WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Physics-informed X-ray tomography of magnetization and material parameters
Abstract
Three-dimensional spin textures are stabilized by microscopic interactions within their host materials. X-ray vector tomography can image these nanoscale structures, but weak magnetic contrast and a limited range of viewing angles often leave parts of the magnetization poorly determined. Here we show that a reconstruction constrained by the micromagnetic energy recovers the three-dimensional magnetization from such data and gains sensitivity to the underlying material interactions. Applied to the chiral magnet CoZnMn, the method resolves the three-dimensional helical texture even from a small fraction of the dual-axis projections typically required for a successful tomographic reconstruction, or from a single tilt axis alone. By testing which ratio of exchange to Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction in the reconstruction best reproduces the measured projections, we obtain a value for the sample that differs by about 10 % from the literature value derived from the helical winding period. Taken together, our findings suggest a way to reduce the time needed for vector tomography and to extend it to determining fundamental magnetic interactions in a material.
Magnetic materials support a rich family of three-dimensional textures, including skyrmion strings [1, 2], hopfions [3], and vortex rings [4]. These textures carry a nontrivial topology that governs how they form, move, and interact, which makes them candidates for three-dimensional spintronic devices [5, 6]. To understand the three-dimensional structure and behavior of these textures, we must image the full magnetization vector field. X-ray magnetic vector tomography provides this capability by reconstructing the vector field from projections recorded with X-ray magnetic circular dichroism (XMCD) contrast [7] about two rotation axes [8, 9, 10]. X-ray vector imaging has since been extended to laminography [11], and electron magnetic tomography has been used to reconstruct magnetic vector fields from holographic [12] or Lorentz [13] images. However, textures that vary across the depth as well as in the plane require samples several hundred nanometers or even micrometers thick. To study these systems, high-resolution imaging has been made possible with the use of hard X-rays [8] and pre-edge phase contrast with coherent soft X-ray techniques [14]. However, weak magnetic scattering can result in noisy dichroic projections. This, combined with practical constraints on accessible measurement angles, radiation dose, and available synchrotron beamtime, can result in nanoscale features in the magnetization vector field being poorly constrained [15].
To prevent noise from distorting the reconstruction, we can spatially smooth it by penalizing sharp changes in the magnetization [16, 17]. Mathematically, this gradient penalty has the same form as the exchange interaction (stiffness ) that aligns neighboring moments in micromagnetic theory [18, 19], giving the smoothing a direct physical basis. However, because the experimental resolution often approaches the scale of the magnetic features, this smoothing alone blurs the domain walls and helical winding we may want to image. In micromagnetic theory, stable states are local minima of the full energy functional, of which exchange is only one term. In a real magnet, these features persist because exchange competes with the demagnetizing interaction (scaled by the saturation magnetization ), which favors flux closure, and in chiral magnets also with the Dzyaloshinskii–Moriya interaction (constant ), which twists neighboring moments. Previous studies have applied the micromagnetic model only after the reconstruction, adjusting simulations by hand to reproduce the imaged texture [2, 12, 20]. This manual tuning is time-consuming and cannot restore features that the reconstruction has already lost or distorted.
Here, we present an approach that avoids this loss of information by constraining the reconstruction itself with the micromagnetic energy, similar to our approach when recovering the magnetization of a thin film from stray-field magnetometry [21]. We extend X-ray magnetic vector tomography with the complete micromagnetic energy functional of the sample and demonstrate its two roles on a thick disk of the room-temperature chiral magnet [22], imaged with dichroic soft X-ray ptychography. First, the energy encodes our prior knowledge of the interactions in the material and helps us recover the magnetization vector field where a limited number of noisy projections alone is not enough. Second, because the reconstruction explicitly incorporates these competing interactions, it allows us to test the assumed model itself. Since material parameters are usually only determined for the bulk and do not always translate to a nanostructure, we identify the relevant parameters of the sample that best reproduce the measured projections. This prospect of texture-driven magnetometry on individual nanostructures is relevant for a wide variety of magnetic material systems.
Physics-informed reconstruction from XMCD projections
In magnetic tomography, XMCD imaging records two projections at every sample orientation, with opposite circular X-ray polarization , giving a transmission image pair and [8, 23]. At the X-ray absorption edges of nickel, the XMCD effect provides contrast that is sensitive to the local magnetization component along the beam propagation direction [7] and reverses sign between and . We sum and to yield a purely electronic channel and subtract them to yield a magnetic (XMCD) channel (Figure 1b and Methods). Because XMCD contrast is proportional to the magnetization component parallel to the beam propagation direction, each measured projection records the line integral of that component along the beam [8]. In our geometry, the beam stays along while the stage rotates the sample by (Figure 1a), so in the sample frame the beam direction is [9]. The forward model simulates the measurement of a given magnetization configuration: for normalized magnetization , it computes the simulated projection , the counterpart of the measured , via the discrete Radon transform , the operator that takes these line integrals [24]:

Figure 1. Physics-informed magnetization reconstruction from XMCD tomography. a, Dual-axis tomography. Circularly polarized X-rays transmit through the sample, which we rotate about by ( series) and about by ( series). b, X-ray imaging. At every tilt we record transmission images at both circular polarizations . The pair separates into the magnetic XMCD channel and the non-magnetic electronic channel [Eq. (5)]. c, The measured projections feed into the physics-informed reconstruction, which minimizes the joint objective [Eqs. (2) and (4)], shown at . Gradient-based optimization returns the reconstruction , shown by its components (). Scale bars, 200 nm.
Unlike the scalar density imaged in conventional tomography, the magnetization is a vector field probed only along the beam, so rotating the sample changes not only the viewing angle but also which component is sensed. To reconstruct all three vector components, the acquisition therefore needs to combine two orthogonal tilt series (Figure 1a) or to use a laminography geometry [11]. Tilting about confines the beam to the plane, so this series (the series) is sensitive to and but never to . Tilting about confines the beam to the plane, so the series is sensitive to and but never to .
Recovering the three-dimensional magnetization configuration requires finding a vector field whose forward projections reproduce the measured data (Figure 1c). Even a complete dual-axis acquisition does not uniquely determine the magnetization: line integrals of determine at most the divergence-free part of the magnetization [25, 26], since any internal gradient field that vanishes at the sample boundary integrates to zero along every beam path [9]. In physical terms, the magnetic volume and surface charges of the sample cannot be fully recovered without additional constraints. In practice, depending on the sample geometry and the setup, projections cannot always be recorded over the complete angular range, leaving a so-called missing wedge of unrecorded viewing directions in tomography and a missing cone in laminography [27]. Moreover, weak XMCD signals make the projections particularly susceptible to noise and imaging artifacts across the angular range.
Despite these challenges, iterative magnetic vector tomography [8, 9] has recovered three-dimensional magnetic textures by minimizing the data misfit between simulated and measured projections. However, without further constraints, these limitations can leave nanoscale features poorly resolved and introduce artifacts into the reconstruction. We therefore add the micromagnetic energy of the material to this data misfit and minimize the combined objective function ,
where the data misfit , a normalized form of the error metric of magnetic vector tomography [9], measures how closely the simulated projections reproduce the measured projections ,
The energy weight balances this data misfit against the micromagnetic energy.
The micromagnetic energy enters Eq. (2) as the physics prior. This penalty increases with the energy of the magnetization state, driving the reconstruction toward physically plausible configurations. It sums the exchange, demagnetizing, and bulk Dzyaloshinskii–Moriya (DMI) energies,
parameterized by the exchange stiffness , saturation magnetization , and DMI constant Eq. (8), Methods. The micromagnetic energy is only meaningful inside the material, where the magnetization has unit length (), whereas the surrounding vacuum carries no magnetization at all. We therefore define a disk mask that marks which cells of the reconstruction volume belong to the sample, and restrict both the forward model and the energy computation to these cells. Previous studies defined such a mask from a scalar tomogram of the non-magnetic electronic channel [8]. For our flat disk, however, the missing wedge elongates this tomogram along (Methods). We instead take the disk outline from the electronic channel of the face-on projection and extend it through the fabricated 300 nm thickness. We minimize using gradient-based optimization, with automatic differentiation supplying the gradients [28].
Reconstructing the magnetic state
To demonstrate our physics-informed reconstruction, we apply it to tomographic data measured on a 1.1 m-diameter, 300 nm-thick CoZnMn disk to recover its three-dimensional magnetization configuration. CoZnMn belongs to the Co–Zn–Mn family of room-temperature helical magnets [22], which host skyrmions [22], Bloch points [20], and hopfions [29]. We image the disk in the remanent state, where it hosts a helical configuration. The XMCD phase projections were measured 3 eV below the Co absorption edge (778.1 eV) using dichroic soft X-ray ptychography, a coherent diffractive imaging method that recovers the phase shift of the transmitted X-rays. At this pre-edge energy, the X-rays are only weakly attenuated while the magnetic phase contrast persists, which allows imaging of samples up to an order of magnitude thicker than at the absorption edge [14]. The two tilt series cover (29 projections, series) and (38 projections, series) and a pixel size of about 10 nm. To reconstruct the magnetization with Eq. (2), we choose the energy weight and specify the material parameters. We use the literature values of and [20] and , the DMI constant that best reproduces the measured projections (Sec. IV, Extended Data Table I).
We first examine how the energy weight influences the reconstructed state by sweeping across several orders of magnitude and plotting the micromagnetic energy against the data misfit in an L-curve (Figure 2a), similar to how regularization weights are determined in inverse problems [30, 31]. At , the physics prior is too weak to constrain the reconstruction, which is nearly identical to an unconstrained one (, Extended Data Figure 1) and shows a limitation common to magnetic vector tomography: because the X-ray beam stays close to over the restricted tilt range, the measurement strongly constrains the out-of-plane stripes in , whereas the weakly probed in-plane components and remain much noisier and less resolved (Figure 2b, top row). At , the energy term pulls the reconstruction toward a low-energy state at the expense of data agreement: the stripes differ from both the reconstruction and the measured projections (Figure 2b, bottom row). To select the balanced weight , we increase up to the bend of the L-curve (), just before the reconstruction begins to clearly deviate from the measurements ( versus ). At this weight, keeps the stripe pattern of the reconstruction and of the measured projections (Extended Data Figure 2), and and form a coherent three-dimensional helical texture (Figure 2b, middle row).
Figure 2. Influence of the energy weight on the reconstruction. a, L-curve of micromagnetic energy versus data misfit as is swept, marking three reconstructions with increasing weight: a low weight (), the balanced weight (), and a high readout weight (, Sec. IV). b, Reconstructed magnetization components , , and at these three operating points. Scale bar, 200 nm.
Extended Data Figure 1. Synthetic validation of both operating regimes. Synthetic projections are generated from a known magnetization state with noise and reconstructed with the experimental protocol (Methods, ’Synthetic validation’). a, The reconstruction of the measured disk without the energy term (, top) and the ground truth relaxed from it (bottom), components , , in the disk plane. b, Input XMCD projections, noiseless (top) and with noise (bottom), for three views: the series at its largest tilt, normal incidence, and the series at its largest tilt. c, The reconstructions of the four acquisitions of Figure 3 at , laid out as Figure 3b. Each row label gives the relative error to the truth. d, L-curve of the full acquisition, micromagnetic energy versus data misfit for from to , with and indicated. e, of the full acquisition versus , with , and the value at indicated. f, Reconstructions with , , or set to a wrong value, in the balanced regime (, left) and the readout regime (, right, on the refined grid of Figure 4a). The top row shows and the bottom row the data misfit . Scale bars, 200 nm.
Extended Data Figure 2. Measured, modeled and residual projections. Measured XMCD projections (top row of each block), the projections of the reconstruction at (middle) and the residual (bottom), for the series (upper block) and the series (lower block), on one gray scale. Each block shows five single frames spread evenly over the tilt range in which the stripes are resolved: normal incidence, the ends of that range, and the frames halfway to either end. Numbers in the residual panels give the frame-wise relative residual , whose root-mean-square over all frames is (Eq. (3)). Scale bar, 200 nm.
However, the true magnetization of the measured disk is unknown, and the data misfit alone cannot show whether the reconstructed and are correct. We therefore test the method on a synthetic disk whose magnetization we know [9]. To obtain a realistic , we start from the unconstrained reconstruction () of the measured disk and relax it into an energy minimum with the Landau–Lifshitz–Gilbert equation [32, 33] in NeuralMag [28] (Extended Data Figure 1). We then simulate the experiment on this disk: we compute its projections at the measured tilt angles, add noise matched to the measurement, and reconstruct the magnetization from these synthetic projections with the same physics-informed protocol. Comparing the reconstruction with the known gives the relative error . Without the physics prior (), the reconstruction recovers the stripes but fails to resolve the in-plane components, resulting in a large overall error of (Extended Data Figure 1,Extended Data Figure 1). Including the physics prior at the balanced weight accurately recovers all three components and reduces the error to .
Finally, because the material parameters supplied to the physics-based reconstruction are often only approximately known in experiment, we use the synthetic disk to test how sensitive the reconstructed state is to parameter mismatch. When we reconstruct the full dataset at while offsetting the input or by , the error increases from to at most , whereas offsetting by and yields and
caption: Reconstructions from sparse and single-axis projection data. One row per acquisition condition: the full dual-axis measurement combining both tilt series (67 projections), a sparse dual-axis acquisition retaining only every eighth projection of each series (9), and the two single-axis acquisitions, series alone (29) and series alone (38). a, Acquisition in the geometry of Figure 1a: the beam directions swept by the series (blue) and by the series (orange), or the nine retained beam directions. b, Disk-plane , , cross sections, all reconstructed with the physics prior at . Red frames mark the component that the single series does not measure: for the series and for the series. Scale bar, 200 nm.
0.23, respectively (Extended Data Figure 1). The error rises most when is underestimated, because a weaker exchange stiffness smooths the measurement noise less. Apart from this case, parameter offsets of leave the reconstructed state largely unchanged, so normal uncertainty in the material parameters of the sample is tolerable.
Reconstruction from sparse and single-axis data
Time-resolved and field-dependent studies require a complete dual-axis tilt series for every time step or field value. Tomograms at successive time steps have been recorded [11], but faster acquisitions would allow for better temporal resolution and a wider range of phenomena and experimental parameters to be explored. To maximize the efficiency of these measurements, we test whether the physics prior can recover the magnetization from reduced projection data, either by sparse angular sampling or by omitting an entire tilt series. We reconstruct the disk under four acquisition conditions (Figure 3): the full dual-axis measurement, a sparse dataset with only every eighth projection of each tilt series (9 projections), and either tilt series alone ( series or series). All four use , ten times the balanced weight , to compensate for the reduced number of projections. Both the sparse and the single-axis reconstructions reproduce the chiral stripe pattern of the full dataset (Figure 3b). A single tilt series rotates the sample about one axis, so the magnetization component along that axis never aligns with the beam and goes unmeasured (§ 0.1). The physics prior fills it in: the micromagnetic energy couples the unmeasured component to the two measured ones, so all three come out consistent (red-framed panels in Figure 3b). The two single-axis reconstructions differ mainly at the edge of the sample, where the disk mask fits worst, and noise differences between the two series slightly change the stripe pattern (Extended Data Figure 2).
Figure 3. Sensitivity of the selection to the energy weight and the magnetization scale . Data misfit versus , as in the selection of Figure 4. a, Curves for a sweep of at the default , colored by . The dotted line marks the literature . At small the data term predominately shapes and no dip forms. The dip sharpens through the intermediate regime and freezes past the knee (), where settles into the energy minimum nearest to the data and the curves for the highest decades coincide. The selection weight lies in this regime. There the minimum stays at on the grid of this sweep, the value read off the refined grid of Figure 4a. b, The same curves at for between and , with dotted as in a. A larger deepens the dip and a smaller flattens it. The minimum stays at for every .
However, agreement between the reduced and full reconstructions of the measured disk does not show that the unmeasured component is correct. We therefore repeat the four acquisitions on the synthetic disk, whose magnetization is known. At the weight of Figure 3 (), the reconstruction recovers the three-dimensional helical winding in all three components for every acquisition, with between 0.08 and 0.16 (Extended Data Figure 1), compared with 0.74 for the complete dataset without the physics prior. Consequently, a small fraction of the projections, or a single tilt series alone, suffices to recover the three-dimensional texture, so that vector tomography experiments become faster and can cover more experimental conditions.
Reading material parameters from the data misfit
The magnetic texture of the disk forms through the competition between the micromagnetic interactions, so the measured texture should contain information about the material parameters. Here, we explore whether the tomographic reconstruction itself can determine the material parameters of the sample. However, varying the assumed parameters has little effect at the balanced weight , where the reconstruction is primarily guided by the measurement data (Sec. II). To increase the sensitivity of the reconstruction to the material parameters, we instead raise to a high weight ( in Figure 2b). In this regime, the physics prior dominates the objective function, forcing toward a low-energy state dictated by the assumed parameters. If those parameters differ from the sample’s true constants, the resulting texture does not match the measured projections and the data misfit rises. Consequently, we can find the best-matching parameters by reconstructing across candidate values at and looking for the minimum in .
We first vary one parameter at a time around the literature values , , and [20], performing a separate tomographic reconstruction of the disk at for each value (Figure 4a). Across a range in , changes by less than 1%, showing that the data misfit is relatively insensitive to the saturation magnetization. In contrast, and form two wells of equal depth with minima at and . Because a 9% decrease in and a 10% increase in change the ratio by the same factor, these mirrored minima indicate that we are only sensitive to the ratio of . To test this across
Figure 4. Sensitivity of the data misfit to the material parameters. a, Data misfit at when one parameter is varied, with the other two fixed at the literature values , , [20]. The misfit stays flat in , whereas and trace two wells with minima on either side of the literature point, 9% below and 10% above (dotted lines, the vertices of the dashed parabolas). b, Data misfit over a grid in and (deviation from , ) at . The misfit is low along a valley of constant . The white line is the fitted trough of that valley, the red and blue lines are the and cuts of a. c, Depth-averaged of the four reconstructions, with and labeled relative to , . Along the valley: the minimum of the cut (orange) and the on-valley cell farthest from it (brown). Across the valley: the low-energy states at on the grid edges, with and (cyan and pink). Markers of the same colors mark these reconstructions in b, and those at in a. Black marks the literature values. d, Mean of the four measured XMCD projections within of normal incidence ( and ), for comparison with the textures in c. Scale bars, 200 nm.
both parameters simultaneously, we reconstruct the disk over a two-dimensional grid (Figure 4b). The misfit forms a continuous valley along a line of constant , confirming that the tomographic data fix only the relative strength of exchange and DMI. The constant-ratio valley reflects the competing roles of exchange and DMI in the micromagnetic energy, where sets the equilibrium winding period of the helix (given by the pitch in an unbounded crystal) [34]. Along the valley floor, parameter pairs with widely different absolute values therefore converge to nearly identical stripe textures with the same period (Figure 4c, orange and brown). In contrast, when we step off the valley by changing by at fixed , the stripe period shifts noticeably: (cyan) widens the stripes, whereas (pink) tightens the winding. Only parameter pairs along the valley floor reproduce the stripe period seen in the measured face-on projections (Figure 4d).
With fixed at , the minimum at gives (Figure 4a). This well is shallow: rises by less than 1% within of the optimum. Even so, its minimum stays at the same for every energy weight from to (Extended Data Fig. 3a). Only at lower weights does the well flatten and shift toward smaller , before disappearing near the balanced weight .
Our readout lies 10% above the literature value , although our disk winds with the same 120 nm period (Figure 4d) as the nanowire from which was derived [20]. The literature value follows from inserting this period into the bulk relation , which describes a helix in an unbounded crystal, whereas our readout models the full micromagnetic energy of the confined disk. We test this difference with the synthetic disk, whose is known: relaxed at and (Methods), it forms stripes with a 122 nm period, longer than the 109 nm that the bulk relation predicts. Applied to this period, the bulk relation underestimates by about 10%, as in the measured disk. Our readout, in contrast, returns the used to relax the synthetic disk from its simulated projections (Extended Data Figure 1).
Even at the optimal , the high-weight reconstruction () has a larger data misfit than the balanced reconstruction ( versus 0.83, Figure 2a). In a real sample, however, pinning sites, local defects, or focused-ion-beam damage can distort the texture in ways that our energy model does not capture, increasing the data misfit at . In our disk these local distortions are small enough that the overall texture still lies close to a minimum of Eq. (4), allowing a clear dip in . If strong pinning instead traps a sample in a metastable state that Eq. (4) cannot reproduce, the high-weight reconstruction converges to a state far from the measured texture for every parameter set, leaving uniformly high and preventing a readout.
Conclusions
We have presented an approach to imaging nanoscale magnetic textures that incorporates the micromagnetic energy into the objective function, with a single weight selecting between two operating regimes of the same reconstruction. In the balanced regime the prior helps recover the texture from noisy, incomplete measurements, and the result tolerates the typical uncertainty of the assumed material parameters. A larger weight on the micromagnetic energy switches to the second regime, in
which the data misfit can be used to read out the parameters that shape the texture. Moreover, a parameter’s impact on the reconstruction matches its sensitivity in the readout: parameters that barely affect the texture cannot be extracted, but they also barely change the reconstructed state, whereas parameters that strongly shape the texture can be determined directly from the misfit. In the helimagnetic CoZnMn disk, the reconstruction is relatively insensitive to , whereas the ratio sets the period of the helical winding. At the literature exchange stiffness , the readout returns , 10% above , although the disk winds with the 120 nm period from which was derived. The bulk relation behind describes an unbounded crystal and underestimates in the confined disk. The ratio therefore has to be measured in the nanostructure itself.
The sparse-data recovery and the parameter readout together suggest a strategy for experimental design. Dense dual-axis tilt series, typically required for high-resolution three-dimensional imaging, take a significant amount of beamtime in vector tomography. With the physics prior, far fewer projections are required, and even a single tilt axis can provide a robust reconstruction. Every projection a reconstruction can spare buys beamtime for additional specimens, magnetic fields, or time points within one allocation, and thus for more complex experiments such as in situ studies. A single well-sampled measurement of a prepared reference state, such as a helical texture whose period pins the constants, could then validate the energy model and fix the material parameters, while subsequent conditions are imaged with sparse acquisitions.
We demonstrate this physics-informed approach with XMCD tomography, but automatic differentiation in micromagnetic software [28, 35] allows the physics prior to be paired with any differentiable forward model and extended with further interactions of the host material. The same approach can therefore be extended to other magnetic imaging modalities, including electron holographic and Lorentz tomography [12, 13] and laminography [11].
Methods
Data acquisition and preprocessing
a. Sample. The CoZnMn disk of Extended Data Table I sits on a focused-ion-beam support wedge. The disk was cut from a single crystal grown at the University of Warwick by the Bridgman method [14]. The table gives its acquisition and discretization. The material parameters , , and are those of Ref. [20] for the same compound: from demagnetization data, and with chosen there to reproduce the helical period imaged in a 200 nm thick nanowire. b. X-ray data acquisition. We acquired the projections at room temperature using dichroic soft X-ray ptychography [8, 23] on the I08-1 ptychography end station of Diamond Light Source under proposal MG37535-2. An APPLE-II undulator produced circularly polarized X-rays of either helicity, set by its gap and phase, and the Au 600 lines/mm grating of the SX-700 plane-grating monochromator [36] tuned them 3 eV below the Co L edge (778.1 eV). A 10 µm pinhole defined the secondary source, and a Fresnel zone plate with a diameter of 333 µm, an outermost zone width of 70 nm, and a mean focal length of 14.156 mm between 770 and 807 eV focused the beam. The sample sat on an L-bracket on an SR-5714C rotation stage (SmarAct GmbH), about 50 µm downstream of the focus, and we scanned it through the beam along a spiral path to avoid grid artifacts. An in-vacuum Axis-SXRF-2020EUV sCMOS detector (Axis Photonique Inc.) recorded the diffraction patterns. We measured the two polarizations separately as and , each yielding a series of diffraction patterns. At the absorption peak, resonant attenuation would block transmission through the disk, whereas at this pre-edge energy the transmission remains high while the magnetic phase contrast persists [14]. We reconstructed the complex-valued object projections (amplitude and phase contrast images) and the probe with PtyPy [37] after cropping the diffraction patterns to 1024 × 1024 pixels and binning them to 512 × 512 pixels, running 1000 iterations of the relaxed averaged alternating reflections (RAAR) engine, 200 iterations of maximum-likelihood refinement, and another 500 RAAR iterations.
c. Preprocessing. Each complex projection carries an absorptive channel (the log amplitude) and a dispersive channel (the phase). In either channel, we combine the projections of the two polarizations to isolate the electronic term and the XMCD term ,
Both encode the same projected moment, but at the pre-edge energy the phase XMCD has the higher signal-to-noise ratio, and therefore is selected as the reconstruction input. Starting from a coarse pre-alignment of the projections, we fit an ellipse to the projected disk outline in every frame and shift its center onto the rotation axis [38], register the exposures of each angle (both polarizations and any repeats) against each other on the electronic channel before averaging them, and apply the composed shift in a single cubic interpolation per exposure. We then remove the phase ramp of every projection by fitting a plane to the phase over the air region, detected by an Otsu threshold [39] on the transmission amplitude, and subtracting it. For the electronic channel, we subtract from its median outside the disk support in every frame, which normalizes the transmitted amplitude to the background.
d. Tilt geometry. The stage angles enter the forward model through one rotation per series about its axis. We calibrate the zero point of each series from the same disk outlines. The disk outline is a circle when the disk faces the beam and an ellipse that narrows as the disk tilts away. We fit the aspect ratio of this ellipse in all frames of a series at once with , where is the stage angle recorded with each frame in the raw data. The fit has three free parameters: the zero point , a scale , and , which accounts for the blurred, partly absorbing rim. We apply rounded to the nearest degree, the precision of the stage labels (Extended Data Table I).
Magnetic reconstruction framework
e. Loss functional. Both the physics prior and the Tikhonov reconstruction minimize a squared data misfit plus one regularizer with weight ,
In the data term of Eq. (3), is the forward model of Eq. (7), the measured XMCD projection, and the norms run over the projection pixels of projection . Each residual is normalized by that projection’s own measurement power, so every view carries equal weight. The residual is always evaluated on the full projection frame: the disk mask acts on the magnetization field, never on the data residual.
f. Forward model. The Tikhonov reconstructions use an isotropic 120 × 120 × 120 tomography grid with a cell spacing of ≈ 9.96 nm (one cell per projection pixel across the central projection window). The physics reconstructions instead run on a box that just encloses the disk (Extended Data Table I). In the lab frame the beam runs along , the projection pixel spans the transverse plane, and the stage rotation carries a sample point to the lab position (Figure 1a). Equation (1) written out with the magnetization scale and the disk mask gives the value of the projection at projection pixel as the line integral along the beam,
where the sample-frame field is evaluated at the sample point the rotation carries to , and is the amplitude the projector sees at every cell inside the mask: under the unit-norm constraint the projected magnetization has everywhere in the material. It collects , the magnetic scattering factor, the atomic density and the cell size into one constant [8], which we read from the Tikhonov reconstructions (‘Magnetization-scale calibration’ below). We evaluate this integral on the cell grid with the differentiable projector of SCICO [24].
g. Tikhonov regularization. The Tikhonov reconstruction treats as an unconstrained Cartesian vector field inside the disk mask , without a magnetization norm constraint: it replaces by in the forward model, so cells outside the mask carry no magnetization and the penalty of Eq. (6) sums over the disk. We minimize the resulting objective with the L-BFGS implementation in JAXopt [40], relying on its zoom line search to set the step size. On the measured data we use (Extended Data Figure 4). An unmasked variant reconstructs the field freely on the full box.
Extended Data Figure 4. Tikhonov reconstructions and the magnetization scale . a, L-curve of the Tikhonov sweep, solution norm versus the data misfit , for the unmasked field on the full box and for the mask-confined field, with marked. b, The learned magnetization scale (interior median ) versus for the same two sweeps, marked as in a. changes monotonically with . The fixed of the physics reconstructions (dashed line, Methods, ’Magnetic reconstruction framework’) is the mask-confined value at . c, The unmasked reconstruction at , components , , in the disk plane (, left) and a side view (, right), shown in full with the mask boundary drawn gray dashed. The field smears across the full depth and leaks outside the mask. d, The mask-confined reconstruction at , in the same layout. The masked volume carries the same in-plane stripe pattern at higher contrast, and the amplitude rises from (unmasked) to . Each reconstruction is shown on one color scale, set by its 99.5th percentile over all components. Scale bars, 200 nm.
h. Micromagnetic energy regularization. The physics reconstruction sets and , the plain micromagnetic energy of Eq. (4) in joules, so carries the inverse units of energy. The unit-norm constraint needs the mask to separate material from vacuum and the scale of Eq. (7) to match the measured amplitude (Extended Data Table I gives the bounding box). With exchange stiffness , saturation magnetization , demagnetizing field , and bulk Dzyaloshinskii–Moriya constant , its terms take their standard form [19],
We compute the energy with NeuralMag [28] on its JAX backend. It evaluates the local terms by finite differences and the demagnetizing field by FFT convolution.
The energy must be evaluated on a grid that resolves the characteristic length scales of the material, the exchange length and the DMI length . The tomography cell of , the projection pixel, bounds the spatial resolution and samples the helical period with cells, but it sits above , so we refine it by a factor of two and evaluate the energy on the resulting physics grid ( cells per period), below both micromagnetic length scales. We reconstruct the magnetization on this finer grid and block-average it onto the tomography grid before projection.
i. Optimization details. Riemannian Adam [41], the manifold generalization of Adam [42], keeps exactly at every step (custom JAX implementation). We run at a constant learning rate of with the standard coefficients (, , ) for 300 to 400 iterations from a cold start at . The zero vector lies outside the unit sphere, so the first step is a Euclidean gradient step whose normalization places every cell on the sphere, and all later steps are Riemannian. Each physics reconstruction fits on one MIG slice of an NVIDIA RTX PRO 6000 Blackwell GPU in single precision. The energy, the projector, and the optimizer update fuse into one kernel under just-in-time compilation [43], which costs about once per configuration. On the full GPU, a compiled 400-iteration reconstruction then takes , and enters the kernel as a runtime argument, so the nine-point L-curve sweep ( to in decade steps) reuses one compilation and completes in about three minutes.
j. Disk mask. We obtain the in-plane disk outline by Otsu thresholding [39] the electronic channel of the zero-tilt projection (Figure 1b). The outline includes the short neck that joins the disk to the support wedge, so the reconstructed texture continues into it. We set the mask to this uniform outline across 30 cells in the -direction, matching the fabricated 300 nm sample thickness (Extended Data Table I). A separate scalar tomography of the electronic channel confirms this mask (Extended Data Figure 5).
Extended Data Figure 5. Validation of the disk mask through total-variation (TV) tomography of the electronic channel. a, L-curve: total variation versus the electronic-channel data misfit as the TV weight is swept. The misfit is flat up to the operating point (red) and rises beyond it, where the reconstruction over-smooths. b, The disk mask used in all magnetic reconstructions, shown in three dimensions with the three slice planes of c: the disk plane () at mid-slab and the two side views (, ) through the disk center. c, Reconstructed density at , 1 (operating point), and 100, shown in the disk plane (, top row) and the two side views (, ). At the density is streaky, and at it is over-smoothed. The density extends beyond the slab in because of the missing wedge, more so at larger . Scale bar, 200 nm.
k. Electronic-channel tomography. We validate the disk mask with a scalar tomography of the electronic channel of Eq. (5), taken from the log amplitude. We reconstruct a non-negative density on a free box of the tomography grid, without the mask, by minimizing
where the squared misfit averages the relative residual over all projections ,
the electronic-channel counterpart of Eq. (3). Here is the scalar line integral of Eq. (7) along the beam of projection , and is the anisotropic total variation, the absolute differences between neighboring cells averaged over the cells of the box. Total variation favors piecewise-constant densities with sharp edges, the form of a uniform disk in air. We enforce through and run 300 L-BFGS iterations from a uniform start for each from to in decade steps. The root is the misfit axis of the L-curve (Extended Data Figure 5).
l. Magnetization-scale calibration. The magnetization scale of Eq. (7) matches the unit-norm magnetization to the measured XMCD amplitude [8]. We read it from the Tikhonov reconstructions, whose free amplitude defines a learned scale as the interior median . At , the mask-confined Tikhonov reconstruction and its unmasked variant give and . All physics reconstructions use , the mask-confined value (Extended Data Figure 4).
Synthetic validation
m. Ground truth generation. The synthetic ground truth is a disk of the measured sample’s dimensions (diameter , thickness ) initialized from the measurement itself: we take the reconstruction of the full measurement without the energy term (), a unit field on the physics grid (Extended Data Fig. 1a). We relax this state with the Landau–Lifshitz–Gilbert equation [32, 33] in NeuralMag [28] to equilibrium at the Extended Data Table I parameters with , and block-average it onto the tomography grid. The relaxation turns the noisy seed into a smooth labyrinth of stripes that follows the arrangement of the measured texture (Extended Data Fig. 1a).
n. Measurement simulation. We project this state with the forward model of Eq. (7), the operator the reconstruction inverts, at the calibrated stage angles of the measurement and at the magnetization scale of the reconstructions, so the measured noise amplitude carries over directly. The noise is a stationary Gaussian field with the radially averaged power spectrum of air-only patches of the measured XMCD channel, scaled to the median standard deviation of the measured air pixels, and added with opposite sign to the two polarizations.
o. Evaluation. We reconstruct the synthetic projections using the same solver settings and disk mask as the experimental data. Fidelity is quantified by the relative reconstruction error , evaluated inside the disk mask.
Use of large language models
We used the large language model tools Claude (Anthropic) and Antigravity (Google) to assist with writing the analysis and reconstruction code, with the data analysis, and with drafting and editing the manuscript text. The authors reviewed, tested, and revised all output and take full responsibility for the code, the results, and the content of this article.
Data and code availability
The measured XMCD projections, the preprocessed solver inputs, the synthetic ground truth, and every reconstruction shown in the main text and the Extended Data will be archived at Zenodo upon journal publication. The preprocessing and reconstruction code (the xmcdrecon package, JAX and NeuralMag), with the recipes and commands behind every measured-data reconstruction of this work, will be released on GitHub and archived at Zenodo upon journal publication.
Acknowledgments
We acknowledge Diamond Light Source for time on instrument I08-1 under proposal MG37535-2. This research was funded in whole or in part by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) 10.55776/PIN1629824 and 10.55776/P34671. P.M., R.Y., M.R.F., and C.D. acknowledge funding from the Max Planck Society Lise Meitner Excellence Program and funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the ERC Starting Grant 3DNANOQUANT 101116043. A.F.-P. acknowledges support by the European Community under the Horizon 2020 Program, Contract No. 101001290 (3DNANO¬MAG). The crystal growth at Warwick was supported by two Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council grants: EP/Z535874/1, “Single Crystal Growth at Warwick”, and EP/Z534067/1, “Controlling the Formation and Properties of Topological Magnetic Phenomena”. For the purpose of open access, the authors have applied a CC BY public copyright license to any Author Accepted Manuscript version arising from this submission.
Author contributions
A.S. developed the physics-informed reconstruction framework, carried out the reconstructions and the analysis, and wrote the manuscript. P.M. prepared the samples, performed the X-ray ptychographic tomography measurements, the ptychographic reconstruction and coarse alignment of the projections, and contributed to the magnetic reconstructions and the analysis. L.J.R.H. and B.K. set up and operated beamline I08-1 and supported the ptychographic tomography measurements. L.T., R.Y., and M.R.F. contributed to the X-ray measurements. D.A.M. and G.B. grew the single crystals. A.C. contributed to the implementation of the reconstruction method. D.S. contributed to the supervision of the project. A.F.-P. and M.G.-S. contributed to the conception and planning of the project and to writing the proposal. C.D. supervised the experimental work. C.A. is the lead developer of the underlying NeuralMag micromagnetic framework and contributed to and supervised the development of the reconstruction method. All authors discussed the reconstructions, the analysis, and the results, and commented on the manuscript.
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Extended Data
| experimental | ▪ synthetic | |
| Saturation magnetization | 460.55 kA m | |
| Exchange stiffness | 5.729 pJ m | |
| Bulk DMI constant (literature) | 0.60 × 10 J m | |
| Bulk DMI constant (readout, used in all reconstructions) | 0.66 × 10 J m | 0.66 × 10 J m (truth) |
| Tomography cell size | ≈ 9.96 nm | |
| Physics cell size | ≈ 4.98 nm (2× refine) | |
| Stored projection window | 250 × 250 px | |
| Thickness | 300 nm | |
| Diameter | 1.1 µm | |
| series (projections, range) | 29, [−41, +15]° | |
| series (projections, range) | 38, [−30, +47]° | |
| Projections | measured | simulated at the measured angles with measured noise |
| Angle offset ( series, series) | 15°, 33° | — |
| Reconstruction box (tomography cells) | 120 × 120 × 30 | |
| Physics grid (cells) | 240 × 240 × 60 | |
| Face-on stripe period (nm) | 120 | 122 |
| Main figures | 1–4 | — |
| Extended Data figures | 2–5 | 1 |
Table I. The two datasets of this work, with their material parameters, acquisition, and discretization. The upper block lists the literature parameters of Ref. [20], the DMI constants, and the two grids. The lower block lists the acquisition and geometry of each dataset, including the zero-point offset added to the logged stage angles of each measured series (Methods, ’Data acquisition and preprocessing’). The synthetic dataset is described in Methods, ’Synthetic validation’. The last two rows list the figures that use each dataset.
References
- [1]S. Seki, M. Suzuki, M. Ishibashi, R. Takagi, N. D. Khanh, Y. Shiota, K. Shibata, W. Koshibae, Y. Tokura, and T. Ono, Direct visualization of the three-dimensional shape of skyrmion strings in a noncentrosymmetric mag- net, Nature Materials 21, 181 (2022).
- [2]M. T. Birch, D. Cortés-Ortuño, L. A. Turnbull, M. N. Wilson, F. Groß, N. Träger, A. Laurenson, N. Bukin, S. H. Moody, M. Weigand, G. Schütz, H. Popescu, R. Fan, P. Steadman, J. a. T. Verezhak, G. Balakrishnan, J. C. Loudon, A. C. Twitchett-Harrison, O. Hovorka, H. Fanghor, F. Y. Ogrin, J. Gräfe, and P. D. Hatton, Real-space imaging of confined magnetic skyrmion tubes, Nature Communications 11, 1726 (2020).DOI
- [3]N. Kent, N. Reynolds, D. Raftrey, I. T. G. Campbell, S. Virasamy, S. Dhuey, R. V. Chopdekar, A. Hierro-Rodriguez, A. Sorrentino, E. Pereiro, S. Ferrer, F. Hellman, P. Sutcliffe, and P. Fischer, Creation and observation of Hopfions in magnetic multilayer systems, Nature Communications 12, 1562 (2021).DOI
- [4]C. Donnelly, K. L. Metlov, V. Scagnoli, M. Guizar-Sicairos, M. Holler, N. S. Bingham, J. Raabe, L. J. Heyderman, N. R. Cooper, and S. Gliga, Experimental observation of vortex rings in a bulk magnet, Nature Physics 17, 316 (2021).DOI
- [5]N. Nagaosa and Y. Tokura, Topological properties and dynamics of magnetic skyrmions, Nature Nanotechnology 8, 899 (2013).DOI
- [6]A. Fert, N. Reyren, and V. Cros, Magnetic skyrmions: advances in physics and potential applications, Nature Reviews Materials 2, 17031 (2017).DOI
- [7]G. Schütz, W. Wagner, W. Wilhelm, P. Kienle, R. Zeller, R. Frahm, and G. Materlik, Absorption of circularly polarized x rays in iron, Physical Review Letters 58, 737 (1987).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10035022
- [8]C. Donnelly, M. Guizar-Sicairos, V. Scagnoli, S. Gliga, M. Holler, J. Raabe, and L. J. Heyderman, Three-dimensional magnetization structures revealed with X-ray vector nanotomography, Nature 547, 328 (2017).DOI
- [9]C. Donnelly, S. Gliga, V. Scagnoli, M. Holler, J. Raabe, L. J. Heyderman, and M. Guizar-Sicairos, Tomographic reconstruction of a three-dimensional magnetization vector field, New Journal of Physics 20, 083009 (2018).DOI
- [10]A. Hierro-Rodriguez, C. Quirós, A. Sorrentino, L. M. Alvarez-Prado, J. I. Martín, J. M. Alameda, S. McVitie, E. Pereiro, M. Vélez, and S. Ferrer, Revealing 3D magnetization of thin films with soft X-ray tomography: magnetic singularities and topological charges, Nature Communications 11, 6382 (2020).DOI
- [11]C. Donnelly, S. Finizio, S. Gliga, M. Holler, A. Hrabec, M. Odstrčil, S. Mayr, V. Scagnoli, L. J. Heyderman, M. Guizar-Sicairos, and J. Raabe, Time-resolved imaging of three-dimensional nanoscale magnetization dynamics, Nature Nanotechnology 15, 356 (2020).DOI
- [12]D. Wolf, S. Schneider, U. K. Rößler, A. Kovács, M. Schmidt, R. E. Dunin-Borkowski, B. Büchner, B. Rellinghaus, and A. Lubk, Unveiling the three-dimensional magnetic texture of skyrmion tubes, Nature Nanotechnology 17, 250 (2022).DOI
- [13]C. Phatak, A. K. Petford-Long, and M. De Graef, Three-dimensional study of the vector potential of magnetic structures, Physical Review Letters 104, 253901 (2010).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20867379
- [14]J. Neethirajan, B. J. Daurer, M. Di Pietro Martínez, A. Hrabec, L. Turnbull, Y. Yamamoto, M. R. Ferreira, A. Štefančič, D. A. Mayoh, G. Balakrishnan, Z. Pei, P. Xue, L. Chang, E. Ringe, R. Harrison, S. Valencia, M. Kazemian, B. Kaulich, and C. Donnelly, Soft X-Ray Phase Nanoscopy of Micrometer-Thick Magnets, Physical Review X 14, 031028 (2024).
- [15]R. A. Crowther, D. J. DeRosier, and A. Klug, The reconstruction of a three-dimensional structure from projections and its application to electron microscopy, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. A Mathematical and Physical Sciences 317, 319 (1970).DOI
- [16]F. Bruckner, C. Abert, G. Wautischer, C. Huber, C. Vogler, M. Hinze, and D. Suess, Solving Large-Scale Inverse Magnetostatic Problems using the Adjoint Method, Scientific Reports 7, 40816 (2017).DOI
- [17]A. Silinga, A. Kovács, S. McVitie, R. E. Dunin-Borkowski, K. Fallon, and T. P. Almeida, Model-Based Iterative Reconstruction of Three-Dimensional Magnetisation in a Nanowire Structure Using Electron Holographic Vector Field Tomography, Microscopy and Microanalysis 31, ozaf043 (2025).DOI
- [18]W. Brown, Micromagnetics, Interscience tracts on physics and astronomy (Interscience Publishers, 1963).
- [19]C. Abert, Micromagnetics and spintronics: models and numerical methods, The European Physical Journal B 92, 120 (2019).DOI
- [20]M. T. Birch, D. Cortés-Ortuño, K. Litzius, S. Wintz, F. Schulz, M. Weigand, A. Štefančič, D. A. Mayoh, G. Balakrishnan, P. D. Hatton, and G. Schütz, Toggle-like current-induced Bloch point dynamics of 3D skyrmion strings in a room temperature nanowire, Nature Communications 13, 3630 (2022).DOI
- [21]A. Setescak, F. Bruckner, D. Suess, Y.-G. Choi, H. Binger, L. Boer, C. Zhang, H. Yang, C. Donnelly, U. Vool, and C. Abert, A Fourier-Space Approach to Physics-Informed Magnetization Reconstruction from Nitrogen-Vacancy Measurements, Phys. Rev. Lett. 10.1103/nc5g-3yw9 (2026), in press; preprint at arXiv:2602.17180.DOI
- [22]Y. Tokunaga, X. Z. Yu, J. S. White, H. M. Rønnow, D. Morikawa, Y. Taguchi, and Y. Tokura, A new class of chiral materials hosting magnetic skyrmions beyond room temperature, Nature Communications 6, 7638 (2015).DOI
- [23]C. Donnelly, V. Scagnoli, M. Guizar-Sicairos, M. Holler, F. Wilhelm, F. Guilloud, A. Rogalev, C. Detlefs, A. Menzel, J. Raabe, and L. J. Heyderman, High-resolution hard x-ray magnetic imaging with dichroic ptychography, Physical Review B 94, 064421 (2016).DOI
- [24]T. Balke, F. Davis, C. Garcia-Cardona, S. Majee, M. McCann, L. Pfister, and B. Wohlberg, Scientific Computational Imaging Code (SCICO), Journal of Open Source Software 7, 4722 (2022).DOI
- [25]H. Braun and A. Hauck, Tomographic reconstruction of vector fields, IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing 39, 464 (1991).DOI
- [26]J. L. Prince, Tomographic reconstruction of 3-D vector fields using inner product probes, IEEE Transactions on Image Processing 3, 216 (1994).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18291921
- [27]M. Holler, M. Odstrčil, M. Guizar-Sicairos, M. Lebegue, E. Müller, S. Finizio, G. Tinti, C. David, J. Zusman, W. Unglaub, O. Bunk, J. Raabe, A. F. J. Levi, and G. Aeppli, Three-dimensional imaging of integrated circuits with macro- to nanoscale zoom, Nature Electronics 2, 464 (2019).DOI
- [28]C. Abert, F. Bruckner, A. Voronov, M. Lang, S. A. Pathak, S. Holt, R. Kraft, R. Allayarov, P. Flauger, S. Koraltan, T. Schref, A. Chumak, H. Fanghor, and D. Suess, NeuralMag: an open-source nodal finite-difference code for inverse micromagnetics, npj Compu- tational Materials 11, 193 (2025).
- [29]K. Zhu, W. Gao, Z. Wang, S. Sun, S. Huang, J. Tong, J. Li, H. Tian, Z. Li, H. Yang, Y. Zhang, O. Eriksson, F. N. Rybakov, N. S. Kiselev, and J. Li, Magnetic hopfions at room temperature (2026), arXiv:2607.26839.arxiv.org/abs/2607.26839
- [30]P. C. Hansen and D. P. O’Leary, The Use of the L-Curve in the Regularization of Discrete Ill-Posed Problems, SIAM Journal on Scientific Computing 14, 1487 (1993).DOI
- [31]D. Calvetti, S. Morigi, L. Reichel, and F. Sgallari, Tikhonov regularization and the L-curve for large discrete ill-posed problems, Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics Numerical Analysis 2000. Vol. III: Linear Algebra, 123, 423 (2000).
- [32]L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Theory of the dispersion of magnetic permeability in ferromagnetic bodies, Physikalische Zeitschrift der Sowjetunion 8, 153 (1935).
- [33]T. Gilbert, A phenomenological theory of damping in ferromagnetic materials, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics 40, 3443 (2004).DOI
- [34]K. Karube, J. S. White, V. Ukleev, C. D. Dewhurst, R. Cubitt, A. Kikkawa, Y. Tokunaga, H. M. Rønnow, Y. Tokura, and Y. Taguchi, Metastable skyrmion lattices governed by magnetic disorder and anisotropy in β-Mn-type chiral magnets, Physical Review B 102, 064408 (2020).DOI
- [35]F. Bruckner, S. Koraltan, C. Abert, and D. Suess, magnum.np: a PyTorch based GPU enhanced finite difference micromagnetic simulation framework for high level development and inverse design, Scientific Reports 13, 12054 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2302.08843
- [36]X. Yang, H. Wang, M. Hand, K. Sawhney, B. Kaulich, I. V. Kozhevnikov, Q. Huang, and Z. Wang, Design of a multilayer-based collimated plane-grating monochromator for tender X-ray range, Journal of Synchrotron Radiation 24, 168 (2017).DOI
- [37]B. Enders and P. Thibault, A computational framework for ptychographic reconstructions, Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 472, 20160640 (2016).DOI
- [38]M. Odstrčil, M. Holler, J. Raabe, and M. Guizar-Sicairos, Alignment methods for nanotomography with deep sub-pixel accuracy, Optics Express 27, 36637 (2019).DOI
- [39]N. Otsu, A Threshold Selection Method from Gray-Level Histograms, IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics 9, 62 (1979).DOI
- [40]M. Blondel, Q. Berthet, M. Cuturi, R. Frostig, S. Hoyer, F. Llinares-López, F. Pedregosa, and J.-P. Vert, Efficient and Modular Implicit Differentiation, in Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, Vol. 35 (2022) pp. 5230–5242.arxiv.org/abs/2105.15183
- [41]G. Bézicgneul and O.-E. Ganea, Riemannian Adaptive Optimization Methods, in International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR) (2019).arxiv.org/abs/1810.00760
- [42]D. P. Kingma and J. Ba, Adam: A Method for Stochastic Optimization (2017), arXiv:1412.6980 [cs].arxiv.org/abs/1412.6980
- [43]J. Bradbury, R. Frostig, P. Hawkins, M. J. Johnson, Y. Katariya, C. Leary, D. Maclaurin, G. Necula, A. Paszke, J. VanderPlas, S. Wanderman-Milne, and Q. Zhang, JAX: composable transformations of Python+NumPy programs (2018).






