betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Orbital-Induced Peierls Transitions: How Orbitals Orchestrate Lattice Instability

Abstract

The Peierls transition is typically regarded as a phenomenon inherent to one-dimensional (1D) materials. However, orbital degrees of freedom can induce this instability even in higher dimensions. Two mechanisms are primarily responsible. First, the anisotropic shape of pp and dd orbitals can lead to effective "1D-zation" of the electronic spectrum. Second, orbital degrees of freedom can lift band degeneracy by shifting bands relative to each other via the local or band Jahn-Teller effect, thereby affecting the nesting of the Fermi surface. The orbital-induced Peierls effect is most commonly observed when ligand octahedra surrounding transition metals share edges, and less frequently in face-sharing geometries. In this review, we discuss the underlying physical mechanisms, the materials in which this phenomenon occurs, the characteristics of the high-temperature undistorted phase, and the role of local effects such as the formation of molecular orbitals.

Introduction

The Peierls transition is undoubtedly one of the most renowned phenomena in condensed matter physics. It was first predicted theoretically [1] and subsequently confirmed experimentally [2, 3, 4].

Peierls considered a linear chain with distance aa between atoms and a one-dimensional (1D) electron gas, and showed that it is always energetically favorable to break the uniform spacing. The resulting lattice distortion leads to the appearance of gaps at wavevectors kn=±nπ/mak_n = \pm n\pi/ma, where nn and mm are integers and n=1,2,...,m−1n = 1, 2, ..., m - 1 [5], see Figure 1. Significant energy is gained if the band is exactly filled up to one of these gaps at knk_n. For example, in a chain of ss ions at half-filling (one electron per site), such a gap appears precisely at kF=±π/2ak_F = \pm\pi/2a, as shown in the top panel of Figure 2(a). Consequently, the chain becomes unstable toward dimerization, which is responsible for the formation of these gaps in the ε(k)\varepsilon(k) dispersion. Indeed, one can show that for small distortions u~\tilde{u}, the gain in electronic energy ∼u~2ln⁡u~\sim\tilde{u}^2 \ln\tilde{u} always dominates over the loss in elastic energy ∼Bu~2/2\sim B\tilde{u}^2/2 due to additional lattice distortions [6].

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Peierls was the first to show that the electron dispersion of a linear chain of atoms spaced at distance aa is modified by lattice distortions. The vertical breaks in the sketch are proportional to corresponding displacements. If the electron filling is such that the Fermi energy lies exactly within the gap, the distortion lowers the electronic energy. Otherwise, the distortion is ineffective: the average of the maximal εmax\varepsilon^{max} and minimal εmin\varepsilon^{min} energies remains equal to the band energy of the undistorted chain, while the elastic energy cost is always positive. Hence, no net gain is achieved.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Illustration of the Peierls transition for different numbers of electrons (a-c). For the case of a single electron, different interpretations of the transition are presented: the instability leading to gap opening in the electronic spectrum is illustrated in the top panel of (a). The formation of bonding and antibonding states assuming orthogonal wavefunction due to dimerization and corresponding energy gain is shown in the middle panel of (a). The bottom panel of (a) illustrates nesting of the Fermi surface, which leads to divergence of the generalized susceptibility in Lindhard theory or in the random phase approximation (RPA), see Eq. (1).

In chemical terms, this is essentially the formation of hydrogen molecules, as depicted in the middle part of Figure 2(a). At half-filling, only bonding levels are occupied, resulting in an energy gain by the formation of molecular orbitals, with Eb=−2tE_b = -2t per dimer (tt is the hopping amplitude between these two sites). In contrast, for two electrons per site, no such gain occurs, since both bonding and antibonding levels are occupied. In that case, the system experiences an energy loss due to elastic deformation, which counteracts dimerization.

The Peierls transition affects the distribution of electrons and is therefore closely connected with the formation of charge density waves (CDWs) [6, 7]. In the simplest case of half-filling, small on-site electron correlations (Hubbard UU), and a chain geometry, the electronic density is concentrated within the dimer; i.e., a bond-centered CDW is formed in this situation.

Microscopically, one of the driving forces of a CDW or

Peierls transition is the momentum-dependent electron-phonon coupling. In this picture, phonons modulate the hopping integrals tt, and this turns out to be extremely efficient when, e.g., molecular bonding (in clusters) occurs. Interestingly, one can exclude phonons from the treatment and then end up with an effective electron-electron attraction, which results in CDW formation or the Peierls transition [6].

While the Peierls transition is often referred to as dimerization, Peierls himself clearly pointed out that the instability can lead to very different types of lattice distortions depending on the electron count [5]. For example, it can result in tetramerization at 1/4-filling (with gap appearing at ±π/4a\pm\pi/4a) or trimerization at 1/3 band filling (with gap at ±π/3a\pm\pi/3a), as illustrated in Figure 2(b,Figure 2c). On the other hand, increasing the dimensionality of the system - by going to two-dimensional (2D) or three-dimensional (3D) structures - inevitably introduces band dispersion in the additional dimensions. This tends to close the aforementioned gaps and thereby minimize or even completely eliminate the energy gain associated with the lattice period modulation that is so effective in 1D.

In more modern terms, the Peierls transition is associated with nesting of the Fermi surface. For a chain aligned along the zz-direction, the Fermi surface consists of two planes perpendicular to kzk_z, as shown in the lowest part of Figure 2(a). They can be matched by shifting one of them by a vector q⃗=2k⃗F\vec{q} = 2\vec{k}_{F}. The generalized susceptibility of the non-interacting electron system in the static limit is given by the Lindhard formula:

χ0(q⃗)=∑k⃗∑mm′nm(k⃗+q⃗)−nm′(k⃗)εm(k⃗+q⃗)−εm′(k⃗)−iθ(1)\chi_0(\vec{q}) = \sum_{\vec{k}} \sum_{mm'} \frac{n_m(\vec{k}+\vec{q})-n_{m'}(\vec{k})}{\varepsilon_m(\vec{k}+\vec{q})-\varepsilon_{m'}(\vec{k})-i\theta} \tag*{(1)}

where mm and m′m' are band indexes n(k⃗)n(\vec{k}) is the Fermi–Dirac distribution function and θ\theta is a positive infinitesimal that ensures the correct causal behavior, see e.g. [8, 9].

Shifting one of the planes that form the Fermi surface by a wavevector q⃗\vec{q} leads to a divergence in the generalized susceptibility — a hallmark of instability (Fermi surface

nesting [9], see also Figure 2(a) bottom panel). When going from one to two or three dimensions, the Fermi surface often deforms due to hybridization (hopping) along the extra directions and may even lose its nesting condition.

The key ingredient that helps to extend this essentially 1D physics to higher dimensionality is the orbital degrees of freedom. Both pp and dd orbitals have a very anisotropic spatial distribution, which facilitates electron hopping in one direction but nearly completely suppresses it in others.

Thus, the first effect related to orbital degrees of freedom is that their anisotropic shape can result in “1D-ization” of the electron band structure [10], and this promotes the Peierls transition.

In the present review, we restrict ourselves to considering only dd orbitals. In octahedral geometry, the ege_g orbitals are directed toward the ligands, while the t2gt_{2g} point away from them. In a situation, when neighboring MX6MX_6 (MM = transition metal, XX = ligands) octahedra share common corners, the strongest is the ege_g-ege_g hopping between two metals via ligand pp orbital directed along this bond, see Figure 3(a). In contrast, when neighboring octahedra share their edges or faces, direct hopping between t2gt_{2g} orbitals becomes extremely efficient, as shown in Figure 3(b) and (c). We will see in what follows that the orbital-induced Peierls transition occurs nearly exclusively in these two geometries and is facilitated by direct t2gt_{2g}-t2gt_{2g} hopping (although CDW instabilities are not limited by these cases and can occur in any geometry). The physical origin of this feature is that a ligand lies between two transition metals in the common-corner geometry, preventing them from being brought close enough to achieve maximal energy gain through the formation of molecular orbitals between dd orbitals.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Different type of sharing in octahedral geometry: (a) common corner with the x2−y2x^2-y^2 orbital, (b) common edge with the xyxy orbital, and (c) common face with the a1ga_{1g} orbital.

The second ingredient that orbitals bring to Peierls physics is the (band) Jahn–Teller effect.

In the conventional (local) Jahn–Teller effect in materials with localized electrons, vibronic coupling typically results in additional distortions of the ligand polyhedra and a corresponding splitting of energy levels [6]. It results in the localization of an electron in a particular orbital and often leads to corresponding orbital ordering and cooperative distortions [11].

In metals the band Jahn–Teller effect is related not only to the lifting of band degeneracy, but also to changes in the widths of the different bands. As will be illustrated with many examples below, this helps to improve the nesting condition. For instance, in normal AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4} spinels, transition metals occupying BB sites reside in octahedra that share their edges, and the overall crystal structure is rather 3D and uniform. This implies the degeneracy of the t2gt_{2g} bands, see Figure 4(a). However, in CuIr2_{2}S4_{4} and LiRh2_{2}O4_{4}, one of the t2gt_{2g} bands (xyxy band) becomes wider with the tetragonal elongation along the cc-axis and the concomitant compression in the abab-plane. As a result, the Fermi surfaces are created solely by the xyxy band rather than the three, see Figure 4(b), and the degree of the Fermi surface nesting can be enhanced under the band Jahn–Teller effect. In fact, the band Jahn–Teller effect and the Peierls instability are often intrinsically synergetic: both tend to lower the energy through lattice distortions, and in many systems, tetragonal and Peierls-type distortions set in concurrently at the same transition temperature. Consequently, in real materials, it becomes challenging to unambiguously separate the energy gains arising from the band Jahn–Teller effect from those due to the Peierls mechanism, a point to which we return in the discussion below.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Schematic drawings for t2gt_{2g} band dispersions of AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4} spinels (transition metals at B sites) in the cubic (a=b=ca=b=c) situation (a) and the elongated tetragonal (a=b<ca=b<c) situation (b). Setting the xx-, yy-, and zz-axes along the aa, bb, and cc directions of the cubic/tetragonal crystal, the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx bands run along the [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0], [0,1,±1][0,1,\pm1], and [±1,0,1][\pm1,0,1] directions, respectively. When the Fermi level is close to the upper bound of the t2gt_{2g} bands, holes can be accommodated only in the xyxy band due to the band Jahn–Teller distortion with a=b<ca=b<c along the cc- or zz-axis.

The idea of orbital-induced Peierls mechanism has been introduced in [12] motivated by this peculiar phase transitions in spinels and then applied to many other classes of materials. In Table I we summarize materials, which low-temperature structures can be explained by the orbital-induced Peierls transition.

MaterialOcc.LatticeTsT_sCluster
MgTi2_2O4_4d1d^1Spinel260K [13]dimer [12]
NbO2_2d1d^1Rutile1081K [14]dimer [15]
NaTiSi2_2O6_6d1d^1Pyroxene210K [16]dimer [17, 18, 19]
NaTiO2_2d1d^1Triangular250K [20, 21]dimer
MoO2_2d2d^2Rutile- [22]dimer [23]
Na2_2Ti3_3Cl8_8d2d^2Kagome200K [24, 25, 26]trimer [27]
LiVO2_2d2d^2Triangular500K [28, 29, 30, 31]trimer [32]
BaV10_{10}O15_{15}d2.2d^{2.2}Triangular123K [33, 34]trimer [35]
AlV2_2O4_4d2.5d^{2.5}Spinel700K [36, 37]tri&tetramer [38]
GaV2_2O4_4d2.5d^{2.5}Spinel415K [39]tri&tetramer
ReS2_2d3d^3Triangular- [40, 41]chain [32]
IrTe2_2d5d^5Triangular270K [42, 43]dimer [44]
RuPd5d^5MnP260K [45, 46]trimers [47]
LiRh2_2O4_4d5.5d^{5.5}Spinel170K [48, 49]dimer [48]
CuIr2_2S4_4d5.5d^{5.5}Spinel230K [50, 51]dimers [12]

Table I. TABLE I: Selected materials whose structural transitions at TsT_s or dimerized structures are explained by the orbital-induced Peierls transition. If clusters exist at all temperatures; this is indicated by “–”. Last column contains references to theoretical studies related to this mechanism. Materials with a honeycomb lattice are not included in this list. Dimerization in this case is also governed by orbital degrees of freedom, but via local physics related to the formation of molecular orbitals rather than band effects, see also Experimental methods section. We also note that due to the large crystal-field splitting t2gt_{2g} states are filled in the 4d4d and 5d5d transition metals such as Ir, Rh, and Ru.

There are many interesting edge-sharing transition-metal compounds with partially filled t2gt_{2g} orbitals. As described above, the direct hopping between t2gt_{2g} orbitals of the neighboring sites plays the major role in the edge-sharing systems. As typical examples, rutile-type, CdI2_{2}-type, ilmenite-type, nolanite-type, and spinel-type structures are illustrated in Figure 5(a), (Figure 5b), (Figure 5c), (Figure 5d), and (Figure 5e), respectively. In the rutile-type structure, the edge sharing chains run along the cc-axis, and the xyxy orbitals have the substantial direct hopping along it. In the CdI2_{2}-type structure, the edge sharing octahedra form the triangular lattice in the abab-plane. The same motif of the MX6MX_{6} octahedra packing is observed in α-NaFeO2_{2} structure. The xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx orbitals respectively have the direct hopping along the [1,−1,0][1,-1,0], [0,1,−1][0,1,-1], and [1,0,−1][1,0,-1] directions. The edge sharing octahedra form the honeycomb network and kagome network in the ilmenite-type structure and the nolanite-type structure, respectively, in which part of the transition-metal MM ions in the triangular lattice are periodically replaced by alkaline and alkaline-earth cations as illustrated in Figure 5(c) and (d). In the spinel-type structure, the edge sharing octahedra form the pyrochlore network and the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx orbitals respectively have the direct hopping along the [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0], [0,1,±1][0,1,\pm1], and [1,0,±1][1,0,\pm1] directions.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. Examples of various structures with orbital-induced Peierls transition: (a) rutile-type structure containing chains of edge-sharing MX6MX_6 octahedra, (b) CdI2_2-type (α\alpha-NaFeO2_2 has very similar motif) structure having triangular lattice of transition-metal sites, (c) ilmenite-type structure (transition-metal sites form honeycomb network), (d) nolanite-type structure (transition-metal sites form kagome network), and (e) spinel-type structure (transition-metal sites form pyrochlore network consisting of metal tetrahedra). The MX6MX_6 octahedra are shaded. The transition-metal MM and ligand XX are indicated by red and yellow balls. In (c) and (d), alkaline or alkaline-earth cations partly substituted for transition-metal ions of (b) are indicated by blue balls. In (e), A-site cations are indicated by blue balls. The xx-, yy-, zz-axes are along the MM-XX bonds. The MM-MM bonds along [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0], [0,1,±1][0,1,\pm1], and [±1,0,1][\pm1,0,1] are indicated by red, blue, and green lines, respectively. Structures were generated using VESTA [59].

Peierls OR NOT REALLY Peierls: LOCAL EFFECTS {#sec:}

The Peierls transition is often considered as a band phenomenon, with distortions formed spontaneously at a certain temperature TsT_s and associated with the energy gain due to gap formation in the band spectrum. However, modern experimental methods such as pair distribution function (PDF) analysis of X-ray or neutron diffraction data show that dimers or other clusters typically survive even in the high-temperature phase, see Calculation and experimental methods section and, e.g., [52, 53, 54, 55, 56], whereas a simplistic theory of the Peierls transition would not predict this. Such clusters are sometimes referred to as orbital molecules [57].

The energy gain due to the formation of bonding states in a cluster is typically much larger than the gap in the band spectrum in a “pure” Peierls theory. Therefore, while the long-range order of clusters disappears at TsT_s, the clusters themselves still exist even at much higher temperatures. Such a state may be considered as a valence bond liquid with clusters floating over the lattice [58]. In a sense, Peierls physics can be considered a source of instability or a driving force, whereas local chemical bonding in clusters is characterized by very different energetics and often cannot be broken easily.

There are also other important local effects in addition to molecular bonding. First of all, these are the correlation effects related to Coulomb interactions between electrons. In the simplest approach, molecular orbitals are linear combinations of atomic orbitals (MO LCAO). In the case of an isolated dimer with two electrons, the corresponding wavefunction is

ΨMO=12(c1↑†+c2↑†)(c1↓†+c2↓†)∣0⟩(2)\Psi_{MO}=\frac{1}{2}(c_{1\uparrow}^{\dagger}+c_{2\uparrow}^{\dagger})(c_{1\downarrow}^{\dagger}+c_{2\downarrow}^{\dagger})|0\rangle \tag*{(2)}

where ∣0⟩|0\rangle is the vacuum state, 1 and 2 denote the two atoms, and term (c1↑†+c2↑†)(c_{1\uparrow}^{\dagger}+c_{2\uparrow}^{\dagger}) (or (c1↓†+c2↓†)(c_{1\downarrow}^{\dagger}+c_{2\downarrow}^{\dagger})) creates a molecular orbital occupied by spin up (or down). ΨMO\Psi_{MO} contains terms with two electrons being placed at the same site (c1↑†c1↓†(c_{1\uparrow}^{\dagger}c_{1\downarrow}^{\dagger} and c2↑†c2↓†)c_{2\uparrow}^{\dagger}c_{2\downarrow}^{\dagger}). On-site repulsion of electrons destabilizes such a state and, in the limit of large Hubbard UU, leads to the Heitler-London (HL) wavefunction

ΨHL=12(c1↑†c2↓†−c1↓†c2↑†)∣0⟩(3)\Psi_{HL}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(c_{1\uparrow}^{\dagger}c_{2\downarrow}^{\dagger}-c_{1\downarrow}^{\dagger}c_{2\uparrow}^{\dagger})|0\rangle \tag*{(3)}

while the intermediate regime can be described by Coulson-Fisher theory [60]. Similar local physics related to electron-electron interaction is relevant for concentrated crystalline solids.

Hubbard UU can localize electrons at particular sites without forming molecular orbitals of any kind. Indeed, CuO4_4 plaquettes share common edges in the famous CuGeO3_3, but all t2gt_{2g} orbitals of Cu2+^{2+} are occupied. Consequently, there is no energetic gain from forming molecular orbitals, and we end up with localized electrons and S=1/2S=1/2 per site. Nevertheless, the corresponding chain can dimerize and gain energy by forming spin singlets (Stot=0S_{\rm tot}=0 from two S=1/2S=1/2) via the spin-Peierls mechanism [61, 62, 63]. This state, however, is very different from both the MO LCAO and HL pictures explained above.

In the strong-coupling (large UU) regime of materials with orbital degrees of freedom, orbital ordering often occurs [6]. However, orbital quantum fluctuations have been theoretically proposed to stabilize exotic phases with static or dynamical spin and orbital dimerization, owing to the strong exchange interactions in the orbital sector described by corresponding pseudospins (see, e.g., [64, 65]). This possibility is referred to as the orbital Peierls effect and represents an extremely interesting phenomenon. This coupling might effectively quench quantum fluctuations by locking the orbitals into static patterns, thereby rendering the orbital order largely classical in nature.

In real transition-metal compounds the situation can be even more complex because of a larger number of orbitals, spin-orbit coupling, effects of ligand crystal field, band structure due to other electrons, magnetism, etc. Therefore, even the seemingly simple situation of V4+^{4+} (d1d^1) dimers in VO2_2 still attracts a lot of attention.

While considerable progress had already been achieved in the early stages of Peierls transition studies by taking into account electron-phonon interaction of different forms [66], disorder [67, 68], and fluctuations [69], a true many-electron theory for real materials that describes both the dimerized and the high-temperature disordered phase, including all relevant local and non-local interactions, has yet to be developed.

In fact, local and band effects are hard, if possible at all, to disentangle. The instability due to nesting in the band spectrum and the tendency to form local clusters typically work hand in hand. Therefore, in this review, we do not restrict ourselves to considering only situations with a “canonical” Peierls transition, but also discuss materials where orbital degrees of freedom induce the formation of various clusters due to other (local) factors.

Quasi One-Dimensional Lattices

In quasi-1D edge-sharing systems such as rutile, pyroxene, or hollandite, the t2gt_{2g} orbital degeneracy is already lifted due to the anisotropic crystal structure of the quasi 1D arrangement of the MX6MX_{6} octahedra. Yet, the orbital degrees of freedom can play significant roles in the rich electronic and lattice transitions in these systems. Indeed, in this geometry one of the t2gt_{2g} orbitals provides a direct dd-dd overlap and form a wide band, while others mostly participate in ligand-assisted hopping as schematically shown in Figure 6.

Image not extracted

Figure 6. In edge-sharing geometry, there are two types of orbitals: the xyxy orbitals have a strong dd-dd hopping and large bandwidth susceptible to the Peierls transition, while xzxz and yzyz orbitals form π\pi bonds with ligands or pp orbitals, their bandwidths are typically smaller and they often behave as more correlated with localized electrons.

In the classical metal-insulator transition in rutile-type VO2\mathrm{VO}_{2} (V4+\mathrm{V}^{4+}, 3d13d^{1}) [70], the d1d^{1}-d1d^{1} dimerization is assisted by orbital reconfiguration [71] and electronic correlation effects [72], which can be controlled in thin films through the substrate effect [73]. Under the orbital-assisted mechanism, one of the t2gt_{2g} bands accommodates most of the dd electrons, forming a half-filled quasi-1D band. The Fermi surface of the half-filled band tends to satisfy the nesting condition [74] and the electron-phonon interaction induces the doubling of the unit cell due to dimerization along the edge-sharing chain.

The dimerization in NbO2\mathrm{NbO}_{2} (Nb4+\mathrm{Nb}^{4+}, 4d14d^{1}) [14] having the same rutile crystal structure is attracting renewed interest due to its chaotic breakdown which can be applied to neural computing [75]. While the correlation effects are generally expected to weaken for more extended 4d4d and 5d5d wavefunctions [76], even in NbO2\mathrm{NbO}_{2} spectroscopic experiments [77] and theoretical analysis [78] suggest the importance of electronic correlations.

One of the most interesting question is how sensitive these transitions to the dd-band filling. From the perspective of the local physics discussed in the previous section, the d1d^{1}-d1d^{1} dimerization is expected to remain robust against hole doping. Indeed, if filling of the quasi one-dimensional band is less than 1/21/2, the d0d^{0} sites are created and the remaining d1d^{1} sites form the d1d^{1}-d1d^{1} dimers as realized in Ti4O7\mathrm{Ti}_{4}\mathrm{O}_{7} (Ti3.5+\mathrm{Ti}^{3.5+}, formally 3d0.53d^{0.5}) [79, 80]. When the d1d^{1}-d1d^{1} dimers are embedded between the d0d^{0} sites, the HL-like singlet bond character would be enhanced [81]. In opposite situation of electron doping, the d2d^{2} sites are created and the remaining d1d^{1} sites form the d1d^{1}-d1d^{1} dimers. Even in the d2d^{2} systems such as rutile-type MoO2\mathrm{MoO}_{2}, dimerization is realized [23, 82], while the importance of correlation effects is suggested by photoemission spectroscopy [83]. This is achieved via an orbital-selective mechanism (described at the very end of this review), in which some electrons form molecular orbitals, while others remain site-localized (forming weak π\pi bonds) [84]. On the other hand, the d2d^{2}-d2d^{2} dimer in V4O7\mathrm{V}_{4}\mathrm{O}_{7} (V3.5+\mathrm{V}^{3.5+}, formally 3d1.53d^{1.5}) [85], the V3+\mathrm{V}^{3+} ions with S=1S=1 are antiferromagnetically coupled via the dd-pp-dd superexchange path [86].

Finally, it should be mentioned that dimerization is possible not only in edge-sharing chains discussed so far, but also in face-sharing geometries. The band which is expected to be susceptible to the Peierls instability has the a1ga_{1g} character, see Figure 3(c). Representative examples of such materials are trihalides such as TiI3\mathrm{TiI}_{3} (Ti3+\mathrm{Ti}^{3+}, 3d13d^{1}) with Ts=323T_{s}=323 K [87], as well as β\beta-RuCl3\mathrm{RuCl}_{3} and RuBr3\mathrm{RuBr}_{3} (Ru3+\mathrm{Ru}^{3+}, 4d54d^{5}) with Ts=206T_{s}=206 K and 384 K, respectively [88]. However, there are indications that the high-temperature structure in the latter material may only appear uniform, while in fact being a disordered version of dimerized chains due to stacking faults [89]. This again points to the importance of local effects, such as chemical bonding.

Two Dimensional Lattices

Triangular network. In contrast to the quasi-1D lattices, only edge-sharing is possible in 2D lattices. Most of the materials with a triangular lattice discussed below have the CdCl2\mathrm{CdCl}_{2} or α\alpha-NaFeO2\mathrm{NaFeO}_{2} structure shown in Figure 5(b).

Let us consider a yz/xz/xyyz/xz/xy three-band model on a triangular lattice. Since ligand orbitals are not included in this simple model, the conventional (local) Jahn-Teller effect – which relies on distortion of the ligand octahedra to lift the degeneracy of the t2gt_{2g} subshell – is not operative in this situation. Instead, interplay between band Jahn-Teller effect and Peierls instability can be discussed.

The hopping integrals between the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx orbitals along [1,−1,0][1,-1,0], [0,1,−1][0,1,-1], and [−1,0,1][-1,0,1], respectively, are given by txyt_{xy}, tyzt_{yz}, and tzxt_{zx} (txy=tyz=tzxt_{xy}=t_{yz}=t_{zx} for the undistorted triangular lattice). The xyxy, zxzx, and yzyz orbitals form 1D bands: ε1=2txycos⁡(kX)\varepsilon_1=2t_{xy}\cos(k_X), ε2=2tzxcos⁡(kX/2+3kY/2)\varepsilon_2=2t_{zx}\cos(k_X/2+\sqrt{3}k_Y/2), and ε3=2tyzcos⁡(−kX/2+3kY/2)\varepsilon_3=2t_{yz}\cos(-k_X/2+\sqrt{3}k_Y/2), respectively. Here, kXk_X and kYk_Y are the wave numbers along the [1,−1,0][1,-1,0] and [1,1,−2][1,1,-2] directions in the unit of 1/a1/a (aa is the lattice constant of the triangular lattice).

As an example, let us consider the three one-dimensional bands with a single hole, as shown in Figure 7(a). These give rise to one-dimensional Fermi surfaces with 5/6 filling, as illustrated in Figure 7(b). In real materials, there are also ligand-assisted hoppings (tyz−zxt_{yz-zx}, tzx−xyt_{zx-xy}, and txy−yzt_{xy-yz}) mixing these bands, which can lead to imperfect Fermi surface nesting.

Image not extracted

Figure 7. (a) Band dispersion for an undistorted triangular lattice three-band model (yz/zx/xyyz/zx/xy orbitals) with one t2gt_{2g} hole per site. The t2gt_{2g} hole is shared by the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx bands. (b) Fermi surfaces for the undistorted triangular lattice three-band model with one t2gt_{2g} hole per site. (c) Band dispersion for a distorted triangular lattice (compressed along [1,−1,0][1,-1,0] direction). The t2gt_{2g} hole is accommodated by the xyxy band. (d) Fermi surfaces for the distorted case. (e) Orbital ordering and dimerization by the orbital-induced Peierls effect on the triangular lattice. Short metal-metal bonds and active lobes of the xyxy orbitals are shown in red. (f) Possible band dispersion for a distorted triangular lattice with one t2gt_{2g} electron per site.

The degeneracy of the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx bands can be lifted by band Jahn-Teller type compression along [1,−1,0][1,-1,0]. Then txy>tyz=tzxt_{xy}>t_{yz}=t_{zx} and only the wider xyxy band may accommodate the t2gt_{2g} hole as shown in Figure 7(c). The xyxy band forms a 1D band with nesting vector 2kF2k_{\mathrm{F}} as illustrated in Figure 7(d). The orbital-induced Peierls state is robust against the indirect transfer terms txy−yzt_{xy-yz} and txy−zxt_{xy-zx} due to the Jahn-Teller energy splitting between the xyxy and yz/zxyz/zx orbitals. In the presence of txy−yzt_{xy-yz} and txy−zxt_{xy-zx}, a quasi-1D Fermi surface dominated by the xyxy character still keeps the nesting condition. Since the xyxy band accommodates one electron and is half-filled, the periodicity along the [1,−1,0][1,-1,0] direction is doubled with xyxy-xyxy dimers as shown in Figure 7(e).

In the orbital-induced Peierls mechanism, the t2gt_{2g} orbital degeneracy is broken by either a local Jahn-Teller effect (which splits localized levels) or a band Jahn-Teller effect (which not only splits bands but also alters their widths - a factor that can be even more important). This leads to an instability, and the resulting quasi-1D electronic state is further stabilized by a Peierls transition. The band Jahn-Teller effect would be relevant for IrTe2_2 (one hole in t2gt_{2g}) with relatively large width of Ir 5d5d band. On the other hand, in NaTiO2_2 with smaller width of Ti 3d3d band, the local Jahn-Teller distortion may play a role as discussed below. In order to describe NaTiO2_2, the O 2p2p orbitals should be explicitly considered. In the case of one t2gt_{2g} electron per site, the band Jahn-Teller effect may not work and modification of the bandwidth may be not so critical. Whereas the xyxy bandwidth is increased, the center of the xyxy band is shifted to the higher energy due to a local Jahn-Teller effect as illustrated in Figure 7(f).

Among the triangular lattice systems, NaTiO2_2 (Ti3+^{3+}, 3d13d^1) exhibits a transition to the nonmagnetic insulating state with lattice distortion from trigonal to monoclinic [20, 21]. The xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx orbitals can form 1D bands with the direct t2gt_{2g}-t2gt_{2g} transfer term, which may induce band Jahn-Teller distortion and subsequent Peierls instability. In these layered structures a trigonal field with the trigonal axis pointing perpendicular to the layers is often very important. It breaks the three-fold degeneracy and the t2gt_{2g} orbitals split into the a1ga_{1g} [13(xy+yz+zx)][\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}(xy+yz+zx)] and egπe_g^\pi [13(xy+e±2πi/3yz+e±4πi/3zx)][\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}(xy+e^{\pm2\pi i/3}yz+e^{\pm4\pi i/3}zx)] orbitals. As a result, the strong mixing between the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx orbitals provide the one hole pocket at the zone center (with a1ga_{1g} character) and the six hole pockets around the M points (with egπe_g^\pi character) for the d1d^1 system. The Fermi surfaces calculated for the trigonal phase [90] are roughly consistent with this simple picture except the hole pocket at the zone center. The absence of the hole pocket can be assigned to the trigonal ligand field which stabilizes the a1ga_{1g} orbital.

Although the band structure of the undistorted state is affected by the trigonal ligand field, the synergetic effect of the band Jahn-Teller distortion and the Peierls distortion may reorganize the band structure. Contraction along the [1,−1,0][1,-1,0] direction makes the xyxy band wider and also pushes it up in energy. Then, a single electron can be accommodated in the quasi 1D xz/yzxz/yz bands as shown in Figure 7(f), they become 1/4-filled and this results in dimerization with four times periodicity as shown in Figure 8(a). The orbital polarization of NaTiO2_2 is likely to be induced by the local Jahn-Teller effect rather than the band Jahn-Teller one. However, it is still awaiting experimental and theoretical studies to resolve the inconsistency between the lattice distortion and the spin singlet state.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. (a) Possible orbital ordering in NaTiO2_2. (b) Stripe-type charge and orbital ordering in IrTe2_2; Ir ions with nearly completely filled t2gt_{2g} shell, i.e. close to 3+ are shown by yellow balls. (c) Orbital ordering and trimers in LiVO2_2 and LiVS2_2. (d) Orbital ordering and zig-zag bonds in LiVS2_2. The thick solid lines indicate the short bonds of dimers and trimers. Active lobes of the t2gt_{2g} orbitals (i.e., those involved in strong bonding in clusters or the Peierls instability) are shown in red, blue, and green.

It is interesting to mention a NaTiO2_2 analogue on a square lattice (in fact, an inverse K2_2NiF4_4 structure): Na2_2Ti2_2Sb2_2O, in which the same Ti3+^{3+} ions with 3d13d^1 configuration are separated by oxygen (i.e. through common-corner sharing). This prevents dimerization (negatively charged ion in between), but leads to a charge-density wave with suppressed, though not-zero, magnetic susceptibility [91, 92, 93] similar to many Peierls materials.

IrTe2_2 (formally Ir4+^{4+}, 5d55d^5) with the Ir triangular lattice exhibits a structural transition at ∼ 270 K from the trigonal to the monoclinic phase accompanied by anomalies in electrical resistivity and magnetic susceptibility [42, 43, 94, 95]. An electron diffraction study shows that the structural transition is accompanied by a superstructure with wave vector of q⃗=(1/5,0,−1/5),(1/6,0,−1/6)\vec{q} = (1/5,0,-1/5), (1/6,0,-1/6) and (1/8,0,−1/8)(1/8,0,-1/8) [95, 96, 97, 98]. Such superstructure can be explained by CDW driven by a perfect or partial nesting of multi-band Fermi surfaces [95]. In addition, the monoclinic distortion suggests a band Jahn-Teller-like effect and the orbital-induced Peierls instability, which is partly supported by photoemission measurements [44, 99]. The periodicity of the superstructure is not consistent with the simple dimer model shown in Figure 7(e). Te has a lower electronegativity than oxygen (as in NaTiO2_2); it cannot fully oxidize Ir to Ir4+^{4+} (which would require removing four electrons), so IrTe2_2 remains metallic with Ir having a mixed valence (3+/4+) [100]. Structurally, this results in charge stripes consisting of Ir4+^{4+}-Ir4+^{4+} dimers and Ir3+^{3+} sites [96, 97], as illustrated in Figure 8(b), while a particular ordering or dimers is controlled by elastic forces [101]. Domain structure [102, 103, 104] and the photoinduced effect [105] of the anisotropic arrangement of the dimers have been studied by means of various spectromicroscopy techniques.

LiVO2_2 is a classical system with V3+^{3+} (3d23d^2) which exhibits a magnetic-nonmagnetic transition around 500 K with V trimerization [53, 106, 107, 108]. Pen et al. pointed out that two of the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx orbitals are occupied at the V sites connected by the [1 -1,0], [0,1,-1], and [-1,0,1] bonds of the triangular lattice forming the spin singlet state [29]. In the limit of weak Hund’s coupling, the d2d^2 trimers on the triangular lattice correspond to a kind of orbital-induced Peierls state without global orbital polarization (while at each V particular orbitals are occupied as discussed below). For the case of d1d^1 discussed in the previous paragraphs, one of the t2gt_{2g} orbitals should be selected for the subsequent Peierls instability. In the d2d^2 configuration of LiVO2_2, at each V site, two t2gt_{2g} electrons are distributed to three chains running through it. The xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx bands along the three chains running along the [1 -1,0], [0,1,-1], and [-1,0,1] directions are 1/3-filled and can induce orbital ordering and dimerization with three times periodicity.

Under the dimerization along the three directions, trimers are formed with yz/zxyz/zx, zx/xyzx/xy, and xy/yzxy/yz orbitals occupied at the three V sites, resulting in a non-magnetic ground state as shown in Figure 8(c). Although

the multiplet structure of V 2p X-ray absorption spectroscopy of LiVO2_2 indicates localized V 3d electrons with substantial Hund’s coupling [109], such a simple band picture is still useful to understand the nonmagnetic ground state with the trimers. An alternative would be the formation of total Stot=0S_{\mathrm{tot}} = 0 from three S=1S = 1 spins, but the transition temperature Ts=500T_s = 500 K appears suspiciously high for this scenario.

LiVS2_2 (the same V3+^{3+}, t2g2t_{2g}^2) exhibits a metal-insulator transition at 314 K which is accompanied by V trimerization similar to LiVO2_2 [110]. Since the V 3d electrons are more itinerant in LiVS2_2 than in LiVO2_2, the effect of Hund’s coupling is expected to be weaker. Since ratio of the band gap, EGE_G, to transition temperature TsT_s is large EG/kBTc=6E_G/k_{\mathrm{B}}T_c = 6 [111], the short range order of the short V-V bonds may survive even above TsT_s and, indeed, the zigzag chain correlations are observed in this phase [112]. In contrast to the trimer state in Figure 8(c), the zigzag chain structure can be stabilized by the ferro-type orbital order as shown in Figure 8(d). For example, when the xyxy and zxzx orbitals are occupied at every V site, the xyxy-xyxy and zxzx-zxzx dimers form the zigzag chains as indicated by the thick lines in the figure.

Li2_2MoO3_3 (Mo4+^{4+}, 4d24d^2) in contrast to many other Li2_2MoO3_3 materials discussed in the next subsection has a α–NaFeO2_2 structure with triangular lattice. It exhibits Mo trimers similar to LiVO2_2 [113], which can be randomly mixed with Li ions [114]. The Mo trimers can survive upto the highest temperature. Recent electrochemical study combined with DFT calculations show that molecular bonding is rather robust and suggest formation of Mo-Mo dimers under delithiation [114].

BaV10O15BaV_{10}O_{15} (V2.8+V^{2.8+}, 3d23d^2) with V2+/V3+V^{2+}/V^{3+} mixed valence exhibits a structural transition at 123 K driven by V trimerization (small triangles) [33] and V 3d3d orbital order similar to LiVO2LiVO_2 [34]. BaV10O15BaV_{10}O_{15} also has a triangular-like lattice, but with part of the V sites removed and adjacent V layers attached to each other (so that the inter-layer coupling is important [35]). Having extra dd electrons than in LiVO2LiVO_2 one can occupy other orbitals. It is possible to create molecular orbitals from them and to put an extra electron in the bonding molecular orbital. Therefore, the trimer is expected to be stable against electron doping (up to the doping level of 1/3 per V site). Indeed, the V trimer in BaV10O15BaV_{10}O_{15} is likely to accommodate one extra electron. The extra electron would be shared by the three V sites or localized on one of the V sites. The V2+/V3+V^{2+}/V^{3+} charge disproportionation is observed by X-ray photoemission spectroscopy [35], indicating that the ground state of the trimer would be a superposition of V2+V^{2+}-V3+V^{3+}-V3+V^{3+}, V3+V^{3+}-V2+V^{2+}-V3+V^{3+}, and V3+V^{3+}-V3+V^{3+}-V2+V^{2+} configurations. However, since one of the VO6VO_6 octahedron in the trimer shares its face with the one in the neighboring layer, the extra electron would be localized at this V site [35].

Even more exotic dimerization pattern is observed in the 1T1T polymorphs of ReS2ReS_2, ReSSeReSSe, and ReSe2ReSe_2 (Re4+Re^{4+}, 5d35d^3) [40, 41]. In this case, we have one electron in each t2gt_{2g} band (i.e., half-filling) and neglecting correlation effects, Hund’s exchange and spin-coupling one can expect dimerization in all three directions, exactly as in experiment, see Figure 9. These dimers are stacked in the “diamond necklace” structure, which, as we see, can be explained by the orbital-induced Peierls mechanism [32]. Moreover, TcS2TcS_2 (Tc4+Tc^{4+}, 4d34d^3) [41], LiMoS2LiMoS_2 (Mo3+Mo^{3+}, 4d34d^3) [115], and even NaMoO3NaMoO_3 (Mo3+Mo^{3+}, 4d34d^3) [116], which has a very different α\alpha-NaFeO3NaFeO_3 crystal structure, show the same pattern. It should be noted that the orbital-Peierls-like treatment can predict periodicity, but

Image not extracted

Figure 9. Crystal structure of 1T polymorphs of ReS2ReS_2, ReSSeReSSe, ReSe2ReSe_2, TcS2TcS_2, as well as LiMoS2LiMoS_2 and NaMoO3NaMoO_3, where dimerization in three different directions results in a “diamond necklace” pattern. Metal are shown as red balls, ligands as white balls, and metal-metal dimers as bold dark blue lines.

it is typically unable to lock the phase between the chains (i.e., how they are stacked in the lattice). This last problem can be solved, for example, by considering extensions of loop models [117].

Kagome network. This lattice is obtained from triangular network by removing 1/6 of the sites, Figure 10. In materials considered below, transition metals are again in the octahedral surrounding and these octahedra share their edges.

Image not extracted

Figure 10. Kagome network. (a) Orbital ordering for d1d^1 on a kagome network. (b) Orbital ordering for d2d^2 on a kagome network in Na2Ti3Cl8Na_2Ti_3Cl_8. The same trimerization is observed in Zn2Mo3O8Zn_2Mo_3O_8, LiZn2Mo3O8LiZn_2Mo_3O_8 and many other Mo3O8Mo_3O_8-based materials. The thick solid lines indicate the short bonds. Active lobes of the t2gt_{2g} orbitals are shown in red, blue, and green.

In the case of d1d^1 or d5d^5 metals one of the t2gt_{2g} orbitals should be selected for the subsequent Peierls instability as shown in Figure 10(a). Such dimerized state in the kagome network cannot be nonmagnetic since 1/3 of the transition-metal sites are not involved in the dimers. On the other hand, d2d^2 or d4d^4 kagome materials are expected to have a stable nonmagnetic state.

Na2Ti3Cl8Na_2Ti_3Cl_8 consists of a Ti2+Ti^{2+} (3d23d^2, two electrons in t2gt_{2g}) kagome network and exhibits partial trimerization around 210 K and full trimerization at 190 K [24, 25, 26], which leads to formation of so-called breathing kagome lattice. It is possible to describe the spin singlet trimer based on the antiferromagnetically coupled localized spin S=1S=1 [118]. However, the spin-lattice coupling may not be strong enough to explain the substantial lattice displacement of the trimerization and rather high temperatures structural transitions. The large lattice distortion suggests that the strong electron-lattice rather than the spin-lattice interaction plays a vital role. Therefore, although Na2Ti3Cl8Na_2Ti_3Cl_8 is highly insulating, it is useful to describe the trimerization based on the itinerant picture of orbital-induced Peierls mechanism [27]. Similar to the triangular lattice, the kagome network can be decomposed into three chains running along the [1,−1,0][1,-1,0], [0,1,−1][0,1,-1], and [−1,0,1][-1,0,1] directions. Therefore, the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx orbitals can form quasi 1D bands along the three directions. At each Ti site, two t2gt_{2g} electrons are distributed to two chains running through it. Therefore, as illustrated in Figure 10(b), each 1D band is half-filled and induces the lattice modulation with two times periodicity. The short Ti-Ti bonds along the three directions form the trimers in agreement with the experimental observation.

The Mo4+^{4+} (4d24d^2) kagome network in Zn2_2Mo3_3O8_8 hosts Mo3_3 trimers similar to Na2_2Ti3_3Cl8_8 [119, 120]. The Mo trimers with six t2gt_{2g} electrons are stable up to the highest temperature available indicating that the trimer is more stable in the more itinerant system. Moreover, they remain stable even under doping. This suggests the importance of local physics: the formation of chemical bonding. In this picture, three t2gt_{2g} orbitals form three molecular orbitals, which accommodate six electrons per trimer (see Figure 11, which also applies to LiVO2_2), yielding a substantial energy gain. Electron doping does little harm, as extra electrons occupy non-bonding levels, resulting in the orbital-selective behavior discussed in the last section.

Figure 11. (a) Formation of molecular bonds in trimers (shadowed triangle), where the MX6MX_6 octahedra (transition metals, MM, are shown by black balls, while ligands, XX, by white ones) share their edges in the triangular network systems such as LiVO2_2 and the kagome network systems such as Zn2_2Mo3_3O8_8. (b) Electronic structure, when each of metal has d2d^2 electronic configuration as e.g. in Zn2_2Mo3_3O8_8. (c) Situation of d7/3d^{7/3} configuration as realized, e.g., in LiZn2_2Mo3_3O8_8 and Nb3_3Cl8_8. (d) Electronic structure of Mo-Mo dimer in MoO2_2: part of electrons occupy molecular orbitals, while the other one stay at localized atomic-like orbitals.

Indeed, one can easily intercalate different ions between the Mo3_3O8_8 layers, and the materials obtained in this way exhibit extraordinary physical properties. For example, Mo3_3 trimers survive in LiZn2_2Mo3_3O8_8, where there are seven Mo 4dd electrons per trimer [119, 120]. E.g. at the Mo site with yzyz and zxzx electrons occupied, the xyxy orbital is available. In the three Mo sites in the trimer, such “free” orbitals (xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx at the three Mo sites) can form the “non-bonding” molecular orbital. Such “non-bonding” molecular orbital is occupied by the extra electron as illustrated in Figure 11(b) and (c). The Mo3_3 trimers have localized spin 1/2 due to the extra electron and form a geometrically frustrated spin 1/2 triangular lattice. This can be viewed as a cluster Mott insulating state [121, 122], providing exotic spin-liquid behavior [119, 120].

regular lattice. This can be viewed as a cluster Mott insulating state [121, 122], providing exotic spin-liquid behavior [119, 120]. Mo3+^{3+}/Mo4+^{4+} charge fluctuation is observed by X-ray photoemission spectroscopy [123]. This situation is similar to the V3_3 trimer in BaV10_{10}O15_{15}. Possible relationship between the charge fluctuation and the spin-liquid behavior should be examined by further studies.

There is also a very large class of materials with similar breathing kagome lattices and general formula Nb3_3X8_8, where XX = F, Cl, Br, and I. Nb3_3Cl8_8 is one of the most studied among them. Since Nb2+^{2+} : Nb3+^{3+} = 1 : 2, the Nb trimer also accommodates seven t2gt_{2g} electrons and hosts localized spin 1/2 [124, 125, 126]. The spin-1/2 triangular lattice of the cluster Mott insulating state is a new playground to study the spin liquid and exotic superconductivity [127]. Interestingly, Nb3_3Cl8_8 and Nb3_3Br8_8 exhibit a magnetic–nonmagnetic transition around 90 K [128] and 390 K [129], respectively, although orbital degeneracy is already lifted. Formation of a nonmagnetic state often implies dimerization, but in this case this must be dimers made out of Stot=1/2S_{\mathrm{tot}} = 1/2 trimers. Different scenarios have been proposed including intra- and inter-layer dimerization[126, 128] and X-ray photoemission spectroscopy indeed observes Nb2+^{2+}/Nb3+^{3+} charge fluctuations [130]. Theoretical studies suggest that there is an extremely strong exchange coupling between layers, much larger than intralayer exchange interaction and transition to a nonmagnetic state can be considered as formation of dimerized bilayers [131].

Honeycomb network

It is not straightforward to apply the orbital-induced Peierls description to the honeycomb network since it cannot be decomposed into chains. This suggests importance of local physics related to formation of clusters due to chemical bonding in which orbital degrees of freedom play a very important role (see also the Peierls or not really Peierls section above).

Yet, it is still possible to decompose the honeycomb network into zigzag chains (the same zigzag chains are observed in quasi-1D pyroxenes). As shown in Figure 12(a), assuming ferro-type orbital order of xyxy, local xyxy-xyxy bonds can be created alternately along the zigzag chain for d1d^1 or d5d^5 systems. This can explain the fact that α\alpha-TiCl3_3 and α\alpha-TiBr3_3 (Ti3+^{3+}, 3d13d^1) having the honeycomb lattice become nonmagnetic below structural transition at 217 K [132] and 178 K [133], respectively. The direct abab initio and structure calculations have shown that both materials tend to dimerize [134] in contrast to the earlier prediction [135]. Raman measurements for α\alpha-TiBr3_3 are consistent with this structural model [133]. A very similar situation is observed in α\alpha-ZrCl3_3 (Zr3+^{3+}, 4d14d^1), where the energy gain due to dimerization prevents [136] realization of the SU(4)SU(4) spin-orbit liquid proposed theoretically [137]. Ilmenite-type MgVO3_3 (V4+^{4+}, 3d13d^1) also exhibits V-V dimers on the honeycomb lattice below 500 K [138]. The transition temperature increases up to 625 K in ZnVO3_3 where the Zn-Zn dimers coexist with the V-V dimers [139].

Figure 12. Honeycomb network. (a) Possible orbital ordering on the d1d^1 or d5d^5 honeycomb lattice of α\alpha-RuCl3_3 and Na2_2IrO3_3 under pressure. (b) Orbital ordering with single bonding of two different active orbitals. (c) Orbital ordering with double bonding including two orbitals at each site, case of d4d^4 in Li2_2RuO3_3. (d) Orbital ordering with triple bonding on the d3d^3 honeycomb network in MoCl3_3. The thick solid, thick dashed, and thin dot-dashed lines indicate the σ\sigma-, π\pi-, and δ\delta-bondings, respectively.

4d4d and 5d5d honeycomb systems with d1d^1 or d5d^5 configurations (such as Na2_2IrO3_3, α\alpha-RuCl3_3, and α\alpha-RuBr3_3) do not show dimerization at ambient pressure, which is probably suppressed by the strong spin-orbit coupling [140]. Under high pressure, α\alpha-RuCl3_3 and α\alpha-RuBr3_3 exhibit Ru-Ru dimerization with the ferro-type orbital order as illustrated in Figure 12(a) [141, 142]. Iridates such as α\alpha-Li2_2IrO3_3 [143], Ag3_3LiIr2_2O6_6 [144], and Na2_2IrO3_3 [145, 146] also undergo a pressure induced phase transition to the dimerized state. Since the direct hopping terms txyt_{xy}, tyzt_{yz}, and tzxt_{zx} are relatively large in the 4d4d and 5d5d systems, the energy gain by the dimerization overcomes the spin-orbit coupling when they are enhanced under pressure. One of the t2gt_{2g} orbitals is selected to form the anisotropic dimers as illustrated in Figure 12(a).

In this context, it is highly interesting that Li2_2RuO3_3 with Ru4+^{4+} (4d44d^4, two holes in t2gt_{2g}) shows a very different packing of dimers: instead of the parallel dimers realized in all previously discussed materials, the armchair pattern shown in Figure 12(b) appears below Ts=540T_s = 540 K, where structural and metal-insulator transitions occur simultaneously [147, 148].

Assuming ferro-type orbital order of xyxy and yzyz holes in this d4d^4 electronic configuration, xyxy-xyxy and yzyz-yzyz singlet bonds (antibonding states in the case of holes) can be created as illustrated in Figure 12(b). The difference of dimer arrangement between Figure 12(a) and (Figure 12b) is due to the “π\pi phase shift” of the dimerization between the neighboring zig-zag chains. With the Li ion at the center of the hexagon, the dimer arrangement of Figure 12(b) would be favored since otherwise the hexagon needs to be compressed along the horizontal direction in the case of Figure 12(a).

Interestingly, in LiVO2_2, two electrons at each site participate in two singlet bonds on different metal-metal bonds, leading to the formation of V3_3 trimers with Stot=0S_{\rm tot} = 0. In Li2_2RuO3_3, the situation seems similar, but with holes instead of electrons. However, these holes are involved in the formation of only one short bond with the same neighbor; no larger cluster, such as short hexagons, appears. Instead, the 12(yz+zx)\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(yz+zx) orbitals form π\pi-bonding mainly through dd-pp-dd hoppings illustrated in Figure 6 in addition to the xyxy-xyxy σ\sigma-bonding [58]. Under the orbital order with yzyz, 12(zx+xy)\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(zx+xy) on one Ru-Ru bond and xyxy, 12(yz+zx)\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(yz+zx) on another, the short bonds are further stabilized by the double bonding in the nonmagnetic phase of Li2_2RuO3_3 [Fig. 12(c)].

This makes Ru ions in dimers even more strongly coupled. Indeed, the short (long) Ru-Ru bond length is about 2.6Å (3.0Å) in Li2_2RuO3_3 while the short (long) Ir-Ir bond length is about 2.7Å (3.0Å) in the pressure induced dimerized phase of α\alpha-Li2_2IrO3_3 with Ir4+^{4+} (5d55d^5, only σ\sigma-bonding) [143]. The short Ru-Ru bond would be consistent with the armchair arrangement of the dimers. A recent optical study reports that the relatively weak π\pi-bonding by the yzyz and zxzx orbitals can be selectively broken and the partially disordered phase can be optically

created [149]. In a similar manner, TcCl3_3 with Tc3+^{3+} (4d44d^4, two holes in t2gt_{2g}) has Tc-Tc dimers on the honeycomb lattice, but the dimer pattern is different from that of Li2_2RuO3_3: they are parallel to each other [150] (presumably due to the absence of ions sitting in the centers of hexagons as theoretically analyzed by Jackeli and Khomskii [151]).

α\alpha-MoCl3_3 with Mo3+^{3+} (4d34d^3, three electrons in t2gt_{2g}) undergoes a magnetic-nonmagnetic transition around Ts=585T_s = 585 K with the strong Mo-Mo dimerization below TsT_s [152, 153, 154]. The Mo-Mo dimerization in the honeycomb network is illustrated in Figure 12(d). In addition to the xyxy-xyxy σ\sigma-bonding and the 12(yz+zx)\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(yz+zx) π\pi-bonding, 12(yz−zx)\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(yz-zx) orbitals may form δ\delta-bonding although δ\delta-bonding is usually weak. Indeed, the magnetic susceptibility drops below TsT_s [154], so that all three t2gt_{2g} electrons seem to be bonded. Interestingly, SrRu2_2O6_6 [155], BaRu2_2O6_6 [156], and AgRuO3_3 [157], which share the same honeycomb lattice and the Ru5+^{5+} 4d34d^3 electronic configuration, do not dimerize; instead, at least some of them appear to exhibit quasimolecular orbitals on Ru6_6 hexagons [158, 159].

THREE-DIMENSIONAL LATTICES

In the spinel-type AM2X4AM_2X_4 compounds, which crystal structure is shown in Figure 5(e), the MM sites occupied by transition metals form the pyrochlore network in which M4M_4 tetrahedra share their corners. MX6MX_6 octahedra again share their edges, and, e.g., along the [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0] direction only the transfer integral between the xyxy orbitals are allowed by symmetry, if only a direct t2g−t2gt_{2g}-t_{2g} hoppings considered (effect of the ligand assisted processes will be discussed later). Also along the [1,0,±1][1,0,\pm1] and [0,1,±1][0,1,\pm1] directions, only the zxzx and yzyz orbitals have non-zero transfer integrals, respectively. Consequently, the xyxy, yzyz, and zxzx orbitals form 1D bands along the [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0], [1,0,±1][1,0,\pm1], or [0,1,±1][0,1,\pm1] directions, respectively. Similar to the argument for the triangular lattice, symmetry breaking of the t2gt_{2g} orbital degeneracy due to band or local Jahn-Teller effect can create quasi-1D Fermi surfaces driving the Peierls instability. In this section, transition metal compounds with 3D pyrochlore network are discussed in the context of orbital-induced Peierls picture.

CuIr2_2S4_4 and LiRh2_2O4_4. There are 5.5 t2gt_{2g} electrons (0.5 holes) per transition metal in these materials. In the cubic spinel, the 0.5 holes are distributed in the three t2gt_{2g} bands and each band accommodates 1/6 holes. The six pairs of 1D Fermi surfaces (six pairs of parallel planes in the 3D kk-space) may have the Peierls instability due to electron-phonon interaction or electron-electron interaction. Since the paired parallel planes are spanned by the wave vectors along [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0], [1,0,±1][1,0,\pm1], [0,1,±1][0,1,\pm1] with the magnitude of π/6\pi/6 (unit of the wave vectors is 1/a1/a, where aa is the MM-MM distance), the pyrochlore network may undergo distortion with 12 times periodicity along [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0], [1,0,±1][1,0,\pm1], and [0,1,±1][0,1,\pm1] directions. However, as discussed for the triangular lattice case, the indirect MM-MM transfers via the ligands are not negligibly small. The finite transfer integrals between the different t2gt_{2g} orbitals deform the Fermi surfaces and break the nesting condition. Indeed, the calculated Fermi surfaces for the cubic CuIr2_2S4_4 have no Fermi surface nesting [160, 161, 162].

In the orbital-induced Peierls scenario, one of the t2gt_{2g} bands, e.g. xyxy, becomes wider than the other two (due to band Jahn-Teller effect) and accommodates all the holes as illustrated in Figure 13(a). Then the quasi-one-dimensional band with 3/4-filling can provide the Peierls instability with four times periodicity along [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0].

Figure 13. (a) Sketch of yzyz, zxzx, and xyxy bands under band Jahn-Teller distortion (elongated along the cc- or zz-axis) for CuIr2_2S4_4 and LiRh2_2O4_4. (b) Charge and orbital ordering with the octamer (shaded) on the Ir pyrochlore network in CuIr2_2S4_4. Ir3+^{3+} with completely filled t2gt_{2g} shell are shown by yellow balls, the Ir 5d xy5d\ xy orbitals of Ir4+^{4+} form the short Ir-Ir bonds along [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0], which are indicated by the thick lines. Charge and orbital ordering on the Rh pyrochlore network in LiRh2_2O4_4. The Rh 4d xy4d\ xy orbitals of the Rh4+^{4+} site form the short Rh-Rh bonds along [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0]. (d) Orbital ordering and dimerization in MgTi2_2O4_4. The Ti 3d yz3d\ yz and zxzx orbitals form the short Ti-Ti bonds along [0,1,±1][0,1,\pm1] and [1,0,±1][1,0,\pm1], respectively. The helices formed by the short and long Ti-Ti bonds are shaded and their helicity are indicated by the arrows. Only transition metals are shown by yellow balls or sites with orbitals

CuIr2_2S4_4 exhibits a metal-insulator transition around 230 K [163] with tetragonal elongation (a<ca < c) and trigonal octamer charge ordering [50, 51] as shown in Figure 13(b). All the holes are accommodated in the xyxy orbitals and the Ir3+^{3+}-Ir3+^{3+}-Ir4+^{4+}-Ir4+^{4+} arrangement with the Ir4+^{4+}-Ir4+^{4+} dimers is formed along [1,±1,0][1,\pm1,0] in agreement with the orbital-induced Peierls scenario. CuIr2_2S4_4 with the unique electronic and lattice properties harbor the partially disordered state induced by light or X-ray illumination [164, 165, 166, 167], where the long range charge order is destructed but the tetragonal distortion (and orbital order) remains.

LiRh2_2O4_4 undergoes the cubic to tetragonal transition (again a<ca < c) at 220 K which is followed by the tetragonal charge ordering and the Rh4+^{4+}-Rh4+^{4+} dimerization as shown in Figure 13(c). The Rh3+^{3+}-Rh4+^{4+} charge fluctuation [168] and the local Rh4+^{4+}-Rh4+^{4+} dimers [169] are observed between 220 K and 170 K, indicating that orbital symmetry breaking plays more important roles in LiRh2_2O4_4.

Here, one can speculate that, in the Rh 4d4d bands narrower than the Ir 5d5d bands, the band Jahn-Teller distortion alone can stabilize this particular distortion. In case of CuIr2_2S4_4, the local Ir-Ir dimers are found even in the cubic phase [52] while the Rh-Rh dimers are observed only in the tetragonal phase. The charge ordering of LiRh2_2O4_4 satisfies the Anderson condition on the pyrochlore network indicating importance of the Coulomb repulsive force between holes while the octamer charge ordering of CuIr2_2S4_4 violates it. In LiRh2_2O4_4, the energy gain by the dimerization is smaller due to the electron correlation while the band Jahn-Teller instability is stronger than in CuIr2_2S4_4.

MgTi2_2O4_4. Spinel-type MgTi2_2O4_4 (Ti3+^{3+}, 3d13d^1) exhibits a metal-insulator transition around 260 K which is accompanied by a structural transition from cubic to tetragonal (a>ca > c) [13]. The tetragonal structure has Ti3+^{3+}-Ti3+^{3+} dimerization with spirals of long and short Ti-Ti bonds [170]. With a>ca > c, the yzyz and zxzx bands are wider than the xyxy band and accommodate the Ti 3d3d electrons. Quasi one-dimensional yzyz and zxzx bands are formed along [0,1,±1][0,1,\pm1] and [1,0,±1][1,0,\pm1] and accommodate 0.5 electron respectively. The 1/4-filled yzyz and zxzx bands provide the Peierls instability with four time periodicity of yzyz-yzyz and zxzx-zxzx dimers as shown in Figure 13(d). However, since the TiO6_6 octahedron is also compressed along the cc-axis, the center of mass of the xyxy band becomes lower in energy than those of the yzyz and zxzx bands due to the ligand field. Thus MgTi2_2O4_4 shares the competition between the band Jahn-Teller effect and the ligand field effect (i.e. local Jahn-Teller effect for which change of bandwidth is not important) with NaTiO2_2. Similar to Na2_2Ti3_3Cl8_8, it is possible to explain the orbital ordering of MgTi2_2O4_4 based on the localized picture [171] although it is difficult to describe the metal-insulator transition. The localized nature of the Ti-Ti dimer has experimentally been suggested from the survival of the local Ti-Ti dimers above the transition temperature [172] and the multiplet structure of the Ti 2p X-ray absorption spectrum [173]. Both the itinerant model and the localized model provide the same conclusion on the orbital ordering of MgTi2_2O4_4.

AlV2_2O4_4, GaV2_2O4_4, and LiV2_2O4_4. Different structural models have been proposed for the spinel-type AlV2_2O4_4 (V2.5+^{2.5+}, 3d2.53d^{2.5}) [36, 37, 174]. A recent structural study shows that AlV2_2O4_4 appears to exhibit a remarkable formation of two distinct types of clusters: V2+^{2+} tetrahedra and V3+^{3+} triangles along with a single unpaired V3+^{3+} ion with a localized S=1S=1, i.e. it can be considered as Al4_4([V4_4]8+^{8+}[V3_3]9+^{9+}V3+^{3+})O16_{16} [37]. The V2+^{2+}/V3+^{3+} charge disproportionation is confirmed by X-ray photoemission spectroscopy [38].

Spinel lattice can be represented as alternating along the [1, 1, 1] direction between kagome and triangular layers of transition-metal ions, see Figure 14(a). The V3+^{3+} ions with a d2d^2 configuration in one of the kagome planes (K1) group into trimers. In the next kagome layer (K2), a V2+^{2+} ion with one additional electron forms tetrahedra with V3+^{3+} ions in the neighboring triangular plane (T1). The remaining V3+^{3+} ion, with a dangling S=1S=1, resides in the last triangular layer (T2).

High-temperature and possible low-temperature structures of spinel AlV₂O₄

Figure 14. (a) High-temperature structure of spinel AlV2_2O4_4, which can be decomposed into kagome (red spheres) and triangular (green spheres) layers of V ions. (b) A possible low-temperature structure. Short V–V bonds, shown in blue, illustrate the formation of V4_4 tetrahedra and V3_3 triangles.

Interestingly, if one assumes that all V4_4 tetrahedra are oriented in the same direction as in Figure 14(b), this unusual coexistence of tetrahedra and trimers can be explained by the orbital-induced Peierls transition. Along the [1 -1,0], [1,0,-1], and [0,1,-1] chains in the kagome layers, a doubling of the period occurs due to the two half-filled t2gt_{2g} bands at each V site, similarly to Na2_2Ti3_3Cl8_8 (see Figure 15). However, the average valence of V is 2.5+, leaving additional 0.5 electron per site. This corresponds to a 1/4 filling of the remaining t2gt_{2g} orbitals, which in turn leads to a tetramerization (period 4) along the [1,1,0], [1,0,1], and [0,1,1] chains that cross both the kagome and triangular layers.

Figure 15. 1/4-filled bands along the [1,1,0], [0,1,1], and [1,0,1] chains and V2+^{2+}/V3+^{3+} charge ordering for AlV2_2O4_4. The black circles indicate V3+^{3+} sites in triangular layers. In the V3+^{3+} (d2d^2) kagome network layer, the V3+^{3+} trimers are formed by the yz/zxyz/zx, zx/xyzx/xy, and yz/xyyz/xy orbital ordering. The shaded triangles and tetrahedra indicate the V trimers and tetramers, respectively. In the V2+^{2+} (d3d^3) kagome network layer, the tetramers are formed with the V2+^{2+} sites (yz/zx/xyyz/zx/xy) in the neighboring triangular lattice layer. The dash-dotted lines indicate the same V2+^{2+} site.

This picture of the orbital-induced Peierls transition explains the formation of isolated V ions, trimers, and tetrahedra all pointing in the same direction (i.e., a ferroelectric structure, since it breaks inversion symmetry). However, available experimental data indicate a disorder in the orientation of the tetrahedra [37], which may arise from small off-stoichiometry and/or partial cation inversion between Al and V sites - a common feature in spinels, see e.g. [175, 176]. Another important factor is configurational entropy, given that the transition to the clustered structure occurs at a very high temperature (700 K). Although this prevents a definitive assignment of the transition mechanism, orbital degrees of freedom are clearly central - whether through local chemical bonding between V ions or via cooperative effects like the Peierls transition. Notably, as we argue in the “Peierls or not really Peierls” section above, these two possibilities are not mutually exclusive and often go hand in hand.

Similar to AlV2_2O4_4, spinel-type GaV2_2O4_4 (V2.5+^{2.5+}, 3d2.53d^{2.5}) exhibits the trimer-tetramer structure [39] in which mixed valence state can be realized by Zn substitution for Ga [54]. Ga1−x_{1-x}Znx_xV2_2O4_4 with 0.06≤x≤0.750.06 \le x \le0.75 still have disordered trimers and/or tetramers although the global structure is cubic. Most probably, while V2+^{2+} tetramer can be decomposed into trimer and monomer with the valence change from V2+^{2+} to V3+^{3+}, the V3+^{3+} trimers in the kagome network layers are robust.

The orbital-induced Pierels mechanism would be relevant for the pressure induced insulating phase of LiV2_2O4_4 [177, 178, 179, 180, 181]. The average valence of V is +3.5 (3d1.53d^{1.5}) in LiV2_2O4_4. Assuming that the V sites in the triangular lattice layers are V5+^{5+} (d0d^0), the average valence of V of the kagome network layers are V3+^{3+}. Robustness of the trimers in the V3+^{3+} kagome layers would be consistent with the pressure induced insulating phase of LiV2_2O4_4.

Calculation and experimental methods

Theoretical methods. Equation (1) has been widely used to study the Peierls transition. It not only allows one to find a divergence at a certain qq-vector, suggesting a new distorted structure, but also to determine which bands (or orbitals) are involved and thereby to gain insight into the microscopic mechanism behind the transition. However, first of all, it should be noted that (1) represents an expression for the generalized susceptibility of the electronic system, and an instability can occur not necessarily in the charge (lattice) sector; a divergence in χ0(q⃗)\chi_0(\vec{q}) can also signal a tendency to form, e.g., a long-range magnetic order or to lead to superconductivity.

Second, large peak in the Lindhard susceptibility (1) alone does not guarantee a Peierls instability. The full criterion involves the dimensionless electron-phonon coupling λq⃗\lambda_{\vec{q}}. Following the standard Dyson equation formalism for phonons, see, e.g., [7], Eq. (20), it can be written as

λq⃗=2∣gq⃗∣2Mω0(q⃗)χ0(q⃗),(4)\lambda_{\vec{q}} = \frac{2|g_{\vec{q}}|^2}{M\omega_0(\vec{q})}\chi_0(\vec{q}), \tag*{(4)}

where ω0(q⃗)\omega_0(\vec{q}) is the bare phonon frequency, MM is the ionic mass (or the relevant reduced mass for the phonon mode), and gq⃗g_{\vec{q}} is the electron-phonon coupling matrix element. An instability requires λq⃗>1\lambda_{\vec{q}} > 1. Hence, a sharp (logarithmic) divergence in χ0(q⃗)\chi_0(\vec{q}) can be suppressed by weak coupling or a stiff lattice, while a soft phonon can stabilize the transition even with “moderate” nesting. This underscores the importance of lattice softness, which is naturally captured by ab initio phonon calculations. Therefore, a more direct approach is to perform DFT calculations of the phonon spectrum of the high-temperature structure. The phonon softening, or the appearance of imaginary phonon modes at a specific wave vector q⃗\vec{q}, is strong evidence of a lattice instability. While such standard calculations do not explicitly compute the electron-phonon matrix elements, they directly capture the bare phonon frequency ω0(q⃗)\omega_0(\vec{q}) - the lattice softness - which critically enhances the dimensionless coupling constant λq⃗\lambda_{\vec{q}} that drives the Peierls transition.

Another important question is which approximation should be used to study possible nesting and instability in (1). Typically, one considers nonmagnetic DFT calculations, but interactions can do more than just renormalize the electronic spectrum close to the Fermi level. For example, spin-orbit coupling can substantially modify the electronic structure of materials based on heavy elements and therefore must be taken into account (see, e.g., the case of CsW2_2O6_6 [199]). And even more delicate question is whether strong Coulomb correlations should be taken into consideration in a static way, as is done in the DFT+U approximation, or whether methods such as dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) [183] with a frequency-dependent self-energy (which properly renormalizes the electronic structure close to EFE_F) must be used. Interestingly, pulling localized states away from the Fermi level using a static potential, as in DFT+U, sometimes helps to reveal nesting in materials subjected to Peierls transitions, or occurs, e.g., in the hollandite K2_2Cr8_8O16_{16} [184].

Phonon calculations and crystal structure optimization are also not always as straightforward as anticipated. On the one hand, ab initio methods are generally thought to provide correct crystal structures only if the ground-state electronic structure is described properly. Therefore, one might expect that including the Hubbard terms is essential for transition metal oxides. However, DFT+U often fails to describe the Peierls transition; for example, in canonical VO2_2, it yields uniform V chains [185]. This occurs because DFT+U replaces the large energy gain from the formation of molecular orbitals - which is proportional to the hopping tt - with a much smaller exchange coupling of the order t2/Ut^2/U. Extensions of DMFT taking into account both (local) correlation effects and band formation on the same footing are promising in describing materials with Peierls transition [186].

Experimental methods. It is worth noting that historically, the formation of clusters was often detected by thermodynamic measurements such as specific heat signaling phase transitions, or by magnetic susceptibility, since clusters typically turn out to be nonmagnetic. The most direct and significant technique for studying Peierls distortions is, of course, diffraction. However, this approach has limitations not only related to issues such as twinning, incoherent scattering, etc., but also to problems typical for materials undergoing Peierls transition. As discussed above, these transitions often occur in two-dimensional systems with triangular or kagome lattices. Such layered materials frequently exhibit stacking faults, i.e., irregularities or disruptions in the ideal sequence of atomic or layer stacking. This arises from the weak (often van der Waals) bonding between layers. For example, this seems to be precisely the problem in LiVO2_2 [53, 56], where magnetic susceptibility shows a drop [187] most probably associated with the formation of nonmagnetic V trimers, yet diffraction techniques (and even Raman measurements [30]) are unable to refine structural trimers in the low-temperature phase.

The orbital anisotropy and the electronic configuration of particular ions can be probed by X-ray absorption spectroscopy, especially when combined with theoretical many-electron calculations, which are typically performed nowadays within the configuration interaction approximation. This combination can reproduce very fine details of X-ray absorption spectra and extract the electronic wave functions that fully characterize the system. Such an approach was used, for example, to demonstrate that the dimerization in VO2_2 cannot be described within a conventional Peierls theory; electronic correlations are involved in reducing charge fluctuations and making the system more 1D (via orbital degrees of freedom) and thus susceptible to a Peierls-like transition [71].

The charge modulation/disproportionation and valence state can be probed by core level photoemission spectroscopy. In particular, hard X-ray photoemission spectroscopy (HAXPES) can detect charge fluctuations and the degree of electron localization within clusters formed in the low-temperature phase [123].

Another extremely important experimental technique, which has been discussed in the Peierls or not really Peierls section is PDF analysis of neutron or X-ray diffraction data. It allows to figure out what happens with clusters in the high-temperature phase, i.e. above TsT_{\mathrm{s}}. One of the main results obtained in different PDF studies is that clusters typically survive at temperatures much higher than TsT_{\mathrm{s}}, see Table II.

MaterialStructural transitionClusters exist at least up to
LiRh2_2O4_4170 K350 K [49]
NaTiSi2_2O6_6210 K490 K [55]
CuIr2_2S4_4230 K780 K∗^{*} [52]
MgTi2_2O4_4260 K500 K [172]
GaV2_2O4_4415 K1100 K [39]
Li2_2RuO3_3540 K920 K [58]
AlV2_2O4_4700 K1100 K [37]

Table II. List of materials for which PDF study has been performed. In last column the highest experimentally studied temperature at which PDF observes short metal-metal bond is indicated (this means that they can survive at even higher TT). ∗^{*} is used to indicate vanishing difference between short and long bonds at high TT.

For pyroxene NaTiSi2_2O6_6, where dimerization of quasi-1D chains occurs at Ts=210T_{\mathrm{s}} = 210 K, PDF finds that ∼6\sim6 Ti sites remain correlated at 490 K [55]. I.e. we see that while a long-range order of dimers disappear there still exist pieces of dimerized chains (3 dimers in average). Difference between short (lsl_{\mathrm{s}}) and long (lll_{\mathrm{l}}) Ti-Ti bond length is δl=ll−ls=0.154\delta l = l_{\mathrm{l}} - l_{\mathrm{s}} = 0.154 Å in low-temperature phase [188], reduces to 0.124 Å at 490 K [55].

Another example with clusters is magnetite, Fe3_3O4_4, which adopts the spinel structure with edge-sharing FeO6_6 octahedra. Below the Verwey transition at TV≈125T_{\mathrm{V}} \approx125 K, three Fe ions form linear clusters of Fe3+^{3+}–Fe2+^{2+}–Fe3+^{3+} trimerons [189]. X-ray PDF studies demonstrate that the long-range trimeron order disappears just above TVT_{\mathrm{V}}, while short-range correlations persist up to the Curie temperature TC=850T_{\mathrm{C}} = 850 K and its temperature dependence exactly copies that of the magnetization, see Figure 16 and [190].

Shift parameter and magnetisation as a function of temperature

Figure 16. Shift parameter fvf_{\mathrm{v}}, which characterizes the strength of distortions leading to the formation of trimerons, plotted together with the temperature dependence of the magnetization in Fe3_3O4_4. The long-range order of trimerons breaks at the Verwey temperature TV≈125T_{\mathrm{V}} \approx125 K (structural transition; green symbols), whereas local order (blue and red symbols) persists up to much higher temperatures. The inset shows a Fe3+^{3+}-Fe2+^{2+}-Fe3+^{3+} trimeron. Adapted from [190].

This 20% decrease of δl\delta l in the two phases of NaTiSi2_2O6_6 contrasts a lot with what is observed in CuIr2_2S4_4 [52]. In this material, short Ir-Ir dimers have ls=2.97l_{\mathrm{s}} = 2.97 Å (δl=0.69\delta l = 0.69 Å) in the low-temperature phase [51]. There are still “short” in some sense Ir-Ir bonds above the structural transition, but they become 3.5 Å and the corresponding short-long bond difference δl\delta l decreases down to 0.08 Å [52], i.e. on nearly 90%. Such a strong modification of the local structure implies a change of the orbital state between the two phases of CuIr2_2S4_4 [52].

Thus, there can be at least three situations. First, the clusters stay nearly unchanged and start to “float” over the lattice in the high-temperature phase. Moreover, some pieces of the initial dimerized structure and the corresponding orbital state can remain locally intact. It would be very interesting to study in more detail how the disorder develops with temperature in this situation. The second option is when the bond lengths in clusters change considerably, as, e.g., in CuIr2_2S4_4. Most probably, in this case we have rich multiplet structure in the cluster and an interplay between different degrees of freedom. Thus, volume expansion (or thermal activation) changes the electronic state considerably by (i) redistributing electrons among the molecular and localized orbitals in the cluster, (ii) transforming their wavefunctions, e.g. going from the MO-LCAO-like to the HL-like state, or (iii) even activating other multiplets. The last option is complete destruction of clusters immediately above TsT_{\mathrm{s}}. This situation appears rather rare. A single documented case from PDF analysis is IrTe2_2 [191, 192], while extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) seems to suggest locally persisting Ir-Ir dimers above TsT_{\mathrm{s}} [193].

In electrochemistry the scanning transmission electron microscopy is routinely used for direct visualization of atomic structure. It was proven to be extremely helpful in studying formation of clusters, disorder effects, see, e.g., [114], and can supplement PDF analysis.

Finally, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is sensitive to the local symmetry and the occupation of valence dd-orbitals since they strongly affect the electric field gradient (EFG) tensor at the nucleus. The NMR shift typically clearly signals the transition to the nonmagnetic state that often accompanies Peierls transitions [194, 195, 196]. Moreover, besides detecting Peierls transitions, NMR can also provide information about the character of involved orbitals via studying anisotropic tensors of Knight shift and quadrupole splitting frequency, see e.g. [108].

Pressure effect. This is a rather typical situation for Mott insulators: external pressure increases the overlap between dd orbitals and therefore their bandwidth WW, while the on-site Coulomb repulsion (Hubbard UU) decreases due to increased screening. Consequently, the W/UW/U ratio grows, and pressure typically lowers the temperature of the metal-insulator transition [197].

In clusterized materials, the situation can be just the opposite. The formation of clusters often leads to reduced volume, and such states can therefore be stabilized by pressure. E.g. chemical pressure due to substitution of Na by a smaller Li ion increases temperature of structural transition in LiTiSi2_2O6_6 with respect to NaTiSi2_2O6_6 [16]. The whole system remains insulating in this case, while electrons can fluctuate between sites within the cluster, like it happens e.g. in LiZn2_2Mo3_3O8_8 [122, 123]. Thus, one may expect very different behavior in these systems, with pressure working for the insulating phase rather than against it.

This is exactly what happens in LiV2_2O4_4, where pressure induces a metal-insulator transition and structural study clearly demonstrate formation of short V-V bonds under pressure[198]

However, there is another factor which should always be taken into account when we discuss pressure effect. This is the tendency to move toward a truly three-dimensional situation, characterized by a large bandwidth along all directions and suppressed nesting. These two mechanisms will counteract each other and affect the temperature of the metal-insulator transition.

Orbital selectivity. Another very important aspect of the orbital-induced Peierls transition is the electronic structure of the low-temperature phase. Two very different scenarios are possible.

First, all electrons form molecular orbitals, as occurs in, e.g., LiVO2_2, LiVS2_2, or Na2_2Ti3_3Cl8_8 with a trimerized triangular lattice. In these compounds, each V or Ti ion with a d2d^2 configuration has two neighbors in the trimer, and these two electrons participate in two molecular orbitals, see Figure 11(a). So altogether we have 3 molecular orbitals and 6 electrons occupying all of them as shown in Figure 11(b).

A very different situation is found in MoO2_2 (4d24d^2) with a rutile structure, where dimers rather than trimers are formed. Due to the common-edge geometry, only one of the t2gt_{2g} orbitals can form a molecular orbital due to direct t2gt_{2g}–t2gt_{2g} overlap. Consequently, orbital-selective behavior is anticipated, where some orbitals provide localized or metallic electrons while others participate in molecular bonding [84, 199]. Case of MoO2_2 with two electrons per site is illustrated in Figure 11(d). Orbital selectivity in MoO2_2 results in the coexistence of metallic conductivity and Peierls distortions [23, 82]. This behaviour is seen in many systems, including cluster-Mott insulator LiZn2_2Mo3_3O8_8 [123], high-TcT_c superconductor La3_3Ni2_2O7_7 [200], and others. Effect of orbital selectivity should be explicitly taken into account in such systems, since only part of the electronic subsystem will be able to respond to external perturbations such as a magnetic field or an electric current (this will be reflected e.g. in field and temperature behavior of the magnetic susceptibility).

Future Outlook

In the present review, the current understandings and the research trends on the orbital-induced Peierls transitions and the related effects are discussed based on the rich literature. The multimer or cluster formation in various transition-metal compounds can be described by the orbital-induced Peierls mechanism in which the (band) Jahn-Teller instability and the Peierls instability occur in a synergetic manner. Yet there are many unsolved mysteries related to the orbital-induced Peierls transition. In particular, the fluctuations above the transition temperature or beyond the critical pressure are insufficiently explored. Development of the experimental techniques on modern X-ray and neutron sources is expected to play vital roles to probe such fluctuations with higher energy, momentum, time, and space resolutions. It is highly challenging to theoretically describe the spin-charge-orbital-lattice fluctuations and their possible impacts on exotic superconducting states that often emerge in the proximity to the multimer states. The orbital-induced transitions often occurs near the room temperature and are accompanied by the huge entropy and lattice changes, which can be controlled by electric, magnetic, optical, and thermal stimuli. In the context of materials development, such phase transitions can be applied for future energy transformation and storage devices.

Acknowledgments

We would like to devote this review to Daniel Khomskii our friend and teacher.

SVS thanks Paul Attfield, Simon Billinge, Emil Bozin, Martin Jansen, Klim Kugel, and Stephen Wilson for fruitful discussions. TM thanks Naoyuki Katayama for informative discussions. SVS was supported by Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation through IMP UrD RAS. TM was supported by Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research (No. JP26K00663) from Japan Society for the Promotion of Science.

Competing Interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

References

References

  1. [1]According to some accounts, this effect was first derived by Rudolf Peierls in the early 1930s while drafting a textbook on solid-state physics, which was eventually published in 1955 [5]. Others attribute it to his lecture notes from the 1953 Les Houches School of Physics [201].
  2. [2]Comès, R., Lambert, M., Launois, H. & Zeller, H. R. Evidence for a Peierls distortion or a Kohn anomaly in one-dimensional conductors of the type K2Pt(CN)4Br0.30·xH2O. Physical Review B 8, 571–575 (1973).
  3. [3]Monçeau, P., Ong, N. P., Portis, A. M., Meerschaut, A. & Rouxel, J. Electric field breakdown of charge-density-wave–induced anomalies in NbSe3. Physical Review Letters 37, 602–606 (1976).DOI
  4. [4]Dumas, J., Schlenker, C., Marcus, J. & Buder, R. Nonlinear conductivity and noise in the quasi one-dimensional blue bronze K0.30MoO3. Physical Review Letters 50, 757–760 (1983).DOI
  5. [5]Peierls, R. E. Quantum Theory of Solids. International Series of Monographs on Physics Ser (Oxford University Press, Incorporated, Oxford, 1996).
  6. [6]Khomksii, D. I. Basic Aspects of the Quantum Theory of Solids: Order and Elementary Excitations (Cambridge university press, New York, 2010).
  7. [7]Pouget, J.-P. The Peierls instability and charge density wave in one-dimensional electronic conductors. Comptes Rendus Physique 17, 332–356 (2016).DOI
  8. [8]Jérôme, D. & Schulz, H. Organic conductors and superconductors. Advances in Physics 31, 299–490 (1982).
  9. [9]Fazekas, P. Lecture Notes on Electron Correlation and Magnetism (World Scientific, 1999).
  10. [10]Streltsov, S. V. & Khomskii, D. I. Orbital physics in transition metal compounds: New trends. Physics-Uspekhi 60, 1121 (2017).DOI
  11. [11]Kulik, K. I. & Khomskii, D. I. The Jahn-Teller Effect and Magnetism: Transition Metal Compounds. Soviet Physics Uspekhi 25, 4, 231–256 (1982). 10.3367/UFNr.0136.198204c.063.
  12. [12]Khomskii, D. I. & Mizokawa, T. Orbitally induced Peierls state in spinels. Physical Review Letters 94, 156402 (2005).
  13. [13]Isobe, M. & Ueda, Y. Observation of phase transition from metal to spin-singlet insulator in MgTi2O4 with s=1/2 pyrochlore lattice. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 71, 1848–1851 (2002).DOI
  14. [14]Janninck, R. & Whitmore, D. Electrical conductivity and thermoelectric power of niobium dioxide. Journal of Physics and Chemistry of Solids 27, 1183–1187 (1966).
  15. [15]Eyert, V. The metal-insulator transition of NbO2: An embedded Peierls instability. Europhysics Letters 58, 851 (2001). cond-mat/0106137.DOI
  16. [16]Isobe, M., Ninomiya, E., Vasilev, A. N. & Ueda, Y. Novel phase transition in spin-1/2 linear chain systems: NaTiSi2O6 and LiTiSi2O6. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 71, 1423–1426 (2002).DOI
  17. [17]Wezel, J. V. & Brink, J. V. D. Orbital-assisted Peierls state in NaTiSi2O6. Europhysics Letters (EPL) 75, 957 (2006).
  18. [18]Streltsov, S., Popova, O. & Khomskii, D. Comment on ”sodium pyroxene NaTiSi2O6: Possible Haldane spin-1 chain system”. Physical Review Letters 96 (2006).
  19. [19]Feiguin, A. E., Tsvelik, A. M., Yin, W. & Bozin, E. S. Quantum liquid with strong orbital fluctuations: The case of a pyroxene family. Physical Review Letters 123, 237204 (2019).DOI
  20. [20]Takeda, K., Miyake, K., Takeda, K. & Hirakawa, K. Phase transition in NaTiO2: A candidate for S=1/2 triangular Heisenberg antiferromagnet. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 61, 2156–2157 (1992).
  21. [21]Clarke, S. J., Fowkes, A. J., Harrison, A., Ibber son, R. M. & Rosseinsky, M. J. Synthesis, structure, and magnetic properties of NaTiO2. Chemistry of Materials 10, 372–384 (1998).
  22. [22]Magnéli, A., Andersson, G., Sundkvist, G. & Sundkvist, G. On the MoO2 structure type. Acta Chemica Scandinavica 9, 1378–1381 (1955).DOI
  23. [23]Eyert, V., Horny, R., Höck, K.-H. & Horn, S. Embedded Peierls instability and the electronic structure of MoO2. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 12, 4923 (2000).
  24. [24]Hinz, D. J., Meyer, G., Dedec ke, T. & Urland, W. Na2Ti3Cl8: From isolated Ti2+ ions to [Ti3]6+ clusters. Angewandte Chemie International Edition in English 34, 71–73 (1995).DOI
  25. [25]Hanni, N., Frontzek, M., Hauser, J., Cheptiakov, D. & Kramer, K. Low temperature phases of Na2Ti3Cl8 revisited. Zeitschrift für anorganische und allgemeine Chemie 643, 2063–2069 (2017).
  26. [26]Kelly, Z. A., Tran, T. T. & McQueen, T. M. Nonpolar-to-polar trimerization transitions in the S = 1 kagomé magnet Na2Ti3Cl8. Inorganic Chemistry 58, 11941–11948 (2019).DOI
  27. [27]Khomskii, D. I., Mizokawa, T. & Streltsov, S. V. Comment on ”Spin-lattice coupling and the emergence of the trimerized phase in the S=1 kagome antiferromagnet Na2Ti3Cl8”. Physical Review Letters 127 (2021).
  28. [28]Bongers, P. F. Structuur En Magnetische Eigenschappen van Enkele Complexe Oxyden Der Overgangselementen. Ph.D. thesis, The University of Leiden, Leiden (1957).
  29. [29]Pen, H. F., van den Brink, J., Khomskii, D. I. & Sawatzky, G. A. Orbital ordering in a two-dimensional triangular lattice. Physical Review Letters 78, 1323–1326 (1997).
  30. [30]Ponosov, Y. S. et al. Raman study of the structural transition in LiVO2. Physical Review B 110, 214104 (2024).
  31. [31]Yun, S. et al. Direct observation of V-trimers in the crystal structure of LiVO2. Communications Chemistry 8, 202 (2025).DOI
  32. [32]Khomskii, D. I. & Streltsov, S. V. Orbital effects in solids: Basics, recent progress, and opportunities. Chemical Reviews 121, 2992–3030 (2021).
  33. [33]Kajita, T. et al. Opening of a charge gap with V trimerization in BaV₁₀O₁₅. Physical Review B 81, 060405 (2010).DOI
  34. [34]Takubo, K. et al. Orbital states of V trimers in BaV₁₀O₁₅ detected by resonant x-ray scattering. Physical Review B 86, 085141 (2012).
  35. [35]Yoshino, T. et al. Unusual valence state and metal-insulator transition in BaV₁₀O₁₅ probed by hard x-ray photoemission spectroscopy. Physical Review B 95 (2017).DOI
  36. [36]Matsuno, K. et al. Charge ordering and spin frustration in AlV₂−xCrₓO₄. Physical Review Letters 90, 096404 (2003).
  37. [37]Browne, A. J., Kimber, S. A. J. & Attfield, J. P. Persistent three- and four-atom orbital molecules in the spinel AlV₂O₄. Physical Review Materials 1, 052003 (2017).
  38. [38]Okawa, M. et al. Charge disproportionation for trimerization and tetramerization in spinel-type AlV₂O₄. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 93, 074709 (2024).DOI
  39. [39]Browne, A. J., Lithgow, C., Kimber, S. A. J. & Attfield, J. P. Orbital molecules in the new spinel GaV₂O₄. Inorganic Chemistry 57, 2815–2822 (2018).DOI
  40. [40]Murray, H. H., Kelty, S. P., Chianelli, R. R. & Day, C. S. Structure of rhenium disulfide. Inorganic Chemistry 33, 4418–4420 (1994).
  41. [41]Lamfers, H.-J., Meetsma, A., Wiegers, G. A. & Boer, J. L. D. The crystal structure of some rhenium and technetium dichalcogenides. Journal of Alloys and Compounds 241, 34–39 (1996).DOI
  42. [42]Jobic, S. et al. Crystal and electronic band structure of irte2: Evidence of anionic bonds in a cdi2-like arrangement. Zeitschrift für anorganische und allgemeine Chemie 598, 199–215 (1991).DOI
  43. [43]Matsumoto, N., Taniguchi, K., Endoh, R., Takano, H. & Nagata, S. Resistance and susceptibility anomalies in IrTe₂ and CuIr₂Te₄. Journal of Low Temperature Physics 117, 1129–1133 (1999).DOI
  44. [44]Ootsuki, D. et al. Orbital degeneracy and Peierls instability in the triangular-lattice superconductor Ir₁−xPtₓTe₂. Physical Review B 86, 014519 (2012).
  45. [45]Hirai, D., Takayama, T., Hashizume, D. & Takagi, H. Metal-Insulator Transition and Superconductivity Induced by Rh Doping in the Binary Pnictides RuPn (Pn = P, As, Sb). Physical Review B 85, 14, 145009 (2012).DOI
  46. [46]Koch, R. J., Aryal, N., Ivashko, O., Liu, Y., Abeykoon, M., Bauer, E. D., Zimmermann, M. V., Yin, W., Petrovic, C. & Bozin, E. S. Fluctuating Ru Trimer Precursor to a Two-Stage Electronic Transition in RuP. Physical Review B 106, 21, 214516 (2022).DOI
  47. [47]Hirai, D., Kojima, K., Katayama, N., Kawamura, M., Nishio-Hamane, D. & Hiroi, Z. Linear Trimer Molecule Formation by Three-Center–Four-Electron Bonding in a Crystalline Solid RuP. Journal of the American Chemical Society 144, 39, 17857–17864 (2022).DOI
  48. [48]Okamoto, Y. et al. Band jahn-teller instability and formation of valence bond solid in a mixed-valent spinel oxide LiRh₂O₄. Physical Review Letters 101, 086404 (2008).
  49. [49]Knox, K. R. et al. Local structural evidence for strong electronic correlations in spinel LiRh₂O₄. Physical Review B 88, 174114 (2013).DOI
  50. [50]Radaelli, P. G. et al. Formation of isomorphic ir3+ and ir4+ octamers and spin dimerization in the spinel CuIr₂S₄. Nature 416, 155–158 (2002).
  51. [51]Ohashi, T. et al. Reexamination of the charge-ordered dimer pattern in the spinel compound CuIr₂S₄ using single-crystal synchrotron x-ray diffraction. Physical Review B 111, 224114 (2025).DOI
  52. [52]Bozin, E. S. et al. Local orbital degeneracy lifting as a precursor to an orbital-selective Peierls transition. Nature Communications 10, 3638 (2019).DOI
  53. [53]Kojima, K., Katayama, N., Tamura, S., Shiomi, M. & Sawa, H. Vanadium trimers randomly aligned along the c-axis direction in layered LiVO₂. Physical Review B 100, 235120 (2019).DOI
  54. [54]Browne, A. J. & Attfield, J. P. Orbital molecules in vanadium oxide spinels. Physical Review B 101, 024112 (2020).
  55. [55]Koch, R. J. et al. Dual orbital degeneracy lifting in a strongly correlated electron system. Physical Review Letters 126, 186402 (2021).DOI
  56. [56]Kojima, K. et al. Short-range order and increased transition temperature in LiVO₂ with weakened trimer frustration. Physical Review B 107, L020101 (2023).DOI
  57. [57]Attfield, J. P. Orbital Molecules in Electronic Materials. APL Materials 3, 4 (2015).
  58. [58]Kimber, S. A. J. et al. Valence bond liquid phase in the honeycomb lattice material Li₂RuO₃. Physical Review B 89, 081408 (2014).DOI
  59. [59]Momma, K. & Izumi, F. VESTA 3 for three-dimensional visualization of crystal, volumetric and morphology data. Journal of Applied Crystallography 44, 1272 (2011).DOI
  60. [60]Coulson, C. A. & Fischer, I. XXIV. Notes on the molecular orbital treatment of the hydrogen molecule. Philosophical Magazine 40, 386 (1949).DOI
  61. [61]Hase, M., Terasaki, I. & Uchinokura, K. Observation of the spin-Peierls transition in linear Cu²⁺ (spin-1/2) chains in an inorganic compound CuGeO₃. Physical Review Letters 70, 3651–3654 (1993).
  62. [62]Bulaevskii, L. N. Buzdin, A. I. & Khomskii, D. I. Spin-Peierls transition in magnetic field. Solid State Communications 27, 5–10 (1978).
  63. [63]Buzdin, A. I. & Bulaevskii, L. N. Spin-Peierls transition in quasi-one-dimensional crystals. Soviet Physics Uspekhi 23, 409–417 (1980).
  64. [64]Pati, S. K., Singh, R. R. P. & Khomskii, D. I. Alternating Spin and Orbital Dimerization and Spin-Gap Formation in Coupled Spin-Orbital Systems. Physical Review Letters 81, 5406–5409 (1998).DOI
  65. [65]Horsh, P., Khaliullin, G. & Olés, A. M. Dimerization versus Orbital-Moment Ordering in a Mott Insulator YVO₃. Physical Review Letters 91, 257203 (2003).
  66. [66]Bulaevskii, L. N. Peierls structure transition in quasi-one-dimensional crystals. Soviet Physics Uspekhi 18, 131–150 (1975).
  67. [67]Lloyd, P. Exactly solvable model of electronic states in a three-dimensional disordered Hamiltonian: Non-existence of localized states. Journal of Physics C: Solid State Physics 2, 1717–1725 (1969).DOI
  68. [68]Thouless, D. J. A relation between the density of states and range of localization for one dimensional random systems. Journal of Physics C: Solid State Physics 5, 77–81 (1972).DOI
  69. [69]Lee, P. A., Rice, T. M. & Anderson, P. W. Fluctuation effects at a Peierls transition. Physical Review Letters 31, 462–465 (1973).
  70. [70]Morin, F. J. Oxides which show a metal-to-insulator transition at the Neel temperature. Physical Review Letters 3, 34–36 (1959).DOI
  71. [71]Haverkort, M. W. et al. Determination of the orbital mo ment and crystal-field splitting in LaTiO3. Physical Review Letters 94, 056401 (2005).
  72. [72]Biermann, S., Poteryaev, A., Lichtenstein, A. I. & Georges, A. Dynamical singlets and correlation-assisted Peierls transition in VO₂. Physical Review Letters 94, 026404 (2005).
  73. [73]Aetukuri, N. B. et al. Control of the metal-insulator transition in vanadium dioxide by modifying orbital occupancy. Nature Physics 9, 661–666 (2013).
  74. [74]Kim, S., Kim, K., Kang, C.-J. & Min, B. I. Correlation-assisted phonon softening and the orbital-selective Peierls transition in VO₂. Physical Review B 87, 195106 (2013).DOI
  75. [75]Kumar, S., Strachan, J. P. & Williams, R. S. Chaotic dynamics in nanoscale NbO₂ Mott memristors for analogue computing. Nature 548, 318–321 (2017).DOI
  76. [76]Moore, G. C. et al. High-throughput determination of Hubbard u and Hund j values for transition metal oxides via the linear response formalism. Physical Review Materials 8, 014409 (2024).DOI
  77. [77]O’Hara, A., Nunley, T. N., Posadas, A. B., Zollner, S. & Demkov, A. A. Electronic and optical properties of NbO₂. Journal of Applied Physics 116, 213705 (2014).
  78. [78]Craco, L. Orbital-selective electronic localization in dimerized NbO₂: From Peierls to Mott. Physical Review B 109, 235136 (2024).DOI
  79. [79]Lakkis, S., Schlenker, C., Chakraverty, B. K., Buder, R. & Marezio, M. Metal-insulator transitions in ti₄o₇ single crystals: Crystal characterization, specific heat, and electron paramagnetic resonance. Physical Review B 14, 1429–1440 (1976).DOI
  80. [80]Leonov, I. et al. Charge order and spin-singlet pair formation in Ti₄O₇. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 18, 10955 (2006).DOI
  81. [81]Taguchi, M. et al. Anomalous state sandwiched between Fermi liquid and charge ordered Mott-insulating phases of Ti₄O₇. Physical Review Letters 104, 106401 (2010).
  82. [82]Rogers, D. B., Shannon, R. D., Sleight, A. W. & Gillson, J. L. Crystal chemistry of metal dioxides with rutile-related structures. Inorganic Chemistry 8, 841–849 (1969).DOI
  83. [83]Stoeberl, V., Abbate, M., Alves, L., dos Santos, C. & Mossanek, R. X-ray spectroscopy and electronic structure of MoO₂. Journal of Alloys and Compounds 691, 138–143 (2017).
  84. [84]Streltsov, S. & Khomskii, D. Orbital-dependent singlet dimers and orbital-selective Peierls transitions in transition-metal compounds. Physical Review B 89, 161112 (2014).DOI
  85. [85]Hodeau, J.-L. & Marezio, M. The crystal structure of V₄O₇ at 120°K. Journal of Solid State Chemistry 23, 253–263 (1978).
  86. [86]Botana, A. S., Pardo, V., Baldomir, D., Ushakov, A. V. & Khomskii, D. I. Electronic structure of V₄O₇: Charge ordering, metal-insulator transition, and magnetism. Physical Review B 84, 115138 (2011).DOI
  87. [87]Angelkort, J., Schönleber, A. & Van Smaalen, S. Low- and high-temperature crystal structures of Ti₁₁. Journal of Solid State Chemistry 182, 525–531 (2009).
  88. [88]Hillebrecht, H., Ludwig, T. & Thiele, G. About trihalides with TiI₃ chain structure: Proof of pair forming of cations in β-RuCl₃ and RuBr₃ by temperature dependent single crystal x-ray analyses. Zeitschrift für anorganische und allgemeine Chemie 630, 2199–2204 (2004).
  89. [90]Subedi, A. Mott-to-good-enough insulator-insulator transition in LiVO₂. Physical Review B 95, 214119 (2017).DOI
  90. [91]Ozawa, T. C., Kauzlarich, S. M., Bieringer, M. & Greedan, J. E. Possible Charge-Density-Wave/Spin-Density-Wave in the Layered Pnictide-Oxides: Na₂Ti₂Pn₂O (Pn = As, Sb). Chemistry of Materials 13, 5, 1804–1810 (2001).DOI
  91. [92]Davies, N. R., Johnson, R. D., Princep, A. J., Gannon, L. A., Ma, J.-Z., Qian, T., Richard, P., Li, H., Shi, M., Nowell, H., Baker, P. J., Shiy, Y. G., Ding, H., Luo, J., Guo, Y. F. & Boothroyd, A. T. Coupled Commensurate Charge Density Wave and Lattice Distortion in Na₂Ti₂Pn₂O (Pn = As, Sb) Determined by X Ray Diffraction and Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy. Physical Review B 94, 10, 104515 (2016).
  92. [93]Ren, M. Q., Yan, Y. J., Jiang, J., Tan, S. Y., Miao, J., Chen, C., Song, Y., Zhang, C. L., Dai, P. C., Xie, B. P., Zhang, T. & Feng, D. L. Lattice Distortion and Charge Density Wave in Na₂Ti₂Sb₂O Revealed by Scanning Tunnelling Microscopy. Philosophical Magazine 97, 7, 527–534 (2017).DOI
  93. [94]Pyon, S., Kudo, K. & Nohara, M. Superconductivity induced by bond breaking in the triangular lattice of IrTe₂. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 81, 053701 (2012).DOI
  94. [95]Yang, J. J. et al. Charge-orbital density wave and superconductivity in the strong spin-orbit coupled IrTe₂:Pd. Physical Review Letters 108, 116402 (2012).
  95. [96]Pascut, G. L. et al. Dimerization-induced cross-layer quasi-two-dimensionality in metallic IrTe₂. Physical Review Letters 112, 086402 (2014).DOI
  96. [97]Toriyama, T. et al. Switching of conducting planes by partial dimer formation in IrTe₂. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 83, 033701 (2014).DOI
  97. [98]Takubo, K. et al. Commensurate versus incommensurate charge ordering near the superconducting dome in Ir₁₋ₓPtₓTe₂ revealed by resonant x-ray scattering. Physical Review B 97, 205142 (2018).
  98. [99]Ootsuki, D. et al. Electronic Structure Reconstruction by Orbital Symmetry Breaking in IrTe₂. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 82, 093704 (2013).
  99. [100]Oh, Y. S., Yang, J. J., Horibe, Y. & Cheong, S.-W. Anionic depolymerization transition in IrTe₂. Physical Review Letters 110, 127209 (2013).
  100. [101]Artyukhin, S. Towards modeling of VBS states in IrTe₂. Talk presented at Spin-Orbit Entangled Quantum Magnetism (2024).
  101. [102]Oike, H., Kamitani, M., Tokura, Y. & Kagawa, F. Kinetic approach to superconductivity hidden behind a competing order. Science Advances 4, eaau3489 (2018).DOI
  102. [103]Mizokawa, T. et al. Domain dependent Fermi arcs observed in a striped phase dichalcogenide. Advanced Quantum Technologies 5, 2200029 (2022).
  103. [104]Nicholson, C. W. et al. Bonding states underpinning structural transitions in IrTe₂ observed with micro-ARPES. Physical Review B 110, 205123 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2407.09317
  104. [105]Ideta, S. et al. Ultrafast dissolution and creation of bonds in IrTe₂ induced by photodoping. Science Advances 4, eaar3867 (2018).DOI
  105. [106]Rüdorff, W. & Becker, H. Notizen: Über Umsetzun- gen des Vanadin(iii)Oxyds und des Vanadin(iv)Oxyds mit Einigen Metalloxyds. Zeitschrift für Naturforschung B 9, 613–614 (1954).
  106. [107]Tian, W. et al. Single crystal growth and characterization of new nearly stoichiometric LiVO₂. Materials Research Bulletin 39, 1319–1328 (2004).
  107. [108]Jin-no, T., Shimizu, Y., Itoh, M., Niitaka, S. & Takagi, H. Orbital reformation with vanadium trimerization in d² triangular lattice LiVO₂ revealed by ⁵¹V NMR. Physical Review B 87, 075135 (2013).DOI
  108. [109]Pen, H. F. et al. Phase transition in LiVO₂ studied by near-edge x-ray-absorption spectroscopy. Physical Review B 55, 15500–15505 (1997).
  109. [110]Katayama, N. et al. Anomalous metallic state in the vicinity of metal to valence-bond solid insulator transition in LiVS₂. Physical Review Letters 103, 146405 (2009).
  110. [111]Tanaka, T. et al. Trimer V³⁺ spin singlet state and pseudo gap in LiVS₂ studied by ⁵¹V and ⁷Li nuclear magnetic resonance. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 78, 054709 (2009).DOI
  111. [112]Katayama, N. et al. Slow dynamics of disordered zigzag chain molecules in layered LiVS₂ under electron irradiation. npj Quantum Materials 6, 16 (2021).DOI
  112. [113]James, A. & Goodenough, J. Structure and bonding in Li₂MoO₃ and Li₂−xMoO₃ (0 ≤ x ≤ 1.7). Journal of Solid State Chemistry 76, 87–96 (1988).DOI
  113. [114]Savina, A. A. et al. Chemical, local molybdenum clustering, and electrochemistry in the Li₂+xMo₁−xO₃ solid solutions. Inorganic Chemistry 61, 5637–5652 (2022).DOI
  114. [115]Schwarzmüller, S., Wurst, K., Heymann, G. & Huppertz, H. Pressure-assisted synthesis of highly crystalline 1T″-LiₓMoS₂. Chemistry – A European Journal 30, e202302565 (2024).DOI
  115. [116]Vitoux, L. et al. NaMoO₂: a layered oxide with molybdenum clusters. Inorganic Chemistry 59, 4015–4023 (2020).DOI
  116. [117]Knowles, A. & Ganesh, R. Novel network model for d³ transition metal dichalcogenides in the 1T structure: Holography from local constraints. Physical Review B 112, 075101 (2025).
  117. [118]Paul, A., Chung, C. M., Birol, T. & Changlani, H. J. Spin-lattice coupling and the emergence of the trimerized phase in the s=1 kagome antiferromagnet Na₂Ti₃Cl₈. Physical Review Letters 124, 167203 (2020).
  118. [119]Sheckelton, J. P., Neilson, J. R., Soltan, D. G. & Mcqueen, T. M. Possible valence-bond condensation in the frustrated cluster magnet Li₂Zn₂Mo₃O₈. Nature Materials 11, 493–496 (2012).DOI
  119. [120]Mourigal, M. et al. Molecular quantum magnetism in Li₂Zn₂Mo₃O₈. Physical Review Letters 112, 27202 (2014).
  120. [121]Chen, C.-W., Choe, J. & Morosan, E. Charge density waves in strongly correlated electron systems. Reports on Progress in Physics 79, 084505 (2016).
  121. [122]Nikolaev, S. A., Solovyev, I. V. & Streltsov, S. V. Quantum spin liquid and cluster mott insulator phases in the Mo₃O₈ magnets. npj Quantum Materials 6, 25 (2021).DOI
  122. [123]Streltsov, S. V. et al. Beyond a cluster-Mott state in the breathing kagome lattice of LiZn₂Mo₃O₈. Physical Review B 111, 085124 (2025).DOI
  123. [124]COTTON, F. A. & ROTH, W. J. CHEMInform abstract: Preparation and structure of Nb₃Cl₈(CNCMe₃)₅. Chem-Inform 18 (1987).DOI
  124. [125]Ströbele, M., Glaser, J., Lachgar, A. & Meyer, H.-J. Struktur und elektrochemische untersuchung von Nb₃Cl₈. Zeitschrift für anorganische und allgemeine Chemie 627, 2002–2004 (2001).doi.org/10.1002/1521-3749(200108)627:8<2002::aid-zaac2002>3.0.co;2-c
  125. [126]Haraguchi, Y. et al. Magnetic - nonmagnetic phase transition with interlayer charge disproportionation of Nb₃ trimers in the cluster compound Nb₃Cl₈. Inorganic Chemistry 56, 3483 (2017).
  126. [127]Zhang, Y., Lin, L.-F., Moreo, A. & Dagotto, E. Electronic structure, dimer physics, orbital-selective behavior, and magnetic tendencies in the bilayer nickelate superconductor La₃Ni₂O₇ under pressure. Physical Review B 108, L180510 (2023).
  127. [128]Sheckelton, J. P., Plumb, K. W., Trump, B. A., Broholm, C. L. & McQueen, T. M. Rearrangement of van der Waals stacking and formation of a singlet state at T = 90 K in a cluster magnet. Inorganic Chemistry Frontiers 4, 481–490 (2017).
  128. [129]Pasco, C. M., El Baggari, I., Bianco, E., Kourkoutis, L. F. & McQueen, T. M. Magnetic transition to a singlet ground state in a 2d van der waals layered trimerized kagomé magnet. ACS Nano 13, 9457–9463 (2019).
  129. [130]Nakamura, R. et al. Charge fluctuations in a cluster mott state: Hard x-ray photoemission study on a breathing kagome magnet Nb₃Cl₈. Physical Review B 110, L081109 (2024).
  130. [131]Aretz, J. et al. From strong to weak correlations in breathing-mode kagome van der waals materials: Nb₃(F, Cl, Br, I)₈ as a robust and versatile platform for many-body engineering. Physical Review X 15, 041042 (2025).DOI
  131. [132]Ogawa, S. Magnetic transition in TiCl₃. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 15, 1901 (1960).DOI
  132. [133]Pei, S. et al. Orbital-fluctuation freezing and magnetic-nonmagnetic phase transition in α-TiBr₃. Applied Physics Letters 133103, 113 (2020).DOI
  133. [134]Gapansev, V. V., Gazizova, D. D. & Streltsov, S. V. Dimerization in α-TiCl₃ and α-TiBr₃: the DFT study. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 33, 495803 (2021).
  134. [135]Motizuki, K., Miyata, S. & Suzuki, N. The theoretical study of the phase transition in layer compound TiCl₃. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 45, 1613–1621 (1978).
  135. [136]Ushakov, A., Solovyev, I. & Streltsov, S. V. Can the highly symmetric SU(4) spin-orbital model be realized in α-ZrCl₃? JETP Letters 112, 642–646 (2020).
  136. [137]Yamada, M. G., Oshikawa, M. & Jackeli, G. Emergent SU(4) symmetry in α-ZrCl₃ and crystalline spin-orbital liquids. Physical Review Letters 121, 97201 (2018).
  137. [138]Yamamoto, H., Kamiyama, S., Yamada, I. & Kimura, H. Cation dimerization in a 3d¹ honeycomb lattice system. Journal of the American Chemical Society 144, 1082–1086 (2022).
  138. [139]Yamamoto, H. et al. ZnVO₃: an ilmenite-type vanadium oxide hosting robust V-V dimers. Dalton Trans. 53, 16195–16201 (2024).
  139. [140]Foyevtsova, K., Jeschke, H. O., Mazin, I. I., Khomskii, D. I. & Valent, R. Ab initio analysis of the tight-binding parameters and magnetic interactions in Na₂IrO₃. Physical Review B 88, 035107 (2013).
  140. [141]Bastien, G. et al. Pressure-induced dimerization and valence bond crystal formation in the Kitaev-Heisenberg magnet α-RuCl₃. Physical Review B 97, 241108 (2018).
  141. [142]Shen, B. et al. Magnetic versus nonmagnetic polymorphs of RuBr₃ under pressure. Physical Review B 109, 224402 (2024).
  142. [143]Hermann, V. et al. Competition between spin-orbit coupling, magnetism, and dimerization in the honeycomb iridates: A-Li₂IrO₃ under pressure. Physical Review B 97, 20104 (2018). Jin, C. et al. Pressure-induced dimerization and crossover from negative to positive magnetoresistance in Ag₃LiIr₂O₆. Physical Review B 109, 094411 (2024).
  143. [145]Hu, K., Zhou, Z., Wei, Y.-W., Li, C.-K. & Feng, J. Bond ordering and phase transitions in Na₂IrO₃ under high pressure. Physical Review B 98, 100103 (2018).
  144. [146]Xu, Y. et al. Pressure-induced structural evolution with a turnover point in the honeycomb iridate Na₂IrO₃. The Journal of Physical Chemistry C 127, 20177–20182 (2023).
  145. [147]Miura, Y., Yasui, Y., Sato, M., Igawa, N. & Kakurai, K. New-type phase transition of Li₂RuO₃ with honeycomb structure. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 76, 033705 (2007).
  146. [148]Miura, Y., Sato, M., Yamakawa, Y., Habaguchi, T. & Ono, Y. Structural transition of Li₂RuO₃ induced by molecular-orbit formation. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 78, 094706 (2009).
  147. [149]McArdle, P. et al. Orbital-selective metallicity in the valence-bond liquid phase of Li₂RuO₃. Physical Review B 105, 245148 (2022).
  148. [150]Poineau, F. et al. β-technetium trichloride: Formation, structure, and first-principles calculations. Inorganic Chemistry 51, 4915–4917 (2012).
  149. [151]Jackeli, G. & Khomskii, D. I. Classical Dimers and Dimerized Superstructure in an Orbitally Degenerate Honeycomb Antiferromagnet. Physical Review Letters 100, 147203 (2008).
  150. [152]Schäfer, H. et al. Neue untersuchungen über die chloride des molybdäns. Zeitschrift für anorganische und allgemeine Chemie 353, 281–310 (1967).
  151. [153]Hillebrecht, H. et al. Structural and scanning microscopy studies of layered compounds MCl₃ (M = Mo, Ru, Cr) and MOCl₂ (M = V, Nb, Mo, Ru, Os). Journal of Alloys and Compounds 246, 70–79 (1997).
  152. [154]McGuire, M. A. et al. High-temperature magnetostructural transition in van der waals-layered α-MoCl₃. Physical Review Materials 1, 064001 (2017).
  153. [155]Hiley, C. I. et al. Ruthenium(v) oxides from low-temperature hydrothermal synthesis. Angewandte Chemie - International Edition 53, 4423–4427 (2014).
  154. [156]Marchandier, T. et al. Magnetic and intercalation properties of BaRu₂O₆ and SrRu₂O₆ (2020). Chemistry of Materials 32, 8471–8480 (2020).
  155. [157]Prasad, B. E. et al. AgRuO₃, a strongly exchange coupled honeycomb compound lacking long range magnetic order. Chemistry - A European Journal 23, 1521 (2017).
  156. [158]Streltsov, S., Mazin, I. & Foyevtsova, K. Localized itinerant electrons and unique magnetic properties of SrRu₂O₆. Physical Review B 92, 134408 (2015).
  157. [159]Schnelle, W. et al. Magnetic and electronic ordering phenomena in the Ru₂O₆-layer honeycomb lattice compound AgRuO₃. Physical Review B 103, 214413 (2021).
  158. [160]Oda, T., Shirai, M., Suzuki, N. & Motizuki, K. Electronic band structure of sulphide spinels CuM₂S₄ (M=Co, Rh, ir). Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 7, 4433 (1995).
  159. [161]Sasaki, T., Arai, M., Furubayashi, T. & Matsumoto, T. Band-structure theory for the insulating phase of the thiospinel transition-metal compound, CuIr₂S₄. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 73, 1875–1880 (2004).
  160. [162]Sarkar, S., De Raychaudhury, M. & Saha-Dasgupta, T. Density-functional study of the electronic and optical properties of the spinel compound CuIr₂S₄. Physical Review B 79, 113104 (2009).
  161. [163]Nagata, S., Hagino, T., Seki, Y. & Bitoh, T. Metal-insulator transition in thiospinel CuIr₂S₄. Physica B: Condensed Matter 194–196, 1077–1078 (1994).
  162. [164]Ishibashi, H. et al. X-ray-induced disordering of the dimerization pattern and apparent low-temperature enhancement of lattice symmetry in spinel CuIr₂S₄. Physical Review B 66, 144424 (2002).
  163. [165]Takubo, K. et al. X-ray photoemission study of CuIr₂S₄:Ir³⁺–Ir⁴⁺ charge ordering and the effect of light illumination. Physical Review Letters 95, 246401 (2005).
  164. [166]Kiryukhin, V. et al. Incommensurate structural correlations in the disordered spin-dimer state induced by x-ray and electron irradiation in CuIr₂S₄. Physical Review Letters 97, 225503 (2006).
  165. [167]Naseska, M. et al. First-order kinetics bottleneck during photoinduced ultrafast insulator–metal transition in 3d orbitally-driven Peierls insulator CuIr₂S₄. New Journal of Physics 23, 053023 (2021).
  166. [168]Nakatsu, Y. et al. Hard x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy of the metal-insulator transition in LiRh₂O₄. Physical Review B 83, 115120 (2011).
  167. [169]Shiomi, M. et al. Charge-ordered state satisfying the Anderson condition in LiRh₂O₄ arising from local dimer order. Physical Review B 105, L041103 (2022).
  168. [170]Schmidt, M. et al. Spin singlet formation in MgTi₂O₄: Evidence of a helical dimerization pattern. Physical Review Letters 92, 056402 (2004).
  169. [171]Di Matteo, S., Jackeli, G., Lacroix, C. & Perkins, N. B. Valence-bond crystal in a pyrochlore antiferromagnet with orbital degeneracy. Physical Review Letters 93, 077208 (2004).
  170. [172]Yang, L. et al. Two-orbital degeneracy lifted local precursor to a metal-insulator transition in MgTi₂O₄. Physical Review B 102, 235128 (2020).
  171. [173]Yamaguchi, T. et al. Electronic structure of spinel-type MgTi₂O₄: Valence change at surface and effect of Fe substitution for Mg. Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 91, 074704 (2022).
  172. [174]Horibe, Y. et al. Spontaneous formation of vanadium “molecules” in a geometrically frustrated crystal: AlV₂O₄. Physical Review Letters 96, 086406 (2006).
  173. [175]Goodenough, J. B. Magnetism and the Chemical Bond. Interscience Monographs on Chemistry: Inorganic Chemistry Section 1, 393 (1963).
  174. [176]Zhidkov, I. S., Belik, A. A., Kukharenko, A. I., Cholakh, S. O., Taran, L. S., Fujimori, A., Streltsov, S. V. & Kurmaev, E. Z. Cu-Site Disorder in CuAl₂O₄ as Studied by XPS Spectroscopy. JETP Letters 114, 9 (2021).
  175. [177]Kondo, S. et al. LiV₂O₄: A heavy fermion transition metal oxide. Physical Review Letters 78, 3729–3732 (1997).
  176. [178]Urano, C. et al. LiV₂O₄ spinel as a heavy-mass fermi liquid: Anomalous transport and role of geometrical frustration. Physical Review Letters 85, 1052–1055 (2000).
  177. [179]Anisimov, V. I. et al. Electronic structure of the heavy fermion metal LiV₂O₄. Physical Review Letters 83, 364–367 (1999).
  178. [180]Eyert, V., Höck, K.-H., Horn, S., Loidl, A. & Riseborough, P. S. Electronic structure and magnetic interactions in LiV₂O₄. Europhysics Letters 46, 762 (1999).
  179. [181]Uehara, A., Shinaoka, H. & Motome, Y. Charge-spin-orbital fluctuations in mixed valence spinels: Comparative study of AlV₂O₄ and LiV₂O₄. Physical Review B 92, 195150 (2015).
  180. [183]Georges, A., Krauth, W. & Rozenberg, M. J. Dynamical mean-field theory of strongly correlated fermion systems and the limit of infinite dimensions. Review of Modern Physics 68, 13–125 (1996).
  181. [184]Toriyama, T. et al. Peierls mechanism of the metal-insulator transition in ferromagnetic hollandite K₂Cr₈O₁₆. Physical Review Letters 107, 266402 (2011).
  182. [185]Wickramaratne, D., Bernstein, N. & Mazin, I. I. Role of defects in the metal-insulator transition in VO₂ and V₂O₃. Physical Review B 99, 214103 (2019).
  183. [186]Mlkvik, P., Merkel, M. E., Spaldin, N. A. & Ederer, C. Single-site DFT+DMFT for vanadium dioxide using bond-centered orbitals (2024). 2402.12798.
  184. [187]Kobayashi, K., Kosuge, K. & Kachi, S. Electric and magnetic properties of LiₓV₂₋ₓO₃. Materials Research Bulletin 4, 95–106 (1969).
  185. [188]Redhammer, G. Ü. J., Ohashi, H. & Roth, G. Single-crystal structure refinement of NaTi₂Si₆O₁₆ clinopyroxene at low temperatures (298 < T < 100 K). Acta Crystallographica Section B Structural Science 59, 730–746 (2003).
  186. [189]Senn, M. S., Wright, J. P. & Attfield, J. P. Charge Order and Three-Site Distortions in the Verwey Structure of Magnetite. Nature 481, 7380, 173–176 (2012).
  187. [190]Perversi, G., Pachoud, E., Cumby, J., Hudspeth, J. M., Wright, J. P., Kimberg, S. A. J. & Paul Attfield, J. Co-Emergence of Magnetic Order and Structural Fluctuations in Magnetite. Nature Communications 10, 1, 2857 (2019).
  188. [191]Yu, R. et al. Absence of local fluctuating dimers in superconducting Ir₁₋ₓ(Pt, Rh)ₓTe₂. Physical Review B 97, 174515 (2018).
  189. [192]Yu, R. et al. Phase separation at the dimer-superconductor transition in Ir₁₋ₓRhₓTe₂. Physical Review B 98, 134506 (2018).
  190. [193]Paris, E. et al. Pressure dependence of the local structure of iridium ditelluride across the structural phase transition. Physical Review B 93, 134109 (2016).
  191. [194]Shimizu, Y., Tanaka, M., Itoh, M. & Katsufuji, T. Spin-singlet formation in the geometrically frustrated spinel oxide AlV₂O₄: ⁵¹V and ²⁷Al NMR measurements. Physical Review B 78, 144423 (2008).
  192. [195]Arapova, I. et al. Magnetic properties of Li₂RuO₃ as studied by NMR and LDA + DMFT calculations. JETP Letters 105, 375–379 (2017).
  193. [196]Heimann, I. et al. Orbital disorder and ordering in NaTiSi₂O₆ : ²⁹Si and ²³Na NMR study (2022). Physical Review B 106, 075429 (2020).
  194. [197]Khomskĭi, D. I. Transition Metal Compounds (Cambridge University Press, 2014).
  195. [198]Browne, A. J., Pace, E. J., Garbarino, G. & Attfield, J. P. Structural study of the pressure-induced metal-insulator transition in LiV₂O₄. Physical Review Materials 4, 015002 (2020).
  196. [199]Streltsov, S. V. & Khomskii, D. I. Covalent bonds against magnetism in transition metal compounds. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 113 (2016).
  197. [200]Zhang, Y., Lin, L.-F., Moreo, A. & Dagotto, E. Electronic structure, dimer physics, orbital-selective behavior, and magnetic tendencies in the bilayer nickelate superconductor La₃Ni₂O₇ under pressure. Physical Review B 108, 18, L180510 (2023).
  198. [201]Dalitz, R. H. & Peierls, S. R. Selected Scientific Papers of Sir Rudolf Peierls: (With Commentary), vol. 19 of World Scientific Series in 20th Century Physics (co-published by Imperial college press and World scientific, 1997).

Paper details

vlnc:W_5h3p9qn6
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents