WorksMathematics
Reduction numbers under flat extensions
Abstract
The reduction number of the maximal ideal of a localization (or even faithfully flat extension) need not increase under specialization. Nevertheless, for each fixed local ring the reduction numbers of the maximal ideals of all its localization have a finite common bound. A connection to (generalized) Loewy length is given.
Introduction
If is an ideal and , then is called a reduction of if for some . The least such is denoted by . A minimal reduction is a reduction minimal under inclusion, and throughout this note
The restriction to minimal reductions matters: allowing every reduction in this minimum would give zero by taking . In the local setting, it controls the Hilbert–Samuel function, the structure of the associated graded ring, and the Cohen–Macaulayness of blow-up algebras. There is an extensive literature on bounds for reduction numbers. In particular, Vasconcelos obtained general bounds for reduction numbers of ideals and multiplicity-dependent bounds for primary ideals. Related estimates have been developed using the Eakin–Sathaye theorem and, under additional hypotheses, the theory of Sally modules and associated graded rings. For more details, see the book of Vasconcelos [12]. A natural question, going back to Vasconcelos, is how this invariant behaves under localization, and whether it is uniformly bounded on the prime spectrum of a fixed ring.
Question 1.1 (Vasconcelos, see [12 Page 83]). Let be local and let be prime ideals of .
(i) Is ?
(ii) Can be infinite?
Part (i) asks whether reduction numbers are monotone under specialization, i.e. whether passing from the larger prime to the smaller prime can only decrease the reduction number. Part (ii) asks whether, for a fixed Noetherian local ring, the reduction numbers of the maximal ideals of all its localizations admit a common finite bound, independently of the prime. Recall that a positive answer to (i) gives a positive answer to (ii), and not necessarily the converse.
Theorem 1.2. (i) The implication “” is not the case.
(ii) .
Without the noetherian hypothesis, can be infinite, even when , and every term in the supremum is finite (see § 5.3). Section 3 deals with the following question from the exercise [12 1.193] attributed to Hanes (see [3 Conjecture 3.1]):
Question 1.3. Let be a flat local morphism. Is ?
We present progress on the monotonicity property of the reduction number with respect to faithfully flat extensions, under additional Cohen–Macaulay hypotheses (see Proposition 3.4). In Proposition 3.5, we establish a positive answer under suitable graded assumptions. We note that this was recently proved by Pollitz and KC [11] via a different argument; our proof appears simpler and yields a sharp bound, although the assumptions in [11] are sharper than ours. On the negative side, we present Proposition 3.8. This is inspired by [4], and of course the motivational example from the book of Huneke-Swanson [6].
In Section 4 we present one-dimensional Cohen–Macaulay rings with and for every . The proof of Theorem 1.2(ii) occupies Section 5 and combines three ingredients. The first is an elementary estimate, proved in Section 5.1, which bounds the number of generators of a power of the maximal ideal of a -dimensional local ring in terms of , , and the colength of a parameter ideal; this estimate does not require the Cohen–Macaulay property. Combined with the Eakin–Sathaye theorem, it yields a local bound for every parameter ideal , valid whenever the residue field is infinite. The second ingredient, proved in Section 5.2, is a uniform Briançon–Skoda statement for complete reduced local rings, which supplies a single exponent such that for every prime and every reduction of . This converts the local colength bound into a uniform bound on the colength , hence on . The third ingredient is a uniform embedding-dimension bound, obtained from the Cohen structure theorem and Lech’s inequality for flat local maps, which makes the resulting bound depend only on the fixed ring .
Recall from previous remarks that the reduction number is connected with the generalized Loewy length; our reference for this is [11] and the references therein. Pollitz and Nawaj KC [11] considered the following, known as the Loewy Length Conjecture with a contribution to an unpublished manuscript of Corso, Huneke, Polini and Ulrich:
Conjecture 1.4. For a local ring and a nonzero -module with finite projective dimension, the following inequality holds:
Here, denotes the Loewy length. A conjectural connection between this and the reduction number was hinted to us by Pollitz and KC. It may be worth mentioning that
is also considered in the literature; see [1] and references therein, we call it Matsumura’s number. In the final section we show that Conjecture 1.4 needs some additional assumptions, for instance that the residue field is infinite. This follows by an analysis of a ring given by Hashimoto and Shida [4], Example 3.2.
Conveniences
All rings are commutative with identity. Unless explicitly stated otherwise, rings are Noetherian. For a local ring , write for the minimal number of generators of a finite module , and for its length when finite. For a finite-length module , write for the least with .
Remark 2.1. The convention , taking the minimum over minimal reductions, is essential to the formulation of the problem. With the larger class of all reductions the minimum would always be zero, since is a reduction of , and both questions would trivialize. Minimal reductions exist for finitely generated ideals in Noetherian local rings regardless of the residue field; for completeness we recall the argument here. Indeed, minimal reductions exist for finitely generated ideals in Noetherian local rings, also when the residue field is finite. For and an ideal , choose a reduction for which is as small as possible. Lift a basis to and put . Since , a reduction equality for , followed by Nakayama’s lemma applied to , shows that is a reduction. Independence of the chosen initial classes gives . If is a reduction, minimality of gives , hence and by Nakayama. Thus is minimal. In particular, the reduction number is a finite integer for the ideals considered in Theorem 1.2(ii). The books of Matsumura [10], Huneke–Swanson [6] and Vasconcelos [12] serve as our standard references.
Dealing with an exercise
Some positive side
We start with:
Lemma 3.1. Let be flat and local morphism of artinian rings. Then . The equality holds, if in addition is unramified (or at least ).
Proof. Let be an integer. The condition is equivalent with . But, . Now, let . Since the zero ideal is a minimal reduction of , we know . Let . This, in turns, imply that , and consequently, . Now, suppose . Then iff , and so . □
The second assertion is not true in the higher dimension:
Example 3.2. Let and , where denotes the algebraic closure of . Let and . The natural homomorphism is faithfully flat, and .
Proof. By [6 Example 8.3.2] (also see [4]), the ideal is basic: it has no proper reductions. Consequently, is its own minimal reduction, and, with our convention, . On the other hand, choose with , and put . The calculation in [6 Example 8.3.2] shows that . Moreover, is a minimal reduction of . Since and , the quotient has a nonzero degree-two component and vanishes in all degrees greater than two. Hence , as is not basic. □
Remark 3.3. In general, the reduction number does not behave well with respect to a superficial element ; that is, the equality need not hold. However, when , one has , see [9 Lemma 2.14].
Proposition 3.4. Let be a flat local homomorphism of Cohen–Macaulay local rings of the same dimension, with infinite residue fields.
(i) If is Cohen–Macaulay, then .
(ii) Assume in addition to part i) that . Then .
Proof. i) Reduction by regular sequence shows that , where and , with a suitable superficial system of parameters for . Similarly, . Combining with Lemma 3.1 it is enough to show that . This follows by the Cohen–Macaulay assumption of where we take reduction by so that is -regular (see Remark 3.3).
ii) Since , and by flatness, we have
This implies that is also Cohen–Macaulay. Then by Remark 3.3 . By arguing as part i), we have . □
Proposition 3.5. Let be a degree-preserving flat homomorphism of standard graded Cohen–Macaulay -algebras over an infinite field , where and . Let and .
(i) One has .
(ii) Assume in addition to part i) that . Then .
Proof. i) Set . Since is flat and the two rings have the same dimension, is zero-dimensional. Hence is an Artinian graded -algebra.
Claim 3.6. One has .
Proof. Since is a finite-dimensional graded -vector space, choose a homogeneous -basis with . Lift each to a homogeneous element of the same degree. Because is finite and flat over , these lifts form a homogeneous -basis of . Thus, as graded -modules, , where denotes the graded shift of . Taking Hilbert series gives
The degrees of the homogeneous basis elements give . The claim follows.
As and are Cohen–Macaulay of the same dimension , we can write
where and are the respective -polynomials. It follows that . Since is a nonzero polynomial with nonnegative coefficients, we obtain . Finally, for a standard graded Cohen–Macaulay algebra over an infinite field, the reduction number of the homogeneous maximal ideal equals the degree of its -polynomial. Thus
ii) Under this additional assumption, is just residue field and so , and so the claim follows.
Claim 3.6.
Observation 3.7. One has .
Proof. For any ideal , consider the special fiber ring . Since completion is faithfully flat, we have a natural graded isomorphism . Recall from [6 Proposition 8.2.4] that an ideal is a reduction of if and only if its image satisfies for all sufficiently large . Moreover,
The point is that , i.e., any reduction of is algebraic, that it is extended from an ideal of .
A negative side
The following example uses finite residue fields and non-Cohen–Macaulay rings.
Proposition 3.8. Let , . Let also . Then is flat and . Also, .
Proof. For a coefficient field , the associated graded ring is . Recall that is local and finite free of rank , hence flat, with and . Let , see [10 Ex. 14.2(iii)]. Let be a minimal reduction of . If were infinite, then every minimal reduction of is minimally generated by exactly the analytic spread of elements (see [6 Proposition 8.3.7]). Here, we have no such cardinality assumption. Then, we argue directly, i.e., there exists an integer such that . Consider the quotient map . Since , applying to the reduction equality gives . Consequently, . Hence there exists whose image modulo has a nonzero linear term in . In particular, the initial form of is with .
Claim 3.9. One has .
Proof. First, . Indeed, if , then , and a reduction would require for some . Reducing modulo would give in , which is impossible. Hence , so the image of in is nonzero. Next, must generate the maximal ideal of the discrete valuation ring . Indeed, the image of modulo is , and a reduction of in a DVR is generated by an element of -adic valuation exactly 1. Hence has a nonzero linear term. Write , so that . Reducing modulo , . Since has nonzero linear term, we conclude . Thus in .
Since , the relation expresses as a scalar multiple of . Therefore
is finite-dimensional over , because it is a quotient of . Thus there exists an integer such that for all , i.e., . By the definition of the associated graded ring, this implies . Set . The preceding equality yields . Since is a finitely generated -module and is the maximal ideal, Nakayama’s lemma gives . Hence . It follows that is a reduction of . Finally, implies . Since is a minimal reduction and is itself a reduction, we conclude that . This proves that every minimal reduction of is principal.
Claim 3.10. .
Proof. Let be a principal reduction of so that is a minimal reduction. Write for the initial form of in the associated graded ring . For a minimal reduction of , the reduction number is . Passing to the associated graded ring, the condition is equivalent to the surjectivity of the multiplication map , i.e. to the vanishing . Since is a reduction, is a finite-dimensional artinian graded -algebra, so it vanishes in all sufficiently high degrees. Because is a nonzerodivisor of degree 1, the quotient is nonzero precisely for , where is the largest index with nonzero component. Hence iff .
Let be such that is a minimal reduction of , and write for its initial form in . Equivalently, says that is not contained in : a reduction of must detect the -direction modulo , and the only way to do so at first order is to have a nonzero -coefficient in . Over , the only possible initial forms are and , and . Consequently, . Over , choose . Then , because has inverse over . Thus . Equality holds because has no quadratic relations: its degree-two component has dimension 3, while multiplication by one linear form from its degree-one component has rank at most 2.
Something is not monotone
Let be any field. Let us compute reduction number in our favorite non Cohen–Macaulay ring.
Example 4.1. Let with . Since , we have . Thus is a reduction of . Moreover, is a minimal reduction, and , since but . Hence . Now localize at the prime ideal . Since , the element is a unit in . The relation therefore implies in . Consequently, . Taking the zero ideal as a reduction of itself, we obtain . Thus and .
Our main ring in this section follows by adding a binomial relation to . Namely, (and its generalization), and we want to compare the reduction number of localization at with .
Proposition 4.2. The ring is a complete one-dimensional Cohen–Macaulay and local, , and .
Proof. Let . The defining relations give a -basis for . For completeness, independence follows by realizing this algebra as the subalgebra with basis of , with and . The relations reduce every power series to a -linear combination of , and their images are independent in . Thus is free of rank three over , and is a nonzerodivisor. Relations and say that , hence is nilpotent and ; consequently and is Cohen–Macaulay. One has . The principal ideal is a reduction. Let us verify minimality directly. If a reduction of is contained in , write . For a sufficiently large , the identities imply, by cancellation of , that . If were proper, Nakayama’s lemma would give , contrary to . Hence and . Also . A minimal reduction with reduction number zero would have to equal itself, which is impossible since contains the proper reduction . Therefore . Inverting gives with the convenience that and .
Claim 4.3. This ring is local, and its maximal ideal contracts to .
Proof. Consider the localization map . One has . To this end, observe that and localizing at gives . Thus the kernel of the composite map is exactly . This kernel is also , since is the kernel of . Therefore, the maximal ideal of contracts to . Thus , because both invert precisely the elements outside , up to the resulting localization.
Thanks to Claim 4.3, . In an artinian local ring the zero ideal is a reduction of the nilpotent maximal ideal, so it is its unique minimal reduction. Here and , which gives .
Proposition 4.4. For every integer there is a complete one-dimensional Cohen–Macaulay local ring with a prime such that and . Moreover, the failure can be made arbitrarily large by varying the ring, so no inequality of the form with a fixed function can hold in general.
Proof. Let . Inside , take the subring . It is finite free over , hence Noetherian, and is nilpotent with quotient . Its unique maximal ideal is . Thus is generated by . Squaring, the generators of are all products of two of these:
and whenever . Hence . On the other hand
Therefore . The -adic and -adic topologies agree, so is complete; freeness over makes it Cohen–Macaulay of dimension one. The same minimality argument as in Proposition 4.2 gives . Finally, , whose maximal ideal has reduction number .
Remark 4.5
Remark 4.5. i) Proposition 4.4 generalizes Proposition 4.2: the latter is the case . Indeed, with , ,
which is exactly for .
ii) In both cases is the nilpotent ideal with , , and after inverting ,
with reduction number , resp. , at the maximal ideal . The pair shows that the gap is unbounded.
iii) The rings we constructed were not be reduced.
Observation 4.6. If is -dimensional reduced ring, then for any , .
Proof. We may assume . Since is reduced it satisfies Serre’s condition . But, , it follows that is a field and so . Consequently, .
A finite bound for every fixed local ring
A bound from parameter colength
The next estimate works without a Cohen–Macaulay assumption (compare with [12, Theorem 2.44).
Lemma 5.1. Let have dimension , and let be a parameter ideal. Set . For every integer , .
Proof. First suppose . If and is any -primary ideal, and
a short exact sequence of -modules. Apply multiplication by to each term:
The snake lemma gives the exact kernel–cokernel sequence
Set . For the endomorphism of the finite-length module ,
hence . Thus the kernel term and the cokernel term are equal and cancel in the length identity. In order to all terms be of finite length, we rewrite:
Taking lengths along this exact sequence,
This gives
Since , it follows that . Taking proves the assertion for . For , we look at and . Then , is a parameter of , and . Lifting generators from the image and adjoining these elements gives
To bound the last length, we increase the exponents of one at a time. The key observation is that, for any finite-length -module and any , the filtration has successive factors , for . Each factor is a homomorphic image of , so . Applying this inequality successively to , we obtain
Consequently, , as desired.
We use the following form of the Eakin–Sathaye theorem [6 Theorem 8.6.8]:
Fact 5.2. If has infinite residue field and , then there exist such that . For an -primary ideal in dimension , this is a minimal reduction. Here and below in applications of this statement.
Corollary 5.3. If has infinite residue field and dimension , then for every parameter ideal , . More generally, any integer satisfies .
Proof. Set and take . If , Lemma 5.1 gives . For , it gives
For the strict inequality, expand . In addition to , its term alone is , since . Now apply Fact 5.2 with . □
A finite bound for sup
Here is the precise standard uniformity input used below. Huneke’s uniform Briançon–Skoda theorem implies that (see [5]). The bar denotes integral closure of an ideal.
Fact 5.4. If is a complete reduced Noetherian local ring, there is an integer such that for every ideal .
Lemma 5.5. For a Noetherian local ring there is an integer such that, for every and every reduction of , .
Proof. Let , let , and choose with . Apply Fact 5.4 to the complete reduced local ring , obtaining ; set . Fix and as in the statement, put , and set . The map is faithfully flat, being a base change of . The reduction relation says that is integral over ; this property persists in (see [6, Proposition 8.1.1]) and in (see [6, Lemma 8.1.3 (3)]). Consequently, in the st power of the image of is contained in the integral closure of the st power of the image of , hence in the image of by Fact 5.4. Thus . Raising to the th power yields
Contract along the faithfully flat map to obtain the desired claim (see [10, Theorem 7.5(ii)]). □
Remark 5.6. We need a uniform embedding-dimension bound. By the Cohen structure theorem choose a surjection from a complete regular local ring , and write . Then for all . Indeed, choose a prime of over . The map is flat and local. Lech’s embedding-dimension inequality for flat local maps gives ; see [8]. If is the preimage of in , then is a quotient of the regular local ring , whose dimension is at most . This proves the desired claim.
Our next main result is as follows.
Theorem 5.7. Let be a Noetherian local ring of dimension . Choose as in Lemma 5.5 and as in Remark 5.6. Finally, let and . Then, for every prime for which is infinite, we have . In particular, the supremum in Theorem 1.2(ii) is finite, for arbitrary residue field of .
Proof. Fix such a , and set and . If , is Artinian and the unique minimal reduction of is zero. Lemma 5.5 therefore gives and .
Suppose . Since the residue field of is infinite, has a minimal reduction generated by elements; it is a parameter ideal. By Lemma 5.5, . Since (see Remark 5.6), the graded pieces of the -adic filtration satisfy . Summing these inequalities, with the degree-zero term equal to one, gives
Corollary 5.3 now implies . The dimension-zero case also satisfies this bound, because and hence .
Finally, every nonmaximal prime of a local ring has infinite residue field. Otherwise , which embeds into its finite fraction field , would be a finite domain and thus a field; this would make maximal. If is infinite, . If it is finite, only is omitted, and Remark 2.1 gives . In that case the supremum is at most .
If , then and the assertion is immediate from nilpotence of . This completes the proof of Theorem 1.2(ii).
An infinite supremum without noetherianity
Definition 5.8. Let be any field, , , and for set . Inside , define .
Thus an element of is a sequence eventually equal to a single element of . Write for the idempotent supported at coordinate .
Notation 5.9. Set .
The diagonal element is a nonzerodivisor in and in .
Remark 5.10. For this subsection only, allow non-Noetherian rings, and use the same definitions of reduction and minimal reduction whenever they exist.
Observation 5.11. The ring is quasi-local and non-Noetherian, with maximal ideal .
Proof. Every element of has the form with and . If , each coordinate is a unit in , and its inverse sequence is eventually the inverse of a single unit of . Write . For any element since , we have . Applying this with and multiplying by gives
Using , the second term becomes , so , i.e. . Thus , and . So is a unit of . Since , this proves that is quasi-local with maximal ideal . For non-Noetherianity: multiplication by identifies as -vector spaces. The classes of the are linearly independent in , so this space is infinite-dimensional. Hence is not finitely generated. □
:::
Lemma 5.12. The primes of consist of , primes for , and one additional prime . So, . Their localizations satisfy , and .
Proof. Inverting yields . Let be the direct-sum ideal in this expression. If a prime of omits some , then localization forces and . It therefore selects the th factor, whose unique prime is . Let denote this prime of . Then . If contains every , it contains ; since , it must be itself. Every element of has finite support and is annihilated by for a suitable finite set . This annihilator lies outside , and so . Contracting and to defines and , respectively, and proves the asserted localization formulas. All these primes omit and lie strictly below . Conversely, any prime of containing equals , because . We have therefore listed every prime. The primes of are all maximal, so . □
Corollary 5.13. The reduction numbers are , and . In particular, every displayed reduction number is finite and their supremum is infinite.
Proof. We have , and because . We verify that is a minimal reduction without using a finite-generation assumption. If is a reduction of , write with an ideal of . For some , . Cancellation inside gives . A proper ideal of the local ring lies in , which would force . Hence and . Thus , since reduction number zero would force itself to be minimal. According to Lemma 5.12, localizing at , the maximal ideal is , with nonzero th power and zero st power. Its unique minimal reduction is zero and its reduction number is . At the maximal ideal is zero and the reduction number is zero. Hence all displayed reduction numbers are finite, while their supremum over is infinite. □
Loewy Length Conjecture
We start with a modification of Conjecture 1.4.
Question 6.1. Let be a noetherian local ring and a finitely generated -module of finite projective dimension with . Does for some system of parameters ?
For every finite field there is a one-dimensional hypersurface with residue field and a nonzero module of projective dimension one for which the containment fails at :
Notation 6.2. Let , , and , with .
Also, we need an auxiliary ring:
Notation 6.3. Let be a quadratic extension, and set .
Lemma 6.4. Any -module of finite projective dimension, has finite projective dimension as an -module.
Proof. The ring is free of rank two over . So, the claim is clear. □
Example 6.5. There is an -module of finite projective dimension and Loewy length .
Proof. Let and define . Substitution gives and . In , generates a prime ideal and as . If , then , and cancellation gives . Thus multiplication by is injective on , i.e., there is a short exact sequence $0 \to S \xrightarrow{\cdot u} S \to M \to 0$ of -modules. In we have , so substitution gives . Because , none of the factors vanishes, hence is a unit in . Therefore , as claimed. Under this isomorphism, the class of maps to the generator of , while the class of maps to . Since is an -module via , the maximal ideal acts through the images of and in . But in the class of equals times the class of . Hence, as operators on , , . Thus every element of acts as a multiple of , and , and inductively for all . Since , we have , and therefore . Similarly , because in . Thus, Loewy length of is . □
For , is the ring of Hashimoto and Shida [4 Example 3.2]. Bartels proved the generalized Loewy length of is , see [2 Proposition 3.5]. This gives:
Corollary 6.6. Adopt the above notation. Then .
KC and Pollitz proved their inequality for infinite residue fields when is Cohen–Macaulay, see [11 Conjecture A and Theorem B].
Acknowledgments
The author is grateful to Josh Pollitz and Nawaj KC for useful comments.
References
M. ASGHARZADEH
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]M. Asgharzadeh, On the Rees, Dilworth and Matsumura number, arXiv:1712.03828.arxiv.org/abs/1712.03828
- [2]R. F. Bartels, Generalized Loewy length of Cohen–Macaulay local and graded rings, J. Algebra 653 (2024), 28–41.DOI
- [3]D. Hanes, Length approximations for independently generated ideals, J. Algebra 237 (2) (2001) 708–718.DOI
- [4]M. Hashimoto and A. Shida, Some remarks on index and generalized Loewy length of a Gorenstein local ring, J. Algebra 187 (1997), 150–162.DOI
- [6]I. Swanson and C. Huneke, Integral closure of ideals, rings, and modules, London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series, 336, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2006.
- [8]C. Lech, Inequalities related to certain couples of local rings, Acta Math. 112 (1964), 69–89.DOI
- [9]T. Marley, Hilbert functions of ideals in Cohen-Macaulay rings, PhD Thesis (1989).
- [10]H. Matsumura, Commutative ring theory, Cambridge Studies in Advanced Math, 8, (1986).DOI
- [11]Nawaj KC, J. Pollitz, Lower bounds on Loewy lengths of modules of finite projective dimension, Advances in Mathematics 473 (2025), 110309.arxiv.org/abs/2404.18368
- [12]W. V. Vasconcelos, Integral Closure: Rees Algebras, Multiplicities, Algorithms, Springer Monographs in Mathematics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2005.