WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Scalar Casimir Effect from Bilocal Correlations in a Wormhole Foam
Abstract
We determine how spatially bilocal correlations induced by a dilute ensemble of virtual Euclidean wormholes modify the scalar Casimir interaction between parallel Dirichlet plates. From the leading monopole action, we isolate an equal-Euclidean-time sector and construct a point-throat, first-order matched spectator model with fixed foam statistics. Global two-plate inclusion-exclusion over all mouth-pair center positions yields a continuous fixed-separation kernel free of the logarithmic image structures produced by a restricted translation sector. The kernel is quadratically suppressed at coincidence, changes sign near 0.695 plate spacings, and tends to a positive large-separation plateau. Averaging over truncated-Gaussian, log-normal, and Gamma distributions with a common relative width yields closely spaced energy curves but a finite shape dependence. Differentiating the dimensional energy at fixed ensemble parameters gives a leading-order pressure threshold of 0.05 in the large-separation limit. In the truncated-Gaussian scan extending to twelve plate spacings, an amplitude of 0.06 yields a crossover near a separation ratio of 3.17, whereas amplitudes of 0.02 and 0.04 remain attractive and 0.05 is critical. The scalar cavity therefore provides a scale-selective probe of spatial bilocality whose leading boundary response can change sign within the declared model.
Introduction
The Casimir effect is among the clearest manifestations of how boundaries alter the spectrum of quantum fields and generate a finite interaction after boundary-independent and isolated-body contributions are removed [1–3]. Its significance does not require identifying the measured force with an absolute vacuum energy: the observable is the change induced by the boundary configuration, a distinction that is especially important when the Casimir effect is used to test modifications of field propagation or additional weak interactions [4].
The quantum-field-theoretic treatment of ideal boundaries has clarified both the utility and the limitations of such models. Boundary conditions can be formulated as controlled limits of interactions with background fields, while finite forces between rigid bodies may coexist with nonuniversal surface self-energies [5, 6]. Rigorous attraction results also exist for reflection-related configurations under specified positivity assumptions [7]; consequently, any sign change produced by an additional nonlocal kernel must be interpreted within the assumptions of that effective theory rather than as a contradiction of a universal attraction principle.
Casimir forces have been measured over micrometre and submicrometre ranges with torsion-balance, atomic-force microscope, and micromachined-oscillator techniques [8, 9, 10]. Relating an ideal calculation to those measurements requires the electromagnetic field and a controlled treatment of optical response, temperature, geometry, roughness, and electrostatic systematics [11, 12, 13, 14]. In the present work, this experimental record motivates the use of a Casimir cavity as a sensitive boundary observable; it does not provide a direct constraint on the ideal massless-scalar model developed below.
At a more fundamental level, quantum fluctuations of geometry and topology motivated the spacetime-foam picture, beginning with Wheeler’s geometrodynamical arguments and later Euclidean path-integral constructions [15, 16]. Modern assessments emphasize that spacetime foam denotes a family of proposals whose physical content depends on the underlying quantum-gravity framework and whose phenomenological status remains model dependent [17]. A gas of virtual wormholes is therefore treated here as a specific effective realization of this broader idea, not as an experimentally established microscopic description of the vacuum.
Euclidean wormholes and baby universes have been studied as mechanisms capable of inducing low-energy interactions and modifying the treatment of couplings or quantum coherence [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23]. This literature also contains longstanding questions about the gravitational path integral, negative modes, factorization, and the Lorentzian interpretation of Euclidean saddles; a contemporary review makes clear that the associated particle-physics and cosmological consequences are conditional on how those issues are resolved [24]. We accordingly use the Euclidean-wormhole framework as an effective model input and keep its continuation and microscopic interpretation distinct from the boundary calculation itself.
The specific starting point is the statistical program developed by Savelova and by Kirillov and Savelova, in which a dilute ensemble of Euclidean wormholes modifies scalar Green functions and generates a leading bilocal contribution to the scalar effective action [25, 26]. Subsequent studies in the same program have examined arbitrary wormhole distribution functions, possible fractal or relic populations, and consequences for cosmological, scattering, and gravitational responses [27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32]. These works motivate a statistical treatment of mouth separations, but they do not determine the equal-time reduction, the benchmark separation distributions, or the Casimir kernel adopted in this paper.
Nonlocal quantum field theories require particular care because a Euclidean kernel does not by itself define a causal and unitary Lorentzian theory. Foundational and later analyses show that analyticity, continuation prescriptions, initial-value structure, and the definition of amplitudes are essential to that question [33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39]. We therefore restrict the wormhole ensemble to equal Euclidean time so that the retained bilocality is spatial and the effective interaction is local in time after continuation. This is an explicit model reduction: it excludes the complementary unequal-time sector and does not establish reflection positivity or unitarity for the unreduced wormhole theory.
Nonlocality is not new to Casimir physics. Nonlocal interactions concentrated near material boundaries, nonlocal scalar propagators with continuous massive spectra, and boundary effective actions with geometrically organized nonlocal terms have all been investigated [40, 41, 42]. These studies establish that boundary vacuum energies can respond to nonlocal kernels, but their kernels arise from different physical constructions. To our knowledge, the Casimir response generated specifically by the spatial bilocal kernel of a statistical Euclidean wormhole ensemble, including an average over mouth-separation distributions, has not previously been worked out.
The existing literature connecting Casimir observables and wormholes follows two other directions that must be separated from the present problem. In one, a quantum field is quantized in a prescribed Lorentzian wormhole geometry, so the background spacetime modifies the spectrum or local vacuum energy of the cavity [43, 44, 45, 46]. Here the plates instead remain in an ordinary flat-background boundary problem, while the virtual Euclidean ensemble modifies the scalar two-point structure through correlations between its mouths.
In the other direction, Casimir or Casimir-like negative energies are investigated as sources capable of sustaining Lorentzian wormhole geometries, including long-throat, semiclassical-foam, quantum-gravity-inspired, and modified-gravity constructions [47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53]. The causal role is reversed in our setting: Casimir energy does not support a wormhole, and no individual wormhole is the cavity background. The cavity is used as a probe of an externally specified statistical correlation structure.
Our objective is to determine, within a dilute point-throat and leading-monopole approximation, how this spatially bilocal structure changes the interaction energy and pressure of a massless scalar field between parallel Dirichlet plates. We adopt an explicit matched boundary prescription in which the foam is a fixed spectator ensemble, the scalar Green functions are defined on the plate-separated components, the two-plate inclusion-exclusion difference is formed before the mouth-pair center is integrated over the full normal line, and the result is averaged over a normalized separation density. Three positive-support families matched at the same mean and coefficient of variation are used to measure residual shape dependence. The energy and pressure are kept distinct, and any attraction-repulsion boundary is reported only for the retained leading-order kernel.
The resulting framework provides a scale-selective test of the effective nonlocal correlation rather than a microscopic prediction for the abundance or distribution of wormholes. It also separates what is demonstrated from what remains open: the calculation establishes the scalar Dirichlet response of the equal-time spectator model, whereas an electromagnetic extension, realistic material boundaries, a microscopic derivation of the separation distribution, unequal-time correlations, and foam backreaction are required before contact with experimental bounds or a broader Lorentzian claim can be made.
This paper is organized as follows. Section II develops the bilocal scalar action, defines the equal-time spatial ensemble, and checks its momentum-space normalization. Section III constructs the globally subtracted parallel-plate kernel and analyzes its limiting behavior. Section IV averages that kernel over general and benchmark mouth-separation distributions and obtains the total interaction energy. Section V derives the physical pressure, assesses perturbative control, identifies the leading-order attraction-repulsion regimes, and discusses the phenomenological scope. Section VI summarizes the conclusions, while the appendices document the global center integration and the numerical implementation, and compare the matched spectator prescription with an alternative one in which the mouth pairs are confined to the slab.
Bilocal scalar action and equal-time spatial reduction
In this section we begin with the free scalar field and then introduce the leading bilocal monopole inherited from the Euclidean-foam construction. Only after that source term is stated do we define the equal-time isotropic ensemble, derive its momentum-space normalization, and formulate the first-order vacuum correction. Boundary assumptions are postponed to the next section. Throughout this section we use Euclidean signature and natural units, , and write for the physical dimension of length.
Bilocal effective action and equal-time reduction
We consider a massless real scalar field in four-dimensional Euclidean space, where is a Euclidean spacetime point and is a Euclidean index, with free action
and . For two Euclidean points and , the corresponding free Green function satisfies
For the nonzero displacement , its four-dimensional kernel is
Equation (3) is the kernel for ; its coincidence limit is singular. Equation (2) holds in the distributional sense, and only finite subtracted combinations are retained when the vacuum observable is constructed.
Now, let be the throat radius, the two mouth positions, the collection of wormhole parameters, and the ensemble density with measure . In the dilute-wormhole approximation, the leading monopole contribution to the scalar effective action derived by Kirillov and Savelova is bilocal [26],
In the full geometric construction a wormhole may also carry a relative gluing orientation between its mouths. At the lowest-monopole level retained in Eq. (4), however, the scalar contribution is independent of this orientation, so that the relevant parameters may be represented by [25, 26]. The essential feature of Eq. (4) is therefore that the foam does not introduce an additional local scalar degree of freedom: it couples two values of the same field evaluated at the wormhole mouths.
For a homogeneous Euclidean ensemble, specialize to the position of a reference mouth and define the mouth-separation four-vector . Translational invariance then gives
Since the scalar field has , dimensional consistency requires the four-dimensional ensemble density to have . With the measure , the integrated event intensity consequently has , where
Our purpose is to isolate a sector in which the foam-induced interaction remains spatially nonlocal but becomes local in time after Wick rotation. We therefore do not identify the original ensemble with an one ( is the -dimensional orthogonal group); instead, we write and define the reduced equal-Euclidean-time ensemble by imposing
Because , one has . Thus, the reduced event intensity, defined as
has . Therefore, is not a three-dimensional number density of persistent wormholes. It is the intensity of the delta-supported Euclidean ensemble selected by Eq. (7), and in general it need not be numerically equal to .
For identical throats of radius , retained at leading monopole order, and an isotropic distribution of the spatial mouth separation, let denote the normalized radial probability density,
and let be the throat-radius integration variable. Thus, we write
This describes the separation of the two mouths within the reduced ensemble, rather than a microscopic prediction for the foam distribution. More general wormhole distributions have been considered in the Euclidean foam framework [27]; here remains arbitrary. It is important to emphasize that finite spherical throats can be nonoverlapping only if . Here, we use point-throat geometry in the radial average, extend the integral to , and retain only the leading monopole coupling. For finite , the excluded probability is not quantified by the present reduction.
Also, it is useful to let denote Euclidean time and to choose the mouth midpoint as the spatial center coordinate,
Let be the solid-angle measure of the unit vector ; division by implements isotropy. Substituting Eqs. (7) and (10) into Eq. (5) then gives
From this point onward we abbreviate . Notice that the combination is dimensionless, providing an immediate dimensional check of the reduced action. Also note that the restriction in Eq. (7) is therefore a modeling choice rather than a claim that the original Euclidean wormhole ensemble is intrinsically . It selects the equal-time spatially nonlocal sector retained in the effective theory.
Momentum-space representation and normalization check
The momentum-space representation of Eq. (12) provides an independent normalization check and identifies the scale dependence of the quadratic insertion. Let be the Euclidean frequency and the spatial wave-number magnitude. We use the Euclidean Fourier convention
The field difference entering the bilocal interaction becomes
After squaring this expression and integrating over and , the momentum-conserving delta functions collapse the second Fourier integral. Using and comparing the result with the standard quadratic form, one obtains
where
For an isotropic distribution, the angular average is the spherical Bessel function of order zero ,
Now, defining the isotropic spatial form factor of the mouth-separation distribution by
we can write the quadratic insertion as
This insertion therefore has , matching the dimension of the free quadratic kernel in Eq. (2).
Equation (19) also provides a direct normalization check against the original four-dimensional foam result. For a homogeneous wormhole distribution, let denote Euclidean four-momentum and let denote the Fourier transform of the separation density. Kirillov and Savelova write the leading momentum-space correction in the form [26]
Applying the equal-time distribution of Eqs. (7)–(10) gives
The right-hand side is independent of because the imposed equal-time density is supported at . Thus the equal-time reduction introduces no additional numerical factor into the leading quadratic insertion. This agreement also provides an independent check of the normalization of Eq. (12). The calculation retains the full spatial form factor rather than a finite derivative expansion. It therefore does not identify the kernel with a Pauli–Villars regulator or draw a Lorentzian stability conclusion from the Euclidean expression.
The insertion characterizes the translationally invariant reduced ensemble in unbounded space. We now express the same first-order term through a background-generic bilocal Green-function combination.
First-order vacuum functional
Let
denote evaluated at , and the expectation in that Gaussian theory. Expanding to first order in the dilute-foam interaction gives
At this stage the Green function is left unspecified; the boundary geometry is introduced in the next section.
For a fixed pair of mouths,
Hence, at first order in the event intensity and at leading monopole order in , the dependence on a subsequently chosen background is encoded in the same bilocal Green-function combination,
Substitution into Eq. (12) gives
For a static configuration of Euclidean duration , the associated vacuum-energy correction is
It is important to highlight that equation (26) is background-generic and is not yet a Casimir observable. The next section specifies the boundary Green functions and defines the corresponding finite interaction subtraction.
Parallel-plate cavity and the fixed-separation kernel
Section II fixed the free field, the equal-time ensemble, and its leading bilocal interaction without boundaries. We now add the boundary-matching postulate: is used as a quadratic effective action for a scalar field obeying Dirichlet conditions, the wormhole distribution is held fixed, the scalar Gaussian average is taken, and the two-plate inclusion-exclusion difference is formed last. We call this the matched spectator model.
Dirichlet Green function and interaction subtraction
Let be the Cartesian coordinate normal to the plates, their separation, and their area, with the infinite-area limit understood. The ideal Dirichlet plates occupy and , where . Energies and forces will be reported per unit area. For reference, the standard massless scalar Casimir energy and pressure are [2, 3]
For Euclidean points and , write and . The Euclidean Dirichlet Green function between the two plates can be represented by the image series, where labels the images,
The first term generates the translational images, whereas the second implements the reflections required by the Dirichlet boundaries. The Casimir interaction must be isolated from the free-space vacuum contribution and from the self-energies associated with either plate separately. Let and denote the Green functions for the isolated plates at and , respectively. We therefore introduce the inclusion-exclusion combination
In particular, the ultraviolet-divergent local coincidence piece is common to the four Green functions and cancels from Eq. (30).
For the bilocal interaction derived in § 0.2, the relevant quantity is not a single Green function but the combination in Eq. (25). The boundary-dependent counterpart is therefore
The inclusion-exclusion subtraction must be formed for this complete bilocal combination before any image or spatial sector is discarded. This ordering is essential because the cross-mouth term probes configurations in which the two mouths can occupy different regions separated by the plates.
The Green functions in Eq. (30) are defined component by component. Equation (29) applies inside the slab; exterior components and the one-plate problems use the corresponding single-image Green functions, while propagation across an ideal Dirichlet plate is set to zero. This prescription specifies the boundary model, but it is an imposed extension of the homogeneous bilocal kernel: the source construction does not determine whether a virtual mouth pair couples scalar regions that an ideal plate disconnects. An alternative prescription, in which only pairs with both mouths inside the slab are retained, is compared in Appendix C; it preserves the sign structure of the kernel but changes the quantitative thresholds.
For a nonnegative normalized , Eq. (19) is nonnegative in unbounded Euclidean space. This does not determine the sign of the Casimir interaction because the inclusion-exclusion operation in Eq. (30) acts on a difference of Green functions and need not preserve the sign of the free insertion.
Under the boundary-matching prescription stated at the beginning of this section, the plates constrain the scalar field but do not confine or rearrange the virtual-wormhole ensemble. The center of a mouth pair is consequently integrated over the full normal coordinate. Let denote the normal component of that center, with domain , rather than only over . Configurations with two mouths inside the slab, one mouth inside and one outside, and both mouths outside must therefore all be retained. Their explicit geometric decomposition is given in Appendix A.
Geometry of a spatial mouth pair
For a fixed mouth separation , let denote the angle between and the normal to the plates. We define
Reflection symmetry about the plate normal allows the angular average to be restricted to . It is convenient to introduce the dimensionless variables
where and are respectively the normal and parallel mouth separations in units of . The integration domain is , , , and . The endpoint is the formal coincident-mouth limit of the point-throat model; it is not allowed for two finite nonoverlapping throats. Because , Eq. (33) gives a nonnegative normal separation .
The dimensionless center coordinate and the two normal mouth coordinates are
This makes the origin of the two geometric sectors transparent. For , both mouths lie between the plates when . At this interval shrinks to zero, while for the two mouths can instead straddle the complete slab, with one below and the other above . The global center integral must therefore be evaluated separately for and . The complete interval decomposition, including the one-inside/one-outside and both-outside sectors, is displayed in Appendix A.
Global fixed-separation kernel
For a monodisperse mouth separation , Eq. (27) and the interaction subtraction above give, to first order in the event intensity and at leading order in , an energy per unit area that we express through the dimensionless fixed-pair response as
The overall scaling follows directly from dimensional analysis: , as required for an energy per unit area.
From here on, distances are measured in units of . The free propagator is , where is the distance between the two points. To remove the factor and the dimension of , we work with the dimensionless combination
In this combination, each free-propagator term of (between a mouth and one of its images) contributes simply , where is the distance in units of ; for example, a distance contributes . We insert Eq. (31) into Eq. (26) and divide by as in Eq. (27). The integral over the directions parallel to the plates gives the area , the angular average equals by reflection symmetry (Eq. (32)), and we write . Comparison with Eq. (35) then gives, for fixed ,
Two kinds of terms appear. The coincident-mouth terms do not depend on : their global integral is for each mouth (the slab contributes and the two exterior regions together; see Appendix A). The cross-mouth term defines the function
the globally integrated correlation between the two mouths. The functions defined next are the pieces of obtained by splitting the integral according to where the two mouths lie relative to the plates (see Appendix A): is the sum over translational images when both mouths are inside the slab, minus the free-space term; is the sum over reflections in the two plates, minus the single-plate reflections already removed by Eq. (30); and the arctangent terms come from the sectors in which at least one mouth lies outside the slab.
For , the translational-image contribution is
and the reflected residual is
The global center integration then yields
The factor arises from the translational-image contribution over the interval in which both mouths lie inside the slab, whereas is the reflected residual left by the complete two-plate subtraction. The remaining arctangent term collects the sectors with at least one mouth outside the slab: for these are the four exterior sectors of Table I, in which reduces to a single image term, and no straddling sector exists in this branch. Appendix A gives the corresponding interval-by-interval construction.
| interval, | mouth locations | interval, | mouth locations |
| both below | both below | ||
| lower below, upper inside | lower below, upper inside | ||
| both inside | lower below, upper above | ||
| lower inside, upper above | lower inside, upper above | ||
| both above | both above |
Table I. Center-coordinate sectors for the two mouth positions. The first pair of columns applies to , whereas the second pair applies to . The intervals are open and their endpoints have zero measure. The mouth locations refer to and : “below”, “inside”, and “above” mean , , and , respectively. At , the central interval in the partition is empty.
For , no both-inside interval remains and the global center integration reduces to
The apparent factors and for an orientation parallel to the plate normal are evaluated through their continuous limits as (equivalently ); the combined branch expressions are finite. The two branches join continuously at . Indeed,
This establishes equality of the branch values at the sector boundary; it does not by itself prove differentiability of the angular integrand.
With both branches now defined, introduce the composite angular kernel
For the boundary prescription stated above, the globally integrated response is then
The first term in Eq. (42) is the globally integrated coincident-mouth contribution, whereas collects the cross-mouth part (defined as the global integral of above). Its piecewise form records the change in the allowed mouth placements at .
Equations (36)–(42) define the fixed-separation kernel of the matched spectator model. A treatment that retains only the translational sector produces apparent logarithmic image structures at special separations , with . They are absent after the exterior and reflected sectors required by Eq. (30) are included. The resulting kernel is continuous and numerically regular over the displayed domain. One-sided numerical derivatives of the two branches agree under refinement, but no closed proof is claimed; pressure derivatives are therefore checked by two routes in Appendix B.
Asymptotic behavior and numerical kernel
The asymptotic behaviors of provide independent checks of the global construction. At short separation, for example,
where the absence of a constant or linear term is consistent with the original bilocal difference , which vanishes when the two mouths coincide. In particular, .
At large separation, in turn, one obtains
and hence
Thus the finite large-separation plateau survives the complete global integration, but the approach to it is smooth rather than displaying the image singularities of an incomplete spatial-sector treatment.
Figure 1 shows a fixed-pair response that is slightly negative over a subinterval below the plate spacing and crosses zero at in the numerical evaluation. Near the origin its departure from zero is quadratic, as required by Eq. (43). At larger the curve is positive and moves toward the analytic limit in Eq. (45). The zero and the plotted trend belong to the matched point-throat model defined above. They do not establish a corresponding statement for finite throats or for a different boundary matching.
Figure 1. Matched spectator-model fixed-separation response versus the mouth-separation ratio . The solid curve is the numerical kernel, the horizontal dashed line in the main panel marks its large- limit , and the vertical dotted line marks . The inset magnifies the short-separation region and compares the numerical kernel (solid) with the leading expansion (dashed).
Distribution of spatial mouth separations
The equal-time model leaves the mouth separation as a statistical input. We therefore average the fixed-pair response over a normalized radial density and compare three phenomenological families whose first two relative moments are matched.
Ensemble average and scale families
Let be normalized as in Eq. (9). We define the dimensionless ensemble response by averaging the fixed-separation result in Eq. (35):
where
Equation (47) is the central ensemble result. Since the fixed-separation kernel is continuous and numerically regular, averaging is not required as a regularization prescription. Its role is physical: specifies the statistical distribution of the spatial nonlocality scale sampled by the cavity. It is also important to highlight that the leading scalar effective action does not determine the microscopic form of . In the present work it is therefore treated phenomenologically, subject to normalization and to the point-throat limitation stated in § 0.2. The three benchmark distributions are used solely to test shape dependence.
Let denote the mean mouth separation, and the family identity together with any dimensionless parameters that fix its shape. Introducing the positive dimensionless variables
the corresponding scale family is
Here, the scaled density satisfies , has unit mass and unit mean, and is held fixed when is varied. However, values at below denote a limiting kernel value, not a distribution with zero mean separation.
Eq. (47) then becomes
This representation makes explicit that, for a fixed distribution shape, the cavity response depends on the mean separation only through the dimensionless ratio .
Benchmark separation distributions
To isolate sensitivity to the shape of , we compare three positive-support families at the same mean and the same coefficient of variation (CV),
Thus CV is dimensionless. The continuous families considered here use CV ; the zero-width case is a distributional limit. The benchmark value is a chosen ensemble width, not a fitted measurement. Matching these first two relative moments ensures that differences between the resulting Casimir curves predominantly reflect higher moments and distribution shape.
As a minimal unimodal benchmark, we use a Gaussian truncated to positive separations. Let be a length-valued location parameter that may have either sign, be a length-valued width, and
denote the length-valued normalization with erf meaning the error function. The normalized density is then
In general . Now, let and denote the standard-normal density and cumulative distribution, respectively, and let us define the dimensionless auxiliaries
The mean and variance of the truncated Gaussian are written using the physical variance as
The benchmark values of and are therefore obtained numerically from Eqs. (55) and (56), with .
Let be an arbitrary fixed reference length; it makes the logarithm dimensionless and is not a fitted scale. Let and denote the dimensionless location and width in log space. As a second positive-support family we use the log-normal distribution
Matching its arithmetic mean and coefficient of variation to and gives
Substituting Eq. (58) into Eq. (57) cancels from the probability density; it is only a dimensional reference, not an additional model parameter.
For the Gamma family, let and denote the dimensionless shape and length-valued scale parameters, respectively, and let denote Euler’s Gamma function. The third benchmark is the density
Its mean and coefficient of variation are
Hence the matched parameters are
The three benchmark families therefore share the same and but differ in their higher moments and tail structure. This provides a direct test of whether the Casimir response is sensitive to the detailed form of the spatial mouth-separation distribution.
Controlled distribution limits and total Casimir energy
For a fixed scale family with unit mass and finite third moment, assume also that the remainder after the quadratic term is bounded by a constant times on . The short-distance expansion may then be averaged term by term as . Applied to Eq. (43), this gives
Consequently,
The leading short-separation response is therefore controlled by the second moment. The stated remainder requires the third moment; it is valid for all three benchmark families but need not exist for a heavy-tailed distribution.
At the opposite extreme, let be nonnegative, normalized, fixed as varies, and free of an atom at . If is bounded on , its pointwise limit for every permits dominated convergence in Eq. (50). The closed endpoint limits and numerical evaluation support boundedness for the retained kernel, but a finite scan alone does not prove it. Under this explicit condition,
Thus
The two limits suppress shape dependence for different reasons: the leading small- term depends on a moment, whereas the large- limit follows from normalization and the kernel plateau. Neither statement is uniform over all probability laws. For the three fixed benchmark families, the largest visible differences are therefore expected in the crossover region .
Define the dimensionless nonnegative amplitude . It is a coordinate of the ensemble scan, not an independently fitted observable. Combining Eqs. (46) and (28) then gives
For a fixed-shape scale family, is defined by Eq. (50). The no-foam limit is .
Figure 2 compares the three benchmark families at and . Matching the mean and coefficient of variation brings the three energy curves close together, but the inset retains a maximum pairwise separation of about in the normalized energy. The remaining spread is therefore small on the scale of the main panel, not zero; it records the effect of higher moments and tail shape. As increases, the positive part of the fixed-pair kernel offsets the ordinary negative Casimir energy, and the three curves cross zero near . This is an energy zero, not a force reversal. Moreover, the plot holds fixed and hence compares different ensemble parameters.
Figure 2. Total Casimir interaction energy normalized by the magnitude of the ordinary massless-scalar Dirichlet energy, , versus . The curves correspond to truncated-Gaussian, log-normal, and Gamma mouth-separation distributions matched at and , with . The dash-dotted horizontal line denotes the no-foam value , and the solid horizontal line denotes zero total interaction energy. The inset displays on an expanded vertical scale to resolve the separation among the three curves.
Pressure, perturbative control, and regime structure
The force follows from the dimensional energy, not from a scan at fixed . We therefore differentiate at fixed physical ensemble parameters before examining the leading-order pressure and its sign.
Pressure and asymptotic behavior
At fixed , , , and distribution label , the total interaction energy per unit area is
where and are defined in Eqs. (48) and (50). The physical pressure is
with , , , and the distribution label held fixed. We reserve for the radial probability density and for the Casimir pressure.
Since , differentiation of the foam contribution gives
We therefore define
With this definition, , and Eq. (69) is the compact pressure correction used below. It is useful to define the dimensionless fixed-pair pressure kernel:
Thus, using Eq. (50), Eq. (70) can then be written as
This representation is useful for establishing the large- behavior without introducing inverse moments of the separation distribution.
Defining the dimensionless coefficients and (the latter symbol is distinct from the plate area ), Eq. (44) takes the form
Substitution into Eq. (71) shows that the term cancels identically,
For the following limit, a sufficient condition is that be nonnegative and normalized, have no atom at , and that be bounded on . The analytic endpoint limits and the numerical kernel support this condition for the three benchmarks, but the finite numerical scan is not itself a proof of global boundedness. Subject to this stated condition, dominated convergence in Eq. (72) yields
Unlike an expansion of term by term, this derivation does not require the existence of the inverse moment . The asymptotic foam correction to the pressure is therefore
Expressed in terms of , the total pressure normalized by the magnitude of the ordinary Dirichlet result becomes
Consequently,
and the leading-order asymptotic threshold for a change in the sign of the total pressure is
Equations (78) and (79) describe the large- limit of a fixed- ensemble scan. They are not a physical limit: at fixed , , and , one has , and decreasing can also violate .
For comparison, the large- total energy follows from Eq. (65),
and changes sign at
The energy and pressure thresholds are therefore distinct. In particular, a positive total interaction energy does not by itself imply a repulsive Casimir force.
Perturbative control and domain of validity
The approximation scheme contains independent geometric, statistical, and field-theoretic assumptions. The dimensionless geometric packing fraction is
This parameter controls geometric overlap. Statistical independence is a separate assumption: the connected position correlator is set to zero in the spectator benchmark and is not made small by Eq. (82).
The dimensionless amplitude controlling the relative size of the foam contribution at the cavity scale is instead
Hence geometric diluteness, , does not by itself imply a negligible Casimir correction: can remain finite when .
A separate diagnostic follows from the momentum-space quadratic insertion derived in Eq. (19). For a real dummy argument , the function has global minimum approximately . Therefore any normalized positive obeys
Comparing the resulting maximal free-space insertion with the lowest Dirichlet normal-mode wave number, , gives
This is not an operator-norm bound. Equation (19) is diagonal in the translationally invariant Fourier basis, whereas the cavity problem is naturally expanded in Dirichlet modes. Equation (85) is therefore used only as a free-space mode-scale diagnostic for repeated quadratic insertions. It does not enter the derivation of the Casimir kernel.
For the plotted values, Eq. (85) gives at and at . Values below unity do not bound the omitted boundary-conditioned terms, especially in the exterior sectors. Nor is an error bound available for the first omitted multipole in the layers adjacent to a plate. The resulting pressure reversal is therefore a leading-order feature of the retained monopole kernel, not a precision prediction.
Repeated insertions of the fixed quadratic action must be distinguished from a response of the wormhole statistics. In Ref. [26], governs propagation for a prescribed distribution, whereas the subsequent nonlinear terms describe topology response. The first of those terms is
For a Gaussian scalar field, Wick theorem gives
If one ignores composite-operator subtraction and uses only as a dimensional scale, the unrenormalized terms would count as
and hence
Neither Wick’s identity nor this dimensional estimate determines the boundary-subtracted quartic Casimir term: inclusion-exclusion of squared correlators is not the square of the subtracted quadratic correlator. The spectator model holds the foam statistics fixed and therefore excludes . A quartic extension would require a regulator, a composite-operator prescription, and its own complete one- and two-plate subtraction. No numerical uncertainty is assigned from Eq. (89). Repeated insertions of , topology response through , and connected two-wormhole effects are distinct omissions. The last are governed by and vanish only because statistical independence was imposed.
The independent requirements of the present calculation may therefore be summarized schematically as
together with the fixed-ensemble assumption. Because the benchmark densities have support arbitrarily close to , the point-throat limit is taken before the distribution average; Eq. (90) is not a uniform finite- support bound. The free-space estimate is not part of this validity gate because it does not bound the boundary-conditioned operator or the exterior sectors.
As a dimensional illustration, and give ; at the same , corresponds to . These values only show that a small packing fraction can coexist with a visible leading-order amplitude. They neither fix a physical wormhole population nor bound the omitted terms.
Pressure reversal and regime map
We now evaluate the pressure for the truncated-Gaussian benchmark with . Figure 3 shows Eq. (77) for several values of the effective foam amplitude. At , the free-space diagnostic gives but does not certify the boundary-conditioned expansion. The retained pressure vanishes at
Figure 3. Total Casimir pressure normalized by the magnitude of the ordinary massless-scalar Dirichlet pressure, , versus for the truncated-Gaussian distribution with CV = 0.30. The fixed- curves use , , , and ; the no-foam reference is . The horizontal line at zero separates negative (attractive) from positive (repulsive) pressure.
Also, across , the and curves remain negative and approach the large- limits and of Eq. (78), whereas the critical curve approaches zero without crossing it. The curve changes sign near and then tends toward the positive asymptote in Eq. (78). This is a numerical statement about the displayed leading-order family. It neither proves attraction for every when nor controls the sign after higher insertions, finite-throat effects, or multipoles are included.
Within the retained kernel, Eq. (77) defines a zero-pressure locus. Whenever , the boundary is
Figure 4 displays this curve in the plane: below the boundary the retained pressure is negative, whereas above it the pressure is positive. Since , the boundary approaches at large . Thus, for the displayed benchmark, increasing the nonlocal separation alone does not reverse the force when . For , by contrast, a finite crossover can occur, and the point is the example displayed explicitly in Figure 3.
Figure 4. Leading-order pressure-sign map in the plane for the truncated-Gaussian distribution with CV = 0.30 and . The solid curve is the zero-pressure boundary defined by Eq. (92); the region below it has , and the region above it has . The dashed horizontal line marks the large- limit . The marker at identifies the zero of the corresponding pressure curve in Figure 3.
The boundary in Figure 4 classifies the sign of the retained pressure over the plotted domain. It is not a dynamical stability diagram. Horizontal cuts reproduce the parameter scans in Figure 3, but they are not trajectories generated by moving the plates. At fixed , , and , physical variation of obeys . Such a trajectory can cross the boundary differently from a horizontal cut. The dashed level is only the large- limit of the present benchmark, and the shaded signs remain conditional on the omitted corrections listed above.
Phenomenological interpretation
The physical lever in this model is the correlation scale. Equation (83) allows the leading cavity amplitude to remain visible even when the packing fraction is small, while Figure 2-Figure 4 show that the response becomes appreciable only when has weight at separations comparable to . This scale selectivity is the result supported by the scalar Dirichlet benchmark. It is not an experimental limit: comparison with precision Casimir data would require an electromagnetic boundary model and a microscopic specification of the ensemble. We also stress that the threshold and the plateau belong to the matched spectator prescription: for the confined alternative of Appendix C the corresponding minimum amplitudes for a pressure reversal are or , depending on how is normalized.
Conclusions
We have determined how an equal-Euclidean-time spatial bilocal interaction changes the scalar Casimir energy and pressure between parallel Dirichlet plates within a point-throat, leading-monopole matched spectator model. The foam statistics are held fixed while the scalar field obeys the boundary conditions, and a global two-plate inclusion-exclusion subtraction over all mouth-pair center positions isolates the finite boundary observable.
For a fixed mouth separation, the resulting dimensionless kernel is continuous and numerically regular over the evaluated domain. Its quadratic suppression near coincident mouths, subsequent sign change, and finite large-separation plateau identify the mouth separation relative to the plate spacing as the controlling geometric scale. Including the exterior, straddling, and reflected sectors is essential: it removes the logarithmic image structures produced by a restricted translation sector.
Averaging this kernel over a normalized separation density preserves the same scale selection. For fixed scale families satisfying the stated moment and boundedness conditions, the short-separation response is governed at leading order by the second moment, whereas normalization fixes the large-separation plateau. The three matched benchmark families yield closely spaced energy curves, with a maximum pairwise difference of about 0.014 in normalized energy over the resolved comparison region. Higher moments and tail shape therefore produce a numerically resolved residual, while the mean correlation scale supplies the dominant response.
The pressure follows by differentiating the dimensional energy while the physical ensemble parameters are held fixed. This distinguishes the pressure from a derivative along a fixed-amplitude scan and yields a leading-order large-separation sign threshold. In the finite truncated-Gaussian scan, the subcritical curves remain attractive, the critical curve approaches zero, and only the supercritical benchmark crosses into the repulsive sector. The result is a parameter-space classification of the retained monopole kernel, not a physical trajectory obtained by varying the plate spacing.
Taken together, the results show that the scalar Casimir interaction can act as a scale-selective response to spatial bilocal correlations within the declared matched spectator model. A microscopic separation distribution and a first-principles boundary matching would sharpen that interpretation (Appendix C illustrates the size of the boundary-matching uncertainty), while finite-throat, higher-multipole, correlated-ensemble, and higher-insertion calculations would quantify its accuracy. Extending the construction to the electromagnetic field with material response is the necessary step toward a comparison with precision Casimir measurements.
Acknowledgments
CRM would like to thank the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq) for partial financial support, under the grant 301122/2025-3. MCA would like to thank Fundação Cearense de Apoio ao Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (FUNCAP) under process No. DC3-0235-00076.01.00/24, and Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico - Brasil (CNPq) under process No. 304145/2025-4 for financial support. EO thanks the Fundação Cearense de Apoio ao Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (FUNCAP), under the grant BP6-0241-00335.01.00/25.
Global center integration for the bilocal kernel
This appendix records the sector decomposition and closed expressions used by the matched boundary prescription in Sec. III. It checks the algebra of that prescription. However, it does not derive the prescription from the topology-averaged source theory.
For a pair of fixed separation we use the variables defined in Eqs. (33) and (34), with . The parallel and normal separations are and , respectively. The cross-mouth part of the bilocal observable depends on the relative location of and with respect to the two plates. Since the foam is treated as a spectator, the center coordinate is not restricted to the slab: the integration extends over . The relevant decomposition changes at . The ordered sectors for the two parameter ranges are listed side by side below as complete five-row partitions. Table I displays the two complete partitions side by side. Within either regime, its five open intervals cover the full real line without overlap, up to endpoints of zero measure.
Table II lists the integrand of in each sector of Table I. The rows follow from the component-wise prescription of Sec. III A: outside the slab, and the isolated-plate functions reduce to single-image functions and vanish between points separated by a plate, whereas remains the free propagator. When both mouths are inside the slab, the first two terms are the translational images minus the direct term, which gives [Eq. (94)]. The last three are the reflections in the two plates minus the single-plate reflections already removed by , which gives [Eq. (A5)], so the first row reproduces the sign in Eq. (38). In the other sectors a single term survives: the reflection in the plate at when the lower mouth is below the slab, the reflection in the plate at when the upper mouth is above it, and the free propagator when the mouths lie on opposite sides of the slab. The coincident-mouth terms are treated at the end of this appendix.
| mouth locations | |
| both inside | |
| lower below; upper below or inside | |
| upper above; lower inside or above | |
| lower below, upper above ( only) |
Table II. Integrand of the cross-mouth term in each sector of Table I, with and . Its integral over is the function .
Sector
When , there exists a finite interval in which both mouths lie between the plates. From Eq. (34), the condition is equivalent to
Its dimensionless length is therefore . This is the origin of the factor multiplying the translational contribution in Eq. (38).
For two points inside the slab, the translational part of the two-plate image sum depends only on their relative displacement. After subtracting the free-space term, the relevant dimensionless sum is, with the image index,
For dimensionless dummy parameters and , use the standard summation identity
For , setting and in Eq. (95) recovers the closed form already defined in Eq. (36), with (the normal-orientation endpoint is its continuous limit). Integration over the both-inside interval therefore produces the contribution
The reflected image sector depends explicitly on the center coordinate. After the one-plate pieces have been removed by the inclusion-exclusion prescription, the residual integrand in the both-inside interval can be written as
The first term contains the complete reflected two-plate image sum, while the last two terms subtract the isolated reflections associated with the plates at and . Integrating over the both-inside interval gives the reflected residual already defined in Eq. (37). The remaining intervals contain at least one exterior mouth. The component-wise prescription stated in Sec. III A reduces their image terms to affine denominators. For real constants , with , and for , the required primitive is
The prefactor follows from the chain rule, and direct differentiation of the displayed primitive recovers the integrand. The endpoint is evaluated only after the sector contributions are combined, rather than by substituting into an individual primitive. After exploiting reflection symmetry between the regions below and above the cavity and combining the corresponding endpoint contributions, the net exterior term becomes
Explicitly, for the exterior sectors give , and each half-line integral equals , which sum to Eq. (98). Combining the exterior, translational, and reflected contributions recovers the branch already stated in Eq. (38).
Sector
For , the interval in Eq. (93) has zero or negative length, and no center position exists for which both mouths lie simultaneously inside the cavity. The global integration is therefore built entirely from the complementary sectors in which the mouths occupy different regions or both lie outside the slab. Using the same component-wise prescription in these intervals yields
For ,
Substitution of Eq. (100) into Eq. (99) gives the branch in Eq. (39).
Equivalently, in the sectors of Table I for , . The straddling interval has length and there, while and .
Matching at
At the boundary , the domain implies ; one has and . The factors and vanish, and both branches reduce to the common value already displayed in Eq. (40). This proves continuity but not differentiability. As a separate numerical check, one-sided finite differences at , , , and converge to the same branch derivative. At a step of the largest mismatch is below . This test supports the numerical differentiation of the pressure kernel but is not promoted to an analytic theorem.
The reflected residual in Eq. (37) must be retained together with the translational and exterior sectors. Omitting it leaves the restricted image structures described in Sec. III C. With all adopted sectors present, the fixed-separation response is numerically regular over the evaluated domain.
| at | ||
| (70, 55, 100) | 0.2630001 | 3.171340 |
| (100, 80, 140) | 0.2630003 | 3.171336 |
| (130, 100, 180) | 0.2630002 | 3.171338 |
Table 3. Quadrature convergence for the dimensionless kernel value and for the pressure root at . The first column gives the angular, center-coordinate, and distribution quadrature orders ; the last column reports the root obtained in each run. The three tabulated resolutions show convergence at the displayed precision.
Coincident-mouth terms and the constant
The terms are given by the expressions of Table II applied to a mouth and its own images, that is, with ; the divergent direct term of the first row then cancels against . Inside the slab the integrand reduces to , whose integral over is . Below and above the slab the integrands are and , each integrating to . The total is per mouth, which is the constant in Eq. (42).
Numerical implementation and convergence tests
The numerical evaluation applies Eqs. (42)–(72) over the parameter domains shown in the figures. The kernel quadrature, distribution average, and pressure calculation are implemented within the common procedure described below.
The kernel integral uses Gauss-Legendre rules with orders and . For the angular interval is split exactly at ; within the branch, the residual integral is mapped to . Endpoint expressions are evaluated in their regular combined limits. The production run uses and a natural cubic spline through a nonuniform kernel grid: 41 points on , 91 on , 101 on , and 257 on , with shared endpoints removed. For the analytic small- expression is used only as a stabilizing branch. Direct evaluation of the closed integral across the overlap verifies the expected departure; at the absolute difference is .
The distribution average in Eq. (50) uses Gauss-Legendre nodes up to the quantile of each benchmark. The retained mass differs from unity by less than in all three cases. The energy, pressure, and regime scans use 161, 237, and 211 uniformly spaced values of over , , and , respectively.
The pressure is calculated both by differentiating a spline of and by the direct integral in Eq. (72). These routes share the same fixed-pair kernel, so their agreement tests numerical differentiation, not the physical derivation of the kernel. In the production run they give and 3.17133625 for ; their difference is . Convergence of the displayed precision is summarized in Table III.
A higher-order run with gives and , consistently with the convergence shown in Table III. At an exact root, by definition, so is the independent root diagnostic. The four resolutions support at the stated precision. The small- and large- analytic checks, branch matching, quadrature refinement, and two pressure routes test different numerical failure modes; none of them establishes the source-to-boundary matching assumption.
Alternative boundary prescription: pairs confined to the slab
The kernel of Sec. III C follows from the matched spectator prescription, in which the pair center is integrated over the whole normal line and the field is disconnected across each plate. To gauge how much of the sign structure depends on that postulate, we compare it with a second, equally simple alternative prescription: only pairs whose two mouths both lie inside the slab are retained, with the same and the same prefactor . The integral is then restricted to , which is empty for , and Eq. (35) defines a kernel ,
where is the “both inside” expression of Table II, and is the coincident-mouth term of a mouth at height (in units of ) inside the slab, , with the trigamma function. Two normalizations are considered. In the first, and are those of the main text. In the second, counts only pairs that fit in the slab, so the kernel is divided by the length available to the pair center, averaged over orientations, , i.e. for and for : .
Numerically, the confined kernel shares the sign structure of : it starts negative, at small (against in the spectator case), crosses zero near (against 0.695), reaches a maximum near , and then decays as , so there is no plateau. The conditional kernel tends to a plateau , to be compared with . We checked Eq. (101) against a direct sum over images at and 1.7 (agreement to eight digits). Averaging over the truncated-Gaussian benchmark with CV = 0.30 and repeating the pressure analysis of § 2 C, the minimum amplitude for which can change sign is . The results are collected in Table IV and Figure 5.
| prescription | kernel at large | at | |
| spectator (global) | plateau | 0.051 () | 0.25 |
| confined, same | 0.59 | 2.9 | |
| confined, of fitting pairs | plateau | 0.11 | 0.55 |
Table IV. Minimum foam amplitude for a pressure sign change, truncated-Gaussian benchmark with CV = 0.30 and , for the three prescriptions, and the corresponding free-space diagnostic of Eq. (85).
Figure 5. Spectator (global) and confined prescriptions. (a) Fixed-separation kernels , , and ; the dash-dotted line marks . (b) Zero-pressure boundary for the truncated-Gaussian benchmark with CV = 0.30 (shown where ); the dash-dotted line marks .
The qualitative structure—negative response at small separation, a sign change near , and an appreciable effect only when has weight at separations comparable to —is common to the prescriptions. The existence of a plateau, and the numerical value of the minimum amplitude, are not: they range from to . For the confined kernel with the same , the reversal requires , where exceeds unity, so the first-order expansion is not expected to be reliable and no controlled repulsive regime is found in that case. Both prescriptions are postulates, and neither is derived from the topology-averaged source theory. The results of the main text should therefore be read as conditional on the matched spectator prescription.
References
References
- [5]K. Symanzik, Nuclear Physics B 190, 1 (1981).
- [6]N. Graham, R. Jaffe, V. Khemani, M. Quandt, M. Scandurra, and H. Weigel, Nuclear Physics B 645, 49 (2002), arXiv:hep-th/0207120 [hep-th].DOI
- [7]O. Kenneth and I. Klich, Physical Review Letters 97, 160401 (2006), arXiv:quant-ph/0601011 [quant-ph].DOI
- [8]S. K. Lamoreaux, Physical Review Letters 78, 5 (1997), see erratum: Physical Review Letters 81, 5475 (1998).
- [9]U. Mohideen and A. Roy, Physical Review Letters 81, 4549 (1998).
- [10]R. S. Decca, D. Lopez, E. Fischbach, G. L. Klimchitskaya, D. E. Krause, and V. M. Mostepanenko, Phys. Rev. D 75, 077101 (2007), arXiv:hep-ph/0703290.
- [11]G. L. Klimchitskaya, U. Mohideen, and V. M. Mostepanenko, Reviews of Modern Physics 81, 1827 (2009), arXiv:0902.4022 [cond-mat.other].DOI
- [12]V. B. Bezerra, G. L. Klimchitskaya, V. M. Mostepanenko, and C. Romero, Phys. Rev. A 69, 022119 (2004), arXiv:quant-ph/0401138.DOI
- [13]G. L. Klimchitskaya, Universe 7, 47 (2021).
- [14]R. I. P. Sedmik and M. Pitschmann, Universe 7, 234 (2021), arXiv:2107.07645 [physics.ins-det].DOI
- [15]J. A. Wheeler, Annals of Physics 2, 604 (1957).
- [16]S. Hawking, Nuclear Physics B 144, 349 (1978).
- [17]S. Carlip, Reports on Progress in Physics 86, 066001 (2023), arXiv:2209.14282 [gr-qc].DOI
- [18]S. W. Hawking, Phys. Lett. B 195, 337 (1987).
- [19]S. W. Hawking, Physical Review D 37, 904 (1988).
- [20]S. B. Giddings and A. Strominger, Nucl. Phys. B 307, 854 (1988).
- [21]S. B. Giddings and A. Strominger, Nuclear Physics B 306, 890 (1988).
- [22]S. R. Coleman, Nucl. Phys. B 310, 643 (1988).
- [23]S. Coleman, Nuclear Physics B 307, 867 (1988).
- [24]A. Hebecker, T. Mikhail, and P. Soler, Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences 5, 35 (2018), arXiv:1807.00824 [hep-th].DOI
- [25]E. P. Savelova, Grav. Cosmol. 21, 48 (2015).
- [26]A. A. Kirillov and E. P. Savelova, Gen. Rel. Grav. 47, 97 (2015).
- [27]A. A. Kirillov and E. P. Savelova, Eur. Phys. J. C 84, 307 (2024).
- [28]A. A. Kirillov, E. P. Savelova, and P. O. Vladykina, Universe 7, 178 (2021).
- [29]A. A. Kirillov and E. P. Savelova, Journal of Astrophysics 2013, 1 (2013), arXiv:1006.5181 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
- [30]A. A. Kirillov and E. P. Savelova, Universe 4, 35 (2018).
- [31]A. A. Kirillov and E. P. Savelova, Gravitation and Cosmology 24, 337 (2018).
- [32]A. A. Kirillov and E. P. Savelova, International Journal of Modern Physics D 34, 2550040 (2025), arXiv:2307.02400 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2307.02400
- [33]G. V. Efimov, Communications in Mathematical Physics 5, 42 (1967).
- [34]E. T. Tomboulis, Superrenormalizable gauge gravitational theories (1997), arXiv:hep-th/9702146 [hep-th].DOI
- [35]E. T. Tomboulis, Physical Review D 92, 125037 (2015), arXiv:1507.00981 [hep-th].DOI
- [36]K. Osterwalder and R. Schrader, Communications in Mathematical Physics 42, 281 (1975).
- [37]F. Briscese and L. Modesto, Physical Review D 99, 104043 (2019), arXiv:1803.08827 [gr-qc].DOI
- [38]A. S. Koshelev and A. Tokareva, Physical Review D 104, 025016 (2021), arXiv:2103.01945 [hep-th].DOI
- [39]F. Briscese and L. Modesto, The European Physical Journal C 81, 730 (2021), arXiv:2103.00353 [hep-th].DOI
- [40]C. Fosco and E. Losada, Physics Letters B 675, 252 (2009), arXiv:0902.2198 [hep-th].DOI
- [41]M. Saravani, Classical and Quantum Gravity 36, 065005 (2019), arXiv:1811.10442 [hep-th].DOI
- [42]A. Boasso, C. D. Fosco, B. C. Guntzsche, and F. D. Mazzitelli, Physical Review D 114, 025012 (2026), arXiv:2605.17124 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2605.17124
- [43]A. R. Khabibullin, N. R. Khusnutdinov, and S. V. Sushkov, Classical and Quantum Gravity 23, 627 (2006), arXiv:hep-th/0510232 [hep-th].
- [44]A. C. L. Santos, C. R. Muniz, and L. T. Oliveira, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 30, 2150032 (2021).
- [45]F. Sorge, International Journal of Modern Physics D 29, 2050002 (2020).
- [46]C. R. Muniz, V. B. Bezerra, and J. M. Toledo, Eur. Phys. J. C 81, 209 (2021).
- [47]L. M. Butcher, Physical Review D 90, 024019 (2014), arXiv:1405.1283 [gr-qc].DOI
- [48]R. Garattini, International Journal of Modern Physics A 17, 829 (2002), arXiv:gr-qc/0110087 [gr-qc].DOI
- [49]R. Garattini, Eur. Phys. J. C 79, 951 (2019), arXiv:1907.03623 [gr-qc].DOI
- [50]R. Garattini, Eur. Phys. J. C 80, 1172 (2020), arXiv:2008.05901 [gr-qc].DOI
- [51]C. R. Muniz, T. Tangphati, R. M. P. Neves, and M. B. Cruz, Phys. Dark Univ. 46, 101673 (2024), arXiv:2406.08250 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2406.08250
- [52]C. Muniz, M. Cruz, R. Neves, M. Farooq, and M. Zubair, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2025 (07), 015, arXiv:2503.12943 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2503.12943
- [53]P. H. F. Oliveira, G. Alencar, I. C. Jardim, and R. R. Landim, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 37, 2250090 (2022), arXiv:2107.00605 [hep-th].DOI




