betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Arc connected continua and the double commutant property

Abstract

Let KK be a compact metrizable space. For f∈C(K)f\in C(K) let MfM_f be the largest lower semicontinuous map with k∈Mf(k)⊆f−1(f(k))k\in M_f(k)\subseteq f^{-1}(f(k)). We say that KK has the double commutant property if for every f∈C(K)f\in C(K) every continuous function that is constant on all sets Mf(k)M_f(k) is constant on the fibres of ff; this is exactly the condition that the double commutant of every multiplication operator on C(K)C(K) is the closed algebra generated by the operator and the identity. We show that an arc connected continuum has this property if the points having an open locally connected neighbourhood are dense, and we extend this to some continua that are not arc connected. We then develop new techniques that work when such points are not dense, or do not exist at all, and prove that several well-known continua have the property: the Cantor comb, the Cantor fan and, more generally, the cone over every compact metrizable space, every smooth fan with a closed set of end points, and the Cantor grid (C×[0,1])∪([0,1]×C)(C\times[0,1])\cup([0,1]\times C). The property passes to open images. Examples show that the hypotheses cannot be weakened in several directions. For individual functions we show that, on a continuum all of whose arc components are dense, every function that is constant on no arc satisfies the double commutant condition, and that on every smooth dendroid and every fan the functions satisfying it are dense.

Introduction

The initial motivation for this paper comes from operator theory. It follows from von Neumann’s classical double commutant theorem (see [35]) that if (Ω,Σ,μ)(\Omega,\Sigma,\mu) is a measure space, ff is a real-valued function from L∞(μ)L^\infty(\mu), and MfM_f is the operator of multiplication by ff on L2(μ)L^2(\mu) then the double commutant {Mf}′′\{M_f\}^{\prime\prime} of MfM_f coincides with the closure in the strong operator topology of the algebra generated by MfM_f and the identity operator II.

De Pagter and Ricker [38] extended the above result to the spaces Lp(μ)L^p(\mu), 1≤p<∞1 \le p < \infty, over Maharam measure spaces, and showed that on L∞[0,1]L^\infty[0,1] the double commutant of the operator of multiplication by the independent variable consists of the multiplications by Riemann integrable functions, so it is strictly larger than the strongly closed algebra generated by the operator and the identity, which coincides with the algebra of multiplications by functions from C[0,1]C[0,1].

In view of these results it is natural to consider the following problem. Let KK be a compact Hausdorff space, let C(K)C(K) be the space of all real-valued continuous functions on KK, and for f∈C(K)f \in C(K) let AfA_f be the closure of the algebra generated by the multiplication operator MfM_f on C(K)C(K) and the identity. What properties of ff and KK ensure that {Mf}′′=Af\{M_f\}^{\prime\prime}=A_f?

A significant part of this problem is the following one: which properties of KK ensure that {Mf}′′=Af\{M_f\}^{\prime\prime}=A_f for every f∈C(K)f \in C(K)? Clearly this property is a topological invariant of KK, and we say that such a KK has the double commutant property, or K∈DCPK \in DCP.

We restrict our attention to the case when KK is a continuum (a compact metrizable connected space), and only indicate that by virtue of the results of [38] the maximal ideal space of algebra L∞[0,1]L^\infty[0,1] is not in DCP\mathcal{DCP}, and that some results concerning metrizable compact spaces with isolated points are contained in [23 Theorem 1.15].

The results obtained by the author in [23] and in [24] can be briefly summarized as follows.

  • If a metrizable compact space without isolated points is in DCP\mathcal{DCP}, then it is a continuum.

  • Every locally connected continuum is in DCP\mathcal{DCP}.

  • There are continua that are not in DCP\mathcal{DCP}, e.g. K=cl⁡{(x,sin⁡(1/x)):0<x≤1}K=\operatorname{cl}\{(x,\sin(1/x)):0<x\leq1\}.

  • There are arc connected but not locally connected continua, e.g. the broom and the bookcase, that are in DCP\mathcal{DCP}; it is not known whether every arc connected continuum (in particular the Cantor fan) is in DCP\mathcal{DCP}.

  • There are continua that are not arc connected but are in DCP\mathcal{DCP}, for example K=([−1,0]×[−1,1])∪cl⁡{(x,sin⁡(1/x)):0<x≤1}K=([-1,0]\times[-1,1])\cup\operatorname{cl}\{(x,\sin(1/x)):0<x\leq1\}.

In the current paper, while not arriving at a complete description of the continua in DCP\mathcal{DCP}, we considerably strengthen the results of [23] and [24]. Below we state the main results; the definitions needed for them are given here and recalled where they are used.

The topological reformulation. We write f∈D(K)f\in\mathcal{D}(K) if {Mf}′′=Af\{M_f\}^{\prime\prime}=A_f; thus K∈DCPK\in\mathcal{DCP} if and only if D(K)=C(K)\mathcal{D}(K)=C(K). The following notions translate the problem into topology.

Definition 1.1. Let KK be a compact metrizable space and f∈C(K)f\in C(K).

(i) A map Ψ\Psi from KK into the nonempty subsets of KK is lower semicontinuous (lsc) if {k:Ψ(k)∩V≠∅}\{k:\Psi(k)\cap V\ne\varnothing\} is open for every open V⊆KV\subseteq K.

(ii) MfM_f denotes the largest lsc map with k∈Mf(k)⊆f−1(f(k))k\in M_f(k)\subseteq f^{-1}(f(k)) for all k∈Kk\in K (it exists; see Definition 2.1).

(iii) A function g∈C(K)g\in C(K) is ff-admissible if it is constant on every set Mf(k)M_f(k).

Every function of the form h∘fh\circ f is ff-admissible. The point of the definition is the converse.

Theorem A (Theorem 2.6). Let KK be a compact metrizable space and f,g∈C(K)f,g\in C(K). Then Mg∈{Mf}′′M_g\in\{M_f\}^{\prime\prime} if and only if gg is ff-admissible. Consequently f∈D(K)f\in\mathcal{D}(K) if and only if every ff-admissible function is constant on the fibres of ff, and K∈DCPK\in\mathcal{DCP} if and only if this holds for every f∈C(K)f\in C(K).

The argument for Theorem A goes back to [23], and it is closely related to Ditor’s theory of averaging operators and lower semicontinuous sections [14] (Remark 2.7). Operator theory enters only through this theorem; from Section 3 on, all arguments are topological.

Local structure: locally connected points and teeth. Our sufficient conditions are expressed in terms of two kinds of local structure.

Definition 1.2. For a continuum KK, L(K)L(K) denotes the set of points of KK that have an open locally connected neighbourhood. It is an open subset of KK.

For a locally connected continuum L(K)=KL(K)=K; for the Cantor fan L(K)=∅L(K)=\varnothing. Where L(K)L(K) is not dense we use instead a product structure along arcs.

Definition 1.3. A tooth chart of a continuum KK is a continuous map h:U×[0,1]→Kh:U\times[0,1]\to K, UU a nonempty open subset of a compact metrizable space, together with an interval Jh=(0,1)J_h=(0,1) or Jh=(0,1]J_h=(0,1], such that hh maps U×JhU\times J_h homeomorphically onto an open subset OhO_h of KK. The arcs h({y}×Jh)h(\{y\}\times J_h) are the open teeth, and h(y,0)h(y,0) is the root of the tooth. Given a family of tooth charts, a point v∈Kv\in K is a star point if it has arbitrarily small open neighbourhoods SS such that every p∈S∖{v}p\in S\setminus\{v\} is joined to vv by an arc A⊆SA\subseteq S with A∖{v}A\setminus\{v\} contained in one open tooth.

When UU is a clopen subset of the Cantor set and Jh=(0,1)J_h=(0,1), the set OhO_h is a Cantor box (§ 3), an open piece of a Cantor fence C×[0,1]C\times[0,1] in the sense of [27]. The teeth of the Cantor comb are its vertical segments, rooted on the base; the teeth of a cone Cone⁡(Y)\operatorname{Cone}(Y) are the segments {y}×(0,1]\{y\}\times(0,1], all rooted at the vertex, which is a star point. Star points are thus modelled on the top of a fan [6], at which the legs of the fan meet (see [3]). Note, however, that tooth charts require open product neighbourhoods, which a general fan need not have: in the Lelek fan the end points are dense, and no nonempty open set is of the form OhO_h (an end point of the fan lying in OhO_h would have to be of the form h(y,1)h(y,1) with Jh=(0,1]J_h=(0,1], so the nonempty open set h(U×(0,1))h(U\times(0,1)) would contain no end points).

Main results. Our most general sufficient condition is the following; it is proved as Theorem 4.25 together with Theorem 4.15.

Theorem B. Let KK be a metrizable continuum with a family of tooth charts, let BB be the union of the sets OhO_h, and let R⊆KR\subseteq K be closed. Assume:

(1) KK is arc connected, or every arc component PP of KK is dense or satisfies P⊆cl⁡Int⁡PP\subseteq\operatorname{cl}\operatorname{Int}P;

(2) K=cl⁡L(K)∪R∪BK=\operatorname{cl}L(K)\cup R\cup B, and h(U×{0})⊆R∪cl⁡L(K)h(U\times\{0\})\subseteq R\cup\operatorname{cl}L(K) for every chart hh;

(3) every point of (R∪cl⁡L(K))∖(L(K)∪B)(R\cup\operatorname{cl}L(K))\setminus(L(K)\cup B) has arbitrarily small open neighbourhoods U′U' such that every component of U′∩TU'\cap T, TT an open tooth, has an end point in U′∖BU'\setminus B (an end point of h({y}×I)h(\{y\}\times I), II an interval, is a point h(y,α)h(y,\alpha) with α\alpha an end point of II);

(4) every point of RR lies in cl⁡L(K)\operatorname{cl}L(K) or is a star point.

Then K∈DCPK\in\mathcal{DCP}, and so is every image of KK under an open continuous map.

Condition (3) is a mild local condition at the points outside the teeth; (2) and (4) say that every tooth is rooted either in the closure of L(K)L(K) or at a star point. Theorem B contains the following special cases.

  • With no charts at all, its hypotheses say that L(K)L(K) is dense and (1) holds (Theorem 4.7); in particular every arc connected continuum with L(K)L(K) dense is in DCP\mathcal{DCP} (Theorem 4.4). This contains the locally connected continua [23] and the broom and the bookcase of [24].

  • The Cantor comb M=(C×[0,1])∪([0,1]×{0})M=(C\times[0,1])\cup([0,1]\times\{0\}), in which L(M)L(M) is not dense, and the cone over every nonempty compact metrizable space, in particular the Cantor fan FF, in which L(F)=∅L(F)=\varnothing, are in DCP\mathcal{DCP} (Theorem 4.22); this answers two questions of [24]. So are the Cantor ladder and the suspension of every nonempty compact metrizable space (Remark 4.24).

  • Every smooth fan with a closed set of end points is an open image of the Cantor fan [10], hence in DCP\mathcal{DCP} (Corollary 4.23).

  • If K×Y∈DCPK\times Y\in\mathcal{DCP} for some nonempty compact metrizable YY, then K∈DCPK\in\mathcal{DCP} (Corollary 4.16).

The Cantor grid is shown to be in DCP\mathcal{DCP} in this paper but is not covered by Theorem B, for any family of tooth charts: the points where its arcs cross lie in no open tooth and are neither in cl⁡L(G)=∅\operatorname{cl}L(G)=\varnothing nor star points (Remark 4.26). An additional argument at these points gives the following.

Theorem C (Theorem 4.31). The Cantor grid G=(C×[0,1])∪([0,1]×C)G=(C\times[0,1])\cup([0,1]\times C) is in DCP\mathcal{DCP}, although L(G)=∅L(G)=\varnothing.

The hypotheses of Theorem B cannot simply be dropped. By Proposition 4.36, no compactification of a ray, or of two disjoint open rays, with a nondegenerate remainder is in DCP\mathcal{DCP} (for instance the sin⁡(1/x)\sin(1/x) continuum or a ray spiralling onto a circle), although adding the disk bounded by the circle gives a continuum in DCP\mathcal{DCP} (Example 4.12). Example 4.38 shows that arc connectedness cannot be weakened to the condition that every point can be joined by an arc to L(K)L(K), and Example 4.39, in which L(K)L(K) is dense, that the condition on arc components in (1) cannot be dropped. Indecomposability does not help either: by a theorem of Fukaishi and Matsuhashi [18 Theorem 1.1] and Theorem 4.15, there are indecomposable, even tree-like indecomposable [30], continua not in DCP\mathcal{DCP} (Remark 5.13).

Individual functions. For continua not covered by Theorem B, such as solenoids, the buckethandle continuum and the Lelek fan, we show that many individual functions belong to D(K)\mathcal{D}(K).

Theorem D. Let KK be a metrizable continuum.

(i) If all arc components of KK are dense, then every f∈C(K)f \in C(K) that is constant on no arc belongs to D(K)\mathcal{D}(K) (Theorem 5.1).

(ii) If there are retractions rnr_n of KK onto subsets in DCP\mathcal{DCP} with rn→id⁡Kr_n \to\operatorname{id}_K uniformly, then φ∘rn∈D(K)\varphi\circ r_n \in\mathcal{D}(K) for all φ∈C(K)\varphi\in C(K); in particular D(K)\mathcal{D}(K) is dense in C(K)C(K) (Proposition 5.4).

Part (i) applies to arc connected continua, solenoids and the buckethandle continuum. Part (ii) applies, through the small retractions onto trees and finite fans constructed by Fugate [20, 19], to every smooth dendroid and every fan, for instance the Lelek fan (Corollaries 5.6 and 5.7); such approximations are what Eberhart and Fugate call approximation from within [16]. Density of D(K)\mathcal{D}(K) is, however, no evidence that K∈DCPK \in\mathcal{DCP}: the sin⁡(1/x)\sin(1/x) continuum admits small retractions onto arcs, so D(K)\mathcal{D}(K) is dense for it, yet it is not in DCP\mathcal{DCP} (Remark 5.8).

References

  1. [1]J. M. Aarts and L. G. Oversteegen, The geometry of Julia sets, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 338 (1993), 897–918.
  2. [2]I. Banič, G. Erceg, S. Greenwood and J. Kennedy, Retract or not: a tale of two fans, arXiv:2507.22162 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2507.22162
  3. [3]I. Banič, G. Erceg, A. Ullanes, I. Jelić, J. Kennedy and V. Nall, Towards the complete classification of fans, Topology Appl. 388 (2026), Paper No. 109871.
  4. [4]I. Banič, G. Erceg and J. Kennedy, The Lelek fan as the inverse limit of intervals with a single set-valued bonding function whose graph is an arc, Mediterr. J. Math. 20 (2023), no. 3, Paper No. 159.arxiv.org/abs/2206.00087
  5. [5]W. D. Bula and L. G. Oversteegen, A characterization of smooth Cantor bouquets, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 108 (1990), 529–534.DOI
  6. [6]J. J. Charatonik, On fans, Dissertationes Math. (Rozprawy Mat.) 54 (1967), 1–37.
  7. [7]W. J. Charatonik, Smooth dendroids as inverse limits of dendrites, Fund. Math. 124 (1984), 163–168.DOI
  8. [8]W. J. Charatonik, The Lelek fan is unique, Houston J. Math. 15 (1989), 27–34.
  9. [9]J. J. Charatonik and W. J. Charatonik, The property of Kelley for fans, Bull. Polish Acad. Sci. Math. 36 (1988), 169–173.
  10. [10]J. J. Charatonik and W. J. Charatonik, Images of the Cantor fan, Topology Appl. 33 (1989), 163–172.DOI
  11. [11]J. J. Charatonik, W. J. Charatonik and J. R. Prajs, Confluent mappings and arc Kelley continua, Rocky Mountain J. Math. 38 (2008), no. 4, 1091–1115.DOI
  12. [12]J. J. Charatonik and C. Eberhart, On smooth dendroids, Fund. Math. 67 (1970), 297–322.DOI
  13. [13]S. Z. Ditor and L. Q. Eifler, Some open mapping theorems for measures, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 164 (1972), 287–293.DOI
  14. [14]S. Z. Ditor, Averaging operators in C(S) and lower semicontinuous sections of continuous maps, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 175 (1973), 195–208.DOI
  15. [15]C. A. Eberhart, A note on smooth fans, Colloq. Math. 20 (1969), 89–90.DOI
  16. [16]C. A. Eberhart and J. B. Fugate, Approximating continua from within, Fund. Math. 72 (1971), 223–231.DOI
  17. [17]R. Engelking, General Topology, revised and completed edition, Sigma Series in Pure Mathematics 6, Heldermann, Berlin, 1989.
  18. [18]S. Fukaishi and E. Matsuhashi, Open retractions of indecomposable continua, Colloq. Math. 148 (2017), no. 2, 191–194.
  19. [19]J. B. Fugate, Retracting fans onto finite fans, Fund. Math. 71 (1971), 113–125.DOI
  20. [20]J. B. Fugate, Small retractions of smooth dendroids onto trees, Fund. Math. 71 (1971), 255–262.DOI
  21. [21]A. Illanes, Continuum Theory, Universitext, Springer, Cham, 2025.DOI
  22. [22]W. T. Ingram and W. S. Mahavier, Inverse Limits. From Continua to Chaos, Developments in Mathematics 25, Springer, New York, 2012.DOI
  23. [23]A. K. Kitover, Bicommutants of multiplication operators, Positivity 14 (2010), no. 4, 753–769.DOI
  24. [24]A. K. Kitover, Double commutants of multiplication operators on C(K), Integration: Math. Theory Appl. 3 (2012), no. 3, 307–313; arXiv:1305.6286.arxiv.org/abs/1305.6286
  25. [25]W. Kuperberg, Uniformly pathwise connected continua, in: Studies in Topology (Proc. Conf. Charlotte, NC, 1974), Academic Press, New York, 1975, 315–324.DOI
  26. [26]K. Kuratowski, Topology, Vol. II, Academic Press, New York, 1968.
  27. [27]D. S. Lipham, Endpoints of smooth plane dendroids, Fund. Math. 269 (2025), 171–185.
  28. [28]L. Lum, Order preserving and monotone retracts of a dendroid, Topology Proc. 1 (1976), 57–61.
  29. [29]S. Macías, Topics on Continua, Chapman & Hall/CRC, Boca Raton, FL, 2005.
  30. [30]E. Matsuhashi and J. A. Ortega Becerril, Open retractions of indecomposable continua, II, Colloq. Math., online first (2025), doi:10.4064/cm9677-10-2025.DOI
  31. [31]E. Michael, Continuous selections, J. Ann. of Math. (2) 63 (1956), 361–382.
  32. [32]E. Michael, A linear mapping between function spaces, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 15 (1964), 407–409.
  33. [34]S. B. Nadler, Jr., Continuum Theory. An Introduction, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1992.
  34. [35]J. von Neumann, Zur Algebra der Funktionaloperationen und Theorie der normalen Operatoren, Math. Ann. 102 (1929), 370–427.DOI
  35. [36]J. Nikiel, Topologies on pseudo-trees and applications, Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 82 (1989), no. 416.DOI
  36. [37]L. G. Oversteegen and J. R. Prajs, On confluently graph-like compacta, Fund. Math. 178 (2003), 109–127.DOI
  37. [38]B. de Pagter and W. J. Ricker, Bicommutants of algebras of multiplication operators, Proc. London Math. Soc. (3) 72 (1996), 458–480.
  38. [39]A. Pełczyński, Linear extensions, linear averagings, and their applications to linear topological classification of spaces of continuous functions, Dissertationes Math. (Rozprawy Mat.) 58 (1968), 92 pp.
  39. [40]S. Štimac, Homeomorphisms of composants of Knaster continua, Fund. Math. 171 (2002), 267–278.DOI
  40. [41]G. T. Whyburn, Analytic Topology, Amer. Math. Soc. Colloquium Publications 28, Amer. Math. Soc., New York, 1942.

Paper details

vlnc:W_6b78zsjz
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC0-1.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Claude

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents