betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Effects of physical and chemical pressure on charge density wave transitions in LaAg1-xAuxSb2 single crystals

Abstract

The structural characterization and electrical transport measurements at ambient and applied pressures of the compounds of the La(Ag1-xAux)Sb2 family are presented. Up to two charge density wave (CDW) transitions could be detected upon cooling from room temperature and an equivalence of the effects of chemical and physical pressure on the CDW ordering temperatures was observed with the unit cell volume being a salient structural parameter. As such La(Ag1-xAux)Sb2 is a rare example of a non-cubic system that exhibits good agreement between the effects of applied, physical, pressure and changes in unit cell volume from steric changes induced by isovalent substitution. Additionally, for La(Ag0.54Au0.46)Sb2 anomalies in low temperature electrical transport were observed in the pressure range where the lower charge density wave is completely suppressed.

Introduction

Physical (hydrostatic) pressure and chemical substitution are two common ways to tune the physical properties of materials. Whereas hydrostatic pressure is considered to be a clean parameter that does not introduce additional disorder, as well as changes in band filling in many cases, the experimental techniques available under pressure are more limited. Chemical substitution necessarily involves some additional disorder. In the case of aliovalent substitutions the corresponding electron- or hole- doping effects are often dominant. For isovalent substitution the primary effect is thought to be steric and the comparison with physical pressure can be more relevant. Whereas such isovalent substitutions can be referred to as ”chemical pressure” differences in how pressure and substitution affect a compound, especially a non-cubic one, can be greater than similarities in some cases. It is of particular importance when there is a desire to stabilize a particular high pressure phase/state (like high temperature superconductivity [1]) using chemical and/or physical pressure. Additionally, observation of an apparent equivalence [2, 3, 4] or non-equivalence [5] of chemical and physical pressure can help in understanding of structure - property relations and in recognizing relevant structural motifs.

The members of the family of compounds chosen for this study, LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2, demonstrate charge density wave (CDW) transitions, or spontaneous superstructures formed by electrons. [6] Decades ago Peierls showed the instability of a (one-dimensional) metal interacting with the lattice towards a lattice distortion and the opening of a gap in the electronic spectrum. [7] This concept is often applied to CDW formation in low-dimensional materials, although alternatives are widely discussed. [8, 9, 10] Studies of CDW phenomena in solids and competition of CDW with other collective phenomena remain one of the active subfields of quantum materials research.

In this work we study effects of pressure on single crystals of the selected members of the LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 family which is compared to the chemical pressure implemented via Ag ↔\leftrightarrow Au substitution. The end-compounds, LaAgSb2_2 and LaAuSb2_2 were first synthesized almost three decades ago [11, 12] and were reported to crystallize in the same tetragonal ZrCuSi2_2-type structure (P4/nmmP4/nmm, No. 129). CDW transitions were observed in electrical transport at ∼210\sim210 K and ∼100\sim100 K for LaAgSb2_2 and LaAuSb2_2 respectively. [13, 14] Synchrotron X-ray scattering study [15] and further thermodynamic measurements [16] identified second, lower temperature, CDW transition at ∼185\sim185 K in LaAgSb2_2. Similarly, in addition to TCDW1≈110T_{CDW1} \approx110 K, a second CDW transition at TCDW2∼90T_{CDW2} \sim90 K was detected by electrical transport measurements in near stoichiometric LaAuSb2_2. [17] The synthesis and evolution of the higher temperature, TCDW1T_{CDW1} in the LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 series was reported in Ref. [18] but without any measurements of TCDW2T_{CDW2} or companion applied pressure studies.

For LaAgSb2_2 pressure reportedly suppressed TCDW1T_{CDW1} [19, 20, 21, 22, 23] as well as TCDW2T_{CDW2} [21, 23] with the results being consistent in majority of publications. [19, 20, 21] Qualitatively similar behavior under pressure was also observed for LaAuSb2_2. [17, 24, 25] Additionally, in LaAgSb2_2 and LaAuSb2_2, low temperature superconductivity was discovered and studied under pressure [23, 24]. It has to be noted that the exact Au stoichiometry in LaAux_xSb2_2 depends on details of the synthesis and affects both the ambient pressure values of TCDW1T_{CDW1} and TCDW2T_{CDW2} and their pressure derivatives. [17]

Earlier comparison of the effects of pressure and chemical substitution in this family of materials [19] was based on a study of the La1−x_{1-x}Rx_xAgSb2_2 series (R=Y,Ce,Nd,GdR = \mathrm{Y}, \mathrm{Ce}, \mathrm{Nd}, \mathrm{Gd}) and significant contribution of disorder prevailing in the case of substitution was found thus resulting in significant difference between physical and chemical pressure. In this work we address the same question in the different, transition metal site, substitution series.

Materials and Methods

Single crystals of LaAg1−xAuxSb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{1-x}\mathrm{Au}_{x}\mathrm{Sb}_{2} were grown from an antimony-rich self-flux following the method described in Refs. [13, 17, 26]. Pure elements were loaded into an alumina Canfield crucible set [27] which was placed into an amorphous silica tube and sealed in partial atmosphere of argon. The sealed tubes were heated to 1050 °C over 10 hours, held for 8 hours, then cooled to 800 °C over a period of 10 hours prior to starting the crystal growth. Crystal growth occurred during the 100 hour cooling from 800 °C to 670 °C, after which the excess flux was decanted with the aid of a centrifuge.

In this work, crystals of LaAg1−xAuxSb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{1-x}\mathrm{Au}_{x}\mathrm{Sb}_{2} with nominal compositions x=0,0.25,0.5,0.75x = 0, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75 were grown with the initial La : T : Sb (T = Ag1−xAux\mathrm{Ag}_{1-x}\mathrm{Au}_{x}) growth compositions: 1 : 2 : 20 (T2). To investigate whether reported Au deficiency [14, 17, 18] is relevant and can be tuned for the intermediate Au concentrations in LaAg1−xAuxSb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{1-x}\mathrm{Au}_{x}\mathrm{Sb}_{2}, for x=0.25,0.75x = 0.25, 0.75 the growth composition of 1 : 6 : 20 (T6) was used as well. For the end compound, LaAuxSb2\mathrm{LaAu}_{x}\mathrm{Sb}_{2}, the data from the recent Ref. [17] are used when appropriate.

Cu-Kα\alpha x-ray diffraction patterns were taken using a Rigaku Miniflex-II diffractometer. The crystals were ground and the powder was mounted on a low-background single-crystal silicon plate using a trace amount of Dow Corning silicone vacuum grease. The mount was spun during data collection to reduce possible effects of texture. Data taken for Rietveld refinement were collected in two overlapping blocks: 10∘≤2θ≤48∘10^\circ\le2\theta\le48^\circ and 38∘≤2θ≤100∘38^\circ\le2\theta\le100^\circ, with the second block counted for 4-5 times longer than the first to compensate for the loss of scattered intensity at higher angles due to the x-ray form factors. The two data blocks for each sample were co-refined within GSAS using a single set of structural and instrumental parameters but with independent scale factors to allow for the different counting times used. Parameters for both the primary phase and any impurity were refined. We found that the materials were easy to grind into a random powder and no texture or preferential orientation effects were observed in the residuals. The diffractometer and analysis procedures were checked using Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} (SRM 676a[28]); our fitted values of a=4.7586(2)a = 4.7586(2) Å and c=12.9903(7)c = 12.9903(7) Å were both 1.6(4)×10−41.6(4) \times10^{-4} Å smaller than the values on the certificate[28], suggesting a small but statistically significant mis-calibration of the instrument. The fitted lattice parameters given in the analysis that follows do not include this correction.

Chemical analysis of the crystals was performed using an Oxford Instruments energydispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS) system on a Thermo Scientific Teneo scanning electron microscope. The measurements were performed on polished abab surfaces of single crystals with four to eight points taken for every sample.

Standard, linear 4-probe ac resistivity was measured on bar-shaped samples of LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 in two arrangements: I∥abI\parallel ab and, when needed, I∥cI\parallel c. The size of the samples was 1.5 - 2 mm length, 0.2 - 0.4 mm width and about 0.1 mm thickness. The frequency used was 17 Hz, typical current values were 3 mA for in-plane electrical transport and 5 mA for the cc-axis measurements. The contact resistances between the leads and the samples were below 1Ω1\Omega. Based on our experience with the LaAux_xSb2_2 samples with similar size and contact resistance, [17] we do not expect the heating effects to be observed either at ambient pressure or in the pressure cell environment. The measurements were performed using the ACT option of a Quantum Design Physical Property Measurement System (PPMS).

For selected samples, resistivity measurements under pressure were performed in a hybrid, BeCu / NiCrAl piston-cylinder pressure cell (modified version of the one used in Ref. [29]) in the temperature environment provided by a PPMS instrument. A 40 : 60 mixture of light mineral oil and n-pentane was used as a pressure-transmitting medium. This medium solidifies at room temperature in the pressure range of 30 - 40 kbar, [4, 29, 30] which is above the maximum pressure in this work. Elemental Pb was used as a low temperature pressure gauge.[31] It has been shown that in piston-cylinder pressure cells the value of pressure depends on temperature (see Ref. [32] for mineral oil : n-pentane pressure medium and this particular design of the cell). Below we use the Pb gauge pressure value. Given that the upper transition for LaAgSb2_2, highest in the series, is at ambient pressure at ∼200\sim200 K, this may give rise to pressure differences with the values determined by Pb gauge by at most 2 kbar.

Results

Structure and substitution

The x-ray diffraction patterns for all LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 samples were fitted using the GSAS/EXPGUI packages.[33, 34] Small amounts of residual flux were generally observed as impurity phases and were included in the fits as necessary. Figure 1 shows a typical x-ray diffraction data set for the T2 growth of LaAg0.75_{0.75}Au0.25_{0.25}Sb2_2 with ∼1\sim1 wt.% Sb as impurity. In the fit, the occupations of the La, Sb1, and Sb2 sites as well as the total occupation of the T = Ag/Au 2b2b site were fixed as 1, whereas the Ag/Au ratio was allowed to vary. As the parameter that actually contributes to the scattering from a given site in the structure is the average scattering length for that site, it was not meaningful to refine both the Au/Ag ratio and a possible vacancy level using a single measurement (our x-ray diffraction patterns) of the average scattering length. The same (reduced) average scattering could be constructed from Au-only + some level of vacancy, a fully occupied site with Au + some Ag, or some appropriate, and continuously variable combination of Au + Ag + vacancy. The results from Rietveld analysis of the powder x-ray data for LaAgSb2_2 and five LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 samples are listed in Table I and Table II in the Appendix. The EDS results for LaAgSb2_2 and four LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 samples are presented in Table III in the Appendix. The values in the table are the average of the measurements taken at between four and eight different places on the samples’ surfaces, standard deviations are listed in the parentheses.

Figure 1. (color online) Cu-Kα\alpha x-ray diffraction patterns for the T2 growth of LaAg0.75_{0.75}Au0.25_{0.25}Sb2_2 showing the two overlapping data blocks that were co-fitted using the GSAS/EXPGUI packages. [33, 34] The red points are the data and the green lines show the fits with the residuals shown below each fitted pattern. The Bragg markers show the positions of the reflections from (top) Sb, and (bottom) LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2.

Sampleaa (Å)cc (Å)VV (Å3^{3})
LaAgSb2\mathrm{LaAgSb}_2 (T2)4.3915(1)10.8485(4)209.21(1)
LaAg0.75Au0.25Sb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{0.75}\mathrm{Au}_{0.25}\mathrm{Sb}_2 (T2)4.3991(1)10.7669(4)208.36(1)
LaAg0.75Au0.25Sb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{0.75}\mathrm{Au}_{0.25}\mathrm{Sb}_2 (T6)4.3996(1)10.7601(4)208.28(1)
LaAg0.5Au0.5Sb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{0.5}\mathrm{Au}_{0.5}\mathrm{Sb}_2 (T2)4.4074(2)10.6777(6)207.42(2)
LaAg0.25Au0.75Sb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{0.25}\mathrm{Au}_{0.75}\mathrm{Sb}_2 (T2)4.4205(2)10.5715(5)206.52(2)
LaAg0.25Au0.75Sb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{0.25}\mathrm{Au}_{0.75}\mathrm{Sb}_2 (T6)4.4202(1)10.5716(4)206.55(1)
LaAuxSb2\mathrm{LaAu}_x\mathrm{Sb}_2 (T2)[17]4.4430(2)10.4237(4)205.77(1)
LaAuxSb2\mathrm{LaAu}_x\mathrm{Sb}_2 (T6)[17]4.4347(1)10.4653(3)205.88(1)

Table I. Lattice parameters of LaAg1−xAuxSb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{1-x}\mathrm{Au}_x\mathrm{Sb}_2 samples (labels in parentheses indicate initial growth compositions, see Experimental details section for more details).

SampleatomsitexyzoccupancyUeqU_{eq}
LaAgSb2_2 (T2)La2c0.250.250.2397(1)10.0260(5)
Ag2b0.750.250.510.0297(6)
Sb12a0.750.25010.0275(5)
Sb22c0.250.250.6691(2)10.0275(5)
LaAg0.75_{0.75}Au0.25_{0.25}Sb2_2 (T2)La2c0.250.250.2424(2)10.0335(6)
Ag2b0.750.250.50.80(1)0.033(1)
Au2b0.750.250.50.20(1)0.033(1)
Sb12a0.750.25010.0318(7)
Sb22c0.250.250.6696(2)10.0318(7)
LaAg0.75_{0.75}Au0.25_{0.25}Sb2_2 (T6)La2c0.250.250.2418(2)10.0281(7)
Ag2b0.750.250.50.79(2)0.027(1)
Au2b0.750.250.50.21(2)0.027(1)
Sb12a0.750.25010.0275(7)
Sb22c0.250.250.6700(2)10.0275(7)
LaAg0.5_{0.5}Au0.5_{0.5}Sb2_2 (T2)La2c0.250.250.2448(2)10.0366(7)
Ag2b0.750.250.50.54(2)0.042(1)
Au2b0.750.250.50.46(1)0.042(1)
Sb12a0.750.25010.0357(8)
Sb22c0.250.250.6700(2)10.0357(8)
LaAg0.25_{0.25}Au0.75_{0.75}Sb2_2 (T2)La2c0.250.250.2455(3)10.0159(8)
Ag2b0.750.250.50.32(2)0.021(1)
Au2b0.750.250.50.68(2)0.021(1)
Sb12a0.750.25010.0177(8)
Sb22c0.250.250.6999(3)10.0177(8)
LaAg0.25_{0.25}Au0.75_{0.75}Sb2_2 (T6)La2c0.250.250.2453(2)10.0298(6)
Ag2b0.750.250.50.36(2)0.0320(8)
Au2b0.750.250.50.64(2)0.0320(8)
Sb12a0.750.25010.0331(6)
Sb22c0.250.250.6998(2)10.0331(6)

Table II. Atomic coordinates, occupancy, and isotropic displacement parameters of LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 samples (labels in parentheses indicate initial growth compositions, see Experimental details section for more details)

Analysis of the x-ray diffraction as well as EDS results show (Figure 2) that the measured Ag/Au ratio deviates from the nominal with the experimental points for xmeasx_{meas} being slightly below the xmeas=xnomx_{meas} = x_{nom} line with xmeas/xnom=0.88±0.02x_{meas}/x_{nom} = 0.88\pm0.02 and 0.90±0.030.90\pm0.03 for x-ray diffraction and EDS results respectively. In the rest of the text we will use xx - values determined from the x-ray diffraction.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. (color online) Measured vs nominal values of Au concentration xx in LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 (filled symbols). Double filled red circles for xnom=0.25x_{\mathrm{nom}} = 0.25 (not clearly discerned on the plot) and 0.75, as well as double filled black rhombi for xnom=0.25x_{\mathrm{nom}} = 0.25 correspond to T2 and T6 growths, see Materials and Methods section. These data are presented in the Appendix in a tabular form (Table II, III). For example of two red circles at xnom=0.75x_{\mathrm{nom}} = 0.75, higher corresponds to T2 and lower to T6 growth. Data for LaAux_xSb2_2 [17] (open symbols) are added for the reference, here again multiple symbols correspond to different initial La : Au : Sb growth compositions. [17] Dashed line corresponds to xmeas=xnomx_{\mathrm{meas}} = x_{\mathrm{nom}}.

The lattice parameters, unit cell volume and the c/ac/a ratio as a function of Au substitution are presented in Figure 3. All these quantities have an approximately linear dependence of xx, in good agreement with Ref. [18].

Image not extracted

Figure 3. (color online) Lattice parameters, unit cell volume and c/ac/a ratio vs Au concentration in LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 determined from Rietveld refinement (filled symbols). Data for LaAux_xSb2_2 [17] (open symbols) are added for the reference. Dashed lines are guide to the eye.

CDW at ambient pressure

Whereas in the case of LaAux_xSb2_2 the CDW temperatures were significantly affected by initial growth compositions, [17] this appears to be not so critical for LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 with the intermediate Au compositions. For the nominal LaAg0.75_{0.75}Au0.25_{0.25}Sb2_2 and LaAg0.25_{0.25}Au0.75_{0.75}Sb2_2 samples the difference between T2 and T6 initial compositions in the XRD-refined Au concentrations is 0.01 - 0.04 (5 - 6%) (Table II) and in the CDW ordering temperatures 3 - 6 K (2 - 5%), with the difference, not surprisingly, being larger for the latter samples with higher Au concentration. The normalized in-plane resistivity and the CDW ordering temperatures for T2 and T6 samples of LaAg0.75_{0.75}Au0.25_{0.25}Sb2_2 and LaAg0.25_{0.25}Au0.75_{0.75}Sb2_2 are shown in Figure 4(a) and (b) respectively.

Normalized in-plane resistivity and ordering temperatures for LaAg$_{0.75}$Au$_{0.25}$Sb$_2$ and LaAg$_{0.25}$Au$_{0.75}$Sb$_2$

Figure 4. (color online) Normalized in-plane resistivity, ρab/ρab(300 K)\rho_{ab}/\rho_{ab}(300\ \mathrm{K}) and the ordering temperatures CDW1 and CDW2 for T2 and T6 samples with nominal compositions (a) LaAg0.75_{0.75}Au0.25_{0.25}Sb2_2 and (b) LaAg0.25_{0.25}Au0.75_{0.75}Sb2_2.

The overall evolution of the in-plane resistivity of LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 is shown in Figure 5. CDW transition temperatures decrease with Au substitution. The suppression of TCDW1T_{CDW1} is in fair agreement with the prior results. [18] The ambient pressure x−Tx-T phase diagram based on the data of Figure 4 and Figure 5 is presented in Figure 6. The TCDWT_{CDW} values were determined from extrema in the dρab/dTd\rho_{ab}/dT data; an example of which is shown in the inset to figure 5.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. (color online) Normalized in-plane resistivity for LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2. Data are vertically shifted for clarity. The curve for LaAu0.991_{0.991}Sb2_2 [17] is added for the reference. The inset shows an example of dρab/dTd\rho_{ab}/dT for LaAgSb2_2 with two CDW transitions marked.

Transition temperatures CDW1 and CDW2 versus $x-\mathrm{Au}$ in LaAg$_{1-x}$Au$_x$Sb$_2$, with an inset showing RRR versus $x-\mathrm{Au}$

Figure 6. (color online) Transition temperatures, CDW1 and CDW2, as a function of xx in LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2. Data are vertically shifted for clarity. Dashed lines are guide for the eye. The inset shows residual resistivity ratio, RRR=ρab(300 K)/ρab(1.8 K)RRR=\rho_{ab}(300\ \mathrm{K})/\rho_{ab}(1.8\ \mathrm{K}) as a function of xx - Au.

On going from LaAgSb2_2 to LaAuSb2_2, based on electrical transport data, both CDW transitions persist, but both of them are suppressed by ∼100\sim100 K without a significant change of the value of TCDW1−TCDW2T_{CDW1}-T_{CDW2}. The TCDW1(x)T_{CDW1}(x) and TCDW2(x)T_{CDW2}(x) behavior has an upward curvature. Most likely the disorder induced by substitution contributes to additional suppression of CDW transition temperatures, although to the extent significantly smaller than e.g. in 2H-TaSe2−x_{2-x}Sx_x. [35] The presence of substitutional disorder is, expectedly, seen in the evolution of residual resistivity ratio (RRR=ρab(300 K)/ρab(1.8 K)RRR=\rho_{ab}(300\ \mathrm{K})/\rho_{ab}(1.8\ \mathrm{K})) with Au substitution (Figure 6, inset), which shows a broad local minimum for intermediate substitution values. Similar moderate but visible effect of substitutional disorder was observed in studies of superconducting transition temperature in Yx_xLu1−x_{1-x}Ni2_2B2_2C. [36] A clearer example can be found in a similar, isoelectronic substitution in the Mn(Pt1−x_{1-x}Pd+x_{+x})5_5P series. [37]

C CDW under pressure

Note that often (see above) both CDW1 and CDW2 are reasonably well discerned in the derivatives of in-plane resistivity, with the feature associated with CDW2 being less pronounced. Having in mind that (at least in LaAgSb2_2 [15]) the CDW2 wavevector is along the cc-axis, the ρc\rho_c measurements provide better identification of the TCDW2T_{CDW2} with TCDW1T_{CDW1} still being strong. Therefore the measurements for LaAgSb2_2 under pressure were performed in I∥cI\parallel c, H∥abH\parallel ab geometry.

Main panel of the Figure 7 presents cc-axis resistivity data taken for LaAgSb2_2 at different pressures. The overall resistivity is suppressed as pressure increases. The CDW transitions are moving down in temperature. The insets help to quantify above statement. The relative change of the cc-axis resistivity under pressure, is similar for both temperatures presented, 300 K and 50 K, 1/ρc(0)⋅dρc/dP=−(0.012−0.014) kbar−11/\rho_c(0) \cdot d\rho_c/dP = -(0.012 - 0.014)\ \mathrm{kbar}^{-1}. Both CDW temperatures decrease under in a close to linear fashion, with the derivatives dTCDW1/dP=−4.6±0.2 K/kbardT_{\mathrm{CDW1}}/dP = -4.6 \pm0.2\ \mathrm{K/kbar} and dTCDW2/dP=−7.0±0.3 K/kbardT_{\mathrm{CDW2}}/dP = -7.0 \pm0.3\ \mathrm{K/kbar}. Simple, linear, extrapolation suggests that CDW2 will be suppressed to 0 K at ∼25\sim25 kbar and CDW1 at ∼43\sim43 kbar. The observed TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} derivatives are consistent with the published values of −(4.3−5.1) K/kbar-(4.3 - 5.1)\ \mathrm{K/kbar} for CDW1

Temperature-dependent $c$-axis resistivity of LaAgSb$_2$ at different applied pressures, with upper and lower insets showing transition temperatures and normalized resistivity

Figure 7. (color online) Temperature-dependent cc-axis resistivity of LaAgSb2_2 measured at different applied pressures. Upper inset: CDW transition temperatures, TCDW1T_{CDW1} and TCDW2T_{CDW2}, as a function of pressure. Lower inset: normalized resistivity at 300 K and 50 K as a function of pressure.

[19, 20, 21] and - 8.0 K/kbar for CDW2. [21]

In order to extend the pressure dependence of TCDW1T_{\mathrm{CDW1}} and TCDW2T_{\mathrm{CDW2}} across the substitutional series, a similar data set (but for ρab\rho_{ab}) for LaAg0.54Au0.46Sb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{0.54}\mathrm{Au}_{0.46}\mathrm{Sb}_2 (nominal LaAg0.5Au0.5Sb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{0.5}\mathrm{Au}_{0.5}\mathrm{Sb}_2) is presented in Figure 8. The relative change in the in-plane resistivity at 300 K and 200 K is 1/ρab(0)⋅dρab/dP=−(0.009−0.01) kbar−11/\rho_{ab}(0) \cdot d\rho_{ab}/dP = -(0.009 - 0.01)\ \mathrm{kbar}^{-1}, the same as that in LaAgSb2\mathrm{LaAgSb}_2. [20] The initial pressure derivatives of the CDW transitions are dTCDW1/dP=−4.9±0.1 K/kbardT_{\mathrm{CDW1}}/dP = -4.9 \pm0.1\ \mathrm{K/kbar} and dTCDW2/dP=−9.4±0.1 K/kbardT_{\mathrm{CDW2}}/dP = -9.4 \pm0.1\ \mathrm{K/kbar}. For CDW2 simple, linear, extrapolation yields ∼12.5\sim12.5 kbar as a critical pressure of complete suppression of CDW2. Since we cannot observe any distinguishable feature in dρab/dTd\rho_{ab}/dT data at 9.3 kbar below 50 K (see Figure 13 in the Appendix), it is possible that the TCDW2(P)T_{\mathrm{CDW2}}(P) behavior is super-linear and the critical pressure for CDW2 is lower than ∼12.5\sim12.5 kbar obtained from the linear extrapolation. Alternatively, the feature associated with CDW2 could be suppressed so much, that it cannot be detectable within our signal-to-noise ratio and digital differentiation. The data in Figure 9 potentially favors the former possibility. TCDW1(P)T_{\mathrm{CDW1}}(P) dependence has some curvature, the data extrapolate to the value of the critical pressure of ∼26\sim26 kbar.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. (color online) Temperature-dependent in-plane resistivity of LaAg0.54Au0.46Sb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{0.54}\mathrm{Au}_{0.46}\mathrm{Sb}_2 measured at different applied pressures. Upper inset: CDW transition temperatures, TCDW1T_{\mathrm{CDW1}} and TCDW2T_{\mathrm{CDW2}}, as a function of pressure. Lower inset: normalized resistivity at 300 K and 200 K as a function of pressure. Note, some minor corrections of pressure values, following Ref. [17] were applied.

Image not extracted

Figure 9. (color online) Pressure dependence of (a) in-plane resistivity at 2 K (dashed lines are guide to the eye); (b) exponent α\alpha in ρ=ρ0+ATα\rho= \rho_0 + AT^\alpha fit of low temperature resistivity (fit performed between 1.8 K and 20 K) for LaAg0.54_{0.54}Au0.46_{0.46}Sb2_2.

Resistivity derivatives for LaAg$_{0.54}$Au$_{0.46}$Sb$_2$ at 5.2 kbar and 9.3 kbar

Figure 13. (color online) Resistivity derivatives, dρab/dTd\rho_{ab}/dT, data at 5.2 kbar and 9.3 kbar for LaAg0.54_{0.54}Au0.46_{0.46}Sb2_2. Arrows point to CDW transition temperatures. The 5.5 kbar data are shifted vertically by 10 for clarity.

Since for LaAg0.54Au0.46Sb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{0.54}\mathrm{Au}_{0.46}\mathrm{Sb}_2 CDW2 appears to be suppressed to 0 K within our pressure range, we examine if this suppression has any bearing on the low temperature electrical transport. Indeed, the zero applied field data in Figure 9(a) and Figure 9(b) show changes in behavior near 9.3 kbar with the power law exponent, α\alpha, having the clearest signature of a possible transition near the 9.3 kbar. So most probably the value of the critical pressure for CDW2 is around 9.3 kbar. The changes observed are rather subtle, however the features associated with CDW suppression in LaAgSb2_2 [21] and LaAux_xSb2_2 [17] were subtle as well.

Discussion

The pressure dependence of the CDW transitions of LaAgSb2_2, La(Ag0.54_{0.54}Au0.46_{0.46})Sb2_2 and LaAux_xSb2_2 samples is shown in Figure 10. For different members of the family the behavior is very similar. It is noteworthy that the CDW2 suppression rates are almost a factor of 2 higher than those for CDW1. This is possibly due to different effect of pressure on the nesting features along aa- and cc-axes (note that for LaAgSb2_2 the CDW wave-vectors were found to be (0.026 0 0)(0.026\ 0\ 0) and (0 0 0.16)(0\ 0\ 0.16) for CDW1 and CDW2 respectively [15]).

Pressure dependence of CDW transitions

Figure 10. (color online) Pressure dependence of (a) TCDW1T_{\mathrm{CDW1}} and (b) TCDW2T_{\mathrm{CDW2}} for different La(Ag1−x_{1-x}Aux_x)Sb2_2. shown on the same plot. Data for LaAux_xSb2_2 are taken from Ref. [17]. Insets: the same data positioned on universal lines by horizontal shifts, ΔP\Delta P.

The TCDW(P)T_{\mathrm{CDW}}(P) data could be combined on the same universal line by horizontal shift of the data (as shown in the insets to Figure 10). This universal behavior suggest equivalence of the chemical and physical pressure. The approximate scaling is 2 kbar ∼\sim 0.1 xx-Au for CDW1 and slightly smaller pressure shift per 0.1 xx-Au for CDW2. We recall that in a similar way the P−TP-T phase diagrams for Ba(Fe1−x_{1-x}Rux_x)2_2As2_2 with different value of xx were combined to form a universal phase diagram by ΔP\Delta P shifts with 30 kbar ∼\sim 0.1 xx-Ru. [4] In contrast, the pressure and substitution data in the La1−x_{1-x}Rx_xAgSb2_2 (RR = Ce, Nd) series [20] cannot be combined on the same line by ΔP\Delta P shifts. Apparently rare earth and transition metal substitutions in LaAgSb2_2 affect the pressure derivatives of CDW transition temperatures in different manner, with RR-substituted compounds having higher (and RR-dependent) suppression rates. Of course, whereas both Ag/Au and La/R substitutions are isoelectronic, substitution of Ce or Nd for La brings local moment magnetism that substitution of Au for Ag does not.

To gain some further insight on which structural parameter could be of importance for change of the CDW temperature under pressure and with Au substitution we plot TCDW1T_{\mathrm{CDW1}} as a function of basic structural parameters, aa, cc, c/ac/a and VV in Figure 11. For ambient pressure data the structural parameters obtained from the Rietveld refinement are used. For the high pressure data the structural parameters were obtained from the P=0P = 0 values using LaAgSb2_2 elastic constants from Ref. [19] and assuming that their change within the La(Ag1−x_{1-x}Aux_x)Sb2_2 series is insignificant.

CDW1 transition temperature as a function of structural parameters

Figure 11. (color online) CDW1 transition temperature for La(Ag1−x_{1-x}Aux_x)Sb2_2 and LaAux_xSb2_2 [17] at ambient and high pressure as a function of (a) aa; (b) cc; (c) c/ac/a; and (d) VV structural parameters. Encircled points discussed in the text.

The data in Figure 11 clearly show that whereas using aa, cc, and c/ac/a as a structural parameter results in distinctly different trends for chemical and physical pressure, all the data on TCDW1T_{\mathrm{CDW1}} vs VV plot fall fairly well on the same line. To check if this holds for CDW2 as well, we plotted TCDW2T_{\mathrm{CDW2}} vs VV in Figure 12 as well. The TCDW2T_{\mathrm{CDW2}} data also scale with the unit cell volume well. We have few outlier points encircled in Figure 11(d) and Figure 12. These point correspond to measurably off-stoichiometric LaAux_xSb2_2 [17], whereas the rest of the data are for the compounds with stoichiometry very close to 1:1:2. That is possibly the reason for these few point being outliers. The TCDWT_{\mathrm{CDW}} vs VV scaling could be even better if the elastic constants measured for each compound were used, however to address this, further elastic properties measurements should be performed. It is of a surprise, that despite La(Ag1−x_{1-x}Aux_x)Sb2_2 being tetragonal, anisotropic compounds, the chemical and physical pressure appear to be equivalent with a salient structural parameter being the unit cell volume (that lacks any anisotropic information). Hopefully further band structure calculations will be able to address this issue.

CDW2 transition temperature as a function of unit cell volume

Figure 12. (color online) CDW2 transition temperature for La(Ag1−x_{1-x}Aux_x)Sb2_2 and LaAux_xSb2_2 [17] at ambient and high pressure as a function of the unit cell volume, VV. Encircled points discussed in the text.

Summary

Study of compounds of the La(Ag1−x_{1-x}Aux_x)Sb2_2 family at ambient and high pressure show that both CDW transitions are suppressed with Au substitution and under pressure in a manner that indicate equivalence of chemical and physical pressure in this series with the unit cell volume being a suitable structural control parameter and with suppression rates being different for CDW1 and CDW2. Such equivalence of physical and chemical pressure was not observed in the La1−x_{1-x}Rx_xAgSb2_2 series. [20]. Different CDW suppression rates probably reflect the fact that (at least for LaAgSb2_2) the CDW wave-vectors are orthogonal, along aa- and cc-axis for CDW1 and CDW2 respectively.

Additionally, for La(Ag0.54_{0.54}Au0.46_{0.46})Sb2_2 anomalies in low temperature electrical transport were observed in the pressure range where CDW2 is completely suppressed.

Acknowledgments

We thank Warren E. Straszheim for help with the EDS measurements, and Elena Gati and Raquel A. Ribeiro for useful discussions. PCC would like to acknowledge Paul Delvaux for ongoing inspiration. Work at the Ames National Laboratory was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Basic Energy Sciences, Materials Sciences and Engineering Division. The Ames National Laboratory is operated for the U.S. Department of Energy by Iowa State University under contract No. DE-AC02-07CH11358. L.X. was supported, in part, by the W. M. Keck Foundation. Much of this work was carried out while D.H.R. was on sabbatical at Iowa State University and Ames Laboratory and their generous support (again under under contract No. DE-AC02-07CH11358) during this visit is gratefully acknowledged. D.H.R. was supported as well by Fonds Québécois de la Recherche sur la Nature et les Technologies.

Rietveld refinement and EDS results

This Appendix contains tables with the results of Rietveld refinements and EDS chemical analysis of the LaAg1−xAuxSb2\mathrm{LaAg}_{1-x}\mathrm{Au}_x\mathrm{Sb}_2 samples. Data for LaAuxSb2\mathrm{LaAu}_x\mathrm{Sb}_2[17] in the Table I are added for comparison.

SampleLa at.%Ag at. %Au at.%Sb at. %AuAg+Au\frac{\mathrm{Au}}{\mathrm{Ag}+\mathrm{Au}}3(Ag+Au)La+Sb\frac{3(\mathrm{Ag}+\mathrm{Au})}{\mathrm{La}+\mathrm{Sb}}
LaAgSb2_2 (T2)25.4(2)25.9(1)048.7(2)01.05(2)
LaAg0.75_{0.75}Au0.25_{0.25}Sb2_2 (T2)25.6(1)20.4(2)5.08(7)48.9(1)0.199(5)1.03(6)
LaAg0.75_{0.75}Au0.25_{0.25}Sb2_2 (T6)25.5(2)20.2(2)5.40(4)48.9(1)0.211(4)1.03(3)
LaAg0.5_{0.5}Au0.5_{0.5}Sb2_2 (T2)25.6(1)14.8(2)10.50(8)49.2(1)0.415(9)1.01(3)
LaAg0.25_{0.25}Au0.75_{0.75}Sb2_2 (T6)25.7(1)7.4(1)17.7(1)49.28(8)0.71(1)1.00(2)

Table 3. EDS results for LaAg1−x_{1-x}Aux_xSb2_2 samples

B LaAg0.54_{0.54}Au0.46_{0.46}Sb2_2 under pressure

Figure 13 presents the derivatives of the resistivity data taken at 5.2 kbar and 9.3 kbar for LaAg0.54_{0.54}Au0.46_{0.46}Sb2_2 sample.

References

References

  1. [1]Wang, Dong, Ding, Yang, and Mao, Ho-Kwang. Future Study of Dense Superconducting Hydrides at High Pressure. Materials 2021, 14, 7563.DOI
  2. [2]Klintberg, Lina E., Goh, Swee K., Kasahara, Shigeru, Nakai, Yusuke, Ishida, Kenji, Sutherland, Michael, Shibauchi, Takasada, Matsuda, Yuji, and Terashima, Takahito. Chemical Pressure and Physical Pressure in BaFe₂(As₁₋ₓPₓ)₂. J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 2010, 79, 123706.
  3. [3]Paglione, Johnpierre and Greene, Richard L. High-temperature superconductivity in iron-based materials. Nat. Phys. 2010, 6, 645.DOI
  4. [4]Kim, S. K., Torikachvili, M. S., Colombier, E., Thaler, A., Bud’ko, S. L., and Canfield, P. C. Combined effects of pressure and Ru substitution on BaFe₂As₂. Phys. Rev. B 2011, 84, 134525.DOI
  5. [5]Fernandes, A. A. R., Santamaria, J., Bud’ko, S. L., Nakamura, O., Guimpel, J., and Schuller, Ivan K. Effect of physical and chemical pressure on the superconductivity of high-temperature oxide superconductors. Phys. Rev. B 1991, 44, 7601.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9998675
  6. [6]Monceau, Pierre. Electronic crystals: an experimental overview. Adv. Phys. 2012, 61, 325.DOI
  7. [7]Peierls, R. E. Quantum Theory of Solids, Oxford University, Oxford (1955).
  8. [8]Johannes, M. D. and Mazin, I. I., Fermi surface nesting and the origin of charge density waves in metals. Phys. Rev. B 2008, 77, 165135.DOI
  9. [9]Eiter, Hans-Martin, Lavagnini, Michela, Hackl, Rudi Hack, Nowadnick, Elizabeth A., Kemper, Alexander F., Devereaux, Thomas P., Chu, Jiun-Haw, Analytis, James G., Fisher, Ian R., and Degiorgi, Leonardo. Alternative route to charge density wave formation in multiband systems. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 2013, 110, 64.DOI
  10. [10]Zhu, Xuetao, Cao, Yanwei, Zhang, Jiandi, Plummer, E. W., and Guo, Jiandong. Classification of charge density waves based on their nature. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 2015, 112, 2367.DOI
  11. [11]Brylak, Markus, Möller, Manfred H., and Jeitschko, Wolfgang. Ternary Arsenides ACuAs₂ and Ternary Antimonides AAgSb₂ (A = Rare-Earth Elements and Uranium) with HfCuSi₂-Type Structure. J. Solid State Chem. 1995, 115, 305.DOI
  12. [12]Sologub, O., Hiebl, K., Rogl, P., Noël, H., and Bodak, O. On the crystal structure and magnetic properties of the ternary rare earth compounds RETSb₂ with RE = rare earth and T = Ni, Pd, Cu and Au. J. Alloys Compd. 1994, 210, 153.DOI
  13. [13]Myers, K. D., Bud’ko, S. L., Fisher, I. R., Islam, Z., Kleinke, H., Lacerda, A. H., and Canfield, P. C. Systematic study of anisotropic transport and magnetic properties of RAgSb₂ (R = Y, La – Nd, Sm, Gd – Tm). J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 1999, 205, 27.DOI
  14. [14]Seo, S., Sidorov, V. A., Lee, H., Jang, D., Fisk, Z., Thompson, J. G., and Park T. Pressure effects on the heavy-fermion antiferromagnet CeAuSb₂. Phys. Rev. B 2012, 85, 205145.arxiv.org/abs/1203.5164
  15. [15]Song, C., Park, J., Koo, J., Lee, K.-B., Rhee, J. Y., Bud’ko, S. L., Canfield, P. C., Harmon, B. N., and Goldman, A. I. Charge-density-wave orderings in LaAgSb₂: An x-ray scattering study. Phys. Rev. B 2003, 68, 035113.DOI
  16. [16]Bud’ko, S. L., Law, S. A., Canfield, P. C., Samolyuk, G. D., Torikachvili, M. S., and Schmiedeshoff, G. M. Thermal expansion and magnetostriction of pure and doped RAgSb₂ (R = Y, Sm, La) single crystals. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 2008, 20, 115210.DOI
  17. [17]Xiang, Li, Ryan, Dominic H., Straszheim, Warren E., Canfield, Paul C., and Bud’ko, Sergey L. Tuning of charge density wave transitions in LaAuₓSb₂ by pressure and Au stoichiometry. Phys. Rev. B 2020, 102, 125110.DOI
  18. [18]Masubuchi, S., Ishii, Y., Ooiwa, K., Fukuhara, T., Shimizu, F., and Sato, H. Chemical Substitution Effect on CDW State in LaAgSb₂. JPS Conf. Proc. 2014 3, 011053.
  19. [19]Bud’ko, S. L., Wiener, T. A., Ribeiro, R. A., Canfield, P. C., Lee, Y., Vogt, T., and Lacerda, A. H. Effect of pressure and chemical substitutions on the charge-density-wave in LaAgSb₂. Phys. Rev. B 2006, 73, 184111.DOI
  20. [20]Torikachvili, M. S., Bud’ko, S. L., Law, S. A., Tillman, M. E., Mun, E. D., and Canfield, P. C. Hydrostatic pressure study of pure and doped La₁−ₓRₓAgSb₂ (R = Ce, Nd) charge-density-wave compounds. Phys. Rev. B 2007, 76, 235110.DOI
  21. [21]Akiba, Kazuto, Nishimori, Hiroaki, Umeshita, Nobuaki, and Kobayashi, Tatsuo C. Successive destruction of charge density wave states by pressure in LaAgSb₂. Phys. Rev. B 2021, 103, 085134.DOI
  22. [22]Zhang, Bowen, An, Chao, Chen, Xuliang, Zhou, Ying, Zhou, Yonghui, Yuan, Yifang, Chen, Chunhua, Zhang, Lili, Yang, Xiaoping, and Yang, Zhaorong. Structural and electrical transport properties of charge density wave material LaAgSb₂ under high pressure. Chin. Phys. B 2021, 30, 076201.DOI
  23. [23]Akiba, Kazuto, Umeshita, Nobuaki, and Kobayashi, Tatsuo C. Observation of superconductivity and its enhancement at the charge density wave critical point in LaAgSb₂. Phys. Rev. B 2022, 106, L161113.
  24. [24]Du, F., Su, H., Luo, S. S., Shen, B., Nie, Z. Y., Yin, L. C., Chen, Y., Li, R., Smidman, M., and Yuan, H. Q. Interplay between charge density wave order and superconductivity in LaAuSb₂ under pressure. Phys. Rev. B 2020, 102, 144510.DOI
  25. [25]Lingannan, Govindaraj, Joseph, Boby, Vajeeston, Ponniah, Kuo, Chia Nung, Lue, Chin Shan, Kalaiselvan, Ganesan, Rajak, Piu, and Arumugam, Sonachalam. Pressure-dependent modifications in the LaAuSb₂ charge density wave system. Phys. Rev. B 2021, 103, 195126.DOI
  26. [26]Zhao, Lishan, Yelland, Edward A., Bruin, Jan A. N., Sheikin, Ilya, Canfield, Paul C., Fritsch, Veronika, Sakai, Hideaki, Mackenzie, Andrew P., and Hicks, Clifford W. Field-temperature phase diagram and entropy landscape of CeAuSb₂. Phys. Rev. B 2016, 93, 195124.DOI
  27. [27]Canfield, Paul C., Kong, Tai, Kaluarachchi, Udhara S., and Jo, Na Hyun. Use of frit-disc crucibles for routine and exploratory solution growth of single crystalline samples. Philos. Mag. 2016, 96, 84.
  28. [28]Standard Reference Material 676a, NIST (2015).
  29. [29]Bud’ko, S. L., Voronovskii, A. N., Gapotchenko, A. G., and Itskevich, E. S. The Fermi surface of cadmium at an electron-topological phase transition under pressure. Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 1984, 86, 778 [Sov. Phys. JETP 1984, 59, 454].
  30. [30]Torikachvili, M. S., Kim, S. K., Colombier, E., Bud’ko, S. L., and Canfield, P. C. Solidification and loss of hydrostaticity in liquid media used for pressure measurements. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 2015, 86, 123904.DOI
  31. [31]Eiling, A., and Schilling, J. S., Pressure and temperature dependence of electrical resistivity of Pb and Sn from 1 - 300K and 0 - 10 GPa - use as continuous resistive pressure monitor accurate over wide temperature range; superconductivity under pressure in Pb, Sn and In. J. Phys. F: Met. Phys. bf 1981, 11, 623.DOI
  32. [32]Xiang, Li, Gati, Elena, Bud’ko, Sergey L., Ribeiro, Raquel A., Ata, Arif, Tutsch, Ulrich, Lang, Michael, and Canfield, Paul C. Characterization of the pressure coefficient of manganin and temperature evolution of pressure in piston-cylinder cells. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 2020, 91, 095103.arxiv.org/abs/2007.11703
  33. [33]Larson, A. C. and Von Dreele, R. B. General Structure Analysis System (GSAS). Los Alamos National Laboratory Report LAUR 86-748 (2004).
  34. [34]Toby, B. H. EXPGUI, a graphical user interface for GSAS. J. Appl. Cryst. 2001, 34, 210.
  35. [35]Li, Lijun, Deng, Xiaoyu, Wang, Zhen, Liu, Yu, Abeykoon, Milinda, Doorhyee, Eric, Tomic, Aleksandra, Huang, Yanan, Warren, John B., Bozin, Emil S., Billinge, Simon J. L., Sun, Yuping, Zhu, Yimei, Kotliar, Gabriel, and Petrovic, Cedomir. Superconducting order from disorder in 2H-TaSe₂−ₓSₓ. npj Quant. Mat. 2017, 2, 11.
  36. [36]Fuchs, G., Müller, K.-H., Freudenberger, J., Nenkov, K., Drechsler, S.-L., Shulga, S. V., Lipp, D., Gladun, A., Cichorek, T., and Gegenwart, P. Influence of disorder on superconductivity in non-magnetic rare-earth nickel borocarbides. Pramana - J. Phys. 2002, 58, 791.DOI
  37. [37]Slade, Tyler J., Mudiyanselage, Ranuri S. Dissanayaka, Furukawa, Nao, Smith, Tanner R., Schmidt, Juan, Wang, Lin-Lin, Kang, Chang-Jong, Wei, Kaya, Shu, Zhixue, Kong, Tai, Baumbach, Ryan, Kotliar, Gabriel, Bud’ko, Sergey L., Xie, Weiwei, and Canfield, Paul. C. Mn(Pt₁−ₓPdₓ)₅P: Isovalent Tuning of Mn Sublattice Magnetic Order. Preprint 2022 arXiv:2211.01818.

Paper details

vlnc:W_3yfcad28
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents