WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Beyond the Fast Rotators: A JWST Multi-Cycle Treasury Survey of Substellar Weather
Abstract
Atmospheric variability provides a unique window into the three-dimensional structure, dynamics, and evolution of brown dwarf and giant exoplanet atmospheres. Recent JWST time-resolved spectroscopic observations have revealed complex wavelength-dependent variability, offering unprecedented insights into cloud structures, thermal perturbations, and atmospheric chemistry. However, existing programs have focused primarily on individual benchmarks and specific scientific questions, resulting in heterogeneous spectral and temporal coverage and leaving important regions of the substellar population underexplored, particularly across a broad range of rotation periods, spectral types, and viewing geometries. A JWST Multi-Cycle Treasury program could systematically investigate substellar weather across a diverse, well-characterized population. By combining broad infrared spectroscopic coverage with observations spanning multiple rotations and strategically selected epochs, this program would constrain the contributions of different physical mechanisms while investigating how atmospheric structures depend on rotation, viewing geometry, and fundamental physical properties. Extended monitoring would also improve rotational-period determinations and reveal how atmospheric features evolve from rotation to rotation and over longer timescales. This coordinated effort would provide a consistently designed and uniformly processed dataset of time-resolved spectra and variability diagnostics, enabling population-level comparisons, testing predictions from three-dimensional circulation models, and establishing a framework for interpreting the atmospheric diversity and evolution of brown dwarfs and directly imaged giant exoplanets.
Introduction
Atmospheric dynamics shape the observed properties of planetary atmospheres, as illustrated by the evolving cloud bands, storms, and vortices of Solar System gas giants [36, 34]. Brown dwarfs provide an opportunity to investigate analogous processes beyond the Solar System, across a much broader range of temperatures, gravities, and rotational regimes. However, unlike Solar System planets, their atmospheres remain spatially unresolved, making time-resolved observations essential for probing their three-dimensional structure and evolution. Over the past decades, photometric and spectroscopic surveys have established atmospheric variability as a widespread phenomenon among brown dwarfs (e.g., [17, 33, 8, 27, 43]). Ground-based monitoring, HST, and Spitzer have revealed diverse variability amplitudes, rotation periods, and evolving light-curve morphologies, while JWST now enables their characterization across a much broader infrared wavelength range, probing a wider range of atmospheric pressures.
Despite these advances, our understanding of the physical mechanisms driving substellar variability remains incomplete. Heterogeneous condensate clouds are commonly invoked to explain rotationally modulated brightness variations ([5, 25, 3]), while thermal perturbations, atmospheric circulation, and thermochemical disequilibrium may also contribute ([41, 21, 26, 30]). Recent JWST observations have begun to reveal wavelength- and molecule-dependent variability that cloud heterogeneity alone cannot always explain, highlighting the complexity of the underlying atmospheric processes [6, 26, 10, 30, 28, 29, 35].
A comprehensive understanding of substellar weather requires moving beyond individual benchmark objects and limited observational configurations. The diversity of rotation periods, viewing geometries, atmospheric properties, and light-curve morphologies raises fundamental questions about how atmospheric structures form, evolve, and manifest in time-resolved observations. Addressing these questions requires a coordinated observational framework that samples a broader range of physical parameters, combines complementary atmospheric diagnostics, and characterizes variability over appropriate temporal baselines. A JWST Multi-Cycle Treasury program envisions a total of order 1,500 hours, sampling spectral type (L, T, Y), rotation (2-22 hr, [40]), and viewing geometry (close to pole-on or equator objects), with repeated multi-rotation observations of selected targets across cycles to study the weather and climate of substellar objects.
Scientific Motivation
How do rotation, viewing geometry, and atmospheric evolution shape the diversity of substellar weather and climate, and how can JWST disentangle the physical mechanisms driving this variability across the brown dwarf population?
Atmospheric dynamics, cloud coverage, temperature variations, and chemical disequilibrium
Recent JWST time-resolved spectroscopy has revealed complex wavelength- and pressure-dependent variability that heterogeneous clouds alone cannot always explain. In WISE 1049A, CO and show greater variability than , even at comparable atmospheric pressures ([30], Figure 1a). Similarly, harmonic analyses of SIMP 0136 identify distinct variability patterns across atmospheric depths and cloud- and molecule-sensitive spectral regions ([26, 32]). These findings suggest contributions from thermal and chemical processes in addition to cloud heterogeneity, highlighting the challenges of disentangling their relative roles. Meanwhile, mid-infrared observations provide direct constraints on silicate clouds through their prominent absorption features at , offering insight into cloud composition, particle properties, and vertical structure [9, 22, 38].

Figure 1. Connecting spectroscopic variability to three-dimensional atmospheric dynamics. (a, left) Single spectrum from the time series and three wavelength-dependent light curves of WISE 1049B, each from a spectrum snapshot, plus schematic atmospheric structures at different pressure levels traced by CO, HO, and CH [30]. (b, right top) Predicted temperature structures from atmospheric circulation models at different evolutionary times [39], and (c, right bottom) schematic examples of polar vortices and equatorial cloud bands viewed at different inclinations [14].
Complementary analyses using principal component analysis (PCA) have identified temperature variations and changes in cloud vertical structure as the dominant contributors to the observed spectroscopic variability of SIMP 0136 ([1, 35]). Moreover, brown dwarfs with similar fundamental properties can exhibit different spectra and atmospheric cloud characteristics, raising questions about how these processes depend on intrinsic atmospheric conditions and global circulation [39, 38]. Combining JWST/NIRSpec molecular diagnostics with MIRI measurements of cloud-sensitive features across a diverse sample would allow us to investigate how cloud structure, thermal perturbations, and chemical processes jointly shape substellar variability, providing observational constraints for atmospheric retrievals and three-dimensional circulation models.
Rotation, inclination, and effective temperature
Rotation and viewing geometry are fundamental to interpreting substellar atmospheric variability. Observational studies find that brown dwarfs viewed closer to equator-on tend to show larger near-infrared variability amplitudes, redder colors, and stronger silicate absorption than those viewed closer to pole-on [42, 38, 14, 20]. Atmospheric circulation models predict distinct dynamical regimes, including zonal jets, atmospheric waves, and vortices, whose spatial distributions and observable variability depend on rotation and atmospheric conditions [39, 15]. Recent models extending to Y dwarfs further explore the interplay between rotation, convection, and cloud radiative feedback in the coldest substellar atmospheres [2]. Together, these predictions motivate observations across a broader range of rotation periods, temperatures, and viewing geometries to test how atmospheric dynamics translate into observed light-curve morphologies.
However, these trends come from relatively small, heterogeneous samples, making it difficult to disentangle viewing geometry from intrinsic atmospheric properties. Moreover, the relationship between rotation rate, atmospheric circulation, and observed light-curve morphology remains poorly constrained, particularly across different rotational regimes, and often shows strong degeneracies. Understanding these effects requires determining whether differences in variability amplitudes, wavelength-dependent behavior, and light-curve complexity arise from distinct atmospheric structures or from projection effects along our line of sight. A systematic JWST time-resolved spectroscopic survey spanning a broader range of rotation periods, and atmospheric conditions would enable direct comparisons of wavelength-dependent variability and morphology. Where available, independent inclination constraints would add another dimension for interpreting variability trends and testing the viewing-angle dependence predicted by atmospheric circulation models, without requiring inclination measurements for the entire sample.
Atmospheric evolution over multiple timescales
Multi-epoch observations reveal striking differences in substellar weather persistence. WISE 1049B exhibits evolving light-curve morphologies over seven months [11], whereas Ross 458c shows remarkably similar variability patterns across more than seven years ([24]; Figure 2). Multi-epoch HST monitoring of the planetary-mass companion VHS 1256 b also reveals substantial changes in amplitude and morphology, with variability reaching up to 38% in the -band [45]. More recently, JWST/NIRISS and NIRSpec observations of SIMP 0136, separated by approximately 15 rotations, have revealed different wavelength-dependent variability patterns and atmospheric structures [1, 32, 35].

Figure 2. Diversity of atmospheric variability and rotational coverage of JWST observations of brown dwarfs. Left: Examples of light-curve evolution in WISE 1049B (5-12 m) and Ross 458c (1.10-1.63 m), illustrating changes in variability amplitude and morphology across observing epochs. Data taken from [7, 11, 23, 24]. Right: Rotational coverage of JWST time-resolved spectroscopic programs across Cycles 1–5, expressed as the ratio of the observing baseline per visit () to the rotational period (). Marker colors indicate spectral type, while shapes distinguish NIRSpec-only observations (circles) from programs combining NIRSpec (PRISM, G395H, G235H) and MIRI (MRS and LRS, in squares). Open black outlines identify multi-epoch programs. Dashed horizontal lines indicate one and two rotational periods.
These results demonstrate that atmospheric variability can evolve on timescales from a few rotations to years, although the physical mechanisms controlling such evolution remain poorly constrained, particularly in the coolest T/Y dwarfs. Continuous monitoring over multiple rotations is also needed to resolve periodicity ambiguities, as illustrated by revised rotation periods for Ross 458C [24] and 2MASS J1721+33 [31]. Together with archival HST and Spitzer observations, repeated JWST spectroscopy across rotations, months, and years would probe the evolution of molecular and cloud-sensitive features, testing models that predict atmospheric waves and slowly evolving structures on distinct timescales ([14, 13]).
Connecting to Exoplanets, Solar System weather and future facilities
Brown dwarfs provide accessible laboratories for studying atmospheric processes shared with giant exoplanets and Solar System planets, such as vortices, cloud coverage, and temperature fluctuations [37, 16], while the coldest T/Y dwarfs extend these comparisons toward Jupiter-like temperature regimes [12, 19]. Beyond substellar science, a homogeneous JWST variability dataset would provide a benchmark for developing and validating atmospheric models, spectral decomposition methods, and time-series retrieval techniques. These methods will provide a valuable testing ground for future high-precision exoplanet spectroscopy, including observations with extremely large telescopes and future space missions, where reliable interpretations of atmospheric composition and potential biosignatures will require careful treatment of spectral degeneracies, atmospheric heterogeneity, and temporal variability.
Why JWST, and why a Multi-Cycle Treasury program?
JWST has transformed the study of substellar weather through high-precision, time-resolved spectroscopy spanning molecular and cloud-sensitive wavelengths. Programs approved across Cycles 1–5 have revealed complex wavelength-dependent variability in benchmark objects such as WISE 1049AB (GO 2965, (e.g., [7, 30, 11])), VHS 1256 b (GO 3375, [44]), SIMP 0136 (GO 3548, [26, 35]) extending to colder objects such as Ross 458c (GO 5226, [24]) and WISE 0855 (GO 2327, [28, 18]). Other programs have targeted objects with known magnetic activity, such as the radio-emitting T dwarf 2M J1047+21 (GO 3496 and GO 6474), broadening the range of atmospheric phenomena accessible to JWST time-resolved spectroscopy.
However, as Figure 2 right illustrates, detailed spectroscopic variability observations remain unevenly distributed across spectral types and rotational regimes. Early-L dwarfs are largely absent from the current JWST sample, limiting comparisons between warmer, cloud-dominated atmospheres and the evolving cloud structures at the L/T transition. At the other extreme, the coldest T/Y dwarfs remain poorly characterized in time-resolved spectroscopy, despite their importance for understanding cloud formation, atmospheric chemistry, and dynamics in colder, more planet-like conditions. The survey (GO 11740) could provide an important first step toward detecting variability in a larger sample of Y dwarfs, but its short ( hr) observations cannot generally characterize full rotational cycles or atmospheric evolution. These gaps, together with the heterogeneous wavelength and temporal coverage of existing programs, motivate a coordinated investigation across the substellar sequence.
Despite this substantial investment, existing JWST programs employ diverse observing modes, including NIRSpec/PRISM, G235H, G395H, and G395M, together with MIRI/LRS and MRS, providing complementary but heterogeneous spectral and temporal coverage. These differences complicate direct comparisons across the population and motivate a standardized observing strategy.
Proposed Program and Estimated Observing Time
We envision a stratified sample spanning the L, T, and Y spectral sequence, selected to explore the combined effects of atmospheric regime, rotation, and viewing geometry. Rather than maximizing the number of targets, the program would aim to provide meaningful coverage of fast, intermediate, and slow rotators, with a subset of independently constrained inclinations spanning approximately pole-on, intermediate, and equator-on orientations. Warmer early-L dwarfs would probe cloud-dominated atmospheres, while late-T and Y dwarfs would extend these comparisons toward colder, giant-planet-like conditions.
Observing strategy and atmospheric characterization. NIRSpec/PRISM time-resolved spectroscopy would form the core of the program, providing consistent molecular and continuum variability diagnostics across the sample. Complementary MIRI/LRS or MRS spectroscopy at each observing epoch would characterize mid-infrared atmospheric opacities, including silicate absorption in cloudy L dwarfs. A selected subset, particularly near the L/T transition, would additionally receive MIRI time-series spectroscopy to probe rotational changes in silicate absorption and cloud properties. Although NIRSpec and MIRI observe sequentially, their complementary wavelength coverage and sensitivity to different atmospheric pressures would provide stronger constraints on the physical mechanisms driving substellar variability.
Multi-epoch atmospheric evolution. Approximately half of the sample would be revisited at three epochs in total: initially, several months later, and more than one year after the first observation (following similar strategy of GO 8846). Each visit would aim to cover two rotations, allowing tracking of changes in variability amplitude, morphology, and wavelength-dependent behavior across timescales. Existing HST, Spitzer, and JWST observations would provide additional temporal benchmarks and guide target selection.
Analysis framework and community legacy. The program would deliver uniformly reduced time-resolved spectra, spectroscopic light curves, and standardized variability measurements. These datasets would support principal component analysis, time-series atmospheric retrievals, light-curve decomposition and classification, and comparisons with atmospheric circulation models ([39, 4, 14, 35]). The resulting public products would provide a consistent benchmark for testing atmospheric models across the substellar population.
Program scale and the need for a Multi-Cycle Treasury allocation. For an illustrative sample of 30 objects with a mean rotational period of 9 hr (spanning 2–20 hr, [40]), two consecutive rotations of NIRSpec/PRISM spectroscopy would require approximately 540 hours for the initial observations. Two additional epochs for half the sample would add another 540 hours. Complementary MIRI/LRS or MRS spectroscopy at each epoch for all objects or one rotation of MIRI/LRS for selected L/T transition objects would bring the total to approximately 60–250 hr of mid-infrared observations, with durations depending on target brightness and instrumental configuration. Including these observations and operational overheads, the anticipated allocation would be on the order of 1500 hours under preliminary assumptions. The final time request would depend on the rotational-period distribution, sensitivity requirements, and observing feasibility. This coordinated combination of population coverage and repeated monitoring across multiple years would establish a legacy dataset that would be difficult to achieve through independent GO programs.
References
- [1]Akhmetshyn, R., et al. 2025, The Astrophysical Journal, 993, 237
- [2]Akin, C., et al. 2026, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 708, A110
- [3]Apai, D., et al. 2013, ApJ, 768, 121
- [5]Artigau, É., et al. 2009, ApJ, 701, 1534
- [6]Biller, B. A., et al. 2013, ApJ, 778, L10
- [7]—. 2024, MNRAS, 532, 2207
- [8]Buenzli, E., et al. 2014, ApJ, 782, 77
- [9]Burningham, B., et al. 2021, MNRAS, 506, 1944
- [10]Chen, X., et al. 2024, MNRAS, 533, 3114
- [11]—. 2025, MNRAS, 539, 3758
- [12]Faherty, J. K., et al. 2026, ARA&A, 64, 409
- [13]Fuda, N., et al. 2024, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 975, L32
- [14]—. 2024, ApJ, 965, 182
- [15]Hammond, M., et al. 2023, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 525, 150
- [16]Kaspi, Y., et al. 2023, Nature Astronomy, 7, 1463
- [17]Koen, C. 2013, MNRAS, 428, 2824
- [18]Kothari, H., et al. 2026, ApJ, 1008, 131
- [19]Kühnle, H., et al. 2025, A&A, 695, A224
- [20]Lam, M., et al. 2026, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 709, A56
- [21]Lee, E. K., et al. 2023, MNRAS, 523, 4477
- [22]Luna, J. L., et al. 2021, ApJ, 920, 146
- [23]Manjavacas, E., et al. 2019, AJ, 157, 101
- [24]—. 2026, arXiv preprint arXiv:2609.22072arxiv.org/abs/2609.22072
- [25]Marley, M. S., et al. 2010, ApJ, 723, L117
- [26]McCarthy, A. M., et al. 2025, ApJ, 981, L22
- [27]Metchev, S. A., et al. 2015, ApJ, 799, 154
- [28]Miles, B. E., et al. 2026, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2609.20664arxiv.org/abs/2609.20664
- [29]Nasedkin, E., et al. 2025, A&A, 702, A1
- [30]Oliveros-Gomez, N., et al. 2026, ApJ, 997, 136
- [31]O’Toole, C., et al. 2026, A&A, 710, A22
- [32]Plummer, M. K., et al. 2026, The Astronomical Journal, 171, 195
- [33]Radigan, J. 2014, ApJ, 797, 120
- [34]Rodríguez-Ovalle, P., et al. 2025, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 696, A173
- [35]Schrader, M. A., et al. 2026, A&A, 713, A192
- [36]Showman, A. P., et al. 2019, The Astrophysical Journal, 883, 4
- [37]Simon, A. A., et al. 2016, The Astrophysical Journal, 817, 162
- [38]Suárez, G., et al. 2023, ApJ, 954, L6
- [39]Tan, X., et al. 2021, MNRAS, 502, 678
- [40]Tannock, M. E., et al. 2021, AJ, 161, 224
- [41]Tremblin, P., et al. 2015, ApJ, 804, L17
- [42]Vos, J. M., et al. 2017, ApJ, 842, 78
- [43]Vos, J. M., et al. 2020, AJ, 160, 38
- [44]Whiteford, N., et al. 2026, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2608.06583arxiv.org/abs/2608.06583
- [45]Zhou, Y., et al. 2022, The Astronomical Journal, 163, 17