betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Non-Gaussian generalization of the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model

Abstract

We consider a natural generalization of the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model for small-scale turbulent dynamo. This generalization takes account of statistical time asymmetry of a turbulent flow, and, thus, allows to describe velocity fields with energy cascade. For three-dimensional velocity field, generalized Kazantsev equation is derived, and evolution of the second order magnetic field correlator is investigated for large but finite magnetic Prandtl numbers. It is shown that as Prm→∞Pr_m \to \infty, the growth increment tends to the limit known from the T-exponential (Lagrangian deformation) method. Magnetic field generation is shown to be weaker than that in the Gaussian velocity field for any direction of the energy cascade, and depends essentially on the Prandtl number.

Introduction

Magnetic field generation in turbulent plasma is one of the most probable mechanisms responsible for stellar, interstellar and intergalactic magnetism (see, e.g., [53, 36, 41, 7, 49]). Small-scale turbulent dynamo has been the object of interest of many researchers (see, e.g., [10, 8, 2]) as it can provide intensive increase of magnetic field ([36, 29]). In these problems, characteristic scale of magnetic field fluctuations is much smaller than the scale at which turbulence is generated: this corresponds to inertial and viscous scale ranges of turbulence.

The conception of small (seed) initial magnetic field fluctuations implies that there exists an important stage of kinematic dynamo: magnetic field is small enough to cause no feedback on the velocity distribution, so it is passively advected by the turbulent flow. Magnetic Prandtl number, i.e. ratio of the kinematic viscosity ν\nu to the magnetic diffusivity ϰ\varkappa, is the most important characteristic of this advection process. In the paper we consider large Prandtl numbers:

Corresponding author: A.V. Kopyev

[email protected]

Prm=ν/ϰ≫1.Pr_m = \nu/\varkappa\gg1.

Such situation is observed, e.g., in interstellar medium ([7, 43]). This means that the magnetic diffusive scale length rdr_d is much smaller than the Kolmogorov viscous scale rνr_\nu. We assume the characteristic scale length ll of initial magnetic field fluctuation to lie between these two scales,

rd≪l≪rν.r_d \ll l \ll r_\nu.

Evolution of magnetic field is described by a stochastic partial differential equation with random velocity field acting as multiplicative noise. The velocity statistics is assumed to be stationary and known. The problem is to find the statistics of the magnetic field, in particular, its correlations.

Kazantsev-Kraichnan model ([21, 28]) is the simplest and natural approximation for the velocity statistics: the velocity field is assumed to be Gaussian and δ\delta-correlated in time. In this model, all magnetic field correlators are governed by the only two-point velocity correlator.

This model is an essential simplification. Actually, unlike the additive random processes, in stochastic equations with multiplicative noise the cumulants of all orders give comparable contributions to any statistical moment. So, the Central limit theorem ’does not work’ for these processes, and, to calculate even the second-order correlators of magnetic field, one should use the Large deviation principle and take all velocity correlators into account. So, the replacement of arbitrary random velocity field by Gaussian process can change the result crucially.

Besides, in Gaussian approximation for velocity field and hence, in Kazantsev-Kraichnan model, there is no energy cascade. The energy of magnetic field excitation comes from the energy of the turbulent flow, which is generated at large scales; thus, the cascade may be important for dynamo. The non-zero third-order velocity correlator is responsible for energy cascade and for time asymmetry in general ([24, 11]): indeed, the inversion of time would result in the change of sign of all velocities, and time symmetry implies that the statistics would not change; hence, the third order correlator is zero for time symmetric flows. Its presence indicates time asymmetry. So, the account of non-Gaussianity is highly desirable.

There are two different theoretical approaches to investigate the magnetic field statistics. One of them is based on the Lagrangian deformations statistics (see [54, 9] (Il’yn et al. 2018)): it implies direct solution of the magnetic field evolution equation by means of the T-exponential formalism. The physical meaning of this method can be formulated in terms of independent magnetic blobs, each of them undergoing its evolution in the turbulent flow ([35, 25] (Il’yn et al. 2019; Il’yn et al. 2021)). This approach allows to calculate the magnetic field correlators of all orders, and to consider inhomogenous, in particular, localized initial magnetic field distributions. In this frame, it is possible to deal with arbitrary (not necessarily Gaussian) velocity statistics. So, this approach allows to consider velocity statistics wider than the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model.

However, this approach is restricted to so-called Batchelor regime ([4]): the characteristic scale of the magnetic field must lie deep inside the viscous range of turbulence, so that the velocity field can be approximated by a linear function. This means that the solutions found by this method are definitely applicable for some finite time range t∝ln⁡rv/lt \propto\ln r_v/l. Later on, the characteristic scale of the magnetic field continues

to increase and reaches the inertial range of turbulence. The ’Lagrangian deformation’ approach may fail to predict the behavior of correlators at this stage. The details of applicability of the method to the inertial stage are considered by Il’yn et al. (2021).

The other approach is based on statistical properties of pair correlators and allows to derive a closed differential equation for the pair correlator of magnetic field (Kazantsev equation). It was used and developed in many papers (see, e.g., [21, 27, 52, 25, 46, 33, 20] (Shekchokhin & Alexakis 2016)); hereafter we will refer to it as to Kazantsev approach. The advantage of the method is its applicability to any stage of the magnetic field evolution. However, it is restricted to statistically homogenous magnetic field configurations, and it allows to calculate the second-order two-point correlator only. There is one more vice of this approach: it requires Gaussian and δ\delta-correlated in time velocity statistics, so it is restricted to the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model of velocity field. Only for several models with some special additional conditions its applicability has been enlarged ([45, 6] (Kleorin et al. 2002)).

The two approaches produce concordant results wherever their domains of applicability overlap ([9] (Il’yn et al. 2021)), they are also verified by numerical simulations ([34, 48, 51]). However, there remains the domain where neither of them can be applied: processes with non-Gaussian and/or not δ\delta-correlated velocity statistics cannot be analyzed at late (inertial) stage of their evolution neither by the Lagrangian deformations approach nor by the classical Kazantsev method. The finite correlation time was taken into account in [6, 34, 45] (); Kleorin et al. 2002) for some special types of flows. The non-Gaussian velocity statistics in combination with the inertial stage has not been considered yet.

To fill this gap, in this paper we consider the simplest non-Gaussian generalization of the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model introduced in Il’yn et al. (2016, 2019). It implies a non-zero third-order velocity correlator, and thus, takes into account the time asymmetry of the flow. This model allows to investigate the long-time evolution of statistics for advection (and, more generally, multiplicative) equations for arbitrary velocity field with small but non-zero third order correlator. We generalize the Kazantsev method to apply it to this ’V3V^{3}-model’, and find the two-point pair magnetic field correlator. We show that inside the Batchelor regime, the results obtained for the V3V^{3}-model by means of the Lagrangian deformations approach and by means of the generalized Kazantsev method coincide, which verifies the new generalized method. Now, for later (inertial) stage, we show that the V3V^{3}-model is stable relative to the limit of ’zero non-Gaussianity’ as it turns into the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model. We calculate the magnetic field growth increment for finite time asymmetry, and evaluate the correction produced by finite Prandtl number.

It appears that small time asymmetry decreases the magnetic field generation, independently of the direction of the energy cascade. The range of Prandtl numbers that produce effective generation is also narrower as non-Gaussian time-asymmetry increases. The V3V^{3}-model is shown to be a useful and effective instrument to investigate magnetic field advection in finite-Prandtl non-Gaussian flows.

The paper is organized as follows. In the next section, we briefly review the basic ideas and equations of the two approaches by the example of the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model. Then we recall the formulation and restrictions of the V3V^{3} model and the results obtained for this model by means of the Lagrangian deformations method (Section III). In Section IV we derive the modified Kazantsev equation in order to apply the Kazantsev approach to the V3V^{3} model. In the limit of infinite Prandtl number, it appears to be possible to solve the equation and to find the increment of the pair magnetic field correlator. The results of numerical solution of the equation for finite Prandtl numbers, validation of the method and check of its stability is performed in Section V. In Discussion we analyze the obtained results, and pay special attention to the applicability of δ\delta-correlated in time velocity distribution and to comparison with the models with finite correlation time.

Gaussian velocity field: recall of classic results

To introduce the notations and equations needed, we start from the classical problem statement. Kinematic transport of magnetic field B(t,r)\mathbf{B}(t,\mathbf{r}) advected by random statistically homogeneous and isotropic nondivergent velocity field v(t,r)\mathbf{v}(t,\mathbf{r}), ∇⋅v=0\nabla\cdot\mathbf{v}=0, is described by the evolution equation

∂B∂t+(v∇)B−(B∇)v=ϰΔB,(1)\frac{\partial\mathbf{B}}{\partial t}+(\mathbf{v}\nabla)\mathbf{B}-(\mathbf{B}\nabla)\mathbf{v}=\varkappa\Delta\mathbf{B}, \tag*{(1)}

where ϰ\varkappa is the diffusivity. The random process v(r,t)\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{r},t) is assumed to be stationary, and to have given statistical properties.

The initial conditions for magnetic field are also stochastically isotropic and homogeneous. The aim is to find statistical characteristics of the process B\mathbf{B}, in particular, its pair correlator.

From statistical homogeneity and isotropy, and non-divergency of B\mathbf{B} it follows that its simultaneous pair correlator has the form

⟨Bi(R,t)Bj(R+r,t)⟩=G(r,t)δij+12rG′(r,t)(δij−rirjr2).(2)\langle B_i(\mathbf{R},t)B_j(\mathbf{R}+\mathbf{r},t)\rangle=G(r,t)\delta_{ij}+\frac{1}{2}rG'(r,t)\left(\delta_{ij}-\frac{r_i r_j}{r^2}\right). \tag*{(2)}

The average here is taken over the initial conditions B(r,0)\mathbf{B}(\mathbf{r},0) and over the possible realizations of the velocity field v(r,t)\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{r},t).

So, we are interested in time dependence of GG: if it increases exponentially,

G∼eγtG(r),(3)G\sim e^{\gamma t}G(r), \tag*{(3)}

one calls the process ’turbulent dynamo’, and γ\gamma is called the magnetic field increment.

The Kazantsev-Kraichnan model implies that the velocity field is Gaussian, δ\delta-correlated in time; its statistics is completely determined by the second-order correlator

⟨vi(R,t)vj(R+r,t+τ)⟩=Dij(r)δ(τ).(4)\langle v_i(\mathbf{R},t)v_j(\mathbf{R}+\mathbf{r},t+\tau)\rangle=D_{ij}(r)\delta(\tau). \tag*{(4)}

The correlator does not depend on R\mathbf{R} and tt because of homogeneity and stationarity. To make contact with finite correlation time real flows, one can define DijD_{ij} by

Dij(r)=∫⟨vi(R,t)vj(R+r,t+τ)⟩ dτ.(5)D_{ij}(\mathbf{r})=\int\langle v_i(\mathbf{R},t)v_j(\mathbf{R}+\mathbf{r},t+\tau)\rangle\,d\tau. \tag*{(5)}

Just as in (2), non-divergency and isotropy oblige the tensor DijD_{ij} to be determined by only one scalar function of a scalar argument. For the purposes of next subsection, it is convenient to consider the (time-integrated) longitudinal structure function

σ(r)=14∫dτ⟨(v(r,τ)−v(0,τ))rr⟩×⟨(v(r,0)−v(0,0))rr⟩.(6)\sigma(r)=\frac{1}{4}\int d\tau\left\langle\left(\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{r},\tau)-\mathbf{v}(0,\tau)\right)\frac{\mathbf{r}}{r}\right\rangle\times\left\langle\left(\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{r},0)-\mathbf{v}(0,0)\right)\frac{\mathbf{r}}{r}\right\rangle. \tag*{(6)}

Then

σ(r)=12(Dij(0)rirjr2−Dij(r)rirjr2).\sigma(r)=\frac{1}{2}\left(D_{ij}(0)\frac{r_i r_j}{r^2}-D_{ij}(r)\frac{r_i r_j}{r^2}\right).

If one presents DijD_{ij} in the form analogous to (2),

Dij=P(r)δij+12rP′(r)(δij−rirjr2),(7)D_{ij}=P(r)\delta_{ij}+\frac{1}{2}rP'(r)\left(\delta_{ij}-\frac{r_i r_j}{r^2}\right), \tag*{(7)}

then

σ(r)=12(P(0)−P(r)).\sigma(r)=\frac{1}{2}\left(P(0)-P(r)\right).

In presence of viscosity, the velocity field is smooth at the smallest scales, and

P(r)=r→0P(0)−23Dr2+O(r3),D=−34P′′(0),(8)P(r)\underset{r\to0}{=}P(0)-\frac{2}{3}Dr^2+O(r^3),\quad D=-\frac{3}{4}P''(0), \tag*{(8)}

Kazantsev Equation

The equation to describe the evolution of the second-order correlator (2) can be found from Eq. (1) by means of multiplying and subsequent averaging. The cross-correlations of magnetic field and velocity can be split by means of the Furutsu-Novikov theorem due to Gaussianity and delta-correlation (Furutsu [13]; Novikov [38]):

⟨vi(r,t)g[v]⟩=12∫dr′Dij(r−r′)⟨δg[v]δvj(r′,t)⟩(9)\langle v_i(\boldsymbol{r},t)g[\boldsymbol{v}]\rangle= \frac{1}{2}\int\mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{r}'D_{ij}(\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{r}')\left\langle\frac{\delta g[\boldsymbol{v}]}{\delta v_j(\boldsymbol{r}',t)}\right\rangle \tag*{(9)}

where g[v]g[\boldsymbol{v}] is an arbitrary analytic functional of v(r,t)\boldsymbol{v}(\boldsymbol{r},t) and δ/δv\delta/\delta v is a functional derivative. Thus, for G(r,t)G(\boldsymbol{r},t) one gets the equation

∂G(r,t)∂t=LGaussG(10)\frac{\partial G(\boldsymbol{r},t)}{\partial t}=L_{\mathrm{Gauss}}G \tag*{(10)}
LGauss=2σ(r)∂2∂r2+2(σ′(r)+4rσ(r))∂∂r+2(σ′′(r)+4rσ′(r))+2χ(∂2∂r2+4r∂∂r).L_{\mathrm{Gauss}}=2\sigma(r)\frac{\partial^2}{\partial r^2}+2\left(\sigma'(r)+\frac{4}{r}\sigma(r)\right)\frac{\partial}{\partial r}+2\left(\sigma''(r)+\frac{4}{r}\sigma'(r)\right)+2\chi\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial r^2}+\frac{4}{r}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\right).

In a turbulent hydrodynamic flow, σ\sigma has the following asymptotics:

σ(r)={D3r2,r≪rν,const⁡⋅rξ,rν≪r≪L,12P(0),r≫L.(11)\sigma(r)= \begin{cases} \frac{D}{3}r^2, & r\ll r_\nu,\\ \operatorname{const}\cdot r^\xi, & r_\nu\ll r\ll L,\\ \frac{1}{2}P(0), & r\gg L. \end{cases} \tag*{(11)}

where rνr_\nu is the viscous dissipation scale, and LL is the integral scale of turbulence. The time scale

D−1=2rνvνD^{-1}=\frac{2r_\nu}{v_\nu}

is of the order of the eddy turnover time at the viscous scale (see Brandenburg & Subramanian [7]). The first asymptote in (11) corresponds to the viscous range of scales, the second presents the inertial range, and the last string is for the integral range of turbulence (see Landau & Lifshitz [30]).

The well-known result (Kleeorin et al. [22]; Schekochihin et al. [47]) is that for large Prandtl numbers, independently of the parameter ξ\xi (characterizing the inertial range), the equation (10) has a growing mode with the increment

γ=52D−O(ln⁡−2rdrν)\gamma=\frac{5}{2}D-O\left(\ln^{-2}\frac{r_d}{r_\nu}\right)

where

rd=χD∝rνPrm.r_d=\sqrt{\frac{\chi}{D}}\propto\frac{r_\nu}{\sqrt{Pr_m}}.

Thus, turbulent dynamo exists at large Prandtl numbers, and the increment is determined by the viscous range of turbulence.

'Lagrangian Deformations' Approach

This alternative way can only be applied for scales deep inside the viscous range, which corresponds to the early stage of evolution of initially small-scale (l≪rνl\ll r_\nu) magnetic fluctuation (Chertkov et al. [9]). For scales much smaller than rνr_\nu, the velocity field is smooth. So, one chooses a co-moving quasi-Lagrangian reference frame (Belinicher & Lvov [5]) associated to some fluid particle r0(t)\boldsymbol{r}_0(t), and in this frame expands the (relative) velocity into a series up to the first order:

δvi(r,t)=Aij(t)rj.\delta v_i(\boldsymbol{r},t)=A_{ij}(t)r_j.

This is called Batchelor approximation (Batchelor [4]), and AijA_{ij} is the velocity gradient tensor:

Aij=∂jvi(r0(t),t).A_{ij}=\partial_jv_i(\boldsymbol{r}_0(t),t).

The transport equation (1) now takes the form:

∂tBi+Ajkrk∂jBi−AijBj=χΔBi(12)\partial_tB_i+A_{jk}r_k\partial_jB_i-A_{ij}B_j=\chi\Delta B_i \tag*{(12)}

In Kazantsev-Kraichnan model, the statistics of AA is determined by its second-order correlator:

⟨Aij(t)Akp(t′)⟩=Dijkpδ(t−t′),\langle A_{ij}(t)A_{kp}(t')\rangle=D_{ijkp}\delta(t-t'),

where, in accordance with (4),

Dijkp=−∂j∂pDik(0).D_{ijkp}=-\partial_j\partial_pD_{ik}(0).

The equation (12) can be solved explicitly by means of the Fourier transform (Zel’dovich et al. [54]); for brevity, here we restrict ourselves to one spatial point and hence, to one-point correlator:

Bm(t)=Qmn−1∫Bn(p,0)e−ipipj∫(QQT)ij(t′)dt′dp.(13)B_m(t)=Q^{-1}_{mn}\int B_n(\boldsymbol{p},0)e^{-\mathrm{i}p_ip_j\int(QQ^{T})_{ij}(t')\mathrm{d}t'}\mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{p}. \tag*{(13)}

Here Q(t)Q(t) is the evolution matrix defined by the equation

dQdt=−QA,Q(0)=1.(14)\frac{\mathrm{d}Q}{\mathrm{d}t}=-QA,\qquad Q(0)=1. \tag*{(14)}

It is convenient to use the polar decomposition for the evolution matrix:

Q=sdR,s,R∈SO(3),d=diag⁡{e−ζit}.Q=s d R,\qquad s,R\in SO(3),\qquad d=\operatorname{diag}\{e^{-\zeta_i t}\}.

From incompressibility it follows det⁡Q=1\det Q=1, hence, ζ1+ζ2+ζ3=0\zeta_1+\zeta_2+\zeta_3=0.

It is well known (Furstenberg [12]; Letchikov [31]) that the long-time asymptotic behavior of these three components is quite different: as QQ obeys Eq. (14), s(t)s(t) stabilizes at some random value that depends on the realization of the process; ζi(t)\zeta_i(t) are asymptotically stationary random processes and tend (with unitary probability) to the limits λi\lambda_i,

λ1≥λ2≥λ3,\lambda_1 \ge\lambda_2 \ge\lambda_3 ,

the set of λi\lambda_i is called the Lyapunov spectrum (Oseledets [40]); and R(t)R(t) rotates randomly. We note that since QQT=sd2sTQQ^T = sd^2s^T and (Q−1)TQ−1=sd−2sT(Q^{-1})^TQ^{-1} = sd^{-2}s^T, the matrix RR vanishes in the expression for B2(t)B^2(t). This simplifies the calculation of the statistical moments. The Kazantsev-Kraichnan model provides one more significant simplification: in particular, it corresponds to time-reversible flow, which means λ2=0\lambda_2 = 0.

Without loss of generality, the initial conditions for B(p,0)B(\mathbf{p},0) can be chosen Gaussian, with pair correlator

⟨Bn(0,p)Bm(0,p′)⟩=δ(p+p′)e−p2l2(p2δmn−pmpn),(15)\langle B_n(0,\mathbf{p})B_m(0,\mathbf{p}')\rangle= \delta(\mathbf{p}+\mathbf{p}')e^{-p^2l^2}(p^2\delta_{mn}-p_mp_n), \tag*{(15)}

Raising (13) to the square and taking average over the initial conditions, one can obtain ([9, 54])

⟨B2⟩i.c.∼{d2/d1,ln⁡d2>0,d3/d2,ln⁡d2<0.\langle B^2\rangle_{i.c.}\sim \begin{cases} d_2/d_1, & \ln d_2>0,\\ d_3/d_2, & \ln d_2<0. \end{cases}

To average this expression over all possible realizations of AA, one considers the probability density of ζ\zeta:

P(y,t)=⟨∏j=13δ(ζj(t)−yj)⟩,P(\mathbf{y},t)=\left\langle\prod_{j=1}^{3}\delta(\zeta_j(t)-y_j)\right\rangle,
⟨B2⟩i.c.,v=∫P(ζ,t)⟨B2⟩i.c.dζ1…dζ3.(16)\langle B^2\rangle_{i.c.,v}=\int P(\boldsymbol{\zeta},t)\langle B^2\rangle_{i.c.}d\zeta_1\ldots d\zeta_3. \tag*{(16)}

The incompressibility condition leaves only two independent variables (e.g., ζ1,ζ2\zeta_1,\zeta_2). The probability density of ζj\zeta_j for any (not necessarily Gaussian) A(t)A(t) can be expressed in terms of statistics of the process A(t)A(t) (Il’yın et al. 2016, 2019).

Eventually, for the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model one gets ([9])

lim⁡t→∞1tln⁡⟨B2⟩=52D,(17)\lim_{t\to\infty}\frac{1}{t}\ln\langle B^2\rangle=\frac{5}{2}D, \tag*{(17)}
lim⁡t→∞1tln⁡⟨B2n⟩=(2n+n22)D.(18)\lim_{t\to\infty}\frac{1}{t}\ln\langle B^{2n}\rangle=\left(2n+\frac{n^2}{2}\right)D. \tag*{(18)}

We see that (17) coincides with the increment obtained in the Kazantsev approach. So, it appears that the asymptote found in Batchelor approximation remains to be valid not only during the initial stage, t<1Dˉln⁡(rν/l)t<\frac{1}{\bar{D}}\ln(r_\nu/l), but also at later stages of evolution. This fact is non-trivial, since, e.g., in two-dimensional flows the Kazantsev equations shows no growing modes, and the exponential increase of magnetic field at the initial Batchelor stage changes to decrease at larger time ([46, 25]).

V3 model in the method of Lagrangian deformations

To generalize the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model, one has to add higher-order connected correlators; in particular, to take time asymmetric processes into account, one has to deal with third-order correlators. The isotropy and incompressibility conditions reduce the degrees of freedom of the whole tensor ⟨AijAkmAnl⟩\langle A_{ij}A_{km}A_{nl}\rangle to one arbitrary multiplier FF. The general expression for all the components is given by Pumir [42]; here we restrict our consideration to the correlators of the diagonal elements AijA_{ij} (no summation), since these components are the only ones needed for calculation of ⟨B2⟩\langle B^2\rangle (Il’yın et al. 2016, 2019):

⟨App(t)Aqq(t′)Arr(t′′)⟩=Ffpqrδ(t−t′)δ(t−t′′),(19)\langle A_{pp}(t)A_{qq}(t')A_{rr}(t'')\rangle=Ff_{pqr}\delta(t-t')\delta(t-t''),\qquad \tag*{(19)}
f111=f222=f333=f123=−43,f_{111}=f_{222}=f_{333}=f_{123}=-\frac{4}{3},
f112=f113=f221=…=23.f_{112}=f_{113}=f_{221}=\ldots=\frac{2}{3}.

We note that here fpqrf_{pqr} is not a tensor. The right-hand side of (19) is written in the form corresponding to an effective δ\delta-process (Il’yın et al. 2016). The validity of this approximation is verified by the possibility to reduce any finite-correlation time non-Gaussian process to some delta-correlated process, see Appendix A.

In the frame of the V3V^3 model, we set all the higher order connected correlators zero. A vice of this simplification is that the probability density is negative in some range of its argument ([37] (Rytov et al. 1978)) as only the second and the third connected correlators are unequal to zero. This artefact can be fixed in the case of small FF by addition negligibly small but non-zero higher-order correlators. These higher-order corrections would not affect the magnetic field increment.

So, the time asymmetry of the velocity field in Batchelor regime is governed by only one parameter FF. The coefficient FF is the index of asymmetry of the flow. The direction of cascade observed in real three-dimensional hydrodynamic flows corresponds to F>0F>0 (Il’yın & Zybin 2015). The numerical simulation ([14]) and the experiment ([32]) give an estimate of the relation between the Lyapunov exponents λ2/λ1≃0.14\lambda_2/\lambda_1\simeq0.14. The Lyapunov exponents are related to the parameters FF and DD ([3] (Il’yın et al. 2016)) by λ1/λ2=(2D−F)/(2F)\lambda_1/\lambda_2=(2D-F)/(2F). So, this result for the Lyapunov spectrum corresponds to

F/D≃0.13(20)F/D\simeq0.13 \tag*{(20)}

Returning to the calculation of ⟨B2⟩\langle B^{2}\rangle, one makes use of the statistics of AA to calculate the probability density P(ζ,t)P(\zeta,t) (Il’yn et al. 2016, 2019); the long-time asymptote of the integral in (16) can be found by the saddle point method, and the result is (Il’yn et al. 2019):1

lim⁡t→∞1tln⁡⟨B2(t)⟩=4D39F2+7D−(4D2+27F2)3/218F2,(21)\lim_{t\to\infty}\frac{1}{t}\ln\langle B^{2}(t)\rangle=\frac{4D^{3}}{9F^{2}}+7D-\frac{\left(4D^{2}+27F^{2}\right)^{3/2}}{18F^{2}}, \tag*{(21)}

In the limit F≪1F\ll1 we arrive to

γ=52D(1−24380(FD)2+o((FD)2))(22)\gamma=\frac{5}{2}D\left(1-\frac{243}{80}\left(\frac{F}{D}\right)^{2}+o\left(\left(\frac{F}{D}\right)^{2}\right)\right) \tag*{(22)}

We see that the average coincides with that for Kazantsev-Kraichnan model if F=0F=0. Analogous calculations for the higher order increments lead to

lim⁡t→∞1tln⁡⟨B2n(t)⟩≃(2n+n22)D−332(2+n)4F2D\lim_{t\to\infty}\frac{1}{t}\ln\langle B^{2n}(t)\rangle\simeq\left(2n+\frac{n^{2}}{2}\right)D-\frac{3}{32}(2+n)^{4}\frac{F^{2}}{D}

The dependence γ(F)\gamma(F) for the exact and approximated equations (21) and (22) is presented in Figure 1. One can see that the approximation (22) works well for F/D≲0.1F/D\lesssim0.1.

Figure 1. γ\gamma as a function of FF, all values normalized by DD. The solid line corresponds to (21), and the dashed line represents (22).

The expression (22) generalizes (17) for time asymmetric flows, but it is still derived for linear velocity field, and thus, is only valid at Batchelor stage of magnetic field evolution. To investigate the dynamo generation at longer time, one should apply the Kazantsev approach to the V3V^{3} model.

V3 model in the generalized Kazantsev theory

In the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model there is only one nontrivial velocity correlator:

⟨vi(r,t)vj(r′,t′)⟩=Dij(r−r′)δ(t−t′).(23)\langle v_i(r,t)v_j(r',t')\rangle=D_{ij}(r-r')\delta(t-t'). \tag*{(23)}

In the frame of the V3V^{3} model ideology, we add the third order correlator:2

⟨vi(r,t)vj(r′,t′)vk(r′′,t′′)⟩=Fijk(r−r′,r−r′′)δ(t−t′)δ(t−t′′).(24)\langle v_i(r,t)v_j(r',t')v_k(r'',t'')\rangle=F_{ijk}(r-r',r-r'')\delta(t-t')\delta(t-t''). \tag*{(24)}

The correspondence with velocity gradients statistics (8),(19) requires

D=−34d2dr2(1r2rirjDij)∣r=0,(25)D=-\left.\frac{3}{4}\frac{d^{2}}{dr^{2}}\left(\frac{1}{r^{2}}r_i r_jD_{ij}\right)\right|_{r=0}, \tag*{(25)}
F=−34∂3∂r1∂r1′∂r1′′F111(0,0).(26)F=-\frac{3}{4}\frac{\partial^{3}}{\partial r_1\partial r'_1\partial r''_1}F_{111}(0,0). \tag*{(26)}

Again, just as in the case of velocity gradients, the requirement of isotropy and incompressibility of the flow leaves only one free parameter for the tensor FijkF_{ijk}: it is the multiplier FF that plays the role.

To apply the Kazantsev method to the non-Gaussian velocity field, one has to use the non-Gaussian version of the Furutsu-Novikov relation (Klyatskin [23]; Rytov et al. 1978) to take the nonzero third order correlator into account:

⟨vi(r,t)g[v]⟩=12∫dr′ Dij(r−r′)⟨δδvj(r′,t)g[v]⟩+16∫dr′ dr′′ Fijk(r−r′,r−r′′)⟨δ2δvj(r′,t)δvk(r′′,t)g[v]⟩.(27)\begin{aligned} \langle v_i(r,t)g[v]\rangle={}&\frac{1}{2}\int dr'\,D_{ij}(r-r')\left\langle\frac{\delta}{\delta v_j(r',t)}g[v]\right\rangle\\ &+\frac{1}{6}\int dr'\,dr''\,F_{ijk}(r-r',r-r'')\left\langle\frac{\delta^{2}}{\delta v_j(r',t)\delta v_k(r'',t)}g[v]\right\rangle. \tag*{(27)} \end{aligned}

In this equation the time integral is already calculated; see the details in Appendix § 8.

Taking average of the square of Eq. (1), we then arrive to the modification of the Kazantsev equation (10)

∂G(r,t)∂t=(LGauss+δL)G(r,t).(28)\frac{\partial G(r,t)}{\partial t}=(L_{\mathrm{Gauss}}+\delta L)G(r,t). \tag*{(28)}

The expression for δL\delta L is very cumbersome. Shorter expressions for important particular choices of Fijk(r)F_{ijk}(r) will be presented in the next Subsections.

We are interested in the long-time asymptotics of the magnetic field correlator, so we seek for the solutions

G(r,t)=eγtG(r),G(r,t)=e^{\gamma t}G(r),

which transform (28) into the ordinary differential equation

γG(r)=(LGauss+δL)G(r).(29)\gamma G(r) = (L_{\mathrm{Gauss}} + \delta L)G(r). \tag*{(29)}

The important feature is that Eqs. (28),(29) are third order differential equations with a small multiplier at the elder derivative. This results in appearance of a non-physical solution that does not coincide with the solutions of (10) as F→0F \to0; instead, it goes to infinity. This solution must not be taken into consideration (see also more details in Appendix C). Technically, this non-physical solution is a consequence of the truncated sequence of correlators; if one adds higher order correlators of AA into consideration, the number of solutions of the Kazantsev equation would increase in accordance with the order of the highest correlator. The non-physical solutions would grow unrestrictedly as the magnitudes of the higher order correlators tend to zero. These solutions have to be excluded by accurate choice of the boundary conditions.

Batchelor Regime

In the Batchelor approximation, velocity gradients are assumed to be constant in space (although dependent on time). Accordingly, the second derivatives of DijD_{ij} and the third derivatives of FijkF_{ijk} are assumed to be constant all over the liquid volume. Then, in accordance with (7),(8),

σ(r)=D3r2.(30)\sigma(r) = \frac{D}{3}r^2. \tag*{(30)}

The exact expression for Fijk(r−r′,r−r′′)F_{ijk}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}',\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}'') in the case is presented in Appendix B. Substituting this in (27), we get

LGaussB=23D(r2∂2∂r2+6r∂∂r+10)+2χ(∂2∂r2+4r∂∂r),(31)L_{\mathrm{Gauss}}^{B} = \frac{2}{3}D\left(r^2\frac{\partial^2}{\partial r^2}+6r\frac{\partial}{\partial r}+10\right)+2\chi\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial r^2}+\frac{4}{r}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\right), \tag*{(31)}

and the additional term in (28),(29) (see details of the derivation in Appendix B):

δLB=19F(2r3∂3∂r3+21r2∂2∂r2+14r∂∂r−70).(32)\delta L^{B} = \frac{1}{9}F\left(2r^3\frac{\partial^3}{\partial r^3}+21r^2\frac{\partial^2}{\partial r^2}+14r\frac{\partial}{\partial r}-70\right). \tag*{(32)}

The analytic analysis of Eq (28),(30),(32) is performed in Appendix C. We show that the fastest-growing mode corresponds to

γ=52D(1−24380(FD)2+o((FD)2)).(33)\gamma= \frac{5}{2}D\left(1-\frac{243}{80}\left(\frac{F}{D}\right)^2+o\left(\left(\frac{F}{D}\right)^2\right)\right). \tag*{(33)}

This coincides with the exponents (22) found in the previous Section. The important consequence from this expression is that, independently of the sign of FF, the resulting γ\gamma is smaller than that found in the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model. This means that the magnetic field generation is weaker in time-asymmetric flows than in the flow with Gaussian velocity gradients, independently of the direction of the energy cascade. Also, γ\gamma is monotonic function of F2F^2: the time asymmetry of the flow decreases the generation.

The coincidence of the results obtained by means of the Lagrangian deformation method and of the modified Kazantsev approach is not trivial and not evident, and we will consider it in more details in Discussion. Anyway, it proves that both methods work well as long as Batchelor approximation is valid. However, the Kazantsev approach allows to investigate later stages of magnetic field evolution, when characteristic scales of magnetic lines lengths exceed the viscous scale, and spatial inhomogeneity of velocity gradients cannot be neglected.

Nonlinear Velocity Field

To take this inhomogeneity into account, one should consider scales comparable or larger than the viscous scale: outside this scale the correlators change essentially. In (11) this is expressed by means of three different ranges. We also have to cut off the third-order correlator. Since it is known [39, 29] that (in the case of large PrmPr_m) the details of the outer ranges do not affect the result significantly, we simplify (11) to

σ(r)={D3r2,r≤rν,D3rν2,r>rν.(34)\sigma(r)= \begin{cases} \frac{D}{3}r^2, & r\le r_\nu,\\ \frac{D}{3}r_\nu^2, & r>r_\nu. \end{cases} \tag*{(34)}

In the V3V^3 model, we cut FijkF_{ijk} at the same boundary r=rνr=r_\nu. The first term in (29) then takes the form

L~Gauss={LGaussB,r≤rν,(23Drν2+2χ)(∂2∂r2+4r∂∂r),r>rν.(35)\widetilde{L}_{\mathrm{Gauss}} = \begin{cases} L_{\mathrm{Gauss}}^{B}, & r\le r_\nu,\\ \left(\frac{2}{3}Dr_\nu^2+2\chi\right)\left(\frac{\partial^2}{\partial r^2}+\frac{4}{r}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\right), & r>r_\nu. \end{cases} \tag*{(35)}

and the second term is

δL~={δLB,r≤rν,0,r>rν.(36)\widetilde{\delta L} = \begin{cases} \delta L^{B}, & r\le r_\nu,\\ 0, & r>r_\nu. \end{cases} \tag*{(36)}

Since we consider large magnetic Prandtl numbers, viscosity is large as compared to magnetic diffusivity, and

rd2=χD≪rν2.(37)r_d^2=\frac{\chi}{D}\ll r_\nu^2. \tag*{(37)}

So, in addition to the small parameter F/DF/D in the Batchelor problem statement, here we have one more small parameter

1/μ=rd/rν.1/\mu=r_d/r_\nu.

The equation (29) with (34),(36) can be solved in special functions. However, we make an analytic estimate for the contribution of large but finite μ\mu to the magnetic increment:

γmax⁡≳D(52−243F232D2−2π23ln⁡2μ(1+O(F2/D2)))(38)\gamma_{\max} \gtrsim D\left(\frac{5}{2}-\frac{243F^{2}}{32D^{2}}-\frac{2\pi^{2}}{3\ln^{2}\mu}\left(1+O(F^{2}/D^{2})\right)\right) \tag*{(38)}

(See Appendix C for the derivation). This estimate shows that, in the first approximation, the non-Gaussianity and the finiteness of the magnetic Prandtl number (μ<∞\mu< \infty) act independently.

In the next Section we will consider the numerical solutions to the equation (29) for finite μ\mu, investigate the dependence of magnetic field generation on the parameters FF and μ\mu, and check the reliability of the model.

Numerical solution of the generalized Kazantsev equation

The generalized Kazantsev equation (28) is a third-order differential equation with small multiplier F/DF/D at the elder derivative. It is not evident if its solutions are stable and converge to the solutions of (10) in the limit F/D→0F/D \to0. We also test our theoretical conclusion (38) and show that the behavior of the increment does not depend on the details of the cutoff at large rr.

Technical Details

We consider the Eq. (29) with σ\sigma and δL\delta_L determined by (34) and (36). In dimensionless notations

x=r/rd,Γ=γ/D,f=F/D,μ=rν/rdx = r/r_d,\quad\Gamma= \gamma/D,\quad f = F/D,\quad\mu= r_\nu/r_d

we get the equation for G(x)G(x):

ΓG=23(x2θ(μ−x)+μ2θ(x−μ)+3)G′′+43(3xθ(μ−x)+2μ2xθ(x−μ)+6x)G′+203θ(μ−x)G+19f(2x3G′′′+21x2G′′+14xG′−70)θ(μ−x).(39)\begin{aligned} \Gamma G={}&\frac{2}{3}\left(x^{2}\theta(\mu-x)+\mu^{2}\theta(x-\mu)+3\right)G''\\ &+\frac{4}{3}\left(3x\theta(\mu-x)+\frac{2\mu^{2}}{x}\theta(x-\mu)+\frac{6}{x}\right)G'\\ &+\frac{20}{3}\theta(\mu-x)G+\frac{1}{9}f\left(2x^{3}G'''+21x^{2}G''+14xG'-70\right)\theta(\mu-x). \tag*{(39)} \end{aligned}

where θ(y)\theta(y) denotes the Heaviside function.

The solution G(x)G(x) depends on two parameters ff and μ\mu. The asymptotes of the solutions can be found analytically.

In the limit x→0x \to0, (39) has three modes:

G(1)=1−Yx2,Y=13−7f18−Γ20(40)G_{(1)}=1-Yx^{2},\qquad Y=\frac{1}{3}-\frac{7f}{18}-\frac{\Gamma}{20} \tag*{(40)}
G(2)(x)∼x−3,G(3)(x)∼x6exp⁡(92fx2).(41)G_{(2)}(x)\sim x^{-3},\qquad G_{(3)}(x)\sim x^{6}\exp\left(\frac{9}{2fx^{2}}\right). \tag*{(41)}

The first two of them are close to the corresponding solutions for the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model; the third one is ’produced’ by the third-order term. The last two modes diverge as x→0x \to0, so, they must be excluded from the physical solution.

The other asymptote is x≫μx \gg\mu. The equation is significantly simplified in this limit because σ(r)\sigma(r) becomes a constant:

p2G=G′′+4G′x,p2=Γ2(1+13μ2).(42)p^{2}G=G''+\frac{4G'}{x},\qquad p^{2}=\frac{\Gamma}{2(1+\frac{1}{3}\mu^{2})}. \tag*{(42)}

The exact solution to this equation is

G(x)=Y1e−pxx(1+1px)+Y2epxx(1−1px).(43)G(x)=Y_{1}\frac{e^{-px}}{x}\left(1+\frac{1}{px}\right)+Y_{2}\frac{e^{px}}{x}\left(1-\frac{1}{px}\right). \tag*{(43)}

Again, the divergency condition G(x)→x→∞0G(x)\mathop{\to}_{x\to\infty}0 requires Y2=0Y_{2}=0 and leaves only one of the two modes.

To solve equation (39) numerically, we fix some Γ\Gamma and the initial point x1≪1x_{1}\ll1. The initial conditions G(x1),G′(x1),G′′(x1)G(x_{1}),G'(x_{1}),G''(x_{1}) are determined by the asymptote (40). Then we get the numerical solution G(x)G(x) up to x=μx=\mu, and match it with the asymptote (43); the condition Y2=0Y_{2}=0 singles out a discrete spectrum of possible values Γ\Gamma. We are looking for the maximal value Γ=Γmax⁡\Gamma=\Gamma_{\max}. We also check the stability of the solution relative to the choice of x1x_{1}.

Results

As it follows from (38), the theoretical prediction for γ(f,μ)\gamma(f,\mu) is

Γ=γD≃(52−c2f2−c3+O(f2)ln⁡2μ)(44)\Gamma=\frac{\gamma}{D}\simeq\left(\frac{5}{2}-c_{2}f^{2}-\frac{c_{3}+O(f^{2})}{\ln^{2}\mu}\right) \tag*{(44)}
c2=24332≃7.59,c3≲2π23≃6.6c_{2}=\frac{243}{32}\simeq7.59,\qquad c_{3}\lesssim\frac{2\pi^{2}}{3}\simeq6.6

First, we analyze the dependence Γ(f)\Gamma(f) for some fixed μ\mu. The results for three values of μ\mu are presented in Figure 2. We see that, in accordance with (44), Γ(f)\Gamma(f) has parabolic shape at small ff for all considered values of μ\mu. To observe the dependence of the second-order term on μ\mu, we fit the results of the simulation by parabolic functions in the range 0≤f≤0.10 \leq f \leq0.1; at larger ff, the higher-order terms in (44) may come into play. The results are presented in Table 1. One can see that the absolute term is smaller than 2.5 and increases as a function μ\mu. The magnitude of the declination agrees with (44). The absolute value of the coefficient at f2f^2 decreases as a function of μ\mu, approaching the theoretical prediction c2c_2 for μ=∞\mu=\infty.

Figure 2. Numerically calculated Γ(f)\Gamma(f) for μ=30\mu= 30 (lower band), 100 and 300 (upper band) fitted by parabolic functions inside the range 0<f<0.10 < f < 0.1. The declination at higher ff is a result of higher-order terms in (44).

μ\muC1C_1C2C_2
301.884±0.0031.884 \pm0.00311.5±0.511.5 \pm0.5
1002.159±0.0012.159 \pm0.0019.5±0.29.5 \pm0.2
3002.277±0.0012.277 \pm0.0018.7±0.38.7 \pm0.3
∞\infty (theory)2.57.59

Table 1. Fit of the numerical data (Figure 2) for 0<f<0.10 < f < 0.1: Γ(f)=C1−C2f2\Gamma(f)=C_1-C_2f^2

Second, we calculate the function Γ(μ)\Gamma(\mu) at some given ff. We take f=0.13f=0.13 because it corresponds to the asymmetry of a real flow (20) observed in the numerical calculation [14] and experiment [32]. We also calculate Γ(μ)\Gamma(\mu) for a symmetric flow, f=0f=0: in this case, the equation (39) becomes a second order equation. The results are presented in Figure 3. We fit the graphs by the ansatz

Figure 3. Numerical calculation of Γ(μ)\Gamma(\mu) for f=0f=0 (upper set of dots) and f=0.13f=0.13 (lower set of dots) fitted by (45).

Γ(μ)=C1−C3ln⁡2μ.(45)\Gamma(\mu)=C_1-\frac{C_3}{\ln^2\mu}. \tag*{(45)}

The correspondence is good enough; for f=0f=0, we get C1=2.50±0.02C_1=2.50\pm0.02 and C3=6.64±0.33C_3=6.64\pm0.33, which coincides with the theoretical prediction c1c_1 and c3c_3 in (44).

The choice of the σ(r)\sigma(r) profile at r≃rνr\simeq r_\nu is rather conditional; the details of the velocity structure function at this range of scales are believed not to effect

the result significantly. This has been checked numerically [39] for the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model, but it has to be also proved for F≠0F\ne0. So, apart from (34), we consider a smooth function

σ~(r)=D3×(r/rd)21+(r/rν)2.(46)\widetilde{\sigma}(r)=\frac{D}{3}\times\frac{(r/r_d)^2}{1+(r/r_\nu)^2}. \tag*{(46)}

At r→∞r\to\infty and r→0r\to0 it has the same asymptotes as σ(r)\sigma(r). We perform the same calculations with this function. In Figure 4, the dependence Γ(μ)\Gamma(\mu) for f=0.13f=0.13 is presented for both choices of σ\sigma. We see that the details of the saturation do not affect the increment behavior crucially.

Figure 4. Dependence of the results on the shape of the velocity structure function. Γ(μ)\Gamma(\mu) for f=0.13f=0.13 in the case of the step-like σ(r)\sigma(r) (34) (upper dots) and the smoothed σ~(r)\widetilde{\sigma}(r) (46) (lower dots) fitted by (45).

Finally, from (44) it follows that γ(f,μ)\gamma(f,\mu) becomes negative outside some region in the f,μf,\mu plane. So, the range of the parameters at which the generation of magnetic field is possible is restricted by some μ>μcrit(f)\mu>\mu_{\mathrm{crit}}(f). The numerical calculations confirm this prediction. We also find the dependence μcrit(f)\mu_{\mathrm{crit}}(f): it is presented in Figure 5. One can see that the presence of non-Gaussian term decreases the range of μ\mu that permits the generation.

Figure 5. The boundary of the magnetic field generation range γ>0\gamma> 0, μcrit\mu_{\mathrm{crit}} as a function of ff. The triangle corresponds to the point (20)

Discussion

Thus, in this paper we consider the magnetic field generation in a turbulent hydrodynamic flow. We derive the generalization of the Kazantsev equation for the case of time asymmetric flows with small but finite third order velocity correlator, which is, probably, the general case of real hydrodynamic turbulent flows. The non-zero third order correlator corresponds to the time asymmetry of the flow and is responsible for the energy cascade.

We use the V3V^3 model: slightly non-Gaussian stochastic velocity field is replaced by an effective δ\delta-process, and the velocity connected correlators of the order higher than three are assumed to be zero. The validity of this model is argued in Section III and Appendix A. We also use one more (unessential) simplifying assumption on the shape of velocity structure function, which is considered piecewise.

The main results are:

  • We show that the magnetic field generation weakens in presence of time asymmetry, independently of the direction of the energy cascade (38): the increment of average magnetic energy density decreases proportionally to the square of the magnitude FF of the third order correlator.

  • The range of magnetic Prandtl numbers (presented in the considered model by the parameter μ\mu) that allow the magnetic field generation also becomes narrower for finite FF: the critical Prandtl number increases as a function of FF (Figure 5).

  • We show that, despite the presence of a small higher-order derivative, the numerical solution of the generalized Kazantsev equation converges in the limit F→0F \to0 to the solution of the Kazantsev equation. This proves that the generalized Kazantsev equation allows to investigate numerically the magnetic field evolution in time-asymmetric flows with intermediate magnetic Prandtl numbers.

Now we proceed to the discussion of some interesting particular consequences.

We solve the generalized Kazantsev equation analytically in the limit of the Batchelor regime, rν=∞r_\nu= \infty. In this limit, the resulting increment (33) coincides with the result that follows from the Lagrangian deformation method (22). This coincidence not only proves the reliability of both methods. It also reflects a non-trivial physical fact: the time-averaged magnetic energy density measured at some fixed point coincides with that measured along a liquid particle trajectory. Not only the methods of calculation differ in the two approaches but also the averages ⟨B2⟩\langle B^2\rangle are taken over different ensembles. So, the coincidence not only verifies the results but also proves the equivalence of these two averages. This coincidence is not a consequence of ergodicity, since the trajectory of a particle as well as magnetic energy are functionals of the velocity field, and, thus, are not independent.

The equivalence of the two average was found for passive scalar [3] and vector [9] advection in the case of Kazanatsev-Kraichnan velocity field. Now we see that it also holds for vector advection in time-asymmetric velocity fields.

Another important coincidence establishes the relation between the magnetic increments calculated for the Batchelor limit and for the case of finite Prandtl number. Namely, the theoretical analysis and numerical simulation confirm that, as μ→∞\mu\to\infty, the increment γ(μ,F)\gamma(\mu,F) converges to the value γ(F)\gamma(F) found for the Batchelor regime. This is also not trivial: for instance, this equality does not hold for two-dimensional flows [25, 46] or for higher-order correlators in three-dimensional flows [55]. The Kazantsev equation corresponds to the infinite-time limit; the convergence of the solutions in the limit Prm→∞Pr_m \to\infty (and its coincidence with the value obtained for the Batchelor case) means that the limits Prm→∞Pr_m \to\infty and t→∞t \to\infty commute. This also has been known for Gaussian flows [21, 39] (Kulstrud & Anderson 1992), now this is also checked for the time asymmetric case.

Eventually, the deformation of the magnetic energy spectrum and its evolution is also an interesting and important question [21, 46, 6, 1] (Kulstrud & Anderson 1992). In the frame of V3V^3 model it is also possible to find the spectrum evolution, however this problem is rather complicated and deserves separate investigation. We will explore it in the next paper.

Summarizing, we stress that the asymmetry of the hydrodynamic flow statistics is an essential feature that may affect the process of magnetic field generation. The V3V^3 model allows to investigate the asymmetric flows, and thus opens the prospective for investigation of transport problems in the flows with energy cascade.

The authors are grateful to Professor A.V. Gurevich for his permanent attention to their work. A.M.K. thanks Professor Ya.N. Istomin for considerable contribution to the work on its early stage. The work of A.V.K. and A.M.K. was supported by the RSF Grant No. 20-12-00047.

Grounds for the effective δ\delta-process introduction

The equation (12) is a stochastic differential equation, the random velocity gradient tensor A\mathbf{A} acts as a multiplicative noise [4].

One can show that for any non-Gaussian process with finite corelation time, there exists some corresponding effective δ\delta-process (Il’yn et al. 2016). This means that

lim⁡T→∞1Tlog⁡⟨B2(T)⟩=lim⁡T→∞1Tlog⁡⟨B2(T)⟩eff,(47)\lim_{T\to\infty}\frac{1}{T}\log\langle B^{2}(T)\rangle=\lim_{T\to\infty}\frac{1}{T}\log\langle B^{2}(T)\rangle_{\mathrm{eff}}, \tag*{(47)}

where the average in the right-hand side is calculated for velocity statistics defined by the effective δ\delta-process. The reason to replace an arbitrary finite-correlation time process by the corresponding δ\delta-process is that in the equation with multiplicative noise, the higher order connected correlators of the noise contribute to the long-time statistical properties of the solutions only via their integrals. This allows to substitute singular correlation functions for the real correlators.

We demonstrate this fact by a simple example. Consider a one-dimensional stochastic equation with multiplicative noise ξ(t)\xi(t):

∂tx(t)=ξ(t)x(t),x(0)=0,(48)\partial_t x(t)=\xi(t)x(t),\quad x(0)=0, \tag*{(48)}

where ξ(t)\xi(t) is a continous stationary random process with finite correlation time. Let it have regular fast decaying connected correlation functions (cumulants):

⟨ξ(t1)⋯ξ(tn)⟩c=W(n)(t1−t2,…,t1−tn).\langle\xi(t_1)\cdots\xi(t_n)\rangle_c=W^{(n)}(t_1-t_2,\ldots,t_1-t_n).

The cumulant generating functional is defined by

⟨e∫ξ(t)η(t) dt⟩=eW[η(t)],(49)\left\langle e^{\int\xi(t)\eta(t)\,\mathrm{d}t}\right\rangle=e^{W[\eta(t)]}, \tag*{(49)}

then

W[η(t)]=∑n1n!∫W(n)(t1−t2,…,t1−tn)η(t1)⋯η(tn) dt1⋯dtn(50)W[\eta(t)]=\sum_n\frac{1}{n!}\int W^{(n)}(t_1-t_2,\ldots,t_1-t_n)\eta(t_1)\cdots\eta(t_n)\,\mathrm{d}t_1\cdots\mathrm{d}t_n \tag*{(50)}

The solution of the Eq. (A2) for each continuous realization of ξ(t)\xi(t) can be written as

x(T)=e∫0Tξ(t) dt(51)x(T)=e^{\int_0^T \xi(t)\,\mathrm{d}t} \tag*{(51)}

We are interested in the statistical moments

⟨xm(T)⟩=⟨em∫0Tξ(t) dt⟩\langle x^m(T)\rangle=\left\langle e^{m\int_0^T \xi(t)\,\mathrm{d}t}\right\rangle

From (A3) it then follows that

⟨xm(T)⟩=eW[mθ(t)θ(T−t)],\langle x^m(T)\rangle=e^{W[m\theta(t)\theta(T-t)]},

where θ\theta is the Heaviside step-like function. According to (A4), we then have

lim⁡T→∞1Tlog⁡⟨xm(T)⟩=w(m),\lim_{T\to\infty}\frac{1}{T}\log\langle x^m(T)\rangle=w(m),
w(m)=∑nmnn!w(n).w^{(m)}=\sum_n \frac{m^n}{n!}w^{(n)}.
w(n)=∫W(n)(τ2,…,τn)dτ2…dτn,w^{(n)}=\int W^{(n)}(\tau_2,\ldots,\tau_n)d\tau_2\ldots d\tau_n,

We see that as T→∞T \to\infty the statistical moments of xx depend only on the integrals w(n)w^{(n)} and do not depend on the detailed shape of the correlators. So, for any random process ξ(t)\xi(t) (i.e., for any given W(n)W^{(n)}), we can consider a series of random processes ξε(t)\xi_\varepsilon(t) with

Wε(n)=1εn−1W(n)(τ2/ε,…,τn/ε)W_\varepsilon^{(n)}=\frac{1}{\varepsilon^{n-1}}W^{(n)}(\tau_2/\varepsilon,\ldots,\tau_n/\varepsilon)

and all these processes would produce the same long-time asymptotes for the moments of x(t)x(t). The effective process ξeff(t)\xi_{eff}(t) is defined as the formal limit of this consequence as ε→0\varepsilon\to0. Its connected correlation functions are

⟨ξeff(t1)…ξeff(tn)⟩c=w(n)δ(t1−t2)…δ(t1−tn)\langle\xi_{eff}(t_1)\ldots\xi_{eff}(t_n)\rangle_c=w^{(n)}\delta(t_1-t_2)\ldots\delta(t_1-t_n)

In the case of multidimensional stochastic processes and stochastic fields the expression for the exact solution looks much more complicated than (A5), since the integral transforms into a continuous matrix product (T-exponent). However the long-time asymptotes of the solutions’ moments still depend only on the integrals of the connected correlators of the noise. This is the reason and the justification for substitution of the effective δ\delta-process for any random process. This tool is convenient in turbulence and turbulent transport problems, since it allows to get closed equations for statistical moments.

Derivation of the generalized Kazantsev equation

We start with Eq. (1); to get the equation for the pair correlator, we multiply it by B\mathbf{B} and take the average. For brevity, we denote

Bα=Bα(r,t),Bα′=Bα(r′,t),B_\alpha=B_\alpha(\mathbf{r},t),\qquad B'_\alpha=B_\alpha(\mathbf{r}',t),
vα=vα(r,t),vα′=vα(r′,t),v_\alpha=v_\alpha(\mathbf{r},t),\qquad v'_\alpha=v_\alpha(\mathbf{r}',t),
∂α=∂∂rα,∂α′=∂∂rα′,∂αρ=∂∂(r′−r)α.\partial_\alpha=\frac{\partial}{\partial r_\alpha},\qquad\partial'_\alpha=\frac{\partial}{\partial r'_\alpha},\qquad\partial^\rho_\alpha=\frac{\partial}{\partial(r'-r)_\alpha}.

We also take into account that homogeneity of the flow, which results in ∂mρ⟨…⟩=−∂m′⟨…⟩=−∂mρ⟨…⟩\partial^\rho_m\langle\ldots\rangle=-\partial'_m\langle\ldots\rangle=-\partial^\rho_m\langle\ldots\rangle and ⟨vp′BqBα⟩=−⟨vpBqBα′⟩\langle v'_pB_qB_\alpha\rangle=-\langle v_pB_qB'_\alpha\rangle. Then the equation for the pair correlator takes the form

∂∂t⟨BαBβ′⟩=−εαmnεnpq∂mρ⟨vpBqBβ′⟩−εβmnεnpq∂mρ⟨vpBqBα′⟩+2κ∂mρ∂mρ′⟨BαBβ′⟩.(52)\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\langle B_\alpha B'_\beta\rangle=-\varepsilon_{\alpha mn}\varepsilon_{npq}\partial^\rho_m\langle v_pB_qB'_\beta\rangle-\varepsilon_{\beta mn}\varepsilon_{npq}\partial^\rho_m\langle v_pB_qB'_\alpha\rangle+2\kappa\partial^\rho_m\partial^{\rho'}_m\langle B_\alpha B'_\beta\rangle. \tag*{(52)}

Now we have to split the mixed correlations by means of the generalized Furutsu-Novikov equation Furutsu [13]; Klyatskin [23]:

⟨vpBqBr′⟩=∫dr1dt1⟨vp(r,t)vi1(r1,t1)⟩⟨δ(Bq(r,t)Br(r′,t))δvi1(r1,t1)⟩+12∫dr1dt1dr2dt2⟨vp(r,t)vi1(r1,t1)vi2(r2,t2)⟩⟨δ2(Bq(r,t)Br(r′,t))δvi1(r1,t1)δvi2(r2,t2)⟩.(53)\begin{aligned} \langle v_pB_qB'_r\rangle={}&\int d\mathbf{r}_1dt_1\langle v_p(\mathbf{r},t)v_{i_1}(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)\rangle\left\langle\frac{\delta(B_q(\mathbf{r},t)B_r(\mathbf{r}',t))}{\delta v_{i_1}(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)}\right\rangle\\ &+\frac{1}{2}\int d\mathbf{r}_1dt_1d\mathbf{r}_2dt_2\langle v_p(\mathbf{r},t)v_{i_1}(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)v_{i_2}(\mathbf{r}_2,t_2)\rangle\left\langle\frac{\delta^2(B_q(\mathbf{r},t)B_r(\mathbf{r}',t))}{\delta v_{i_1}(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)\delta v_{i_2}(\mathbf{r}_2,t_2)}\right\rangle. \tag*{(53)} \end{aligned}

Since the variational derivatives contain delta-functions, to avoid the products of delta-functions with coinciding arguments, we have to deal more accurately with the time coincidence in correlators. Namely, we have to introduce a ’regularized δ\delta-function’: a bell-shaped function δε(τ)\delta_\varepsilon(\tau) satisfying the normalization condition ∫δε(τ)dτ=1\int\delta_\varepsilon(\tau)d\tau=1 and with the width of the order of the correlation time. Then (23) and (24) can be written more precisely:

⟨vi(r,t)vj(r1,t1)⟩=Dij(r−r1)δε(t−t1).(54)\langle v_i(\mathbf{r},t)v_j(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)\rangle=D_{ij}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_1)\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_1). \tag*{(54)}

and

⟨vi(r,t)vj(r1,t1)vk(r2,t2)⟩=13Fijk(r−r1,r−r2)(δε(t−t1)δε(t−t2)+δε(t−t1)δε(t1−t2)+δε(t−t2)δε(t1−t2)).(55)\langle v_i(\mathbf{r},t)v_j(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)v_k(\mathbf{r}_2,t_2)\rangle=\frac{1}{3}F_{ijk}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_1,\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_2)\left(\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_1)\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_2)+\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_1)\delta_\varepsilon(t_1-t_2)+\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_2)\delta_\varepsilon(t_1-t_2)\right). \tag*{(55)}

The isotropy and homogeneity conditions imply that the expression for FijkF_{ijk} can be written as a composition of δ\delta-symbols and the components of a,b\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b}. The non-divergency condition results in the requirement ∂Fijk/∂ai=∂Fijk/∂bj=(∂/∂ak+∂/∂bk)Fijk=0\partial F_{ijk}/\partial a_i=\partial F_{ijk}/\partial b_j=(\partial/\partial a_k+\partial/\partial b_k)F_{ijk}=0; also, the existence of viscosity means that FijkF_{ijk} is proportional to r3r^3, i.e., is a third-order polynom. These conditions determine the tensor FijkF_{ijk} to a constant multiplier:

Fijk(a,b)=−118F((2a2−15b2−2a⋅b)ajδik+(2b2−15a2−2a⋅b)bkδij+(20b2−5a2−16a⋅b)aiδjk+(20a2−5b2−16a⋅b)biδjk−(5a2+b2−26a⋅b)akδij−(5b2+a2−26a⋅b)bjδik+4aiajak+4bibjbk+12aiajbk+12biajbk−2aibjak−2bibjak−16aibjbk−16biajak).(56)\begin{aligned} F_{ijk}(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{b})={}&-\frac{1}{18}F\bigl((2a^2-15b^2-2\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{b})a_j\delta_{ik}+(2b^2-15a^2-2\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{b})b_k\delta_{ij}\\ &+(20b^2-5a^2-16\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{b})a_i\delta_{jk}+(20a^2-5b^2-16\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{b})b_i\delta_{jk}\\ &-(5a^2+b^2-26\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{b})a_k\delta_{ij}-(5b^2+a^2-26\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{b})b_j\delta_{ik}\\ &+4a_i a_j a_k+4b_i b_j b_k+12a_i a_j b_k+12b_i a_j b_k-2a_i b_j a_k-2b_i b_j a_k\\ &-16a_i b_j b_k-16b_i a_j a_k\bigr). \tag*{(56)} \end{aligned}

Analogous calculations for the inertial range were performed by Kopyev & Zybin [26].

Taking the Variational Derivative

To take the variational derivative, we make a formal functional consequence from (1):

Bq(r,t)=εqi1j1εj1l1k1∫−∞t∂i1(vl1(r,τ)Bk1(r,τ))dτ+κ∂i1∂i1∫−∞tBq(r,τ)dτ.(57)B_q(\mathbf{r},t)=\varepsilon_{q i_1 j_1}\varepsilon_{j_1 l_1 k_1}\int_{-\infty}^{t}\partial_{i_1}\left(v_{l_1}(\mathbf{r},\tau)B_{k_1}(\mathbf{r},\tau)\right)d\tau+\kappa\partial_{i_1}\partial_{i_1}\int_{-\infty}^{t}B_q(\mathbf{r},\tau)d\tau. \tag*{(57)}

The variational derivative of this expression is:

δBq(r,t)δvj(r1,t1)=εqi1j1εj1l1k1∫−∞t∂i1(δjl1δ(r−r1)δ(τ−t1)Bk1(r,τ))dτ+εqi1j1εj1l1k1∫t1t∂i1(vl1(r,τ)δBk1(r,τ)δvj(r1,t1))dτ+κ∂i1∂i1∫t1tδBq(r,τ)δvj(r1,t1)dτ.(58)\begin{aligned} \frac{\delta B_q(\mathbf{r},t)}{\delta v_j(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)} ={}&\varepsilon_{q i_1 j_1}\varepsilon_{j_1 l_1 k_1}\int_{-\infty}^{t}\partial_{i_1}\left(\delta_{j l_1}\delta(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_1)\delta(\tau-t_1)B_{k_1}(\mathbf{r},\tau)\right)d\tau\\ &+\varepsilon_{q i_1 j_1}\varepsilon_{j_1 l_1 k_1}\int_{t_1}^{t}\partial_{i_1}\left(v_{l_1}(\mathbf{r},\tau)\frac{\delta B_{k_1}(\mathbf{r},\tau)}{\delta v_j(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)}\right)d\tau\\ &+\kappa\partial_{i_1}\partial_{i_1}\int_{t_1}^{t}\frac{\delta B_q(\mathbf{r},\tau)}{\delta v_j(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)}d\tau. \tag*{(58)} \end{aligned}

The δ\delta-functions here are ’real’, not regularized. The lower limits of the integrals in the last two summands are changed, in accordance with the causality principle; after multiplying by δε\delta_\varepsilon in the velocity correlators in (B7), these lower limits will make no difference. Taking the second derivative, we get:

δ2Bq(r,t)δvj(r1,t1)δvk(r2,t2)∣t1,t2→t−0≃εqi1j1εj1jk1∫−∞tdτ1 ∂i1(δ(r−r1)δ(τ−t1)δBk1(r,t)δvk(r2,t2))=εqi1j1εj1jk1εk1i2j2εj2kk2θ(t−t1)θ(t−t2)×∂i1(δ(r−r1)∂i2(δ(r−r2)Bk2)).(59)\begin{aligned} \left.\frac{\delta^2B_q(\mathbf{r},t)}{\delta v_j(\mathbf{r}_1,t_1)\delta v_k(\mathbf{r}_2,t_2)}\right|_{t_1,t_2\to t-0} &\simeq\varepsilon_{q i_1 j_1}\varepsilon_{j_1 j k_1}\int_{-\infty}^{t}d\tau_1\,\partial_{i_1}\left(\delta(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_1)\delta(\tau-t_1)\frac{\delta B_{k_1}(\mathbf{r},t)}{\delta v_k(\mathbf{r}_2,t_2)}\right)\\ &=\varepsilon_{q i_1 j_1}\varepsilon_{j_1 j k_1}\varepsilon_{k_1 i_2 j_2}\varepsilon_{j_2 k k_2}\theta(t-t_1)\theta(t-t_2)\\ &\qquad\times\partial_{i_1}\left(\delta(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_1)\partial_{i_2}\left(\delta(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_2)B_{k_2}\right)\right). \tag*{(59)} \end{aligned}

Here we omit the terms that become zero being multiplied by the regularized δ\delta-function. Now we substitute these expressions into (B7). For the regularized delta functions we have

∫−∞+∞dt1∫−∞tdτ δε(t−t1)δ(τ−t1)=∫−∞+∞dt1 δε(t−t1)θ(t−t1)=∫−∞tdt1 δε(t−t1)=12.(60)\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}dt_1\int_{-\infty}^{t}d\tau\,\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_1)\delta(\tau-t_1)=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}dt_1\,\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_1)\theta(t-t_1)=\int_{-\infty}^{t}dt_1\,\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_1)=\frac{1}{2}. \tag*{(60)}
∫−∞tdt1∫−∞tdt2 δε(t−t1)δε(t−t2)=14∫−∞tdt1∫−∞tdt2 δε(t−t1)δε(t1−t2)=∫0+∞dx∫t1−t+∞dy δε(x)δε(y)=38.(61)\int_{-\infty}^{t}dt_1\int_{-\infty}^{t}dt_2\,\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_1)\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_2)=\frac{1}{4}\int_{-\infty}^{t}dt_1\int_{-\infty}^{t}dt_2\,\delta_\varepsilon(t-t_1)\delta_\varepsilon(t_1-t_2)=\int_{0}^{+\infty}dx\int_{t_1-t}^{+\infty}dy\,\delta_\varepsilon(x)\delta_\varepsilon(y)=\frac{3}{8}. \tag*{(61)}

These relations allow to take the time integrals in (B7). Thus, we arrive to (27). Taking the space integrals, we get the closed equation for the pair correlator:

∂∂t⟨BαBβ′⟩=2κ∂mρ∂mρ⟨BαBβ′⟩+12(εαmnεnpqδβr+εβmnεnpqδαr)εj1jk1∂i1ρ(εqi1j1Djp(0)⟨Bk1Br′⟩−εri1j1Djp(ρ)⟨BqBk1′⟩)+16(εαmnεnpqδβr+εβmnεnpqδαr)εj1jk1εj2kk2∂pρ(2εqi1j1εri2j2∂i2ρ(∂i1(2)Fkpj(ρ,ρ)⟨Bk1Bk2′⟩)+Fkpj(ρ,ρ)∂i1ρ⟨Bk1Bk2′⟩)+εri1j1εk1i2j2∂i1ρ(∂i2(2)Fpjk(ρ,ρ)⟨BqBk2′⟩+Fpjk(ρ,ρ)∂i2ρ⟨BqBk2′⟩),(62)\begin{aligned} \frac{\partial}{\partial t}\langle B_{\alpha}B'_{\beta}\rangle ={}&2\kappa\partial^{\rho}_{m}\partial^{\rho}_{m}\langle B_{\alpha}B'_{\beta}\rangle\\ &+\frac{1}{2}\left(\varepsilon_{\alpha mn}\varepsilon_{npq}\delta_{\beta r}+\varepsilon_{\beta mn}\varepsilon_{npq}\delta_{\alpha r}\right)\varepsilon_{j_{1}j_{k_{1}}}\partial^{\rho}_{i_{1}}\left(\varepsilon_{qi_{1}j_{1}}D_{jp}(0)\langle B_{k_{1}}B'_{r}\rangle-\varepsilon_{ri_{1}j_{1}}D_{jp}(\rho)\langle B_{q}B'_{k_{1}}\rangle\right)\\ &+\frac{1}{6}\left(\varepsilon_{\alpha mn}\varepsilon_{npq}\delta_{\beta r}+\varepsilon_{\beta mn}\varepsilon_{npq}\delta_{\alpha r}\right)\varepsilon_{j_{1}j_{k_{1}}}\varepsilon_{j_{2}k k_{2}}\partial^{\rho}_{p}\left(2\varepsilon_{qi_{1}j_{1}}\varepsilon_{ri_{2}j_{2}}\partial^{\rho}_{i_{2}}\left(\partial^{(2)}_{i_{1}}F_{kpj}(\rho,\rho)\langle B_{k_{1}}B'_{k_{2}}\rangle\right)\right.\\ &\left.\qquad+F_{kpj}(\rho,\rho)\partial^{\rho}_{i_{1}}\langle B_{k_{1}}B'_{k_{2}}\rangle\right)+\varepsilon_{ri_{1}j_{1}}\varepsilon_{k_{1}i_{2}j_{2}}\partial^{\rho}_{i_{1}}\left(\partial^{(2)}_{i_{2}}F_{pjk}(\rho,\rho)\langle B_{q}B'_{k_{2}}\rangle+F_{pjk}(\rho,\rho)\partial^{\rho}_{i_{2}}\langle B_{q}B'_{k_{2}}\rangle\right), \tag*{(62)} \end{aligned}

where ρ=r′−r\boldsymbol{\rho}=\mathbf{r}'-\mathbf{r} and ∂n(2)\partial^{(2)}_{n} denotes the derivative over the second argument.

Making use of (7), we express all the coefficients in the (B16) by means of the function P(r)P(r) and the longitudinal velocity structure function. After cumbersome symbol math-assisted calculations, we arrive to the generalized Kazantsev equation: (28), (31), (32) for the Batchelor regime and (28), (35), (36) for the nonlinear velocity field.

Solutions of the generalized Kazantsev equation

Kazantsev-Kraichnan Model, Linear Velocity Field

Consider first the simplest Kazantsev equation for the Kazantsev-Kraichnan model (10) in the Batchelor regime, i.e., with σ=(D/3)r2\sigma=(D/3)r^{2} (which corresponds to rν→∞r_{\nu}\to\infty). The substitution of the ansatz

G(t,r)=eγtG(r)G(t,r)=e^{\gamma t}G(r)

reduces this equation to the ordinary differential equation

γG=23D(r2G′′+6rG′+10G)+2κ(G′′+4rG′).\gamma G=\frac{2}{3}D\left(r^{2}G''+6rG'+10G\right)+2\kappa\left(G''+\frac{4}{r}G'\right).

We proceed to the dimensionless variables x=r/rdx=r/r_{d}; with account of κ=Drd2\kappa=Dr_{d}^{2}, we get

(x2+3)G′′+(6x+12x)G′+(10−32Γ)G=0,(63)\left(x^{2}+3\right)G''+\left(6x+\frac{12}{x}\right)G'+\left(10-\frac{3}{2}\Gamma\right)G=0, \tag*{(63)}

where

Γ=γ/D.\Gamma=\gamma/D.

The two exact solutions of this equation can be written by means of hypergeometric functions. Here we restrict our consideration to the analysis of their asymptotic behavior, to get the experience necessary to generalize the solutions to the cases of nonzero FF and/or finite rνr_{\nu}.

One of two independent solutions diverges as x→0x\to0, so we are interested in the other one. It satisfies the boundary condition G′(0)=0G'(0)=0.

As x→∞x\to\infty, the equation (C17) is simplified to a homogenous differential equation; its characteristic equation is

α(α−1)+6α+10−32Γ=0.\alpha(\alpha-1)+6\alpha+10-\frac{3}{2}\Gamma=0.

and the solution is

G(Γ)(x)≃x→∞A+xα++A−xα−.G^{(\Gamma)}(x)\underset{x\to\infty}{\simeq}A_{+}x^{\alpha_{+}}+A_{-}x^{\alpha_{-}}.

where

α±=−52±322Γ−5.\alpha_{\pm}=-\frac{5}{2}\pm\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}\sqrt{2\Gamma-5}.

The real and imaginary parts of α+(Γ)\alpha_{+}(\Gamma) are illustrated in Figure 6. One can see that for all Γ<5/2\Gamma<5/2, G(Γ)(x)G^{(\Gamma)}(x) decreases as x→∞x\to\infty with the same rate and oscillates, while for Γ>5/2\Gamma>5/2 it decreases slower (and for Γ>20/3\Gamma>20/3 even grows), without oscillations.

Figure 6. Real (orange) and imaginary (blue) parts of α+\alpha_{+} for different Γ>0\Gamma> 0.

Now, let us return to the evolution equation (10). The equation (C17) can be reduced to the Sturm-Liouville equation (by the change of variables y=arsinh⁡(x/3)y = \operatorname{arsinh}(x/\sqrt{3}), q(y)=(3+x2)1/4x2G(x)q(y) = (3 + x^{2})^{1/4}x^{2}G(x)). So, an arbitrary initial perturbation G0(x)G_{0}(x) can be decomposed into a sum (integral) of the eigenfunctions G(Γ)(x)G^{(\Gamma)}(x). The time dependence of each summand is exponential with its own rate, G(Γ)(t,x)∝eγtG^{(\Gamma)}(t,x) \propto e^{\gamma t}, so the term with the biggest γ\gamma would survive after large time. Now, if the initial function is localized (more precisely, decreases not faster than x−5/2x^{-5/2} as x→∞x \to\infty), then all the terms in the decomposition must oscillate or decrease at x→∞x \to\infty faster than G0(x)G_{0}(x). Since Im⁡α+(Γ≥5/2)=0\operatorname{Im}\alpha_{+}(\Gamma\ge5/2) = 0 and Re⁡α+(Γ≥5/2)>−5/2\operatorname{Re}\alpha_{+}(\Gamma\ge5/2) > -5/2, we get the upper boundary of the spectrum:

Γmax⁡=52,G(x,t)∝eΓmax⁡Dt.\Gamma_{\max} = \frac{5}{2}, \qquad G(x,t) \propto e^{\Gamma_{\max}Dt}.

Non-Zero Time Asymmetry

Now we take account of F≠0F \ne0, and apply the same ideas to analyze the equation (28), (32). The equation for the eigenvalues is

γG=23D(r2G′′+6rG′+10G)+2κ(G′′+4rG′)+19F(2r3G′′′+21r2G′′+14rG′−70G).(64)\gamma G = \frac{2}{3}D\left(r^{2}G'' + 6rG' + 10G\right) + 2\kappa\left(G'' + \frac{4}{r}G'\right) + \frac{1}{9}F\left(2r^{3}G''' + 21r^{2}G'' + 14rG' - 70G\right). \tag*{(64)}

In the dimensionless variables, this is equivalent to

(x2+3)G′′+(6x+12x)G′+(10−32Γ)G+1f(2x3G′′′+21x2G′′+14xG′−70G)=0,(65)\left(x^{2} + 3\right)G'' + \left(6x + \frac{12}{x}\right)G' + \left(10 - \frac{3}{2}\Gamma\right)G + \frac{1}{f}\left(2x^{3}G''' + 21x^{2}G'' + 14xG' - 70G\right) = 0, \tag*{(65)}

where f=F/Df = F/D is the new small parameter. Again, we consider the asymptote x→∞x \to\infty and get the homogenous differential equation with the characteristic polynom:

f3β(β−1)(β−2)+(1+72f)β(β−1)+(6+73f)β+(10−353f−32Γ)=0.(66)\frac{f}{3}\beta(\beta- 1)(\beta- 2) + \left(1 + \frac{7}{2}f\right)\beta(\beta- 1) + \left(6 + \frac{7}{3}f\right)\beta+ \left(10 - \frac{35}{3}f - \frac{3}{2}\Gamma\right) = 0. \tag*{(66)}

This equation has three solutions, two of them are close to α±\alpha_{\pm}, and the third solution is real (negative) and very big:

G(Γ)≃B+ξβ++B−ξβ−+Bfξβf,ξ→∞,(67)G^{(\Gamma)} \simeq B_{+}\xi^{\beta_{+}} + B_{-}\xi^{\beta_{-}} + B_{f}\xi^{\beta_{f}}, \qquad\xi\to\infty, \tag*{(67)}
βf∝−1/f,(68)\beta_{f} \propto-1/f, \tag*{(68)}
β±−α±∝f.(69)\beta_{\pm} - \alpha_{\pm} \propto f. \tag*{(69)}

The third summand is an artefact of the model; it corresponds to the non-physical solution and must be excluded by setting Bf=0B_{f} = 0.

The internal limit x→0x \to0 gives also three solutions, only one of them is convergent. We assume that there exist modes that converge at both limits x→0x \to0 and x→∞x \to\infty. Unlike the Gaussian (Kazantsev-Kraichnan) case, this is not guaranteed. This supposition is to be proved by numerical simulations. This is done in Section V. Also, the completeness of this set of functions is not evident; however, we suppose that the asymptotic time dependence of arbitrary solution is exponential, as it was in the case of the second order equation, so this arbitrary solution can be presented as a sum of eigenfunctions; we are again interested in the eigenfunction with the fastest increment.

But as soon as we suppose the existence of the spectrum, we can derive the upper boundary of the eigenvalue in the decomposition of an arbitrary initial distribution G0(x)G_0(x) based on the asymptotic behavior of the eigenfunctions. The eigenfunctions presented in the decomposition can either decrease faster than G0(x)G_0(x) or oscillate as x→∞x \to\infty. From the characteristic polynom (C20) we find that the condition of oscillations Im⁡β≠0\operatorname{Im}\beta\ne0 holds for

Γ<Γmax⁡=8+126f2−(4+27f2)3/218f2.(70)\Gamma< \Gamma_{\max} = \frac{8 + 126f^2 - (4 + 27f^2)^{3/2}}{18f^2}. \tag*{(70)}

This coincides with (21). In the limit f≪1f \ll1, we arrive to the Equation (33).

Finite Prandtl Numbers

To evaluate the effect of the nonlinearity of velocity field, we consider the function σ(r)\sigma(r) truncated in accordance with (34). For this model, the Kazantsev equation is step-wise: it coincides with (C18) for r<rνr < r_\nu, while for r>rνr > r_\nu it becomes

γG=23D(G′′+4rG′)(rν2+2rd2),r>rν.(71)\gamma G = \frac{2}{3}D\left(G'' + \frac{4}{r}G'\right)(r_\nu^2 + 2r_d^2), \quad r > r_\nu. \tag*{(71)}

So, one has to match the solution of (C18) with the descending solution of this equation. The coincidence of GG and G′G' determines the spectrum of γ\gamma. But the biggest γmax⁡(μ)\gamma_{\max}^{(\mu)} is still restricted by the condition Im⁡β≠0\operatorname{Im}\beta\ne0.

To estimate the correction to γ\gamma produced by large but finite rνr_\nu, we note that the solution of (C18) oscillates as a function of rr, and the phase of the oscillations is determined by the imaginary part of β+\beta_+:

G(r)∝r+β+∝eiIm⁡β+ln⁡μ.(72)G(r) \propto r_+^{\beta_+} \propto e^{i\operatorname{Im}\beta_+ \ln\mu}. \tag*{(72)}

Matching the amplitudes of both branches of the solution at r=rνr = r_\nu is provided by a multiplier; to match the derivatives, one has to choose the phase. However, half a period of oscillations is enough to ensure any phase that is needed. So, the correction to γmax⁡\gamma_{\max} produced by finite rνr_\nu at any rate leaves it within the range of γ\gamma in which the phase of G(rν)G(r_\nu) changes by π\pi:

Im⁡β+(Γmax⁡(μ))ln⁡μ=π.(73)\operatorname{Im}\beta_+\left(\Gamma_{\max}^{(\mu)}\right)\ln\mu= \pi. \tag*{(73)}

The bigger μ\mu, the closer is Γmax⁡(μ)\Gamma_{\max}^{(\mu)} to the ’Batchelor’ value Γmax⁡\Gamma_{\max}.

References

  1. [1]Aiyer, A. K., Subramanian, K., & Bhat, P., Journ. Fluid Mech., 824, 785-817 (2017)
  2. [2]A. Alexakis and L. Biferale, Phys. Reports 767, 1 (2018)
  3. [3]E. Balkovsky and A. Fouxon, Phys. Rev. E 60, 4164 (1999)
  4. [4]G. Batchelor, J. Fluid. Mech., 5, 113 (1959)
  5. [5]V.I. Belinicher and V.S. L’vov, Sov. Phys. JETP 66, 303 (1987); Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 93, 533 (1987)
  6. [6]Bhat, P., & Subramanian, K. Astrophys. J. Lett., 791(2), L34 (2014)
  7. [7]A. Brandenburg, K. Subramanian Phys.Rep. 417, 1 (2005)
  8. [8]A. Brandenburg, D. Solokoff, K. Subramanian, Space Sci Rev 169 123 (2012)
  9. [9]M. Chertkov, G. Falkovich, I. Kolokolov and M. Vergassola, Phys. Rev. Lett., 83, 4065 (1999)
  10. [10]G. Falkovich, K. Gawedzki, M. Vergassola, Rev. Mod. Phys. 73, 913 (2001)
  11. [11]Frisch U. Turbulence: the legacy of A.N. Kolmogorov. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press (1995)
  12. [12]H. Furstenberg, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc, 108, 377 (1963)
  13. [13]Furutsu, K. J. Res. NBS, 67D, 303 (1963)
  14. [14]S. Girimaji and S. Pope, J. Fluid Mech., 220, 427 (1990)
  15. [20]Ya.N. Istomin, & A. Kiselev, MNRAS 436, (3), 2774 (2013)
  16. [21]A.P. Kazantsev, Sov. Phys JETP, 26, 1031, 9 (1968)
  17. [22]N. Kleeorin, I. Rogachevskii, D. Sokoloff, Phys. Rev. E 65 036303 (2002)
  18. [23]V.I. Klyatskin, Dynamics of Stochastic Systems, Elsevier (2005)
  19. [24]A.N. Kolmogorov, Dokl.Akad.Nauk SSSR 32, 19 (1941); reprinted in Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 434 15 (1991)
  20. [25]I.V. Kolokolov, J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 50, 155501 (2017)
  21. [26]A.V. Kopyev, K.P. Zybin, Journal of Turbulence 19 (9), 717 (2018)
  22. [27]R.H. Kraichnan, Phys. Fluids., 11, 945 (1968)
  23. [28]R. Kraichnan and S. Nagarajan, Phys. Fluids, 10, 859 (1967)
  24. [29]R. Kulsrud and S. Anderson, Astrophys. J., 396, 606, 9 (1992)
  25. [30]L. D. Landau, E. M. Lifshitz Hydrodynamics. Vol. 6 (2nd ed.). Butterworth-Heinemann (1987)
  26. [31]A.V. Letchikov, Russian Math. Surveys, 51, 49 (1996)
  27. [32]B. Luthi, A. Tsinober, and W.Kinzelbach J. Fluid Mech., 528, 87 (2005)
  28. [33]Malyshkin, L., Boldyrev, S. (2007) Astrophys. J. Lett., 671 (2), L185.
  29. [34]J. Mason, L. Malyshkin, S. Boldyrev, & F. Cattaneo Astrophys. J. 730, 86 (2011)
  30. [35]H.K. Moffat and P.J. Saffman, Phys.Fluids 7 (1), 155 (1964)
  31. [36]H.K. Moffatt, Magnetic field generation in electrically conducting fluids (Cambridge Univ. Press, 1978)
  32. [37]A.S. Monin, A.M. Yaglom Statistical fluid mechanics II. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ Press (1987)
  33. [38]Novikov, E. A. Soviet Phys. JETP, 20, 1290 (1965)
  34. [39]V.G. Novikov, A.A. Ruzmaikin, & D.D. Sokoloff, Soviet Phys. JETP, 58, 527 (1983)
  35. [40]V.I. Oseledets, Trans. Moscow Math. Soc. 19, 197 (1968); Moscow.Mat.Obsch. 19, 179 (1968)
  36. [41]E.N. Parker, Cosmic magnetic fields, their origin and activity (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1979)
  37. [42]A.Pumir Phys. Rev. Fluids 2, 074602 (2017)
  38. [43]F. Rincon J. Plasma Phys., 85 205850401 (2019)
  39. [45]Schekochihin, A. A., & Kulsrud, R. M. Physics of Plasmas, 8(11), 4937 (2001)
  40. [46]Schekochihin, A. A., Boldyrev, S. A., & Kulsrud, R. M. Astrophys.J., 567 (2), 828 (2002)
  41. [47]A.A. Schekochihin, S.C. Cowley, G.W. Hammet, J.L. Maron, & J.C. McWilliams New J. of Phys. 4, 84.1 (2002)
  42. [48]A.A. Schekochihin, S.C. Cowley, S.F. Taylor, J.L. Maron, & J.C. McWilliams Astrophys. J., 612 (1), 276 (2004)
  43. [49]Schober, J., Rogachevskii, I., Brandenburg, A., Boyarsky, A., Frohlich, J., Ruchayskiy, O., & Kleeorin, N. Astrophys. J., 858(2), 124 (2018)
  44. [51]A. Seta, P.J. Bushby, A. Shukurov, & T.S. Wood Phys. Rev. Fluids, 5 (4), 043702 (2020)
  45. [52]S.I. Vainshtein, & L.L. Kichatinov, J. Fluid Mech. 168, 73 (1986)
  46. [53]Ya.B. Zeldovich, A.A. Ruzmaikin, D.D. Sokoloff ’Magnetic Fields in Astrophysics’ NY: Gordon & Breach. (1984)
  47. [54]Ya.B. Zel’dovich, A.A. Ruzmaikin, S.A. Molchanov and D.D. Sokoloff, J. Fluid Mech., 144, 1 (1984)
  48. [55]K.P. Zybin, A.S. Il’yн, A.V. Kopyev, and V.A. Sirota Europhys. Lett. 132, 24001 (2020)

Paper details

vlnc:W_5de8pjjz
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents