betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The Alpha–Omega Problem in the Assessments of Atmospheric Power

Abstract

Atmospheric power is commonly assessed with two Lorenz-cycle formulations treated as equivalent: the αωαω formulation, yielding gas expansion power WωW_ω, and the v⋅∇z\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla z formulation, yielding kinetic-energy generation by horizontal pressure gradients, WKW_K. We show that, for a statistically stationary global moist atmosphere, Wω=WK+WP+WnhW_ω=W_K+W_P+W_{\rm nh}, where WPW_P is the power of lifting precipitating water and WnhW_{\rm nh} is power associated with departures from gas-phase hydrostatic balance. Since WP≃1W_P\simeq1 W m−2^{-2} globally, equality would require Wnh≃−WP<0W_{\rm nh}\simeq-W_P<0, so the associated vertical force imbalance would have to do negative work globally. Using six-hourly ERA5, JRA-3Q, and MERRA-2 fields for 2025, we find that resolved WωW_ω varies by a factor of 1.7 (1.9–3.2 W m−2^{-2}), versus 1.2 for WKW_K (2.4–2.8 W m−2^{-2}). Zonal-mean αωαω profiles have area-weighted contributions near ±50\pm50 W m−2^{-2}, making global WωW_ω a cancellation residual, whereas v⋅∇z\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla z profiles vary much less with latitude. The difference Wω−WKW_ω-W_K ranges from −0.61-0.61 to +0.87+0.87 W m−2^{-2}. Thus reanalysis-derived WωW_ω cannot provide an independent constraint on atmospheric power. Two treatments of the omitted surface layer give cross-reanalysis mean WKW_K of 2.8 and 3.1 W m−2^{-2}, with corrected values spanning 2.6–3.5 W m−2^{-2}. Both exceed the observation-based Lorenz available-potential-energy generation estimate of 1.2 W m−2^{-2}. Assuming Wnh≥0W_{\rm nh}\geq0, adding WP≃1W_P\simeq1 W m−2^{-2} gives total atmospheric power of about 3.8–4.1 W m−2^{-2}, motivating investigation of additional power-generation mechanisms.

Introduction

The rate at which the atmosphere generates mechanical power is a basic measure of its circulation intensity and provides a quantitative constraint on the mechanisms that maintain it. Published estimates of atmospheric power, however, differ substantially in magnitude and do not always refer to the same physical quantity.

Most quantitative estimates have been made within the Lorenz energy cycle (LEC) [16, 24, 1, 20, 11, 25] (Li, Ingersoll, Jiang, Feldman, & Yung 2007; Ma, Lembo, & Franzke 2021; Oh et al. 2026). In the Lorenz framework, differential diabatic heating generates available potential energy (APE), which is subsequently converted into kinetic energy by atmospheric motion. For a statistically stationary global atmosphere, the total generation of APE must balance its net conversion to kinetic energy. In the classical four-reservoir cycle, this net conversion is

WLEC≡C(PM,KM)+C(PE,KE).(1)W_{\mathrm{LEC}} \equiv C(P_M,K_M) + C(P_E,K_E). \tag*{(1)}

Here WLECW_{\mathrm{LEC}} is the global mean APE-to-kinetic-energy conversion rate per unit surface area; PMP_M and KMK_M are the zonal-mean APE and kinetic-energy reservoirs, respectively; PEP_E and KEK_E are the corresponding eddy APE and kinetic-energy reservoirs; and C(X,Y)C(X,Y) denotes the conversion rate from reservoir XX to reservoir YY. The corresponding APE generation is GLEC≡G(PM)+G(PE)G_{\mathrm{LEC}} \equiv G(P_M) + G(P_E), where G(PM)G(P_M) and G(PE)G(P_E) denote diabatic generation of zonal-mean and eddy APE, respectively. In statistical steady state the classical LEC requires GLEC=WLECG_{\mathrm{LEC}} = W_{\mathrm{LEC}}.

The conversion side of the LEC, WLECW_{\mathrm{LEC}}, has commonly been evaluated using two formulations. The first is the pressure-velocity form,

Wω=−1S∫Vω dV,ω≡DpDt,(2)W_\omega= -\frac{1}{S}\int_V \omega\,\mathrm{d}V,\qquad\omega\equiv\frac{Dp}{Dt}, \tag*{(2)}

where SS is Earth’s total surface area, VV is atmospheric volume, pp is air pressure, and D/DtD/Dt is the material derivative. For the statistically stationary global means considered here, with negligible pressure-work flux through the control boundary, this quantity represents gaseous expansion power. Under hydrostatic balance it can be written on pressure levels as

Wω=−1Sg∫S∫ptpsαω dp dS,(3)W_\omega= -\frac{1}{Sg}\int_S\int_{p_t}^{p_s}\alpha\omega\,\mathrm{d}p\,\mathrm{d}S, \tag*{(3)}

where α≡1/ρ\alpha\equiv1/\rho is the specific volume of gaseous air, ρ\rho is its density, gg is gravitational acceleration, SS denotes Earth’s surface, and ptp_t and psp_s are the top and surface pressures. (3) is the alpha–omega form commonly used in LEC calculations.

The second formulation gives the rate of kinetic-energy generation by horizontal pressure gradients,

WK=−1S∫Vu⋅∇p dV,(4)W_K = -\frac{1}{S}\int_V \mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla p\,\mathrm{d}V, \tag*{(4)}

where u\mathbf{u} is horizontal air velocity and ∇p\nabla p is the pressure gradient. Transforming the volume integral to pressure coordinates gives

WK=−1Sg∫S∫ptpsu⋅∇pΦ dp dS,(5)W_K = -\frac{1}{Sg}\int_S\int_{p_t}^{p_s}\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla_p\Phi\,\mathrm{d}p\,\mathrm{d}S, \tag*{(5)}

where ∇p\nabla_p denotes differentiation with respect to horizontal position at fixed pressure and Φ\Phi is geopotential. Unlike (3), this transformation does not require hydrostatic balance. (5) is commonly called the v⋅∇z\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla z formulation in the LEC literature, where v\mathbf{v} in this conventional label denotes horizontal velocity; here we denote horizontal velocity by u\mathbf{u}.

The generation and conversion sides of the cycle can in principle be estimated independently. APE generation can be diagnosed from atmospheric temperature and diabatic heating rates, the latter being constrained by radiative, sensible, and latent heat-flux fields. The conversion side is constrained by wind, pressure, geopotential, and temperature fields. Because global fields of diabatic heating are much less directly constrained observationally, most global LEC estimates have used the conversion side of the budget [29]. Reanalysis-based estimates of WLECW_{\mathrm{LEC}} from these pressure-level formulations are generally around 2–3 W m−2^{-2}, with appreciable dependence on dataset and methodology [20, 11] (Li et al. 2007; Ma et al. 2021; Oh et al. 2026). Outside the LEC framework, MERRA-based estimates include kinetic-energy generation by horizontal pressure gradients, WKW_K, of about 2.5 W m−2^{-2} [7], and a moist-atmospheric heat-engine work output of about 3.7 W m−2^{-2} [14]. In contrast, the observation-based APE-generation components reported by Romanski and Rossow [29] sum to only GLEC=1.23G_{\mathrm{LEC}} = 1.23 W m−2^{-2}. Whether these differences reflect distinct physical components of atmospheric power or differences among the diagnostics is therefore a basic issue for interpreting the atmospheric energy budget.

For a statistically stationary dry hydrostatic atmosphere obeying source-free continuity, complete global integration with consistent boundaries gives Wω=WKW_\omega= W_K [16, 28]. The two expressions have therefore generally been treated as equivalent formulations of the same Lorenz conversion. Nevertheless, discrepancies between their empirical estimates, of varying magnitude, have been noted and discussed in several contexts when analyzing pressure-level reanalysis data. Li et al. (2007) identified reanalysis pressure vertical velocity ω\omega as having relatively low data quality and, to take advantage of the higher data quality of horizontal velocity, transformed C(PM,KM)C(P_M, K_M) and C(PE,KE)C(P_E, K_E) into horizontal-wind form using the continuity equation. Marques et al. [20] found the two formulations to be comparable only when below-ground pressure-level data were excluded from the calculations. Y.-H. Kim and Kim [11] obtained broadly comparable global conversions using the alpha–omega and horizontal-wind formulations, although differences remained among individual conversion terms.

Thus, these discrepancies have generally been interpreted as arising from data quality or implementation rather than from a failure of the underlying equivalence. Using an ECMWF forecast model, Steinheimer et al. [30] characterized the two formulations as hydrostatically equivalent, compared them in selected cases, and found their global averages identical within error margins, although without reporting this analysis in detail. They then employed the alpha–omega formulation exclusively. As discussed below, however, such a comparison is itself conditioned by the continuity equation used by the model to determine ω\omega. In the most recent multi-reanalysis assessment, Oh et al. (2026) likewise described the two formulations as theoretically equivalent when globally integrated, but noted that the alpha–omega formulation is more sensitive to uncertainty because of inaccuracies in reanalysis ω\omega and therefore adopted the v⋅∇z\mathbf{v} \cdot\nabla z formulation.

More serious inconsistencies appear in the alpha–omega estimates themselves. From the conversion components reported by W.-M. Kim and Choi [10], the net APE-to-kinetic-energy conversion is −3.54 W m−2-3.54\ \mathrm{W\ m^{-2}} for NCEP2 but +3.00 W m−2+3.00\ \mathrm{W\ m^{-2}} for ERA-Interim. Independently, Makarieva et al. [18] likewise obtained negative global pressure-velocity power from NCAR/NCEP and positive from MERRA. Thus alpha–omega estimates can differ even in sign among reanalyses, whereas the horizontal-wind formulation is substantially more robust.

These results expose two distinct questions. First, are the alpha–omega and horizontal-wind formulations physically equivalent in a moist atmosphere? Second, what relation should be expected between the two diagnostics when they are evaluated from reanalysis fields whose mass-continuity equation, archived fields, and subsequent mass corrections need not reproduce physical gaseous-air continuity?

The first question is theoretical. The usual transformation between Eqs. (2) and (4) uses source-free continuity. In gaseous moist air, evaporation and condensation are sources and sinks of gas mass, and the vertical pressure gradient need not equal the weight of gaseous air alone. For a statistically stationary global control volume, we derive

Wω=WK+WP+Wnh,(6)W_\omega= W_K + W_P + W_{nh}, \tag*{(6)}

where WPW_P is the gravitational power associated with lifting water that subsequently leaves the gas phase and WnhW_{nh} is the power associated with departure from gas-phase hydrostatic balance. The dry hydrostatic equality is recovered when both terms vanish.

The second question concerns the continuity equation actually associated with the reanalysis fields. Model pressure velocity is tied to the mass variable and source convention of the underlying dynamical system, which need not coincide with physical gaseous-air continuity. Archived fields can acquire additional continuity inconsistencies through assimilation, interpolation, and temporal sampling, while postprocessing procedures may impose physical dry-air conservation and reconstruct ω\omega from the corrected mass fluxes. Agreement or disagreement between the two reanalysis diagnostics therefore need not constitute a direct measurement of the physical terms in Eq. (6).

This distinction is especially important because the global alpha–omega integral is a small residual of much larger positive and negative contributions. Steinheimer et al. [30] showed strong cancellation between these contributions, so spatially structured changes in ω\omega can be small relative to the local terms yet large relative to the global residual.

Finite resolution introduces a further distinction between archived and total physical power. Pressure-level fields omit kinetic-energy generation by motions below their spatial and temporal resolution. They also omit the real partial layer between the lowest valid pressure surface and the ground. This can be consequential because prominent kinetic-energy generation occurs in the lower atmosphere [7], while our calculations below show a pronounced maximum near the surface.

Section 2 derives the relation between WωW_{\omega} and WKW_{\mathrm{K}} for gaseous moist air, including nonhydrostatic vertical-force work. Section 3 examines how the mass-continuity conventions of reanalysis systems, continuity errors in archived fields, and subsequent mass corrections affect the relation between the two resolved diagnostics. Sections 4 and 5 evaluate both diagnostics from six-hourly ERA5, JRA-3Q, and MERRA-2 pressure-level fields for 2025. The analysis is designed to determine which differences between published power estimates reflect atmospheric physics and which reflect the construction and conditioning of the diagnostic.

Atmospheric power with phase changes and nonhydrostatic motion

The relation between Eqs. (2) and (4) follows from mass continuity and vertical force balance. Let v=u+wez\boldsymbol{v}=\boldsymbol{u}+w\boldsymbol{e}_{z} be the gas-phase velocity, where ww is vertical velocity, ez\boldsymbol{e}_{z} is the upward unit vector, and zz is height. Since ω=∂p/∂t+v⋅∇p\omega=\partial p/\partial t+\boldsymbol{v}\cdot\nabla p,

Wω=W−Bp,W≡−1S∫Vv⋅∇p dV,Bp≡1S∫V∂p∂t dV,(7)W_{\omega}=W-B_{p},\qquad W\equiv-\frac{1}{\mathcal{S}}\int_{V}\boldsymbol{v}\cdot\nabla p\,\mathrm{d}V,\qquad B_{p}\equiv\frac{1}{\mathcal{S}}\int_{V}\frac{\partial p}{\partial t}\,\mathrm{d}V, \tag*{(7)}

where WW is total pressure-gradient power and BpB_{p} is pressure storage. Splitting WW into horizontal and vertical parts gives

W=WK−1S∫Vw∂p∂z dV.(8)W=W_{\mathrm{K}}-\frac{1}{\mathcal{S}}\int_{V}w\frac{\partial p}{\partial z}\,\mathrm{d}V. \tag*{(8)}

Gaseous moist air obeys

∂ρ∂t+∇⋅(ρv)=ρ˙,(9)\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot(\rho\boldsymbol{v})=\dot{\rho}, \tag*{(9)}

where ρ˙\dot{\rho} is the gas-phase mass source, positive for evaporation and negative for condensation. Multiplication by gzgz and integration over the atmosphere gives

1S∫Vρgw dV=WP+Bg,(10)\frac{1}{\mathcal{S}}\int_{V}\rho g w\,\mathrm{d}V=W_{\mathrm{P}}+B_{g}, \tag*{(10)}

with

WP≡−1S∫Vgzρ˙ dV,Bg≡1Sddt∫Vρgz dV+1S∫∂Vρgzv⋅n dS,(11)W_{\mathrm{P}}\equiv-\frac{1}{\mathcal{S}}\int_{V}gz\dot{\rho}\,\mathrm{d}V,\qquad B_{g}\equiv\frac{1}{\mathcal{S}}\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\int_{V}\rho gz\,\mathrm{d}V+\frac{1}{\mathcal{S}}\int_{\partial V}\rho gz\boldsymbol{v}\cdot\boldsymbol{n}\,\mathrm{d}S, \tag*{(11)}

where BgB_{g} contains gaseous gravitational-energy storage and boundary fluxes, ∂V\partial V is the control-volume boundary, and n\boldsymbol{n} is its outward unit normal. For the global atmospheric volume, the boundary-flux term vanishes at the surface because z=0z=0 and at the top of the atmosphere as atmospheric mass tends to zero.

For a statistically stationary global water cycle, let PP be the global-mean precipitation mass flux and define the effective source–sink height

HP=−1PS∫Vzρ˙ dV.(12)H_P=-\frac{1}{PS}\int_V z\dot{\rho}\,\mathrm{d}V. \tag*{(12)}

Then

WP=gPHP.(13)W_P=gPH_P. \tag*{(13)}

When evaporation occurs predominantly near the surface, HPH_P can be interpreted as an effective mean height of removal of water from the gas phase.

Define the departure from gas-phase hydrostatic balance by

fnh≡−∂p∂z−ρg,(14)f_{\mathrm{nh}}\equiv-\frac{\partial p}{\partial z}-\rho g, \tag*{(14)}

and let Wnh≡S−1∫Vwfnh dVW_{\mathrm{nh}}\equiv S^{-1}\int_V w f_{\mathrm{nh}}\,\mathrm{d}V. Combining Eqs. (7), (8), and (10) gives

Wω=WK+WP+Wnh+B,B≡Bg−Bp.(15)W_\omega=W_K+W_P+W_{\mathrm{nh}}+B,\qquad B\equiv B_g-B_p. \tag*{(15)}

For a statistically stationary global control volume, B=0B=0, giving Eq. (6).

Here WnhW_{\mathrm{nh}} measures the global work done by departures from gas-phase hydrostatic balance. Condensate loading may contribute to this departure, but no decomposition of WnhW_{\mathrm{nh}} is required here. If WK>WωW_K>W_\omega while WP>0W_P>0 and BB is negligible, then Wnh<−WPW_{\mathrm{nh}}<-W_P; this global condition does not imply negative buoyancy everywhere.

Pressure can be used as a vertical coordinate without assuming hydrostatic balance, provided that pp is monotonic with height. Define the pressure-to-height Jacobian

Jp≡−(∂z∂p)x,y,t>0.(16)J_p\equiv-\left(\frac{\partial z}{\partial p}\right)_{x,y,t}>0. \tag*{(16)}

Then dV=Jp dp dS\mathrm{d}V=J_p\,\mathrm{d}p\,\mathrm{d}S, and the volume-integral expansion power becomes

Wω=−1S∫S∫ptpsJpω dp dS.(17)W_\omega=-\frac{1}{S}\int_S\int_{p_t}^{p_s}J_p\omega\,\mathrm{d}p\,\mathrm{d}S. \tag*{(17)}

From Eq. (14),

Jp=1ρg+fnh.(18)J_p=\frac{1}{\rho g+f_{\mathrm{nh}}}. \tag*{(18)}

Only under gas-phase hydrostatic balance, fnh=0f_{\mathrm{nh}}=0, does Jp=α/gJ_p=\alpha/g, reducing Eq. (17) to the conventional alpha–omega expression.

By contrast, the pressure-coordinate representation of WKW_K does not require hydrostatic balance. Implicit differentiation of p(x,y,z,t)=pp(x,y,z,t)=p at fixed pressure gives

∇zp=−∂p∂z∇pz,(19)\nabla_zp=-\frac{\partial p}{\partial z}\nabla_pz, \tag*{(19)}

where ∇z\nabla_z denotes the horizontal gradient at fixed height. Since Jp=−(∂p/∂z)−1J_p=-(\partial p/\partial z)^{-1}, the Jacobian cancels:

Jp∇zp=∇pz.(20)J_p\nabla_zp=\nabla_pz. \tag*{(20)}

Therefore

WK=−1S∫S∫ptpsu⋅∇pz dp dS=−1Sg∫S∫ptpsu⋅∇pΦ dp dS.(21)W_K=-\frac{1}{S}\int_S\int_{p_t}^{p_s}\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla_pz\,\mathrm{d}p\,\mathrm{d}S =-\frac{1}{Sg}\int_S\int_{p_t}^{p_s}\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla_p\Phi\,\mathrm{d}p\,\mathrm{d}S. \tag*{(21)}

The same distinction appears in mass continuity. In general pressure coordinates, define the mass Jacobian

μp≡ρJp.(22)\mu_p\equiv\rho J_p. \tag*{(22)}

(9) then becomes

∂μp∂t+∇p⋅(μpu)+∂(μpω)∂p=Jpρ˙.(23)\frac{\partial\mu_p}{\partial t}+\nabla_p\cdot(\mu_p\mathbf{u})+\frac{\partial(\mu_p\omega)}{\partial p}=J_p\dot{\rho}. \tag*{(23)}

Under hydrostatic balance, Jp=α/gJ_p=\alpha/g and μp=1/g\mu_p=1/g, so that Eq. (23) reduces to

∇p⋅u+∂ω∂p=αρ˙.(24)\nabla_p\cdot\mathbf{u}+\frac{\partial\omega}{\partial p}=\alpha\dot{\rho}. \tag*{(24)}

Vertical integration with consistent boundary terms then reproduces Wω=WK+WP+BW_\omega=W_K+W_P+B, the hydrostatic limit of Eq. (15).

Thus departures from hydrostatic balance affect the two pressure-coordinate diagnostics asymmetrically. They invalidate the conventional αω\alpha\omega representation of WωW_\omega by changing the pressure-to-volume Jacobian, whereas the corresponding Jacobian cancels identically in the pressure-coordinate representation of WKW_K. The three reanalyses analyzed below employ hydrostatic dynamical cores, so this additional distinction does not affect the internal evaluation of their pressure-level diagnostics; it becomes relevant when these diagnostics are interpreted as measures of power in the actual atmosphere or applied to nonhydrostatic model output. Accordingly, these hydrostatic reanalyses cannot independently diagnose the actual atmospheric WnhW_{\mathrm{nh}}. In the comparisons below, WnhW_{\mathrm{nh}} enters through the physical identity for the atmosphere, not as a resolved reanalysis diagnostic.

Hydrostaticity therefore removes the Jacobian ambiguity for the reanalyses, but it does not remove a separate numerical issue: the alpha–omega diagnostic is strongly cancellation dominated. This follows from the same vertical pressure-work decomposition used above. Under hydrostatic balance,

−αω=gw−α(∂p∂t+u⋅∇zp).(25)-\alpha\omega=gw-\alpha\left(\frac{\partial p}{\partial t}+\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla_zp\right). \tag*{(25)}

Thus −αω-\alpha\omega contains the mass-specific vertical pressure-gradient work gwgw, which changes sign between ascent and subsidence. Yet Eq. (10) constrains its global mass-weighted integral to WP+BgW_P+B_g. Large positive and negative vertical-work contributions must therefore nearly cancel in the global mean. This cancellation is distinct from the physical difference between WωW_\omega and WKW_K in Eq. (15); it persists even in a dry hydrostatic atmosphere.

The severity of this cancellation reflects the disparity between vertical and horizontal pressure gradients. A characteristic vertical gradient is

∣∂p∂z∣∼psH∼104 Pa km−1,(26)\left|\frac{\partial p}{\partial z}\right|\sim\frac{p_s}{H}\sim10^4\ \mathrm{Pa\ km^{-1}}, \tag*{(26)}

where HH is a pressure scale height, whereas a large-scale horizontal pressure gradient is typically of order 1 Pa km−11\ \mathrm{Pa\ km^{-1}}. Even with ∣w∣/∣u∣∼10−2|w|/|u|\sim10^{-2}, local vertical pressure-gradient power density can exceed its horizontal counterpart by about two orders of magnitude.

Unresolved motions and resolved mass continuity

The preceding section showed that, in the physical atmosphere, Eq. (15) relates Wω−WKW_\omega-W_K to WPW_P, WnhW_{\mathrm{nh}}, and the storage and boundary term BB. Since Eq. (11) expresses WPW_P as the geopotential moment of the gas-phase mass source ρ˙\dot{\rho}, the source or sink in gaseous mass continuity enters the difference between the two power formulations directly. In the hydrostatic limit, the physical difference between WωW_\omega and WKW_K therefore depends on this mass source, apart from storage and boundary terms.

The pressure velocity in a model or reanalysis, however, is tied to the continuity equation of its resolved dynamical system rather than directly to Eq. (24). To distinguish the two, let a superscript r denote resolved model or reanalysis fields, without implying a Reynolds averaging operation, and write their hydrostatic pressure-coordinate continuity equation schematically as

∇p⋅ur+∂ωr∂p=Sr,(27)\nabla_p \cdot\mathbf{u}^{r} + \frac{\partial\omega^{r}}{\partial p} = S^{r}, \tag*{(27)}

where SrS^{r} is the source term represented in the continuity equation that determines the resolved mass transport. If the mass variable were gaseous air and its physical source were represented, then Sr=αrρ˙rS^{r} = \alpha^{r}\dot{\rho}^{r}. More generally this need not be the case.

For a hydrostatic set of resolved fields whose pressure, mass measure, velocity, and continuity equation are internally consistent, the same integration used in § 2 gives

Wωr=WKr+WSr+Br,WSr≡−1Sg∫S∫ptpsΦrSr dp dS,(28)W_{\omega}^{r} = W_{K}^{r} + W_{S}^{r} + B^{r}, \qquad W_{S}^{r} \equiv-\frac{1}{S_g}\int_{S}\int_{p_t}^{p_s}\Phi^{r}S^{r}\,\mathrm{d}p\,\mathrm{d}S, \tag*{(28)}

where BrB^{r} denotes the corresponding storage and boundary contributions. Only when Sr=αrρ˙rS^{r} = \alpha^{r}\dot{\rho}^{r} does WSrW_{S}^{r} have the meaning of a resolved gaseous WPW_{P}. In particular, a source-free model continuity equation has WSr=0W_{S}^{r} = 0 and, apart from boundary and storage terms, restores the conventional hydrostatic equivalence of the two resolved diagnostics.

The distinction is explicit in the ECMWF Integrated Forecasting System (IFS). In the standard IFS formulation used before Cycle 46R1, the dynamical continuity equation conserves total atmospheric mass rather than dry-air mass [19]. Physical parameterizations can nevertheless change total atmospheric water through surface exchange, precipitation, and subgrid transport. Because these water-mass changes are not coupled to the standard dynamical continuity equation, they imply equal and opposite changes of dry-air mass, so that the total atmospheric mass source remains zero. Writing SwS_w for such a total-water source or sink, the implied constituent bookkeeping is schematically

Sdart=−Sw,St=Sw+Sdart=0.(29)S_d^{\mathrm{art}} = -S_w, \qquad S_t = S_w + S_d^{\mathrm{art}} = 0. \tag*{(29)}

Internal phase changes among the model water species cancel in the total-water budget, so Eq. (29) should not be interpreted as an artificial dry-air source accompanying every condensation event. Its relevance here is that the source-free total-mass continuity equation used by the dynamical core does not contain the physical gas-phase source in Eq. (24).

This distinction provides a natural interpretation of the equivalence reported by Steinheimer et al. [30]. Their calculations used IFS Cycle 32R3; for selected cases they evaluated both the αω\alpha\omega and V⋅∇Φ\mathbf{V} \cdot\nabla\Phi formulations and found their global values identical within error margins. Since the dry-mass-conserving IFS continuity formulation was introduced only in Cycle 46R1 [19], their Cycle 32R3 calculation used the earlier source-free total-mass formulation. We infer that the reported agreement is consistent with the model’s source-free total-mass continuity constraint, provided that the pressure-work variables and mass measure used in the comparison were internally consistent with that continuity equation. It therefore does not establish physical gas-phase equivalence of the two formulations. ERA5 was produced with IFS Cycle 41R2 [6] and likewise predates the dry-mass-conserving formulation.

JRA-3Q has a closely related structure. It is based on a TL479 version of JMA’s global numerical weather prediction system as of December 2018 [13]. In the JMA Global Spectral Model, the specific-humidity and cloud-water equations contain tendencies from parameterized processes, whereas the pressure-mass continuity equation has a zero right-hand side. Pressure velocity ω\omega is obtained by integrating this source-free continuity equation [8]. Thus model physics can change atmospheric water variables without the corresponding gas-phase source appearing in the continuity equation that determines ω\omega. Accordingly, a model-output category such as “large-scale” or “resolved” precipitation is not equivalent to a resolved ρ˙\dot{\rho} in Eq. (24).

MERRA-2 uses a different mass-budget convention. GEOS-5 was modified so that sources and sinks of atmospheric water enter the atmospheric mass budget while globally integrated dry atmospheric mass is conserved (Takacs, Suárez, & Todling, [31]). This avoids the compensating dry-air variations implied when total atmospheric mass is held fixed despite changes in water mass. Nevertheless, this is a continuity budget for total model atmospheric mass, not the gas-phase continuity equation of Eq. (9). In particular, phase changes between water vapor and suspended cloud condensate do not change total atmospheric mass, whereas conversion of suspended condensate to precipitation and re-evaporation of precipitation do enter the MERRA-2 mass source (Takacs et al., [31]). The three reanalyses therefore need not encode the physical gaseous source ρ˙\dot{\rho} in the same way, even before any further processing of their archived fields.

The distinction between physical and model continuity is separate from another well-known problem: archived analysis fields need not satisfy the intended continuity constraint exactly. Such inconsistencies can arise from data assimilation, interpolation from model to pressure levels, temporal sampling, lower-boundary treatment, and other processing. Trenberth [32] found large continuity residuals in pressure-level ECMWF analyses and showed that postprocessing of the analyzed fields can substantially disrupt mass consistency. Subsequent work developed corrections of the analyzed velocity field designed to restore mass conservation ([34, 33]).

The target of these corrections is physically motivated rather than an arbitrary numerical closure condition. In the usual approximation that suspended condensate is neglected in the column mass budget, define the column masses of water vapor and dry air by

Mv≡1g∫0psqv dp,Md≡psg−Mv,(30)M_v \equiv\frac{1}{g}\int_{0}^{p_s} q_v\,\mathrm{d}p,\qquad M_d \equiv\frac{p_s}{g}-M_v, \tag*{(30)}

and the corresponding horizontal mass fluxes by

Fv≡1g∫0psqvu dp,Fd≡1g∫0ps(1−qv)u dp.(31)\mathbf{F}_v \equiv\frac{1}{g}\int_{0}^{p_s} q_v\mathbf{u}\,\mathrm{d}p,\qquad\mathbf{F}_d \equiv\frac{1}{g}\int_{0}^{p_s}(1-q_v)\mathbf{u}\,\mathrm{d}p. \tag*{(31)}

Physical dry-air conservation and the atmospheric water budget require

∂Md∂t+∇⋅Fd=0,∂Mv∂t+∇⋅Fv=E−P.(32)\frac{\partial M_d}{\partial t}+\boldsymbol{\nabla}\cdot\mathbf{F}_d=0,\qquad\frac{\partial M_v}{\partial t}+\boldsymbol{\nabla}\cdot\mathbf{F}_v=E-P. \tag*{(32)}

Adding the two equations gives the corresponding physical column mass budget,

1g∂ps∂t+∇⋅(1g∫0psu dp)=E−P.(33)\frac{1}{g}\frac{\partial p_s}{\partial t}+\boldsymbol{\nabla}\cdot\left(\frac{1}{g}\int_{0}^{p_s}\mathbf{u}\,\mathrm{d}p\right)=E-P. \tag*{(33)}

Thus dry-air mass is conserved, whereas total atmospheric mass changes with the net surface exchange of water. The dry-air constraint can be imposed without prescribing EE and PP themselves; together with the moisture budget it makes the inferred mass balance consistent with, and testable against, independent estimates of E−PE-P.

This distinction is especially relevant when the native model and the postprocessed analysis obey different constraints. A field can be internally consistent with a model continuity equation that conserves total mass and yet fail the physical dry-air constraint in Eq. (32). Conversely, even a model with a physically consistent treatment of dry and water mass can acquire additional continuity residuals through assimilation and archival processing. A diagnosed continuity residual therefore need not have a single origin.

For uncorrected analysis fields, let

Rd≡∂Mda∂t+∇⋅Fda,(34)R_{\mathrm{d}} \equiv\frac{\partial M_{\mathrm{d}}^{a}}{\partial t} + \nabla\cdot\mathbf{F}_{\mathrm{d}}^{a}, \tag*{(34)}

where the superscript a denotes the original analysis. A common correction is to add a height-independent horizontal velocity δu\delta\mathbf{u} so that the corrected dry-air flux satisfies Eq. (32). For such a barotropic correction,

∇⋅(Mdaδu)=−Rd.(35)\nabla\cdot\left(M_{\mathrm{d}}^{a}\delta\mathbf{u}\right) = -R_{\mathrm{d}}. \tag*{(35)}

Equation (35) represents a simple column-barotropic correction; more complete three-dimensional adjustment procedures have also been developed [34]. The column continuity constraint fixes the divergence of the required mass-flux correction, but it does not uniquely specify a three-dimensional correction to the wind field. The choice of a barotropic correction, a vertically varying correction, or additional constraints on the correction therefore introduces information beyond mass conservation itself [32, 34].

Pressure velocity can subsequently be reconstructed by vertically integrating the local continuity equation satisfied by the corrected fields. In general, if the imposed pressure-coordinate continuity has source ScS^{c},

ωc(p)=ωc(pt)+∫ptp[Sc−∇p′⋅uc] dp′.(36)\omega^{c}(p) = \omega^{c}(p_{\mathrm{t}}) + \int_{p_{\mathrm{t}}}^{p} \left[S^{c} - \nabla_{p}^{\prime} \cdot\mathbf{u}^{c}\right] \,\mathrm{d}p^{\prime}. \tag*{(36)}

The column correction makes the upper and lower boundary conditions compatible, but the resulting ωc\omega^{c} depends on both the continuity equation being imposed and the procedure used to correct the horizontal mass fluxes.

The role of such a correction is explicit in the calculation of Laliberté et al. [14]. Their remapping of CESM fields and data assimilation in MERRA left small continuity errors that could become significant in energy-flux calculations. They therefore applied a barotropic correction to the horizontal winds and recovered ω\omega by integrating the corrected continuity equation, imposing vanishing ω\omega at both the upper and lower boundaries. Their αω\alpha\omega diagnostic is consequently a quantity conditioned by the imposed mass-continuity procedure rather than a diagnostic based directly on an independently archived pressure-velocity field.

There are therefore two conceptually distinct ways in which reanalysis fields can depart from the physical gaseous continuity equation used in § 2. First, the underlying model can employ a mass variable and source convention that differ from physical gaseous-air continuity, as in the source-free total-mass formulations discussed above. Second, assimilation, interpolation, temporal sampling, lower-boundary treatment, and other processing can introduce additional continuity residuals into the archived fields. A subsequent mass correction may restore an intended physical conservation constraint, but it does not uniquely reconstruct the unknown three-dimensional error in the original velocity field.

These distinctions are especially important for WωW_{\omega}. As shown in § 2, the alpha–omega diagnostic is strongly cancellation dominated, so comparatively small structured changes in ω\omega can produce substantial changes in its global integral. Corrections to horizontal winds can also alter WKW_{K}, but WKW_{K} is not reconstructed by vertically integrating a continuity residual and is not intrinsically subject to the same ascent–subsidence cancellation. Consequently, the reanalysis difference Wω−WKW_{\omega} - W_{K} can reflect the mass-continuity convention of the underlying model, residual inconsistencies in archived fields, and any subsequent mass correction, in addition to the physical terms appearing in Eq. (15). Depending on how continuity and pressure velocity are treated, the resulting WωW_{\omega}, and especially its difference from WKW_{K}, can therefore vary substantially among reanalyses. This behavior is examined directly for ERA5, JRA-3Q, and MERRA-2 in the following section.

Data and methods

We use MERRA-2 [4], ERA5 [6], and JRA-3Q [13]. Their different models, assimilation systems, grids, and vertical discretizations provide a test of inter-reanalysis robustness. We analyze the full calendar year 2025 at 1460 common six-hourly times, applying identical processing to all three reanalyses for a structural intercomparison of the two power diagnostics.

We use pressure-level zonal and meridional wind, geopotential or geopotential height, pressure vertical velocity, temperature, and specific humidity, together with surface pressure. The files analyzed here contain 37 pressure levels from 1000 to 1 hPa for ERA5, 42 levels from 1000 to 0.1 hPa for MERRA-2, and 45 levels from 1000 to 0.01 hPa for JRA-3Q. Product-specific fill values are converted to missing values before a common physical mask is applied.

Because the three products extend to different upper pressure levels, we also tested a common upper boundary at 1 hPa. Truncation at 1 hPa changes WKW_K by 0.008 W m−2^{-2} for MERRA-2 and 0.031 W m−2^{-2} for JRA-3Q, and changes WωW_\omega by 0.002 and 0.010 W m−2^{-2}, respectively. These differences do not affect the conclusions.

Moist specific volume is calculated from virtual temperature,

αv=RdT(1+0.608q)p,Rd=287.05 J kg−1 K−1,(37)\alpha_v = \frac{R_d T(1 + 0.608q)}{p}, \qquad R_d = 287.05\ \mathrm{J\,kg^{-1}\,K^{-1}}, \tag*{(37)}

where TT is temperature, qq is specific humidity, pp is pressure in pascals, and RdR_d is the gas constant of dry air. The local alpha–omega power per unit mass is

cαω=−αvω.(38)c_{\alpha\omega} = -\alpha_v\omega. \tag*{(38)}

On each reanalysis latitude–longitude grid, kinetic-energy generation by horizontal pressure gradients per unit mass is

k=−uacos⁡ϕ∂Φ∂λ−va∂Φ∂ϕ,(39)k = -\frac{u}{a\cos\phi}\frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial\lambda} - \frac{v}{a}\frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial\phi}, \tag*{(39)}

where uu and vv are zonal and meridional wind, aa is Earth’s radius, λ\lambda is longitude, ϕ\phi is latitude, and Φ\Phi is geopotential. Longitude derivatives use a periodic centered difference. For ERA5 and MERRA-2, centered latitude differences are used and the geographic pole rows are excluded. JRA-3Q is supplied on nonuniform Gaussian latitudes; its meridional derivative uses a second-order three-point formula on the actual latitude coordinates, with one-sided three-point formulas at the two polewardmost Gaussian rows. A value of kk is retained only when the central point and all four derivative-stencil points are finite and above the local surface. Geopotential height, where supplied, is converted using Φ=gz\Phi= gz.

For WKW_K, this five-point requirement can raise the effective lowest usable pressure level above that determined by the local surface pressure alone. A central point can itself lie above the surface while one or more neighboring points required for the derivative lie below terrain. This additional masking does not arise for cαωc_{\alpha\omega}, whose evaluation requires no horizontal derivative stencil. For all three reanalyses, we quantify the stencil effect by recording, at each pressure level, the area-weighted fraction for which the central point is valid, the fraction for which the full five-point stencil is valid, their difference, and the fraction of center-valid area retained by the stencil. The additional global area excluded by the stencil is confined mainly to the lowest pressure levels: its maximum annual-mean value is 2.1% in ERA5, 2.7% in JRA-3Q, and 3.6% in MERRA-2, in all cases at 975 hPa. At 1000 hPa, the stencil retains 97.0%, 95.9%, and 94.4% of the center-valid area, respectively. The additional loss falls below 0.5% of global area by 750 hPa and is negligible by 500 hPa. These quantities are averaged over the 1460 six-hourly analysis times.

For either x=cαωx=c_{\alpha\omega} or x=kx=k, complete archived layers are integrated as

Cxres=∑i=1N−1xi+xi+12pi−pi+1g,(40)C_x^{\mathrm{res}}=\sum_{i=1}^{N-1}\frac{x_i+x_{i+1}}{2}\frac{p_i-p_{i+1}}{g}, \tag*{(40)}

where NN is the number of ordered pressure levels and ii is the level index. A layer is used only when both bounding values are finite and both pressures satisfy pi≤psp_i \le p_s.

For WKW_K, the pressure-level and stencil masks leave an unresolved interval between the lowest valid level p1p_1 and surface pressure psp_s. We estimate the sensitivity to this interval in two ways. First, as a zero-surface sensitivity construction, we set ks=0k_s=0 and connect this value linearly to the lowest valid value k1k_1, giving

CK,0surf=k12ps−p1g.(41)C_{K,0}^{\mathrm{surf}}=\frac{k_1}{2}\frac{p_s-p_1}{g}. \tag*{(41)}

This construction provides a simple zero-surface treatment against which the linear extrapolation below can be compared.

As a second estimate, we linearly extrapolate kk from the two lowest valid levels, p1>p2p_1>p_2,

kslin=k1+k1−k2p1−p2(ps−p1),(42)k_s^{\mathrm{lin}}=k_1+\frac{k_1-k_2}{p_1-p_2}(p_s-p_1), \tag*{(42)}

and calculate

CK,linsurf=k1+kslin2ps−p1g.(43)C_{K,\mathrm{lin}}^{\mathrm{surf}}=\frac{k_1+k_s^{\mathrm{lin}}}{2}\frac{p_s-p_1}{g}. \tag*{(43)}

Where a second valid lower level is unavailable, the zero-surface estimate (41) is used instead. The two treatments characterize the sensitivity of WKW_K to the unresolved near-surface layer without assuming that either reproduces its detailed vertical structure.

We do not include an analogous surface-layer correction in the reported WωW_\omega. Unlike kk, the alpha–omega power density has no natural zero boundary value. At the lower boundary, pressure velocity satisfies

ωs=DspsDt=∂ps∂t+us⋅∇ps,(44)\omega_s=\frac{D_sp_s}{Dt}=\frac{\partial p_s}{\partial t}+\boldsymbol{u}_s\cdot\nabla p_s, \tag*{(44)}

and is therefore generally nonzero at the surface. Consequently, cαω,s=−αv,sωsc_{\alpha\omega,s}=-\alpha_{v,s}\omega_s has no corresponding natural zero-surface prescription. Nor is there a physical reason to assume that the strongly sign-varying cαωc_{\alpha\omega} field varies linearly from its lowest archived pressure level to the surface. We therefore report WωW_\omega for complete archived pressure layers only, avoiding an additional lower-boundary assumption in this already cancellation-dominated diagnostic. Alternative surface constructions, where calculated, are retained only as numerical sensitivity tests and do not define the reported WωW_\omega.

Annual global means are obtained by summing the vertically integrated column contributions with grid-cell-area weighting and dividing by the total surface area SS; the normalization is therefore not changed by terrain or stencil masking. Masked contributions are treated as unresolved rather than by renormalizing the remaining valid area. For JRA-3Q, grid-cell areas are evaluated using the supplied Gaussian quadrature weights. Zonal means are formed analogously within each latitude band. Vertical profiles are annual global means of the archived layer contributions. Robustness is assessed from synchronized six-hourly correlations, the partition above and below 500 hPa, and signed latitude profiles.

OpenAI ChatGPT was used as an interactive assistant for manuscript editing, checking mathematical derivations and analysis code, and reference verification.

Results

Global integrals

Table 1 summarizes the 2025 annual means. On complete archived layers, WKres=2.36W_K^{\mathrm{res}} = 2.36, 2.48, and 2.84 W m−2^{-2} in ERA5, JRA-3Q, and MERRA-2, respectively. With the zero-surface treatment ks=0k_s = 0, the omitted surface layer adds 0.23, 0.24, and 0.27 W m−2^{-2}, giving totals of 2.59, 2.72, and 3.12 W m−2^{-2} and a cross-reanalysis mean of 2.81 W m−2^{-2}. Linear extrapolation gives larger surface contributions of 0.51, 0.54, and 0.63 W m−2^{-2}, corresponding to totals of 2.87, 3.02, and 3.47 W m−2^{-2} and a cross-reanalysis mean of 3.12 W m−2^{-2}.

For comparison, Table 1 also gives the 1980–2023 mean resolved WKW_K values calculated from the conversion components reported by Oh et al. (2026). They agree closely with the 2025 archived-layer values obtained here for all three reanalyses.

The alpha–omega diagnostic varies more strongly. Its archived-layer means are 3.23, 1.87, and 2.94 W m−2^{-2}, while the corresponding values after linear surface extrapolation are 2.53, 1.28, and 3.20 W m−2^{-2}. The cross-reanalysis range therefore increases from 1.36 to 1.92 W m−2^{-2}. Pairwise correlations of the synchronized six-hourly WKW_K series are 0.92–0.96 with ks=0k_s = 0 and 0.93–0.96 with linear extrapolation, compared with 0.69–0.77 for linearly extrapolated WωW_\omega.

Latitudinal structure and cancellation

The annual zonal-mean profiles reveal the contrasting numerical conditioning (Figure 1). Kinetic-energy generation by horizontal pressure gradients is positive through almost the entire latitude range and closely agrees among the three products. After area weighting, its positive latitude-band contributions are 2.37–2.85 W m−2^{-2}, while negative contributions have magnitudes below 0.01 W m−2^{-2}. Thus global WKW_K is not a small residual of large opposite-signed zonal terms.

Figure 1. Annual zonal-mean archived-layer column power for 2025. (a) Kinetic-energy generation by horizontal pressure gradients, WKW_K. (b) Alpha–omega power WωW_\omega. Profiles are shown for ∣ϕ∣≤85∘|\phi| \le85^\circ; the omitted polar bands make net signed contributions smaller than 0.01 W m−2^{-2} to WKW_K and 0.04 W m−2^{-2} to WωW_\omega. Note the different ordinate scales.

The alpha–omega profiles have similar large-scale shapes but much larger amplitudes. Column values reach about 390–410 W m−2^{-2} near 7°N and −163 to −172 W m−2^{-2} near 25–26°N, compared with global means of only 1.87–3.23 W m−2^{-2}. Area-weighted positive contributions are 50.4–52.4 W m−2^{-2} and negative contributions are −47.2 to −50.5 W m−2^{-2}. The sum of the absolute positive and negative branch contributions therefore exceeds the global residual by factors of about 30–55.

Vertical structure and surface sensitivity

Horizontal kinetic-energy generation is concentrated in the lower atmosphere (Figure 2). The largest archived layer occurs at 962.5 hPa in all three products. Below 500 hPa, the archived atmosphere supplies 82.7%, 82.1%, and 72.5% of WKresW_K^{\mathrm{res}} in ERA5, JRA-3Q, and MERRA-2. The corresponding values are 1.95, 2.04, and 2.06 W m−2^{-2}, a range of only 0.11 W m−2^{-2}.

Figure 2. Annual global-mean archived-layer contributions for 2025. (a) WKW_K and (b) WωW_\omega. Pressure decreases upward; the dashed line marks 500 hPa. Each point is the contribution of one pressure layer. Surface corrections are not included in the plotted profiles and are reported separately in Table 1.

The zero-surface treatment adds 0.23, 0.24, and 0.27 W m−2^{-2} to WKW_K in ERA5, JRA-3Q, and MERRA-2, respectively. These corrections are 9.6–9.7% of the archived-layer values and about 8.8% of the corrected totals. Linear extrapolation adds 0.51, 0.54, and 0.63 W m−2^{-2}, raising the archived-layer values by 21.5–22.1% and accounting for 17.7–18.1% of the extrapolated totals. The difference between the two treatments is 0.28–0.35 W m−2^{-2} across the three products, while their similar relative contributions indicate that the sensitivity is systematic rather than reanalysis specific.

Alpha–omega power is less coherent in the lower atmosphere. Its contribution below 500 hPa is 2.06 W m−2^{-2} in ERA5, 0.76 W m−2^{-2} in JRA-3Q, and 1.23 W m−2^{-2} in MERRA-2. The contrast is even clearer in the surface treatment. Linear extrapolation consistently increases WKW_K in all three reanalyses, by 0.51, 0.54, and 0.63 W m−2^{-2} in ERA5, JRA-3Q, and MERRA-2, respectively. Applied in exactly the same way to WωW_\omega, however, the surface correction is −0.70, −0.59, and +0.26 W m−2^{-2}, respectively: it decreases WωW_\omega in ERA5 and JRA-3Q but increases it in MERRA-2. Thus the near-surface correction has a consistent sign and magnitude for WKW_K, but is sign-indefinite for WωW_\omega.

On complete archived layers, Wωres−WKresW_\omega^{\mathrm{res}} - W_K^{\mathrm{res}} is +0.87, −0.61, and +0.10 W m−2^{-2} in ERA5, JRA-3Q, and MERRA-2, respectively. For the closure comparison, applying the common linear surface extrapolation to both diagnostics changes these differences to −0.34, −1.74, and −0.27 W m−2^{-2}. The sign-indefinite alpha–omega surface contribution therefore adds substantial uncertainty to any closure calculation; the archived and extrapolated differences are interpreted separately below.

Discussion and conclusions

The archived-layer differences Wω−WKW_\omega- W_K are 0.87 W m−2^{-2} for ERA5, 0.10 W m−2^{-2} for MERRA-2, and −0.61 W m−2^{-2} for JRA-3Q. If these quantities were evaluated from a single internally consistent representation of physical gaseous-air continuity, Eq. (15) would relate their difference to the physical WPW_P, WnhW_{nh}, and boundary and storage terms. § 3 shows why this interpretation cannot in general be applied to reanalysis pressure-level fields.

The three reanalyses do not encode atmospheric mass continuity in the same way. ERA5 inherits the source-free total-mass continuity formulation of the pre-Cycle-46R1 IFS, while the JMA dynamical system underlying JRA-3Q likewise diagnoses pressure velocity from a source-free pressure-mass continuity equation. MERRA-2 instead uses a mass-budget formulation in which changes of atmospheric water affect total atmospheric mass while dry-air mass is conserved. Moreover, archived pressure-level fields can contain additional continuity inconsistencies introduced by assimilation, interpolation, temporal sampling, and lower-boundary treatment. The three values of Wω−WKW_\omega- W_K above should therefore not be interpreted as three independent estimates of the physical WP+WnhW_P + W_{\mathrm{nh}}.

This also changes the interpretation of agreement between the two diagnostics. The near equality of WωW_\omega and WKW_K in MERRA-2 does not imply that the physical WPW_P is small. Conversely, the substantial positive ERA5 difference and negative JRA-3Q difference do not imply corresponding physical source or nonhydrostatic terms. Likewise, the agreement reported by Steinheimer et al. [30] for an earlier IFS cycle is naturally consistent with the source-free total-mass continuity equation used by that model generation and therefore does not establish physical equivalence of the two formulations.

Treatment of the unrepresented surface layer provides an additional numerical distinction. The alpha–omega surface extrapolation is not robust across the three reanalyses and makes Wω−WKW_\omega-W_K negative in all three products. We therefore do not use the surface-extrapolated alpha–omega values to infer a physical closure. For WKW_K, we instead carry two surface treatments. Imposing the zero-surface condition ks=0k_s = 0 gives corrections of 0.23–0.27 W m−2^{-2} and a cross-reanalysis mean total of 2.81 W m−2^{-2}, while linear extrapolation gives 0.51–0.63 W m−2^{-2} and a mean total of 3.12 W m−2^{-2}. Thus the treatment of the omitted layer shifts the inferred mean WKW_K by about 0.31 W m−2^{-2} but does not alter its inter-reanalysis coherence or its order of magnitude. We retain both surface treatments when estimating total atmospheric power below.

Although the present analysis is restricted to 2025, its resolved WKW_K values closely reproduce the 1980–2023 values calculated from the conversion components reported by Oh et al. (2026) (Table 1), with differences below 4% for all three reanalyses. This supports the use of the 2025 WKW_K values as representative of the longer-term magnitude, while the present calculation itself does not quantify interannual variability.

ReanalysisWKW_K archivedOh et al.Cs0C_s^0sum0_0CslinC_s^{\mathrm{lin}}sumlin_{\mathrm{lin}}WωW_\omega archivedCslinC_s^{\mathrm{lin}}sumlin_{\mathrm{lin}}
MERRA-22.842.870.273.120.633.472.940.263.20
ERA52.362.450.232.590.512.873.23−0.702.53
JRA-3Q2.482.460.242.720.543.021.87−0.591.28

Table 1. Atmospheric-power diagnostics for 2025 from 1460 six-hourly analysis times. “Archived” denotes complete pressure layers. For WKW_K, Cs0C_s^0 and sum0_0 use the zero-surface condition ks=0k_s = 0, while CslinC_s^{\mathrm{lin}} and sumlin_{\mathrm{lin}} use linear extrapolation to psp_s. For WωW_\omega, only the linear surface treatment is shown. The column labelled “Oh et al.” gives the 1980–2023 mean resolved WKW_K obtained as C(PE,KE)+C(PM,KM)C(P_E,K_E) + C(P_M,K_M) by Oh et al. (2026); these values do not include a surface correction. Values are W m−2^{-2}.

The cancellation shown in Figure 1 helps explain why WωW_\omega is especially sensitive to these distinctions. Its global value is a small residual of much larger positive and negative contributions, whereas WKW_K is positive at almost every latitude and agrees much more closely among the three products. Trenberth-type mass corrections impose a physically motivated dry-air conservation constraint on analyzed fields, but the column constraint does not uniquely reconstruct the three-dimensional velocity error. When ω\omega is subsequently recovered by vertically integrating the corrected continuity equation, the resulting field is conditional on both the continuity constraint and the chosen mass-flux correction. Corrections to horizontal winds can also alter WKW_K, but WKW_K is not itself reconstructed by vertical integration of continuity and is not intrinsically subject to the same ascent–subsidence cancellation.

Consequently, reanalysis-derived WωW_\omega is best regarded as a diagnostic of the particular mass-continuity treatment embodied in, or subsequently imposed on, the analyzed fields rather than as an independent measurement of physical atmospheric power. Its difference from WKW_K can contain the effects of model mass-continuity conventions, continuity residuals in archived fields, and postprocessing corrections in addition to the physical terms in Eq. (15). The large spread of Wω−WKW_\omega- W_K across the three reanalyses is consistent with this sensitivity.

An observational scale for total WPW_P can be obtained from the tropical precipitation-profile estimate. Pauluis and Dias [26], with the correction of Pauluis and Dias [27], estimated precipitation-induced dissipation at about 1.5 W m−2^{-2} for the tropical belt 30°S–30°N from TRMM precipitation profiles for 1999–2007. Since this belt occupies one half of Earth’s surface, the tropical contribution alone corresponds to 0.75 W m−2^{-2} in the global mean. Using GPCP v2.3 for 2000–2009, Nützel et al. [22] report mean precipitation rates of 3.05 mm day−1^{-1} in the same tropical belt and 2.70 mm day−1^{-1} globally, implying an extratropical mean of 2.35 mm day−1^{-1}. If extratropical precipitation were assigned the same mean lifting height HPH_P as tropical precipitation, the corresponding global WPW_P would be about 1.33 W m−2^{-2}. Neglecting the extratropical contribution altogether gives 0.75 W m−2^{-2}. These deliberately crude estimates place global WPW_P at order 1 W m−2^{-2}. We therefore use WP≃1W_P \simeq1 W m−2^{-2} only as an illustrative scale and emphasize the need for a dedicated global precipitation-path estimate.

To our knowledge, global WnhW_{\rm nh} is not presently constrained by observations. If Wnh≥0W_{\rm nh} \ge0, the two surface-corrected estimates of resolved WKW_K, together with the illustrative physical WP≃1W_P \simeq1 W m−2^{-2}, give cross-reanalysis total-power scales of about 3.8 W m−2^{-2} for ks=0k_s = 0 and 4.1 W m−2^{-2} for linear extrapolation. Importantly, this inference uses WKW_K and the independently estimated physical WPW_P; it does not use either reanalysis WωW_\omega or the residual Wω−WKW_\omega- W_K.

This power scale sharpens the contrast with estimates of generation within the Lorenz framework. Romanski and Rossow [29], using largely observation-based temperature and diabatic-heating fields, reported annual global means GZ=1.52G_Z = 1.52 W m−2^{-2} and Ge=−0.29G_e = -0.29 W m−2^{-2}. Their sum gives GLEC=1.23G_{\rm LEC} = 1.23 W m−2^{-2}. To our knowledge, this remains the only global estimate in which APE generation was directly constrained by observations rather than inferred from reanalysis or model energetics. The revised radiative-flux-profile product of Zhang and Rossow [36] now makes such an updated calculation possible, but it has not yet been reported. The Romanski–Rossow estimate therefore remains a relevant observational benchmark.

A similarly low power scale was obtained by Kleidon [12], whose two-box maximum-power model gives about 1.6 W m−2^{-2} for kinetic-energy generation associated with poleward heat transport between tropical and extratropical regions. This value should not, however, be interpreted as a general upper bound on kinetic-energy generation by differential heating. Kleidon’s model explicitly excludes kinetic-energy generation by the Hadley circulation, whereas in the conventional Lorenz energy cycle the Hadley circulation contributes to the conversion C(PM,KM)C(P_M, K_M).

The more direct contrast for the present analysis is with WKW_K. Even without a surface-layer correction, the resolved WKW_K values of 2.36–2.84 W m−2^{-2} substantially exceed the observationally constrained GLEC=1.23G_{\mathrm{LEC}} = 1.23 W m−2^{-2}. This disparity suggests that a substantial part of kinetic-energy generation diagnosed by WKW_K is not represented by conventional Lorenz APE generation. The two surface treatments raise the cross-reanalysis mean WKW_K to 2.81–3.12 W m−2^{-2}; including the illustrative WP≃1W_P \simeq1 W m−2^{-2} gives the corresponding total atmospheric-power scale of about 3.8–4.1 W m−2^{-2}.

This discrepancy motivates consideration of additional pathways of atmospheric power generation not represented by the conventional Lorenz APE framework. One such possibility has a long history. In 1885, Heinrich Hertz proposed an atmospheric steam-engine interpretation. As reported by Mulligan and Hertz [21], Hertz estimated the relevant evaporation–condensation temperature difference to be about 15 K. For T≃300T \simeq300 K, this gives an efficiency scale ΔT/T≃0.05\Delta T/T \simeq0.05. Applied to the global latent heat flux of order 80 W m−2^{-2} corresponding to the GPCP precipitation rates quoted above, this gives a power scale of about 4 W m−2^{-2}. The agreement in magnitude with the atmospheric power inferred here is consistent with a substantial role for water phase transitions in atmospheric power generation. A more complete thermodynamic formulation and quantitative assessment of this steam-engine argument are the subject of ongoing work. Resolving this discrepancy will require improved observational constraints, particularly on WPW_P and WnhW_{\mathrm{nh}}, together with further theoretical work on atmospheric power-generation mechanisms.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare there are no conflicts of interest for this manuscript.

Acknowledgments

This work received institutional support from the Biotic Pump Greening Group Institute and the Institute for Advanced Study, Technical University of Munich. No specific grant funding was received.

Data and Code Availability

ERA5 data were obtained from the Copernicus Climate Data Store, using the ERA5 hourly pressure-level and single-level products ([2, 3]). MERRA-2 data were obtained from the NASA Goddard Earth Sciences Data and Information Services Center, collection M2I3NPASM (inst3_3d_asm_Np) (Global Modeling and Assimilation Office (GMAO), 2015). JRA-3Q data were obtained from the NSF NCAR Geoscience Data Exchange, dataset d640000, using the high-resolution isobaric analysis (anl_p) and surface analysis (anl_surf) products [9]. The derived data and Mathematica scripts used in this study are archived in Zenodo at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21966314 [35].

References

  1. [1]Boer, G. J., & Lambert, S. (2008). The energy cycle in atmospheric models. Climate Dynamics, 30, 371–390. doi: 10.1007/s00382-007-0303-4DOI
  2. [2]Copernicus Climate Change Service. (2023a). ERA5 hourly data on pressure levels from 1940 to present [Dataset]. Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) Climate Data Store (CDS). Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.24381/cds.bd0915c6 doi: 10.24381/cds.bd0915c6
  3. [3]Copernicus Climate Change Service. (2023b). ERA5 hourly data on single levels from 1940 to present [Dataset]. Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) Climate Data Store (CDS). Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.24381/cds.adbb2d47 doi: 10.24381/cds.adbb2d47
  4. [4]Gelaro, R., McCarty, W., Suárez, M. J., Todling, R., Molod, A., Takacs, L., … Zhao, B. (2017). The modern-era retrospective analysis for research and applications, version 2 (MERRA-2). Journal of Climate, 30, 5419–5454. doi: 10.1175/JCLI-D-16-0758.1DOI
  5. [6]Hersbach, H., Bell, B., Berrisford, P., Hirahara, S., Horányi, A., Muñoz Sabater, J., … Thépaut, J.-N. (2020). The ERA5 global reanalysis. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society, 146, 1999–2049. doi: 10.1002/qj.3803DOI
  6. [7]Huang, J., & McElroy, M. B. (2015). A 32-year perspective on the origin of wind energy in a warming climate. Renewable Energy, 77, 482–492. doi: 10.1016/j.renene.2014.12.045DOI
  7. [8]Japan Meteorological Agency. (2019). Outline of the operational numerical weather prediction at the japan meteorological agency (Tech. Rep.). Tokyo, Japan: Japan Meteorological Agency. (188 pp.)
  8. [9]Japan Meteorological Agency. (2023). Japanese reanalysis for three quarters of a century (jra-3q) [Dataset]. Research Data Archive at the National Center for Atmospheric Research, Computational and Information Systems Laboratory. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.5065/AVTZ-1H78 doi: 10.5065/AVTZ-1H78
  9. [10]Kim, W.-M., & Choi, Y.-S. (2017). Long-term change of the atmospheric energy cycles and weather disturbances. Climate Dynamics, 49(9–10), 3605–3617. doi: 10.1007/s00382-017-3533-0DOI
  10. [11]Kim, Y.-H., & Kim, M.-K. (2013). Examination of the global Lorenz energy cycle using MERRA and NCEP-reanalysis 2. Climate Dynamics, 40, 1499–1513. doi: 10.1007/s00382-012-1358-4DOI
  11. [12]Kleidon, A. (2021). Physical limits of wind energy within the atmosphere and its use as renewable energy: From the theoretical basis to practical implications. Meteorologische Zeitschrift, 30(3), 203–225. doi: 10.1127/metz/2021/1062DOI
  12. [13]Kosaka, Y., Kobayashi, S., Harada, Y., Kobayashi, C., Naoe, H., Yoshimoto, K., … Onogi, K. (2024). The JRA-3q reanalysis. Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan, 102(1), 49–109. doi: 10.2151/jmsj.2024-004DOI
  13. [14]Laliberté, F., Zika, J. D., Mudryk, L., Kushner, P. J., Kjellsson, J., & Döös, K. (2015). Constrained work output of the moist atmospheric heat engine in a warming climate. Science, 347(6221), 540–543. doi: 10.1126/science.1257103DOI
  14. [16]Lorenz, E. N. (1955). Available potential energy and the maintenance of the general circulation. Tellus, 7, 157–167. doi: 10.3402/tellusa.v7i2.8796DOI
  15. [18]Makarieva, A. M., Gorshkov, V. G., Nefiodov, A. V., Sheil, D., Nobre, A. D., & Li, B.-L. (2017). Quantifying the global atmospheric power budget. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics Discussions. (Preprint; revision not accepted for publication in ACP) doi: 10.5194/acp-2017-17DOI
  16. [19]Malardel, S., Diamantakis, M., Agusti-Panareda, A., & Flemming, J. (2019). Dry mass versus total mass conservation in the IFS (ECMWF Technical Memorandum No. 849). Reading, UK: European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts. doi: 10.21957/s3ho2aq29
  17. [20]Marques, C. A. F., Rocha, A., Corte-Real, J., Castanheira, J. M., Ferreira, J., & Melo-Gonçalves, P. (2009). Global atmospheric energetics from NCEP reanalysis 2 and ECMWF–ERA40 reanalysis. International Journal of Climatology, 29, 159–174. doi: 10.1002/joc.1704DOI
  18. [21]Mulligan, J. F., & Hertz, H. G. (1997). An unpublished lecture by heinrich hertz: “on the energy balance of the earth”. American Journal of Physics, 65(1), 36–45. doi: 10.1119/1.18565DOI
  19. [22]Nützel, M., Stecher, L., Jöckel, P., Winterstein, F., Dameris, M., Ponater, M., . . . Kunze, M. (2024). Updating the radiation infrastructure in MESSy (based on MESSy version 2.55). Geoscientific Model Development, 17, 5821–5849. doi: 10.5194/gmd-17-5821-2024DOI
  20. [24]Oort, A. H. (1964). On estimates of the atmospheric energy cycle. Monthly Weather Review, 92(11), 483–493. doi: 10.1175/1520-0493(1964)092<0483:OEOTAE>2.3.CO;2doi.org/10.1175/1520-0493(1964)092<0483:oeotae>2.3.co;2
  21. [25]Pan, Y., Li, L., Jiang, X., Li, G., Zhang, W., Wang, X., & Ingersoll, A. P. (2017). Earth’s changing global atmospheric energy cycle in response to climate change. Nature Communications, 8, 14367. doi: 10.1038/ncomms14367DOI
  22. [26]Pauluis, O., & Dias, J. (2012). Satellite estimates of precipitation-induced dissipation in the atmosphere. Science, 335(6071), 953–956. doi: 10.1126/science.1215869DOI
  23. [27]Pauluis, O., & Dias, J. (2013). Corrections and clarifications. Science, 339(6117), 271–271. doi: 10.1126/science.339.6117.271-bDOI
  24. [28]Peixoto, J. P., & Oort, A. H. (1992). Physics of climate. New York: American Institute of Physics.
  25. [29]Romanski, J., & Rossow, W. B. (2013). Contributions of individual atmospheric diabatic heating processes to the generation of available potential energy. Journal of Climate, 26(12), 4244–4263. doi: 10.1175/JCLI-D-12-00457.1DOI
  26. [30]Steinheimer, M., Hantel, M., & Bechtold, P. (2008). Convection in Lorenz’s global energy cycle with the ECMWF model. Tellus A, 60(5), 1001–1022. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0870.2008.00348.xDOI
  27. [31]Takacs, L. L., Suárez, M. J., & Todling, R. (2016). Maintaining atmospheric mass and water balance in reanalyses. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society, 142(697), 1565–1573. doi: 10.1002/qj.2763DOI
  28. [32]Trenberth, K. E. (1991). Climate diagnostics from global analyses: Conservation of mass in ECMWF analyses. Journal of Climate, 4(7), 707–722. doi: 10.1175/1520-0442(1991)004<0707:CDFGAC>2.0.CO;2doi.org/10.1175/1520-0442(1991)004<0707:cdfgac>2.0.co;2
  29. [33]Trenberth, K. E., & Fasullo, J. T. (2018). Applications of an updated atmospheric energetics formulation. Journal of Climate, 31(16), 6263–6279. doi: 10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0838.1DOI
  30. [34]Trenberth, K. E., Hurrell, J. W., & Solomon, A. (1995). Conservation of mass in three dimensions in global analyses. Journal of Climate, 8(4), 692–708. doi: 10.1175/1520-0442(1995)008(0692:COMITD)2.0.CO;2doi.org/10.1175/1520-0442(1995)008<0692:comitd>2.0.co;2
  31. [35]Makarieva, A., & Nefiodov, A. (2026). Data and code for “The Alpha-Omega Problem in the Assessments of Atmospheric Power” [Dataset]. Zenodo. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21966314 doi: 10.5281/zenodo.21966314
  32. [36]Zhang, Y., & Rossow, W. B. (2023). Global radiative flux profile data set: Revised and extended. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 128(5), e2022JD037340. doi: 10.1029/2022JD037340DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_4wwv6d39
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 2

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents