betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Local position-space two-nucleon potentials from leading to fourth order of chiral effective field theory

Abstract

We present local, position-space chiral NN potentials through four orders of chiral effective field theory ranging from leading order (LO) to next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order (N3LO, fourth order) of the Delta-less version of the theory. The long-range parts of these potentials are fixed by the very accurate pi-N LECs as determined in the Roy-Steiner equations analysis. At the highest order (N3LO), the NN data below 190 MeV laboratory energy are reproduced with the respectable chi^2/datum of 1.45. A comparison of the N3LO potential with the phenomenological Argonne v_18 (AV18) potential reveals substantial agreement between the two potentials in the intermediate range ruled by chiral symmetry, thus, providing a chiral underpinning for the phenomenological AV18 potential. Our chiral NN potentials may serve as a solid basis for systematic ab initio calculations of nuclear structure and reactions that allow for a comprehensive error analysis. In particular, the order by order development of the potentials will make possible a reliable determination of the truncation error at each order. Our new family of local position-space potentials differs from existing potentials of this kind by a weaker tensor force as reflected in relatively low D-state probabilities of the deuteron (P_D less or equal 4.0% for our N3LO potentials) and predictions for the triton binding energy above 8.00 MeV (from two-body forces alone). As a consequence, our potentials may lead to different predictions when applied to light and intermediate-mass nuclei in ab initio calculations and, potentially, help solve some of the outstanding problems in microscopic nuclear structure.

Introduction

A primary goal of theoretical nuclear physics is to explain nuclear structure and reactions in terms of the forces between nucleons—in present-day popular jargon dubbed the ab initio approach. The current prevailing belief in the community is that chiral effective field theory (EFT) is best suited to provide those forces, because it can be related to low-energy QCD in a straight-forward way and produces abundant three-nucleon forces (3NFs) needed for any quantitative nuclear structure prediction [1–4].

Since chiral EFT is a low-momentum expansion, most chiral NNNN potentials of the past have been developed in momentum space—and are non-local. However, this feature makes them unsuitable for a large group of ab initio few- and many-body algorithms, particularly, the ones known as quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods [5, 6]. Variational Monte Carlo (VMC) and Green’s Function Monte Carlo (GFMC) techniques provide reliable solutions of the many-body Schrödinger equation for, presently, up to 12 nucleons. Spectra, form factors, transitions, low-energy scattering, and response functions for light nuclei have been successfully calculated using QMC methods [7]. A further extension, the Auxiliary Field Diffusion Monte Carlo (AFDMC) [5, 6], additionally samples the spin-isospin degrees of freedom, thus, making possible the study of neutron matter. In summary, QMC techniques have substantially contributed to the progress in ab initio nuclear structure of the past 20+ years, and will continue to do so. Thus, it is important that high-quality nuclear interactions are available for application by these promising many-body methods.

An important advantage of chiral EFT is that it allows for a systematic quantification of the uncertainties of the predictions. For this it is necessary to conduct calculations at different orders of the chiral expansion. However, so far, local chiral NNNN potentials have been developed only at next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO) [8] or in the hybrid format, NNLO/N3^{3}LO [9, 10], where two-pion exchange (2PE) contributions are included up to NNLO and contact terms up to next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order (N3^{3}LO). To make proper uncertainty quantifications possible, local chiral NNNN potentials at all orders from leading order (LO) to N3^{3}LO (and, if necessary, even beyond) are needed. It is the purpose of this work to construct such local NNNN potentials of high quality and make them available for QMC calculations as well as any other purposes where they can be of use.

We will develop these potentials within the Δ\Delta-less theory, which has two degrees of freedom, namely, pions (Goldstone bosons) and nucleons, and does not include a Δ(1232)\Delta(1232)-isobar degree of freedom. If an explicit Δ\Delta-isobar is included in chiral EFT (Δ\Delta-full theory [11–16]), then the two-nucleon force (2NF) and 3NF contributions are enhanced at next-to-leading order (NLO), resulting in a smoother convergence when advancing from leading order (LO) to NNLO. However, summing up all contributions at NNLO brings about very similar results for both versions of the theory [15]. The predictions of both theories beyond NNLO are expected to be very similar [16]. In contrast to recent claims [17], it has been shown in Ref. [18] that there is no advantage to the Δ\Delta-full theory.

This paper is organized as follows: In Sec. II, we present the expansion of the NNNN potential through all orders from LO to N3^{3}LO. The reproduction of the NNNN scattering data and the deuteron properties are given in Sec. III. Uncertainty quantification is considered in Sec. IV. Sec. V concludes the paper.

The chiral NNNN potential

Effective Lagrangians

In the Δ\Delta-less version of chiral EFT, which is the one we are applying, the relevant degrees of freedom are pions and nucleons. Consequently, the effective Lagrangian is subdivided into the following pieces,

Leff=Lππ+LπN+LNN+…(1)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{eff}} = \mathcal{L}_{\pi\pi} + \mathcal{L}_{\pi N} + \mathcal{L}_{NN} + \ldots \tag*{(1)}

where Lππ\mathcal{L}_{\pi\pi} deals with the dynamics among pions, LπN\mathcal{L}_{\pi N} describes the interaction between pions and a nucleon, and LNN\mathcal{L}_{NN} contains two-nucleon contact interactions which consist of four nucleon-fields (four nucleon legs) and no meson fields. The ellipsis stands for terms that involve two nucleons plus pions and three or more nucleons with or without pions, relevant for nuclear many-body forces. Since the interactions of Goldstone bosons must vanish at zero momentum transfer and in the chiral limit (mπ→0m_\pi\to0), the low-energy expansion of the effective Lagrangian is arranged in powers of derivatives and pion masses, implying to following organization:

Lππ=Lππ(2)+Lππ(4)+…(2)\mathcal{L}_{\pi\pi} = \mathcal{L}_{\pi\pi}^{(2)} + \mathcal{L}_{\pi\pi}^{(4)} + \ldots \tag*{(2)}
LπN=LπN(1)+LπN(2)+LπN(3)+LπN(4)+…(3)\mathcal{L}_{\pi N} = \mathcal{L}_{\pi N}^{(1)} + \mathcal{L}_{\pi N}^{(2)} + \mathcal{L}_{\pi N}^{(3)} + \mathcal{L}_{\pi N}^{(4)} + \ldots \tag*{(3)}
LNN=LNN(0)+LNN(2)+LNN(4)+…(4)\mathcal{L}_{NN} = \mathcal{L}_{NN}^{(0)} + \mathcal{L}_{NN}^{(2)} + \mathcal{L}_{NN}^{(4)} + \ldots \tag*{(4)}

where the superscript refers to the number of derivatives or pion mass insertions (chiral dimension) and the ellipses stand for terms of higher dimensions. We use the heavy-baryon formulation of the Lagrangians, the explicit expressions of which can be found in Ref. [1].

Power counting

Based upon the above Lagrangians, an infinite number of diagrams contributing to the interactions among nucleons can be drawn. Nuclear potentials are defined by the irreducible types of these graphs. By definition, an irreducible graph is a diagram that cannot be separated into two by cutting only nucleon lines. These graphs are then analyzed in terms of powers of QQ with Q=p/ΛbQ = p/\Lambda_b, where pp is generic for a momentum (nucleon three-momentum or pion four-momentum) or a pion mass and Λb∼mρ∼0.7\Lambda_b \sim m_\rho\sim0.7 GeV is the breakdown scale [19]. Determining the power ν\nu has become know as power counting.

Following the Feynman rules of covariant perturbation theory, a nucleon propagator is p−1p^{-1}, a pion propagator p−2p^{-2}, each derivative in any interaction is pp, and each four-momentum integration p4p^4. This is also known as naive dimensional analysis or Weinberg counting.

Since we use the heavy-baryon formalism, we encounter terms which include factors of p/MNp/M_N, where MNM_N denotes the nucleon mass. We count the order of such terms by the rule

p/MN∼(p/Λb)2(5)p/M_N \sim(p/\Lambda_b)^2 \tag*{(5)}

for reasons explained in Ref. [20].

Applying some topological identities, one obtains for the power of a connected irreducible diagram involving AA nucleons [1, 20]

ν=−2+2A−2C+2L+∑iΔi ,(6)\nu= -2 + 2A - 2C + 2L + \sum_i \Delta_i \,, \tag*{(6)}

with

Δi≡di+ni2−2 ,(7)\Delta_i \equiv d_i + \frac{n_i}{2} - 2 \,, \tag*{(7)}

where LL denotes the number of loops in the diagram; did_i is the number of derivatives or pion-mass insertions and nin_i the number of nucleon fields (nucleon legs) involved in vertex ii; the sum runs over all vertexes ii contained in the connected diagram under consideration. Note that Δi≥0\Delta_i \ge0 for all interactions allowed by chiral symmetry.

An important observation from power counting is that the powers are bounded from below and, specifically, ν≥0\nu\ge0. This fact is crucial for the convergence of the low-momentum expansion.

For an irreducible NNNN diagram (A=2A = 2, C=1C = 1), the power formula collapses to the very simple expression

ν=2L+∑iΔi ,(8)\nu= 2L + \sum_i \Delta_i \,, \tag*{(8)}

which is most relevant for our current work.

In summary, the chief point of the chiral perturbation theory (ChPT) expansion of the potential is that, at a given order ν\nu, there exists only a finite number of graphs. This is what makes the theory calculable. The expression (p/Λb)ν+1(p/\Lambda_b)^{\nu+1} provides an estimate of the relative size of the contributions left out and, thus, of the relative uncertainty at order ν\nu. The ability to calculate observables (in principle) to any degree of accuracy gives the theory its predictive power.

ChPT and power counting imply that nuclear forces evolve as a hierarchy controlled by the power ν\nu, see Figure 1 for an overview. In what follows, we will focus on the 2NF.

Figure 1. Hierarchy of nuclear forces in ChPT. Solid lines represent nucleons and dashed lines pions. Small dots, large solid dots, solid squares, and solid diamonds denote vertexes of index Δi=0\Delta_i = 0, 1, 2, and 4, respectively. Q=p/ΛbQ = p/\Lambda_b with pp a momentum or pion mass and Λb\Lambda_b the breakdown scale. Further explanations are given in the text.

NNLON3^{3}LO
c1c_{1}−0.74(2)-0.74(2)−1.07(2)-1.07(2)
c2c_{2}3.20(3)3.20(3)
c3c_{3}−3.61(5)-3.61(5)−5.32(5)-5.32(5)
c4c_{4}2.44(3)2.44(3)3.56(3)3.56(3)
dˉ1+dˉ2\bar{d}_{1}+\bar{d}_{2}1.04(6)1.04(6)
dˉ3\bar{d}_{3}−0.48(2)-0.48(2)
dˉ5\bar{d}_{5}0.14(5)0.14(5)
dˉ14−dˉ15\bar{d}_{14}-\bar{d}_{15}−1.90(6)-1.90(6)

Table 1. The πN\pi N LECs as determined in the Roy-Steiner-equation analysis of πN\pi N scattering conducted in Ref. [28]. The given orders of the chiral expansion refer to the NNNN system. The cic_i and dˉi\bar{d}_i are the LECs of the second and third order πN\pi N Lagrangian [1] and are in units of GeV−1^{-1} and GeV−2^{-2}, respectively. The uncertainties in the last digits are given in parentheses after the values. We use the central values.

The long-range NNNN potential

The long-range part of the NNNN potential is built up from pion exchanges, which are ruled by chiral symmetry. The various pion-exchange contributions are best analyzed by the number of pions being exchanged between the two nucleons:

Vπ=V1π+V2π+V3π+⋯(9)V_{\pi}=V_{1\pi}+V_{2\pi}+V_{3\pi}+\cdots \tag*{(9)}

where the meaning of the subscripts is obvious and the ellipsis represents 4π4\pi and higher pion exchanges. For each of the above terms, we have a low-momentum expansion:

V1π=V1π(0)+V1π(2)+V1π(3)+V1π(4)+⋯(10)V_{1\pi}=V_{1\pi}^{(0)}+V_{1\pi}^{(2)}+V_{1\pi}^{(3)}+V_{1\pi}^{(4)}+\cdots \tag*{(10)}
V2π=V2π(2)+V2π(3)+V2π(4)+⋯(11)V_{2\pi}=V_{2\pi}^{(2)}+V_{2\pi}^{(3)}+V_{2\pi}^{(4)}+\cdots \tag*{(11)}
V3π=V3π(4)+⋯(12)V_{3\pi}=V_{3\pi}^{(4)}+\cdots \tag*{(12)}

where the superscript denotes the order ν\nu of the expansion. Higher order corrections to the one-pion exchange (1PE) are taken care of by mass and coupling constant renormalizations. Note also that, on shell, there are no relativistic corrections. Thus, V1π=V1π(0)V_{1\pi}=V_{1\pi}^{(0)} through all orders. The leading 3π3\pi-exchange contribution that occurs at N3^{3}LO, V3π(4)V_{3\pi}^{(4)}, has been calculated in Refs. [21, 22] and found to be negligible. We, therefore, omit it.

Order by order, the long-range NNNN potential then builds up as follows:

VπLO=V1π(0)(13)V_{\pi}^{\mathrm{LO}}=V_{1\pi}^{(0)} \tag*{(13)}
VπNLO=VπLO+V2π(2)(14)V_{\pi}^{\mathrm{NLO}}=V_{\pi}^{\mathrm{LO}}+V_{2\pi}^{(2)} \tag*{(14)}
VπNNLO=VπNLO+V2π(3)(15)V_{\pi}^{\mathrm{NNLO}}=V_{\pi}^{\mathrm{NLO}}+V_{2\pi}^{(3)} \tag*{(15)}
VπN3LO=VπNNLO+V2π(4)(16)V_{\pi}^{\mathrm{N3LO}}=V_{\pi}^{\mathrm{NNLO}}+V_{2\pi}^{(4)} \tag*{(16)}

We note that we add to VπN3LOV_{\pi}^{\mathrm{N3LO}} the 1/MN1/M_N corrections of the NNLO 2PE proportional to cic_i (cf. Table I). This correction is proportional to ci/MNc_i/M_N (cf. Figure 9 and Appendix A § 8.1, below) and appears nominally at fifth order, but we include it at fourth order. As demonstrated in Ref. [23], the 2PE football diagram proportional to c22c_{2}^{2} that appears at N3^{3}LO (Figure 8(a) and Appendix A § 7.4) is unrealistically attractive, while the ci/MNc_i/M_N correction is large and repulsive. Therefore, it makes sense to group these diagrams together to arrive at a more realistic intermediate-range attraction at N3^{3}LO. This is common practice and has been done so in Refs. [24, 26, 27].

Figure 8. Two-pion exchange contributions at N3LON^{3}\mathrm{LO} with (a) the N3LON^{3}\mathrm{LO} football diagram, (b) the leading 2PE two-loop contributions, and (c) the leading relativistic corrections. Basic notation as in Figure 1. The shaded disc stands for all one-loop πN\pi N graphs as illustrated. Open circles are relativistic 1/MN1/M_{N} corrections.

Relativistic corrections of NNLO diagrams

Figure 9. Relativistic corrections of NNLO diagrams. Notation as in Figure 1. Open circles are relativistic 1/MN1/M_N corrections.

The explicit mathematical expressions for the pion-exchanges up to N3^{3}LO are very involved. We have, therefore, moved them into the Appendix A.

Chiral symmetry establishes a link between the dynamics in the πN\pi N-system and the NNNN-system through common low-energy constants (LECs). Therefore, consistency requires that we use the LECs for subleading πN\pi N-couplings as determined in the analysis of low-energy πN\pi N-scattering. Currently, the most reliable πN\pi N analysis is the one by Hofrichter and Ruiz de Elvira et al. [28], in which the Roy-Steiner equations are applied. These LECs carry very small uncertainties (cf. Table I); in fact, the uncertainties are so small that they are negligible for our purposes.

References

  1. [33]R. B. Wiringa, V. G. J. Stoks, and R. Schiavilla, Phys. Rev. C 51, 38-51 (1995).
  2. [34]G. J. M. Austin and J. J. de Swart, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 2039 (1983).
  3. [35]J. R. Berger­voet, P. C. van Campen, W. A. van der Sanden, and J. J. de Swart, Phys. Rev. C 38, 15 (1988).
  4. [36]U. van Kolck, M. C. M. Rentmeester, J. L. Friar, T. Goldman, and J. J. de Swart, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 4386 (1998).
  5. [37]R. Blankenbecler and R. Sugar, Phys. Rev. 142, 1051 (1966).
  6. [38]M. M. Nagels, Baryon-Baryon Scattering in a One-Boson-Exchange Potential Model, Ph.D. thesis, University of Nijmegen (1975).DOI
  7. [39]H. Shimoyama, Chiral Symmetry and the Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction: Developing a Chiral NN Potential in Configuration Space, Ph.D. thesis, University of Idaho (2005).
  8. [40]P. Herd, Local Nucleon-Nucleon Potentials Based upon Chiral Effective Field Theory, Master of Science Thesis, University of Idaho (2015).
  9. [41]Prog. Theor. Phys. (Kyoto), Suppl. 3 (1956).
  10. [42]T. E. O. Ericson and M. Rosa-Clot, Nucl. Phys. A 405, 497 (1983).
  11. [43]R. Machleidt, Adv. Nucl. Phys. 19, 189 (1989).
  12. [44]R. Machleidt, K. Holinde, and Ch. Elster, Phys. Rep. 149, 1 (1987).
  13. [46]V. G. J. Stoks, R. A. M. Klomp, M. C. M. Rentmeester, and J. J. de Swart, Phys. Rev. C 48, 792 (1993).
  14. [47]D. E. González Trotter et al., Phys. Rev. C 73, 034001 (2006).
  15. [48]Q. Chen et al., Phys. Rev. C 77, 054002 (2008).
  16. [49]R. A. Arndt, W. J. Briscoe, I. I. Strakovsky, and R. L. Workman, Phys. Rev. C 76, 025209 (2007).
  17. [50]W. A. van der Sanden, A. H. Emmen, and J. J. de Swart, Report No. THEF-NYM-83.11, Nijmegen (1983), unpublished; quoted in Ref. [35].
  18. [51]R. C. Malone et al., Measurement of the Neutron-Neutron Quasifree Scattering Cross Section in Neutron-Deuteron Breakup at 10.0 and 15.6 MeV, arXiv:2203.02619 [nucl-ex].
  19. [52]R. Machleidt, Phys. Rev. C 63, 024001 (2001).
  20. [53]V. G. J. Stoks and J. J. de Swart, Phys. Rev. C 42, 1235 (1990).
  21. [54]V. G. J. Stoks (private communication).
  22. [55]V. G. J. Stoks, R. A. M. Klomp, C. P. F. Terhegg en, and J. J. de Swart, Phys. Rev. C 49, 2950-2962 (1994).
  23. [56]P. Reinert, H. Krebs, and E. Epelbaum, Eur. Phys. J. A 54, no.5, 86 (2018).
  24. [57]R. Navarro Pérez, J. E. Amaro, and E. Ruiz Arriola, Phys. Rev. C 88, no.6, 064002 (2013).
  25. [58]S. Klarsfeld, J. Martorell and D. W. L. Sprung, J. Phys. G 10, 165-179 (1984).
  26. [59]J. Mathelitsch and B. J. Verwest, Phys. Rev. C 29, 739-746 (1984).
  27. [60]J. J. de Swart, C. P. F. Terheggen and V. G. J. Stoks, [arXiv:nucl-th/9509032 [nucl-th]].DOI
  28. [61]R. J. Furnstahl, D. R. Phillips, and S. Wesolowski, J. Phys. G 42, 034028 (2015).
  29. [62]R. Navarro Perez, J. E. Amaro, and E. Ruiz Arriola, Phys. Rev. C 89, 064006 (2014).
  30. [63]R. Navarro Perez, E. Garrido, J. E. Amaro, and E. Ruiz Arriola, Phys. Rev. C 90, 047001 (2014).
  31. [64]R. Navarro Perez, J. E. Amaro, E. Ruiz Arriola, P. Maris, and J. P. Vary, Phys. Rev. C 92, 064003 (2015).
  32. [65]E. Marji et al., Phys. Rev. C 88, 054002 (2013).
  33. [66]E. Epelbaum, A. Nogga, W. Gloeckle, H. Kamada, U. G. Meissner, and H. Witala, Phys. Rev. C 66, 064001 (2002).
  34. [67]A. Nogga, P. Navratil, B. R. Barrett, and J. P. Vary, Phys. Rev. C 73 (2006) 064002.
  35. [68]K. Hebeler, S. K. Bogner, R. J. Furnstahl, A. Nogga, and A. Schwenk, Phys. Rev. C 83, 031301(R) (2011).
  36. [69]A. Gärdestig and D. R. Phillips, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 (2006) 232301.
  37. [70]D. Gazit, S. Quaglioni, and P. Navrátil, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103 (2009) 102502.
  38. [71]L. E. Marcucci, A. Kievsky, S. Rosati, R. Schiavilla, and M. Viviani, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 052502 (2012).
  39. [72]P. Navratil, V. G. Gueorguiev, J. P. Vary, W. E. Ormand, and A. Nogga, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99 (2007) 042501.
  40. [73]T. Krüger, I. Tews, K. Hebeler, and A. Schwenk, Phys. Rev. C 88, 025802 (2013).
  41. [74]C. Drischler, K. Hebeler, and A. Schwenk, Phys. Rev. C 93, 054314 (2016).
  42. [75]C. Drischler, A. Carbone, K. Hebeler, and A. Schwenk, Phys. Rev. C 94, 054307 (2016).
  43. [76]A user-friendly FORTRAN code for all NN potentials presented in this paper can be obtained from one of the authors (R.M.) upon request.
  44. [77]N. Kaiser, R. Brockmann, and W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A 625, 758 (1997).
  45. [78]N. Kaiser, Phys. Rev. C 64, 057001 (2001).
  46. [79]D. R. Entem, N. Kaiser, R. Machleidt, and Y. Nosyk, Phys. Rev. C 91, 014002 (2015).
  47. [80]The OBEPR presented in Appendix F of of Ref. [44] is used.

Paper details

vlnc:W_3pqqbeev
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents