betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Positivity of simplicial volume of convex projective manifolds

Abstract

Let ΩΩ be an irreducible properly convex projective domain admitting a discrete cocompact group action of projective automorphisms. We prove that the Holmes–Thompson volumes of projective simplices with vertices in ΩΩ are uniformly bounded. As a consequence, we prove that a closed properly convex projective manifold of dimension at least two has positive simplicial volume if and only if it is irreducible.

Introduction

One of the guiding problems in the study of properly convex projective manifolds is to understand how the geometry of their developing domains constrains the topology of compact quotients. In the divisible strictly convex case, the Hilbert geometry is Gromov hyperbolic and many features of negatively curved manifolds persist ([4]). General divisible properly convex domains, however, can have nontrivial boundary segments and properly embedded simplices. In particular, neither negative sectional curvature nor hyperbolicity of the fundamental group is available in general.

Recall that a properly convex domain Ω⊂RPn\Omega\subset\mathbb{RP}^{n} is an open convex subset that is bounded in some affine chart. It is divisible if a discrete subgroup Γ<Aut⁡(Ω)\Gamma< \operatorname{Aut}(\Omega) acts cocompactly, and a closed properly convex projective manifold is a quotient M=Γ\ΩM = \Gamma\backslash\Omega with Γ\Gamma torsion-free. The Hilbert metric on Ω\Omega is a complete projectively invariant Finsler metric. Its geodesics include the ordinary projective segments, although uniqueness of geodesics can fail when the boundary contains segments.

For an oriented closed nn-manifold, its simplicial volume is the ℓ1\ell^{1}-seminorm of the real fundamental class,

∥M∥=inf⁡{∑j∣aj∣∣∑jajσj represents [M]}.\lVert M\rVert= \inf\left\{ \sum_j \lvert a_j\rvert\mathrel{\bigg|} \sum_j a_j\sigma_j \text{ represents } [M] \right\}.

In hyperbolic geometry, positivity of ∥M∥\lVert M\rVert follows by integrating the volume form over straight simplices, whose volumes have a uniform upper bound ([12]). This produces a bounded cocycle with positive evaluation on the fundamental class, which is the geometric paradigm underlying Gromov’s theory ([11]). We establish an analogous bound for projective simplices in Ω\Omega, measured using the Holmes–Thompson volume of the Hilbert metric.

Let C⊂Rn+1C \subset\mathbb{R}^{n+1} be either of the two proper open cones projecting to Ω\Omega. We say that Ω\Omega is irreducible when there are no nonzero complementary subspaces L1,L2L_1,L_2 and proper open convex cones Ci⊂LiC_i \subset L_i with C=C1×C2C=C_1\times C_2. Equivalently, Ω\Omega is not a nontrivial projective join. This is the same irreducibility convention used in the rigidity theory of divisible properly convex domains (also called indecomposability in the sense of Vey and Benoist); it should not be confused with any connected-sum decomposition of MM. For a divisible domain, Vey’s irreducibility theorem says that this condition implies that every finite-index subgroup of a dividing group Γ\Gamma acts irreducibly on Rn+1\mathbb{R}^{n+1}; see [4 Theorem 5.1].

Theorem A. Let Ω⊂RPn\Omega\subset\mathbb{RP}^n, n≥2n \ge2, be an irreducible divisible properly convex domain. There exists VΩ<∞V_\Omega<\infty such that

Vol⁡HT,Ω(σ)≤VΩ\operatorname{Vol}_{\mathrm{HT},\Omega}(\sigma) \le V_\Omega

for every (possibly degenerate) projective nn-simplex σ\sigma with vertices in Ω\Omega. The volume is the Holmes–Thompson volume of the Hilbert metric of Ω\Omega.

The assertion concerns simplices in the universal cover. In particular, their vertices can approach arbitrary faces of ∂Ω\partial\Omega and their projections to a compact quotient need not be embedded. The natural Blaschke volume of the canonical affine sphere is comparable with Holmes–Thompson volume on a compact quotient. Equivariant straightening of singular simplices therefore gives the principal topological applications.

Corollary B. Every closed properly convex real projective manifold of dimension n≥2n \ge2 whose projective domain is irreducible has positive simplicial volume.

Corollary C. Let M=Γ\ΩM=\Gamma\backslash\Omega be a closed properly convex real projective manifold of dimension n≥2n \ge2. Then ∥M∥>0\lVert M\rVert>0 if and only if Ω\Omega is irreducible.

The main ingredient towards the proof of Theorem A is a characterization of irreducible divisible domains Ω\Omega in terms of the geometry of the associated affine sphere asymptotic to CC. This carries the Blaschke metric hh, which Calabi proved to have nonpositive Ricci tensor [7 Theorem 5.1]. We give a proof of this inequality in the cocompact setting needed here in Proposition 2.2 and improve this estimate in the case of existence of directions annihilating the Ricci tensor.

Theorem D. Let Ω⊂RPn\Omega\subset\mathbb{RP}^n, n≥2n \ge2, be a divisible properly convex domain, CC its positive cone, and hh the Blaschke metric of the canonical affine sphere, normalized to affine mean curvature −1-1. If

Ric⁡h,p(v,v)=0for some p∈Ω and 0≠v∈TpΩ,\operatorname{Ric}_{h,p}(v,v)=0 \qquad\text{for some }p\in\Omega\text{ and }0\ne v\in T_p\Omega,

then CC is a nontrivial direct product of proper open convex cones. Consequently, if CC is irreducible, there is ε>0\varepsilon>0 such that Ric⁡h≤−εh\operatorname{Ric}_h\le-\varepsilon h throughout $\Omega.

The two-dimensional equality case is known: see for example Li–Li–Simon [18]. A similar argument appears in Hu–Li–Vranc̆ken [14] who give characterizations of Calabi products under algebraic conditions on the cubic tensor. Section 2 shows that the null distribution is parallel and produces an ambient one-parameter automorphism whose eigenspaces split CC.

Related work. The relation between the Euler characteristic and simplicial volume has recently advanced substantially. In [BFR26], Bucher–Francaviglia–Rago construct bounded angle cocycles using immersed straightenings. In particular, their Theorem 1.2 proves that for any closed properly convex real projective dd-manifold there is a constant cd>0c_d>0, with cd≤(d+2)/4c_d\le(d+2)/4, such that

∣χ(M)∣≤cd∥M∥.(1)|\chi(M)|\le c_d\lVert M\rVert. \tag*{(1)}

Thus Gromov’s question whether vanishing simplicial volume forces vanishing Euler characteristic has an affirmative answer within the class of closed properly convex projective manifolds. This result should not be conflated with positivity of simplicial volume itself: (0.1) gives no information when χ(M)=0\chi(M)=0. Indeed, Bucher–Francaviglia–Rago explicitly ask in their Question 1.4 whether closed convex real projective manifolds with irreducible universal cover necessarily have positive simplicial volume. Corollary B is an affirmative answer to precisely that question. Our method is different from the angle-cocycle approach. Rather than representing the Euler class by a bounded cocycle, we produce a uniform volume bound for projective simplices and hence a bounded representative of the volume class.

Several previously known positivity results provide useful points of comparison. For an aspherical closed manifold with word-hyperbolic fundamental group, positivity follows from bounded-cohomological results of Mineyev [20]. For closed locally symmetric spaces of noncompact type, positivity was established by Lafont–Schmidt [17], with the relevant exceptional case treated by Bucher–Karlsson [5]. These cover strictly convex divisible domains and irreducible symmetric divisible domains, respectively, but not the full range of irreducible properly convex domains containing boundary segments.

Positivity is also known for closed aspherical manifolds of dimension at least two whose fundamental groups are non-elementary relatively hyperbolic. This follows from the relative bounded cohomology theorem of Mineyev–Yaman, for which Franceschini gives another proof [9 Theorem 1.1]. In convex projective geometry, this applies to certain non-strictly convex divisible domains whose dividing groups are relatively hyperbolic with respect to stabilizers of maximal properly embedded simplices, as well as to examples with peripheral subgroups arising from properly embedded cones; see [BFR26, Section 1] and the references therein. Corollary B establishes positivity for all irreducible divisible domains, without a relative hyperbolicity hypothesis.

There are also geometric examples in dimension four worth emphasizing. Riolo–Seppi–Slavich [21] construct closed indecomposable convex projective four-manifolds with positive Euler characteristic by gluing hyperbolic pieces. Their simplicial volume is known to be positive by the corresponding decomposition results, as noted in [BFR26]. Our theorem is not restricted to such decompositions.

Strategy of the proof. An elementary example illustrates the obstruction that our proof must exclude. Consider the open projective triangle

Ωtri={[x:y:1]∈RP2:x,y>0}.\Omega_{\mathrm{tri}}=\{[x:y:1]\in\mathbb{R}\mathbb{P}^{2}:x,y>0\}.

Positive dilations of the two affine coordinates are projective automorphisms of this domain. Invariance under these dilations implies that its Holmes–Thompson measure has the form

dVol⁡HT,Ωtri=cHTdx dyxy,cHT>0.d\operatorname{Vol}_{\mathrm{HT},\Omega_{\mathrm{tri}}}=c_{\mathrm{HT}}\frac{dx\,dy}{xy},\qquad c_{\mathrm{HT}}>0.

In particular, this measure is a constant multiple of Euclidean area in the coordinates (log⁡x,log⁡y)(\log x,\log y). The transformations (x,y)↦(ex,y)(x,y)\mapsto(e x,y) and (x,y)↦(x,ey)(x,y)\mapsto(x,e y) generate a group dividing Ωtri\Omega_{\mathrm{tri}}: in logarithmic coordinates, their action is simply translation by Z2\mathbb{Z}^{2}. Let γ(x,y)=(ex,y)\gamma(x,y)=(e x,y), and consider the projective triangles

σm=conv⁡{(1,1),(1,3),(em,1)},m≥1.\sigma_m=\operatorname{conv}\{(1,1),(1,3),(e^m,1)\},\qquad m\geq1.

Here we keep the first two vertices fixed and move the third along the orbit γm(1,1)\gamma^m(1,1). Each triangle contains the rectangle

[1,1+em2]×[1,2].\left[1,\frac{1+e^m}{2}\right]\times[1,2].

Consequently,

Vol⁡HT,Ωtri(σm)≥cHTlog⁡2log⁡(1+em2)⟶∞.\operatorname{Vol}_{\mathrm{HT},\Omega_{\mathrm{tri}}}(\sigma_m)\geq c_{\mathrm{HT}}\log2\log\left(\frac{1+e^m}{2}\right)\longrightarrow\infty.

Geometrically, these triangles contain a strip whose width in logarithmic coordinates stays fixed while its length tends to infinity.

The singular values of the transformations producing this growth have a particularly simple form. The determinant-one representative of γm\gamma^m is

diag⁡(e2m/3,e−m/3,e−m/3).\operatorname{diag}\left(e^{2m/3},e^{-m/3},e^{-m/3}\right).

There are only two distinct singular values: one direction expands relative to the other two, which are rescaled equally. Thus the volume growth occurs along a sequence for which the total distortion, i.e. the difference between the logarithms of the top and bottom singular values, grows without bound, while the variation within each of the two groups of singular values remains zero. Our proof obtains a quantitative obstruction to this behaviour for irreducible divisible domains and uses it to control the volumes of simplices.

We now give some details on how this is achieved. First, we strengthen Calabi’s nonpositivity of the Blaschke Ricci tensor: we show that if the Ricci tensor vanishes on a single nonzero vector then the cone splits as a nontrivial product. Irreducibility excludes this possibility, and cocompactness then gives a uniform estimate Rich≤−εh\mathrm{Ric}_h\leq-\varepsilon h for some ε>0\varepsilon>0.

The Gauss map of the hyperbolic affine sphere converts this curvature bound into a restriction on the singular values of cone automorphisms. Put N=n+1N=n+1, and let μ1(g)≥⋯≥μN(g)\mu_1(g)\geq\cdots\geq\mu_N(g) be the logarithms of the singular values of a representative normalized by ∣det⁡g∣=1|\det g|=1. Define

R(μ(g))=μ1(g)−μN(g),R(\mu(g))=\mu_1(g)-\mu_N(g),
Dk(μ(g))=∑i≤k(μ1(g)−μi(g))+∑i>k(μi(g)−μN(g)),1≤k<N.D_k(\mu(g))=\sum_{i\leq k}\left(\mu_1(g)-\mu_i(g)\right)+\sum_{i>k}\left(\mu_i(g)-\mu_N(g)\right),\qquad1\leq k<N.

Here RR measures the total spread of the logarithmic singular values, while DkD_k measures their variation within the first kk entries and within the remaining entries. In particular, DkD_k vanishes exactly when the entries are constant within each of these two groups. Such patterns arise naturally on a product cone, where one can rescale the two factors independently. In the example above we had R(μ(γm))=mR(\mu(\gamma^m))=m and D1(μ(γm))=0D_1(\mu(\gamma^m))=0, thus those are the quantities that we need to control in order to exclude the phenomenon described in the previous example. We achieve this by proving the quantitative estimate

Dk(μ(γ))≥δR(μ(γ))−cgap,∀γ∈Γ,1≤k<N.(2)D_k(\mu(\gamma))\geq\delta R(\mu(\gamma))-c_{\mathrm{gap}},\qquad\forall\gamma\in\Gamma,\quad1\leq k<N. \tag*{(2)}

for some δ>0\delta>0. This is a consequence of the relation between the Ricci curvature and the displacement of a fixed point in the symmetric space of positive definite quadratic forms. The estimate in particular says that as the distortion of a group element grows, its singular values cannot become concentrated in two groups with nearly equal values within each group.

As illustrated in the example above, this controls the volume of simplices. Consider a projective image D\mathcal{D} of Ω\Omega contained in the positive orthant, equipped with the measure

dy1⋯dyny1⋯yn=d(log⁡y1)⋯d(log⁡yn).\frac{dy_1\cdots dy_n}{y_1\cdots y_n}=d(\log y_1)\cdots d(\log y_n).

Our intermediate goal is to bound its total mass uniformly over all such projective images. In logarithmic coordinates, this is an ordinary Euclidean volume problem. Suppose that D\mathcal{D} contains boxes centred at aa and bb, with half-widths raira_i and rbirb_i in the ii-th coordinate, where 0<r≤1/40<r\leq1/4. Taking convex combinations of these boxes shows that, for every 0≤λ≤10\leq\lambda\leq1, the domain D\mathcal{D} contains the box centred at

pλ=(1−λ)a+λbp^\lambda=(1-\lambda)a+\lambda b

with half-widths rpiλrp_i^\lambda. Dividing the ii-th coordinate by piλp_i^\lambda sends this box to the fixed box [1−r,1+r]n[1-r,1+r]^n. We compare these coordinate changes as the centre moves along the segment. Write λ=e−s\lambda=e^{-s} and put ξi=log⁡(bi/ai)\xi_i=\log(b_i/a_i). Then

pi(s)=(1−e−s)ai+e−sbi.p_i(s)=(1-e^{-s})a_i+e^{-s}b_i.

For s≥log⁡2s \ge\log2, the factor 1−e−s1-e^{-s} lies between 1/21/2 and 11. Thus the size of pi(s)p_i(s) is determined, up to a fixed factor, by the larger of aia_i and e−sbie^{-s}b_i. Equivalently,

log⁡pi(s)={log⁡bi−s+O(1),s<ξi,log⁡ai+O(1),s≥ξi,\log p_i(s)= \begin{cases} \log b_i-s+O(1), & s<\xi_i,\\ \log a_i+O(1), & s\ge\xi_i, \end{cases}

where the errors are bounded by log⁡2\log2. Each coordinate therefore has a simple model: its logarithm decreases with slope −1-1 until s=ξis=\xi_i, and is constant afterwards.

References

  1. [1]A. Ash, D. Mumford, M. Rapoport, and Y.-S. Tai, Smooth Compactifications of Locally Symmetric Varieties, second edition, Cambridge Mathematical Library, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2010. doi:10.1017/CBO9780511674693.DOI
  2. [3]R. Benedetti and C. Petronio, Lectures on Hyperbolic Geometry, Universitext, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1992. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-58158-8.DOI
  3. [4]Y. Benoist, A survey on divisible convex sets, Advanced Lectures in Mathematics 6 (2008), 1–18.
  4. [5]M. Bucher-Karlsson, Simplicial volume of locally symmetric spaces covered by SL₃ℝ∕SO(3), Geom. Dedicata 125 (2007), 203–224.
  5. [7]E. Calabi, Complete affine hyperspheres. I, in Symposia Mathematica, Vol. X (Convegno di Geometria Differenziale, INDAM, Rome, 1971), Academic Press, London, 1972, pp. 19–38.
  6. [8]D. Faifman, A Funk perspective on billiards, projective geometry and Mahler volume, J. Diff. Geom. 127 (2024), no. 1, 161–212. doi:10.4310/jdg/1717356157.
  7. [9]F. Franceschini, A characterization of relatively hyperbolic groups via bounded cohomology, Groups Geom. Dyn. 12 (2018), no. 3, 919–960. doi:10.4171/GGD/463.
  8. [10]A. Goffi and F. Pediconi, A note on the strong maximum principle for fully nonlinear equations on Riemannian manifolds, J. Geom. Anal. 31 (2021), 8641–8665. doi:10.1007/s12220-021-00607-2.
  9. [11]M. Gromov, Volume and bounded cohomology, Publ. Math. Inst. Hautes Études Sci. 56 (1982), 5–99. Numdam.DOI
  10. [12]U. Haagerup and H. J. Munkholm, Simplices of maximal volume in hyperbolic n-space, Acta Math. 147 (1981), 1–11. doi:10.1007/BF02392865.
  11. [13]R. Hildebrand, On the ∞-norm of the cubic form of complete hyperbolic affine hyperspheres, Results Math. 64 (2013), 113–119. doi:10.1007/s00025-012-0301-7.
  12. [14]Z. Hu, H. Li, and L. Vrancken, Characterizations of the Calabi product of hyperbolic affine hyperspheres, Results Math. 52 (2008), 299–314. doi:10.1007/s00025-008-0312-6.
  13. [16]B. Klartag and A. V. Kolesnikov, Remarks on curvature in the transportation metric, Anal. Math. 43 (2017), 67–88. arXiv:1604.04165.
  14. [17]J.-F. Lafont and B. Schmidt, Simplicial volume of closed locally symmetric spaces of non-compact type, Acta Math. 197 (2006), 129–143.
  15. [18]A.-M. Li, H. Li, and U. Simon, Centroaffine Bernstein problems, Differential Geom. Appl. 20 (2004), no. 3, 331–356. doi:10.1016/j.difgeo.2003.12.004.DOI
  16. [19]J. Loftin, Survey on affine spheres, Handbook of Geometric Analysis, no. 2 (2010).
  17. [20]I. Mineyev, Straightening and bounded cohomology of hyperbolic groups, Geom. Funct. Anal. 11 (2001), 807–839.
  18. [21]S. Riolo, A. Seppi, and L. Slavich, Convex projective manifolds, symmetric spaces and geometric decompositions, arXiv:2607.05662.
  19. [22]C. A. Rogers and G. C. Shephard, The difference body of a convex body, Arch. Math. 8 (1957), 220–233. doi:10.1007/BF01899997.DOI
  20. [23]K. Yano, Gromov invariant and S¹-actions, J. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo Sect. IA Math. 29 (1982), no. 3, 493–501. doi:10.15083/00039566.

Paper details

vlnc:W_48updsxd
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents