betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Systematic Approach for Tuning Flux-driven Josephson Parametric Amplifiers for Stochastic Small Signals

Abstract

Many experiments operating at millikelvin temperatures with signal frequencies in the microwave regime are beginning to incorporate Josephson Parametric Amplifiers (JPA) as their first amplification stage. While there are implementations for a wideband frequency response with a minimal need for tuning, designs using resonant structures with small numbers of Josephson elements still achieve the best noise performance. In a typical measurement scheme involving a JPA, one needs to control the resonance frequency, pump frequency and pump power to achieve the desired amplification and noise properties. In this work, we propose a straightforward approach for operating JPAs with the help of a look-up table (LUT) and online fine-tuning. Using the proposed approach, we demonstrate the operation of a flux-driven JPA with 20 dB gain around 5.9 GHz, covering approximately 100 MHz with 20 kHz tuning steps. The proposed methodology was successfully used in the context of a haloscope axion experiment.

Introduction

Quantum mechanics imposes a minimum uncertainty constraint in all measurement systems. This property manifests itself in the context of microwave detection chains as the quantum limit on added noise and given by TQ=hf2kBT_Q = \frac{h f}{2 k_B} [1]. While there have been demonstrations of techniques evading this limit [2] (e.g. squeezing), they typically require the phase of the expected signal to be known [3]. Therefore, such techniques are not directly applicable to measurements of signals with a stochastic phase component. Experiments looking for signatures from axion-like particles as components for the unknown matter in our galaxy involve such measurements [4, 5, 6, 7].

By convention, the noise characteristics of detection chains are quantified using their so-called noise temperature TnT_n, which is defined using the measured power within a bandwidth BB given as P=G(Psrc+kBBTn)P = G(P_{\mathrm{src}} + k_B B T_n), where GG is the power gain of the whole chain, PsrcP_{\mathrm{src}} is the source signal with its accompanying noise and kBk_B is Boltzmann constant. Currently, the lowest noise temperatures in the microwave regime are achieved using Josephson parametric amplifiers (JPA) as the first stage in the detection chain. Since the noise temperature of a JPA depends on its input noise [8], such systems typically operate in the millikelvin regime to reduce the thermal background. While there are many competing JPA designs, this work focuses on a flux-driven JPA design [9] comprising a λ/4\lambda/4 resonator terminated with a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID). The DC component of the magnetic flux through the SQUID loop controls the resonance frequency (frf_r) while the AC component provides the inductance modulation necessary to achieve parametric amplification. The design incorporates a second transmission line that inductively couples to the SQUID loop. This path, referred to as the pump line, provides the AC component of the magnetic flux. An external coil provides the static magnetic field in the experimental fixture. In order to operate the JPA with the desired amplification and noise properties one needs to tune the coil current (ibi_b), pump frequency (fpf_p), and pump power (PpP_p). This work demonstrates a method for controlling these parameters to achieve the minimum noise temperature for a particular gain requirement. The proposed method is implemented in an experiment searching for a hypothetical particle, the axion, expected to comprise the unknown matter content in the milky way galaxy.

Methodology

When the JPA is operated in the three-wave mixing mode, the relation fp=fs+fif_p=f_s+f_i will be satisfied where fsf_s is the signal frequency and the fif_i is the idler frequency [10]. Throughout this work, the output is always measured at the signal frequency. The JPA gain is a function of frequency typically with a peak occuring at fsc=fp/2f_{sc}=f_p/2. Using GJG_J to denote the peak gain value, the tuning is done by following the steps below:

  1. Tune ibi_b such that frf_r is equal to the desired fscf_{sc}.

  2. Set fpf_p to 2fsc2f_{sc}.

  3. Increase PpP_p until the desired gain is obtained.

  4. Repeat step 2 and 3 for small deviations from frf_r by changing ibi_b.

  5. Pick a set of ibi_b, fpf_p, PpP_p that has the lowest PpP_p for the desired gain at fscf_{sc}.

While the optimization protocol described above is straightforward, it requires fscf_{sc} to be known ahead of time. Since for many experiments fscf_{sc} is decided during the experiment, this is not very practical. In order to avoid spending time on optimization during the experiment, we generate a look-up table (LUT) for JPA state parameters using fscf_{sc} and GJG_J as indexing pairs. Introducing the detuning variable as δ=fp/2−fr\delta=f_p/2-f_r,1 we first do a set of characterization measurements with the following steps:

  1. With the pump off, measure frf_r as a function of ibi_b.

  2. Given the frequency range of interest [fmin⁡,fmax⁡][f_{\min}, f_{\max}], measure GJG_J at ib(fr=fmin⁡)i_b(f_r=f_{\min}) and ib(fr=fmax⁡)i_b(f_r=f_{\max}) as a function of PpP_p and δ\delta. From these measurements, define a rectangular sweeping region for δ\delta and PpP_p where GJ≥0G_J \ge0 dB.

  3. Perform a detailed GJG_J measurement by sweeping δ\delta and PpP_p at a set of ibi_b covering [fmin⁡,fmax⁡][f_{\min}, f_{\max}]. This step yields the complete GJG_J dataset for (ib,fp,Pp)→(fsc,GJ)(i_b,f_p,P_p)\to(f_{sc},G_J).

In order to investigate the noise behavior with respect to ibi_b, fpf_p, PpP_p, and GJG_J we have measured TnT_n as a function of fpf_p and PpP_p for a small set of ibi_b.2 These measurements reveal that for a particular GJG_J, TnT_n is minimized when PpP_p is minimized (see Figure 1). Using this as a constraint we construct the LUT using the following algorithm:

Measurements performed on a test bench setup

Figure 1. Measurements performed on a test bench setup. (a) GJG_J as a function of δ\delta and PpP_p. The overlaid lines correspond to contours calculated from the same data with the upper sections avoided for clarity. (b) TnT_n as a function of δ\delta and PpP_p. The gain contours shown in (a) are overlaid for comparison. It can be seen that noise temperatures along a particular equigain curve are minimal at the lowest PpP_p.

  1. Upsample the GJG_J dataset in δ\delta, PpP_p and ibi_b using linear interpolation.

  1. Using fsc=fp/2f_{sc}=f_p/2, group data points in intervals with lengths fstepf_{step} in the range [fmin⁡,fmax⁡][f_{\min}, f_{\max}].

  1. For each frequency interval, group measurements by their gains with the bin edges given by the set SG={G1,G2,…,GN}S_G=\{G_1,G_2,\ldots,G_N\}.

  1. Construct the LUT by picking the {ib,fp,Pp}\{i_b,f_p,P_p\} with the smallest PpP_p for each gain group within each frequency interval.

  1. If the table is not densely populated enough, repeat from step 1 with higher upsampling factors.

The end product of this process is a LUT providing a mapping of the form (fsc,GJ)→(ib,fp,Pp)(f_{sc},G_J)\rightarrow(i_b,f_p,P_p). With access to this table, an index look-up operation is sufficient to find the noise-optimal operation point for a desired GJG_J. The benefit to this approach, as opposed to selecting the desired working point from the full GJG_J dataset during experiment is the reduced computational complexity.

Application

The described procedure is implemented as part of an axion haloscope in the Center for Axion and Precision Physics Research (CAPP). The haloscope consists of a microwave cavity, an 8 T superconducting magnet surrounding it, and a receiver chain to transfer the signal into the spectrum analyzer. The experiment is housed in a Bluefors LD400 dilution refrigerator with the cavity and the JPA installed at the mixing-chamber (MC) plate. The MC temperature was kept at 40 mK during all of the experiments.

The GJG_J is estimated by measuring s21s_{21} at a single frequency f=fsc+1f=f_{sc}+1 kHz using a vector network analyzer (see Figure 3). First, a baseline measurement (soffs_{\mathrm{off}}) is performed after tuning frf_r away from the frequency region of interest3. Then the JPA is tuned to the desired working point, and a subsequent s-parameter measurement (soffs_{\rm off}) is performed. From these two measurements, the power gain4 is estimated via GJ=10log⁡10∣son/soff∣2G_J = 10\log_{10}\lvert s_{\rm on}/s_{\rm off}\rvert^2. Following the procedure described in the previous section, the swept data set for GJG_J is obtained for frf_r in the range 5.8–5.96 GHz. The LUT is generated using this data set with fstep=10f_{\rm step} = 10 kHz and SG={18,20,22,25}S_G = \{18, 20, 22, 25\}5. The JPA tuning is then performed as part of the haloscope experiment following the steps below at each iteration:

Simplified diagram for an axion haloscope

Figure 3. Simplified diagram for an axion haloscope. The colors are used to highlight several experimentally relevant signal paths. The JPA characterization measurements are performed with the room temperature switch pointing at the path shown in orange.

fscf_{\rm sc} (Hz)GJG_J (dB)ibi_b (μ\muA)fpf_p (GHz)PpP_p (dBm)
⋮\vdots⋮\vdots⋮\vdots⋮\vdots⋮\vdots
(5862243665, 5862253665](18.0, 20.0]-259.65411.724500-5.4
(5862243665, 5862253665](20.0, 22.0]-259.65411.724500-5.2
(5862243665, 5862253665](22.0, 25.0]-259.54811.724492-5.0
(5862253665, 5862263665](18.0, 20.0]-259.57011.724516-5.4
(5862253665, 5862263665](20.0, 22.0]-259.57011.724516-5.2
(5862253665, 5862263665](22.0, 25.0]-259.57011.724516-5.0
(5862263665, 5862273665](18.0, 20.0]-259.59111.724540-5.4
(5862263665, 5862273665](20.0, 22.0]-259.59111.724540-5.2
(5862263665, 5862273665](22.0, 25.0]-259.59111.724540-5.0
(5862273665, 5862283665](18.0, 20.0]-259.61211.724566-5.4
(5862273665, 5862283665](20.0, 22.0]-259.61211.724566-5.2
(5862273665, 5862283665](22.0, 25.0]-259.48511.724559-5.0
(5862283665, 5862293665](18.0, 20.0]-259.50611.724582-5.4
(5862283665, 5862293665](20.0, 22.0]-259.50611.724582-5.2
(5862283665, 5862293665](22.0, 25.0]-259.50611.724582-5.0
(5862293665, 5862303665](18.0, 20.0]-259.63311.724602-5.4
(5862293665, 5862303665](20.0, 22.0]-259.63311.724602-5.2
(5862293665, 5862303665](22.0, 25.0]-259.52711.724606-5.0
⋮\vdots⋮\vdots⋮\vdots⋮\vdots⋮\vdots

Table 1. A small section from a LUT constructed with the method described in this work. The colored rows correspond to points contributed from measurements shown in Figure 2.

Heat maps of $G_J$ as a function of $\delta$ and $P_p$ for three example $i_b$ values

Figure 2. GJG_J as a function of δ=fp/2−fr\delta= f_p/2 - f_r and PpP_p performed at three example ibi_b corresponding to fr=5.862 41f_r = 5.862\,41 GHz (a), fr=5.862 47f_r = 5.862\,47 GHz (b) and fr=5.862 53f_r = 5.862\,53 GHz (c). In a typical dataset there are a total of 341 such measurements. The circles correspond to the points chosen by the algorithm for inclusion in the LUT.

  1. Tune the cavity to target frequency fcavf_{\rm cav}.

  2. Let fscf_{\rm sc} to be fcavf_{\rm cav}.

  3. Search the LUT for an entry corresponding to the chosen fscf_{\rm sc} and GJ=20G_J = 20 dB. If there is an entry, use the corresponding (ib,fp,Pp)(i_b, f_p, P_p) to set the working point. If there is no entry, abort the procedure.

  4. The impedance seen by the JPA will be slightly different depending on the cryogenic switch position. Since the LUT is generated with the switch pointing at the noise source, the GJG_J measured at this step will usually be off by about 1–2 dB. To compensate, fine-tune PpP_p until GJG_J is (20.0±0.4)(20.0 \pm0.4) dB. This will also correct for the small drifts in the pump signal power.

  5. Measure the noise temperature.

  6. Integrate axion-sensitive spectra.

In addition to in-situ measurements, noise temperatures of selected points from the LUT were also measured with the cryogenic switch pointing at the noise source (see Figure 4).

Plot of noise temperature versus operating frequency for cavity and noise source measurements

Figure 4. TnT_n versus operating frequency (fscf_{sc}) for the detection chain in the axion experiment. Blue data points correspond to combined results of in-situ measurements during data taking runs spanning 6 months. The orange data set was measured within a day while the cryogenic switch is pointing at a 50 Ω\Omega resistor at 40 mK (noise source). The major source of difference between the two measurements is related to the non-ideal behavior of circulators leading to complex interactions between the cavity and the JPA. The noise temperature being higher than the quantum limit of 140 mK is attributed to the accumulated loss and reflection effects of the components before the JPA with the approximate contribution of 20 to 26 mK from the later amplification stages.

Conclusion

For a JPA based detection chain, the TnT_n and GJG_J depend on the control parameters in a non-trivial manner. While it is possible to minimize TnT_n at a given GJG_J by adjusting the JPA control parameters during the experiment, this is time-consuming and tedious when the number of working points required is large. In this work, we proposed a look-up table based method for optimizing the noise temperature of a JPA at a given gain and operating frequency. In order to generate a viable LUT, a straightforward characterization protocol for gain measurements was used. The construction of the LUT relies on the knowledge that the TnT_n is minimized with PpP_p which was confirmed by separate measurements. The proposed approach was applied successfully in the context of an axion haloscope experiment around 5.9 GHz. The LUT generation protocol was fully automated with a typical measurement time of about 12 hours for 120 MHz of coverage. The produced LUT is then viable for the whole duration of a cooldown which typically lasted more than a month. During the axion experiment, the JPA center frequency was tuned from 5.83 to 5.94 GHz using 20 kHz steps while maintaining minimal noise temperature. The tuning times were nominally less than 2 s with the limiting factor being the time cost of measurements during online gain correction. Moreover, it was observed that LUTs constructed on separate cooldowns of the cryostat yielded nearly identical results in noise temperature. Currently, this method is employed in all experiments involving a JPA in CAPP.

Acknowledgement

This work is supported in part by the Institute for Basic Science (IBS-R017-D1) and JST ERATO (Grant No. JPMJER1601). Arjan F. van Loo was supported by a JSPS postdoctoral fellowship.

References

  1. [1]C. Caves, Phys. Rev. D 26, 1817 (1982)
  2. [2]L. Zhong, E. Menzer, R. Di Candia, et al., New Journal Of Physics 15, 125013 (2013)
  3. [3]A. Clerk, M. Devoret, S. Girvin, et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 1155 (2010)
  4. [4]B. Brubaker, L. Zhong, Y. Gurevich, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 061302 (2017)
  5. [5]S. Lee, S. Ahn, J. Choi, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 101802 (2020)
  6. [6]J. Jeong, S. Youn, S. Bae, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 221302 (2020)
  7. [7]O. Kwon, D. Lee, W. Chung, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 191802 (2021)
  8. [8]Ç. Kutlu, A. F. van Loo, S. V. Uchaikin, et al., Supercond. Sci. Technol. 34, 085013 (2021).
  9. [9]T. Yamamoto, K. Inomata, M. Watanabe, et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 93, 042510 (2008)
  10. [10]A. Roy, M. Devoret, Comptes Rendus Physique 17, 740 (2016)

Paper details

vlnc:W_3ts5yygg
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents