betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Statistical Analysis of Neutron Star Cooling: Implications for the Nuclear Equation of State and Nucleon Pairing

Abstract

We perform a statistical analysis of the thermal evolution of isolated neutron stars by confronting theoretical cooling curves with luminosity-age measurements for 24 sources. For each object, we explore five purely nucleonic equations of state (APR4, FSU2R, DD2, IST, and NL3ωρωρ) combined with representative models of neutron superfluidity and proton superconductivity, while varying the gravitational mass and envelope composition. The analysis spans approximately 10510^5 cooling curves. Within this framework, we find that only the NL3ωρωρ equation of state and, to a lesser extent, IST, both including neutron triplet pairing, provide an overall satisfactory description of the data. The remaining equations of state are in significant tension with the observations. These results demonstrate that NS cooling provides complementary constraints on dense matter, alongside nuclear structure, global NS observables, and gravitational-wave observations, while probing the interplay between the EoS and nucleon pairing.

Introduction

The extreme densities reached in the interior of neutron stars (NSs) provide a natural laboratory for studying strongly interacting matter beyond the reach of terrestrial experiments. NS properties are determined by the equation of state (EoS) of dense matter, which relates the pressure, density, and energy density and thus allows astrophysical observations to constrain the underlying microphysics. Different observables probe different aspects of the EoS. Precision measurements of massive pulsars already rule out very soft EoSs (Antoniadis et al. 2013; Romani et al. 2021). Constraints on the NS mass–radius relation are provided by X-ray observations with NICER (Miller et al. 2019; Vinciguerra et al. 2024; Dittmann et al. 2024; Salmi et al. 2024a,b; Choudhury et al. 2024; Mauviard et al. 2025) and by multi-messenger detection of the binary NS merger GW170817, which probes the tidal deformability (Abbott et al. 2018, 2020; Dietrich et al. 2020; Künert et al. 2026). In addition, the thermal evolution of NSs provides a complementary probe of dense matter, as cooling predictions for a given EoS can be directly confronted with the X-ray observations of isolated NSs (Blaschke et al. 2000; Popov et al. 2006; Blaschke & Grigorian 2007; Wei et al. 2019, 2020; Fortin et al. 2021; Das et al. 2024; Marino et al. 2024), and an opportunity to test physics beyond the Standard Model (Sedrakian 2016, 2019; Hamaguchi et al. 2018; Buschmann et al. 2022; Ángeles Pérez-García et al. 2022; Ávila et al. 2024; Giangrandi et al. 2024).

The standard cooling scenario involves thermal photon emission from the stellar surface and neutrino emission from the NS interior. After the early thermal-relaxation time, during which the crust and core become thermally coupled, NSs cool predominantly through neutrino emission from the bulk of the star and, at later times, through photon emission from the surface (Page et al. 2004; Yakovlev & Pethick 2004; Potekhin et al. 2015). The efficiency of neutrino emission processes is sensitively dependent on the particle composition. In particular, once the kinematic threshold set by the Fermi-momentum triangle condition for the β\beta-decay process and its inverse, known as the direct Urca (DU) process, is reached, the stellar temperature drops rapidly (Lattimer et al. 1991). If this condition is not met, the less efficient modified Urca (MU) process, which involves an additional spectator nucleon and has no threshold, along with nucleon–nucleon bremsstrahlung, results in slower cooling (Page et al. 2004).

Another key factor affecting the thermal evolution of NSs is the formation of Cooper pairs. According to the Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer (BCS) theory (Cooper 1956; Bardeen et al. 1957; Bohr et al. 1958), an attractive interaction between degenerate fermions leads to the formation of Cooper pairs. Neutrons form singlet-state (1S0{}^{1}S_{0}) superfluidity in the inner crust, but this pairing is suppressed in the core, where the effective neutron–neutron interaction in the singlet channel becomes repulsive. Instead, core neutrons are expected to pair in the triplet state (3P2{}^{3}P_{2}), while protons can undergo singlet-state pairing (Potekhin et al. 2015). Pairing opens an energy gap Δ\Delta in the single-particle excitation spectrum around the Fermi surface, with a width of 2Δ2\Delta. These paired phases affect NS thermal evolution through two competing mechanisms. On the one hand, it suppresses standard neutrino emission processes and reduces the heat capacity. On the other hand, it opens an additional neutrino emission channel associated with Cooper pair breaking and formation (PBF), which can enhance cooling when the temperature drops below the critical temperature (Baym et al. 1969; Chen et al. 1986; Baldo et al. 1992; Yakovlev et al. 1999; Yakovlev & Pethick 2004; Sedrakian & Clark 2019). While nucleon singlet-state pairing is well-studied, the formation of the neutron 3P2{}^{3}P_{2} channel in the NS core remains uncertain (Lombardo & Schulze 2001; Dean & Hjorth-Jensen 2003); therefore, cooling observations provide a sensitive probe to the nucleon pairing and gap models.

For a given EoS, envelope composition, and stellar mass, the predicted time evolution of the surface temperature or luminosity can therefore be directly compared with observations, allowing one to assess which nuclear properties are compatible with the data. In this work, we focus on the set of 24 isolated NSs (see Appendix A) of different ages (Potekhin, A. Y. 2023) and perform a global statistical analysis by comparing a large set of theoretical cooling curves, generated with the public code NSCool (Page 2016), to the available luminosity age data. We consider five purely nucleonic EoSs, APR4, DD2, FSU2R, IST, and NL3ωρ\omega\rho, and a representative set of neutron and proton pairing models. For each EoS and pairing gap combination, we scan over the NS gravitational mass and envelope composition, and quantify the agreement with the data via a chi-square analysis.

Among the observed sources, the compact object at the center of the Cassiopeia A (Cas A) supernova remnant is of particular interest because of its young age and the rapid decrease in its surface temperature. With an estimated age of approximately 356 years, it is one of the youngest known isolated NSs. (Ho & Heinke 2009; Heinke & Ho 2010; Shternin et al. 2011; Elshamouty et al. 2013; Wijngaarden et al. 2019; Shternin et al. 2021). A recent combined re-analysis of the X-ray spectra suggests a surface temperature decrease of 1.4-2.5% over two decades of observations and a mass estimate of M=1.55±0.25 M⊙M = 1.55 \pm0.25\,M_{\odot} (Shternin et al. 2022) offering a sensitive probe for rapid cooling mechanisms and nucleon pairing in the stellar core (Page et al. 2011; Blaschke et al. 2012, 2013; Ho et al. 2015; Taranto et al. 2016). It is a subject of debate due to its unusually rapid temperature decrease, which has motivated extensive discussion of possible rapid cooling mechanisms, including a strong neutron 3P2{}^{3}P_{2} pairing in the core (Page et al. 2011; Ho et al. 2015), rapid cooling driven by activation of the DU process in middle-mass stars (Taranto et al. 2016), modified neutrino emission via a one-pion exchange (Blaschke et al. 2012, 2013), etc.

The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes the EoSs used and NS properties. Section 3 summarizes the neutrino and photon emission processes from NSs and the nuclear pairing combinations adopted. Section 4 describes the statistical analysis, and the results are given in Section 5. We present our conclusions in Section 6. The observational data are given in Appendix A.

Throughout the article, we use natural units with ℏ=c=1\hbar= c = 1, except for the stellar luminosity, which is expressed in erg/s.

NS Properties

Hadronic EoSs

To account for the different baryonic matter uncertainties, we use five different models, the APR4, IST, FSU2R, DD2, and NL3ωρ\omega\rho EoSs, for β\beta-equilibrated matter, with different compositions, stiffness, and

saturation density properties. In Table 1 we list their main physical properties and briefly summarize each in the following.

EoSMmax⁡M_{\max} [M⊙M_{\odot}]R1.4R_{1.4} [km]MDUM_{\mathrm{DU}} [M⊙M_{\odot}]nDUn_{\mathrm{DU}} [fm−3^{-3}]
APR42.1711.331.980.78
DD22.4213.20N/AN/A
FSU2R2.0512.801.920.61
IST2.0811.401.910.87
NL3ωρ\omega\rho2.7513.822.550.50

Table 1. Parameters of the considered models. The columns correspond to the maximum gravitational mass, radius of the 1.4 M⊙M_{\odot} star, gravitational mass, and baryonic density at the onset of the nuclear DU process for each EoS considered.

The APR4 EoS (Akmal et al. 1998) is based on the Argonne v18 two-nucleon interaction (Wiringa et al. 1995; Machleidt et al. 1996) supplemented by relativistic boost corrections and the three-body forces (Wiringa et al. 1988). It is known for its comparatively soft behaviour at supranuclear densities and for including microscopic many-body correlations (Akmal & Pandharipande 1997). The model achieves realistic saturation properties and supports a maximum mass of about 2 M⊙M_{\odot} when three-body interactions are included.

The DD2 EoS (Typel et al. 2010) is a nucleonic relativistic mean–field (RMF) EoS with density-dependent meson-nucleon couplings calibrated to nuclear structure data and constrained by microscopic Dirac-Brueckner calculations at low densities. The DD2 EoS provides a relatively stiff symmetry energy and yields large radii. An important feature of the DD2 EoS is its consistent treatment of medium effects through density-dependent couplings, enabling it to reproduce both finite-nucleus properties and homogeneous matter up to several times saturation density.

The FSU2R EoS (Tolos et al. 2017) is an updated version of the RMF FSU2 model (Chen & Piekarewicz 2014), predicting smaller NS radii while satisfying the observational constraint on the maximum NS mass. The main modifications concern the density dependence of the nuclear symmetry energy, with a reduction in its slope from L=113L = 113 MeV in FSU2 to L=44.3L = 44.3 MeV in FSU2R. This softens the pressure of neutron-rich matter around nuclear saturation density, leading to more compact NS configurations. At the same time, the EoS retains sufficient stiffness at higher densities to support a maximum mass of approximately 2.05 M⊙M_{\odot}. The FSU2R parameters are constrained by empirical nuclear data, ensuring a consistent description of finite nuclei and bulk nuclear matter.

The IST EoS (Sagun et al. 2019) is based on the induced surface tension (IST) framework, which accounts for the short-range hard-core repulsion between particles. The IST term arises naturally in dense matter due to short-range repulsion and provides a smooth transition between the excluded volume description at low densities and the eigenvolume regime at high densities, where the IST contribution vanishes (Sagun et al. 2014). In the dilute-gas limit, the IST EoS accurately reproduces the first four virial coefficients of a gas of hard spheres. The hard-core radius of nucleons is constrained by fits to particle ratios measured in heavy-ion collision experiments over a wide range of center-of-mass collision energies (Sagun et al. 2018), while the eigen surface tension parameters are determined to reproduce the nuclear liquid–gas phase transition and its critical endpoint (Sagun et al. 2017; Kucherenko et al. 2022). The long-range attraction of the mean-field type and symmetry energy parameters are constrained by NS observations and the tidal deformability inferred from the GW170817 binary NS merger (Sagun et al. 2019). In this work, we employ Set B of the IST EoS developed in Sagun et al. (2020).

The NL3ωρ\omega\rho EoS (Horowitz & Piekarewicz 2001) is an extension of the original NL3 RMF EoS (Lalazissis et al. 1997) in which the density dependence of the symmetry energy is modified through an isoscalar-isovector ω−ρ\omega-\rho mixing term. This additional nonlinear coupling alters the effective ρ\rho–meson mass allowing for variations in the symmetry energy slope while preserving the well-established isoscalar properties of the NL3 model and its successful description of finite nuclei. The resulting family of parametrizations is consistent with current constraints and yields a relatively stiff high-density behaviour, supporting NS gravitational masses above 2 M⊙_\odot (Carriere et al. 2003; Pais & Providência 2016). In this work, we used the NL3ωρ\omega\rho formulation presented in (Pais & Providência 2016), which satisfies current nuclear matter and astrophysical constraints.

It is worth noting that the particle composition of the adopted EoSs differs. While the IST EoS includes neutrons, protons, and electrons, the APR4, FSU2R, DD2, and NL3ωρ\omega\rho EoSs also include muons. The presence of muons modifies the DU threshold by increasing the minimum proton fraction required to satisfy momentum conservation. As a result, the DU process is activated at higher gravitational masses (Page et al. 2004).

For the realistic description of the outer layers, all the EoSs are supplemented by the Haensel-Zdunik (HZ) EoS for the outer crust and the Negele-Vautherin (NV) EoS for the inner crust (Negele & Vautherin 1973; Haensel & Zdunik 1990).

Nuclear superfluidity and superconductivity

Nucleon pairing in the crust and core affects the thermal evolution of NSs by modifying the heat capacity and neutrino emissivity. While superfluidity and superconductivity suppress standard neutrino emission processes, Cooper pair breaking and formation (PBF) provide an additional neutrino emission channel that can enhance cooling (Lattimer et al. 1991; Page et al. 2006; Pote\-kh\-in et al. 2015).

Given the significant uncertainties associated with nucleon pairing gaps (Lombardo & Schulze 2001; Dean & Hjorth-Jensen 2003), particularly for the neutron triplet pairing channel, it is often convenient to describe it by simple analytic functions. In this work, we adopt the parametrization proposed by Yanagi (2019), based on a modified Gaussian function

Tc(kF)=Tc,max⁡exp⁡[−(kF−kF,0δkF)2−r(kF−kF,0δkF)4](1)T_c(k_F) = T_{c,\max}\exp\left[-\left(\frac{k_F-k_{F,0}}{\delta k_F}\right)^2-r\left(\frac{k_F-k_{F,0}}{\delta k_F}\right)^4\right] \tag*{(1)}

where Tc,max⁡T_{c,\max} denotes the maximum critical temperature predicted by the model, kF,0k_{F,0} is the Fermi momentum at which this maximum is obtained, δkF\delta k_F represents the width of the Gaussian profile in momentum space, and rr is an additional dimensionless free parameter introduced to adjust the shape of the pairing gap. All these quantities are treated as parameters of the model.

In total, nine models were considered, with three Gaussian parametrisations for each of the three pairing channels: neutron singlet (n 1S0^1S_0), proton singlet (p 1S0^1S_0), and neutron triplet (n 3P2^3P_2). For the n 1S0^1S_0 channel, parametrisations ‘N1’ and ‘N3’ correspond to the SFB (Schwenk et al. 2003) and CCDK [32] models, respectively. In the p 1S0^1S_0 channel, ‘P1’ and ‘P3’, correspond to the AO (Amundsen & Østgaard 1985) and CCDK [32] pairing models, while for the n 3P2^3P_2 channel, ‘T1’ and ‘T3’, they represent the ‘a’ and ‘c’ models, respectively (Kaminker et al. 2001, 2002). The ‘N2’, ‘P2’ and ‘T2’ models were constructed as intermediate cases, with parameters taken as the arithmetic means of the corresponding values in the two limiting models. For the triplet supplemented pairing, we only take permutations in the singlet neutron and proton channels of the most representative models, namely ‘N1’ and ‘N3’ for the n 1S0^1S_0 and ‘P1’ and ‘P3’ for the p 1S0^1S_0, and combine each of them with the three n 3P2^3P_2 ‘T1’, ‘T2’, and ‘T3’. A cross-check of the Gaussian fits against the pairing models already implemented in NSCool confirmed full consistency with our fitted results. Altogether, we consider each pairing combination as an ordered set ‘i-j-k’, with i, j, and k denoting the identifiers of the pairing models. Table 2 lists the different pairing and parameter values considered in this work.

ChannelModelTc,max⁡T_{c,\max} [10910^9 K]kF,0k_{F,0} [fm−1^{-1}]δkF\delta k_F [fm−1^{-1}]rr [ ]
n 1S0n\,^1S_0N1 (SFB)5.1080.8100.5641.086
N25.4160.7310.4240.663
N3 (CCDK)5.7240.6520.2840.240
n 3P2n\,^3P_2T1 (a)1.0001.8000.5000.000
T25.5002.1500.6000.000
T3 (c)10.0002.5000.7000.000
p 1S0p\,^1S_0P1 (AO)2.3500.4900.3100.000
P24.4750.5750.4150.345
P3 (CCDK)6.6000.6600.4600.690

Table 2. Free parameters describing the Gaussian profile of the pairing gap for the neutron singlet (n 1S0^1S_0), neutron triplet (n 3P2^3P_2), and proton singlet (p 1S0^1S_0) channels. See text for details.

TOV equations

The astrophysical properties of NSs are obtained by solving the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equations, which describe hydrostatic equilibrium in general relativity for a spherically symmetric and non-rotating configuration (Oppenheimer & Volkoff 1939; Tolman 1939). For a given EoS, these equations determine the radial profiles of pressure and enclosed mass as functions of the energy density

dpdr=−G(ϵ+p)(M+4πr3p)r2(1−2GM/r),(2)\frac{dp}{dr}=-\frac{G(\epsilon+p)(M+4\pi r^3p)}{r^2(1-2GM/r)}, \tag*{(2)}
dMdr=4πr2ϵ.(3)\frac{dM}{dr}=4\pi r^2\epsilon. \tag*{(3)}

Here, ϵ\epsilon and pp denote the energy density and pressure, respectively, while M(r)M(r) is the gravitational mass enclosed within radius rr. The gravitational mass and radius are obtained by integrating the TOV equations outward from the centre, where the energy density is fixed as an initial condition, until the pressure vanishes at the surface. The gravitational mass as a function of radius for all the EoSs considered is shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2. Gravitational mass as a function of the star radius for the considered EoSs. The filled circles denote the DU onset mass for each EoS. The dotted segments indicate regions not covered by the simulations, while the solid segments correspond to the mass values included in the cooling dataset. The yellow and cyan bands represent the 1σ1\sigma mass constraints on the heaviest pulsars PSR J1810+1744 (Romani et al. 2021), and PSR J0952-0607 (Romani et al. 2022), respectively. The updated NICER measurement for PSR J0030+0451 is shown by the solid (95% CL) and dashed (68% CL) brown contours (Kini et al. 2026), in addition to the filled region (95% CL) (Miller et al. 2019). PSR J0437-4715 is depicted with dashed (68% CL) and solid (95% CL) yellow contours (Choudhury et al. 2024), together with the yellow filled region (Miller et al. 2026). The PSR J0740+6620 constraints are shown by the solid purple (Dittmann et al. 2024) and blue (Salmi et al. 2024a) contours. The results from the LIGO-Virgo Collaboration for the GW170817 (Abbott et al. 2018) and GW190425 (Abbott et al. 2020) binary NSs mergers are shown in teal and magenta, respectively. The solid and dashed dark green contours show the NICER measurements of PSR J0614-3329 (Mauviard et al. 2025). PSR J1231-1411 is depicted with the purple filled region and the dotted contour inside it, corresponding to the 95% and 68% CL (Qi et al. 2025), and with the solid (95% CL) and dashed (68% CL) purple contours (Salmi et al. 2024b). The gray-shaded region in the top-left corner is ruled out by the causality constraint.

NS Cooling

Cooling processes

The thermal evolution of an NS is described by the thermal balance equation, which relates the redshifted temperature of matter at the bottom of the envelope, Tb∞T_b^\infty, to the redshifted neutrino and photon luminosities

CvdTb∞dt=−Lν∞−Lγ∞+H∞,(4)C_v\frac{dT_b^\infty}{dt}=-L_\nu^\infty-L_\gamma^\infty+H^\infty, \tag*{(4)}

where tt is the time measured by a distant observer, CvC_v is the total heat capacity, and TbT_b is the local matter temperature at the bottom of the envelope, typically defined at a density ρb∼1010 g cm−3\rho_b\sim10^{10}\ {\rm g\,cm^{-3}}. The local effective surface temperature, TsT_s, determines the photon luminosity (Page (1997)). Their redshifted counterparts are Tb∞T_b^\infty and Ts∞T_s^\infty, respectively. The photon luminosity measured by a distant observer is given by Lγ∞=4πR2(Ts∞)4L_\gamma^\infty= 4\pi R^2(T_s^\infty)^4, where RR is the circumferential radius of the star. In contrast, neutrino emission occurs from the bulk of the star. The term H∞H^\infty represents additional contributions from internal heating or cooling mechanisms, e.g., magnetic field decay, dark matter effect, etc. ((Ho et al. 2015; Sagun et al. 2023; Ávila et al. 2024; Giangrandi et al. 2024)). In this work, no additional heating sources are considered, H∞=0H^\infty= 0.

Figure 1. Critical temperatures of singlet neutron (left panel), triplet neutron (middle panel), and singlet proton (right panel) superfluidities in NS matter, as functions of the neutron number density, nnn_n, and the proton number density, npn_p, for different superfluidity and superconductivity models for the parameters used in Table 2.

NS cooling could be roughly split into three stages: (i) unequilibrated stage (Sales et al. (2020)); (ii) neutrino emission dominated stage, and (iii) photon emission dominated stage ((Page et al. 2004; Yakovlev & Pethick 2004)). The early time up to the moment when the core and crust become thermally coupled is called the thermal relaxation time, which takes around ∼100\sim100–300300 years since the formation of the NS. During this stage, the surface temperature is largely independent of the stellar mass, core neutrino luminosity, and internal composition, being mainly determined by the crustal thermal energy content, neutrino losses, and heat transport. Once the crust and core thermally couple, the thermal evolution of the core is transmitted to the surface and becomes observable.

After thermal relaxation, the high thermal conductivity maintains an approximately uniform temperature throughout the interior below the envelope. The neutrino-dominated cooling stage lasts for approximately 10510^5 years and transitions to a photon-dominated phase for older NSs, producing a characteristic ‘shoulder’-type behaviour in the cooling curve (Page et al. (2006)). The transition between these regimes depends on the particle composition of the NS and star mass. Neutrino emission in the core arises from weak interactions of degenerate baryons and leptons. The most efficient mechanisms are the β\beta-decay

n→p+l−+νˉl,(5)n \to p + l^- + \bar{\nu}_l, \tag*{(5)}

and its inverse

p+l−→n+νl,(6)p + l^- \to n + \nu_l, \tag*{(6)}

where ll stands for leptons, either electrons or muons. These processes require the Fermi momenta (pFp_F) of the particle species involved to satisfy a triangle inequality pF,p+pF,l≥pF,np_{F,p} + p_{F,l} \geq p_{F,n} ((Lattimer et al. 1991; Page et al. 2006; Potekhin et al. 2015)). This condition imposes a threshold on the proton fraction, typically Yp≳0.11Y_p \gtrsim0.11 (Lattimer et al. (1991)) for neutron–proton–electron (npenpe) matter and a larger value given by

Yp=(1+(1+xe1/3)3)−1,(7)Y_p = \left(1 + \left(1 + x_e^{1/3}\right)^3\right)^{-1}, \tag*{(7)}

when muons are present. Here, xe=ne/(ne+nμ)x_e = n_e/(n_e+n_\mu) and the densities of electrons and muons are nen_e and nμn_\mu, respectively. Below this limit, only the less efficient MU, where an extra spectator nucleon enables the reaction, along with nucleon–nucleon bremsstrahlung processes, operate (Page et al. (2004, 2006)).

The surface temperature of an NS is set by heat transport through its thin outer envelope, described by the TbT_b–TsT_s relation that connects the isothermal interior to the photosphere. This relation is governed by a thin layer ((Gudmundsson et al. 1982, 1983)), where electrons are only partially degenerate and the thermal conductivity is least efficient. Small variations in the envelope composition can significantly modify the TbT_b–TsT_s relation by altering the thermal insulation of the star. In particular, light-element envelopes, H or He, provide a higher thermal conductivity than heavy-element ones, leading to higher surface temperatures for a given TbT_b and resulting in systematic variations in the predicted cooling curves ((Page 1997; Chabrier et al. 1997; Potekhin et al. 1997; Beznogov et al. 2021)). The envelope composition is parameterised by η=ΔM/M\eta= \Delta M/M, where ΔM\Delta M denotes the mass of light elements. Typical values span η∼10−18\eta\sim10^{-18} for almost pure heavy-element envelopes up to ∼10−6\sim10^{-6} for accreted light-element envelopes. In this way, the envelope provides the bridge between the NS particle composition and the X-ray observations ((Potekhin et al. 1997; Page 1997)).

Cooling Curves

We study the thermal evolution for different values of the NS gravitational mass, envelope composition, EoS and superconductivity/superfluidity model using NSCool standard settings, not considering the effects of magnetic fields, additional cooling and/or heating mechanisms and accretion (Page (2016)).

For configurations with unpaired matter and singlet pairing, the mass grid was sampled from 1.00 to 2.00 M⊙_\odot with a step of 0.01 M⊙_\odot (and 0.10 M⊙_\odot for triplet pairing). This upper limit was adopted. for the APR4, FSU2R, and IST EoSs as the DU process is activated at gravitational masses below or close to 2 M⊙2\,M_{\odot} (see Table 1). Once DU operates, the enhanced neutrino emission leads to rapid cooling, producing a noticeable decrease in the surface luminosity within the time range covered by the observational data. For the DD2 and NL3ωρ\omega\rho EoSs, the mass grid was extended beyond 2.00 M⊙2.00\,M_{\odot} up to values close to the maximum gravitational mass allowed by each EoS, using a step of 0.10 M⊙0.10\,M_{\odot}. On the other hand, the envelope composition was parametrized by η=10−x\eta= 10^{-x}, with xx ranging from 6 to 18 and sampled in steps of 1 (and 2 in the case of triplets).

The resulting datasets contain approximately 17660 cooling curves for the APR4, FSU2R, and IST EoSs, 18480 for the DD2 EoS, and 18880 for the NL3ωρ\omega\rho Eos. The resulting cooling curves are shown in Figure 3.

Figure 3. Cooling curves for stars with gravitational masses spanning the range indicated by the colour bar and computed using the APR4 (a), DD2 (b), FSU2R (c), IST (d), and NL3ωρ\omega\rho (e) EoSs. Each panel displays the red-shifted photon luminosity, Lγ∞L_{\gamma}^{\infty}, as a function of the stellar age, tt, for different gravitational masses, envelope compositions, and pairing combinations. The cooling curves are shown for unpaired matter (solid), models including only neutron 1S0^{1}S_{0} pairing (dashed), both neutron and proton singlet pairing (dotted), and, for the latter case, additional neutron 3P2^{3}P_{2} triplet pairing (dash-dotted). The utilized observational data are listed in the Appendix A.

Data Analysis

The goal of this section is to confront the cooling curves generated with NSCool for different EoS, with the observed NS data shown in Figure 3 and listed in Appendix A. For each NS ν\nu, the predicted luminosity is determined jointly by the underlying EoS, the specific superconductivity and superfluidity model, and the set of nuisance parameters θν={MNSν,ΔMν}\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\nu} = \{M_{\mathrm{NS}}^{\nu}, \Delta M^{\nu}\}, where MNSνM_{\mathrm{NS}}^{\nu} is the gravitational mass of the NS, ΔMν\Delta M^{\nu} accounts for the envelope. We therefore consider a given model to be described by an EoS and a superconductivity/superfluidity models, labeled as ‘i-j-k’, where ii, jj, and kk denote the numerical identifiers of the neutron and proton pairing gaps in the 1S0^{1}S_{0} (singlet), n 3P2n\,^{3}P_{2} (triplet), and p 1S0p\,^{1}S_{0} (singlet) channels, respectively, as listed in Table 2 and described in § 2.2. We also consider the case of unpaired matter that corresponds to ‘0-0-0’. In total, this results in 75 different models (5 EoS times 15 different pairing combinations).

Our statistical analysis follows the frequentist framework adopted in Tanabashi et al. (2018); Buschmann et al. (2022). Under the assumption that the luminosity and age measurements are independently Gaussian distributed, the likelihood for each star ν\nu can be written as

Lν(dν∣EoS,θν)=N(L(EoS,θν)−L0ν,σLν),(8)\mathcal{L}_{\nu}(d_{\nu}\mid\mathrm{EoS},\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\nu}) = \mathcal{N}\left(\mathcal{L}(\mathrm{EoS},\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\nu})-L_{0}^{\nu},\sigma_{L}^{\nu}\right), \tag*{(8)}

where the observational data set for each star ν\nu is given by dν={L0ν,σLν}d_{\nu} = \{L_{0}^{\nu},\sigma_{L}^{\nu}\}, with L0νL_{0}^{\nu} denoting the measured luminosity and σLν\sigma_{L}^{\nu} the associated uncertainty. Here, N(x,σ)\mathcal{N}(x,\sigma) denotes a normal distribution with zero mean and standard deviation σ\sigma, evaluated at xx. In practice, we evaluate the likelihood along the theoretical cooling curve at the central value and therefore neglect time uncertainties in the analysis. The joint-likelihood over the whole observational data is then constructed as the product over individual stars as

L(d∣EoS,θ)=∏ν=1NLν(dν∣EoS,θν),(9)\mathcal{L}(d\mid\mathrm{EoS},\boldsymbol{\theta}) = \prod_{\nu=1}^{N}\mathcal{L}_{\nu}(d_{\nu}\mid\mathrm{EoS},\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\nu}), \tag*{(9)}

where NN corresponds to the observational data. Note that the total list of model nuisance parameters is denoted by θ={θν}ν=1N\boldsymbol{\theta} = \{\boldsymbol{\theta}^{\nu}\}_{\nu=1}^{N}. For a given EoS and superfluidity/superconductivity models, the best-fit nuisance parameters, θ^\hat{\boldsymbol{\theta}}, associated with a particular observational data point are obtained by maximizing the joint likelihood (Demortier 2007). Under the assumption of Gaussian distributed measurements, constant variance, and zero mean, this procedure is equivalent to minimizing the corresponding chi-square

χ2=(L(EoS,θ)−L0)2σL2,(10)\chi^{2} = \frac{\left(\mathcal{L}(\mathrm{EoS},\boldsymbol{\theta})-L_{0}\right)^{2}}{\sigma_{L}^{2}}, \tag*{(10)}

between the ensemble of cooling curves and the observational point (Tanabashi et al. 2018). For each source, we therefore determine the configuration of nuisance parameters that minimizes χ2\chi^{2}, which we denote as χmin⁡2\chi_{\min}^{2}.

The analysis is carried out in two steps. First, for each observational NS data point and each EoS and pairing combination, we identify the best fitting parameters by maximizing the individual likelihood with respect to the NS mass and envelope composition. The corresponding goodness-of-fit for each NS is shown in Figure 4 for all EoSs and pairing combinations considered in this work.

Figure 4. Minimum χ2+1\chi^2+1 values obtained for each EoS by fitting the cooling-curve dataset to each observational data point considered (see Appendix A for details) for different pairing assumptions: unpaired matter (top panel), neutron 1S0{}^{1}S_{0} pairing only (2nd panel from above), neutron and proton 1S0{}^{1}S_{0} pairing (3rd panel from above) and including neutron 3P2{}^{3}P_{2} pairing (bottom panel). The solid and dashed horizontal lines indicate the 2σ2\sigma and 3σ3\sigma confidence thresholds, respectively, drawn from a χ\chi-square distribution.

For comparison we also show in the horizontal σ\sigma-lines in Figure 4 the nominal confidence levels derived from the cumulative χ2\chi^{2} distribution (that has been assumed). For a given number of degrees of freedom, the cumulative distribution determines the χ2\chi^{2} value above which the agreement between model and data is rejected at the corresponding confidence level (Cowan et al. 2011). In particular, the 1, 2, and 3σ\sigma lines correspond to confidence intervals of 68, 95, and 99.7, respectively, obtained from the pp-value of the cumulative χ2\chi^{2} distribution for the corresponding number of dof. Throughout this work, quoted nσn\sigma thresholds refer to the frequentist confidence regions (Tanabashi et al. 2018).

In the second step, we require a single EoS and pairing model to describe the entire observational dataset. Using the joint likelihood in Eq. (9) and the individual chi-square contributions defined in Eq. (10), we minimize each source’s contribution over its gravitational mass and envelope composition, and sum these minima to obtain a global discrepancy statistic. We assume the resulting statistics to follow a chi-square distribution with N−2N-2 degrees of freedom, χred2=χ2/dof⁡\chi_{\rm red}^{2}=\chi^{2}/{\operatorname{dof}}, where NN is the number of luminosity measurements included in the analysis and the subtraction of two is motivated heuristically by the two stellar quantities varied for each source, MNSM_{\rm NS} and ΔM\Delta M. A dedicated determination of the probability distribution is needed for a more accurate determination of the exclusion lines. Therefore, the resulting thresholds are only illustrative. Finally, we also note that we performed two separate analyses, one with all the NS cooling data, including Cas A (Shternin et al. 2022) and another without it (see Figure 5).

Figure 5. Reduced global χ2\chi^2 over a given pairing combination considered in this work. The dashed, solid, and dotted horizontal lines indicate the 1σ1\sigma, 2σ2\sigma, and 3σ3\sigma nominal confidence thresholds, respectively. The top panel shows the analysis excluding the Cas A data, while the bottom panel includes Cas A using the GRADED-mode observations with variable hydrogen column density (see text for details).

For the observational data points used in the analysis, listed in Appendix A, asymmetric uncertainties in age and luminosity are treated conservatively by adopting the larger uncertainty with respect to the central value. We adopt the luminosity uncertainties quoted in the observational compilation without adding further systematic uncertainties.

Results

We now discuss the results of the analysis presented in the previous section. We begin by examining the best fits for individual NSs and the role of the different superfluid and superconducting channels. This provides insight into which data points are more difficult to reproduce within the model.

We then combine these results to perform a global analysis of the full observational dataset, comparing the different EoS–pairing models using the normalized global minimum chi-square. In this global analysis, we consider two cases: one including all sources and another excluding Cas A, in order to assess the impact of this distinctive source on the overall results.

Individual NS fits

We begin by fitting each NS cooling data point independently. The minimum values of χ2\chi^{2}, obtained by varying the NS mass, the envelope composition, and the pairing models listed in Table 2, are shown in Figure 4. The data points are labelled from 1 to 24, and different colours correspond to different EoSs. The four panels represent the various pairing scenarios: unpaired matter (top), neutron singlet pairing (second from above), neutron and proton singlet pairing (third from above), and neutron and proton singlet pairing combined with neutron triplet pairing (bottom). The solid and dotted blue lines indicate the 2σ2\sigma and 3σ3\sigma nominal confidence intervals, respectively.

Cooling curves from unpaired matter and singlet pairing show similar performance in reproducing the cooling data across all EoSs. Among them, the DD2 EoS exhibits some tension with the data, with seven data points showing a less satisfactory agreement. For the remaining EoSs, the most challenging cases correspond to data points 6, 13, and 14, whose χ2\chi^2 values typically lie well above the 3σ3\sigma threshold.

The situation changes significantly when neutron triplet pairing is included. Several data points that were previously disfavored at more than the nominal 3σ3\sigma level are shifted below the 2σ2\sigma confidence threshold, meaning that most data points can be reproduced for all EoS by the cooling curve of at least one combination of the models listed in Table 2. The main exceptions are the data points 13 and 14 for the FSU2R EoS, and 21 and 22 for the DD2 EoS.

Global minimum χ2\chi^2

We now perform a global analysis by combining all data points and requiring each individual model—defined by a given EoS and pairing set (ii–jj–kk)—to simultaneously reproduce the full cooling dataset. This is done by varying the two nuisance parameters, MνNSM_{\nu}^{\mathrm{NS}} and ΔMν\Delta M^{\nu}.

The resulting reduced χ2\chi^2 values for each model combination are shown in Figure 5, both excluding (upper panel) and including (lower panel) the Cas A data (see Figure 6).

Figure 6. Red-shifted photon luminosity, Lγ∞L_{\gamma}^{\infty}, as a function of stellar age, tt, for the best-fit cooling curves corresponding to the considered EoSs - APR4, DD2, FSU2R, IST, and NL3ωρ\omega\rho. The observational data corresponds to the data presented in Table A2.

Overall, the vast majority of the sampled model combinations provide a poor simultaneous description of the adopted cooling data, as indicated by their large minimum global chi-square values. The only clear exceptions are the NL3ω\omega models with ‘T3’ triplet pairing and the IST model with ‘N1’ singlet and ‘T1’ triplet neutron pairing. The origin of the poor fits in the remaining models can be traced back to Figure 4, in particular to stars number 13, CXOU J061705.3+222127 (IC 443), and 14, PSR B0833-45 (Vela). These objects, characterized by very small error bars, lie in an intermediate region of the luminosity plot in Figure 3, roughly spanning 1–100 kyr and 103110^{31}–103310^{33} erg s−1^{-1}. Within the set of EoS models considered here, this region is difficult to reproduce: models without DU processes tend to predict higher luminosities, whereas those with an active DU channel typically yield lower luminosities. Only the NL3ωρ\omega\rho model with triplet pairing fully covers this intermediate regime, with the IST EoS providing a partial match. This ultimately explains why these models are the only ones capable of satisfying all observational constraints.

In Negreiros et al. (2018), it was shown that the FSU2R EoS can provide a satisfactory description of relatively cool stars when rapid DU cooling is combined with neutron and proton singlet pairing. However, the proton pairing adopted in that study is substantially stronger, with a critical temperature well above those considered in the present study and in the literature.

These results differ from those reported in Das et al. (2024), where it was found that singlet pairing scenarios alone can account for the cooling data. This difference is attributed to the distinct microphysical inputs adopted in the study. In particular, Ref. Das et al. (2024) considers a relatively limited set of EoSs, among which there is the Brueckner–Hartree–Fock EoS with the Argonne V18 nucleon–nucleon potential (Baldo & Burgio 2012) permitting a very early onset of the DU processes. In addition, the singlet pairing gaps adopted in that study are substantially larger than their typical maximum values reported in the literature and extend over a considerably broader density range, reaching densities several times higher than those commonly considered. These assumptions lead to a strong suppression of the neutrino emissivity, enabling the observational data to be reproduced. Given these differences in setup, a direct quantitative comparison between the two analyses is not straightforward.

Cassiopeia A

We now briefly discuss Cas A, which is distinctive within the dataset containing two decades of observation (Figure 6). For Cas A, we used the observations obtained by Chandra/ACIS in GRADED mode, adopting the data in which the hydrogen column density, NHN_{\rm H}, is treated as a free parameter (Shternin et al. 2022) (see Table A2 in Appendix).

No.Object namett [yr]Lγ∞L_{\gamma}^{\infty} [103310^{33} erg s−1^{-1}]Refs.
24Cas A (GRADED NH_{\rm H} var)320.088.272−0.225+0.2328.272^{+0.232}_{-0.225}(Shternin et al. 2022)
322.108.662−0.236+0.2438.662^{+0.243}_{-0.236}
324.108.197−0.223+0.2308.197^{+0.230}_{-0.223}
327.097.685−0.209+0.2157.685^{+0.215}_{-0.209}
329.847.685−0.209+0.2157.685^{+0.215}_{-0.209}
330.837.205−0.196+0.2027.205^{+0.202}_{-0.196}
332.377.407−0.202+0.2087.407^{+0.208}_{-0.202}
333.397.614−0.208+0.2137.614^{+0.213}_{-0.208}
334.367.614−0.208+0.2137.614^{+0.213}_{-0.208}
335.337.009−0.191+0.1967.009^{+0.196}_{-0.191}
336.807.009−0.191+0.1967.009^{+0.196}_{-0.191}
337.387.407−0.202+0.2087.407^{+0.208}_{-0.202}
338.377.073−0.193+0.1987.073^{+0.198}_{-0.193}
339.377.139−0.195+0.1997.139^{+0.199}_{-0.195}

Table A2. Cas A observations with Chandra ACIS in GRADED mode, whereas the hydrogen column density, NHN_{\rm H}, is variable. Time is given in years, and luminosities are expressed in units of 103310^{33} erg s−1^{-1}.

We find that including Cas A does not drastically modify the overall global fit, since the reduced χ2\chi^2 values change only moderately across the EoSs and pairing configurations considered. However, it is worth noting that Cas A introduces a preference in the parameter space. Figure 6 shows the best fits to the Cas A data. The FSU2R EoS accompanied with singlet neutron pairing and the IST EoS including singlet neutron and strong proton pairing provide the best agreement. The corresponding curves are obtained for heavy NSs with M≳1.94M \gtrsim1.94–1.97M⊙M_\odot.

Although Cas A has a limited impact on the overall global fit, it can substantially affect the statistical viability of specific pairing configurations. In particular, the inclusion of Cas A shifts the fixed pairing combination N1-T1-P1 for the IST EoS from being compatible at the nominal 2σ2\sigma level to exceeding the 3σ3\sigma confidence threshold. Similar results were obtained in Tsiopelas & Sagun (2020, 2021) for the IST EoS. This shows that, despite its modest statistical weight within the full sample, Cas A acts as a strong discriminator for particular pairing combinations within otherwise acceptable cooling scenarios. This is presented in the bottom panel of Figure 5.

Conclusions and discussion

We presented a frequentist χ2\chi^2 analysis of the thermal evolution of isolated NSs by confronting a large grid of cooling curves obtained with NSCool code with the luminosity-age observations of 24 sources. For each object, we varied the gravitational mass and envelope composition and explored five nucleonic EoSs: APR4, DD2, FSU2R, IST, and NL3ωρ\omega\rho, combined with and without representative proton singlet, neutron singlet and triplet pairing models.

We found that models without pairing provide a poor description of the data. Including neutron and proton singlet pairing improves the agreement for a subset of sources, but remains overall insufficient, leaving several objects in strong tension with the data. Particularly, four middle-age objects with a lower surface temperature challenge the NS thermal evolution modeling: CXOU J061705.3+222127 (IC 443) (number 13), PSR B0833-45 (Vela) (number 14), PSR J0205+6449 (3C 58) (number 21), and PSR B2334+61 (number 22).

Within the set of EoSs and superfluidity/superconductivity models considered, a consistent description of the full dataset is only achieved when neutron triplet pairing is included; even in this case, viable fits are restricted to the NL3ωρ\omega\rho EoS and, to a lesser extent, the IST EoS. The remaining EoSs explored, namely, the APR4, DD2, and FSU2R, are therefore disfavoured. We also assessed the impact of the Cas A data on the overall analysis and found that they do not qualitatively alter the global fit values across the different EoSs, although they can discriminate between specific fixed pairing configurations.

The two cooler middle-age objects, PSR J0205+6449 (3C 58) and PSR B2334+61, together with CXOU J085201.4-461753 (Vela Jr.), were also identified in Marino et al. (2024) as objects that cannot be explained without enhanced cooling. In Marino et al. (2024), the authors found that the DU process needs to be activated to reproduce the observed surface temperatures of these objects. Providing an efficient neutrino-emission channel capable of explaining faintest middle-age NSs. However, we find that models with active DU cooling tend to over-suppress the luminosity at later times, making it difficult to reproduce the data in the central region of the luminosity-age diagram. This tension is alleviated when neutron triplet pairing is included.

The need for enhanced cooling through the DU process has also been reported in (Beznogov & Yakovlev 2015a,b; Das et al. 2024). These studies showed that singlet proton pairing can efficiently suppress the neutrino emission, while the PBF process associated with neutron 3P2{}^{3}P_{2} pairing does not always provide a satisfactory description of the data. While the results regarding the active cooling channels and pairing gaps are not yet conclusive, recent studies broadly indicate that enhanced neutrino cooling is required to reproduce the observational data, particularly for Cas A and the cooler middle-aged objects. The results suggest that activated DU cooling can be too strong and therefore requires a compensating effect, either through singlet proton or neutron triplet pairing. Alternatively, rapid cooling could be explained by additional processes of the MU neutrino reaction rates, as investigated in (Grigoriyan & Voskresensky 2005; Blaschke et al. 2013; Shternin et al. 2018). This problem is intrinsically multiparametric, as the choice of the underlying EoS, and hence the proton fraction and symmetry energy, affects the required strength of the pairing gaps and pairing channels. These results demonstrate that, in addition to multimessenger observations, NS cooling provides complementary constraints on dense matter, placing important constraints on the proton fraction and symmetry energy of realistic nucleonic NS EoSs alongside those obtained from nuclear structure, global NS observables, and recent gravitational-wave observations, while offering new insights into the interplay between the EoS and nucleon pairing properties.

As a further extension of the present study, it will be important to broaden the range of EoSs considered in the analysis to assess whether the apparent need for neutron triplet pairing found here is a generic feature across different EoSs or instead specific to the subset explored in this study. Such an extension could provide further insight into the underlying nuclear physics. Another natural extension would be to incorporate independent constraints on NS masses. Our current analysis does not make use of mass measurements, which in some cases could provide significant additional constraining power. This may be particularly relevant for well-studied objects such as Cas A. Finally, it would be interesting to investigate the impact of magnetic field and assess how its inclusion may affect the conclusions drawn here.

Acknowledgements

A.A. and R.Z.F acknowledge the financial support provided by FCT - Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia, I.P., through the Strategic Funding UID/04650/2025 and UID/04564/2025 and national funds with DOI identifiers 10.54499/2023.11681.PEX, 10.54499/2024.00249.CERN funded by measure RE-C06-i06.m02 – “Reinforcement of funding for International Partnerships in Science, Technology and Innovation” of the Recovery and Resilience Plan - RRP, within the framework of the financing contract signed between the Recover Portugal Mission Structure (EMRP) and the FCT - Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia, I.P. as an intermediate beneficiary. A.A. also acknowledge the support by FCT - Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia, I.P. by project reference 2025.01054.BD and DOI identifier 10.54499/2025.01054.BD. V.S. gratefully acknowledges support from the UKRI-funded “The next-generation gravitational-wave observatory network” project (Grant No. ST/Y004248/1). V.S. acknowledges the gratitude to the FCT for support under Advanced Computing Projects 2024.07037.CPCA.A1 with DOI identifier 10.54499/2024.07037.CPCA.A1. The authors also acknowledge the support from the FCT within the project No. 2023.10526.CPCA.A2 with DOI identifier 10.54499/2023.10526.CPCA.A2.

Data availability

The cooling data underlying this article are publicly available via the Zenodo database at 10.5281/zenodo.22102266.

Observational data

No.Object namett [kyr]Lγ∞L_{\gamma}^{\infty} [103310^{33} erg s−1^{-1}]Refs.
1RX J0822.0-4300 (Puppis A)4.45−0.75+0.754.45^{+0.75}_{-0.75}5−1.1+1.15^{+1.1}_{-1.1}(Becker et al. 2012; De Luca et al. 2012)
2CXOU J085201.4-461753 (Vela Jr.)3.075−0.675+2.0253.075^{+2.025}_{-0.675}0.5−0.37+0.10.5^{+0.1}_{-0.37}(Allen et al. 2015; Ho et al. 2026; Marino et al. 2024)
32XMM J104608.7-594306 (Homunculus)20.5−9.5+9.520.5^{+9.5}_{-9.5}0.348−0.271+0.2720.348^{+0.272}_{-0.271}(Pires et al. 2015)
41E 1207.4-5209 (G296.5+10.0)7−4.667+147^{+14}_{-4.667}1.31−0.16+0.491.31^{+0.49}_{-0.16}(Roger et al. 1988; Mereghetti et al. 2002)
5CXOU J160103.1-513353 (G330.2+1.0)0.8−0.2+0.20.8^{+0.2}_{-0.2}4.9−0.5+1.44.9^{+1.4}_{-0.5}(Borkowski et al. 2018; Ho et al. 2021)
61WGA J1713.4-3949 (G347.3-0.5)1.6085−0.0005+0.00051.6085^{+0.0005}_{-0.0005}2−0.3+0.32^{+0.3}_{-0.3}(Ho et al. 2021; Cassam-Chenai et al. 2004)
7XMMU J172054.5-372652 (G350.1-0.3)0.65−0.05+0.050.65^{+0.05}_{-0.05}11.8−1+111.8^{+1}_{-1}[79] (Ho et al. 2021)
8XMMU J173203.3-344518 (HESS J1731-347)4−2+24^{+2}_{-2}10.8−3+3.710.8^{+3.7}_{-3}(Maxted et al. 2018; Doroshenko et al. 2022)
9CXOU J181852.0-150213 (G015.9+00.2)3.4−0.7+2.63.4^{+2.6}_{-0.7}8.4−4.2+6.88.4^{+6.8}_{-4.2}(Sasaki et al. 2018; Klochkov et al. 2016)
10CXOU J185238.6+004020 (Kes 79)6−2.8+1.86^{+1.8}_{-2.8}10.4−2+2.410.4^{+2.4}_{-2}(Sun et al. 2004; Bogdanov 2014)
11PSR J0357+3205 (Morla)750−550+550750^{+550}_{-550}0.015−0.011+0.0250.015^{+0.025}_{-0.011}(Kirichenko et al. 2014)
12PSR J0538+2817 (Sim 147)30−10+3030^{+30}_{-10}1.09−0.46+0.271.09^{+0.27}_{-0.46}(Ng et al. 2006; Kramer et al. 2003)
13CXOU J061705.3+222127 (IC 443)30−5+530^{+5}_{-5}0.26−0.01+0.010.26^{+0.01}_{-0.01}(Chevalier 1999; Swartz et al. 2015)
14PSR B0833-45 (Vela)22−5+522^{+5}_{-5}0.424−0.012+0.0120.424^{+0.012}_{-0.012}(Aschenbach 2002; Ofengeim & Zyuzin 2018)
15PSR B0950+081900−1300+57001900^{+5700}_{-1300}0.00008−0.00006+0.000150.00008^{+0.00015}_{-0.00006}(Igoshev 2019; Abramkin et al. 2022)
16PSR B1951+32 (CTB 80)64−18+1864^{+18}_{-18}0.18−0.11+0.30.18^{+0.3}_{-0.11}[72] (Migliazzo et al. 2002)
17PSR J1119-6127 (G292.2-00.5)5.65−1.45+1.455.65^{+1.45}_{-1.45}1.9−0.8+1.91.9^{+1.9}_{-0.8}(Kumar et al. 2012; Ng et al. 2012)
18RX J0720.4-3125850−150+150850^{+150}_{-150}0.19−0.08+0.130.19^{+0.13}_{-0.08}(Tetzlaff et al. 2011; Hambaryan et al. 2017)
19RX J1605.3+3249440−60+70440^{+70}_{-60}0.253−0.246+0.2460.253^{+0.246}_{-0.246}(Tetzlaff et al. 2012; Malacaria et al. 2019; Pires et al. 2019)
20RX J1856.5-3754 (Upper Scorpius)420−80+80420^{+80}_{-80}0.065−0.015+0.0150.065^{+0.015}_{-0.015}(Mignani et al. 2013; Yoneyama et al. 2017)
21PSR J0205+6449 (3C 58)0.841−0.084+0.0840.841^{+0.084}_{-0.084}0.144−0.05+0.060.144^{+0.06}_{-0.05}(Kothes 2013; Potekhin et al. 2020; Marino et al. 2024)
22PSR B2334+617.7−0.77+0.777.7^{+0.77}_{-0.77}0.078−0.01+0.030.078^{+0.03}_{-0.01}(Marino et al. 2024)
23PSR B0656+14 (Monogem Ring)353.18−43.65+43.65353.18^{+43.65}_{-43.65}0.347−0.101+0.1430.347^{+0.143}_{-0.101}(Suzuki et al. 2021; Zharikov et al. 2021)

Table A1. Observational dataset used in this work, taken from Potekhin et al. (2020) (see also Potekhin, A. Y. (2023)). Stellar age is presented in kyr and luminosities, Lγ∞L_{\gamma}^{\infty}, are given in units of 103310^{33} erg s−1^{-1}.

This paper has been typeset from a TeX/LaTeX file prepared by the author.

References

  1. [32]Chen J. M. C., Clark J. W., Davé R. D., Khodel V. V., 1993, Nucl. Phys. A, 555, 59
  2. [72]Li X.-H., Lu F. J., Li T. P., 2005, Astrophys. J., 628, 931
  3. [79]Mayer M. G. F., Becker W., 2021, Astron. Astrophys., 651, A40

Paper details

vlnc:W_52uawtxc
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents