WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Oscillation modes, Decoherence, Beam Transfer Functions, and Instabilities for a Beam Subjected to Space-Charge Forces
Abstract
Based on the oscillation modes of a bunch subject to the space-charge force, we discuss the decoherence of the dipole oscillation, the beam transfer function, and the beam instability. The longitudinal phase space is discretized into grids in the azimuthal and radial directions, respectively. The transverse dipole moment in the longitudinal phase space is represented by a vector of length , and the transformation given by the Vlasov equation is represented by a matrix transformation of size . Solving the eigenvalue problem of this matrix gives the eigen-oscillation modes of the bunch. Using the resulting eigenvectors within a standard linear-algebraic treatment, we analyze these three phenomena. The analysis was performed for the Rapid Cycling Synchrotron (RCS) of the China Spallation Neutron Source (CSNS) using and , and it visualizes the features related to the continuous distribution of the tune, Landau damping, and isolated modes separated from the continuous tune region.
Introduction
The behavior of beam particles moving in a circular accelerator can be described by equations of motion and/or a Hamiltonian. The primary objective is to determine at a given for an initial set of coordinates and momenta . We generally deal with the six-dimensional phase space represented by . Here, to handle coupled oscillations in the transverse and longitudinal directions, we use the four-dimensional subspace . The oscillation can be treated similarly to the oscillation.
To investigate the collective behavior of a beam, we consider the phase-space distribution of particles, . The motion of a single particle is described by equations of motion and a Hamiltonian, , which depend only on the phase-space coordinates of that particle; the effects of the other particles are incorporated by averaging. The equation of motion governing is called the Vlasov equation and is expressed as follows:
The Vlasov equation can also be expressed using Poisson brackets:
Here, the Poisson bracket is expressed by the operator . A formal solution can be written as:
(4) has the opposite sign of compared to Hamiltonian equations of motion:
This is a difference in perspective: focusing on the particle distribution versus on the motion of individual particles. The distribution of a single particle can be represented using the Dirac delta function as
and tracking the distribution using the Vlasov equation yields
It can be seen that the transformation of the individual particle coordinates follows Eq. (4), meaning that the distribution changes due to particle motion. In other words, the Vlasov equation states that the current phase-space density equals the past phase-space density, as the past density moves along with the particle motion. In Hamiltonian dynamics, the symplecticity ensures that the Jacobian of the transformation is unity. The premise is that the phase-space density does not change with motion. The Vlasov equation is derived from a single-particle Hamiltonian for independent motion within an averaged field, and short-range two-particle collisions such as intrabeam scattering are not considered.
(3) is represented by a matrix transformation once the phase space is discretized. However, if one attempts to discretize the six-dimensional phase space, the matrix becomes extremely large. Therefore, by restricting the treatment to the dipole mode in the direction alone, it suffices to discretize the longitudinal phase space. Here, for a beam subjected to the space-charge force, we obtain the eigen-oscillations and eigenvectors (eigen-oscillation distributions) by solving the eigenvalue problem for the transformation matrix of the dipole-mode distribution, represented by a vector obtained by discretizing the longitudinal phase space into
| Circumference | (m) | 227.9 |
| Injection Energy | (GeV) | 0.08 |
| Bunch population | ||
| Bunch length | (m) | 25 |
| Slippage factor | ||
| Synchrotron tune | 0.01 | |
| Chromatic phase | ||
| Space charge tune shift |
Table 1. Parameters of CSNS used as a numerical application.
(azimuthal) (radial) , i.e., a matrix of size .
Starting from the oscillation modes of a bunch undergoing synchro-betatron oscillations in an accelerator, we discuss the oscillation modes of a bunch oscillating under the influence of space-charge forces. As application examples, we discuss (i) the oscillations initialized by a uniform offset, (ii) the oscillations under sinusoidal forced excitation, i.e., the beam transfer function, and (iii) the beam instability that appear when an impedance is added.
Studies on the head-tail oscillation modes and instabilities have been carried out in many papers [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]. They were based on the airbag square-well (ABS) model in the longitudinal phase space, which is easy to handle analytically. Numerical studies extending this approach have been carried out in Ref. [4]. Experiments and analyses for (i) kicker excitation and (ii) forced oscillation have been carried out based on the ABS model in Refs. [7] and [3, 8]. Coupled-bunch instabilities are analyzed based on the ABS model in Ref. [9]. The numerical treatment using the circulant matrix model is presented in Ref. [6].
The analysis presented here has been used to study coupled-bunch instability [10]. Here we focus on the oscillation modes (eigenvectors) obtained by solving the eigenvalue problem of a matrix. Our method allows us to handle arbitrary longitudinal distributions. The above subjects (i)-(iii) are discussed by a unified linear-algebraic technique; Landau damping is visualized in all three subjects.
This paper is organized as follows. The particle distribution for free synchro-betatron motion is analyzed in § 2: the basic formalism is presented in § 2 A, and the application examples (i) and (ii) are discussed in § 2 B and II C, respectively. The particle distribution with space-charge forces is analyzed in § 5: the basic formalism is presented in § 5 A and § 5 B, and the application examples (i), (ii), and (iii) are discussed in § 5 C, III D, and IV, respectively.
For a numerical analysis, the parameters of the China Spallation Neutron Source (CSNS) are used, as listed in Table I.
Synchro-betatron oscillations
Distribution of particles undergoing free synchro-betatron oscillations
The solution in the linear dynamics of a circular accelerator is well known. There are invariants in each degree of freedom, as
For , we do not consider the tilt of the - phase space; . is defined as the aspect ratio of the - ellipse; in the phase-space trajectories. Using the cavity parameters and the slippage factor (), it is expressed as , independent of , where is the circumference of a circular accelerator. For simplicity, we denote and for the synchrotron phase-space variables.
The Hamiltonian is expressed as
or, considering the change in one revolution,
The solution to the equation of motion shows that the betatron and synchrotron phases change in one revolution as and .
The stationary solution is a distribution function that depends only on .
The Poisson bracket of functions of the same variable vanishes, .
The betatron variables are replaced by
Thus, they are represented by , , . Further, we introduce . With this, betatron oscillation as a function of is represented by a simple phase rotation:
While is used as a function of to describe motion, is also used as coordinates in phase space. Using the longitudinal coordinates or as phase-space coordinates, we treat the evolution of the averaged transverse phase-space variables,
where and are the longitudinal beam densities. is sometimes omitted when it is trivial.
Non-stationary oscillations encompass any distribution not expressible solely by . Consider the case where the initial transverse distribution is given by in the -direction, with its center of mass in the longitudinal phase space given by , and the longitudinal distribution is around the center.
in the - and - spaces. We can find . The distribution is not an equilibrium distribution for , since it is not a function of . As a typical example, in the case of a Gaussian in both planes, and are
Integration over and , after redefining the variable , gives, as expected,
where is an even function of the arguments and ; namely .
After one turn, the distribution function undergoes the inverse transformation on , changing the betatron and synchrotron phases by and :
By redefining the variables,
Thus, the center-of-mass position in phase space after one revolution is
Here we introduce the synchro-betatron oscillation mode. Since is periodic with respect to the synchrotron phase, the azimuthal direction in phase space, we perform a Fourier expansion into azimuthal modes:
Focusing on a mode with ,
The same argument holds if the initial offset is taken to be instead of . Eq. (20) means that the azimuthal dependence of the distribution, in the longitudinal phase space, is an eigenmode of the free synchro-betatron motion, with eigenfrequency (tune) .
Chromaticity
Chromaticity is a quantity characterizing the dependence of the betatron tune on the momentum deviation () in single-particle motion. The tune is expanded with respect to the momentum deviation, and its coefficient is called the chromaticity. Here, only the first-order term is considered and is denoted by the linear chromaticity :
In the case of a finite chromaticity, the -mode in the expansion of Eq. (20) is no longer an eigenmode. The -mode including the variation due to becomes an eigenmode of oscillation, with tune [10]:
where the chromatic phase is introduced. The variation due to chromaticity within the bunch is characterized by . When the energy is below the transition, is negative, and the sign of is opposite to the sign of the chromaticity .
Decoherence and recoherence of a kicked beam
Consider the case where the beam distribution is shifted by uniformly in the -direction as an initial condition. In practice, this is realized by giving an offset at injection or by kicking the entire bunch with a kicker magnet located upstream in betatron phase.
For , it is evident that the center of mass of the bunch undergoes betatron oscillation with tune . The bunch oscillation then contains only the mode. For a finite chromaticity , the eigenmodes with eigenfrequencies are , so a uniformly shifted distribution is represented by a superposition of multiple modes:
is obtained by applying to both sides:
where can be viewed as a normalized radial coordinate in the longitudinal phase space. is the -th order Bessel function. The Bessel-function identity ensures that summing over all yields the uniform shift . In practice, is truncated at some value . Let us examine how many modes are needed to represent a uniform shift. Substituting Eq. (25) into Eq. (24) and truncating at :
For zero chromaticity (), the mode alone can represent the uniform shift, as mentioned above. No dipole moment is associated with the oscillation of the modes. For , various modes mix, because they possess a dipole mode. Figure 1 shows the distribution for in the case , . It is distributed in , roughly reproducing a uniform distribution. For , , and for , , so is desirable. This makes sense when we consider that is the wavenumber in the direction and is the wavenumber in the azimuthal direction. Corresponding to the shift in , the imaginary part of , , arises.
Figure 1. Reconstruction of intra-bunch phase amplitude for a uniform initial amplitude with , .
Time evolution
Let us consider the time evolution of this uniformly shifted bunch. Each mode moves with its own frequency :
Here, time is measured in turns. At , is real and only has an component, but an imaginary part appears over time. Figure 2 shows the center of mass for 1000 turns. Even if the dipole amplitude disappears momentarily, it revives every 100 turns (). Multiplying by the phase variation due to the tune in Eq. (12):

Figure 2. Oscillation of the bunch centroid with initial amplitude 1, without space charge forces.
If the longitudinal distribution is Gaussian, (i.e., , the integral can be performed:
where is the modified Bessel function. The periodic behavior with period can be inferred because the sum becomes large when is an integer multiple of .
Frequency response to forced oscillation: Beam Transfer Function
We set up a device that generates an electromagnetic field at high frequency at a specific location () in the accelerator, and that gives a transverse momentum kick to the beam at a given frequency once per revolution:
A change of momentum occurs at . The corresponding Hamiltonian is . The distribution function changes as follows:
The average momentum changes by:
To find the component of , we multiply both sides by and integrate over :
Here, the input frequency is normalized by . Since includes , it also changes the longitudinal distribution , but this is ignored since it is small. Considering the repetition over , the change in is described by a differential equation:
where is the tune of the input frequency. The solution of Eq. (34) is obtained by Fourier transformation, applying to both sides:
Here, the identity
was used. By the inverse transform, applying , the amplitude of the mode is obtained:
where is the fractional part of the tune . In the sum over integer , is recast by adding the integer part of : is used as the new . In this way, when the input frequency is close to plus an integer , i.e., , the denominator in Eq. (36) becomes close to zero, forming a peak. It is common practice to perform tune measurements by applying a forced excitation at a frequency that differs from the beam betatron frequency by an integer multiple of the revolution frequency.
The condition for the response from modes excited by a sweep of the input frequency to form a peak is that the denominator of Eq. (36) becomes zero: . Cases with are also considered. The tune (frequency) at which the response peaks is , corresponding to .
By calculating and for and , the magnitude of the response of each mode to the input frequency can
be evaluated. Let us focus on the numerator amplitude in Eq. (36), i.e., neglect , , etc., and obtain the relative amplitude for :
In the case of , the amplitudes for modes other than are zero because of . Figure 3 shows the amplitude as a function of the fractional tune of the input frequency for each chromaticity. The amplitude is plotted at the fractional input frequency , and those for different are overlaid. A symmetric amplitude distribution appears around the tune . At , only the betatron mode responds strongly in several near . At , the maximum is at , and the response becomes weaker as increases. The relation between tune and amplitude for () is similar to that for (). There are slight differences in how the fractional part of the tune is handled.
The dipole moment as a function of is also a measurable quantity,
We are interested in the Fourier component of the dipole moment at the input frequency ,
Figure 4 shows the Fourier component at the input frequency. is plotted at the fractional input frequency , and those for different are overlaid in plot (a). For , with has a peak value at . It has a decent value at . for is shown in plot (b). In Eq. (39), the integral can be evaluated using the integrand at : . This behavior is consistent with plot (b). Note that .
Eq. (39) shows that the peak structure seen in plot (b) appears symmetrically for determined by . The peak structure in plot (b) shifts by as is changed. Plot (c) shows the shift for , which gives for . These behaviors are reasonable, since the frequency matches the intra-bunch variation of chromaticity when .
Oscillation of beams subject to space-charge forces
Formalism to treat space-charge force
Space-charge forces are forces acting between non-relativistically moving charged particles. Consider how space-charge forces affect oscillations within a bunch. Considering small oscillations of the bunch, a particle at in phase space, or its distribution, experiences a space-charge force corresponding to the deviation from the center integrated over at :
where
Using expressions and for the dipolar and quadrupolar wake force integrated over the circumference,
the equation of motion for the space-charge force is expressed by
Impedance, which is Fourier transform of the wake force, is expressed as
The impedance is inherently a function of frequency , but since the wake force is a delta function, it is a constant.
Here, we transform Eq. (40) into a form that converts a function of phase-space variables into a function of :
As in Eq. (22), expand into azimuthal modes. The equation of motion for each mode is obtained by multiplying by and integrating.
The on the right-hand side is also expanded with . Using and the Bessel function formula:
| Type | |||
| G | |||
| W |
Table 2. for several longitudinal distributions. is the step function. The beam size is defined by , and particles are distributed over and in the water-bag distribution, where .
Here, variables are normalized as , . in the first line of Eq. (47) is defined as:
The integrations have been carried out for several longitudinal distributions, and the results for the Gaussian and water-bag distributions are summarized in Ref. [10].
In the second line of Eq. (47), enters the integrand, but by shifting the integration over , it can be written in a form independent of . This is possible because the impedance of the space-charge force is constant.
Here, as in Eq. (34), we express it as an equation of motion for :
Because the change due to the space-charge force is equally distributed between and , a factor of appears. Setting :
By solving this equation as an eigenvalue problem, the eigen-oscillation modes and their eigenfrequencies can be found.
Eq. (50) is reduced to an eigenvalue problem by discretizing in . Actually, we discretize with () instead of . The orthogonal functions are expressed as
and elsewhere. The normalization and orthogonality relations are:
This method was first used by K. Oide for the analysis of longitudinal instabilities [11] and extended to the transverse beam-beam instabilities [12].
Before solving the eigenvalue problem, we try to calculate the tune shift as the lowest-order perturbation, taking the diagonal elements of Eq. (50). As explained in detail later, taking the discretization as the basis of the eigenvalue problem, the first term of the diagonal element on the right side of Eq. (50) is larger than the second term. The -dependent tune shift is:
The tune shift, which is independent of , is given for the Gaussian distribution as
That for the water-bag distribution is
The coefficient is the so-called space-charge tune shift at the peak line density . Figure 5 shows the -dependent term, , given in Eqs. (54) and (55).
Figure 5. Plot of for the Gaussian and water-bag distributions.
Next, let us move on to solving the eigenvalue problem. Expand in terms of and represent the coupling coefficient as :
Applying to Eq. (50) yields:
With the change of variables from to , the distribution function will henceforth be written as , with the two related by .
The eigenvalue equation to be solved is:
The first two terms on the left side are the diagonal matrix , and the third term, the matrix , is expressed as:
Equations (58) and (59) constitute a complex square matrix of dimension . Here, we introduce a cutoff for the frequency in the integral. Since was discretized with , we used , i.e. , as the cutoff frequency and set it as the upper and lower limits of the integral.
Since this matrix is not Hermitian, the eigenvectors satisfy the following orthogonality relation, represented by left and right eigenvectors:
The eigen-oscillation states are represented by a linear combination of the basis vectors consisting of the radial function and the azimuthal function :
The state corresponding to the conjugate is defined as . The orthogonality relation for the eigen-oscillation states is:
Here, orthogonality in and the orthogonality relations for , Eqs. (52) and (60), were used. The time evolution of the oscillation state involves a phase rotation by the eigenfrequency (tune) at each turn:
Any oscillation state can be represented by a linear combination of eigenvectors:
Given an oscillation state , the coefficients of the linear combination can be determined by applying to both sides:
Beam oscillation mode given by solving the eigenvalue problem
The eigenvalue problem was solved using the parameters of the CSNS, where the longitudinal phase-space distribution was Type W in Table II. This is a uniform-density distribution in phase space, a so-called water-bag distribution. Using a vector of length , with , , we solve the eigenvalue problem for a matrix for each bunch intensity.
Figure 6 plots the eigen-tunes as a function of the bunch population, where the number of particles in the bunch was varied up to in 100 steps, and the eigenvalue problem was solved at each step. Without space-charge forces, the eigen-tunes were and were degenerate for the radial modes , but the space-charge force lifts this degeneracy, generating a tune shift for each radial mode. Particles with smaller synchrotron amplitudes experience a larger negative tune shift due to stronger space-charge forces, and vice versa. Many of the lines shifting negatively with increasing in the figure are due to the space-charge tune shift. The magnitude of the shift corresponds to the synchrotron amplitude ( or ).

Figure 6. Tunes of oscillations for each bunch intensity, obtained by solving the eigenvalue problem, where and . The horizontal scale of the bunch population is – in (a) and is enlarged to – in (b).
In Figure 6, for , there are modes clearly isolated from other modes. For better readability of the figure, is set to 10. This isolated mode is easily understood. When the chromaticity is 0, a distribution where all particles in the bunch are uniformly shifted undergoes betatron oscillations without being affected by space-charge forces. For , it is not clear whether there are isolated modes.
Figure 7 shows the eigen-oscillation patterns of the separated modes represented by Eq. (61). The top row is for , arranged from left to right for . Only the real part is plotted, so the amplitude distribution is depicted. The distributions show vertical oscillations corresponding to in the azimuthal direction. Tracking the time evolution by multiplying by reveals the oscillation pattern rotating in the - phase space due to synchrotron oscillations.

Figure 7. Eigen-oscillation patterns of the separated modes obtained from Eq. (61) using the eigenvectors. Horizontal and vertical axes are and , respectively. Top row: , , Bottom row: , . From left to right: .
The bottom row shows the oscillation patterns for . They are uniform in the direction, and the structure is only seen in the direction. Space-charge forces do not act on such a distribution as seen in Eq. (40). Individual particles undergo synchrotron oscillations. Space-charge forces act so that synchrotron oscillations are not coherently visible in the direction of synchrotron motion. When tracking the time evolution, synchrotron oscillations are not seen when the amplitude is large, but rotation becomes visible when the amplitude becomes small. The tune approaches but does not completely reach , so the synchrotron oscillation
component has not vanished.
Decoherence and recoherence of a kicked beam
Consider a distribution uniformly shifted in the direction. The initial state is given by . This initial distribution is expanded in terms of the eigenvectors:
Substituting into Eq. (66), the coefficients are obtained for as:
The extent to which each eigenmode is included in the uniformly shifted distribution can be seen from . Figure 8 shows the amplitudes of the eigenmodes for each chromaticity . At , only the mode with tune equal to is induced. For , as increases, modes with tunes higher than become included. Modes with tunes lower than are continuously distributed as seen in Figure 6, so individual modes have small components.

Figure 8. Linear combination coefficients for the beam initialized by a uniform dipole distribution, obtained from Eq. (68).
Each eigenmode oscillates according to its own eigen-tune :
Figure 9 plots the centroid oscillation of the bunch for each chromaticity. Coherence is lost due to differences in the tunes of the included eigenmodes, and the centroid initially approaches zero, but coherence recovers again. The recovery period is turns, as seen in Figure 2 without the space-charge force, but with the space-charge force, the period becomes longer than . Although the mode is quite close to the tune, the modes included vary with chromaticity as seen in Figure 8, so the degree of deviation of the period from depends on chromaticity. For small chromaticity, a small number of modes are excited, so the periodicity is clearly longer than . For high chromaticity, several to tens of modes with are excited, so the behavior is complex, though the periodicity is longer than .
Figure 9. Centroid oscillation of the bunch for each chromaticity, with an initial amplitude of , obtained from Eq. (69), where , .
Frequency response of forced oscillation: Beam Transfer Function
For the case with a strong space-charge force, we find the response of each eigenmode to a sinusoidal forced oscillation . The momentum change at is given by
Multiplying by and integrating over , the coefficient for each eigenmode is obtained:
Considering the repetition over , we express the change in by a differential equation:
The solution of Eq. (72) is obtained similarly to Eqs. (35)–(36), giving:
When the beam receives the momentum change at a certain frequency, the strength of each induced mode is indicated by . The condition for the linear combination coefficient corresponding to the modal response to form a peak is that the denominator of Eq. (73) becomes zero: . The condition means that excitation occurs when the oscillation mode tune and the forced oscillation tune differ by an integer . As is done in Sec. II C, we express using the fractional part. Consider the case where a certain mode is excited by a sweep of the input frequency (). The tune (frequency) at which peaks corresponds to multiple integer values , with frequencies and . Denote the response at a specific in the sum over in Eq. (73) as :
Figure 10 presents the amplitude induced by forced oscillation for , where the horizontal axis is the fractional part of the oscillation tune and different are overlaid. Points are located at on the horizontal axis. The eigenvectors are independent of and . As seen in Eq. (74), depends on and through the argument of the Bessel function, . The figure does not change for a finite chromaticity except for a shift in , .
Figure 10. Amplitude induced by forced oscillation, where the beam intensity is and ( and ) in plots (a)–(d).
The mode induced at the frequency corresponding to , combined with the eigenvector, has the following dipole amplitude distribution:
By integrating Eq. (75) over or for each and , measurable quantities, and are obtained. They characterize the magnitude of the response of each mode to the input frequency. The response for , in which mode excited by frequency , is:
Figure 11 shows the response for at . At , the result is almost the same as without the space-charge force. Only the betatron mode responds strongly for several near . No dipole moment is associated with the oscillation of the modes even in the presence of the space-charge force. The difference is clear for when compared to Figure 3 without the space-charge force. A peak appears at for , and the peak shifts to higher for increasing . This behavior is the same for : the peak structure depends only on . The height of the response is higher than that without the space-charge force. There is also no response for the modes, as seen in Figure 8 and Figure 10.

Figure 3. Relation between output tune and amplitude for each chromaticity (without space-charge forces), where and .
The dipole moment as a function of is given by the integral of Eq. (75) over ,
and its integral, , exhibit a sinusoidal structure in due to the chromatic modulation and the oscillation mode subject to the space-charge force, as shown in Figure 7. The Fourier component of the dipole moment at the input frequency is given by
Figure 11. Beam response for induced by a forced oscillation with frequency .
Figure 12 shows the response of at . The corresponding figure without the space-charge force is shown in Figure 4. Plot (a) depicts the response at the eigen-tune , and those for different are overlaid. The plot is drawn for ; the same plot applies for . The discrete mode with visible amplitude corresponds to the isolated mode seen in Figure 6. The mode is the isolated pure dipole mode. The modes are lined up from left to right as . We express the isolated modes using . for the isolated modes is shown in plot (b), where . As seen in Figure 4, plot (c) shifts as changes, by . This is because Eq. (39) contains . Here, both Eqs. (74) and (77) contain . The eigenvectors do not depend on , because the space-charge impedance in Eq. (44) is independent of frequency. The peak structure of only shifts with , but its values do not change. This explains why the same plot is obtained for in plot (a). Plot (c) shows the shift of the response for different chromaticities.

Figure 4. Beam response for forced oscillation at the frequency (without space-charge forces). (a) the response as a function of the fractional input tune for various , with different overlaid, (b) the response as a function of for each at , and (c) the response for different in the mode.
The difference from the response without the space-charge force is (i) there is a response for only one mode for the modes, but no response for the modes, (ii) the frequency separation of the response between modes is narrower than , and (iii) the response for the modes is more than twice as strong as that without the space-charge force.
This behavior is closely connected to the oscillation mode with and without the space-charge force. (i) and (ii) are explained by the fact that an isolated mode exists for each of the modes, whereas no isolated modes exist for . The modes with have only a continuous spectrum, as shown in Figure 6. (iii) is explained by the mode pattern seen in Figure 7. The distribution of the transverse amplitude is sinusoidal in , and is independent of . The Fourier integral therefore gives a larger value compared with the pure synchro-betatron mode, .
The continuous modes do not respond to forced oscillations: this is due to Landau damping. Even for the modes, the response is limited to the discrete modes. Only isolated modes separated from the continuum respond to forced oscillation. Figure 13 summarizes the frequency response for the isolated modes for various bunch intensities, where at . The lines with are almost overlapping, and those with are almost overlapping. shows transient behavior. For and , the difference in the response gets bigger as increases, and at and 4, it differs by a factor of five.
Figure 13. Frequency response for the isolated modes for various bunch intensities, , where at .
Beam Instability
We discuss the beam instability that arises when the frequency components possessed by the beam match those of the impedance. Frequency shifts caused by the impedance are assumed to be small: that is, transverse mode coupling is not considered. The main subjects are the head-tail instability and the coupled-bunch instability. The impedance is expressed as a resonator model with , and the contribution of the kick factor is small relative to the synchrotron tune. Cases where the resonator frequency is high with a large but not a large are also included. This would apply to the impedance and beam instability in high-intensity proton accelerators such as neutron sources. The impedance induced by the ceramic chambers in CSNS is at with [13]. The impedance induced by the kicker magnets in J-PARC is at – with – [14].
In conventional instability theories, the underlying oscillation modes were those of the free synchro-betatron oscillation in Eq. (22). The synchro-betatron modes are degenerate in the radial direction, so there is uncertainty about which radial mode to use as the base. Generally, the lowest-order flat radial mode is used. It has been found that the oscillation modes differ significantly for beams with strong space-charge forces. The eigenvalue
problem including space-charge forces and the impedance was solved in Ref. [10], where the impedance was evaluated at . This implicitly assumed , where was the resonator frequency normalized by the revolution frequency. Here, following the conditions described earlier, we take the underlying eigenmodes as oscillation modes that account for the space charge. The space-charge force dominates the effects on intra-bunch oscillations, and the instability is caused by the impedance under resonance conditions in which the oscillation mode frequency and the impedance frequency match.
The wake force is now added to the equation of motion. In this section, we use the wake and impedance in conventional units and , respectively [15]. The equation is expressed in terms of its Fourier transform, the impedance .
Using , multiplying both sides by and integrating over :
where
The growth rate of mode per revolution can be determined by examining the imaginary part of the tune multiplied by :
in Eq. (79) contains the same terms as expressed by Eqs. (74) and (77). Thus, a rough sketch of the instability can be understood from Figure 4, Figure 12 and Figure 13. For example, for , the growth rate and time are and , when . The growth rate is positive when the impedance is negative: that is, . The condition and the result do not change with and without the space-charge force because of , . For a finite chromaticity, differences emerge between the cases with and without the space-charge force. Without the space-charge force, instability occurs at . The growth rate decreases to 27%, 16%, 12% and 10% for and 4 as shown in Figure 4(b). The growth rate is independent of the sign of .

Figure 12. Response for forced oscillation of the beam subject to the space-charge force. (a) , where those for different are overlaid. (b) for the isolated modes with different . (c) Shift of the response for different chromaticities.
With the space-charge force at (), instability occurs at , where is the tune of an isolated mode related to the -th synchro-betatron mode. The growth rate decreases to 52%, 49%, 46% and 44% for and 4 as shown in Figure 12(b) and Figure 13. The instability does not occur for due to Landau damping. The growth of other bunch intensities is obtained from the reduction factor seen in Figure 13.
The formulae are extended to the multi-bunch instability with bunches stored with equal spacing (),
where is the mode number of the coupled-bunch instability [10, 15] and ().
Conclusions
Understanding the oscillation modes amounts to representing the transformation of the system by a matrix and solving an eigenvalue problem. The beam distribution is represented by a vector of length , and the transformation of the beam distribution is represented by a matrix. Solving this eigenvalue problem yields the oscillation modes of the bunch; the beam oscillation is expressed as a linear combination of the eigen-oscillation modes, and the time evolution and the linear response are analyzed. Solving the eigenvalue problem relies on numerical methods, but once the eigenvalues and eigenvectors are obtained, their treatment is standard linear algebra.
Oscillation modes of the beam were discussed for cases in which particles undergo free synchro-betatron oscillations, and for particles correlated by the space-charge forces. Eigen-oscillation states were found for both cases, considering the modulation due to chromaticity in the synchro-betatron modes. Without space-charge forces, eigen-oscillations exist at the betatron oscillation frequency and its sideband frequencies arising from periodic azimuthal displacements () due to synchrotron oscillations, and are degenerate with respect to the radial direction in synchrotron phase space.
Space-charge forces lift this degeneracy, causing the tune to depend not only on but also on . While a group of modes with continuously distributed tunes over appears, for , modes with discrete tunes, separated and isolated from the continuous tune region, emerge.
These tune distributions have a significant impact on the following phenomena in high-intensity proton rings, depending on the presence or absence of the space-charge force:
Decoherence and recoherence (echo) when a bunch is uniformly displaced as an initial condition,
Beam transfer function when forced oscillation is applied to a bunch,
Beam instability caused by a resonator impedance with a high quality factor .
The initial state of a kicked bunch contains a mixture of various eigenmodes when chromaticity is nonzero. By representing the initial state as a linear combination of individual eigenmodes and propagating each mode with its own eigenfrequency, decoherence and recoherence can be discussed. The linear coefficients are dominated by isolated modes, and as the chromaticity increases, isolated modes of higher order are included more. When forced oscillation is applied, modes corresponding to that frequency are excited. Only isolated modes are excited; continuous modes are not excited due to Landau damping. That is, modes are not excited. Excitation depends on integer multiples of the revolution frequency added to the tune of the forced oscillation. As the chromaticity (or ) is changed, the beam response does not change when the frequency is chosen so as to satisfy . The strength of the response depends on the space-charge force. The response is several times higher than that without the space-charge force. Beam instability is discussed based on the space-charge oscillation modes, namely, we assume that the oscillation modes are determined by the space-charge force, but are not affected by the impedance. The impedance with a low frequency and a high quality factor being studied in CSNS and J-PARC meets this condition. Instability growth and the beam-transfer function are expressed by the same formula. Only isolated modes with are excited by the impedance, but continuous modes distributed over are not excited due to Landau damping. The growth rate depends on the space-charge force. The growth for is several times faster than that without the space-charge force.
Acknowledgements
This work is jointly supported by the Guangdong Special Support Program (Project No. 2024TQ08A570) and Guangdong Basic and Applied Basic Research Foundation (Project No. 2021B1515120021).
References
- [1]M. Blaskiewicz, Fast head-tail instability with space charge, Phys. Rev. ST-AB 1, 044201 (1998).DOI
- [2]A. Burov, Head-tail modes for strong space charge, Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 12, 044202 (2009); 12, 109901 (2009) [erratum].arxiv.org/abs/0812.3914
- [3]V. Kormilov and O. Boine-Frankenheim, Head-tail instability and Landau damping in bunches with space charge, Phys. Rev. ST-Accel and Beams 13, 114201 (2010).
- [4]A. Macridin, A. Burov, E. Stern, J. Amundson, P. Spentzouris, Simulation of transverse modes with their intrinsic Landau damping for bunched beams in the presence of space charge, Phys. Rev. ST-Accel and Beams 18, 074401 (2015).DOI
- [5]Y. H. Chin, A. W. Chao, and M. M. Blaskiewicz, Two particle model for studying the effects of space-charge force on strong head-tail instabilities, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 19, 014201 (2016).DOI
- [6]X. Buffat, E. Metral, E. Gottlob, C. Hogh, A. Oeftiger, T. Pieloni, Description of beam instabilities in synchrotrons with wakefields and space charge forces using the circulant matrix model, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 24,060101 (2021).DOI
- [7]N. Yoshimura, T. Toyama, Y. Shobuda, Space charge effects on the intrabunch motion under large chromaticity at the main ring in the J-PARC, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 28, 101003 (2025).
- [8]R. Singh, O. Boine-Frankenheim, O. Chorny, P. Forck, R. Haselt, W. Kaufmann, P. Kowina, K. Lang and T. Weiland, Interpretation of transverse tune spectra in a heavy-ion synchrotron at high intensities, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 16, 034201 (2013).DOI
- [9]A. Burov, Coupled-beam and coupled-bunch instabilities, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 21, 114401 (2018).arxiv.org/abs/1606.07430
- [10]K. Ohmi, L. Huang, H. Liu and L. Rao, Space charge effects on coupled-bunch instability in high-intensity proton rings, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 28, 070101 (2025).
- [11]K. Oide, A mechanism of longitudinal single-bunch instability in storage rings, Part. Accel. 51, 43(1995), https://inspirehep.net/files/c68532571e82719dad511ab5f1e4ee76.
- [12]K. Ohmi, N.Kuroo, K.Oide, D.Zhou and F.Zimmermann, Coherent beam-beam instability in collisions with a large crossing angle, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 134801 (2017). K. Ohmi, Y. Zhang, C. Lin, Beam-beam mode coupling in collision with a crossing angle, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 26, 111001 (2023).
- [13]Liangsheng Huang, Sheng Wang, Shouyuan Xu, Xinguang Liu, Mingyang Huang, Renhong Liu, Biao Tan, Hanyang Liu, Li Rao, Yanliang Han, Source of instability in the rapid cycling synchrotron of the China Spallation Neutron Source, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 140, 71 (2025).DOI
- [14]Y. Shobuda, Y.H. Chin, P.K. Saha, H. Hotchi, H. Harada, Y. Irie, F. Tamura, N. Tani, T. Toyama, Y. Watanabe, M. Yamamoto, Theoretical elucidation of space charge effects on the coupled-bunch instability at the 3 GeV rapid cycling synchrotron at the Japan Proton Accelerator Research Complex, Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2017, 013G01 (2017).DOI
- [15]A. Chao, Physics of Collective Beam Instabilities in High Energy Accelerators, Wiley-Interscience Publication, New York, 1993), and references therein.





