betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Convective boundary mixing in main-sequence stars: theory and empirical constraints

Abstract

The convective envelopes of solar-type stars and the convective cores of intermediate- and high-mass stars share boundaries with stable radiative zones. Through a host of processes we collectively refer to as "convective boundary mixing" (CBM), convection can drive efficient mixing in these nominally stable regions. In this review, we discuss the current state of CBM research in the context of main-sequence stars through three lenses. (1) We examine the most frequently implemented 1D prescriptions of CBM – exponential overshoot, step overshoot, and convective penetration – and we include a discussion of implementation degeneracies and how to convert between various prescriptions. (2) Next, we examine the literature of CBM from a fluid dynamical perspective, with a focus on three distinct processes: convective overshoot, entrainment, and convective penetration. (3) Finally, we discuss observational inferences regarding how much mixing should occur in the cores of intermediate- and high-mass stars, and the implied constraints that these observations place on 1D CBM implementations. We conclude with a discussion of pathways forward for future studies to place better constraints on this difficult challenge in stellar evolution modeling.

Review

Citation: Anders, E. H.; Pedersen, M. G. Convective boundary mixing in main-sequence stars: theory and empirical constraints. Preprints 2023, 1, 1. https://doi.org/10.3390/galaxies11020056

Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Copyright: © 2023 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).

Correspondence: [email protected]

These authors contributed equally to this work.

Introduction

Convection occurs in all main-sequence stars, and there is broad agreement that widely-used prescriptions like the mixing length theory [MLT, [1], discussed in chapter 1 in this series] adequately describe many properties of bulk convection in stellar interiors. There is, however, a great deal of disagreement and uncertainty regarding how to model the boundaries of convection zones, where the stellar stratification changes from being convectively unstable to stable. Convective boundaries exist at radial coordinates where the buoyant force changes sign (from acceleration to deceleration [2]), but most models and MLT unphysically assume that the convective velocity vanishes at these locations. The true boundary of a convection zone—the location where the convective velocity is zero—lies beyond the traditional “convective boundary,” and some parameterization of “convective boundary mixing” (CBM) is generally employed alongside MLT to allow convective motions to extend outside of the MLT convection zone.

While low-mass stars are fully convective, stars like the Sun with masses 0.35M⊙≲M⋆≲1.2M⊙0.35M_{\odot} \lesssim M_{\star} \lesssim1.2M_{\odot} develop stable interiors and turbulent convective envelopes [3, 4, 5]. Convective motions can “undershoot” from the unstable envelope into the stable interior and cause mixing, which can alter surface Lithium abundances [6, 7, 8] and the sound speed below the convection zone [9, 10, 11]. In “massive stars” with masses M∗≳1.1M⊙M_\ast\gtrsim1.1M_\odot, efficient nuclear burning from the CNO cycle destabilizes the core to convection, while the envelope becomes convectively stable [5, 12]; some of these stars also have opacity-driven convection zones near the surface [13, 14]. CBM from the core convection zone injects fresh hydrogen fuel into the high-temperature central burning region of the star, thereby extending the stellar lifetime and increasing the size of the helium core at the end of the main sequence. Unfortunately, observations cannot be uniformly explained with one standard CBM prescription [15], leading to uncertainty in how to include CBM in stellar evolution calculations. These uncertainties are not subtle: evolving a 15 M⊙M_\odot model using differing mixing prescriptions can significantly alter the main sequence lifetime by ∼25%\sim25\% and the helium core mass by ∼40%\sim40\%, with consequences that ripple beyond the main sequence, such as in determining what type of remnant the star eventually leaves behind [16, 17]. Fortunately, there seems to be a tight relationship between a star’s core mass, its envelope mass, and its core composition if the star is to remain in equilibrium [18], which may limit the range of feasible CBM prescriptions to characterize.

Observations of massive stars cannot be explained without CBM which increases the convective core size compared to “standard” stellar models. For example, radial profiles of the Brunt-Väisälä frequency measured via asteroseismology demonstrate substantial mixing outside the standard core boundary [19]. The population of observed eclipsing binaries [20] and the width of the main sequence in the temperature-luminosity plane observed in stellar clusters [21, 22, 23, 24] can be partially explained by introducing a mass-dependent CBM into stellar models. Simulations of 3D turbulent convection whose initial conditions are based on 1D stellar evolution models consistently report significant entrainment at convective boundaries and expansion of the convection zone (e.g., [25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31]), so the picture from numerical simulations aligns with that inferred from observations.

In this review, we discuss CBM in stars. Our goals in writing this review are:

  1. to provide context for investigators who need to employ CBM in their own studies.

  2. to summarize past works and provide launching points for future studies aimed at improving CBM prescriptions.

  3. to facilitate communication between observers, 1D modelers, and 3D numericists.

In section 2, we describe 1D parameterizations of CBM. In section 3, we describe the results of numerical simulations exhibiting CBM. In section 4, we describe observations and empirical calibrations of CBM. We conclude with a discussion in section 5.

Theoretical (1D) parametrizations

How does CBM modify stellar evolution?

In stellar evolution software instruments, the mixing caused by convection, CBM, and other mixing processes are generally parameterized as a turbulent diffusivity [32]. That is, for some chemical composition (e.g., hydrogen, XX), time evolution is assumed to follow,

∂tX=∇⋅[(Dconv+DCBM+Dother)∇X],(1)\partial_t X = \nabla\cdot[(D_{\mathrm{conv}} + D_{\mathrm{CBM}} + D_{\mathrm{other}})\nabla X], \tag*{(1)}

when changes to the composition from nuclear reactions are ignored. Here each DD is a diffusion coefficient. In this formalism, it is impossible to distinguish between CBM and other mixing processes which could occur in the vicinity of a convective boundary (e.g., shear, rotation, etc). This formalism generally allows us to probe the shape and magnitude of the radial profile of mixing, but not the fundamental process at work. Regardless, within this review we will assume that excess mixing which connects to and extends beyond the convective boundary are convection-induced CBM processes. We additionally limit the scope of this review to purely hydrodynamical CBM processes; complicating effects of e.g., magnetism or radiative transfer are not considered.

In Figure 1, we briefly demonstrate how CBM affects the evolution of stars with convective cores. Panel a shows that increasing the radial extent of mixing beyond the convective boundary (going from light to darker lines) decreases a star’s effective temperature (panel b) and increases its luminosity (panel c) at the TAMS (terminal-age main sequence). This increased mixing also increases the length of the main sequence (panel d) by providing more fuel and significantly increases the helium core mass at the end of the main sequence (panel e); these latter changes introduce uncertainty into the star’s post-main-sequence evolution and into the eventual remnant that the star leaves behind. While not pictured here, vectors in the mass–luminosity plane can help disentangle the effects of mass loss and internal mixing on the evolutionary tracks of very massive stars [22, 24]. The slope of the vector is set by the mass-loss rate, while the length of the vector is set by the age and internal mixing, see Figure 1 in Higgins and Vink [24]. If the star’s rotational velocity is known, the CBM parameter can be directly derived from the length of the vector.

Illustration of the effect of increasing the size of the CBM region assuming exponential diffusive overshoot

Figure 1. Illustration of the effect of increasing the size of the CBM region assuming exponential diffusive overshoot. (a) HR diagram showing the evolutionary tracks for a 10 M⊙10\,M_{\odot} star with different extents of the CBM region. The fovf_{\mathrm{ov}} parameter sets the extent of the CBM region and how rapidly the mixing decreases with distance from the convective core boundary, see § 2.4. fov=0.002f_{\mathrm{ov}}=0.002 is a low value, whereas fov=0.04f_{\mathrm{ov}}=0.04 is considered a high value for this parameter. (b) Percentage change in the effective temperature at the TAMS compared to the fov=0.002f_{\mathrm{ov}}=0.002 case for three different initial masses. (c) Same as (b) but for the luminosity at the TAMS. (d) Same as (b) but for the age at the TAMS. (e) Same as (b) but for the helium core mass obtained at the TAMS. Figure made by the authors using MESA models. MESA inlists and data used to generate the figure are available on Zenodo [33].

Convective boundaries

In 1D stellar evolution software instruments, convection zone boundaries coincide with a sign change in a determinant YY [34], § 2. We define regions with Y<0Y<0 to be stable to convection. The simplest convective stability criterion is the Schwarzschild criterion,

YS≡∇rad−∇ad<0.(2)Y_{\mathrm{S}} \equiv\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}-\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}<0. \tag*{(2)}

Here, the logarithmic temperature gradient is ∇≡dln⁡P/dln⁡T\nabla\equiv\mathrm{d}\ln P/\mathrm{d}\ln T (pressure PP and temperature TT). When ∇\nabla is evaluated at constant entropy and mean molecular weight, its value is the adiabatic gradient ∇ad\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}. The gradient required to radiatively transport the full stellar luminosity is ∇rad\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}.

In the presence of gradients in the mean molecular weight μ\mu, a better convective stability criterion is the Ledoux criterion,

YL≡YS+χμχT∇μ<0.(3)\mathcal{Y}_{\mathrm{L}} \equiv\mathcal{Y}_{\mathrm{S}} + \frac{\chi_{\mu}}{\chi_{\mathrm{T}}}\nabla_{\mu} < 0. \tag*{(3)}

The Ledoux criterion includes the composition gradient ∇μ=dln⁡μ/dln⁡P\nabla_{\mu} = d\ln\mu/d\ln P, where χT=(dln⁡P/dln⁡T)ρ,μ\chi_{\mathrm{T}} = (d\ln P/d\ln T)_{\rho,\mu}, χμ=(dln⁡P/dln⁡μ)ρ,T\chi_{\mu} = (d\ln P/d\ln\mu)_{\rho,T}, and ρ\rho is the density. The composition term is generally stabilizing when the radial gradient of μ\mu is negative.

In this review, we are interested in cases where an unstable convection zone (CZ) with YL≥0\mathcal{Y}_{\mathrm{L}} \geq0 borders a stable radiative zone (RZ) with YL≤YS<0\mathcal{Y}_{\mathrm{L}} \leq\mathcal{Y}_{\mathrm{S}} < 0. We therefore do not consider e.g., semiconvection or thermohaline mixing (see chapters 2 & 3 of Garaud [35] as well as section 3 & figure 3 of Salaris and Cassisi [36]). We note that evolutionary timescales are much longer than the convective overturn timescale on the main sequence [37]. In this regime, both the Ledoux criterion and the Schwarzschild criterion should retrieve the same location for the convective boundary, as argued by Gabriel et al. [38] and shown using hydrodynamical simulations by Anders et al. [2]. Therefore, we will refer to the convective boundary and the Schwarzschild boundary interchangeably.

The Schwarzschild boundary (YS=0\mathcal{Y}_{\mathrm{S}} = 0) generally corresponds to an interface where the entropy gradient goes from being marginally stable (or unstable, ∇s≤0\nabla_{\mathrm{s}} \leq0) to being stable (∇s>0\nabla_{\mathrm{s}} > 0). “Convective boundaries” defined by Y\mathcal{Y} therefore specify where the radial buoyancy force changes from destabilizing (in the convection zone) to stabilizing (in the radiative zone). The location where convective velocity goes to zero therefore always lies “outside” of the convective boundaries defined by YS\mathcal{Y}_{\mathrm{S}}. The CBM prescriptions that we discuss below therefore attempt in spirit to estimate the size of the region in which convective velocities decelerate beyond the convective boundary.

Internal mixing profiles

The time evolution of the mass fraction XiX_i of chemical element ii depends on nuclear reactions Ri\mathcal{R}_i and mixing processes Mi\mathcal{M}_i. 1D stellar evolution software instruments typically treat element mixing as a diffusive process, so the time evolution equation

∂Xi∂t=Ri+Mi,=Ri+1ρr2∂∂r[ρr2Dmix∂Xi∂r]+Mimicro,(4)\begin{aligned} \frac{\partial X_i}{\partial t} = \mathcal{R}_i + \mathcal{M}_i, \\ &= \mathcal{R}_i + \frac{1}{\rho r^2}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\left[\rho r^2 D_{\mathrm{mix}}\frac{\partial X_i}{\partial r}\right] + \mathcal{M}_i^{\mathrm{micro}}, \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

where ρ\rho is the density and rr is the radius coordinate. We group extra microscopic atomic diffusion effects like radiative levitation or gravitational settling into Mimicro\mathcal{M}_i^{\mathrm{micro}}. The mass fraction XiX_i diffuses with a diffusivity of DmixD_{\mathrm{mix}} in units of cm2^2 s−1^{-1}.

The sum of a variety of different physical processes such as convection, rotation, magnetic fields, and waves all contribute to Dmix(r)D_{\mathrm{mix}}(r) in different regions and at different magnitudes. We decompose the turbulent diffusivity based on whether or not convection is present,

Dmix(r)=Dconv(r)+DCBM(r)+Denv(r),(5)D_{\mathrm{mix}}(r) = D_{\mathrm{conv}}(r) + D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) + D_{\mathrm{env}}(r), \tag*{(5)}

where Dconv(r)D_{\mathrm{conv}}(r) is the contribution from convective regions, DCBM(r)D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) characterizes convective boundary mixing regions, and Denv(r)D_{\mathrm{env}}(r) is the mixing profile in the radiative envelope. Parameterizing mixing into diffusion profiles in this way discards information about the specific processes that cause mixing, which makes it difficult to disentangle the individual mixing contributions of CBM, rotational mixing, and other processes that occur at the same radial coordinate. Examples of four Dmix(r)D_{\mathrm{mix}}(r) profiles are illustrated in the top panels of Figure 2. The associated stratification produced by these mixing coefficients is shown in the bottom panels of Figure 2.

Figure 2. Illustration of four different convective boundary mixing prescriptions in 1D. Internal mixing profiles are shown in the top panels, while the corresponding temperature gradients are given in the bottom panels. (a) Exponential diffusive overshoot, (b) step overshoot, (c) convective penetration, and (d) extended convective penetration. Convective regions are indicated in grey. DCBM(r)D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) and Denv(r)D_{\mathrm{env}}(r) are shown respectively in blue and green in the top panels. In the bottom panels, the plotted curves show the adiabatic temperature gradient (green), the radiative temperature gradient (blue), and the adopted temperature gradient (orange). Figure made by the authors using MESA models. The data used to generate the figure are available on Zenodo [33].

The remainder of this section will focus on the different DCBM(r)D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) parameterizations that are commonly used in 1D stellar evolution codes. We use the term CBM to refer to any boundary mixing process. We adopt a terminology where convective overshoot only mixes chemical composition so that (∇T=∇rad\nabla_{\mathrm{T}} = \nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}) in the CBM region, and convective penetration mixes both chemical composition and entropy so that (∇T=∇ad\nabla_{\mathrm{T}} = \nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}) in the CBM region.

Overshoot or overmixing

Overshooting (e.g., [39]) or overmixing (e.g., [40]) occurs when fluid motions beyond the convective boundary transport elements but not heat and thereby do not alter the temperature gradient. Two prescriptions for convective overshooting are common in 1D stellar evolution codes.

Exponential diffusive overshoot [41, 42], see Figure 2 (a), is a 1D parameterization of results from 2D hydrodynamical simulations of surface convection zones in solar-type stars, mainsequence A-type stars, and cool DA white dwarfs. It is used by the stellar evolution code GARSTEC [43], and used to be the default overshoot option in MESA [34, 44, 45, 46, 47]. Exponential diffusive overshoot is a mixing efficiency which decreases exponentially with distance from the convective boundary,

DCBM(r)=D0exp⁡[−2(r−r0)fovHp,0]with∇T=∇rad.(6)D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) = D_0 \exp\left[\frac{-2(r-r_0)}{f_{\mathrm{ov}}H_{\mathrm{p},0}}\right] \qquad\text{with} \qquad\nabla_T = \nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}. \tag*{(6)}

In this formalism, the free parameter fovf_{\mathrm{ov}} determines what fraction of a pressure scale height corresponds to the e-folding length scale of the mixing efficiency, and thereby indirectly sets the extent of the CBM region; CBM models based on the scale height have been used as long as CBM has been considered [48, 49]. Here, rr is the radial coordinate and HpH_{\mathrm{p}} is the pressure scale height. The convective boundary occurs at rccr_{\mathrm{cc}} and has scale height Hp,ccH_{\mathrm{p,cc}}, but MLT assumes that the convective velocity and mixing are both zero at rccr_{\mathrm{cc}}. As a result, exponential diffusive overshoot is calibrated at r0=rcc−f0Hp,ccr_0 = r_{\mathrm{cc}} - f_0H_{\mathrm{p,cc}}, where f0f_0 is usually fixed to a value between 0.002-0.005. At r0r_0, the convective mixing efficiency is D0=Dmix(r0)D_0 = D_{\mathrm{mix}}(r_0) and the pressure scale height is Hp,0H_{\mathrm{p},0}. The mixing efficiency follows the MLT value for r<r0r < r_0, and follows Eqn. 6 for r≥r0r \ge r_0.1

Step overshoot provides a simpler mixing profile in the CBM region (see Figure 2, b),

DCBM(r)=D0for r0≤r≤rov,with∇T=∇rad.(7)D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) = D_0 \qquad\text{for } r_0 \le r \le r_{\mathrm{ov}}, \qquad\text{with} \qquad\nabla_T = \nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}. \tag*{(7)}

Here the free parameter αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} determines the extent rov=r0+(αov+f0)Hp,0r_{\mathrm{ov}} = r_0 + (\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} + f_0)H_{\mathrm{p},0} of the overshoot region which is characterized by a constant mixing efficiency D0D_0. This CBM formalism is adopted in the stellar evolution codes DSEP [50, 51], BaSTI [52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58], TGEC [59, 60], and YREC [61], and is available in MESA.

Convective penetration

Convective Penetration occurs when convection mixes chemicals and entropy beyond the convective boundary [39], see Figure 2 (c). Convective penetration is identical to step overshoot, except the adiabatic temperature gradient is adopted in the CBM region:

DCBM(r)=D0for r0≤r≤rpen,with∇T=∇ad.(8)D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) = D_0 \qquad\text{for } r_0 \le r \le r_{\mathrm{pen}}, \qquad\text{with} \qquad\nabla_T = \nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}. \tag*{(8)}

Here rpen=r0+(αpen+f0)Hp,0r_{\mathrm{pen}} = r_0 + (\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} + f_0)H_{\mathrm{p},0}, and αpen\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} is the free CBM parameter. The convective penetration formalism is adopted in the stellar evolution code GENEC [62], and a similar option is available for the YREC code. We caution that the names “step overshoot” and “convective penetration” are often used interchangeably in the literature. We distinguish between the two based on the temperature gradient in the CBM region (e.g., [39, 63]).

Extended convective penetration

Extended convective penetration [64, 65] combines convective penetration and diffusive exponential overshooting, see Figure 2 (d). In this formalism, the convective boundary mixing region has two components. The convection zone is adjacent to a convective penetrative region with constant mixing and an adiabatic temperature gradient. Further from the convective boundary, the mixing exponentially decays and the temperature gradient gradually transitions from ∇ad\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} to ∇rad\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}. The exact mixing coefficients are

DCBM(r)=Dpenfor r0≤r≤rpenD_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) = D_{\mathrm{pen}} \qquad\text{for } r_0 \le r \le r_{\mathrm{pen}}
DCBM(r)=Dpenexp⁡[−2(r−rpen)fpenHp,pen]for rpen<r≤rCBM,(9)D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) = D_{\mathrm{pen}}\exp\left[\frac{-2(r-r_{\mathrm{pen}})}{f_{\mathrm{pen}}H_{\mathrm{p,pen}}}\right] \qquad\text{for } r_{\mathrm{pen}} < r \le r_{\mathrm{CBM}}, \tag*{(9)}

where Hp,pen=Hp(rpen)H_{\mathrm{p,pen}} = H_{\mathrm{p}}(r_{\mathrm{pen}}) and rCBMr_{\mathrm{CBM}} is the radius at the outer boundary of the CBM region. The thermal stratification is [64]

∇T=∇adfor r0≤r≤rpen\nabla_T = \nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} \qquad\text{for } r_0 \le r \le r_{\mathrm{pen}}
∇T=ft(r)∇ad+[1−ft(r)]∇radfor rpen<r≤rCBM,(10)\nabla_T = f^t(r)\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} + [1-f^t(r)]\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}} \qquad\text{for } r_{\mathrm{pen}} < r \le r_{\mathrm{CBM}}, \tag*{(10)}

There are two free parameters: αpen\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} and fpenf_{\mathrm{pen}}. ft(r)f^t(r) is a radial profile which varies from one in the convection zone to zero in the stable radiative envelope. ft(r)f^t(r) has been prescribed in two ways in the literature. Its first implementation was based on the amount of mass in rpen<r≤rCBMr_{\mathrm{pen}} < r \le r_{\mathrm{CBM}} [64]. Another implementation define it as ft(r)=[log⁡Pe(r)+2]/4f^t(r) = [\log Pe(r) + 2]/4 for values of 10−2<Pe<10210^{-2} < Pe < 10^2, where the Péclet number PePe [65], which is the ratio between the time scales of the radiative and advective heat transport and can be estimate from e.g., MLT velocities.

To our knowledge, extended convective penetration is not currently a standard option in any stellar evolution codes, but it has been studied using a modified version of MESA [64, 65]. However, the option of changing the temperature gradient within the CBM region is available in existing codes. For example, the ASTEC code [66] uses the same mixing profile DCBMD_{\mathrm{CBM}} as the step overshoot and convective penetration schemes wherein mixing efficiency is considered constant for a certain distance αCBMHp\alpha_{\mathrm{CBM}}H_{\mathrm{p}} beyond the convective boundary, but ASTEC can smoothly vary the temperature gradient within this region [66, 67].

Limiting the extent of the CBM region

The diffusive overshoot, convective penetration, and extended convective penetration prescriptions listed above all rely on a free CBM parameter multiplied by the pressure scale height to define the extent of the CBM region. As a result, small convective cores (with rcc→0r_{\mathrm{cc}} \to0 and Hp→∞H_{\mathrm{p}} \to\infty) can produce unphysically large CBM regions. This problem primarily arises in lower mass stars that start off with small convective cores on the main sequence. To circumvent this issue, some stellar evolution codes implement a mass-dependent CBM parameter which is zero at low stellar mass, constant at high mass, and smoothly increases at intermediate mass. Such an approach is partially validated by observational evidence of a relationship between CBM mixing parameters and stellar mass, but the observational evidence is ambiguous, see § 4. Mass-dependent CBM parameters were used to compute the YREC Y2Y^2 isochrones [68], the YaPSI isochrones [69], a set of isochrones computed with GARSTEC and used to fit the open cluster M67 [70], and a grid of stellar models with derived internal structure constants computed with MESA [71].

Various alternative approaches limit the size of CBM regions based on the size of the convection zone. The ASTEC and Cesam2k codes enforce that the size of the CBM region is βCBM×min⁡(rcc,Hp,cc)\beta_{\mathrm{CBM}} \times\min(r_{\mathrm{cc}}, H_{\mathrm{p,cc}}) [66, 72]. The YREC code defines the actual radius of the CBM region as rCBM=βCBM/(Hp−1+rcc−1)r_{\mathrm{CBM}} = \beta_{\mathrm{CBM}}/(H_{\mathrm{p}}^{-1} + r_{\mathrm{cc}}^{-1}) which simplifies to rCBM=βCBMHpr_{\mathrm{CBM}} = \beta_{\mathrm{CBM}}H_{\mathrm{p}} for large convective cores [73]. The GARSTEC code uses a modified pressure scale height H~p=Hp×min⁡[1,(rcc/Hp)2]\widetilde{H}_{\mathrm{p}} = H_{\mathrm{p}} \times\min\left[1,(r_{\mathrm{cc}}/H_{\mathrm{p}})^2\right] [43, 70], and as a default MESA uses βCBM×min⁡(Hp,rcc/αMLT)\beta_{\mathrm{CBM}} \times\min(H_{\mathrm{p}},r_{\mathrm{cc}}/\alpha_{\mathrm{MLT}}) where αMLT\alpha_{\mathrm{MLT}} is the mixing length parameter. Here we use βCBM\beta_{\mathrm{CBM}} to collectively refer to the free parameter assumed for a given CBM prescription, so it could be e.g., fovf_{\mathrm{ov}} or αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}}. A result of these constraints is that the input βCBM\beta_{\mathrm{CBM}} parameter in the code can be different from the effective βCBM\beta_{\mathrm{CBM}} used to set the size of the CBM region (see Ref. [73], Figure 2 and Figure 5 for examples of this). A further problem is that inconsistent implementations between different codes produce CBM regions with different sizes even if the same αCBM\alpha_{\mathrm{CBM}} parameter and CBM prescription are nominally employed. These subtle differences impede direct comparisons between results obtained using different codes when the sizes of the convective cores are small as is the case for stars around 1.2 M⊙1.2\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} [74].

Vorticity and temperature for simulations with small and large stiffness

Figure 5. The vorticity (top) and temperature (bottom) are shown for simulations whose values of SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} are small (left) and large (right). The black line marks the Schwarzschild boundary of the simulations. Note that increasing SS decreases the depth to which dynamics overshoot beyond the Schwarzschild boundary. Note also that as stiffness increases, the internal gravity wave amplitude in the stable region decreases with respect to the convection amplitude. Figure 2 of Rogers and Glatzmaier [120]; © AAS. Reproduced with permission.

Comparing different CBM parameters

In order to make comparisons between results obtained using different CBM prescriptions (e.g., exponential vs. step overshooting), a robust conversion between their input parameters must be established. Such conversions can be achieved in two ways.

The first is to compare observations to models generated using different CBM prescriptions and find the CBM parameters which best reproduce the observed diagnostics. Such comparisons have previously been achieved through, e.g., the asteroseismic modeling of the slowly pulsating B star KIC 7760680 where comparisons between results using exponential diffusive and step overshoot suggested a relation of αov/fov=13.33\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}}/f_{\mathrm{ov}} = 13.33 for this 3.25 M⊙3.25\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} star [75], see also § 4.4. Similarly, comparisons have been made using detached, double-lined, eclipsing binary stars (see also § 4.3). As an example, the study of 29 such systems with component masses between 1.21.2 and 4.4 M⊙4.4\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} revealed a relation of αpen/fov=11.36±0.22\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}}/f_{\mathrm{ov}} = 11.36 \pm0.22 between models using convective penetration and exponential diffusive overshoot [76]. The comparison suggested that there is a slight dependence of this ratio on surface gravity log⁡g\log g, metallicity ZZ, mass MM, or effective temperature TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}}. Splitting the sample in two groups depending on either the effective temperature or surface gravity resulted in αpen/fov=10.50±0.25\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}}/f_{\mathrm{ov}} = 10.50 \pm0.25 for cooler giant stars and αpen/fov=11.71±0.27\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}}/f_{\mathrm{ov}} = 11.71 \pm0.27 for hotter dwarf stars [76]. A similar study of 12 binary systems with component masses between 4.584.58 and 17.07 M⊙17.07\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} likewise suggest a conversion factor between fovf_{\mathrm{ov}} and αpen\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} larger than 10 [77].2

Another method for deriving conversions between different CBM parameters is to directly compare models which use different CBM prescriptions. Magic et al. [70] suggested a conversion factor of αov/fov≈11\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}}/f_{\mathrm{ov}} \approx11 using models with masses between 2 and 6 M⊙6\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}. Noels et al. [78] compared two evolutionary tracks of a 10 M⊙10\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} star using either step overshoot or convective penetration, finding that an αpen=0.175\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} = 0.175 achieved a similar result to the step overshoot case with αov=0.2\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} = 0.2, i.e. αov/αpen=1.14\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}}/\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} = 1.14.

Here we provide a comparison between models computed with the stellar structure and evolution code MESA v22.05.1 for a 2 M⊙2\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} and 10 M⊙10\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} star assuming 1) exponential diffusive overshoot, and 2) diffusive step overshoot. Using these models, we investigate what αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} parameter is required to reproduce the same luminosity and convective core mass (mccm_{\mathrm{cc}}, the mass coordinate of the Schwarzschild boundary of the convection zone) of the star with exponential diffusive overshoot at a fixed value of fovf_{\mathrm{ov}}. These comparisons are carried out at fixed main-sequence age (Xc/XiniX_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}}) and stellar mass. In other words, we look for solutions to the relations log⁡L1(Xc/Xini,fov)=log⁡L2(Xc/Xini,αov)\log L_{1}(X_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}},f_{\mathrm{ov}})=\log L_{2}(X_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}},\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}}) and mcc,1(Xc/Xini,fov)/M=mcc,2(Xc/Xini,αov)/Mm_{\mathrm{cc},1}(X_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}},f_{\mathrm{ov}})/M = m_{\mathrm{cc},2}(X_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}},\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}})/M. Here XcX_{\mathrm{c}} is the current core hydrogen mass fraction and XiniX_{\mathrm{ini}} is the initial hydrogen mass fraction. An example of these solutions is shown for the 10 M⊙10\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} star in Figure 3. Panels (a) and (b) show the derived relations for the luminosity and convective core mass, respectively, at different main-sequence ages indicated by the color of the lines. The black dashed curve shows the expected trend assuming the standard “rule-of-thumb” αov≈10fov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} \approx10f_{\mathrm{ov}}, whereas the black dotted line shows the linear fit to the derived relations. The differences between the linear fits and relations derived at different ages are shown in panel (c) and (d), where the grey shaded region gives the 3σstd3\sigma_{\mathrm{std}} uncertainty regions for the relations. As seen in the figure, the relations are not strictly linear and also show a small dependence on the chosen XcX_{\mathrm{c}} in the current core hydrogen mass fraction and XiniX_{\mathrm{ini}} value.

Derived correlations between $\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}}$ and $f_{\mathrm{ov}}$ for a $10\,M_{\odot}$ star at different main-sequence ages

Figure 3. Derived correlations between αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} and fovf_{\mathrm{ov}} for a 10 M⊙10\,M_{\odot} star at different main-sequence ages given as Xc/XiniX_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}}. (a) The colored curves show the relation between αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} and fovf_{\mathrm{ov}} required to obtain log⁡L1(Xc/Xini,fov)=log⁡L2(Xc/Xini,αov)\log L_1(X_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}},f_{\mathrm{ov}})=\log L_2(X_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}},\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}}). The black dashed curve shows the expected trend assuming αov=10fov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}}=10f_{\mathrm{ov}}, while the black dotted lines shows the combined linear fit to the colored lines. (b) Same as (a) but fulfilling mcc,1(Xc/Xini,fov)/M=mcc,2(Xc/Xini,αov)/Mm_{\mathrm{cc},1}(X_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}},f_{\mathrm{ov}})/M=m_{\mathrm{cc},2}(X_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}},\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}})/M. (c) Differences between the derived αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} versus fovf_{\mathrm{ov}} relation for a given Xc/XiniX_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}} and the linear fit shown by the dotted black line in panel a. The grey shaded region gives the 3σstd3\sigma_{\mathrm{std}} uncertainty region of the linear fit. (d) Same as (c) but for the comparison between the αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} and fovf_{\mathrm{ov}} parameters needed to get the same convective core masses. Figure made by the authors using MESA models. MESA inlists and data used to generate the figure are available on Zenodo [33].

In summary, we find a general relation of the form

αov=A+Bfov.(11)\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} = A + B f_{\mathrm{ov}}. \tag*{(11)}

For the 2 M⊙2\,M_{\odot} star, we find A=(0.042±0.004)A=(0.042\pm0.004) and B=(14.11±0.25)B=(14.11\pm0.25) when fitting for luminosity and A=(0.036±0.01)A=(0.036\pm0.01) and B=(14.05±0.71)B=(14.05\pm0.71) when fitting for core mass. For the 10 M⊙10\,M_{\odot} star, we find A=(0.0256±0.0008)A=(0.0256\pm0.0008) and B=(10.75±0.04)B=(10.75\pm0.04) when fitting for luminosity and A=(0.0256±0.001)A=(0.0256\pm0.001) and B=(10.74±0.05)B=(10.74\pm0.05) when fitting for core mass. The reported errors are the 3σstd3\sigma_{\mathrm{std}} errors.

We note three important observations for the four relations given above. The first is that relations between αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} and fovf_{\mathrm{ov}} for a given mass are same within the errors independently of whether they are derived based on the luminosity or the convective core mass. The second observation is that the errors on the parameters for the relations for the 2 M⊙2\,M_{\odot} star are larger than for the 10 M⊙10\,M_{\odot}, implying a stronger age dependence on the relations for the 2 M⊙2\,M_{\odot} star. Finally, the slopes (BB) of the relations are steeper for the 2 M⊙2\,M_{\odot} star than the 10 M⊙10\,M_{\odot} one and cannot be reconciled within the 3σstd3\sigma_{\mathrm{std}} errors, showing that the exact conversions to use are also mass dependent. We emphasize that making direct comparisons between absolute values of different CBM parameters is non-trivial. Therefore, when studying CBM and the extent of the CBM region, carrying out an ensemble study of a group of stars using the same stellar evolution code and the same CBM prescription is recommended.

1D models not covered in this review

A full discussion of physically-motivated 1D models of CBM is beyond the scope of this review. Techniques not discussed here include CBM models based on linear or fundamental mode analysis [79, 80, 81], nonlinear modal expansion [82], models of overshooting bubbles based on local MLT [48, 83], nonlocal MLT models [84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90], non-MLT multiscale models [91], “turbulent convection models” (e.g. [92, 93]), Canuto’s stellar mixing model (e.g. [94]), and non-local “turbulent kinetic energy models” (e.g. [95, 96]). We briefly also note that there exist models which aim to characterize overshooting convective motions in the optically-thin atmosphere of stars like the Sun [79, 97], reviewed briefly in Nordlund [86], but we focus here on convection confined to optically thick portions of the star.

In this section, we have focused on the most frequently-used techniques in the stellar modeling literature; we note that these MLT-based implementations may not necessarily be logically consistent [98], but their ease of implementation and use has made them widespread in the stellar structure literature. Other local-MLT-based CBM prescriptions or profiles such as diffusive Gumbel overshooting [99, 100] and diffusive double exponential overshoot [101] have been proposed, but a full discussion of them is likewise beyond the scope of this review.

3D Hydrodynamical Perspectives of Convective Boundary Mixing

We now describe convective boundary mixing from its fluid dynamical roots. Many simulations have examined a convective layer interacting with a stable layer in a variety of natural contexts (e.g., stellar envelope convection, core convection, and even atmospheric convection). In order to paint the most complete picture of convective boundary mixing, we will discuss the results of these studies from a perspective that is impartial to the motivation or setup.

Hydrodynamical CBM simulations often employ simplified equation sets (e.g., the Boussinesq [102] or Anelastic [103, 104, 105, 106] approximations3). For generality, we will use the equation formulation most applicable to stellar interiors, the Fully Compressible Navier-Stokes equations ([107], §15 and §49), which are

∂tρ+∇⋅(ρu)=0,(12)\partial_t \rho+ \nabla\cdot(\rho\boldsymbol{u}) = 0, \tag*{(12)}
∂tu+u⋅∇u=−1ρ∇P+g+1ρ∇⋅Π,(13)\partial_t \boldsymbol{u} + \boldsymbol{u} \cdot\nabla\boldsymbol{u} = -\frac{1}{\rho}\nabla P + \boldsymbol{g} + \frac{1}{\rho}\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{\Pi}, \tag*{(13)}
∂ts+u⋅∇s=1ρT(∇⋅(k∇T)+ρϵ+Φ),(14)\partial_t s + \boldsymbol{u} \cdot\nabla s = \frac{1}{\rho T}\left(\nabla\cdot(k\nabla T) + \rho\epsilon+ \Phi\right), \tag*{(14)}

where ρ\rho is the density, uu is the velocity, TT is the temperature, ss is the specific entropy, gg is the gravitational acceleration vector, kk is the radiative conductivity, and ee is the specific energy production rate (erg g−1^{-1} s−1^{-1}) from nuclear burning. The viscous stress tensor, viscous heating, and rate-of-strain tensor are respectively defined

Πij=2ρν[eij−13(∇⋅u)δij],(15)\Pi_{ij}=2\rho\nu\left[e_{ij}-\frac{1}{3}(\nabla\cdot u)\delta_{ij}\right], \tag*{(15)}
Φ=2ρν[eijeij−13(∇⋅u)2]=2ρν[Tr⁡(eˉ⋅eˉ)−13(∇⋅u)2],(16)\Phi=2\rho\nu\left[e_{ij}e_{ij}-\frac{1}{3}(\nabla\cdot u)^2\right]=2\rho\nu\left[\operatorname{Tr}(\bar{e}\cdot\bar{e})-\frac{1}{3}(\nabla\cdot u)^2\right], \tag*{(16)}
eij=12(∇u+[∇u]T).(17)e_{ij}=\frac{1}{2}\left(\nabla u+[\nabla u]^{T}\right). \tag*{(17)}

where ν\nu is the viscous diffusivity (kinematic viscosity). Stars are composed of magnetized plasmas and thus magnetohydrodynamic effects should in general be accounted for, but for simplicity we will restrict our discussion to the hydrodynamic case in this review.

Arguments about CBM processes are often rooted in energetics. The kinetic energy equation is obtained by dotting Eqn. (13) with ρu\rho u and applying Eqn. (12) to retrieve

∂t(KE+PE)+∇⋅(u(KE+PE+P)+u⋅Π)=P∇⋅u−Φ.(18)\partial_t(\mathcal{K}\mathcal{E}+\mathcal{P}\mathcal{E})+\nabla\cdot\left(u(\mathcal{K}\mathcal{E}+\mathcal{P}\mathcal{E}+P)+u\cdot\Pi\right)=P\nabla\cdot u-\Phi. \tag*{(18)}

Here, the kinetic energy is KE=ρ∣u∣2/2\mathcal{K}\mathcal{E}=\rho|u|^2/2 and the potential energy is PE=ρϕ\mathcal{P}\mathcal{E}=\rho\phi, and we have assumed time invariance ∂tϕ=0\partial_t\phi=0 of the gravitational potential ϕ\phi (defined from g=−∇ϕg=-\nabla\phi). Eqn. (18) is written in conservation form, with the time derivative and divergence of energy fluxes on the left-hand side and the sources and sinks of energy on the right-hand side. An entropy equation is obtained by multiplying Eqn. (14) by ρ\rho and applying Eqn. (12),

∂t(ρs)+∇⋅(uρs)=1T(∇⋅(k∇T)+ρe+Φ).(19)\partial_t(\rho s)+\nabla\cdot(u\rho s)=\frac{1}{T}\left(\nabla\cdot(k\nabla T)+\rho e+\Phi\right). \tag*{(19)}

We note that we could have instead multiplied by ρT\rho T to obtain the internal energy equation, but that would generally return the same constraints as the kinetic energy equation, so a different thermal energy constraint is needed.

We next take a volume integral (denoted by angle brackets ⟨⟩\langle\rangle) of Eqns. (18) & (19) over the full convection zone and any important CBM region. We apply the divergence theorem to the flux terms and assume that the volume we are examining is bounded by regions where u≈0u\approx0, so the integral of the fluxes can be neglected. We are left with

∂t(⟨KE⟩+⟨PE⟩)=⟨P∇⋅u⟩−⟨Φ⟩,(20)\partial_t(\langle\mathcal{K}\mathcal{E}\rangle+\langle\mathcal{P}\mathcal{E}\rangle)=\langle P\nabla\cdot u\rangle-\langle\Phi\rangle, \tag*{(20)}
∂t⟨ρs⟩=⟨1T[∇⋅(k∇T)+ρe]⟩+⟨1TΦ⟩.(21)\partial_t\langle\rho s\rangle=\left\langle\frac{1}{T}\left[\nabla\cdot(k\nabla T)+\rho e\right]\right\rangle+\left\langle\frac{1}{T}\Phi\right\rangle. \tag*{(21)}

Eqn. (20) states that the evolution of the total (kinetic and potential) energy of the convection zone is determined by the fraction of PdVPdV work (⟨P∇⋅u⟩\langle P\nabla\cdot u\rangle) that is not consumed by dissipative processes (⟨Φ⟩\langle\Phi\rangle) on small scales. Eqn. (21) forms the basis for deriving thermal scaling laws for convective regions [108, 109] and also serves as a basis for the integral constraint of Roxburgh [110].

We will use this energetics framework to describe three processes that can occur in hydrodynamical CBM. These processes are depicted in Figure 4 and parallels can be drawn between these processes and the prescriptions in § 2. The first process is a small-scale conversion of convective kinetic energy into potential energy beyond the boundary, which is referred to as “convective overshoot.” The second is a process wherein either kinetic energy or buoyant work are used to increase the potential energy of the convection zone, referred to as “entrainment.”

Figure 4. Three CBM processes are shown schematically in the top row. White fluid represents the well-mixed CZ, while purple fluid is the stable RZ. (Left) Convective overshoot (§ 3.2) occurs when a fluid parcel from the CZ crosses into the RZ; a positive entropy gradient in the RZ accelerates the parcel back toward the CZ. (Middle) Shear flows and overshooting motions drag RZ fluid into the CZ in a process called entrainment (§ 3.4). (Right) Convective penetration occurs when convection maintains a well-mixed region of fluid beyond the Schwarzschild boundary (§ 3.5). The bottom panel shows the structure of a statistically-stationary convective boundary, which resembles the 1D “extended convective penetration” prescription (§ 2.6). This figure was originally published online under a CC BY license in Anders et al. [112].

The third process occurs in a statistically stationary state where ∂t(⟨KE⟩+⟨PE⟩)=0\partial_t(\langle\mathcal{K}\mathcal{E}\rangle+ \langle\mathcal{P}\mathcal{E}\rangle) = 0, and a balance between work producing energy and dissipation is achieved; this process is called “convective penetration.” We note that there is a great deal of degeneracy in the literature studying these processes, and these terms (in particular “overshoot” and “penetration”) are often used interchangeably; note that when we use these terms in this review we are referring to distinct processes. As in the bottom panel of Figure 4, we will assume that the stellar structure consists of a convection zone (CZ, ∇≈∇ad<∇rad\nabla\approx\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} < \nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}) and a radiative zone (RZ, ∇≈∇rad<∇ad\nabla\approx\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}} < \nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}), and that the CBM region consists of both a penetrative zone (PZ, ∇≈∇ad>∇rad\nabla\approx\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} > \nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}) and an overshoot zone (OZ, ∇≈∇rad<∇ad\nabla\approx\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}} < \nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}). We note that the convection zone itself could also have additional structure (e.g., “Deardorff zones”, see Ref. [111]), but we do not include that level of detail here.

Nondimensional Fluid Parameters

Many hydrodynamical studies of convective boundary mixing processes seek a description of how a CBM length scale or rate varies as a nondimensional fluid parameter is changed. Commonly measured nondimensional numbers are the bulk Richardson number, RiB\mathrm{Ri}_{\mathrm{B}}, and the stiffness or relative stability, SS. These parameters compare the buoyancy stability of the RZ to how unstable or vigorous the convection is in the CZ.

The Richardson number was first examined in the astrophysical context by Meakin and Arnett [25] and is typically defined

RiB=ΔbLσ2,withΔb=∫r1r2N2 dr,(22)\mathrm{Ri}_{\mathrm{B}} = \frac{\Delta b L}{\sigma^{2}}, \qquad\text{with} \qquad\Delta b = \int_{r_1}^{r_2} N^{2}\,\mathrm{d}r, \tag*{(22)}

where σ\sigma is the root-mean-square turbulent velocity in the convective region near the interface, N2N^2 is the Brunt-Väisälä frequency, LL is a typical length scale for turbulent motions, and the convective interface is assumed to span some radial extent ranging from r1r_1 to r2r_2. There is degeneracy in how r1r_1, r2r_2, and LL are defined in the literature.

An alternative approach is to measure the “stiffness” or “relative stability” SS of the radiative-convective interface. This has historically been defined in two ways. Early simulations defined a structure-based SS [113]4,

Sstruct≈∣∇rad−∇ad∣RZ∣∇rad−∇ad∣CZ(23)S_{\mathrm{struct}} \approx\frac{\left|\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}-\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}\right|_{\mathrm{RZ}}}{\left|\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}-\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}\right|_{\mathrm{CZ}}} \tag*{(23)}

where the logarithmic temperature gradients are defined in Sct. 2.2. This definition is useful in simulations where convection is driven by an unstable temperature gradient which achieves ∇=∇rad\nabla=\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}} by e.g., an enforced boundary condition, but it is less useful in describing convection in the cores of massive stars where ∇≈∇ad≪∇rad\nabla\approx\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}\ll\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}. Recently, a dynamical definition of the stiffness has been favored by some authors [114, 115, 116],

Sdyn=NRZ2ωconv2(24)S_{\mathrm{dyn}}=\frac{N_{\mathrm{RZ}}^2}{\omega_{\mathrm{conv}}^2} \tag*{(24)}

where NRZ2N_{\mathrm{RZ}}^2 is the typical value of the Brunt-Väisälä frequency in the stable radiative zone and ωconv2=[2πuconv/L]2\omega_{\mathrm{conv}}^2=[2\pi u_{\mathrm{conv}}/L]^2 is the square angular convective frequency, where uconvu_{\mathrm{conv}} is the average turbulent convective velocity and LL is a typical convective length scale. We then see that Sdyn≈RiBS_{\mathrm{dyn}}\approx\mathrm{Ri}_{\mathrm{B}}, aside from the length scales which are used. It is generally expected that stiff convective interfaces (with large values of SS or RiB\mathrm{Ri}_{\mathrm{B}}) should have very small CBM regions. Stellar evolution models [5] and asteroseismic inferences [117] expect the stiffness value at the core boundaries of massive stars to be very large (Sdyn∼106−8S_{\mathrm{dyn}}\sim10^{6-8}).

We also note that there is an explicit link between the Mach number Ma2=uconv2/cs2\mathrm{Ma}^2=u_{\mathrm{conv}}^2/c_{\mathrm{s}}^2 of convection and SdynS_{\mathrm{dyn}}; knowledge of Ma\mathrm{Ma} in a convection zone therefore provides information about CBM. Take cs2=P/ρ=gHPc_{\mathrm{s}}^2=P/\rho=gH_P to be the sound speed in a star in hydrostatic equilibrium, where HPH_P is the pressure scale height and gg is the gravitational acceleration. Neglecting composition gradients, and assuming N2=(g/HP)(∇ad−∇rad)N^2=(g/H_P)(\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}-\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}) in the RZ (Equation 6.18 of Ref. [118]) and ωc2=[2πuconv/HP]2\omega_{\mathrm{c}}^2=[2\pi u_{\mathrm{conv}}/H_P]^2 in the CZ, it can be shown that

Sdyn=Ma−2(∇ad−∇rad)RZ(2π)2(25)S_{\mathrm{dyn}}=\mathrm{Ma}^{-2}\frac{(\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}-\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}})_{\mathrm{RZ}}}{(2\pi)^2} \tag*{(25)}

Anders et al. [116] recently introduced a new “penetration parameter” P\mathcal{P} to the zoo of parameters that describe CBM. The extent of an adiabatic penetration zone is assumed to be determined by the magnitude of the negative buoyant work done within this zone [39, 110]. Therefore, a luminosity (or flux) based parameter can be defined [116],

P=−(Lrad−Lad)CZ(Lrad−Lad)RZ(26)\mathcal{P}=-\frac{(L_{\mathrm{rad}}-L_{\mathrm{ad}})_{\mathrm{CZ}}}{(L_{\mathrm{rad}}-L_{\mathrm{ad}})_{\mathrm{RZ}}} \tag*{(26)}

where the numerator (CZ) is averaged over some part of the convective zone and the denominator (RZ) is averaged over some part of the region that would be a radiative zone if not for convective penetration. Here, LadL_{\mathrm{ad}} is the radiative luminosity that would be carried if the stratification were adiabatic ∇=∇ad\nabla=\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}, and LradL_{\mathrm{rad}} is the radiative luminosity that would be carried if the stratification were ∇=∇rad\nabla=\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}; Since (Lrad−Lad)RZ<0(L_{\mathrm{rad}}-L_{\mathrm{ad}})_{\mathrm{RZ}}<0, P>0\mathcal{P}>0 always. Large penetrative regions are expected when P\mathcal{P} is large. There is an implicit link between the penetration parameter and the structural relative stability parameter, P∼Sstruct−1\mathcal{P} \sim S_{\mathrm{struct}}^{-1}. It therefore makes sense that simulations (e.g., [119, 120]) see negligible penetration when Sstruct≫1S_{\mathrm{struct}} \gg1. Note that the dependence of convective penetration on P\mathcal{P} or SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} is why we distinguish between SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} and SdynS_{\mathrm{dyn}}. Many simulations are set up in such a manner that Sstruct∼SdynS_{\mathrm{struct}} \sim S_{\mathrm{dyn}}; however, stars can have P∼Sstruct∼1\mathcal{P} \sim S_{\mathrm{struct}} \sim1 and Sdyn≫1S_{\mathrm{dyn}} \gg1 simultaneously.

We finally note that studies dating back to Zahn [39] & Hurlburt et al. [113] ponder the importance of the Péclet number on CBM (e.g., [63, 119, 121, 122, 123, 124]). The Péclet number measures the ratio of the thermal diffusion timescale to the convective overturn timescale,

Pe=τthermτconv=uconvLχrad,(27)\mathrm{Pe} = \frac{\tau_{\mathrm{therm}}}{\tau_{\mathrm{conv}}} = \frac{u_{\mathrm{conv}}L}{\chi_{\mathrm{rad}}}, \tag*{(27)}

where χrad\chi_{\mathrm{rad}} is the radiative diffusivity of the fluid. The associated argument suggests that CBM regions have an adiabatic penetration zone where Pe\mathrm{Pe} is large as well as a “thermal adjustment layer” where Pe∼1\mathrm{Pe} \sim1. The size of the CBM region is expected to scale like SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} for the adiabatic penetration zone and like Sstruct−1/4S_{\mathrm{struct}}^{-1/4} for the thermal adjustment layer [113]. While these scalings were observed by early simulations (e.g., [125, 126]), they have not appeared in more recent simulations [119, 120]. Main-sequence convection is very turbulent with bulk Pe≫1\mathrm{Pe} \gg1 [5], so it is hard to imagine that a large thermal adjustment layer should appear at the radial location where convective flows have damped to the point of becoming laminar (Pe∼1\mathrm{Pe} \sim1).

Convective Overshoot

Convective overshoot is a process which occurs on the scale of an individual convective flow when the flow traverses the convective boundary. We define the convective boundary as the location where the entropy gradient becomes positive. In the bulk convection zone, buoyancy forces act in the expected sense (low entropy blobs accelerate upwards and high entropy blobs accelerate downwards). Beyond the convective boundary, buoyancy forces act in the opposite sense and motions become wave-like (low entropy blobs are accelerated downwards, and vice versa). A “hot” upflow in the convection zone therefore accelerates downward after passing the convective boundary. This wave-like restoring motion of a convective parcel beyond the convective boundary is convective overshoot. Convective overshoot is visualized in Figure 5.

Convective overshoot occurs in all simulations which include a convection zone bordered by a radiative zone. First seen by Hurlburt et al. [127], many studies have observed overshooting and have generally sought to understand how it depends on Pe\mathrm{Pe} and SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} (e.g., [113, 119, 120, 128, 129, 130, 131, 132]). Others sought to understand how the imposed convective flux determined the depth of overshoot [125, 133, 134].

Recently, an energetics-based model of convective overshoot has emerged. This model is laid out in Korre et al. [135], eqns. 30–35, and is also described in Leconet et al. [114]. They argue that a convective blob passing the convective boundary will overshoot adiabatically until the parcel’s kinetic energy is converted into potential energy. This argument was presented in the context of a simplified, Boussinesq model; here we briefly recreate it in the context of the fully compressible Eqns. (12)–(14). The conversion of kinetic energy into gravitational potential energy occurs through the action of buoyant work,

12ρCBuconv2=∫rCBrCB+δovFbuoy dr∼δov⟨Fbuoy⟩,(28)\frac{1}{2}\rho_{\mathrm{CB}}u_{\mathrm{conv}}^{2} = \int_{r_{\mathrm{CB}}}^{r_{\mathrm{CB}}+\delta_{\mathrm{ov}}} F_{\mathrm{buoy}}\,\mathrm{d}r \sim\delta_{\mathrm{ov}}\langle F_{\mathrm{buoy}}\rangle, \tag*{(28)}

where ρCB\rho_{\mathrm{CB}} is the density near the convective boundary, uconvu_{\mathrm{conv}} is the bulk convective velocity, rCBr_{\mathrm{CB}} is the radial location of the convective boundary, δov\delta_{\mathrm{ov}} is the overshoot distance, and FbuoyF_{\mathrm{buoy}} is the radial component of the buoyancy force. In the limit of low-Mach number flows applicable to core convection or deep envelope convection on the main sequence [5], and for an ideal gas [136], the buoyant force in this limit becomes

Fbuoy=−ρgs′cp,(29)F_{\mathrm{buoy}}=-\rho g\frac{s'}{c_p}, \tag*{(29)}

where s′s' is the specific entropy fluctuation associated with a convective blob and cpc_p is the specific heat at constant pressure. The buoyant force near the convective boundary for a parcel traveling adiabatically is approximately

⟨Fbuoy⟩∼∫ρgcpdsdr dr=∫ρN2 dr.(30)\left\langle F_{\mathrm{buoy}}\right\rangle\sim\int\rho\frac{g}{c_p}\frac{\mathrm{d}s}{\mathrm{d}r}\,\mathrm{d}r=\int\rho N^2\,\mathrm{d}r. \tag*{(30)}

Assuming that the density is roughly the background density and does not vary sharply near the convective boundary provides

12ρCBucz2∼δovρCB∫N2 dr.(31)\frac{1}{2}\rho_{\mathrm{CB}}u_{\mathrm{cz}}^2\sim\delta_{\mathrm{ov}}\rho_{\mathrm{CB}}\int N^2\,\mathrm{d}r. \tag*{(31)}

Dividing by a characteristic length scale LL, ρCB\rho_{\mathrm{CB}}, and Δb=∫N2dr\Delta b = \int N^2 \mathrm{d}r provides

δovL∼RiB−1,(32)\frac{\delta_{\mathrm{ov}}}{L} \sim\mathrm{Ri}_{B}^{-1}, \tag*{(32)}

i.e., the overshoot depth is inversely proportional to the Richardson number or similarly the dynamical stiffness SdynS_{\mathrm{dyn}}. Korre et al. [135] take this argument one step further for more direct comparison with simplified models of overshoot in convective simulations. They derive how they expect the overshoot distance to scale with SdynS_{\mathrm{dyn}}. For a stratification near the convective boundary like N2=N02[(r−rcb)/L]αN^2 = N_0^2[(r-r_{\mathrm{cb}})/L]^\alpha (where rcbr_{\mathrm{cb}} is the radial coordinate of the convective boundary), they evaluate Δb\Delta b and rearrange Eqn. (31) to find

Δb=N021+αδov1+αLα⇒1+α2ucz2L2N02∼(δovL)2+α⇒(δovL)∼Sdyn−1/(2+α).(33)\Delta b = \frac{N_0^2}{1+\alpha}\frac{\delta_{\mathrm{ov}}^{1+\alpha}}{L^\alpha} \quad\Rightarrow\quad \frac{1+\alpha}{2}\frac{u_{\mathrm{cz}}^2}{L^2N_0^2}\sim\left(\frac{\delta_{\mathrm{ov}}}{L}\right)^{2+\alpha} \quad\Rightarrow\quad \left(\frac{\delta_{\mathrm{ov}}}{L}\right)\sim S_{\mathrm{dyn}}^{-1/(2+\alpha)}. \tag*{(33)}

So e.g., for a simulation where N2N^2 is a constant above the convective boundary, (δov/L)∼Sdyn−1/2(\delta_{\mathrm{ov}}/L)\sim S_{\mathrm{dyn}}^{-1/2}, and for a simulation where it increases linearly, it should scale as (δov/L)∼Sdyn−1/3(\delta_{\mathrm{ov}}/L)\sim S_{\mathrm{dyn}}^{-1/3}, which is the case examined by Lecoanet et al. [114]. A stratification which is well approximated by N2∼r2N^2\sim r^2 in a small region outside of the convection zone would therefore reproduce the S1/4S^{1/4} observed by early simulations [113, 119].

We note briefly that one fairly robust result from the literature of overshooting convection is that overshoot depths are almost universally seen to decrease as SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} (and SdynS_{\mathrm{dyn}}) increases. One exception is the recent result of Cai [132] who observed that convective exit velocities increased in the very-high SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} regime, which in turn produced increasing overshoot depths; the process which would drive these increased velocities is not clear.

Convective Overshoot as Turbulent Diffusion

Overshooting has been incorporated into 1D stellar evolution models by parameterizing convective mixing using a diffusivity profile (see § 2.3). An exponential diffusive profile was observed in the early simulations of Freytag et al. [41]; this profile was adopted by Herwig [42], and this has been the standard choice in the field ever since. More recently, Jones et al. [28] found that an exponential turbulent diffusivity described the turbulent diffusion measured in their simulations well. Herwig et al. [137] have noted that convective velocities start to fall off before reaching the CZ boundary, which complicates the implementation of this exponential diffusivity. Separately, Lecoanet et al. [114] see a fast decrease of turbulent diffusivity outside of their convection zone, but they argue that it is better parameterized as step overshooting (§ 2.4).

We note that there are two separate questions which must be answered to robustly describe convective overshoot as a turbulent diffusivity. First, how do the convective velocities decrease beyond the convective boundary? Korre et al. [135] find that the kinetic energy is well-defined by a Gaussian beyond the convective boundary (e.g., their fig 4), while Pratt et al. [99] use extreme value statistics to characterize the maximum depth that convective plumes overshoot to at any point in time, and find their results best-described by a Gumbel distribution (exp⁡(−exp⁡(−x))\exp(-\exp(-x))). Once the velocity profile beyond the convective boundary is understood, we must then ask how the velocity profile relates to the mixing produced by overshooting convection.

Entrainment

Entrainment is the process by which convection “scrapes” material from an adjacent stable layer into the convective region and then mixes that material. Entrainment is caused by multiple processes (e.g., splashing from convective overshoot or shear instabilities driven by horizontal convective flow [138]; for simplicity, we consider entrainment to be any process accompanied by a measurable mixing of the mean radial entropy or chemical profile at the convective boundary. Energetically, entrainment occurs when convection exerts buoyancy work on the adjacent stable fluid. This work raises the potential energy of a portion of the adjacent fluid enough to dislodge it and drag it into the convecting region.

The earliest entrainment studies examined a stable, linear composition gradient which was destabilized by heating from below, resulting in the emergence of a convection zone which grows by entrainment. This simple setup has been studied both in the lab and numerically for the past 60 years [139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146]. These studies proposed and observed an E∝RiB−1E \propto\mathrm{Ri}_{B}^{-1} relationship, where E=ue/utE = u_{e}/u_{t} is the entrainment efficiency, with ueu_{e} the entrainment velocity (the rate at which the convective boundary advances) and utu_{t} is the turbulent convective velocity [141]. These studies measured the height of the convective boundary vs. time h(t)h(t), and found generally h(t)∝t1/2h(t) \propto t^{1/2} (e.g., [139, 143, 146]) or h(t)∝t1/3h(t) \propto t^{1/3} [141]. Entrainment has also been observed and studied in other simulations of Boussinesq convection bounded by a stable region; these studies further established the dependence of the entrainment rate on RiB\mathrm{Ri}_{B} or SS [115, 147].

More recently, Meakin and Arnett [25] introduced the concept of turbulent entrainment into studies of stellar astrophysics. They perform 3D hydrodynamic simulations of stellar convection using stellar structure models as initial conditions and find significant turbulent entrainment and advancement of the convective boundary (see Figure 6). They find that the entrainment efficiency follows a power law scaling of E=ARiB−nE = A\mathrm{Ri}_{B}^{-n}, where A∼10−1−10−2A \sim10^{-1} - 10^{-2} and n≈1n \approx1, well in line with previous geophysical studies. These results have been corroborated by many hydrodynamical studies over the past decade (e.g., [26, 28, 31, 148, 149, 150]), typically finding power laws with n≈1n \approx1 and A∈[10−2,1]A \in[10^{-2},1] (see Figure 7). These results have inspired Staritsin [151] and Scott et al. [152] to include power-law implementations of turbulent entrainment into stellar models, but they find that the entrainment law calibrated to simulations leads to the entire star being engulfed by the convection zone on evolutionary timescales. They do find decent agreement with other forms of boundary mixing using A∼10−4A \sim10^{-4}, but to date no dynamical simulations have revealed a value of AA this small.

Radial gradient of the oxygen concentration profile in an oxygen-burning shell

Figure 6. Data are from a hydrodynamical simulation of an oxygen-burning shell; radial coordinate is on the y-axis and time coordinate is on the x-axis. Color shows the radial gradient of the oxygen concentration profile at each time; the thick bright lines denote the top and bottom boundaries of the convective region. Turbulent convection occurs at times t≳50t \gtrsim50, and entrainment causes measurable movement of the convective boundary. Figure 4 of Meakin and Arnett [25]; © AAS. Reproduced with permission.

Entrainment rate plotted against the bulk Richardson number for simulations of neon, oxygen, and carbon burning shells

Figure 7. Entrainment rate is plotted against the bulk Richardson number for simulations of neon burning shells [31], oxygen burning shells [25], and carbon burning shells [150]. Entrainment laws ARiB−nA Ri_{\mathrm{B}}^{-n} with A∼(0.05,1)A \sim(0.05,1) and n∼1n \sim1 are reported. Figure 5 of Rizzuti et al. [31]; © Oxford University Press. Reproduced with permission.

We interpret the state of the astrophysical entrainment literature as follows. Stellar models underestimate the size of convection zones consistently. As a result, when stellar models are used as initial conditions for 3D hydrodynamical simulations, significant turbulent entrainment is observed as the convecting regions expand to an equilibrium size. Unfortunately most simulations are not long enough to observe the equilibrium sizes of convecting regions, so the saturation size of convective zones is uncertain. Anders et al. [2] studied a simulation under the Boussinesq approximation in which the Ledoux and Schwarzschild criteria initially disagree regarding the location of the convective boundary. Convection entrains material at the Ledoux boundary until the two criteria agree, after which point entrainment stops. Unfortunately, we are unaware of any studies which both employ the fully compressible equations and allow the size of the convection zone to fully saturate through entrainment, so these findings should be confirmed in more complex setups.

One may ask if entrainment should be included in standard stellar evolution models, just like exponential and step overshoot prescriptions. We believe that a precise implementation of entrainment is not necessary during the main sequence or other phases of evolution where the evolutionary timescale is very long compared to the entrainment rate [2]. However, proper entrainment implementations will improve stellar evolution calculations of short-lived phases of evolution where the size of convection zones are changing rapidly and where time-dependent convection implementations are necessary [153].

Convective Penetration

The boundary of a well-mixed convective region can advance by entrainment significantly beyond the Schwarzschild boundary. When this occurs, we refer to the process as convective penetration, characterized by a nearly adiabatic and chemically homogeneous region which is part of the convection zone but which is characterized by ∇rad<∇ad\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}} < \nabla_{\mathrm{ad}}.

Convective penetration was hypothesized by Roxburgh and Zahn [39, 110, 154, 155], but has been elusive in simulations and experiments. The hallmark of penetrative convection is mixing of the entropy gradient beyond the Schwarzschild boundary. Entropy mixing beyond the initial convective boundary has often been reported [113, 119, 120, 123, 126, 156, 157], but it is often unclear if the reported process is convective penetration or if it is movement of the Schwarzschild boundary by entrainment. Another hallmark of penetrative convection is substantial negative convective flux (and excess radiative flux) beyond the schwarzschild boundary; this is frequently observed [99, 121, 127, 158, 159], but also often seen in studies of non-penetrative overshooting convection.

Unfortunately, studies aimed at understanding convective penetration have found inconsistent or contradictory results regarding how penetration depends on e.g., SS or RiB\mathrm{Ri}_{\mathrm{B}}. Early studies [113, 158] suggested that penetration and SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} were linked at low values of SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} (a regime that produces a dynamical SdynS_{\mathrm{dyn}} which is not relevant for core convection, see Couston et al. [115]), but later studies [119, 120] found no link between SstructS_{\mathrm{struct}} and convective penetration. However, many simulations have found that penetration lengths can depend on the magnitude of energy fluxes [125, 133, 134, 160, 161].

Robust evidence of convective penetration in numerical simulations was observed by Anders et al. [116] in 3D Cartesian and Baraffe et al. [162] in 2D spherical simulations. The dynamics of penetrative convection are shown in the top two panels of Figure 8. The thermal structure of a convective region with a penetration region is shown in the bottom left panel of

3D hydrodynamic simulation showing velocity, scaled temperature anomaly, averaged gradient profiles, and penetration-zone extent

Figure 8. A snapshot in time of a 3D hydrodynamic simulation is displayed in the upper two panels with the velocity (left) and scaled temperature anomaly (right) shown. The Schwarzschild boundary is shown as a dashed line, and the height where ∇\nabla departs from ∇ad\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} is plotted as a thick horizontal line. Note in the upper right panel that hot CZ upwellings turn cold in the penetration zone between the dashed and solid lines. (Bottom left) The time- and horizontally-averaged ∇\nabla profiles from a simulation like the one in the top panel; a distinct convection zone (CZ), nearly adiabatic penetration zone (PZ), overshoot zone (grey shaded region) and radiative zone (RZ) are seen. (Bottom right) The extent of the PZ is plotted against the penetration parameter, with the expected scaling overplotted in orange; P\mathcal{P} is found to be the most important parameter for determining the size of the PZ. From Figure 1 (upper two panels), Figure 2 (bottom left panel) and part of Figure 7 (bottom right panel) from Anders et al. [116]; these figures were originally published online under a CC BY license.

Figure 8. The extent of the penetration region scales strongly with the penetration parameter P\mathcal{P}, as shown in the bottom right panel of Figure 8.

Convective penetration occurs in the stationary state, so Eqn. (21) becomes

−⟨1T(∇⋅(k∇T)+ρϵ)⟩=⟨1TΦ⟩.(34)-\left\langle\frac{1}{T}\left(\nabla\cdot(k\nabla T) + \rho\epsilon\right)\right\rangle= \left\langle\frac{1}{T}\Phi\right\rangle. \tag*{(34)}

This can be rearranged into the integral constraint of Roxburgh [110, 154, 155],

∫V−(Ftot−Frad)1T02dT0dr dV=∫VΦT0 dV,(35)\int_V -(F_{\mathrm{tot}}-F_{\mathrm{rad}})\frac{1}{T_0^2}\frac{dT_0}{dr}\,dV = \int_V \frac{\Phi}{T_0}\,dV, \tag*{(35)}

where FtotF_{\mathrm{tot}} is the total flux, FradF_{\mathrm{rad}} is the radiative flux, and T0T_0 is the temperature stratification. We follow Anders et al. [2] and break up constraint integrals into a CZ (convective zone) and PZ (penetrative zone) portion. Noting that Fconv=Ftot−FradF_{\mathrm{conv}} = F_{\mathrm{tot}} - F_{\mathrm{rad}}, and that dT0/dr<0dT_0/dr < 0, we get

∫CZFconv∣1T02dT0dr∣ dV=∫CZΦT0 dV+[−∫PZFconv∣1T02dT0dr∣ dV+∫PZΦT0 dV].(36)\int_{\mathrm{CZ}} F_{\mathrm{conv}}\left|\frac{1}{T_0^2}\frac{dT_0}{dr}\right|\,dV = \int_{\mathrm{CZ}} \frac{\Phi}{T_0}\,dV + \left[-\int_{\mathrm{PZ}} F_{\mathrm{conv}}\left|\frac{1}{T_0^2}\frac{dT_0}{dr}\right|\,dV + \int_{\mathrm{PZ}} \frac{\Phi}{T_0}\,dV\right]. \tag*{(36)}

The left-hand side (LHS) of Eqn. (36) is a buoyant “engine” which quantifies the buoyant work done by the convection in the bulk CZ. In an energetically stationary state, this positive work must be balanced out by the terms on the right-hand side (RHS) of the equation. We note that in an adiabatically mixed PZ, where ∇≈∇ad\nabla\approx\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} but ∇ad>∇rad\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} > \nabla_{\mathrm{rad}}, radiation carries too much flux Frad>FtotF_{\mathrm{rad}} > F_{\mathrm{tot}}, so Fconv<0F_{\mathrm{conv}} < 0 is required for equilibrium. Therefore, all terms on the RHS of Eqn. (36) are positive and contribute to consumption of the LHS work. We therefore see that either dissipation is highly efficient in the convection zone, or a penetrative region characterized by negative buoyant work is required to achieve energy conservation. Zahn [39] noted that the size of a penetrative region is controlled by how drastically ∇rad\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}} departs from ∇ad\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} in the PZ. This intuition appears mathematically here: a rapid departure where ∇rad≪∇ad\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}} \ll\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} (small P\mathcal{P}) leads to a large negative FconvF_{\mathrm{conv}}, so only a small PZ is required for balance in Eqn. (36). A very gradual departure where ∇rad∼∇ad\nabla_{\mathrm{rad}} \sim\nabla_{\mathrm{ad}} (large P\mathcal{P}) leads to Fconv∼0F_{\mathrm{conv}} \sim0 in the PZ, and so its size is set by the turbulent dissipative properties of the convection.

We note that it is unintuitive for dissipation (Φ\Phi) to play an important role in astrophysical convection, where viscosities are very small. In turbulent flows, the so-called “zeroth law of turbulence” states that energy which is injected into a turbulent cascade at large scales must eventually be dissipated at small scales. Therefore the rate of turbulent dissipation is not determined by the magnitude of viscosity but rather by the rate of energy transfer from the largest eddies into the cascade, which scales something like U3/ℓU^3/\ell (Ref. [163], Section 6.1.1). We also note that astrophysical convection occurs in a magnetized plasma, where additional dissipation processes (e.g., Ohmic dissipation) complicate this picture, but a full discussion of this work is beyond the scope of this review. We simply note that dissipation is expected to be substantial, and this has been shown in direct numerical simulations (e.g., [158, 164, 165]), although a satisfying model for the magnitude of viscous dissipation in astrophysical convection has not yet been created. This is an idea that appears both in the literature of convective penetration, and in the other fields like gravity wave mixing [96], and should be examined in more detail.

Rotational Constraint & Magnetic Pumping

In this review, we focused on results from hydrodynamical (not magnetohydrodynamical), nonrotating fluid simulations. All stars rotate and this rotation often strongly influences convective dynamics [5]. It is generally believed that rotation should decrease the extent of CBM (although it may create e.g., meridional circulations which themselves separately increase mixing). There is evidence that rotation increases the dissipation in convective flows [166, 167, 168], which would decrease the extent of a penetration zone; analytic work by Augustson and Mathis [100] also predicts that rotation should decrease the extent of penetration zones. Brummell et al. [119] find that rotation decreases overshoot, while Dietrich and Wicht [130] find that only SS affects overshoot and not rotation. Browning et al. [121] studied 3D rotating core convection and found prolate penetration zones aligned with the rotation axis, which is consistent with the local box simulations of Pal et al. [169] who found less penetration at the equator than at the poles. The effects of magnetism are even less studied, but convection can pump magnetic fields out of the convection zone and into CBM regions; this process was discovered by Drobyshevski and Yuferev [170] and has been observed in simulations [171, 172]; magnetic pumping has been suggested as a mechanism for solar active region formation [173] and has been used to study the structure of the Sun’s magnetic field below the convection zone [174]. The manner in which rotation and magnetism affect CBM remains unclear, and future studies should explore the importance of these effects on each of the processes discussed in this review.

Empirical calibrations

Stellar clusters

Early observational inferences on CBM dating back to 1971 come from the studies of the old open cluster M67. Both Racine [175] and Torres-Peimbert [176] reported that the observed gap above the main-sequence turnoff, could not be reproduced by isochrones computed with standard models [176]. A hook is seen in the isochrone at the main-sequence turnoff and the rapid evolution caused by hydrogen exhaustion results in a gap in the number of stars observed above the turnoff. By including CBM in the models, Prather and Demarque [49] demonstrated that this hook and hence gap can persist to much greater ages and thereby explain the observed gap in M67. Similar discrepancies between observations and standard model predictions were found around the same time for the open clusters NGC 752 [177] and NGC 2420 [178]. For the latter cluster, an update in the adopted opacity tables remained insufficient to explain the gap and the inclusion of CBM in the models was required [179]. In comparison, Maeder and Mermilliod [180] considered a sample of 34 open clusters, finding that the inclusion of CBM is required to explain the extension of the core-hydrogen burning phase beyond the theoretical sequence predicted by standard models.

Several additional open and globular clusters have been studied in detail to investigate whether CBM is required to explain their morphology and distribution of stars in the color-magnitude diagram (CMD) (e.g. NGC 3680 [181], IC 4651 [182], NGC 2164 [183], NGC 1831 [184], NGC 1866 [185], NGC 6134 [186], NGC 2173 [187], SL 556 [187], NGC 2155 [187], NGC 1783 [188], NGC 419 [189]). Meaningful inferences on the CBM from these types of studies requires non-cluster and binary members to be properly identified [182, 190]. Isochrones including CBM improve model agreement with observations for these clusters. The inclusion of improved opacity tables in the models generally tend to decrease the amount of required CBM, and in some cases may be sufficient to explain the observations without requiring any additional CBM [191].

Demarque et al. [68] were some of the first to consider a mass dependent CBM in the calculation of model isochrones. The Y2Y^{2} isochrones included a gradual increase in the CBM parameter up to a critical mass above which a constant value was assumed, finding good fits to the observed CMDs of the seven considered open clusters including M67. However, the need for CBM is not unambiguous. Michaud et al. [192] argued that no CBM is required to reproduce the observed CMD of either M67 or NGC 188 if microscopic diffusion is included in the models. A similar conclusion for M67 was later found by Viani and Basu [193].

Similar mass dependent CBM to the one adopted by Demarque et al. [68] has since been included in other isochrones such as the PARSEC isochrones [194], while others like the MIST isochrones [195, 196] adopt a single value for the CBM parameter. Recently, Johnston et al. [197] introduced the concept of an isochrone cloud, which shows what an isochrone would look like if the internal mixing were allowed to vary on a star-by-star basis without assuming, e.g., a mass-dependent CBM. In this case the isochrone is no longer a thin line but fans out for masses with convective cores. Same age models with higher mixing will be less evolved due to the extended main-sequence lifetime and define the blue edge of the isochrone cloud, whereas models with less mixing will be further evolved and therefore have lower temperatures corresponding to the red edge of the isochrone cloud, see Figure 3 of Johnston et al. [198]. The isochrone clouds were later used to model two younger stellar clusters showing extended main-sequence turnoffs (eMSTOs) [198]. eMSTOs are a broadening of the main-sequence of a cluster near its turn-off for M≳1.4 M⊙M \gtrsim1.4\,M_{\odot}, and are common in young and intermediate age clusters (e.g., [199, 200]). Age spreads [201], binary interactions [202], rotation [203], and variations in CBM [204] have been suggested as possible explanations for the eMSTOs. Spectroscopic observations focusing on measuring projected rotational velocities, vsin⁡iv \sin i, of stars in the eMSTO have shown in recent years that the spread appears to coincide with a spread in vsin⁡iv \sin i amongst the stars, with faster rotating stars being redder and cooler than those with lower projected rotational velocities [205, 206, 207, 208, 209]. These observations suggest that rotation is the dominant effect behind the eMSTO, and that the eMSTO is caused by the combined effects of gravity darkening [210, 211], where rotation causes the equators of the stars to be cooler than the poles, and a spread in inclination angles. Lipatov et al. [212] recently provided a tool for accounting for these effects in the model isochrones. Note that the effects on the positions of the stars in the CMD caused by gravity darkening and spreads in inclination angles are opposite to those caused by internal mixing, where faster rotating stars are expected to have higher amounts of internal mixing. Knowing the inclination angles of the stars could help disentangling the relative importance of these different effects on the morphology of the eMSTO.

Apsidal motion

Apsidal motion, the change in the position of the periastron of a binary orbit, provides direct evidence of the internal density concentration of the stars in the binary system [213]. Measurements of Apsidal motion are based on the calculation of the apsidal constant kjk_j (j=2,3,4j = 2,3,4), also known as the density or internal structure constant. From an observational standpoint, only the second order apsidal motion constant k2k_2 is usually important [214], and takes on a value of k2=0.75k_2 = 0.75 for a homogeneous density distribution [213, 214]. In reality, rather than deriving the individual component apsidal constants, one instead works with a weighted average value k‾2\overline{k}_2 of the two binary components [214].

Figure 9 a) illustrates how the size of the CBM region affects log⁡k2\log k_2 throughout the main-sequence evolution for three different initial stellar masses. The decrease in log⁡k2\log k_2 during the main-sequence evolution is caused by the fusion of hydrogen to helium, resulting in the stars becoming more centrally condensed as they evolve. Aside from CBM, changing the opacity and metallicity of the models likewise changes the predicted k2k_2 values [215], see panel b of Figure 9. Stellar rotation also impacts the derived k2k_2 values by making the stars more centrally condensed [216]. Finally, both CBM and stellar winds lead to more centrally condensed models but impact the stellar luminosities differently by making the models more (less) luminous when CBM (mass loss) is included [214].

Evolution of the apsidal constant $k_2$ for three different initial stellar masses

Figure 9. Evolution of the apsidal constant k2k_2 for three different initial stellar masses. (a) Variation in k2k_2 resulting from varying the extent of the CBM region assuming exponential diffusive overshoot and a fixed initial chemical composition of X=0.71X = 0.71, Y=0.276Y = 0.276, and Z=0.014Z = 0.014. (b) Variation in k2k_2 resulting from changing the initial metallicity of the stars, assuming a mass dependent CBM [71]. Figure made by the authors using MESA models (panel a) and preexisting model grids by Claret [71] (panel b). MESA inlists and data used to generate panel (a) are available on Zenodo [33].

The binary system Spica (α\alpha Virginis) is one of the first systems where the measured apsidal motion constants implied a need for CBM to reconcile models with observations [217, 218]. Initial studies of this system showed that the observed luminosities and effective temperatures could be matched to the models by varying the initial mass and helium content, but the predicted apsidal constant was a factor of two too high compared to the observed value. Including CBM allowed LL, TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}}, and k2k_2 to simultaneously be reconciled. However, the use of different opacity tables could potentially reconcile these quantities without CBM [216]. Further constraints could potentially be obtained by studying the primary star, which is a known β\beta Cep pulsator. While the oscillations of this star have previously been studied using both photometry and spectroscopy [219, 220, 221, 222, 223, 224], no detailed asteroseismic modeling has so far been achieved. Given that the primary β\beta Cep star has been selected as a priority 1A target for the future asteroseismic CubeSpec space mission [225] this might change in the future.

The need for CBM to reconcile the observed apsidal constants with theoretical values is not unambiguous. Claret and Gimenez [226] studied 14 eclipsing binaries in the mass range of 1.5–23 M⊙_\odot and showed that a rotation correction to k2k_2 could reconcile the observed and theoretical values. For the binary system PV Cas, however, the inclusion of rotation was insufficient to reconcile the observed and theoretical k2k_2 values [227]. Several studies which employ a single value of the CBM parameter for all masses find good agreements between modeled and observed apsidal motion constants within the observational errors (e.g., [228, 229, 230, 231, 232, 233, 234]), while others find the theoretical values to be either larger (e.g., [229, 234, 235, 236, 237]) or smaller (e.g., [230, 238, 239])

than observations. More recent studies rely on model grids where a mass dependent CBM was assumed (see § 4.3.1), and find good agreement between theory and observations [240]. A few studies have tried to optimize the CBM parameters of individual binary components based on the apsidal constant. One such study of 27 double lined eclipsing binaries found good agreement with a predetermined mass dependent overshooting5 The only outlier was the moderately evolved, high mass (M1≈14M⊙M_1 \approx14 M_\odot, M2≈11M⊙M_2 \approx11 M_\odot) system V453 Cyg, where more CBM was favored. This is not the only example of systems requiring higher CBM parameters. The study of the apsidal motion of the high mass binary system V380 Cyg indicated the need for a high overshooting parameter of αov≈0.6±0.1\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} \approx0.6 \pm0.1 for the primary component [242], though the errors on the estimate was later suggested to be larger [243]. Finally, a separate study of two massive, eccentric binary systems in the open cluster NGC 6231 required enhanced internal mixing either from CBM or turbulent diffusion to reconcile the theoretical apsidal constants with the observed values [244].

Mass discrepancy

The mass discrepancy problem is a disagreement between spectroscopically derived stellar masses6 and those obtained from stellar evolution models. This disagreement appears on the HR diagram because stars and their expected evolutionary tracks do not overlap [245, 246]. Derived spectroscopic masses are systematically lower than evolutionary masses (see Figure 10 a)), hinting towards missing or inadequate physics in the standard stellar structure and evolution models used. In stellar binaries, the mass discrepancy is a disagreement between dynamically derived component masses and evolutionary masses from standard models when a common age is enforced (see Figure 10 b)). This problem was first seen for the binary systems SZ Cen [182, 247], BW Aqr [248], and BK Peg [248], where the inclusion of CBM is needed in order to obtain satisfactory fits to the more massive components of the systems. These early studies did not consider a difference in CBM parameters between the components of the systems.

Examples of observed mass discrepancies

Figure 10. Examples of observed mass discrepancies. Better agreement between both MEvolM_{\mathrm{Evol}}-MSpecM_{\mathrm{Spec}} and MEvolM_{\mathrm{Evol}}-MDynM_{\mathrm{Dyn}} is generally found for less evolved stars. a) Observed mass discrepancy between spectroscopic (x-axis) and evolutionary (y-axis) masses derived for a sample of 32 high-mass stars [245, 246]. Similar errors to those for MSpecM_{\mathrm{Spec}} were assumed for MEvolM_{\mathrm{Evol}} for the round data points. b) Observed mass discrepancy between dynamical (x-axis) and evolutionary (y-axis) masses derived for a sample of 11 double-lined eclipsing binaries [77]. Errors on the measurements are typically smaller than the size of the data points. Figure made by the authors using data from Groenewegen et al. [245], Herrero et al. [246], and Tkachenko et al. [77].

Large CBM parameters (primary αov=0.3−0.5\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} = 0.3 - 0.5; secondary αov=0.1−0.4\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} = 0.1 - 0.4) derived from vectors in the mass-luminosity plane were found for the high-mass (M1=39.5M⊙M_1 = 39.5 M_\odot, M2=33.5M⊙M_2 = 33.5 M_\odot) detached eclipsing binary system HD 166734 [22]. These stars are blue supergiants (BSGs), and explaining the population of BSGs is a long standing problem for stellar structure and evolution theory. The area in the HR diagram where the BSGs are found is expected to be scarcely populated due to rapid post-MS stellar evolution, but the opposite is observed [249]. There are two likely explanations for this: 1) the main-sequence is extended compared to standard models and BSGs are core-hydrogen-burning stars, or 2) BSGs are post-MS stars undergoing core helium burning. The mass-luminosity plane inference of high CBM parameters suggests that most blue supergiants (BSGs) are on the main-sequence close to the TAMS [24]. However, the fact that BSGs are slow rotators (vsin⁡i≤50 km s−1v \sin i \leq50\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}}) compared to hotter massive stars with vsin⁡i≤400 km s−1v \sin i \leq400\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} seemingly supports the core helium burning scenario, because rotational velocity should decrease after the main-sequence as the stellar envelope expands [250]. This expansion is tied to the star’s log⁡g\log g value, and Brott et al. Brott et al. [251] used log⁡g\log g values to calibrate the CBM parameter at 16M⊙16 M_\odot, finding αov=0.335\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} = 0.335. However, the drop from vsin⁡i≈400 km s−1v \sin i \approx400\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} to ≤50 km s−1\leq50\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}} coincides with the effective temperature of ≈22000 K\approx22000\ \mathrm{K}, where rotational braking due to enhanced mass-loss may occur [252]. Such braking requires a CBM parameter αov≥0.335\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} \geq0.335 to occur at masses as low as 10M⊙10 M_\odot.

Another binary system which suggests the importance of CBM is V380 Cyg. The primary component’s mass discrepancy is extreme and may be in excess of 10 − 30 % [77,242,253, 254]. One solution to this problem is to use a CBM parameter of αpen=0.6±0.1\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} = 0.6 \pm0.1 for the primary component, with no CBM required to reconcile the less evolved near-ZAMS secondary component [242]. Recent updated component parameters show that a discrepancy also exists for the secondary component, which can be fixed by decreasing the metallicity and increasing the mass of the star within its 3σ3\sigma error [254]. For the primary a mass at the 3σ3\sigma limit combined with a high rotation (vZAMS=241 km s−1v_{\mathrm{ZAMS}} = 241\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1}) and strong level of CBM (αpen=0.6\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} = 0.6) was required to reconcile the evolutionary models with the observations [254]. Another complication is that the primary has high microturbulence velocity (ξ=15 km s−1\xi= 15\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1}), and neglecting this in the spectroscopic analysis causes the effective temperature to be overestimated by ≈1700 K\approx1700\ \mathrm{K} (≈8%\approx8\%)[77]. This would likewise impact the derived TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}} of the secondary both from spectroscopic disentangling and photometric analysis of the light curve. Appropriately accounting for the effect of microturbulence in the spectroscopic analysis in combination with the inclusion of CBM could fully explain the mass-discrepancy of this system. Such an analysis has yet to be carried out.

In comparison to the four binary systems discussed above, excellent fits to the observations were found for the binary systems V792 Her [255], AI Phe [256], and UX Men [257] using standard models without CBM. These systems cover the mass range 1.2−1.5 M⊙1.2 - 1.5\,M_\odot, whereas the more massive components of SZ Cen, BW Aqr, BK Peg, and V380 Cyg have masses between 1.43−11.43 M⊙1.43 - 11.43\,M_{\odot}. These seven systems provide some indication that a mass dependence may exist for CBM.

A search for mass dependent CBM using binary systems

Detached double-lined eclipsing binaries (DDLEB) provide great test beds for stellar structure and evolution models. The component masses, radii, and effective temperatures of DDLEBs can be precisely and accurately measured, and the components can reasonably be assumed to share a common age and composition. The advantage of using DDLEBs over single stars can clearly be seen from a comparison of the errors between panels a and b in Figure 10.

The largest sample of DDLEBs that have been used to investigate the presence of a mass dependence of CBM consists of 50 systems (100 stars) in the mass range of 1.21.2 to 4.4 M⊙4.4\,M_{\odot} [258]. For all of these systems, the masses and radii are known to a 3% accuracy or better, while the effective temperatures are known to a 5% accuracy. An ensemble study of these stars revealed that the extent of the CBM region appears to be steadily increasing with mass from 1.2−2 M⊙1.2 - 2\,M_{\odot} and reaches a plateau that persists up the upper limit of the mass in the sample of 4.4 M⊙4.4\,M_{\odot}, see grey data points in Figure 11. The associated by-eye fit to the data [20] is shown by the solid blue line in Figure 11, while an earlier result by the same authors for a smaller sub-sample of 33 DDLEBs and where convective penetration was used instead of exponential diffusive overshoot is indicated by the orange dotted line [258]. The switch from using convective penetration to exponential diffusive overshoot was mainly a result of a change in the adopted stellar structure and evolution codes, and also allowed for derivation of a relation αpen/fov=11.36±0.22\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}}/f_{\mathrm{ov}} = 11.36 \pm0.22 [76] that could be used to perform a conversion between the two CBM parameters, see also § 2.8. The small offset between the orange dotted and solid blue line in Figure 11 for M>2 M⊙M > 2\,M_{\odot} is caused by differences in the assumed primordial helium abundance [76].

Inferred mass versus CBM obtained for a sample of 50 DDLEBs

Figure 11. Inferred mass versus CBM obtained for a sample of 50 DDLEBs (grey points with errors) [262], compared to different empirical relations available in the literature obtained from modeling different samples of DDLEBs. Conversion factors of αpen/fov=11.36\alpha_{\rm pen}/f_{\rm ov}=11.36 [76] and αpen/αov=1\alpha_{\rm pen}/\alpha_{\rm ov}=1 were assumed for the inclusion of the individual curves in the figure. The plotted range is limited to the mass range of the 50 DDLEBs. Errors of σfov=0.006\sigma_{f_{\rm ov}}=0.006 were assumed for main-sequence stars, while σfov=0.004\sigma_{f_{\rm ov}}=0.004 were used for giants [262]. Figure made by the authors using data from Claret and Torres [262], Claret and Torres [20], Claret and Torres [76], Claret and Torres [258], Claret [261], Ribas et al. [260], and Schroder et al. [259].

One of the first studies of DDLEBs where a mass dependent CBM was investigated relied on a sample of three ζ\zeta Aurigae systems (wide eclipsing binaries where the primary component is a late-type bright giant or supergiant) and three related non-eclipsing binaries also containing an evolved primary component [259]. As indicated in Figure 1, the effects of CBM on evolutionary tracks become more pronounced as stars age, so these systems were suggested as ideal test beds for CBM. The size of the CBM region was found to slightly increase with mass from ≈0.24 Hp,cc\approx0.24\,H_{\mathrm{p,cc}} at 2.5 M⊙2.5\,M_{\odot} to ≈0.32 Hp,cc\approx0.32\,H_{\mathrm{p,cc}} at 6.5 M⊙6.5\,M_{\odot}, see yellow dotted curve in Figure 11. Ribas et al. [260] relied on a sample of eight DDLEBs with masses between 2 and 12 M⊙12\,M_{\odot}, and likewise found an increase in the extent of the CBM region with mass but with a steeper slope for the increase towards higher masses, see black dashed line in Figure 11. This latter result was largely guided by V380 Cyg, which was one out of only two systems in the sample with masses above 3.4 M⊙3.4\,M_{\odot}. Like the studies mentioned above, a large CBM parameter αov≈0.6\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} \approx0.6 was found for this system, whereas a lower αov∼0.2\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} \sim0.2-0.5 was needed for the similar mass system HV 2274. An age dependence of the CBM parameter was suggested as a possible solution to this difference in αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}}. Ribas et al. [260] also used data from prior studies of lower mass stars for the construction of their mass versus CBM relation partly shown by the black dashed line in Figure 11. A similar study with a significant overlap (eight out of 13) in the considered sample of DDLEBs with masses between 1.35 and 27.27 M⊙27.27\,M_{\odot} also arrived at a mass dependent CBM, but with a much shallower slope for stars with masses above ≈2 M⊙\approx2\,M_{\odot} [261], see green dashed-dotted curve in Figure 11. In this case the errors on the derived CBM parameters are large, and the CBM-Mass relation therefore ambiguous.

If BSGs are core-hydrogen-burning stars, their distribution in the HR diagram provides some evidence for a mass-dependent CBM. Castro et al. [21] provided the first observational spectroscopic HR diagram8 of massive stars in the Milky Way, and compared the main-sequence density distributions to non-rotating model grids with two values of the CBM parameter. They find evidence of the CBM increasing from αov=0.1\alpha_{\rm ov}=0.1 at 8 M⊙8\,M_\odot to αov=0.335\alpha_{\rm ov}=0.335 at ≈15 M⊙\approx15\,M_\odot, and larger αov\alpha_{\rm ov} is needed for higher masses. The inclusion of rotation in their models still showed that CBM is required, but mass-dependence is not unambiguous.

Evidence against mass dependent CBM and complications

The detection of a mass dependent CBM relying on ensembles of DDLEBs is not unambiguous and the reliability of the result has been questioned in several cases. Costa et al. [263] studied an earlier sample of 38 out of the 50 DDLEBs mentioned above, using stellar models including both CBM and rotational mixing and applied a Bayesian analysis to investigate the mass dependence of CBM [263]. Due to the wide scatter and large errors on the derived CBM parameters, the authors do not find a clear mass dependence on the CBM but rather identify a wide distribution of valid CBM parameters between ≈0.15−0.4 Hp,cc\approx0.15-0.4\,H_{\rm p,cc} for M>1.9 M⊙M>1.9\,M_\odot, contrary to the constant value shown for the solid blue and dotted orange curves in Figure 11. They suggest that the distribution could be explained using models with a constant CBM parameter αov=0.2\alpha_{\rm ov}=0.2 and initial rotational velocities between 0-80% break-up velocity. Constantino and Baraffe [264] analyzed a different subset of eight representative systems out of the 50 DDLEBs to determine whether or not the derived CBM parameters for each system are unique. They found that the uncertainties on the derived fOVf_{\mathrm{OV}} values are high and a single value of the CBM parameter could be used for the entire mass range of 1.3−3.7 M⊙1.3-3.7\,M_{\odot}. No mass dependence on the CBM was found, but the results did indicate that CBM was needed for M>2 M⊙M > 2\,M_{\odot}. The derived uncertainties may be too pessimistic, as this work did not take into account additional constraints available from including the effective temperatures in the analysis [262]. Uncertainties could be further reduced if more precise effective temperatures and metallicities were obtained [264].

Meng and Zhang [265] considered a sample of four eclipsing binary systems relying on a CBM formalism that did not use the pressure scale height to determine the extent of the CBM region, and found no CBM dependence on the mass in the range 1.21.2 to 2.5 M⊙2.5\,M_{\odot}. Stancliffe et al. [266] also found no CBM dependence on mass or metallicity for their sample of nine eclipsing binaries with M=1.3−6.2 M⊙M = 1.3-6.2\,M_{\odot} using both exponential diffusive overshoot and a nontraditional CBM formalism where an adjustment was made directly to the Schwarzschild criterion based on the ratio between the radiation and gas pressure and a free CBM parameter [266]. A more recent study relied on a sample of 11 DDLEBs with M=4.6−17.1 M⊙M = 4.6-17.1\,M_{\odot} where the fundamental and atmospheric parameters were all derived using the same methodology, in contrast to the ensemble studies mentioned above [77]. No mass dependence on the CBM parameter was found for this sample, but the observed mass discrepancy could be explained by a combination of a need for higher core masses and the lack of proper treatment of microturbulent velocities in the spectroscopic analysis of the stars.

Discussions dating back more than 30 years argue that, in order to constrain helium abundances, opacity tables, mixing length and/or CBM parameters, the binary star parameters must be known to accuracies of at least 1% (for radii), 2% (for mass and temperature), and 25% (for metallicity) [267]. These numbers have been backed up by more recent statistical studies on using binary systems to constrain CBM. Valle et al. [268] argue that systems with masses between 1.11.1 and 1.6 M⊙1.6\,M_{\odot} where both components are on the main-sequence cannot be used to calibrate CBM when the errors on the component masses are appropriately accounted for. The only exception is when the primary is in the last 5% of its main-sequence evolution. This study assumed errors on the effective temperature, metallicity, component masses, and radii of 100 K, 0.1 dex, 1%, and 0.5% respectively. The observed biases and uncertainties are reduced when the errors on observed parameters are reduced. In comparison, a similar statistical analysis using the more evolved binary system TZ Fornacis (Mprimary=2.057±0.001 M⊙M_{\mathrm{primary}} = 2.057 \pm0.001\,M_{\odot}, Msecondary=1.958±0.001 M⊙M_{\mathrm{secondary}} = 1.958 \pm0.001\,M_{\odot}) found that good constraints on CBM could be obtained, owing to the low errors on the component masses [269]. Biases were also found from a subsequent statistical analysis assuming a M=2.50 M⊙M = 2.50\,M_{\odot} primary star in three different post-main-sequence evolutionary stages and a M=2.38 M⊙M = 2.38\,M_{\odot} secondary [270]. However, differentiating between cases of no and mild CBM is generally pointless unless the primary is undergoing central helium burning. For the 50 DDLEBs in Figure 11, 59% of the component masses are known to better than a 1% accuracy, while for 20% and 2% of the stars the masses are known to a 0.5% and 0.1% accuracy, respectively. The errors on the component masses were not taken into account when deriving the CBM parameters for the 50 DDLEBs in Figure 11, but the metallicity was allowed to vary within the observed errors [20, 76, 262].

The results of the statistical analyses mentioned above seem backed up by earlier attempts at studying CBM using 49 DDLEBs, which found that both models with and without CBM provide satisfactory fits to the observations of 80% of the systems, but models with CBM provide better fits for systems with components in the post-main-sequence stage of stellar evolution [271]. This once again points towards the complications arising from using main-sequence DDLEBs to constrain CBM.

Finally, all of the studies discussed above have been done under the same assumption that the evolution of the binary systems can be treated as the evolution of two single stars without accounting for impacts from binary interactions on the stellar models. Such an assumption has been shown to be reasonable for the evolution of well-detached preinteraction binary systems at least when rotational mixing in single versus binary stars is considered [e.g. 272]. For detached, short-period binaries with strong tidal interactions, some studies suggest an enhanced rotation mixing in the presence of strong dynamical tides [273]. Others suggest that the effects of tides are limited in detached systems [272, 274], while another recent study indicate that internal mixing is less efficient in detached binary systems than for single stars [275].

Asteroseismology

Asteroseismology is the study and interpretation of stellar pulsations, and provides a powerful tool for studying stellar interiors. The pulsations are observed as variations in the surface brightness of the stars and extend deep into the stellar interiors, thereby carrying information about the conditions within. Modifications to the interior structure result in changes to the expected oscillation frequencies, and confronting predicted oscillation frequencies with observations in a process known as asteroseismic modeling provides important constraints on stellar structure and evolution theory. Such constraints have especially been made possible in the past couple of decades since the advent of space telescopes including WIRE (e.g., [288]), MOST [289], CoRoT [290, 291], Kepler [292, 293], K2 [294], BRITE [295], and TESS [296], which provide high-precision, high-cadence, and long time base-line photometric light curves. This high-quality data resulted in a drastic increase in the number of detected oscillation frequencies in stars all across the HR diagram and provided the high frequency resolution needed for mode identification required for asteroseismic modeling. Several review papers and books on asteroseismology already exist (e.g., [297, 298, 299, 300, 301, 302, 303, 304, 305], and references therein). Therefore, we refer to these papers for details on different types of pulsators, analysis methods, new discoveries, and procedures for asteroseismic modeling, and focus here on the inferences made on the CBM from asteroseismic studies of both single and binary stars.

Onset of the convective core

One avenue to place constraints on CBM is studying stars in the mass regime where the transition between radiative to convective cores is expected to occur (≈1.1 M⊙\approx1.1\,M_{\odot}). In this regime we find the solar-like oscillators that oscillate in pressure (pp) modes. These oscillations are an excellent probe of the convective core size, because they are modified by the presence of acoustic glitches in the sound speed profile caused by the sharp chemical gradient at the convective boundary [306, 307, 308, 309]. As an example, a convective core with either little or a moderate amount of overshooting was found for the 1.18±0.04 M⊙1.18 \pm0.04\,M_{\odot} star KIC 12009504 whereas no convective core could unambiguously be found for KIC 6106415 (1.11±0.04 M⊙1.11 \pm0.04\,M_{\odot}) [310]. Another example is HD 203608 (0.94±0.09 M⊙0.94 \pm0.09\,M_{\odot}), for which models with convective cores agree better with the observations than models without [311].

Stars like the Sun arrive at the zero-age main-sequence (ZAMS) with a small convective core, which quickly disappears during the main-sequence evolution. The presence of the convective core is caused by an excess of 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He} and 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} at the ZAMS, which are transformed to 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} and 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} through highly exothermic nuclear burning capable of sustaining a convective core [312]. The inclusion of CBM extends the lifetime of the convective cores [312], possibly even until the end of the main-sequence if sufficiently high CBM parameters are considered [313] (see also Roxburgh [312] for a detailed discussion). For HD 203608, such overshooting (αov=0.17±0.03\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} = 0.17 \pm0.03) allows the convective core to survive until the present age of the star [311]. For this particular star, the convective core would have disappeared at an age of 200 Myr without CBM, whereas it is expected to survive until ≈7\approx7 Gyr with overshooting. Stars of similar masses where no convective cores are found are of equal interest as they provide an upper limit for the extent of the CBM region.

Extent of the CBM region across the main-sequence

To compare asteroseismic inferences on CBM to the results presented in Figure 11 for the study of binary stars, we compiled a sample of pulsating main-sequence stars for which a mass and CBM parameter has been derived asteroseismically. This full sample is shown in panel a of Figure 12, including also three of the CBM–mass relations from Figure 11 for reference. The asteroseismic CBM parameters were all converted to αpen\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} assuming αpen≈αov\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} \approx\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} and αpen≈11.36fov\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} \approx11.36 f_{\mathrm{ov}}. The lack of measurements between ≈2\approx2 and ≈3M⊙\approx3 M_{\odot} corresponds to the gap between the δ\delta Sct and SPB instability strips. For 13 stars in this sample only a lower (upright triangle) and upper (inverted triangle) limit on the CBM are available. Nine of the 13 stars are located in the open cluster NGC 6910 [314]. As seen in panel a, there is a general trend of increasing CBM parameter with increasing stellar mass for stars with M≲2.5M⊙M \lesssim2.5 M_{\odot}, however, the scatter is larger and the CBM parameters generally higher than the values found for the sample of 50 DDLEB in Figure 11. For the higher mass stars, a wide range in CBM parameters are found with no clear dependence on stellar mass and inconsistent with a single value of the CBM parameter as previously found for the DDLEBs. We note that for a few of the stars, no CBM was needed to match the models to the observations.

Asteroseismically derived CBM parameters for pulsating main-sequence stars

Figure 12. Asteroseismically derived CBM parameters available in the literature for 154 pulsating main-sequence stars. Panel a displays the results from all studies we identified in the literature [19, 20, 65, 73, 75, 259, 260, 310, 311, 314, 315, 316, 317, 318, 319, 320, 321, 322, 323, 324, 325, 326, 327, 328, 329, 330, 331, 332, 333, 334, 335, 336, 337, 338, 339, 340]. Panels b-d show sub-samples of the stars from panel a, where an ensemble study was carried out using the same stellar structure and evolution code and modeling methodology [73, 315, 316, 317]. In panel f only M≥3 M⊙M \geq3\,M_{\odot} stars from panel a with a known Xc/XiniX_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}} value are shown. For stars without estimated errors on the initial mass and CBM parameter, we adopt the average fractional errors from the sample with error estimates. To combine the data from all sources in panel a and f we assumed αov≈αpen\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} \approx\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}} and 11.36fov≈αpen11.36 f_{\mathrm{ov}} \approx\alpha_{\mathrm{pen}}. Figure made by the authors.

The CBM parameters shown in Figure 12 were derived using a variety of different stellar structure and evolution codes and different 1D prescriptions for the CBM. As discussed in § 2.7 and § 2.8, making direct comparisons and conversions between CBM parameters obtained from different sources is non-trivial. For this reason, we show in panels b-e four different subsamples of the stars in panel a where a consistent stellar structure and evolution code and modeling methodology was applied to each sample. The data are color-coded according to the age of the stars either measured in Gyrs or taken as the ratio between the current and initial core hydrogen mass fraction Xc/XiniX_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}}. In panel f, we show all stars with M≥3M⊙M \geq3 M_{\odot} for which an estimate of Xc/XiniX_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}} is available irrespective of the adopted code and modeling procedure. As the main-sequence lifetime is largely dependent on both the initial stellar mass and internal mixing properties of the stars, Xc/XiniX_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}} provides a much better age indicator when doing comparison studies [341]. For this high-mass sample, we expect the differences in CBM prescription to be largely insignificant (cf. § 2.7).

Panels b and c of Figure 12 show two different ensemble studies of solar-like oscillating stars, which both indicate an increase in the CBM parameter with mass albeit at different levels. For both samples, the derived CBM parameters are higher than the relation derived by Claret & Torres [20] from DDLEBs. The sample in panel b was modeled using the Cesam2k code both with (open squares) and without (filled circles) microscopic diffusion, indicating that less CBM is needed to explain the observations if microscopic diffusion is taken into account [315]. This is in line with previous results from the open cluster M67 [192, 193]. In comparison, the sample in panel c was modeled using the YREC code, using the concept of an effective overshoot parameter which accounts for the automatic adjustment of the size of the CBM region to avoid nonsensical core sizes [73]. A similar study also derived the effective overshoot parameters for a sample of solar-like oscillators, finding the current effective overshoot parameter to be zero up to ≈1.1M⊙\approx1.1 M_{\odot} above which a scatter in the effective αov\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} values appears and increases towards higher masses [342].

Both of the samples of pulsating stars in panels d and e were modeled using different versions of the MESA code and using machine learning algorithms to derive the stellar parameters from the observed oscillation properties of the stars. For the sample of solar-like stars in panel d, the majority of the stars show an increase in CBM parameter with mass and generally higher CBM parameters than the relation predicted by Claret & Torres [20]. For the sample of

γ\gamma Dor stars in panel e), no clear mass dependence is found. However, the errors on the CBM parameter are large and span the entire parameter range considered [317]. This is likely caused by the inability of the neural network to capture the fine details of the pulsation properties of the models which are important for constraining this parameter.

The final panel f of Figure 12 focuses on the M≥3M⊙M \ge3M_{\odot} stars in the sample where a common Xc/XiniX_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{ini}} age indicator is available. For 26 of the stars shown here an ensemble study was carried out, whereas the remaining stars were studied individually. As already mentioned earlier, a much larger scatter in the CBM parameter is seen here with no indication that a single parameter fits all of the stars. No clear dependence on age is seen either. One possible explanation for the observed scatter is that additional interior physical processes are influencing the measured and required CBM. As an example, envelope mixing arising from, e.g., internal rotation has a similar effect in bringing additional hydrogen to the core and can therefore enhance the effective core size. This gives rise to some degeneracies between the CBM and envelope mixing, which can be difficult to disentangle. On the other hand, internal magnetic fields can inhibit CBM. As an example, the low amount of overshooting (fov=0.004−0.002+0.012f_{\mathrm{ov}} = 0.004^{+0.012}_{-0.002}) found for the pulsating magnetic B-type star HD 43317 suggests that the magnetic fields of the star might be suppressing the mixing near the core boundary [331]. The lack of observed high-radial order gravity (g) modes suggests that a near-core magnetic field of at least 500 kG is suppressing these modes in the star [343]. Prior to these results, the asteroseismic modeling of the magnetic β\beta Cep star V2052 Ophiuchi revealed a lower overshoot parameter (αov=0.07−0.07+0.08\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} = 0.07^{+0.08}_{-0.07}, [325]) compared to its similar mass β\beta Cep counterpart θ\theta Ophiuchi (αov=0.44±0.07\alpha_{\mathrm{ov}} = 0.44 \pm0.07, [321]), indicating that magnetic fields are likely inhibiting the CBM for this star as well. For the lower mass (M=2.4M⊙M = 2.4M_{\odot}) magnetic pulsating Ap star, a CBM parameter of fov=0.014f_{\mathrm{ov}} = 0.014 was found [333] with no clear indication of inhibition of the CBM by the magnetic fields of the star.

Differentiating between different CBM prescriptions

Gravity mode oscillators are of particular interest for studying CBM, as g modes have their main probing power in the near core regions of the stars. SPB stars (3−10M⊙3 - 10M_{\odot}, g-modes) have been shown to be capable of distinguishing not only between different shapes of DCBM(r)D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) profiles [64, 344] but also between different choices of temperature gradients in the CBM region [64]. A higher frequency precision corresponding to longer light curves (>1>1 yr) are needed to distinguish between different shapes of the mixing profiles compared to between radiative and adiabatic temperature gradients (>90>90 d) [64]. Oscillations in β\beta Cep variables (10−25M⊙10 - 25M_{\odot}, p- and g-modes) can also distinguish between different CBM profiles and temperature gradients, but require the mass of the star to be known to at least 1% precision. Similar theoretical studies have not been carried out for γ\gamma Dor (g-modes) or δ\delta Sct (p-modes) stars, while it was found for solar-like oscillators that their p-modes could not be used to differentiate between exponential diffusive overshoot and step overshoot [315].

So far asteroseismic inferences on the shape of DCBM(r)D_{\mathrm{CBM}}(r) and choice of ∇T\nabla_T have only been attempted in a few cases, with the majority of studies focusing on estimating “just” the extent of the CBM region as discussed in the previous section. KIC 10526294 and KIC 7760680 are the first two SPB stars where a comparison between results assuming a step and exponential diffusive overshoot prescription was made [75, 327]. For both stars it was found that models with exponential diffusive overshoot provide better matches to the observed period spacing pattern compared to models with step overshoot. In a subsequent study of KIC 7760680, the CBM profile was fixed to that of an extended convective penetration while the temperature gradient was varied between a purely radiative gradient and one gradually changing from adiabatic to radiative based on the Peclet number (see § 2.6) [65]. For this star, a radiative temperature gradient in the CBM region was preferred. However, it was also found that models without CBM were statistically preferred over models including CBM when the number of additional free parameters was taken into account. A comparison between step and exponential overshoot was briefly made for the SPB star KIC 8264293. The difference between the two was found to be minor, likely because the star is near the ZAMS and thereby lacks a significant chemical gradient at the core boundary, and the more extensive asteroseismic modeling of the star focused only on the exponential diffusive overshoot [340]. Finally, an ensemble asteroseismic study of 26 SPB stars revealed that 54.9% of the stars preferred convective penetration, whereas for 45.1% the exponential diffusive overshoot prescription did better at reproducing the observed period spacing pattern [19, 338].

Discussion & Future Work

In this review, we provided an overview of convective boundary mixing (CBM) in the main sequence stars. We discussed the most frequently-used prescriptions for including CBM in 1D stellar evolution models. We described CBM from a hydrodynamics perspective, with an emphasis on lessons learned from simulations. We provided an overview of the observations that are at odds with “standard” 1D models, and showed how excess (often mass-dependent) mixing can better align models and observations.

Despite great progress in recent years, there remains plenty of work to do before a complete understanding of CBM will be achieved. In particular, most CBM processes described hydrodynamically and in simulations still lack robust parameterizations in 1D models. We encourage 1D modelers and 3D numericists to forge partnerships to derive, test, and apply new simulation-based prescriptions. We note in particular that there is a great deal of degeneracy in the language which is used to describe CBM processes in the literature (e.g., “overshoot” and “penetration” are often used interchangeably), and our community must adopt language which clearly differentiates between the various physical mechanisms at work. Below, we enumerate suggestions for future work and recommendations for future experiments which we believe will help to sort out the decades-old problem of CBM in stellar evolution.

From the perspective of 1D modeling and applying those models to observations, we have the following suggestions:

  1. First and foremost, it is valuable to “grow the catalogue” of CBM observations. More observational constraints will allow us to not only test and verify new models but also may allow us to understand how complications such as e.g., rotation affect CBM.

  2. A uniform analysis of past observations using a consistent stellar structure and boundary mixing scheme should be performed.

  3. To ease comparisons in future work, authors should clearly state which quantities their CBM prescriptions mix. Specifically, does CBM adjust ∇T\nabla_{\mathrm{T}} or not?

  4. Evidence for extended convective penetration (§ 2.6) is seen in hydrodynamical simulations, and this prescription should be included in more stellar structure codes and models.

  5. In main sequence intermediate- to high-mass stars, the mass and radius of the convective core should be clearly reported along with the mass and size of the CBM region. Whether the reported convective core mass does or does not include the mass in the CBM region should also be specified. This circumvents difficulties associated with making comparisons between codes using different CBM prescriptions and methods of limiting the size of the CBM region.

  6. When reporting ages of stars on the main sequence, also report a quantity such as the core hydrogen fraction Xc/XinitX_{\mathrm{c}}/X_{\mathrm{init}} for easier comparison across works.

We also recommend that the following experiments be performed and prescriptions be derived from 3D hydrodynamical simulations:

  1. Whenever possible, 3D hydrodynamical simulations should strive to provide prescriptions that do not have free parameters but instead rely on stellar structure.

  1. For example, overshoot depth and turbulent diffusive mixing profiles, should be carefully calibrated and parameterized so that overshoot can be evaluated as a function of stellar structure rather than a specified fovf_{\mathrm{ov}}.

  1. 1D prescriptions derived from 3D simulation data should be validated using the same initial conditions employed in the 3D simulations. If the 1D prescription produces a different result from the 3D data, this should be explored in detail.

  1. Simulations probing the thermal structure near a convective boundary should be evolved until thermal equilibrium is achieved. Performing short simulations which are initialized with CBM regions of various sizes can however qualitatively answer the question, “which way does the convective boundary move?”

  1. It is not clear how to properly parameterize dissipation, but dissipation sets the size of a convective penetration region. Future studies should answer the following: what sets the magnitude of the viscous dissipation? How does rotation affect it? How does magnetism and the presence of Ohmic dissipation affect it?

  1. Entrainment is important when convective regions are first forming, or when the convective luminosity or nuclear burning change rapidly compared to the convective overturn timescale. These evolutionary stages should be modeled by time-dependent convection (TDC) prescriptions [153]. Future work should test whether TDC models reproduce the entrainment rates at convective boundaries observed in simulations, and TDC models should be improved where they disagree with simulations.

A long-standing problem for stellar modelers and observers is the uncertainty that convective boundary mixing introduces into 1D stellar models. The uncertainties associated with CBM not only affect studies focused on stars, but also ripple through other astrophysical disciplines which depend on state-of-the-art stellar models. Great strides have been made in the past few decades in understanding CBM both from observations, 1D, and 3D simulations. By combining the efforts of these often disparate lines of work, we can create and validate new mixing prescriptions and solve this long-lived problem.

Author Contributions: E.H.A and M.G.P. contributed equally in all aspects to this manuscript and have read & agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding: E.H.A. was supported by a CIERA Postdoctoral Fellowship. This research was supported in part by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. NSF PHY-1748958 as well as through the TESS Guest Investigator program Cycle 4 under Grant No. 80NSSC22K0743 from NASA and by the Professor Harry Messel Research Fellowship in Physics Endowment, at the University of Sydney (M.G.P.).

Data Availability Statement: Inlists used to generate MESA stellar models in this work and data plotted in original figures are available online in the supplementary materials Zenodo [33].

Acknowledgments: EHA thanks Adam Jermyn, Daniel Leconet, Benjamin Brown, Jeffrey Oishi, Adrian Fraser, and Rafa Fuentes for years of discussions on topics related to CBM. We thank Raphael Hirschi, Casey Meakin, Federico Rizzuti, and Tami Rogers for allowing us to reproduce figures from their past work. We also thank Jorick Vink, Dominic Bowman, and Jennifer van Saders for inviting and organizing us in writing this review. We are grateful to the participants of KITP’s “Probes of Transport in Stars” program from Fall 2021, where we had many useful discussions regarding CBM.

Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest. The funders had no role in the design of the study; in the collection, analyses, or interpretation of data; in the writing of the manuscript; or in the decision to publish the results.

Abbreviations

The following abbreviations are used in this manuscript:

BSGBlue supergiant
CBMConvective Boundary Mixing
CZConvection Zone
DDLEBDetached double-lined eclipsing binary
eMSTOextended main-sequence turn-off
LHSLeft-hand side
RHSRight-hand side
RZRadiative Zone
PZPenetrative Zone
TAMSTerminal age main sequence
ZAMSzero-age main sequence

Table 1.

References

  1. [1]Böhm-Vitense, E. Über die Wasserstoffkonvektionszone in Sternen verschiedener Effektivtemperaturen und Leuchtkräfte. Mit 5 Textabbildungen. Zeitschrift für Astrophysik 1958, 46, 108.
  2. [2]Anders, E.H.; Jermyn, A.S.; Lecoeanet, D.; Fraser, A.E.; Cresswell, I.G.; Joyce, M.; Fuentes, J.R. Schwarzschild and Ledoux are Equivalent on Evolutionary Timescales. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 2022, 928, L10, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2203.06186]. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/ac5cb5.
  3. [3]Chabrier, G.; Baraffe, I. Structure and evolution of low-mass stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1997, 327, 1039–1053, [arXiv:astro-ph/9704118].arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9704118
  4. [4]Chabrier, G.; Baraffe, I. Theory of Low-Mass Stars and Substellar Objects. Annual Review of Astronomy & Astrophysics 2000, 38, 337–377, [arXiv:astro-ph/0006383]. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.astro.38.1.337.
  5. [5]Jermyn, A.S.; Anders, E.H.; Lecoeanet, D.; Cantiello, M. An Atlas of Convection in Main-sequence Stars. The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 2022, 262, 19, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2206.00011]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4365/ac7cee.
  6. [6]Pinsonneault, M. Mixing in Stars. Annual Review of Astronomy & Astrophysics 1997, 35, 557–605. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.astro.35.1.557.
  7. [7]Carlos, M.; Meléndez, J.; Spina, L.; dos Santos, L.A.; Bedell, M.; Ramirez, I.; Asplund, M.; Bean, J.L.; Yong, D.; Yana Galarza, J.; et al. The Li-age correlation: the Sun is unusually Li deficient for its age. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2019, 485, 4052–4059, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1903.02735]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz681.
  8. [8]Dumont, T.; Palacios, A.; Charbonnel, C.; Richard, O.; Amard, L.; Augustson, K.; Mathis, S. Lithium depletion and angular momentum transport in solar-type stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2021, 646, A48, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2012.03647]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202039515.
  9. [9]Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.; Monteiro, M.J.P.F.G.; Rempel, M.; Thompson, M.J. A more realistic representation of overshoot at the base of the solar convective envelope as seen by helioseismology. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2011, 414, 1158–1174, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1102.0235]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.18460.x.
  10. [10]Bergemann, M.; Serenelli, A. Solar Abundance Problem. In Determination of Atmospheric Parameters of B; 2014; pp. 245–258. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-06956-2_21.
  11. [11]Basu, S. Global seismology of the Sun. Living Reviews in Solar Physics 2016, 13, 2, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1606.07071]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41116-016-0003-4.
  12. [12]Hansen, C.J.; Kawaler, S.D.; Trimble, V. Stellar interiors : physical principles, structure, and evolution; Springer, 2004.
  13. [13]Cantiello, M.; Braithwaite, J. Envelope Convection, Surface Magnetism, and Spots in A and Late B-type Stars. The Astrophysical Journal 2019, 883, 106, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1904.02161]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab3924.
  14. [14]Jermyn, A.S.; Anders, E.H.; Cantiello, M. Centrifugal Wind in A-type Stellar Variability. The Astrophysical Journal 2022, 926, 94, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2201.10567]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ac4e89.
  15. [15]Johnston, C. One size does not fit all: Evidence for a range of mixing efficiencies in stellar evolution calculations. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2021, 655, A29, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2107.09075]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202141080.
  16. [16]Kaiser, E.A.; Hirschi, R.; Arnett, W.D.; Georgy, C.; Scott, L.J.A.; Cristini, A. Relative importance of convective uncertainties in massive stars. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2020, 496, 1967–1989, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2006.01877]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staa1595.
  17. [17]Schootemeijer, A.; Langer, N.; Grin, N.J.; Wang, C. Constraining mixing in massive stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2019, 625, A132, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1903.10423]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201935046.
  18. [18]Farrell, E.J.; Groh, J.H.; Meynet, G.; Eldridge, J.J.; Ekström, S.; Georgy, C. SNAPSHOT: connections between internal and surface properties of massive stars. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2020, 495, 4659–4680, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2005.06454]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staa1360.
  19. [19]Pedersen, M.G.; Aerts, C.; Pápics, P.I.; Michielsen, M.; Gebruers, S.; Rogers, T.M.; Molenberghs, G.; Burssens, S.; Garcia, S.; Bowman, D.M. Internal mixing of rotating stars inferred from dipole gravity modes. Nature Astronomy 2021, 5, 715–722, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2105.04533]. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41550-021-01351-x.
  20. [20]Claret, A.; Torres, G. The Dependence of Convective Core Overshooting on Stellar Mass: Additional Binary Systems and Improved Calibration. The Astrophysical Journal 2018, 859, 100, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1804.03148]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aabd35.
  21. [21]Castro, N.; Fossati, L.; Langer, N.; Simón-Díaz, S.; Schneider, F.R.N.; Izzard, R.G. The spectroscopic Hertzsprung-Russell diagram of Galactic massive stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2014, 570, L13, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1410.3499]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201425028.
  22. [22]Higgins, E.R.; Vink, J.S. Massive star evolution: rotation, winds, and overshooting vectors in the mass-luminosity plane. I. A calibrated grid of rotating single star models. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2019, 622, A50, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1811.12190]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201831423.
  23. [23]Martinet, S.; Meynet, G.; Ekström, S.; Simón-Díaz, S.; Holgado, G.; Castro, N.; Georgy, C.; Eggenberger, P.; Buldgen, G.; Salmon, S.; et al. Convective core sizes in rotating massive stars. I. Constraints from solar metallicity OB field stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2021, 648, A126, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2103.03672]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202039426.
  24. [24]Higgins, E.R.; Vink, J.S. Stellar age determination in the mass-luminosity plane. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2023, 518, 1158–1169, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2210.13480]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stac3141.
  25. [25]Meakin, C.A.; Arnett, D. Turbulent Convection in Stellar Interiors. I. Hydrodynamic Simulation. The Astrophysical Journal 2007, 667, 448–475, [arXiv:astro-ph/0611315]. https://doi.org/10.1086/520318.
  26. [26]Gilet, C.; Almgren, A.S.; Bell, J.B.; Nonaka, A.; Woosley, S.E.; Zingale, M. Low Mach Number Modeling of Core Convection in Massive Stars. The Astrophysical Journal 2013, 773, 137. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/773/2/137.
  27. [27]Cristini, A.; Meakin, C.; Hirschi, R.; Arnett, D.; Georgy, C.; Viallet, M.; Walkington, I. 3D hydrodynamic simulations of carbon burning in massive stars. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2017, 471, 279–300, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1610.05173]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stx1535.
  28. [28]Jones, S.; Andrassy, R.; Sandalski, S.; Davis, A.; Woodward, P.; Herwig, F. Idealized hydrodynamic simulations of turbulent oxygen-burning shell convection in 4π geometry. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2017, 465, 2991–3010, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1605.03766]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw2783.
  29. [29]Andrassy, R.; Herwig, F.; Woodward, P.; Ritter, C. 3D hydrodynamic simulations of C ingestion into a convective O shell. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2020, 491, 972–992, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1808.04014]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz2952.
  30. [30]Higl, J.; Müller, E.; Weiss, A. Calibrating core overshooting parameters with two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2021, 646, A133, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2012.05262]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202039532.
  31. [31]Rizzuti, F.; Hirschi, R.; Georgy, C.; Arnett, W.D.; Meakin, C.; Murphy, A.S. Realistic 3D hydrodynamics simulations find significant turbulent entrainment in massive stars. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2022, 515, 4013–4019, [arXiv:astro-ph/2207.03223]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stac1981.
  32. [32]Brandenburg, A.; Svedin, A.; Vasil, G.M. Turbulent diffusion with rotation or magnetic fields. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2009, 395, 1599–1606, [https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article-pdf/395/3/1599/18227249/mnras0395-1599.pdf]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.14646.x.
  33. [33]Anders, E.H.; Pedersen, M.G. Supplemental Materials for "Convective boundary mixing in main-sequence stars: theory and empirical constraints", 2023. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7735067.
  34. [34]Paxton, B.; Schwab, J.; Bauer, E.B.; Bildsten, L.; Blinnikov, S.; Duffell, P.; Farmer, R.; Goldberg, J.A.; Marchant, P.; Sorokina, E.; et al. Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Convective Boundaries, Element Diffusion, and Massive Star Explosions. The Astrophysical Journal Supplemental Series 2018, 234, 34, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1710.08424]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4365/aaa5a8.
  35. [35]Garaud, P. Double-Diffusive Convection at Low Prandtl Number. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 2018, 50, 275–298. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-fluid-122316-045234.
  36. [36]Salaris, M.; Cassisi, S. Chemical element transport in stellar evolution models. Royal Society Open Science 2017, 4, 170192, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1707.07454]. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.170192.
  37. [37]Georgy, C.; Saio, H.; Meynet, G. Blue supergiants as tests for stellar physics. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2021, 650, A128, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2104.06278]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202040105.
  38. [38]Gabriel, M.; Noels, A.; Montalbán, J.; Miglio, A. Proper use of Schwarzschild Ledoux criteria in stellar evolution computations. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2014, 569, A63, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1405.0128]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201423442.
  39. [39]Zahn, J.P. Convective penetration in stellar interiors. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1991, 252, 179–188.
  40. [40]Woo, J.H.; Demarque, P. Empirical Constraints on Convective Core Overshoot. The Astronomical Journal 2001, 122, 1602–1606, [arXiv:astro-ph/0106061]. https://doi.org/10.1086/322122.
  41. [41]Freytag, B.; Ludwig, H.G.; Steffen, M. Hydrodynamical models of stellar convection. The role of overshoot in DA white dwarfs, A-type stars, and the Sun. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1996, 313, 497–516.
  42. [42]Herwig, F. The evolution of AGB stars with convective overshoot. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2000, 360, 952–968. [arXiv:astro-ph/astro-ph/0007139].DOI
  43. [43]Weiss, A.; Schlattl, H. GARSTEC—the Garching Stellar Evolution Code. The direct descendant of the legendary Kippenhahn code. Astrophysics and Space Science 2008, 316, 99–106. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10509-007-9606-5.
  44. [44]Paxton, B.; Bildsten, L.; Dotter, A.; Herwig, F.; Lessa, P.; Timmes, F. Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA). The Astrophysical Journal Supplemental Series 2011, 192, 3, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1009.1622]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0067-0049/192/1/3.
  45. [45]Paxton, B.; Cantiello, M.; Arras, P.; Bildsten, L.; Brown, E.F.; Dotter, A.; Mankovich, C.; Montgomery, M.H.; Stello, D.; Timmes, F.X.; et al. Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars. The Astrophysical Journal Supplemental Series 2013, 208, 4, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1301.0319]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0067-0049/208/1/4.
  46. [46]Paxton, B.; Marchant, P.; Schwab, J.; Bauer, E.B.; Bildsten, L.; Cantiello, M.; Dessart, L.; Farmer, R.; Hu, H.; Langer, N.; et al. Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Binaries, Pulsations, and Explosions. The Astrophysical Journal Supplemental Series 2015, 220, 15, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1506.03146]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0067-0049/220/1/15.
  47. [47]Paxton, B.; Smolec, R.; Schwab, J.; Gautschy, A.; Bildsten, L.; Cantiello, M.; Dotter, A.; Farmer, R.; Goldberg, J.A.; Jermyn, A.S.; et al. Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Pulsating Variable Stars, Rotation, Convective Boundaries, and Energy Conservation. The Astrophysical Journal Supplemental Series 2019, 243, 10, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1903.01426]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4365/ab2241.
  48. [48]Roxburgh, I.W. A note on the boundary of convective zones in stars. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1965, 130, 223. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/130.3.223.
  49. [49]Prather, M.J.; Demarque, P. Convective Overshoot Mixing in Old Open Clusters . The Astrophysical Journal 1974, 193, 109–112. https://doi.org/10.1086/153134.
  50. [50]Dotter, A.; Chaboyer, B.; Jevremović, D.; Baron, E.; Ferguson, J.W.; Sarajedini, A.; Anderson, J. The ACS Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters. II. Stellar Evolution Tracks, Isochrones, Luminosity Functions, and Synthetic Horizontal-Branch Models. The Astronomical Journal 2007, 134, 376–390, [arXiv:astro-ph/0706.0847]. https://doi.org/10.1086/517915.
  51. [51]Dotter, A.; Chaboyer, B.; Jevremović, D.; Kostov, V.; Baron, E.; Ferguson, J.W. The Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Database. The Astrophysical Journal Supplemental Series 2008, 178, 89–101, [arXiv:astro-ph/0804.4473]. https://doi.org/10.1086/589654.
  52. [52]Cassisi, S.; Salaris, M. A critical investigation on the discrepancy between the observational and the theoretical red giant luminosity function ‘bump’. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1997, 285, 593–603, [arXiv:astro-ph/astro-ph/9702029]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/285.3.593.
  53. [53]Salaris, M.; Cassisi, S. A new analysis of the red giant branch ‘tip’ distance scale and the value of the Hubble constant. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1998, 298, 166–178, [arXiv:astro-ph/9803103]. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-8711.1998.01598.x.
  54. [54]Pietrinferni, A.; Cassisi, S.; Salaris, M.; Castelli, F. A Large Stellar Evolution Database for Population Synthesis Studies. I. Scaled Solar Models and Isochrones. The Astrophysical Journal 2004, 612, 168–190, [arXiv:astro-ph/0405193]. https://doi.org/10.1086/42498.
  55. [55]Pietrinferni, A.; Cassisi, S.; Salaris, M.; Castelli, F. A Large Stellar Evolution Database for Population Synthesis Studies. II. Stellar Models and Isochrones for an α-enhanced Metal Distribution. The Astrophysical Journal 2006, 642, 797–812, [arXiv:astro-ph/0603721]. https://doi.org/10.1086/501344.
  56. [56]Cordier, D.; Pietrinferni, A.; Cassisi, S.; Salaris, M. A Large Stellar Evolution Database for Population Synthesis Studies. III. Inclusion of the Full Asymptotic Giant Branch Phase and Web Tools for Stellar Population Analyses. The Astronomical Journal 2007, 133, 468–478, [arXiv:astro-ph/0612669]. https://doi.org/10.1086/509870.
  57. [57]Percival, S.M.; Salaris, M.; Cassisi, S.; Pietrinferni, A. A Large Stellar Evolution Database for Population Synthesis Studies. IV. Integrated Properties and Spectra. The Astrophysical Journal 2009, 690, 427–439, [arXiv:astro-ph/0809.0265]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/690/1/427.
  58. [58]Pietrinferni, A.; Cassisi, S.; Salaris, M.; Percival, S.; Ferguson, J.W. A Large Stellar Evolution Database for Population Synthesis Studies. V. Stellar Models and Isochrones with CNO Abundance Anticorrelations. The Astrophysical Journal 2009, 697, 275–282, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/0903.0825]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/697/1/275.
  59. [59]Hui-Bon-Hoa, A. The Toulouse Geneva Evolution Code (TGEC). Astrophysics and Space Science 2008, 316, 55–60. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10509-007-9605-6.
  60. [60]Théado, S.; Alecian, G.; LeBlanc, F.; Vauclair, S. The new Toulouse-Geneva stellar evolution code including radiative accelerations of heavy elements. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2012, 546, A100, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1210.4360]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201219610.
  61. [61]Demarque, P.; Guenther, D.B.; Li, L.H.; Mazumdar, A.; Straka, C.W. YREC: the Yale rotating stellar evolution code. Non-rotating version, seismology applications. Astrophysics and Space Science 2008, 316, 31–41, [arXiv:astro-ph/0710.4003]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10509-007-9698-y.
  62. [62]Eggenberger, P.; Meynet, G.; Maeder, A.; Hirschi, R.; Charbonnel, C.; Talon, S.; Ekström, S. The Geneva stellar evolution code. Astrophysics and Space Science 2008, 316, 43–54. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10509-007-9511-y.
  63. [63]Viallet, M.; Meakin, C.; Prat, V.; Arnett, D. Toward a consistent use of overshooting parametrizations in 1D stellar evolution codes. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2015, 580, A61, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1506.03100]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201526294.
  64. [64]Michielsen, M.; Pedersen, M.G.; Augustson, K.C.; Mathis, S.; Aerts, C. Probing the shape of the mixing profile and of the thermal structure at the convective core boundary through asteroseismology. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2019, 628, A76, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1906.05304]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201935754.
  65. [65]Michielsen, M.; Aerts, C.; Bowman, D.M. Probing the temperature gradient in the core boundary layer of stars with gravito-inertial modes. The case of KIC 7760680. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2021, 650, A175, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2104.04531]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202039926.
  66. [66]Christensen-Dalsgaard, J. ASTEC—the Aarhus Stellar Evolution Code. Astrophysics and Space Science 2008, 316, 13–24, [arXiv:astro-ph/0710.3114]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10509-007-9675-5.
  67. [67]Monteiro, M.J.P.F.G.; Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.; Thompson, M.J. Seismic study of overshoot at the base of the solar convective envelope. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1994, 283, 247–262.
  68. [68]Demarque, P.; Woo, J.H.; Kim, Y.C.; Yi, S.K. Y2 Isochrones with an Improved Core Overshoot Treatment. The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 2004, 155, 667–674. https://doi.org/10.1086/424966.
  69. [69]Spada, F.; Demarque, P.; Kim, Y.C.; Bojovian, T.S.; Brewer, J.M. The Yale-Potsdam Stellar Isochrones. The Astrophysical Journal 2017, 838, 161, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1703.03975]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aa661d.
  70. [70]Magic, Z.; Serenelli, A.; Weiss, A.; Chaboyer, B. On Using the Color-Magnitude Diagram Morphology of M67 to Test Solar Abundances. The Astrophysical Journal 2010, 718, 1378–1387, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1004.3308]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/718/2/1378.
  71. [71]Claret, A. Updating the theoretical tidal evolution constants: Apsidal motion and the moment of inertia. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2019, 628, A29, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1907.11538]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201936007.
  72. [72]Morel, P.; Lebreton, Y. CESAM: a free code for stellar evolution calculations. Astrophysics and Space Science 2008, 316, 61–73, [arXiv:astro-ph/0801.2019]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10509-007-9663-9.
  73. [73]Viani, L.S.; Basu, S. Examining the Relationship Between Convective Core Overshoot and Stellar Properties Using Asteroseismology. The Astrophysical Journal 2020, 904, 22, [arXiv:astro-ph/2009.09344]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/abba17.
  74. [74]Deheuvels, S. Probing core overshooting using asteroseismology. Bulletin de la Société Royale des Sciences de Liège 2019, 88, 84–105.arxiv.org/abs/2001.04178
  75. [75]Moravveji, E.; Townsend, R.H.D.; Aerts, C.; Mathis, S. Sub-inertial Gravity Modes in the B8V Star KIC 7760680 Reveal Moderate Core Overshooting and Low Vertical Diffusive Mixing. The Astrophysical Journal 2016, 823, 130, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1604.02680]. https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/823/2/130.
  76. [76]Claret, A.; Torres, G. The Dependence of Convective Core Overshooting on Stellar Mass: A Semi-empirical Determination Using the Diffusive Approach with Two Different Element Mixtures. The Astrophysical Journal 2017, 849, 18, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1710.08417]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aa8770.
  77. [77]Tkachenko, A.; Pavlovski, K.; Johnston, C.; Pedersen, M.G.; Michielsen, M.; Bowman, D.M.; Southworth, J.; Tsymbal, V.; Aerts, C. The mass discrepancy in intermediate- and high-mass eclipsing binaries: The need for higher convective core masses. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2020, 637, A60, [arXiv:astro-ph/2003.08982]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202037452.
  78. [78]Noels, A.; Montalbán, J.; Miglio, A.; Godart, M.; Ventura, P. Overshooting and semiconvection: structural changes and asteroseismic signatures. Astrophysics and Space Science 2010, 328, 227–236. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10509-009-0203-7.
  79. [79]Unno, W. Anisotropy of Solar Convection. The Astrophysical Journal 1957, 126, 259. https://doi.org/10.1086/146397.
  80. [80]Böhm, K.H. The Mixing of Matter in the Layer Below the Outer Solar Convection Zone. The Astrophysical Journal 1963, 138, 297. https://doi.org/10.1086/147640.
  81. [81]Saslaw, W.C.; Schwarzschild, M. Overshooting from Stellar Convective Cores. The Astrophysical Journal 1965, 142, 1468. https://doi.org/10.1086/148430.
  82. [82]Zahn, J.P.; Toomre, J.; Latour, J. Nonlinear modal analysis of penetrative convection. Geophysical and Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 1982, 22, 159–193. https://doi.org/10.1080/03091928208221741.
  83. [83]Straus, J.M.; Blake, J.B.; Schramm, D.N. Effects of convective overshoot on lithium depletion in main-sequence stars. The Astrophysical Journal 1976, 204, 481–487. https://doi.org/10.1086/154192.
  84. [84]Spiegel, E.A. A Generalization of the Mixing-Length Theory of Turbulent Convection. The Astrophysical Journal 1963, 138, 216. https://doi.org/10.1086/147628.
  85. [85]Shaviv, G.; Salpeter, E.E. Convective Overshooting in Stellar Interior Models. The Astrophysical Journal 1973, 184, 191–200. https://doi.org/10.1086/152318.
  86. [86]Nordlund, A. On Convection in Stellar Atmospheres. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1974, 32, 407.
  87. [87]Maeder, A. Stellar evolution III: the overshooting from convective cores. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1975, 40, 303–310.
  88. [88]Cogan, B.C. Convective Overshooting in Main-Sequence Models. The Astrophysical Journal 1975, 201, 637–640. https://doi.org/10.1086/153931.
  89. [89]Ulrich, R.K. A Nonlocal Mixing-Length Theory of Convection for Use in Numerical Calculations. The Astrophysical Journal 1976, 207, 564–573. https://doi.org/10.1086/154523.
  90. [90]Langer, N. Non-local treatment of convection and overshooting from stellar convective cores. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1986, 164, 45–50.
  91. [91]Marcus, P.S.; Press, W.H.; Teukolsky, S.A. Multiscale model equations for turbulent convection and convective overshoot. The Astrophysical Journal 1983, 267, 795–821. https://doi.org/10.1086/160915.
  92. [92]Zhang, Q.S.; Li, Y. Turbulent Convection Model in the Overshooting Region. I. Effects of the Convective Mixing in the Solar Overshooting Region. The Astrophysical Journal 2012, 746, 50. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/746/1/50.
  93. [93]Zhang, Q.S. A Simple Scheme to Implement a Nonlocal Turbulent Convection Model for Convective Overshoot Mixing. The Astrophysical Journal 2016, 818, 146, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1601.01756]. https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/818/2/146.
  94. [94]Canuto, V.M. Stellar mixing. V. Overshooting. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2011, 528, A80. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201014450.
  95. [95]Kupka, F.; Montgomery, M.H. A-star envelopes: a test of local and non-local models of convection. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2002, 330, L6–L10, [arXiv:astro-ph/0112401]. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-8711.2002.05268.x.
  96. [96]Kupka, F.; Ahlborn, F.; Weiss, A. Stellar evolution models with overshooting based on 3-equation non-local theories I. Physical basis and the computation of the dissipation rate. arXiv e-prints 2022, p. arXiv:207.12296, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2707.12296].DOI
  97. [97]Chen, C.J. Response of an Optically Thin, Isothermal Atmosphere to a Convective Overshoot. Solar Physics 1974, 37, 53–62. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00157843.
  98. [98]Renzini, A. Some embarrassments in current treatments of convective overshooting. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1987, 188, 49–54.
  99. [99]Pratt, J.; Baraffe, I.; Goffrey, T.; Constantino, T.; Viallet, M.; Popov, M.V.; Walder, R.; Folini, D. Extreme value statistics for two-dimensional convective penetration in a pre-main sequence star. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2017, 604, A125, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1706.04852]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201630362.
  100. [100]Augustson, K.C.; Mathis, S. A Model of Rotating Convection in Stellar and Planetary Interiors. I. Convective Penetration. The Astrophysical Journal 2019, 874, 83, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1902.10593]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab0b3d.
  101. [101]Herwig, F.; Freytag, B.; Fuchs, T.; Hansen, J.P.; Hueckstaedt, R.M.; Porter, D.H.; Timmes, F.X.; Woodward, P.R. Convective and Non-Convective Mixing in AGB Stars. In Proceedings of the Why Galaxies Care About AGB Stars: Their Importance as Actors and Probes; Kerschbaum, F.; Charbonnel, C.; Wing, R.F., Eds., 2007, Vol. 378, Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, p. 43, [arXiv:astro-ph/0701097].
  102. [102]Spiegel, E.A.; Veronis, G. On the Boussinesq Approximation for a Compressible Fluid. The Astrophysical Journal 1960, 131, 442. https://doi.org/10.1086/146849.
  103. [103]Lantz, S.R. Dynamical Behavior of Magnetic Fields in a Stratified, Convecting Fluid Layer. PhD thesis, Cornell University, New York, 1992.
  104. [104]Braginsky, S.I.; Roberts, P.H. Equations governing convection in earth’s core and the geodynamo. Geophysical and Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics 1995, 79, 1–97. https://doi.org/10.1080/03091929508228992.
  105. [105]Lantz, S.R.; Fan, Y. Anelastic Magnetohydrodynamic Equations for Modeling Solar and Stellar Convection Zones. The Astrophysical Journal Supplemental Series 1999, 121, 247–264. https://doi.org/10.1086/313187.
  106. [106]Jones, C.A.; Kuzanyan, K.M.; Mitchell, R.H. Linear theory of compressible convection in rapidly rotating spherical shells, using the anelastic approximation. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 2009, 634, 291. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112009007253.
  107. [107]Landau, L.D.; Lifshitz, E.M. Fluid Mechanics; 1987.
  108. [108]Grossmann, S.; Lohse, D. Scaling in thermal convection: a unifying theory. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 2000, 407, 27–56, [arXiv:nlin.CD/chaos/9909032]. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112099007545.
  109. [109]Jones, C.A.; Mizerski, K.A.; Kessar, M. Fully developed anelastic convection with no-slip boundaries. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 2022, 930, A13, [arXiv:physics.flu-dyn/2101.11357]. https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2021.905.
  110. [110]Roxburgh, I.W. Integral constraints on convective overshooting. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1989, 211, 361–364.
  111. [111]Käpylä, P.J.; Rheinhardt, M.; Brandenburg, A.; Arlt, R.; Käpylä, M.J.; Lagg, A.; Olbert, N.; Warnecke, J. Extended Subadiabatic Layer in Simulations of Overshooting Convection. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 2017, 845, L23, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1703.06845]. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/aa83ab.
  112. [112]Anders, E.H.; Jermyn, A.S.; Lecoanet, D.; Fuentes, J.R.; Korre, L.; Brown, B.P.; Oishi, J.S. Convective Boundary Mixing Processes. Research Notes of the American Astronomical Society 2022, 6, 41. https://doi.org/10.3847/2515-5172/ac5892.
  113. [113]Hurlburt, N.E.; Toomre, J.; Massaguer, J.M.; Zahn, J.P. Penetration below a Convection Zone. The Astrophysical Journal 1994, 421, 245. https://doi.org/10.1086/173642.
  114. [114]Lecoanet, D.; Schwab, J.; Quataert, E.; Bildsten, L.; Timmes, F.X.; Burns, K.J.; Vasil, G.M.; Oishi, J.S.; Brown, B.P. Turbulent Chemical Diffusion in Convectively Bounded Carbon Flames. The Astrophysical Journal 2016, 832, 71, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1603.08921]. https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/832/1/71.
  115. [115]Couston, L.A.; Lecoanet, D.; Favier, B.; Le Bars, M. Dynamics of mixed convective-stably-stratified fluids. Physical Review Fluids 2017, 2, 094804, [arXiv:physics.flu-dyn/1709.06454]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.2.094804.
  116. [116]Anders, E.H.; Jermyn, A.S.; Lecoanet, D.; Brown, B.P. Stellar Convective Penetration: Parameterized Theory and Dynamical Simulations. The Astrophysical Journal 2022, 926, 169, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2101.11356]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ac408d.
  117. [117]Aerts, C.; Augustson, K.; Mathis, S.; Pedersen, M.G.; Mombarg, J.S.G.; Vanlaer, V.; Van Beeck, J.; Van Reeth, T. Rossby numbers and stiffness values inferred from gravity-mode asteroseismology of rotating F- and B-type dwarfs. Consequences for mixing, transport, magnetism, and convective penetration. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2021, 656, A121, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2110.06220]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202142151.
  118. [118]Kippenhahn, R.; Weigert, A.; Weiss, A. Stellar Structure and Evolution; 2013. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-30304-3.
  119. [119]Brummell, N.H.; Clune, T.L.; Toomre, J. Penetration and Overshooting in Turbulent Compressible Convection. The Astrophysical Journal 2002, 570, 825–854. https://doi.org/10.1086/339626.
  120. [120]Rogers, T.M.; Glatzmaier, G.A. Penetrative Convection within the Anelastic Approximation. The Astrophysical Journal 2005, 620, 432–441. https://doi.org/10.1086/423415.
  121. [121]Browning, M.K.; Brun, A.S.; Toomre, J. Simulations of Core Convection in Rotating A-Type Stars: Differential Rotation and Overshooting. The Astrophysical Journal 2004, 601, 512–529, [arXiv:astro-ph/0310003]. https://doi.org/10.1086/380198.
  122. [122]Rempel, M. Overshoot at the Base of the Solar Convection Zone: A Semianalytical Approach. The Astrophysical Journal 2004, 607, 1046–1064. https://doi.org/10.1086/383605.
  123. [123]Rogers, T.M.; Glatzmaier, G.A.; Jones, C.A. Numerical Simulations of Penetration and Overshoot in the Sun. The Astrophysical Journal 2006, 653, 765–773, [arXiv:astro-ph/0601668]. https://doi.org/10.1086/508482.
  124. [124]Brun, A.S.; Miesch, M.S.; Toomre, J. Modeling the Dynamical Coupling of Solar Convection with the Radiative Interior. The Astrophysical Journal 2011, 742, 79. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/742/2/79.
  125. [125]Singh, H.P.; Roxburgh, I.W.; Chan, K.L. A study of penetration at the bottom of a stellar convective envelope and its scaling relationships. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1998, 340, 178–182.
  126. [126]Saikia, E.; Singh, H.P.; Chan, K.L.; Roxburgh, I.W.; Srivastava, M.P. Examination of Scaling Relationships Involving Penetration Distance at the Bottom of a Stellar Convective Envelope. The Astrophysical Journal 2000, 529, 402–413. https://doi.org/10.1086/308249.
  127. [127]Hurlburt, N.E.; Toomre, J.; Massaguer, J.M. Nonlinear Compressible Convection Penetrating into Stable Layers and Producing Internal Gravity Waves. The Astrophysical Journal 1986, 311, 563. https://doi.org/10.1086/164796.
  128. [128]Kiraga, M.; Jahn, K.; Muthsam, H.J.; Stępień, K. 2D Computer Simulations of Stellar Convection Using a Three-Layer Model. Acta Astronomica 1995, 45, 685–704.
  129. [129]Bazán, G.; Arnett, D. Two-dimensional Hydrodynamics of Pre-Core Collapse: Oxygen Shell Burning. The Astrophysical Journal 1998, 496, 316–332, [arXiv:astro-ph/9702239]. https://doi.org/10.1086/305346.
  130. [130]Dietrich, W.; Wicht, J. Penetrative Convection Induced by Solidly Rotating Spherical Shells. Frontiers in Earth Science 2018, 6, 189, [arXiv:astro-ph.EP/1811.04718]. https://doi.org/10.3389/feart.2018.00189.
  131. [131]Cai, T. Upward Overshooting in Turbulent Compressible Convection. I. Effects of the Relative Stability Parameter, the Prandtl Number, and the Péclet Number. The Astrophysical Journal 2020, 888, 46. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab58c5.
  132. [132]Cai, T. Upward Overshooting in Turbulent Compressible Convection. II. Simulations at Large Relative Stability Parameters. The Astrophysical Journal 2020, 891, 49. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab711c.
  133. [133]Tian, C.L.; Deng, L.C.; Chan, K.L. Numerical simulations of downward convective overshooting in giants. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2009, 398, 1011–1022, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1603.01690]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.15178.x.
  134. [134]Kăprylă, P.J. Overshooting in simulations of compressible convection. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2019, 631, A122, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1812.07916]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201834921.
  135. [135]Korre, L.; Garaud, P.; Brummell, N.H. Convective overshooting and penetration in a Boussinesq spherical shell. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2019, 484, 1220–1237, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1810.06700]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz047.
  136. [136]Brown, B.P.; Vasil, G.M.; Zweibel, E.G. Energy Conservation and Gravity Waves in Sound-proof Treatments of Stellar Interiors. Part I. Anelastic Approximations. The Astrophysical Journal 2012, 756, 109, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1207.2804]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/756/2/109.
  137. [137]Herwig, F.; Freytag, B.; Hueckstaedt, R.M.; Timmes, F.X. Hydrodynamic Simulations of He Shell Flash Convection. The Astrophysical Journal 2006, 642, 1057–1074, [arXiv:astro-ph/0601164]. https://doi.org/10.1086/501119.
  138. [138]Woodward, P.R.; Herwig, F.; Lin, P.H. Hydrodynamic Simulations of H Entrainment at the Top of He-shell Flash Convection. The Astrophysical Journal 2015, 798, 49. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/798/1/49.
  139. [139]Turner, J.S. The behaviour of a stable salinity gradient heated from below. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1968, 33, 183–200. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112068000242.
  140. [140]Deardorff, J.W.; Willis, G.E.; Lilly, D.K. Laboratory investigation of non-steady penetrative convection. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1969, 35, 7–31. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112069000942.
  141. [141]Kato, H.; Phillips, O.M. On the penetration of a turbulent layer into stratified fluid. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1969, 37, 643–655. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112069000784.
  142. [142]Linden, P.F. The deepening of a mixed layer in a stratified fluid. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1975, 71, 385–405. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112075002637.
  143. [143]Fernando, H.J.S. The formation of a layered structure when a stable salinity gradient is heated from below. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1987, 182, 525–541. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112087002441.
  144. [144]Molemaker, M.J.; Dijkstra, H.A. The formation and evolution of a diffusive interface. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1997, 331, 199–229. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112096003862.
  145. [145]Leppinen, D.M. The erosion of a salinity step by distributed and localized heat sources. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 2003, 44, 625–644, [https://doi.org/10.1080/716100516]. https://doi.org/10.1080/716100516.
  146. [146]Fuentes, J.R.; Cumming, A. Penetration of a cooling convective layer into a stably-stratified composition gradient: Entrainment at low Prandtl number. Physical Review Fluids 2020, 5, 124501, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2007.04265]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.5.124501.
  147. [147]Toppaladoddi, S.; Wettlaufer, J.S. Penetrative convection at high Rayleigh numbers. Physical Review Fluids 2018, 3, 043501, [arXiv:physics.flu-dyn/1706.00711]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.3.043501.
  148. [148]Arnett, D.; Meakin, C.; Young, P.A. Turbulent Convection in Stellar Interiors. II. The Velocity Field. The Astrophysical Journal 2009, 690, 1715–1729, [arXiv:astro-ph/0809.1625]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/690/2/1715.
  149. [149]Mocák, M.; Müller, E.; Weiss, A.; Kifonidis, K. The core helium flash revisited. II. Two and three-dimensional hydrodynamic simulations. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2009, 501, 659–677, [arXiv:astro-ph/0811.4083]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200811414.
  150. [150]Cristini, A.; Hirschi, R.; Meakin, C.; Arnett, D.; Georgy, C.; Walkington, I. Dependence of convective boundary mixing on boundary properties and turbulence strength. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2019, 484, 4645–4664, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1901.10531]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz312.
  151. [151]Staritsin, E.I. Turbulent entrainment at the boundaries of the convective cores of main-sequence stars. Astronomy Reports 2013, 57, 380–390. https://doi.org/10.1134/S1063772913050089.
  152. [152]Scott, L.J.A.; Hirschi, R.; Georgy, C.; Arnett, W.D.; Meakin, C.; Kaiser, E.A.; Ekström, S.; Yusof, N. Convective core entrainment in 1D main-sequence stellar models. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2021, 503, 4208–4220, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2103.06196]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stab752.
  153. [153]Jermyn, A.S.; Bauer, E.B.; Schwab, J.; Farmer, R.; Ball, W.H.; Bellinger, E.P.; Dotter, A.; Joyce, M.; Marchant, P.; Mombarg, J.S.G.; et al. Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Time-Dependent Convective Boundary Mixing, Energy Conservation, Automatic Differentiation, and Infrastructure. arXiv e-prints 2022, arXiv:2208.03651, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2208.03651].DOI
  154. [154]Roxburgh, I.W. Convection and stellar structure. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1978, 65, 281–285.
  155. [155]Roxburgh, I.W. Limits on convective penetration from stellar cores. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1992, 266, 291–293.
  156. [156]Kitiashvili, I.N.; Kosovichev, A.G.; Mansour, N.N.; Wray, A.A. Dynamics Of Turbulent Convection and Convective Overshoot in a Moderate-mass Star. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 2016, 821, L17, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1512.07298]. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8205/821/1/L17.
  157. [157]Baraffe, I.; Pratt, J.; Vlaykov, D.G.; Guillet, T.; Goffrey, T.; Le Saux, A.; Constantino, T. Two-dimensional simulations of solar-like models with artificially enhanced luminosity. I. Impact on convective penetration. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2021, 654, A126, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2109.00943]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/20210441.
  158. [158]Singh, H.P.; Roxburgh, I.W.; Chan, K.L. Three-dimensional simulation of penetrative convection: penetration below a convection zone. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1995, 295, 703.
  159. [159]Brun, A.S.; Strugarek, A.; Varela, J.; Matt, S.P.; Augustson, K.C.; Emeriau, C.; DoCao, O.L.; Brown, B.; Toomre, J. On Differential Rotation and Overshooting in Solar-like Stars. The Astrophysical Journal 2017, 836, 192, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1702.06598]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aa5c40.
  160. [160]Käpylä, P.J.; Korpi, M.J.; Stix, M.; Tuominen, I. Effects of rotation and input energy flux on convective overshooting. In Proceedings of the Convection in Astrophysics; Kupka, F.; Roxburgh, I.; Chan, K.L., Eds., 2007, Vol. 239, pp. 437–442, [arXiv:astro-ph/0609350]. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1743921307000865.
  161. [161]Hotta, H. Solar Overshoot Region and Small-scale Dynamo with Realistic Energy Flux. The Astrophysical Journal 2017, 843, 52, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1706.06413]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aa784b.
  162. [162]Baraffe, I.; Clarke, J.; Morrison, A.; Vlaykov, D.G.; Constantino, T.; Goffrey, T.; Guillet, T.; Le Saux, A.; Pratt, J. A study of convective core overshooting as a function of stellar mass based on two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2023, [https://academic.oup.com/mnras/advance-article-pdf/doi/10.1093/mnras/stad009/48524790/stad009.pdf]. stad009, https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stad009.
  163. [163]Pope, S.B. Turbulent Flows; 2000.
  164. [164]Viallet, M.; Meakin, C.; Arnett, D.; Mocák, M. Turbulent Convection in Stellar Interiors. III. Mean-field Analysis and Stratification Effects. The Astrophysical Journal 2013, 769, 1, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1212.6365]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/769/1/1.
  165. [165]Currie, L.K.; Browning, M.K. The Magnitude of Viscous Dissipation in Slowly Stratified Two-dimensional Convection. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 2017, 845, L17, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1707.08858]. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/aa8301.
  166. [166]Julien, K.; Legg, S.; McWilliams, J.; Werne, J. Penetrative convection in rapidly rotating flows: preliminary results from numerical simulation. Dynamics of Atmospheres and Oceans 1996, 24, 237–249. Stratified flows, https://doi.org/10.1016/0377-0 265(95)00449-1.
  167. [167]Julien, K.; Knobloch, E.; Rubio, A.M.; Vasil, G.M. Heat Transport in Low-Rossby-Number Rayleigh-Bénard Convection. Physical Review Letters 2012, 109, 254503. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.109.254503.
  168. [168]Aurnou, J.M.; Horn, S.; Julien, K. Connections between nonrotating, slowly rotating, and rapidly rotating, turbulent convection transport scalings. Physical Review Research 2020, 2, 043115, [arXiv:physics.flu-dyn/2009.03447]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch. 2.043115.
  169. [169]Pal, P.S.; Singh, H.P.; Chan, K.L.; Srivastava, M.P. Turbulent compressible convection with rotation—penetration above a convection zone. Astrophysics and Space Science 2008, 314, 231–239, [arXiv:astro-ph/0802.1824]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10509-008-9764-0.
  170. [170]Drobyshevski, E.M.; Yuferev, V.S. Topological pumping of magnetic flux by three-dimensional convection. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1974, 65, 33–44. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112074001236.
  171. [171]Tobias, S.M.; Brummell, N.H.; Clune, T.L.; Toomre, J. Transport and Storage of Magnetic Field by Overshooting Turbulent Compressible Convection. The Astrophysical Journal 2001, 549, 1183–1203. https://doi.org/10.1086/319448.
  172. [172]Ziegler, U.; Rüdiger, G. Box simulations of rotating magnetoconvection. Effects of penetration and turbulent pumping. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2003, 401, 433–442. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20030207.
  173. [173]Fisher, G.H.; McClymont, A.N.; Chou, D.Y. The Stretching of Magnetic Flux Tubes in the Convective Overshoot Region. The Astrophysical Journal 1991, 374, 766. https://doi.org/10.1086/170161.
  174. [174]van Ballegooijen, A.A. The overshoot layer at the base of the solar convective zone and the problem of magnetic flux storage. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1982, 113, 99–112.
  175. [175]Racine, R. Photometry of M67 to M_{v} = +12. The Astrophysical Journal 1971, 168, 393. https://doi.org/10.1086/151095.
  176. [176]Torres Peimbert, S. On the Ages of the Galactic Clusters NGC 188, M67 AND NGC 6791. Boletin de los Observatorios Tonantzintla y Tacubaya 1971, 6, 3–14.
  177. [177]Bell, R.A. The reddening, distance modulus, chemical composition and age of the galactic cluster NGC 752. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1972, 157, 147–156. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/157.2.147.
  178. [178]McClure, R.D.; Newell, B.; Barnes, J.V. PDS Photometry of the Open Cluster NGC 2420. The Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific 1978, 90, 170. https://doi.org/10.1086/130302.
  179. [179]Demarque, P.; Sarajedini, A.; Guo, X.J. The Gap in the Color-Magnitude Diagram of NGC 2420: A Test of Convective Overshoot and Cluster Age. The Astrophysical Journal 1994, 426, 165. https://doi.org/10.1086/174052.
  180. [180]Maeder, A.; Mermilliod, J.C. The extent of mixing in stellar interiors: evolutionary models and tests based on the HR diagrams of 34 open clusters. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1981, 93, 136–149.
  181. [181]Kozhurina-Platais, V.; Demarque, P.; Platais, I.; Orosz, J.A.; Barnes, S. The Age of NGC 3680 and a Test of Convective Overshoot. The Astronomical Journal 1997, 113, 1045–1056. https://doi.org/10.1086/118321.
  182. [182]Andersen, J.; Clausen, J.V.; Nordstrom, B. New Strong Evidence for the Importance of Convective Overshooting in Intermediate-Mass Stars. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 1990, 363, L33. https://doi.org/10.1086/185858.
  183. [183]Vallenari, A.; Chiosi, C.; Bertelli, G.; Meylan, G.; Ortolani, S. Star clusters of the large magellanic cloud. III. CCD-photometry of NGC 2164. Astronomy & Astrophysics Supplemental Series 1991, 87, 517–540.
  184. [184]Vallenari, A.; Chiosi, C.; Bertelli, G.; Meylan, G.; Ortolani, S. Stars Clusters of the Large Magellanic Cloud: CCD Photometry of NGC 1831. The Astronomical Journal 1992, 104, 1100. https://doi.org/10.1086/116300.
  185. [185]Chiosi, C.; Bertelli, G.; Meylan, G.; Ortolani, S. Globular clusters in the Large Magellanic Cloud : NGC 1866, a test for convective overshoot. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1989, 219, 167–191.
  186. [186]Bruntt, H.; Frandsen, S.; Kjeldsen, H.; Andersen, M.I. Strömgren photometry of the open clusters NGC 6134 and NGC 3680. Astronomy & Astrophysics Supplemental Series 1999, 140, 135–143. https://doi.org/10.1051/aas:1999412.
  187. [187]Woo, J.H.; Gallart, C.; Demarque, P.; Yi, S.; Zoccali, M. Testing Intermediate-Age Stellar Evolution Models with VLT Photometry of Large Magellanic Cloud Clusters. II. Analysis with the Yale Models. The Astronomical Journal 2003, 125, 754–769, [arXiv:astro-ph/astro-ph/0208142]. https://doi.org/10.1086/345959.
  188. [188]Mucciarelli, A.; Origlia, L.; Ferraro, F.R. The Intermediate-Age Globular Cluster NGC 1783 in the Large Magellanic Cloud. The Astronomical Journal 2007, 134, 1813, [arXiv:astro-ph/0707.4655]. https://doi.org/10.1086/522034.
  189. [189]Girardi, L.; Rubele, S.; Kerber, L. Discovery of two distinct red clumps in NGC 419: a rare snapshot of a cluster at the onset of degeneracy. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2009, 394, L74–L78, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/0901.0773]. https://doi.org/10.111/j.1745-3933.2008.00614.x.
  190. [190]Nordstrom, B.; Andersen, J. Open clusters under the microscope. The Messenger 1991, 63, 34–37.
  191. [191]Dinescu, D.I.; Demarque, P.; Guenther, D.B.; Pinsonneault, M.H. The Ages of the Disk Clusters NGC 188, M67, and NGC 752, Using Improved Opacities and Cluster Membership Data. The Astronomical Journal 1995, 109, 2090. https://doi.org/10.1086/117434.
  192. [192]Michaud, G.; Richard, O.; Richer, J.; VandenBerg, D.A. Models for Solar Abundance Stars with Gravitational Settling and Radiative Accelerations: Application to M67 and NGC 188. The Astrophysical Journal 2004, 606, 452–465, [arXiv:astro-ph/astro-ph/0402544]. https://doi.org/10.1086/383001.
  193. [193]Viani, L.; Basu, S. Isochrones of M67 with an Expanded Set of Parameters. In Proceedings of the European Physical Journal Web of Conferences, 2017, Vol. 160, European Physical Journal Web of Conferences, p. 05005, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1705.06761]. https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/201716005005.
  194. [194]Bressan, A.; Marigo, P.; Girardi, L.; Salasnich, B.; Dal Cero, C.; Rubele, S.; Nanni, A. PARSEC: stellar tracks and isochrones with the Padova and TRieste Stellar Evolution Code. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2012, 427, 127–145, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1208.4498]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.21948.x.
  195. [195]Dotter, A. MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST) 0: Methods for the Construction of Stellar Isochrones. The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 2016, 222, 8, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1601.05144]. https://doi.org/10.3847/0067-0049/222/1/8.
  196. [196]Choi, J.; Dotter, A.; Conroy, C.; Cantillo, M.; Paxton, B.; Johnson, B.D. MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST). I. Solar-scaled Models. The Astrophysical Journal 2016, 823, 102, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1604.08592]. https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/823/2/102.
  197. [197]Johnston, C.; Tkachenko, A.; Aerts, C.; Molenberghs, G.; Bowman, D.M.; Pedersen, M.G.; Buysschaert, B.; Pápics, P.I. Binary asteroseismic modelling: isochrone-cloud methodology and application to Kepler gravity mode pulsators. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2019, 482, 1231–1246, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1810.00780]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/sty2671.
  198. [198]Johnston, C.; Aerts, C.; Pedersen, M.G.; Bastian, N. Isochrone-cloud fitting of the extended main-sequence turn-off of young clusters. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2019, 632, A74, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1910.00591]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201936549.
  199. [199]Milone, A.P.; Marino, A.F.; Di Criscienzo, M.; D’Antona, F.; Bedin, L.R.; Da Costa, G.; Pïotto, G.; Tailo, M.; Dotter, A.; Angeloni, R.; et al. Multiple stellar populations in Magellanic Cloud clusters - VI. A survey of multiple sequences and Be stars in young clusters. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2018, 477, 2640–2663, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1802.10538]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/sty661.
  200. [200]Goudfrooij, P.; Girardi, L.; Bellini, A.; Bressan, A.; Correnti, M.; Costa, G. The Minimum Mass of Rotating Main-sequence Stars and its Impact on the Nature of Extended Main-sequence Turnoffs in Intermediate-age Star Clusters in the Magellanic Clouds. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 2018, 864, L3, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1807.04737]. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/aada0f.
  201. [201]Milone, A.P.; Bedin, L.R.; Piotto, G.; Anderson, J. Multiple stellar populations in Magellanic Cloud clusters. I. An ordinary feature for intermediate age globulars in the LMC? Astronomy & Astrophysics 2009, 497, 755–771, [arXiv:astro-ph/0810.2558]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200810870.
  202. [202]Yang, W.; Meng, X.; Bi, S.; Tian, Z.; Li, J.; Liu, K. The Contributions of Interactive Binary Stars to Double Main-sequence Turnoffs and Dual Red Clump of Intermediate-age Star Clusters. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 2011, 731, L37, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1103.3128]. https://doi.org/10.1088/2041-8205/731/2/L37.
  203. [203]Bastian, N.; de Mink, S.E. The effect of stellar rotation on colour-magnitude diagrams: on the apparent presence of multiple populations in intermediate age stellar clusters. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2009, 398, L11–L15, [arXiv:astro-ph.GA/0906.1590]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-3933.2009.00696.x.
  204. [204]Yang, W.; Tian, Z. The Effects of the Overshooting of the Convective Core on Main-sequence Turnoffs of Young- and Intermediate-age Star Clusters. The Astrophysical Journal 2017, 836, 102, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1701.05963]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aa5b9d.
  205. [205]Bastian, N.; Kamann, S.; Cabrera-Ziri, I.; Georgy, C.; Ekström, S.; Charbonnel, C.; de Juan Ovelar, M.; Usher, C. Extended main sequence turnoffs in open clusters as seen by Gaia - I. NGC 2818 and the role of stellar rotation. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2018, 480, 3739–3746, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1807.10779]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/sty2100.
  206. [206]Marino, A.F.; Przybilla, N.; Milone, A.P.; Da Costa, G.; D’Antona, F.; Dotter, A.; Dupree, A. Different Stellar Rotations in the Two Main Sequences of the Young Globular Cluster NGC 1818: The First Direct Spectroscopic Evidence. The Astronomical Journal 2018, 156, 116, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1807.04493]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-3881/aad3cd.
  207. [207]Sun, W.; de Grijs, R.; Deng, L.; Albrow, M.D. Stellar Rotation and the Extended Main-sequence Turnoff in the Open Cluster NGC 5822. The Astrophysical Journal 2019, 876, 113, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1904.03547]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab16e4.
  208. [208]Kamann, S.; Bastian, N.; Gossage, S.; Baade, D.; Cabrera-Ziri, I.; da Costa, G.; de Mink, S.E.; Georgy, C.; Giesers, B.; Göttgens, F.; et al. How stellar rotation shapes the colour-magnitude diagram of the massive intermediate-age star cluster NGC 1846. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2020, 492, 2177–2192, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2001.01731]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz3583.
  209. [209]Kamann, S.; Saracino, S.; Bastian, N.; Gossage, S.; Usher, C.; Baade, D.; Cabrera-Ziri, I.; de Mink, S.E.; Ekstrom, S.; Georgy, C.; et al. The effects of stellar rotation along the main sequence of the 100-Myr-old massive cluster NGC 1850. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2023, 518, 1505–1521, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2211.00693]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stac3170.
  210. [210]von Zeipel, H. The radiative equilibrium of a rotating system of gaseous masses. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1924, 84, 665–683. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/84.9.665.
  211. [211]Espinosa Lara, F.; Rieutord, M. Gravity darkening in rotating stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2011, 533, A43, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1109.3038]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201117252.
  212. [212]Lipatov, M.; Brandt, T.D.; Gossage, S. Rotational Variation Allows for Narrow Age Spread in the Extended Main-sequence Turnoff of Massive Cluster NGC 1846. The Astrophysical Journal 2022, 934, 105, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2206.08167]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ac78e1.
  213. [213]Russell, H.N. On the advance of periastron in eclipsing binaries. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1928, 88, 641–643. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/88.8.641.
  214. [214]Claret, A.; Gimenez, A. The effect of core overshooting and mass loss on the internal density concentration of main sequence stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1991, 244, 319.
  215. [215]Semieniuk, I.; Paczyński, B. Apsidal Motion in Binary Systems. III. Model Computations. Acta Astronomica 1968, 18, 33.
  216. [216]Stothers, R. The apsidal-motion test for models of main-sequence stars. The Astrophysical Journal 1974, 194, 651–655. https://doi.org/10.1086/153286.
  217. [217]Mathis, J.S.; Odell, A.P. The apsidal constant and structure of alpha Virginis. The Astrophysical Journal 1973, 180, 517. https://doi.org/10.1086/151981.
  218. [218]Odell, A.P. The structure of Alpha Virginis. II. The apsidal constant. The Astrophysical Journal 1974, 192, 417–424. https://doi.org/10.1086/153073.
  219. [219]Shobbrook, R.R.; Herbison-Evans, D.; Johnston, I.D.; Lomb, N.R. Light variations in Spica. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1969, 145, 131. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/145.2.131.
  220. [220]Shobbrook, R.R.; Lomb, N.R.; Herbison-Evans, D. The short period light and velocity variations in Alpha Virginis. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1972, 156, 165. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/156.2.165.
  221. [221]Smith, M.A. The nonradial oscillations of Spica. I. Two commensurable modes. The Astrophysical Journal 1985, 297, 206–223. https://doi.org/10.1086/163517.
  222. [222]Smith, M.A. The non-radial oscillations of Spica. II. A “quasi-toroidal” mode. The Astrophysical Journal 1985, 297, 224–232. https://doi.org/10.1086/163518.
  223. [223]Harrington, D.; Koenigsberger, G.; Moreno, E.; Kuhn, J. Line-profile Variability from Tidal Flows in Alpha Virginis (Spica). The Astrophysical Journal 2009, 704, 813–830, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/0908.3336]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/704/1/813.
  224. [224]Tkachenko, A.; Matthews, J.M.; Aerts, C.; Pavlovski, K.; Pápics, P.I.; Zwintz, K.; Cameron, C.; Walker, G.A.H.; Kuschnig, R.; Degroote, P.; et al. Stellar modelling of Spica, a high-mass spectroscopic binary with a β Cep variable primary component. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2016, 458, 1964–1976, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1601.08069]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw255.
  225. [225]Bowman, D.M.; Vandenbussche, B.; Sana, H.; Tkachenko, A.; Raskin, G.; Delabie, T.; Vandoren, B.; Royer, P.; Garcia, S.; Van Reeth, T.; et al. The CubeSpec space mission. Asteroseismology of massive stars from time-series optical spectroscopy: Science requirements and target list prioritisation. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2022, 658, A96, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2111.09814]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202142375.
  226. [226]Claret, A.; Gimenez, A. The apsidal motion test of the internal stellar structure : comparison between theory and observations. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1993, 277, 487–502.
  227. [227]Claret, A. The role of the stellar rotation on the internal constitution of PV Cassiopeiae. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2008, 490, 1103–1107. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20079004.
  228. [228]Wolf, M.; Zejda, M.; de Villiers, S.N. Apsidal motion in southern eccentric eclipsing binaries: GL Car, QX Car, NO Pup and V366 Pup. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2008, 388, 1836–1842. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.13527.x.
  229. [229]North, P.; Gauderon, R.; Barblan, F.; Royer, F. VLT multi-object spectroscopy of 33 eclipsing binaries in the Small Magellanic Cloud. New distance and depth of the SMC, and a record-breaking apsidal motion. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2010, 520, A74, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1005.4336]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200810284.
  230. [230]Bulut, İ. Apsidal motion elements of six eccentric eclipsing binaries: V799 Cas, CC Cep, V1136 Cyg, V345 Lac, V364 Lac and V402 Lac. New Astronomy 2013, 21, 22–26. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.newast.2012.08.010.
  231. [231]Zasche, P.; Wolf, M. Apsidal motion and absolute parameters for five LMC eccentric eclipsing binaries. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2013, 558, A51, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1310.2425]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201322054.
  232. [232]Lacy, C.H.S.; Torres, G.; Fekel, F.C.; Muterspaugh, M.W.; Southworth, J. Absolute Properties of the Eclipsing Binary Star IM Persei. The Astronomical Journal 2015, 149, 34. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-6256/149/1/34.
  233. [233]Bakış, V. Young eccentric binary KL CMa revisited in the light of spectroscopy. New Astronomy 2015, 40, 14–19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.newast.2015.02.005.
  234. [234]Hong, K.; Lee, J.W.; Kim, S.L.; Koo, J.R.; Park, J.H.; Kim, C.H.; Lee, C.U.; Kim, H.W.; Kim, D.J.; Han, C. Absolute Dimensions and Apsidal Motions of Three Binary Systems in the Large Magellanic Cloud. The Astronomical Journal 2019, 158, 185. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-3881/ab44ad.
  235. [235]Andersen, J.; Clausen, J.V.; Nordstrom, B.; Popper, D.M. Absolute dimensions of eclipsing binaries. VIII. V760 Scorpii. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1985, 151, 329–339.
  236. [236]Gimenez, A.; Kim, C.H.; Nha, I.S. Apsidal motion in the early-type eclipsing binaries CW Cephei, Y Cygni and AG Persei. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1987, 224, 543–555. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/224.3.543.
  237. [237]Bakiş, V.; Bakiş, H.; Dermirçan, O.; Eker, Z. Absolute dimensions and apsidal motion of the eccentric binary PT Velorum. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2008, 384, 1657–1667. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.12822.x.
  238. [238]Degirmenci, Ö.L.; Gülmen, Ö.; Sezer, C.; Ibanoğlu, C.; Çakırlı, Ö. Up-to-date UBV light and O-C curves analyses of the eclipsing binary V477 Cygni. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2003, 409, 959–967. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20031006.
  239. [239]Bakiş, V.; Bulut, Á.; Bilir, S.; Bakiş, H.; Demircan, O.; Hensberge, H. Absolute Dimensions and Apsidal Motion of the Young Detached System LT Canis Majoris. Publications of the Astronomical Society of Japan 2010, 62, 1291–1299, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1007.4107]. https://doi.org/10.1093/pasj/62.5.1291.
  240. [240]Baroch, D.; Giménez, A.; Morales, J.C.; Ribas, I.; Herrero, E.; Perdelwitz, V.; Jordi, C.; Granzer, T.; Allende Prieto, C. Absolute dimensions and apsidal motion of the eclipsing binaries V889 Aquilae and V402 Lacertae. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2022, 665, A13, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2206.13121]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202244287.
  241. [242]Guinan, E.F.; Ribas, I.; Fitzpatrick, E.L.; Giménez, Á.; Jordi, C.; McCook, G.P.; Popper, D.M. Eclipsing Binaries as Astrophysical Laboratories: Internal Structure, Core Convection, and Evolution of the B-Star Components of V380 Cygni. The Astrophysical Journal 2000, 544, 409–422, [arXiv:astro-ph/0005029]. https://doi.org/10.1086/317211.
  242. [243]Claret, A. The absolute dimensions and evolved EBS V380 Cygni: A case of critical evolution. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2003, 399, 1115–1119. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20021857.
  243. [244]Rosu, S.; Rauw, G.; Nazé, Y.; Gosset, E.; Sterken, C. Apsidal motion in massive eccentric binaries: The case of CPD-41° 7742, and HD 152218 revisited. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2022, 664, A98, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2205.11207]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202243707.
  244. [245]Groenewegen, M.A.T.; Lamers, H.J.G.L.M.; Pauldrach, A.W.A. The winds of O-stars. II. The terminal velocities of stellar winds of O-type stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1989, 221, 78–88.
  245. [246]Herrero, A.; Kudritzki, R.P.; Vilchez, J.M.; Kunze, D.; Butler, K.; Haser, S. The mass and helium discrepancy in massive young stars. In The Atmospheres of Early-Type Stars; Haber, U.; Jeffery, C.S., Eds.; 1992; Vol. 401, p. 21. https://doi.org/10.1007/3-540-55256-1_269.
  246. [247]Gronbech, B.; Gyldenkerne, K.; Jorgensen, H.E. Four-colour photometry of eclipsing binaries. VII. SZ Cen, light curves, photometric elements, absolute dimensions and determination of helium content. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1977, 55, 401–409.
  247. [248]Clausen, J.V. Absolute dimensions of eclipsing binaries. XIX. BW Aquarii: a late F-typeindicator of overshooting. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1991, 246, 397.
  248. [249]Fitzpatrick, E.L.; Garmany, C.D. The H-R Diagram of the Large Magellanic Cloud and Implications for Stellar Evolution. The Astrophysical Journal 1990, 363, 119. https://doi.org/10.1086/169322.
  249. [250]Hunter, I.; Lennon, D.J.; Dufton, P.L.; Trundle, C.; Simón-Díaz, S.; Smartt, S.J.; Ryans, R.S.I.; Evans, C.J. The VLT-FLAMES survey of massive stars: atmospheric parameters and rotational velocity distributions for B-type stars in the Magellanic Clouds. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2008, 479, 541–555, [arXiv:astro-ph/0711.2264]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20078511.
  250. [251]Brott, I.; de Mink, S.E.; Cantiello, M.; Langer, N.; de Koter, A.; Evans, C.J.; Hunter, I.; Trundle, C.; Vink, J.S. Rotating massive main-sequence stars. I. Grids of evolutionary models and isochrones. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2011, 530, A115, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1102.0530]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201016113.
  251. [252]Vink, J.S.; Brott, I.; Gräfener, G.; Langer, N.; de Koter, A.; Lennon, D.J. The nature of B supergiants: clues from a steep drop in rotation rates at 22 000 K. The possibility of Bi-stability braking. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2010, 512, L7, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1003.1280]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201014205.
  252. [254]Tkachenko, A.; Degroote, P.; Aerts, C.; Pavlovski, K.; Southworth, J.; Pápics, P.I.; Moravveji, E.; Kolbas, V.; Tsymbal, V.; Debosscher, J.; et al. The eccentric massive binary V380 Cyg: revised orbital elements and interpretation of the intrinsic variability of the primary component*. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2014, 438, 3093–3110, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1312.3601]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stt2421.
  253. [255]Fekel, F.C. Chromospherically Active Stars. VIII. HD 155683 = V972 Herculis: Observational Constraints on Evolutionary Theory. The Astronomical Journal 1991, 101, 1489. https://doi.org/10.1086/115781.
  254. [256]Andersen, J.; Clausen, J.V.; Nordstrom, B.; Gustafsson, B.; Vandenberg, D.A. Absolute dimensions of eclipsing binaries. XIII. AI Phoenicis : a casestudy in stellar evolution. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1988, 196, 128–140.
  255. [257]Andersen, J.; Clausen, J.V.; Magain, P. Absolute dimensions of eclipsing binaries. XIV. UX Mensae. Astronomy & Astrophysics 1989, 211, 346–352.
  256. [258]Claret, A.; Torres, G. The dependence of convective core overshooting on stellar mass. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2016, 592, A15. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201628779.
  257. [259]Schroder, K.P.; Pols, O.R.; Eggleton, P.P. A critical test of stellar evolution and convective core ‘overshooting’ by means of zeta Aurigae systems. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1997, 285, 696–710. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/285.4.696.
  258. [260]Ribas, I.; Jordi, C.; Giménez, Á. The mass dependence of the overshooting parameter determined from eclipsing binary data. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2000, 318, L55–L59. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-8711.2000.04035.x.
  259. [261]Claret, A. Does convective core overshooting depend on stellar mass?. Tests using double-lined eclipsing binaries. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2007, 475, 1019–1025. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20078024.
  260. [262]Claret, A.; Torres, G. The Dependence of Convective Core Overshooting on Stellar Mass: Reality Check and Additional Evidence. The Astrophysical Journal 2019, 876, 134, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1904.02714]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab1589.
  261. [263]Costa, G.; Girardi, L.; Bressan, A.; Marigo, P.; Rodrigues, T.S.; Chen, Y.; Lanza, A.; Goudfrooij, P. Mixing by overshooting and rotation in intermediate-mass stars. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2019, 485, 4641–4657, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1903.04368]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz728.
  262. [264]Constantino, T.; Baraffe, I. Significant uncertainties from calibrating overshooting with eclipsing binary systems. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2018, 618, A177, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1808.03523]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201833568.
  263. [265]Meng, Y.; Zhang, Q.S. Calibrating the Updated Overshoot Mixing Model on Eclipsing Binary Stars: HY Vir, YZ Cas, χ2 Hya, and VV Crv. The Astrophysical Journal 2014, 787, 127, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1404.4411]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/787/2/127.
  264. [266]Stancliffe, R.J.; Fossati, L.; Passy, J.C.; Schneider, F.R.N. Confronting uncertainties in stellar physics: calibrating convective overshooting with eclipsing binaries. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2015, 575, A117, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1501.05322]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201425126.
  265. [267]Andersen, J. Accurate masses and radii of normal stars. Astronomy and Astrophysics Reviews 1991, 3, 91–126. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00873538.
  266. [268]Valle, G.; Dell’Omodarme, M.; Prada Moroni, P.G.; Degl’Innocenti, S. Calibrating convective-core overshooting with eclipsing binary systems. The case of low-mass main-sequence stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2016, 587, A16, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1601.01535]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201527389.
  267. [269]Valle, G.; Dell’Omodarme, M.; Prada Moroni, P.G.; Degl’Innocenti, S. Statistical errors and systematic biases in the calibration of the convective core overshooting with eclipsing binaries. A case study: TZ Fornacis. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2017, 600, A41, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1612.07066]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201628240.
  268. [270]Valle, G.; Dell’Omodarme, M.; Prada Moroni, P.G.; Degl’Innocenti, S. Overshooting calibration and age determination from evolved binary systems. A statistical investigation on biases and random variability. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2018, 615, A62, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1803.07058]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201832668.
  269. [271]Pols, O.R.; Tout, C.A.; Schroder, K.P.; Eggleton, P.P.; Manners, J. Further critical tests of stellar evolution by means of double-lined eclipsing binaries. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 1997, 289, 869–881. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/289.4.869.
  270. [272]Mahy, L.; Sana, H.; Abdul-Masih, M.; Almeida, L.A.; Langer, N.; Shenar, T.; de Koter, A.; de Mink, S.E.; de Wit, S.; Grin, N.J.; et al. The Tarantula Massive Binary Monitoring. III. Atmosphere analysis of double-lined spectroscopic systems. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2020, 634, A118, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1912.08107]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201936151.
  271. [273]de Mink, S.E.; Cantiello, M.; Langer, N.; Pols, O.R.; Brott, I.; Yoon, S.C. Rotational mixing in massive binaries. Detached short-period systems. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2009, 497, 243–253, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/0902.1751]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200811439.
  272. [274]Martins, F.; Mahy, L.; Hervé, A. Properties of six short-period massive binaries: A study of the effects of binarity on surface chemical abundances. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2017, 607, A82, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1709.00937]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201731593.
  273. [275]Pavlovski, K.; Southworth, J.; Tkachenko, A.; Van Reeth, T.; Tamajo, E. High-mass eclipsing binaries: a testbed for models of interior structure and evolution – Accurate fundamental properties and surface chemical composition for V1034 Sco, GL Car, V573 Car and V346 Cen. arXiv e-prints 2023, p. arXiv:2301.04215, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2301.04215]. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2301.04215.
  274. [288]Buzasi, D.; Catanzarite, J.; Laher, R.; Conrow, T.; Shupe, D.; Gautier, T. N., I.; Kreidl, T.; Everett, D. The Detection of Multimodal Oscillations on α Ursae Majoris. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 2000, 532, L133–L136, [arXiv:astro-ph/0002512]. https://doi.org/10.1086/312573.
  275. [289]Walker, G.; Matthews, J.; Kuschnig, R.; Johnson, R.; Rucinski, S.; Pazder, J.; Burley, G.; Walker, A.; Skaret, K.; Zee, R.; et al. The MOST Asteroseismology Mission: Ultra-Precise Photometry from Space. The Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific 2003, 115, 1023–1035. https://doi.org/10.1086/377358.
  276. [290]Auvergne, M.; Bodin, P.; Boisnard, L.; Buey, J.T.; Chaintreuil, S.; Epstein, G.; Jouret, M.; Lam-Trong, T.; Levacher, P.; Magnan, A.; et al. The CoRoT satellite in flight: description and performance. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2009, 506, 411–424, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/0901.2206]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200810860.
  277. [291]Baglin, A.; Auvergne, M.; Barge, P.; Deleuil, M.; Michel, E.; CoRoT Exoplanet Science Team. CoRoT: Description of the Mission and Early Results. In Proceedings of the Transiting Planets; Pont, F.; Sasselov, D.; Holman, M.J., Eds., 2009, Vol. 253, pp. 71–81. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1743921308026252.
  278. [292]Borucki, W.J.; Koch, D.; Basri, G.; Batalha, N.; Brown, T.; Caldwell, D.; Caldwell, J.; Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.; Cochran, W.D.; DeVore, E.; et al. Kepler Planet-Detection Mission: Introduction and First Results. Science 2010, 327, 977. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1185402.
  279. [293]Koch, D.G.; Borucki, W.J.; Basri, G.; Batalha, N.M.; Brown, T.M.; Caldwell, D.; Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.; Cochran, W.D.; DeVore, E.; Dunham, E.W.; et al. Kepler Mission Design, Realized Photometric Performance, and Early Science. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 2010, 713, L79–L86, [arXiv:astro-ph.EP/1001.0268]. https://doi.org/10.1088/2041-8205/713/2/L79.
  280. [294]Howell, S.B.; Sobeck, C.; Haas, M.; Still, M.; Barclay, T.; Mullally, F.; Troeltzsch, J.; Aigrain, S.; Bryson, S.T.; Caldwell, D.; et al. The K2 Mission: Characterization and Early Results. The Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific 2014, 126, 398, [arXiv:astro-ph.IM/1402.5163]. https://doi.org/10.1086/676406.
  281. [295]Weiss, W.W.; Rucinski, S.M.; Moffat, A.F.J.; Schwarzenberg-Czerny, A.; Koudelka, O.F.; Grant, C.C.; Zee, R.E.; Kuschnig, R.; Mochnacki, S.; Matthews, J.M.; et al. BRITE-Constellation: Nanosatellites for Precision Photometry of Bright Stars. The Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific 2014, 126, 573, [arXiv:astro-ph.IM/1406.3778]. https://doi.org/10.1086/677236.
  282. [296]Ricker, G.R.; Winn, J.N.; Vanderspek, R.; Latham, D.W.; Bakos, G.Á.; Bean, J.L.; Berta-Thompson, Z.K.; Brown, T.M.; Buchhave, L.; Butler, N.R.; et al. Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS). Journal of Astronomical Telescopes, Instruments, and Systems 2015, 1, 014003. https://doi.org/10.1117/1.JATIS.1.1.014003.
  283. [297]Aerts, C.; Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.; Kurtz, D.W. Asteroseismology; 2010. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-5803-5.
  284. [298]Chaplin, W.J.; Miglio, A. Asteroseismology of Solar-Type and Red-Giant Stars. Annual Review of Astronomy & Astrophysics 2013, 51, 353–392, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1303.1957]. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-astro-082812-104938.
  285. [299]Aerts, C.; Mathis, S.; Rogers, T.M. Angular Momentum Transport in Stellar Interiors. Annual Review of Astronomy & Astrophysics 2019, 57, 35–78, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1809.07779]. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-astro-091918-104359.
  286. [300]Bowman, D.M. Asteroseismology of high-mass stars: new insights of stellar interiors with space telescopes. Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Science 2020, 7, 70, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2008.11162]. https://doi.org/10.3389/fspas.2020.578584.
  287. [301]Holdsworth, D.L. The RoAp Stars Observed by the Kepler Space Telescope. Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences 2021, 8, 31, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2102.12198]. https://doi.org/10.3389/fspas.2021.626398.
  288. [302]Christensen-Dalsgaard, J. Solar structure and evolution. Living Reviews in Solar Physics 2021, 18, 2, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2007.06488]. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41116-020-0028-3.
  289. [303]Aerts, C. Probing the interiors of stars through asteroseismology. Reviews of Modern Physics 2021, 93, 015001, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1912.12300]. https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.93.015001.
  290. [304]Guzik, J.A. Highlights of Discoveries for δ Scuti Variable Stars From the Kepler Era. Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences 2021, 8, 55, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2105.12553]. https://doi.org/10.3389/fspas.2021.653558.
  291. [305]Kurtz, D.W. Asteroseismology Across the Hertzsprung-Russell Diagram. Annual Review of Astronomy & Astrophysics 2022, 60, 31–71. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-astro-052920-094232.
  292. [306]Houdek, G.; Gough, D.O. An asteroseismic signature of helium ionization. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2007, 375, 861–880, [arXiv:astro-ph/0612030]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2006.11325.x.
  293. [307]Roxburgh, I.W.; Vorontsov, S.V. Acoustic wave reflection by stellar cores: can it be seen in the autocorrelation function of p-mode measurements? Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2007, 379, 801–806. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.11979.x.
  294. [308]Cunha, M.S.; Metcalfe, T.S. Asteroseismic Signatures of Small Convective Cores. The Astrophysical Journal 2007, 666, 413–422, [arXiv:astro-ph/0705.3009]. https://doi.org/10.1086/520045.
  295. [309]Cunha, M.S.; Brandão, I.M. Probing tiny convective cores with the acoustic modes of lowest degree. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2011, 529, A10, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1008.1299]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201015188.
  296. [310]Silva Aguirre, V.; Basu, S.; Brandão, I.M.; Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.; Deheuvels, S.; Doğan, G.; Metcalfe, T.S.; Serenelli, A.M.; Ballot, J.; Chaplin, W.J.; et al. Stellar Ages and Convective Cores in Field Main-Sequence Stars: First Asteroseismic Application to Two Kepler Targets. The Astrophysical Journal 2013, 769, 141, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1304.2772]. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/769/2/141.
  297. [311]Deheuvels, S.; Michel, E.; Goupil, M.J.; Marques, J.P.; Mosser, B.; Dupret, M.A.; Lebreton, Y.; Pichon, B.; Morel, P. Survival of a convective core in low-mass solar-like pulsator HD 203608. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2010, 514, A31, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1002.3461]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200911991.
  298. [312]Roxburgh, I.W. Present Problems of the Solar Interior. Solar Physics 1985, 100, 21. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00158420.
  299. [313]Mowlavi, N. A peculiar effect of core overshooting on the internal structure of low mass stars. In Proceedings of the IAU Colloq. 137: Inside the Stars; Weiss, W.W.; Baglin, A., Eds., 1993, Vol. 40, Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, p. 454.DOI
  300. [314]Moździerski, D.; Pigulski, A.; Kołaczkowski, Z.; Michalska, G.; Kopacki, G.; Carrier, F.; Walczak, P.; Narwid, A.; Śledźliki, M.; Fu, J.N.; et al. Ensemble asteroseismology of pulsating B-type stars in NGC 6910. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2019, 632, A95, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1910.11873]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201936418.
  301. [315]Deheuvels, S.; Brandão, I.; Silva Aguirre, V.; Ballot, J.; Michel, E.; Cunha, M.S.; Lebreton, Y.; Appourchaux, T. Measuring the extent of convective cores in low-mass stars using Kepler data: toward a calibration of core overshooting. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2016, 589, A93, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1603.02332]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201527967.
  302. [316]Bellinger, E.P.; Angelou, G.C.; Hekker, S.; Basu, S.; Ball, W.H.; Guggenberger, E. Fundamental Parameters of Main-Sequence Stars in an Instant with Machine Learning. The Astrophysical Journal 2016, 830, 31, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1607.02137]. https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/830/1/3110.48550/arXiv.1607.02137.
  303. [317]Mombarg, J.S.G.; Van Reeth, T.; Aerts, C. Constraining stellar evolution theory with asteroseismology of γ Doradus stars using deep learning. Stellar masses, ages, and core-boundary mixing. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2021, 650, A58, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2103.13394]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/20203954310.48550/arXiv.2103.13394.
  304. [318]Dupret, M.A.; Thoul, A.; Scuflaire, R.; Daszyńska-Daszkiewicz, J.; Aerts, C.; Bourge, P.O.; Waelkens, C.; Noels, A. Asteroseismology of the β Cep star HD 129929. II. Seismic constraints on core overshooting, internal rotation and stellar parameters. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2004, 415, 251–257. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20034143.
  305. [319]Ausseloos, M.; Scuflaire, R.; Thoul, A.; Aerts, C. Asteroseismology of the β Cephei star ν Eridani: massive exploration of standard and non-standard stellar models to fit the oscillation data. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2004, 355, 352–358. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2004.08320.x.
  306. [320]Mazumdar, A.; Briquet, M.; Desmet, M.; Aerts, C. An asteroseismic study of the β Cephei star β Canis Majoris. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2006, 459, 589–596, [arXiv:astro-ph/astro-ph/0607261]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20064980.
  307. [321]Briquet, M.; Morel, T.; Thoul, A.; Scuflaire, R.; Miglio, A.; Montalbán, J.; Dupret, M.A.; Aerts, C. An asteroseismic study of the β Cephei star of Ophiuchi: constraints on global stellar parameters and core overshooting. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2007, 381, 1482–1488, [arXiv:astro-ph/0706.3274]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.12142.x.
  308. [322]Desmet, M.; Briquet, M.; Thoul, A.; Zima, W.; De Cat, P.; Handler, G.; Ilyin, I.; Kambe, E.; Krzesinski, J.; Lehmann, H.; et al. An asteroseismic study of the β Cephei star 12 Lacertae: multisite spectroscopic observations, mode identification and seismic modelling. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2009, 396, 1460–1472, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/0903.5477]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.14790.x.
  309. [323]Aerts, C.; Briquet, M.; Degroote, P.; Thoul, A.; van Hoolst, T. Seismic modelling of the β Cephei star HD 180642 (V1449 Aquilae). Astronomy & Astrophysics 2011, 534, A98, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1109.0705]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201117629.
  310. [324]Briquet, M.; Aerts, C.; Baglin, A.; Nieva, M.F.; Degroote, P.; Przybylla, N.; Noels, A.; Schiller, F.; Vuckovic, M.; Oreiro, R.; et al. An asteroseismic study of the O9V star HD 46202 from CoRoT space-based photometry. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2011, 527, A112, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1101.3162]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201015690.
  311. [325]Briquet, M.; Neiner, C.; Aerts, C.; Morel, T.; Mathis, S.; Reese, D.R.; Lehmann, H.; Costero, R.; Echevarria, J.; Handler, G.; et al. Multisite spectroscopic seismic study of the β Cep star V2052 Ophiuchi: inhibition of mixing by its magnetic field. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2012, 427, 483–493, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1208.4250]. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.21933.x.
  312. [326]Walczak, P.; Daszyńska-Daszkiewicz, J.; Pamyatnykh, A.A.; Zdravkov, T. The hybrid B-type pulsator γ Pegasi: mode identification and complex seismic modelling. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2013, 432, 822–831, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1304.4129]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stt492.
  313. [327]Moravveji, E.; Aerts, C.; Pápics, P.I.; Triana, S.A.; Vandoren, B. Tight asteroseismic constraints on core overshooting and diffusive mixing in the slowly rotating pulsating B8.3V star KIC 10526294. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2015, 580, A27, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1505.06902]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201425290.
  314. [328]Schmid, V.S.; Aerts, C. Asteroseismic modelling of the two F-type hybrid pulsators KIC 10080943A and KIC 10080943B. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2016, 592, A116, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1605.07958]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201628617.
  315. [329]Daszyńska-Daszkiewicz, J.; Pamyatnykh, A.A.; Walczak, P.; Colgan, J.; Fontes, C.J.; Kilcrease, D.P. Interpretation of the BRITE oscillation data of the hybrid pulsator ν Eridani: a call for the modification of stellar opacities. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2017, 466, 2284–2293, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1612.05820]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw3315.
  316. [330]Sánchez Arias, J.P.; Córsico, A.H.; Althaus, L.G. Asteroseismology of hybrid δ Scuti-γ Doradus pulsating stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2017, 597, A29, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1609.02864]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201629126.
  317. [331]Buysschaert, B.; Aerts, C.; Bowman, D.M.; Johnston, C.; Van Reeth, T.; Pedersen, M.G.; Mathis, S.; Neiner, C. Forward seismic modeling of the pulsating magnetic B-type star HD 43317. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2018, 616, A148, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1805.00802]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201832642.
  318. [332]Aerts, C.; Pedersen, M.G.; Vermeylen, E.; Hendriks, L.; Johnston, C.; Tkachenko, A.; Pápics, P.I.; Debosscher, J.; Briquet, M.; Thoul, A.; et al. Combined asteroseismology, spectroscopy, and astrometry of the CoRoT B2V target HD 170580. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2019, 624, A75, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1902.04093]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201834762.
  319. [333]Khalack, V.; Lovekin, C.; Bowman, D.M.; Kobzar, O.; David-Uraz, A.; Paunzen, E.; Sikora, J.; Lenz, P.; Kochukhov, O.; Holdsworth, D.L.; et al. Rotational and pulsational variability in the TESS light curve of HD 27463. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2019, 490, 2102–2111, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1910.00512]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz2782.
  320. [334]Hendriks, L.; Aerts, C. Deep Learning Applied to the Asteroseismic Modeling of Stars with Coherent Oscillation Modes. The Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific 2019, 131, 108001, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1811.03639]. https://doi.org/10.1088/1538-3873/aaaeeec.
  321. [335]Wu, T.; Li, Y. High-precision Asteroseismology in a Slowly Pulsating B Star: HD 50230. The Astrophysical Journal 2019, 881, 86, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1907.04968]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab2ad8.
  322. [336]Fedurco, M.; Paunzen, E.; Hümmerich, S.; Bernhard, K.; Parimucha, Š. Pulsational properties of ten new slowly pulsating B stars. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2020, 633, A122, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1912.09358]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201935478.
  323. [337]Wu, T.; Li, Y.; Deng, Z.m.; Lin, G.f.; Song, H.f.; Jiang, C. Asteroseismic Analyses of Slowly Pulsating B Star KIC 8324482: Ultraweak Element Mixing beyond the Central Convective Core. The Astrophysical Journal 2020, 899, 38. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aba430.
  324. [338]Pedersen, M.G. On the Diversity of Mixing and Helium Core Masses of B-type Dwarfs from Gravity-mode Asteroseismology. The Astrophysical Journal 2022, 930, 94, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2203.02046]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ac5b05.
  325. [339]Niemczura, E.; Walczak, P.; Mikołajczyk, P.; Schöller, M.; Hummel, C.A.; Hubrig, S.; Różański, T. Seismic modelling of the pulsating mercury-manganese star HD 29589. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2022, 514, 5640–5658. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stac1632.
  326. [340]Szewczuk, W.; Walczak, P.; Daszyńska-Daszkiewicz, J.; Możdżierski, D. Seismic modelling of a very young SPB star - KIC 8264293. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2022, 511, 1529–1543, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2201.07039]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stac168.
  327. [341]Pedersen, M.G. Internal Rotation and Inclinations of Slowly Pulsating B Stars: Evidence of Interior Angular Momentum Transport. The Astrophysical Journal 2022, 940, 49, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2208.14497]. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ac947f.
  328. [342]Angelou, G.C.; Bellinger, E.P.; Hekker, S.; Mints, A.; Elsworth, Y.; Basu, S.; Weiss, A. Convective boundary mixing in low- and intermediate-mass stars - I. Core properties from pressure-mode asteroseismology. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2020, 493, 4987–5004, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2002.02546]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staa390.
  329. [343]Lecoanet, D.; Bowman, D.M.; Van Reeth, T. Asteroseismic inference of the near-core magnetic field strength in the main-sequence B star HD 43317. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2022, 512, L16–L20, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/2202.03440]. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnrasl/slac013.
  330. [344]Pedersen, M.G.; Aerts, C.; Pápics, P.I.; Rogers, T.M. The shape of convective core overshooting from gravity-mode period spacings. Astronomy & Astrophysics 2018, 614, A128, [arXiv:astro-ph.SR/1802.02051]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201732317.

Paper details

vlnc:W_4en5vcvg
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents