betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

The degree pair (126,84) in the plane Jacobian problem: the point (16/3,10) is not a regular corner

Abstract

In the list of Guccione, Guccione, Horruitiner and Valqui of the possible shapes of a counterexample to the plane Jacobian conjecture with degrees at most 150, two shapes have maximal degree 126. One of them consists of the standard (3,2)-pairs of degrees (126,84) whose chain of corners is (12,30), (16/3,10), (11/6,3). We show that (16/3,10) is not a regular corner of any (3,2)-pair in K[x^{+-1/3},y]; hence no such pair exists, and the shape of maximal degree 144 of the same list whose chain passes through (16/3,10) does not occur either. The proof uses only the propositions of Guccione-Guccione-Valqui on regular corners, applied to every root of the edge polynomial at that corner and not only to the root which generates the next corner of the chain, together with elementary arithmetic, which is reproduced by an ancillary script. The other shape of maximal degree 126 is the subject of a companion note. The argument has not yet been examined by specialists.

Statement

Throughout, KK is an algebraically closed field of characteristic zero, L(l)=K[x±1/l,y]L^{(l)} = K[x^{\pm1/l},y], [P,Q]=PxQy−PyQx[P,Q] = P_xQ_y-P_yQ_x and (m,n)=(3,2)(m,n)=(3,2). We use the notation of [1]: vρ,σv_{\rho,\sigma}, ℓρ,σ\ell_{\rho,\sigma}, st⁡ρ,σ\operatorname{st}_{\rho,\sigma}, en⁡ρ,σ\operatorname{en}_{\rho,\sigma}; the interval of directions I=](1,−1),(1,0)]I=](1,-1),(1,0)]; (m,n)(m,n)-pairs in L(l)L^{(l)} and their regular corners [1 Definitions 4.3 and 5.5]. For a regular corner ((a/l,b),(ρ,σ))((a/l,b),(\rho,\sigma)) of (P,Q)(P,Q) we write ℓρ,σ(P)=xk/lp(z)\ell_{\rho,\sigma}(P)=x^{k/l}p(z) with z:=x−σ/ρyz:=x^{-\sigma/\rho}y, and we distinguish, as in [1 Section 5, before Remark 5.9]: Case I, [ℓρ,σ(P),ℓρ,σ(Q)]≠0[\ell_{\rho,\sigma}(P),\ell_{\rho,\sigma}(Q)]\ne0; Case II, the bracket vanishes and pp has at least two distinct linear factors; Case III, the bracket vanishes and p=μ(z−λ)rp=\mu(z-\lambda)^r with λ≠0\lambda\ne0. One always has v1,−1(st⁡ρ,σ(P))≠0v_{1,-1}(\operatorname{st}_{\rho,\sigma}(P))\ne0 (loc. cit.); Case II is called II.a) if this number is negative and II.b) if it is positive.

Theorem 1.1. No (3,2)(3,2)-pair in L(3)L^{(3)} has a regular corner at the point (16/3,10)(16/3,10).

Corollary 1.2. There is no standard (3,2)(3,2)-pair (P,Q)(P,Q) whose chain of corners, in the sense of [2 Theorem 2.20], contains Ai=(16/3,10)A_i=(16/3,10) with li=3l_i=3. In particular the following two shapes of [2 Section 6] do not occur:

  • (i) the chain (12,30)(12,30), (16/3,10)(16/3,10), (11/6,3)(11/6,3), of degrees (126,84)(126,84);

  • (ii) the chain (12,36)(12,36), (12,30)(12,30), (16/3,10)(16/3,10), (11/6,3)(11/6,3), of maximal degree 144.

Proof. By items (3) and (6) (or (9)) of [2 Theorem 2.20], (Ai,(ρi,σi))(A_i,(\rho_i,\sigma_i)) is a regular corner of the (3,2)(3,2)-pair (Pi,Qi)(P_i,Q_i) in L(li)L^{(l_i)}, which contradicts Theorem 1.1 when li=3l_i=3. It remains to see that li=3l_i=3 in (i) and (ii). Let Ai−1=(12,30)A_{i-1}=(12,30); in (i), i=1i=1 and l0=1l_0=1; in (ii), i=2i=2, and l1=1l_1=1 because l1l_1 is l0=1l_0=1 in Case II.a) and lcm⁡(ρ0,1)\operatorname{lcm}(\rho_0,1) in Case II.b), where (ρ0,σ0)=(1,0)(\rho_0,\sigma_0)=(1,0) since A0A_0 and A1A_1 have the same first coordinate and lie on the same edge. As Ai∉Z2A_i\notin\mathbb{Z}^2, the corner (Ai−1,(ρi−1,σi−1))(A_{i-1},(\rho_{i-1},\sigma_{i-1})) is not of Case II.a) (item (7)), so item (8) applies: AiA_i lies on the line of direction (−σi−1/ρi−1,1)(-\sigma_{i-1}/\rho_{i-1},1) through (ki−1/(mli−1),0)(k_{i-1}/(ml_{i-1}),0), and so does Ai−1=1men⁡ρi−1,σi−1(Pi−1)A_{i-1}=\frac{1}{m}\operatorname{en}_{\rho_{i-1},\sigma_{i-1}}(P_{i-1}). Since Ai−1−Ai=(20/3,20)A_{i-1}-A_i=(20/3,20), we get (ρi−1,σi−1)=(3,−1)(\rho_{i-1},\sigma_{i-1})=(3,-1) and li=lcm⁡(3,1)=3l_i=\operatorname{lcm}(3,1)=3. □

Remark 1.3. If (P,Q)(P,Q) is a (2,3)(2,3)-pair with a regular corner, then (Q,P)(Q,P) is a (3,2)(3,2)-pair with the same regular corner [1 Corollary 5.7]; so Theorem 1.1 also holds for (2,3)(2,3)-pairs.

The tools

We use the following statements, for an (m,n)(m,n)-pair (P,Q)(P,Q) in L(l)L^{(l)} and a regular corner ((a/l,b),(ρ,σ))((a/l,b),(\rho,\sigma)).

(T1) [1 Proposition 5.19]: the point (a/l,b)(a/l,b) is the first entry of a regular corner of Case I or of Case II of a (possibly different) (m,n)(m,n)-pair in L(l)L^{(l)}; in Case I, l−a/b>1l-a/b>1; in Case II, gcd⁡(a,b)>1\gcd(a,b)>1. The directions of these corners are not larger than (ρ,σ)(\rho,\sigma) (proof of that proposition).

(T2) Case I. By [1 Proposition 1.13], vρ,σ(P)+vρ,σ(Q)=ρ+σv_{\rho,\sigma}(P)+v_{\rho,\sigma}(Q)=\rho+\sigma; moreover en⁡ρ,σ(P)=m(a/l,b)\operatorname{en}_{\rho,\sigma}(P)=m(a/l,b) by definition and en⁡ρ,σ(P)=mnen⁡ρ,σ(Q)\operatorname{en}_{\rho,\sigma}(P)=\frac{m}{n}\operatorname{en}_{\rho,\sigma}(Q) [1 Corollary 5.7(2)]. Hence

m(alρ+bσ)=mm+n(ρ+σ),(1)m\left(\frac{a}{l}\rho+b\sigma\right)=\frac{m}{m+n}(\rho+\sigma), \tag*{(1)}

which determines (ρ,σ)(\rho,\sigma), and vρ,σ(P)=mm+n(ρ+σ)v_{\rho,\sigma}(P)=\frac{m}{m+n}(\rho+\sigma), vρ,σ(Q)=nm+n(ρ+σ)v_{\rho,\sigma}(Q)=\frac{n}{m+n}(\rho+\sigma). By [1 Proposition 5.13], either 1mst⁡ρ,σ(P)=(a′/l,0)\frac{1}{m}\operatorname{st}_{\rho,\sigma}(P)=(a'/l,0) with a′∈Na'\in\mathbb{N} (statement and proof), or {st⁡ρ,σ(P),st⁡ρ,σ(Q)}={(k/l,0),(1−k/l,1)}\{\operatorname{st}_{\rho,\sigma}(P),\operatorname{st}_{\rho,\sigma}(Q)\}=\{(k/l,0),(1-k/l,1)\} with k∈Nk\in\mathbb{N}.

(T3) Case II. By [1 Proposition 5.14], with d:=gcd⁡(a,b)d:=\gcd(a,b), aˉ:=a/d\bar{a}:=a/d, bˉ:=b/d\bar{b}:=b/d: d>1d>1, and there is μ∈N\mu\in\mathbb{N} with d∤μd\nmid\mu, μ≤l(bl−a)+1/bˉ\mu\leq l(bl-a)+1/\bar{b}, such that (ρ,σ)(\rho,\sigma) is the direction orthogonal to (μaˉ−l,μbˉl−l)(\mu\bar{a}^{-l},\mu\bar{b}l-l); moreover ρ/gcd⁡(ρ,l)≤b\rho/\gcd(\rho,l)\leq b. The point A′:=1mst⁡ρ,σ(P)A':=\frac{1}{m}\operatorname{st}_{\rho,\sigma}(P) lies in 1lZ×N0\frac{1}{l}\mathbb{Z}\times\mathbb{N}_0 (proof of that proposition), below (a/l,b)(a/l,b) on the line of direction (−σ/ρ,1)(-\sigma/\rho,1) through it, and v1,−1(A′)≠0v_{1,-1}(A')\neq0 as recalled above. One has ℓρ,σ(P)=λRm\ell_{\rho,\sigma}(P)=\lambda R^m for a (ρ,σ)(\rho,\sigma)-homogeneous R∈L(l)R\in L^{(l)} [1 Remark 3.1 and Corollary 5.7].

(T4) Case II.a). (A′,Pred⁡P(ρ,σ))(A',\operatorname{Pred}_P(\rho,\sigma)) is a regular corner of (P,Q)(P,Q) [1 Remark 5.11].

(T5) Case II, roots. Let λ∈K×\lambda\in K^\times be a root of pp of multiplicity mλm_\lambda with

mλ≥ml⋅aρ+blσρ+σ.(2)m_\lambda\geq\frac{m}{l}\cdot\frac{a\rho+bl\sigma}{\rho+\sigma}. \tag*{(2)}

Then, with l′:=lcm⁡(ρ,l)l':=\operatorname{lcm}(\rho,l) and φ(y):=y+λxσ/ρ\varphi(y):=y+\lambda x^{\sigma/\rho}, the pair (φP,φQ)(\varphi P,\varphi Q) is an (m,n)(m,n)-pair in L(l′)L^{(l')} with a regular corner at (kml,0)+mλm(−σρ,1)\left(\frac{k}{ml},0\right)+\frac{m_\lambda}{m}\left(-\frac{\sigma}{\rho},1\right), of direction smaller than (ρ,σ)(\rho,\sigma) [1 Proposition 5.18].

The use of (T5) for a root other than the one continuing a chain, followed by (T1) and (T2), is the argument of [2 Proposition 6.1].

Arithmetic

In this section (m,n)=(3,2)(m,n)=(3,2). For a point (a/l,b)(a/l,b) we say that Case I is arithmetically impossible if, for the direction given by (1), none of the starting points allowed in (T2) exists, and that Case II is arithmetically impossible below (ρ∗,σ∗)(\rho_*,\sigma_*) if no μ\mu as in (T3) gives a direction of II smaller than (ρ∗,σ∗)(\rho_*,\sigma_*).

Lemma 3.1. (a) At (16/3,10)(16/3,10), l=3l=3: Case I is arithmetically impossible (direction (21,−11)(21,-11)); the directions allowed in Case II are (12,−5)(12,-5) and (2,−1)(2,-1).

(b) At C1:=(5/6,1)C_1:=(5/6,1), l=6l=6: l−a/b=1l-a/b=1 and gcd⁡(5,1)=1\gcd(5,1)=1.

(c) At C2:=(8/6,2)C_2:=(8/6,2), l=6l=6: Case I is arithmetically impossible (direction (27,−17)(27,-17)); the only direction allowed in Case II below (2,−1)(2,-1) is (12,−7)(12,-7).

(d) At (9/12,1)(9/12,1), l=12l=12: Case I is arithmetically impossible (direction (16,−11)(16,-11)), and gcd⁡(9,1)=1\gcd(9,1)=1.

(e) At C4:=(14/6,4)C_4:=(14/6,4), l=6l=6: Case I is arithmetically impossible (direction (57,−32)(57,-32)), and so is Case II below (2,−1)(2,-1).

(f) At C5:=(17/6,5)C_5:=(17/6,5), l=6l=6: Case I is arithmetically impossible (direction (144,−79)(144,-79)), and gcd⁡(17,5)=1\gcd(17,5)=1.

(g) At (7/3,4)(7/3,4), l=3l=3: Case I is arithmetically impossible (direction (57,−32)(57,-32)), and gcd⁡(7,4)=1\gcd(7,4)=1.

(h) At (11/3,6)(11/3,6), l=3l=3: Case I is arithmetically impossible (direction (87,−52)(87,-52)), and gcd⁡(11,6)=1\gcd(11,6)=1.

Proof. Direct computation; for instance in (c), (1) reads (43−15)ρ+(2−15)σ=0\left(\frac{4}{3}-\frac{1}{5}\right)\rho+\left(2-\frac{1}{5}\right)\sigma=0, so (ρ,σ)=(27,−17)(\rho,\sigma)=(27,-17), v(P)=6v(P)=6, v(Q)=4v(Q)=4, and 276⋅3a′=6\frac{27}{6}\cdot3a'=6, 276k=4\frac{27}{6}k=4, 276k=6\frac{27}{6}k=6 have no integer solution; in Case II, d=2d=2, (aˉ,bˉ)=(4,1)(\bar{a},\bar{b})=(4,1), the direction is orthogonal to (4μ−6,6μ−6)(4\mu-6,6\mu-6) with μ\mu odd, μ≤25\mu\le25: μ=1\mu=1 gives no direction of I, μ=3\mu=3 gives (2,−1)(2,-1), μ=5\mu=5 gives (12,−7)(12,-7) with ρ/gcd⁡(ρ,6)=2≤2\rho/\gcd(\rho,6)=2\le2, and 7≤μ≤257\le\mu\le25 violates ρ/gcd⁡(ρ,6)≤2\rho/\gcd(\rho,6)\le2. All items are checked by the ancillary script. □

By (T1), (T2), (T3) and Lemma 3.1(b),(e),(f),(g),(h):

none of the points C1C_1, C5C_5 (l=6l=6), (7/3,4)(7/3,4), (11/3,6)(11/3,6) (l=3l=3) is the first entry of a regular corner of a (3,2)(3,2)-pair in L(l)L^{(l)}, and C4C_4 (l=6l=6) is not the first entry of a regular corner of direction smaller than (2,−1)(2,-1).

Lemma 3.2. No (3,2)(3,2)-pair in L(6)L^{(6)} has a regular corner at C2=(8/6,2)C_2=(8/6,2) of direction smaller than (2,−1)(2,-1).

Proof. By (T1) and Lemma 3.1(c) there would be a (3,2)(3,2)-pair (P′,Q′)(P',Q') in L(6)L^{(6)} with a regular corner (C2,(12,−7))(C_2,(12,-7)) of Case II. Put z:=x7/12yz:=x^{7/12}y. The point A′A' of (T3) is C2−h(7/12,1)C_2-h(7/12,1) with h∈{1,2}h\in\{1,2\} and lies in 16Z×N0\frac{1}{6}\mathbb{Z}\times\mathbb{N}_0, so h=2h=2 and A′=(1/6,0)A'=(1/6,0). Thus ℓ12,−7(P′)=x1/2p(z)\ell_{12,-7}(P')=x^{1/2}p(z) with deg⁡p=6\deg p=6, p(0)≠0p(0)\ne0. Since xi∈L(6)x^i\in L^{(6)} only for ii even, and since ℓ12,−7(P′)\ell_{12,-7}(P') is a cube by (T3), p=λ(z2−c)3p=\lambda(z^2-c)^3 with c≠0c\ne0. A root λ\lambda of z2=cz^2=c has mλ=3m_\lambda=3, and the right-hand side of (2) is 35⋅8⋅12−2⋅6⋅73=35\frac{3}{5}\cdot\frac{8\cdot12-2\cdot6\cdot7}{3}=\frac{3}{5}. By (T5) some (3,2)(3,2)-pair in L(12)L^{(12)} has a regular corner at (16,0)+(712,1)=(9/12,1)\left(\frac{1}{6},0\right)+\left(\frac{7}{12},1\right)=(9/12,1), which contradicts (T1), (T2) and Lemma 3.1(d). □

Proof of Theorem 1.1

Assume that some (3,2)(3,2)-pair in L(3)L^{(3)} has a regular corner at A1:=(16/3,10)A_1:=(16/3,10). By (T1) and Lemma 3.1(a) there is a (3,2)(3,2)-pair (P,Q)(P,Q) in L(3)L^{(3)} with a regular corner (A1,(ρ,σ))(A_1,(\rho,\sigma)) of Case II, with (ρ,σ)∈{(12,−5),(2,−1)}(\rho,\sigma)\in\{(12,-5),(2,-1)\}. Let A′=(a′/3,b′)A'=(a'/3,b') be the point of (T3).

*The direction (12,−5).∗Here(12,-5).* HereA'=A_1-h(5/12,1)with$0<h≤10with \$0<h\le10, and A′∈13Z×N0A'\in\frac{1}{3}\mathbb{Z}\times\mathbb{N}_0 forces h∈{4,8}h\in\{4,8\}: A′=(11/3,6)A'=(11/3,6) or A′=(2,2)A'=(2,2). The second is excluded by v1,−1(A′)≠0v_{1,-1}(A')\ne0. In the first, v1,−1(A′)<0v_{1,-1}(A')<0, so we are in Case II.a) and (11/3,6)(11/3,6) is the first entry of a regular corner by (T4), contrary to (3).

The direction $(2,-1). Put z:=x1/2yz:=x^{1/2}y. Now A′=A1−h(1/2,1)A'=A_1-h(1/2,1) with hh even, so b′∈{0,2,4,6,8}b'\in\{0,2,4,6,8\} and A′=(1/3+b′/6,b′)A'=(1/3+b'/6,b'). The line of the edge meets the first axis at (1/3,0)(1/3,0), so ℓ2,−1(P)=xp(z)\ell_{2,-1}(P)=xp(z) with p=z2b′/3p~(z)p=z^{2b'/3}\widetilde{p}(z), p~(0)≠0\widetilde{p}(0)\ne0, deg⁡p~=3(10−b′)\deg\widetilde{p}=3(10-b'). Since xzi∈L(3)xz^i\in L^{(3)} only for ii even, and since ℓ2,−1(P)\ell_{2,-1}(P) is a cube by (T3),

p~(z)=λ′∏i(z2−ci)3μi,ci∈K× distinct,μi≥1,∑iμi=10−b′2≤5.\widetilde{p}(z)=\lambda'\prod_i(z^2-c_i)^{3\mu_i},\qquad c_i\in K^\times\ \text{distinct},\qquad\mu_i\ge1,\qquad\sum_i\mu_i=\frac{10-b'}{2}\le5.

The right-hand side of (2) is 35⋅16⋅2−10⋅31=2\frac{3}{5}\cdot\frac{16\cdot2-10\cdot3}{1}=2, so every root λ\lambda of p~\widetilde{p}, of multiplicity 3μi≥33\mu_i\ge3, satisfies (2). By (T5), for every ii some (3,2)(3,2)-pair in L(6)L^{(6)} has a regular corner at

Cμi=(13,0)+μi(12,1)=(2+3μi6,μi).C_{\mu_i}=\left(\frac{1}{3},0\right)+\mu_i\left(\frac{1}{2},1\right)=\left(\frac{2+3\mu_i}{6},\mu_i\right).

of direction smaller than (2,−1)(2,-1). By (3) and Lemma 3.2, μi∉{1,2,4,5}\mu_i\notin\{1,2,4,5\}, so μi=3\mu_i=3 for every ii. Then 10−b′2\frac{10-b'}{2} is a positive multiple of 33, hence b′=4b'=4 and A′=(7/3,4)A'=(7/3,4). Since v1,−1(A′)<0v_{1,-1}(A')<0 we are in Case II.a), and (7/3,4)(7/3,4) is the first entry of a regular corner by (T4), contrary to (3). □

Remark 4.1. The corner C3=(11/6,3)C_3=(11/6,3), which continues the chain of [2], passes the tests used here: Case I is arithmetically possible there, with direction (12,−7)(12,-7) and st⁡(Q)=(1/6,0)\operatorname{st}(Q)=(1/6,0), st⁡(P)=(5/6,1)\operatorname{st}(P)=(5/6,1). In the shapes of Corollary 1.2 one has b′=0b'=0 (Case II.b), the multiplicities μi\mu_i add up to 55, and the contradiction comes from the roots other than the one continuing the chain, whose multiplicities add up to 22.

Scope

  • Proved here, relative to the cited results: Theorem 1.1 and Corollary 1.2. The inputs are (T1)–(T5), that is [1 Propositions 1.13, 5.13, 5.14, 5.18, 5.19, Corollary 5.7, Remarks 3.1, 5.11], and [2 Theorem 2.20] for the corollary.

  • Verified by exact computation: Lemma 3.1 and the numerical values in the proofs (ancillary file verify_126_84.py in the folder anc; Python standard library only).

  • Not claimed: a statement on the plane Jacobian conjecture itself. The other shape of maximal degree 126 in [2], of degrees (84, 126), is treated in the companion note [3], by a different method which rests on more inputs. The completeness of the list of [2] is not re-examined here.

  • The argument has been checked only by the author with AI assistance (Claude, Anthropic); it has not been validated by professionals.

Independent researcher, France

References

  1. [1]C. Valqui, J. A. Guccione, J. J. Guccione, On the shape of possible counterexamples to the Jacobian Conjecture, J. Algebra 471 (2017), 13–74, doi:10.1016/j.jalgebra.2016.08.039; arXiv:1401.1784v3. Statement numbers refer to the arXiv version v3.DOI
  2. [2]J. A. Guccione, J. J. Guccione, R. Horruitiner, C. Valqui, Some algorithms related to the Jacobian Conjecture, arXiv:1708.07936v1.arxiv.org/abs/1708.07936
  3. [3]D. Niedbala Giraudin, The degree pair (84, 126) in the plane Jacobian problem: exclusion of the shape with final corner (19/7, 5), companion note (2026).

Paper details

vlnc:W_4y7b75au
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Anthropic Claude Fable

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents