WorksMathematics
The algebraic classification of three-dimensional nilpotent left-symmetric dialgebras
Abstract
Left-symmetric dialgebras (LSDA) are to left-symmetric algebras what Leibniz algebras are to Lie algebras. We classify the three-dimensional nilpotent LSDA over the complex numbers. To do this we adapt the annihilator-extension (Skjelbred-Sund) method to dialgebras, using the annihilator with respect to both products on both sides, and we compute the second cohomology of all two-dimensional nilpotent LSDA. Up to isomorphism, besides the null and split algebras there are nine non-split algebras and families; the 2-step nilpotent families depend on four and three parameters. We give isomorphism criteria and separating invariants, identify the left-symmetric and diassociative algebras in the list, and complete the two-dimensional classification of an earlier paper.
Introduction
An algebra is left-symmetric if the associator is symmetric in and . These algebras go back to Cayley’s work on rooted trees [5] and arose independently in Vinberg’s theory of homogeneous convex cones [24] and in the study of affine structures on Lie groups. They are also called pre-Lie, Vinberg or Koszul–Vinberg algebras. The commutator of a left-symmetric product is a Lie bracket, and left-symmetric algebras appear in operad theory [6], deformation theory, renormalisation and Rota–Baxter theory [16]. Burde’s survey [4] collects their main applications in geometry and physics. Classifications are known in low dimensions: Kim [14] described the complete left-symmetric structures on nilpotent Lie algebras of small dimension, and Bai [2] classified the three-dimensional left-symmetric algebras over .
Loday introduced dialgebras, vector spaces with two products and , as the natural setting for Leibniz algebras [18, 19]: an associative dialgebra (diassociative algebra) gives a Leibniz algebra in the same way an associative algebra gives a Lie algebra. Diassociative algebras have since been studied structurally [10, 17], and the nilpotent ones were classified in dimension three [21] and four [22]. Felipe [8] defined left-symmetric dialgebras (LSDA) as the dialgebra analogue of left-symmetric algebras: they are to left-symmetric algebras what Leibniz algebras are to Lie algebras. When the axioms reduce to the left-symmetric identity, and every diassociative algebra is an LSDA. The author began the structure theory of LSDA in [20], introducing annihilators and nilpotency and classifying the two-dimensional LSDA over a field of characteristic zero.
The standard tool for nilpotent algebras of small dimension is the method of annihilator (central) extensions of Skjelbred and Sund [23], first used for nilpotent Lie algebras [7, 9]. Every nilpotent algebra is an annihilator extension of a smaller one, and isomorphism classes of extensions correspond to orbits of the automorphism group on subspaces of a second cohomology space. Hegazi, Abdelwahab and Calderón Martín adapted it to Malcev and other non-associative algebras [11], and it has since been applied to many varieties (Leibniz [1], Jordan, Novikov, bicommutative, Zinbiel and others); see the survey by Kaygorodov [13]. Boza, Fedriani, Núñez and Tenorio [3] review the history of Lie algebra classifications.
For LSDA no classification beyond dimension two is known, and the two-dimensional list of [20 Theorem 2.6] needs to be completed (Remark 3.2). The cohomology needed for annihilator extensions has not been set up for LSDA either. A difficulty specific to dialgebras is the choice of annihilator: the extension method needs the subspace killed on both sides by both products, which is smaller than the ideal used in [20 Definition 2.3].
In this paper we classify all three-dimensional nilpotent left-symmetric dialgebras over (Theorem 4.1), using annihilator extensions adapted to dialgebras. Besides the null and split algebras, there are nine non-split algebras and families, two of which depend on four and three parameters.
Preliminaries
All vector spaces are finite-dimensional over . For subspaces , of an algebra and a product , is the span of all .
Definition 2.1 ([8, 20]). A left-symmetric dialgebra (LSDA) is a vector space with two bilinear products and such that, for all ,
We keep the numbering of [20]. A homomorphism of LSDA is a linear map preserving both products.
Remark 2.2. If , then (1.1) and (1.2) are trivial and (1.3), (1.4) both become the left-symmetric identity, so an LSDA with equal products is a left-symmetric algebra. Every diassociative algebra [19] is an LSDA: its axioms make both sides of (1.3) and of (1.4) zero and give (1.1), (1.2) directly. Moreover, the commutator of an LSDA satisfies the (right) Leibniz identity [8], [20, Theorem 1.13]; for diassociative algebras this is Loday’s functor Dias Leib, and for it is the commutator LSA Lie. These relations form the extended Loday diagram of [20] (Figure 1), in which hooked arrows are inclusions of subcategories and the horizontal arrows on the right are the commutator functors.
Figure 1. The extended Loday diagram: associative algebras (As), diassociative algebras (Dias), left-symmetric algebras (LSA), left-symmetric dialgebras (LSDA), Lie and Leibniz (Leib) algebras.
Definition 2.3. Let be an LSDA.
The annihilator of is . It is an ideal of $S.
(2) Put and for . Then for all : this is clear for , and for every summand () of has or , so by induction it lies in or , which are summands of . The algebra is nilpotent if for some ; the least such is the nilpotency index.
(3) is split if , a direct sum of ideals with , and non-split otherwise.
The annihilator in [20 Definition 2.3] is the intersection of the right -annihilator and the left -annihilator . It contains and may be strictly larger. Annihilator extensions need the subspace killed by both products on both sides, which is above.
Lemma 2.4. Every non-zero nilpotent LSDA has . More precisely, if is the nilpotency index of , then .
Proof. Since we have , and by minimality of . The terms with and in the definition of give , , , . Hence . □
Since is an ideal, is again a nilpotent LSDA, of smaller dimension by Lemma 2.4. This is the basis of the inductive method below.
Definition 2.5. Let be an LSDA and a vector space. A pair of bilinear maps is a 2-cocycle if, for all ,
The cocycles form a space . For a linear map , the pair is a coboundary; the coboundaries form , and . We write . For the annihilator extension has the products
Lemma 2.6. Let be a pair of bilinear maps . Then is an LSDA if and only if . Moreover .
Proof. Products involving vanish, so it suffices to check (1.1)–(1.4) on . For example in . Each identity in therefore splits into its -component, which is the same identity in , and its -component, which is the corresponding condition of Definition 2.5. For , each condition is applied to an identity of , so it holds. □
Lemma 2.7. .
Proof. . For we have , with the two terms in and . So iff and ; the same holds for the other three conditions. □
Lemma 2.8. Let be an LSDA with and . Then for some with .
Proof. Choose a complement and let be the projection onto along . Identify with ; since is an ideal, the products of are . Put for . Then , so is a cocycle by Lemma 2.6, and Lemma 2.7 gives . □
Fix a basis of and write with . For put . Since , the condition depends only on the subspace .
Lemma 2.9. Let with .
is split if and only if are linearly dependent in .
If and are non-split, then if and only if there is with .
Proof. (1) If the classes are dependent, change the basis of so that with . Replacing by its graph changes by a coboundary and makes ; then is an ideal with complement , so is split. Conversely, let be a direct sum of ideals with . Then . Choose a complement ; all products lie in , so with respect to and a basis of ending with , the last component of the cocycle vanishes. A change of complement and of basis of replaces the by invertible combinations plus coboundaries, so the classes are dependent.
(2) Let be an isomorphism. By Lemma 2.7 both annihilators equal , so . Hence with , linear and . Comparing the -components of and for gives
Conversely, if , and satisfy this equation, the same computation shows that is an isomorphism. Applying gives with . Thus iff are the images of under some invertible matrix . For two independent families this is exactly equality of their spans. □
Corollary 2.10. The non-split -dimensional nilpotent LSDA with -dimensional annihilator correspond bijectively to the pairs , where runs over the -dimensional nilpotent LSDA up to isomorphism and over the -orbits of -dimensional subspaces with . Every split algebra is with nilpotent of dimension .
Proof. Lemmas 2.4, 2.8 and 2.9. □
Two-dimensional nilpotent LSDA and their cohomology
Notation. In all multiplication tables only the non-zero products of basis vectors are listed. For an algebra with basis we write (resp. ) for the cocycle with (resp. ) and all other values . For we put and . and denote the null algebras of dimensions 1 and 2.
Proposition 3.1. Every two-dimensional nilpotent LSDA over is isomorphic to the null algebra or to exactly one algebra
Always , and consists of the maps , with .
Proof. Let be non-null. By Lemma 2.4, , and is one-dimensional nilpotent, hence . Since has zero products, every pair is a cocycle and , so . The condition means . acts by on both coordinates, so the one-dimensional subspaces , that is the points , are pairwise inequivalent. By Corollary 2.10 this gives the list. An automorphism preserves , so and ; comparing with gives . □
:::
Remark 3.2 (Corrections to [20]). In Case 2 of the proof of [20 Theorem 2.6] () the identities give and , but only the subcase , , was treated. It yields the nilpotent algebra , (), which is after interchanging and ; this algebra does not appear in the list – of the statement. The remaining subcases give three further algebras: (that is, ), (that is, ), and the non-nilpotent algebra , obtained after the change removes a product . The last algebra is not isomorphic to any of –, because its product is zero, while each of – has . Hence [20 Theorem 2.6] should be supplemented by the nilpotent algebras of Proposition 3.1 and by the algebra ; all of them satisfy (1.1)–(1.4).
In what follows we normalise when , so the algebras are () and .
Proposition 3.3. Let . A pair is a cocycle if and only if
and . Consequently:
| Conditions on | Basis of | |||
| none | 0 | 2 | ||
| none | 0 | 8 | all | |
| , | , | 2 | , | |
| 2 | , | |||
| , | 4 | , , , |
Table 3.
Here equals 2, 8, 3, 3, 5 in the five rows.
Proof. The only non-zero products of are and , so a term or of Definition 2.5 is non-zero only when the inner pair is . Evaluating the four conditions on all basis triples gives:
first condition, : for ;
second condition, : for ;
third condition, triples , , , : , , and ;
fourth condition, triples , : .
All remaining triples give . Since , these equations are equivalent to the stated ones. For we get . Specialising to , to and to gives the rows of the table; for and every pair is a cocycle and . □
Lemma 3.4. Let , as in Proposition 3.1, and a rescaling of . Then has
Proof. Expand with , and use . □
The main theorem
Theorem 4.1 (Main Theorem). Every three-dimensional nilpotent left-symmetric dialgebra over is isomorphic to exactly one of the following algebras: the null algebra , a split algebra with , or one of the nine non-split algebras and families –, and $T below. Only non-zero products are listed; the basis is chosen so that spans (for , and span it), hence every product with as a factor is zero.
Algebras with two-dimensional and non-null (nilpotency index 4):
, : , , , ;
: , ;
: , , ;
, : , , , ;
, : , , ;
, : as but with .
Algebra with two-dimensional annihilator (nilpotency index 3):
: , .
2-step nilpotent algebras with (nilpotency index 3):
, with , , such that , or and :
, , ,
, , ;
, with , such that : , , , , and moreover if , if .
Algebras with different names are not isomorphic. Within the families:
(1) , , , and are isomorphic only for equal parameters (equal points of for the projective ones);
(2) if and only if there are with such that or ;
(3) if and only if for some ; that is, is a complete invariant.
Thus has four essential parameters (two when ) and has three. Normal forms for : if one may take or , and then is determined up to and the swap ; if , the algebra depends only on the unordered pair of points , .
Proof of the main theorem
Let be a three-dimensional nilpotent LSDA. By Lemma 2.4, , and means . If is split, then with a two-dimensional nilpotent LSDA, so is or by Proposition 3.1. In the latter case every satisfies and with , so is an isomorphism invariant. From now on is non-split, and by Corollary 2.10 it corresponds to a pair with .
Two-dimensional annihilator
If , then and is a two-dimensional subspace of , so is the whole space. The condition holds. Taking gives .
One-dimensional annihilator,
Now , and . By Lemma 2.9 the relevant group is acting as in Lemma 3.4, on classes modulo . Since and , the condition means . In each case has the products of plus the -components given by .
Case I: , . By Proposition 3.3, with . By Lemma 3.4, and . Modulo the pair is recorded by the number , and the shift changes it by per unit of . Choosing makes this class zero, and gives . Hence there is a single orbit, represented by , which gives .
Case II: . Here modulo , with . Since , Lemma 3.4 gives . The orbits are , giving , and (take and , so ), giving . Whether is invariant, so .
Case III: . Take the representative with and write , with . The class of modulo is well defined, and Lemma 3.4 gives
If , choose with and with , so . The transformations preserving this normal form satisfy and , so they fix . This gives , with pairwise non-isomorphic members. If , then and , with . For only the point survives, giving . For put , so and ; again only survives, giving . The quantities (zero or not) and (zero or not when ) are invariant, so , and are mutually non-isomorphic.
One-dimensional annihilator, (the 2-step case)
Now every pair is a cocycle and , so is a pair of matrices , . Since , Lemma 2.9 says that and give isomorphic algebras for , , and only these. The algebra is non-split if and only if there is no with for .
Step 1 (symmetric and skew parts). Write with symmetric and . Since , the group acts by and . Because iff and , the algebra is non-split iff , or and have no common kernel vector.
Step 2 (orthogonal geometry). Let be the space of symmetric matrices with the quadratic form and its polar form . The map preserves , its kernel is the group of scalar matrices, and its image is a connected three-dimensional subgroup of , hence equal to . With we have , so the action on is with and independent. The non-zero isotropic vectors of are the symmetric matrices of rank one.
Step 3 (two types). Let . Either lies in a non-degenerate plane of , or is a degenerate plane; in the second case for the isotropic line , because contains no totally isotropic plane. Every vector, and every degenerate plane, lies in a non-degenerate plane, and by Witt’s theorem [15] all non-degenerate planes are conjugate under to the plane of diagonal matrices. So we get:
type D: after a congruence and are both diagonal, i.e. they are simultaneously diagonalisable by congruence;
type T: are linearly independent and the binary form has a double root.
After moving to , type has both in . The type is invariant under the group, so no algebra of type is isomorphic to one of type .
Step 4 (type D). Write . For the action is
which realises exactly the triples with ; for and it swaps and and fixes . Conversely, let map one algebra of type in diagonal form to another, with . Then restricts to an isometry from onto , both inside . By Witt’s theorem in it extends to , and on equals with diagonal or antidiagonal, since those are exactly the for which is proportional to . Hence the equivalence is realised by the maps above, which proves the isomorphism criterion for . If , a common kernel vector exists iff (then ) or (then ).
Step 5 (type T). Since is determined by the algebra, equivalences between normal forms fix , so is a multiple of and is lower triangular. Writing , a direct computation gives
Type means that and are linearly independent. Keeping fixed, can be moved to any vector independent of : we take if and otherwise. The maps preserving this are those with and , and they act by with arbitrary. Hence is a complete invariant. Type is always non-split: if with and , then gives and then gives .
This completes the proof of Theorem 4.1, except for the non-isomorphism of algebras with different names, which follows from Proposition 6.1.
Invariants, non-isomorphism and special subclasses
Table 1 lists invariants of all algebras of Theorem 4.1. Here is the Lie algebra of derivations, i.e. linear maps with for ; its dimension equals . For the families, is given at generic parameters.
| Algebra | dim Ann | nil. index | dim | dim Der | diassociative | ||
| 1 | 4 | 2 | 2 | no | no | ||
| 1 | 4 | 2 | 3 | no | no | ||
| 1 | 4 | 2 | 2 | no | no | ||
| 1 | 4 | 2 | 2 | no | no | ||
| 1 | 4 | 2 | 3 | yes | iff | ||
| 1 | 4 | 2 | 2 | no | iff | ||
| 2 | 3 | 2 | 3 | no | yes | ||
| 1 | 3 | 1 | 3 | iff | yes | ||
| 1 | 3 | 1 | 3 | no | yes | ||
| 2 | – | 3 | 1 | 5 | iff | yes | |
| 3 | – | 2 | 0 | 9 | yes | … |
Table 1. Invariants of the three-dimensional nilpotent LSDA.
Proposition 6.1. The algebras of Theorem 4.1 with different names are pairwise non-isomorphic.
Proof. and the isomorphism class of are invariants. By Proposition 3.1 they separate (for each ), the group , the group , the group , , the split algebras and . Inside each group the algebras correspond to different orbits by Lemma 2.9 and § 5: or not for ; or not and or not for ; simultaneous diagonalisability for and . The column gives an independent check for and for . □
Corollary 6.2 (Left-symmetric algebras). Up to isomorphism, the three-dimensional nilpotent complex left-symmetric algebras are , (), (, , ) and the 2-step algebras with
Proof. These are the algebras of Theorem 4.1 with . For this means one form . If then and . If we normalise ; then and the swap, so is the only invariant, with the two orbits and when . In the condition would be needed, which is excluded. □
Corollary 6.3 (Diassociative algebras). The three-dimensional nilpotent complex LSDA that are diassociative are , , , all , all , and .
Proof. Algebras with satisfy every identity of degree three, in particular the five diassociative axioms. For –, the axioms on basis triples hold only for and with ; for instance and in and . □
Remark 6.4. For a generic algebra of type the stabiliser of in is one-dimensional, and the maps () give two more dimensions; this agrees with in Table 1.
Concluding remarks
The three-dimensional nilpotent LSDA form nine non-split classes, with a four-parameter family already in the 2-step case. Natural next steps are the geometric classification (degenerations and irreducible components of the variety of three-dimensional nilpotent LSDA), the classification of four-dimensional nilpotent LSDA by the same method, and the classification of all three-dimensional LSDA, extending Theorem 2.6 of [20].
References
- [1]S. Albeverio, B. A. Omirov, I. S. Rakhimov, Classification of 4-dimensional nilpotent complex Leibniz algebras, Extracta Math. 21 (2006), no. 3, 197–210.DOI
- [2]C. Bai, Bijective 1-cocycles and classification of 3-dimensional left-symmetric algebras, Comm. Algebra 37 (2009), no. 3, 1016–1057.DOI
- [3]L. Boza, E. M. Fedriani, J. Núñez, Á. F. Tenorio, A historical review of the classifications of Lie algebras, Rev. Un. Mat. Argentina 54 (2013), no. 2, 75–99.
- [4]D. Burde, Left-symmetric algebras, or pre-Lie algebras in geometry and physics, Cent. Eur. J. Math. 4 (2006), no. 3, 323–357.DOI
- [5]A. Cayley, On the theory of analytic forms called trees, in: Collected Mathematical Papers, Vol. 3, Cambridge Univ. Press, 1890, 242–246.
- [6]F. Chapoton, M. Livernet, Pre-Lie algebras and the rooted trees operad, Internat. Math. Res. Notices 2001, no. 8, 395–408.DOI
- [7]W. A. de Graaf, Classification of 6-dimensional nilpotent Lie algebras over fields of characteristic not 2, J. Algebra 309 (2007), no. 2, 640–653.DOI
- [8]R. Felipe, A brief foundation of the left-symmetric dialgebras, Comunicaciones del CIMAT, No. I-11-02, 2011.
- [9]M. Goze, Y. Khakimdjanov, Nilpotent Lie Algebras, Mathematics and its Applications 361, Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1996.DOI
- [10]C. M. González, Associative algebras from a structural viewpoint, Comm. Algebra 41 (2013), no. 5, 1903–1912.DOI
- [11]A. S. Hegazi, H. Abdelwahab, A. J. Calderón Martín, The classification of n-dimensional non-Lie Malcev algebras with (n − 4)-dimensional annihilator, Linear Algebra Appl. 505 (2016), 32–56.
- [13]I. Kaygorodov, Non-associative algebraic structures: classification and structure, Commun. Math. 32 (2024), no. 3, 1–62.DOI
- [14]H. Kim, Complete left-invariant affine structures on nilpotent Lie groups, J. Differential Geom. 24 (1986), no. 3, 373–394.DOI
- [15]T. Y. Lam, Introduction to Quadratic Forms over Fields, Graduate Studies in Mathematics 67, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, 2005.DOI
- [16]X. Li, D. Hou, C. Bai, Rota–Baxter operators on pre-Lie algebras, J. Nonlinear Math. Phys. 14 (2007), no. 2, 269–289.DOI
- [17]L. Lin, Y. Zhang, F[x, y] as a dialgebra and a Leibniz algebra, Comm. Algebra 38 (2010), no. 9, 3417–3447.
- [18]J.-L. Loday, Une version non commutative des algèbres de Lie: les algèbres de Leibniz, Enseign. Math. (2) 39 (1993), no. 3–4, 269–293.DOI
- [19]J.-L. Loday, A. Frabetti, F. Chapoton, F. Goichot, Dialgebras and Related Operads, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1763, Springer, Berlin, 2001.DOI
- [20]I. M. Rikhsioboev, On the classification of left-symmetric dialgebras, Contemp. Math. 672, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, 2016. DOI 10.1090/conm/672/13464.
- [21]I. M. Rikhsioboev, I. S. Rakhimov, W. Basri, Classification of 3-dimensional complex diassociative algebras, Malaysian J. Math. Sci. 4 (2010), no. 2, 241–254.
- [22]I. M. Rikhsioboev, I. S. Rakhimov, W. Basri, On four dimensional nilpotent diassociative algebras, J. Gen. Lie Theory Appl. 9 (2015), no. 1, 7 pp.
- [23]T. Skjelbred, T. Sund, Sur la classification des algèbres de Lie nilpotentes, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris Sér. A-B 286 (1978), no. 5, A241–A242.
- [24]È. B. Vinberg, The theory of homogeneous convex cones, Trudy Moskov. Mat. Obšč. 12 (1963), 303–358.
