betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The multiple origins of spurs in stellar streams: a challenge for dark matter diagnostics

Abstract

Spurs along stellar streams are often interpreted as signatures of interactions with dark matter subhalos, and thus have been proposed as diagnostics on the clustering and nature of dark matter. Although galactic baryonic components could play similar roles as gravitational perturbers of streams, the possible signatures they leave and the degeneracy with subhalos have been overlooked. In this paper, we analyse simulations of streams experiencing disruptions by dark matter subhalos, a galactic bar, and a galaxy merger. Although spurs are more frequently found to be induced by the galaxy merger, the spurs originating from all these processes are morphologically similar. Therefore, such morphological features should not be used alone to characterise the mechanism of their origin, nor to constrain the nature of dark matter.

Introduction

Simulations of stellar streams in the Λ\LambdaCDM framework have shown that subhalo flybys leave measurable imprints, such as gaps, kinks, and spurs (e.g., Ibata et al. 2002; Johnston et al. 2002; Yoon et al. 2011; Carlberg 2012, 2013; Erkal & Belokurov 2015a,b; Erkal et al. 2016; Bonaca et al. 2019). Inhomogeneities and gaps along streams can also arise from internal dynamics, through epicyclic motions of escaping stars [26, 30, 21], from baryonic perturbers such as galactic bars, globular clusters, and galactic mergers [17, 33, 19, 20], and artificially from inhomogeneous observations [38]. Spurs, as features extending off the main stream track, constitute a complementary signature to gaps. Specific spurs in GD-1 and Ophiuchus have been scrutinized in great detail with the goal of associating them to a perturber. In GD-1, the spur has been revealed by Gaia astrometry [36] and interpreted as evidence of an impact with a compact dark matter subhalo [2]. Orbital modelling further suggested that the perturber could be a globular cluster or a dark matter subhalo associated with the Sagittarius galaxy [1]. An interaction of GD-1 with Sagittarius has also been considered [8] (Diliberto et al. 2022), but a Sagittarius or a globular cluster trigger for this spur is now considered unlikely [3]. A spur has also been identified in the Ophiuchus stream [4], and recently modelled as tidal debris scattered by the decelerating galactic bar [40], i.e. without invoking subhalos.

Current and future large observational programs from the Rubin Observatory [23], combined with spectroscopic surveys such as 4MOST [9], DESI [11], and WEAVE [24], will soon detect new streams and map known ones with unprecedented detail. Statistical pipelines are already built to infer the impact of individual dark matter subhalos (Lu et al. 2026b,a). However, the other perturbations to the streams’ morphologies and possible degeneracies are often overlooked.

In this letter, we use NN-body simulations of streams evolved under three perturbations: a galactic merger, a galactic bar, and a population of dark matter subhalos, to test whether these conditions trigger spur formation, and to identify possible degeneracies.

Numerical methods

We model the same 36 stellar streams as in Guillaume et al. [20], using the same globular cluster model, i.e. a Plummer [35] profile with a particle mass of 6.5 M⊙_\odot. Each cluster is integrated independently for 5 Gyr. We use pyfalcon, a Python interface to the falcON tree code [10] with a softening length of 1 pc to compute the self-gravity of the cluster particles, and Agama [39] to compute the external acceleration from the fitted galactic potentials, as described below. We integrate the motion of particles with a leapfrog scheme with a fixed time step of 50 kyr. We checked the accuracy of the integration by monitoring energy conservation for streams integrated in a static potential. Spurs are identified by visual inspection of the streams.

To generate the external potentials, we start from the collisionless NN-body simulations of Guillaume et al. [20], modelling a Milky Way-mass galaxy undergoing a galactic merger with a mass ratio of 1:10. The potential of each galaxy is then fitted following Petersen & Peñarrubia [34] and Lilleengen et al. [27], with a time-dependent multipole expansion up to the order 10 (Rivero et al., in prep.) using Agama. The fit uses all particles within 400 kpc of the centre of mass of each galaxy. The total potential is the sum of the two galaxies, fitted separately. We repeat this procedure for the Milky Way-mass galaxy in isolation, in which a bar develops naturally and becomes visible after 2 Gyr. The bar reaches a radius of ∼8\sim8 kpc, with a pattern speed decreasing from 27 to 17 km s−1^{-1} kpc−1^{-1} between ∼3\sim3 and 5 Gyr. Additionally, by fitting the isolated galaxy before the bar forms, we obtain a model for an axisymmetric disc, used as a reference below. Finally, we create a fourth model by converting 10% of the dark matter mass of the isolated galaxy into a population of subhalos. The subhalo mass follows dN/dM∝M−1.9\mathrm{d}N/\mathrm{d}M \propto M^{-1.9} between 10510^{5} and 10910^{9} M⊙_\odot (Springel et al. [37]). Each subhalo is represented by a single particle exerting a Plummer [35] force on the streams in accordance with the pyfalcon force kernel. The Plummer scale radius is set as in Erkal et al. [16] from the Via Lactea II simulation (Diemand et al. [12]) as 1.62 kpc (Msub/108 M⊙)0.5(M_{\rm sub}/10^{8}\ {\rm M}_\odot)^{0.5}, giving ≃51\simeq51 pc for 10510^{5} M⊙_\odot and ≃5.1\simeq5.1 kpc for 10910^{9} M⊙_\odot subhalos. The initial positions and velocities of the subhalos are drawn randomly from the initial dark matter particles within 400 kpc in the NN-body simulation. Each subhalo is first integrated alone in the fitted potential, and its trajectory is stored. We then integrate each stellar stream in the same fitted potential including the subhalos along their precomputed trajectories. The gravitational effect of the streams on subhalos is thus neglected. Using Plummer rather than NFW subhalos (Navarro et al. [32]) may underestimate the number of spurs, as NFW subhalos produce twice as many gaps (Menker & Benson [31]), although fewer than 1% of encounters probe the density profile. Conversely, neglecting structural evolution, tidal mass loss and dynamical friction (Errani & Peñarrubia [18]) possibly overestimates the subhalo impact.

Results

Spurs created by a galactic merger

The first and second rows of Figure 1 show the same stream in the axisymmetric, unperturbed disc and in the merger configuration respectively. For completeness, Fig. A.2 shows its radial and proper motions. A spur is visible at the leading end (Φ1>0\Phi_1 > 0), while being absent in the axisymmetric case. Two gaps are also present, at Φ1∼−20∘\Phi_1 \sim-20^\circ and 25°. This combination of a spur and gaps resembles the morphology of the GD-1 stream ([36, 2]). Therefore, our study adds mergers to the list of possible origins of such observed features. However, a deeper exploration of the parameter space is needed before

Figure 1. The same stream shown in four configurations (top to bottom): axisymmetric disc, galactic merger, galactic bar, and with dark matter subhalos, in great-circle coordinates, with Φ2\Phi_2 (top) and galactocentric distance rr (bottom) shown as a function of Φ1\Phi_1.

concluding on the uniqueness of this scenario to explain the observed structure of GD-1.

To understand how this spur forms, we show this stream at four epochs in Figure 2. The first panel displays the moment of first pericentre passage of the satellite galaxy, which also corresponds to the closest encounter of the stream and the satellite. The stars at the leading end experience a shallower potential from the satellite than the rest of the stream. Shortly after the second pericentre passage (2.90 Gyr), these stars are offset from the main stream, forming a spur at Φ1∼50∘\Phi_1 \sim50^\circ, best visible in the Φ1\Phi_1–projection. With time, the spur elongates (third and fourth epochs). A second spur appears near Φ1∼−30∘\Phi_1 \sim-30^\circ at 3.35 Gyr and near Φ1∼−120∘\Phi_1 \sim-120^\circ at 4.62 Gyr, made of stars having experienced a deep satellite potential. Both spurs consist of stars whose interaction with the satellite strongly differs from that of the rest of the stream. This differential gravitational force from the satellite along the stream induces the kinetic and orbital deviations observed as spurs.

Figure 2. Evolution of the stream from Fig. 1 in the galactic merger scenario, at four epochs. Particles are coloured by the minimum values of the satellite potential they experienced during the course of the merger.

Streams on smaller orbits undergo multiple interactions with the satellite and the main galactic disc, yielding strong perturbations and more complex morphologies than the illustration of Figure 1. Half of the streams in the merger simulation develop one or several visible spurs, as shown in Figure 3. Streams on wide orbits are less likely to be significantly perturbed by the infalling satellite and galactic disc and thus yield no spurs.

Figure 3. Pericentre and apocentre of the 36 stellar streams in the three scenarios: galactic merger, barred galaxy, and with dark matter subhalos. Black crosses mark the streams that do not form any visible spur. Coloured circles mark the ones that form at least one spur: the colour gives the inclination of the orbital plane, and the size gives the spur formation rate per stream per Gyr. Dashed lines indicate constant eccentricities.

Spurs created by the galactic bar

Through differential gravitational torques, a galactic bar can also perturb stellar streams and produce gaps and asymmetric tidal tails (e.g., [17, 33]). Here, we show that the bar-induced spur proposed for Ophiuchus (Yang et al. [40]) is not unique to that stream but a generic outcome of bar–stream interactions. The third row of Figure 1 shows the same stream as before but now evolved in the barred galaxy potential, where it develops a spur in its trailing arm at Φ1∼−50∘\Phi_1 \sim-50^\circ.

Of the 36 streams in the bar setup, 25% form a spur, and all after the bar has formed. As shown in Figure 3, these have pericentres smaller than 11 kpc, and are preferentially on prograde orbits, with a lower formation rate than in the merger case. However, among all the 24 streams with a pericentre smaller than 11 kpc, only 9 develop a spur. Therefore, while the presence of a bar is a necessary condition, a passage near it is not sufficient to trigger spur formation. Other factors such as the orbital phase of the stream relative to the bar and the inclination of the orbital plane must be taken into account. These aspects will be explored in a forthcoming dedicated study of the parameter space.

Spurs created by dark matter subhalos

The last row of Figure 1 shows that our stream example yields two spurs (Φ1≈−25∘\Phi_1 \approx-25^\circ and 25∘25^\circ) in the configuration with dark matter subhalos. Among the 36 stellar streams, 28% develop at least one visible spur in this simulation, all of them with apocentres shorter than 40 kpc (Figure 3). The spatial distribution of subhalos follows the dark matter profile of the galaxy. They are thus more numerous toward the centre. Therefore, a stream with a small apocentre and thus a short orbital period experiences numerous and diverse encounters with subhalos and is more likely to yield spurs than more distant streams. Yet, the streams in this case have the lowest spur formation rate per stream.

Here, the nature of the perturbation differs from the merger case. The satellite galaxy is a single, massive and spatially extended perturber that acts on a large portion of a given stream at once. The tidal effect thus covers larger scales. By contrast, encounters with the more numerous but smaller and less massive dark matter subhalos disturb only short segments of the stream, on local, smaller scales. A stream can therefore accumulate the distinct signatures of several impacts at different positions and times, caused by subhalos with a wide range of masses and impact parameters. Consequently, while the encounter with a single subhalo is sufficient to trigger the formation of a spur [2], the repetition and diversity of encounters in a galactic halo makes it impossible to associate a given spur with a particular event or subhalo, or to determine if more than one subhalo has been involved in this formation.

Discussion and conclusion

Using NN-body simulations of a population of stellar streams, we show that spurs are not a signature unique to interactions with dark matter subhalos. A galactic merger, a galactic bar, and a population of dark matter subhalos all produce spurs, in respectively 50, 25, and 28% of the streams modelled. Our simulations demonstrate that each process can produce morphologically similar spurs. The high fraction of streams showing a spur, and the high formation rate caused by a galaxy merger suggest that observed spurs on the streams around the Milky Way may have been caused by recent or ongoing interactions with Sagittarius and/or the Large Magellanic Cloud.

Although spiral arms and giant molecular clouds are not included in our simulations, they could also produce spurs through the same mechanism of tidal perturbation. This degeneracy implies that the presence of a spur in an observed stream should not be taken as evidence for dark matter subhalos, unless all other types of perturbers have been ruled out. Disentangling the signatures of different perturbers is challenging for streams with small pericentres, since these are simultaneously exposed to strong effects from the Milky Way itself (bar, spiral arms, giant molecular clouds), and have a higher probability of having interacted with infalling satellites and recent mergers.

A statistical approach applied to the broader stream population may nonetheless offer a viable path forward: rather than attributing individual features to individual perturbers, an aggregate measure of disruption across many streams, compared to predictions from simulations, could still constrain the abundance and properties of dark matter subhalos. Such a measure should combine morphology with kinematics as different dark matter models may imprint both properties differently [7]. Suites of simulations spanning a wider range of subhalo populations, bar strengths, and merger histories, combined with a systematic characterisation of the resulting stream properties, would be needed to build a holistic theoretical framework.

Acknowledgements. Co-funded by the European Union (Widening Participation, ExGal-Twin, GA 101158446). GFT acknowledges support from the Agencia Estatal de Investigación del Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (AEI-MCIN) under grant number RYC2024-051016-I funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and by the European Social Fund Plus. GFT and AR acknowledge support from the Agencia Estatal de Investigación del Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (AEI-MCIN) under grant number PID2023-150319NB-C21.

Kinematics

Figures A.1–A.4 show radial and proper motions for the same stream presented in Figure 1 for the four configurations: axisymmetric disc, galaxy merger, barred disc, and with dark matter subhalos, respectively. The spur particles overlap with the main stream in proper motion perpendicular to the stream, but are offset in radial velocity and in proper motion along the stream.

Full set of observables for the same example stream as in Fig. 1, in the axisymmetric disc potential

Figure A.1. Full set of observables for the same example stream as in Figure 1, in the axisymmetric disc potential. From top to bottom: Φ2\Phi_2, galactocentric distance rr, radial velocity vrv_r, and proper motions μΦ1\mu_{\Phi_1} and μΦ2\mu_{\Phi_2}, all as a function of Φ1\Phi_1. The progenitor is marked by a red circle in each panel.

Full set of observables for the same example stream as in Fig. 1, in the galactic merger

Figure A.2. Same as Fig. A.1, for the stream evolved with the galactic merger.

Kinematic plots for the stream evolved with the galactic bar

Figure A.3. Same as Fig. A.1, for the stream evolved with the galactic bar.

Kinematic plots for the stream evolved with the population of dark matter subhalos

Figure A.4. Same as Fig. A.1, for the stream evolved with the population of dark matter subhalos.

References

  1. [1]Bonaca, A., Conroy, C., Hogg, D. W., et al. 2020, ApJ, 892, L37
  2. [2]Bonaca, A., Hogg, D. W., Price-Whelan, A. M., & Conroy, C. 2019, ApJ, 880, 38
  3. [3]Bonaca, A. & Price-Whelan, A. M. 2025, New A Rev., 100, 101713
  4. [4]Caldwell, N., Bonaca, A., Price-Whelan, A. M., Sesar, B., & Walker, M. G. 2020, AJ, 159, 287
  5. [7]Carlberg, R. G., Jenkins, A., Frenk, C. S., & Cooper, A. P. 2024, ApJ, 975, 135
  6. [8]de Boer, T. J. L., Erkal, D., & Gieles, M. 2020, MNRAS, 494, 5315
  7. [9]de Jong, R. S., Agertz, O., Berbel, A. A., et al. 2019, The Messenger, 175, 3
  8. [10]Dehnen, W. 2002, Journal of Computational Physics, 179, 27
  9. [11]DESI Collaboration, Aghamousa, A., Aguilar, J., et al. 2016, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:1611.00036
  10. [12]Diemand, J., Kuhlen, M., Madau, P., et al. 2008, Nature, 454, 735
  11. [16]Erkal, D., Belokurov, V., Bovy, J., & Sanders, J. L. 2016, MNRAS, 463, 102
  12. [17]Erkal, D., Koposov, S. E., & Belokurov, V. 2017, MNRAS, 470, 60
  13. [18]Errani, R. & Peñarrubia, J. 2020, MNRAS, 491, 4591
  14. [19]Ferrone, S., Montuori, M., Di Matteo, P., et al. 2025, A&A, 699, A289
  15. [20]Guillaume, C., Renaud, F., Martin, N. F., et al. 2026, A&A, 705, A6
  16. [21]Ibata, R., Thomas, G., Famaey, B., et al. 2020, ApJ, 891, 161
  17. [23]Ivezić, Ž., Kahn, S. M., Tyson, J. A., et al. 2019, ApJ, 873, 111
  18. [24]Jin, S., Trager, S. C., Dalton, G. B., et al. 2024, MNRAS, 530, 2688
  19. [26]Küpper, A. H. W., Kroupa, P., Baumgardt, H., & Heggie, D. C. 2010, MNRAS, 401, 105
  20. [27]Lilleengen, S., Petersen, M. S., Erkal, D., et al. 2023, MNRAS, 518, 774
  21. [30]Mastrobuono-Battisti, A., Di Matteo, P., Montuori, M., & Haywood, M. 2012, A&A, 546, L7
  22. [31]Menker, P. & Benson, A. 2026, MNRAS, 548, stag538
  23. [32]Navarro, J. F., Frenk, C. S., & White, S. D. M. 1997, ApJ, 490, 493
  24. [33]Pearson, S., Price-Whelan, A. M., & Johnston, K. V. 2017, Nature Astronomy, 1, 633
  25. [34]Petersen, M. S. & Peñarrubia, J. 2021, Nature Astronomy, 5, 251
  26. [35]Plummer, H. C. 1911, MNRAS, 71, 460
  27. [36]Price-Whelan, A. M. & Bonaca, A. 2018, ApJ, 863, L20
  28. [37]Springel, V., Wang, J., Vogelsberger, M., et al. 2008, MNRAS, 391, 1685
  29. [38]Thomas, G. F., Ibata, R., Famaey, B., Martin, N. F., & Lewis, G. F. 2016, MNRAS, 460, 2711
  30. [39]Vasiliev, E. 2019, MNRAS, 482, 1525
  31. [40]Yang, Y., Lewis, G. F., Erkal, D., et al. 2025, ApJ, 984, 189

Paper details

vlnc:W_5fx5wtry
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents