WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Systematic shell model study for and isotones and nuclear isomers
Abstract
In the present work, we have done a systematic shell model study of and isotones. For the isotones, we have performed calculations using SN100PN interaction, while for isotones, we have used KHPE interaction. Similarities between these two isotonic chains have been reported, using the strong resemblance between the high- orbitals. Apart from the nuclear spectroscopic properties, we have also explained different isomeric states in these two regions. In the =82 region, we have mainly discussed the properties of the and isomers, while in the region for , , and isomers. We have reported , , -factor, and quadrupole moments of the isomeric states for comparison in these two isotonic chains.
Introduction
The spectroscopy of and and its neighbors in many ways are similar to each other. Several nuclear structure studies have been done theoretically and experimentally by comparing the spectroscopy. Some similarities have been pointed out in [1–5], showing universal patterns of nuclear structure in both regions. Using the correspondence between the high- orbitals located above the and shell gaps, Astier et al. [6] assigned the isomeric state of as the fully aligned state of the configuration. They used this analogy to assign the isomeric state of with compared to the isomeric state measured in .
The single-particle energy gaps in the two cases are comparably large, and the orbitals above and below the shell gaps are similarly arranged [7]. Every single particle state in the region has its counterpart in the vicinity of . Several groups [1–5, 7, 8] have worked to develop a general theoretical description of nuclear structural properties near and far from the -stability line using the shell model. They have emphasized the desirability of particular comparisons between experimental information around the and look for the corresponding nuclear properties in the region.
In semi-magic nuclei, the seniority quantum number distinguishes between the different nuclear states with identical valence nucleons occupying one orbital or a simple configuration according to the nucleon number [9]. This property provides us with an appropriate framework to establish a similarity between the and regions in terms of the orbital in each model-space using the shell-model wave-function. Seniority is the number of particles not in pairs coupled to angular momentum . In the seniority scheme, the properties of a nucleus can be described from the neighboring isotopes or isotones with the addition or removal of valence nucleons [10–13]. Studies of even-even semi-magic nuclei within the generalized seniority scheme [14–16] have shown that the seniority-zero state can define the ground state. And the seniority states by pairs coupled to two unpaired nucleons represent low-lying excited states.
The region has long been the subject of shell-model studies due to the remarkable regularities exhibited in the low-lying states of these nuclei and also the strong doubly magic character of . This region gives an opportunity over a large number of nuclei ( to 152) to study the effect of adding protons to a doubly magic core. Extensive research of this type was conducted over the past few years with the emergence of the shell when particles and (or) holes were added to the [17, 18]. In this context, experimental data of energy levels and (or) properties for light even-even isotones are rich, and have encouraged many shell-model calculations [19–24]. Shell-model calculations using effective interactions derived from realistic nucleon-nucleon () potentials have been performed in the region with some excellent results [25–29]. The evolution of the low-energy properties of the isotones as a function of has been well reproduced by the theory in some of these studies [26–28].
The lead isotopes and the nuclei have long been the subject of both experimental and theoretical studies. These stable or near stable nuclei have been extensively investigated. A relatively large amount of experimental data is available in this region. While the high-spin states in nuclei near have been studied extensively, data on electromagnetic transition rates between the low-spin states are insufficient. The good doubly magic character of suggests successful shell model results and has motivated many shell-model calculations. On the other hand, the heavy mass region with protons and neutrons filling different major shells offers favorable conditions for the formation of isomeric states due to the presence of high- orbitals. With the close resemblance between proton-neutron multiplets in the and regions, an analogue of [1–4, 30], has led to a new focus on low-spin states in the lead region. The energy levels of , , [1–3] were performed by employing an effective interaction derived from Bonn-A interaction. Using the highlights of previous works by different groups, the structural information and the electromagnetic properties can be predicted with the shell-model calculation for the Sn and Pb region.
There are experimental indications for the similar properties of nuclei belonging to and regions, but no systematic theoretical results are available. Motivated with the recent experimental data for spectroscopic properties, we have performed a systematic shell model study of () and () isotones. The aim of the present paper is to investigate the similarity between and isotones. The present study will add more information to the earlier works.
These two isotonic chains are very rich in terms of nuclear isomers [32, 33] [6, 31]. Thus we have also reported shell model results of nuclear isomers in these two regions. For the region we have discussed and isomers, while for region the , , and isomers. The role of and configurations in the region, while , and configurations in are very crucial to decide nuclear isomers in these two regions.
This paper is organized as follows. In the Sec. II, we present details about theoretical formalism. Comprehensive discussions are reported in Sec. III. In this section, we have discussed spectroscopy of and isotones in terms of seniority. Finally, a summary and conclusions are drawn in Sec. IV.
Formalism: model space and interactions
The shell-model calculations for the isotones have been performed in the 50-82 valence shell composed of the orbits , , , , and using the interaction SN100PN taken from Brown et al. [34] [22]. This interaction has four parts, corresponding to the neutron-neutron, neutron-proton, proton-proton component of the nuclear forces and Coulomb repulsion between the protons. The residual two-body interaction was obtained from the CD-Bonn G-matrix within the so-called -box folded diagram theory and the further part was multiplied by a factor of 0.90 to improve the agreement with the experiment for . The single-particle energies for the neutrons are -10.610, -10.289, -8.717, -8.694, and -8.816 MeV for the , , , , and orbitals, respectively, and those for the protons are 0.807, 1.562, 3.316, 3.224, and 3.605 MeV. We have performed calculations with the SN100PN interaction in some previous studies in this region [35, 36, 37].
The shell-model calculations for the isotones have been performed in the valence shell 82-126 for proton and 126-184 for neutron using the interaction KHPE [38]. The model space here consists of , , , , , proton orbitals and , , , , , , neutron orbitals. The effective realistic residual interaction of Kuo and Herling [39, 40] was derived from a free nucleon-nucleon potential of Hamada and Johnston [41] with renormalization due to the finite extension of model space by the reaction matrix techniques developed by Kuo and Brown [42]. In the present work, we have performed shell model calculations with KHPE interaction without any truncation. Recently, we have performed an extensive calculation for Rn isotopes with the KHPE interaction [43]. In the present work, we have used the shell model code KSHELL [44] for the diagonalization of matrices.
Results and discussion
A even isotones
In Figures 1, 2 we present the calculated energy levels of isotones for even and odd nuclei, respectively, obtained in the 50 – 82 model space in comparison with the experimental data. In the isotones, the states correspond to proton excitations, for which the configurations are built within the proton orbitals (, , , , ). The study of wave functions suggests that for all the low-lying positive-parity states, the valence protons occupy the two orbitals, and . The main configurations of the low-lying positive-parity states correspond to , , and or configuration mixing of these components, where is the number of valence protons. We can simply represent these configurations as . The main structure of negative-parity states in the isotones above is constructed by removing one proton from the model space to the orbital. Then the lowest negative-parity state gives rise to configuration. Our calculation shows that different configurations identify these low-lying states with varied natures. In our calculation, we take the low-lying yrast states, i.e., the assembling of the lowest state for each spin. One can see that the shell-model calculation very well reproduces the experimental energy levels.
The contains two valence protons outside the core. The present calculations reproduce the characteristic of spherical even-even nuclei that there is a large gap of about 1.2 MeV between ground state and the first excited state as shown in Figure 1. The wave functions of the calculated states are pure, indicating the dominance of single-particle excitations in this nucleus. The lowest four states of arise from the configuration. The ground state of may be described by two protons residing in the orbital as one pair coupled to angular momentum , i.e., seniority . For the yrast chain of configuration with seniority , the and levels are also reproduced well. The other positive-parity states with energy between 2-3 MeV from proton excitation within the major shell are reproduced well. These states have the main configuration of , with seniority . The level at 3.055 MeV, which is close to the experimental level at 2.934 MeV, has a configuration of (71%). The negative-parity states are observed above 3.5 MeV. These states belong to the multiplets of , with seniority . The levels of , from the multiplet have good accordance with experimental data in both energy and order.

Figure 1. Comparison of calculated and experimental [45] excitation energy spectra for the even isotones using SN100PN interaction.
The low-lying states in can be well understood in terms of seniority, with a closed neutron shell and four protons beyond the closed shell. The configuration with seniorities and 2 gives rise to a state with and a multiplet with , , , , , in order of increasing energy. These states are well reproduced, with over 50-90% probability of this configuration in the wave functions of the respective calculated states. For the ground state of this contribution amounts to 53%. The wave functions of the states are rather pure with small admixtures, indicating the dominance of single-particle excitations. Different multiplets arising from three protons in the orbital and a single proton in the orbital ( states) and two protons in each orbital ( states) are also possible. The configuration produces a , , , , multiplet, where the even-spin states are reproduced well. The state at 2.262 MeV decays only to the state and not to the state, is observed in [45]. The calculation shows that the states , are the member of the multiplet.
For , the multiplets of are , , , , . However, the contribution of is also not small in the , , and states, with 20-30% probability of this configuration. For the states , , , , , , the leading configuration is , contribution amounts to 40-60%. The state is mainly due to the configuration . The state is mainly due to one-proton excitation from the orbital to , with the predominant configuration of . One can see the state has seniority , and the even parity states as well as the , states have seniority . There are a few pair states which have two or three pairs, such as the , states with seniority . This indicates that the generalized seniority is a good quantum number here.
Ce can be described similarly to Ba with two more protons in the valence space. The , configuration gives rise to , , , , , multiplets. The , configuration produces , , , , multiplet in order of increasing energy. However, these states from the two configuration chain are arising from significant configuration mixing with and , respectively for the two chains, with 12-20% probabilities of these configurations mixing with over 35-45% of the leading configuration. Similar to Ba, the states and are mainly due to one-proton excitation from the orbital to , with the predominant configuration of . The calculation shows that the state is a member of the multiplet.
For Nd, we compare selected calculated levels to their experimental counterparts. The , configuration gives rise to a , , , multiplet. However, these states are arising from significant configuration mixing with with 10-15% probability of this configuration mixing with over 20-35% of the leading configuration. Contrast to Ba and Ce, the states and are mainly due to one-proton excitation from the orbital to and the state is due to one-proton excitation from the orbital to with the predominant configuration of and , respectively. Thus these negative parity states are seniority states.
Interestingly, it can be seen that the isomeric state of Te and Xe is better represented by coupling the octupole phonon to the non-isomeric state rather than to the isomeric state, while the isomeric state of Ba, Ce and Nd, is better represented by coupling the octupole phonon to the isomeric state. Particularly, it was suggested for Xe and Ba in [46]. From this calculation, a broad understanding into the structure of the low-lying levels can be obtained.
odd isotones
I is a single-closed nucleus with three valence protons. The present results well explain those measured experimental energies of the low-lying positive-parity states. Most of the experimental states in I are tentative, and our calculation confirms all the proposed states with spin-parity in correct order. In I, the low-lying energies are obtained mainly in terms of the three configurations, , , and , which are mostly pure states with dominant configuration probability over 75-100%. The lowest-energy configuration can create , , , and . Similar to with seniority in Te, the ground state with seniority single-proton, in I. Our calculated wave functions indicate that the , , , and states have the predominant configuration . The multiplet contains the , , and states where the corresponding compositions are over 90%. These states, therefore, belonged to the single-particle nature. The dominant configuration of the lower state is (). The state is found to be the member of the same multiplet as state, but . The negative-parity states , , and between 3 and 4 MeV are due to one proton excitation from the orbital into the orbital . The predominant configuration is , with seniority .
For Cs, the calculated low-lying yrast states are due to configuration mixing. The , , , , and states have a leading configuration of , but with some differences. The and states are mixed with a considerable amount of component, while this component is small in . The ground state, in which two proton pairs are coupled to the odd proton is seniority state. As in I, the states are , , , and , excitations with a broken pair coupled to a proton in the . In Cs an extra pair of valence protons is available to generate high-spin yrast states. The , , , and states belong to the multiplet with seniority , with a broken pair coupled to a proton in the , except for which is seniority state. The is a member of the , . The negative parity excitations involve one proton from to orbital, with . The negative parity states , , and are multiplets of configuration.
Figure 2. Comparison of calculated and experimental [45] excitation energy spectra for the odd isotones using SN100PN interaction.
For , the calculated low-lying yrast states for to are due to the mixing of several configurations, except for , and , where leading configuration dominates. The , , , , , and states have a leading configuration of , configuration probability ranges from 39-82%. The state is arising from configuration with 24% probability. The ground state and are seniority state, in which proton pairs are coupled to the odd and proton, respectively. The states with , , and states , , are arising due to coupling of or broken pair (or pairs) with . The seniority and , gives rise to the multiplet and , respectively. The , , and states have a leading configuration of , excitations with a broken pair coupled to a proton in the . The negative-parity states are due to one proton excitation from the orbital or into the orbital . The dominant configuration , with seniority gives rise to the multiplet , and . The and are states, with dominant configuration . The state is a state with dominant configuration (41%), and has a significant contribution from (34%) configuration.
For , the excitation energies and ordering of the positive-parity yrast states are well reproduced in the present calculations. The negative parity states are with some discrepancies, as they are compressed in energy with respect to the experimental data. The has similar multiplet structure as , as well the calculated wave functions have a significant admixture of configurations involving excitations of the or orbital. Compared to low-lying states, relatively less configuration mixing is observed at high-lying states. Whereas, in , the number of multiplets and maximum spin achievable is large with an extra pair of valence protons in or orbital. In , state becomes the ground state as the number of protons increases, in which proton pairs are coupled to the odd is a seniority state, with configuration . Similar to , the multiplets are seniority or 5, with a broken pair(s) coupled to a proton in the , with , , , and , where and are states. The multiplets are , , , with and is state. The is a state of configuration, and is a state of configuration. As in with two added protons, the negative-parity states are mainly due to and configurations with seniority . The first group has members , , and states, the states with , and are member of second group.
C even isotones
Isotones with represent an excellent example of the applicability of the seniority scheme with , as the low-lying spectrum follows the seniority scheme for the semi-magic nuclei above the core. Calculations in the entire range of proton configurations using KHPE interaction showed a good agreement with the experimental data. This calculation confirmed the seniority conservation for the isotones up to .
In Figure 3, Figure 4 we present the calculated energy levels of isotones for even and odd nuclei, respectively, obtained in the shell-model configuration space in comparison with the experimental data. In the isotones, the low-lying states correspond to proton excitations, for which the configurations are built within the proton orbitals . The study of wave functions suggests that for all the low-lying positive-parity states, the valence protons occupy the three orbitals, , and . The main configurations of the low-lying positive-parity states correspond to , , , and or combinations of them, where is the number of valence protons. We can simply represent these configurations as . The main structure of negative-parity states in the isotones above is simply constructed by exciting one proton from the model space to the orbital, and also from for odd isotones. Our calculation shows that these low-lying states are identified by different configurations with a combination of mixed and pure states. In our calculation, we take the low-lying yrast states. One can see the experimental energy levels are very well reproduced for the isotones by the shell-model calculation.
Figure 3. Comparison of calculated and experimental [45] excitation energy spectra for the even isotones using KHPE interaction.
Figure 4. Comparison of calculated and experimental [45] excitation energy spectra for the odd isotones using KHPE interaction.
contains two valence protons outside the core. The low-lying yrast states, , , , and are constructed by proton-dominated two-particle excitations of the configuration, in a similar fashion to the situation in . The wave functions of the states are pure, indicating the dominant single-particle excitations in . In contrast, two protons need to occupy the orbital to make states above . The ground state is a seniority state. The states and are seniority states, with one broken proton pair. The state is a member of the configuration and seniority . The state consists of the configuration.
The low-lying states in Rn are made up of four valence protons beyond the closed shell, with a closed neutron shell should be well understood in terms of seniority structure, same as Xe. In the first four excited states and the percentage of the dominant configurations, ranges from 60% to 65% while it becomes 42% in the ground state. All the levels arising from the configuration have a configuration mixing with the and configurations. The ground state of Rn may be described by four protons residing in the orbital as two pairs coupled to angular momentum , i.e., seniority . The excited states are seniority states of one broken pair with the dominant configuration. The excited state dominated by the configuration is a seniority state with one odd proton coupled to , with 71% contribution. The state has a significant mixing with and configurations. The state is dominated by configuration, with over 95% contribution. The is seniority state with the breaking of two proton pairs. The low-lying dominated by configuration is a seniority state.
For Ra, Th and U, the low-lying states are due to significant configuration mixing. In Ra, the components of are . These states are arising from significant configuration mixing with and , with 24% probabilities of these configurations mixing with over 28-32% of the leading configuration. The ground state of Ra can be described by with 24% probability as two pairs coupled to angular momentum , i.e., seniority . However, the (21%) and (21%) components are also not small for the ground state. The excited state dominated by the configuration is a seniority state with two proton pairs and one odd proton coupled to , with over 43% contribution. The state is mainly due to one-proton excitation from the orbital to , with the predominant configuration of . One can see the state is seniority state, and the even parity states as well as the are seniority states.
Th can be described similarly to Ra with two more protons in the valence space. The , configuration gives rise to a multiplets. However, these states are arising from significant configuration mixing with and , with over 16-20% probabilities of these configurations mixing with over 20-22% of the leading configuration. Similar to Ra with two extra proton in and orbital, the ground state can be described by seniority with configuration and the is a seniority state dominated by the configuration. The is due to admixture of and configurations with almost the same contribution 16-17% as the dominant one (18%). The is a seniority state of configuration with 23%, including the admixture of and configurations with over 20-22% contribution.
Showing similar structure as Th the multiplets from the configuration including the ground state now arises from in U with two added valence protons. The multiplets are due to significant mixing with several configurations, with 8-9% probabilities of these configurations mixing with 19-22% of the leading configuration. In U the contribution of configurations apart from the dominant one has decreased compared to Ra and Th. The seniority scheme here is the same as the Ra and Th. In contrast to other even isotones, the state is a multiplet of , highly mixed with and configurations with almost the same contribution 13-15% as the dominant one (over 15%). The is a multiplet of with 19%, including the admixture of and configurations with over 16% contributions.
N = 126 odd isotones
The spectra of the odd-even isotones calculated assuming the pure configuration with seniority and 3 are compared with the experimental data. The experimental spectra themselves no longer contain all the levels predicted by the seniority scheme. These isotones belong to the region of neutron-rich short-lived nuclei and, the precise determination of their spectra of excited states is a complex experimental task.
The low-lying levels of At can be described by the coupling of three valence protons residing outside the , closed shell. The level scheme of At, Fr and Ac are very similar. In At, all the spins considered are pure states with 96-100% contribution and for ground state over 67% contribution. The Po and At both are confined to a single orbital for the low-lying states. The results are explained relating in a configuration () to those in a configuration (). The , , and states are identically defined by three protons in with seniority , except for . For , there are two independent states with seniority and 3, respectively. In , the is the ground state and we can assume it has seniority . The and states are formed by configuration with seniority . The and are seniority states with one proton excitation from to orbital, which is configuration. The energy of the state is higher compared to other first negative parity states. Because the single-particle energy of the orbital is higher than that of the orbital, the energy of the state is higher compared to the and states. The and states consist of the configuration. In contrast the state cannot be constructed by the configuration.
In , the calculated low-lying yrast states are due to configuration mixing. The , , and states have a leading configuration of , with 38-60% probability which is the lowest for the ground state. The ground state, in which two proton pairs are coupled to the odd proton, is seniority state. As in , the seniority states are , and , excitations with a broken pair coupled to a proton in the orbital. The and states belong to the multiplet is seniority state, with a broken pair coupled to a proton in the orbital. The is a seniority state having a leading configuration of , where two protons in the orbital with spin eight coupled to the last proton in the orbital. The maximum spin of this configuration is 29/2.
For , the calculated yrast states are due to large configuration mixing. The ground state has the leading configuration , although another configuration has a significant probability almost the same as the leading term of 22%. This shows the importance of orbital for the formation of low-lying states around and above it. The , and states have a leading configuration of , with probability over 27%. However, these states are coming from the mixing of two more configurations, and , with over 19-24% contribution. The and states belong to the multiplet, and the state belongs to the multiplet, with over 38% contribution. The seniority scheme for the states followed here is the same as those in At and Fr.
For Pa, the calculated yrast states are also due to large configuration mixing. The , and states have a leading configuration of , with probability from 20-23%, which is the lowest for the ground state. Similar to the Ac, these states are coming from the mixing of two more configurations and , with over 12-18% contribution with the leading term. The , and states belong to the multiplet with seniority , with a broken pair coupled to a proton in the . The state belongs to the multiplet with seniority , where a broken pair in the orbital coupled to the last proton in the orbital. In contrast to the other odd isotones, the excitation energy of the isomeric state is lower than the () at . Previously, this was also expected in the experimental work [47].
Similarity between Sn and Pb regions
The low-lying states are expected to rise only from the three high- orbitals , and for the isotones with . For the isotones (), the breaking of a first proton pair generates different multiplets occupying the and orbitals depending on the number of valence protons. In doubly even nuclei, the low-lying excited states are generated from breaking of one proton pair with seniority from the configuration. The positive parity states with are possible in the same configuration space coexisting with core-couple states. Hence, for the states, seniority must be with breaking a second or more proton pair (up to ). Although the admixture of configuration from the and orbitals are small but very crucial to generate the correct level scheme [48, 49]. In doubly even nuclei, odd parity states are generated by the and multiplets.
Similarly, in the Pb-region, particular orbitals are consistently responsible for forming the low-lying states and isomers. The low-lying states are expected to rise only from the three high- orbitals , and for the isotones with . For the isotones (), the breaking of a first proton pair generates different multiplets occupying the and orbitals depending on the number of valence protons. In doubly even nuclei, the low-lying excited states are generated from breaking of one proton pair with seniority from the configuration. The positive parity states with are possible in the same configuration space coexisting with core-couple states. Hence, for the states seniority must be with breaking of a second or more proton pair (up to ). In doubly even nuclei, odd parity states are generated by the and multiplets, with seniority for states up to .
In Figure 5, we show the similarity between the shell structures in the Sn and Pb regions for the fully-aligned states with one broken proton pair in the isotones with , involving the three orbitals just above the gap, , , and , and in the isotones with , involving the three orbitals just above the gap, , , and . In these two regions the orbital angular momentum differ by one unit, with the same orientation of the intrinsic spin, , , and . Similar evolution can be seen for the same seniority states in the two states of the isotones and the two states of the isotones. Similarly for the odd isotones with seniority the behavior between the and states of the isotones and the and states of the isotones.
Figure 5. Calculated excitation energies of the fully-aligned states with one broken proton pair in the isotones with (a), and in the isotones with (b) in comparison with experimental excitation energies for isotones (c), and isotones (d). The isomeric states are highlighted with filled symbols.
In Figure 6, we have shown the variation of proton effective single-particle energies for and isotones corresponding to SN100PN and KHPE interactions, respectively. For isotones, as we increase proton number, the gap between proton effective single-particle energies for and orbital decreases. This effect can be seen as a decrease in energy (see Figure 5) for and states having configurations composed of and . For isotones with KHPE interaction, the gap between proton effective single-particle energies for and orbital decreases by 436 keV as we move from to , this is also reflected in the decrease in the energies of and isomers.
Figure 6. Variation of proton effective single-particle energies for different orbitals of and isotones.
It should be noted that the configuration is more appropriate than taking the two orbitals individually as the two orbitals are close in energy. Similarly, for the configuration in the Pb-region. Since we have two different orbitals in the configurations of the even isotones, two different combinations of orbitals can give the same angular momentum. Such as, from and in Sn-region, and from and in Pb-region. It is found that the low-lying is an isomeric state, regardless of the configuration.
The different natures and the evolution of the two and states can be confirmed by the different values of the calculated half-lives in Table 1. We can see the exchange of configuration in both the Sn-region (between two ) and
| Transition | (SM) | (Expt.) | Transition | (SM) | (Expt.) | ||||||
| - | 126.90 ns | 164.1(9) ns | - | 106.16 ns | 98.9(25) ns | ||||||
| - | 1.17 ps | ps | - | 33.70 ps | - | ||||||
| - | 1.47 s | 2.95(17) s | - | 1.83 s | 0.91(3) s | ||||||
| - | 10.72 ps | ps | - | 37.56 ps | - | ||||||
| - | 3.60 s | 0.85(16) s | - | 130.88 s | 67.8(15) s | ||||||
| - | 11.48 ps | 55(17) ps | - | 58.23 ps | - | ||||||
| - | 13.95 s | 7.31(15) s | - | 41.90 s | 134 (4) s | ||||||
| - | 6.26 ps | - | - | 25.16 ps | - | ||||||
| - | 5279 s | 16.5 s | - | 26.39 s | ms | ||||||
| - | 3.94 ps | - | - | 17.90 ps | - |
Table 1. The calculated (SM) half-life with configuration for state in Sn-region and state Pb-region with respect to the experimental data (Expt.) [45].
Pb-region (between two ) at almost in the middle of the range of isotones for and for . This is because of the small gap in the single-particle energy between the orbitals and in the Sn-region and and in the Pb-region. Although, from the shell-model calculation, the configuration exchange for is taking place at . The half-lives of and states are always larger than and states, confirming the isomeric nature for the first yarst states of these spins, despite the change of configuration. The state decays with the transition, and the transition shows a large impact by reducing the half-life from ns to ps. Similarly, the state is solely dominated by the transition, thus giving a smaller half-life than the state. Our calculation supports the experimental counterpart of the and half-lives except for and , whose half-lives show large discrepancies with the experimental values. For , the energy levels are reproduced well, but the transition value is very small (0.0003 W.u.). This could be the reason for the large magnitude of the calculated half-life. In the case of , as there is no experimental information available for the electromagnetic transition of , we can not say due to which part discrepancy is arising.
We have calculated transition for the state of , which is not measured experimentally. In comparison with the isomeric nature of state in , configuration has been proposed in [50] for the . Following the behavior of states in the Sn-region and our shell-model results, we can propose the configuration of state for to be based on (or ).
In Figure 7, the occupancy of different orbitals for the isomers in and isomers in regions are shown. The behavior of the dominant part of the wave function is similar in both the regions, i.e., the orbital for isomers, while the orbital for isomers. The contribution of orbital in the Sn-region and orbital in the Pb-region is continuously increasing with the increase in number. This shows the importance of these two high- orbitals even in the formation of low-lying isomeric states, while the dominant orbitals and are expected to be sufficient in the formation of low-lying isomeric states, giving a pure configuration. As we focus precisely on the contribution of different orbitals in the configuration, it appears that fragmentation of the dominant wave function into different orbitals increases significantly with the increase in the number. This is reflected in the values of these two isomeric states discussed ahead. In Figure 8, we can see a sharp decrease in the transition values for the and isomeric state, after and , respectively. The values are higher at and , as the configuration is pure, without any fragmentation into the other orbitals. There might be other factors affecting the behavior of the transition value.
Figure 7. The occupancy for different orbitals corresponding to and isomers.
Figure 8. Comparison of calculated and experimental [45] values of different transitions for and isotones.
and
The reduced electric transition probabilities provide much information. Such as, a small value indicates a single-particle structure, while a larger value provides an understanding of collective motion. It also tells about the accuracy of the shell-model wave functions. Here, the transitions are calculated, interconnecting different even and odd parity states. The results for different transition rates, displayed in Figure 8 and the result of
| Transition | (SM) | (Expt.) | Even | Transition | (SM) | (Expt.) | Odd | Transition | (SM) | (Expt.) | |
| 1.43 | 3.80(14) | 0.34 | 3.71(10) | 7.71 | 21.5(19) | ||||||
| 6.70 | 8.2(3) | 7.62 | 19.7(11) | ||||||||
| 1.52 | 0.22 | 1.8 | 7.18 | 25.8(23) | |||||||
| 5.83 | 7.11 | ||||||||||
| 5.72 | 0.19 | 3.09(9) | 6.52 | 27.4(9) | |||||||
| 0.76 | 6.47 | 21.8(6) | |||||||||
| 4.96 | 0.32 | 21(2) | 5.70 | ||||||||
| 0.12 | 5.57 | 5.0(15) | |||||||||
| 3.42 | 4.45 | ||||||||||
| 0.04 | 0.55 |
Table 2. The calculated (SM) transition strengths in W.u. for Sn and Pb region isotones compared to the experimental data (Expt.) [45] using the effective charge .
in Figure 9. These values are calculated using the standard effective charges and .
Figure 9. Comparison of calculated and experimental [45] and transition probabilities and first excitation energy for and isotones.
A similar general trend of decreasing value is observed in Figure 8 as the proton number increases for both the and isotones. For the spins, the decrement of values away from the shell-closure is an outcome of the seniority scheme. The transition that is even-tensor, one body transition between the states of the same seniority, will follow the trend determined by the matrix elements. Relating to this, the orbitals involved in the wave-functions of the initial and final states differ by one unit of angular momentum and the formation of the involved states in transition rates for both regions follows the same seniority scheme. Surprisingly, the transition rates for the same seniority states in the two different closed-shell regions and follow the same trend. The trend of transition rates suggests that seniority is a good quantum number for and shell closure. This argument is only valid near the shell closure where valence nucleons are small because collectivity increases for a large number of valence particles and away from the shell closure.
In Figure 9, we can observe increment of the transition probabilities as the proton number increases. The large transition rates in , and in the Sn-region and and in the Pb-region indicate the collective nature of these nuclei. A weak transition rate is observed for the in the Sn-region similar to in the Pb-region. Overall, larger strengths are reached for larger in the isotones. Their strengths are similar as for the isotones in the mass region.
From the results shown in Figure 9, it is worth noticing that analogous increase in the first excitation energy is observed for and regions as the proton number increases. For instance, 1.211 MeV in and 1.200 MeV in to 1.522 MeV in and 1.764 MeV in . The increase of and decrease of energy level and the larger value than the shows the spherical character of these nuclei in both
the region. The increase in values is very rapid in both regions. In contrast, excitation energy shows a gradual increment. This behavior indicates the emergence of collectivity.
In Table II we have reported shell model results for transition strengths corresponding to the experimental data. The octupole transitions in isotones resembles that for [51, 52]. The transitions are retarded due to the spin-flip single particle transformation and , in comparison with the transformation and which gives rise to fast transition, in and isotones, respectively. Thus, the value increases with proton number (despite it decreases for and , because of the exchange of configuration), while the value decreases. Similar behaviour can be seen for isotones with weak transition. The value slows down with proton number and dominated by single proton spin-flip transitions (despite it increases for and ), while a strong value is reproduced.
The and are supposed to arise due to octupole coupling with core excitation. The transition is expected to be very fast for the state generated from the coupling between orbital and the collective state. Thus, strong transitions are observed for the isomeric state, which are due to single particle transformation . For , a fast decay from state to state and a weak decay to the state has been observed experimentally. This is because the wave functions of the and should come from the contribution of , and mixing of and for the state. In contrast, in our shell-model calculation, the wave-function of the two states is reversed for , giving a weak decay to the state and fast decay for the state. In the case of , our calculation replicates the observed behavior for the .
In our shell-model calculation, the deficiency in the transitions is due to the need for larger model space, especially the particle-hole core-excitations across the shell gaps. This could be examined in a different work by including a larger model space in the shell model calculation [53].
G g-factor and quadrupole moment
In the Table III, we have reported shell model results for -factor and quadrupole moments for the , and isomers in isotones and , , isomers with ground state in isotones corresponding to the experimental data.
The -factors are very sensitive to which orbital unpaired particles (or holes) are occupying. Thus, the -factor measurements explain the purity of a particular configuration and the contribution of the component in the wave function. The -factors are particularly sensitive to the core polarization effects that couple the spin-orbit partners. The influence of excitation between spin-orbit (spin-flip) partners across a magic shell gap on the magnetic moment is called the first-order core polarization effect. The influence of excitation is called second-order core polarization. And the -factors are not very sensitive to second-order core polarization effects (quadrupole particle-core coupling interactions). However, quadrupole moments are extremely sensitive to this. Therefore, the
The calculated -factor (in n.m.) and quadrupole moment (in eb) for isomeric states in and isotones compared to the experimental data [45]. Shell-model calculations are performed with and ; .
| A | SM | SM | |||
| 0.525 | -0.373 | ||||
| 1.057 | -0.673 | ||||
| 0.560 | -0.125 | ||||
| 1.055 | -0.548 | ||||
| 0.98(2) | 0.964 | -0.097 | |||
| 1.056 | -0.414 | ||||
| 1.029 | 0.120 | ||||
| 1.056 | -0.315 | ||||
| 1.028 | 0.397 | ||||
| +1.05 (13) | 1.056 | -0.233 | |||
| 0.911 | -0.569 | ||||
| 0.908 | -0.267 | ||||
| 0.904 | 0.062 | ||||
| 0.896 | 0.411 | ||||
| +0.919(6) | 0.737 | -0.552(20) | -0.577 | ||
| 1.024 | -0.86(11) | -0.967 | |||
| +0.894(2) | 0.586 | -0.18(2) | -0.308 | ||
| 1.038 | -0.779 | ||||
| 0.885(4) | 0.589 | -0.060 | |||
| 1.088(6) | 1.038 | -0.599 | |||
| 0.599 | 0.146 | ||||
| 1.037 | -0.421 | ||||
| 0.973 | 0.035 | ||||
| 1.037 | -0.248 | ||||
| +0.92 [54] | 0.584 | -0.33(12) [55] | -0.264 | ||
| +0.910(8) | 0.588 | 0.53(5) | -0.524 | ||
| +0.887(2) [54] | 0.585 | -0.14(2) | -0.121 | ||
| 0.888(3) | 0.5908 | -0.178 | |||
| +0.920(13) | 0.587 | +0.04(10) | 0.093 | ||
| 0.910(10) | 0.605 | 0.101 | |||
| 0.590 | 0.126 | ||||
| 0.795 | 0.194 |
Table 3.
-factor is found to be constant in a chain of isotopes or isotones.
According to the additivity rule, -factors of the isomeric states with a rather pure or configuration should all be the same. Examples of the additivity of nuclear magnetic moments are given in Ref. [56]. The and isomers are from proton excitations out of the and 82 core, respectively, so their -factors are usually large and positive. These two isomers show almost the same -factor throughout the isotonic chain. The -factors of and isomers could be affected by particle-octupole vibration coupling admixtures. It needs to be investigated more from the theoretical perspective. In some isotones, due to first-order core polarization, Pauli-blocking can cause a breakdown of the additivity rule for -factors. This can result in a changing -factor as a function of . From our calculation we have seen that the configurations of the isomers are getting more mixed with increasing , in particular mixing with the configuration in the Sn-region or configuration in the Pb-region.
This mixing alone is not able to explain the breakdown of additivity. Other types of mixing are needed to be considered in the wave function to describe the deviation from the additivity rule. This configuration mixing could be where the particle-core couple to octupole-vibrations and (or) first-order core polarization effects couple to valence particles. A detailed discussion can be found in [32]. The main impact of the octupole mixing into the wave function is that fewer protons will occupy the pure orbital. This results in a reduced Pauli blocking and thus better agreement with the experimental data. The main configuration of the isomers is expected to be pure. The -factor of these isomers should be the same for all of them (additivity theorem).
The -factors of and increase with the increasing proton number. In the Sn-region, -factor of one proton in the orbital is smaller than that of one proton in the orbital. Thus, when we take coupled -factor with increasing number, the -factor of from the configuration space will be larger than the . Therefore, the -factor for the increases with the proton number while it decreases for the . In the Pb-region, the -factor of from the configuration space gives a larger -factor than the . Similar to the Sn-region, the -factor for the increases with the proton number while it decreases for the . This shows the sensitivity of -factors to the coupling of spin-flip partners (first-order core polarization) into the wave function. In Figure 10 the evolution of the -factor for two and states has been shown with respect to the number. From the figure, we can see that for the isomeric state, a deviation towards lower neutron numbers also appears. The more nucleons occupy the orbital, the higher the first-order core-polarization effect; thus deviation of -factor appears towards a higher nucleon number. This parabolic curve might indicate that the correction in the -factor is related to the maximum number of particles (or holes).
Figure 10. Trend of the -factor for the two (in Sn region) and (in Pb region) in comparison with the experimental data [45].
Our calculated results of quadrupole moments, as shown in Table III are in a reasonable agreement with the available experimental data. Out of seven experimentally measured quadrupole moments, six quadrupole moments from the shell model are within the error bars and measured signs. In , for the state, the sign is not reproduced in our calculation. In the Sn-region, no experimental data is available for the quadrupole moments. Unlike the -factor, quadrupole moments change in the isotonic chain with the increase in the number. The deformation increases with the increase in the number above the shell-closure, and the quadrupole moment indicates the deformation. If we increase proton number beyond shell-closure, it is important to include the effect of second-order core polarization by including lower orbitals in shell-model space. The effect of second-order core polarization on the quadrupole moments can be seen in Table III. The deviation of the calculated quadrupole moment increases with the increase in the number.
Conclusions
In the present work, we have performed a new type of investigation for the similarities between the () and () isotones in the framework of the nuclear shell model with well known SN100PN and KHPE interactions, respectively. The isotones with and are semi-magic nuclei. From comparing the spectroscopy of Sn and Pb regions, similar patterns of nuclear structure are found in the framework of the shell-model. The low-lying part of the spectrum should obey the seniority scheme, which is reflected in our present study. For these two regions, we have discussed spectroscopic and electromagnetic properties. Our study confirms several isomeric states in and isotones are due to the breaking of high- nucleon pairs and well described in terms of seniority quantum number. A similar evolution of excitation energies can be seen between the same seniority states in the Sn and Pb regions. We propose the wave function of state for to be .
Using the correspondence between the Sn and Pb regions, the high- orbitals above the shell gaps show similar behavior, eventually deciding other spectroscopic properties. The decrease in transition value with proton number for the seniority and 3 multiplet is an outcome of the seniority scheme and also due to the gradual decrease in the occupation of and orbitals in the Sn and Pb region, respectively. The rest of the occupation is scattered to the , and , orbitals in Sn and Pb region, respectively.
A strong resemblance can be seen in the growth of transition probabilities and in the variation of the first excitation energy. The , and states in the Sn region and their counterpart , and states in the Pb region show several similarities in the structural formation. Their evolution leads to a similar trend of -factor and in both regions. Also, the structure of in the Sn region and states in the Pb region are related to the octupole coupling with two and , respectively. Depending on the two different configurations, one among the two and states will be the octupole coupled core-excited state, which couples to and states in the Sn and Pb region, respectively. The value is crucial for a better understanding and explaining the similarities between these two regions. The retardation of the value in both regions is due to the spin-flip matrix element. The breakdown in additivity for the -factor could be explained with the first-order core polarization with mixing to the octupole coupling effects. These correlations can not be accounted in the present shell-model calculation. Overall, shell model results agree with the available experimental data. We have also predicted electromagnetic properties where experimental data are not available. Our study will be beneficial for future experimental study.
Acknowledgments
B. Bhoy acknowledges financial support from MHRD, Government of India. P. C. Srivastava acknowledges a research grant from SERB (India), CRG/2019/000556. We would like to thank Prof. Larry Zamick for several illuminating discussions.
References
- [32]A. E. Stuchbery, A. P. Byrne, G. D. Dracoulis, B. Fabricius, T. Kibédi, An experimentally derived magnetic moment for the f7/2 proton in trans-lead nuclei, Nuclear Physics A 555, 355 (1993).
- [33]P. Walker and Z. Podolyák, 100 years of nuclear isomers—then and now, Phys. Scr. 95, 044004 (2020).
- [34]R. Machleidt, F. Sammarruca, and Y. Song, Nonlocal nature of the nuclear force and its impact on nuclear structure, Phys. Rev. C 53, R1483(R) (1996).
- [35]P. C. Srivastava, B. Bhoy, and M. J. Ermatamov, Different seniority states of 119−126Sn isotopes: shell-model description, Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2019, 103D01 (2019).
- [36]V. Kumar, P. C. Srivastava, M. J. Ermatamov, and I. O. Morales, Analysis of proton and neutron pair breakings: High-spin structures of 124−127Te isotopes, Nucl. Phys. A 942, 1 (2015).DOI
- [37]P. C. Srivastava, M. J. Ermatamov, and I. O. Morales, High-spin structures of 136Xe, 137Cs, 138Ba, 139La and 140Ce: a shell model description, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 40, 035016 (2013).
- [38]E. K. Warburton and B. A. Brown, Appraisal of the Kuo-Herling shell-model interaction and application to A = 210-212 nuclei, Phys. Rev. C 43, 602 (1991).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9967102
- [39]T. T. S. Kuo and G. H. Herling, US Naval Research Laboratory Report no. 2258 (1971) unpublished.
- [40]G. Herling and T. T. S. Kuo, Two-particle states in 210Pb, 210Bi and 210Po with realistic forces, Nucl. Phys. A 181, 113 (1972).DOI
- [41]T. Hamada and I.D. Johnston, A potential model representation of two-nucleon data below 315 MeV, Nucl. Phys. 34, 382 (1962).
- [42]T.T.S. Kuo and G.E. Brown, Structure of finite nuclei and the free nucleon-nucleon interaction: An application to 18O and 18F, Nucl. Phys. 85, 40 (1966).
- [43]B. Bhoy and P. C. Srivastava, Systematic shell-model study of Rn isotopes with A= 207 to 216 and isomeric states, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 48, 125103 (2021).DOI
- [44]N. Shimizu, Y. Mizusaki, Y. Utsuno and Y. Tsunoda, Thick-restart block Lanczos method for large-scale shell-model calculations, Comput. Phys. Commun. 244, 372 (2019).DOI
- [45]Evaluated nuclear structure data file (ENSDF), http://nndc.bnl.gov/ensdf/
- [46]J. K. Hwang, J. H. Hamilton, and A. V. Ramayya, One-phonon octupole vibrational states in 136Xe, 137Cs, 138Ba, 140Ce and 142Nd with N = 82, Eur. Phys. J. A 49, 125 (2013).DOI
- [47]F.P. Heßberger, S. Hofmann, I. Kojouharov, D. Ackermann, S. Antalic, P. Cagarda, B. Kindler, B. Lommel, R. Mann, A.G. Popeko, S. Saro, J. Uusitalo, and A.V. Yeremin, Radioactive decay of 217Pa, Eur. Phys. J. A 15, 335 (2002).
- [48]W.Enghardt, L.Käubler, H.Prade, H.-J.Keller, F.Stary, In-beam study of multiparticle excitations in the semi-magic nucleus 140Ce, Nucl. Phys. A 449, 417 (1986).DOI
- [49]H. Prade, W. Enghardt, H.U. Jäger, L. Käubler, H.-J.Keller, F. Stary, In-beam study and structure of the N = 82 nucleus 141Pr, Nucl. Phys. A 370, 47 (1981).DOI
- [50]A. P. Leppanen et al., α decay studies of the nuclides 218U and 219U, Phys. Rev. C 75, 054307 (2007).
- [51]J. P. Omtvedt, H. Mach, B. Fogelberg, D. Jerrestam, M. Hellstrom, L. Spanier, K. I. Erokhina, and V. I. Isakov, Effective Charges and Octupole Collectivity in the 132Sn region, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 3090 (1995).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10059492
- [52]I. Bergstrom, J. Blomqvist, P. Carle, B. Fant, A. Kallberg, L.O. Norlin, K.-G. Rensfelt, and U. Rosengard, On the Electromagnetic Properties of Core-Excited High-Spin States in 210Po and 211At, Phys. Scr. 31, 333 (1985).
- [53]B.A. Brown, Double-Octupole States in 208Pb, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 5300 (2000).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11135981
- [54]B. Maheshwari, D. Choudhury, A.K. Jain, Puzzle on isomeric configurations in and around N = 126 closed shell, Phys. Rev. C 105, 024315 (2022).DOI
- [55]J. G. Cubiss et al., Charge radii and electromagnetic moments of 195−211At, Phys. Rev. C 97, 054327 (2018).DOI
- [56]K. Heyde, The Nuclear Shell Model (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1990).








