betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The beam exchange of a circular cooler ring with a ultrafast harmonic kicker

Abstract

In this paper, we describe a harmonic kicker system used in the beam exchange scheme for the Circulator Cooling Ring (CCR) of the Jefferson Lab Electron Ion Collider(JLEIC). By delivering an ultra-fast deflecting kick, a kicker directs electron bunches selectively in/out of the CCR without degrading the beam dynamics of the CCR optimized for ion beam cooling. We will discuss the design principle of the kicker system and demonstrate its performance with various numerical simulations. In particular, the degrading effects of realistic harmonic kicks on the beam dynamics, such as 3D kick field profiles interacting with the magnetized beam, is studied in detail with a scheme that keeps the cooling efficiency within allowable limits.

Introduction

A proposal [1] for the Jefferson Laboratory Electron-Ion Collider (JLEIC) includes the Circulator Cooling Ring (CCR), which can dramatically increase luminosity of the electron-ion collision at a 45 GeV center-of-mass energy by cooling the ion beam in a storage ring at an energy of up to 100 GeV/nucleon. The cooling is done by passing the ion beam through a series of cooling solenoid channels—located in an overlapping segment of the CCR and the ion storage ring—along with a co-moving electron beam (see Figure 1(a)), whose beam parameters are dictated mostly by the ion beam parameters and listed in Table I [2]. In order to deliver an electron beam current of 0.76 A at a bunch repetition rate of fb=476.3f_b = 476.3 MHz to the cooling channels while taking into account the technological limitation on the injection current from the gun (whose state-of-art limit is ∼75\sim75 mA), the CCR is designed to increase the current in the cooler by causing the electron bunches to re-circulate in the ring for 11 turns. The schematic layout of the CCR complex and the exchange region with a kicker system is shown in Figure 1.

Schematic layout of the CCR complex and the exchange region

Figure 1. The schematic view of the CCR.

In Figure 1(a), the electron beam from a magnetized RF gun at 43.3 MHz gets accelerated by the energy recovery linac (ERL) to a nominal 55 MeV energy and enters the exchange region (grey strip) to be transferred to the upper level. On the upper level, the electron beam joins the CCR populated with the re-circulating beam at 476.3 MHz and circulates in the ring for 11 turns before exiting through the exchange region and going back to the ERL, and eventually to the beam dump. In a closer look at the exchange region illustrated in Figure 1(b), an injected bunch follows the purple dashed line: goes through a pre-kicker cavity (PREK), gets bent towards the upper level by a large-angle deflecting magnet (VDD) and bent back level via a septum (S) magnet. It is then kicked down by an injection kicker (IK) to merge with the CCR beam (the grey dashed line), and then kicked up (together with the re-circulating bunches) by a DC kicker magnet (DCK) to start circulation. During the re-circulation, the bunches in the exchange region avoid the influence of the septum by following the path of the grey dashed line created by a series of magnets—a DCK, a pair of focusing magnets, and another DCK. During re-circulation, the bunches do not experience kicks due to phase mismatch of the harmonic modes of the kick. After 11 passes, an extracted bunch follows the red dashed line: after the DCK magnet, it gets kicked down by an extraction kicker (EK), gets transferred down to the ERL ring via the septum magnet and another large-angle deflecting magnet (VRD), and goes through a post kicker (PSTK) cavity before returning to the ERL.

According to the proposed beam exchange scheme [1], every 11th bunch at the injection/extraction points in the CCR must be injected/extracted into/out of the ring at a kick frequency of fk=43.3f_k = 43.3 MHz—The ion beam bunch frequency will double to 952.6 MHz in a future upgrade, leading to the doubled exchange/CCR bunch frequencies of the electron beam. The design of the kicker system was based on fk=86.6f_k = 86.6 MHz as a preparation for this upgrade. Such an exchange scheme would need an ultra-fast kicker system that selectively delivers a deflecting kick of 2.5 mrad angle to the exchanged bunches only. This implies the rise-fall time of the kick must be much smaller than the bunch spacing of 1/fb=2.11/f_b = 2.1 ns. The most promising candidate for a fast kicker is a harmonic kicker based on a quarter wave resonator (QWR) whose kick profile is made of a linear combination of RF harmonic modes so that it has a sharply peaked temporal profile around an exchanged bunch.

In a CCR, a magnetized beam has some advantages over a non-magnetized beam, including a strong suppression of the CSR microbunching/energy spread growth [3] and stronger cooling [4]. For a high energy electron beam, the transverse velocity spread in the beam frame is enlarged by the Lorentz factor and hence the transverse temperature is usually much higher than the longitudinal velocity. For a strongly magnetized electron beam, the Larmor radius is much smaller than the impact factor. The ions interact with the Larmor circles instead of the free electron. The cooling time is mainly determined by the longitudinal temperature of the electrons and a stronger cooling, i.e. a shorter cooling time, can be achieved [5],[6],[7]. To maintain a constant electron bunch size in the solenoid, the beta function is determined by the momentum of the electron and the magnetic field. In the JLEIC configuration, the beta function of the electron beam is much smaller than the beta function of the ion beam. To make sure the electron beam size matches the ion beam size, the emittance of an unmagnetized electron beam will have to be very large, which leads to very high temperature and lowers the cooling rate. But for a magnetized electron beam, the beam size is determined by the drift emittance, while the cooling rate is determined by the Larmor emittance. We could simultaneously achieve a large drift emittance to match the beam size and a small Larmor emittance to obtain a good cooling rate [8]. A round magnetized beam within the cooling solenoid can be achieved by generating a round magnetized beam at a photocathode gun immersed in a solenoid and propagating it through a rotationally invariant and “decoupled” beamline to the cooler, as first conceived in [9] and later adopted in the CCR design with an extension of the scheme to the entire CCR (i.e. to come back to the cooler after circulation) [1]. At the start and end point of a globally invariant beamline, the beam has the same canonical angular momentum (CAM) and consequently roundness of the beam is preserved. If the beamline is decoupled as well, then the Larmor (rotational) motion of the beam is decoupled from the drift (Larmor center) motion, implying the Larmor emittance as a measure of the Larmor motion of the beam is conserved. The lattice design of an optimized beamline in a CCR without kickers can be found in [10].

In this note, we describe design of a harmonic kicker system and demonstrate by numerical simulations that the optimized beam dynamics of the CCR for the maximum cooling efficiency can be maintained (within tolerance limits) after a harmonic kicker system is implemented. The basic ideas in the design of a harmonic kicker presented here are not new. The first prototype of a harmonic kicker was developed in [12] [11] for different beam dynamics of the CCR. In [11], a linear combination of 10 harmonic modes, distributed over three different cavities, was designed as a kick profile, the idea of using two kickers, injection (IK) and extraction (EK), with an intervening betatron phase advance of π\pi to cancel out the residual fields of the kick for the re-circulating bunches was conceived, and pre/post kickers were introduced to flatten the RF curvature of harmonic kick on the exchanged bunches, preventing longitudinal profiles of angular distribution from bending into a “banana” shape. Subsequently these ideas were demonstrated by the numerical simulation studies using the particle tracking code ELEGANT [13] based on a simple model of the kick fields, where the only non-trivial component of the kick is in the kick direction with the spatial profile being transversely uniform and longitudinally δ\delta function-like or “impulsive”, i.e., F⃗L=eVk(t)δ(z)x^\vec{F}_L=eV_k(t)\delta(z)\hat{x} (F⃗L\vec{F}_L is the Lorentz force as a kick acting on an electron, ee is an electron charge, VkV_k is a kick voltage, x^\hat{x} is the kick direction—regardless of any physical direction and might be vertical—and zz is a longitudinal coordinate with the origin at the cavity center). The analysis of the beam propagation in [11] was limited to a non-magnetized beam.

ParametersUnitMagnetized beam
Beam energy EEMeV20 – 55
Bunch frequency fbf_bMHz476.3
Bunch charge QbQ_bnC1.6
Kick frequency fkf_kMHz86.6
Kick angle θ\thetamrad2.5
Bunch distr.⊥-Uniform-ellipse
Bunch distr.∥-Top-hat
Bunch length llcm3
rmsrms Energy spread δE/E\delta E/E×10−4\times10^{-4}3
Effective emittance (hor.) εeff,x\varepsilon_{eff,x}mm mrad36
Effective emittance (vert.) εeff,y\varepsilon_{eff,y}mm mrad36
Drift emittance εdrift\varepsilon_{drift}mm mrad36
Larmor emittance εLarmor\varepsilon_{Larmor}mm mrad1(19)
Twiss parameter (hor.) βx\beta_xm10
Twiss parameter (hor.) αx\alpha_x-0
Twiss parameter (vert.) βy\beta_ym120
Twiss parameter (vert.) αy\alpha_y-0
Magnetization MMmm mrad35
Gun frequency fgf_gMHz43.3
Gun voltage VgV_gkV400
Cathode spot radius σcath\sigma_{cath}mm2.2
Cathode magnetic field BcathB_{cath}T0.1
Cooler Solenoid field BcoolB_{cool}T1
Beam spot radius σcool\sigma_{cool}mm0.7
Electron beta at the coolercm36

Table 1. Beam parameters of the CCR at the kicker and at the photocathode gun. The Twiss parameters are at the kickers. The value in the bracket for the Larmor emittance refers to the tolerance limit.

The current work is an adaptation of the aforementioned basic approach to a beam dynamics with updated parameters (See Table I) of the CCR, with improvement on the number of modes for the kick profile to the 5 modes within a single cavity [14]. Furthermore, a kick model is now generalized to resemble the realistic kick field of the kicker cavity. The 3D field map of the QWR can be obtained from the RF simulations [15] using the 3D FEA code CST-MWS [16], although its direct application to analysis is impractical—not applicable in the ELEGANT—and therefore the kick model that appropriately approximates the profile needs to be introduced. In contract to the aforementioned simple kick model, the realistic kick fields are not transversely uniform, nor are they “impulsive”. Through the transversely non-uniform fields, the electrons at different offsets see different kick voltages, leading to serious degradation of beam dynamics since the cancellation scheme is not effective anymore. As long as the beam trajectory remains flat, i.e., at zero-slope, throughout the effective range of the kick fields, a phase space transform with non-zero offsets can be systematically described by a multipole expansion of the RF fields near the beam axis analogous to expansions of static magnet fields, as was first done in [17, 18, 19]. Then the multipole fields can be implemented into ELEGANT as beamline elements. We will present a modified configuration of a kicker system that cancels the multipole contributions in the residual kicks, as demonstrated by the ELEGANT simulations. On the other hand, the longitudinally extended profile of the kick fields, which closely resembles the pseudo-Gaussian profiles, allows the offsets of the beam to evolve over the effective field range. This evolution becomes more evident with the magnetized beam whose canonical angular momentum (CAM) defines non-trivial transverse slopes. Moreover, this evolution can not be cancelled by any cancellation scheme. We will show that the accumulated offset evolution reduces the magnetization and increases the Larmor emittance of the beam, leading to decreased the cooling efficiency. In the ELEGANT simulation, the extended kick profile is modeled as a series of impulsive kicks over the effective field range and the resulting Larmor emittance increase is shown to be smaller than 19 mm mrad, the tolerance limit for the efficient cooling.

II The baseline design of a harmonic kicker system

In this section, the baseline design of a harmonic kicker system is presented based on a simplified model of the CCR beam dynamics: the non-magnetized electron beam with a simple kick model. First we present the design principle of the kicker that leads to the implementation of the aforementioned ideas in a single cavity with 5 harmonic modes. Then a few important beam parameters are analytically computed and finally a proof of principle using the ELEGANT simulations is demonstrated. The beam dynamics based on a more realistic kick model will be discussed in the following sections.

A Harmonic kick design

The schematic view of the kicks on electron bunches in the injection scheme (the extraction scheme is analogous) is shown in Figure 2. The injected bunch train at fk=43.3 MHzf_k = 43.3\,\mathrm{MHz} merges with the re-circulating bunches at fb=476.3 MHzf_b = 476.3\,\mathrm{MHz} via a vertically deflecting kick at the crosspoint. The Nb=11N_b = 11 bunches pass through the kicker in a single kick period 1/fk1/f_k. Each bunch is indexed by m=0,1,⋯10m = 0,1,\cdots10: m=0m = 0 is the injected bunch and the others (m≠0m \ne0) are re-circulating bunches. All the particles within the bunches are assumed to move at v⃗=cz^\vec{v} = c\hat{z} (cc is speed of light). Given beam parameters from Table I, simple trigonometry in Figure 2 gives a good estimate for a kick voltage with Pkick≈θP≈137.5 keV/cP_{\mathrm{kick}} \approx\theta P \approx137.5\,\mathrm{keV}/c for the given kick angle of θ∼2.5 mrad\theta\sim2.5\,\mathrm{mrad}. Furthermore, the kick must be applied on the electron bunches selectively, i.e., delivered on injected bunches only at kick frequency fkf_k and not affect beam dynamics of the re-circulating bunches. This requires a temporal profile of a kick to be sharply peaked at kick frequency fkf_k and drop to negligible value within tb=1/fb=2.1 nst_b = 1/f_b = 2.1\,\mathrm{ns}.

Figure 2. A schematic view of the kicker. The black arrowed line is injection transport, while the yellow line is the CCR. The kick is represented by a big red downward arrow. The yellow ellipses are injected bunches, while the green ellipse is a re-circulating bunch in the CCR. The dotted transparent ellipse is an empty bucket reserved for the upgrade.

The required profile can be achieved using a harmonic kick, which is defined as a linear combination of harmonic modes with base frequency fkf_k. First, to define the relevant quantities more precisely, the coordinate system we will use is set up as follows. The longitudinal coordinate along the beam line is denoted by either ss or zz and the transverse coordinates by xx (vertical) and yy (horizontal), respectively. The origin s=0s = 0 is at the cavity center. The time reference particle in the mmth bunch arrives at the cavity center is set to be t=m/fbt = m/f_b. Consider a generic charged particle in the mmth bunch that arrives at the cavity center at t=m/fb+τt = m/f_b + \tau. Then the trajectory is z(t)=c(t−m/fb−τ)z(t) = c(t - m/f_b - \tau). The fractional energy of the particle is δ=E/Er−1\delta= E/E_r - 1, with EE and ErE_r being the energy of the particle and the reference particle, respectively. Next we assume the simple kick model used for the baseline design, i.e., F⃗L=eVkδ(z)x^\vec{F}_L = eV_k\delta(z)\hat{x}. Then the relevant equation of motion for the particle is given by

dpxdt=Fx(z,t)=∑n=0Nℜ[eVnδ(z)e−i(ωnt+ϕn)],(1)\frac{dp_x}{dt}=F_x(z,t)=\sum_{n=0}^{N}\Re\left[eV_n\delta(z)e^{-i(\omega_n t+\phi_n)}\right], \tag*{(1)}

while dynamics in yy direction is trivial. In the second equality, the Lorentz force is given as a harmonic kick, i.e., a linear combination of NN harmonic modes (plus one DC mode) with each mode written as the product of the spatial (longitudinal) profile Vnδ(z)V_n\delta(z) and the temporal (harmonic) profile. Also ωn\omega_n (n>0n>0, with ω0=0\omega_0=0) and NN are the angular frequency of the nnth mode and the number of harmonic modes, respectively. The RF phase ϕn\phi_n of the kicker is chosen so that the kick reaches the peak value at t=0t=0 (on-crest phase), i.e., ϕn=0\phi_n=0 for all n≥0n\geq0. Changing the independent variable from tt to ss and integrate the kick field over the cavity length, the kick voltage delivered by a harmonic kick is given as

Vx(mfb+τ)=V0+∑n=1NVncos⁡{2π(2n−1)fk(mfb+τ)},(2)V_x\left(\frac{m}{f_b}+\tau\right)=V_0+\sum_{n=1}^{N}V_n\cos\left\{2\pi(2n-1)f_k\left(\frac{m}{f_b}+\tau\right)\right\}, \tag*{(2)}

where n=0n=0 refers to the static mode provided by the external DC magnet. Now let us apply the general formula (2) to the requirements for the harmonic kickers. Whenever a reference particle in each exchanged bunch arrives at the kicker cavity, i.e., τ=0\tau=0 and m=0m=0, the kick must deliver a kick voltage VkickV^{kick}:

Vx(0)=V0+∑n=1NVn=Vkick=137.5 kV.(3)V_x(0)=V_0+\sum_{n=1}^{N}V_n=V^{kick}=137.5\,\mathrm{kV}. \tag*{(3)}

In (2), a set of constraints arise from the practical implementation of the kicker. In practice, a physical kicker cavity can accommodate only a few modes because of the kicker’s power-to-deflecting voltage efficiency and RF wave controlling issues. Thus NN must be truncated at a number less than 10. In case a harmonic kicker is based on the quarter wave resonator (QWR), only odd harmonics appears in (2) with $\omega_n=2\pi(2n-1)f_k$ because all the resonant frequencies supported by the QWR that has a coaxial structure with its closed end electrically shorted are odd harmonics. With the superposition of a few modes, the temporal profile of the kick would inevitably have “ripples”, i.e., non-zero residual kicks on the recirculating bunches between the kicks (For example, see Fig. 3(a)). These residual kicks could degrade the beam quality and should be minimized. More precisely, the kick should be close to zero with its slope also close to zero at temporal location of each recirculating bunch: from {xref}(2)`, we must have for mmth recirculating bunch (m=1,2,⋯ ,Nb−1m=1,2,\cdots,N_b-1)

Vx(mfb)=V0+∑n=1NVncos⁡{2π(2n−1)fkm/fb}=0.(4)V_x\left(\frac{m}{f_b}\right)=V_0+\sum_{n=1}^{N}V_n\cos\left\{2\pi(2n-1)f_km/f_b\right\}=0. \tag*{(4)}

For stability of the kick with respect to arrival time (to the kicker) jitter, RF control errors, and the extent over the bunch length, the kick voltage slope must be close to zero as well

Vx′(mfb)=−∑n=1NVn2π(2n−1)fk×sin⁡{2π(2n−1)fkm/fb}=0.(5)V_x'\left(\frac{m}{f_b}\right)=-\sum_{n=1}^{N}V_n2\pi(2n-1)f_k\times\sin\left\{2\pi(2n-1)f_km/f_b\right\}=0. \tag*{(5)}

Note that the constraints defined in equations in (4), (5), are not all independent due to the symmetry of trigonometric functions:

cos⁡[2π(2n−1)mfkfb]=cos⁡[2π(2n−1)(Nb−m)fkfb],(6)\cos\left[2\pi(2n-1)m\frac{f_k}{f_b}\right]=\cos\left[2\pi(2n-1)(N_b-m)\frac{f_k}{f_b}\right], \tag*{(6)}
sin⁡[2π(2n−1)mfkfb]=−sin⁡[2π(2n−1)(Nb−m)fkfb].(7)\sin\left[2\pi(2n-1)m\frac{f_k}{f_b}\right]=-\sin\left[2\pi(2n-1)(N_b-m)\frac{f_k}{f_b}\right]. \tag*{(7)}

References

  1. [12]Y. Huang, H. Wang, R. A. Rimmer, S. Wang, and J. Guo, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 19, 084201 (2016).
  2. [13]ELEGANT, http://www.anl.gov/APS .
  3. [14]G. Park, J. Guo, S. Wang, F. Fors, R. Rimmer, and H. Wang, “The Development of a new fast harmonic kicker for the JLEIC circulator cooler ring”, TUPAL068, Proceedings of the 9th International Particle Accelerator Conference, Vancouver, Canada (2018).DOI
  4. [15]G. Park, J. Guo, S. Wang, J. Henry, M. Marchlik, R. Rimmer, F. Marhauser, and H. Wang, “Status update of a harmonic kicker development for JLEICÓ, Proceedings of the 10th International Particle Accelerator Conference, Melbourne, Australia (2019).
  5. [16]CST, simulation packages, http://www.cst.com.
  6. [17]D.T. Abel, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 9, 05001 (2006).
  7. [18]J. Garcia et.al., in Proceedings of the 3rd International Particle Accelerator Conference, New Orleans, Louisiana (2012).
  8. [19]J. Garcia, R. De Maria, A. Grudiev, R. T. Garcia, R. B. Appleby, and D.R. Brett Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 19,
  9. [20]W.K.H. Panofsky and W.A. Wenzel, Review of Scientific Instruments, November 1956, p.967
  10. [21]M.J. Browman, Review of Scientific Instruments, November 1956, p.967
  11. [22]G. Park, J. Guo, S. Wang, R. Rimmer, and H. Wang, JLAB Technote, JLAN-TN-18-044.
  12. [23]A. Burov, S. Nagaitsev, Y. Derbenev, Phys. Rev. E 66, 016503 (2002).
  13. [24]K.-J. Kim, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams, 6, 104002 (2003).
  14. [25]D. Douglas, S. Benson, C. Tennant, JLAB Tech note, JLAB-TN-18-006 .
  15. [26]D. Douglas, “Beam Exchange Kickers and Magnetization: A Cautionary Tale”, JLAB Tech note, JLAB-TN-17-026 .
  16. [27]GPT, http://www.pulsar.nl/gpt .

Paper details

vlnc:W_4fcw5ut4
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents