 (1978), no. 5, A241–A242.
  84. [84]W. Teng, Splitting of operations for di-associative algebras and tri-associative algebras, arXiv:2502.21070 (2025). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2502.21070.DOI
  85. [85]D. A. Towers, Zinbiel algebras are nilpotent, arXiv:2202.12026 (2022). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2202.12026.arxiv.org/abs/2202.12026
  86. [86]R. Velásquez, R. Felipe, Split dialgebras, split quasi-Jordan algebras and regular elements, J. Algebra Appl. 8 (2009), 191. doi:10.1142/S0219498809003278.DOI
  87. [87]D. Yau, Deformation theory of dialgebra morphisms, Algebra Colloq. 15 (2008), 279–292.arxiv.org/abs/math/0604404
  88. [88]A. Zahari, Classification, α_k-derivations and centroids of 4-dimensional complex Hom-associative dialgebras, arXiv:2305.04041 (2023). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2305.04041.DOI
  89. [89]A. Zahari, I. Bakayoko, On BiHom-associative dialgebras, arXiv:2101.07646 (2021). doi:10.48550/arXiv.2101.07646.
  90. [90]Z. Zhang, Y. Chen, B. Yu, No dialgebra has Gelfand–Kirillov dimension strictly between 1 and 2, arXiv preprint (2019).arxiv.org/abs/1904.12677
  91. [91]G. W. Zinbiel, Encyclopedia of types of algebras 2010, arXiv:1101.0267 (2010). doi:10.48550/arXiv.1101.0267.arxiv.org/abs/1101.0267

Paper details

vlnc:W_3mbm4cj3
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY-SA 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Claude

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents