betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Higher forbidden unique β−β^- decay transitions and shell-model interpretation

Abstract

In the present work, we have predicted the half-lives for the β−β^{-} decay for higher forbidden unique transitions in the mass range of nuclei from A = 40-138. For these transitions, the experimental data for half-lives are not available except for a few cases. The calculations for half-lives are performed within the framework of the nuclear shell model (SM). We have used the effective interactions sdpf-mu, gxpf1a, gwbxg, G-matrix, snet, sn100pn, and jj56pnb to perform the SM calculations in different mass regions. A comprehensive discussion has been made between the SM-predicted half-lives and the scaled half-lives from proton-neutron quasiparticle random-phase approximation (pnQRPA). The results of the present study will be useful to plan new experiments to measure half-lives for these higher forbidden unique β−β^{-} transitions.

Introduction

The nuclear β\beta-decay, also known as the weak nuclear processes occurring inside the nuclei, is a powerful tool for exploring the structure and properties of atomic nuclei. It plays an important role in subatomic physics and astrophysics [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10]. To study the β\beta-decay, we need a theoretical model that can explain the properties of the nuclei. In the present work, we use the nuclear shell model (SM) to calculate the matrix elements involved in beta decay for higher forbidden unique transitions. The decay rates depend on the precisely calculated wave functions of parent and daughter nuclei involved in nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) [11].

The transitions in the β\beta-decay can be categorized into two types, allowed and forbidden, based on the orbital angular momentum (ll) of the emitted leptons. When l=0l = 0, it is categorized as allowed, while l>0l > 0 leads to forbidden transitions. Allowed transitions are characterized by a change in total angular momentum ΔJ=0,±1\Delta J = 0, \pm1 and no change in parity (Δπ=+1\Delta\pi= +1). The forbidden transitions are further categorized as forbidden non-unique (FNU) and forbidden unique (FU). For the KKth-FNU transition, ΔJ=K\Delta J = K (In case of K=1K=1, ΔJ=0,1\Delta J = 0, 1), where KK is the order of forbiddenness and parity changes in the odd-forbidden and remains same in the even-forbidden decays according to Δπ=(−1)K\Delta\pi= (-1)^K. Basically, forbidden unique decays are a special case of forbidden non unique (FNU) decays. In the KKth FU transition, ΔJ=K+1\Delta J = K + 1, here, the angular momentum change between the initial and final nuclear states is maximal and parity follows the same as in FNU decays. Consequently, the decay rate and the shape factor are significantly simplified as the contribution of only one matrix element [12].

The majority of β\beta-decay transitions observed in nature are of the allowed type and a few with a low order of ‘KK’. However, recent research has focused on finding rare beta decays that have longer half-lives. These transitions are hindered by low QQ value or high order of ‘KK’. The theoretical formalism of nuclear beta decay is explained in the book by Behrens and Bühring [13]. With advancements in measurement technology, the study of higher forbidden beta decays became interesting. Recently, half-lives for 148 forbidden unique beta transitions, including 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th, and 7th orders, have been predicted using the proton-neutron quasiparticle random-phase approximation (pnQRPA) model by Kostensalo and Suhonen [14]. The experimental half-lives for these higher forbidden unique transitions are not yet available.

The forbidden unique decays exhibit a straightforward dependence on the weak axial-vector coupling constant gAg_A (t1/2∝gA−2t_{1/2} \propto g_A^{-2}). For bare nucleons, the value gA=1.27g_A = 1.27 is extracted from the partially conserved axial-vector current hypothesis (PCAC) but this value is affected inside the nuclear matter due to nuclear medium effects or nuclear many-body effects and a quenching is needed to reproduce the experimental data. So, the role of gAg_A is important to calculate half-lives more precisely. There are few methods are available to study the quenching in gAg_A values in higher forbidden unique β\beta- decay. Previously, the effective value of gAg_A has been investigated through a half-life comparison method, where predicted and experimental values are compared across various gAg_A values [15, 16, 17]. This approach can be used to find out the quenching once experimental data becomes accessible. The spectrum-shape method (SSM) is the popular one to study the quenching in which the shapes of calculated and experimental electron spectra are compared [17, 18, 19]. In the present manuscript, we have done a systematic SM study for the higher forbidden unique β−\beta^{-} transitions to test the predictive power of our computed nuclear wave functions in the mass region A=40A = 40-138138.

The present manuscript is structured into the following sections. The section II is divided into two subsections: subsection II A explains the theoretical formalism used to calculate the shape factor, nuclear matrix elements (NMEs), and half-lives, while subsection II B reported the shell model Hamiltonian employed. Section III presents the SM results for half-lives of higher FU β−\beta^{-} decay transitions. Finally, we conclude the manuscript in Section IV.

Theoretical Framework

Formalism

In the present work, we have calculated the partial half-lives for the forbidden unique β−\beta^{-} transitions. The generalized theoretical formalism of nuclear β\beta-decay is available in Refs [20, 21]. For allowed and forbidden types of β\beta-decay, the detailed formalism is given in the books by Behrens and Bühring [13] and by Schopper [22]. The formalism of nuclear β\beta-decay theory is based on the impulse approximation which says that the decaying nucleon doesn’t interact with the other nucleons around it at the moment of decay. However, before and after the decay, it interacts with these nucleons strongly. This simplified approach helps in understanding and calculating both allowed and forbidden β\beta-decay processes.

The expression for calculating the partial half-life is given as [13, 20]

t1/2=κC~,(1)t_{1/2} = \frac{\kappa}{\widetilde{C}}, \tag*{(1)}

where κ\kappa is a constant and value is given as [23]

κ=2π3ℏ7ln⁡(2)me5c4(GFcos⁡θC)2=6289 s,(2)\kappa= \frac{2\pi^{3}\hbar^{7}\ln(2)}{m_{e}^{5}c^{4}(G_{F}\cos\theta_{C})^{2}} = 6289\ \mathrm{s}, \tag*{(2)}

where, GFG_{F} is the Fermi constant and θC\theta_{C} is the Cabibbo angle. The C~\widetilde{C} is the dimensionless integrated shape function and can be calculated as

C~=∫1w0C(we)pwe(w0−we)2F0(Z,we) dwe.(3)\widetilde{C} = \int_{1}^{w_{0}} C(w_{e})p w_{e}(w_{0}-w_{e})^{2}F_{0}(Z,w_{e})\,\mathrm{d}w_{e}. \tag*{(3)}

In the above expression the usual dimensionless kinematics quantities divided by the electron rest mass are used as w0=W0/mec2w_{0}=W_{0}/m_{e}c^{2}, we=We/mec2w_{e}=W_{e}/m_{e}c^{2}, and p=pec/mec2=we2−1p=p_{e}c/m_{e}c^{2}=\sqrt{w_{e}^{2}-1}. The w0w_{0} is the endpoint energy, wew_{e} and pep_{e} are the total energy and momentum of emitted electrons, respectively. The term F0(Z,we)F_{0}(Z,w_{e}) is the Fermi function, and ZZ is the atomic number of the daughter nucleus. The C(we)C(w_{e}) is the shape factor that contains information about the nuclear structure.

The general form of shape factor C(we)C(w_{e}) is given as:

C(we)=∑ke,kν,Kλke[MK(ke,kν)2+mK(ke,kν)2−2γkekeweMK(ke,kν)mK(ke,kν)],(4)C(w_{e})=\sum_{k_{e},k_{\nu},K}\lambda_{k_{e}}\left[M_{K}(k_{e},k_{\nu})^{2}+m_{K}(k_{e},k_{\nu})^{2}-\frac{2\gamma_{k_{e}}}{k_{e}w_{e}}M_{K}(k_{e},k_{\nu})m_{K}(k_{e},k_{\nu})\right], \tag*{(4)}

where, kek_{e} and kνk_{\nu} (=1,2,3,…)(=1, 2, 3,\ldots) are positive integers and associated with the partial-wave expansion of the leptonic wave functions, and KK denotes the order of forbiddenness of the β\beta decay. The terms MK(ke,kν)M_{K}(k_{e},k_{\nu}) and mK(ke,kν)m_{K}(k_{e},k_{\nu}) can be expressed in terms of different NMEs and other kinematic factors [13, 20]. Here, γke=ke2−(αZ)2\gamma_{k_{e}}=\sqrt{k_{e}^{2}-(\alpha Z)^{2}} and y=(αZwe/pec)y=(\alpha Z w_{e}/p_{e}c) are the auxiliary quantities, and α=1/137\alpha=1/137 is the fine structure constant and the term λke=Fke−1(Z,we)/F0(Z,we)\lambda_{k_{e}}=F_{k_{e}-1}(Z,w_{e})/F_{0}(Z,w_{e}), is the Coulomb function, in which Fke−1(Z,we)F_{k_{e}-1}(Z,w_{e}) is the generalized Fermi function [20, 21, 24] which can be calculated using formula

Fke−1(Z,we)=4ke−1(2ke)(ke+γke)[(2ke−1)!!]2eπy(2peRℏ)2(γke−ke)(∣Γ(γke+iy)∣Γ(1+2γke))2.(5)F_{k_{e}-1}(Z,w_{e})=4^{k_{e}-1}(2k_{e})(k_{e}+\gamma_{k_{e}})[(2k_{e}-1)!!]^{2}e^{\pi y}\left(\frac{2p_{e}R}{\hbar}\right)^{2(\gamma_{k_{e}}-k_{e})}\left(\frac{|\Gamma(\gamma_{k_{e}}+iy)|}{\Gamma(1+2\gamma_{k_{e}})}\right)^{2}. \tag*{(5)}

NMEs contain all the information about nuclear-structure and can be expressed as

V/AMKLS(N)(pn)(ke,m,n,ρ)=4πJ^i∑pnV/AmKLS(N)(pn)(ke,m,n,ρ)(Ψf∥[c^p†c~n]K∥Ψi).(6){}^{V/A}\mathcal{M}_{KLS}^{(N)}(pn)(k_{e},m,n,\rho)=\frac{\sqrt{4\pi}}{\sqrt{\hat{J}_{i}}}\sum_{pn}{}^{V/A}m_{KLS}^{(N)}(pn)(k_{e},m,n,\rho)(\Psi_{f}\Vert[\hat{c}_{p}^{\dagger}\tilde{c}_{n}]_{K}\Vert\Psi_{i}). \tag*{(6)}

Here, summation runs over the proton (p) and neutron (n) single particle states. The functions V/AmKLS(N)(pn)(ke,m,n,ρ){}^{V/A}m_{KLS}^{(N)}(pn)(k_{e},m,n,\rho) are the single particle matrix elements (SPMEs), they do not depend on the nuclear models. The terms (Ψf∥[c^p†c~n]K∥Ψi)(\Psi_{f}\Vert[\hat{c}_{p}^{\dagger}\tilde{c}_{n}]_{K}\Vert\Psi_{i}) are the one-body transition densities (OBTDs) between the initial (Ψi)(\Psi_{i}) and final (Ψf)(\Psi_{f}) nuclear states and these are model-dependent. In the present work, the SPMEs use harmonic oscillator wave functions [20, 21]. The OBTDs are calculated using nuclear shell model codes KSHELL [25] and NUSHELLX [26]. We have also included here the next-to-leading-order (NLO) corrections to the shape factor which increase the number of NMEs (full details about the NLO corrections are given in Refs. [19, 20]).

Shell-Model Hamiltonian

We have performed calculations within the framework of shell-model. The nuclear shell-model Hamiltonian can be written in terms of single particle energies and two nucleon interactions as

H=T+V=∑αϵαcα†cα+14∑αβγδvαβγδcα†cβ†cδcγ,(7)H=T+V=\sum_{\alpha}\epsilon_{\alpha}c_{\alpha}^{\dagger}c_{\alpha}+\frac{1}{4}\sum_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}v_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}c_{\alpha}^{\dagger}c_{\beta}^{\dagger}c_{\delta}c_{\gamma}, \tag*{(7)}

where α={n,l,j,t}\alpha=\{n,l,j,t\} represents a single-particle state and ϵα\epsilon_{\alpha} is the single particle energy of state α\alpha and cα†c_{\alpha}^{\dagger} and cαc_{\alpha} are the fermion pair creation and annihilation operators. The term vαβγδ=⟨αβ∣V∣γδ⟩v_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}=\langle\alpha\beta|V|\gamma\delta\rangle represents the antisymmetrized two-body matrix element (TBME).

We have taken different effective interactions for different model spaces for nuclei ranging from mass A=40−138A=40-138. The effective interactions sdf-mu [27], gxpf1a [28], gwbxg [29, 30], G-matrix [31], snet [32, 33], sn100pn [34, 35] and jj56pnb [36, 37] are used for the calculations and shown in last column of Table I-IIIB.

TransitionForbiddennessQ valuePartial half-lifeInteraction
β−\beta^{-} DecayKth FU(keV)SMRef [14]
50Ca(0+)→50Sc(5+){}^{50}\mathrm{Ca}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{50}\mathrm{Sc}(5^{+})4th FU4947.9(30)2.8×1052.8 \times10^{5} yr3.3(5)×1053.3(5) \times10^{5} yr
50Sc(5+)→50Ti(0+){}^{50}\mathrm{Sc}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{50}\mathrm{Ti}(0^{+})4th FU6894.7(25)1.0×1051.0 \times10^{5} yr1.3(2)×1051.3(2) \times10^{5} yr
52V(3+)→52Cr(0+){}^{52}\mathrm{V}(3^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{52}\mathrm{Cr}(0^{+})2nd FU3976.48(16)1.2 yr7.3(9)×1037.3(9) \times10^{3} yr
52Ti(0+)→52V(3+){}^{52}\mathrm{Ti}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{52}\mathrm{V}(3^{+})2nd FU1965.3(28)4.0×1014.0 \times10^{1} yr1.1(20)×1021.1(20) \times10^{2} yr
52Sc(3+)→52Ti(0+){}^{52}\mathrm{Sc}(3^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{52}\mathrm{Ti}(0^{+})2nd FU8954 (4)54.3 h34.4(5) h
54V(3+)→54Cr(0+){}^{54}\mathrm{V}(3^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{54}\mathrm{Cr}(0^{+})2nd FU7037 (11)24.6 d9.4(2) d
54Mn(3+)→54Fe(0+){}^{54}\mathrm{Mn}(3^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{54}\mathrm{Fe}(0^{+})2nd FU696.4(11)6.5×1056.5 \times10^{5} yr6.3(9)×1056.3(9) \times10^{5} yr
56Cr(0+)→56Mn(3+){}^{56}\mathrm{Cr}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{56}\mathrm{Mn}(3^{+})2nd FU1626.5(6)9.5×1029.5 \times10^{2} yr4.4(60)×1024.4(60) \times10^{2} yr
56Mn(3+)→56Fe(0+){}^{56}\mathrm{Mn}(3^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{56}\mathrm{Fe}(0^{+})2nd FU3695.50(21)4.1 yr3.9(6) yr
58Co∗(5+)→58Ni(0+){}^{58}\mathrm{Co}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{58}\mathrm{Ni}(0^{+})4th FU381.6(11)2.0×10182.0 \times10^{18} yr1.3(2)×10181.3(2) \times10^{18} yr
60Fe(0+)→60Co(5+){}^{60}\mathrm{Fe}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{60}\mathrm{Co}(5^{+})4th FU237(3)2.2×10192.2 \times10^{19} yr2.5(4)×10192.5(4) \times10^{19} yr
60Co(5+)→60Ni(0+){}^{60}\mathrm{Co}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{60}\mathrm{Ni}(0^{+})4th FU2822.81(21)2.4×1092.4 \times10^{9} yr3.1(5)×1093.1(5) \times10^{9} yr
62Fe(0+)→62Co∗(5+){}^{62}\mathrm{Fe}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{62}\mathrm{Co}^{*}(5^{+})4th FU2546(19)2.9×1092.9 \times10^{9} yr1.9(4)×1091.9(4) \times10^{9} yr
62Co∗(5+)→62Ni(0+){}^{62}\mathrm{Co}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{62}\mathrm{Ni}(0^{+})4th FU5322 (19)1.1×1071.1 \times10^{7} yr4.7(6)×10124.7(6) \times10^{12} yr
84Se(0+)→84Br∗(6−){}^{84}\mathrm{Se}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{84}\mathrm{Br}^{*}(6^{-})5th FU1835(26)8.5×10178.5 \times10^{17} yr2.7(8)×10192.7(8) \times10^{19} yr
84Br∗(6−)→84Kr(0+){}^{84}\mathrm{Br}^{*}(6^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}(0^{+})5th FU4656(26)9.0×1099.0 \times10^{9} yr1.7(3)×10101.7(3) \times10^{10} yr
84Rb∗(6−)→84Sr(0+){}^{84}\mathrm{Rb}^{*}(6^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}(0^{+})5th FU890.6(23)1.1×10211.1 \times10^{21} yr1.7(3)×10171.7(3) \times10^{17} yr
86Rb∗(6−)→86Sr(0+){}^{86}\mathrm{Rb}^{*}(6^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{86}\mathrm{Sr}(0^{+})5th FU1776.10(20)4.3×10144.3 \times10^{14} yr3.3(5)×10143.3(5) \times10^{14} yr
92Nb(7+)→92Mo(0+){}^{92}\mathrm{Nb}(7^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{92}\mathrm{Mo}(0^{+})6th FU355.3(18)5.8×10285.8 \times10^{28} yr6.3(1)×10286.3(1) \times10^{28} yr
94Nb∗(3+)→94Mo(0+){}^{94}\mathrm{Nb}^{*}(3^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{94}\mathrm{Mo}(0^{+})2nd FU2045.0(15)1.1×1021.1 \times10^{2} yr1.7(30)×1021.7(30) \times10^{2} yr
96Tc(7+)→96Ru(0+){}^{96}\mathrm{Tc}(7^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{96}\mathrm{Ru}(0^{+})6th FU259(5)4.3×10304.3 \times10^{30} yr1.7(4)×10301.7(4) \times10^{30} yr
98Nb∗(5+)→98Mo(0+){}^{98}\mathrm{Nb}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{98}\mathrm{Mo}(0^{+})4th FU4591(5)3.0×1073.0 \times10^{7} yr3.0(5)×1063.0(5) \times10^{6} yr
100Nb∗(5+)→100Mo(0+){}^{100}\mathrm{Nb}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{100}\mathrm{Mo}(0^{+})4th FU6402(8)4.3×1044.3 \times10^{4} yr6.9(9)×1046.9(9) \times10^{4} yr
104Mo(0+)→104Tc(3+){}^{104}\mathrm{Mo}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{104}\mathrm{Tc}(3^{+})2nd FU2155(24)1.6×1021.6 \times10^{2} yr4.1(6)×1014.1(6) \times10^{1} yr
104Tc(3+)→104Ru(0+){}^{104}\mathrm{Tc}(3^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{104}\mathrm{Ru}(0^{+})2nd FU5597(25)2.3 yr78.1(10) d
104Rh∗(5+)→104Pd(0+){}^{104}\mathrm{Rh}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{104}\mathrm{Pd}(0^{+})4th FU2435.8(27)4.4×10114.4 \times10^{11} yr2.5(4)×1092.5(4) \times10^{9} yr
98Zr(0+)→98Nb∗(5+){}^{98}\mathrm{Zr}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{98}\mathrm{Nb}^{*}(5^{+})4th FU2243(10)8.3×1088.3 \times10^{8} yr1.7(3)×1091.7(3) \times10^{9} yr
100Zr(0+)→100Nb∗(5+){}^{100}\mathrm{Zr}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{100}\mathrm{Nb}^{*}(5^{+})4th FU3419(11)9.1×1079.1 \times10^{7} yr3.1(6)×1073.1(6) \times10^{7} yr

Table I. Comparison of shell model half-lives for 2nd-, 3rd-, 4th-, 5th-, 6th- and 7th- FU β−\beta^{-} transitions with coupling constants gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{\mathrm{eff}}=1.0, gV=1.0g_{V}=1.0, and half-lives using pnQRPA approach with gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{\mathrm{eff}}=1.0 [14]. The ground-state to ground-state Q value is taken from AME2020 [43]. Here, the 0+0^{+} is the ground state of an even-even nucleus and the asterisk (*) represents the involved isomeric states.

In the case of sdpf-mu effective interaction we have used full sdpf model space with 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} as a core. The valence model space has the orbitals 1d5/21d_{5/2}, 2s1/22s_{1/2}, 1d3/21d_{3/2}, 1f7/21f_{7/2}, 2p3/22p_{3/2}, 1f5/21f_{5/2} and 2p1/22p_{1/2}. For the generation of a negative parity state in 40K^{40}\mathrm{K}, we have used a truncation of 1p-1h excitation from sdsd to pfpf shell. Here, we are exciting only one particle either proton or neutron, while 2p-2h calculations have been done for 40Ca^{40}\mathrm{Ca} case.

We have used gxpf1a effective interaction for nuclei having mass range from A=40−62A=40-62 and the calculations have been done without truncation in full pfpf model space and 40Ca^{40}\mathrm{Ca} is considered as a core. Here, the orbitals for valence protons and neutrons are 1f7/21f_{7/2}, 2p3/22p_{3/2}, 1f5/21f_{5/2}, 2p1/22p_{1/2} with single particle energies (SPEs) (in MeV) are −8.6240-8.6240, −5.6793-5.6793, −1.3829-1.3829, −4.1370-4.1370.

The model space of gwbxg effective interaction consists of 1f5/21f_{5/2}, 2p3/22p_{3/2}, 2p1/22p_{1/2}, 1g9/21g_{9/2} proton orbitals and 2p1/22p_{1/2}, 1g9/21g_{9/2}, 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, and 3s1/23s_{1/2} neutron orbitals and SPEs (in MeV) used in this interaction are −5.322-5.322, −6.144-6.144, −3.941-3.941, −1.250-1.250, for the proton orbitals, and −0.696-0.696, −2.597-2.597, +5.159+5.159, +1.830+1.830, +4.261+4.261, +1.741+1.741 for the neutron orbitals, respectively using 68Ni^{68}\mathrm{Ni} as a core. This effective interaction is prepared with different interactions and the original 974 two-body matrix elements (TBMEs) are obtained from the bare G-matrix of the H7B potential [H7B] [38], for more details, see Refs [39, 40, 41]. For A=84−92A=84-92 we apply 1p-1h truncation across N=50N=50 shell, and from mass A=94A=94 to 104 we completely filled 1g9/21g_{9/2} orbital and open all four neutron orbitals above N=50N=50.

Corresponding to G-matrix interaction, the model space of the present study consists of two proton orbitals 2p1/22p_{1/2} and 1g9/21g_{9/2} with SPEs (in MeV) are 0.000, +0.9000 and five neutron orbitals 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 3s1/23s_{1/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, 1g7/21g_{7/2}, and 1h11/21h_{11/2} with SPEs are 0.000, +1.2600, +2.6300, +2.230, +3.500 respectively. Here, 88Sr^{88}\mathrm{Sr} is taken as inert core and we have not employed any truncation in the present calculations. The realistic effective interaction obtained by the G-matrix approach, which was constructed by the effective microscopic interaction derived from a charge-symmetry breaking nucleon-nucleon potential [42] with further modifications in the monopole part and was used in Ref. [31].

The snet effective interaction consists of 17 orbitals, eight are proton orbitals and nine are neutron orbitals. In the calculations using snet effective interaction, we have put a minimum of 8-10 protons in 1g9/21g_{9/2} orbital and a maximum of 2 protons in 1g7/21g_{7/2} orbital, while neutrons are occupying the 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, 3s1/23s_{1/2} and 1h11/21h_{11/2} orbitals. Further, for computational reasons, we have restricted a minimum of 2-6 neutrons in the 1h11/21h_{11/2} orbital from A=114A=114 to 124, respectively.

The shell-model effective interaction sn100pn is made up of 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, 3s1/23s_{1/2}, 1h11/21h_{11/2}, orbitals for protons and neutrons in the 50-82 model space. The SPEs (in MeV) for neutrons orbitals are −10.609-10.609, −10.289-10.289, −8.717-8.717, −8.694-8.694, and −8.815-8.815 corresponding to the 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, 3s1/23s_{1/2}, and 1h11/21h_{11/2} neutron orbitals, respectively. The SPEs (in MeV) for protons orbitals are +0.8072+0.8072, +1.5623+1.5623, +3.3160+3.3160, +3.2238+3.2238, and +3.6051+3.6051 corresponding to neutron orbitals 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, 3s1/23s_{1/2}, 1h11/21h_{11/2}, respectively. The residual two-body interaction starts with a G-matrix derived from the CD-Bonn nucleon-nucleon interaction [35]. This sn100pn interaction is designed from Ref. [34]. We have not applied any truncation where sn100pn interaction is used.

The jj56pn [37] effective interaction is created for valence space where proton numbers (ZZ) ranging from 50 to 82 and neutron numbers (NN) ranging from 82 to 126. This interaction is derived from N3LO interaction [36] and the Coulomb interaction part is included in the proton-proton interaction part. The proton orbitals 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, 3s1/23s_{1/2}, 1h11/21h_{11/2} have SPEs (in MeV) −9.667-9.667, −8.705-8.705, −6.959-6.959, −7.327-7.327, −6.871-6.871 and neutron orbitals 1h9/21h_{9/2}, 2f7/22f_{7/2}, 2f5/22f_{5/2}, 3p3/23p_{3/2}, 3p1/23p_{1/2}, 1i13/21i_{13/2} have −0.842-0.842, −2.4030-2.4030, −0.3980-0.3980, −1.549-1.549, −1.040-1.040, +0.2970+0.2970, respectively. Using this interaction we have not used any truncation in our calculations.

Results and Discussion

In the present manuscript, we have calculated the SM half-lives for higher forbidden unique β−\beta^- decay transitions. The ground state to ground state Q values are adopted from AME2020 [43]. The SM half-lives are calculated for gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{\mathrm{eff}}=1.0 and gV=1.0g_{V}=1.0 and compared with the scaled half-lives from pnQRPA approach for gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{\mathrm{eff}}=1.0 which are extracted from Ref. [14], see Tables I–III.

For mass range A=50−62A=50-62, the OBTDs are calculated using gxpf1a interaction without truncation. Table I clearly shows that as forbiddenness increases, the half-lives also increase by several orders of magnitude. The half-lives vary from an hour to several years. For example, the SM half-life for 52Sc(3+)→52Ti(0+)^{52}\mathrm{Sc}(3^+)\rightarrow{}^{52}\mathrm{Ti}(0^+) is 54.3 h and for 60Fe(0+)→60Co(5+)^{60}\mathrm{Fe}(0^+)\rightarrow{}^{60}\mathrm{Co}(5^+) is 2.2×10192.2\times10^{19} year, respectively and these half-lives are also comparable with scaled half-lives from pnQRPA approach. In the case of 58Co∗^{58}\mathrm{Co}^{*}, the involved excited isomeric state is represented by an asterisk(*), similar notation has been used for other isomeric states. For 52V^{52}\mathrm{V} and 62Co∗^{62}\mathrm{Co}^{*}, we see a large difference in the order of half-lives from SM and pnQRPA approach. For 58Co(5+)→58Ni(0+)^{58}\mathrm{Co}(5^+)\rightarrow{}^{58}\mathrm{Ni}(0^+) and 60Fe(0+)→60Co(5+)^{60}\mathrm{Fe}(0^+)\rightarrow{}^{60}\mathrm{Co}(5^+) transitions, the half-lives are longer as compared to other 4th- FU transitions in the mass range A=50A=50-62 because of small Q-values involved.

We have employed gwbxg effective interaction for the 84Se^{84}\mathrm{Se} to 104Rh∗^{104}\mathrm{Rh}^{*}. From 84Se^{84}\mathrm{Se} to 92Nb^{92}\mathrm{Nb}, in our SM calculations, we filled 2p1/22p_{1/2} neutron orbital to make 68Ni^{68}\mathrm{Ni} as a core and there is further one neutron excitation from 1g9/21g_{9/2} to 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, and 3s1/23s_{1/2} orbitals. From 94Nb∗^{94}\mathrm{Nb}^{*} to 104Rh∗^{104}\mathrm{Rh}^{*}, we have completely filled the lower orbitals 2p1/22p_{1/2}, 1g9/21g_{9/2} to make 78Ni^{78}\mathrm{Ni} as a core. For the cases of 84Se^{84}\mathrm{Se}, 84Rb∗^{84}\mathrm{Rb}^{*}, 104Tc^{104}\mathrm{Tc} and 104Rh∗^{104}\mathrm{Rh}^{*}, we obtain a large difference in the half-lives between SM and pnQRPA approaches.

We have performed SM calculations without any truncations, using the G-matrix effective interaction for 98Zr{}^{98}\mathrm{Zr} to 124Cd{}^{124}\mathrm{Cd}. For most of the transitions, we obtain larger SM half-lives compared to the scaled half-lives from the pnQRPA. However, in the cases of 98Zr(0+)→98Nb∗(5+){}^{98}\mathrm{Zr}(0^{+})\rightarrow{}^{98}\mathrm{Nb}^{*}(5^{+}) and 122Cd(0+)→122In∗(5+){}^{122}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+})\rightarrow{}^{122}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+}) transitions, the SM half-lives are shorter than the scaled pnQRPA half-lives.

In the Indium chain, we have performed the SM calculations using snet effective interaction. Due to large dimensions, we have restricted the neutron orbitals. For 114In{}^{114}\mathrm{In} and 116In{}^{116}\mathrm{In} we have applied a truncation of νh11/2(0−2)\nu h_{11/2}^{(0-2)}, for 118In{}^{118}\mathrm{In} and 120In{}^{120}\mathrm{In}, a truncation of νh11/2(0−4)\nu h_{11/2}^{(0-4)} and for 122In{}^{122}\mathrm{In} and 124In{}^{124}\mathrm{In}, a truncation of νh11/2(0−6)\nu h_{11/2}^{(0-6)}, respectively. Here, all the decay transitions are from the isomeric excited states of odd-odd nuclei to g.s. of an even-even nuclei. The SM half-lives for all In isotopes are shorter than the scaled pnQRPA half-lives except for 114In∗(5+)→114Sn(0+){}^{114}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+})\rightarrow{}^{114}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+}) transition.

We have performed the SM calculations using sn100pn effective interaction for the decay transitions in the cases of 126−130Sn{}^{126-130}\mathrm{Sn}, 120−132Sb{}^{120-132}\mathrm{Sb}, 134Te{}^{134}\mathrm{Te}, 130,134I{}^{130,134}\mathrm{I}, 134,136Cs{}^{134,136}\mathrm{Cs}, and 138La{}^{138}\mathrm{La} nuclei. We have not employed any truncation except for 120,122Sb{}^{120,122}\mathrm{Sb}. A minimum of 6-8 neutrons in the 1g7/21g_{7/2} orbital (νg7/2(6−8)\nu g_{7/2}^{(6-8)}) are restricted in the cases for 120,122Sb{}^{120,122}\mathrm{Sb}. The SM half-lives are longer in most cases, with a few in reasonable agreement with the scaled pnQRPA half-lives.

For 136Te{}^{136}\mathrm{Te} and 138Xe{}^{138}\mathrm{Xe}, we have employed the SM calculations using jj56pnb effective interaction without any truncation. For these nuclei, we are getting a difference of one order of magnitude in their half-lives between SM and pnQRPA approach.

In Table II B, we compare SM half-lives with the measured half-lives or lower limits for the transitions 40K(4−)→40Ca(0+){}^{40}\mathrm{K}(4^{-})\rightarrow{}^{40}\mathrm{Ca}(0^{+}), 48Ca(0+)→48Sc(5+){}^{48}\mathrm{Ca}(0^{+})\rightarrow{}^{48}\mathrm{Sc}(5^{+}), 96Zr(0+)→96Nb(5+){}^{96}\mathrm{Zr}(0^{+})\rightarrow{}^{96}\mathrm{Nb}(5^{+}) and 138La(5+)→138Ce(2+){}^{138}\mathrm{La}(5^{+})\rightarrow{}^{138}\mathrm{Ce}(2^{+}). A detailed discussion and comparison of the SM half-lives with the experimental half-lives for these transitions is reported below.

40K(4−)→40Ca(0+){}^{40}\mathrm{K}(4^{-})\rightarrow{}^{40}\mathrm{Ca}(0^{+}): The 40K{}^{40}\mathrm{K} is a naturally occurring nucleus and can decay through the β−\beta^{-}, β+\beta^{+}, and EC channels. The 40K{}^{40}\mathrm{K} isotope is important for geochronological applications. The partial half-life for β−\beta^{-} channel is 1.398(3)×1091.398(3) \times10^{9} yr with branching ratio 89.28(13)% for the corresponding transition [44]. The recent measurements have been made for the spectral shape of the β\beta-spectra [48]. For this transition, the OBTDs are obtained from

TransitionForbiddennessQ valuePartial half-lifeInteraction
β−\beta^{-} DecayKth FU(keV)SMRef. [14]
118Cd(0+)→118In∗(5+){}^{118}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{118}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+})4th FU527(21)2.5×10162.5 \times10^{16} yr; 1.8(5)×10161.8(5) \times10^{16} yrG-matrix
118Cd(0+)→118In∗(8−){}^{118}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{118}\mathrm{In}^{*}(8^{-})7th FU527(21)8.6×10338.6 \times10^{33} yr; 3.1(1mag)×10323.1(1\mathrm{mag}) \times10^{32} yrG-matrix
120Cd(0+)→120In∗(5+){}^{120}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{120}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+})4th FU1770(40)7.0×10107.0 \times10^{10} yr; 3.8(8)×10103.8(8) \times10^{10} yrG-matrix
120Cd(0+)→120In∗(8−){}^{120}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{120}\mathrm{In}^{*}(8^{-})7th FU1770(40)5.5×10245.5 \times10^{24} yr; 2.2(3)×10222.2(3) \times10^{22} yrG-matrix
120Pd(0+)→120Ag∗(6−){}^{120}\mathrm{Pd}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{120}\mathrm{Ag}^{*}(6^{-})5th FU5372(5)1.4×10101.4 \times10^{10} yr; 4.4(7)×1084.4(7) \times10^{8} yrG-matrix
120Pd(0+)→120Ag(3+){}^{120}\mathrm{Pd}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{120}\mathrm{Ag}(3^{+})2nd FU5372(5)30.4 d; 8.8(6) dG-matrix
120Ag(3+)→120Cd(0+){}^{120}\mathrm{Ag}(3^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{120}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+})2nd FU8306(6)6.4 d; 4.5(8) dG-matrix
120Ag∗(6−)→120Cd(0+){}^{120}\mathrm{Ag}^{*}(6^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{120}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+})5th FU8306(6)9.0×1079.0 \times10^{7} yr; 2.2(4)×1062.2(4) \times10^{6} yrG-matrix
122Cd(0+)→122In∗(8−){}^{122}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{122}\mathrm{In}^{*}(8^{-})7th FU2960(50)8.6×10198.6 \times10^{19} yr; 2.0(7)×10192.0(7) \times10^{19} yrG-matrix
122Cd(0+)→122In∗(5+){}^{122}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{122}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+})4th FU2960(50)3.2×1073.2 \times10^{7} yr; 2.0(4)×1082.0(4) \times10^{8} yrG-matrix
124Cd(0+)→124In∗(8−){}^{124}\mathrm{Cd}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{124}\mathrm{In}^{*}(8^{-})7th FU4170(30)1.8×10171.8 \times10^{17} yr; 9.4(2)×10159.4(2) \times10^{15} yrG-matrix
114In∗(5+)→114Sn(0+){}^{114}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{114}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+})4th FU1989.9(3)2.6×10122.6 \times10^{12} yr; 9.4(2)×1099.4(2) \times10^{9} yrsnet
116In∗(5+)→116Sn(0+){}^{116}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{116}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+})4th FU3276.22(24)3.8×1093.8 \times10^{9} yr; 1.7(3)×10131.7(3) \times10^{13} yrsnet
116In∗(8−)→116Sn(0+){}^{116}\mathrm{In}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{116}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+})7th FU3276.22(24)5.4×10205.4 \times10^{20} yr; 1.4(2)×10301.4(2) \times10^{30} yrsnet
118In∗(5+)→118Sn(0+){}^{118}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{118}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+})4th FU4425(8)1.3×1081.3 \times10^{8} yr; 1.7(3)×10121.7(3) \times10^{12} yrsnet
118In∗(8−)→118Sn(0+){}^{118}\mathrm{In}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{118}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+})7th FU4425(8)3.1×10183.1 \times10^{18} yr; 4.2(5)×10204.2(5) \times10^{20} yrsnet
120In∗(5+)→120Sn(0+){}^{120}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{120}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+})4th FU5370(40)1.2×1071.2 \times10^{7} yr; 4.0(6)×10174.0(6) \times10^{17} yrsnet
122In∗(5+)→122Sn(0+){}^{122}\mathrm{In}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{122}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+})4th FU6370(50)2.1×1062.1 \times10^{6} yr; 1.1(2)×10141.1(2) \times10^{14} yrsnet
122In∗(8−)→122Sn(0+){}^{122}\mathrm{In}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{122}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+})7th FU6370(50)4.1×10154.1 \times10^{15} yr; 4.7(2)×10184.7(2) \times10^{18} yrsnet
124In∗(8−)→124Sn(0+){}^{124}\mathrm{In}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{124}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+})7th FU7360(30)6.4×10146.4 \times10^{14} yr; 5.3(8)×10185.3(8) \times10^{18} yrsnet
126Sn(0+)→126Sb∗(5+){}^{126}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{126}\mathrm{Sb}^{*}(5^{+})4th FU378(30)2.6×10182.6 \times10^{18} yr; 4.7(1mag)×10184.7(1\mathrm{mag}) \times10^{18} yrsn100pn
126Sn(0+)→126Sb(8−){}^{126}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{126}\mathrm{Sb}(8^{-})7th FU378(30)3.7×10333.7 \times10^{33} yr; 2.3(4)×10152.3(4) \times10^{15} yrsn100pn
128Sn(0+)→128Sb∗(5+){}^{128}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{128}\mathrm{Sb}^{*}(5^{+})4th FU1268(13)1.2×10131.2 \times10^{13} yr; 2.8(4)×10132.8(4) \times10^{13} yrsn100pn
128Sn(0+)→128Sb(8−){}^{128}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{128}\mathrm{Sb}(8^{-})7th FU1268(13)1.1×10261.1 \times10^{26} yr; 1.4(3)×10231.4(3) \times10^{23} yrsn100pn
130Sn(0+)→130Sb(8−){}^{130}\mathrm{Sn}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{130}\mathrm{Sb}(8^{-})7th FU2153(14)2.3×10222.3 \times10^{22} yr; 3.1(5)×10193.1(5) \times10^{19} yrsn100pn
120Sb∗(8−)→120Te(0+){}^{120}\mathrm{Sb}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{120}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+})7th FU945(7)8.3×10298.3 \times10^{29} yr; 4.7(1)×10264.7(1) \times10^{26} yrsn100pn
122Sb∗(8−)→122Te(0+){}^{122}\mathrm{Sb}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{122}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+})7th FU1979.1(21)2.8×10242.8 \times10^{24} yr; 4.7(6)×10214.7(6) \times10^{21} yrsn100pn
124Sb∗(5+)→124Te(0+){}^{124}\mathrm{Sb}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{124}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+})4th FU2905.07(13)9.0×10109.0 \times10^{10} yr; 1.9(3)×10121.9(3) \times10^{12} yrsn100pn
124Sb∗(8−)→124Te(0+){}^{124}\mathrm{Sb}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{124}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+})7th FU2905.07(13)1.8×10221.8 \times10^{22} yr; 3.4(5)×10193.4(5) \times10^{19} yrsn100pn
126Sb∗(5+)→126Te(0+){}^{126}\mathrm{Sb}^{*}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{126}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+})4th FU3670(30)6.7×1096.7 \times10^{9} yr; 1.1(2)×10111.1(2) \times10^{11} yrsn100pn

Table 2. Same as Table I.

TransitionForbiddennessQ valuePartial half-lifeInteraction
β−\beta^{-} DecayKth FU(keV)SMRef. [14]
126Sb(8−)→126Te(0+){}^{126}\mathrm{Sb}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{126}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+})7th FU3670(30)5.0×10205.0 \times10^{20} yr; 1.1(2)×10181.1(2) \times10^{18} yrsn100pn
128Sb(5+)→128Te(0+){}^{128}\mathrm{Sb}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{128}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+})4th FU4364(19)1.0×1091.0 \times10^{9} yr; 1.6(2)×10101.6(2) \times10^{10} yrsn100pn
130Sb(8−)→130Te(0+){}^{130}\mathrm{Sb}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{130}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+})7th FU5067(14)4.0×10184.0 \times10^{18} yr; 9.4(2)×10159.4(2) \times10^{15} yrsn100pn
132Sb(8−)→132Te(0+){}^{132}\mathrm{Sb}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{132}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+})7th FU5553(4)1.2×10181.2 \times10^{18} yr; 4.4(6)×10154.4(6) \times10^{15} yrsn100pn
134Te(0+)→134I∗(8−){}^{134}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{134}\mathrm{I}^{*}(8^{-})7th FU1510(5)7.6×10267.6 \times10^{26} yr; 3.1(5)×10233.1(5) \times10^{23} yrsn100pn
130I(5+)→130Xe(0+){}^{130}\mathrm{I}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{130}\mathrm{Xe}(0^{+})4th FU2944(3)1.5×10111.5 \times10^{11} yr; 7.8(1)×10117.8(1) \times10^{11} yrsn100pn
134I∗(8−)→134Xe(0+){}^{134}\mathrm{I}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{134}\mathrm{Xe}(0^{+})7th FU4082(5)1.7×10201.7 \times10^{20} yr; 1.1(2)×10171.1(2) \times10^{17} yrsn100pn
134Cs∗(8−)→134Ba(0+){}^{134}\mathrm{Cs}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{134}\mathrm{Ba}(0^{+})7th FU2058.84(25)5.9×10245.9 \times10^{24} yr; 3.9(5)×10213.9(5) \times10^{21} yrsn100pn
136Cs(5+)→136Ba(0+){}^{136}\mathrm{Cs}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{136}\mathrm{Ba}(0^{+})4th FU2548.2(19)4.8×10114.8 \times10^{11} yr; 7.8(1)×10117.8(1) \times10^{11} yrsn100pn
136Cs∗(8−)→136Ba(0+){}^{136}\mathrm{Cs}^{*}(8^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{136}\mathrm{Ba}(0^{+})7th FU2548.2(19)5.0×10235.0 \times10^{23} yr; 3.1(5)×10193.1(5) \times10^{19} yrsn100pn
138La(5+)→138Ce(0+){}^{138}\mathrm{La}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{138}\mathrm{Ce}(0^{+})4th FU1052.42(41)6.2×10156.2 \times10^{15} yr; 1.4(3)×10161.4(3) \times10^{16} yrsn100pn
136Te(0+)→136I(6−){}^{136}\mathrm{Te}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{136}\mathrm{I}(6^{-})5th FU5120(14)2.0×1082.0 \times10^{8} yr; 2.3(5)×1092.3(5) \times10^{9} yrjj56pnb
138Xe(0+)→138Cs(6−){}^{138}\mathrm{Xe}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{138}\mathrm{Cs}(6^{-})5th FU2915(10)3.0×10123.0 \times10^{12} yr; 1.3(3)×10111.3(3) \times10^{11} yrjj56pnb

Table 3. Same as Table I.

the SM using the 2p-2h truncation corresponding to excitation from sdsd to pfpf shell to get 4−4^{-} state of 40K{}^{40}\mathrm{K} and 0+0^{+} of 40Ca{}^{40}\mathrm{Ca} using the sdpf-mu interaction. The shell model half-life is 9.2×1089.2 \times10^{8} yr for this transition with the values gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{\mathrm{eff}} = 1.0 and gV=1.0g_{V} = 1.0. The variation of the shellmodel partial half-life with the different gAeffg_{A}^{eff} values is shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1. The variation of shell model partial half-life with gV=1.0g_{V}=1.0 and different gAeffg_{A}^{eff} values. The vertical dashed lines (red in colour) are the error value of the experimental partial half-life.

48Ca(0+)→48(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{48}Sc(5+)(5^{+}): The doubly magic nucleus 48^{48}Ca is unstable against a single beta decay. The 48^{48}Ca (0+)(0^{+}) can decays to 4+4^{+}, 5+5^{+}, 6+6^{+} states of the daughter nucleus 48^{48}Sc which is followed by a large change in angular momentum along with a small QQ value. The decay to 4+4^{+} and 6+6^{+} states are FNU decay and to 5+5^{+} state is a FU decay. Previously, Aunola et al. and Haaranen et al. estimated partial half-lives of 1.1−0.6+0.8×10211.1^{+0.8}_{-0.6} \times10^{21} yr [49] and 5.2−1.3+1.7×1020gA−25.2^{+1.7}_{-1.3} \times10^{20} g_{A}^{-2} yr [50], respectively. For the 48^{48}Ca case, there is a competition between single β−\beta^{-} and ββ−\beta\beta^{-} decay channel with the observed half life for ββ−\beta\beta^{-} decay channel is 6.4×10196.4 \times10^{19} yr [51]. In the present calculations, the SM half-life corresponding to a single β−\beta^{-} decay is 5.0×10205.0 \times10^{20} yr for gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{eff}=1.0 and gV=1.0g_{V}=1.0 and the experimental limit for the half-life is greater than 2.5×10202.5 \times10^{20} yr given in Ref. [46].

96^{96}Zr(0+)→96(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{96}Nb(5+)(5^{+}): This case is similar to previous 48^{48}Ca case. The 0+0^{+} g.s. can decay to 4+4^{+}, 5+5^{+} and 6+6^{+} states of daughter nucleus 96^{96}Nb and the most likely branch is 4th- FU decay. The higher forbiddenness 4th- FU decay along with the low QQ-value have a longer half-life as compared to the double beta decay channel. The recently measured lower limit of experimental single beta decay half-life is greater than 2.4×10192.4 \times10^{19} yr [47]. Previously, calculated shell-model half-life was (1/gA2)×1019(1/g_{A}^{2}) \times10^{19} yr [52] and QRPA half-life was 2.4×10202.4 \times10^{20} yr [53]. In the present work, the calculated shell model half-life with gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{eff}=1.0 and gV=1.0g_{V}=1.0 (g.s. to g.s Q value 163.97(0.10)163.97(0.10) keV) is 1.3×10201.3 \times10^{20} yr.

138^{138}La(5+)→138(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{138}Ce(2+)(2^{+}): 138^{138}La is a naturally occurring nucleus with half-life of 1.02(1)×10111.02(1) \times10^{11} yr [54]. The branching ratio for 2nd- FU β−\beta^{-} decay 138^{138}La(5+)→138(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{138}Ce∗(2+)^{*}(2^{+}) is 34.5% and the partial half-life for the corresponding transition is 2.97(3)×10112.97(3) \times10^{11} yr. The SM calculations predict the half-life value 7.7×10107.7 \times10^{10} yr with gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{eff}=1.0 and gV=1.0g_{V}=1.0. The variation of shell-model results of partial half-life with the gAeffg_{A}^{eff} values is shown in Figure 1.

Conclusion

In the present work, we have performed the SM calculations for higher β−\beta^{-} decay transitions including 2nd-

TransitionForbiddennessQQ value (keV)Partial half-life (yr) ExperimentalPartial half-life (yr) SMInteraction
40^{40}K(4−)→40(4^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{40}Ca(0+)(0^{+})3rd FU1310.91(6)1.398(3)×1091.398(3) \times10^{9} [44, 45]9.2×1089.2 \times10^{8}sdpf-mu
48^{48}Ca(0+)→48(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{48}Sc(5+)(5^{+})4th FU279(5)>2.5×1020> 2.5 \times10^{20} [46]5.1×10205.1 \times10^{20}gxpf1a
96^{96}Zr(0+)→96(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{96}Nb(5+)(5^{+})4th FU163.97(10)>2.4×1019> 2.4 \times10^{19} [47]1.3×10201.3 \times10^{20}gwbxg
138^{138}La(5+)→138(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{138}Ce(2+)(2^{+})2nd FU1052.5(4)2.97(3)×10112.97(3) \times10^{11} [44, 45]7.7×10107.7 \times10^{10}sn100pn

Table 4. Comparison of shell model half-lives for β−\beta^{-} transitions with the coupling constants gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{eff}=1.0, gV=1.0g_{V}=1.0, and the measured half-lives (or lower limits). The ground-state to ground-state Q value is taken from AME2020 [43].

, 3rd-, 4th-, 5th-, 6th- and 7th- FU, for nuclei in mass range A=40A=40-138. We have employed the effective interactions sdpf-mu, gxpf1a, gwbxg, G-matrix, snet, sn100pn, and jj56pnb to obtain the OBTDs. Further, the OBTDs have been used to calculate the partial half-lives within the framework of β\beta-decay theory. The present manuscript is focused on those higher FU decay transitions for which experimental data is unavailable except for the 3rd-FU 40K(4−)→40Ca(0+){}^{40}\mathrm{K}(4^{-}) \rightarrow{}^{40}\mathrm{Ca}(0^{+}), 4th-FU, 48Ca(0+)→48Sc(5+){}^{48}\mathrm{Ca}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{48}\mathrm{Sc}(5^{+}), 4th-FU 96Zr(0+)→96Nb(5+){}^{96}\mathrm{Zr}(0^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{96}\mathrm{Nb}(5^{+}) and 2nd-FU 138La(5+)→138Ce(2+){}^{138}\mathrm{La}(5^{+}) \rightarrow{}^{138}\mathrm{Ce}(2^{+}) transitions. For these transitions, the measured half-life or its lower limit is available. The calculations are performed with gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{\mathrm{eff}}=1.0 and gV=1.0g_{V}=1.0 and results are compared with the expected half-lives from pnQRPA approach at gAeff=1.0g_{A}^{\mathrm{eff}}=1.0.

The variation in half-lives between the two approaches is due to the use of different nuclear structure formalism involved. The present SM study will be useful to compare upcoming experimental data for half-lives of these higher forbidden β−\beta^{-} decay transitions.

Acknowledgement

This work is supported by a research grant from SERB (India), CRG/2022/005167. We also acknowledge the National Supercomputing Mission (NSM) for providing computing resources of ‘PARAM Ganga’ at the Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee. We would also like to thank Anil Kumar for the useful discussion.

References

References

  1. [1]K. Langanke and G. Martínez-Pinedo, “Nuclear weak-interaction processes in stars”, Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 819 (2003).DOI
  2. [2]T. Suzuki, “Nuclear weak rates and nuclear weak processes in stars”, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 126, 103974 (2022).DOI
  3. [3]E. Caurier, K. Langanke, G. Martínez-Pinedo and F. Nowacki, “Shell-model calculations of stellar weak interaction rates. I. Gamow-Teller distributions and spectra of nuclei in the mass range A= 45-65”, Nucl. Phys. A 653, 439 (1999).
  4. [4]K. Langanke and G. Martínez-Pinedo, “Shell-model calculations of stellar weak interaction rates: Weak rates for nuclei in the mass range A=45-65 in supernovae environments”, Nucl. Phys. A 673, 481 (2000).
  5. [5]H. Schatz et al., “Strong neutrino cooling by cycles of electron capture and β− decay in neutron star crusts”, Nature 505, 62 (2014).DOI
  6. [6]T. Suzuki, H. Toki, and K. Nomoto, “Electron-capture and β-decay rates for sd-shell nuclei in stellar environments relevant to high-density O-Ne-Mg cores”, The Astrophysical Journal, 817, 163 (2016).DOI
  7. [7]A. Saxena, P.C. Srivastava and T. Suzuki, “Ab initio calculations of Gamow-Teller strengths in the sd shell nuclei”, Phys. Rev. C 97, 024310 (2018).DOI
  8. [8]A. Kumar, N. Shimizu, Y. Utsuno, C. Yuan, and P. C. Srivastava, “Large-scale shell model study of β− decay properties of N = 126, 125 nuclei: Role of Gamow-Teller and first-forbidden transitions in the half-lives”, Phys. Rev. C 109, 064319 (2024).DOI
  9. [9]S. Sharma, P. C. Srivastava, A. Kumar, and T. Suzuki, “Shell-model description for the properties of the forbidden β− decay in the region “northeast” of 208Pb”, Phys. Rev. C 106, 024333 (2022).DOI
  10. [10]S. Sharma, P. C. Srivastava, A. Kumar, T. Suzuki, C. Yuan, and N. Shimizu, “Shell-model study for allowed and forbidden β− decay properties in the mass region “south” of 208Pb”, Phys. Rev. C 110, 024320 (2024).DOI
  11. [11]J. T. Suhonen, “Value of the Axial-Vector Coupling Strength in β and ββ Decays: A Review”, Front. Phys. 5, 55 (2017).DOI
  12. [12]J. Suhonen, From Nucleons to Nucleus: Concept of Microscopic Nuclear Theory, (Springer, Berlin 2007).DOI
  13. [13]H. Behrens and W. Bühring, Electron Radial Wave Functions and Nuclear Beta-Decay (Clarendon Press, 1982).
  14. [14]J. Kostensalo, and J. Suhonen, “Spin-multipole nuclear matrix elements in the pn quasiparticle random-phase approximation: Implications for β and ββ half-lives”, Phys. Rev. C 95, 014322 (2017).DOI
  15. [15]H. Ejiri, N. Soukouti and J. Suhonen, “Spin-dipole nuclear matrix elements for double beta decays and astroneutrinos”, Phys. Lett. B 729, 27 (2014).
  16. [16]H. Ejiri and J. Suhonen, “GT neutrino-nuclear responses for double beta decays and astro neutrinos”, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 42, 055201 (2015).DOI
  17. [17]J. Kostensalo and J. Suhonen, “gA-driven shapes of electron spectra of forbidden β decays in the nuclear shell-model”, Phys. Rev. C 96, 024317 (2017).DOI
  18. [18]A. Kumar, P. C. Srivastava, and J. Suhonen, “Second-forbidden nonunique β− decays of 59,60Fe:possible candidates for gA sensitive electron spectral-shape measurements”, Eur. Phys. J. A 57, 225(2021).
  19. [19]M. Haaranen, P. C. Srivastava, and J. Suhonen “Forbidden non-unique β decays and effective values of weak coupling constants”, Phys. Rev. C 93, 034308 (2016).DOI
  20. [20]M. Haaranen, J. Kotila, and J. Suhonen, “Spectrum-shape method and the next-to-leading-order terms of the β-decay shape factor”, Phys. Rev. C 95, 024327 (2017).DOI
  21. [21]M. T. Mustonen, M. Aunola, and J. Suhonen, “Theoretical description of the fourth-forbidden non-unique β decays of 113Cd and 115In”, Phys. Rev. C 73, 054301 (2006); Erratum Phys. Rev. C 76, 019901 (2007).DOI
  22. [22]H. F. Schopper, Weak Interaction and Nuclear Beta Decay (North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1966).
  23. [23]C. Patrignani and Particle Data Group, “Review of Particle Physics”, Chinese Phys. C 40, 100001 (2016).
  24. [24]A. Kumar, P. C. Srivastava, J. Kostensalo and J. Suhonen, “Second-forbidden nonunique β− decays of 24Na and 36Cl assessed by the nuclear shell-model”, Phys. Rev. C. 101, 064320 (2020).
  25. [25]N. Shimizu, T. Mizusaki, Y. Utsuno and Y. Tsunoda, “Thick-restart block Lanczos method for large-scale shell-model calculations”, Comput. Phys. Commun. 244, Y. Utsuno, T. Otsuka, B. A. Brown, M. Homma, T. Mizusaki, and N. Shimizu “Shape transitions in exotic Si and S isotopes and tensor-force-driven Jahn-Teller effect”, Phys. Rev. C 86, 051301(R) (2012).
  26. [28]M. Homma, T. Otsuka, B. A. Brown, and T. Mizusaki, “Shell-model description of neutron-rich pf-shell nuclei with a new effective interaction GXPF 1”, Eur. Phys. J. A 25, suppl 1, 499 (2005).
  27. [29]Z. Ren et al., “Reinvestigation of the level structures of the N = 49 isotones ⁸⁹Zr and ⁹¹Mo”, Phys RevC 106, 024323(2022).DOI
  28. [30]P. Dey et al., “Experimental investigation of high-spin states in ⁹⁰Zr”, Phys RevC 105, 044307(2022).DOI
  29. [31]N. Boelaert, N. Smirnova, K. Heyde, and J. Jolie, “Shell model description of the low-lying states of the neutron deficient Cd isotopes” Phys RevC 75, 014316 (2007).DOI
  30. [32]A. Hosaka, et al., “G-matrix effective interaction with the paris potential”, Nucl. Phys. A 71, 444 (1986).DOI
  31. [33]B.A. Brown, et al., “Gamow-Teller strength in the region of ¹⁰⁰Sn”, Phys. Rev. C 50, 2270(R) (1994).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9969964
  32. [34]B. A. Brown, N. J. Stone, J. R. Stone, I. S. Towner, and M. Hjorth-Jensen, “Magnetic moments of the 2₁⁺ states around ¹³²Sn”, Phys RevC 71, 044317 (2005).DOI
  33. [35]R. Machleidt, F. Sammarruca, and Y. Song, “Nonlocal nature of the nuclear force and its impact on nuclear structure”, Phys. Rev. C 53 R1483(R) (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9971179
  34. [36]D. R. Entem, and R. Machleidt, “Accurate charge-dependent nucleon-nucleon potential at fourth order of chiral perturbation theory”, Phys. Rev. C 68, 041001(R) (2003).DOI
  35. [37]B. A. Brown, unpublished.
  36. [38]A. Hosaka, K.-I. Kubo and H. Toki, “G-matrix effective interaction with the paris potential”, Nucl. Phys. A 444, 76 (1985).DOI
  37. [39]X. Ji and B. H. Wildenthal, “Effective interaction for N=50 isotones”, Phys. Rev. C 37, 1256 (1988).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9954564
  38. [40]D. H. Gloeckner, “Shell-model systematics of the zirconium and niobium isotopes ”, Nucl. Phys. A 253, 301 (1975).DOI
  39. [41]F. J. D. Serduke, R. D. Lawson, and D. H. Gloeckner, “Shell-model study of the N = 49 isotones”, Nucl.Phys. ADOI
  40. [42]R. Machleidt, “High-precision, charge-dependent Bonn nucleon-nucleon potential”, Phys Rev C. 63, 024001 (2001).DOI
  41. [43]M. Wang, W. J. Huang, F. G. Kondev, G. Audi and S. Naimi, “The AME 2020 atomic mass evaluation (II). Tables, graphs and references” Chin. Phys. C 45(3), 030003(2021).
  42. [44]P. Belli, R. Bernabei, F. A. Danevich, et al., “Experimental searches for rare alpha and beta decays”, Eur. Phys. J. A 55, 140 (2019).DOI
  43. [45]M. Redshaw, “Precise Q value determinations for forbidden and low energy β-decays using Penning trap mass spectrometry”, Eur. Phys. J. A 59, 18 (2023).DOI
  44. [46]A. Bakalyarov et al., “Improved limits on β− and ββ− decays of ⁴⁸Ca”, JETP Lett. 76, 545 (2002).DOI
  45. [47]S. W. Finch, and W. Tornow, “Search for the β decay of ⁹⁶Zr”, Nucl. Instrum. Methods A 806, 70-74(2016).DOI
  46. [48]A. G. Carles, and K. Kossert, “Management of the shape-factor functions of the long-lived radionuclides ⁸⁷Rb, ⁴⁰K and ¹⁰Be”, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. 572, 760-767(2007).DOI
  47. [49]M. Aunola, J. Suhonen and T. Sikkonen, “Shell-model study of the highly forbidden beta decay ⁴⁸Ca → ⁴⁸Sc”, Europhys. Lett. 46, 577 (1999).DOI
  48. [50]M. Haaranen, M. Horoi, and J. Suhonen, “Shell-model study of the 4th- and 6th-forbidden β-decay branches of ⁴⁸Ca”, Phys. Rev. C 89, 034315 (2014).DOI
  49. [51]R. Arnold et al., “Measurement of the double-beta decay half-life and search for the neutrinoless double-beta decay of ⁴⁸Ca with the NEMO-3 detector”, Phys. Rev. D 93, 112008 (2016).
  50. [52]M. Alanssari et al., “Single and Double Beta-Decay Q Values among the Triplet ⁹⁶Zr, ⁹⁶Nb, and ⁹⁶Mo”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 072501 (2016).DOI
  51. [53]H Heiskanen, M. T. Mustonen and J. Suhonen, “Theoretical half-life for beta decay of ⁹⁶Zr”, J. Phys. G: Nucl. and Part. Phys. 34, 837 (2007).DOI
  52. [54]G. Audi G. et al., “The NUBASE2016 evaluation of nuclear properties”, Chin. Phys. C 41, 030001(2017).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_6ek2re7z
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents