betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

The continuum limit of three-dimensional SU(2) lattice Yang–Mills theory on a torus III: Regional renormalization and large-field control

Abstract

We consider the Wilson lattice gauge measure for SU(2)\mathrm{SU}(2) on a periodic three-dimensional torus of fixed size, with bare coupling g2=g32ag^2=g_3^2a proportional to the lattice spacing aa, as dictated by the superrenormalizability of three-dimensional Yang–Mills theory. Observables are Wilson loops of the lattice configuration evolved by the Wilson flow, the lattice gradient flow of the Wilson action, at positive flow time. We prove that, at every fixed value of the coupling, the joint laws of finitely many flowed Wilson loops converge as the lattice spacing tends to zero along the sequences of lattice sides nMknM^k, for fixed odd M≥3M\ge3 and fixed positive nn divisible by four. For each such refinement class, the limits are realized by a unique probability measure on the space of gauge orbits of Yang–Mills heat-flow trajectories at positive times, a version of the state space introduced by Cao and Chatterjee. At each fixed positive time, the energies of the selected trajectories πk(U)\pi_k(U), with UU distributed under the lattice Wilson measures, are tight uniformly in the lattice spacing. The limiting measure is invariant under the lattice symmetries and the center symmetries. We also show that, at short distances, the rescaled deficits (1−W)/(g32ε)(1-W)/(g_3^2\varepsilon) of the normalized fundamental Wilson loops WW of loops x+εℓx+\varepsilon\ell, flowed for time σε2\sigma\varepsilon^2 with fixed σ>0\sigma>0, converge to explicit quadratic functions of the heat-smoothed Gaussian free field. As the coupling tends to zero, the measure concentrates on flat connections, with Gaussian fluctuations of explicit covariance near regular commuting holonomies and fluctuations governed by the constant-mode quartic form near the central holonomies. The proof is a multiscale renormalization group analysis in the tradition of Bałaban, carried out on a small-field event whose complement we show to have small probability, uniformly in the lattice spacing, using reflection positivity and chessboard estimates. It is combined with stochastic estimates for the lattice heat flow and a deterministic analysis of the Wilson flow for rough initial data.

Detail from a map by Abraham Ortelius depicting sea creatures and a ship

Figure 1. Image: detail from Abraham Ortelius, Theatrum orbis terrarum (1570). Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division. https://www.loc.gov/resource/g3200m.gct00126/?sp=106

WARNING!

We have extensively audited this manuscript using large language models, including adversarial reviews by multiple models. However, the proof is too complex for Lean formalization at the present time, and it has not yet undergone verification by a human expert.

Authors’ note

With the exception of this note, the entire document is machine-written. We have taken care to supervise this writing to ensure that the proofs meet a minimum standard of readability and that previous literature is appropriately cited.

The manuscript began as an attempt to pursue the program of Magnen, Rivasseau, and Sénéor [132] using large language models. Our hope was that understanding the problem on the torus might offer some insight into the general case. The construction that resulted from this starting point is three-dimensional and lattice-based and draws extensively on Bałaban’s renormalization group methods.

As we were verifying these results, we learned that Alpöge and Sussman announced that they appear to have a YM4 existence argument, following Bałaban’s program (https://github.com/ethanwsussman/Yang--Mills-LLM-experiment). We are thrilled and look forward to learning more about these exciting developments. We hope that this manuscript nonetheless contributes to understanding constructive approaches to three-dimensional Yang–Mills theory. The first version of these results was posted to the first author’s GitHub on October 17, 2026 (https://github.com/pmaronow/3d-ym-torus). Prior to posting the first version of this work, we did not inspect the ongoing work of Alpöge and Sussman. Further, to the best of our knowledge, the LLMs we used did not access their work during the mathematical development and drafting of this manuscript. This version contains additional clarifications relative to the first version; it has also been partitioned into five volumes.

We welcome suggestions concerning mathematical corrections, omitted citations, and attribution of ideas.

P. L. was partially supported by NSF grant DMS-2450004.

Part VI: Large-field control and the small-field event (continued)

Comparison of reconstructions on block regions

This section compares one renormalization group step on a block region with the same step on the whole torus. Fix a composition TMsT^{s}_{M} of s≤Js \le J averaging steps and a union Ω\Omega of blocks of its output lattice. In Section 18 we reconstructed the fine configuration on Ω\Omega from the coarse field on Ω\Omega and free logarithmic coordinates, with the coordinates outside Ω\Omega held fixed. We also constructed the stationary point of the effective classical action in these coordinates and proved a gap for its free Hessian. Here we prove that the regional construction differs from the torus construction with the coarse field extended by zero outside Ω\Omega only by terms which decay exponentially with the distance to the boundary of Ω\Omega. We also prove that the regional construction is stable under small analytic perturbations of the incoming action. All estimates are bounds on absolute Taylor coefficients. Their constants do not depend on the shape of Ω\Omega, the number of its components, the depth, the number of preceding renormalization group steps, or the values of previously frozen coordinates.

We use these estimates in the localized renormalization group analysis behind the exponential-moment bound for blocked actions (Step 1 in Section 3.4). There the configurations are decomposed according to the regions where some averaged plaquette has large curvature, and the renormalization group is run outside these regions with the link variables inside them held fixed. § 2.2 integrates the fluctuations on block regions using the reconstructions and perturbation estimates proved here. Section 21 uses the gauge transformation of Lemma 19.5 and the perturbation theorem Theorem 19.9 to construct large-field decompositions, and Section 23 uses the domain conditions of Lemmas 19.3 and 19.7 and Theorem 19.9 to choose the parameters.

The results, in order, are as follows: Lemma 19.3 treats successive minimization; Theorem 19.4 compares the regional and torus stationary points, together with the minimized actions, the Hessians, and the Haar disintegration densities; Lemma 19.5 constructs a gauge transformation which is the identity at prescribed vertices; Theorem 19.6 compares the gauge-transformed reconstructions and bounds their input columns; Lemma 19.7 collects the conditions on the radii; and Theorem 19.9 proves stability under perturbations of the incoming action.

The inputs are Theorem 18.12 (regional coordinates, the gap of the free Hessian, and the regional stationary point), Lemma 18.15 (coefficient bounds for connected networks which reach the fixed complement), Lemma 18.8 (derivatives of constrained stationary values), Lemma 18.9 (freezing of coordinates), the coefficient algebra of Definition 18.1, the target-dependent gauge transformation of Theorem 13.2, the classical coefficient bounds of Theorem 10.11, and the equality of effective classical actions on compact gauge overlaps, Theorem 11.6.

We compare constrained minimizers through the implicit equation for their response, and we control the response by an exponentially decaying inverse of the constrained Hessian. This approach follows Bałaban’s analysis of the variational problem for background fields [16, (182)–(190), pp. 307–308, and Proposition 9, p. 309], although our constraints, coordinate domains, and coefficient norms differ from his. The comparison between the regional and the torus problems and the gauge transformation fixing the prescribed endpoints are constructed here. The exponentially weighted resolvent bound, proved in Lemma 18.3, is the finite-dimensional version of the exponential-conjugation method of Combes and Thomas [61].

The mechanism. The regional problem and the torus problem with coarse field extended by zero have the same constraints away from a fixed neighborhood of the boundary of Ω\Omega. If we restrict the torus stationary point to the regional coordinates, the gradient of the regional objective at this point is therefore concentrated near the boundary, up to exponentially decaying tails. This residual gradient has two sources, which are the two terms of the formula for rRr_R in Theorem 19.4. First, the reconstructed fine field changes. Second, the tangent map of the constraints changes, since the regional problem omits the coarse constraints on links leaving Ω\Omega. Writing pp for the restricted torus stationary point and zRz_R for the regional stationary point, we have zR−p=−AR−1rRz_R-p=-A_R^{-1}r_R, where rRr_R is the residual gradient and ARA_R, the regional Hessian averaged along the segment from pp to zRz_R, has a positive gap. Since this inverse decays exponentially in the distance, the two stationary points differ by an amount which decays exponentially away from the boundary. The remaining work is to make this mechanism stable under differentiation, composition, and successive minimization. This requires bounds on all Taylor coefficients, with any one external index fixed. A bound on the values of a holomorphic map does not give the spatial weights and the fixed-index sums which are needed when these functions are composed later.

Figure 19.1 shows the sets which appear below. Two of them play different roles: the prescribed vertices, where the gauge transformation must be the identity, and the complement of the incoming list, which controls the spatial decay of the perturbation in Theorem 19.9.

Figure 19.1. The geometry in the output lattice (schematic). The solid inner rectangle is the fixed complement H=ΩcH = \Omega^c, and its boundary is the interface WW. The dashed rectangle bounds the enlargement HLJH_{L_J} of HH by the reconstruction stencil. The cutoff χ\chi of Lemma 19.5 vanishes inside the inner dotted rectangle and equals one outside the outer dotted rectangle. The black dots are protected vertices, here the endpoints of the paths of two based transports of frozen coordinates. The small dotted rectangle inside HH is the complement of the incoming list DinD_{\mathrm{in}} of Theorem 19.9, which lies within a fixed distance of HH.

Setting and conventions

Geometry. Throughout this section M≥3M \ge3 is odd, J≥1J \ge1 is fixed, 1≤s≤J1 \le s \le J, and Bs=MsB_s=M^s. The composition TMsT_M^s of ss averaging steps maps configurations of side MsmM^s m to configurations of side m≥4m \ge4, and the prior depth d0≥0d_0 \ge0 is an arbitrary integer. When s=Js = J the composition is one renormalization group step, with blocking factor B=MJB = M^J. Positions are measured in units of the output lattice, of side mm. Let Ω\Omega be a union of blocks of the output lattice, let H=ΩcH = \Omega^c be its fixed complement, let WW be the interface between Ω\Omega and HH, and let HLJH_{L_J} be the enlargement of HH by the fixed reconstruction stencil LJL_J of Theorem 18.12. A coordinate is a label carrying a position, a direction, a color, and a scale index; its position is taken at the lattice where the coordinate was introduced and embedded in output units. In particular the newly frozen coordinates are counted with the density of the lattice on which they were introduced, not as coordinates of the output lattice. The density constant vJv_J of Definition 18.1 includes the colors, the directions, and the at most JJ scale indices. For a label ii in Ω\Omega we write δ(i)=dist⁡(i,W)\delta(i) = \operatorname{dist}(i, W). Here dist⁡\operatorname{dist} and tt are the graph distance and the ℓ1\ell^1 network length of the refined position graph fixed before Definition 18.1; coefficient bounds imported at a Euclidean rate bb are used at rate b/3b/\sqrt{3}. If Ω\Omega is empty, every statement below with a fixed index in Ω\Omega is void. If HH is empty, every boundary difference considered below is zero; we never use an expression of the form 0⋅e∞0 \cdot e^\infty.

Coordinates. We use the following coordinates.

  • The coarse field cc is the logarithm of the output links internal to Ω\Omega, and c⊕0c \oplus0 is its extension by zero to all output links of the torus.

  • The free logarithmic coordinates z=(zi)0≤i<sz = (z_i)_{0 \le i < s} of Theorem 18.12 parametrize the solutions of the block averaging constraints in Ω\Omega, with one block ziz_i for each intermediate scale ii; here i=0i = 0 is the finest scale. On the torus we write z=(zL,zH)z = (z_L, z_H), where zLz_L are the coordinates of the regional list and zHz_H are the remaining torus coordinates.

  • ΨR(c,z;ξ~)\Psi_R(c, z; \widetilde{\xi}) is the logarithm of the regional reconstruction of the fine field before gauge transformation, including its prescribed small values outside Ω\Omega, and ΨT(cT,zT)\Psi_T(c_T, z_T) is the logarithm of the torus reconstruction before gauge transformation. We call the links of the input lattice of TMsT_M^s fine links.

  • In the successive reconstruction the free coordinates of scale ii are ai+Ki−1/2qia_i + K_i^{-1/2}q_i, where aia_i is the conditional stationary point and KiK_i the constrained Hessian of that scale, and qiq_i is the fluctuation increment. The increments qiq_i replace giwig_iw_i, where wiw_i are the normalized fluctuation variables; no coupling is absorbed into KiK_i.

  • In § 2.1.7 we also use the jointly normalized coordinates uu, defined by z=z0+K0−1/2uz = z_0 + K_0^{-1/2}u, where z0z_0 is the joint stationary point and K0K_0 the Hessian there.

  • The newly frozen coordinates ξ~\widetilde{\xi} are the small logarithmic coordinates frozen at the present step; they enter ΨR\Psi_R through its prescribed values outside Ω\Omega. The previously frozen coordinates brecb_{\mathrm{rec}} are fixed real parameters, kept at the lattices on which they were introduced.

The points z=0z = 0, q=0q = 0, and u=0u = 0 are different. Both q=0q = 0 and u=0u = 0 correspond to the joint stationary point z=z0z = z_0 (for qq this is part of Lemma 19.3). The point z=0z = 0 is the origin of the constraint coordinates.

Frozen coordinates and stationary points. No derivative in the previously frozen coordinates brecb_{\mathrm{rec}} is taken or asserted in this section. In Theorems 19.4 and 19.6 the newly frozen coordinates ξ~\widetilde{\xi} are analytic variables, which may be complexified and differentiated. In Theorem 19.9 the perturbed objects are differentiated only in the coarse field, the free coordinates, and the interpolation parameter, at fixed real (ξ~,brec)(\widetilde{\xi}, b_{\mathrm{rec}}). All stationary points below are the holomorphic stationary branches in the coordinate domains of Theorem 18.12. At real data the positive free Hessian makes them local minima, and the conditional stationary points are the conditional constrained minimizers of the successive minimization.

Dependence of constants. All constants and radii in this section have the dependence described in item (3) of Definition 4.14. They may depend on MM and JJ, on the larger classical and reconstruction domains and the ratios of their radii, on the coefficient bounds on these domains, on the gaps of the free Hessians and the bounds on their weighted inverses, on the fixed spatial decay exponents, on νJ\nu_J, and on any fixed bound on the size of the perturbation. In Lemma 19.7 and Theorem 19.9 they may also depend on the fixed analytic radii, on K∗K_\ast, and on the ratios of these radii. They do not depend on LL, γ\gamma, the lattice side, the depth d0d_0, the shape or topology of Ω\Omega, the number of components of Ω\Omega or HH, the values of the previously frozen coordinates, or the number of preceding renormalization group steps. They are evaluated before the later choices of the boundary-layer width wbdw_{\mathrm{bd}}, the erosion width, the widths of the protected neighborhoods, the bound βrec\beta_{\mathrm{rec}} on newly frozen coordinates, and the enclosing product domains of Section 20. Each constant includes a finite maximum over 1≤s≤J1 \le s \le J and over the finitely many initial segments. We do not assert uniformity as J→∞J \to\infty. Theorem 18.12 provides the gap of the free Hessian at every integer depth d0d_0, and when only this classical estimate is used, no condition on an effective interaction is imposed.

The torus construction domain. Every use of Theorem 13.2 below takes place on its construction product. For a composition of ss averaging steps, we denote the radius and coefficient constant of that theorem by rsr_s and CsTC_s^{\mathrm{T}}. Before the later profiles and widths are chosen, we fix positive UT,QTU_{\mathrm{T}}, Q_{\mathrm{T}} in the common larger product of coarse fields and fluctuation increments such that

UT+QT<12min⁡1≤s≤Jrs,CT(UT+QT)<12,CT=max⁡1≤s≤JCsT.(1)U_{\mathrm{T}}+Q_{\mathrm{T}} < \frac{1}{2}\min_{1\le s\le J}r_s,\qquad C_{\mathrm{T}}(U_{\mathrm{T}}+Q_{\mathrm{T}})<\frac{1}{2},\qquad C_{\mathrm{T}}=\max_{1\le s\le J}C_s^{\mathrm{T}}. \tag*{(1)}

Here QTQ_{\mathrm{T}} bounds max⁡i∥qi∥∞\max_i\lVert q_i\rVert_\infty for the fluctuation increments, not the raw free coordinates ai+K−1/2qia_i+K^{-1/2}q_i. Decreasing UT,QTU_{\mathrm{T}},Q_{\mathrm{T}} if necessary, we may assume that the intermediate classical, inverse, and Haar-density margins of Theorem 13.2 hold. Later radii for coarse fields and fluctuation increments are chosen below UTU_{\mathrm{T}} and QTQ_{\mathrm{T}}, so each use of Theorem 13.2 has u+v<rsu+v<r_s, a positive denominator, and its intermediate margins. The rational row bound of that theorem alone does not show that a larger product is allowed.

Coefficient bounds. We use the coefficient algebra of Definition 18.1, Theorem 18.12, and Lemma 18.15 and its coefficient bounds with each external index fixed in turn. A rooted coefficient sum of a tensor fixes one external index, its root, which is either an output or an input, and sums the absolute values of the Taylor coefficients over the remaining indices, with the weight eate^{at}, where tt is the ℓ1\ell^1 length of a shortest connected network spanning the positions involved. For a fixed input index the sum is the volume-normalized column sum of Definition 4.6, with the mesh of that input. A coefficient bound is a bound on all these sums, with any external index fixed. Taylor tensors at complex arguments use bilinear transposes. A majorant series is the series of absolute coefficients after the prescribed rooted sums and weights; the original coefficients need not be positive. In a scalar majorant the variable tt is a radius after these rooted sums, never a sum of radii over all lattice sites. We say that a tensor, or a convergent series of tensors, has boundary-localized coefficient bounds if it satisfies the bounds of Lemma 18.15: with any index ii in Ω\Omega fixed, its rooted coefficient sums carry the additional weight ecδ(i)e^{c\delta(i)} for a fixed c>0c>0.

A product or contraction joins the connecting networks of its factors at the contracted indices. We root the joined network at any external index and sum over the internal indices, using the corresponding rooted bounds of the factors. The boundary-localized estimate applies if one factor is boundary-localized, or if the joined network visits HLJH_{L_J}. An index deep in HH is bounded there, and the decay comes from its connection to the fixed index in Ω\Omega. In particular, for decay exponents b>a>0b>a>0, the sum over such indices is bounded by

eaδ(e)∑h∈HLJe−bdist⁡(e,h)≤eaδLJ′SJ(b−a),SJ(u)=CVJ∑r≥0(r+1)3e−ur,(2)e^{a\delta(e)}\sum_{h\in H_{L_J}}e^{-b\operatorname{dist}(e,h)}\le e^{a\delta_{L'_J}}\mathcal{S}_J(b-a),\qquad\mathcal{S}_J(u)=C_{V_J}\sum_{r\ge0}(r+1)^3e^{-ur}, \tag*{(2)}

where LJ′L'_J also includes the fixed convention for link endpoints. This is the case of a fixed index in Ω\Omega in Lemma 18.15; there is no factor of the volume of HH.

Implicit series. The implicit equations below are solved in the absolute coefficient algebra. After the construction constant CJC_J is increased, the scalar majorant of the solution without boundary weight can be taken to satisfy

References

No references were extracted for this paper.

Paper details

vlnc:W_49xcdk2j
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 6

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents