betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Structural flexibility dictates reactivity of single-atom catalysts

Abstract

Unravelling the origins of single-atom catalyst reactivity is a central challenge in heterogeneous catalysis research. A key question is whether the activity arises solely from atomic isolation or from distinct structural and electronic configurations of the single atoms. Here, we use precisely defined Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 model catalyst sites synthesized on an inert support to quantify the effect of coordination geometry on chemical reactivity. Both the Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 models have the same electronic configuration (high-spin Fe2+^{2+} with S=2), and even their d-orbital occupancies and positions with respect to Fermi level are almost identical. Despite this electronic similarity, the adsorption energy of CO differs by more than 0.6 eV between the Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 sites, as indicated by density functional theory computations and confirmed by atomically-resolved scanning tunneling microscopy experiments. We trace this reactivity difference to the structural flexibility of the Fe-N3_3 sites, which allows strengthening of the Fe 3dxz/yz_{xz/yz}-CO 2ππ* back-bonding by lifting the Fe atom from the -N3_3 plane. These results demonstrate that coordination geometry plays a crucial role in defining the reactivity of single-atom catalysts, and that such effects cannot be predicted by analysis of the sites' electronic structures alone.

Introduction

Single-Atom Catalysts (SACs) featuring metal atoms stably embedded in carbon-based materials show high promise for many reactions including oxygen evolution/reduction,[1, 2, 3, 4] hydrogen evolution,[3, 4, 5] methane conversion,[4, 6] alkene hydrogenations[7, 8] and hydroformylations.[3, 9] The motivation to utilize “single-atoms” instead of larger clusters is obvious: the best catalysts are often precious metals, thus reducing the amount needed can greatly improve the economic viability of technologies that are currently too expensive to become widespread. Recent years saw an explosion of SAC synthesis and analysis methods, but rational design remains a challenge because the reactivity of SACs is not easy to predict. Noble metals like Au can become reactive when dispersed as single Au1_1 atoms,[10, 11, 12] while traditional catalysts like Pt may show the opposite trend with their reactivity being decreased at the single-atom limit.[13, 14, 15] These variations complicate SAC design, but they also open realistic opportunities for developing SACs from abundant elements like Fe or Ni that could surpass the expensive catalysts of today.

The reactivity of SACs is equally dependent on the metal atom itself and its surroundings.[16, 17, 18] [19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27] The local environment defines the crucial parameters like the coordination number of the metal atom, its oxidation state, d-orbital filling, spin configuration or accessibility to reactants. Modifying one of these parameters typically perturbs several others, making the search for clear reactivity trends a very complex task. Various “universal descriptors” of SAC reactivity were proposed in the literature,28–32 many of which are derived from the so-called “d-band center model” developed on extended surfaces of metals and alloys.33–35 However, experimental verification of the proposed reactivity trends is challenging, mainly because the reactivity differences between similar sites are difficult to ascertain on high-surface-area catalysts. The most reactive SAC sites are rarely the most abundant ones, thus they can be easily overlooked in bulk-averaged datasets.36,37 It is now widely accepted that undercoordinated sites like metal-N3\mathrm{N}_3 are likely to be more reactive than the more commonly found metal-N4\mathrm{N}_4,26,38–40 but direct experimental views on the fundamental reasons for the increased reactivity are missing.

To address the challenges outlined above, we developed a model platform in which a single reactivity-defining parameter can be intentionally varied, and the reactivity trends can be unambiguously ascertained using atomically-resolved experiments and computational modelling. Specifically, we synthesized 2D metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) containing perfectly defined Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_3 and Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_4 sites residing atop an inert graphene support. Then, we quantify the reactivity of these Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_3/-N4\mathrm{N}_4 sites towards carbon monoxide (CO), a crucially important molecule in both fundamental studies and applications. We use variable-temperature Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) to directly image the CO molecules adsorbing and desorbing from the individual Fe-Nx\mathrm{N}_x sites, and our temperature-dependent STM dataset allows us to quantify the CO adsorption energy. Our data show that CO is stable on the Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_3 sites up to 180 K, but it does not adsorb on the Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_4 sites even at temperatures as low as 115 K. This is consistent with Density Functional Theory (DFT) computations showing that the CO adsorption energy differs by 0.62 eV between the two systems. We demonstrate that the origin of the different reactivity lies in the structural flexibility of the Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_3 sites, which allows significant lifting of the Fe atoms from the −N3-\mathrm{N}_3 plane. This structural change allows more efficient orbital hybridization which stabilizes the Fe-CO bond by 0.61 eV, primarily through the Fe 3dxz/yz3d_{xz/yz}-CO 2π∗2\pi^* back-bonding channel.

Overall, our experimental and computational approach identifies a direct link between structure and reactivity, and demonstrates that structural flexibility can play a decisive role in adsorption energetics. Thus, this parameter needs to be considered in any proposed universal descriptors of single-atom reactivity.

Results and Discussion

Synthesis and analysis of Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_{3} and Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} models

We have chosen Fe-DCA (DCA = 9,10-dicyanoanthracene) and Fe-TCNQ (TCNQ = 7,7,8,8-tetracyanoquinodimethane) 2D Metal-Organic Frameworks as suitable models containing high surface density of well-defined Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} and Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_{3} sites. Both systems were synthesized on a chemically inert graphene/Ir(111) support according to protocols described in Methods section. Figure 1 shows room temperature STM images, Low-Energy Electron Diffraction (LEED) patterns and DFT models of both model systems. Figure 1A-C reveals that Fe-DCA/graphene crystallizes in a honeycomb-kagomé structure with Fe2_{2}(DCA)3_{3} stoichiometry, consistently with previous reports of 2D metal-DCA structures.41–46 The Fe cations are coordinated to three cyano- groups, resulting in stable Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_{3} sites. This structure is present in two symmetry-equivalent domains on the graphene/Ir(111) support; these domains are rotated by ±12∘\pm12^\circ from the high-symmetry directions of the support. This is well visible in the LEED pattern shown in Figure 1B, and in large-scale STM images presented in Figure S1. Importantly, DFT computations indicate that the weak interaction with the graphene support allows the Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_{3} site to remain planar (see the side view in Figure 1C); in contrast to similar systems placed on metal supports.46

Structural characterization of Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ 2D MOFs on graphene by Scanning Tunneling Microscopy, Low Energy Electron Diffraction and Density Functional Theory computations

Figure 1. Structural characterization of Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ 2D MOFs on graphene by Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM), Low Energy Electron Diffraction (LEED) and Density Functional Theory computations (DFT). (A,B,C) The Fe-DCA structure accommodates Fe in 3-fold coordinated Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_3 sites, as visible in the STM image and DFT model. The LEED pattern shows that the structure is present in two orientations on the graphene/Ir support. DFT model shown in panel C indicates that the interaction between graphene and Fe-DCA is weak; the Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_3 sites remain planar. (D,E,F) The Fe-TCNQ features 4-fold coordinated Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_4 sites. LEED pattern indicates that this structure is present in 15 orientations on the graphene/Ir surface. In DFT models, the carbon atoms are black, nitrogen atoms are blue, Fe atoms are brown and hydrogen atoms are white. The STM scanning parameters are Usample=−0.6U_{\mathrm{sample}}=-0.6 V, Ibias=0.06I_{\mathrm{bias}}=0.06 nA (A), and Usample=1.2U_{\mathrm{sample}}=1.2 V, Ibias=0.06I_{\mathrm{bias}}=0.06 nA (B).

Large-scale STM image of the Fe-DCA/gr/Ir(111) system

Figure S1. Large-scale STM image of the Fe-DCA/gr/Ir(111) system (135 × 135 nm, Usample=−1.8U_{\mathrm{sample}} = -1.8 V, Itunnel=0.05I_{\mathrm{tunnel}} = 0.05 nA)

Figure 1D-E shows a similar dataset acquired on the Fe-TCNQ/graphene/Ir model system. Fe-TCNQ 2D MOF crystallizes in a rectangular lattice with Fe1_{1}(TCNQ)1_{1} stoichiometry, as shown in the STM image and DFT model presented in Figure 1D,E. The Fe cations are coordinated to four cyano- groups, resulting in stable Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites. Previous literature indicates that the most stable Fe-TCNQ structure is physically corrugated due to the preference of the Fe cations to reside in tetrahedral coordination environment.47 Such non-planar structure is also stable on the weakly-interacting graphene/Ir support, although its physical corrugation is slightly reduced by the van der Waals interaction with the support (shown in the side view in Figure 1E, details in reference 47). The physical corrugation of the Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites can be observed in room-temperature STM data acquired at specific tunneling conditions, as shown in Figure S2 in the SI. The Fe-TCNQ structure is present in 15 symmetry equivalent domains on the graphene/Ir support, as shown in the LEED pattern presented in Figure 1F.48

STM images of Fe-TCNQ/gr/Ir(111) at different bias voltages

Figure S2. STM images of Fe-TCNQ/gr/Ir(111) taken on the same spot with different bias voltages. (A) At sample bias of −0.6-0.6 V, the Fe-TCNQ layer looks homogeneous. (B) At sample bias of −1.3-1.3 V, a characteristic “zig-zag” pattern is observed on some areas of the Fe-TCNQ monolayer. Previous literature shows that this is because the Fe-N4_4 sites prefer quasi-tetrahedral coordination geometry, which can be achieved by an ordered array of differently tilted TCNQ linkers.[5]

The Fe cations within Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ differ in their local coordination geometry, but they are remarkably similar in their electronic structure. Our DFT results shown in Figure 2 indicate that the Fe within Fe-DCA is in high-spin d6d^6 (S=2S=2) Fe2+\mathrm{Fe}^{2+} state, and this assignment is consistent with recent experimental characterization of a similar system by X-Ray Adsorption (XAS).46 Figure 2A shows the electronic density of states (DOS) projected on the Fe 3dd-orbitals within the Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ structures. The features observed in the DOS plots can be qualitatively rationalized by the crystal/ligand field theory: in Fe-DCA structure, the coordination geometry of Fe is trigonal planar, leading to degeneracy of symmetry-equivalent orbitals dxy/(x2−y2)d_{xy}/(x^2-y^2) as well as dxz/dyzd_{xz}/d_{yz}. Our computational results indicate that these four Fe 3dd orbitals are singly-occupied, while the dz2d_{z^2} (which has minimal spatial overlap with the -CN groups of the DCA linkers) accommodates two electrons. The formal electronic configuration of the Fe atom is thus [Ar] 3d6[\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^6, with the d-orbital occupancy of (dxz)1(d_{xz})^1 (dyz)1(d_{yz})^1 (dxy)1(d_{xy})^1 (dx2−y2)1(d_{x^2-y^2})^1 (dz2)2(d_{z^2})^2, as summarized in Table 1A. As evident from the DOS plots and Table 1, five electrons reside in the majority spin channel, while only one electron in the (dz2)(d_{z^2}) orbital is in the minority spin channel; the spin of the Fe2+\mathrm{Fe}^{2+} atom is thus S=2S=2 (quintet).

Density of states projected on the Fe 3d orbitals of the Fe-N$_3$ and Fe-N$_4$ sites within Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ

Figure 2. Density of states (DOS) projected on the Fe 3d orbitals of the Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 sites within Fe-DCA (A) and Fe-TCNQ (B). In both systems, the electronic configuration is high-spin d6^6, with the dxz_{xz}, dyz_{yz}, dxy_{xy} and dx2−y2_{x^2-y^2} orbitals being singly-occupied, and the dz2_{z^2} being doubly-occupied.

Fe d-orbital occupancy (e−^-)
A
All d-orbitalsdxz_{xz}dyz_{yz}dxy_{xy}dx2−x2_{x^2-x^2}dz2_{z^2}
Fe-DCA/gr6.091.051.041.071.081.86
Fe-TCNQ/gr6.051.001.001.191.001.85
BFe d-orbital center of mass (eV)
All d-orbitalsdxz_{xz}dyz_{yz}dxy_{xy}dx2−x2_{x^2-x^2}dz2_{z^2}
Fe-DCA/gr-2.78-2.24-2.22-2.91-2.93-3.55
Fe-TCNQ/gr-2.63-2.21-2.03-2.79-2.48-3.61

Table 1. Fe 3d orbital occupancies (A) and centers of mass (B) calculated for the Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ systems supported on graphene.

The same electronic configuration is found by DFT computations of Fe-N4_4 sites within Fe-TCNQ (Figure 2B, and Table 1A), and this result is also consistent with recent XAS study.49 In the quasi-tetrahedral Fe-N4_4 site the hybridization between the Fe d-orbitals and TCNQ states involves mainly the dxz,yz_{xz,yz} orbitals which have the highest spatial overlap with the N p orbitals. Same as in the case of Fe-DCA, all the d orbitals save for (dz2_{z^2})2^2 are singly-occupied, leading to the formal electronic configuration of [Ar] 3d6^6, with the d-orbital occupancy of (dxz_{xz})1^1 (dyz_{yz})1^1 (dxy_{xy})1^1 (dx2−y2_{x^2-y^2})1^1 (dz2_{z^2})2^2 and spin S=2.

The electronic configuration of the Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 sites within Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ is almost identical, but it is well known that the reactivity of transition metals depends not only on the filling of the d-orbitals, but also on their position with respect to Fermi level.21,33,34,50 This parameter is commonly quantified by the center of mass of the whole d-band or of the individual dd-orbitals, and the dependence of the dd-band position on reactivity is commonly referred to as the “dd-band center model”. In Table 1B, we summarize the centers of the dd-band as well as the centers of individual dd-orbitals for both systems. We find that the positions of the dd-orbital centers are very similar, albeit slightly higher in Fe-TCNQ. This applies to the dd-orbitals expected to be involved in bonding with upright-standing adsorbates (dz2d_{z^2}, dxzd_{xz}, dyzd_{yz}) as well as the ones expected to be non-bonding (dxyd_{xy}, dx2−y2d_{x^2-y^2}). Thus, based on the electronic structure parameters, one is tempted to assume that the Fe atoms within these systems should bind reactants like carbon monoxide (CO) with similar strength, perhaps slightly more strongly in the Fe-N4_4 coordination. However, the opposite is true, as shown both by theory and experiment below.

CO adsorption on Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 models

Carbon monoxide is a crucially important molecule for both industrial applications and fundamental studies. Industrial applications utilize CO as a reactant in preferential CO oxidation (PROX),51 water-gas shift52 or Fischer-Tropsch synthesis,53 while in fundamental studies CO is widely used as a probe molecule, whose C-O stretching frequency is used to evaluate charge states, coordination numbers and chemical reactivities of model SACs.[14] [37, 54, 55]

Our DFT data presented in Figure 3 show that CO binds to Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 sites in a qualitatively similar way, but the CO adsorption energies (EadsCOE_{\mathrm{ads}}^{\mathrm{CO}}) significantly differ, being −0.84-0.84 eV on Fe-N3_3, but only −0.23-0.23 eV on Fe-N4_4. The mechanism of Fe-CO bonding on Fe-Nx_x is consistent with the picture known from studies of extended metal surfaces:34,50,56,57 The σ\sigma-bond is facilitated by highest-occupied molecular orbital of CO (5σ5\sigma) that hybridizes with the dz2d_{z^2} orbital of the Fe atom, while the π\pi-bond back-donation takes place through hybridization of the lowest unoccupied, doubly degenerate molecular orbital of CO (2π∗2\pi^*) with the dxzd_{xz}, dyzd_{yz} orbitals of Fe. Both these effects are clearly observed in DOS plots shown in Figure 3. While the σ\sigma-bonding appears very similar in both cases, there is a significant difference in the π\pi-bonding, which is much more pronounced in the Fe-DCA case (2π∗/dxz/yz2\pi^*/d_{xz/yz} peaks at −2.9-2.9 eV and −1.1-1.1 eV) than in the Fe-TCNQ case (2π∗/dxz/yz2\pi^*/d_{xz/yz} peaks at −2.6-2.6 eV and −0.8-0.8 eV). This qualitative observation is supported by the computed occupancy of the 2π∗2\pi^* orbital, which is 0.720.72 e−^- in the CO/Fe-DCA case, but only 0.360.36 e−^- in CO/Fe-TCNQ. The higher occupancy of the 2π∗2\pi^* orbital also results in increased C-O bond length;34,56 which is 116 pm on CO/Fe-DCA and 114 pm on CO/Fe-TCNQ. All this indicates that the covalent bond between CO and Fe is indeed significantly stronger in the CO/Fe-DCA case than in CO/Fe-TCNQ, and this conclusion is further supported by additional analyses presented in Figures S3-S7 in the SI. The observation of a stronger Fe-CO bond in CO/Fe-DCA is in line with the computed EadsCOE_{\mathrm{ads}}^{\mathrm{CO}} values, but in disagreement with the expectations based on dd-band center positions presented in Table 1B.

Computed physical and electronic structures of CO/Fe-DCA and CO/Fe-TCNQ systems supported in graphene

Figure 3. Computed physical and electronic structures of CO/Fe-DCA and CO/Fe-TCNQ systems supported in graphene. (A) Upon CO adsorption the Fe cation is significantly lifted from its initial Fe-N3_3 coordination. The binding energy is found to be −0.84-0.84 eV. The density of states plot indicates that the covalent Fe-CO bonding occurs through hybridization of 5σ\sigma CO orbital with Fe 3dz2d_{z^2}, and 2π∗\pi^* CO orbital with Fe 3dxz/yzd_{xz/yz}. (B) The Fe-N4_4 site is initially quasi-tetrahedral, but upon CO adsorption it gets planarized. The Fe-CO bonding is qualitatively similar to the Fe-N3_3 case, but the adsorption is significantly weaker (−0.23-0.23 eV). The Fe 3dxz/yd_{xz/ y}-CO 2π∗\pi^* bonding is significantly less pronouced, as seen in the much lower occupancy of the CO 2π∗\pi^* orbital.

We carried out variable-temperature STM measurements to provide experimental confirmation of the DFT results. Figure 4A shows an STM image of Fe-DCA/graphene acquired at 128 K prior to CO exposure, panels B,C show STM images acquired on the same area in a background CO pressure of 2×10−82 \times10^{-8} mbar. In subsequent STM images acquired in a CO background, the adsorbed CO molecules are imaged as bright features appearing one-by-one on the Fe-N3_3 sites.

Variable-temperature STM images and analysis of CO adsorption and desorption on Fe-N$_3$ sites within Fe-DCA

Figure 4. Following adsorption and desorption of CO on Fe-N3_3 sites within Fe-DCA by variable-temperature STM. (A) STM image of the clean Fe-DCA/gr acquired at 128 K prior to CO dosing. (Vbias=−1.0V_{\mathrm{bias}}=-1.0 V, Itunnel=50I_{\mathrm{tunnel}}=50 pA). (B) STM image taken at 131 K, after ≈\approx40 min exposure to 2×10−82\times10^{-8} mbar CO (about 35 Langmuir dose). The CO molecules are observed as bright features appearing on the Fe-N3_3 sites (Vbias=−0.9V_{\mathrm{bias}}=-0.9 V, Itunnel=50I_{\mathrm{tunnel}}=50 pA). (C) STM image taken at 133 K, after ≈\approx70 min of CO exposure (about 60 Langmuir dose). The number of CO molecules is increasing with higher CO exposure (Vbias=−0.7V_{\mathrm{bias}}=-0.7 V, Itunnel=50I_{\mathrm{tunnel}}=50 pA). (D-F) Variable-temperature STM allows to follow the change in equilibrium coverage of CO on Fe-N3_3 sites. (D) STM image acquired in a CO background (pCO=5×10−8p_{\mathrm{CO}}=5\times10^{-8} mbar) at 162 K. Many Fe-N3_3 sites are capped with a CO molecule. (E) STM image acquired in the same CO background pressure at a temperature of 181 K. The number of adsorbed CO molecules is significantly reduced. (F) Analysis of temperature-dependent CO coverage on the Fe-DCA/gr, measured in a CO background of 5×10−85\times10^{-8} mbar. The red dots are experimental data extracted from STM images, the blue curve is a Langmuir isobar fit, calculated for Eads=−0.63E_{\mathrm{ads}}=-0.63 eV and background pressure of 5×10−85\times10^{-8} mbar and normalized for maximum observed coverage.

Having identified the CO/Fe-N3_3 species, we increased the CO background pressure to 5×10−85\times10^{-8} mbar, and we continuously imaged the Fe-DCA 2D MOF while heating the sample with a slow temperature ramp of 0.2-0.3 K/min. Figure 4D shows an image taken at 162 K, where a high coverage of CO molecules on Fe-N3_3 sites is observed. As the temperature rises, the fraction of occupied Fe sites decreases, as seen in Figure 4E showing an STM image taken at 181 K. We analyzed the fractional coverage of CO on Fe-N3_3 sites in subsequent STM images taken at temperatures between 144 – 188 K, and we used equilibrium thermodynamics approach to calculate the CO adsorption energy from this experimental dataset. Figure 4C shows experimental data fitted with a Langmuir isobar calculated for the experimental CO pressure of 5×10−85\times10^{-8} mbar. The Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} was treated as a variable parameter of the fit (see SI for details), and the best agreement was found for Eads_CO=−0.63E_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}}=-0.63 eV. This value is consistent with the computational prediction, considering the well-known fact that the DFT methodology used typically overestimates the CO binding by about 0.2 eV21,34,50 due to underestimation of the CO HOMO-LUMO gap.58

The same set of experiments was carried out on the Fe-TCNQ/graphene system, but no evidence of CO adsorption was observed at temperatures down to 115 K. Figure 6A shows that the Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites remain free of CO even when scanned in a 5×10−85 \times10^{-8} mbar CO background at 118 K. The image shows three rotational domains of Fe-TCNQ monolayer and an island of Fe-TCNQ bilayer in a top left corner.59 The monolayer Fe-TCNQ domains feature a characteristic “zig-zag” pattern, indicating that the Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites remain in a CO-free quasi-tetrahedral coordination (see ref 47 for details). This agrees with computational predictions: Figure 5B shows calculated Langmuir isobar for Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} values of −0.2 eV and −0.3 eV, indicating that the Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites are only expected to stably coordinate CO molecules at temperatures well below 100 K in the CO pressure of 5×10−85 \times10^{-8} mbar. The experimental observations are thus fully consistent with computations, unambiguously proving that the CO adsorption energy is significantly higher on Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_{3} sites within Fe-DCA than on the Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites within Fe-TCNQ.

Scanning tunneling microscopy image and Langmuir isobar for Fe-TCNQ

Figure 5. Carbon monoxide does not adsorb on the Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites within Fe-TCNQ at 118 K. (A) Scanning tunneling microscopy image of Fe-TCNQ, acquired at 118 K in a background CO pressure of 5×10−85 \times10^{-8} mbar (total CO dose higher than 100 Langmuir). The characteristic “zig-zag” appearance is observed on the monolayer Fe-TCNQ areas, which clearly indicates that the Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites remain in the quasi-tetrahedral coordination, and no CO is adsorbed. (B) Langmuir isobar calculated for the experimental CO pressure and Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} of −0.3 eV and −0.2 eV. The CO molecules are only expected to be stably adsorbed at temperatures below 100 K (resp. below 70 K for Eads_CO=−0.2E_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}}=-0.2 eV).

Energetics of the Fe-CO bonding as a function of the Fe-lifting above the -N_x plane for CO/Fe-DCA and CO/Fe-TCNQ models

Figure 6. Energetics of the Fe-CO bonding as a function of the Fe-lifting above the -Nx\mathrm{N}_x plane (Δz\Delta z) for the CO/Fe-DCA (A) and CO/Fe-TCNQ (B) models. When the structures are fixed in a planar configuration (Δz=0.0\Delta z=0.0Å), the EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} values of the two models are identical. Lifting the Fe atom above the -Nx\mathrm{N}_x plane significantly stabilizes the EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} in both systems. The main difference lies in the EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}}, which rises much slower in Fe-DCA than in Fe-TCNQ. The minimum of the total CO adsorption energy (Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}}) thus lies at Δz=0.6\Delta z=0.6Å for Fe-DCA, where the EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} is significantly stronger (−1.19 eV). In contrast, the quickly rising EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}} prevents such structural change in Fe-TCNQ, and the minimum of Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} lies at Δz=0.0\Delta z=0.0Å.

The origin of different reactivity of Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_{3} and Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites

The observed difference in Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_{3} and Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} reactivity does not originate from the ground state electronic structures of the Fe-Nx\mathrm{N}_{x} sites, because these are almost identical, as shown in Figure 2 and Table 1. Therefore, in the following section we focus on the effect of the CO-induced structural relaxations that are present in both models. Specifically, in the Fe-DCA case the CO ligation lifts the Fe atom up from the -N3\mathrm{N}_{3} plane to form a tetrahedral geometry, while the quasi-tetrahedral Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_{4} sites within Fe-TCNQ get planarized upon CO adsorption. The computed Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} values contain contributions from both the Fe-CO bond (EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}}) and from the structural distortion (EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}}):

Eads_CO=Ebond+EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} = E_{\mathrm{bond}} + E_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}}

where EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} can be calculated as the energy difference between the most stable structure with CO and the same structure frozen in the CO-induced geometry with the CO molecule removed to the gas phase. The EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}} is calculated as the energy difference between the most stable MOF structure and the structure frozen in the distorted geometry after removing the CO. The values of Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}}, EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} and EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}} are summarized in Table 2. The computations were carried out both in a free-standing approximation and supported on graphene, this allows to rigorously quantify any effects induced by the interaction with the support. The data show that CO-induced lifting of the Fe atom within the Fe-DCA/graphene structure costs 0.18 eV, while the Fe-CO bond stabilizes the system by −1.02 eV. Together, these contributions add up to Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} of −0.84 eV. The value of Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} is very similar between an ideal free-standing and graphene-supported Fe-DCA models, but in the free-standing approximation the lack of van der Waals interaction with the support allows larger CO-induced structural distortions; this results in different values of EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} and EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}}.

Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}}EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}}EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}}
free-standing Fe-DCA−0.76 eV−1.22 eV0.46 eV
Fe-DCA/graphene−0.84 eV−1.02 eV0.18 eV
free-standing Fe-TCNQ−0.20 eV−0.41 eV0.21 eV
non-planar Fe-TCNQ/graphene−0.23 eV−0.42 eV0.19 eV
planar Fe-TCNQ/graphene−0.32 eV−0.41 eV0.09 eV

Table 2. Computed CO adsorption energies (Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}}), energies of the Fe-CO bond (EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}}) and energies required to distort the MOF structures to accommodate the CO adsorbate (EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}}) on the individual Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ models.

The CO-induced structural relaxation is qualitatively the opposite in Fe-TCNQ, as the CO-free structure features Fe in non-planar Fe-N4_4 sites, and the CO ligation causes their planarization. Therefore, the energy required for the Fe-N4_4 planarization depends on the initial structure. When the EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}} is referenced to a free-standing structure with Fe in perfect tetrahedrons, the energy required to planarize one Fe site is 0.21 eV, and this value is very similar (0.19 eV) when a slightly planarized Fe-TCNQ/graphene structure is taken as a reference (shown in Figure 1E). Finally, when a hypothetical perfectly planar structure is assumed, the structural changes induced by CO adsorption cost only 0.09 eV. Regardless of the different energy references (which lead to different Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} values from −0.20 eV to −0.32 eV), the strength of the Fe-CO bond remains remarkably consistent in these different models, falling within (−0.410 ± 0.006) eV. This is because the coordination geometry of the final CO/Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_4 structure is the same in all the tested Fe-TCNQ models.

To summarize, it is found that the cost of structural relaxations (EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}}) is comparable across the different graphene-supported Fe-N3\mathrm{N}_3 and Fe-N4\mathrm{N}_4 models. This indicates that the observed differences in Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} do not stem from different electronic structures of the Fe cations, nor from the different energetic costs of adsorbate-induced relaxations. However, the structural distortions do not only cost energy; they can simultaneously stabilize the Fe-CO bonding by allowing more efficient hybridization. This effect is clearly seen in Figure 6A, where we plot the Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}}, EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} and EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}} values of CO/Fe-DCA models, whose structures were kept fixed in intermediate points between the CO-free and CO-adsorbed structures. When the Fe-DCA structure is fixed to be planar (Δz=0.0\Delta z = 0.0 Å), then the EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} is −0.41 eV, i.e. identical to the EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} value found in Fe-TCNQ models. However, once the Fe atom is lifted above the plane, the EbondE_{\mathrm{bond}} is significantly strengthened, by about (−0.12 ± 0.03) eV per every 0.1 Å increase of Δz\Delta z. The price paid for the Fe-CO bond stabilization is the EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}}, but this is very low for small Δz\Delta z, and only starts to significantly increase at Δz≥0.3\Delta z \ge0.3 Å. The minimum energy of the system is found at Δz=0.6\Delta z = 0.6 Å, which is close to the structural distortion of the fully relaxed system (Δzrel=0.68\Delta z_{\mathrm{rel}} = 0.68 Å). At this point the total Eads_CO=−0.81E_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} = -0.81 eV is very close to the value found in fully-relaxed structures (−0.84 eV).

A similar analysis was carried out on the CO/Fe-TCNQ system to test if a similar Fe-CO bond stabilization mechanism could take place here. First, we tested the ground-state Fe-TCNQ structure with the Fe-N4_4 sites being fixed in the quasi-tetrahedral geometry. The Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} value of only −0.10-0.10 eV highlights again the crucial role of structural flexibility: without the possibility to planarize the Fe-N4_4 structure, the site is inert to any chemical interaction with CO. As the next step, we have taken the planarized CO-induced geometry as a reference structure (Δz=0.0\Delta z = 0.0 Å), and we lifted the Fe atom from this reference. As shown in Figure 6B, this stabilizes the Fe-CO bond in a similar way as in the Fe-N3_3 site, by about (−0.08±0.02)(-0.08 \pm0.02) eV per every 0.1 Å increase of Δz\Delta z. However, the EMOF_distortionE_{\mathrm{MOF\_distortion}} rises faster already from low Δz\Delta z, making this Fe-CO bond stabilization mechanism unfavorable. This presents the fundamental difference between the two sites that results in significantly stronger CO adsorption on the Fe-N3_3 compared to Fe-N4_4 sites.

Discussion

Overall, our results reveal that the fundamental origin of the distinct reactivities of Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 lies in their different structural flexibility. When the Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 sites are fixed in similar (planar) geometries, then the CO binding energies are identical (−0.410±0.006-0.410 \pm0.006 eV), as one would expect based on their identical electronic configuration, similar d-orbital center positions and minimal steric hinderance for CO adsorption. However, this picture dramatically changes once the structures are allowed to relax. The structural flexibility of the Fe-N3_3 site allows lifting of the Fe cation by 0.68 Å, which costs 0.18 eV but strengthens the Fe-CO bond by additional 0.61 eV. In contrast, on the Fe-N4_4 site a price of 0.19 eV is paid to planarize the Fe-N4_4 geometry, and while an additional Fe-CO bond stabilization is possible by lifting of the Fe atom from the -N4_4 plane, it is energetically unfavorable due to the structural rigidity of the Fe-N4_4 geometry.

Having identified the physical origin of the differing Fe-CO bond strengths, we further analyzed how the observed structural changes correlate to the electronic structure parameters of the CO-free models. In both models, lifting of the Fe atom enables stabilization of both the Fe 3dz2_{z^2} - CO 5σ and Fe 3dxz/yz_{xz/yz} - CO 2π* bonds, but the effect is significantly stronger on the π bonding (detailed in Figure S3-Figure S7 in the SI). Thus, within the d-band center model framework one would expect that such stronger Fe-CO bonding could be correlated to an up-shift of the Fe dxz/yz_{xz/yz} and dz2_{z^2} centers in CO-free structures. However, our data do not indicate such a scenario; the Fe d-orbital center positions of CO-free structures do not follow a consistent trend upon Fe-lifting (detailed in Figure S8 in the SI). This means that the observed trend of increasing Fe-CO bond strength upon Fe-lifting is not easily correlated to the electronic parameters of CO-free structures in their electronic ground states.

COHP diagrams between the frontier molecular orbitals of CO and Fe 3d orbitals for CO adsorbed on FeDCA and FeTCNQ

Figure S3. COHP diagrams between the frontier molecular orbitals of CO and Fe 3d orbitals (summed up) for the CO molecule adsorbed on FeDCA (panel A), and FeTCNQ (panel B). The red curve represents a cumulative sum of −COHP (−ICOHP). COHP values stabilizing (destabilizing) a bond are colored in green (red). −COHP values integrated up to Fermi level are written in red.

Figure S7. Evolution of the bond length (panel A) and the occupation of the LUMO orbitals (panel B) of the CO adsorbed on the FeTCNQ and FeDCA network with the shift of the Fe atom in the z-axis.

D-band center positions of the Fe atom within Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ as a function of the Fe lifting

Figure S8. D-band center positions of the Fe atom within Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ as a function of the Fe lifting. (A) Fe-DCA without CO, (B) Fe-DCA with CO, (C) Fe-TCNQ without CO, (D) Fe-TCNQ with CO.

All this implies that the reactivity descriptors based on electronic parameters of the ground state structures have limited applicability for SAC systems. The different local environments of the SAC sites inevitably lead to different possibilities for structural relaxation, and such relaxation can significantly affect the adsorption energetics. The coordination number of the metal and the nature of the metal-ligand bonds are the most obvious parameters defining the local environment, but significant differences should also be expected between sites with the same coordination number and same ligands: for example, in TCNQ-based 2D MOFs the metal sites are typically coordinated to four cyano- groups, but the preference for square-planar or tetrahedral local geometry varies from cation to cation. While the Ni cations in Ni-TCNQ prefer geometries close to square-planar,60 a similar Co-TCNQ system shows preference for tetrahedral Co sites.61 Such differences will significantly affect both the energy required for planarization and the energy required for potential cation lifting. Structural flexibility can thus significantly vary even in very similar systems, implying the need for analyzing the individual systems on a case-by-case basis, and establishing general trends from reliable quantitative datasets, where both the electronic properties and structural flexibility are considered. This makes computational screening for promising SACs a much more complex task, but it significantly increases the chances of finding efficient SACs.

Conclusions

This work quantifies the reactivity differences between model single-atom catalyst sites with identical electronic structure (high-spin d6d^{6}) but different local coordination geometry. It is found that threefold coordinated Fe-N3_{3} sites are significantly more reactive towards carbon monoxide than fourfold coordinated Fe-N4_{4} sites; the difference in adsorption energy is 0.62 eV. This difference can be tracked down to distinct possibilities of structural relaxations: the Fe cation in trigonal-planar geometry can be easily lifted above the plane, which costs 0.18 eV but strengthens the Fe-CO bond by 0.61 eV, primarily through increased Fe 3dxz/yz3d_{xz/yz} - CO 2π∗2\pi^{*} back-bonding. In contrast, a similar mechanism is unfavorable in Fe-N4_{4} sites due to the structural rigidity of the square-planar geometry. These results demonstrate the crucial role of coordination geometry in single atom catalysis, and that these effects are not captured by reactivity descriptors based solely on the electronic structure parameters.

Acknowledgements

Z.J. acknowledges funding from the Czech Science Foundation (GAČR grant 24-10593L). J.P. was supported by the European Union’s Horizon Widera 2022 program under grant agreement No. 101130765. The DFT computations were carried out at IT4I National Supercomputing Center (supported by MEYS CR through the e-INFRA CZ, ID: 90140). The CzechNanoLab project LM2023051, funded by MEYS CR, is acknowledged for the financial support of the research at CEITEC Nano Research Infrastructure.

Contributions

Z.J., D.H., T.L., A.J. acquired and analyzed the experimental data, J.P. and T.L. carried out the computational analysis. Z.J. and J.Č. conceptualized and supervised the research. Z.J. and J.Č. acquired the research funding. Z.J. and J.P. wrote the manuscript with the input from all co-authors.

Supporting information

Experimental and computational methods, additional STM data and additional computational analysis of the Fe\mathrm{Fe}-CO bonding in the Fe\mathrm{Fe}-N3\mathrm{N}_3 and Fe\mathrm{Fe}-N4\mathrm{N}_4 models. The supporting information file contains additional references.62–77

Supplementary Information

Correspondence to: [email protected], [email protected]

Experimental Methods

Experiments were carried out in an ultrahigh vacuum system consisting of multiple chambers interconnected by a central transfer line, separated by gate valves. The base pressure of all the chambers used in this study is below 5×10−105 \times10^{-10} mbar. The Ir(111) single crystals were purchased from MaTecK and SPL, the Ir(111) surface was prepared by cycles of Ar+ sputtering (1.5 keV, 10 min) and annealing up to 1300 °C for 10 min. When graphene was present on the sample prior to cleaning, the first annealing cycle took place in O2_2 background (up to 1100 °C, pO2=1×10−6p_{\mathrm{O}_2} = 1 \times10^{-6} mbar). The temperature was measured by a LumaSense IMPAC IGA 140 pyrometer with the emissivity set to 0.1.

Graphene on Ir(111) was grown by adsorbing saturation coverage of ethylene at room temperature, followed by pumping out the ethylene background and ramping the temperature up to 1250 °C in UHV. At 1250 °C the sample was re-exposed to ethylene (5×10−75 \times10^{-7} mbar, 5 min). This protocol combines temperature-programmed growth (TPG) with chemical vapor deposition (CVD) and consistently leads to a full monolayer coverage of high-quality graphene/Ir(111).[1, 2]

TCNQ was evaporated from a quartz crucible heated to 115 °C (MBE Komponenten OEZ), Fe was evaporated from an alumina crucible heated to 1030 °C (MBE Komponenten HTEZ). The evaporation rate of Fe was checked by a water-cooled quartz crystal microbalance. The sample temperature during Fe-TCNQ synthesis was calibrated by a special sample holder with a K-Type thermocouple attached close to the crystal surface. The Fe-TCNQ synthesis protocol involved saturation by TCNQ at a ≈ 80 °C, followed by co-deposition of Fe and TCNQ at the same temperature. After the co-deposition step, the samples were annealed to 420 °C. This annealing step leads to improved long-range order of the Fe-TCNQ 2D MOF and also leads to the desorption of TCNQ molecules adsorbed atop the 2D MOF.[3] A detailed analysis of graphene-supported Fe-TCNQ systems is provided in refs 4,5.

DCA was evaporated from a quartz crucible placed in a Createc NATC evaporator heated by a heat transfer fluid kept at 110 °C (using a Huber CC304 bath thermostat). The sample temperature during Fe+DCA codeposition was ≈ 70 °C, afterwards the sample was post-annealed up to ≈ 90 °C.

Scanning tunneling microscopy images were recorded in the constant current mode using a variable-temperature SPECS Aarhus 150 system equipped with a tungsten tip. During low-temperature operation, the sample stage is cooled by liquid nitrogen flow through a stage-locking piston, the thermal contact during STM scanning is facilitated by copper braids. The temperature of the sample rises during STM scanning, which results in large thermal drift. The image distortion was corrected during post-processing to fit the known dimensions of the measured structures: the unit cells of the gr/Ir moiré, Fe-TCNQ and Fe-DCA 2D MOFs. Where possible, nonlinear image distortion was corrected as described in ref. 6. Carbon monoxide was dosed directly to the STM chamber by a high-precision leak valve, the pressure was monitored by a Bayard-Alpert gauge.

Low Energy Electron Diffraction data were acquired in a SPECS FE-LEEM P90 instrument, diffraction patterns were modelled and visualized using ProLEED Studio software.[7, 8]

Langmuir isobar analysis

The Langmuir isobar shown in Figure 4C and Figure 5B in the main text is given by the expression

θ(T)=1exp⁡(Eads_CO−μ(T)kT)+1\theta(T) = \frac{1}{\exp\left(\frac{E_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}}-\mu(T)}{kT}\right)+1}

where θ(T)\theta(T) is the normalized fractional CO coverage, Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} is the CO adsorption energy, kk is Boltzmann constant, TT is temperature and μ(T)\mu(T) is the equilibrium chemical potential of the gas-phase CO and adsorbed CO which can be expressed as

μ(T)=kT[ln⁡(ph3(2πmkT)3/2kT)+ln⁡(TTR)],\mu(T) = kT \left[\ln\left(\frac{ph^3}{(2\pi m kT)^{3/2}kT}\right) + \ln\left(\frac{T}{T_{\mathrm{R}}}\right)\right],

where pp is the pressure of CO, hh is Planck constant, mm is the mass of the CO molecule and TR=2.78T_{\mathrm{R}} = 2.78 K is the rotational temperature of CO. In the analysis presented in Figure 4C, the isobar was evaluated for the experimental CO pressure of 5×10−85 \times10^{-8} mbar, while the Eads_COE_{\mathrm{ads\_CO}} was treated as a variable parameter of the fit.

Computational Methods

Spin-polarized density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed with the Vienna ab initio Simulation Package (VASP)[9] using the projector augmented wave method (PAW)[10] to treat core electrons. We used a nonlocal van der Waals corrected optPBE-vdW functional[11] for the description of exchange correlation energy. A Hubbard-like coulomb repulsion correction U−J=4U-J = 4 eV in Dudarev’s formulation[12] was employed for an appropriate description of Fe 3d orbitals. For iron, nitrogen, oxygen, hydrogen and carbon, 11 valence electrons (3s23p64s23d63s^2 3p^6 4s^2 3d^6), 5 valence electrons (2s22p32s^2 2p^3), 6 valence electrons (1s22p41s^2 2p^4), 1 valence electron (1s11s^1), and 4 valence electrons (2s22p22s^2 2p^2), respectively, were expanded in a plane-wave basis set with an energy cutoff set to 520 eV. The Brillouin zone was sampled with a 3×3×13 \times3 \times1 Γ\Gamma-centered Monkhorst–Pack grid.[13] Geometry optimization was stopped when all residual forces acting on atoms were less than 0.02 eV/Å. We used the Occupation Matrix Control[14] (OMC) of the Fe 3d manifold in the Fe-DCA networks to generate the initial electronic configuration with correct occupation matrices (corresponding to the electronic ground state). For the three-fold coordinated Fe atom, the occupation matrix in the spin-up channel was set close to the identity matrix, while for the spin-down channel, one electron was assigned to the dz2d_{z^2} orbital (see eq. (1)). This electronic configuration was subsequently relaxed without the OMC. This procedure allowed us to reliably obtain the most stable electronic configuration. The occupation matrices for the spin-up and for the spin-down channel employed in calculations are:

M↑=(0.98000000.95000000.95000000.95000000.98),M↓=(0.1000000.1000000.92000000.1000000.1)(1)M_{\uparrow} = \begin{pmatrix} 0.98 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0.95 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0.95 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.95 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.98 \end{pmatrix}, \quad M_{\downarrow} = \begin{pmatrix} 0.1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0.1 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0.92 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0.1 \end{pmatrix} \tag*{(1)}

For interface calculations, a single graphene sheet was used as a substrate. To create the interface models, we kept the substrate atoms at their positions calculated from DFT, adjusted the molecular layer accordingly, and added a 15 Å thick vacuum layer. For the Fe-TCNQ/gr interface, we proceed from the supercell employed in our previous work,[5] but doubled in the bb direction in order to avoid interactions between the adsorbates over the periodically repeated replicas. The matrix notation of the employed supercell is (−4−13102)\begin{pmatrix} -4 & -13 \\ 10 & 2 \end{pmatrix} for graphene and (4002)\begin{pmatrix} 4 & 0 \\ 0 & 2 \end{pmatrix} for the Fe-TCNQ layer, resulting in Fe-TCNQ lattice parameters that lie between those of the gas-phase tilted configuration and the planarized configuration.[5]

The Fe-DCA/gr interface was modelled using the supercell with the matrix notation (7−292)\begin{pmatrix} 7 & -2 \\ 9 & 2 \end{pmatrix} for graphene, which was merged with the primitive unit cell of the honeycomb-kagomé Fe-DCA. The dimensions of the supercell are 0.8% larger than the lattice parameter of the FeDCA gas phase model.

The Crystal Orbital Hamilton Population (COHP) analysis of the Fe-CO bonding was calculated using the LOBSTER code,[15, 16] and the LUMO occupations were calculated as integrated projections of a full system wavefunction onto a gas-phase CO Kohn-Sham orbitals, following the methodology described in reference [17].

Additional STM data of Fe-DCA/gr

Figure S1 shows a large-scale STM image of Fe-DCA/gr. The Fe-DCA structure is observed in two distinct rotations with respect to the graphene/Ir moiré, in agreement with the LEED data presented in the main text. The characteristic dimensions of the Fe-DCA islands are higher tens of nm. The bright features on top of the Fe-DCA islands are most likely excess Fe+DCA species; further annealing up to 110 °C did not lead to desorption of these features.

Additional STM data of Fe-TCNQ/gr

The STM appearance of the Fe-TCNQ/gr/Ir(111) system strongly depends on the applied bias voltage, as described in detail in reference [5]. At sample bias around −0.6-0.6 V (Figure S2A), the Fe-TCNQ monolayer looks homogeneous, but at sample bias close to −1.3-1.3 V (Figure S2B), characteristic “zig-zag” appearance is observed on parts of the monolayer Fe-TCNQ areas. This is because at these tunneling conditions the most intense signal originates from the electronic states located at the cyano- and methyl- groups of the TCNQ molecule, which are physically corrugated within the quasi-tetrahedral Fe-N4_4 sites. The quasi-tetrahedral motif is accommodated by tilting and twisting of the TCNQ linkers; the characteristic “zig-zag” pattern appears when the tilt angles of TCNQ molecules are ordered.[5]

Analysis of Fe-CO bonding using COHP approach

Additional computational analysis was carried out using Crystal Orbital Hamilton Population (COHP) approach to elucidate the contribution of the individual orbitals to the Fe-CO covalent bonding. Figure S3 shows the calculated COHP and integrated COHP (ICOHP) values for CO bonding between the frontier molecular orbitals and the Fe 3d orbitals. Comparison of the CO/Fe-DCA and CO/Fe-TCNQ systems reveals a stronger covalent character of the Fe–CO bond in CO/Fe-DCA, consistent with the higher binding energy. Notably, the ICOHP values associated with LUMO–Fe and LUMO+1–Fe interactions (π\pi bonding) are four times lower for Fe-TCNQ, whereas the ICOHP values for HOMO–Fe interactions (σ\sigma bonding) are only reduced by a factor of two.

Next, in Figure S4 and Figure S5 we compare the orbital-resolved contributions to the ICOHP from the individual Fe 3d orbitals (Figure S4 shows this for CO/Fe-DCA, Figure S5 for CO/Fe-TCNQ). The dxyd_{xy} and dx2−y2d_{x^2-y^2} contribution to ICOHP is zero because there is no effective overlap with the CO molecular orbitals. The σ\sigma bonding is represented with the dz2d_{z^2} orbital, and π\pi bonding with the dxzd_{xz} and dyzd_{yz} orbitals. Both the σ\sigma and π\pi channels show a similar trend: in CO/Fe-DCA, the COHP peaks appear at higher energies and with larger absolute values than in CO/Fe-TCNQ (for example, the dz2d_{z^2} antibonding peak is located at −2.2 eV for CO/Fe-DCA, and −4.1 eV for CO/Fe-TCNQ). This observation is consistent with the basic assumption of the d-band center model: filled electronic states positioned closer to Fermi level (with d-orbital centers at higher energies) hybridize more effectively with the frontier molecular orbitals of CO, resulting in a more pronounced covalent character.

COHP diagrams between the Fe 3d orbitals and the summed frontier molecular orbitals for a CO molecule adsorbed on Fe-DCA

Figure S4. COHP diagrams between the Fe 3d3d orbitals and the summed frontier molecular orbitals for a CO molecule adsorbed on Fe-DCA. The red curve represents a cumulative sum of −COHP-\mathrm{COHP} (−ICOHP-\mathrm{ICOHP}). COHP values stabilizing (destabilizing) a bond are colored in green (red). −COHP-\mathrm{COHP} values integrated up to Fermi level are written in red.

COHP diagrams between the Fe 3d orbitals and the summed frontier molecular orbitals for a CO molecule adsorbed on FeTCNQ

Figure S5. COHP diagrams between the Fe 3d3d orbitals and the summed frontier molecular orbitals for a CO molecule adsorbed on FeTCNQ. The red curve represents the cumulative sum of −COHP-\mathrm{COHP} (black curve). The projected density of states is shown in gray. COHP values stabilizing (destabilizing) a bond are colored in green (red). −COHP-\mathrm{COHP} values integrated up to Fermi level are written in red.

Figure S6 shows the ICOHP values for the σ\sigma and π\pi channels of CO/Fe-DCA and CO/Fe-TCNQ plotted as a function of Δz\Delta z (the lifting of the Fe atom from the -Nx_x plane). In both systems, the contribution of the π\pi channel rises faster than that of the σ\sigma channel. This indicates that both the Fe 3dz23d_{z^2} - CO 5σ5\sigma and Fe 3dxz/yz3d_{xz/yz} - CO 2π∗2\pi^* interactions are stabilized upon Fe lifting, but the effect is significantly stronger on the Fe 3dxz/yz3d_{xz/yz} - CO 2π∗2\pi^*.

ICOHP values for CO–Fe bonds, showing CO $\sigma$ and $\pi$ channels for FeTCNQ and FeDCA as a function of $\Delta z$

Figure S6. ICOHP values for the bond between the CO molecule and the Fe atom in the FeTCNQ and FeDCA, plotted as a function of the Fe-atom lifting from the -Nx_x plane.

Figure S7 shows the CO bond lengths and the occupation of the CO LUMO orbital as a function of the Fe atom lifting from the -Nx_x plane. As expected, both properties show a similar trend, and both are significantly higher in Fe-DCA compared to Fe-TCNQ. This behavior is consistent with the activation of the CO molecule upon adsorption, where increased occupation of the LUMO orbital correlates with stronger Fe-CO adsorption energy and weaker intramolecular C-O bond.

Analysis of Fe dd-orbital center positions upon Fe lifting

Finally, we analyze how the Fe dd-orbital center positions evolve upon lifting of the Fe atom from the -Nx_x, in both the Fe-DCA and Fe-TCNQ systems. In Figure S8, we plot the energies of the Fe 3d orbitals centers relative to the Fermi level as a function of the Δz\Delta z. Figure S8A,C shows that in Fe-N3_3 and Fe-N4_4 sites with fixed planar geometries (Δz=0\Delta z = 0 Å), the Fe dd-orbital center positions are very similar; this is consistent with the fact that the CO adsorption energies on these fixed structures are virtually identical, as described in the main text. However, upon lifting of the Fe atom, we observe inconsistent trends in the Fe 3d orbital center positions: In Fe-DCA the dd-orbital centers are rising in energy with increasing Δz\Delta z (up to Δz=1.0\Delta z = 1.0 Å), while in Fe-TCNQ the opposite is happening and the dd-orbital center positions are consistently decreasing in energy. This shows that the trends observed in CO binding strengths (shown in Figure 6 in the main text and S8 in the SI) cannot be easily correlated to the position of the dd-orbitals centers prior to CO adsorption.

Finally, in Figure S8B,D we plot the position of the Fe 3d orbital centers after CO adsorption as a function of Δz\Delta z. Notably, both the absolute positions and qualitative trends are distinct between the two systems (comparison between panels B,D) and also between the CO-free and CO-adsorbed models (comparison between panels A,B and C,D). This behavior is different from the common assumption of the dd-band center model applied to extended metallic surfaces, where the adsorption of weak probe molecules at low coverage typically induces only minor changes in the dd-band center positions.[18]

In summary, our analysis provides further indications that SAC reactivity descriptors based solely on electronic structure parameters do not fully determine the adsorption properties of “single atoms” embedded within carbon-based materials. Additional parameters including coordination geometry and structural flexibility of the active site must be considered.

References

  1. [1]N’Diaye, A. T., Coraux, J., Plasa, T. N., Busse, C. & Michely, T. Structure of epitaxial graphene on Ir(111). New J Phys 10, 43033 (2008).DOI
  2. [2]Coraux, J. et al. Growth of graphene on Ir(111). New J Phys 11, 23006 (2009).
  3. [3]Jakub, Z. et al. Identical Fe–N₄ Sites with Different Reactivity: Elucidating the Effect of Support Curvature. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 17, 10136–10144 (2025).
  4. [4]Jakub, Z. et al. Remarkably stable metal–organic frameworks on an inert substrate: M-TCNQ on graphene (M = Ni, Fe, Mn). Nanoscale 14, 9507–9515 (2022).
  5. [5]Jakub, Z. et al. How the Support Defines Properties of 2D Metal–Organic Frameworks: Fe-TCNQ on Graphene versus Au(111). J Am Chem Soc 146, 3471–3482 (2024).
  6. [6]Choi, J. I. J. et al. The growth of ultra-thin zirconia films on Pd₃Zr(0001). J Phys: Condens Matter 26, 225003 (2014).
  7. [7]Prochazka, P. & Cechal, J. ProLEED Studio: software for modeling low-energy electron diffraction patterns. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 57, 187–193 (2024).DOI
  8. [8]Čechal, J. & Procházka, P. Low-energy electron microscopy as a tool for analysis of self-assembled molecular layers on surfaces. J Phys: Condens Matter 37, 293003 (2025).DOI
  9. [9]Kresse, G. & Furthmüller, J. Efficiency of ab-initio total energy calculations for metals and semiconductors using a plane-wave basis set. Comput Mater Sci 6, 15–50 (1996).DOI
  10. [10]Blöchl, P. E. Projector augmented-wave method. Phys. Rev. B 50, 17953–17979 (1994).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9976227
  11. [11]Klimeš, J., Bowler, D. R. & Michaelides, A. Chemical accuracy for the van der Waals density functional. J Phys: Condens Matter 22, 22201 (2009).
  12. [12]Dudarev, S. L., Botton, G. A., Savrasov, S. Y., Humphreys, C. J. & Sutton, A. P. Electron-energy-loss spectra and the structural stability of nickel oxide: An LSDA+U study. Phys Rev B 57, 1505–1509 (1998).DOI
  13. [13]Monkhorst, H. J. & Pack, J. D. Special points for Brillouin-zone integrations. Phys Rev B 13, 5188–5192 (1976).DOI
  14. [14]Allen, J. P. & Watson, G. W. Occupation matrix control of d- and f-electron localisations using DFT + U. Phys Chem Chem Phys 16, 21016–21031 (2014).DOI
  15. [15]Dronskowski, R. & Bloechl, P. E. Crystal orbital Hamilton populations (COHP): energy-resolved visualization of chemical bonding in solids based on density-functional calculations. J Phys Chem 97, 8617–8624 (1993).DOI
  16. [16]Maintz, S., Deringer, V. L., Tchougréeff, A. L. & Dronskowski, R. LOBSTER: A tool to extract chemical bonding from plane-wave based DFT. J Comput Chem 37, 1030–1035 (2016).
  17. [17]Lüftner, D. et al. Understanding the photoemission distribution of strongly interacting two-dimensional overlayers. Phys Rev B 96, 125402 (2017).DOI
  18. [18]Hammer, B. & Nørskov, J. K. B. T.-A. in C. Theoretical surface science and catalysis—calculations and concepts. Adv Catal 45, 71–129 (2000).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_3nyjf2eq
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents