WorksMathematics
Rational Torsion and Ramification Constraints on Odd Superelliptic Jacobians
Abstract
Let C: y^d = f(x) be a smooth projective superelliptic curve over Q, where d >= 3 is odd, f(x) in Q[x] is separable of degree n >= 3, and gcd(d,n) = 1. Let J = Jac(C) be its Jacobian. We study the rational torsion subgroup J(Q)_tors through the interaction of ramification geometry, Galois actions, reduction at primes of good reduction, and the geometry of divisors. First, we describe the subgroup R_d contained in J[d] generated by the ramification-point differences and determine its Galois-invariant subgroup explicitly in terms of the sizes of the Galois orbits of the roots of f. This yields a precise description of the rational d-torsion classes arising from ramification, without assuming that they account for all of J(Q)[d]. Second, we establish criteria based on the orders of reduced Jacobians that can prove the vanishing of the full rational torsion subgroup. Finally, we derive geometric constraints on divisor classes represented by effective divisors of degree smaller than the genus, including a restriction arising when distinct effective divisors represent the same class. Explicit examples illustrate how the Galois-theoretic and reduction-theoretic methods can be combined to study rational torsion on odd superelliptic Jacobians.
Introduction
Let
be a smooth projective superelliptic curve over , where is odd, is separable of degree , and . Let be its Jacobian, and write for the subgroup of rational torsion points. The study of rational torsion on Jacobians is a central problem in arithmetic geometry: it asks which divisor classes of finite order are defined over the ground field, and how the geometry and arithmetic of the underlying curve constrain their possible orders and structure.
For elliptic curves, the Nagell–Lutz theorem gives an explicit integrality condition for rational torsion, and Mazur’s theorem classifies the possible rational torsion subgroups over [10]. In higher genus, there is no comparable general classification for Jacobians of arbitrary curves. One therefore seeks effective structural information and criteria that can be applied to specific families or individual curves. The geometry of algebraic curves, including special divisors and Weierstrass points, provides important tools in this setting [1, 5]. The arithmetic study of Jacobians also draws on the theory of Néron models and reduction, which provides a framework for relating torsion over number fields to torsion over finite residue fields [3, 12].
For superelliptic curves, the covering structure provides a natural starting point. The map
is a cyclic covering of degree , and its ramification points yield distinguished divisor classes on the Jacobian. The structure of torsion subgroups associated with superelliptic Jacobians has been studied from several perspectives; see, for example, Jedrzejak [7] and Wawrów [14]. The cyclic symmetries of curves and their induced actions on Jacobians also fit into the broader study of group actions and decompositions of Jacobians [8].
Related Diophantine questions involving superelliptic curves have also been investigated. In particular, our earlier work on a generalized fruit Diophantine equation connects a Diophantine problem with the study of superelliptic curves [2]. This provides part of the broader motivation for examining how arithmetic conditions on a curve interact with its geometric structure. The present paper focuses specifically on rational torsion on Jacobians, using ramification classes, Galois actions, reduction at primes of good reduction, and restrictions arising from low-degree divisors. For further background on the arithmetic of curves and their Jacobians, we refer to Hindry and Silverman [6].
The aim of this paper is to combine three complementary approaches to rational torsion: the Galois action on ramification classes, reduction at primes of good reduction, and the geometry of low-degree divisors. The first approach identifies a distinguished subgroup of the geometric -torsion and computes its rational Galois invariants. The second gives criteria that can force the entire rational torsion subgroup to vanish, without assuming that all rational torsion comes from ramification. The third describes geometric restrictions on divisor classes that admit effective representatives of degree smaller than the genus. These approaches answer different questions, and keeping them separate is essential: the ramification calculation alone does not classify all of .
Ramification classes and Galois invariants. Let be the roots of in , and let
be the corresponding geometric ramification points. Since , the curve has a unique point above infinity. The divisor relations
show that the classes
are -torsion and satisfy . We define the ramification-supported subgroup
Although is stable under the absolute Galois group , its generators need not be rational. Consequently,
and equality is not automatic.
The first structural result identifies the abstract group generated by these classes and gives a concrete description of its Galois invariants. The following statements are proved in Section 4.
Lemma 1.1. [Structure of the ramification subgroup] The homomorphism
is surjective and has kernel equal to the diagonal subgroup
In particular,
Theorem 1.2. [Galois invariants of the ramification subgroup] Suppose that the roots of decompose into -orbits
Then there is an isomorphism
Under this isomorphism, corresponds to
This result reduces the computation of the rational classes generated by ramification differences to a single congruence involving the sizes of the Galois orbits. In particular, it shows precisely how the arithmetic symmetry of the branch locus affects this distinguished subgroup.
Corollary 1.3. [The transitive case] If acts transitively on the roots of , then
In particular, if , then
This is a statement about the ramification-supported subgroup only; it does not, by itself, imply that .
Good reduction and rational torsion. The structural results above describe a distinguished part of the rational -torsion, but they do not control every rational torsion class. To obtain information about the full group , we use reduction at primes of good reduction. The underlying principle is standard: if is a prime of good reduction, reduction is injective on the torsion subgroup of order prime to ; see, for example, Hindry–Silverman [6 Theorem C.1.4]. Thus a rational torsion point of prime order forces to divide . Comparing the orders of reduced Jacobians at several primes can therefore eliminate possible prime divisors of rational torsion.
The precise criterion and a convenient sufficient condition are proved in § 7.
Theorem 1.4. [Good-reduction criterion for torsion vanishing] Let be primes of good reduction for . Suppose that, for every prime number , there is an index such that
Then
Corollary 1.5. [A gcd criterion for torsion vanishing] Let be distinct primes of good reduction for , where . Suppose that
and
Then
The theorem gives a prime-by-prime elimination criterion, while the corollary packages it into conditions on finitely many group orders. These results are independent of any assumption that the rational -torsion is generated by ramification classes. When the orders are obtained from point counts or Frobenius polynomials, the criterion becomes an explicit method for proving torsion vanishing.
Geometric restrictions from divisors. A complementary question is how a divisor class can be represented on the curve. Fix the rational point . Riemann–Roch gives effective representatives of degree at most for classes in , while effective divisors of degree map under the Abel–Jacobi map from into a proper subvariety of . These observations do not classify torsion points, but they restrict the geometry of classes with small representatives. The relevant results are established in § 8.
Proposition 1.6. [Effective representatives of degree at most the genus] Every class can be written as
where is an effective divisor of degree for some . More generally, if is represented by a divisor of degree zero defined over , then there exist an integer , with , and an effective divisor of degree defined over such that
Proposition 1.7. [Finiteness of rational points mapping to torsion] Assume . There are only finitely many points for which
is a torsion point. This follows from the Manin–Mumford theorem [11].
Theorem 1.8. [Low-degree divisor constraint] Let , and let be distinct effective divisors of degree . If
then the complete linear system has positive dimension. Equivalently,
The dimension bound for the Abel–Jacobi image and this condition on linear systems are geometric restrictions rather than a complete classification of torsion classes. They complement the reduction criteria by addressing the shape of divisor representatives instead of the prime divisors of their orders.
Examples and organization. Section 7 illustrates how the results interact in explicit examples.
For
the polynomial is irreducible over , so its roots form a single Galois orbit. Corollary 1.3 gives . This alone does not settle the full rational torsion, but the finite-field computations at the good primes 7 and 11, together with Corollary 1.5, give
For the curve
the roots form two Galois orbits of size 2. By Theorem 1.2, the Galois-invariant part of the ramification subgroup is
To determine the full rational 3-torsion in this example, we use the Prym variety associated with the involution . The resulting decomposition of the Jacobian, together with the Galois-module description of Prym 3-torsion, yields
see Section 7.2 and [9 §7.2].
The paper is organized as follows. § 4 fixes notation and conventions. § 5 recalls the background on superelliptic curves, their ramification, principal divisors, good reduction, and Weierstrass points. § 6 proves the structural results for the ramification subgroup and computes its Galois invariants. § 7 establishes the reduction-theoretic criteria for rational torsion vanishing. § 8 develops the geometric constraints from effective divisors and low-degree linear systems. § 9 gives the two examples, and § 10 concludes with further directions.
Acknowledgements
The author gratefully acknowledges the University Grants Commission (UGC), Government of India, for financial support. The author thanks Prof. Kalyan Banerjee for valuable guidance and constructive comments. The author also thanks the Department of Mathematics, SRM University-AP, for providing a supportive research environment.
AI Declaration
ChatGPT was used solely to assist with the literature review and to check grammatical errors in the manuscript. All mathematical ideas, proofs, calculations, and the writing of the manuscript were carried out independently by the author. The author takes full responsibility for the mathematical correctness, originality, and content of the paper.
Relevant Notations and Conventions
Throughout the paper, we use the following notation and conventions.
Base field and Galois groups. The base field is . We fix an algebraic closure and write
for the absolute Galois group. If is separable, then denotes the Galois group of its splitting field over , viewed as a permutation group on the roots of . For a prime , we write for an inertia subgroup at .
Group invariants. If a group acts on an abelian group , we write
for the subgroup of -invariant elements.
The superelliptic curve. Let
be a smooth projective curve over , where is odd and is separable of degree . We assume and write for the genus. The natural cyclic covering is denoted by
Under these hypotheses, the covering has degree and is totally ramified above the roots of and at infinity.
The cyclic action. We write for the group of -th roots of unity in . The automorphism
defines an action of on and hence on its Jacobian. This action is understood over ; it need not be defined over for every .
The Jacobian and its torsion. We denote the Jacobian of by
For a positive integer , the geometric -torsion subgroup is
The rational -torsion subgroup is
We write for the torsion subgroup of . For a prime , we denote its -primary subgroup by .
Ramification points and the ramification subgroup. Let be the distinct roots of . For each , let
be the corresponding ramification point. Since , there is a unique point above infinity, and it is defined over . We write
The principal-divisor relation
implies that . We define the geometric ramification subgroup by
The absolute Galois group acts on by permuting the ramification classes. In particular,
The inclusion is not assumed to be an equality: the ramification subgroup need not account for all rational -torsion.
Divisors and divisor classes. For a nonzero rational function on a curve, denotes its principal divisor. We write when two divisors are linearly equivalent. Whenever a divisor class is regarded as an element of , it is understood to have degree zero. If a divisor involves points defined only over , its divisor class is initially regarded as a geometric class in .
Good reduction. A prime is a prime of good reduction for if has a smooth proper model over . In this case, has good reduction at , and its special fiber is the Jacobian of the reduced curve over . We denote the reduction map on rational points by
We use this map to constrain rational torsion by comparing the orders of Jacobians over finite fields.
Weierstrass points. For a smooth projective curve of genus , a geometric point is a Weierstrass point if its gap sequence differs from the generic sequence . We write for the set of geometric Weierstrass points. This set is finite and satisfies the classical bound
see [1].
Genus formula. Since , the Riemann–Hurwitz formula gives
Symmetric powers and the Abel–Jacobi map. For , we write for the -th symmetric power of , which parametrizes effective divisors of degree . Using the rational point , we define the Abel–Jacobi map
More generally, an effective divisor of degree determines the class .
Background theory
In this section, we collect the geometric and arithmetic facts used in the subsequent analysis. We describe the ramification of the cyclic covering and the resulting genus formula, record the principal divisor relations associated with the covering, and recall the reduction property of Jacobians and the classical bound for Weierstrass points.
Superelliptic curves and ramification
Let
where is separable of degree , is odd, and . We write for the smooth projective model of this curve and set . The natural projection
is a morphism of degree .
Proposition 3.1 (Ramification structure). Let be the roots of in , and put
The map is totally ramified with ramification index above each . Since , there is a unique point above infinity, and the map is also totally ramified at that point.
Proof. At a finite point of the affine curve, the equation is
Since the curve is smooth in characteristic zero, the ramification points of the projection to the -line occur precisely where . Thus , and the defining equation then gives . The finite ramification points are therefore exactly the points . Because is separable, near we can write
Consequently,
so is a local parameter at and
The ramification index at is therefore .
At infinity, the pole orders of and are determined by the equation . Since , there is a single point above infinity, with pole orders for and for . The ramification index there is . These statements also follow from the standard ramification theory of superelliptic curves; see [13 Chapter III].
Proposition 3.2 (Genus formula). Under the hypotheses above, the genus of is
Proof. The morphism has degree and is totally ramified at the finite branch points and at infinity. Applying the Riemann–Hurwitz formula gives
Since , this becomes
and hence
See also [13 Chapter III].
Lemma 3.3 (Good reduction criterion). Suppose that has degree , is separable over , and satisfies . Let be a prime such that
Then the smooth projective model of has good reduction at , and the reduced curve has genus
Proof. The discriminant condition implies that the reduction of modulo is separable and has the same degree . Since , the affine equation
has no singular points over : a singular point would satisfy
The last equation forces , which would give , contradicting separability.
The leading-coefficient condition preserves the degree of the equation after reduction. Moreover, ensures that the cover is tame, and gives the same single point above infinity as in characteristic zero. The smooth projective model therefore has the same ramification structure and genus. These conditions give the standard good-reduction criterion for this superelliptic model; see [4].
Principal divisors from the covering
The ramification points give natural torsion classes in the geometric Jacobian. The relevant relations follow directly from the divisors of and .
Proposition 3.4. For each root of , the following principal-divisor identity holds on :
Consequently,
Moreover,
In particular,
Proof. On , the divisor of is
Pulling this divisor back under and using total ramification at and gives
This proves the first identity and the associated -torsion relation.
At each , the function vanishes to order one. Its only pole is at infinity, where it has pole order . Hence
Passing to divisor classes proves the final relation.
Néron models and reduction of torsion
We recall the reduction property used in Section 5.
Theorem 3.5 (Injectivity on prime-to- torsion). Let be a prime of good reduction for . The reduction map
is injective on the subgroup of rational torsion points whose orders are relatively prime to .
Proof. Since has good reduction at , its Jacobian has an abelian scheme as its good integral model over . The kernel of reduction on -points has no nontrivial torsion of order prime to . Thus a torsion point of order prime to that reduces to zero must itself be zero. Restricting this property to proves the assertion. See [6 Theorem C.1.4].
Weierstrass points
We finish by recalling the classical bound for Weierstrass points. This result is background and is not specific to superelliptic curves.
Theorem 3.6 (Weierstrass-point bound). Let be a smooth projective curve of genus over a field of characteristic zero. If denotes its set of Weierstrass points over an algebraic closure, then
Proof. The bound follows from the classical theory of Weierstrass gap sequences and the total weight formula for Weierstrass points; see [1 Chapter IV].
For comparison, a hyperelliptic curve of genus has exactly Weierstrass points. The bound above applies more generally and will only be used as background in the present work.
The divisor identities in Proposition 3.4 identify the classes as natural geometric -torsion classes. The reduction theorem supplies an independent arithmetic constraint on rational torsion. In the next section, we study the subgroup generated by the ramification classes and its Galois invariants, without assuming that this subgroup exhausts the rational -torsion of .
Ramification Classes and Galois Invariants
Let
where is separable of degree , is odd, and . We work with the smooth projective model of and write . Let be the finite ramification points, and let denote the unique point above infinity. Throughout this section, the points and their divisor classes are considered over .
Put
and define the ramification subgroup
The purpose of this section is to determine the structure of and describe its subgroup of Galois-invariant elements.
Principal Divisors and the Ramification Subgroup
The functions and have divisors
and
Consequently,
Proof of Lemma 1.1. Since , we have . We prove the reverse inclusion.
Let , and choose representatives . Then the divisor
is principal. Hence there exists such that
We first observe that the covering is geometrically cyclic of degree . Indeed, since is separable, it has a simple root, say . Writing , with , we see that is Eisenstein at in . Consequently,
Moreover, fixing a primitive -th root of unity , the automorphism
generates the Galois group
In particular, we have the eigenspace decomposition
where acts on the -th eigenspace by multiplication by . Since fixes each of the points , we obtain
Thus has trivial divisor and is therefore a nonzero constant. Hence is an eigenfunction for . By the above eigenspace decomposition, there exist and such that
For each , the point is totally ramified under , and hence
for every . Since , it follows that
As this holds for every , we conclude that
Therefore , proving that . Hence , and the first isomorphism theorem yields
Remark 4.1. Because , every class in has a unique representative satisfying
Indeed, adding the diagonal vector changes the coordinate sum by , and multiplication by is invertible modulo . In particular, the subgroup can be represented uniquely by sum-zero coefficient vectors.
Galois Invariants of the Ramification Subgroup
The absolute Galois group
permutes the roots of and hence the ramification points . It therefore acts on . Write the decomposition of the roots into Galois orbits as
Proof of Theorem 1.2. By Lemma 1.1 and Remark 4.1, every element of has a unique coefficient-vector representative whose coordinate sum is zero modulo . The Galois group permutes the coordinates of this representative.
Suppose that a class in is Galois invariant. For every , its coefficient vector and the vector obtained by applying represent the same class. Both have coordinate sum zero, so uniqueness implies that the two vectors are equal. Hence the coefficients are constant on each Galois orbit . Write the common coefficient on as . The sum-zero condition becomes
Conversely, any vector satisfying this congruence defines a coefficient vector that is constant on each Galois orbit and whose coordinate sum is zero. It therefore defines a Galois-invariant class in . The uniqueness of the sum-zero representative proves that the correspondence is bijective, and it is plainly a homomorphism.
Proof of Corollary 1.3. There is a single Galois orbit, of size . Theorem 1.2 therefore reduces the invariant condition to modulo . Since is invertible modulo , this forces .
Relation with Rational -Torsion
The subgroup is stable under the Galois action, but its individual generators need not be rational. Since
we have the inclusion
Theorem 1.2 thus gives an explicit description of the rational -torsion classes that are generated by the ramification differences.
It does not, by itself, describe all of . A rational -torsion class may lie outside . Consequently, the vanishing of does not imply the vanishing of without an additional argument controlling the quotient .
The Covering Automorphism and the Base Field
The automorphism
is generally defined over , rather than over . Accordingly, a decomposition into character spaces for the -action must be formulated over a field containing the -th roots of unity, and the action of on those character spaces must be treated separately.
In particular, individual nontrivial character spaces cannot be assumed to be -stable without proof. No isotypic-vanishing hypothesis is needed for the results established in this section: the conclusions above concern only the ramification-generated subgroup and its Galois invariants.
Reduction-theoretic constraints on rational torsion
The ramification and Galois-theoretic analysis of the preceding section describes a subgroup of the rational torsion of the Jacobian. We now complement that analysis with reduction-theoretic constraints on the full rational torsion subgroup .
The basic principle is that, at a prime of good reduction, the reduction map is injective on torsion of order prime to the residue characteristic. Consequently, the order of a rational torsion point imposes divisibility conditions on the finite groups . Comparing these groups at several primes can therefore eliminate possible prime divisors of rational torsion.
In Section 4, we obtained information about the Galois-invariant part of the ramification subgroup. The results below are complementary: they constrain the full rational torsion subgroup and do not require a hypothesis identifying rational -torsion with the ramification subgroup.
Good reduction and torsion constraints
Let , and let be a prime of good reduction for . Write
The following standard result will be used repeatedly.
Proposition 5.1 (Good reduction and prime-to- torsion). Let be a prime of good reduction for . The reduction map
is injective.
Proof. This is the standard injectivity of reduction on torsion of order prime to the residue characteristic; see Hindry–Silverman [6 Theorem C.1.4].
We next record the numerical consequence of this proposition. Let have order . Write
where is the prime-to- part of . The point
has order . By Proposition 5.1, its reduction has the same order. It follows that
In particular, if is a prime divisor of and , then
Thus every prime divisor of the order of a rational torsion point must divide the order of the reduced Jacobian at every chosen prime of good reduction different from that torsion prime.
Elimination of torsion primes by good reduction
The preceding divisibility condition yields a criterion for proving that the rational torsion subgroup is trivial. Proof of Theorem 1.4. Suppose, to the contrary, that . Choose a nonzero torsion point , and let be a prime divisor of . The point
is nonzero and has order .
By hypothesis, there is an index such that
Since has order , its reduction modulo has the same order , by Proposition 5.1. Therefore
a contradiction. Hence .
The hypothesis of Theorem 1.4 can often be verified by computing the orders of the reduced Jacobians. The following convenient sufficient condition accounts explicitly for the possibility that a candidate torsion prime equals one of the chosen residue characteristics.
Proof of Corollary 1.5. We verify the hypothesis of Theorem 1.4 for every prime . First suppose that . If divided for every , then it would divide their gcd, contradicting the assumption that this gcd is 1. Hence there is an index such that
Since , this is the required index.
Now suppose that for some . Since , choose . The second hypothesis gives
and . Thus the required index exists in this case as well. Theorem 1.4 now gives the result.
Application to the superelliptic family
Consider
where is odd, is separable of degree , and
Let . Under these hypotheses, the smooth projective curve has a unique point at infinity, and its genus is
To apply the reduction criteria, choose an integral model of the curve and a set of primes at which that model has good reduction. The set of excluded primes depends on the chosen integral model. In particular, for a model with , primes dividing , the leading coefficient of , or the discriminant of must be excluded when using the usual smooth-model criterion. More generally, denominators introduced when passing from a rational equation to an integral model must also be taken into account. The good-reduction hypothesis should be verified for the model actually used.
For , let and denote the reductions of and , respectively. Set
These finite-field cardinalities are the numerical input for Theorem 1.4 and Corollary 1.3. Indeed, suppose that is nonzero, and let be a prime divisor of . Then
has order . For any with , the reduction of has order , so
Consequently, to prove that the rational torsion subgroup is trivial, it is enough to choose good primes and show that for every prime there is an index such that
In practice, one can factor the integers and use these factorizations to eliminate candidate torsion primes.
The cardinalities can be computed from Frobenius data. With the standard normalization
where the are the Frobenius eigenvalues on the first étale cohomology of , the characteristic polynomial satisfies
Equivalently, the required cardinality can be obtained from the Frobenius polynomial of the curve or Jacobian over . The precise convention for arithmetic versus geometric Frobenius must be kept consistent with the polynomial normalization.
The reduction-theoretic information developed here complements the ramification analysis in § 6. That section computes the Galois-invariant part of the subgroup generated by the ramification classes and places constraints on rational -torsion arising from the geometry of the covering. The present section instead constrains the full rational torsion subgroup by using reductions at suitable good primes. It does not rely on an equality between the ramification subgroup and all of .
The two approaches can therefore be used together. Structural information about , when available, can be combined with the reduction constraints to eliminate possible torsion primes. If the resulting arguments rule out every prime divisor of the order of a rational torsion point, then
The examples below illustrate how finite-field computations can supply the reduction data needed for these criteria.
Geometric constraints on exceptional torsion
The reduction-theoretic results of § 7 constrain the possible prime divisors of through good reduction. We now consider complementary geometric restrictions arising from the degrees of divisors representing classes in the Jacobian.
The key observation is that classes admitting effective representatives of small degree are controlled by the symmetric powers of and their images under the Abel–Jacobi map. Since the -th symmetric power has dimension , these images have dimension at most . In particular, when , they lie in proper subvarieties of . We also explain how equality between classes represented by distinct effective divisors imposes a condition on the associated complete linear system.
Throughout this section, is a smooth projective curve over of genus , , and is a fixed rational point. In our superelliptic setting, the coprimality condition supplies such a unique point at infinity.
Reduced representatives and Abel–Jacobi constraints
We first recall the existence of effective representatives of degree at most .
Proof of Proposition 1.6. Let be a divisor of degree zero over representing . By the Riemann–Roch theorem,
where is a canonical divisor. Since , we obtain
Thus there exists a nonzero rational function such that
is effective. The divisor is defined over and has degree . Therefore,
which proves the first assertion.
For the more general statement, let be the smallest nonnegative integer such that
Such an integer exists by the first part, and . Choose a nonzero such that
is effective. By the minimality of , the effective divisor cannot contain ; otherwise, subtracting would give a nonzero section of when . Hence has degree , and
This completes the proof.
The proposition gives an effective representative of degree . It does not assert that every class has a representative of degree strictly less than . Whenever a class has a representative with , the Abel–Jacobi map places that class in a proper subvariety of , as explained below.
Proof of Proposition 1.7. Consider the Abel–Jacobi embedding
Since , the image is not a translate of a positive-dimensional abelian subvariety of . By the Manin–Mumford theorem [11], the intersection of with the set of geometric torsion points is finite. Consequently, its subset consisting of images of rational points is also finite. This proves the proposition.
Low-degree linear systems
The next result gives a necessary condition for two distinct effective divisors of small degree to determine the same class in the Jacobian.
Proof of Theorem 1.8. The equality of divisor classes gives
and hence . Thus and are distinct effective members of the complete linear system . Therefore contains at least two distinct members, so
Since , we conclude that .
Remark 6.1. For , effective divisors of degree are parametrized by the symmetric power , which has dimension . The Abel–Jacobi map
therefore has image of dimension at most . Consequently, the geometric classes admitting effective representatives of degree lie in a proper subvariety of .
This dimension bound is a geometric restriction; it does not imply that the image contains only finitely many torsion points. Theorem 1.8 provides an additional restriction: if two distinct effective divisors of the same degree represent the same divisor class, then their common complete linear system has positive dimension. These observations constrain the geometry of divisor representatives but do not, by themselves, classify the rational torsion subgroup .
The geometric constraints in this section complement the reduction-theoretic criteria of § 7. Good reduction restricts possible prime divisors of rational torsion through the finite groups , whereas the Abel–Jacobi map and the geometry of linear systems constrain classes admitting representatives of small degree. Neither method alone establishes a general classification of , but they provide distinct restrictions that may be combined when studying a specific curve.
Examples
We illustrate the structural, reduction-theoretic, and geometric constraints developed in the preceding sections through two explicit superelliptic curves. The first example has a transitive Galois action on the roots of the defining polynomial and admits a reduction-theoretic argument for the vanishing of the full rational torsion subgroup. The second example has two Galois orbits of roots and illustrates how the orbit decomposition determines the Galois-invariant part of the ramification subgroup.
A transitive genus-4 example
Consider the superelliptic curve
over , and let .
Since , the genus formula gives
Moreover, is Eisenstein at 2, and hence irreducible over . Thus the Galois group acts transitively on its five roots. There is a single Galois orbit of size .
By Theorem 1.2, the Galois-invariant part of the ramification subgroup is described by
Since , the only solution is . Hence
This conclusion concerns the ramification subgroup only; it does not, by itself, imply that .
We next use good reduction to constrain the full rational torsion subgroup. The discriminant of is
The leading coefficient of is 1. Therefore, the primes and do not divide . Both are primes of good reduction for the curve.
For and , put
Since , the smooth projective model has a unique point at infinity. Thus the projective point count is obtained by counting the affine solutions of
over and adding this point at infinity.
The point counts reported in the manuscript are
| 7 | 8 | 50 | 344 | 2766 |
| 11 | 12 | 154 | 1332 | 15274 |
Table 1.
These counts are stated to have been obtained by exhaustive finite-field enumeration and checked by the same procedure. The SageMath verification is included in Appendix § 11.
We now recover the Frobenius polynomials from these counts. For a prime of good reduction, let
where the are the Frobenius eigenvalues, with the normalization for which
The point-counting formula gives
Writing
the values are the power sums of the Frobenius eigenvalues. Newton’s identities determine the first four coefficients of , and the functional equation determines the remaining coefficients.
For , the point counts give
Newton’s identities give
where denotes the -th elementary symmetric function of the Frobenius eigenvalues. The functional equation then yields
Consequently,
Similarly, for ,
Newton’s identities give
Using the functional equation, we obtain
It follows that
We now verify the hypotheses of Corollary 1.5. First,
Moreover,
Thus the primes 7 and 11 satisfy both the gcd and the cross-divisibility conditions of the corollary. Consequently,
This conclusion follows from the reduction-theoretic calculation and does not depend on any additional hypothesis concerning the ramification subgroup.
A non-transitive example
Consider the curve
over , and let denote its Jacobian. The polynomial
has two Galois orbits of roots, namely
Consequently, Theorem 1.2 gives
Thus the ramification subgroup supplies a nontrivial rational subgroup of order 3. We now determine the full rational 3-torsion of .
Consider the involution
Its quotient is the genus-one curve
The curve has a rational point, so its Jacobian is an elliptic curve over . The change of variables
transforms the equation of into the Weierstrass equation
Consequently, the Jacobian of is isomorphic over to . The point has order 3. Moreover, the 3-division polynomial of is
Its only rational roots are and . The latter does not give a rational point on , since it yields . For , we obtain precisely the points . It follows that
We next study the Prym variety associated with . Write for the Prym variety of the double cover , so that
The curve is a member of the bielliptic Picard family
with and . The smoothness condition in this family is satisfied, since
Thus the Prym results of Laga–Shnidman [9 §2.5, §7.2] apply to this curve. In particular, the natural map
is an isogeny with kernel of order a power of 2. It therefore induces an isomorphism on rational 3-primary torsion, and
It remains to show that .
Let be a primitive cube root of unity and put in . By Lemma 7.8 of [9], the group is a two-dimensional vector space over , with basis
Here the points are viewed as points on the smooth projective model of , and the differences denote their corresponding divisor classes in the Prym.
By Proposition 7.9 of [9], the Galois action on this basis is induced by the action on the root pairs. More explicitly, changing the sign of while fixing sends to and fixes ; changing the sign of while fixing fixes and sends to . Consequently, the representation is
where and are the quadratic characters associated with and , respectively. Since both characters are nontrivial, there are no nonzero Galois-invariant vectors, and hence
Equation (7.3) of [9] gives an exact sequence of Galois modules
where is the quadratic twist of by . Under this twist, the two characters describing the action on the corresponding -torsion become
Both characters are nontrivial. Therefore
Taking Galois invariants in the exact sequence, we conclude that
or equivalently . It follows that
In this example, the rational -torsion is therefore exactly the subgroup supplied by the Galois-invariant ramification classes.
Concluding remarks and further directions
In this paper, we have studied rational torsion on the Jacobians of odd superelliptic curves
where is separable, is odd, and . Our approach combines the geometry of the ramification points of the covering , the Galois action on these points, and reduction-theoretic constraints on rational torsion.
The structural results of § 6 describe the subgroup generated by the classes of the ramification points relative to the point at infinity. They also give an explicit description of its Galois-invariant subgroup in terms of the Galois orbits of the roots of . In particular,
and the orbit structure can therefore yield concrete information about rational -torsion. This calculation concerns the ramification-generated subgroup; without additional arguments, it does not determine all of .
The reduction-theoretic results of § 7 provide a complementary method. At primes of good reduction, the prime-to- torsion of injects into . Consequently, suitable finite-field point counts can eliminate individual prime-primary components of rational torsion. Under the hypotheses of Corollary 1.5, these constraints imply
Thus, the reduction method can establish complete torsion vanishing without requiring a separate hypothesis about the ramification-generated subgroup.
The examples in § 9 illustrate how the Galois-invariant ramification subgroup and reduction-theoretic methods complement one another. For the curve
the transitive Galois action on the five roots implies
The point counts at the good primes 7 and 11, together with the required cross-divisibility conditions, yield
by Corollary 1.5.
For the curve
the two Galois orbits of roots give
Thus the ramification classes provide a nontrivial rational subgroup of order 3. The Prym variety associated with the involution allows us to go further: the quotient curve has Jacobian isomorphic to
and the Prym 3-torsion calculation shows that the Prym contributes no nontrivial rational 3-torsion. Consequently,
This example therefore illustrates how combining the orbit description of ramification classes with the arithmetic of a Prym variety can determine the full rational 3-torsion, rather than only the contribution from the ramification subgroup; see [9 §7.2].
Several questions merit further investigation.
(1) Torsion outside the ramification subgroup. The quotient records the part of the geometric -torsion not accounted for by the ramification classes. Understanding its Galois action, together with the cohomological obstruction associated with
may yield additional criteria for determining . In particular, one should identify hypotheses that genuinely imply the desired description of rational torsion, rather than infer it from the vanishing of quotient invariants alone.
(2) Non-coprime degrees. It would be useful to extend the structural analysis to . In this setting, the points above infinity and their divisor classes require separate treatment, and the ramification relations may differ from those considered here.
(3) Curves over general number fields. The structural and reduction-theoretic arguments can be investigated over a general number field . Such an extension would require accounting for the -action, the residue fields at primes of good reduction, and the corresponding reduction maps.
(4) Finite-field computations. Systematic computation of Frobenius polynomials and Jacobian orders for explicit superelliptic families may provide effective ways to select good primes that eliminate rational torsion. The interaction between these computations and the automorphisms of the covering may also be worth exploring.
(5) Low-degree divisor geometry. The results of § 8 give necessary geometric conditions for distinct effective divisors of degree less than the genus to represent the same divisor class. A more detailed study of the Abel–Jacobi images of , for , may provide further restrictions on rational torsion classes admitting effective representatives of small degree.
Overall, the results show that ramification geometry, Galois symmetry, and arithmetic reduction provide complementary tools for studying rational torsion on odd superelliptic Jacobians. Determining when these tools can be combined into general classification theorems remains an interesting problem.
Finite-field verification for Example 7.1
We verify the finite-field point counts for the curve
over , where and . Since , the smooth projective model has a unique point at infinity. Thus, if denotes the number of -rational points on the projective curve, then
The following SageMath code counts the cube roots of each field element once and then uses these counts to enumerate the affine points. The assertions check the values used in Subsection 7.1.
def point_count(p, k):
F = GF(p^k, name=’a’)
# Count the cube roots of each element of F.
cube_counts = {}
for y in F:
z = y^3
cube_counts[z] = cube_counts.get(z, 0) + 1
# Count affine points satisfying y^3 = x^5 - 2.
count_affine = 0
for x in F:
rhs = x^5 - F(2)
count_affine += cube_counts.get(rhs, 0)
# There is exactly one point at infinity.
return count_affine + 1
expected = {
7: [8, 50, 344, 2766],
11: [12, 154, 1332, 15274],
}
for p in [7, 11]:
computed = [point_count(p, k) for k in [1, 2, 3, 4]]
print("p =", p, "point counts =", computed)
assert computed == expected[p]
The expected output is
p = 7 point counts = [8, 50, 344, 2766]
p = 11 point counts = [12, 154, 1332, 15274]References
- [1]Enrico Arbarello, Maurizio Cornalba, Phillip A. Griffiths, and Joe Harris. Geometry of Algebraic Curves. Volume I. Vol. 267. Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften. New York: Springer, 1985.
- [2]Kalyan Banerjee, Kalyan Chakraborty, and Ankita Das. “Generalized fruit Diophantine equation and super elliptic curves”. In: Monatshefte für Mathematik (2026). DOI: 10.1007/s00605-026-02201-6.DOI
- [3]Siegfried Bosch, Werner Lütkebohmert, and Michel Raynaud. Néron Models. Vol. 21. Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete (3). Berlin: Springer, 1990.
- [4]Irene I. Bouw and Stefan Wewers. “Computing L-functions and semistable reduction of superelliptic curves”. In: Glasgow Mathematical Journal 59.1 (2017), pp. 77–108. DOI: 10.1017/S0017089516000057.DOI
- [5]Marc Coppens. “Weierstrass points of curves of genus 3”. In: Manuscripta Mathematica 67 (1990), pp. 193–213.
- [6]Marc Hindry and Joseph H. Silverman. Diophantine Geometry: An Introduction. Vol. 201. Graduate Texts in Mathematics. New York: Springer-Verlag, 2000. DOI: 10.1007/978-1-4612-1210-2.DOI
- [7]Tomasz Jȩdrzejak. “On the Torsion of the Jacobians of Superelliptic Curves”. In: Journal of Number Theory 145 (2014), pp. 402–425. DOI: 10.1016/j.jnt.2014.06.013.DOI
- [8]Ernst Kani and Michael Rosen. “Idempotent relations and factors of Jacobians”. In: Mathematische Annalen 284 (1989), pp. 307–327.DOI
- [9]Jef Laga and Ari Shnidman. “The Geometry and Arithmetic of Bielliptic Picard Curves”. In: Journal of the London Mathematical Society 112.5 (2025), e70347. DOI: 10.1112/jlms.70347.DOI
- [10]Barry Mazur. “Modular curves and the Eisenstein ideal”. In: Publications Mathématiques de l’IHÉS 47 (1977), pp. 33–186.DOI
- [11]David Mumford. Tata Lectures on Theta II: Jacobian Theta Functions and Differential Equations. Boston: Birkhäuser, 1984.
- [12]Joseph H. Silverman. Advanced Topics in the Arithmetic of Elliptic Curves. Vol. 151. Graduate Texts in Mathematics. New York: Springer, 1994.DOI
- [13]Henning Stichtenoth. Algebraic Function Fields and Codes. 2nd ed. Vol. 254. Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Berlin: Springer, 2009.DOI
- [14]Wojciech Wawrów. “On torsion of superelliptic Jacobians”. In: Journal de Théorie des Nombres de Bordeaux 33.1 (2021), pp. 223–235. DOI: 10.5802/jtnb.1158.DOI