betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Stanley Deser 19th March 1931 - 21st April 2023

Abstract

Stanley Deser was Ancell Professor Emeritus at Brandeis University and Visiting Professor at the California Institute of Technology. He was a world-renowned theoretical physicist whose accomplishments include the Arnowitt-Deser-Misner (ADM) formulation of general relativity, supergravity with Zumino, the dynamics of flat space with Jackiw and 't Hooft and many other contributions to the quantum theory of gravity. In the 1980s he was instrumental in securing National Science Foundation approval of the LIGO gravitational wave experiment against much opposition. He was awarded the Einstein Medal in 2015 for important contributions to general relativity, in particular the development of the ADM formalism. Other awards include: The Dannie Heineman Prize 1994; Fellow of the National Academy of Sciences 1994; Honorary Member of the Torino Academy of Sciences 2001; Member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences 1979, Fellow of the American Institute of Physics.

Photograph of Stanley Deser

Figure 1. Stanley Deser © Brandeis

LIFE

Refugee

Stanley Deser was born in Rovno, Poland, a city now known as Rivne, Ukraine, on March 19, 1931, the only child of Norman and Miriam. Norman was a chemist and the family were reasonably well off but fled Poland’s antisemitic regime in 1935 first for Palestine and then for Paris where they lived until 1940.

Stanley’s formal education began in the French public and private school systems. In his autobiography, Forks in the Road [29], he recalls:“The kindergarten, known as the Ecole Maternelle, was the polar opposite of its name. We were crowded, about 43–44 kids per class, all wearing black aprons, presided over by a formidable presence whose main pleasure was using her ferrule, but not for measuring. She loved to quell any disturbances and menaces in her class of dangerous five year-olds with it. Another wrinkle in the system was the weekly reseating of the students according to our perceived performance in the previous one. I always ended up around 43rd or 44th in line; I may have reached 42nd once. This technique of course achieved the wrong end, because all we stupid children were furthest away from the font of wisdom. Then my parents decided to put me, not that they had much choice, into a horrible little private school; there were two of us in my class. It wasn’t really a school, just a woman and a few stray kids. At least I wasn’t seated at number 44.”

The Deser family lived on Rue Lafayette, a broad boulevard on the north side of Paris. With World War II engulfing Europe, they began to see the exodus of Dutch and Belgian refugees. In 1940, they too realised the danger and decided to leave everything. They owned a tiny car, a Simca 5. Neither of his parents could drive; his uncle, who lived with them, was the only one who knew how. Stanley wrote of his parents “I rushed with my father to empty our safe. That evening, my mother sewed the coins into a belt of towels, a much-practiced maneouver of refugees.” After a restless night they jumped into the car and escaped Paris hours before the Nazi tanks came rolling in.

About a week from Paris, they reached Bayonne and Biarritz, very close to the southwest Atlantic Spanish border, having by-passed Orleans and Bordeaux. Aristides de Sousa Mendes, the Portuguese consul in Bordeaux who oversaw the French southwest region, foreseeing the coming slaughter, unilaterally decided to issue transit visas to all who were waiting in his sub-consulates. The Desers put their passports into a basket that was hauled up through a window and back down with the life-saving visas. Armed with the necessary documents, they abandoned the car and caught the last safe train out of France and secured passage on one of the last boats out of Lisbon to New York.

The New World

“In the old Ellis Island days, the immigration inspectors arbitrarily renamed the newly landed. Our experience was not so drastic; we were allowed to make our own choice of first name. I was born Salomon, then underwent a change to Lucien in France because my parents felt it would ease my way. We were told Lucien would never do in the US, so among the options we were offered, Stanley seemed the least objectionable. ”

Anyone with a childhood as tumultuous as his might reasonably expect adulthood to be something of an anticlimax, but for the now “Stanley” Deser another adventure was only just beginning, albeit an intellectual one in theoretical physics. Readers of his autobiography can relish the anecdotes, told with wit and literary aplomb, involving the greatest minds of 20th century physics. They will come away with a greater appreciation of a golden era for quantum field theory and general relativity to which Deser was himself a major contributor. One such story recalls former hero of the Manhattan Project J Robert Oppenheimer, betrayed and humiliated by H-bomb advocate Edward Teller, phoning Teller to politely request he approve the young Deser’s job application (which he did).

Stanley entered Brooklyn College of the City of New York with a competitive Regents Scholarship in January 1946, graduating in June 1949 BS Summa cum Laude. Professor Melba Phillips was a major influence, as was cultural life in New York City. The next step was Harvard University, where he gained his MA in 1950, and PhD in 1953 with Nobel laureate Julian Schwinger. It was here he discovered his passions for theoretical high energy and particle physics. His postdoctoral positions included the Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton 1953-55 working with M. Goldberger and W. Thirring, the Niels Bohr Institute 1955-57, where he wrote his first paper on quantum gravity, and Harvard University 1957-1958, working with W. Gilbert (FRS 1987) and E. C. G. Sudarshan.

Stanley was Married 25 August 1956 to Elsbeth Klein, an artist. He joined Brandeis University in 1958 first as Associate then full Professor of Physics until emeritus in 2005. From 1964 to 1970 he was Co-Director and Co-Editor, Brandeis Summer Institutes in Theoretical Physics and from 1969 to 1971 and from 1976 to 1977 he was Chairman of the Brandeis Physics Department. He held visiting professorships at the Institut Henri Poincare of the Sorbonne; University of the Republic, Uruguay; Faculty of Science, University of Paris-Orsay; Kings College, London; College de France, Paris; All Souls College, Oxford; Imperial College, London; Physics Department, Texas A&M University; Physics Department UCLA; Observatoire de Meudon and Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques, France; University of Vienna and California Institute of Technology. In the 1980s he was instrumental in securing NSF approval of the LIGO gravitational wave experiment against much opposition. His numerous awards are listed in § 4.

Stanley died on April 21 2023. He leaves behind three daughters, Toni, Clara, and Abigail, as well as four grandchildren, Ursula, Oscar, Louise, and Simon. He was preceded in death by his wife Elsbeth and a daughter, Eva.

WORK

This section reviews Stanley’s central role in advancing theoretical high energy physics at a more technical level, emphasising the key turning points in the development of the discipline. Quantum Gravity is the would-be unified theory that eluded Einstein, mystified the greatest minds of twentieth century physics and continues to baffle those of the twenty-first. Stanley Deser was not only one of the world’s leading experts on this conundrum but through his work on the canonical formalism, supergravity and string theory perhaps also one of the providers of its solution.

The job of theoretical physicists is twofold :(1) To explain the data garnered by their experimental colleagues; (2) To imagine new phenomena that no-one has yet thought of and for which, therefore, there are as yet no experiments. This is speculation but speculation in the strait-jacket imposed by mathematical consistency and agreement with what we know already to be true. Throughout his long career, Deser focussed on such foundational consistency conditions, for example with higher spins [23 1985b], massive gravity [10], positivity of energy [9 1977b] and electromagnetic duality [19 1977], he questioned not merely whether a theory was elegant or useful but whether it could exist at all.

The ADM formalism

Building on earlier work of Paul Dirac (FRS 1958), the Arnowitt-Deser-Misner (ADM) formulation [8] did for Einstein’s general relativity what Hamilton did for classical mechanics. The formalism regards spacetime as a family of spacelike surfaces labeled by their time coordinate tt, and with coordinates on each slice given by xix^{i}. The dynamical variables of this theory are taken to be the metric tensor of three-dimensional spatial slices gij(t,xk)g_{ij}(t,x^{k}) and their conjugate momenta. Using these variables it is possible to define a Hamiltonian, and thereby write the equations of motion for general relativity in the form of Hamilton’s equations.

Analysing the dynamics of the gravitational field is complicated by the general coordinate invariance that underlies the theory. Ordinarily in field theory, it is sufficient to specify the fields and their first time derivatives initially in order to determine their time development. For general relativity, however, it is necessary that the metric field be separated into the parts carrying the true dynamical information and those parts characterizing the coordinate system. In this respect, the coordinate invariance plays a role similar to the gauge invariance of the Maxwell field in electromagnetism. In both cases there are redundant variables.

ADM begin by making a 3+13+1 dimensional decomposition of the metric;

gij≡4gij,N≡(−4g00)−1/2,Ni≡4g0ig_{ij} \equiv{}^{4}g_{ij}, \qquad N \equiv\left(-{}^{4}g^{00}\right)^{-1/2}, \qquad N_i \equiv{}^{4}g_{0i}
πij≡−4g(4Γpq0−gpq4Γrs0grs)gipgjq\pi^{ij} \equiv\sqrt{-{}^{4}g}\left({}^{4}\Gamma^{0}_{pq}-g_{pq}{}^{4}\Gamma^{0}_{rs}g^{rs}\right)g^{ip}g^{jq}

where every 4-dimensional quantity carries a prefix 4^{4}, thus 4Γμνρ^{4}\Gamma^{\rho}_{\mu\nu} is the 4-dimensional affine connection, and all other quantities are 3-dimensional. In particular gijg^{ij} is the inverse of gijg_{ij}. The full metric may thus be written 4g00=−(N2−NiNi){}^{4}g_{00}=-(N^{2}-N_{i}N^{i}) where Ni=gijNjN^{i}=g^{ij}N_{j}, 4g0i=Ni/N2{}^{4}g_{0i}=N_{i}/N^{2}, 4g00=−1/N2{}^{4}g^{00}=-1/N^{2}, 4gij=gij−NiNj/N2{}^{4}g^{ij}=g^{ij}-N^{i}N^{j}/N^{2} and −4g=Ng\sqrt{-{}^{4}g}=N\sqrt{g}.

Richard Arnowitt, Stanley Deser and Charles Misner at the ADM-50 conference

Figure 2. Richard Arnowitt, Stanley Deser and Charles Misner at the ADM-50: A Celebration of Current GR Innovation conference held in November 2009 to honor the 50th anniversary of their paper.Photographer unknown; from Wikipedia under a CC BY-SA 3.0 licence. ©

The 3-dimensional variables, such as gijg_{ij}, are chosen to be three-covariant under all coordinate transformations that leave the t=const⁡t=\operatorname{const} surfaces unchanged. In contrast NN and NiN_i are not. Momentum is more difficult to define within the surface, since it refers to motion in time leading out of the original t=const⁡t=\operatorname{const} surface. The second fundamental form does not depend on the choice of coordinates away from the surface. This may also be seen from a standard definition Kij=n(i;j)K_{ij}=n_{(i;j)}, which expresses KijK_{ij} as the covariant spatial part of the tensor n(μ;ν)n_{(\mu;\nu)} (the four-dimensional covariant derivative of the unit normal, nμ=−Nδμ0n_\mu=-N\delta^0_\mu to the surface). For convenience ADM choose the closely related variable πij=g(Kij−gijK)\pi^{ij}=\sqrt{g}(K^{ij}-g^{ij}K). While the 12 (gij,πij)(g_{ij},\pi^{ij}) constitute a complete set of Cauchy data, they do not provide a minimal set. We may eliminate four by using the constraint equations and then another 4 by imposing coordinate conditions. This leaves two degrees of freedom which was to expected since a massless spin 2 field has just two.

Introducing the transverse traceless components πijTT\pi^{ijTT} and gijTTg_{ij}^{TT} where, for a symmetric second rank tensor fijf_{ij},

fij,jTT≡0fiiTT≡0fT≡f,ii−1∇2fij,ijf_{ij,j}^{TT}\equiv0 \qquad f_{ii}^{TT}\equiv0 \qquad f^{T}\equiv f_{,ii}-\frac{1}{\nabla^{2}}f_{ij,ij}

ADM were able to write down the fundamental equal time Poisson bracket relations for πijTT\pi^{ijTT} and gijTTg_{ij}^{TT}

[gijTT(x),πklTT(x′)]=δijkl(x−x′)[g_{ij}^{TT}(x),\pi^{klTT}(x')]=\delta_{ij}^{kl}(x-x')
[gijTT(x),gklTT(x′)]=0[g_{ij}^{TT}(x),g_{kl}^{TT}(x')]=0
[πijTT(x),πklTT(x′)]=0[\pi^{ijTT}(x),\pi^{klTT}(x')]=0

where δijkl(x−x′)\delta_{ij}^{kl}(x-x') is a conventional Dirac δ\delta function, symmetric, transverse and traceless on each pair of indices.

In summary, by casting general relativity into canonical form, the Arnowitt-Deser-Misner approach formed the basis of early attempts to quantize gravity and continues to be used in modern methods based on supergravity, extra dimensions, string theory and M-theory.

Non-renormalizablity

One of the major obstacles facing quantum gravity were the infinities that rendered the theory “non-renormalizable”, in contrast to those arising in models of the strong nuclear, electromagnetic and weak nuclear forces, where they could be absorbed into a renormalization of the masses and coupling constants. The arrival of dimensional regularization in 1972 opened the door to loop corrections to Feynman diagrams in quantum field theory which manifestly preserved gauge invariance. In particular, it was also applied by ’t Hooft and Veltman [‘t Hooft 1972] to quantum gravity showing that although pure gravity was finite at one loop, it ceased to be finite when coupled to a scalar field. This raised the question of whether couplings to other forms of matter might avoid this problem.

For example, let us consider the case of the Einstein-Maxwell Lagrangian

L=−−g[κ−2R+14FμνFρσgμρgνσ]L=-\sqrt{-g}\left[\kappa^{-2}R+\frac{1}{4}F_{\mu\nu}F^{\rho\sigma}g^{\mu\rho}g^{\nu\sigma}\right]

where κ2=8πG\kappa^2=8\pi G and GG is Newton’s constant, gμνg_{\mu\nu} is the metric tensor, gμνg^{\mu\nu} is its inverse and gg its determinant. RR is the curvature scalar and FμνF_{\mu\nu} is the curl of the Maxwell potential AμA_\mu, Fμν=∂μAν−∂νAμF_{\mu\nu}=\partial_\mu A_\nu-\partial_\nu A_\mu. Deser and Van Nieuwenhuizen [15] calculated the one-loop counterterms ΔL\Delta L necessary to cancel the infinities using dimensional regularization with parameter ϵ=D−4\epsilon=D-4 where DD is the spacetime dimension. Since κ\kappa is the only dimensional constant there will be no divergences proportional to LL itself nor a cosmological term −g\sqrt{-g}.

Explicit calculation yields one non-vanishing term

ΔL=(−g/ϵ)13760RμνRμν\Delta L=\left(\sqrt{-g}/\epsilon\right)\frac{137}{60}R_{\mu\nu}R^{\mu\nu}

and the theory is not one-loop renormalizable. Similar negative results were found for Yang-Mills fields [12 1974c] and for spin 1/21/2 fermions [14], but as discussed in § 2.5 the game was about to change dramatically with the arrival of Supergravity.

Weyl anomalies

The conformal invariance under Weyl rescalings of the metric tensor

gμν(x)→Ω2(x)gμν(x)g_{\mu\nu}(x)\to\Omega^2(x)g_{\mu\nu}(x)

displayed by classical massless field systems in interaction with gravity no longer survives in the quantum theory. As a consequence, the regularized energy-momentum tensor develops a non-vanishing trace:

gαβ⟨Tαβ⟩≠0g^{\alpha\beta}\langle T_{\alpha\beta}\rangle\ne0

In April 1976 Deser, Duff and Isham wrote down the most general form of the trace of the energy-momentum tensor in various dimensions [11]. By general covariance and dimensional analysis, it must take the following form:

D=2gαβ⟨Tαβ⟩=cRD=4gαβ⟨Tαβ⟩=αR2+βRμνRμν+γRμνρσRμνρσ+δ□RD=2ngαβ⟨Tαβ⟩=(Riemann⁡)n+…(1)\begin{aligned} D&=2 && g^{\alpha\beta}\langle T_{\alpha\beta}\rangle= cR\\ D&=4 && g^{\alpha\beta}\langle T_{\alpha\beta}\rangle= \alpha R^2+\beta R_{\mu\nu}R^{\mu\nu}+\gamma R_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}R^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}+\delta\Box R\\ D&=2n && g^{\alpha\beta}\langle T_{\alpha\beta}\rangle= (\operatorname{Riemann})^n+\ldots \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

(At one-loop, and ignoring boundary terms, there is no anomaly for D odd). The significance of this paper was to demonstrate that, in addition to scheme-dependent terms such as □R\Box R which can be removed by the addition of finite local counterterms such as R2R^2, there are scheme-independent terms such as αR2+\alpha R^2+ βRμνRμν+γRμνρσRμνρσ\beta R_{\mu\nu}R^{\mu\nu}+\gamma R_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}R^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma} which cannot, thus laying to rest any lingering doubts about the inevitability of Weyl anomalies. As is well-known, the effective action arising from closed loops of massless particles is non-local. The title of the paper Non-local Conformal Anomalies was chosen to emphasize that although the trace of the stress tensor and infinite counterterms are local, for example CμνρσCμνρσC_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}C^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma} where

Cμνρσ=Rμνρσ+12(Rμρgνσ−Rνρgμσ+Rνσgμρ−Rμσgνρ)+16R(gνρgμσ−gμρgνσ)C_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}=R_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}+\frac{1}{2}(R_{\mu\rho}g_{\nu\sigma}-R_{\nu\rho}g_{\mu\sigma}+R_{\nu\sigma}g_{\mu\rho}-R_{\mu\sigma}g_{\nu\rho})+\frac{1}{6}R(g_{\nu\rho}g_{\mu\sigma}-g_{\mu\rho}g_{\nu\sigma})

is the Weyl tensor, the finite effective action responsible for the (curvature)2(curvature)^2 anomalies is not, for example

Cμνρσln⁡□ CμνρσC_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\ln\Box\,C^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}

This means, incidentally, that Starobinsky’s original model of cosmic inflation [Starobinsky 1980] which was driven by the Weyl anomaly, involved a non-local Lagrangian and not the local R+R2R+R^2 as is often stated. One may construct a local action involving extra scalar fields which yields the non-local action after integrating out the scalars [Riegert 1984]. However, the exact form of the non-localities is still a matter of debate. In September 1976 Eguchi and Freund [Eguchi 1976] considered two topological invariants: the Pontryagin number

P=1(4π)2∫d4xg ϵμνρσRμναβRρσαβP=\frac{1}{(4\pi)^2}\int d^4x\sqrt{g}\,\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}R_{\mu\nu}{}^{\alpha\beta}R_{\rho\sigma\alpha\beta}

and the Euler number

χ=12(4π)2∫d4xg[RαβγδRαβγδ−4RμνRμν+R2]\chi=\frac{1}{2(4\pi)^2}\int d^4x\sqrt{g}\left[R_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}R^{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}-4R_{\mu\nu}R^{\mu\nu}+R^2\right]

and posed the question: to what anomalies do they contribute? They found that P appears in the integrated divergence of the axial fermion number current, thus providing a novel topological interpretation of the anomaly found by Kimura [Kimura 1969] in 1969 and Delbourgo and Salam [Delbourgo 1972] in 1972. However, they found no analogous role for χ\chi. Drawing on [15], however, one could show that for Conformal Field Theories (CFTs) in D=4D=4, the trace of the stress tensor depends on just two constants [Duff 1977,1994]:

gαβ⟨Tαβ⟩=1(4π)2(cF−aG)g^{\alpha\beta}\langle T_{\alpha\beta}\rangle=\frac{1}{(4\pi)^2}(cF-aG)

where F is the square of the Weyl tensor F=CμνρσCμνρσF=C_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}C^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma} and G is the Euler number density (4π)2χ=∫d4xgG(4\pi)^2\chi=\int d^4x\sqrt{g}G. For free CFTs with NsN_s massless fields of spin ss

720c=6N0+18N1/2+72N1720c=6N_0+18N_{1/2}+72N_1
720a=2N0+11N1/2+124N1720a=2N_0+11N_{1/2}+124N_1

Note the inequalities on the ratio a/ca/c: 31/16≥a/c≥1/331/16\ge a/c\ge1/3 where the upper and lower bounds are saturated by a single vector and a single scalar, respectively. Remarkably, these bounds continue to hold true when the CFT is interacting.

The “conformal-Euler” structure of the anomaly, cF−aGcF-aG, was generalized to arbitrary even dimensions by Deser and Schwimmer [28]

gαβ⟨Tαβ⟩=∑iciIi−(−1)D/2aEDg^{\alpha\beta}\langle T_{\alpha\beta}\rangle=\sum_i c^i I_i-(-1)^{D/2}aE_D

where EDE_D is the Euler density arising from scale-free contributions to the effective gravitational action and the IiI_i are local conformal scalar polynomials involving powers of the Weyl tensor and its derivatives; their number increases rapidly with dimension. The two terms are called Type B and Type A, respectively. The two dimensional anomaly is purely Type A, suggesting that the c-theorem on renormalisation group flow in D = 2 [Zamolodchikov 1986] would generalize to an a-theorem in D = 4. This has now been proved [1]. These theorems confirm that theories at high energies have more degrees of freedom than theories at low energies and that information is lost as we flow from the former to the latter.

Spacetime Weyl anomalies have found application in quantum corrections to the Schwarzschild solution and Newton’s law, particle creation, the Hawking effect, inflationary cosmology, asymptotic safety, wormholes, viscosity bounds, condensed matter physics, hydrodynamics, the graviton mass in the braneworld, conformal collider physics, quantum entanglement, log corrections to black hole entropy, generalized mirror symmetry, and doublecopy theories. An especially important role is played by the holographic Weyl anomaly in the AdS/CFT correspondence [Henningson 1998, Graham 1999].

The cancellation of worldsheet Weyl anomalies not only determines the critical dimensions D=26D = 26 for strings and D=10D = 10 for superstrings but also provides the derivation of the spacetime Einstein equations [Callan 1980].

Consistent Supergravity

The discovery of Supergravity, a supersymmetric version of general relativity, by Freedman, Ferrara and Van Nieuwenhuizen [Freedman 1976] and by Deser and Zumino [17] represents an important milestone in theoretical physics. If Einstein had not already discovered general relativity, supersymmetry would have forced us to invent it: a local supersymmetry transformation is the square root of a general co-ordinate transformation, the basis of relativity. The emphasis of the Deser-Zumino paper was to find a combined spin 2 - spin 3/2 extension of general relativity is which is free of the usual higher spin inconsistencies. This was most easily achieved in first-order formalism where the vierbein eμae_\mu^a and spin connection ωμab\omega_\mu^{ab} are treated independently. The result was a Lagrangian which was the sum of an Einstein term and a minimally coupled Majorana Rarita-Schwinger field ψμ\psi_\mu.

L=−12eR−12ϵμνρσψˉμγ5γνDρψσL = -\frac{1}{2}eR-\frac{1}{2}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\bar{\psi}_\mu\gamma_5\gamma_\nu D_\rho\psi_\sigma

where e=det⁡eμae = \det e_\mu^a, R=eaμebνRμνabR = e^\mu_a e^\nu_b R_{\mu\nu}^{ab} and where Dμ=∂μ−ωμab[γa,γb]/8D_\mu= \partial_\mu-\omega_\mu^{ab}[\gamma_a,\gamma_b]/8 satisfies [Dμ,Dν]=−Rμνab[γa,γb]/8[D_\mu,D_\nu] = -R_{\mu\nu}^{ab}[\gamma_a,\gamma_b]/8. Varying the gravitino ψμ\psi_\mu, the spin connection ωμab\omega_\mu^{ab} and the vierbein eμae_\mu^a independently, the equations of motion are

Rλ≡ϵλμνρ(γμDνψρ−14γτCμντψρ)=0R^\lambda\equiv\epsilon^{\lambda\mu\nu\rho}\left(\gamma_\mu D_\nu\psi_\rho-\frac{1}{4}\gamma_\tau C_{\mu\nu}^{\tau}\psi_\rho\right)=0
Cμντ=i2ψˉμγτψνC_{\mu\nu}^{\tau}=\frac{i}{2}\bar{\psi}_\mu\gamma^\tau\psi_\nu
Gτμ=i2ϵλμνρψˉλγ5γτDνψρG^{\tau\mu}=\frac{i}{2}\epsilon^{\lambda\mu\nu\rho}\bar{\psi}_\lambda\gamma_5\gamma^\tau D_\nu\psi_\rho

where Gaτ=Raτ−eaτR/2G^\tau_a = R^\tau_a-e^\tau_aR/2 with Rτa=Rτλa    λR_{\tau a}=R_{\tau\lambda a}^{\ \ \ \ \lambda} is the (non-symmetric) Einstein tensor and Cμνa=Dμeνa−DνeμaC_{\mu\nu}^{a}=D_\mu e_\nu^a-D_\nu e_\mu^a is the torsion. In general, the consistency problem arises when applying DλD_\lambda to the left hand side of the Rarita-Schwinger equation one obtains an undesirable constraint on the solutions. In the Deser-Zumino set-up, however, DλRλD_\lambda R^\lambda vanishes as a consequence of the other equations of motion.

Supergravity soon became a hot topic for research. For a review, see [Van Nieuwenhuizen 1981]. It was found that the N=1N = 1 supermultiplet with one spin 2 and one spin 3/2 can be enlarged to N=2N = 2 with one spin 2, two spin-3/2 and one spin 1 and so on to a maximal N=8N = 8 with one spin 2, eight spin 3/2, twenty-eight spin 1, fifty-six spin 1/2 and seventy spin 0. Going beyond N=8N = 8 leads to inconsistent higher spins. Since each supersymmetry is associated with a 4-component spinor parameter, this means a maximum of Q=32Q = 32 components. If one asks what is the maximum dimension of spacetime, DD, admitting Q=32Q = 32, one finds D=11D = 11. Thus supergravity led a revival of the Kaluza-Klein idea of extra dimensions which was incorporated in superstring theory whose critical dimension is D=10D = 10 and M-theory whose critical dimension is D=11D = 11.

Deser and Zumino continued their collaboration with influential papers on the spinning string theory [18] and broken supersymmetry [21].

Infinities in supergravity

One of the chief questions in the construction of supergravity [17] (Freedman 1976) was whether this theory would prove renormalizable, in contrast to ordinary Einstein gravity with or without coupling to spin 00, 1/21/2 and 11, as discussed in § 2.2. Supersymmetry places extra constraints on the possible counterterms. Indeed, pure N=1N = 1 supergravity (gravity plus spin 3/23/2 gravitino) was shown to be finite at one and two loops as was N=2N = 2 (gravity plus 2 gravitinos plus a photon) [Grisaru 1976].

However, hopes that these symmetry arguments would continue to three loops and beyond were dashed when Deser, Kay and Stelle [20] showed that a candidate counterterm exists whose bosonic part is given by the square of Bel-Robinson tensor TμναβT_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}

Tμναβ=−RλαμρRλβρν+∗Rλαμρ∗RλβρνT_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta} = -R^{\lambda}{}_{\alpha\mu}{}^{\rho}R_{\lambda\beta\rho\nu} + {}^{*}R^{\lambda}{}_{\alpha\mu}{}^{\rho}{}^{*}R_{\lambda\beta\rho\nu}

which is totally symmetric, traceless and conserved on shell. The study of ultraviolet divergences in supergravity, of which Stanley Deser was a pioneer, has since become a major industry. But just because a candidate counterterm exists it does not necessarily mean it will actually appear and supergravity turns out to exhibit surprising degrees of finiteness, which are still unexplained. Here we reproduce a summary of Bern et al [5] in Table 1.

DQNCountertermLoopDivergence?
4328D8R4D^{8}R^{4}7unknown
4164R4R^{4}3no
4205D2R4D^{2}R^{4}4no
5164R4R^{4}2no

Table 1. Counterterms corresponding to the first potential divergence that satisfy all proven symmetry constraints, but which nevertheless fail to appear. D denotes the spacetime dimension, Q the number of supercharges and N the number of supersymmetries.

It is still an open question whether the maximally supersymmetric (N=8,D=4N = 8, D = 4) supergravity is or is not finite.

Topologically Massive Gravity

Another important strand of Deser’s work concerned the dynamics of gravity and gauge theories in lower-dimensional spacetimes. In an influential collaborations with Jackiw and Templeton (garnering over 3000 citations), vector and gravity models were studied in three-dimensional space-time, where novel, gauge invariant, terms of topological origin give rise to masses for the gauge fields [25].

In separate work with Jackiw and ’t Hooft, Deser investigated the peculiar dynamics of three dimensional gravity [26]. By virtue of the identity,

Rαβμν=ϵμνσϵαβγRσλR^{\mu\nu}_{\alpha\beta} = \epsilon^{\mu\nu\sigma}\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma}R^{\lambda}_{\sigma}

linking curvature and Einstein tensors, empty regions where Gσλ=0G^{\lambda}_{\sigma} = 0 are flat while internal ones with non-vanishing stress-tensors Gσλ=8πGTσλG^{\lambda}_{\sigma} = 8\pi G T^{\lambda}_{\sigma} are not.

Legacy

Given Stanley Deser’s pioneering contributions, it is worthwhile reviewing the current status of supergravity [17] (Freedman 1976) and supersymmetry in general.

Supersymmetry unites bosons (particles with integer spin) and fermions (particles with odd half-integer spin). Roughly speaking, if our equations remain the same when we swap the bosons and fermions, we say they are supersymmetric. For example, known bosons: spin-0 Higgs, spin-1 photon and spin-2 gravitons have as their superpartners the not-yet-discovered fermions: spin-1/2 Higgsinos, spin-1/2 photinos and spin-3/2 gravitinos. Whereas known fermions: spin-1/2 electrons and spin-1/2 quarks have as their superpartners the not-yet-discovered bosons: spin-0 selectrons and spin-0 squarks. The failure to detect these supersymmetric particles at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) in Geneva has affected the theoretical physics communities in different ways.

In the 1970s the formal-theory/quantum-gravity community embraced global and local supersymmetry as fermionic extensions of Einstein’s Special and General Relativities, respectively, providing a natural framework for unifying gravity with the other forces. This continued with the arrival of the 1984 string revolution which replaced 0-dimensional particles by 1-dimensional strings as the fundamental building blocks, thereby solving the problem of ultraviolet divergences. Supergravity was seen to be the low-energy limit of superstring theory. In the 1995 membrane revolution, string theory was seen to be the weak-coupling limit of a deeper, more profound, theory called M-theory which unified the five consistent D=10D = 10 string theories and D=11D = 11 supergravity by incorporating extended membrane-like objects called pp-branes of which strings and particles were respectively the p=1p = 1 and p=0p = 0 special cases. M-theory owes as much to supergravity as it does to string theory especially in the context of 11 dimensions where there are no superstrings.

In the meantime, however, the particle physics community became enamoured of supersymmetry for its own purposes, namely as a possible solution to the “gauge hierarchy problem” (the huge disparity between the energy scale of the weak nuclear force and that of gravity, the Planck scale). Omitting the details, if supersymmetry were to be the solution to the gauge hierarchy problem, one would expect to see the missing superpartners at the Large Hadron Collider; if not then one would not because there would be no reason for them to be light enough. So the failure to detect at them does not rule out supersymmetry itself and the quantum gravity community, many of whom never endorsed the hierarchy idea in the first place, were mainly unfazed.

We recall that there were three outstanding issues in quantum gravity in the 1970s: (1) Ultraviolet divergences and non-renormalizability; (2) The microscopic origin of the Bekenstein-Hawking black hole entropy; (3) The black hole information paradox (the apparent clash between quantum mechanics and general relativity when a black hole evaporates). Fifty years on, a glance at hep-th https://arxiv.org/list/hep-th/new confirms that supergravity, string theory and M-theory continue to be the favourite candidates for reconciling gravity and quantum mechanics. This is not without good reason. Supersymmetry in the form of string theory provided an answer to problem (1), supersymmetry in the form of M-theory has provided an answer to problem (2) and supersymmetry in the form of AdS/CFT has (according to Hawking and others) provided an answer to problem (3). Moreover, no other theory provides adequate answers to any of (1), (2) or (3). Supersymmetry is alive and kicking and Supergravity continues to be an active area of research both as the low energy limit of string theory and in its own right, thanks in large part to Stanley Deser.

More on Stanley Deser’s scientific contributions may be found in the Proceedings of the Deserfest [Liu 2006], a tribute to S. Deser [Tekin 2023], the Stanley Deser Memorial Volume [6] in particular [7].

PERSONAL RECOLLECTIONS OF MJD

I first came into contact with Stanley as a student at the last (1970) Brandeis Summer School, of which he was a co-organizer. He was easy to spot because there was always a cloud of pipe-smoke following him around, but did not get to know him personally until he visited King’s College London in 1976 where he was a guest of Chris Isham and I was a postdoc.

In fact he had a long association with the UK, dating back to collaborations with Hermann Bondi (FRS 1959) and Felix Pirani at King’s, with Dennis Sciama (FRS 1983) at Oxford where he was visiting Fellow of All Souls and Gary Gibbons at Cambridge. The combination of permanent staff, postdocs and visitors made King’s a centre of activity for classical gravity (Felix Pirani and David Robinson), quantum field theory in curved spacetime (Tim Bunch, Steve Christensen, Paul Davies, Larry Ford, Steve Fulling and Bill Unruh (FRS 2001) and quantum gravity (Stanley Deser, Chris Isham, John G. Taylor and the authors MJD and KSS). Many appear in the photograph Figure 3, courtesy of Steve Christensen. See [Robinson 2018] for a history. But the visitor who had the greatest impact on Chris and me was Stanley (the one smoking the cigar): non-local conformal anomalies [15], discussed in § 2.3, solitons of chiral theories in three space dimensions [16]. The DDI collaboration continued at Imperial College with a paper on gravitationally induced CP effects via a ϵμνρRμνabRρ ab\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho}R_{\mu\nu ab}R_{\rho}^{\ ab} in the action [24]. See also my tribute to Chris Isham [4].

King’s College London 1976

Figure 3. King’s College London 1976. FRONT ROW: Dave Storey, Unknown, Steve Christensen, Bernard Kay, Joyce El Eini, Chris Isham, Mike Duff. BACK ROW: John Taylor, Steve Fulling, Stephen Downs-Martin, Tim Bunch, Chris Mannion, David Robinson, Bob Davis, Stanley Deser, Tezt Yoshimura, Paul Davies.. Photograph provided by Steve Christensen.

The chiral solitons paper introduced fourth order terms in the Lagrangian necessary to circumvent the Derrick no-go theorem in three dimensions. An alternative circumvention was to raise the sigma-model Lagrangian to the power 3/2. We obtained what we considered to be nice results [16 1976c] only to discover that some had been anticipated by Skyrme in the early 60s, although this is overlooked in the received history of the Skrymion revival [Aitchison 2019].

My interactions with Stanley were set to increase when I accepted an offer of a two-year NSF postdoc at Brandeis, where there was very active group including Marc Grisaru, Howie Schnitzer and Burt Ovrut. I also enjoyed the warm hospitality extended by Stanley and his wife Elsbeth at their home in Newton. Elsbeth was an accomplished artist and daughter of the Swedish physicist Oskar Klein, whose work on extra dimensions was to have a profound effect on the my career.

Memories of Stanley include a stay in the Academy of Sciences Hotel for one of the Moscow Quantum Gravity conferences circa 1980. Stanley and I set out one night for dinner at a nearby restaurant. In those bleak years before Glasnost it was not uncommon to be turned away from half-empty restaurants on the grounds that they were “full”. This is exactly what happened, but Stanley Deser would not take no for an answer and stuck his foot in the door as the proprietor tried to close it in our faces. Fisticuffs broke out until I managed to pull Stanley away arguing that the meal was probably not worth getting beaten up for.

Stanley passed away in 2023 but in the later stages of his illness we kept up a vigorous exchange of e-mails. Although those who have corresponded with Stanley will recall that his messages, often crammed into the subject line, sometimes needed an Enigma Machine to decipher his cryptic comments. Scientifically, Stanley’s intellect was formidable. But he was also a cultured polymath and linguist, with a deep appreciation of literature and the arts and a connoisseur of fine food and wine. “Frivolous” is the last adjective that springs to mind when recalling Stanley Deser. All the more enjoyable therefore was the game we played: Physics-based Horror Movies. This was prompted by an invitation I received from Peter Freund to deliver the 9th annual Schrödinger lecture in Transylvania. Some weak attempts included Frank Einstein, Bram Stoker’s Theorem, The Texas Chain Rule Massacre, Mary Shelley Glashow, Fadeev-Popov Ghosts, Paranormal Coordinates, The Killing Room, Maxwell’s Demon, Phantom Black Holes and The Bourne Approximation, but Stanley trumped them all with Diracula!

Stanley and other quantum gravity enthusiasts celebrating the Arnowitt?Deser?Misner (ADM) formulation at Texas A&M University

Figure 4. Stanley and other quantum gravity enthusiasts celebrating the Arnowitt?Deser?Misner (ADM) formulation at Texas A&M University. (From left to right) Bryce DeWitt, Stanley Deser, Mary K. Gaillard, Bruno Zumino, Mic© Photograph by Roland Allen.

HONOURS AND AWARDS

  • Sigma Xi 1949

  • Guggenheim Fellowship 1966-67

  • Fulbright Fellowship, Uruguay 1970

  • Fulbright Fellowship, France 1971-72

  • Distinguished Alumnus Award of Honor, Brooklyn College 1971

  • Fellow, American Physical Society 1972

  • Bude Medal, College de France 1976

  • Honorary D. Phil., University of Stockholm Centennial 1978

  • Fellow, American Academy of Arts and Sciences 1979

  • Ryan Memorial lecturer, Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies 1982

  • Investigador Titular Ad Honorem, CIDA, Venezuela 1983

  • Dannie Heineman Prize in Mathematical Physics 1994

  • Fellow, National Academy of Sciences 1994

  • Honorary Foreign Member, Academy of Science of Torino 2001

Honorary D. Tech., Chalmers University of Technology 2001

Lifetime Achievement Award, Brooklyn College 2004

W. Bonnor Prize, GRG Society 2007

Einstein Medal, General Relativity Centennial, 2015

Foreign Member of the Royal Society 2021

REFERENCES TO OTHER AUTHORS

[1] Z. Komargodski and A. Schwimmer, On Renormalization Group Flows in Four Dimensions, JHEP 12 (2011) 099, arXiv:1107.3987

[2] D. C. Robinson, Gravitation and general relativity at King’s College London, Eur. Phys. J. H 44 181-270 (2019) .

[3] Bayram Tekin, A Tribute to S. Deser: Conserved Quantities in Generic Gravity Theories https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2307.12758

[4] M.J. Duff, Chris Isham: mentor, colleague, friend e-Print: 2112.13722 [physics.hist-ph]

[5] Zvi Bern, John Joseph M. Carrasco, Marco Chiodaroli, Henrik Johansson, Radu Roiban, Supergravity amplitudes, the double copy and ultraviolet behavior, arXiv:2304.07392v1 [hep-th] https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2 46 pages, invited chapter for Handbook of Quantum Gravity (Eds. C. Bambi, L. Modesto and I.L. Shapiro, Springer Singapore.

[6] Marc Henneaux, Rafael I. Nepomechie Domenico Seminara, Preface to fields, gravity, strings and beyond: in memory of Stanley Deser J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 58 410301 (2025)

[7] M.J. Duff, Montonen-Olive duality of gauged supergravity? J.Phys.A 58 (2025) 5, 055401 e-Print: 2410.03875 [hep-th] DOI: 10.1088/1751-8121/ada745 Report number: Imperial/TP/2024/mjd/1

BIBLIOGRAPHY

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

MJD is very grateful to Chris Hull and Leron Borsten for discussions that led to improvements to the manuscript. He would also like to thank Kelly Stelle’s widow Marise Westbroek for permission to include Kelly’s contributions.

AUTHOR PROFILES

  • Michael Duff

Michael Duff (FRS 2009) is Emeritus Professor of Theoretical Physics and Distinguished Research Fellow at Imperial College London. He was formerly Abdus Salam Professor of Theoretical Physics and Principal of the Faculty of Physical Sciences. He is recipient of the 2004 Meeting Gold Medal, El Colegio Nacional, Mexico, the 2017 Paul Dirac Gold Medal and Prize, Institute of Physics, UK and the 2018 Trotter Prize, USA. He is a visitor to The Institute of Quantum Science and Engineering at Texas A&M University and was inducted as 2019 Faculty Fellow of the Hagler Institute for Advanced Study there. A special issue of Proceedings of the Royal Society, https://royalsocietypublishing.org/topic/specialcollections/duff-quantum-gravity, Quantum Gravity, Branes and M-theory was dedicated him on the occasion of his 70th birthday.

  • Kellogg Stelle

Kelly Stelle was Professor of Theoretical Physics at Imperial College London and formerly Head of the Theoretical Physics Group. He is the recipient of the 2006 Humboldt Research Award, Alexander von Humboldt Foundation, and the 2020 John William Strutt, Lord Rayleigh Medal and Prize, Institute of Physics. A tribute to his memory maybe found at https://www.online-tribute.com/KellyStelle.

Portrait of Michael Duff FRS

Figure 5 (PDF p. 15). Michael Duff FRS (Portrait by Beyond the Pixels.)

Portrait of Kellogg Stelle

Figure 6 (PDF p. 15). Kellogg Stelle (courtesy of Imperial College)

References

  1. [1][Komargodski 2011] Z. Komargodski and A. Schwimmer, On Renormalization Group Flows in Four Dimensions, JHEP 12 (2011) 099, arXiv:1107.3987DOI
  2. [2][Robinson 2019] D. C. Robinson, Gravitation and general relativity at King’s College London, Eur. Phys. J. H 44 181-270 (2019) .
  3. [3][Tekin 2019] Bayram Tekin, A Tribute to S. Deser: Conserved Quantities in Generic Gravity Theories https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2307.12758
  4. [4][Duff 2021] M.J. Duff, Chris Isham: mentor, colleague, friend e-Print: 2112.13722 [physics.hist-ph]arxiv.org/abs/2112.13722
  5. [5][Bern 2023] Zvi Bern, John Joseph M. Carrasco, Marco Chiodaroli, Henrik Johansson, Radu Roiban, Supergravity amplitudes, the double copy and ultraviolet behavior, arXiv:2304.07392v1 [hep-th] https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2304.07392 46 pages, invited chapter for Handbook of Quantum Gravity (Eds. C. Bambi, L. Modesto and I.L. Shapiro, Springer Singapore.
  6. [6][Henneaux 2025] Marc Henneaux, Rafael I. Nepomchie Domenico Seminara, Preface to fields, gravity, strings and beyond: in memory of Stanley Deser J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 58 410301 (2025)DOI
  7. [7][Duff 2025] M.J. Duff, Montonen-Olive duality of gauged supergravity? J.Phys.A 58 (2025) 5, 055401 e-Print: 2410.03875 [hep-th] DOI: 10.1088/1751-8121/ada745 Report number: Imperial/TP/2024/mjd/1DOI
  8. [8][Deser 1962] The Dynamics of General Relativity (with R. Arnowitt and C.W. Misner) in Gravitation: An Introduction to Current Research, (ed. L. Witten), Wiley, NY (1962); reprinted as gr-qc/0405109. Reprinted in Gen.Rel.Grav. 40 (2008) 1997.
  9. [9][Deser 1968] Positive-Definiteness of Gravitational Field Energy (with D. Brill), Phys. Rev Lett. 20, 75 (1968).DOI
  10. [10][Deser 1972] Can gravitation have a finite range? (with D.G. Boulware) Phys.Rev. D6 (1972) 3368DOI
  11. [11][Deser 1974a] One Loop Divergences of Quantized Einstein-Maxwell Fields, ( with P. van Nieuwenhuizen), Phys.Rev. D10 (1974) 401DOI
  12. [12][Deser 1974b] Nonrenormalizability of Einstein-Yang-Mills Interactions at the One-Loop Level (with H.-S. Tsao and P. van Nieuwenhuizen), Phys. Lett. 50B, 491 (1974).DOI
  13. [14][Deser 1974d] Nonrenormalizability of Quantized Fermion Gravitation Interactions (with P. van Nieuwenhuizen), Nuovo Cimento Lett. 2, 218 (1974)
  14. [15][Deser 1976a] Nonlocal Conformal Anomalies, (with M.J. Duff and C.J. Isham), Nucl.Phys. B111 (1976) 45
  15. [16][Deser 1976b] Finite Energy Static Solutions to Chiral Models in 3 Space Dimensions, (with M. J. Duff and C.J. Isham), Nucl. Phys. 114B, 29 (1976)
  16. [17][Deser 1976c] Consistent Supergravity (with B. Zumino), Phys. Lett. 62B, 335 (1976).DOI
  17. [18][Deser 1976d] A Complete action for the Spinning String, (with B. Zumino), Phys.Lett. B65 (1976) 369
  18. [19][Deser 1976e] Duality Transformations of Abelian and Non-Abelian Gauge Fields (with C. Teitelboim), Phys. Rev. D13, 1592 (1976).DOI
  19. [20][Deser 1977a] Renormalizability Properties of Supergravity, (with J.H. Kay and K.S. Stelle), Phys.Rev.Lett. 38 (1977) 527arxiv.org/abs/1506.03757
  20. [21][Deser 1977b] Supergravity Has Positive Energy (with C. Teitelboim), Phys. Rev. Lett. 39, 249 (1977).DOI
  21. [23][Deser 1979] Consistency Problems of Hypergravity (with C. Aragone), Phys. Lett. 86B, 161 (1979).DOI
  22. [24][Deser 1980] Gravitationally Induced CP Effects (with M.J. Duff and C.J. Isham), Phys. Letters 93B, 419 (1980).DOI
  23. [25][Deser 1982] Topologically Massive Gauge Theories, (with R. Jackiw and S. Templeton) Annals Phys. 140 (1982) 372,
  24. [26][Deser 1984] Three-Dimensional Einstein Gravity: Dynamics of Flat Space, (with R. Jackiw and G. ’t Hooft), Annals Phys.152 (1984) 220.DOI
  25. [28][Deser 1993] Geometric Classification of Conformal Anomalies in Arbitrary Dimensions (with A. Schwimmer), hep-th/9302042, Phys. Lett. B309, 279 (1993).
  26. [29][Deser 2021] Forks In The Road: A Life In Physics by Stanley Deser World Scientific (2021)

Paper details

vlnc:W_47ek59hb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents