betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Steady Rayleigh–Bénard convection: strongly nonlinear high-wavenumber rolls

Abstract

In Rayleigh–Bénard convection, two-dimensional steady rolls bifurcate supercritically at a Rayleigh number RaRa that depends on their horizontal-to-vertical aspect ratio ΓΓ, and they exist at all larger RaRa despite being unstable. Heat transport by certain rolls—quantified by the Nusselt number NuNu—closely resembles turbulent transport, yet NuNu scalings of rolls are understood only for specific boundary conditions and ΓΓ–RaRa limits. Here we investigate the high-wavenumber limit Γ=O(Ra−1/4)Γ= O(Ra^{-1/4}) as Ra→∞Ra \to \infty, using numerics and matched asymptotic analysis. We compute steady rolls between stress-free boundaries for Prandtl numbers 10−1≤Pr≤103/210^{-1} \leq Pr \leq 10^{3/2} and RaRa reaching 101910^{19}. While the Γ=O(Ra−1/4)Γ= O(Ra^{-1/4}) limit gives smaller NuNu than when Γ=O(1)Γ= O(1), we identify prefactors cc in Γ=c Ra−1/4Γ= c\,Ra^{-1/4} that locally maximize NuNu. These locally NuNu-maximizing rolls display approximate scalings Nu∝Ra0.29Nu \propto Ra^{0.29} and Re∝Ra0.40Re \propto Ra^{0.40}, with the Reynolds number ReRe defined using root-mean-square velocity. Our asymptotic analysis reveals a vertically stacked four-layer structure near each boundary, predicting Nu=O(Ra3/10)Nu = O(Ra^{3/10}) and Re=O(Ra2/5)Re = O(Ra^{2/5}). This asymptotic construction largely follows that of Taylor vortices by \cite{Deguchi2023}, but we identify a thin plume region within the middle boundary layer whose inclusion eliminates the logarithmic factors in Deguchi's predictions. Asymptotic arguments and numerics suggest the same scalings for stress-free or no-slip boundaries, unlike in other ΓΓ–RaRa limits. Our asymptotics extend the weakly nonlinear analysis of Blennerhassett & Bassom (1994) into the strongly nonlinear regime and complement the asymptotics of Chini & Cox (2009) for Γ=O(1)Γ= O(1) rolls.

Introduction

Since its introduction by Rayleigh [25], the canonical model for studying buoyancy-driven flow has been Rayleigh–Bénard convection (RBC), where motion in a horizontal fluid layer is sustained by fixing a higher temperature on the bottom boundary than on the top one. The control parameters can be reduced to the dimensionless Rayleigh number RaRa, which quantifies the effect of the imposed temperature difference across the layer; the Prandtl number PrPr, which captures the relative dissipation rates of velocity gradients and temperature gradients; and the geometry of the domain. As RaRa is raised beyond the threshold for the onset of convection, flows become progressively more complex and eventually turbulent.

A central question about RBC is how mean quantities depend on RaRa and PrPr, especially the Nusselt number NuNu, which is the factor by which fluid flow amplifies heat transport across the layer relative to conduction. There is particular motivation to understand the asymptotic scaling of NuNu with PrPr and RaRa in the Ra→∞Ra \to\infty limit because extreme RaRa values are typical in geophysical and astrophysical convection. For instance, RaRa values on the order of 102510^{25} have been estimated for deep oceanic convection [5], and astrophysical values can be far larger. The values of RaRa needed to unambiguously attain asymptotic scaling behaviours are seemingly beyond the reach of any direct numerical simulations or laboratory experiments to date [17, 1, 5, 10]. In light of this difficulty, a series of recent studies has aimed to determine large-RaRa asymptotic scalings of NuNu not for turbulent convection but instead for simpler steady flows that also solve the equations of motion. Although steady flows are dynamically unstable at large RaRa, they have been found to capture aspects of turbulent convection [30, 27, 32, 31, 35, 18, 9, 34, 20, 21, 23, 12, 14]. The scaling of NuNu with RaRa for certain steady flows is very similar to the scaling for turbulent convection, but the maximum NuNu among steady flows is larger than the corresponding turbulent values at all parameters where a direct comparison has been made [35, 34, 9, 21, 14]. The relationship between steady and turbulent transport remains to be fully understood. A prerequisite to this understanding, which motivates our study, is to know how NuNu scales in asymptotic parameter limits for at least certain types of steady flows.

The present work concerns the simplest type of steady flows: two-dimensional (2D) convection rolls that bifurcate directly from the conduction state. Considering a domain that is horizontally periodic or infinite, roll states consist of horizontally periodic counter-rotating pairs. Such states can be uniquely labeled by the fundamental horizontal period Γ\Gamma (in units of layer height) and the number of rolls mm stacked vertically across the layer. For each (Γ,m)(\Gamma,m), linear stability analysis of the conduction state gives a critical Rayleigh number RacRa_c [4], independent of PrPr, at which a branch of steady rolls bifurcates supercritically. While there are no exact formulas for the roll states at general (Pr,Ra)(Pr, Ra), computations indicate that each solution branch persists for all Ra>RacRa > Ra_c at every PrPr, with NuNu increasing monotonically as RaRa is raised. We confine our investigation to roll pairs that span the layer height (i.e., m=1m = 1). Even for single pairs of layer-spanning rolls, however, the parameter-dependence Nu(Γ,Pr,Ra)Nu(\Gamma, Pr, Ra) is far from fully understood.

Computations of steady rolls at large RaRa have been reported for top and bottom boundary conditions that are stress-free [6, 35] or no-slip [30, 27, 34], and there are both close parallels and key differences between the two cases. In the stress-free case, computations [35] as well as asymptotics [6] indicate Nu∼cn(Γ)Ra1/3Nu \sim c_n(\Gamma) Ra^{1/3} as Ra→∞Ra \to\infty with Γ\Gamma fixed, where the prefactor cn(Γ)c_n(\Gamma) is independent of PrPr in this limit and is maximized for Γ≈1.9\Gamma\approx1.9. In the no-slip case, computations [30, 27, 34] indicate a different scaling: Nu∼cn(Γ,Pr)Ra1/4Nu \sim c_n(\Gamma, Pr) Ra^{1/4} as Ra→∞Ra \to\infty with Γ\Gamma and PrPr fixed. However, one can also consider simultaneous limits in which Γ\Gamma approaches zero or infinity at any rate between Γmin⁡=O(Ra−1/4)\Gamma_{\min} = O(Ra^{-1/4}) and Γmax⁡=O(Ra1/2)\Gamma_{\max} = O(Ra^{1/2}) as Ra→∞Ra \to\infty, where (Γmin⁡,Γmax⁡)(\Gamma_{\min}, \Gamma_{\max}) is the interval of Γ\Gamma for which roll states exist, meaning that Ra>Rac(Γ)Ra > Ra_c(\Gamma). In the no-slip case with Pr=1Pr = 1 and sufficiently large RaRa, the dependence of NuNu on Γ\Gamma has a global maximum and one other local maximum, occurring at periods denoted by Γ∗\Gamma^* and Γloc∗\Gamma^*_{\mathrm{loc}}, respectively. Rolls at each maximum become narrower (i.e., larger-wavenumber) as RaRa is raised, with numerics suggesting Γ∗=O(Ra−1/5)\Gamma^* = O(Ra^{-1/5}) and Γloc∗=O(Ra−1/4)\Gamma^*_{\mathrm{loc}} = O(Ra^{-1/4}), and that the global maximizers Γ∗\Gamma^* give Nu=O(Ra1/3)Nu = O(Ra^{1/3}) (Wen et al. [34]). In the stress-free case, steady rolls have not been computed previously outside of Γ=O(1)\Gamma= O(1), and the scaling of NuNu in simultaneous limits of Γ\Gamma and RaRa has not been studied.

Here, we report computations of steady roll pairs in the stress-free case up to asymptotically large RaRa, for various 10−1≤Pr≤103/210^{-1} \le Pr \le10^{3/2} and over a period range Γmin⁡≤Γ≤2π/10\Gamma_{\min} \le\Gamma\le2\pi/10 that broadens as Ra→∞Ra \to\infty because Γmin⁡=O(Ra−1/4)\Gamma_{\min} = O(Ra^{-1/4}). Figure 1(a) shows the dependence of NuNu on Γ\Gamma at three different RaRa values, which is qualitatively representative of curves we have found at all PrPr when RaRa is sufficiently larger than RacRa_c. As in the no-slip case ([27, 34]), each curve in Figure 1(a) has a global maximum at a larger aspect ratio Γ∗\Gamma^* and a secondary local maximum at a smaller aspect ratio, which we find scales as Γloc∗=O(Ra−1/4)\Gamma^*_{\mathrm{loc}} = O(Ra^{-1/4}). Panels (b) and (c) show examples of the global and local maximizers, respectively. The focus of the present work is rolls whose aspect ratios scale as O(Ra−1/4)O(Ra^{-1/4}), including with the exact Γloc∗\Gamma^*_{\mathrm{loc}} values. We therefore compute rolls at Γ\Gamma values near Γloc∗\Gamma^*_{\mathrm{loc}} over large ranges of RaRa, including parameter sweeps where Γ=cRa−1/4\Gamma= cRa^{-1/4} with constant cc.

Figure 1. (a) Dependence of NuNu, compensated by Ra1/3Ra^{1/3}, on the fundamental horizontal wavenumber k=2π/Γk = 2\pi/\Gamma for steady convection rolls at Pr=1Pr = 1 between stress-free boundaries. Lower-wavenumber solutions with k≤10k \le10 are from Wen et al. [35], and they agree quantitatively with the semi-analytical asymptotic construction of Chini & Cox [6]. Stars indicate the secondary local maxima at k=2π/Γloc∗k = 2\pi/\Gamma^*_{\mathrm{loc}}. (b, c) Rolls at Ra=108Ra = 10^8 with the globally NuNu-maximizing period Γ∗≈1.9\Gamma^* \approx1.9 and the locally NuNu-maximizing period Γloc∗≈0.107\Gamma^*_{\mathrm{loc}} \approx0.107, respectively, that are marked in panel (a). Colors represent the dimensionless temperature, ranging from 0 (cold) to 1 (hot), and arrows indicate the velocity vector field. In panel (c), the horizontal axis is scaled larger than the vertical axis for clarity.

Complementing our numerics, we carry out a matched asymptotic analysis in which the domain is decomposed into four vertically stacked layers, one of which is divided horizontally into two regions. The flow in each of the five regions is described by a different asymptotic reduction of the governing partial differential equations (PDEs). Numerical solution of the reduced PDEs is left for future work, but scalings can be anticipated from the matching conditions between solutions in adjacent regions. The resulting predictions for NuNu and for the Reynolds number ReRe, defined using root-mean-square velocity, are that Nu∼cnRa3/10Nu \sim c_n Ra^{3/10} and Re∼crRa2/5Re \sim c_r Ra^{2/5} as Ra→∞Ra \to\infty with Γ=cRa−1/4\Gamma= cRa^{-1/4}, where the prefactors cnc_n and crc_r generally depend on cc and PrPr.

Our asymptotic construction largely follows the analysis of steady axisymmetric Taylor vortices in Taylor–Couette flow by Deguchi [8], who examined the limit Γ=cRa−1/4\Gamma= cRa^{-1/4} along with several other Γ\Gamma–RaRa limits. Axisymmetric Taylor–Couette flow with an asymptotically narrow gap between cylinders is mathematically equivalent to 2D RBC at Pr=1Pr = 1 (Eckhardt et al. [11]). Here, we argue that RBC rolls satisfying Γ=cRa−1/4\Gamma= cRa^{-1/4} exhibit identical transport scalings under both stress-free and no-slip boundary conditions. However, we propose that Deguchi’s solution structure for the Γ=cRa−1/4\Gamma= cRa^{-1/4} limit is incomplete, as certain matching requirements cannot be satisfied. To address this, we introduce another region into the asymptotic structure—an addition that is also supported by our numerical results. The resulting predictions differ slightly from those of Deguchi in that our scalings do not have logarithmic corrections. Our predictions for the different regions are supported by numerical computations with RaRa up to 101910^{19}. Like the asymptotic construction for Γ=O(1)\Gamma= O(1) rolls by Chini & Cox [6], our analysis is strongly nonlinear. It extends the weakly nonlinear analysis of Blennerhassett & Bassom [2], who also considered the Γ=O(Ra−1/4)\Gamma= O(Ra^{-1/4}) regime but only for Γ\Gamma asymptotically close to Γmin⁡\Gamma_{\min}.

The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 gives the governing PDEs and describes the numerical methods used to compute steady solutions regardless of dynamical stability. Section 3 presents rolls of locally NuNu-maximizing period Γloc\Gamma_{\mathrm{loc}} that we have computed up to Ra=1016Ra = 10^{16}. Section 4 develops a matched asymptotic analysis of such rolls and presents additional computations that support the asymptotic predictions with RaRa as large as 101910^{19}. Section 5 illustrates how rolls transition between different asymptotic regimes as we sweep through RaRa at small but fixed Γ\Gamma values, including the change in flow structure from the solutions of Blennerhassett & Bassom [2] to strongly nonlinear high-wavenumber rolls. Section 6 offers conclusions, appendix A details the relation between our asymptotics and those of Blennerhassett & Bassom [2], and appendix B gives numerical properties for many of the rolls we have computed.

Governing equations and numerical methods

We consider a 2D fluid layer in a domain (x,z)∈[0,Γ]×[0,1](x,z) \in[0,\Gamma] \times[0,1] that has been nondimensionalized so that the vertical (zz) extent is unity and the horizontal (xx) direction is Γ\Gamma-periodic. In dimensionless form, the Boussinesq equations generally used to model RBC can be expressed as

∂tu+u⋅∇u=−∇p+(Pr/Ra)1/2∇2u+Tz^,\partial_t \mathbf{u}+\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}=-\nabla p+(Pr/Ra)^{1/2}\nabla^2\mathbf{u}+T\hat{\mathbf{z}},
∇⋅u=0,\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}=0,
∂tT+u⋅∇T=(PrRa)−1/2∇2T,(1)\partial_t T+\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla T=(PrRa)^{-1/2}\nabla^2T, \tag*{(1)}

References

  1. [1]AHLERS, G., GROSSMANN, S. & LOHSE, D. 2009 Heat transfer and large scale dynamics in turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Rev. Mod. Phys. 81, 503–537.DOI
  2. [2]BLENNERHASSETT, P. J. & BASSOM, A. P. 1994 Nonlinear high-wavenumber Bénard convection. IMA J. Appl. Math. 52, 51–77.DOI
  3. [3]BOYD, J. P. 2000 Chebyshev and Fourier Spectral Methods, 2nd edn. Dover.
  4. [4]CHANDRASEKHAR, S. 1981 Hydrodynamic and Hydromagnetic Stability. Dover.
  5. [5]CHILLÀ, F. & SCHUMACHER, J. 2012 New perspectives in turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Eur. Phys. J. E 35, 58.DOI
  6. [6]CHINI, G. P. & COX, S. M. 2009 Large Rayleigh number thermal convection: Heat flux predictions and strongly nonlinear solutions. Phys. Fluids 21, 083603.DOI
  7. [7]CHINI, G. P., MICHEL, G., JULIEN, K., ROCHA, C. B. & CAULFIELD, C. P. 2022 Exploiting self-organized criticality in strongly stratified turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 933, A22.
  8. [8]DEGUCHI, K. 2023 On high-Taylor number Taylor vortices. J. Fluid Mech. 967, A11.DOI
  9. [9]DING, Z. & WU, J. 2021 Coherent heat transport in two-dimensional penetrative Rayleigh–Bénard convection. J. Fluid Mech. 920, A48.
  10. [10]DOERING, C. R. 2020 Turning up the heat in turbulent thermal convection. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 117, 9671–9673.
  11. [11]ECKHARDT, B., DOERING, C. R. & WHITEHEAD, J. P. 2020 Exact relations between Rayleigh–Bénard and rotating plane Couette flow in two dimensions. J. Fluid Mech. 903, R4.
  12. [12]FENG, Z. 2025 Steady solutions of Rayleigh–Bénard convection between Navier-slip boundaries. Phys. Rev. Fluids 10, 053502.
  13. [13]HASSANZADEH, P., CHINI, G. P. & DOERING, C. R. 2014 Wall to wall optimal transport. J. Fluid Mech. 751, 627–662.
  14. [14]HE, X., MOTOKI, S., DEGUCHI, K. & KAWAHARA, G. 2026 High-Rayleigh-number asymptotic classical scaling in three-dimensional steady natural convection. J. Fluid Mech. 1028, A5.
  15. [15]HERRING, J. R. 1963 Investigation of problems in thermal convection. J. Atmos. Sci. 20, 325–338.
  16. [16]HEWITT, D. R., NEUFELD, J. A. & LISTER, J. R. 2012 Ultimate regime of high Rayleigh number convection in a porous medium. Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 224503.
  17. [17]KADANOFF, L. P. 2001 Turbulent heat flow: Structures and scaling. Phys. Today 54, 34–39.
  18. [18]KOOLOTH, P., SONDAK, D. & SMITH, L. M. 2021 Coherent solutions and transition to turbulence in two-dimensional Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Phys. Rev. Fluids 6, 013501.
  19. [19]MICHEL, G. & CHINI, G. P. 2019 Multiple scales analysis of slow–fast quasi-linear systems. Proc. R. Soc. A 475, 20180630.
  20. [20]MOTOKI, S., KAWAHARA, G. & SHIMIZU, M. 2021 Multi-scale steady solution for Rayleigh–Bénard convection. J. Fluid Mech. 914, A14.
  21. [21]MOTOKI, S., KAWAHARA, G. & SHIMIZU, M. 2022 Steady thermal convection representing the ultimate scaling. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 380, 20210037.
  22. [22]O’CONNOR, L., LECOANET, D. & ANDERS, E. H. 2021 Marginally stable thermal equilibria of Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Phys. Rev. Fluids 6, 093501.
  23. [23]OUYANG, Z., WANG, Q., LI, K., WEN, B. & DING, Z. 2025 Touching the classical scaling in penetrative convection. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 122, e2418468122.
  24. [25]RAYLEIGH, LORD 1916 On convection currents in a horizontal layer of fluid, when the higher temperature is on the under side. Philos. Mag. 32, 529–546.
  25. [26]SCHLICHTING, H. & GERSTEN, K. 2016 Boundary-Layer Theory. Springer.
  26. [27]SONDAK, D., SMITH, L. M. & WALEFFE, F. 2015 Optimal heat transport solutions for Rayleigh–Bénard convection. J. Fluid Mech. 784, 565–595.
  27. [28]Souza, A. N., Tobasco, I. & Doering, C. R. 2020 Wall-to-wall optimal transport in two dimensions. J. Fluid Mech. 889, A34.DOI
  28. [29]Trefethen, L. N. 2000 Spectral Methods in MATLAB. SIAM.DOI
  29. [30]Waleffe, F., Boonkasame, A. & Smith, L. M. 2015 Heat transport by coherent Rayleigh–Bénard convection. Phys. Fluids 27, 051702.DOI
  30. [31]Wen, B. & Chini, G. P. 2018 Inclined porous medium convection at large Rayleigh number. J. Fluid Mech. 837, 670–702.DOI
  31. [32]Wen, B., Corson, L. T. & Chini, G. P. 2015 Structure and stability of steady porous medium convection at large Rayleigh number. J. Fluid Mech. 772, 197–224.DOI
  32. [33]Wen, B., Ding, Z., Chini, G. P. & Kerswell, R. R. 2022a Heat transport in Rayleigh–Bénard convection with linear marginality. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 380, 20210039.DOI
  33. [34]Wen, B., Goluskin, D. & Doering, C. R. 2022b Steady Rayleigh–Bénard convection between no-slip boundaries. J. Fluid Mech. 933, R4.DOI
  34. [35]Wen, B., Goluskin, D., LeDuc, M., Chini, G. P. & Doering, C. R. 2020 Steady Rayleigh–Bénard convection between stress-free boundaries. J. Fluid Mech. 905, R4.DOI
  35. [36]Whitehead, J. P. & Doering, C. R. 2011 Ultimate state of two-dimensional Rayleigh–Bénard convection between free-slip fixed-temperature boundaries. Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 244501.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_43nj5hpv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents