WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Entanglement Entropy in Non Relativistic Collisions
Abstract
We study numerically the build-up of entanglement entropy between two colliding, non relativistic particles, that are driven by the plain Schrödinger equation containing local, finite range potentials, and whose initial state is the product of two independent wave packets. Different situations are considered, ranging from a tunnel and mirror effect at low energy in front of a barrier, to higher energies, and also attraction rather than repulsion. While the calculated wave functions and density matrices significantly depend on the physical situations described by our models, the build-up trends and values in time of entanglement entropy look surprisingly alike one another.
Introduction
In a recent paper [1] the relativistic S-matrix theory of collisions was shown to allow a measure of entanglement between either the elastic or inelastic collison of two elementary particles. However, since the S-matrix, by definition involves asymptotic times only, a question was left open, namely how does entanglement evolve at finite times? The present work attempts to answer the question, by means of a non relativistic approach, where one can use time-dependent wave functions. Given two particles, labelled 1 and 2, we generate numerically soluble models providing wave functions and the corresponding density matrices , and and corresponding entropies , and . The time evolution of the entanglement entropy, , can then be calculated and observed.
The effect of scattering on the entanglement of two nonrelativistic colliding particles has been studied in general in Ref.[2]. In the one-dimensional case, dedicated studies have been performed either using a general framework for the potential [3], wave packets for the particles, [4], or an analytic example with a hard-core potential [5]. The novelty of our approach is the full numerical computation of the entanglement entropy for various cases of potentials and its comparison with the relativistic case of Ref.[1].
Section II of this work describes our formalism. Section III presents initial conditions without entanglement, a useful simplification that does not bias our arguments. Section IV describes our numerically soluble models and their results. Section V discusses the existence of an asymptotic entanglement. Section VI is our conclusion. An Appendix states two theorems which facilitate understanding the time evolution of entropies.
Basic Formalism in an Interacting Two-Body Problem
We use a system of units where . Consider in dimension , ( for instance), two non-relativistic, spinless particles, of equal mass , , hence relative mass , with coordinates , , and their associated momenta . Their center of mass (cm) degrees of freedom read, and . Their relative motion (rel) degrees of freedom read , with . For the sake of simplicity, we set this particle pair as driven by a relative, Galilean invariant, scalar and local potential, , . For instance, can be a finite range repulsion or attraction, .
Their Hamiltonian reads, . Notice that this is also the sum of two independent Hamiltonians, , and . The whole wave function can be chosen as a product . Hence, the cm is a passive degree of freedom, that factorizes out. Accordingly, its state can be chosen at first as some wave packet . Let be a reference length for single particle states. Then we choose this as a spherical Gaussian,
At finite times, it evolves under spreading and phase oscillations only,
We define entanglement as follows: whether one handles a time independent theory with a wave function or a time dependent one with a wave function , the question to be raised is whether there exists single particle wave functions , , such that . More precisely, let evolve in time and let the density matrix (dm) of the system be, at all times, the pure dyadic, , and then note that the corresponding entropy, , trivially vanishes at all times. Let be represented as a function , or, in a shorter notation, as . The partial traces, and , define reduced dm’s for particles 1 and 2, respectively. Then the combination,
a semipositve quantity, measures the entanglement, namely how much the product, , differs from the product .
Initial Conditions Without Entanglement
For a vanishing quantity at beginning, set single particle states, , and , with a vector to separate the particles from each other and a vector to boost them against each other. Here, is the same as that length used to define in the previous section. Choose as an initial wave function for the pair of particles the product, . This induces a vanishing two-body entropy, that remains vanishing under time evolution, as explained in the Appendix. It is then also trivial that this initial product, , factorizes as the cm wave function , that packet defined in the previous section, multiplied by a relative wave function, . It is again trivial that, still at , with , then and . Accordingly, , and furthermore, again when , and thus, initially, .
The case when
The case, , makes a trivial situation. Since reduces to , the particle states , evolve independently, with just spreading and phase oscillations. All density operators remain dyadics, all entropies vanish at all times, hence remains vanishing. It is not surprising that finite entanglement demands an activated interaction. See the Appendix for more details.
Numerical Illustrations in 1D
For the sake of simplicity, we now consider toy models only, because higher dimensions, while numerically tractable, demand heavy calculations. Now has only one component , and the other degrees of freedom also reduce to a single component. The initial state reads, . The cm evolution reads,
The oncoming illustrations explore four physical cases, namely 1- a repulsive barrier with a coexistence of tunnel and mirror effects, 2- the same barrier when the relative particle has an energy equal to twice its height, 3- still the same barrier when the energy equals its height and 4- the same energy in front of an attractive pocket of shape and depth equal to the shape and height of the previous barriers.
In all cases we use numerical solutions of the equation, , to calculate the time evolution of in the -representation. Then, when needed, we can use the corresponding density matrix, . Simultaneously, the Gaussian , listed just above, exhibits spreading, and phase oscillations. All told, single particle density operators will be obtained from partial traces, with or , of the single particle coordinate representation of the full dm, . We set . Then we set ; this induces a sufficient separation between the initial particle states.
Case when particles repel each other and a tunnel effect occurs
The boost value, , hence relative energy , in presence of a repulsion , induces both a significant tunnel effect and a significant bouncing, as shown by Figure 1, which displays the modulus of at times and . The figure also shows , scaled down by a coefficient .8 for graphical convenience.
Figure 1. Evolution of if , , and . Full line, potential, scaled down by factor .8. Long dash line, at . Short dash line, at . Notice both bounce and tunnel effects.
While at time the plots of the density operators of single particle 1 and 2 give trivial results, such as circular contour lines for their modulus for instance, because we chose Gaussians as initial conditions, strong deformations are generated by the time evolution. We looked at two examples, the contour plots of and . The latter is shown as Figure 2. We verified that, at each time, the density operator of the second particle results from a trivial parity symmetry operation upon that of the first particle. Both corresponding entropies will thus be the same. We find, at time , the result, , hence, at that time, . At time we obtain . Values at further times seem to stabilize into an asymptotic limit.
Figure 2. Same parameters as for Fig.1. Contour plot, at time , of the modulus of the density operator of particle 1.
Case with relative particle at a higher energy than a barrier
With still , and the same relative mass , but now , hence relative energy 2, twice higher than the barrier, we show in Figure 3 the modulus of at times and , their peaks ranging from left to right. For graphical convenience, is multiplied by 0.8. Notice how, as soon as , the peaks seem to evolve under simple translation and spreading rules. We find and for and , respectively. At larger times, the entanglement again seems to reach a stable, asymptotic value.
Figure 3. Same parameters as for Fig.1, but now . Evolution of . From left to right, peaks at . Peak for scaled down by factor 0.8.
Case where the relative energy equals the height of the barrier
We retain the same barrier but here set . Hence, the relative particle is boosted at just the energy of the barrier top. We recover a situation where similar amounts of transfer and reflection coexist. The result for the density operator of particle 1 at time is shown on Figure 4. Particle 2 shows the same pattern under parity, naturally. The entanglement entropies for times and are found to be worth and , respectively. There is again a hint of an asymptotic behavior of .
Figure 4. Same parameters as for Fig.1, but now . Contour plot of the density operator of particle 1 at time .
Particles experiencing attraction
Now is an attractive pocket, , and we keep and . The contour plot of the density operator for particle 1 is shown, see Figure 5 for . Times and provide for the approximate values 1.0 and 1.2, respectively. Once more, values at further times seem to be compatible with an asymptotic stability of , see the next section.

Figure 5. Still and , but now . Contour plot of the density operator of particle 1 at time .
Preliminary conclusion
It turns out that, in all four cases, shows similar behaviors and orders of magnitude. As a typical example, we show in Figure 6 and Figure 7 the behaviors in time of and , respectively, for the second of our cases above, namely that where with the barrier, .

Figure 6. Evolution in time of the average separation for , and .
Figure 7. Same parameters as for Figure 6. Evolution in time of the entanglement entropy .
Entanglement at large times
It is intuitive, when is a finite range potential, that this potential becomes switched off when time increases. Indeed, while the positive boost used in our toy models makes the particles, initially separated by average distance , first approach each other and reach the interaction zone, separation occurs a little later. The separation degree of freedom is the relative variable, , naturally, and it is natural to estimate the separation by means of the averages, and , the former being driven by the velocity, , and the latter taking spreading into account. As soon as one of such averages reaches, say, one-and-a-half the range of , the collision can be considered as finished and can be considered as driven by only.. This suggests that is of first order in when grows infinite. The numerical estimates obtained from our various toy models confirm such a linear trend, see for example Figure 8, which shows linear trends for all our toy cases.

Figure 8. Full line, evolution in time of for our first toy illustration. Long dashes, moderate ones, small ones, the same evolution for our second, third and fourth numerical illustrations.
There is no doubt that experiences a switch off, and, therefore, that the various density operators of interest reach constant asymptotic entropies, defining an asymptotic .
Summary and conclusion
This work considers the non relativistic collision of two spinless particles. Different toy models allow the calculation of time dependent wave functions and density matrices, hence the calculation of the corresponding entropies. Our numerical evidence is that the entanglement entropy , as a function of time, increases monotonically and saturates, in a sigmoid pattern. This answers the question left open by the authors of [1] in their relativistic approach. We may conjecture that this sigmoid behavior holds for all collisions, but the necessary theorem remains to be proved.
A further result is the confirmation of [1] in that the orders of magnitude that we find for in the non relativistic approach are the same as those found in the relativistic one. Here again, however, a general theorem providing bounds for , if they exist, is missing.
Entropy Theorems
We recall here two simple theorems
Th 1: Unitary transforms leave the entropy invariant.
Let be any density operator. Its negentropy, , reads,
If the Hamiltonian is hermitian, the evolution operator, , is unitary. More generally, let be any unitary operator transforming into . The negentropy becomes
because of the cyclic invariance of the Trace operation. Hence, no change.
Another, trivial argument to state for this invariance is that the unitary transform modifies the eigenstates of and leaves its spectrum intact. For the sake of the argument, assume that this spectrum is made of a finite or infinite discrete set of eigenvalues . Hence the entropy, calculated as, , is obviously invariant if this spectrum is invariant.
Th 2: If the Hamiltonian is separable between particles 1 and 2, the one-body densities evolve independently.
In our models, remains separable concerning cm and rel motions even when . But we set now and . The Hamiltonian can contain both a kinetic energy and an external potential operators. The same holds for . The two-particle evolution operator, , then factorises as , with commuting factors and . The two-body density evolves in time as, .
Then, as a partial trace, the one-body density reads,
where we have again used the cyclic invariance of the Trace operation, to get rid of . A similar result clearly holds for the second density evolution, .
References
- [1]R. Peschanski and S. Seki, “Entanglement Entropy of Scattering Particles,” Phys. Lett. B 758 (2016), 89-92 [arXiv:1602.00720 [hep-th]].DOI
- [2]K. Mishima, M. Hayashi and S.H. Lin, “Entanglement in Scattering Processes,” Phys. Lett. A 333 (2004), 371-377 [arXiv:1602.00720 [hep-th]].
- [3]L. Harshman and G. Hutton, “Entanglement Generation in the Scattering of One-Dimensional Particles,” Phys. Rev. A 77 (2008), 042310 [arXiv:0710.5776 [quant-ph]].DOI
- [4]C. K. Law, “Entanglement production in colliding wave packets,” Phys. Rev. A 70 (2004), 062311.DOI
- [5]F. Schmusser and D. Janzing, “Entanglement generation via scattering of two particles with hard core repulsion,” Phys. Rev. A 73 (2006), 052313 [arXiv:0601177 [quant-ph]].




