betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Hidden Singularity and Fractal Dimensions for Extended Harper Operators

Abstract

We prove that, for every irrational frequency, the spectra of the extended Harper family throughout the zero-measure regime have finite 1/21/2-dimensional Hausdorff measure and lower box dimension at most 1/21/2. Both numbers improve to 1/31/3 on the isotropic critical boundary. The proof is based on a family of unitary transformations, that specializes to the chiral transform of [BJK] for the case of the critical almost Mathieu. This family allows to make every operator in this regime spectrally equivalent to a singular Jacobi operator. Using these singular representatives, we apply the method of [BJK] to construct covers by O(qn)O(q_n) intervals of total length O(qn−1)O(q_n^{-1}), improving to O(qn−2)O(q_n^{-2}) on the isotropic boundary, where qnq_n is the denominator of a canonical approximant to αα. The covers give upper box bounds and, with packing estimates, examples where the box-counting dimension fails to exist.

Introduction

The extended Harper model describes an electron on a square lattice in a uniform perpendicular magnetic field, with hopping between nearest and next-nearest neighbors. It is thus a natural next model after the Harper model in the study of magnetic lattice spectra [14]. The latter goes back to the work of Peierls and Harper [28, 17], and its dependence on the magnetic flux is beautifully depicted by the Hofstadter butterfly [18]. Choosing the Landau gauge and taking a partial Fourier transform in one lattice direction gives a family of one-dimensional quasiperiodic Jacobi operators, also referred to as the extended Harper model (EHM). Writing 2πα2\pi\alpha for the flux through a square and θ∈T=R/Z\theta\in\mathbb{T} = \mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} for the transverse quasimomentum, for λ=(λ1,λ2,λ3)∈[0,∞)3\lambda= (\lambda_1,\lambda_2,\lambda_3) \in[0,\infty)^3 the extended Harper operator on ℓ2(Z)\ell^2(\mathbb{Z}) is

(Hα,θ,λu)m=cλ,α(θ+(m−1)α)um−1+cλ,α(θ+mα)um+1+2cos⁡(2π(θ+mα))um,(H_{\alpha,\theta,\lambda}u)_m = c_{\lambda,\alpha}(\theta+ (m-1)\alpha)u_{m-1} + c_{\lambda,\alpha}(\theta+ m\alpha)u_{m+1} + 2\cos(2\pi(\theta+ m\alpha))u_m,
cλ,α(t)=λ1e−2πi(t+α/2)+λ2+λ3e2πi(t+α/2).(1)c_{\lambda,\alpha}(t) = \lambda_1 e^{-2\pi i(t+\alpha/2)} + \lambda_2 + \lambda_3 e^{2\pi i(t+\alpha/2)}. \tag*{(1)}

For irrational α\alpha, its spectrum is independent of θ\theta; we denote it by Σα,λ\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda}. For λ=(0,λ2,0)\lambda= (0,\lambda_2,0), with λ2>0\lambda_2 > 0, EHM becomes the rescaled almost Mathieu operator, which arises by allowing only nearest-neighbor hopping in the two-dimensional magnetic Laplacian and which features a basic phase transition at λ2=1\lambda_2 = 1. Allowing the additional hoppings leads to a considerably richer phase diagram (cf. Figure 1), with several critical boundaries between regions I, II, and III, and the entire region III being self-dual; see [27, 14, 2]. The triangular lattice is also a special case of extended Harper [19].

EHM regions projected onto $(\Lambda,\lambda_2)$ and onto $\lambda_2=1$

Figure 1. Left: the EHM regions projected onto (Λ,λ2)(\Lambda,\lambda_2), where Λ=λ1+λ3\Lambda= \lambda_1 + \lambda_3. The blue boundary is Λ=max⁡{1,λ2}\Lambda= \max\{1,\lambda_2\}. The purple shading is the projection of Iiso\mathcal{I}_{\mathrm{iso}}; in the interior of region III, only couplings with λ1=λ3\lambda_1 = \lambda_3 belong to C0\mathcal{C}_0. Right: projection onto λ2=1\lambda_2 = 1. The purple ray λ1=λ3≥1/2\lambda_1 = \lambda_3 \ge1/2 is the slice of Iiso\mathcal{I}_{\mathrm{iso}}. The entire shaded triangle LII⊂C0\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{II}} \subset\mathcal{C}_0 has Hausdorff dimension of the spectrum at most 1/21/2 for every irrational frequency. At the blue midpoint (1/2,1,1/2)∈Biso(1/2,1,1/2) \in\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{iso}}, the bound improves to 1/31/3. Red circles mark the critical AMO; green squares mark the triangular operator.

In mathematics, spectral theory of the extended Harper model has been a popular domain for the study of validity and limitations of arguments originally developed for the almost Mathieu family, e.g. [20, 21, 22, 15]. The main interest in this regard comes from two aspects that differ significantly from almost Mathieu: the nontrivial self-dual region III, where the usual duality between supercritical and subcritical regimes is not available, and the set of parameters where the corresponding Jacobi matrix becomes singular, that is cλ,α(θ)c_{\lambda,\alpha}(\theta) has a zero on a period, limiting applicability of methods based on nonsingularity.

The phase diagram of spectral types is by now well understood [2]. Various questions, in particular, about the geometry of the spectrum, however, remain.

In particular, fractal dimensions of the spectrum have been largely unstudied. The question, of course, only makes sense when the spectrum has measure zero, a regime, that has remained rather mysterious, being not amenable to either reducibility or localization methods. For any irrational α\alpha, a direct corollary of Proposition 3.1, Theorems 3.4, 3.5, and 4.1 of [2] and Aubry duality is that, writing Λ=λ1+λ3\Lambda= \lambda_1 + \lambda_3,

∣Σα,λ∣=0⟺λ∈C0={λ:Λ=1≥λ2}∪{λ:λ2=1≥Λ}∪{λ:Λ=λ2≥1}∪{λ:λ1=λ3, Λ≥max⁡{1,λ2}}.\lvert\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda}\rvert= 0 \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad\lambda\in\mathcal{C}_0 = \{\lambda: \Lambda= 1 \ge\lambda_2\} \cup\{\lambda: \lambda_2 = 1 \ge\Lambda\} \cup\{\lambda: \Lambda= \lambda_2 \ge1\} \cup\{\lambda: \lambda_1 = \lambda_3,\ \Lambda\ge\max\{1,\lambda_2\}\}.

The first three regions, denoted by LI\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{I}}, LII\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{II}}, and LIII\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{III}}, respectively, are precisely the critical boundaries where at least two of the three quantities 11, λ2\lambda_2, and Λ=λ1+λ3\Lambda= \lambda_1 + \lambda_3 attain the max⁡(1,λ2,Λ)\max(1,\lambda_2,\Lambda). The fourth, denoted by Iiso\mathcal{I}_{\mathrm{iso}} is the isotropic1 part of the interior of region III.

We distinguish the isotropic critical boundary

Biso={λ:λ1=λ3, λ1+λ3=max⁡{1,λ2}},\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{iso}} = \{\lambda: \lambda_1 = \lambda_3,\ \lambda_1 + \lambda_3 = \max\{1,\lambda_2\}\},

which is the union of intersections Iiso∩Lj\mathcal{I}_{\mathrm{iso}} \cap\mathcal{L}_j, j=I,II,IIIj = \mathrm{I},\mathrm{II},\mathrm{III}.

For the almost Mathieu family, λ=(0,λ2,0)\lambda= (0,\lambda_2,0), there is only one parameter with zero measure spectrum: λ2=1\lambda_2 = 1. Thouless conjectured that Hausdorff dimension is bounded by 1/21/2 in this case, for all irrational α\alpha.

In [5] we developed a method to find tight spectral covers for singular Jacobi matrices, that lead to dimension bounds. Historically, singularity has been an obstacle to overcome when extending various almost Mathieu arguments [21, 22, 2, 16]. In contrast, in [5] we exploit singularity: while critical almost Mathieu is a Schrödinger operator, so certainly not a singular Jacobi matrix, we found what we call a chiral transform that gives it an isospectral singular Jacobi representation, leading to a proof of the Thouless conjecture for every irrational frequency.

Here we show that the method of [5] can be extended to the entire zero-measure regime of the EHM, giving the same bound 1/21/2 without arithmetic restrictions on α\alpha. Moreover, on the isotropic critical boundary the bound improves to 1/31/3.

Operators in LIII\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{III}} and Iiso\mathcal{I}_{\mathrm{iso}} are already singular, and operators in LI\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{I}} are made singular by the standard Aubry duality. For those, the problem reduces to finding good spectral covers.

The region LII\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{II}}, however, is more challenging. It is the self-dual triangle (see Figure 1), that contains critical almost Mathieu and the isotropic triangular model as its boundary points, at (0,1,0)(0,1,0) and (1,1,0)(1,1,0), respectively. The additional challenge is to unlock its hidden singularity. We do it by finding a family of transforms that singularize each Hα,θ,λH_{\alpha,\theta,\lambda} with λ∈LII\lambda\in\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{II}}. The chiral transform of [5] is one element in this family.

Intuitively, the physical question of what survives when additional hopping is allowed is related to the recently established analytic robustness of the almost Mathieu results [13, 11, 26], although we note that criticality itself is not robust [1]. Our results are global and complete in the parameter class considered here, with no smallness assumptions or other restrictions.

Hausdorff dimension

We write meast\mathrm{meas}_{t} for tt-dimensional Hausdorff measure, dim⁡H\dim_{\mathrm H} for Hausdorff dimension, and dim⁡‾B\underline{\dim}_{\mathrm B} and dim⁡‾B\overline{\dim}_{\mathrm B} for lower and upper box dimensions.

Theorem 1.1. For every irrational α\alpha and every λ∈C0\lambda\in\mathcal{C}_{0},

meas1/2(Σα,λ)<∞,dim⁡HΣα,λ≤dim⁡‾BΣα,λ≤12.\mathrm{meas}_{1/2}(\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda}) < \infty,\qquad\dim_{\mathrm H}\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda} \le\underline{\dim}_{\mathrm B}\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda} \le\frac{1}{2}.

For λ∈Biso\lambda\in\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{iso}}, these conclusions improve to

meas1/3(Σα,λ)<∞,dim⁡HΣα,λ≤dim⁡‾BΣα,λ≤13.\mathrm{meas}_{1/3}(\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda}) < \infty,\qquad\dim_{\mathrm H}\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda} \le\underline{\dim}_{\mathrm B}\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda} \le\frac{1}{3}.

The almost Mathieu results of Theorem 1.1 provide a strengthening of the Hausdorff dimension bound of [5], following from the covers proved there in Theorem 7.11. The 1/31/3 bound concerns the bicritical boundary studied in [14], including the point (1/2,1,1/2)(1/2,1,1/2). A different scaling at this boundary was already apparent in the rational bandwidth analysis of [14]; here it leads to a dimension bound for every irrational frequency. In our argument, it is the higher-order zero of the hopping coefficient that produces the improvement.

Box-counting dimension

Of course, a bound on Hausdorff dimension does not in general control box-counting dimension. Already for critical almost Mathieu, the Hausdorff dimension can be zero [25, 3] while the packing dimension is one [23]. Our argument also gives bounds on upper box dimension in terms of the arithmetic properties of the frequency.

Let pn/qnp_n/q_n be the canonical approximants of α\alpha, and set

τ(α)=lim sup⁡nln⁡qn+1ln⁡qn∈[1,∞],β(α)=lim sup⁡nln⁡qn+1qn∈[0,∞].(2)\tau(\alpha)=\limsup_{n}\frac{\ln q_{n+1}}{\ln q_n}\in[1,\infty],\qquad\beta(\alpha)=\limsup_{n}\frac{\ln q_{n+1}}{q_n}\in[0,\infty]. \tag*{(2)}

For almost every α\alpha, τ(α)=1\tau(\alpha)=1 and β(α)=0\beta(\alpha)=0. We call α\alpha weakly Liouville when β(α)>0\beta(\alpha)>0 (and therefore τ(α)=∞\tau(\alpha)=\infty).

Theorem 1.2. For every irrational α\alpha and every λ∈C0\lambda\in\mathcal{C}_{0},

dim⁡‾PΣα,λ≤dim⁡‾BΣα,λ≤τ(α)1+τ(α).\underline{\dim}_{\mathrm P}\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda}\le\overline{\dim}_{\mathrm B}\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda}\le\frac{\tau(\alpha)}{1+\tau(\alpha)}.

For λ∈Biso\lambda\in\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{iso}}, the last bound improves to

dim⁡‾BΣα,λ≤τ(α)2+τ(α).\overline{\dim}_{\mathrm B}\Sigma_{\alpha,\lambda}\le\frac{\tau(\alpha)}{2+\tau(\alpha)}.

Here dim⁡P\dim_{\mathrm{P}} denotes packing dimension. When τ(α)=1\tau(\alpha)=1, which holds for Lebesgue almost every α\alpha, these are upper box-dimension bounds of 1/21/2 and 1/31/3, respectively.

For weakly Liouville frequencies the situation is quite different. Combining our bounds on lower box dimension with the packing estimates of [23, 16] gives

References

  1. [1]A. Avila. Global theory of one-frequency Schrödinger operators. Acta Math. 215(1), 1–54 (2015).DOI
  2. [2]A. Avila, S. Jitomirskaya, and C. A. Marx. Spectral theory of extended Harper’s model and a question by Erdős and Szekeres. Invent. Math. 210(1), 283–339 (2017). arXiv:1602.05111v2.DOI
  3. [3]A. Avila, Y. Last, M. Shamis, and Q. Zhou. On the quasi. one-dimensional properties of the almost Mathieu operator with well-approximated frequencies. Duke Math. J. 173(4), 603–672 (2024).
  4. [4]J. E. Avron and B. Simon. Almost periodic Schrödinger operators. II. The integrated density of states. Duke Math. J. 50(1), 369–391 (1983).DOI
  5. [5]S. Becker, S. Jitomirskaya, and I. Krasovsky. Critical almost Mathieu operator: hidden singularity, gap continuity, and the Hausdorff dimension of the spectrum, https://arxiv.org/abs/1909.04429
  6. [6]S. Becker, S. Jitomirskaya, and I. Krasovsky. Fractal dimensions for graphene in magnetic fields, in preparation.
  7. [7]R. Beinart and G. Plonka. Ambiguities in one-dimensional discrete phase retrieval from Fourier magnitudes. J. Fourier Anal. Appl. 21(6), 1169–1198 (2015).
  8. [10]K. Falconer. Fractal geometry. Mathematical foundations and applications, 1990DOI
  9. [11]L. Ge and S. Jitomirskaya. Intrinsic symplectic structure and sharp arithmetic universality. Preprint (2026), arXiv:2407.08866v2.arxiv.org/abs/2407.08866
  10. [12]A. Y. Gordon, S. Jitomirskaya, Y. Last, and B. Simon. Duality and singular continuous spectrum in the almost Mathieu equation. Acta Math. 178(2), 169–183 (1997).DOI
  11. [13]L. Ge, S. Jitomirskaya, and J. You. The robust Ten Martini problem. Preprint (2026), arXiv:2609.15812v1.arxiv.org/abs/2609.15812
  12. [14]J. H. Han, D. J. Thouless, H. Hiramoto, and M. Kohmoto. Critical and bicritical properties of Harper’s equation with next-nearest-neighbor coupling. Phys. Rev. B 50(16), 11365–11380 (1994). arXiv:cond-mat/9406045.DOI
  13. [15]R. Han. Dry Ten Martini problem for non self-dual extended Harper’s model. arXiv:1607.08571 (2016).arxiv.org/abs/1607.08571
  14. [16]R. Han, F. Yang, and S. Zhang. Spectral dimension for β-almost periodic singular Jacobi operators and the extended Harper’s model. J. Anal. Math. 142(2), 605–666 (2020). arXiv:1804.04322v2.arxiv.org/abs/1804.04322
  15. [17]P. G. Harper. Single band motion of conduction electrons in a uniform magnetic field. Proc. Phys. Soc. Sect. A 68(10), 874–878 (1955).DOI
  16. [18]D. R. Hofstadter. Energy levels and wave functions of Bloch electrons in rational and irrational magnetic fields. Phys. Rev. B 14(6), 2239–2249 (1976).
  17. [19]K. Ino and M. Kohmoto. Critical properties of Harper’s equation on a triangular lattice. Phys. Rev. B 73(20), 205111 (2006).DOI
  18. [20]S. Jitomirskaya, D. A. Koslover, and M. S. Schulteis. Localization for a family of one-dimensional quasiperiodic operators of magnetic origin. Ann. Henri Poincaré 6(1), 103–124 (2005).DOI
  19. [21]S. Jitomirskaya and C. A. Marx. Analytic quasi-periodic cocycles with singularities and the Lyapunov exponent of extended Harper’s model. Commun. Math. Phys. 316(1), 237–267 (2012). arXiv:1010.0751v3.arxiv.org/abs/1010.0751
  20. [22]S. Jitomirskaya and C. A. Marx. Erratum to: Analytic quasi-periodic cocycles with singularities and the Lyapunov exponent of extended Harper’s model. Commun. Math. Phys. 317(1), 269–271 (2013).DOI
  21. [23]S. Jitomirskaya and S. Zhang. Quantitative continuity of singular continuous spectral measures and arithmetic criteria for quasiperiodic Schrödinger operators. J. Eur. Math. Soc. 24(5), 1723–1767 (2022). arXiv:1510.07086v2.
  22. [25]Y. Last and M. Shamis. Zero Hausdorff dimension spectrum for the almost Mathieu operator. Commun. Math. Phys. 348(3), 729–750 (2016).DOI
  23. [26]X. Li, D. Xu, and Q. Zhou. Monotonicity, global symplectification and the stability of the Dry Ten Martini problem. Preprint (2026), arXiv:2601.02222v3.arxiv.org/abs/2601.02222
  24. [27]V. A. Mandelshtam and S. Ya. Zhitomirskaya. 1D-quasiperiodic operators. Latent symmetries. Commun. Math. Phys. 139, 589–604 (1991).DOI
  25. [28]R. Peierls. Zur Theorie des Diamagnetismus von Leitungselektronen. Z. Phys. 80(11–12), 763–791 (1933).DOI
  26. [29]G. Teschl. Jacobi Operators and Completely Integrable Nonlinear Lattices, Mathematical Surveys and Monographs, vol. 72, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2000.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_5998mcpa
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents