betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Optical decoherence in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 spin qubit platforms

Abstract

Erbium ions (Er3+^{3+}) in cerium dioxide (CeO2_2) represent a promising spin-photon interface for quantum communication, but the mechanisms limiting their optical coherence remain poorly understood. Using periodic hybrid density functional theory calculations with finite-size corrections, we identify Ce3+^{3+} polarons and their complexes with oxygen vacancies and Er3+^{3+} dopants as likely sources of optical decoherence. These defects exhibit finite photoionization cross-sections at 0.8 eV, coinciding with both the laser excitation energy used experimentally and the emission energy of Er3+^{3+}. This resonance enables photoionization of the polarons and photoluminescence quenching of Er3+^{3+}, leading to the broadening of optical linewidths, shortening of excited-state lifetimes, and introduction of charge noise. Our concentration-dependent photocurrent measurements in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 films under 0.8 eV illumination validate the predicted decoherence pathway. Our combined computational and experimental results identify a concrete defect-engineering target for improving the Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 platform, and point to a decoherence mechanism likely relevant to other Er3+^{3+}-doped multivalent-oxide quantum platforms.

main.pdf

Cerium dioxide (CeO2_2, ceria) is a prototypical mixed ionic-electronic conductor. Due to its mixed valence nature, where Ce4+^{4+} can be reduced to Ce3+^{3+} to form electron polarons, and its facile oxygen vacancy formation, ceria is a good candidate for electrochemical and thermochemical energy conversion applications[1, 2, 3]. These include its use for thermochemical solar fuel production[4], as a catalyst in automotive exhaust systems[5], and as an electrolyte[6] and anode[7] in fuel cells. The technological importance of CeO2_2 has resulted in extensive investigations of its ionic and electronic conductivity mediated by oxygen non-stoichiometry and polaronic transport[8], and of its properties as a function of dopant concentration, dislocations, grain boundaries, heterointerfaces, and strain[9, 10] [11, 12, 13].

Recently, CeO2_2 has been predicted to be a promising host for spin qubits for quantum technologies14. The low concentration of nuclear spin isotopes (none in Ce and 0.04% in O) is expected to lead to a long electron spin coherence time, predicted to be 47 ms in the regime of nuclear spin-limited noise14. CeO2_2 is also advantageous due to its small lattice mismatch with silicon (−0.4%-0.4\%, orientation-independent)15, facilitating scalability and integration with quantum devices.

Er3+^{3+} is a promising spin defect in CeO2_2, particularly as a spin-photon interface for quantum memories, due to its effective S=1/2S = 1/2 ground state, sharp optical transitions in the telecom-C band, and long coherence times observed in several hosts16–20. Recently, several studies have investigated Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 nanocrystals21 and films[24] [22, 23] as spin qubit platforms. Characterization of films on Si has revealed that Er3+^{3+} substitutes a Ce4+^{4+} site and has several favorable properties for use as a quantum memory; these include an optical coherence time of 0.72 μ\mus, optical excited state lifetime of 3.5 ms, and Hahn-echo spin coherence time (T2,spinT_{2,\mathrm{spin}}) of 0.25 μ\mus22,23 at 4 K.

Encouragingly, T2,spinT_{2,\mathrm{spin}} has been increased to 40 μ\mus at 77 mK and found to be limited by spectral diffusion due to surrounding Er3+^{3+} electron spins[24].

Although spin decoherence in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 films is now partially understood[24], its optical decoherence mechanism remains unclear. For example, its optical homogeneous linewidth is ∼103×\sim10^3 \times higher than its lifetime-limited linewidth, the reason for which is uncertain22,23. Additionally, electron paramagnetic resonance spectra show a resonant peak with g=2.04g = 2.04, whose origin has not yet been fully clarified23. Microstructural characterization of Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 films on Si shows a mixed CeOx_x-SiOy_y interfacial layer and the presence of threading dislocations22. These findings, together with the observed trends in several optical properties as a function of Er3+^{3+} concentration and annealing temperature22,23, suggest that optical decoherence could be caused by charged defects, electric field gradients, and strain. In fact, it is reasonable to expect that the very defects beneficial for energy conversion applications (oxygen vacancies and polarons) may be detrimental for quantum ones. Hence, understanding the factors that affect the optical properties of Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 films is an important step in the realization of the compelling advantages of both CeO2_2 and Er3+^{3+} for quantum applications.

In this work, we investigate the impact of oxygen vacancies and polarons on the optical decoherence of Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 using first-principles calculations. We predict that the thermodynamic charge transition levels of the isolated polaron and its complexes are below 0.8 eV (1530 nm), the wavelength at which optical transitions in Er3+^{3+} occur. Importantly, we establish that these defects have a finite photoionization cross-sections at ∼\sim0.8 eV. These results indicate that the isolated polaron and its complexes can cause photoluminescence quenching of Er3+^{3+} emission and can ionize under the 0.8 eV laser illumination used for Er3+^{3+} excitation. This could lead to optical decoherence by increasing linewidths, reducing optical excited state lifetimes, and causing charge noise. We validate our computational findings through concentration-dependent photocurrent measurements in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 under 0.8 eV laser illumination.

Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were carried out with Quantum Espresso[25, 26, 27]. We used ONCV pseudopotentials[28, 29] and the dielectric-dependent hybrid (DDH) exchange-correlation functional (with Hartree-Fock mixing parameter α=ε∞−1\alpha= \varepsilon_{\infty}^{-1}, where ε∞=5.31\varepsilon_{\infty} = 5.31, as experimentally measured for CeO2_2[30]). Our computational setup ensured accurate bandgap predictions and the localization of the Ce3+^{3+} polaron. The computed optical bandgap (with TDDFT@DDH) is 3.49 eV, consistent with the value of ∼3.55\sim3.55 eV obtained from UV-VIS and reflectivity measurements[31, 32, 33] and from our photoluminescence emission and excitation measurements (see Supplementary Material SM Sections I–III).

We computed the thermodynamic charge transition levels (CTL) and optical charge transition levels (or vertical transition levels, VTL). The former corresponds to the thermal ionization energy, in which an electron (hole) is ionized into the CBM (VBM), thereby changing the charge state of the defect from charge qq to q′q^{\prime}, after which the defect relaxes to the equilibrium configuration corresponding to q′q^{\prime}. The CTL (from the VBM) is computed as[34]

ε(q/q′)=Ef(q,Rq;εF=0)−Ef(q′,Rq′;εF=0)q′−q,(1)\varepsilon(q/q^{\prime}) = \frac{E_{\mathrm{f}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q};\varepsilon_{\mathrm{F}}=0)-E_{\mathrm{f}}(q^{\prime},\mathbf{R}_{q^{\prime}};\varepsilon_{\mathrm{F}}=0)}{q^{\prime}-q}, \tag*{(1)}

and is the central quantity required to obtain the photoionization cross-section; Ef(q,Rq′)E_{\mathrm{f}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q^{\prime}}) is the formation energy of a defect in charge state qq and configuration Rq′\mathbf{R}_{q^{\prime}}[34, 35] (see SM Section IV for calculation of Ef(q,Rq′)E_{\mathrm{f}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q^{\prime}})).

The VTL corresponds to the optical ionization energy, in which an electron (hole) is ionized into the CBM (VBM), thereby changing the charge state of the defect from qq to q′q^{\prime}; the defect remains frozen in the equilibrium configuration corresponding to qq over the timescale of the measurement. The VTL (from the VBM) is computed as[34, 35, 36]

μ(q/q′,Rq)=Ef(q,Rq;εF=0)−Ef(q′,Rq;εF=0)q′−q,(2)\mu(q/q^{\prime},\mathbf{R}_{q}) = \frac{E_{\mathrm{f}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q};\varepsilon_{\mathrm{F}}=0)-E_{\mathrm{f}}(q^{\prime},\mathbf{R}_{q};\varepsilon_{\mathrm{F}}=0)}{q^{\prime}-q}, \tag*{(2)}

and is the central quantity required to understand absorption and emission processes involving carrier exchange with the host material.

In periodic calculations, computing accurate values of CTLs and VTLs requires the evaluation of correction terms EcorrE_{\mathrm{corr}} that account for the artificial electrostatic interactions arising due to the finite supercell size. We use the expression proposed in Ref.[37] to compute Ecorr(q,Rq)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q}) (with ε0=24.5\varepsilon_{0}=24.5 for CeO2_2) and that of Ref.[36] to compute Ecorr(q,Rq′)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q^{\prime}}) (with ε∞=5.31\varepsilon_{\infty}=5.31[30] for CeO2_2), as implemented in sxdefectalign[38]. The evaluation of Ecorr(q,Rq′)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q^{\prime}}) requires special care, as different ionic and electronic screening terms are involved when

considering a charge qq in a fixed configuration corresponding to that of the charge q′q^{\prime}[35, 36].

Finally, the photoionization cross-section is the transition rate per unit photon flux and, for an ensemble of randomly oriented defects, is computed as[39, 40]

σph(ℏω)=4π2α3nrefℏω∑j∣rdj∣2A(ℏω−Edj),(3)\sigma_{\mathrm{ph}}(\hbar\omega)=\frac{4\pi^{2}\alpha}{3n_{\mathrm{ref}}}\hbar\omega\sum_{j}\lvert r_{dj}\rvert^{2}A(\hbar\omega-E_{dj}), \tag*{(3)}

where α\alpha is the fine-structure constant, nrefn_{\mathrm{ref}} is the refractive index of CeO2_2 (2.30), rdjr_{dj} is the optical matrix element between the Kohn-Sham states φd\varphi_{d} and φj\varphi_{j}, computed using the WEST code[41, 42, 43], ℏω\hbar\omega is the photon energy. The sum runs over all final Kohn-Sham states φj\varphi_{j} (the entire Ce 4f band); EdjE_{dj} is the energy difference between the Kohn-Sham eigenvalues of the initial (defect Kohn-Sham state, φd\varphi_{d}) and final states, rigidly shifted so that the smallest value of EdjE_{dj} corresponds to the CTL. A(ℏω−Edj)A(\hbar\omega-E_{dj}) is the normalized spectral function of electron-phonon coupling that accounts for the vibrational overlap between the ground and excited states and is computed using the one-dimensional configurational coordinate diagram (1D-CCD) approach (see SM Section V).

Figure 1 shows the isosurfaces of the spin polarization densities of several defects considered in our study. We investigated the Er3+^{3+} substitutional dopant on the Ce4+^{4+} site (ErCe_{\mathrm{Ce}}) in the −1-1 and 0 charge states. As seen in Figure 1a, our calculations correctly reproduce the localization of the Er 4f orbitals. We also investigated the isolated electron polaron (CeCe1−_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-}, Figure 1b); oxygen vacancy (VOq_{\mathrm{O}}^{q}) in the 0, +1, and +2 charge states; and oxygen vacancy complexes with substitutional Er3+^{3+} ([ErCe_{\mathrm{Ce}}–VOq_{\mathrm{O}}^{q}]) in the 0 and +1 charge states. We note that all the defects investigated here (except the isolated

Er dopant and isolated polaron) are complexes with a polaron (see Figure 1c-Figure 1d).

Isosurfaces of spin polarization densities of several defects

Figure 1. Isosurfaces of spin polarization densities of several defects investigated in this work. (a) ErCe1−_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-} (b) CeCe1−_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-} (c) VO0_{\mathrm{O}}^{0} (i.e., [CeCe1−_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-}–VO2+_{\mathrm{O}}^{2+}–CeCe1−_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-}]) (d) [ErCe_{\mathrm{Ce}}–VO0_{\mathrm{O}}^{0}] (i.e., [ErCe1−_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-}–VO2+_{\mathrm{O}}^{2+}–CeCe1−_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-}]). Defects are described using the expression ABq_{q}, denoting atom A substituting site B with relative charge qq. VO_{\mathrm{O}} denotes oxygen vacancy. Cerium, oxygen, and erbium are represented by gray, red and green spheres, respectively and vacancy by dotted circle. Isosurface level is 8.5×10−38.5 \times10^{-3} e−^{-}/Å3^{3}.

Table 1 lists the computed CTLs of the various defects with respect to the CBM. We first discuss the polaron self-trapping energy of the isolated polaron (also known as polaron formation energy or polaron binding energy), which is related to the CTL as Eself−trap=−ε(0/−1)polE_{\mathrm{self-trap}}=-\varepsilon(0/-1)_{\mathrm{pol}}. Our computed value, −0.62-0.62 eV, lies within the range of values reported in previous ab initio works, which vary from −0.3-0.3 to −1.8-1.8 eV (see SM Section VII)[44, 45]. This variance in the literature values is due to the functional choice and, importantly, to the lack of appropriate finite-size corrections in many of the computed values of Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}}. Crucially, as we discuss in the SM, the use of the DDH functional and proper finite-size corrections ensures piecewise linearity of the exchange-correlation functional, confirming the robustness of our results for Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}}.

While our computed Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}} is slightly higher than that measured using room temperature transient absorption spectroscopy (−0.4-0.4 eV)[46], the agreement with experiment is still satisfactory, since our calculations are at 0 K and do not include renormalization of the bandgap and of Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}} due to finite temperature and nuclear quantum effects.

The CTL of Er3+^{3+} is over 3 eV below the CBM, indicating a large ionization energy. Thus, photoionization of the Er3+^{3+} spin defect under operating conditions is an unlikely decoherence mechanism. Interestingly, the CTLs of all the polaron-related defects, either the isolated polaron or its complexes with VO2+_{\mathrm{O}}^{2+} and [ErCe−VO]1+[\mathrm{Er}_{\mathrm{Ce}}-\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}]^{1+}, are ≲0.8\lesssim0.8 eV. Thus, these defects could potentially photoionize under the 0.8 eV laser illumination used to excite Er3+^{3+}, or cause photoluminescence quenching by absorbing the 0.8 eV emission from Er3+^{3+}. Whether these processes is decided by their photoionization cross-sections (discussed below).

Table 1 also lists the VTLs of the various defects with respect to the CBM. Importantly, the μ(q/q−1,Rq)\mu(q/q-1,R_q) VTLs, which reflect the de-excitation of a delocalized electron in the Ce 4f band to form a localized polaron (isolated or associated with a defect), are all relatively low, indicating that the non-radiative carrier capture of the delocalized electron is likely. In particular, μ(0/−1)pol\mu(0/-1)_{\mathrm{pol}} is negative (−0.05-0.05 eV), which implies that the delocalized electron will undergo vibrational relaxation (on a timescale of picoseconds, i.e., THz rates) to form a polaron. Thus, the g=2.04g=2.04 peak seen in EPR measurements23 is likely due to the Ce3+^{3+} polaron and not a delocalized electron.

CTLs only indicate which defects may ionize in our energy range of interest; computing both the transition dipole moment and the vibrational overlap between the ground and excited states is necessary to confirm whether the transitions occur. These are accounted for in the photoionization cross-sections.

Figure 2 shows the photoionization cross-sections with vibrational broadening (see SM Sections VIII and IX for the cross-sections without vibrational broadening, the 1D-CCD plots, and effective phonon frequencies used to compute A(ℏω−Edj)A(\hbar\omega-E_{dj})). We compute the cross-sections at 4 K to reflect the temperature at which optical and spin characterization measurements are usually performed22,23 (the cross-sections are similar at 300 K, see SM). Notably, the cross-section at 0.8 eV is significant for the ionization of the isolated polaron. Although the photoionization onset is slightly higher than 0.8 eV for the polaron-defect complexes, given the approximate values of the computed CTLs (due to the absence of finite temperature and nuclear quantum effects) and expected bandgap reduction at finite temperatures[47], it is possible that a finite photoionization cross-section occurs at 0.8 eV for the defect complexes as well.

Figure 2. Computed photoionization cross-sections with vibrational broadening at 4 K. Notation in legend described in Figure 1.

Together, our results suggest the following mechanism for optical decoherence in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2. The isolated polaron and its complexes can cause photoluminescence quenching by absorbing the emission from Er3+^{3+} and can photoionize under the 0.8 eV laser used to excite Er3+^{3+}. Photoluminescence quenching of Er3+^{3+} can then lead to broadening of optical linewidths and to the reduction of optical excited state lifetimes. Additionally, the impurities ionized by emission from Er3+^{3+} or by the laser can form another polaron or polaron-defect complex, causing charge noise.

To validate the predicted polaron-mediated optical decoherence pathway, we measured the photocurrent under 0.8 eV laser illumination in two single crystal ∼\sim750 nm-thick CeO2_2 films doped with 2 and 10 ppm Er3+^{3+}. Our samples were grown using molecular beam epitaxy22. Ti/Au gates were fabricated on the samples using standard photolithography techniques (Figure 3 inset). Standard I-V measurements established the presence of charge carriers in the samples (see SM Section X), and subsequent photocurrent measurements were carried out by applying a voltage across the two gates under 0.8 eV (1530 nm) laser illumination. The resulting current with increasing laser power was measured with an electrometer.

Figure 3. Measured photoexcited current at 300 K as a function of laser power under 5 V gate bias across a 60 μ\mum gap in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 films with two different Er3+^{3+} concentrations. Laser focus was kept at 30 μ\mum out of the sample. Photocurrent is defined as Iphoto=I−IdarkI_{\mathrm{photo}}=I-I_{\mathrm{dark}}, where II and IdarkI_{\mathrm{dark}} are the total current and current measured with laser off, respectively. Inset: Ti/Au gates (gold) deposited on Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 (brown) with varying gaps.

Figure 3 shows that both samples give rise to photoexcitation-induced current. We verified that the photocurrent is dominated by carriers from CeO2_2 bulk (not the surface; see SM); this result confirms the presence of charged defects in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 that photoionize under laser illumination used for Er3+^{3+} excitation, as predicted by our calculations. These defects likely arise due to the formation of the interfacial CeOx_x-SiOy_y layer, which reacts with oxygen from the CeO2_2 lattice, leaving behind oxygen vacancies compensated by Ce3+^{3+} polarons.

Interestingly, while the 2 ppm and 10 ppm samples show largely similar I-V curves, indicating similar carrier densities (see SM), they show a significantly different dependence of the photocurrent on laser power. As seen in Figure 3, the 2 ppm sample is more photoresponsive compared to the 10 ppm sample and exhibits a saturation effect at high power.

The distinct concentration-dependent photoresponse can be understood by considering the relative concentration of Ce3+^{3+} and Er3+^{3+}, as depicted in Figure 4. While the total concentration of Ce3+^{3+} is likely the same in both samples (due to the formation of a CeOx_x-SiOy_y interfacial layer in both samples), the relative concentration of Ce3+^{3+}, compared to Er3+^{3+}, is higher in the 2 ppm sample compared to the 10 ppm sample. Thus, the emitted energy from Er3+^{3+} is likely transferred more effectively to Ce3+^{3+} in the 2 ppm sample (Figure 4a) and quenched, ionizing Ce3+^{3+} in the process. In contrast, the higher concentration of Er3+^{3+} in the 10 ppm sample enhances the probability that Er3+^{3+} emission is transferred to other unexcited Er3+^{3+} ions, instead of being transferred to Ce3+^{3+} (Figure 4b). Therefore, the increased probability of energy transfer from Er3+^{3+} to Ce3+^{3+} in the 2 ppm sample explains its higher photocurrent. The saturation behavior in the 2 ppm sample can also be explained by the difference in the two energy transfer routes: Er3+^{3+} to Ce3+^{3+} vs. Er3+^{3+} to Er3+^{3+}. In the 2 ppm sample, the laser and Er3+^{3+} to Ce3+^{3+} transfer ionize most of the Ce3+^{3+} ions, so that at higher power, no Ce3+^{3+} is left to be ionized, thereby saturating the photocurrent. In the 10 ppm sample, the laser ionizes a fraction of the Ce3+^{3+} ions (similar to the 2 ppm case); however, the more probable Er3+^{3+} to Er3+^{3+} energy transfer prevents ionizing all of Ce3+^{3+}. Hence, unionized Ce3+^{3+} ions remain in the sample, where they can ionize at higher laser powers, preventing saturation. Thus, the observation of a photocurrent confirms the photoionization of charged defects under 0.8 eV laser illumination, and the concentration dependence of the photocurrent confirms that these charged defects can cause photoluminescence quenching of Er3+^{3+} emission. Together, these processes lead to optical decoherence.

Figure 4. Identified optical decoherence pathway in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2 with (a) 2 ppm (b) 10 ppm Er3+^{3+} (see text). Red triangle denotes laser illumination. Solid arrow denotes energy transfer from excited Er3+^{3+} to Ce3+^{3+}, ionizing it, in addition to ionization of Ce3+^{3+} due to the laser. In (a), the large concentration of Ce3+^{3+} relative to Er3+^{3+} results in energy transfer from excited Er3+^{3+} to Ce3+^{3+}, ionizing it, in addition to ionization of Ce3+^{3+} due to the laser. In (b), the low concentration of Ce3+^{3+} relative to Er3+^{3+} results in energy transfer from excited Er3+^{3+} to ground-state Er3+^{3+}, instead of Ce3+^{3+}. Ionization of Ce3+^{3+} due to the laser still occurs.

In summary, we elucidated the role of electron polarons and their complexes with oxygen vacancies and Er3+^{3+} dopants on the optical decoherence observed in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2. The thermodynamic and optical charge transition levels and photoionization cross-sections predicted by hybrid DFT calculations and proper finite-size corrections indicate that polarons and their complexes cause photoluminescence quenching of the Er3+\mathrm{Er}^{3+} emission and photoionize under the laser used to excite Er3+\mathrm{Er}^{3+}. These mechanisms cause optical decoherence by increasing linewidths, reducing optical excited state lifetimes, and introducing charge noise. Our concentration-dependent photocurrent measurement further validates the predicted decoherence pathway. The decoherence mechanism proposed here may be relevant for other Er3+\mathrm{Er}^{3+}-doped oxide film platforms that are increasingly being investigated for quantum applications and have mixed-valent cations, such as Er3+\mathrm{Er}^{3+}-doped TiO2\mathrm{TiO}_{2}[48] and CaWO4\mathrm{CaWO}_{4}49 films. Future work will focus on computing the rates for the various energy transfer processes that occur in Er3+\mathrm{Er}^{3+}-doped CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2} and on developing charge noise models. These will further quantify the role of charged defect-mediated decoherence and inform design strategies for its mitigation.

Supplementary Material

Supplementary Material includes details on density functional theory calculations (pseudopotentials, finite-size corrections, piecewise linearity, formation energies, photoionization cross-sections, comparison with previous experimental and computational literature on CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2}) and photocurrent measurements.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Diego Sorbelli, Jiawei Zhan, Yu Jin, and Shreya Verma for helpful discussions. This work was primarily funded by MICCoM, which is part of the Computational Materials Sciences Program funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Basic Energy Sciences, Materials Sciences, and Engineering Division. V.S acknowledges the support from the Maria Goeppert Mayer Named Fellowship, under the Laboratory Directed Research and Development (LDRD) funding from Argonne National Laboratory, provided by the Director, Office of Science, of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC02-06CH11357. The optical and photocurrent measurements were supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Basic Energy Sciences, Materials Sciences and Engineering Division (F.J.H., J.Z.). The material synthesis and photocurrent device fabrication (I.M., G.D.G, S.G.) were supported by Q-NEXT, a U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science National Quantum Information Science Research Center under Award Number DE-FOA-0002253. G.-M.R. is a Research Director of the Fonds de la Recherche Scientifique - FNRS. W.J. acknowledges the support from FNRS. This research used resources of the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center (NERSC), a Department of Energy Office of Science User Facility using NERSC award DDR-ERCAP0029604 and resources of the Argonne Leadership Computing Facility, a U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science user facility at Argonne National Laboratory, which is supported by the Office of Science of the U.S. DOE under Contract No. DE-AC02-06CH11357.

Data Availability Statement

The data that support the findings of this study will be made available on Qresp50.

Author Declarations

The authors have no conflicts to disclose.

Author Contributions

V.S. - Conceptualization (lead), Data Curation (lead), Formal Analysis (equal), Funding Acquisition (equal), Investigation (equal), Methodology (lead), Project Administration (equal), Resources (equal), Software (equal), Validation (equal), Visualization (lead), Writing/Original Draft Preparation (lead), Writing/Review and Editing (equal)

I.M. and G.D.G. - Formal Analysis (equal), Investigation (equal), Validation (equal), Writing/Review and Editing (equal)

W.J. and M.G. - Investigation (equal), Methodology (supporting), Software (equal), Validation (equal), Writing/Review and Editing (equal)

S.G. - Funding Acquisition (equal), Project Administration (equal), Resources (equal), Supervision (equal), Writing/Review and Editing (equal)

G.M.R. - Funding Acquisition (equal), Project Administration (equal), Resources (equal), Supervision (equal), Writing/Review and Editing (equal)

F.J.H. - Methodology (supporting), Supervision (equal), Writing/Review and Editing (equal)

J.Z. - Methodology (supporting), Project Administration (equal), Resources (equal), Supervision (equal), Writing/Review and Editing (equal)

G.G. - Conceptualization (supporting), Project Administration (equal), Resources (equal), Supervision (equal), Writing/Review and Editing (equal)

Optical decoherence in Er3+\mathrm{Er}^{3+}-doped CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2} spin qubit platforms

Vrindaa Somjit; Ignas Masiulionis; Gregory D. Grant; Weiguo Jing; Matteo Giantomassi; Supratik Guha; Gian-Marco Rignanese; F. Joseph Heremans; Jiefei Zhang; Giulia Galli

si.pdf

Density Functional Theory Calculations

Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were carried out within the generalized Kohn-Sham framework[1, 2], using the plane-wave pseudopotential method as implemented in the Quantum Espresso code[3, 4, 5]. ONCV pseudopotentials[6, 7] were used, with 5s25p66s24f15d15s^{2}5p^{6}6s^{2}4f^{1}5d^{1}, 5s25p66s24f115d15s^{2}5p^{6}6s^{2}4f^{11}5d^{1}, and 2s22p42s^{2}2p^{4} as the valence configurations for Ce, Er, and O, respectively. The inclusion of 4f electrons in the valence partition necessitates a large plane-wave cutoff of 200 Ry. The dielectric-dependent hybrid (DDH) exchange-correlation functional was used, with the Hartree-Fock mixing parameter α\alpha set to 0.188 (α=ε∞−1\alpha= \varepsilon_{\infty}^{-1}, where ε∞=5.31\varepsilon_{\infty} = 5.31, as experimentally measured for bulk single crystal CeO2_{2}[8]). Spin-polarized calculations were carried out with a 2×2×22 \times2 \times2 (96 atoms) supercell of cubic fluorite CeO2_{2}, using the experimental lattice constants at 298 K (a=b=c=5.411a = b = c = 5.411 \text{\AA}[9]). The Brillouin zone of the supercell was sampled with the Γ\Gamma point.

Performance of scalar relativistic ONCV pseudopotentials

Tables SI and SII summarize the performance of the Ce and Er ONCV pseudopotentials[6, 7] developed in this work. Their accuracy was assessed using the ν\nu metric, which quantitatively measures the difference between the equations of state (EOS) obtained with a pseudopotential (PS) and those from all-electron (AE) calculations. A smaller ν\nu value indicates better agreement with the AE reference and therefore higher pseudopotential accuracy.

Following the framework proposed by Bosoni et al.⁷,

ν(PS,AE)=100∑Y=V0,B0,B1[wYYPS−YAE(YPS+YAE)/2]2(4)\nu(PS,AE) = 100 \sqrt{\sum_{Y=V_0,B_0,B_1} \left[w_Y \frac{Y_{PS}-Y_{AE}}{(Y_{PS}+Y_{AE})/2}\right]^2} \tag*{(4)}

where the benchmark consists of four mono-elemental cubic crystals and six cubic oxides, as summarized in Tables SI and SII. Here, V0V_0 is the equilibrium volume, B0B_0 is the bulk modulus, and B1B_1 is the pressure derivative of the bulk modulus, all obtained by fitting the EOS to the Birch–Murnaghan equation. The coefficients wYw_Y are weighting factors assigned to each parameter, with wV0=1w_{V_0}=1, wB0=1/20w_{B_0}=1/20, and wB1=1/400w_{B_1}=1/400.

All ONCV pseudopotential calculations were performed with ABINIT[10]. The ν\nu-metric verification followed the protocol of Bosoni et al.⁷: Fermi–Dirac smearing with a smearing temperature of T0=2.25T_0=2.25 mHa was employed, a Γ\Gamma-centered uniform k-point grid with a reciprocal-space spacing finer than ∼0.06\sim0.06 Å−1^{-1} was used, the plane-wave cutoff energy was set to 100 Ha, and the self-consistent field (SCF) convergence threshold was 10−1010^{-10} Ha/atom. The AE reference data were taken as the average of the latest cross-code AE datasets obtained by FLEUR and WIEN2k.

In addition, Tables SI and SII include the ν\nu values reported by Bosoni et al.⁷ for VASP (v6.3)11–15 using the POTPAW_PBE.54 pseudopotentials and for Quantum ESPRESSO using the Standard Solid-State Pseudopotentials (SSSP) library16 (PBE precision, version 1.3).

StructureThis work (ONCV)VASP (PAW)11–15SSSP (PAW)16
SC0.3020.2171.167
BCC1.0410.4341.098
Diamond0.0650.1060.703
FCC0.8190.2320.907
X2OX_{2}\mathrm{O}0.1420.0880.468
XOX\mathrm{O}0.0580.0560.268
X2O3X_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3}0.1480.1130.368
XO2X\mathrm{O}_{2}0.2640.1210.369
X2O5X_{2}\mathrm{O}_{5}0.2460.1440.343
XO3X\mathrm{O}_{3}0.0710.1850.975
Avg ν\nu0.3160.1700.667

Table SI. Ce ONCV pseudopotential performance (ν\nu metric; X=CeX=\mathrm{Ce}). Alt text: Comparison of the Ce ONCV pseudopotential used in this work with VASP PAW and SSSP PAW pseudopotentials, based on the ν\nu metric, across four mono-elemental cubic crystals and six cubic oxides. Our ONCV pseudopotentials have lower ν\nu than SSSP PAW but higher than VASP PAW pseudopotentials.

StructureThis work (ONCV)VASP (PAW)11–15SSSP (PAW)16
SC1.8140.9044.528
BCC2.0220.7633.796
Diamond2.8502.50310.349
FCC2.0090.8904.517
X2OX_{2}\mathrm{O}0.3450.2660.815
XOX\mathrm{O}0.1770.1260.309
X2O3X_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3}0.2370.1370.619
XO2X\mathrm{O}_{2}0.3500.2760.964
X2O5X_{2}\mathrm{O}_{5}0.1870.1520.504
XO3X\mathrm{O}_{3}0.0800.5932.004
Avg ν\nu1.0070.6612.840

Table SII. Er ONCV pseudopotential performance (ν\nu metric, X=Er). Alt text: Comparison of the Er ONCV pseudopotential used in this work with VASP PAW and SSSP PAW pseudopotentials, based on the ν\nu metric, across four mono-elemental cubic crystals and six cubic oxides. Our ONCV pseudopotentials have lower ν\nu than SSSP PAW but higher than VASP PAW pseudopotentials.

Choice of exchange-correlation functional

Table SIII lists the experimentally measured optical bandgap of CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2}. From Table SIII, it is apparent that the optical bandgap and dielectric constants of CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2} significantly depend on deposition parameters, substrate, and sample morphology. For example, in CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2} nanoparticles and nanocrystalline thin films, quantum confinement effects can increase the optical bandgap, causing a blue shift, but the presence of Ce3+\mathrm{Ce}^{3+} ions in the sample can lead to a red shift17,18. The reported bandgap also depends on whether it was inferred from Tauc plot fits, absorption onsets, or absorption peaks, as also discussed by Castleton et al. (19). All the optical bandgaps reported in Table SIII were taken from Tauc plot fits; except for20 and21 (who considered absorption peaks) and22 (who considered absorption onset). We use the value of ε∞=5.31\varepsilon_{\infty}=5.31 as reported for bulk single crystals of CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2}[8] for the exchange fraction (α=ε∞−1\alpha=\varepsilon_{\infty}^{-1}) used in the DDH functional. As discussed in Section VII and shown in Tables SV and SVI, the chosen exchange fraction gives rise to a piecewise linear functional and accurate optical bandgaps (e.g., the first excitation energy computed with TDDFT@DDH is 3.49 eV, similar to the values reported for bulk powder and single crystals in Table SIII and as found in our photoluminescence and photoluminescence excitation measurements of undoped single crystal CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2} films in Figure S1).

Photoluminescence spectrum of undoped single crystal CeO2 films

(a)

Photoluminescence excitation spectrum of undoped single crystal CeO2 films

(b)

Figure S1. (a) Photoluminescence (PL; excitation at 230 nm, 5 nm bandwidth) and (b) photoluminescence excitation (PLE; collection at 450 nm) spectra of undoped single crystal ∼230\sim230 nm thick CeO2_2 films at room temperature measured in this work. Band edge is at ∼360\sim360 nm (3.44 eV).

Abbreviations and acronyms used in Tables SIII and SIV:

UV-vis DRS: ultraviolet-visible diffuse reflectance spectroscopy; EELS: electron energy loss spectroscopy; opt. refl.: optical reflectance spectroscopy; Rests. refl.: Reststrahlen reflectivity spectroscopy; SE: spectroscopic ellipsometry; UV-TAS: ultraviolet transient absorption spectroscopy; HREELS: high resolution electron energy loss spectroscopy; RF: radio-frequency sputtering; e-beam evap.: electron beam evaporation; PLD: pulsed laser deposition; co-evap.: co-evaporation; MOCVD: metal organic chemical vapor deposition; PSE-CVD: pulsed-spray evaporation chemical vapor deposition; ED: electrodeposition; PED: pulsed electron deposition; MBE: molecular beam epitaxy; PE-CVD: plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition; VB XPS: valence band X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy; BIS: Bremsstrahlung isochromat spectroscopy; STM: scanning tunneling microscopy; UPS: ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy; laser abl: laser ablation; ALD: atomic layer deposition

Alt text: Photoluminescence and photoluminescence excitation spectra of undoped CeO2_2 films plotted as intensity vs. wavelength. Both plots show the highest intensity at ∼360\sim360 nm.

Table SIV lists the experimentally measured fundamental bandgap of CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2}. There are far fewer measurements of the fundamental band gap than of the optical bandgap. Valence band X-Ray photoemission spectroscopy (VB-XPS), ultra-violet photoemission spectroscopy (UPS), and scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) measurements are highly surface-sensitive: for example, surface adsorbates, surface orientation, and band-bending strongly influence measured values[48]. The data listed in Table SIV were inferred by approximating the slope of the steepest part of the leading edge of the VBM/4f/5d\mathrm{VBM}/4f/5d bands, and thus, are highly approximate values. We also report the CeCe1−\mathrm{Ce}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-} polaron vertical transition levels (VTLs) μ(−1/0)pol\mu(-1/0)_{\mathrm{pol}} with respect to the VBM where available. Note that from Table 1 in the main text, the CeCe1−\mathrm{Ce}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-} VTLs computed in this work are ≃2.32−2.81 eV\simeq2.32 - 2.81\,\mathrm{eV} with respect to the VBM (depending on whether we consider an isolated CeCe1−\mathrm{Ce}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-} or CeCe1−\mathrm{Ce}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-} bound to oxygen vacancy). Table SIV also lists the polaron formation energy (Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}}) from ultraviolet transient absorption spectroscopy (UV-TAS), -0.4 eV.

DefectCTLEnergyVTLEnergy
ErCe_{\mathrm{Ce}}(0/−1)(0/-1)3.11
Polaron(0/−1)(0/-1)0.62(−1/0)(-1/0)<br>(0/−1)(0/-1)1.40<br>−0.05-0.05
VO_{\mathrm{O}}(+2/+1)(+2/+1)0.74(+1/+2)(+1/+2)<br>(+2/+1)(+2/+1)1.89<br>0.09
VO_{\mathrm{O}}(+1/0)(+1/0)0.81(0/+1)(0/+1)<br>(+1/0)(+1/0)1.56<br>0.22
[ErCe−VO][\mathrm{Er}_{\mathrm{Ce}}-\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}](+1/0)(+1/0)0.84(0/+1)(0/+1)<br>(+1/0)(+1/0)1.91<br>0.23

Table 1. Energy (eV) of the thermodynamic charge transition levels (CTLs, Equation 1) and vertical transition levels (VTLs, Equation 2) relative to the CBM (minimum of the Ce 4f band) for the defects investigated in this work. The difference between the CTL of the defect complex and that of the isolated polaron is the binding energy of the complex. All binding energy values are positive, indicating the stability of the complexes. VO_{\mathrm{O}} denotes oxygen vacancy.

Alt text: Summary of several properties of CeO2_2 samples, including single crystals and thin films, synthesized and measured using various techniques.

SampleExperimentBandgap (eV)a0a_0 (Å)ε∞\varepsilon_\inftyε0\varepsilon_0Notes
Bulk powder22,23UV-vis DRS22particle size
EELS223.15–3.22221–5 μ\mum22
UV-vis233.55235.52220.7–1 μ\mum23
Single crystalOpt. refl.214.721from melt (mm3^3)[8] [21]
bulk[8] [21]Rests. refl.[8]3.8215.31[8]35.321RF sputtering[24]
thin film[24]SE[24]3.3–3.6[24]6.1[24]24.5[8](10–100 nm thick)
Polycrystalline thin filmUV-vis[25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31]3.53–3.6[25]5.42[25]5.06–5.76[27]spray pyrolysis[25] (0.5–1 μ\mum thick; 8–50 nm crystallite size)
3.6–4.11[26]5.50–5.54[27]e-beam evap.[26] (0.14–0.18 μ\mum thick; 15–36 nm crystallite size)
3.12–3.16[27]RF sputtering[27] (0.31–0.37 μ\mum thick; 68–89 nm grains)
3.33–3.66[28]PLD[28] (0.2 μ\mum thickness)
3.10[29]co-evap.[29] (0.3 μ\mum thick)
3.02–3.38[30]ox. Ce film[30] (0.1–0.2 μ\mum thick)
3.23[31]RF sputtering[31] (0.36 μ\mum thick)
SE[32]3.05[32]5.50–5.54[27]5.39[31]5.22[32]MOCVD[32] (1.2–1.5 μ\mum thick; 100–130 nm grains)
Nanocrystalline thin filmUV-vis[33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40] [17]3.23[33]sol-gel[33] (3–4 nm crystallite size)
2.8–3.15[34]PSE-CVD[34] (41–334 nm thick; 6–32 nm crystallite size)
3.18[35]spray pyrolysis[35] (7 nm crystallite size)
2.9–3.35[36]sol-gel[36] (182–217 nm thick; 4–10 nm crystallite size)
3.19–3.75[37]ED[37] (5–6 nm crystalltie size)
3.45–3.53[38]RF sputtering[38] (380–590 nm thick; 6–9 nm crystallite size)
2.5817PED17 (100 nm thick; 5–20 nm crystallite size)
3–3.6[39]sol-gel[39] (120–560 nm thick)
3.1[40]sol-gel[40] (200 nm thick)
UV-TAS20420MBE20 (6 nm thick)
SE[41, 42]2.4–2.84[41]PE-CVD[41] (6–7 nm crystallite size)
3.23[42]5.401[35]4.7[41]RF sputtering[42] (12.5 nm thick)
HREELS[43]3.2[43]5.42175.43[42]e-beam evap.[43] (10–40 nm thick)
NanoparticlesUV-vis DRS[44, 45]2.57–2.93[44]particle size
3.36[45]5.404–5.422[44]5–14 nm[44]
UV-vis[46, 47]3.13–3.66[46]5.408[45]10–100 nm[45]
4.25[47]5.426[46]3.5 nm[46]
2 nm[47]

Table SIII. Experimental optical bandgap, lattice parameter, and dielectric constants of CeO2_2 (see Section III for acronyms and abbreviations)

ExperimentBandgap (O2p\mathrm{O}_{2p}-Ce 4f)Bandgap (O2p\mathrm{O}_{2p}-Ce 5d)CeCe1−\mathrm{Ce}^{1-}_{\mathrm{Ce}} VTL w.r.t. VBMEself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}}Notes
VB XPS-BIS493.56ox. Ce film
STM504.2561.6 (VTL)ox. Ce film forming 1 nm thick CeO2_2(111)
UPS[43]2 (VTL)e-beam evap. 10-40 nm thick CeO2_2(111)
VB XPS512 (VTL)laser abl. single crystal thin film CeO2_2 (001), (110)
VB XPS[48]3–3.2 (VTL)ALD 20 nm thin film CeO2_2(111) surface carbonate species could increase VTL by 0.48 eV
UV-TAS20-0.4 eVMBE 6 nm thin film

Table SIV. Experimental fundamental bandgaps and CeCe1−\mathrm{Ce}^{1-}_{\mathrm{Ce}} VTLs wrt VBM of CeO2_2 (all energies in eV; see Section III for acronyms and abbreviations)

Alt text: Summary of fundamental bandgaps, polaron vertical transition levels, and polaron self-trapping energy of CeO2_2 samples, measured using VB XPS-BIS, STM, UPS, and UV-TAS.

Finally, Table SV reports the fundamental and optical bandgaps obtained using various first-principles methods. We note here that computational studies often try to tune the Hubbard UeffU_{\mathrm{eff}} or exchange fraction α\alpha to match the computed Kohn–Sham gap to the optical bandgap of CeO2_2. However, the Kohn–Sham gap, albeit approximate, should be compared to the fundamental gap, not the optical gap, as it does not account for excitonic effects, which reduce the optical gap compared to the fundamental gap52 (the exciton binding energy in CeO2_2 has not been reported experimentally). Based on the values reported in Table SV and the discussion of Section VII, we conclude that our simulation settings accurately capture the electronic structure of CeO2_2.

Functionala0a_0 (Å)Bandgap (O2p-Ce 4f)Bandgap (O2p-Ce 5d)Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}}CeCe1−_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-} VTL w.r.t. CBM
LDA[1, 2]5.360531.653653
5.37542.0545.6154
PBE555.468531.753653
5.46561.875565.6356
PBE+U57–59 (Ueff=5U_{\mathrm{eff}}=5 eV56,60)5.500562.2554,565.2056
(Ueff=4.5U_{\mathrm{eff}}=4.5 eV54)5.4954,602.3605.354,60-0.54600.9760
HSE03[61] (α=0.25,ω=0.3\alpha=0.25,\omega=0.3 Å−1^{-1})5.408533.353753
HSE06[62] (α=0.25,ω=0.2\alpha=0.25,\omega=0.2 Å−1^{-1})6.9956
5.394563.61[63] [56]6.954-0.30[63] [60] (Eq. 5)
5.4054,603.554,607.060-0.36[63] (Eq. 6)0.8260
HSE06[62] (α=0.15,ω=0.2\alpha=0.15,\omega=0.2 Å−1^{-1})5.418562.85566.4456
PBE0[64, 65] (α=0.25\alpha=0.25)5.39544.5547.9354-1.45[63] (Eq. 5)
5.40[66]4.36[66]8.52[66]-1.86[63] (Eq. 6)
G0W0@LDA+U (Ueff=5.4U_{\mathrm{eff}}=5.4)3.62[67]
4.36[8]6.1[68]
GW0@LDA+U (Ueff=5.4U_{\mathrm{eff}}=5.4)3.88[67]
G0W0@PBE4.02526.0652
GW-BSE3.8852
TDDFT@HSE063.7652
TDDFT@PBE03.8052
PBE (this work)552.065.67
HSE06 (this work)[62]4.266.75-0.55 (Eq. 5)
-0.53 (Eq. 6)
DDH (this work)[69, 70]4.217.03-0.37 (Eq. 5)1.40
-0.62 (Eq. 6)
TDDFT@DDH (this work)3.49

Table SV. Computed lattice parameter, bandgap, polaron self-trapping energy and vertical transition levels w.r.t CBM of CeO2_2 (all energies in eV; definitions of Eq. 5 and Eq. 6 given in Section VII)

Alt text: Summary of computed properties of CeO2_2 with various functionals.

Calculation of Formation Energies

We recall that the general expression for the formation energy of a defect in charge state qq and configuration Rq′\mathbf{R}_{q}^{\prime} is given by[71, 72]

Ef(q,Rq′)=E(q,Rq′)−Eperf+q(εF+εVBM)−∑iniμi+Ecorr(q,Rq′) ,(5)E_{\mathrm{f}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q}^{\prime})=E(q,\mathbf{R}_{q}^{\prime})-E_{\mathrm{perf}}+q(\varepsilon_{\mathrm{F}}+\varepsilon_{\mathrm{VBM}})-\sum_i n_i\mu_i+E_{\mathrm{corr}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q}^{\prime}) \, , \tag*{(5)}

where E(q,Rq′)E(q,\mathbf{R}_{q}^{\prime}) is the total energy of the supercell with the defect (Rq′\mathbf{R}_{q}^{\prime} obtained by relaxing the atomic coordinates of the supercell with the same defect, but with charge q′q^{\prime}); EperfE_{\mathrm{perf}} is the total energy of the pristine (perfect) supercell of the same size; εF\varepsilon_{\mathrm{F}} is the Fermi level relative to the valence band maximum (VBM) εVBM\varepsilon_{\mathrm{VBM}} of the pristine cell; nin_i is the number of atoms of type ii added to (ni>0n_i>0) or removed from (ni<0n_i<0) the supercell with corresponding chemical potentials μi\mu_i; and Ecorr(q,Rq′)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q}^{\prime}) is a correction term for the artificial electrostatic interactions arising due to the finite size of the periodic supercell. Equation (5) allows us to compute the formation energy of a defect with charge qq relaxed to its equilibrium atomic configuration (required to obtain thermodynamic charge transition levels), as well as the formation energy of a defect with charge qq in a configuration frozen in the relaxed equilibrium atomic configuration of q′q^{\prime} (required to obtain optical charge transition levels). We use the expression proposed by Freysoldt, Neugebauer, and Van de Walle to compute Ecorr(q,Rq)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q})[73] (with ε0=24.58\varepsilon_{0}=24.5^{8} for CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2}) as implemented in sxdefectalign[74]. The evaluation of Ecorr(q,Rq′)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q}^{\prime}) requires special care, as different ionic and electronic screening are involved when considering a charge qq in a fixed configuration corresponding to that of the charge q′q^{\prime}[72, 75]. We compute Ecorr(q,Rq′)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(q,\mathbf{R}_{q}^{\prime}) using the expression of Gake et al.[75] (with ε∞=5.318\varepsilon_{\infty}=5.31^{8} for CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2}), also implemented in sxdefectalign[74].

Calculation of Photoionization Cross-Sections

The photoionization cross-section is the transition rate per unit photon flux and is computed as[76, 77]

σph(ℏω)=4π2α3nrefℏω∑j∣rdj∣2A(ℏω−Edj),(6)\sigma_{\mathrm{ph}}(\hbar\omega) = \frac{4\pi^{2}\alpha}{3n_{\mathrm{ref}}}\hbar\omega\sum_{j} \lvert\mathbf{r}_{dj} \rvert^{2} A(\hbar\omega-E_{dj}), \tag*{(6)}

where α\alpha is the fine-structure constant, nrefn_{\mathrm{ref}} is the refractive index of CeO2_2 (2.30), and ℏω\hbar\omega is the photon energy. Here we consider the photoionization of an ensemble of randomly oriented defects; dd denotes the initial defect state with wavefunction φd\varphi_d and the sum runs over all final states φj\varphi_j (i.e., the entire Ce 4f band). rdj\mathbf{r}_{dj} is the optical matrix element (computed as the transition dipole moment) between the initial defect state and final Ce 4f band state and is given by rdj=⟨φd∣r∣φj⟩\mathbf{r}_{dj} = \langle\varphi_d \lvert\mathbf{r} \rvert\varphi_j \rangle. In principle, φd\varphi_d and φj\varphi_j are many-body states, but in practice, we use Kohn-Sham states[77]. We compute rdj\mathbf{r}_{dj} as rdj=⟨φd∣[H^,r]∣φj⟩εd−εj\mathbf{r}_{dj} = \frac{\langle\varphi_d \lvert[\hat{H},\mathbf{r}] \rvert\varphi_j \rangle}{\varepsilon_d-\varepsilon_j}, where εd\varepsilon_d (εj\varepsilon_j) is the energy of the Kohn-Sham orbital of the defect (final) state, as implemented in the WEST code[78, 79, 80]. EdjE_{dj} is the energy difference between the Kohn-Sham eigenvalues of the initial and final states, rigidly shifted so that the smallest value of EdjE_{dj} corresponds to the CTL. A(ℏω−Edj)A(\hbar\omega-E_{dj}) is the normalized spectral function of electron-phonon coupling, given as

A(ℏω−Edj)=∑m∑nPdm(T)∣⟨χdm∣χjn⟩∣2δ(Edj+Ejn−Edm−ℏω).(7)A(\hbar\omega-E_{dj}) = \sum_m \sum_n P_d^m(T) \lvert\langle\chi_d^m \mid\chi_j^n \rangle\rvert^2 \delta(E_{dj}+E_j^n-E_d^m-\hbar\omega). \tag*{(7)}

We used the one-dimensional configurational coordinate diagram (1D-CCD) approach to obtain the effective phonon frequencies of the ground and excited states. The vibrational overlap function ⟨χdm∣χjn⟩\langle\chi_d^m \mid\chi_j^n \rangle between mthm^{\mathrm{th}} (nthn^{\mathrm{th}}) vibrational state of defect state φd\varphi_d (excited state φj\varphi_j) with energy EdmE_d^m (EjnE_j^n) was computed using the recursion method[81]. The delta function was modeled as a Gaussian with width 25 meV. Pdm(T)P_d^m(T) is the thermal distribution function of the vibrational energy in the ground state; Pdm(T)=e−Edm/kBT/∑me−Edm/kBTP_d^m(T) = e^{-E_d^m/k_{\mathrm{B}}T}/\sum_m e^{-E_d^m/k_{\mathrm{B}}T}.

Since ionization occurs due to the excitation of the Ce1−Ce{}^{1-}_{\mathrm{Ce}}\mathrm{Ce} polaron (isolated or as a component of a defect complex), we use the Kohn-Sham wavefunctions and energies of the ground state configuration of the defect to capture the polaronic state of the defects when computing rdj\mathbf{r}_{dj}. We note that we have not tested the convergence of the cross-section as a function of the supercell size, which would be a computationally prohibitive task due to the large plane-wave cutoff (200 Ry) and use of hybrid functionals. However, we do not expect the trends to change with larger cell sizes, given the localized nature of the defects considered here.

LOCALIZED ERBIUM 4F STATES

Figure S2 shows the Inverse Participation Ratio (IPR) of Kohn-Sham orbitals in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2. We see that the Er3+^{3+} 4f levels are localized, as marked by the dotted ovals. The unoccupied spin down states occur in the Ce 5d band, not the Ce 4f band. The energy difference between the occupied and unoccupied spin down orbitals is similar to that found in Er2_2O3_3 using GW0_0@LDA+U[82].

Figure S2. Inverse Participation Ratio (IPR) of Kohn-Sham orbitals in Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2. Er3+^{3+} 4f levels are localized, as marked by the dotted ovals. Blue- valence band, red- Ce 4f band, green- Ce 5d band, VBM- valence band maximum.

Alt text: Inverse participation ratio of Kohn-Sham orbitals of Er3+^{3+}-doped CeO2_2. Localized occupied spin up orbitals seen from −4 to −2 eV, localized occupied spin-down orbitals seen just above the VBM, and localized unoccupied spin down orbitals seen just above the start of the Ce 5d band. Ce 4f band lies between the O 2p valence band and Ce 5d band, from 4.2–5.4 eV.

Effect of the Exchange-Correlation Functional and Finite-Size Corrections on Polaron Self-Trapping Energy and Piecewise Linearity

In CeO2_2, an electron polaron is formed when an excess electron localizes on a Ce4+^{4+} site, converting it to Ce3+^{3+}. The self-trapping energy of an electron polaron (also known as polaron formation energy or polaron binding energy) can be computed as

Eself−trap=E(−1,R−1)−E(−1,Rperf)(8)E_{\mathrm{self-trap}} = E(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1}) - E(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}}) \tag*{(8)}

or

Eself−trap=E(−1,R−1)−Eperf−εCBM+Ecorr(−1,R−1),(9)E_{\mathrm{self-trap}} = E(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1}) - E_{\mathrm{perf}} - \varepsilon_{\mathrm{CBM}} + E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1}), \tag*{(9)}

Here, E(−1,R−1)E(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1}) is the total energy of the supercell with an excess electron that localizes to form the polaron (and Ecorr(−1,R−1)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1}) is its corresponding finite-size correction); E(−1,Rperf)E(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}}) is the total energy of the pristine supercell with an excess delocalized electron. Note that εCBM\varepsilon_{\mathrm{CBM}} is the minimum of the Ce 4f band. A negative Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}} indicates that the polaron is more stable than a delocalized electron in the conduction band. Rearranging the terms in Equation (1) of the main text (see calculation of CTL) and Equation (9) above results in ε(0/−1)pol=−Eself−trap\varepsilon(0/-1)_{\mathrm{pol}}=-E_{\mathrm{self-trap}}.

Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}} computed using Equation (8) gives −0.37-0.37 eV, similar to the value (−0.30-0.30 eV) obtained using HSE06 by Sun et al.60 and Castleton[63]. Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}} computed using Equation (9) gives −0.62-0.62 eV. In principle, with an exact exchange-correlation functional, piecewise linearity would be satisfied[83, 84, 85] (i.e., E(−1,Rperf)−EperfE(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}})-E_{\mathrm{perf}} would be equal to εCBM\varepsilon_{\mathrm{CBM}} of the pristine supercell), and thus Equations (8) and (9) should give the same value (assuming Ecorr(−1,R−1)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1}) is accounted for in Equation (8)). The discrepancy between the two values above is due to the missing finite-size corrections in Equation (8).

Equation (8) assumes that the finite-size corrections for the supercell with the delocalized electron is equal to that of the cell with the localized electron polaron (i.e., Ecorr(−1,Rperf)=Ecorr(−1,R−1)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}})=E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1})), and therefore does not include any corrections. However, as reported in multiple recent studies[72, 75], this is an incorrect assumption, as the electronic and ionic polarizations for the delocalized system are different from those of the localized system, resulting in different finite-size corrections. Thus, Equation (8) should be re-written as

Eself−trap=E(−1,R−1)−E(−1,Rperf)+Ecorr(−1,R−1)−Ecorr(−1,Rperf)(10)E_{\mathrm{self-trap}}=E(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1})-E(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}})+E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1})-E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}}) \tag*{(10)}

Ecorr(−1,R−1)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1}) is calculated using the method of Freysoldt, Neugebauer, and Van de Walle[73] using ε0=24.5\varepsilon_0=24.5[8], and Ecorr(−1,Rperf)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}}) is calculated using the method of Gake et al.[75] using ε∞=5.31\varepsilon_{\infty}=5.31[8]. In particular, in the calculation of Ecorr(−1,Rperf)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}}), the excess electron is only electronically screened. Since the charge is delocalized, only the point-charge correction term needs to be included, accounting for the interaction of the background neutralizing charge with the defect potential. We used the implementation in the sxdefectalign package to obtain the finite-size corrections.

As seen in Table SVI, Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}} calculated using (10) is nearly equal to that calculated using (9). This agreement results from the fact that including Ecorr(−1,Rperf)E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}}) restores piecewise linearity, as shown in Table SVI, where E(−1,Rperf)−Eperf+Ecorr(−1,Rperf)E(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}})-E_{\mathrm{perf}}+E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}}) is nearly equal to the εCBM\varepsilon_{\mathrm{CBM}} of the pristine supercell.

Similarly, if piecewise linearity is satisfied, the Kohn-Sham defect level of the polaron should remain constant while changing its occupation (from −1-1 to 00 in the case of electron polaron), with the supercell geometry fixed to that with the polaronic distortion. As seen in Table SVI, including finite-size corrections improves the agreement between the Kohn-Sham levels, with the difference between εpol(−1)\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pol}}(-1) and εpol(0)\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pol}}(0) reducing from 0.44 eV to 0.26 eV. The correction to εpol(−1)\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pol}}(-1) and εpol(0)\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pol}}(0) were calculated as −2Ecorr(−1,R−1)−1\frac{-2E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{-1})}{-1} and 2Ecorr(0,R−1)−1\frac{2E_{\mathrm{corr}}(0,\mathbf{R}_{-1})}{-1}, respectively, as described by Falletta et al[85].

QuantityValueQuantityValueQuantityValue
Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}}, eq:4-0.37εCBM\varepsilon_{\mathrm{CBM}}14.55εpol(−1)\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pol}}(-1)13.52
Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}}, eq:5-0.62E(−1,Rperf)−EperfE(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}})-E_{\mathrm{perf}}14.24εpol(0)\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pol}}(0)13.96
Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}}, eq:6-0.66E(−1,Rperf)−Eperf+Ecorr(−1,Rperf)E(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}})-E_{\mathrm{perf}}+E_{\mathrm{corr}}(-1,\mathbf{R}_{\mathrm{perf}})14.60εpol(−1)\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pol}}(-1) (w/ corr)13.66
εpol(0)\varepsilon_{\mathrm{pol}}(0) (w/ corr)13.40

Table SVI. Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}} values from various formalisms and demonstration of the effect of finite-size corrections on piecewise linearity using the CBM and polaron Kohn-Sham level

Alt text: Effect of finite-size corrections on polaron self-trapping energy and piecewise linearity. Polaron self-trapping energies computed using different formalisms give the same value only upon including finite-size corrections. Similarly, piecewise linearity in the CBM and polaron Kohn-Sham levels is observed only after including the corrections.

We note here that the deviation from piecewise linearity is larger for the polaron Kohn-Sham level than for the CBM. This could be due to strain-related finite-size effects in our 2×2×22 \times2 \times2 supercell, which are not accounted for by the electrostatics-based correction schemes employed in this work. For instance, Castleton[63] showed that the polaron formation energy computed using LDA+U and a 96-atom supercell can differ by 0.06−0.130.06-0.13 eV from the thermodynamic limit, even with finite-size corrections.

Finally, we note that we do not see any discrepancies when using Equation (8) vs. Equation (9) with the HSE06 functional (see Table SV) - possibly due to the screening incorporated in HSE06, which likely (and spuriously) corrects for the finite-size effects when computing Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}} using Equation (8) (note that in the benchmarking study by Castleton[63], Eself−trapE_{\mathrm{self-trap}} computed using Equation (8) vs. Equation (9) with the PBE0 exchange-correlation functional also shows a sizeable difference, similar to that found with the DDH functional in this work).

CONFIGURATION COORDINATE DIAGRAMS FOR THE CALCULATION OF DEFECT IONIZATION

One-dimensional configuration coordinate diagram for defect ionization, panel (a)

(a)

One-dimensional configuration coordinate diagram for defect ionization, panel (b)

(b)

One-dimensional configuration coordinate diagram for defect ionization, panel (c)

(c)

One-dimensional configuration coordinate diagram for defect ionization, panel (d)

(d)

Figure S3. One-dimensional configuration coordinate diagrams (1D-CCD) of the various defect ionizations considered in this study. Only points used to fit the parabolas are shown. ΔQ\Delta Q is the mass-weighted displacement, calculated as ΔQ=(∑α=1N∑i=x,y,zMαΔRαi2)1/2\Delta Q = \left(\sum_{\alpha=1}^{N}\sum_{i=x,y,z}M_{\alpha}\Delta R_{\alpha i}^{2}\right)^{1/2}, where MαM_{\alpha} = mass of atom α\alpha and ΔRαi\Delta R_{\alpha i} = displacement of atom α\alpha between the excited state and ground state equilibrium structures in the ithi^{\text{th}} direction).

Alt text: 1D-CCD plots for the ionization of the various defects considered in this work (see Table 1 in main text). The points near the relaxed ground- and excited-state structures are used to fit the potential energy surfaces.

Transitionℏωgs\hbar\omega_{\mathrm{gs}}ℏωes\hbar\omega_{\mathrm{es}}ΔQ\Delta Q
CeCe1−→CeCe0+e−\mathrm{Ce}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-} \rightarrow\mathrm{Ce}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{0} + e^{-}45.2869.420.95
VO1+→VO2++e−\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}^{1+} \rightarrow\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}^{2+} + e^{-}39.3146.001.60
VO0→VO1++e−\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}^{0} \rightarrow\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}^{1+} + e^{-}39.1043.291.62
[ErCe–VO]0→[ErCe–VO]1++e−[\mathrm{Er}_{\mathrm{Ce}}\text{–}\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}]^{0} \rightarrow[\mathrm{Er}_{\mathrm{Ce}}\text{–}\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}]^{1+} + e^{-}40.8547.481.60

Table SVII. Ground- and excited-state effective vibrational frequencies (ℏωgs\hbar\omega_{\mathrm{gs}} and ℏωes\hbar\omega_{\mathrm{es}}), and mass-weighted displacements (ΔQ\Delta Q) along the effective phonon mode for the defect transitions above. Frequencies are given in meV and ΔQ\Delta Q in amu1/2^{1/2} Å. Defects are described using the expression ABq\mathrm{A}_{\mathrm{B}}^{q}, denoting atom A substituting site B with relative charge qq. VO\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}} denotes oxygen vacancy.

Alt text: Ground- and excited-state effective phonon frequencies and mass-weighted displacements (ΔQ\Delta Q) along the effective phonon mode of the various defect ionizations considered in this work. The complexes have similar frequencies (∼\sim40 meV in the ground state, ∼\sim45 meV in the excited state), with ΔQ∼1.60\Delta Q \sim1.60. The frequencies of the isolated polaron are slightly higher and the ΔQ\Delta Q is lower.

Photoionization cross-sections without vibrational broadening and with vibrational broadening at 4 K and 300 K

Figure S4. (a)–(d) Photoionization cross-sections without vibrational broadening (obtained by replacing A(ℏω−Edj)A(\hbar\omega-E_{dj}) in Equation (6) with δ(ℏω−Edj)\delta(\hbar\omega-E_{dj})) showing finite cross-sections at 0.8 eV. (e) Photoionization cross-sections with vibrational broadening at 4 K and (f) 300 K. Cross-section at 4 K is similar to that at 300 K, except that the latter is slightly broadened and red-shifted. Defects are described using the expression ABqA_{B}^{q}, denoting atom A substituting site B with relative charge qq. VOV_{\mathrm{O}} denotes oxygen vacancy.

Alt text: Photoionization cross-sections of the defect transitions in this work. Onset seen at the CTL when vibrational broadening is not included. Onset is blue-shifted when vibrational broadening is included. Cross-sections also become smooth when vibrational broadening is included.

Photocurrent Measurements

Figure S5 shows a standard I-V measurement on 2 and 10 ppm doped Er3+\mathrm{Er}^{3+}-CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2} samples, demonstrating that their carrier density is largely similar.

Figure S5. (a) Typical I-V curve at 0.1 V/s scan rate, showing largely similar behavior of the 2 ppm and 10 ppm doped samples. (b) Current varies with depth of laser focus; positive and negative values correspond to focus out of the sample and into the sample, respectively. Sample surface is at 0 µm. Relative current is defined as Irelative=I−Ifocus=0I_{\mathrm{relative}} = I - I_{\mathrm{focus}=0}, where II and Ifocus=0I_{\mathrm{focus}=0} are the total current and current measured with the laser focus on the surface, respectively. Insets in (b) adapted from Heremans et al.[88]. Solid lines between data points are a guide to the eye.

For Er3+\mathrm{Er}^{3+}-CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2} sample synthesis, see Ref.86.

For photocurrent device fabrication, samples were cleaned with isopropanol and deionized (DI) water, then primed with hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS) prior to spin-coating a bi-layer resist stack (LOR 3A and Microposit 1805, prebaked at 180°C and 115°C respectively). Device patterns were written using laser lithography (Heidelberg MLA) and developed in CD-26 for 60 seconds. The developed stacks were then coated with Ti/Au (10/150nm) via e-beam evaporation. Lift-off was performed to reveal the patterned devices by soaking in 80°C NMP for 1 hour, followed by mild sonication (10 sec). The devices were cleaned with acetone and isopropanol, then mounted to carrier circuit boards and wire-bonded.

To confirm that the photocurrent is dominated by carriers from the CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2} bulk (and not the surface), we measured the photocurrent with varying focus under a fixed 1.2 mW laser power in the 10 ppm sample, shown in Figure S5. The slightly higher photocurrent when the laser is focused out of the sample compared to when it is focused into the sample indicates that the photocurrent is proportional to the illuminated volume, confirming the dominant bulk effect.

We note here that the photocurrent is likely carried by electrons. The consumption of oxygen from the CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2} lattice due to the formation of the interfacial CeOx\mathrm{CeO}_{x}-SiOy\mathrm{SiO}_{y} layer leaves behind VO2+\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}^{2+} compensated by CeCe1−\mathrm{Ce}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-}. Under illumination, CeCe1−\mathrm{Ce}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-} ionizes to form free electrons in the conduction band, and due to the applied voltage, the electrons in the conduction band drift to the positive electrode and VO2+\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}^{2+} drifts to the negative electrode. Electrons are then resupplied from the outer circuit back into CeO2\mathrm{CeO}_{2}. In principle, Ce interstitials (e.g., Cei4+\mathrm{Ce}_{i}^{4+}) could also form (also compensated by CeCe1−\mathrm{Ce}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{1-}), but their concentration is likely negligible compared to VO2+\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{O}}^{2+}[87]. Finally, for holes to contribute to photocurrent, there would have to be acceptor states (such as those from cerium vacancies VCe4−\mathrm{V}_{\mathrm{Ce}}^{4-} or oxygen interstitials Oi2−\mathrm{O}_{i}^{2-}) with charge transition levels ≤0.8\le0.8 eV above the valence band. However, these defects are unlikely to form under our experimental conditions and their concentrations are likely negligible compared to oxygen vacancies[87].

Alt text: Figure on the left plots the I-V curve of 2 and 10 ppm doped samples, showing nearly equal currents at a given voltage. Figure on the right plots current as a function of laser focus depth, showing higher current when focus is out of the sample.

References

References

  1. [1]1P. Hohenberg and W. Kohn, “Inhomogeneous electron gas,” Physical review 136, B864 (1964).
  2. [2]2W. Kohn and L. J. Sham, “Self-consistent equations including exchange and correlation effects,” Physical review 140, A1133 (1965).DOI
  3. [3]3P. Giannozzi, S. Baroni, N. Bonini, M. Calandra, R. Car, C. Cavazzoni, D. Ceresoli, G. L. Chiarotti, M. Cococcioni, I. Dabo, et al., “Quantum espresso: a modular and open-source software project for quantum simulations of materials,” Journal of physics: Condensed matter 21, 395502 (2009).DOI
  4. [4]4P. Giannozzi, O. Andreussi, T. Brumme, O. Bunau, M. Buongiorno Nardelli, M. Calandra, R. Car, C. Cavazzoni, D. Ceresoli, M. Cococcioni, et al., “Advanced capabilities for materials modelling with quantum espresso,” Journal of physics: Condensed matter 29, 465901 (2017).DOI
  5. [5]5P. Giannozzi, O. Baseggio, P. Bonfà, D. Brunato, R. Car, I. Carnimeo, C. Cavazzoni, S. De Gironcoli, P. Delugas, F. Ferrari Ruffino, et al., “Quantum espresso toward the exascale,” The Journal of chemical physics 152 (2020).DOI
  6. [6]6D. R. Hamann, “Optimized norm-conserving vanderbilt pseudopotentials,” Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 88, 085117 (2013).DOI
  7. [7]7E. Bosoni, L. Beal, M. Bercx, P. Blaha, S. Blügel, J. Bröder, M. Callsen, S. Cottier, A. De-gomme, V. Dikan, et al., “How to verify the precision of density-functional-theory implementations via reproducible and universal workflows,” Nature Reviews Physics 6, 45–58 (2024).DOI
  8. [8]8S. Mochizuki, “Infrared optical properties of cerium dioxide,” physica status solidi (b) 114, 189–199 (1982).DOI
  9. [9]9H. E. Swanson, Standard X-ray diffraction powder patterns, Vol. 25 (US Department of Commerce, National Bureau of Standards, 1953).
  10. [10]10M. J. Verstraete, J. Abreu, G. Allemand, B. Amadon, G. Antonius, M. Azizi, L. Baguet, C. Barat, L. Bastogne, R. Béjaud, J.-M. Beuken, J. Bieder, A. Blanchet, F. Bottin, J. Bouchet, J. Bouquiaux, E. Bousquet, J. Boust, F. Brieuc, V. Brousseau-Couture, N. Brouwer, F. Bruneval, A. Castellano, E. Castiel, J.-B. Charraud, J. Clérouin, M. Côté, C. Duval, A. Gallo, F. Gen-dron, G. Geneste, P. Ghosez, M. Giantomassi, O. Gingras, F. Gómez-Ortiz, X. Gonze, F. A. Goudreault, A. Grüneis, R. Gupta, B. Guster, D. R. Hamann, X. He, O. Hellman, N. Holzwarth, F. Jollet, P. Kestener, I.-M. Lygatsika, O. Nadeau, L. MacEnulty, E. Marazzi, M. Mignolet, D. D. O’Regan, R. Outerovitch, C. Paillard, G. Petretto, S. Poncé, F. Ricci, G.-M. Rignanese,
  11. [24]S. Guo, H. Arwin, S. Jacobsen, K. Järrendahl, and U. Helmersson, “A spectroscopic ellipsometry study of cerium dioxide thin films grown on sapphire by rf magnetron sputtering,” Journal of Applied physics 77, 5369–5376 (1995).DOI
  12. [25]B. Elidrissi, M. Addou, M. Regragui, C. Monty, A. Bougrine, and A. Kachouane, “Structural and optical properties of ceo2 thin films prepared by spray pyrolysis,” Thin Solid Films 379, 23–27 (2000).DOI
  13. [26]S. Debnath, M. Islam, and M. Khan, “Optical properties of ceo2 thin films,” Bulletin of Materials Science 30, 315–319 (2007).DOI
  14. [27]R. Bueno, J. Martinez-Duart, M. Hernandez-Velez, and L. Vazquez, “Optical and structural characterization of rf sputtered ceo2 thin films,” Journal of materials science 32, 1861–1865 (1997).
  15. [28]E. Ruiz-Trejo, “The optical band gap of gd-doped ceo2 thin films as function of temperature and composition,” Journal of Physics and Chemistry of Solids 74, 605–610 (2013).
  16. [29]C. Hogarth and Z. Al-Dhan, “Optical absorption in thin films of cerium dioxide and cerium dioxide containing silicon monoxide,” Phys. Status Solidi B;(German Democratic Republic) 137 (1986).DOI
  17. [30]K. Sundaram and P. Wahid, “Optical absorption in cerium dioxide thin films,” physica status solidi (b) 161, K63–K66 (1990).
  18. [31]S.-Y. Zheng, A. Andersson-Fäldt, B. Stjerna, and C. Granqvist, “Optical properties of sputter-deposited cerium oxyfluoride thin films,” Applied optics 32, 6303–6309 (1993).DOI
  19. [32]R. G. Toro, G. Malandrino, I. L. Fragalà, R. Lo Nigro, M. Losurdo, and G. Bruno, “Relationship between the nanostructures and the optical properties of ceo2 thin films,” The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 108, 16357–16364 (2004).DOI
  20. [33]A. A. Ansari, “Optical and structural properties of sol–gel derived nanostructured ceo2 film,” Journal of semiconductors 31, 053001 (2010).
  21. [34]Y. Jiang and N. Bahlawane, “Changes in the structural and optical properties of ceo2 nanocrystalline films: Effect of film thickness,” Journal of Alloys and compounds 485, L52–L55 (2009).DOI
  22. [35]J. Zimou, K. Nouneh, R. Hsissou, A. El-Habib, L. El Gana, A. Talbi, M. Bेराich, N. Lotfi, and M. Addou, “Structural, morphological, optical, and electrochemical properties of co-doped ceo2 thin films,” Materials Science in Semiconductor Processing 135, 106049 (2021).DOI
  23. [36]Y. Acosta-Silva, M. Toledano-Ayala, G. Torres-Delgado, I. Torres-Pacheco, A. Méndez-López, R. Castanedo-Pérez, and O. Zelaya-Ángel, “Nanostructured ceo2 thin films prepared by the sol-gel dip-coating method with anomalous behavior of crystallite size and bandgap,” Journal of Nanomaterials 2019, 5413134 (2019).DOI
  24. [37]Y. Yang, X. Du, C. Yi, J. Liu, B. Zhu, and Z. Zhang, “Structural, optical and electrical properties of ceo2 thin films simultaneously prepared by anodic and cathodic electrodeposition,” Applied Surface Science 440, 1073–1082 (2018).DOI
  25. [38]R. Murugan, G. Vijayaprasath, T. Mahalingam, Y. Hayakawa, and G. Ravi, “Effect of rf power on the properties of magnetron sputtered ceo2 thin films,” Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics 26, 2800–2809 (2015).DOI
  26. [39]Z. C. Orel and B. Orel, “Optical properties of pure ceo2 and mixed ceo2/sno2 thin film coatings,” physica status solidi (b) 186, K33–K36 (1994).DOI
  27. [40]N. Özer, “Optical properties and electrochromic characterization of sol-gel deposited ceria films,” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 68, 391–400 (2001).DOI
  28. [41]D. Barreca, G. Bruno, A. Gasparotto, M. Losurdo, and E. Tondello, “Nanostructure and optical properties of ceo2 thin films obtained by plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition,” Materials Science and Engineering: C 23, 1013–1016 (2003).DOI
  29. [42]F.-C. Chiu and C.-M. Lai, “Optical and electrical characterizations of cerium oxide thin films,” Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics 43, 075104 (2010).DOI
  30. [43]A. Pfau and K. Schierbaum, “The electronic structure of stoichiometric and reduced ceo2 surfaces: an xps, ups and hreels study,” Surface Science 321, 71–80 (1994).DOI
  31. [44]B. Choudhury, P. Chetri, and A. Choudhury, “Annealing temperature and oxygen-vacancy-dependent variation of lattice strain, band gap and luminescence properties of ceo2 nanoparticles,” Journal of Experimental Nanoscience 10, 103–114 (2015).
  32. [45]M. M. Khan, S. A. Ansari, D. Pradhan, D. H. Han, J. Lee, and M. H. Cho, “Defect-induced band gap narrowed ceo2 nanostructures for visible light activities,” Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 53, 9754–9763 (2014).DOI
  33. [46]Z. Wang, Z. Quan, and J. Lin, “Remarkable changes in the optical properties of ceo2 nanocrystals induced by lanthanide ions doping,” Inorganic chemistry 46, 5237–5242 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17518463
  34. [47]X.-H. Liao, J.-M. Zhu, J.-J. Zhu, J.-Z. Xu, and H.-Y. Chen, “Preparation of monodispersed nanocrystalline ceo2 powders by microwave irradiation,” Chemical Communications , 937–938 (2001).DOI
  35. [48]X. Zhang, C. Blackman, R. G. Palgrave, S. Ashraf, A. Dey, M. O. Blunt, X. Zhang, T. Liu,
  36. [61]J. Heyd, G. E. Scuseria, and M. Ernzerhof, “Hybrid functionals based on a screened coulomb potential,” The Journal of chemical physics 118, 8207–8215 (2003).DOI
  37. [62]J. Paier, M. Marsman, K. Hummer, G. Kresse, I. C. Gerber, and J. G. Ángyán, “Screened hybrid density functionals applied to solids,” The Journal of chemical physics 124 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16674253
  38. [63]C. W. Castleton, A. Lee, and J. Kullgren, “Benchmarking density functional theory functionals for polarons in oxides: Properties of ceo2,” The Journal of Physical Chemistry C 123, 5164–5175 (2019).DOI
  39. [64]C. Adamo and V. Barone, “Toward reliable density functional methods without adjustable parameters: The pbe0 model,” The Journal of chemical physics 110, 6158–6170 (1999).DOI
  40. [65]M. Ernzerhof and G. E. Scuseria, “Assessment of the perdew–burke–ernzerhof exchange-correlation functional,” The Journal of chemical physics 110, 5029–5036 (1999).
  41. [66]J. Graciani, A. M. Márquez, J. J. Plata, Y. Ortega, N. C. Hernández, A. Meyer, C. M. Zicovich-Wilson, and J. F. Sanz, “Comparative study on the performance of hybrid dft functionals in highly correlated oxides: The case of ceo2 and ce2o3,” Journal of chemical theory and computation 7, 56–65 (2011).DOI
  42. [67]H. Jiang, “Revisiting the gw approach to d-and f-electron oxides,” Physical Review B 97, 245132 (2018).DOI
  43. [68]H. Jiang, R. I. Gomez-Abal, P. Rinke, and M. Scheffler, “Localized and itinerant states in lanthanide oxides united by gw@ lda+ u,” Physical review letters 102, 126403 (2009).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19392301
  44. [69]J. H. Skone, M. Govoni, and G. Galli, “Self-consistent hybrid functional for condensed systems,” Physical Review B 89, 195112 (2014).DOI
  45. [70]J. H. Skone, M. Govoni, and G. Galli, “Nonempirical range-separated hybrid functionals for solids and molecules,” Physical Review B 93, 235106 (2016).DOI
  46. [71]C. Freysoldt, B. Grabowski, T. Hickel, J. Neugebauer, G. Kresse, A. Janotti, and C. G. Van de Walle, “First-principles calculations for point defects in solids,” Reviews of modern physics 86, 253–305 (2014).DOI
  47. [72]S. Falletta, J. Wiktor, and A. Pasquarello, “Finite-size corrections of defect energy levels involving ionic polarization,” Physical Review B 102, 041115 (2020).
  48. [73]C. Freysoldt, J. Neugebauer, and C. G. Van de Walle, “Fully ab initio finite-size corrections for charged-defect supercell calculations,” Physical review letters 102, 016402 (2009).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19257218
  49. [74]C. Freysoldt, “sxdefectalign,” https://sxrepo.mpie.de/projects/sphinx-add-ons/files (2022).
  50. [75]T. Gake, Y. Kumagai, C. Freysoldt, and F. Oba, “Finite-size corrections for defect-involving vertical transitions in supercell calculations,” Physical Review B 101, 020102 (2020).DOI
  51. [76]A. M. Stoneham, Theory of defects in solids: electronic structure of defects in insulators and semiconductors (Oxford University Press, 2001).
  52. [77]L. Razinkovas, M. Maciaszek, F. Reinhard, M. W. Doherty, and A. Alkauskas, “Photoionization of negatively charged nv centers in diamond: Theory and ab initio calculations,” Physical Review B 104, 235301 (2021).DOI
  53. [78]M. Govoni and G. Galli, “Large scale gw calculations,” Journal of chemical theory and computation 11, 2680–2696 (2015).
  54. [79]V. W.-z. Yu and M. Govoni, “Gpu acceleration of large-scale full-frequency gw calculations,” Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 18, 4690–4707 (2022).DOI
  55. [80]J. C. Marcks, M. Onizhuk, Y.-X. Wang, Y. Zhu, Y. Jin, B. S. Soloway, M. Fukami, N. Delegan, F. J. Heremans, A. A. Clerk, et al., “Quantum spin probe of single charge dynamics,” Physical Review Letters 133, 130802 (2024).DOI
  56. [81]P. T. Ruhoff, “Recursion relations for multi-dimensional franck-condon overlap integrals,” Chemical physics 186, 355–374 (1994).DOI
  57. [82]H. Jiang, P. Rinke, and M. Scheffler, “Electronic properties of lanthanide oxides from the gw perspective,” Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 86, 125115 (2012).DOI
  58. [83]J. F. Janak, “Proof that ∂E/∂nᵢ = εᵢ in density-functional theory,” Physical Review B 18, 7165 (1978).
  59. [84]M. K. Harbola, “Relationship between the highest occupied kohn-sham orbital eigenvalue and ionization energy,” Physical Review B 60, 4545 (1999).DOI
  60. [85]S. Falletta, J. Coulter, J. B. Varley, D. Aberg, B. Sadigh, B. Kozinsky, and A. Pasquarello, “Equivalence of charged and neutral density functional formulations for correcting the many-body self-interaction of polarons,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2511.02159 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2511.02159
  61. [87]P. R. Keating, D. O. Scanlon, B. J. Morgan, N. M. Galea, and G. W. Watson, “Analysis of intrinsic defects in ceo2 using a koopmans-like gga+ u approach,” The Journal of Physical Chemistry C 116, 2443–2452 (2012).
  62. [88]F. Heremans, G. Fuchs, C. Wang, R. Hanson, and D. Awschalom, “Generation and transport of

Paper details

vlnc:W_5ufy87jy
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 6

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents